Slashdot Mirror


Rumors of Mini iPods

TheKidWho writes "According to Thinksecret: 'Reliable sources inside and outside of Apple have confirmed Apple will announce the new pocket-size iPods in a number of capacities and in various colors, including stripes. Capacities will be 2 and 4GB -- meaning users could store some 400 and 800 songs, respectively. Prices will start at around $100US, Think Secret has learned. It is not known if the new product line will be available immediately after introduction. It is also expected that current iPod models will be revamped to add body colors as well.' With the $99 price tag, it seems these rumored iPods could make big headway in the low end mp3 player market."

135 of 621 comments (clear)

  1. Batteries? by TechyImmigrant · · Score: 3, Interesting

    But will they introduce a user replaceable battery?

    --
    Evil people are out to get you.
    1. Re:Batteries? by Gandalf+Teh+Ghey · · Score: 2, Interesting

      i want an mp3 player that can record with an internal microphone. thats way more useful than a camera-in-a-cellphone

    2. Re:Batteries? by shawnce · · Score: 5, Informative

      Ummm... the iPod already does this. Or are you talking about having this in just a smaller form factor?

    3. Re:Batteries? by geoffspear · · Score: 2, Redundant

      Yes, moderators, that's an interesting comment, describing a feature that already exists in the iPod.

      --
      Don't blame me; I'm never given mod points.
    4. Re:Batteries? by gl4ss · · Score: 3, Insightful

      and 2gb removable usb drive for 100$...

      not bad imho, though as always it remains to be seen. apple hw is funny in the sense that the RUMOURS are told in the fashion that normal announcements would be otherwise(and likewise, rumours used as facts when comparing to other upcoming hw with shipping dates, specs and reviews).

      -

      --
      world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
    5. Re:Batteries? by dasmegabyte · · Score: 5, Informative

      Well, the iPod shows up as removable storage. It is either a mac FS or FAT32. And you can dump files into it using third party programs, such as EphPod and PodWerks.

      What you're asking for is already done.

      What ISN'T done, is the ability to manage files by directory: to drag and drop them using your os and "just have it work." This isn't done for several reasons, not the least of which is indexing. Maintaining an index of the ID3 data inside an MP3 file is as important as its name...because it is this metadata that allows you to search by genre, artist, 'star' rating, etc. If you just dragged and dropped the files, you'd either have to a) build this index on disconnect, which could lead to LOTS of trouble, not to mention a lengthy startup time or b) build this index when the files are copied, which means having to attach data to the driver, and gets you no closed to cross platform compatibility than having a uniform application.

      Another reason is to assuade fears that Apple was making a file swapping tool. Apple's software is one way only...copy to the ipod or delete it. You can't copy from it. Therefore, Apple can't be sued for abetting piracy...since all the pirates have to use third party tools, of which there are several good ones for Windows, Linux and OSX.

      All told, the iPod is the best cross platform solution around. Apple just doesn't make a Linux version of its software...and there are TONS of compatible options for Linux users. They've already made your dream come true. And they've just answered essential questions you didn't even think to pose in the process.

      --
      Hey freaks: now you're ju
    6. Re:Batteries? by drinkypoo · · Score: 3, Interesting

      This is certainly the crux of the matter. IMO the solution is to make it run off 2-3V external power, and then sell a battery pack that will snap on, plugs into the AC adapter hole (though it probably won't have one, instead running off USB) and you can slap alkalines, nicds, or nimhs in it. Sony has made a number of small portable devices powered on just this plan, and it worked really well. Then they can sell it with a removable battery pack with whatever battery technology they want in it, and you can replace it with an apple-sold or aftermarket (but unsupported) battery pack as well.

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
    7. Re:Batteries? by OmniVector · · Score: 4, Informative

      sacrificing design to make a (tops) 1 hour chore that you have to do once ever 18-30 months slightly easier is not in my opinion a worthwhile choice. so what if you have to buy the battery for $50 or pay apple $99 to replace it. do you see the other mp3 players offering replacable batteries or battery replacement programs?

      really? i didn't think so either.

      --
      - tristan
    8. Re:Batteries? by Jason1729 · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Of course not. If a $500 iPod is disposable, a $100 one certainly is.

      What really annoys me is I can't carry a spare battery with me to swap if it dies when I'm out. I'll have to wait until I can recharge the battery before I can use the iPod again.

      Jason
      ProfQuotes

    9. Re:Batteries? by udecker · · Score: 3, Informative

      Several vendors have external batteries (or chargers) for the iPod.

      A quick search gave me two AA powered solutions.

      Myself, I just keep mine plugged in in the car and have 10 hours of charge whenever I leave the car. Easy enough?

    10. Re:Batteries? by The+Lynxpro · · Score: 3, Informative

      "Legitimate charge? Maybe not. But this way, Apple doesn't have to waste its time and money defending itself against the RIAA, whose members are also their business partners in the ITMS venture. It doesn't hurt its users, since we have other options."

      A challenge by the RIAA against the iPod would've never made it to court. The RIAA sued Diamond over the very first portable MP3 player, the Rio. The RIAA lost. That was the case that set the prescident.

      --
      "Right now, somewhere in this world, Scott Baio is plowing a woman he doesn't love," - Peter Griffin, *Family Guy*
    11. Re:Batteries? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative
      Oh, okay, we get understand now. You don't want to use the iPod to store and/or transfer data files, which it already does. You want to use it to steal music. Yea, it's not very good for that. You need to use some other software written by hackers.

      Why didn't you just say that you want to steal music right away, and save the confusion?

    12. Re:Batteries? by anagama · · Score: 2, Funny


      Sure - it will cost $99 and you will be responsible for shipping and handling charges both ways.

      --
      What changed under Obama? Nothing Good
    13. Re:Batteries? by w3weasel · · Score: 3, Interesting

      just to clarify... you can not load music (mp3, aac etc.) files via the os and have them show up in the ipod's playlists. You can manage files by directory using only the OS's GUI, as long as you dont want them to be available in the ipod's playlists.

      If you are reasonably adept at the CLI, you can shoe-horn files into and out of the active playlists directory on your ipod. This would be a laborious task, and there is no reason to do so, when the iTunes interface is so slick.

      As for flexibility from your iPod, I'm shocked that no-one mentioned this: http://ipodlinux.sourceforge.net/

      The hardware you want, with the OS you want.

      -----------------------
      quit crying you fscking baby!

      --

      Just as irrigation is the lifeblood of the Southwest, lifeblood is the soup of cannibals. -- Jack Handy

    14. Re:Batteries? by Jon+Abbott · · Score: 3, Interesting
      What ISN'T done, is the ability to manage files by directory: to drag and drop them using your os and "just have it work."
      Just to clarify, the iPod does allow you to manage files by directory, and allow you to drag and drop them using the OS, however it does not allow you to do this with MP3 or AAC files that you wish to listen to with the iPod. iTunes manages music files on the iPod, but Finder (or Windows explorer) manages the rest of the files on your iPod (for when it is in firewire disk mode).

      I'm not sure about how it works on Windows, but on a Mac you can have it in firewire disk mode and have iTunes open at the same time, which provides you access to both modes quite easily.
    15. Re:Batteries? by CapnRob · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Yeah, but what you *can* do is carry a wall adapter with you, and charge where you are. Wall adapters are cheaper and lighter than the batteries - true, they're bulkier, and they're not terribly handy in every case, but it does work in most.

    16. Re:Batteries? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      Dumbass. Music loaded through iTunes can most certainly be transferred to a different computer. If you took 2 seconds to see how the filesystem is set up on the iPod, you'd see that all of the music is stored under a hidden directory that is more than visible when doing a simple `ls` in a terminal window. Furthermore, you can just download TinkerTool for free and see those hidden directories in the Finder. It's not hard.

    17. Re:Batteries? by aldoman · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Exactly. This behaviour is far better, I mean the 'newbies' won't ever use the iPod as a hard drive, and if they stumbled across the music on a folder on their desktop (the iPod mounted) then they might be tempted to start uploading through there, instead of keeping a proper libary of music sync'd up through iTunes...

