Slashdot Mirror


Anoto-based Pens From Logitech

flanksteak writes "Logitech has announced the IO Pen, a ball-point pen with a memory. You write stuff with the pen, then drop it in its USB cradle and your bad handwriting appears on your PC. The pen is to be released in November. How cool would this be with support for a wireless protocol?" We've run some previous stories about this - no telling how well it actually works until it's tested, though. And at $9.99/notebook, the paper is about three times as expensive as regular paper.

157 of 428 comments (clear)

  1. not really a "pen" per se by gmajor · · Score: 2, Informative

    It's not really a pen, per se, since you cannot use it with regular paper. What good is the pen, since it can only be used with the special digital paper?

    1. Re:not really a "pen" per se by Scott+Tracy · · Score: 2, Informative

      It has ink in it, so that (a) you can see what you are writing on the special dotted paper, and (b) use it on old-fashioned 20th-century paper.

    2. Re:not really a "pen" per se by Usquebaugh · · Score: 2

      Can you not print your own special paper?

      I see this as a really cool idea but I'll wait for the cheap knock off, no way is it worth $200 to me. It might be worth $200 if it didn't need special paper.

    3. Re:not really a "pen" per se by Anonvmous+Coward · · Score: 2

      "It's not really a pen, per se, since you cannot use it with regular paper. What good is the pen, since it can only be used with the special digital paper?"

      I have an interesting use for it. I make 3D Models for a living. My process is this:

      - Draw a few pictures of what I'm going to build. They sort of resemble blue-prints when I'm done.
      - Scan the drawings
      - ???
      - Profit!

      Okay, I'm kidding about the profit part. It would be a huge time saver for me if I could just link the pen to my computer and send the data down to the computer. If it stores the data in vector format, then it means that I can drastically thin down the lines, re-print the image, then draw finer details of it.

      So not only would this save me time (it should be faster than scanning for what I do...) but it also provides me a capability I don't have today. (again, assuming they store the data in vectors. Their site is none too clear on that issue.)

      $200 is a little steep, but I may invest in it.

  2. The ultimate forger's tool. by mooman · · Score: 5, Funny

    Just lend this pen to people anytime they need to sign something.

    Viola, you've captured their signature and can forge it whenever needed...

    1. Lend pen to important people
    2. Blackmail and defraud
    3. Profit!

    --
    In the Portland, Ore area and like card games? Check out: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/portlandgames/
    1. Re:The ultimate forger's tool. by Scott+Tracy · · Score: 5, Informative

      Unless you loan the pen to someone who has the special paper, that won't work.

      Anoto uses paper with grey dots on it, aligned in a grid, that (for some reason or another) is part of a larger 60,000,000-sq-km unique grid (so no two pieces of paper are the same). The 'pen' has a camera in it, that captures the grey dots as you write, and stores the coordinates. This must use very little memory, but does force you to use more expensive (and likely harder-to-find) paper.

      Still, I've preordered mine at amazon.com for $199. It's supposed to be available Nov 8.

    2. Re:The ultimate forger's tool. by Rantastic · · Score: 5, Insightful
      Viola, you've captured their signature and can forge it whenever needed

      Actually, no. At least, you can't beat signature recognition devices that way. They look at presure changes, speed, and strokes, none of which are captured by this device.

      --
      Ask Slashdot: Where bad ideas meet poor googling skills.
    3. Re:The ultimate forger's tool. by McFly69 · · Score: 2, Funny

      Is it Logitech or Enron that is producing this pen?

      --



      NO! NO! Please don't mod me, I'm too young to die a troll. *click* Oh the pain, the pain...
    4. Re:The ultimate forger's tool. by sporty · · Score: 2, Funny

      What if one comes flying out of the sky at your head? Or you make one randomly appear or find one?

      Voila! Viola!

      --

      -
      ping -f 255.255.255.255 # if only

    5. Re:The ultimate forger's tool. by billbaggins · · Score: 2
      Unless you loan the pen to someone who has the special paper, that won't work
      "Hey, will you sign this picture of you that I printed off the Internet? Umm... could you sign in that white area there? Sorry about the grey spots, my printer's kinda on the blink... Thanks!"

      But really... I don't think having the famous person's *signature* is gonna get you that much. After all, they've been giving the friggin' things away forever... I'll bet Plato did autographed copies of the Apology for his friends...

      And what does a viola have to do with anything? :p

      --
      "The best argument against democracy is a five minute chat with the average voter."
      --Winston Churchill
    6. Re:The ultimate forger's tool. by Dr.+Smooth · · Score: 2, Interesting

      The reason that the grids are unique on different pieces of paper is so that software can get some context about what you're writing on. The statement that no two pieces of paper are the same is not entirely correct. Each piece of paper in the larger grid is assigned a unique ID. That ID is mapped to a particular application, so that by calling the Anoto lookup service, software could know that you're filling out an insurance application, or that you're sending e-mail to somebody. It can then interpret the ink intelligently, since it can then determine where the various fields are on the page and what they mean.

      --

      ...if you ask no questions, beware of lies...

    7. Re:The ultimate forger's tool. by thelexx · · Score: 4, Funny

      Must be nice to have so much money just laying around. At 5%, in 20 years $200 becomes $865. When it's shown that this thing is going to rock the world, and they make it a little less clunky looking, I'll consider it. Until then, my money is going toward retiring somewhere that the drinks are served in pineapples by scantily clad native women.

      --
      "Gold still represents the ultimate form of payment in the world." - Alan Greenspan, 1999
    8. Re:The ultimate forger's tool. by timeOday · · Score: 2
      At 5%, in 20 years $200 becomes $865.
      No it doesn't. It's 200*e^(20*0.05) = 543.66.

      But even if inflation stays low at 3%, that $543 will only be worth $298.

      Now add in all the govt. benefits you WON'T receive because you have money in the bank to drive that number down even more.

    9. Re:The ultimate forger's tool. by rworne · · Score: 2, Insightful
      And now much money do they plan to get for this? And look! it's solvable!

      Assuming the razor blades and ink-jet cartridge marketing plan:

      They sell a 160 page book of letter-size paper for $9.99. That's 9.648m^2 per book. Assuming for a minute that the whole 60,000,000km^2 is made up of just these books, and the entire area of the book is usable, then one book is .000009648km^2.

      So 60,000,000km^2/.000009648km^2 = 6,218,905,472,637 books, or at $10 apiece, $62,189,054,726,370.00 that 's 62 quadrillion dollars at retail. You could probably buy a whole planet for that price. Assume the wholesale cost is half that, you still get 31 quadrillion dollars.

      Anyway, that's a buttload of potential profit for step #2 of the Underpants Gnomes' profitability lemma.

      --
      I tried every decent and legal way I could think of to resolve the issue w/the business before I rented the chicken suit
    10. Re:The ultimate forger's tool. by jovlinger · · Score: 2

      so can anyone figure out how to lay out the dots, so that each OVERLAPPING area of dots is unique?

      I can figure out a backtracking solution to the 1-D case, but that would seem to run in n**2 time. Now I REALLY doubt that they've used an n**2 algorithm for n~= 2**64 (I estimate you'll need 64 bits to get the required accuracy).

      Basically, the 1-D case is: create a sequence of bits so that no substring of length m (chosen a-priori, in our case 64) occurs twice.

      To make things simpler: we can increase m, and accept a less optimal solution (optimality is how many unique sequences occur)

      To make things harder: 1) we want to be able to quickly map the unique number to the offset, and 2) we want a hierarchial solution (so that we don't have to layout the whole sequence at once-- they don't have enough storage to store the whole sequence). This point interacts well with choosing a larger m.

    11. Re:The ultimate forger's tool. by thelexx · · Score: 2

      "No it doesn't. It's 200*e^(20*0.05) = 543.66."

      Compounded interest.

      "Now add in all the govt. benefits you WON'T receive because you have money in the bank to drive that number down even more."

      It's not the role of goverment to provide for my retirement. Period. Call me old fashioned, but I was raised with the spirit that says it's better to eat cat food than to rely on handouts.

      To remain ever so slightly on topic, I still say that in the long run, spending $200 on this pen will bring me closer to the cat food than the pineapple drinks. Provably reverse that and I'll be first in line for one, with an extra ream of the special paper on the side.

      --
      "Gold still represents the ultimate form of payment in the world." - Alan Greenspan, 1999
    12. Re:The ultimate forger's tool. by timeOday · · Score: 2
      The formula I gave is for CONTINUOUSLY compounding interest - the best kind. What formula calculates $865?

      I have to agree with you on the pen, though.

    13. Re:The ultimate forger's tool. by packeteer · · Score: 2

      Well duh. Many large companies make HUGE amounts of money on selling paper. Hewlett-Packard makes somewhere near 80% of their profit of... you guessed it... paper and ink. They sell the printers at basically cost because they know your coming back for paper over couple of months.

