Slashdot Mirror


GlobeTrotter: Mandrake-based 40GB Linux Mobile Desktop

joestar writes "Mandrakesoft & LaCie have just launched "GlobeTrotter", a ultra-compact 40 GB bootable USB hard-drive pre-loaded with Mandrakelinux 10.0 Official. It may be plugged to any available PC with a USB 1 or USB 2 port, automatically recognizes the host-PC's hardware, and then is ready to use. Multiple uses can be imagined, from the office/internet workstation to the multimedia jukebox! The concept is quite similar to Mandrakemove, excepted that it's way more powerful than a USB-key based system! And for $219 it's a credible alternative to a laptop."

199 comments

  1. Alternative to a laptop? by Kell_pt · · Score: 5, Insightful

    It's not really an alternative to a laptop imho - check its weight. Always recall that transportable doesn't make it portable. ;)

    --
    "I don't mind God, it's his fan club I can't stand!" E8
    1. Re:Alternative to a laptop? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      well it fits in your lap doesn't it?

    2. Re:Alternative to a laptop? by Chess_the_cat · · Score: 5, Insightful
      It's not really an alternative to a laptop imho

      Maybe because it's not a laptop. It's a HD with Mandrake preloaded onto it. You plug it into a desktop so you can run Mandrake anywhere.

      --
      Support the First Amendment. Read at -1
    3. Re:Alternative to a laptop? by j.blechert · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I think the bigger problem is that you need host hardware and therefore can't use it in the train, on a bench or wherever else you'd use a laptop...

    4. Re:Alternative to a laptop? by Arathrael · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I suppose it's a credible alternative to a laptop if the only thing you use the laptop for is working at both home and work.

      Just have a machine without hard drive at each location and take the usb drive.

      Otherwise, yes, you could hardly rely on there being available host hardware without password-protected BIOS setups available wherever you want to use it. :-)

    5. Re:Alternative to a laptop? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes, but MANY people have an office and a home office, or multiple computers at the same location (my home office is downstairs and my bedroom upstairs, so I use remote desktop connection to work on my computer in the basement while upstairs close to the family at times), or one at the office one at work, or while traveling and staying with family or friends.

      Also, I have a laptop and don't really want to deal with dual booting, but would love to try linux on the desktop.

      Really, this is ideal for many people. And pretty cheap!

    6. Re:Alternative to a laptop? by Daniel+Ellard · · Score: 1
      A laptop is a computer I can hold in my lap. This is a gizmo that I can hold in my lap but which is useless without a host computer. It's a peripheral.

      Not that I wouldn't mind having one... (Will it work with my powerbook too?)

      --
      Disclaimer: I work for a company, but I don't speak for them.
    7. Re:Alternative to a laptop? by h4rm0ny · · Score: 3, Insightful


      I'm not sure on the speeds you'd get across USB2, but this is also USB1 compatible and I don't think you'd want your swap mounted on it. Nope, you're right and you don't need to qualify it. This is no alternative to a laptop.

      And if the purpose of it was to have portability of software and data, well I have an email client running from a pen-drive and it also stores a few spreadsheets and Word documents. I've not found much else I actually need to carry from computer to computer for rountine work.

      I'd say the best use for this is demoing a linux system to clients.

      --

      Aide-toi, le Ciel t'aidera - Jeanne D'Arc.
    8. Re:Alternative to a laptop? by Kell_pt · · Score: 1

      And for $219 it's a credible alternative to a laptop.

      Maybe because it's not a laptop.

      I was merely addressing the hint in the newspost that it could prove an alternative to a laptop. It certainly looks good otherwise though. :)

      --
      "I don't mind God, it's his fan club I can't stand!" E8
    9. Re:Alternative to a laptop? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      a hd as an alternative to laptop. matbe you'll explaim how on my business trip on planes and hotel rooms, i get my work done. and $219 for 40gb that's twice the price of similar equipment, sound that you have to be stupid an rich to get it.

  2. sounds like an easy way... by ryane67 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    to hijack data off a system that you dont have the password to log into yourself..

    --
    ?SYNTAX ERROR IN LINE 42
    1. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Only if you reboot the PC, I guess. Reboots of PCs on our network wouldn't go unnoticed, anyway, though many corporate lans are far less secure I guess.

    2. Re:sounds like an easy way... by xSquaredAdmin · · Score: 2, Insightful

      You've been able to do that with a Knoppix CD for quite a while, so that isn't anything new.

      --
      Crushing dreams at the speed of sarcasm
    3. Re:sounds like an easy way... by jeffkjo1 · · Score: 4, Informative

      Yea, I love supposedly 'password protected' XP/2000 user login directories are wide open for the viewing in linux. Thanks knoppix!

    4. Re:sounds like an easy way... by caino59 · · Score: 1

      if you can boot from removable medium, you're forked anyway..regardless of using linux or not..

    5. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Proc6 · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Enable file system encryption on NTFS and try again.

      --

      I'm Rick James with mod points biatch!

    6. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Embedded2004 · · Score: 1

      What kind of company logs reboots on PCs? Well windows machines at least. I reboot my windows machine at least once a day at work.

    7. Re:sounds like an easy way... by drawfour · · Score: 2, Insightful

      If the system administrators are smart, they'll password protect the BIOS settings and only allow the hard drive to boot. Not floppy. Not CD. Not USB. Yes, you can reset the BIOS password, but it requires more than hitting the power button and plugging something in.

    8. Re:sounds like an easy way... by nzkbuk · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Well it's a simply registry entry to log reboots into the system log.
      It's much harder to log remote desktop connections.

      So in answer to your question, most companies with any real admin would log it, even for the simple case of 'you say your system is unstable, but it's only rebooted once a day without any program crashes'

    9. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Nyder · · Score: 4, Informative

      drawfour says "Yes, you can reset the BIOS password, but it requires more than hitting the power button and plugging something in."

      yes, all you need is a command prompt (msdos boot disk) then type:
      DEBUG

      and hit Enter. You'll see a dash (-) at the DEBUG prompt. Now type:

      o 70 2e

      which will show as -o 70 2e at the DEBUG prompt. Hit Enter. Then type:

      o 71 ff

      and hit Enter. Finally type:

      Q

      that is one of the ways, there are a few others. don't work in all situations, but will work in most i've had to deal with.

      --
      Be seeing you...
    10. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yea, I love supposedly 'password protected' Linux user login directories are wide open for the viewing in linux. Thanks...er... linux!

      boot: linux single root=/dev/hda1 initrd=

    11. Re:sounds like an easy way... by MonsterChicharo · · Score: 1
      What kind of company logs reboots on PCs? Well windows machines at least. I reboot my windows machine at least once a day at work.

      A lot do, especially those in compliance with BS-7799
    12. Re:sounds like an easy way... by PedanticSpellingTrol · · Score: 2, Funny

      So the old maxim holds true yet again: Once an attacker has physical access to the target, all you can do is sit back and watch the pwnage. Or trigger the halon. It kinda depends on your situation.

    13. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      you win

    14. Re:sounds like an easy way... by nolife · · Score: 1

      most companies with any real admin would log it,

      I am a firm believer in the man with the most tools and logs wins but I call bull on your "real admin" claim referencing your local machine registry entry. Reboots in a local Windows machine logs in a large or small domain are pretty much useless and FAR FAR FAR down the list of something an admin is going to worry about. You can already tell by looking in the local PC logs when a machine has been rebooted by the starting of other services. Things much more useful are logs from the domain, your antivirus servers, your software update servers, all of these and many others tell you the status of a Windows PC and when it was and was not seen and all PC's are accessible from a centralized location. Taking the host OS out of the loop, you can use various other methods of logging like when a switch port joins or leaves the bridge, network scans, or something as simple as the DHCP logs.

      Another point. Everywhere I have ever worked, the PC's are shut off when not in use anyway, if the IT dept needs them for something (updates, verify something on the machine etc), they are woken up.
      In your case, if a PC is already off, booting it with portable media is not going to update the Windows logs.
      Maybe I am missing something here.

      --
      Bad boys rape our young girls but Violet gives willingly.
    15. Re:sounds like an easy way... by typobox43 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      How do you boot from a DOS boot disk if you can't boot from anything but the hard drive?

    16. Re:sounds like an easy way... by dbIII · · Score: 2, Insightful
      Yea, I love supposedly 'password protected' XP/2000 user login directories are wide open for the viewing in linux. Thanks knoppix!
      Remember, if someone with reasonable IT skills gets to sit in front of a machine with no-one watching, and has bootable media, it isn't that hard for them to get full access to the system. If the files are all encrypted the password file can still be taken away and cracked over time.

      I've had a few things delivered where the vendor didn't supply the root password (probably sound policy, I was probably supposed to ring up and ask for it) - but a couple of minutes with install media or the right boot floppy (windows admin password blanker), and you have a new root password that only you know. Even a Sun with no video card doesn't pose much of a challenge - so keep that server room door locked.

    17. Re:sounds like an easy way... by nzkbuk · · Score: 1

      The point I was addressing was what companies would log reboots. And that's every company which wanted to keep serious logs.