    18. Re:Batteries? by b17bmbr · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I'm not sure about how it works on Windows, but on a Mac you can have it in firewire disk mode and have iTunes open at the same time, which provides you access to both modes quite easily.

      you know this and i know this because we have ipods. but around here, not reading the articles or not having actually using a product doesn't disqualify one from making preposterous claims and scurrilous reviews.

      --
      My problem? I was perfectly gruntled, until some numbnuts came by and dissed me.
    19. Re:Batteries? by hesiod · · Score: 2, Insightful

      > Having an additional battery pack doesn't make sense for a portable player.

      Excuse my bold assumption, but you've got to be an idiot. What, then, do you think a battery pack WOULD be good for? Your fucking home audio setup?!?!?! Battery packs are FOR *gasp* portable devices! This is EXACTLY the type of purpose for which battery packs were MADE!

      Sorry for being so blunt & insulting, but I have no idea how anyone can honestly make the statement you just did while possessing the ability to use a mouse or keyboard.

      The only way you would make sense is if it was referring to a battery pack attached to a long cord, but I doubt many companies these days are that stupid. Plus, the original poster said:
      > > sell a battery pack that will snap on [...]

    20. Re:Batteries? by darien · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Dunno about your iPod, but on my Windows one I can just open "My Computer", click my way into the relevant folder on the iPod and copy, play or edit my mp3s to my heart's content. The only "restriction" is that the iPod software uses a cached database of songs rather than indexing the actual drive (which seems to me like a better option than scanning thousands of ID3 tags in realtime), so if you just dump a file in that directory the iPod won't see it until you update the DB using something like EphPod. Obviously if you use iTunes / EphPod / whatever to copy the file there in the first place then that program will also update the DB for you.

    21. Re:Batteries? by charlesparks · · Score: 2, Insightful

      When I say battery pack, I think of an expansion. Something that the product wasn't intended to work with. In this case, the iPod was created as a portable device and only a portable device. For this reason why should Apple create an interface w/o a battery and then allow expansion with a battery pack?

    22. Re:Batteries? by Zach+Fine · · Score: 4, Insightful
      I wrote up the following screed, and then realized I should start right off the bat with the most pertinent point:
      The iPod battery is user-replaceable for $49. See below for a link to one vendor.
      The iPod was obviously designed for optimal simplicity, elegance, and small-size. Apple crammed a flat battery into the thing that is about the size of the entire back of the device, and thus managed to make the highest capacity/size ratio portable mp3 player available.

      Adding an easily user-accessible battery door would (to my mind) break the seamlessness of the iPod's design and possibly require that it be larger as well (consider a door that's the size of practically the entire back of the device -- or whether the dimensions would change if some sort of snap-release tab-in-slot mechanism was added to the entire length and breadth of the current iPod back).

      Given that the battery lasts at least 18-months, I'd prefer to have a seamless design, and then have a little fun with a screwdriver when the time comes (rarely) to change the battery. In addition, I wonder how long the tiny hard drive will last given the conditions in which it's used and the forces to which it's subjected -- it wouldn't surprise me if (had I an iPod) I'd only need to replace the battery once.

      What's that, you didn't know the battery IS user-replaceable? See IpodBattery.com for details on the $49 ipod batteries they sell and to read the installation instructions. It doesn't look all that difficult for anyone who knows how to use a screwdriver.

      People seem to like to pile on criticism of the fact that the iPod battery is not easily replaceable. But I haven't heard the same sort of griping about the non-easily-user-replaceable lithium-ion batteries built into most PDAs (Palm Tungstens, Sony Clies, RIM Blackberrys, Compaq Ipaq, etc). I doubt all these companies forgo providing easy access to the batteries as some conspiracy to force consumers to replace the devices or pay to have a new battery installed, but rather the devices are designed to be as small and tightly packed as possible, and given this concern less regard is rightly given to putting the battery in an easily accessible spot and adding a door.

      It is worth griping a bit about Apple's previous battery replacement policy (they wanted $255 to replace the battery), but they've since changed their tune quite a bit and it'll now cost $99 to have them replace the battery for you. In addition, when buying an iPod, an additional $59 gets the warranty extended to two years.

      'Course, the iPod is out of my price range. I spent less than the cost of a $49 iPod battery on my teensy 128Mb USB-memory-stick-mp3-player-voice-recorder toy (Andus resound, flashed with some similar player's firmware to allow it to be mounted on Macs, Windows, and whatever-else as a real generic USB storage device), and find that this is a more than adequate amount of memory for a few hours of jogging. But if I were to buy an iPod, it would be because I appreciate things that are well designed and a joy to use, and the battery issue wouldn't even be on my radar.

  2. Finally! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    iCan afford one!

    1. Re:Finally! by TheKidWho · · Score: 2, Interesting

      ThinkSecret actually has the best track record out of any apple rumor site. And I dont think Thinksecret EVER released any pictures of a forged Apple PDA.

    2. Re:Finally! by Golias · · Score: 2, Insightful
      It's not an announcement. It's a rumor on a Mac rumors web site.

      It will not come out right after Chritmas, but rather it will ship on the same day as the 17" CRT Bondi iMac, the AMD x86 Macintosh tower, and the tablet-style iBook.

      --

      Information wants to be anthropomorphized.

    3. Re:Finally! by Hawthorne01 · · Score: 2, Informative

      They're hit or miss. The best, IMO, is Macrumors.com. If Arn says it's so, take it to the bank.

      --
      "Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity, and I'm not sure about the former."
  3. Cat got my tounge!~~ by Leffe · · Score: 4, Funny

    Apple realized that you'll have to hide your iPod when you want to be with your 'cool' Windows using friends.

    If they would see the iPod you'd instantly be removed from their hardcore powergaming group!

  4. this is good for joggers by Savatte · · Score: 5, Insightful

    The smaller and lighter the mp3 player, the better for joggers and runners. cd players are too bulky and heavy, but this could easily work.

    1. Re:this is good for joggers by TheKidWho · · Score: 4, Informative

      No, 2gb of flash memory is VERY expenisive, that would make the MP3 player cost at least $500 The new miniPods will most likely use the new 1" toshiba platters and have 32mb RAM like the current iPods do to load MP3s to prevent skipping.

    2. Re:this is good for joggers by squiggleslash · · Score: 4, Insightful
      I seriously doubt the 1" Toshiba drives are sub-$100. They're smaller than the 1.8" drives Apple currently uses for iPods, and are likely to be more expensive as a result.

      I have to be honest, I'll believe this when I see it. I hope I'm proven wrong, but I think either the price is wrong ($200 maybe?), the capacity is wrong (256Mb perhaps?), or they're planning something evil, like tying the machine to a more expensive version of the iTMS.

      Or maybe it's "$99 for the ePod, $299 for the special connecting cable" ;-)

      --
      You are not alone. This is not normal. None of this is normal.
    3. Re:this is good for joggers by ucblockhead · · Score: 4, Insightful

      That depends...as a jogger, the real question is whether this device is solid state or harddrive based. I've never been willing to trust a hard drive to last while running.

      It has little to do with bulk. I've run with things as large as an iPod. I'm just afraid that a few months of the bouncing would cause a hard drive failure. It's why I haven't gotten one.

      --
      The cake is a pie
    4. Re:this is good for joggers by xombo · · Score: 4, Informative

      The iPod precaches all the music you're listening to to 32mb of RAM so it plays for about 30 minutes before spinning the hard drive up again. It works fine for all the joggers I know and I've never had a problem with it in my car, with rattles constantly and can't support a CD player without more than 10 seconds of buffer.

    5. Re:this is good for joggers by transient · · Score: 2, Informative

      I know anecdotal evidence isn't worth much, but I thought I should at least mention that my iPod hasn't been affected by my running at all. I've only had it for a few months though.

      --

      irb(main):001:0>
    6. Re:this is good for joggers by dasmegabyte · · Score: 5, Informative

      The Ipod hard disc has lasted quite well for my running. I've pulled at least 200 miles with it since May. I got freezes at one point but the last update cleared them up.

