Slashdot Mirror
How Restaurants Got So Loud (theatlantic.com)
An anonymous reader shares a report: Other sounds that reach 70 decibels include freeway noise, an alarm clock, and a sewing machine. But it's still quiet for a restaurant. Others I visited in Baltimore and New York City while researching this story were even louder: 80 decibels in a dimly lit wine bar at dinnertime; 86 decibels at a high-end food court during brunch; 90 decibels at a brewpub in a rehabbed fire station during Friday happy hour. Restaurants are so loud because architects don't design them to be quiet. Much of this shift in design boils down to changing conceptions of what makes a space seem upscale or luxurious, as well as evolving trends in food service. Right now, high-end surfaces connote luxury, such as the slate and wood of restaurants including The Osprey in Brooklyn or Atomix in Manhattan.
This trend is not limited to New York. According to Architectural Digest, mid-century modern and minimalism are both here to stay. That means sparse, modern decor; high, exposed ceilings; and almost no soft goods, such as curtains, upholstery, or carpets. These design features are a feast for the eyes, but a nightmare for the ears. No soft goods and tall ceilings mean nothing is absorbing sound energy, and a room full of hard surfaces serves as a big sonic mirror, reflecting sound around the room. The result is a loud space that renders speech unintelligible. Now that it's so commonplace, the din of a loud restaurant is unavoidable. That's bad for your health -- and worse for the staff who works there. But it also degrades the thing that eating out is meant to culture: a shared social experience that rejuvenates, rather than harms, its participants.
This trend is not limited to New York. According to Architectural Digest, mid-century modern and minimalism are both here to stay. That means sparse, modern decor; high, exposed ceilings; and almost no soft goods, such as curtains, upholstery, or carpets. These design features are a feast for the eyes, but a nightmare for the ears. No soft goods and tall ceilings mean nothing is absorbing sound energy, and a room full of hard surfaces serves as a big sonic mirror, reflecting sound around the room. The result is a loud space that renders speech unintelligible. Now that it's so commonplace, the din of a loud restaurant is unavoidable. That's bad for your health -- and worse for the staff who works there. But it also degrades the thing that eating out is meant to culture: a shared social experience that rejuvenates, rather than harms, its participants.
Earplugs and text each other across the table.
const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)
SJW, n: "Someone I don't like, and by the way I'm a fuckwit" - AC
No more drinks and conversation. Eat and move out, so the next group can come in.
Table turnover is one of the key metrics for profitability.
I avoid loud restaurants; I'm sure I'm not the only one. They may look nice, and maybe their looks attract more people than their loudness scares off; but, I do take note if a place is too loud and I don't return- so there is a downside to being loud, they do lose some customers... unless I'm just a unique freak.
"That's the way to do it" - Punch
Comment removed based on user account deletion
Can't clean foam and fabric items easily. Smooth flat plastic or metal surfaces are easier to keep clean. Can't afford to live out, due to the burdens of government requirements health insurance, and so on, therefore high population density, and thus more noise. It seems the volume level of a place increases exponentially to the number of people.
So there you have it. Make your bed and lie in it.
Captcha: reform
There's probably also some positive feedback at the start. You don't want a place to seem _too_ quiet. A little noise makes a place seem lively and popular. So if the current architecture trends amplify sound it probably makes it seem more hospitable for the first couple groups of the night. It's only after that (initially) hospitable atmosphere has done its work and started to draw in a larger crowd that the noise reaches an intolerable level.
There's a pretty good bar right around the corner from us that we like to go to if we can get there early enough when it's more than half empty and quiet. But on more than one occasion we've noped the hell out of there because the evening crowd had already arrived and just walking in the door was already making our ears hurt.
This Space Intentionally Left Blank
Some of it is to save money and practicality in addition to design choices. For example, many recent newer places I've visited don't have carpet or rugs and opt for tile or concrete because it is cheaper and easier to clean. On the other spectrum, some restaurants have started to use glass tile/wood for the walls instead of drywall and paint.
A growing trend with some places is the open kitchen. If you've ever worked in a restaurant, kitchens are loud and were never designed to be quiet. But back in the day, the kitchen was behind walls that separated from the dining experience. With an open kitchen, you see and unfortunately hear everything.
Well, there's spam egg sausage and spam, that's not got much spam in it.
You can buy a variety of acoustic baffling and other sound treatment that looks sleek and modern. In the end, it's just the restaurant being cheap and confusing noise with liveliness. To be fair, a lot of customers do the latter, too.
That is all.