      The point about the "real admin" is that for fault (or potential fault) diagnosis, short of keylogging, you log everything. That way when something does go wrong, you've atleast got a chance of figuring it out.

      Yes there are other logs that you can (and would use) to trace unauthorized activity. Also not all places have pc's who's network cards support WOL, unless you're meaning the screen and HDD's power down while the system is idle in which case tey aren't really 'shut off' are they.

      I think we're digressing a bit from the point that a USB HDD is a far cry from a laptop.

    18. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Use the following steps to get around the encrypted NTFS folder/drive.

      Use a Win2K drive with l0phtCrack (LC5)
      Hack the target drive Administrator password
      Remove Win2K drive
      Boot Windows with Admin password.
      Reset user password (with the NTFS encryption).
      Login with hacked user.
      Remove NTFS encryption.
      Copy decrypted contents to your Win2K drive.

    19. Re:sounds like an easy way... by dildatron · · Score: 1

      yeah... that's a good point.

      --


      If you had nuts on your chin, would they be chin nuts?
    20. Re:sounds like an easy way... by wdd1040 · · Score: 0

      Put DOS on a HDD and put that in the computer. Or, you can load the manufacturer's BIOS flash program that will typically reset all settings, including the password. Or, most desktops have a BIOS password jumper.

      --
      wdd
    21. Re:sounds like an easy way... by damiam · · Score: 1

      There are Windows programs that do effectively the same thing as the above method.

      --
      It's hard to be religious when certain people are never incinerated by bolts of lightning.
    22. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Milican · · Score: 1

      Lets say the user encrypted the data. If you reset the user password from another administrator account that data is lost. However, if you got the password for that user and logged in you would be good.

      JOhn

    23. Re:sounds like an easy way... by drawfour · · Score: 1

      I think you should quote more of what I said.

      If the system administrators are smart, they'll password protect the BIOS settings and only allow the hard drive to boot. Not floppy. Not CD. Not USB.

      Thus, if the BIOS is set to NOT allow the floppy boot, they cannot boot to MSDOS to do whatever you want DEBUG to do. (What do those commands do?) Now, if you're saying all you need is to log into the machine as a user (not Administrator) and run DEBUG to do that, then that seems to be a serious problem with XP. Can you clarify what you meant?

    24. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Krunch · · Score: 1

      Isn't there a "rescue mode" or something that let you boot DOS before you start Windows ? Anyway the smart admin doesn't run Windows and he keeps all the data on a physically inaccessible files server.

      --
      No GNU has been Hurd during the making of this comment.
    25. Re:sounds like an easy way... by nusuth · · Score: 1

      I love supposedly 'password protected' Linux user login directories are wide open for the viewing in windows as long as file system is ext2 or ext3. Thanks windows!

      --

      Gentlemen, you can't fight in here, this is the War Room!

    26. Re:sounds like an easy way... by nusuth · · Score: 1
      I'm not sure (never used PC ports much) but it seems it overries MSB of BIOS checksum with 0xff. With any luck, 0xff is not the right value and BIOS will complain with corrupt checksum on next boot and allow you to change values.

      using debug on hardware ports doesn't usually work under NT series, hence XP should be immune to that.

      --

      Gentlemen, you can't fight in here, this is the War Room!

    27. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Btw, if is possible to use debug on raw hardware, you can use it to boot from whatever you want. And when you are done, you can remove your traces. Your system administrator won't say "All my BIOS passwords get reset one after another, it must be solar storms."

    28. Re:sounds like an easy way... by haggar · · Score: 1

      You don't need to boot from a floppy to get an MSDOS prompt and run debug. I have a Win2K system, opened a dos prompt and ran debug just fine.

      --
      Sigged!
    29. Re:sounds like an easy way... by haggar · · Score: 1

      Did this procedure work with any ThinkPads, as far as you can recall? I don't want to trash our company's laptop while doing this.

      --
      Sigged!
    30. Re:sounds like an easy way... by ultranova · · Score: 1

      Remember, if someone with reasonable IT skills gets to sit in front of a machine with no-one watching, and has bootable media, it isn't that hard for them to get full access to the system. If the files are all encrypted the password file can still be taken away and cracked over time.

      Unless the admin is l33t enough to know that you can disable booting from anything but the hard drive from the BIOS, and keep this setting from being changed with a BIOS password.

      Of course you can always (break) open the case and pocket the hard drive, but that's a lot less likely to not draw attention than just sitting in front of the computer and typing.

      Of course, it's still a good idea to keep the door locked. And, preferably, unmarked - admins know where the server room is, and no one else needs to know.

      --

      Forget magic. Any technology distinguishable from divine power is insufficiently advanced.

    31. Re:sounds like an easy way... by nusuth · · Score: 1

      It shouldn't work. Not as in it destroys your thinkpad, but 2k won't allow debug to access real ports to change the value there. Try this, which has no side effect, to make sure: debug -o 70 2e -i 71 It will give you some number XX, that is the correct value. Write it down. -o 70 2e -o 71 ff If kernel allowed you to write to that port you now have overwritten 2e. Exit cmd. Restart cmd. debug -o 70 2e -i 71 Now the output should be XX if NT does the right thing and ff if it doesn't. To get your right value back -o 70 2e -o 71 XX

      --

      Gentlemen, you can't fight in here, this is the War Room!

    32. Re:sounds like an easy way... by haggar · · Score: 1

      Yep, you are right, the kernel didn't allow for the port to be written to.

      Many thanks for the interesting know-how, though.

      Do you think this procedure (provided I could boot into DOS) would work for a ThinkPad?

      --
      Sigged!
    33. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      A CF card on an appropriate IDE adapter can replace the original hard drive during BIOS password reset.

    34. Re:sounds like an easy way... by nusuth · · Score: 1

      Notebooks usually have somewhat non-standard BIOSes. But Thinkpads are from IBM, original designers of the PC BIOS, so probably it will corrupt the BIOS checksum just fine. Try to change something in the bios and check if the XX value changes too. I don't know what thinkpads do in case of a corrupted checksum. Most desktops just reset the CMOS. Even if they do something else, YOU can manually reset CMOS and get a valid checksum back. But you probably can't manually reset Thinkpad's CMOS. I don't think trying the procedure is a good idea until you have information about Thinkpads' behavior in case of a corrupt CMOS.

      --

      Gentlemen, you can't fight in here, this is the War Room!

    35. Re:sounds like an easy way... by drawfour · · Score: 1

      Yes, and Windows XP has debug as well.

      Now, run as a non-Administrator and try those commands. I'm pretty sure it won't work. Debug is just an application running. If you want to attach debug to another application you are running, then you can, regardless of whether or not you're an Administrator. But to actually do raw stuff to the hardware, you'd have to be an Administrator, and even then I don't know if XP will let you.

    36. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      That doesn't work if the user is an Active Directory user. The local administrator cannot reset an AD user.

    37. Re:sounds like an easy way... by dbIII · · Score: 1
      Unless the admin is l33t enough to know that you can disable booting from anything but the hard drive
      Every admin knows that, but most prefer physical security. When you have a failure and can't get the password you have a paperweight, which is OK if it's only a PC - or OK if a few people have the BIOS passwords and it's also kept in a safe place offsite. In today's IT market you cannot assume that you will be in any one place for the life of the hardware, or even that the hardware will remain on site. Thanks to people not setting BIOS passwords I can buy old servers at auction to fall back on and use them for more than boat anchors.

      admins know where the server room is, and no one else needs to know.
      There is a tendancy in many places to take every client that visits and show them the server room (which is a really good way to make every admin nervous) - so if nothing else there should be a "no food or drink" sign on the door, to prevent those situations where an important client puts a full coffee cup down on the grille of a short rack containing 32 big SCSI disks - a spill that and the entire company can't operate for a week situation.
    38. Re:sounds like an easy way... by haggar · · Score: 1

      You have a very valid point.
      Well, I do have admin rights to this Win2K laptop, and yet the kernel did not allow any writes to the ports performed by debug. Interestingly, debug does not complain, and within the session, you can even read back the values you wrote to the port. But one you close and re-open the session, the value is gone and the old one is in place.

      In other words: you are very right. Too bad, as my laptop is locked down by the otherwise incompetent IM, not allowing me to boot some rather more interesting operating systems on it.

      --
      Sigged!
    39. Re:sounds like an easy way... by nusuth · · Score: 1
      I must have misled you there. What actually happens is not that kernel forbids debug doing certain things, but debug is working in an emulated environment. Kernel just doesn't get the values of the emulated environment and forward it to real system. That is why I wanted you to restart cmd before checking whether the value has indeed changed.

      Since you have admin privilidges (and can install drivers), all is not lost. run debug with http://www.beyondlogic.org/porttalk/porttalk.htm

      --

      Gentlemen, you can't fight in here, this is the War Room!

    40. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      most companies with any real admin would log it

      Shit. I am a real admin and I sure as hell don't log reboots. Maybe I would in a perfect world but with all the other bullshit that I have to do there s just not the time for that to be useful.

    41. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


      Use a Win2K drive with l0phtCrack (LC5)

      Syskey is enabled by default on windows 2000. Unless you already have the admin password you aren't going to be able to use LC to crack the SAM.