      Your pretyt much right in everything but that math. They dont make $10 profit off a pack of paper. And they wont sell them all. The reason the number is so high is that they want to be able to CLEARLY overshoot the amount the ever needed. The thing that makes business men lose so much sleep is when they have orders coming in but no more stock to sell. Its worth it to overshoot and they did.

      --
      unzip; strip; touch; finger; mount; fsck; more; yes; unmount; sleep
    14. Re:The ultimate forger's tool. by mmol_6453 · · Score: 2

      I'd be more concerned that he's actually talking to it...

      --
      What's this Submit thingy do?
  3. read the small print by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    "The IO pen only works when used on location at one of Jupiter's moons"

  4. Wireless? by Shamanin · · Score: 3, Interesting

    What about the amount of power this would require? If my guess is correct, it would seem that they are using a USB connection to avoid excessive power consumption during download transmission of data.

    --
    come on fhqwhgads
  5. 3 times as expensive as regular paper? by Doomrat · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Is 3 times as expensive as something as cheap as paper really that much of a problem for a new technology like this? Compared to most, this isn't so bad.

    1. Re:3 times as expensive as regular paper? by digerata · · Score: 2, Insightful
      And its cheaper than buying a tablet PC to lug around to meetings. Its especially when most people already have atleast one pc at their desk. This method doesn't require another device besides the pen.

      I don't like palm pilots for their limited input functionality and tablets are too big and bulky. This by passes those problems.

      --

      1;
    2. Re:3 times as expensive as regular paper? by MrResistor · · Score: 2

      This method doesn't require another device besides the pen.

      Wrong.

      It requires special paper, MSIE, and .NET.

      At $200 for the pen and $10 per notebook of the special paper, its far more expensive than a regular pen, regular paper, and a cheap USB scanner, which is its real competition.

      As an added bonus the pen exports data in a proprietary format and is dependent on proprietary software, which makes the user dependent on continued vendor support (tried finding drivers for a serial mouse lately?). Oh yeah, and the cheap scanner has better resolution, and can be used on all your old documents as well.

      --
      Under capitalism man exploits man. Under communism it's the other way around.
  6. handwritten e-mail? by misterhaan · · Score: 5, Funny
    Digitally capture handwritten emails
    excellent! now i can keep a record of all my handwritten e-mails as well as my typed ones!
    --

    track7.org has all kinds of interesting stuff!

    1. Re:handwritten e-mail? by TheTomcat · · Score: 5, Funny

      I once had a boss who would [have his secretary] PRINT all of his emails before reading them, then handwrite replies and [have his secretary] type them into his email client.

      Now he can automate his stupidity.

      S

    2. Re:handwritten e-mail? by co_fisha · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I think the best thing about this is the possibility of getting emails from people written in their own hand! Yes typing is quick and easy but it is so monotonous and uniform. Why should an email from my gf look the same as a email from my boss?

    3. Re:handwritten e-mail? by misterhaan · · Score: 2, Funny
      Why should an email from my gf look the same as a email from my boss?
      it shouldn't! if your girlfriend talks to you the same way your boss does, you need a new girlfriend!
      (that or you have a lawsuit against your boss . . . )
      --

      track7.org has all kinds of interesting stuff!

    4. Re:handwritten e-mail? by stefanlasiewski · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I was once an intern in an advertising company who was trying to break into internet advertising, since this was 1996 and the web ads was supposed to be the Next Big Thing.

      I was a recent college grad with Internet Experience (TM). Part of my job was to, yes, print out webpages of successful web ads and bind them in a folder for their strategy meetings.

      Needless to say, they never really landed any big contracts, and were forced to stay with their Junkmail business.

      --
      "Can of worms? The can is open... the worms are everywhere."
    5. Re:handwritten e-mail? by co_fisha · · Score: 2, Interesting

      YES!!

      50 years from now who the hell wants to look at an email. How are you going to find an old forgotton email tucked away in the attic? Is an email going to show the wrinkles of deleting it to the deleted items folder. Email has no personality!

    6. Re:handwritten e-mail? by MaxVlast · · Score: 2

      That's pretty daft.

      My roommate's boss used to print out all of him e-mails upon receipt. I thought that that was pretty dumb until I realized that he did it so all correspondence with a student could be kept in one file. Upon learning that, it made a lot more sense.

      At least he didn't hand write replies.

      --
      There should be a moratorium on the use of the apostrophe.
      Max V.
      NeXTMail/MIME Mail welcome
    7. Re:handwritten e-mail? by Sentry21 · · Score: 2

      If you want e-mails from your girlfriend to be special, buy her a webcam for Christmas. Just hope that she never mis-sends to your parents instead.

      --Dan

    8. Re:handwritten e-mail? by !splut · · Score: 2

      Why should an email from my gf look the same as a email from my boss?

      Well I dunno. Is your girlfriend also your boss? If so that's a good reason. It's also perverse, you sicko.

      --
      The angel in the oatmeal.
    9. Re:handwritten e-mail? by tswinzig · · Score: 2

      I think the best thing about this is the possibility of getting emails from people written in their own hand!

      Yes, I enjoy trying to decipher everyone's crappy handwriting. Hoorah!

      However, I'm inclined to think you'll see more of this not from some stupid pen with special paper, but when tablet pc's become popular.

      --

      "And like that ... he's gone."
    10. Re:handwritten e-mail? by statusbar · · Score: 2

      Hey, you should count your lucky stars! The last thing you want is for this guy to be actually interacting with a computer! Then you'd probably be stuck trying to teach him. Some people ought not to use computers!!!!

      --jeff++

      --
      ipv6 is my vpn
    11. Re:handwritten e-mail? by gvonk · · Score: 2

      I thought that that was pretty dumb until I realized that he did it so all correspondence with a student could be kept in one file. Upon learning that, it made a lot more sense.

      Right. Putting all the emails from a student into a file/folder is a LOT easier if you print it up than if you do it on a computer, right?
      Suuuure.

      --


      El Karma: excelente(principalmente la suma de moderación hecha a los comentarios de los usuarios)
    12. Re:handwritten e-mail? by friscolr · · Score: 2
      50 years from now who the hell wants to look at an email. How are you going to find an old forgotton email tucked away in the attic? Is an email going to show the wrinkles of deleting it to the deleted items folder. Email has no personality!

      email can look good.
      you just gotta look at it in the right way!

      detail, project page

    13. Re:handwritten e-mail? by Tim+Browse · · Score: 2

      I'm betting the guy in question may have had some experience of how good the organisation's backup strategy was...

      Tim

    14. Re:handwritten e-mail? by MaxVlast · · Score: 2

      Actually, it is if you already have a big file on the student.

      --
      There should be a moratorium on the use of the apostrophe.
      Max V.
      NeXTMail/MIME Mail welcome
    15. Re:handwritten e-mail? by B747SP · · Score: 2
      Why should an email from my gf look the same as a email from my boss?

      Dude, a tip: If your boss calls you 'Darling' in his emails, run screaming :-)

      --
      I find your ideas intriguing and I wish to subscribe to your newsletter.
  7. It must be pretty cool, then... by modus · · Score: 5, Informative

    "How cool would this be with support for a wireless protocol?"

    Well, seeing as how Sony Ericsson have already announced a pen using this technology that supports Bluetooth (http://www.expansys.com/product.asp?code=ERIC_CHA TPEN), pretty darn cool.

  8. Paper. by unicron · · Score: 2, Redundant

    What's the point of the special paper anyway? What makes it special and how does it relate to the storing digitally of what you wrote? I dont' see why regular notebook paper wouldn't suffice for writing stuff down the old school way while the pen digitally stored that information.

    --
    Finally, math books without any of that base 6 crap in them.
    1. Re:Paper. by EvanED · · Score: 2

      The special paper has a series of dots that the pen reads to track its movement. The data is stored in the pen.

    2. Re:Paper. by Fnkmaster · · Score: 5, Informative
      Because it doesn't store what you write per se. It has a miniature camera that tracks the microscopic dot pattern on their proprietary digital paper, and uses the location of the surrounding dots to exactly identify its coordinates over time. So it really stores a sequence of coordinates, which it then dumps to PC, which reconstructs the lines connecting the tiny coordinate "snapshots" and results in writing.


      I can certainly imagine ways of doing that that DON'T require digital paper. Either this was the easiest way to implement it (unlikely) or they saw that the real margins for this market are in selling digital paper on an ongoing basis (much more likely).

    3. Re:Paper. by mooman · · Score: 3, Interesting

      No kidding. If you need special paper, then how is this really much different than writing on a graphics tablet?

      I think the more practical device would be a run-of-mill-looking clipboard that you could clip any kind of paper to, write on it, and store that image..
      I think that offers more flexibility (like automatically filling out "forms" in triplicate, storing receipt/stub information for business travellers, and so on) and would be easier to incorporate wireless into. Shoot, you could even put an inconspicuous PCMCIA slot into it for a wifi adapter, disk drive, or whatever...

      --
      In the Portland, Ore area and like card games? Check out: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/portlandgames/
    4. Re:Paper. by quick_dry_3 · · Score: 2

      From my understanding of it, the paper is covered in little dots that are roughly in a grid pattern, a camera in the pen looks at the dot pattern to determine where it is on the paper, and then stores that information.