The noise problem noted is made worse by idiot restaurant owners. One local idiot had two tvs and a radio station, all of which were loud, going at the same time. She refused to turn them down. I paid the bill, left, never went back.
Not much later she went out of business. Gee, I wonder why.
Circle the wagons and fire inward. Entropy increases without bounds.
are now ordering their food delivered. I find going to most restaurants about as pleasant as going to a shopping mall. Ugh!
Coffee shops are usually pretty quiet, if only because they are smaller and fewer people fit into them.
People want to have what they say heard. As the background noise goes up, they talk louder. That brings the background noise level up for others, so they talk louder,
For years, our company held an employee Christmas party at a steak house. The last two years, though, we employees said forget it... the noise level was too high to socialize, even though we all loved the food.
Pubs are supposed to be noisy. If you don't like the atmosphere, then you're not in the right place.
Sound absorbing treatments are usually, at the very least, flame retardant, as they are designed for use in commercial applications and have to follow fire codes for building materials. You can clean them with an upholstery attachment on a vacuum cleaner.
Our favorite breakfast place has pictures hanging on the walls and sound absorbing panels on the ceiling to control noise. It's also broken up into multiple rooms with upholstered chairs and booths. Even when it's packed, which it often is, you can have a conversation with everyone at your table without raising your voice.
The new hipster brunch place that opened up on the other side of town is a giant concrete, wood, glass and steel box. when someone sneezes on the other size of the restaurant it reverberates through the space like a thunderclap.
My Other Computer Is A Data General Nova III.
Yes and one could go on about how most people don't know shit from quality these days.... one may be right even but what gets me is that in this time where about every niche idea seems to prosper, pure quality (without the added and often fake sense of luxury) seems hard to find.
Perhaps I'm just googling wrong.
Continuous loud noise makes people uncomfortable so they won't linger after finishing their meal which results in faster turnover and more customers seated.
I find that if people would put food in their mouths instead of spouting words it might get quieter in restaurants. :)
Sorry, while the acoustics of a lot of restaurants leave much to be desired it's really the self-absorbed patrons and staff. You see we like to think we're all in our own world while eating out but the thing is your conversation levels tend to be a bit loud. People when they're going out and eating with others tend to be a little more boisterous anyway, hey they're having a good time right? Because your conversation is above a normal tone, the folks text to you can't hear their conversation. To compensate, they retaliate subconsciously and talk louder too. It especially gets bad with large groups with more than 4 people or with families / groups with kids under the age of 7 are seated nearby. Restaurants/bars et. al. could do us a favor by putting up some noise dampening material but that still won't fix the loud obnoxious clods two tables over who are in their own little world.
Harrison's Postulate - "For every action there is an equal and opposite criticism"
It sounds like what you're saying is that no true restaurant is louder, because only the quiet places you eat you consider to be restaurants.
"That? Oh, that's a pub. No no that, that's a diner. Wine bar. Lounge. Eatery. Buffet. Bistro. Brewery. Greasy spoon. Family restaurant."
I might buy your argument that those aren't strictly traditional restaurants, but in my experience, in my town, the majority of places you can sit down to be waited on are loud and it's mostly because of infernal music they play over the speakers. It seems people here can't stand to eat in public without music, or at least the restaurant managers think so.
I think what really sets apart the fine dining (at least where I live) is whether or not they play music.
Don't like it, don't go out to eat, grandpa. Stay home and eat your mushed peas.
You can buy a variety of acoustic baffling and other sound treatment that looks sleek and modern. In the end, it's just the restaurant being cheap ...
Cheap and ignorant of the problem. I have, personally, attempted to quiet the equivalent of a loud bar: a conference poster session in absolute worst-case acoustic conditions of hard surfaces and an arched ceiling that concentrated noise. The noise absorbing panels cost a total of $3000, delivered at about $100 per panel, two dozen of them, plus shipping. They took the punishingly-loud situation down through very loud, to merely loud --- with 100 people all talking together in a confined space, you can't do much better than that. The panels are sleek, would look good in any modern decor, and, mounted on the ceiling, are entirely unobtrusive.
So we aren't talking a ton of money, which means the restaurant and bar owners are indeed, being either ignorant, naive, cheap, or some combination of those three.
Put my fist through my alarm clock with its ding-dong death inside my ear. - The Blackjacks.
I'm posting this dummy text because when I post in a thread my moderation points that I just used here are removed. I accidentally downvoted when I wanted to upvote. Why can't Slashdot give me the option to change my moderation, like any other website does that allows voting on comments?