      Since win2k started shipping with Syskey turned on the only real use for LC is if you are a machine admin and you want to find out all the end users passwords.

    42. Re:sounds like an easy way... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0



      Anyway the smart admin doesn't run Windows

      What are you twelve years old? Like the average real world admin has any fscking choice what his machines are going to be running. Oh but I suppose you would format all the drives and install Linux, huh? Yeah, and you'd end up getting fired five minutes later and you might even get sued if your 31337 actions caused enough monetary losses to the company.

    43. Re:sounds like an easy way... by haggar · · Score: 1

      Thank you for sharing all this precious knowledge with me. I am genuinely grateful.

      --
      Sigged!
  3. YAY by umpa · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I think this is great. Not only can you take along your preferred operating system, but your files, too.

    Maybe my hardware is old, but can most boxes boot off USB these days?

    1. Re:YAY by packeteer · · Score: 1

      yes.

      --
      unzip; strip; touch; finger; mount; fsck; more; yes; unmount; sleep
    2. Re:YAY by ryanjensen · · Score: 2, Informative

      The drive comes with a mini-CD containing a bootloader and a recovery program. So if your hardware can at least boot off CD, it can use the LaCie drive.

    3. Re:YAY by Brandybuck · · Score: 1

      So go spend $219 for the drive, then another $1219 for a decent system that will boot off of USB. Sigh.

      --
      Don't blame me, I didn't vote for either of them!
    4. Re:YAY by jrockway · · Score: 1

      You can easily build a system that will boot this thing for under $160.

      1x nForce2 mobo = $30
      1x Athlon = $50
      1x case with cheap PSU = $50
      1x 256M RAM = $30

      The hard drive seems to be the most expensive part of a computer these days. (unless you have 1024M of ECC RAM... that will also take a piece of your wallet...)

      --
      My other car is first.
    5. Re:YAY by Afrosheen · · Score: 1

      Even hard drives are dirt cheap anymore. Ironically enough, you'll pay more for an 80g ata133 drive than you will a 160g ata133 drive. Saw some at Fry's, new in box, for $69 this week.

    6. Re:YAY by jridley · · Score: 1

      I haven't paid more than $600 for a new machine in a while. $160 for the CPU/mainboard (all-on-board stuff, I've been using an Abit board and Athlon 2500+), $50 case+PS, $99 17" monitor, $70 for 512M RAM, $40 for DVDROM+CDRW, $30 for kbd/mouse, 2 years and it still looks fine.

  4. Been there, done that by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    How is this different from just using a regular external hard drive? My roomate has installed Mac OS X on his iPod and exclusively uses that as his mobile platform. Just find a Mac and plug it in.

    1. Re:Been there, done that by Twid · · Score: 1


      OSX has better support for functions like this. Not only does most apple hardware that can run OSX support firewire booting, but also the operating system itself stores all custom configuration data in the user's home directory under ~/Library. So, if you just want a roaming home directory on an external hard drive that's really easy to do, assuming you stick to built-in apps.

      However, in this case the end-user is completely booting Mandrake from the external USB drive, much like you would boot Knoppix from a CD. While you could do that on OSX, I'm willing to bet your roomie is just taking his home directory with him, not booting the whole OS from the iPod. The iPod would work for that, but it would be a bit slow because of the slow drive in the iPod.

      --
      - "When you want something with all your heart, the entire universe conspires to give it to you" -Paulo Coelho
    2. Re:Been there, done that by name773 · · Score: 1

      i don't see how he could log in with just a home directory

    3. Re:Been there, done that by XeRXeS-TCN · · Score: 1

      Certainly a good way to go, if you have the convenience of a Mac wherever you go, but for general day-to-day travel, be it work, or friends' houses, etc, you tend to find that you're far more likely to encounter a PC; not much use for a copy of OSX in that event.

      Not to mention the fact that if you encounter a Mac, chances are that Mac OS X will already be on it; there isn't much point in booting into a *different* copy of OS X just to sit and surf the net or other tasks. You could just use the existing system, and copy any downloads or other files to or from the iPod from there. There's *some* justification for it in the case of email settings and things, but beyond that it seems somewhat superfluous for anything other than system restores.

      One of the points of having a GNU/Linux system on hand means that no matter what wierd or wonderful system is running on a given PC, whether it be an unfamiliar GNU/Linux environment (Like KDE, when you prefer GNOME, or a command line instead of a GUI), or a BSD variant, or BeOS, QNX, Unix, Windows, or any other wierd and wonderful system, you will be able to boot into your own system and play around. Yes, there are GNU/Linux systems for the Mac, but by and large they'll be running OS X. The sheer volume of operating systems available for the x86 platform is enough justification for having your familiar system on hand at all times (Especially in the case of the GNU/Linux zealots, so that they don't have to endure a Windows system even when they're out and about ;p).

      If nothing else, it's really a good opportunity for a GNU/Linux company to make money in a different way. Selling a portable hard drive with a free operating system is a good justification for selling hardware (like the mini usb drive you get with MandrakeMove), and it is relatively innovative, meaning that people who (a) May want to purchase a portable harddrive *anyway*, and/or (b) appreciate the convenience or novelty of the system, will be eager to purchase one.

    4. Re:Been there, done that by boredMDer · · Score: 1

      OS X was going to include home directory on iPod support, but it was dropped late in the development cycle.

      Might be a feature of Tiger.

    5. Re:Been there, done that by Krunch · · Score: 1

      It run Linux you insensitive clod !

      Seriously this as been possible for years now, the news is that a company is selling it.

      --
      No GNU has been Hurd during the making of this comment.
  5. Cheaper by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    1) Download Mandrake
    2) Get the cheapest 40 GB hard drive with USB support you can buy.
    3) Voila!

    1. Re:Cheaper by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not so simple. You also have to build USB support into the Kernel so it doesn't panick (modules don't work as they load too late).

    2. Re:Cheaper by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Stupid fuck, only saves a couple of bucks.

    3. Re:Cheaper by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      4) ??? 5) Profit!!!

    4. Re:Cheaper by Zaiff+Urgulbunger · · Score: 1

      Surely the price of portable HD's should come down soon given that SATA drives cost nearly the same as ATA drives but are hot swapable?

    5. Re:Cheaper by Nyder · · Score: 1

      umm, you can get 3.5" 7200 rpm 40gig drives for around $40 to $50. External Box with USB 2.0 (possible can get one with Firewire) $20+.
      Or you can go laptop 2.5" drives:
      40 gigs around $100, plus $20 for external box (I have 3 of the boxes).
      with these I can get the power off the usb/ps/2 port, while the 3.5 require external power supply. plus the 3.5 drives you can put bigger drives in. I have 2 external boxes that are about 3x8x1 inches, one has both firewire400 and usb 2.0, the other is just usb 2.0 I like those because I can move stuff between all my systems and friends computers. I didn't warm up to my external 2.5 drives because it was smaller, slower, and for some reason, the power from the usb port on my laptop was not enough to poswer it (i used my ps/2 port for the power).

      I think you are mostly paying for then installing the software onto the drives. But then, they only have to tailor the software once. Maybe they'll release the version they made for those.

      --
      Be seeing you...
  6. Costly? by rpbailey1642 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    After reading the article, I wonder what exactly makes it so special? Perhaps the convenience of the entire setup, but for 40 gig, you would expect a lower price. I can get a USB enclosure for a hard drive for $30.00 here or perhaps elsewhere for even less. A 200 gig HD from tigerdirect.com is $89.99. Don't get me wrong, I am really excited to see Linux systems set up like this, but the price kind of threw me off.

    1. Re:Costly? by precogpunk · · Score: 4, Insightful

      You are paying more because Mandrake needs to:
      1. Secure a steady supply of hardware to meet demand.
      2. Install and configure the OS on the hardware.
      3. Write a manual.
      4. Provide tech support for the product.
      5. Market the new product.
      6. Profit.

    2. Re:Costly? by kunudo · · Score: 1

      This seems just like any of the other marketing blurbs /. has hosted lately... Oh well..

      The default theme mandrake comes with is ugly too... :/

    3. Re:Costly? by Rakishi · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I assume they use a mobile (ie 2.5") hd so that the enclosure can be powered by usb. Those aren't all that cheap compared to normal hds.

    4. Re:Costly? by aclarke · · Score: 4, Insightful
      I couldn't see right away from their web site, but I'm 99% positive they're using a 2.5" laptop drive. So a better comparison would be something like a 40GB Drive for $100

      Just so you know, every 3.5" drive enclosure I've ever seen requires a separate power supply. 3.5" disks require too much power to be reliably run from USB or firewire. This is one reason why a 2.5" drive solution is much better for portability.

      So, take $130 of hardware and add $90 for my time to put the drive in the enclosure, install Mandrake, etc. and it doesn't seem like such a bad deal to me.

    5. Re:Costly? by danimrich · · Score: 1

      I guess Mandrake uses a mobile drive so that it can be powered via the USB port in most cases. Also, you're paying for the Porsche Design, if you like it or not...