    5. Re:Paper. by The+Iconoclast · · Score: 2

      They did this, it was called a CrossPad developed by IBM and marketed by Cross Pens. Unfortunately, they EOL'd it and no more were produced. They were even working on a newer USB version, which I beta tested, but that disappeared, too.

      --
      Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati
    6. Re:Paper. by Lil'wombat · · Score: 5, Informative

      The deal with the paper is that the pattern of dots is unique and no- repeating up to a area about the size of the North America. The business plan behind Annoto is to license sections of that mapspace to companys.


      Catalog company X could license 100 sq ft for use in their catalogs - using 2mm at a time for a check box next to each item in their catalog. When you check the box, the pen records those cordinates, when you download the map locations trigger an order form to be filled out on the company's catalog web site. Or 3M could sell POST-IT Faxes - a post-it with a check box to fax, so that when you link your pen with the internet , the message you just scribbled is faxed away.

      My only concern with the company is the Cue-Cat esque business model of makeing people have to pass their informtion through the annoto servers to perform anything useful.

      --

      Truth: If it's not one thing, it's another

    7. Re:Paper. by pmz · · Score: 3, Interesting

      If you need special paper, then how is this really much different than writing on a graphics tablet?

      It's like a Steno pad. You take the wireless pen and the wireless pad of paper wherever you go (meetings, brainstorming at the park, etc.). The handwritten graphics (letters, drawings) are stored within the pen's own memory to later be downloaded to a host computer via USB. Imagine the possibility of automatic meeting minutes (the most boring task imaginable now streamlined)!

      An awesome application for this would be for college students in addition to professionals. Imagine being able to train an OCR program to convert class notes into plain text files which can be categorized on a disk. Imagine being able to grep for topics to avoid having to flip through hundreds of pages of notes.

      The downside is the Windows XP interface in the screenshots. If Logitech is smart, they will also support UNIX/Linux/MacOS. If they are really smart, they'll use Java or really good C, so they don't have to start from scratch on each platform. If it will be truly Windows-only (and remain so at Logitech's discretion), then Logitech needs to go to hell, because there is simply no excuse for non-portable applications now-a-days especially considering the revenue potential of this pen.

      I think the more practical device would be a run-of-mill-looking clipboard that you could clip any kind of paper to, write on it, and store that image.

      The clipboard is a good idea, since the grid is embedded in the backing. However, clipboards can be somewhat clunky to write on due to their size. Smaller pads of paper can be more naturally held in one hand while writing and flipping pages can be done very quickly. If there is a way to make a clipboard behave like a Steno pad, that would be worthwhile.

    8. Re:Paper. by Rader · · Score: 2

      The point is: How does the computer know when you started the next character? Or moved your hand to the next line. If it somehow read the rollerball to record your movement, you would end up with one big scribbled spot.

      Unless you wrote in cursive, and in a circle

    9. Re:Paper. by ivan256 · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I can certainly imagine ways of doing that that DON'T require digital paper.

      Just out of curiosity, how else would you do it? You need to compensate for the fact that people pick up the pen and move to a different spot on the paper while they're writing/drawing. How would you deal with that without special paper.

    10. Re:Paper. by pmz · · Score: 2

      Perhaps they know that the open-source community will take care of that themselves?

      Time will tell whether they keep the interface undocumented. If they keep it undocumented and limit themselves to Windows, then Logitech is nothing more than a Microsoft sell-out. The Mac user market alone would be worth going after with this sort of product. I'm sure there would be many adopters from the UNIX and Linux segments, as well.

    11. Re:Paper. by SpeedBump0619 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Either this was the easiest way to implement it (unlikely) or they saw that the real margins for this market are in selling digital paper on an ongoing basis (much more likely).

      One of the problems with these kind of devices is that they (like mice) use a completely relative coordinate system. The dots allow you to have specific paper for various tasks. Imagine properly formatted page for email. It has TO, FROM, CC, BCC, Subject, etc. The dots give an absolute position and information about what the format of the page is. Thus, when the computer parses the data it can tell that this was an email, and it knows which part of your scribble was the subject, the body, and all the rest.

      My question is can they make it to work with *both* the dots and without. Clearly it's technologically feasible...optical mice can work on most surfaces these days. If so I can use a bluetooth enabled version for all of my device types:

      1) absolute coordinates with onscreen feedback
      as graphics tablets, and possibly touch-screens
      2) relative coordinates with onscreen feedback
      as a replacement mouse
      3) absolute coordinates with writing trail
      on special paper (email/calendar/contact/art)
      4) relative coordinates with writing trail
      on regular paper (free-form notes/authoring)

    12. Re:Paper. by swv3752 · · Score: 2

      Curve analysis? Say that your pointer finger always has to rest on an on button, and with the camera with a wide enough angle of capture, could just reconstuct the curves.

      --
      Just a Tuna in the Sea of Life
    13. Re:Paper. by ivan256 · · Score: 2

      1) Look at the bottom of your mouse.

      The bottom of my mouse has a red light on it. Yours may have a ball or two disks. Either way, when I pick it up off the table the cursor stops moving. Imagine trying to draw a picture or a diagram, or write words, but every time you try to make a mark it starts exactly where the last one ended...

      1a) Look into summasketch pens from the 1980s

      They have a special tablet and a coil of wire to detect their position. How is that different from having a special pad?

      1b) Hang head in shame.

      I'll leave that part to you.

    14. Re:Paper. by EvanED · · Score: 2

      >>then how is this really much different than writing on a graphics tablet?

      Because you then have the digital copy as well as the original. I'd find myself printing most of the stuff I'd use a tablet for anyway, which would be far less quality. (I've mentioned in the past my hatred for having to read from computer screens for more than short periods of time.)

  9. The Coolness Wheres Off by Daveman692 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Ok, so I first read the article and do the "Oooo cool". Then I think about it. We have had the pen and paper thing for the Palm, way overpriced. Then things like a Wacom tablet, very cool for drawing but don't try using it to write with. So now we get this. I personally don't see the full use of it. Yeah, I can take written notes in class and get them on my computer but why not just type them in in the first place. I can barly read my handwriting anyway and normally lose my pens. Bought a pack of 7 UniBall pens a month ago, down to about 2.

  10. Logitech by SexyKellyOsbourne · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Logitech has made some really cool stuff lately -- their speakers are an absolute steal and are better at half the price than anything put out by Creative or Klipsch.

    Too bad this pen reports in a proprietary .PEN format, however -- and even exported to JPGs, the files are probably too big to be used on PDAs, in emails, and other things.

    But worst of all, the software that decodes it REQUIRES the .NET framework to run -- so much for Linux!

    We should write Logitech and request free file formats (like an export to PNG) and free software with open drivers, not some program that forces .NET upon you!

    1. Re:Logitech by JordoCrouse · · Score: 2, Interesting

      But worst of all, the software that decodes it REQUIRES the .NET framework to run -- so much for Linux!

      Well geez. It seems to me that USB is a standard, and unless Logitech encrypted the data they are sending across the line, it should be an easy thing to use USB Snoopy (http://home.jps.net/~koma/) to read the packets and determine how the bytes work.

      It shouldn't matter if they used .NET or GWBASIC to write the driver, because the driver for Linux would have to be different anyway.

      I can't believe you actually got modded up for that.

      --
      Do you have Linux and a DotPal? Click here now!
    2. Re:Logitech by dizco · · Score: 5, Interesting

      No offense, but why must EVERYTHING be ported to Linux? Logitech is a profitable company, why must they make everything multi-platform? What if they don't have the resources or desire to support (or give away free source) to their products to the Linux community? Does that make them "bad" or "wrong"?

      No, not inherently. But it makes the product useless to me. (well, the part where it requires special paper also makes it useless to me..). And I'll continue to feel free to point out that its useless to me, just as you'll countine to feel free to point out that i'm bitching and moaning.

      Hi, how's it going?

      (ps, I didn't actually bitch and moan about this.)

    3. Re:Logitech by RestiffBard · · Score: 4, Funny

      why is it assumed that when new hardware comes out that the "linux geeks" will just figure out how to use it anyway, eventually. why not just create the thing with openness in mind?

      its hardware. why must it be proprietary? the money for this device is in the friggin paper! not the device drivers.

      --
      - /* dead coders leave no comments */
    4. Re:Logitech by pmz · · Score: 2

      How dare they use an OS platform that 99.9999% of the audience for such a techno-gimmicky executive toy is running!

      This isn't the point. It really truly is not difficult to write an application that works across Windows, UNIX, and Mac OS. Use Qt and abstract the USB interface in the code...and that's it. Java is also a good choice. There is simply no excuse for Logitech to use .NET other than some backroom deal with Microsoft.

    5. Re:Logitech by alexjohns · · Score: 2
      Jesus H. Christ, people. +5, Interesting. This is a completely made-up post by a troll. How the fuck did anyone mod this up? I've got 5 moderator points right now, but what's the fucking use? People will believe anything if it's posted and sounds reasonably possible. There's no way to stem the tide of bad mod points.