If I go to a sports bar, I expect certain levels of noise from the patrons and screens (although most of the screens have closed captioning turned on)
If I go out for dinner, I'd like to be able to hold a conversation with the people at my table, and not hear people 10 tables away. Older, more expensive places usually are much quieter.
One of the places I used to like was quiet to medium loud, but they completely overhauled and expanded the place.
Next time I went in, you couldn't hear the person talking next to you. The new decor included a huge glass cupola which acted like a sound magnifier. It was so loud, I was wondering if there were some sound canceling technology that they could install.
Ever been to China? More Chinese are coming to USA, and they are bringing with them their rude habits, maybe soon they will be spitting and smoking in USA restaurants without anyone care. Way too many of these locusts spreading all over the world and bringing their lack of culture everywhere, and also their brainwashed lack of cute about the world and inability to think logically.
so they dont care the the cracker barrel is at 120 decibels.
Young folks canrt afford to eat out more than 2 or 3 times a year, so they dont matter.
Which people often forget was a major source of gossip in the restaurants of old.
This is really correlation not causation though. The major reasons for the changes mentioned are simple:
ADA
Fire Safety
Sanitation/Inspections.
ADA requires larger spaces to accomodate wheelchairs. Gone are the old timey tight spaces where once a heavyset American would have a hard time squeezing by.
Fire Safety has lead to all possible flammable objects being removed or reduced.
Sanitation has lead to stainless-only tableware, a hard plastic easy-wipe surface, and no tablecloth except in extremely upscale restaurants (and in most of the quality ones those have to be changed after any spills or ideally after the customers leave before the next customers are seated, leading to a few minutes worth of bussing and resetting per table, instead of a simple wipedown and new place settings (which most waiters I have seen can have done in around 30 seconds.
I think this is not only loss of civility. Libraries have become much more community locations. Places to go meet with people. And, children's areas are like small playrooms. My son spends most of his time there playing while I get him books to take home.
The noise's purpose is to keep homeless people from sleeping in the restaurant. There are radio stations leased by the restaurants to provide this human pest control.
Around here, it's become almost impossible to find a restaurant without televisions. They're worse than loud noise for killing conversation. I remember the look of shock on the manager's face after eating one night when he asked how our meal was, and we said we were never eating there again because of the televisions.
No idea where you live. I live in Belgium and eat and have eaten all over Europe and I do not find this to be the case. The last fine dining I went to had music, just not very loud. (Do not go to their website. It is horrible. The food and service is the best I ever had.)
The "normal" restaurants where I go to, also have music.
But they are almost always there that if there is nobody, (or if everybody just stops talking suddenly for some reason) it is not dead quiet. In those places I would not expect to pay as much as that one with the fine dining. Closer to 50EUR per person including wine instead. Like here It is just some background music, not some shredder metal set to 11.
Don't fight for your country, if your country does not fight for you.
If you want quiet, check the book out.
Open spaces, high ciment ceilings, minimal furniture, ventilation though the floor (acts like a drum when walking, and pushes dust upwards), ... Not fun. At work we have little choice, restaurants we do! Take out , other places, ... even McDonalds is rebuilding their âoedining roomsâ to provide more intimacy. No open cafeteria style bunch of tables around. I hope they set a trend.
I share the dislike of really loud restaurants - you're usually there to socialize, not exercise your vocal chords.
On a related topic, I have a home office with a nice audio system and I wondered about the benefits of acoustics panels, since I thought I could hear echo in the room. So I bought a kit from Audimute (https://www.audimute.com/). It had 24 12"x24" panels and hardware to mount them on the walls.
I interspersed them with photographs (at least a couple panels on each wall) and also put a number near the floor in the corners behind the speakers.
While not a radical change, it was noticeable and definitely for the better. Sound from the speakers had fewer frequency ranges that seemed to buzz or self-reinforce. (cutting down standing waves). I could no longer say that I could hear slap echo.
I would highly recommend the use of acoustic panels - absolutely no doubt that they make a noticeable difference. Can't understand why they are not used in more public places - they're not really very expensive.
people like it loud.
Someone has to organize the restaurant outing AND they get judged by their choice. If the restaurant quality is good, noise is a PLUS. It adds to the buzz and confirms a good choice was made. Think of the alternative ; same restaurant in silence. Now conversations are actually awkward because it is too quiet. It is almost like a dance floor: crowded is way better than empty.
That why our local P F Changs was a one time only stop. The food was not a factor, being able to hear your dinner partner was.
One local restaurant had the same problem, but now has tapestry on the walls. Makes for a much more pleasant experience.