      Now we should be waiting for standard hard drives that come with Linux preinstalled-this could be a great boost to Linux acceptance.

      --
      where's all that Karma?
    6. Re:Costly? by MmmDee · · Score: 1
      ...add $90 for my time to put the drive in the enclosure, install Mandrake , etc and it doesn't seem like such a bad deal to me.

      And folks really wonder why so much is being outsourced to India? Now if you had said something like, "plus typical oem markup", I might have bought into that figure; however, in today's minimal profit margin days, I'm not sure that's a realistic number.

      --
      No man's an island, unless he's had too much to drink and wets the bed.
    7. Re:Costly? by Compuser · · Score: 1

      First off, complete usb pocket drives go for $90.
      Check pricewatch. This is before bulk discounts.
      Second, $90 for your work. How? I can buy assembled
      usb drive for $90 and now I just write a little
      script to format and rawrite the drive. None of
      this requires any thinking so even in the US it
      would be a minimum wage job to plug drives into
      USB and press a button, then package. So more
      realistically $5 for putting Mandrake on it.
      If they give you Mandrake support with it then that
      could be worth $40. So I think a fair price would be:
      $140 - with Mandrake support
      $100 - no support
      Maybe add $10 for Lacie brand name.

    8. Re:Costly? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If it is a compact 1.8" 40 GB USB hard drive powered from the USB cable, the hard disk drive alone cost about $200. The price is reasonable with the bundled Mandrake Linux installed. You pay for the convenience for its size, and no need for an external power supply.

  7. speed ??? by selderrr · · Score: 4, Insightful

    With USB2, its feasible, but I surely wouldn't boot off a USB1 device unless realy no other options are available. Or the machine has so much ram, I barely acces my swap.

  8. am i the only one.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    am I the only one that finds the default Mandrake theme really ugly?

    Why didn't they just go with Plastik or whatever?

    1. Re:am i the only one.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

      Dude - that's a mirror, not a computer screen

    2. Re:am i the only one.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Damn, someone else must find that one funny too :-D

  9. anyone else... by dj245 · · Score: 1
    read that as "Multiple users can be imagined"?

    because a drive that imagines users to use it would probably make for a better selling product than a mobile USB drive.

    --
    Even those who arrange and design shrubberies are under considerable economic stress at this period in history.
    1. Re:anyone else... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No.

  10. "For computers that don't support booting from USB by Myself · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I've never seen "USB" as an option in the "A, C, CDROM" selections in any BIOS setup program I've ever touched. Is it handled somewhere else, or is it just very rare among ~1-year-old hardware?

    Carrying along a bootable CD and a USB storage device sort of defeats the purpose.

    Loadlin would be a natural for this thing...

  11. Boot off USB by gtoomey · · Score: 1

    Presumably this is only for newer motherboards that can boot off USB.

    1. Re:Boot off USB by PeteQC · · Score: 1

      IF you take time to RTFA, you'll see that it comes with a CD for when your hardware doesn't boot from USB...

      --
      Montreal - Best city to live in!
  12. I hope there are no corners on the drive ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    because if anyone uses these on any site where I am responsible for IT infrastructure and security they will definitely appreciate something with smooth contours.

    You know where it will end up ;-)

    But seriously, these things sound like a major security problem waiting to happen. Imagine some 'visitor' who comes to your establishment, plugs into an unused computer and starts probing and sucking at your network.

    It's a damn nightmare

    1. Re:I hope there are no corners on the drive ... by Scud · · Score: 1

      But seriously, these things sound like a major security problem waiting to happen. Imagine some 'visitor' who comes to your establishment, plugs into an unused computer and starts probing and sucking at your network.

      Agreed. But this differs from Knopplix in what way?

      The fact of the matter is that once you leave your PC unattended, no amount security is going to save you.

      John

      --
      I dream in binary.
    2. Re:I hope there are no corners on the drive ... by Fragmented_Datagram · · Score: 1

      And they couldn't already do this by bringing in a laptop and plugging it into a network port? Or a USB thumb drive with a bootable Linux distro on it?

    3. Re:I hope there are no corners on the drive ... by Feyr · · Score: 1

      cryptoloop, just gotta get lusers to use it (and unmount it when done)

    4. Re:I hope there are no corners on the drive ... by Zaiff+Urgulbunger · · Score: 1

      Along with all the other comments re risks from Knoppix CD's and laptops being plugged into your network, you *could* if you're really concerned and have a computer in a less secure area, "reconfigure" the USD ports with a set of pliers? Physically screwing the port up obviously limits future system expansion potential but depending on your requirements this might be fine. At worst, you'd have to install a USB PCI card at a later date.

    5. Re:I hope there are no corners on the drive ... by jonadab · · Score: 1

      > The fact of the matter is that once you leave your PC unattended, no
      > amount security is going to save you.

      There are some things you can do, they're just a much bigger pain than locking
      up the system in a room with tigers and cobras and security cameras. For
      example, you can use an encrypted filesystem that requires a long key to be
      entered on the keyboard at boot time. That leaves you open to a sniffing
      attack with a KeyGhost or similar device, or clever placement of a hidden
      camera to record your typing in the key. There are ways to guard against that
      too, by using a challenge and response type method to unlock the encrypted
      filesystem, but that can get very complex and require quite a lot out of the
      user. (Of course, if you don't reboot very often, that would help minimize
      the annoyance factor... but then you don't use the authentication system
      very often, so you're very liable to forget it, at which point you now have
      to write it down and lock that up in a safe...) This amounts to quite a lot
      of hassle, and it really would be simpler to lock the system in a room with
      dogs and guards.

      Additionally, all of this stuff still allows the user to boot your hardware
      (albeit not your software) and probably get onto the network, though, so
      then you have to harden your network against internal attacks, which means
      careful firewalling and stuff. Which, admittedly, you theoretically should
      do anyway, in principle, but I suspect most of us don't.

      --
      Cut that out, or I will ship you to Norilsk in a box.
    6. Re:I hope there are no corners on the drive ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      dmcrypt + udev is more fun

  13. knoppix by prestwich · · Score: 1

    Or you could just carry a Knoppix cd with you.
    (and if you are really paranoid about the machines you might come up against a bootable USB-CDrom drive).

  14. Credible alternative to a laptop? by nherc · · Score: 3, Informative
    And for $219 it's a credible alternative to a laptop.
    Yeah, if you can find a laptop to plug it into...

    Perhaps it's a credible alternative to a remote login to your main computer. You are still going to need to find an existing computer to plug this thing into though.

    --
    'He was a dreamer, a thinker, a speculative philosopher... or, as his wife would have it, an idiot.' - Douglas Adams
    1. Re:Credible alternative to a laptop? by jonadab · · Score: 1

      > Perhaps it's a credible alternative to a remote login to your main computer.
      > You are still going to need to find an existing computer to plug this thing
      > into though.

      That wouldn't be a problem in North America (when was the last time you were
      more than three rooms away from a computer, really?), except for the fact that
      the PC in question needs to be set up to boot from USB, which narrows down
      your options rather a lot, since approximately zero percent of the installed
      base of PCs out there are set up to do that. It's not even an *option* on
      most BIOSes, and one imagines that even on systems with the capability the
      default would still be to boot via a more traditional source, such as the
      first floppy drive, or a hard drive or ATAPI CD-ROM drive on one of the IDE
      channels.

      Many modern systems have, in theory, the capability to boot off the network --
      but it's seldom the default. You could carry around a smallish LTSP server
      and a crossover cable, but plugging it into most systems wouldn't get you
      anywhere, because they're not set up to boot that way.

      Of course, if you have unobserved physical access to the system you could
      *alter* the way it's set up, but at that point this ceases to be a benign
      hey-can-I-borrow-your-hardware-for-a-few-m oments thing and becomes rather
      more invasive. And there are still a lot of systems that don't even have
      the capability to boot from USB.

      It's an interesting concept, but the LiveCD + portable data drive solution
      (a la MandrakeMove) seems more realistically useful at this point.

      --
      Cut that out, or I will ship you to Norilsk in a box.
    2. Re:Credible alternative to a laptop? by jonadab · · Score: 1

      > the PC in question needs to be set up to boot from USB

      Actually, I just noticed that it comes with a bootable mini-CD to get around
      that issue. I suspect you'd end up using that most of the time. Does anyone
      know whether the CD then boots the USB drive as the root partition, so that
      you can function as if you'd booted from it directly, once you're booted? If
      it does, then that would give it some advantages over other LiveCD + USB drive
      options (e.g. MandrakeMove), since you could e.g. easily install upgrades.

      --
      Cut that out, or I will ship you to Norilsk in a box.
    3. Re:Credible alternative to a laptop? by slutsker · · Score: 1

      Or, you could just be reasonable and keep all important files on a computer not physically accessible to anyone.

  15. Viable alternative to a laptop? by gexen · · Score: 4, Interesting

    First off, I think it's great that a distribution is doing this. If you're a Linux evangelist, I would imagine a Live-CD may not do everything you want to do.

    But, the main point of this post is to ask how is this a viable alternative to a laptop? I always defined viable alternative as a product that offers a similiar product set designed to do the same job. How exactly is a hard drive loaded with Linux comprable to a laptop?