      Taco, the quality of mods is way down. As a long-time reader, there just aren't that many +5 comments. Go back to the old number of mod points. I doubt this shit will be caught in meta-moderation, either. Who's got the time to do research to see whether the info is bogus? You've given an amazing amount of power to a new form of troll - the 'post-wrong-but-seemingly-astute-information' troll. We'll start seeing a lot of these, I imagine. Gotta be a lot more fun than bottom-feeding at -1 where no-one except fellow trolls and the unemployed see you.

      Please, Rob. I don't have time to read even at +5 anymore. It's too much. And too much of it's crap. There just aren't that many insightful posts. Please, think of the children.

    6. Re:Logitech by pmz · · Score: 2

      No offense, but why must EVERYTHING be ported to Linux?

      Because it really doesn't involve much effort if the software developers make the right choices. This means saying "no" to .NET and using a much better platform, such as Java/Swing or C++/Qt. By choosing .NET, all Logitech communicates to me is that they are trendy, narrow-minded, naive, and possible arrogant or bigoted against non-Windows users.

    7. Re:Logitech by zapfie · · Score: 2

      Uh, maybe because .NET sucks less than other Windows development environments?

      --
      slashdot!=valid HTML
  11. Nice, but... by Torinaga-Sama · · Score: 5, Funny

    You know, I can't even read my own handwriting on regular paper, what good is it going to do if i can download my my own chickenscratch?

    Thats why I went to typeing in the first place.

    --
    (/local/home/curiosity)-#who -u|grep thecat|cut -c 44-49|xargs kill -9
  12. An old wired article? by MankyD · · Score: 2

    I believe Wired ran an article on a company that was working on this. I don't believe it was logitech however. Several thousand invisible dots were crammed onto special sheets of paper that the tip of the pen could discern. Each dot was uniquely spaced allowing for the pen to recognize its location on the paper.

    Applications including automatic faxing, emailing or saving of documents simply by checking off a box in the corner of the paper. I would like to think it was wireless as well.

    I only wish I could remember which issue it was in

    --
    -dave
    http://millionnumbers.com/ - own the number of your dreams
  13. How it works by interiot · · Score: 5, Informative
    This page describes how it works in more detail:
    • Digital paper with Anoto functionality is created by printing a proprietary pattern of very small dots on ordinary paper that is perceived by the eye as a slightly off-white color. The dots have a nominal spacing of 0.3 mm (0.01 inch).
    • As you write, the built-in digital camera in the pen continuously takes pictures of the patterned paper. Then, when you place the pen in its cradle, all of your writing is transferred automatically to your PC.

    So my first question is: how much writing can it store if it's constantly taking pictures?
    1. Re:How it works by TheTomcat · · Score: 4, Informative

      I'm sure it doesn't store whole pictures, in much the same manner that an optical mouse only sends coordinate (delta) information, not whole captures.

      Also, optical mice (mouses), used to require special mousing surfaces. Now they work (nearly) anywhere (not on glass.. shiny black, etc.. I keep mine on my pad of graph paper, 'cause the wood on my desk is glossy and doesn't track with complete accuracy). I suspect that if this technology catches on, they'll be able to do away with the special paper.

      S

    2. Re:How it works by Fnkmaster · · Score: 2
      Well, the "pictures" if you think about it really only need to track where the dots are in the local camera scope. So they probably would only need a few 10s of bytes per snapshot, if the local dot coordinates were stored. Hopefully, though, the pen should contain the "map data" to determine coordinates from the local dot locations (i.e. the interpretation of the local dot patterns is on-board on the pen), so you only need to store an x and a y for each snapshot.


      Figure 10 snapshots per character written for decent resolution. Even if we figure the pen had 8 megs of some solid state storage built in, that could store an awful lot of writing in either case (80000 characters, assuming 100 bytes total per character written). That's more notes than you are going to take in quite a few of those organic chemistry lectures.

    3. Re:How it works by Nogami_Saeko · · Score: 5, Insightful

      It's more likely calculating movements the same way an optical mouse is. Just storing direction and distance data by calculating the difference in pattern at a high sampling rate, so it should be able to store quite a lot of it.

      Wonder if you could scan the paper in and print your own...

      It's possible that the off-white colour is actually florescent or something and the pen might use a UV light source to track the movements.

      Seems like the old inkjet / razorblades selling technique. Give them the technology (cheap?) then sell supplies. I won't buy-in to that type of technology.

      --
      "Nothing strengthens authority so much as silence." - Charles de Gaulle
    4. Re:How it works by Fnkmaster · · Score: 2

      A) Apparently my estimate is close, since Logitech says about 40 pages at a time.

      and

      B) I believe that the entire "map" is described as 60,000,000 sq.km. of dots varied by page, so it obviously ISN'T stored locally on the pen, and the pen must store the local dot coordinates to the camera position.

    5. Re:How it works by morcheeba · · Score: 2

      But the big difference is when you lift the pen/mouse... this pen will want to know where it is in relation to the other words you've scribbled on a page. Each page is unique so it can tell what page you're writing on -- otherwise it would record scribbles on top of each other. (A 'page-change' button wouldn't work because if went back and added notes to page you wrote last week, it wouldn't know which page)

    6. Re:How it works by Polo · · Score: 5, Interesting

      I don't know why this got moderated up, because I don't think the poster quite understands the technology.

      The special paper provides unique coordinates. You know which page is which, when you've changed pages, when you've gone back and annotated old pages, what type of page you're on. You could define special forms and print millions of them, and be able to tell what data was captured and what (unique) form it was written on - even what the order of capture was. It's quite a powerful concept.

      I mean, I can see forms that are all identical and print on the same coordinates. Maybe this would be good for anonymity and cheaper to reproduce.

      There are already plenty of handwriting capture pads and stuff, but the special paper really is the technology, not the pen.

    7. Re:How it works by TheTomcat · · Score: 2

      I understand, it's unfortunate that I didn't express myself properly in the original post.

      What I really meant was: if this paper is really as inconvenient as "special" mouse pads, someone, somewhere will come up with some way of doing without.

      Maybe microscopic sensing.. who knows?

      S

    8. Re:How it works by Polo · · Score: 2

      Snicker...

      But I think the PAPER is the technology.

      I'm sure someone will come up with a way to simplify that pesky pen away... ;)

    9. Re:How it works by Nogami_Saeko · · Score: 2

      My reply is late, but incase that was aimed my way, I use a hacked Epson printer that feeds directly off of rather large ink bottles situated beside the printer that I can open-up and top-off as needed.

      No razor blades for me ;P

      --
      "Nothing strengthens authority so much as silence." - Charles de Gaulle
  14. Kludgy? by rkent · · Score: 4, Insightful

    At the risk of sounding unsupportive of new technology, the description of this thing makes it sound a bit kludgy. It appears to basically be an optical-mouse element tracking a regular ballpoint pen.

    Of course the ability to digitally record your penstrokes is super cool (and I wonder how much memory is in there? How long could I write before I had to dump it?), but requiring the digital paper to go along with it... well, that smacks of Gillette's approach to razorblades.

    Initially, I thought it was going to be some kind of system for actually tracking the literal ball that does the writing. THAT would be neat; normal paper, normal ballpoint pen, and recorded to boot. Then again, I know some optical mice work even without the special patterned mousepad, so I wonder if there's a chance this would work on regular paper...

    1. Re:Kludgy? by Myko · · Score: 2, Informative
      How long could I write before I had to dump it?

      up to 40 pages at a time
      (from this page

    2. Re:Kludgy? by _ph1ux_ · · Score: 2

      well it my be kludgy now - but at least its being worked on and that they managed to get it into a small package.

      Give it a while - someone will come up with a non-proprietary-paper-requiring version with wireless - then all geeks can rejoice.

    3. Re:Kludgy? by spinkham · · Score: 2

      Sun workstations in the past had optical mice that needed a special silver mousepad with lines on it. I used optical mice on them years before I heard of any optical mice for the IBM pc platform.

      --
      Blessed are the pessimists, for they have made backups.
    4. Re:Kludgy? by wavedeform · · Score: 2, Insightful

      The main problem with trying to use the ball for tracking is that you would only know relative movement. Writing involves a lot of absolute positioning. The custom paper is cool because the pen knows where it is on the paper at all times. I can imagine a system with gyros and accelerometers that allows for capturing handwriting without a special surface, but I think that you would have to align the pen with every use.

  15. erasing by sploreg · · Score: 5, Insightful

    How does it handle erasing? Can you digitally white-out your mistakes before it is uploaded? It's a neat idea, but I don't see many people using it. The only thing worse than a paper trail is a digital trail.

    1. Re:erasing by pmz · · Score: 2, Informative

      How does it handle erasing?

      It doesn't. That's why they chose a ball-point pen instead of a pencil. As with an ordinary pen, erasing is accomplished by scribbling out what isn't wanted.