As for sports bars, forget it.
I was at a construction trade show a few years back and came across a booth selling sound deadening pads that you just hung on your wall. The show, like all of them, was very noisy. I strongly recall standing so one ear was turned towards it and the other away. The effect was astonishing, it was MUCH quieter on the pad side. Oddly, however, it was that ear that began hurting after a short time. I think the brain does some sort of scaling and is trying hard to pull more sound out of the quiet side.
In my experience anyway, the more " Family Friendly " a restaurant is, the louder it is likely to be.
If, instead, you eat anywhere that typically requires a reservation and has a dress code, it will be nice and quiet. ( albeit, $$$$ )
A few reasons I dislike eating out these days:
1) Kids screaming / crying / going full heathen and parents refusing to remove them from the dining area
2) Multiple folks have a game running ( kiddos usually ), or live TV or music blasting from the smartphone
3) Some places have half a dozen TV's running half a dozen different stations
4) Self propagating loop in that folks need to talk louder to hear one another as background noise climbs
5) Great aesthetic designs, but poor acoustical design considerations are a real issue in new construction
Eventually, you're basically YELLING at the person sitting across from you just so you can hear one another.
( If I want that kind of experience I'll hit the local Sports Bar where it's expected )
At a Zinburger Wine & Burger Bar they tried to seat us near the open kitchen and it was like a factory, so noisy we had to use gestures to help explain that the table was unacceptable. Finally got the best sheltered booth in the place but even it wasn't too great for trying to carry on a conversation. And no, I've got fantastic hearing, probably because I avoid these kinds of place. The only thing around that might not have been reflecting the noise was the napkins. The food was fine but we won't be back.
If the high-end joint is too loud, don't go.
Twist in Atlanta has really good food, but the place is too loud so I haven't been back.
Restaurants can easily be designed to be quiet, and many are. But, to put all the baffling and special ceiling tiles and carpet and other aides in place costs well over 200k per restaurant to install, requires offsetting design considerations that can add more, and are harder to keep clean.
Plus noisy makes it more of a "scene," and a scene adds to the impression of popularity, so its a trade-off there as well.
Guarantee if you dig deep enough, this is pushed by some law firm looking to stir up a class action lawsuit.
(-1: Post disagrees with my already-settled worldview) is not a valid mod option.
Which is why stuff like this exists:
https://www.soundproofcow.com/...
And this:
http://www.acousticsfirst.com/...
My Other Computer Is A Data General Nova III.
I don't understand where OSHA is in all of this. After the people at the local burrito shop are saying "what?" to me constantly I started pulling out the decimeter on my phone and thinking "yup, that's why". How is it that these employees are allowed to work like this?
I went to Red Robin once. With their brick floors it was so loud I couldn't hear myself fart. I've never gone back because what's the use of farting if you can't hear it?
Even been to a Black Angus? Restaurants with those high-backed booths creating private spaces are the quietest in the world. But that's not how things are done today, as TFA indicates. People who use hearing aids are the ones who still like the quiet style of restaurant, because in a noisy one the cacophony is amplified along with the conversation, and they hear nothing.
I can't believe the article didn't mention the ubiquitous televisions seem to be in many restaurants now, usually tuned to some sports game.
There is no "-1 offended" or "-1 you don't agree with me" mod options for a reason.
I've noticed even in university libraries people talk out loud, eat and drink.
Probably the important word there is "University". At that age, people are either just past "peak rowdiness" or still in it. People tend to notice how they impact other people a little better as they get older.
"That's the way to do it" - Punch
Sometime I do acoistics consulting for places like these. as has been said elsewhere - owners and designers usually have no clue that noise issues can and shoul be dealt with and forget to budget for this. Acoustics when incorporated in the design can look great and be cheaper than dealing with the issue after all surfaces are finished. Another thing that shocked me - my living is wooden floors and I work with a few architects - when asked them whether they came accross the topic of interier acoustics during their studies they jointly replied that they didnt.
From the POV of someone who lives in Asia (for a dozen years) this is because, well, Americans. And I'm only sort of trolling... reverse culture shock is a big, big deal. Hard to describe, but everything is just different, and things like loud restaurants are a shocking affront to the senses.
Most establishments like to put up art. You can buy ready to hang fire retardant sound panels that have printed fabric on them. If those are too expensive, you can buy then panels yourself and stretch fabric over them.
I just finished up the Pasta Pass, and excepting for one time I ate in the main dining area, all of my visits were in the bar section. There are less booths, and furthest away from the restrooms and kitchen doors, which means less people.