    1. Re:Viable alternative to a laptop? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Many people use a laptop so that they can seamlessly keep working once they get home, rather than maintaining two copies of everything. This will allow this.

      I know this is one of the main reasons I use a laptop.

  16. You must be smoking a viable alternative to crack by untaken_name · · Score: 5, Funny

    There is no way that an external hard drive is equivalent to a laptop. This thing doesn't have a keyboard or screen. What are you going to do on the plane, show it off to the other passengers? Viable alternative. mutter.

  17. Yes and no. by hotspotbloc · · Score: 2, Interesting
    Sounds like an easy way to hijack data off a system that you dont have the password to log into yourself.

    Very true unless there's no hard drive in the workstation. If everyone using it is also using this external HD one wouldn't be needed.

    --
    "I hate to advocate drugs, alcohol, violence or insanity but they've always worked for me" - HST
  18. I'll need more space by xactuary · · Score: 2, Funny

    ...to grab the entire contents of a G5 at the Apple Store.

    --
    Say hello to my little sig.
  19. Re:Imagine... by Bricklets · · Score: 3, Funny

    Imagine ... a beowulf cluster of these.

    Why don't you imagine a beowulf cluster of slashdot moderators modding you down instead...

    Oh no! They're coming after me!!

    --
    Little Bricklets
  20. Just not practical. by jonathan_atkinson · · Score: 1, Insightful

    This'll only be useful when 95% of computers support booting from USB. Right now, only 5% do, so you'd just be pissing away the $219.

    --Jon

    --
    Cleanstick.org: Dumb weblog about nothing
    1. Re:Just not practical. by ryanjensen · · Score: 5, Informative

      RTFA, you and everyone else who said this ... the drive also comes with a mini-CD that contains a bootloader and a recovery program. If your computer can boot off CD (much more than 5%) it can boot the to the LaCie drive.

    2. Re:Just not practical. by name773 · · Score: 1

      just include a bootable cd that can access the thing. (another post said that's what they do)

    3. Re:Just not practical. by Brandybuck · · Score: 1

      So then it's not as convenient as just walking around with a portable harddrive and jacking it in to random systems, but you also need to carry around the CD as well. Most of the unbridled enthusiasm the story blurb is trying to get you to share in sort of evaporates once you realize that.

      --
      Don't blame me, I didn't vote for either of them!
    4. Re:Just not practical. by pyrrhonist · · Score: 2, Informative
      So then it's not as convenient as just walking around with a portable harddrive and jacking it in to random systems, but you also need to carry around the CD as well.

      Actually it's more convenient, because most machines are able to boot off a CD by default, so you don't have to mess with the BIOS. Furthermore, it's a mini-CD, so it's not like it takes up a lot of extra room.

      --
      Show me on the doll where his noodly appendage touched you.
    5. Re:Just not practical. by Brandybuck · · Score: 1

      Walking around with a harddrive and CD is "more convenient" than walking around with just a harddrive? What wierd strange world do you come from?

      Yes, I understand what you mean, because setting up a system to boot from a USB device is a major pain in the butt. But the whole concept behind this harddrive seems strange to me. It seems a high price to pay in both dollars and ounces, for a faster Knoppix.

      --
      Don't blame me, I didn't vote for either of them!
    6. Re:Just not practical. by 87C751 · · Score: 1
      Furthermore, it's a mini-CD, so it's not like it takes up a lot of extra room.
      <homer>
      So I'll just take my mini-CD and... wha? A slot-loading CD drive?!? D'oh!!
      </homer>
      --
      Mail? Put "slashdot" in the subject to pass the spam filters.
    7. Re:Just not practical. by pyrrhonist · · Score: 1
      Walking around with a harddrive and CD is "more convenient" than walking around with just a harddrive? What wierd strange world do you come from?

      I live in a weird strange world where most machines don't boot from CD by default. It is far more convienent to just put the CD in and boot the machine than it is to try to find the correct BIOS settings (or find out that the machine in question doesn't have them).

      Like I said before, it's a mini-CD, not an 8" floppy. It fits in a shirt pocket. It's not any more inconvenient than carrying around the HD.

      --
      Show me on the doll where his noodly appendage touched you.
    8. Re:Just not practical. by pyrrhonist · · Score: 1
      So I'll just take my mini-CD and... wha? A slot-loading CD drive?!? D'oh!!

      Or a CD drive mounted sideways!

      --
      Show me on the doll where his noodly appendage touched you.
  21. Quick! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Update your BIOS firmware!

  22. Re:"For computers that don't support booting from by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    I've never NOT seen it among motherboards manufactured in the past 3 years. Even our server (Dual Athlon MP)motherboard has it.

  23. Re:Imagine... by M51DPS · · Score: 1

    But does it run..... nevermind.

  24. a new meaning to "who do you want to hack today?" by KingPunk · · Score: 1

    wow. who would've thought of such an idea?
    im suprised somebody hasnt already
    ..erm they have. http://slax.linux-live.org/
    not to mention many other distros, many of which are made for just such a feat..
    http://featherlinux.berlios.de/ but in all regaurds, atleast its now "cool"
    to have a usb key drive, with a top 5 distro on it.
    (top 5, rh, suse, mandrake, slackware, debian)

    who knows where this will take us. but i invision a future where we'll all cary this little chip around,
    with all our personal information in it, personal files, etc. ("big brother's dream")
    so that we can be more "productive & efficent"
    lord knows where the personal privacy will sease and "common good" begins.
    /end rant

  25. Been there, done that, give you the tee shirt? by astrojetsonjr · · Score: 5, Informative
    40 GB laptop disk $84 - Bascon Computers
    USB 2 case (with keyboard power cable for those PC's with lame USB ports) $32 - Bascon Computers
    Knoppix $0 - the web
    Portability Priceless

    Fits in your pocket, you can carry your system all the time. Most places are starting to care about USB drives so check before you plug in.

    The nice thing is you always have your code, your custom toolchain, music, etc. Like you never left home.

    (OK, so you have to set up Knoppix and that will take an hour or two, far less than it takes you to build that XP box from scratch) - ob Windows vs. Linux dig

  26. Maybe I'm underthinking this.. by DrNibbler · · Score: 1

    I've been doing a lot of home support lately and carry with me an Insert Rescue CD and USB drive for those cases where I need to do backups or need to work with the windows drive in some way. Functionality-wise how is this different from a Knoppix CD and USB drive? I don't see this as new or special.

    --
    Sean.OutaHere()
    1. Re:Maybe I'm underthinking this.. by briber · · Score: 1

      Allright, I'll bite. Suppose you want to show off some of the neat features of Linux to some friends in a college computer lab. In my opinion, one of the most compelling features is intelligent package management. You show this feature off by opening a terminal window and running APT or by launching Synaptic. Then you select the package you want to install, and then... Oh, that's right, YOU booted off a CD. Sorry!

    2. Re:Maybe I'm underthinking this.. by PeteQC · · Score: 1

      Probably the possibility to carry around your own configuration. Correct me if I'm wrong but I don't think that you can "customize" your feature on Knoppix and carry them around.

      One advantage that I see here is that you could change your Linux configuration and have your changes with you on every desktop you use. If they release a new version of OpenOffice (or Mozilla or GIMP...) I would believe you could update your packages...

      --
      Montreal - Best city to live in!
    3. Re:Maybe I'm underthinking this.. by kcb93x · · Score: 1

      You can customize Knoppix, but AFAIK it's a bit of a PITA, so I wouldn't do it unless it was for a large lab (non-modifiable reset on reboot images, anyone?) or massive deployment.

      So this would be a wise choice, for anyone who needs portability, and has access to systems where they are working, but would like their Linux to come with them.

      --
      There are 4 boxes to use in the defense of liberty: soap, ballot, jury, ammo. Use in that order. Starting now.
  27. Laptop Alternative? by nurb432 · · Score: 1

    Umm i dont think so.. to be an alternative it would need a keyboard and display and network...

    This just replaces a smaller flash drive... More storage...

    --
    ---- Booth was a patriot ----
  28. Me neither. by cbreaker · · Score: 1

    Maybe the super-new ones *might* have this option - but not any of them I've seen and I've seen some brand new (past month) boards.

    It sure will be sweet when this is mainstream; boot up a copy of whatever OS and do some troubleshooting or virus removal. Or even just some easy file copies.

    --
    - It's not the Macs I hate. It's Digg users. -
    1. Re:Me neither. by sirReal.83. · · Score: 1
      I'm a little more realistic:

      It sure will be sweet when it's mainstream to know what the term 'OS' means.

      ;p

    2. Re:Me neither. by cbreaker · · Score: 1

      Not sure what you mean. It would be good for a computer-litterate person to be able to boot off of USB; I didn't say anything to the contrary to that.