  16. Another fall of a reliable biometric security by Dark+Coder · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Oh dear...

    First, a poster of someone else's face (facial recognition evasion).

    Second, the goey fingerprint duplicator,

    now this walk-by signature hacker on a PDA?

    What would be next?

    Hijacking IRIS pattern (simply stareing at the bathroom mirror)?

    Stolen DNA pattern?

    There is no solid defense against unrevokable but stolen biometric parameters.

  17. 40 pages at a time. by Prince_Ali · · Score: 2, Informative

    That is according to Logitech.

  18. I WAS excited by RestiffBard · · Score: 5, Funny

    then I went to the website and learned that unless you use windows its a paperweight. not even a heavy paperweight.

    I didn't even bother to find out how much it was. I really liked the idea at first but upon learning that I need MS IE and .Net in order to use the thing my desire to have one went out the window.

    --
    - /* dead coders leave no comments */
  19. I've evaluated the Ericsson Bluetooth Anoto Pen by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

    I have tested the Sony Ericsson Bluetooth Pen paired with their T68i GSM phone. I was evaluating it for a possible global industrial applicaiton.

    I must say that while the concept is great, the technology isn't "there" yet. During my test, I had various tracking problems when filling out a digital paper form.

    Also, if a form was successfully filled out, the handwriting resolution was very dim. The image quality was acceptable if the form was filled out in big, bold, and neat manuscript letters.

    This might be acceptable for some applications, but daily, our millions of customers have millions of writing styles.

    There simply wasn't a way to increase the resolution for productive use with our proprietary industrial OCR engine.

    I'm going to keep up with the technology and wait for improvements in this area. The concept is fantastic and I expect the technology will be more refined within a year or so.

  20. Buy Logitech Stock by ErikTheRed · · Score: 2

    If this takes off, then they've created the first PC-based "razor-blade" market - companies make nothing on the razors, all of the (very high) profits are from the blades - outside of printer consumables.

    Assuming, of course, that they've patented & copyrighted things well enough to require you to buy Logitech (R) (TM) supplies.

    I've always loved Logitech products. If this takes off, then good for them!

    --

    Help save the critically endangered Blue Iguana
  21. Special Paper = Useless by bflong · · Score: 3, Insightful

    The subject says it all. Optical mice can track movement on almost ANY surface. Why should this pen be any diffrent? Needing special paper completely ruins this product.

    --
    Why is it so hot? Where am I going? What am I doing in this handbasket?
    1. Re:Special Paper = Useless by Dr.+Awktagon · · Score: 2

      It's not just that it tracks relative movements like an optical mouse, it also needs absolute coordinates. For one thing, when you pick up your pen, how does it know where you put it down again? Also, it needs to support stuff like checkboxes on the page that say "EMAIL", "FAX", and so on. Otherwise how would the software know you were putting a mark in the checkbox? How would it know you're using the fax page with checkboxes on the left, rather than on top, etc.?

      See, they have a gigantic "map" of every piece of paper and what's on it. Every piece of paper (or maybe just every type of product, rather than individual paper, I'm not sure) is unique. So that's how it knows what you're writing on, how big it is, where the "active" areas are, etc.

      This way you don't have to learn any special symbols, and the pen knows exactly what you're writing on without you telling it.

      Of course, if you're suitably paranoid, you might come up with some "unintended consequences".. does this mean each page is unique and can be ID'd? etc...

    2. Re:Special Paper = Useless by tswinzig · · Score: 4, Informative

      JESUS H. CHRIST. If I see one more comment like this modded as +5 I'm going to cry!

      The paper *IS* the technology development in this case. If you don't understand that, please look at their site again!

      If you would just think about how this could possibly work for a second, you'd realize that.

      Imagine a pen that works your way -- like an optical mouse that tracks movement. Write a long letter out by hand, and upload it to your computer. How would you expect it to look? If you said "just like my letter," you're wrong! With your 'optical mouse' technology, you'd get (if you're lucky) one long sentence.

      The special paper is what allows this thing to know WHERE the pen tip is at at all times. You could draw a circle in the upper right corner, draw a square in the lower left corner, then go back and draw an X in the circle. Then flip a page in the notebook and write a letter. Then go back to page one and draw some more objects.

      Now stick the pen in the USB device, download it, and you'll see two separate pages, just exactly as you drew them.

      And this is only scratching the surface... no pun intended.

      --

      "And like that ... he's gone."
    3. Re:Special Paper = Useless by siegesama · · Score: 2

      Optical mice track movement, the computer tracks the location and applies the mouse's reported movement to that location. Without the paper, you don't have a way to track location. eg: movement alone is essentially useless if you don't know the starting point. The paper gives you a coordinate starting point (so that it knows where each "stroke" goes), and it also gives a consistent up/down (so when you roll the pen ever so slightly in your fingers, it doesn't start recording on an incline).

      --
      what the hell is a 'junk character', anyway?
    4. Re:Special Paper = Useless by ciryon · · Score: 2

      This pen doesn't just track movement, it knows EXACTLY where it is. In this way you can write on page 4 on your notebook and the pen will remember it. Sync it with you computer, write something more on page 4 the computer will be updated correctly.

      It's called digital paper for good reason.

      Ciryon

  22. It's been done ... by mystik · · Score: 2

    Check here

    It didn't do very well, applications never were developed for it. And the handwriting recognition wasn't very good either, but I never took the time to train it. A.T. Cross unfortuantly stopped making it.

    It used any notebook, but it had a special back you had to put the notepad in that recieved a signal the pen emitted. It only used serial, but this was back when USB was just showing up on the scene

    --
    Why aren't you encrypting your e-mail?
  23. big deal... by Lumpy · · Score: 4, Informative

    I would much rather have the old trackpad pen recording system... I can use any paper I desire, and just use the magnetic pen over the thin backplane that my paper is on... easier, better and costs less than the overprices $200 + another $200 a month in special paper.

    --
    Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
  24. Dots... but why? by Find+love+Online · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Well, the special paper has dots that are tracked with a camera in the pen. But the question is, why does it need the dots even? My optical mouse doesn't need dots to work.

    Of course you might run into focus problems, like if you pulled the pen up it wouldn't know where on the paper it was. There are a number of ways to get around this, such as an ultrasound range finder connected to a focusing lens (pretty expensive tech to put into a pen, but if were already putting cameras in 'em), or an accelerometer or gyroscope position finder.

  25. 200 years? by Reality+Master+101 · · Score: 3, Interesting

    The first true breakthrough in pen technology in 200 years

    Er, the ball-point pen invented in 1938 wasn't a "true" breakthrough?

    Yeah, I've always thought that ball-point pens were overrated. Fountain pens forever, baby!

    --
    Sometimes it's best to just let stupid people be stupid.
  26. wireless by _ph1ux_ · · Score: 2

    "How cool would this be with support for a wireless protocol"

    Would it be called the BlueInk protocol.

    WEll - if they did have one with Wireless capability I am sure the CIA would love a few thousand to give to visiting diplomats and anyone else in general.

  27. Is each page in the pad unique? Each notebook? by dpbsmith · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Apparently the pen recognizes absolute position on the paper by recognizing x-y coordinate information encoded in the dot pattern.

    Well, is every page in the special notebook unique? And is each NOTEBOOK unique?

    Suppose you are keeping lists on pages 10, 18, and 26 of a notebook. You add an entry on page 10, flip to page 18, add an entry, flip to page 26, add an entry and download. Now what? Do you see the complete list on page 10 as it appears on the paper? Or do you see a series of separate one-line images?

    Suppose you write a note on page 3 of notebook A and then write another note on page 3 of notebook B, when you download them do you see both notes superimposed on page 3 of "the" notebook?

    1. Re:Is each page in the pad unique? Each notebook? by qengho · · Score: 5, Informative

      is every page in the special notebook unique? And is each NOTEBOOK unique?

      Yes. Here's a Wired story about the guys who invented the paper.

  28. Similar technology... by Gruneun · · Score: 3, Interesting

    We had a somewhat similar piece of hardware for whiteboards, though it didn't require special boards. A suction-cup-equipped sensor stuck on the board and special sleeves fit around the pens. Because we had several sleeves (for several colors) we could get pretty accurate results saved to a nearby, wired desktop. I liked the idea that all the new equipment was non-consumable and we could use our original boards and markers.

    If Logitech really wanted to impress me, the paper could be any paper, placed in a small portfolio sleeve with sensors in the corner. If they're using a template printed on the paper, just make it bold and dark, so it's easy to see through the a sheet of notebook paper. I could teach myself to write on the last piece of paper in a notebook and pull the sheet out when done. It would be much more useful to me than trying to justify a $10 notebook every couple of weeks.

  29. No Bluetooth? What a disappointment by MDMurphy · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I saw the original demoed at CTIA in Orlando earlier this year. Was very impressive when coupled with a bluetooth phone.