      The hard drive in there spins real slow (spindle speed being the major component of shock damage) and it only spins when it's seeking for music. Start a playlist and it'll load 32 meg of your list into memory IMMEDIATELY...and only spin up to add more, which it can usually do in under 10 seconds. This equates to 20-30 seconds of hard disk spin during a 45 minute run.

      Combine that with the one year warranty and an iSkin (with which I've dropped mine a number of times onto concrete from 4 feet, no problems) and you've got the best solution joggers ever had.

      --
      Hey freaks: now you're ju
    7. Re:this is good for joggers by ljavelin · · Score: 4, Interesting

      I run at least 18 miles a week with my iPod for the last 14 months or so. So far, no problems.

      Of course it can't last forever, but it's lookin' good so far.

    8. Re:this is good for joggers by joe_bruin · · Score: 3, Interesting

      no, not flash, DRAM.

      2 GB of flash is currently much too expensive. however, in volume, dram should be sufficiently cheap. yes, it's volatile. but if they have enough battery power to spin up and power a hard-drive, keeping dram alive for a few days at a time should not be a big deal. if you plug it into a usb port every few days, it should never lose power. and if it dies, well, you just have to reload all your music.

      pretty clever.

    9. Re:this is good for joggers by drinkypoo · · Score: 2, Informative
      How do you figure that spindle speed is the major component in shock damage? The great danger of a hard drive is that the heads will crash into the media, which will likely rip the heads off or at least damage them at any speed, or at the very least strip some of the coating off the platters and spread it around the hard drive, causing it to do more damage, and probably knocking the heads out of axial alignment.

      Therefore I should think that the primary thing that would make a drive more susceptible to shock would be the way the arms the heads are attached to are designed; the way they're mounted, their shape, their length, and the material they're made of. The arm can't be very short because the heads have to hold more or less the same angle to the media at different distances from the spindle/the inner cylinder, so this is basically a function of platter diameter and head travel.

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
  5. smaller == cheaper?? by Lord+Bitman · · Score: 5, Funny

    what? Don't these people know how electronics work?! Gah.. well I for one refuse to buy one until they make it cost three times as much as a normal-sized one.

    --
    -- 'The' Lord and Master Bitman On High, Master Of All
  6. Pocket-size? by kutuz_off · · Score: 2, Insightful

    What do they call iPod's size now?

    1. Re:Pocket-size? by Performaman · · Score: 3, Funny

      Tall, Venti, and Grande, of couse!

      --

      I have gas, but my car uses petrol.
  7. The Sony Way? by Destoo · · Score: 5, Insightful

    So that's how it's going to work. Kill the current market by spreading specs and rumors.

    100$ for a 2gb lightweight device by apple? amazing indeed.

    Just like the Playstation 2's specs killed the Dreamcast.

    Sorry, I'm just bitter.
    I probably just need more brandy in my coffee.
    Merry Xmas

    --
    Nouvelles de jeux et technologies en français. TC
    1. Re:The Sony Way? by DeltaSigma · · Score: 5, Insightful

      PS2's specs killed the dreamcast because consoles are released on a much larger time table. New MP3 players come out all the time. They're far closer to commodity hardware than gaming consoles are, thus, someone's not going to wait more than a few months for this ipod to materialize before they go out and buy from a different manufacturer.

    2. Re:The Sony Way? by OmniVector · · Score: 2, Informative

      No. Apple tends to have quite a following, so unlike many other companies it has many rumor sites. You don't really see a sonyrumors.com, or dellrumors.com?

      Just off the top of my head i can name:
      thinksecret.com
      spymac.com
      macrumors.com

      and i'm sure there are a lot more. i seriously doubt this is apple using a pr stunt, as these sorts of leaks happen often within apple and apple isn't to happy about it usually.

      --
      - tristan
    3. Re:The Sony Way? by faust2097 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Just like the Playstation 2's specs killed the Dreamcast.

      I'm sick of that argument. Sega did a perfectly fine job of running the Dreamcast into the ground all by themselves, Sony just helped them along.

    4. Re:The Sony Way? by dasmegabyte · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I wouldn't worry. Think Secret has been wrong so often, a rumour from them actually makes it LESS likely that something is true.

      Seriously, Slashdot, why are you still posting rumours from the people who cried "G5s in the new Powerbooks," "New PDAs from Apple," and other insane, no-chance-is-it-true rumors? Their "reliable sources" aren't.

      --
      Hey freaks: now you're ju
  8. How about a PDA? by GoofyBoy · · Score: 2, Redundant


    Please?

    You know that Apple-fanatics will think it will be the greatest thing even if its 10 lbs and has pointy barbs sticking out of it, but I just want to see what would direction they would go.

    --
    The surprise isn't how often we make bad choices; the surprise is how seldom they defeat us.
    1. Re:How about a PDA? by kurosawdust · · Score: 2, Funny
      You know that Apple-fanatics will think it will be the greatest thing even if its 10 lbs and has pointy barbs sticking out of it...

      The iPoke?

    2. Re:How about a PDA? by Laplace · · Score: 4, Funny

      even if its 10 lbs and has pointy barbs sticking out of it,

      Apple is going to release a 10# PDA that has pointy barbs sticking out if it? Sweet!

      --
      The middle mind speaks!
    3. Re:How about a PDA? by Scrameustache · · Score: 4, Funny

      You know that Apple-fanatics will think it will be the greatest thing even if its 10 lbs and has pointy barbs sticking out of it

      Yes, it will come with a handy carrying chain and will be called the iMace.
      I will swing it mercilessly at anyone using Microsoft crap who dares call me an Apple fanatic...

      --

      You can't take the sky from me...

  9. Pocket-Sized?? by Th0th · · Score: 5, Funny

    Thank god, it's about time! The current Ipods are so bulky and unwieldly, I can't believe apple even introduced them!

    --
    "BadTimes will make you fall in love with a penguin" - Laika
    1. Re:Pocket-Sized?? by scrod · · Score: 2, Funny

      Damn right. I need an iPod so freakin' small that it can get lodged in my ear canal!

  10. but by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    will the headphones still be white? otherwise, how could i identify with other pods?

    1. Re:but by ruiner13 · · Score: 3, Funny
      "will the headphones still be white? otherwise, how could i identify with other pods?"

      you can still spot users by their uncontrollable, spastic dancing wherever they go.

      --

      today is spelling optional day.

  11. Xmas? by clmensch · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Wouldn't it have been smarter to release these BEFORE the holidays? Are they so down to the wire that a Jan. 6 announcement is the last possible day they can release them?

    --
    There is no gravity...the earth just sucks.
    1. Re:Xmas? by McAddress · · Score: 3, Interesting

      the entire idea is to release them after the holidays, this way no one will get a low cost iPod instead of a $300 dollar one. wether this will work or not remains to be seen.

  12. Pocket SIzed? Huh? by ilsa · · Score: 3, Insightful

    The current models fit my jacket pocket just fine, thank you kindly. And it holds lots more music.

    My only thought is that by getting into the ~$100 range, that makes it something parents will buy for spoiled teens more readily. That would make it pocketbook sized. Assuming there is any truth to the rumor, of course.

    --
    -- I Am Not A Terrorist.
  13. Why buy an ipod by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    When you can get a cheap PII 100, install bsd on it, spend a week setting up a web interface and uploading all your songs, buying a cheap sound card, getting a car battery, put it all in a backpack and viola: Open Source MP3 player!

    1. Re:Why buy an ipod by MyHair · · Score: 2, Funny

      Tsk, tsk. Setting up the web interface for any self respecting geek takes just a few minutes. The rest of the week is getting the PHP, PNG, SVG and--in some cases--Flash to look just right and self-adjusting to every mp3 you have.

      And you left out the time for decorative case modding.

    2. Re:Why buy an ipod by Moofie · · Score: 2, Funny

      Because it would be the size of a small dog?

      --
      Why yes, I AM a rocket scientist!
  14. Pocket size! by Otter · · Score: 4, Funny

    Well, damnit, I expect it to be half the size of the current iPod *AND* powered by a standard 9V battery! Otherwise, I'll throw it out when the battery dies and sue Apple!