Places like Chipotles, Potbelly's, etc. that have the modern minimalist look and feel may call it "design", but they've really done it to save money on both initial investment and repairs.
They also do it to save on cleaning cost/expenses and maintenance. Which is easier to keep clean - 1) padded, wooden seats around tables with tablecloths, and drapes over windows, or 2) steel countertops, hard window coverings and painted/sealed concrete floors?
When combined with an increasingly narcissistic generation growing into adulthood that disregards old social mores about speaking in hushed tones in restaurants, I can barely hear any table conversation when dining indoors anymore.
(And to you drunk assholes in the corner booth two tables down at *localSuburbanChainRestaurantOrSportsBar* on any given night - your rambling stories are NOT that boisterously funny. Keep them to yourselves.)
But, it's essence of snail mucus trail fusion and locally sourced thistle weed? You can't not pay $200 for that, especially when they combine it with nuvo Wagyu tartar(Totally not $2/lb ground chuck).
Restaurants, commercial spaces pipe in music to a) provide atmosphere, b) encourage repeat visits and c) sell more product.
We had a 2 hour loop tape in a restaurant which played the same 50 songs in the same order over and over from 10 AM - 11 PM.
I knew how many hours I'd worked by remembering the song playing when I clocked in and whenever it was played again.
The dB increase is aged distributed with younger crowd eateries having louder music - a cheap way to make it a party - to restaurants aimed at 'fine dining' / older persons having more subdued dB levels.
My parents told me that they'd go to a restaurant without any ambient music and actually put a quarter in a jukebox and pick their own music.
I've asked many times at overly loud places for the staff to turn down the music/noise as I'd like to talk to and actually hear my fellow diners.
I started doing that when I was a teenager and didn't want to hear the equivalent obnoxious disco/rap/hiphop/pop popular at the time.
I think due to climate, Australians (certainly here in Queensland) did away with carpets long ago. Very few restaurants where you can hear yourself think, let alone anyone else.
But it also degrades the thing that eating out is meant to culture: a shared social experience that rejuvenates, rather than harms, its participants.
Shared social experiences are enervating, not rejuvenating. I'm an introvert you insensitive clod.
All the three Michelin star restaurants I have eaten in have been pretty quiet and it's been easy to hold a conversation across the table.
No so for most of the non Michelin and somewhat upscale restaurants I've eaten in, where all surfaces are shiny and reflective.
I should use this sig to advertise my book ISBN-13 : 978-1501515132.
Homes have been trending with smooth floor surface and smooth ceiling (newer homes tend to have higher ceilings). No carpet, no popcorn ceiling. I notice people tend to talk louder now.
Several years ago, probably over a decade ago, slashdot published an article (that I failed to find) on restaurant noise. Yes, people were complaining about noisy restaurants back then.
To summarize, a restaurant with dining on two floors set up one with hard surfaces, bare brick walls an an exposed ceiling. It was loud! The other was traditional high-end room with wood tables, drapes an other soft sound absorbent surfaces. It was very quiet. Both were serving the same "New American" menu from the same kitchen.
After 6 months the "quiet" floor was closed and refitted to match the noisy floor because the loud floor was booked solid while the quiet floor always had available tables. The hypothesis was that noisy restaurants were perceived as "exciting" while quiet ones were "boring".
The bottom line was that, no matter how much people complain about noise, they prefer that to quiet dining. Loud dining rooms are often very much by design, not acoustic incompetence.
Kevin Oberman, Network Engineer, Retired
They will never fucking learn the basics of acoustics or hire experts who do know because all they care about is their stupid fucking art.
Any game vendor understands the association of volume and involvement with the product. It's a cornerstone of the industry.
... it's sanitary design. In this age of extreme cost efficiency, the food service industry has realized that it's cheaper in the long run to use surfaces that are easy to clean quickly rather than carpet or cloth. Pure economics... but it results in everything having a "sanitized" look too, regardless of how much effort is spent trying to stylize it.
All this, and not a word as to the root cause. It has nothing to do with walls or ceilings' ability to absorb sound, but *everything* to do with cell phone conversations.
It used to be you could have a face-to-face conversation in a restaurant in hushed tones. Now you just need *one* patron on his phone with bad reception, and everybody has to talk louder to drown him out. Given the number of people who take calls at restaurants, there should be no surprise.
"Acoustics", my ass. How was this not even brought up once? Denial much?
As a european, I can say that likely american restaurants are so noisy, because there are so many americans in them. Seriously, americans are one of the noisiest species on the planet - they even beat the spanish and that isn't easy :-)