    One example used email forms on a pad. You wrote in the different boxes like TO: and SUBJECT: then the message below. When you marked the box checked SEND the message was squirted to the phone via bluetooth, then over the air. You could send text or digital ink which would be included in the email as an attachment.

    This looked to tbe the best way to send email if all you had was a phone. No funky predictive spelling do-dads on a standard phone keypad.

    The logitech looks like they managed to both dumb-down and encumber the thing. USB cradle? IE? .Net ? Yech!

    If the original Anoto pen was available for $199 I'd buy it. No cradle, no 20MB software loads, just use it with your bluetooth phone.

  30. Even Logitech needs recurring income by SirAnodos · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Could someone who knows tell me if it is possible to create a version of this idea that works with regular paper by tracking the ballpoint instead of taking pictures of special digital paper? It almost seems like Logitech has purposefully tied this product to digital paper for the sole purpose of creating recurring income. This reminds me too much of the printer and ink model. There is no way on earth I'm buying such a pen if I have to buy special paper to go with it. Give me a digital pen that works with regular paper and costs less than $70, and I'll strongly consider purchasing. Add some kind of wireless functionality (bluetooth, or even IR) so I can transmit to my PC or PDA, still for less than $70, and there is no way on earth I'm not buying the product.

  31. Let's all waste paper! by doughmein_dot_net · · Score: 3, Insightful
    Doesn't this go against the whole concept of the "paperless office" that was so popular a few years back?

    Just think, we don't have to print out every incoming fax, we can save notes and e-mails typed into the computer... then this thing comes out, and we get to *write* everything down again.

    Yeah, sure, it'd be useful for people who usually take paper notes anyway (like me), but for the whole "making communication easier" thing, it seems like a waste of perfectly good paper to scribble out a quick e-mail to someone with this pen.

    --
    Super ninja monkeys will one day rule the world!
    1. Re:Let's all waste paper! by B747SP · · Score: 2
      then this thing comes out, and we get to *write* everything down again.

      Well yeah, but we never actually stopped writing things down. The paperless office never happened, and never was going to happen. At least this technology lets us get the handwritten stuff we were going to do anyway into our computers without any second pass recovery process - scanning, OCR, etc.

      Think of it as a natural progression from those stupid whiteboards that were supposed to scan the 'page' and dump it to thermal paper. I say 'supposed', because I've never actually seen one that wasn't broken - why I'll bet there's a broken one in a meeting room near you! :-)

      --
      I find your ideas intriguing and I wish to subscribe to your newsletter.
  32. The Microsoft Influence Felt by limekiller4 · · Score: 2

    From the FAQ:
    I use Netscape exclusively as my web browser; do I still need to install Internet Explorer?
    Yes, but only if your system has an older version of Internet Explorer installed. Since Internet Explorer is a core component of Windows, many features of the Logitech io Software are dependent on the program. However, installing Internet Explorer does not mean you must use it as your browser; you can still use Netscape as your default Internet browser.


    Remember when Microsoft, during their DOJ trial, claimed that Explorer was intractable from Windows? That it was such a core component that could not be removed without crippling the whole OS? Not only were they wrong but they were caught fabricating evidence in the form of a VHS tape with telltale impossible graphics and they were busted, wholesale.

    Well this is just an example of how that fabrication -- and by extension Microsoft's influence -- affects a fair market negatively. Netscape, Opera, Mozilla, Konqueror ...all out in the cold because Microsoft created their own necessity.

    "Core component" my ass.

    --
    My .02,
    Limekiller
    1. Re:The Microsoft Influence Felt by tshak · · Score: 2

      Well this is just an example of how that fabrication -- and by extension Microsoft's influence -- affects a fair market negatively. Netscape, Opera, Mozilla, Konqueror ...all out in the cold because Microsoft created their own necessity.


      This is absolutely wrong. I agree that the fabrication in court was stupid, and MS's idiotic legal team could have won on factual grounds IMHO. Of course it wouldn't cripple Windows, per se. But a lot of software (not just logitech's) use the MSHTML component from IE. What logitec is saying is that a newer version of IE contains a DLL or two that they need. This is not taking over Opera, etc. because it has nothing to do with browsing the Internet nor does it have anything to do with your default browser.

      --

      There is no longer anything that can be done with computers that is nontrivial and clearly legal. -- Paul Phillips
    2. Re:The Microsoft Influence Felt by limekiller4 · · Score: 2
      tshak writes:
      "What logitec is saying is that a newer version of IE contains a DLL or two that they need. This is not taking over Opera, etc. because it has nothing to do with browsing the Internet nor does it have anything to do with your default browser."

      I'll concede that you are correct if:

      1. You show that it is as simple as a DLL and;
      2. A reason can be provided why the DLL could not be obtained without installing Explorer.
      In other words, I think you've got a problem no matter which way you go. If the needed component(s) is modular, then Explorer needn't be installed. If it isn't modular, then you'd have to find a reason why they couldn't be and if not, then Microsoft, by association, has done what I originally said; made themselves necessary.
      --
      My .02,
      Limekiller
    3. Re:The Microsoft Influence Felt by tshak · · Score: 2

      Because technically the DLL's (namely MSHTML.DLL) make up the majority of the browser, and it's silly to not include a browser with an OS - especially when most of it needs to be there anyway. It's perfectly possible for MS to remove IExplore.exe, so technicaly a small part of IE doesn't have to be there.

      I just get pissed when people talk about the demise of Netscape because of IE. What about all the shell file explores for DOS? Should we force Microsoft to not include a file browser, dial up networking or a TCP/IP stack (remember Trumpet Winsock?) so that others can compete in this sector still? Part of technology's rapid growth is ubiquity, which can put niche companies out of business. The browser used to be a niche, now it's used more often then a file browser. It makes perfect sense for them to integrate IE, both technically and practically. And, quite frankly, it's their right.

      --

      There is no longer anything that can be done with computers that is nontrivial and clearly legal. -- Paul Phillips
  33. 2 ?s by teamhasnoi · · Score: 2
    Why not Mac compatable? OS X has great handwriting rec. in it - transfer the .pen file to Ink and pooF!

    dot NET=dot SUCKS

    Can I photocopy the paper to make my own?

  34. Obligitory conspiracy theory.... by SirTwitchALot · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Not that I think this is likely... but since each piece of paper is somewhat unique (one sheet from a 60,000 km^2 area.) Couldn't this be used for some kind of tracking. Microsoft uses media player (with their new update) to grab these .pen files, looks at the dot patterns to see which piece of paper it was written on, then figures out where that paper was sold. I'm getting my tinfoil hat ready now.

    --
    Go away, or I will replace you with a very small shell script.
  35. .NET REQUIRED For Full Pen Functionality by limekiller4 · · Score: 4, Funny

    From the FAQ:
    Why do I have to install the .NET framework?
    The .NET framework is necessary for some of the functions of the Logitech io Software.


    Oh isn't that special...

    --
    My .02,
    Limekiller
  36. Gotta love marketing hype by morcheeba · · Score: 2, Redundant

    Logitech claims this is the first true breakthrough in pen technology in 200 years, but I guess the invention of the ball-point pen in 1888 doesn't qualify. Sigh... gotta love marketing hype!!

  37. Much better products out there by afidel · · Score: 2

    One company has a dayminder that has a pressure sensitive pad under the paper and it transfers the data to your palm pilot that sits in a little cradle in the other side of the dayminder. This product does not require any special paper so lifetime costs would be much lower especially if you already own a Palm device.

    --
    There are 4 boxes to use in the defense of liberty: soap, ballot, jury, ammo. Use in that order. Starting now.
    1. Re:Much better products out there by donutello · · Score: 2

      But it doesn't keep track of which sheet of paper you are writing on. For all the pad can tell, you could be writing everything on a single sheet of paper!

      In fact, if that was all you wanted, it would be very easy to adapt to the ballpoint pen. You would need one sheet of paper where the dots were coordinates from the top left of the sheet and that would give you everything you need. The reason Logitech's paper probably costs so much is that each sheet is part of a 60,000 sq km plane so the pen can uniquely identify not just where you are on the page you're writing on but also which page you are on.

      --
      Mmmm.. Donuts
  38. A pen made just for me! by io333 · · Score: 2

    Obviously I must have one. :^)

  39. Re:An old IDG article? by Conare · · Score: 2

    Your wish is my command.

    --
    Stop Continental Drift! Reunite Gondwanaland!
  40. How is this different? by tang · · Score: 2

    How is this different than the crossPad ? I got one of these on clearence at Staples about 3-4 years ago. Its a pen that has a radio transmitter in it, you write on regular paper on a special tablet. This records everything you write in the pad, and on paper. When you get home, you sync it to your computer (rs232, no usb) and viola, your notes ready to be converted with the included IBM handwriging recognition software.
    How is this thing any different, besides the usb?
    I really love my crossPad, its nice to have a paper copy, and a digital copy of everything I jot down.
    -Mkl

  41. Re:.NET Great by tshak · · Score: 2

    How in the world was this A) modded up and B) based on fact? This is like saying that just because someone uses Java (which supports Web Services, just like .NET) that Sun can now capture everything that you do with it. This is total hogwash barely worthy of a -1.