  15. Brand Dilution by kiwioddBall · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Can this be true?

    Steve Jobs is well known for keeping a clean image on his products - it seems strange to me that he would allow rainbow iPods. Rumour has it he objected to the coloured backgrounds in the iPod adverts.

    It seems strange that he would dilute the iPod brand at such a critical point in its existence.

    Hmm.

    Small iPods - no hard drives, only RAM based??

    1. Re:Brand Dilution by Bryant · · Score: 2

      You may recall a number of colorful Apple products sold several years ago: do the iBook and the iMac ring a bell? Jobs is well known for worrying about brand consistency; that doesn't mean he's not willing to rebrand products as necessary.

    2. Re:Brand Dilution by acidrain69 · · Score: 2, Informative

      2-4 gigs? I think not. A gig of flash memory costs more, and this comes with an MP3 player. It's probably still hard drive based. Fewer platters, maybe smaller diameter.

      Kudos to apple if they can actually pull this off. Maybe I will consider buying one of their products now. I don't need to carry around 20 gigs of music anyway, that's excessive. Maybe if I was backpacking across Europe. In normal use, I would never be more than a few days away from my home machine, so I could replenish the music supply when needed.

      And it better have user-accessible batteries. It's funny how people think of Mac as some superior technology, and here is Apple, gouging customers with $99 replacement batteries. Whatever.

      --
      -- Having a Creationist Museum is like having an Atheist place of worship
    3. Re:Brand Dilution by scottgfx · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Quote: "I don't need to carry around 20 gigs of music anyway..."

      Nobody does. But what I've found after owning a 10GB ipod is, that I use it more to shuffle files between home and work. About half of the drive is uncompressed video files for design and compositing work. Of all the things I own, I think it's my favorite. :)

      --
      It's mandatory to wash your hands before returning to the land of Dairy Queen.
  16. back to their roots by musikit · · Score: 4, Informative

    thank you slashdot for going back to your original roots. RUMORS. now we can use slashdot as a archival of vaporware that never made it to market.

  17. perfect gift by soundofthemoon · · Score: 4, Insightful

    This would be really great. I'd love to be able to give something like this to my teenage nieces. Sure they could use a full-size iPod, but $400 is a lot for a teen to carry around and probably lose or break. $100 would be cheap enough that pain of loss wouldn't be too awful.

    Then I could just give them iTMS gift certificates for all future gifts. I'd be the best uncle ever!

    1. Re:perfect gift by soundofthemoon · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Because I'm a software geek, not a hardware geek. Sure, I'll spend a weekend building a PHP/MySQL app to organize my DVD collection, but the most I'll do with hardware is install a new hard drive or memory. I don't get off on "some assembly required" gear, and you can bet my nieces don't either. Now, $250 for 20GB is a pretty good price, but how well does it work? I love how well my iPod works, and it's nice to have all my phone numbers etc with me wherever I go too. Add to that the add-ons like the hookup for dumping photos from a digicam. So yeah it might cost more, but you get a lot more too. There's always a market for quality and features, and even some of us on slashdot shop that way sometimes.

    2. Re:perfect gift by denisonbigred · · Score: 2, Funny

      More like you'll put him in debt for 10 lifetimes (if the RIAA has anything to say about it).

      --

      "There's no way to rule innocent men. The only power any government has is the power to crack down on criminals."
  18. User Interface by CmdrWiggle · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I am iterested to see what kind of user interface Apple comes up with for such a small device. As a G3 iPod owner, I think the control pad is about perfect. Any smaller, and it wouldn't be as usable. Not to mention the hassle of scrolling through 5 gigs of songs on a smaller display.

    But, I am usually impressed with Apple's industrial design, so I'll probably be impressed again (except for the color choices - I mean *stripes*? Ugh).

  19. Storage device? by John_Booty · · Score: 5, Interesting

    What kind of storage device would these use?

    My first thought was the CompactFlash-sized "microdrive" hard drives developed by IBM (not sure if they belong to Hitachi now). A 1GB microdrive sells for about $200, though. Even with the volume discount Apple would surely get, it's hard to image they could hit that $99 price point at any capacity. And I guess flash memory is ruled out for price reasons too....

    --

    OtakuBooty.com: Smart, funny, sexy nerds.
    1. Re:Storage device? by eddy · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Maybe a 'Cornice Storage Element', like the iGP-100?

      --
      Belief is the currency of delusion.
    2. Re:Storage device? by stuartkahler · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Up until now, the only demand for Microdrives has been camera owners who want a single Compact Flash card to take thousands of high resolution pictures. Microdrives use very few parts compared to a regular hard drive, so if they were produced in massive quantities, they could slash the price to a small fraction of the current one. Building the assembly line is likely the greatest expense in producing the drives.

      If Apple came to IBM with an offer to buy a million of the 1 gig drives at $40 each, ($40,000,000 contract), I'm sure some VP would work their ass off to make it happen. Especially since it would help them reduce their price on CF Mirco Drives, and push regular flash memory out of the market. There's a massive market for 1-2 gig Micro Drives that is waiting for the price to get reasonable. Portable USB storage, video and photo cameras, MP3 players, PDAs, digital picture frames, just to name a few. It's actually pretty amazing that a solid state storage device has greater market share than a disc based one right now.

  20. Re:You what? by Bryant · · Score: 2, Informative

    "Introduction" is probably the wrong word; "announcement" would be a better way to put it. Apple, not unusually, often announces products prior to the actual ship date. Sometimes we Apple fanatics (read: frothing fanbois, but we mean well) use "introduction" as synonymous with "announcement."

  21. Karaoke Recorder by AtariAmarok · · Score: 4, Funny

    want an mp3 player that can record with an internal microphone

    4 gigs full of karaoke. Yeecchhh! :)

    Not to mention an accumulation of embarassing bathroom sounds because you forgot to turn it off at some point during the day.

    --
    Don't blame Durga. I voted for Centauri.
  22. Roll on iTunes music store by adamwright · · Score: 5, Interesting

    All I want is the iTunes music store in the UK. My new 40G iPod is reading, meerly 2gig full. My credit card is ready, my bank account is ready. I've got enough of a buy list to spend 100 in 30 seconds.

    So where the hell's the store!?

    1. Re:Roll on iTunes music store by switcha · · Score: 5, Funny
      Filling a 40 GB I-Pod may be a challenge but will cost thousands of dollars if done the ITMS way.

      And will be, what, free if done by buying cd's? You just said that cd's are more $. Good closing argument.

      --
      You know what? ... A little club soda *did* get that out!
    2. Re:Roll on iTunes music store by switcha · · Score: 2, Funny
      Good for you for having cd's. The parent, however, said I've got enough of a buy list to spend 100 in 30 seconds.

      I think it's safe to assume he doesn't already have those songs/albums on cd.

      I've filled 25 Gigs of my I-Pod without spending any money. I already have CD's...

      So your music collection is worth nothing? It figures.

      --
      You know what? ... A little club soda *did* get that out!
  23. Re:Hello all! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    sorry, you must have meant to visit this site.

  24. Re:$99 iPod by evn · · Score: 5, Informative

    The life of the battery is NOT 18 months in all cases. The majority of iPods (many are >2 years old) are still working flawlessly. The manufacturer of the iPod battery claims that the battery should still function after three years of use (or about 500 cycles). YMMV based on the frequency and type of use but so far most 1G iPods are still working so there isn't a reason to suspect this claim is false.

    On occasion you will get a 'dud' something common to all consumer electronics. While it's unfortunate that Apple didn't have a battery replacement/warranty program when those two gentlemen made their movie, that is no longer an issue now. Applecare and battery programs were announces before the ipod's dirty secret domain was even registered.

    Furthermore, if you don't want to pay apple to supply and replace your battery, you can do it yourself - see ipodbattery.com

    Mod down if you must:I know it gets annoying seeing the same old "ipods aren't disposable" posts every day but I'd be upset if someone didn't buy me an iPod for christmas because they saw the parrent post and asusmed it was accurate.