      --
      - It's not the Macs I hate. It's Digg users. -
  29. Re:"For computers that don't support booting from by interiot · · Score: 4, Interesting
    It doesn't completely defeat the purpose:
    • If the CD only needs to boot, load USB drivers, and hand off control to the USB drive, it can be shrunk to a business-card CD. I'm guessing that a business-card CD + 2.5" hard drive isn't any less convenient than one full-size CD.
    • With 40GB available, you can have 58 times as many programs available as you can with a 700MB CD.
    • Hard drives can be written to as well as read from, so you can use it to carry documents and MP3s along with you, and don't have to stream these over the network like you'd have to with Knoppix.
    In short, it's waaaaay more functional than a bootable CD.
  30. Gentoo should do this too.. by Junta · · Score: 4, Funny

    It would be simple to use whatever system you come across as a linux system. Simply plug in the drive, boot, bootstrap, emerge system, compile a kernel, build some choice packages, wait a few days and voila, instant gentoo box.

    -Note: this is a joke.

    --
    XML is like violence. If it doesn't solve the problem, use more.
    1. Re:Gentoo should do this too.. by 87C751 · · Score: 1
      -Note: this is a joke.
      Point of reference: I installed Gentoo on my Latitude CP (233MMX, 128MB) a couple weeks ago. 'emerge gdesklets-base desklet-psidisplays desklet-psisensors' took about 36 hours (for 112 packages, including Gnome).

      Still, you only have to do it once.

      --
      Mail? Put "slashdot" in the subject to pass the spam filters.
  31. Re:"For computers that don't support booting from by MmmDee · · Score: 1
    For what it's worth, there's some discussion at experts exchange at this link

    http://www.experts-exchange.com/Hardware/Laptops_N otebooks/Q_20934463.html

    that suggests there are a few laptops anyways that can boot from USB HD's. A Google search for "motherboard bootable USB" returned >250 hits.

    --
    No man's an island, unless he's had too much to drink and wets the bed.
  32. They charge $100 for the OS! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Why it is so expensive? You can get a USB 2 box for a 2.5 inch drive for $25 (Check Fry's or Outpost) and you can get a 40GB 2.5 inch drive for less than $100. It follows that they charge about $100 for the OS, whih is way too much: in my opinion they should not charge more than $40. Today the laptop drive are so cheap, you can get am 80GB drive for for $150(Pcprogress, basoncomputer). Moreover, Bason computer sells firewire/usb2 boxes with 80GB laptop drives inside for $209. (the empty combo box is about $60). You could buy this 80GB box, install linux yourself, save $9, you have twice the size and have both firewire and USB2 ports!

    I did this about 2 months ago, I installed my preferred Linux distribution, SuSE 91 on a combo box.

    LaCie is traditionally a Mac company, and for this reason they charge a lot. NEVER BUY FROM THEM.!

    1. Re:They charge $100 for the OS! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sure,. as illustrated by you posting here: your time is worth nothing.

  33. Re:a new meaning to "who do you want to hack today by nzkbuk · · Score: 1

    You forgot to point out that slackware was doing this on zipdisks how many years ago now ?

  34. Re:You must be smoking a viable alternative to cra by jhoger · · Score: 4, Informative

    Myself, I gave up on modern "portables" some time back. Battery life sucks so bad, they always need to be plugged in. They heat up like a mo-fo. The keyboards invariably suck. And their hard drives are serious underperformers.

    Since I need to plug in anyway, as a contractor, when I need to go on-site, I take my Shuttle XPC in a little cart, with a real buckling-spring UNICOMP keyboard. It's got 2GB of RAM and a fast CPU, can run VMWare handily so I can launch Winders from my Debian system as necessary.

    I just use the monitor at whatever desk the client decides to assign me for the day.

    If I carry a laptop any more it's a Tandy Model 102, and I just use it for editing text. Now that thing is portable... 20 hours on 4 AA batteries, passes the drop test, and has an excellent keyboard. I transfer files to/from via the serial port.

    We're working on a memory/flash storage expansion for it at http://bitchin100.com/remem_project.html

    -- John.

  35. What this thing needs by Jah-Wren+Ryel · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It needs hardware encryption so that the disk is useless without the right pass-phrase, and optionally a hardware token like a separate USB pendrive (or compact flash, whatever) with a really big one-time pad on it. And I mean real encryption like AES or Blowfish, or at least triple-DES. Not something that Joe-Bob and his little beowulf cluster can crack in a week or too.

    --
    When information is power, privacy is freedom.
    1. Re:What this thing needs by GekkePrutser · · Score: 1

      It needs hardware encryption so that the disk is useless without the right pass-phrase, and optionally a hardware token like a separate USB pendrive (or compact flash, whatever) with a really big one-time pad on it. If you want to encrypt the entire 40GB harddrive with a one-time-pad, you would need a one-time-pad of at least 40GB. Try to fit that on a pendrive :-)

  36. NEVER buy from LaCie, they are very expensive by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    They are a primarily a Mac periferal company and for this reason overcharge you a lot (100% or so) Of course, Mac users are too stupid to realize that they pay too much.

    On the other hand, linux users are very cheap, for them even a difference of $5 or $10 matters, they know all great online places with no brand name, cheap hardware manufactured in Asia, they will never buy overpriced stuff from LaCie.

    Today the market is saturated with cheap, no brand name portable stuff from Asia, pocket portable drives, pocket DVD writers for half price, etc. The Asian manufacturers cut corners, no technical support, no installation manuals, no software. Anyway, linux users dont need all these things. No Nero is needed for burning DVDs under linux!. Since these Asian things are so cheap, if they break just throw them away, you can afford it, for the price of one brand name item, you can get two non brand name items.

  37. Re:You must be smoking a viable alternative to cra by Y2K+is+bogus · · Score: 1

    IBM Thinkpad A30p

    'Nuff said

  38. Noy true, you save about $100 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Besides, you have fun configuring and customizing linux yourself, according to your needs.

    Configuring and customizing the OS is one of the greatest pleasures related to the linux experience, please DONT TAKE THIS AWAY FROM US!

  39. Re:"For computers that don't support booting from by Ziviyr · · Score: 2, Interesting

    With 40GB available, you can have 58 times [google.com] as many programs available as you can with a 700MB CD.

    If we're talking typical case (knoppix) then since the harddrive likely won't be compressed, its only a matter of 20 times as many programs.

    Moving on to the days of DVDs things are going to get even less impressive in that regard...

    --

    Someone set us up the bomb, so shine we are!
  40. This is cool. Naysayers be damnned! by LibrePensador · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Damn, it is hard to please the slashdot crowd. It's too expensive, how is this different from knoppix?

    Well, I find it very inexpensive and convenient. Yes, I could probably do this myself, but I happen to like Mandrake's distribution and this gives me the chance to support my favorite distribution in an all-in-one package that is easy to use.

    If you think you can do it reliably and more cheaply than Mandrake, please by all means give them some competition.

    But I, for one, love Mandrake. It is the fastest distribution of the latest round I tried (Suse 9.1, Fedora 2, Slackware 10) and it is very stable. I also happen to like Suse 9.1 quite a bit for certain uses, but overall lean much more strongly towards Mandrake, but I digress.

    I love this idea. You will be able to take your desktop with you everywhere without needing to use Knoppix. Knoppix is very nice, but this gives you another way to reach portability and will be faster since it runs off a HD, rather than off the CD. You can take music, documents with you and have your fully personalized desktop available anywhere where a computer is available.

    This is more convenient than a laptop in some regards as it doesn't need to be recharged and is less conspicuous and thus less likely to be stolen.

    And I don't know about you, but I can find a computer I can plug into just about anywhere, whether it's at a friend's or a relative's house, the library...

    I think Mandrake is working very hard and they are making incredible progress. I have tested their 10.1 Beta 2 and it is already very, very good, although I would caution new users to wait for the *Official* release, not community, and definitely not RCs.

    --
    Pragmatism as an ideology is not particularly pragmatic in the long term. Keep it in mind when you dismiss Free Software
    1. Re:This is cool. Naysayers be damnned! by BCW2 · · Score: 1

      I think you hit all the good reasons for this. The idea of going anwhere and having your own desktop and files is very nice. I think I will do it with an 80GB drive and put Suse on it. Students could use it at school and have a reliable system instead M$.

      --
      Professional Politicians are not the solution, they ARE the problem.
  41. Re:"For computers that don't support booting from by interiot · · Score: 1
    And guess why you don't see anybody using compressed file systems on their hard drives any more? Because they're too slow, nobody uses them unless they're really forced to. So you've added a fourth bullet point:
    • Faster access than a knoppix CD-ROM

    While I'm here posting, just thought I'd link to NewEgg's huge selection of 2.5 " enclosures, the model numbers really makes it easy to research them.

  42. Re:"For computers that don't support booting from by interiot · · Score: 1

    And here is an article on ibm.com about how to do the trick where the kernel is booted from a floppy/CD, finds the USB mass storage device, mounts it, and uses it as the root filesystems. And another article here. Looks pretty straightforward.

  43. Re:Imagine... by bhtooefr · · Score: 0, Redundant

    Well, can you do a USB RAID on x86 hardware? I've read about a five-USB-floppy OS X (IIRC, it might have been OS 9) RAID, but never anything on x86.

    Of course, a two-JumpDrive RAID 0 might be kinda nice, especially if one only has USB1.1...