    --

    There is no longer anything that can be done with computers that is nontrivial and clearly legal. -- Paul Phillips
  42. Why on Earth do I need this? by ellem · · Score: 2

    Is paper faulty somehow?

    --
    This .sig is fake but accurate.
  43. the "demo" pictures by skydude_20 · · Score: 2

    i love how they always show pictures of technologies like this where everyone happens to have perfect handwritting, with perfect spacing and tabing so that when it is imported to a PC, it still is decently usable. If i really wrote like that, I'd never have to use a computer. What they need is some kind of active translation like the writting similar on an Newton or Palm Grafiti.

    --
    Jesus saves souls and redeems them for valuable cash prizes
  44. HOLY CRAP I WANTED ONE OF THESE!!!! by t0qer · · Score: 2

    Check out terminatorX
    No I mean really check it out, check out the turntables section. See the one made by toqer? Yeah thats me... Well anywho, on with my comment.

    I know 3 DJ's (more hobbiest) and I spent a little time watching how they scratch records, mix and all that good stuff. I noticed that when they scratched, they had a special slip pad underneath the vinyl so it would slide smoothly. This got me to thinking that it was the record that provided the most tactile feedback to the DJ, and not just the turntables.

    So I did that first prototype, it works good, but black doesn't reflect well enough so I would like to do something different. Here comes my big question to the people in the know.

    Since this device is more than just a mouse (it takes pictures and sends them back to the pc) could you track the position on the record with a visual cue? Like a pattern, a barcode or something? I'm thinking if it could be done, just distribute a PDF so people could print up thier own records.


  45. Rimshot... by Inoshiro · · Score: 4, Informative

    "But worst of all, the software that decodes it REQUIRES the .NET framework to run -- so much for Linux!"

    This .NET framework?

    --
    --
    Internet Explorer (n): Another bug -- that is, a feature that can't be turned off -- in Windows.
  46. Seiko's SmartPads and InkLink by Kn0w1 · · Score: 2, Informative
    www.seikosmart.com

    I think I will still prefer the InkLink, especially since it clips to any pad of paper, not require special digital paper. It is also only $100 vs. $200 for the io pen (SmartPad: $100, SmartPad2: $150) and works with PC(windows they should say), Palm, and PocketPC

  47. few questions by u19925 · · Score: 2
    I loose about 1-3 pens a week. So how much would that turn out to be?

    Second question: Is there anyone old enough to remember why typing was invented? I thought it was invented so that we don't have to read ugly handwriting.

    My professor's handwriting was really bad. Once I recd a post-it from him and went to ask him what it says. He was out of the office, so I asked his secretary. Well she couldn't read it. By chance his son came over there (then a UC Berkeley student), neither could he read it. Finally one of his colleagues (they had worked 15 years together) could read it. It was all non-technical. Now imagine if he had this pen and he sent all his emails in his hand-writing.

  48. Boycott Logitech by Frank+of+Earth · · Score: 2

    How cool would this be with support for a wireless protocol?"

    Good luck. I seriously doubt logitech would provide information on developing such a driver for this device.

    Boycott Logitech

  49. Inklink does the same, no special paper required by Abwh · · Score: 2, Informative
    Seiko makes a similar product, although it requires a reader at the top of the page you use, you can use any kind of paper, so it's less expensive in the long term. It uses USB to connect to a computer or it can send the data via infrared to a palm or pocketpc

    here is the company info about it

    I got it to take class notes and it works great. The only bad thing is having to re-position the clip after you write on each page...

    --
    Gerry -- #include "ea!.h"
  50. Glorified 2D barcode reader - could be simplified by stienman · · Score: 3, Interesting

    This is essentially a glorified 2D barcode reader. The camera captures enough information in the little dots to know where it is with good precision in the 60 thousand killometer 2 dimensional barcode.

    They couldn't use an optical mouse mechanism because it can't tell where on the page it is. They have a 60 thousand kilometer space so if you go back to the same page you wrote on a week ago and make changes then it'll show up on the correct page.

    They could simplify it, though, by allowing generic pads to be made where each page in a pad is unique, but if you want to change to a different pad you have to scan the top bound ridge first so it knows you're on a different pad. The pads are currently expensive because each sheet has to be printed individually. Make it simpler with the suggestion above and you can at least make the pads duplicates of 90 different printed sheets.

    I suspect it'll flop. People will only buy the special pads for the pen, but they won't always have a special pad available when they want to write something down.

    I think a simpler technology could suffice here with the parts of an optical mouse. It only needs to know which words are continous, and you can reformat their actual layout later, if needed, on the computer. Add a cheap accelerometer and it'll have a good idea of where things are in relation to each other. Add some powerfull post-processing software and it'll be able to eat drawings as well, matching up areas where the camera saw previously drawn lines.

    In the end, this is a hardware solution to a problem begging for a software solution.

    -Adam

  51. Too bad I only have 1 semester left! by mekkab · · Score: 2

    Think about it- all of your grad school notes (becuase undergrad courses are worthless... 'cept maybe the ones you take in your senior year, unless you take "basket weaving 101" your last semester so you can spend time getting drunk and laid...oh wait, I'm on slashdot...)

    kept for posterity- better yet- all of your grad school and PhD stuff in a format you can easily save and print out later. Sounds like a note takers dream for those qualifying exams!

    This should be standard issue gift for any friends/relatives going on to higher education.
    -

    Actually, I could justify this for work- frequently I take notebooks worth of notes, just to save 'em off for that one day where I will transcribe everything to a notes file... YEAH RIGHT.

    This would take the work out of it.

    I'm buying 3.

    --
    In the future, I would want to not be isolated from my friends in the Space Station.
  52. rant on pen stuff by asv108 · · Score: 2

    This product would be useful if it did not require special paper. The paper requirement is going to make this a niche or early adopter product at best. What I don't understand is why all these tech companies are moving to pen based products, especially the tablet pc. By the time the technology is solid, most purchasers will be comfortable with keyboard and mice interfaces, tablet and pen computing will be relegated to specialty uses. Just go to any college computer lab. Freshmen type 50 wpm with 10 IM windows open.A large amount of the people who desire pen based products will be dead in 15 years.

  53. Limited Mode of Operation by iCharles · · Score: 2
    The other gotcha about the IO (and, Anoto thus far in general) is that it is ballpoint-based. there really is nothing in the technology that makes is particularlly suited to ballpoints. So, you get a very expensive crappy pen.


    Why not multimode? Have modules to support a rollerball, fountain pen, or even a mechanical pencil?

  54. Easier ways... by MrIcee · · Score: 3, Interesting
    This just seems to me to be an overpriced way to sell a lot of specialized paper. The entire concept of paper where every sheet is unique (dot wise) from every other sheet means immediatly it's got a finite lifetime (like, imagine a warehouse fire where 2 million reams of the stuff disappear).

    I'm surprised that nobody has done anything novel such as a small coil in the tip and a ink ball that has a partial metal structure. In such a system you should be able to sense the ball movement and direction. The ball would be super cheap and could be your renuable revenue stream by selling the replacement ink cartridges. Furthermore, such a sensor would be so small that it could easily be placed into just about any profile - not the bloated fat (and probably uncomfortable) pen they came up with.

    I mean, isn't a pen nothing more than a very very very tiny mouse ball? Sensing it's rotation and position should not be hard asuming you can fiddle with the balls composition.

    I don't see any novel technology here, only bad design.

    1. Re:Easier ways... by tswinzig · · Score: 2

      I mean, isn't a pen nothing more than a very very very tiny mouse ball? Sensing it's rotation and position should not be hard asuming you can fiddle with the balls composition.

      Please complete this simple exercise:

      Write a full page letter without picking up your pen one time. How does that letter look? Because that's exactly how you'd have to write it with your cool pen.

      I don't see any novel technology here, only bad design.

      Apparantly because you don't understand what is required to make this type of system work?

      --

      "And like that ... he's gone."
    2. Re:Easier ways... by MrIcee · · Score: 3, Informative
      Write a full page letter without picking up your pen one time. How does that letter look? Because that's exactly how you'd have to write it with your cool pen.

      I can also think of a number of technologies for this particular situation as well. Silicon accelerameters could easily be used to detect movement side to side. Coupled with a simple tip switch (e.g., am I pushing on paper or not) this could kick in to determine amount of movement.

      Again, there *are* solutions for this type of problem that does not include *paper with dots on it*. Quite frankly, that is simply not acceptable because in order for the pen to be useable you have to have the paper.

      Consider the death of optical mice that require the special pads with dots in them.

      Note that companies have produced similar technology for tablets.... such as Wacom. Their pen is totally passive (e.g., no power other than that radiated from the tablet) - yet it senses up/down/tilt/rotation as well as pressure and stroke. Now before you go off the deep end, yes, I understand how the WACOM technology works (I used to write drivers for them) and yes, it is not the same... but a similar mechanism can be created for a pen device that I believe would work well enough to be useful and not require a special pad or special paper.