  25. Re:Cat got my tongue!~~ by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    These might even be small enough to internally smuggle music into prison. This will become much more important when all of the illegal file sharing music lovers are locked away and tunes have more barter value than cigarettes.

  26. Re:a $99 iPod AFTER CHRISTMAS? by xxyyxxzz · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Because Apple's bottom line is far better served if a person spends $400 on a 20 gig model than $100 on a 2 gig model.

    In that sense, it makes perfect business sense.

  27. Re:a $99 iPod AFTER CHRISTMAS? by hibiki_r · · Score: 3, Insightful

    If I was on Apple's shoes, and knew I'd not be able to manufacture enough units on time for christmas, I'd release it in the summer, and make sure the product is not announced until AFTER christmas, to avoid competing against the normal Ipod.

    Nintendo has used a similar tactic in the past when releasing new Gameboy "flavors", It makes the best business sense IMHO. It's just that we've heard about the new product a week too soon.

  28. interview by mabu · · Score: 5, Funny

    Consumer: Sounds cool. What about the battery? Have you all thought about having a user-replaceable battery?

    Steve Jobs: STRIPES! The new iPod will come in STRIPES! Who cares about the battery when you have STRIPES!

  29. Screw the little one. . . by jafac · · Score: 3, Interesting

    The *big* one, speculated about on http://www.macosrumors.com/

    seems more interesting to me. . .

    Sounds like an ideal companion to a mini-dv camcorder. If one could dump video to it in the field, and possibly do edits to it (portable iMovie?) - that'd be great. I don't really have much use for an ipod - too big for pocket transportability (really). Too small (storage-wise) to be useful as a semi-portable "desktop music server" - (though a G4 iBook serves that purpose pretty well).

    --

    These are my friends, See how they glisten. See this one shine, how he smiles in the light.
  30. Re:Ogg Vorbis by MyHair · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Time for Ogg Vorbis support too, don't you think?

    From our point of view, yes. But from Apple, I wonder if a cheap 2 or 4GB iPod will be iTunes music only?

    Just a thought.

  31. please... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    my open source luggable MP3 player runs Gentoo .. it's far superior to BSD. Does BSD have portage? No .. in fact /usr/portage doesn't even exist. Clearly an inferior design.

  32. I think it would be Perfect Timing by mesach · · Score: 5, Insightful

    since they are set to "sell" 100 million songs through the Pepsi promotion...

    All you have to do is introduce a cheap player and then they have the free music, and you have the Apple Ipod cast in stone as the mp3 player to buy.

    --
    moo.
  33. Re:Ogg Vorbis by bogie · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I don't see why. I mean yea some people use Ogg, but why bother supporting a format that almost nobody uses? Sure I know you probably use it and converted your whole collection to it. Don't you think you should have just stuck with the format that 99% of people use and actually has industry wide support from portable music hardware vendors?

    I'm honestly not trying to make fun of you or say something bad about ogg(it's AS good as mp3), but I see no reason to support it just like I don't see any reason to support, FLAC,Monkey's Audio, Real Audio, etc in this particular application. I would be nice to have support for all audio formats in every audio player, but I don't think that is too realistic a thing to ask for right now. It's just not what the majority of Apple's customers are using or asking for.

    I guess as a Linux and OpenSource user I'm supposed to stand up for what's open, but that doesn't change the fact that MP3 is the defacto portable digital audio standard. Maybe over time the Music Store vendors will be able to snuff it out in favor of a "secure" audio format, but until then I'm perfectly content with plain old functional MP3 for portable music players. Just IMHO, YMMV, blah, blah.

    --
    If you wanna get rich, you know that payback is a bitch
  34. The Cornice Storage Element by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

    Linq.. Just for the record, I think the $99 might be a bit optimistic, being a rumor and all.

  35. 1" Hard Drive? by Alpha_Geek · · Score: 3, Informative

    When I saw this story it immediately made me think of this story from back in November on macrumors.

    This snippet is what I recalled:
    Toshiba plans to expand into 1" hard drives in the future. 1" form factor drives are already being produced by Hitachi at this time.

    Toshiba supplies 1.8" drives for the current iPods. Seems a 1" drive is more likely than solid state memory for the new miniPods.

  36. Re:a $99 iPod AFTER CHRISTMAS? by xombo · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Reason being that any wise business will want to get rid of their stock before releasing their product. It will do them no good to liquidate the older iPods at a loss. People will still buy the new iPod if they release it (allbeit unlikely), even if it's after Christmas.

  37. Re:I'd spend a lot less with actual batteries by Unregistered · · Score: 2, Insightful

    If you can make a regular batery fit inside an ipod and give the same charge time, you've got a job waiting for you at any electronics company out there.

  38. Finally by tang101 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Finally - I can deal with a $100 iPod.

    Apple tends to think that we all have oodles of money we can just throw at their neat gadets.

    My budget has been cut since the economic down turn. Nice to see Apple givin' us po' boys a chance to participate.

  39. Re:Pricetag by presearch · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Well... there's like a display, and a case, and some buttons, and some sockets, and a charger, and some headphones,
    and some chips, and a circuit board, and a battery, and a CD, and box, and some profit. Stuff like that.

    They could ship the same device, 'cept for a smaller drive, and people will bitch.
    or they'll reduce the form factor or use lesser components and people will bitch.
    They could have the exact same product they sell today, reduce the price by $150,
    give $150 iTunes credit, and people would -still- bitch.

  40. Re:I'd spend a lot less with actual batteries by the_2nd_coming · · Score: 2, Insightful

    the point of the Lion battery is that it holds a much bigger charge than your punny AA rechargeable batteries.

    why not build a laptop with AA!!!! woo

    --



    I am the Alpha and the Omega-3
  41. Makes perfect sense by SengirV · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Why sell a prodeut for $100 when people are buying in droves at $299 - $499?

    So the idea of releasing them for xmas is a horrible one indeed.

    I think that the timing of the cheaper miniPods coincides nicely with the $100 mill Pepsi give-a-way starting in February.

    It's all a game, the game called 'Maximize Profits'. And selling only the current iPods for xmas make you a big fat winner winner chicken dinner. Also, how many people are going to return their $150 128 meg POS flash MP3 player to Best Buy to get one of these new miniPods? I'd say more than a few.

    --

    Prof. Farnsworth - "Oh a lesson in not changing history from Mr I'm-My-Own-Grandpa!"

  42. I'll believe it.. by Lars+T. · · Score: 4, Funny

    when it's leaked on Apple's web pages.

    --

    Lars T.

    To the guy who modded me down from perfect to terrible Karma - Apple haters still suck

  43. Why you can't use AA's by TClevenger · · Score: 2, Informative
    To fit the space available, Apple went with a custom-sized Lithium Polymer battery (picture). These are of a size and shape that you're not going to be able to easily put together with Lithium Ion cells like a standard cellphone battery, so it's going to cost more.

    That said, since a 600mAh Lithium polymer cell phone battery costs $34.95, the 850mAh or 1200mAh iPod batteries aren't a bad deal at $49.00, and Apple will even do the labor and return shipping for $50 more.

    1. Re:Why you can't use AA's by Lars+T. · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Yeah, and its also fucking larger than the iPod.

      --

      Lars T.

      To the guy who modded me down from perfect to terrible Karma - Apple haters still suck

  44. and for storage, they will use... by ELiTeUI · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Toshiba's new 0.85-inch hard disks!

    ...or at least it would be QUITE a coincidence if they did not use these drives.

    ELiTeUI

  45. Re:$99 iPod by Unregistered · · Score: 4, Informative

    Actually, i'm much sicker of seeing all these uninformed ipods are disposable posts.

    A little more info on ipod batteries.
    The batteries cost about $50. That's a damn good deal for a Li-Poly battery. Apple just charges you $50 more for them to replace it for you. If it's not wrth it to you, buy a battery, pop the case off, and replace it. pretty easy. Yes your cell phone battery is cheaper, but that's becasue it's a low-capacity NiMH battery. A similar battery would almosy double the size of the ipod and last about for 30 mins of music.