  44. Re:You must be smoking a viable alternative to cra by Myself · · Score: 1

    Ahh, Bitchin100 earned a bookmark :) I use mine for more than editing text though, it's a handy little serial terminal for all sorts of tasks. (I seem to have lost the picture of mine plugged into the console port of an oc-192 terminal with the config prompt up.)

    Look for an older, larger laptop with option bays that'll accept batteries. Consider that the machine load-shares between them, so the demand from each individual battery is lower, which makes them more efficient. (Two batteries, each of which runs the machine for 2 hours when used alone, will probably give you 5 hours when used together.)

  45. It ain't a laptop. It is linux on windows machines by SmallFurryCreature · · Score: 1
    I like my linux desktop for work. Sadly I don't always got the choice to install it on work machines. With this I can turn any windows machine into my desktop. Exactly as I got it at home including all those usefull utilities.

    Pretty smart. I could of course lug my own laptop around but that is a lot more expensive and you will be working on a laptop. Not a high end pc.

    This is more like knoppix but with its own HD for easy storage of preferences and adding new applications.

    --

    MMO Quests are like orgasms:

    You may solo them, I prefer them in a group.

  46. Re:You must be smoking a viable alternative to cra by Jeff+DeMaagd · · Score: 1

    Consider a Pentium M based laptop. The laptops that suck are usually based on desktop Pentium 4 chips, those are the kind that sucks batteries and the CPU burns hot like a fire, because they weren't meant to be put into a laptop, period.

    Several models can take 2GB of RAM, and can be had with 2MB cache and a 2GHz clock rate. Being P6-based means that it has a good instructions per cycle (IPC) unlike Pentium 4 chips. You can get efficient laptop hard drives that still run at 7200 RPM.

  47. Re:"For computers that don't support booting from by boredMDer · · Score: 2, Funny

    One problem with those mini CDs, though - if you encounter a machine with a slot-load drive that can't boot off of USB, you can't boot the drake installation.

    Well, you can try, but one would be an idiot to put any other than a full sized CD/DVD in a slotload drive - it may go in, but it probably isn't coming back out.

  48. almost 16 years ago by LennyDotCom · · Score: 1

    I had a externel scsi hd that I could plug into ANY Mac and boot MY desktop.
    This is a little old for mac users

    --
    http://Lenny.com
  49. Re:"For computers that don't support booting from by Guppy06 · · Score: 4, Funny

    "I've never seen "USB" as an option in the "A, C, CDROM"

    You young whipper-snappers with your "CD-ROM boot" and your "network boot" are all a bunch of sissies and don't know it! Why, back in my day you were given one option: floppy drive! Hard drives were too expensive and required a team of oxen to get the durned things spinning, so everything was on a truckload of floppy disks.

    And when I say floppy, I mean floppy! Those things were flopper than you were when you walked in on your grandmother and I this morning! Have you ever tried putting a pancake into a disk drive?

    Them rich snots down the street, they had one of them new-fangled "double density" drive. Managed to get PC-DOS down to less than half a dozen disks (unless you included GW-BASIC!). Us, we were stuck with single sided, single density. Do you have any idea how many of those it takes to fit just one Library of Congress on? Station wagons full!

    "Network boot..." bah! We had a network! It didn't just look like a garden hose, it was a garden hose! We'd roll one of our floppy disks up and shove it in and blow it on through to our friends in order to share our music files!

    You ever hear Asia being played by your internal speaker, boy?

  50. Re:a new meaning to "who do you want to hack today by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    well yeah. but i thought the whole idea, was usb
    not zip. zip was a good idea at the time.. but pesh
    usb owns zip nowadays. heh.

    you're right though. however. slax-linux is mostly
    a live-linux version of slackware, on livecd or usb
    and its actually quite nice. i like the whole idea
    of custom module building etc, so you can talor it to your needs, easier. thats something knoppix and many others should really look into.

    but yeah, peace, smartass ;)

  51. Re:You must be smoking a viable alternative to cra by mottie · · Score: 1

    Agreed. I get home from work at 6pm and don't have to plugin til between 11 and midnight. (for reference I'm on an IBM Thinkpad R40) Sure better battery life would be good, but 5.5 hours is longer than most flights, bus rides, etc.

  52. Re:"For computers that don't support booting from by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Yeah, I hear you. But slick hackers like myself used to punch holes in our single sided floppies to utilize the other side. Sure, they claimed that the double sided floppies were thicker... but I never had a problem.

    My old thought was: "Who needs a HD if you're not running a BBS?"

    If you've set up a PCBoard, WildCAT, or Searchlight BBS - you're old. If you've used an acustical 300baud modem... you're as old as me.

    And hell, I'm not 30 yet! (started hacking a Atari 800xl when I was 7years old - serious programming).

  53. Is it quiet? Does it have a fan? by Qwavel · · Score: 1


    I can't tell from the website whether it has a fan. If it has a fan it is probably too noisy. Can someone with any LaCie 2.5" external drive tell me whether their's is quiet?

    That's great that it gets its power from the USB port. Having to carry around an AC/DC adapter would significantly reduce the portability.

  54. But you have to reboot a working machine! by The+Panther! · · Score: 1

    I'm surprised nobody has mentioned this, but I rather think it's strange that a Linux distro would be in favor of forcibly rebooting a machine just to start your own. I mean, at my office and all the offices I've worked at previously, computers stay on 24/7 and only reboot when IT decided to dump a bunch of Wind0ze updates on us. The Unix/Linux boxen never rebooted unless there was hardware failure involved.

    Even if someone isn't present that day, there's usually something going on that shouldn't be disturbed, even if it's browser windows being open or a notepad window editing text. Finding a machine thats 'safe' to cycle power on is pretty unusual.

    I was really excited about the prospects, especially if it were hijacking the main machine's hardware via USB live through Windows or another Linux install, but I fail to find any real value in this offering. It's interesting, sure, but not if it requires rebooting.

    --
    Any connection between your reality and mine is purely coincidental.
    1. Re:But you have to reboot a working machine! by lachlan76 · · Score: 1

      And how would you load an operating system without rebooting, or using VMWare?

  55. use an iPod instead. by DillMan · · Score: 1

    This makes me wonder, is it possible to do this sort of thing off an iPod? think of the possibilities.

    1. Re:use an iPod instead. by Nermal6693 · · Score: 2, Informative

      Yes. A lot of people have installed the Mac OS 10.4 beta onto their iPod to avoid having to partition their HD. That way, they can boot whichever OS they like by holding Option while turning on their computer (Option displays a list of bootable devices and lets you select one).

    2. Re:use an iPod instead. by Phroggy · · Score: 1

      This makes me wonder, is it possible to do this sort of thing off an iPod? think of the possibilities.

      I don't see why not. Macs can do it, booting from FireWire. I'd expect any PC that can boot from USB or FireWire should be able to boot from an iPod with no trouble. As someone else pointed out, the included bootable CD that makes it work on PCs that can't boot directly from USB is really the key, and of course it shouldn't be hard to make one of those.

      --
      $x='S24;r)>63/* h@<5+oZ)32"5cz';$me='phroggy'x$];
      $x=~y+ -xz+\0-Tx+;print$_^chop$me for split'',$x;
  56. Something Linux can do that Windows XP can't. by Dr.+Mu · · Score: 1
    Imagine trying to make a portable XP drive do what this one does. You take it to a client's office, boot up, and -- whoops! -- XP detects a new hardware configuration and grinds to a halt until you beg Microsoft for permission to continue. Fat chance they'll suffer your frequent pleas for long!

    What's great is that this is a device whose time has come. It's imminent ubiquity seems inevitable, giving Linux a very big leg up on Windows.

  57. Re:Is it quiet? Does it have a fan? by kyrre · · Score: 1

    I used to have a LaCie 40gb Pocket Drive (5400rpm). I sold it due to lack of money for food and rent. Anywho, the 2.5" is quiet, and there is no fan. I was also able to power the drive from FireWire.

    My new Maxtor(5400rpm) offer no such luxury (although it also is fanless and pretty quiet).

    You may consider me a noise freak by the way. I have a fanless C3 733mhz with a fanless 60watt psu as my main computer.

  58. Re:Imagine... by Phroggy · · Score: 1

    Well, can you do a USB RAID on x86 hardware? I've read about a five-USB-floppy OS X (IIRC, it might have been OS 9) RAID, but never anything on x86.

    It was OSX, using the included software RAID tools. Windows XP should be able to do it, but refused to do it with floppies; I don't know if it would handle USB hard drives. Linux would have no problem. Remember the whole point of software RAID is that it's all done in software; being x86 or not has absolutely no relevance. It just depends on whether your OS can do it. Linux can.

    --
    $x='S24;r)>63/* h@<5+oZ)32"5cz';$me='phroggy'x$];
    $x=~y+ -xz+\0-Tx+;print$_^chop$me for split'',$x;
  59. Re:You must be smoking a viable alternative to cra by haggar · · Score: 1

    You have some excellent points, but I think the one about the keyboard is unfair, at least towards ThinkPads. I am no IBM lover, but the ThinkPad has a damn fine keyboard. I feel as confortable with it as I do with a full desktop keyboard, sometimes more so.