      In fact, just considering wacom technology - what would be the difference if you merely used the pen to write on a "clipboard". There are already those types of devices out there - they require no *special paper*. I'd prefer that to special paper because it would let me use just about ANY paper - as long as I was writing things down on the *clipboard*. Again, these devices already exist.

      I don't think it's a far jump to getting rid of the paper and the clip board. Hmmmmm, to bad GPS resolution isn't enough to track the hand movement.

  55. Re:ok but... by Rick+the+Red · · Score: 3, Funny
    Yeah, but this is only 2002, so we've got eight (well, seven) years left to develop Europa.

    --
    If all this should have a reason, we would be the last to know.
  56. Where do you people buy your paper? by zvogt · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Who here thinks $9.99 is 'TRIPLE' the price of a regular notebook? Where I come from a notebook costs about .19, that's more than 50x the price.

  57. This thing is huge! by Nintendork · · Score: 2
    You could use it as a club to beat the hell out of an intruder, then later observe your fighting style on the computer.

    Sorry, but I'm not getting this one. I'll wait for a slimmer version and then decide if it's even worth purchasing.

  58. Why? by OverCode@work · · Score: 4, Interesting

    This is not a troll; I'm serious in doubt as to why this product is useful.

    Notepads are useful largely because they're essentially disposable; you can scribble as much as you want without worrying about running out of paper or about it costing too much. $10 for a replacement notebook is a bit steep. I usually pay $1 or so for my notebooks.

    So I can get an image of my notebook pages... doesn't a $50 scanner do the same thing? Ok, so a scanner takes a little while and only handles a page at a time. Is that limitation worth $150 to that many people, especially with an extra $7 per notebook?

    Cool technology, but I doubt this will be a successful product.

    -John

  59. oh damn... by trb · · Score: 2

    I lost my pen. Not only did I lose my pen, I lost the information stored in it.

  60. Re:Went from Interesting - not interesting by pmz · · Score: 2

    No, someone thinks you're in a very small minority, and wants to maximize their profits by targetting the largest audience they can.

    Again, it would not have been more work for Logitech to adopt a framework other than .NET. There are other options, such as Java/Swing or C++/Qt, that would allow them to easily produce versions portable across UNIX, Linux, Mac OS, and Windows. Right now, the only thing .NET accomplishes is limiting their potential base of customers to those who use Windows. This alientates all the artists who prefer Mac OS and could benefit from digitized sketches. It alientates the "geeks" who would love a pen like this if only for a novelty. It alientates UNIX shops who could use this pen to document meetings and initial designs. There are many people who don't use Windows who would want a pen like this.

  61. Is this related to Digital Ink? by jesterzog · · Score: 2

    One thing I can't help noticing is that the picture looks very similar to Digital Ink, which was developed at the Institute for Complex Engineered Systems at CMU and won the 1997 Gold Industrial Design Excellence Award. I don't know about the functionality.

    The main obvious difference seems to be that the logitech one needs the special paper. Does anyone know if there's a relation?

  62. Gah! So MUCH redundancy! by Matey-O · · Score: 2

    Yes, if you RTFA you'll know the dots correspond to a map larger than the US.

    What _I_ want to know is: Can I scan a page at reasonable resolution and have the laser printer crank out replacements? Then the paper costs about 3 cents a sheet.

    If no, how long til we have a 12k app that generates a useful sequence that can be sent to a laser printer? (BTW, the pages look like they've got a roughtly 12% greyscale screen on them...)

    --
    "Draco dormiens nunquam titillandus."
  63. Is your neighbor a pencil hoarder? by Julian+Morrison · · Score: 5, Funny

    Is your neighbor hoarding pencils? Since the Prevention Of Subversion Act (2009) was passed, all pens have been required to have proper government wireless logging. Owning a pencil is illegal. Report hoarders to the police! Your house may be inspected for contraband at any time - if we catch you with illegal untapped writing materials, the penalty is incarceration as an enemy combatant in Traitor City X-ray. Remember citizen, information is the poison by which treason subverts patriotism. Eternal war for eternal peace! Heil Bush!

  64. Re:Proprietary .PEN and .NET: I shit you not! by alexjohns · · Score: 2
    Hmm, I stand corrected. Looking at the other crap you'd written, I'd assumed you were trolling again. My bad. Apologies all around.

    Does the .NET framework work via the Crossover plugin? I know IE does. Once it's exported to JPG, it doesn't matter which OS you use.

    Overall, there's still too many mod points floating around, I think.

  65. Is Apple listening? by Have+Blue · · Score: 2

    I don't see anything about handwriting recognition or OCR in there. Wouldn't this pen be FAR more useful if it showed up on your computer as text instead of a bad scan of your handwriting? Surely there's a modern OS with a built-in handwriting recognition service out there somewhere...

  66. Chatpen by shadowj · · Score: 2

    Logitech isn't Anoto's only licensee. Sounds like you're talking about Sony Ericsson's Chatpen. It's suddenly hard to find on their website, though... makes you wonder whether they're having second thoughts about shipping it.

    --

    --Larry

    Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by incompetence

  67. Granted it could be Virtual PC . . . by actappan · · Score: 2

    But in this image on the IOpen website, it sure looks like, well, they pasted the image on to that pretty little notebook. Hmm, windows on a TiBook . . .

    --
    \Drew National Data Director, John Edwards for President
  68. Sell your logitech stock by heroine · · Score: 2

    Another word for this innovative 2002 technology: a scanner. You know you're in a recession when different mechanisms are being used to accomplish the same thing, each new mechanism providing less and less advantage. This is a real stretch for any practical improvement over scanners.

  69. here's telling by Splork · · Score: 2

    read this old (april 2001) wired article on anoto.

  70. Privacy and Anoto by billstewart · · Score: 2

    This Anoto pen
    wants to be your friend
    every page you send
    we know end to end
    we'll be watching you.

    Every word you write
    every pen you bite
    every thing you draw
    that's what we just saw
    we'll be watching you

    every check you sign
    it knows just what time
    when you draw a line
    all your base are mine
    we'll be watching you.

    Maybe it's gotten better, but the initial Anoto documentation indicated that they handled coordination of everything written using Anoto. It's closely related to the fact that Anoto has a global data space for their paper - each piece is unique, and which lets them build interesting and special applications if they can see all the data, and part of their business plan was to sell off pieces of the map to companies who wanted to do things with it. There was some encryption stuff build in, but no real documentation on what information was available to whom. For most applications, that's not necessary - the user's PC could do most applications standalone, using the address space to do relative calculations (using x and y distance from the starting point, if the algorithms support that without central processing.)

    I couldn't tell from the web page whether .NET was used just as a bunch of libraries (e..g for communicating with the pen via USB) or if it was also used to talk to Anoto themselves, or to Logitech - does anybody have more information?

    --

    Bill Stewart
    New Fast-Compression-only CPR http://preview.tinyurl.com/dy575ks
  71. Take it to the next level; Lose the $ paper; JOT! by SonicSense · · Score: 2, Informative
    The limited number of scenarios where the IO will actually be both More efficient and cost effective doesn't seem to bode well for the future of this version... pretty high cool factor though, I admit, but just pricey enough to make you think before you leap... What is the Erricson version going to cost?

    This is an old concept. A friend of mine had this same idea years ago in Grad School. We were creating strategic techhology concepts and his digital pen was The JOT! Check it out: annoia.com. Go in, click on The Jot movie...

    Get rid of the expensive paper! Make it do a few other things that might actually make my life easier! Then I'll spend the money.

  72. Down to basics by telstar · · Score: 2

    How do you erase?
    How do you chew on the end?

  73. Jeez, me too by wirefarm · · Score: 2

    I tried to use a 'regular pen' the other day to outline something in a meeting -
    It had been so long since I had 'written' that I felt like I was using my left hand instead.

    Even then, I kept using the Grafitti letter forms that I use to input text into my PalmPilot thingie.

    "The" looked more like "7h3". When my boss asked me to xerox my notes for him, I just typed them up and emailed them instead.

    My handwriting was never any good, but it's certainly gotten much worse lately...

    Cheers,
    Jim

    --
    -- My Weblog.
  74. Exploits galore. by rice_burners_suck · · Score: 2

    I can't wait until they make this into a wireless protocol, and then people's pens start getting exploited. Can you wait until even something you write on PAPER ends up on someone's computer in CHINA?!?!!

  75. Re:Just because it works with a mouse... by EvanED · · Score: 2

    YOu still haven't solved the problem. Try drawing in paint|photoshop|gimp|etc. as you would with a pen/pencil. As in, make a stroke in the upper left of the page, lift the mouse, and make a stroke in the lower-right corner. Not quite what you want, huh? You'll just get the end of the first stroke being the same point as the start as the second; the second won't appear in the bottom right corner.

  76. News Flash: by mmol_6453 · · Score: 2

    "In Silicon Valley, paper is now worth than the ideas written on it!"

    --
    What's this Submit thingy do?