    Apple can' use a standard battery. Cylinder cells hold little charge and are huge. Apple's custom batteries can be molded to make use of every spare area inside the ipod. I remember people comlaining about how the smaller G2 ipods had a shorter battery life. It if was a standard (which doesnn't exist) battery, it would be a lot worse. And a battery hat neesds to be replaced every 300 charges (whiich is about 3 years for most people; the ones whose batteries are dying must charge it too often) doesn't need a little door. THe case isn't that hard to remove.

    Disclaimer, etc:
    I'm a mac fan. Also i just got my new G5 Sunday and am still getting used to the new keyboard, so sorr about the bad typing.

  46. Good Point by Razzak · · Score: 2, Interesting

    With the $99 price point, replacing the battery is no longer necessary. Just buy a new one when your old one dies.

    So you've got:

    People buying iPods and exposure to 'Mac Life'
    People buying Music to go with their iPods
    People re-buying iPods to match their music when their iPod dies.

    Is Steve finally giving apple a smart business plan to go along with smart products?

  47. 2.2G microdrive for $180 by slithytove · · Score: 2, Informative

    You can get a 2.2G one by some company called magicstore new off ebay for $180. Since its a standalone product and more of a niche one than an ipod the profit margin is probably considerable. Still it seems too good to be true that I could get an ipod with 2G for $99 anytime real soon. Also- if they used cf sized microdrives I'd hope they'd just use a cf slot so you could expand. Such players exist, but nothing with the looks, interface or sound quality of an ipod.
    Personally I use an ipaq 2215 (sdio/cf/bluetooth/400mhz) as my portable audio/video player (and pda funcs). Now if only there were a bootloader that worked with it and linux I wouldn't feel dirty every time I use it:)

  48. Re:ipod sucks for jogggers by dasmegabyte · · Score: 2, Informative

    Which iPod do you have, Gen 1 or 2, or Gen 3?

    Mine (gen 3 30 gb) USED to do what your describing, occasionally, if I was running on the road with the 'pod in my hand. It never did it on trails or on a cushioned indoor track. The last update (2.1) fixed the problem. Something to think about.

    And it is certainly not too heavy to run with. My friend's wife (who is around 115 lbs) runs with his, but wouldn't do so until he bought her an iSkin. The iSkin, besides protecting the shell from impact, is silicon and really sticky...when you hold it, you can't imagine EVER dropping it. With the newest revision (which has more rear surface area than the old one) I can put the iPod on my dashboard and take corners without it slipping. And before I got the iSkin, I used to use a forearm strap which was really cool...didn't get in my way at all and never skipped.

    --
    Hey freaks: now you're ju
  49. neuros.. by gimpboy · · Score: 2, Informative

    the neuros does pretty cheap too my emph' added:


    The NiMH batteries in the Neuros and the Lithium Ion battery in the Neuros HD are expected to last at least 1 1/2 - 2 years (depending on usage). Only our Neuros technical team can replace the battery for you and, as a result, it is not consumer-serviceable. Our battery replacement policy is as follows.

    Within Warranty (90 days parts, 1 year labor)
    -If within first 90 days of purchase - NO CHARGE
    -Past 90 days, but within 1 year- $7

    Outside of Warranty
    Neuros 128- $8
    Neuros HD- $12

    To have your battery replaced, please send us the Backpack portion of your Neuros in a padded envelope with your name, address, phone number, e-mail (along with a check payable to Neuros Audio) to:

    Neuros Audio
    Attn: Battery Replacement
    1941 N Hawthorne Ave
    Melrose Park, IL 60160


    really? i didn't think so either.

    you're a pretty comprehensive thinker.

    --
    -- john
  50. Re:WHY DO PEOPLE BUY APPLE? (Hint: free market) by ajkst1 · · Score: 2, Informative

    I owned a 1G iPod that had a battery failure. Yeah, it sucked. But the difference is that I abused that little thing and it lived. I also put it through some harsh conditions and it lived. I bought a 3G 10 GB iPod on eBay for $225. Microsoft couldn't do it and not many other companies could because Apple has a loyal fan base. If you ever use an iPod on a daily basis, you'll realize why people continue to buy them. There are also fixes for the battery problem and replacements that are 3rd-party solutions for less than what Apple charges. It's a rechargable battery smaller than a credit card. It's not something you can just go out to the store and pick up. Ask Dell if their new music player has a user-replaceable battery. $5 says it's not. To quote their own website "Fixed rechargeable battery with up to 16 hours battery life." Key word there is FIXED. And if they have a battery problem, they'll have a replacement program.

  51. Re:Plain old MP3's? by FueledByRamen · · Score: 2, Informative

    It does present a standard USB (or firewire) FS interface (FAT32 for the Windows ones, HFS+ for the Mac iPods). I don't know if you can load songs onto it that way directly; you probably will still need a program to update the song DB files, but there are several OSS projects to do so (mostly directed towards Linux, obviously). I'd just use the iTunes software, but if you don't like it for whatever reason, try one of the free (as in GPL, iTunes already being free as in beer) iPod loaders. It takes standard MP3 files (both VBR and CBR encoded, so your lameenc collection should work just fine) and AAC files.

    --
    Every cloud has a silver lining (except for the mushroom shaped ones, which have a lining of Iridium & Strontium 90)
  52. I hope they keep the games by Dixie_Flatline · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I just got an iPod for Solstice (actually, I got it a few weeks early), and the single best feature about it is the games.

    That's right. The 4 crappy games that came on it are a blessing.

    I HATE shopping. I've hated shopping since I was young and my mother dragged me out to malls to shop around. Back then, they didn't even have chairs everywhere. I stood around and hated the experience. Now, when I go shopping there are chairs everywhere, but nothing to do. It turns out, I still hate the experience.

    But now that I have an iPod, I can listen to the music, toodle around with Parachute or Name that Song, and look up every once in a while to say, "Yes dear, that looks great." I don't know if any of the other MP3 players out there have these little time wasters on them, but they should.

    (Oh, I hear the iPod does other things, too, like keep your contacts, alarms, notes and files. So handy!)

  53. Part Price List by morelife · · Score: 4, Funny

    Mini iPod 99.
    Battery 99.
    Song .99

  54. Damn You Apple!! by ckuske · · Score: 5, Funny

    Just purchased a 10GB iPod for my fiancee for Christmas.

    She'll never fill it up, and I knew that, but she wanted an iPod.

    Now there are smaller ones that are $200 cheaper, and in colors as well, after I shelled out another $50 and got a custom paint job on it at ColorWare.

    Apple, damn you!

  55. Only So they Can Really Say by Bruha · · Score: 5, Funny

    "Sir it would be cheaper to buy a new model than replace the battery"

    Or

    "Would you like to buy the battery replacement plan for 99 dollars sir?"

  56. Small MixUp by rblancarte · · Score: 2, Informative

    It was SpyMac that announced and had forged VIDEO (not just pictures) of the fake Apple PDA (called the iWalk). Looking at their site now doesn't turn up much of any news, fake or real.

    This is not to say that ThinkSecret is clear of wrongdoing. They did post about an Apple PDA called the MacMate back in 1999, but obviously that never came to fruition.

    RonB

    --
    It is human nature to take shortcuts in thinking.
  57. Re:iPod is fine for joggers by Golias · · Score: 2, Insightful
    Maybe I'm just lucky. I trained for the New York Marathon, which involves running over 500 miles over 6 months or so. I carried by little 5GB iPod, listening to books on tape, music, etc.

    If you are training for the New York, you probably have developed much more graceful mechanics than the people complaining of frequent HD problems.

    Instead of insisting on a solid-state MP3 player, those who think the iPod can't handle their jogging should work on inproving their stride. They way they are running, they are probably far more likely to damage their backs and knees than their iPod hard drives.

    --

    Information wants to be anthropomorphized.

  58. vaporware?? by 3Suns · · Score: 2, Insightful

    "From the vaporware dept"... Michael, How can anything be vaporware if the company hasn't announced the product yet and its very existance is only a rumor?