    But, I still have to find a laptop that won't fry my nuts when used as the name implies...

    --
    Sigged!
  60. No-reboot: Integrating with coLinux by vinod · · Score: 1

    coLinux (http://www.colinux.org/) should be integrated with the said solution: You should then have clean interfaces from IE, Windows Explorer (using WebDAV), X windows (with a copy of cygwin installed on the same USB hard disk) - all with a single click of button.

    A good NAT proxy would also be required (to run on windows) to complete the solution.

    -v

  61. Re:"For computers that don't support booting from by gl4ss · · Score: 1

    it usually appears there only if you've got something plugged already in.

    and then it's just completely missing from some, but some fairly 'old' computers have the option while some a bit more modern don't.

    --
    world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
  62. But can I connect it to my Zaurus?? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Not entirely sure why I would want to but having it connected to a 40 gig disk sounds handy..

  63. Re:"For computers that don't support booting from by Myself · · Score: 1

    El Torito is still a black voodoo kludge if you ask me. It's a miracle bootable CDs work at all.

    I've heard quite a lot played through the internal speaker, there was a program called "pianoman" which included a large library of tunes. Find it in the Simtel archive.

    Hint: You didn't need your OS to include BASICA / GWBASIC if you had a real IBM, since it was in ROM and would start if no bootable media were found. Others who ripped IBM's boot code but couldn't steal BASIC because of copyright would fail with the message "NO ROM BASIC".

    Geek points if you know what the GW stands for. :)

  64. with proper formatting & a disclaimer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It shouldn't work. Not as in it destroys your thinkpad, but 2k won't allow debug to access real ports to change the value there.
    Try this, which has no side effects, to make sure:
    debug
    -o 70 2e
    -i 71
    It will give you some number XX, that is the correct value. Write it down.
    -o 70 2e
    -o 71 ff
    If kernel allowed you to write to that port you now have overwritten 2e.
    Exit cmd. Restart cmd.
    debug
    -o 70 2e
    -i 71
    Now the output should be XX if NT does the right thing and ff if it doesn't. To get your right value back
    -o 70 2e
    -o 71 XX

    Disclaimer: The procedure just reads a byte from CMOS offset 2e, attempts to overwrite it, and attempts to restore the value if it had indeed overwritten the byte. But it has been ages (more like 6 years) since I used debug and I don't have any windows box at home so I can't test and say this is 100% safe. Proceed with caution.

  65. Re:You must be smoking a viable alternative to cra by Sunnan · · Score: 1
    I just use the monitor at whatever desk the client decides to assign me for the day.

    How do you configure X to work with any random monitor? I've been trying to do something similar.
  66. Re:"For computers that don't support booting from by Doctor+O · · Score: 1

    Even better, encrypt the filesystem and put the key on the CD so that it performs as just that, a key, to limit access to the thing. Would be the same as setting a BIOS password for a notebook to avoid information theft, only that it would actually work if your encryption is strong enough. Shouldn't be a too big performance hit, either.

    --
    Who is General Failure and why is he reading my hard disk?
  67. Re:Imagine... by bhtooefr · · Score: 1

    *smashes head on desk*

    Duh...

    Come to think of it, Windows would only allow RAIDing internal drives (whatever it's partition manager can touch - not a USB drive, IIRC). Of course, if it were burned right, a CD-ROM RAID would be just wrong, but interesting...

  68. Knoppix on a thumbdrive... by kevmit · · Score: 1

    ...makes this overpriced POS look just like the yesterday's news it is.
    Why would anyone in their right mind pay over 200 bucks for an external 40GB harddrive that's too big to fit comfortably in your pocket or on a keyring, yet just the right size to make it easy to misplace or be stolen. Factor in all the inherent advantages of solid-state over mechanical storage and this looks like a no-brainer to me. (as in, anyone that buys this would have to have no brain)
    Replacement for a laptop? I don't THINK so. The lack of any onboard I/O is going to pose something of a problem for anyone without a direct neural feed.

  69. Re:Imagine... by Phroggy · · Score: 1

    I dunno how the hell you'd burn it, but damn, that would be wrong.

    --
    $x='S24;r)>63/* h@<5+oZ)32"5cz';$me='phroggy'x$];
    $x=~y+ -xz+\0-Tx+;print$_^chop$me for split'',$x;
  70. Re:Alternative to a laptop? Unruly OS-Sticks users by davidsyes · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Maybe when windoze is in airplane cockpits we'll have to worry about USB ports in chair arms. Maybe somebody will hijack the headrest-mounted Playstations. Oh, wait, I think playstations and DVDs are just in JAL/INA.

    Imagine how bloody angry ms would be if someone placed windoze on USB sticks. That could really mess up ms' licensing scheme.

    Regardless of which OS is on a USB stick, what really will become a problem is abusers who use customized "OS-Sticks" (a term I'm coining and will continue to use even if some big powerhouse pickes it up and tries to hijack it as their own...) to wreak havoc on the Kinko's and other places where computers might be carelessly (by then) be deployed with their peripherals ports left (physically) unsecured or left installed.

    With an OS-Stick, the user's privileges are all in hand, unless the BIOS of more or all computers has control over the data flow and control of the machine.

    "Firewall-in-a-BIOS", anyone?

    David Syes

    Let's start displaying Tux with a family (wife/partner/spouse/whatever (industry/standards bodies), along with offspring or adoptees (we users and adoptees/friends of FOSS/Linux/GPL, etc)...

    --
    Previously: "Linux... Toward the Sunrise..." Now: "Linux... Toward the-- No, now, part of Every Sunrise"
  71. Newer BIOSes and VMWare to the rescue? by davidsyes · · Score: 1

    Corporate perceived risk of unmonitored systems (or my instigation by this commentary) will likely spark a frenetic rush to secure sensitive systems.

    I think that with these OS-Sticks likely taking off, legally loadable with Linux, but very unlikely to have windoze loaded legally (except for sysadmin purposes, I suppose), sysadmins everywhere should be worried about machines being shut down, booted by these OS-Sticks, and then pilfered or trashed out by malicious types.

    Imagine a pissed off, marauding employee going around booting up and instantly killing partitions. Or, someone doing it to an Internet cafe, or worse, to a police station, hospital, transit or power station, etc. Or, to a store. Just ONE compromised system will spark a frenzy to check out the others.

    Imagine if a person hides a USB-based device on their person (well, given the pocket and bag checking some sensitive companies carry out, I imagine a desperate data corruptor or data thief will hide theirs in a suppository--assuming hand wands and cavity searches are not in corporate style...) and entered a government, military, or sensitive information facility and STOLE data... the LLNL and Sandia/New Mexico data device losses will pale in comparison to this, even if peripheral or virtual data port logging is being done.

    So, I posit that VMWare and the various BIOS makers can carve out a new market for themselves:

    VMWare:

    DITCH the stand-alone or networked OS-loaded nodes, hook them up to the protected/isolated central or workgroups server (something I've been advocating for environments large and small where trust and security are issues, ESPECIALLY in companies)...

    Phoenix/other BIOS makers:

    We make BIOS that don't let ANYTHING boot or run if it is booted by a peripheral media device... First it has to boot to the master server, then send credentials, then do XYZ...

    The Sarbanes-Oxley Act and other regulations might very well force the financial sector as well as others to secure their data, especially where offices have too much free, unmonitored access.

    --
    Previously: "Linux... Toward the Sunrise..." Now: "Linux... Toward the-- No, now, part of Every Sunrise"
  72. BIGGER PITA than Y2K by davidsyes · · Score: 1

    This may be a bigger pain in the ass than Y2K. Imagine all the scrambling around.

    Imagine ALL the financial and banking and retail shops that have ground-level operations with all their pretty "we exist, we live" displays. All of them will/could be moving up to higher-level digs, forcing another irrational exuberance in the retail space market that'll try to jack up rents or leasing costs.

    Companies will have to scramble like crazy to once again inventory ALL their systems, networked AND stand-alone, just to make sure nothing can be (easily) ripped from them, and to make sure that the machines cannot be read, then used as propagators.

    It would be quite embarrassing if a company were jacked, then used for relaying their own information. And, if a data thief is caught in an office, but manages to destroy the medium sufficiently, the charges against him/her might be reduced, if the data was not propagated or not removed from the premises or the secure room. But, that depends on locales (some places might cut your head off if you see state secrets, while others may release you with reduced charges if you or your hirers could not benefit from the act, though trespass, tampering, unauthorized removal or relocation (like USN "rape", "penetration, however slight, constitutes rape"), however non-removed, still constitutes theft.

    But, the security industry can come up with some bastion or firewall or improved monitoring and access/credentials tools to slow down these weird ideas.

    One rule I have is NEVER offer up destructive information without at least a few antidotes our counters. After all, it may be a matter of time before certain thoughts REALLY ARE illegal, but offering a fix might diminish the punishment meted out.

    David Syes

    --
    Previously: "Linux... Toward the Sunrise..." Now: "Linux... Toward the-- No, now, part of Every Sunrise"