    --

    -3Suns

    ~~~~
    The Revolution will be Slashdotted
  59. what we really need ... by BigGar' · · Score: 2, Funny

    is a mega-Ipod that will store a billion songs and be worn in a backpack like case and the battery worn around the waist like Batman's utility belt. At least that's what I think :-P

    --


    Shop smart, Shop S-Mart.
  60. Re:so the iMac is crippled? by jaysones · · Score: 2, Interesting

    This is not at all the case. Copying your music to the iPod happens automatically by default. You can get songs off the iPod with lots of 3rd party software tools. It's much easier than any other mp3 player I've seen.

    If you have to mortgage your house for a 50 dollar battery, you need to move anyway.

  61. Creative offers replacable batteries by jmichaelg · · Score: 3, Informative
    Almost all of Creative's players have removable batteries.

    Notice that the copy even suggests why you would want replaceable batteries as a standard feature - road trips. Also notice that they aren't dinging you for $100, plus shipping, to replace a battery.

    Don't be surprised when Apple finally caves and makes iPod batteries easily replaceable. They'll claim it's a great new feature.

    i didn't think so either.
    Yep, I agree. You didn't think.

  62. Belkin makes an external battery pack for 3G iPods by teridon · · Score: 4, Informative

    If you are willing to put up with the added bulk, you can add it on to your 3G iPod. The external battery pack uses 4 AA batteries.

    --
    I hold it, that a little rebellion, now and then, is a good thing. -- Thomas Jefferson
  63. DRM + Ogg by Phantasmo · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Apple's in a very good position right now - they've managed to get themselves into the good books of both the Free software community and the music industry.

    However, if they add Ogg Vorbis support to the iPod then they'll have to

    • add DRM technology to the Ogg container format, thereby pissing off the Free software people
    • or add support for another DRM-free format to their player, and infuriate the music industry

    It seems that they are pursuing the third option: ignore Ogg Vorbis and piss off the very small (and to them, not particularly useful) Xiph community.

    --

    The US Army: promoting democracy through unquestioned obedience
  64. Re:i don't get it by martyn+s · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Maybe because it only has, um, 256MB of memory?

  65. This is not quite correct by tkrotchko · · Score: 2, Informative

    "Apple's software is one way only...copy to the ipod or delete it. You can't copy from it. "

    Apple's software, yes. But XPlay lets you drag and drop music either to or from the iPod; I find its a more elegant solution than iTunes, because it lets you use the pieces you like for downloading, ripping, managing ID3 tags. Then when you connect an iPod, it shows a special music folder that you drag and drop your music.

    And yes music comes off as easily as it goes on.

    --
    You were mistaken. Which is odd, since memory shouldn't be a problem for you
  66. Re:i don't get it by martyn+s · · Score: 2, Insightful

    This isn't insightful, this is SLASHDOT, NOTHING on /. is insightful!!!!!!!! MOD PARENT DOWN.

  67. Re:Preposterous by burns210 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    why don't they just reintroduce the 5gig model for sub $200? I mean, everyone would like an ipod, but they are friggin expensive to most people.

    The only reason i am not getting one for christmas is becasue of price. If my significant other could have saved 100 bucks and gotten a 5gig instead of 10gig, i could be rockin out christmas night to my cool new mp3 player.

  68. I'll have my credit card ready by idiot900 · · Score: 2, Informative

    2GB? $100? Made by Apple? I will buy one of these the very second they become available. At that price I won't worry about the battery dying after a couple years, I won't have iPod envy when the new version comes out, I won't cry if I drop it on the floor and break it. A wonderful idea, Apple - I only wonder if they will be able to make enough of them.

  69. iPod battery FAQ by daveschroeder · · Score: 5, Informative

    (Not in relation to the mini-iPods, as I don't know their specifications, but there seem to be enough idiotic battery posts, so...)

    Q: Is the iPod's battery replacable?

    A: Yes. Apple has an official battery replacement program for $99. You send your iPod in (any model iPod), and Apple will replace the battery for $99.

    Q: Is the iPod's battery user-replaceable?

    A: Yes and no. The iPod's case is not designed to be opened, so, in that repsect, it's not what you would generally refer to as "user-replaceable". But, the case can be opened, and there are several third parties that offer replacement batteries for the iPod, such as iPodBattery.com (instructions available at that link) and PDASmart, for as low as $49. Some will even do the replacement for you if you send it it.

    Q: What's the deal? Does Apple think the iPod is disposable?

    A: No.

    Q: I heard that the iPod's battery only lasts 18 months, and then you have to buy a new iPod, is that true?

    A: NO! The vast, vast majority of even the earliest iPods, now over two years old, continue to function just fine. Some iPods, however, have had issues with batteries. Lithium ion batteries are only good for 300 to 500 charge/discharge cycles. For this reason, certain customers' usage patterns may cause the batteries to degrade, or fail, sooner than others.

    A2: If the battery does fail, and the iPod is no longer under its original one year warranty or $59 AppleCare Protection Plan, or any of numerous third party service plans, you don't have to buy a new iPod. You may replace the battery yourself for as little as $49, or have Apple perform the replacement for $99.

    Q: Why didn't Apple use better batteries?

    A: Apple used the best lithium ion battery technology available from leading battery manufacturers. This is the best, most cost effective battery technology available given the requirements of the device. The lithium ion batteries Apple uses are no different than lithium ion batteries used by anyone else. The battery should last most normal users several years.

    Q: Why doesn't Apple make the battery easily replaceable, then? Or use different batteries, like AA?

    A: Because if they did either, the size of the batteries and/or the access panels and mechanisms required to access the battery would make the unit significantly larger than it is, likely by several milimeters in thickness at a minimum, and it may possibly affect other dimensions as well. It was an engineering decision to use an integrated battery; if it were not integrated, the unit would not have the small, sleek form factor that makes it so attractive. Additionally, the iPod's battery is indeed replaceable, as has been discussed above.

    Q: Well, no one else does that!

    A: Wrong. Prime example: Dell's new DJ portable music player uses an integrated, non-user-replaceable lithium ion battery, just like the iPod. Dell also has no plan or program to replace batteries outside of warranty at this time.

    Q: But, Apple only released their battery replacement service because of all the bad publicity from the Neistat brothers' video.

    Wrong again. Apple released the battery replacement program as early as November 14. ipodsdirtysecret.com was only registered on November 20, and started being heavily publicized on November 21. Additionally, Apple had been planning the battery replacement program for months - these types of service programs don't just happen overnight - before Casey Neistat even had his first contact with Apple. The video campaign had nothing to do with Apple's rollout of the battery replacement program.

    1. Re:iPod battery FAQ by Brat+Food · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Course, theres also a little bit of economics to consider here:

      Lets say, the iPod had the choice of using 2AA batteries. Lets's say you got your AA's at $0.50(too high? too low? i dont have to buy them). Lets's see what youve paid for JUST BATTERIES over the "300-500" charge average lifetime of apples built in battery:

      err, $300-$500... I made my math too easy =(

      Probably more depending on how much you use the ipod, if the ipod could run on only 2AAs, and what quality battery you buy for it. Still complaining? If you are really desperate, i think some companies offer *gasp* external battery packs. But even at 99 bucks, Apples battery replacement nost likely means your not gonna blow double that much on batteries over the next few years.

      *CHEERS*

      --

      "Stuff... In my home!? NEVER!" - Zim on Invader Zim
      "I want the toilet seat!" - Little Dog on Two Stupid Dogs
    2. Re:iPod battery FAQ by daveschroeder · · Score: 2, Informative

      If users are complaining about it, it's a flaw. Because the flaw can not be fixed without significant re-engineering, it's fundamental.

      Um, no, not everything that is complained about is a flaw. This issue affects a very, very small portion of iPod owners. The second part of that statement is rendered invalid. Additionally, there is an official program to replace the batteries, if need be, as well as numerous ways to do it yourself. Just because the Neistat brothers couldn't do it means nothing. The instructions are here, with pictures: old, new.

      The vast, vast majority of iPod owners' batteries will last the life of the product. These premature failures are fringe cases. Lithium ion batteries are good for 300 to 500 charge/discharge cycles. If you are a heavy user, i.e., recharging an average of once a day or more, and using the unit daily, AND are always running the unit down to completely dead (a big no-no for all lithium ion batteries) you could conceivably be in a situation where your battery has degraded prematurely. But the plain fact of the matter is that almost all first generation iPods, some of which are over two years old, continue to function just fine, and will continue to do so.

      Other manufacturers are doing the same thing: integrating batteries on hard drive-based players specifically for the purpose of reducing the size.

      Apple, your customers are speaking. Are you listening?

      Apple, an extremely small, vocal percentage of your customers are making an issue out of nothing (since there are several reasonable ways to replace the battery, including official ways through Apple itself) - er, wait, some people who don't even own iPods, but just relish in anything negative related to Apple - are you listening?

      Oh, wait...you already did.

      (Note: if Apple's rumored new "cheap" iPods have easily accessible user-replaceable batteries, it won't be because of slashdot, the Neistat brothers, or "bad press", because the products have been in development for ages before this ever even came up.)

  70. Re:i don't get it by zpok · · Score: 2, Funny

    You're absolutely right. On the same note, I still can't understand why people were so critical of the Citroen 2CV. A wonderful car, wonderful!

    --
    I think, therefore I am...I think.
  71. Re:Preposterous by burns210 · · Score: 2, Funny

    don't forget, you don't just get an mp3 player with the ipod, you can play games like breakout...and stuff on there...

    remember breakout? ya, good times.

  72. Re:OGG support? by tuxedobob · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Okay, this is probably just a troll, since it says it isn't one, but it's a new troll to me. Anyway...

    Is there support for OGG files?

    Probably not. Yes, OGG is an open standard. Yay. That's nice. I don't feel like re-encoding 10GB of songs.

    Can I use it between my home PC and my work PC both of which run Linux?

    Hasn't someone released software to let your Linux-using PC's talk to the iPod? I think so.

    Can I copy a new track to the iPod at home and then download from it to my work PC?

    Yes, just use the iPod like a FireWire hard drive, which it is.

    Will it play those files that I want to copy FROM IT to my other PC?

    This is the same question you just asked. Are you expecting a different answer?

    Oh, and if Apple thinks I am going to pay $100 for a portable player and then $50 for batteries, they are nuts.

    What does the Neuros run on? Happy rays of sunshine? I couldn't tell from the site. Maybe it said it in the "demo", but I'm not downloading flash over dialup.

    BTW, if you don't want DRM, don't download music from a music service. That's the only way you get it, and that's true for any service, not just the iTMS.

    Also, if you get modded, you'll probably be modded flamebait. A troll has to actually look like he knows what he's talking about.

  73. Even better... by Theaetetus · · Score: 2, Informative
    Additionally, if you install TinkerTool and turn on the "show hidden files" option, you'll find a music directory on your iPod that holds all of your audio files. You are then free to copy them off.

    Not that I've used this for ripping from friends' iPods...

    -T

  74. Re:2gigs for 400 songs? by berniecase · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Most of my songs are over the 5 minute mark. Then I completely blow that away with a 20 minute version of Moby Dick from the Led Zeppelin DVD. Or, In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida. Or a two-hour trance mix from Oakenfold. I've found I just have to limit my playlists on my iPod by MB rather than time.

  75. Re:OGG support? by tuxedobob · · Score: 3, Informative

    Oh, forgot to reply to this:

    I thought I read in a post that if you copy music to the iPod as a regualer hard drive, then the iPod won't play it. If that is the case, then it is pretty worthless IMO.

    Okay, here's how it works. The iPod is one drive that works in two different ways. One way is an automatic sync up with iTunes (which you can also do yourself). The other is to use it as a detachable hard drive. The files iTunes puts on your iPod aren't visible when you view it as a hard drive. This makes sense, actually, as it keeps the two uses of it logically separate.

    Now, to copy music back to a computer and be able to play it on your iPod, there are two ways to do it.

    First, is the simple way. Copy the file to your iPod when it's acting as a hard drive. Copy it to the computer in question. Drop it into iTunes (or whatever) and let it copy back to the iPod.

    Second, you can open up the iPod when it's acting as a hard drive, go into the invisible iPod_Control folder, then the Music folder. Next you'll have various folders to choose from. I have F00 - F19. You file will be in one of these folders. Why it spreads your music across 20 folders, I don't know. Maybe it's to try to prevent copying back (but that's a pretty weak scheme for doing so). Maybe it's because the iPod can find a song more easily using some sort of hash (but why not simply access by filename?). Doing it this way, however, you'll notice that all non-alphanumeric and non-period characters have been turned to underscores. I can only assume that's so they can use the same code on the Windows side, which doesn't allow nearly as many characters in filenames as the Mac does.

    (It's interesting to note that each of the folders, F00 - F19, has files running A-Z. It doesn't split up based on first letter, at the very least.)

  76. Re:Batteries? (Creative Nomad) by valmont · · Score: 5, Insightful

    what are the dimensions of a Nomad Zen NX? would you care to give a comparison to iPod's dimensions? i haven't found on their site any documentation about which battery it uses, how much it costs, and what it takes to replace it. It does say it's a replaceable battery, but technically, iPod *also* has a replaceable battery.

    hint: if the iPod is a smaller, more portable form-factor while touting similar capacity, while being less confusing, with less holes to plug shit in, less buttons to fuck with, your average consumer ain't guna give a shit about a device that's a geek's dream. detachable this or that, believe it or not, is confusing to the average user. It's a matter of which audience you cater to. More on this later.

    There are reasons why there are tradeoffs. the iPod is extremely small for the capacity it offers, it is extremely portable and unintrusive. i have fit mine (2G) in just about any pocket i've had. Furthermore, many of my co-workers had bought competing players, absolutely every single one of them complained about either its form-factor or lack of capacity. Nomad Jukebox3 is a big square-ish size, much like today's CD players that are basically the size of a CD, which is NOT a form factor that is nearly as appealing as one of an iPod's. Don't get me wrong the features and interoperability capabilities of the Nomad jukebox3 are simply impressive but when a device's form-factor is not really a constraint, you can go to town with features. That doesn't mean this is necessarily what the average user Apple targets will be drawn to. The Jukebox3's affluence of buttons and holes to plug things in also make it, to your average non-computer geek, a "complicated", "confusing" device, while geeks see those features as a God-Sent. it's all relative. Sure the lack of replaceable battery is frustrating. But it ain't the first time, nor is it ever guna be the last time this sort of issue will plague consumer electronics.

    Replacing an iPod battery is NOT that hard, you just gotta be careful and requires a bit of skills. If that doesn't do it, then pay the $100 for the cost of the battery and to have someone else install it and be done with it. Or buy extended warranty such as AppleCare or one from Fry's, Best Buy, CompUSA, FNAC, or whoever sells you the iPod. It ain't that bad. People always pit the price of a battery against the price of the device it goes into and get infuriated to "pay $100 for a battery for a device that's only $400". No no no and no. Most resilient, quality batteries are expensive and that's the fucking way it is. Especially the type of flat one required for the iPod, it is quite a nice piece of engineering. When it dies, you gotta pay. period. Take a deep fucking breath and accept this fact.

    It always works like this: you shop for some device, it tells you it's rechargeable, but no one ever cares to ask "yes but for how long, what do i do when it can no-longer hold a charge" to make an informed purchasing decision based on those questions. They don't think, then get pissed when the inevitable happens, then go whine at their lawyers, who in the end will be the only winners in the upcoming class-action lawsuit. Once people also get the device they rarely ever look at best practices included in their manual to enhance battery life. There you have it.

    feel free to read a couple more ideas about why things may be the way they are.

    this isn't about zealotry. some people happened to have understood why Apple has made the compromises it did at the time it did and accept 'em without whining all fucking day, and will eventually vote with their feet and potentially wait for improvements, others choose to bitch around, karma-whoring on slashdot, thinking they're smart and have a fucking clue about industrial design and stating the obvious ad nauseum, bragging about how device X or Y has a detachable this or that while never addres