Slashdot Mirror


Japan's Empire of Cool

The Wicked Priest writes "The Washington Post is reporting that culture is among Japan's leading exports." Talks about Anime, Manga, Music, Video Games and so forth. Interesting reading.

406 comments

  1. Don't we get this exact same article... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

    ...every year? I think it's the result of reporters on vacation at the end of the year, doing a cut-and-paste on the date, and hoping the editor doesn't catch the dupe.

    1. Re:Don't we get this exact same article... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah! I want my money back.

    2. Re:Don't we get this exact same article... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They have time to look around. When they see something non-American, they spazz. (Britcoms are old and dull, Canadians are stealth, Bollywood is a myth.)

    3. Re:Don't we get this exact same article... by Otter · · Score: 0, Troll
      Hey, we've got this guy excitedly reporting that, believe it or not, he's heard that Japanese pay attention to American pop culture! Even though Europeans still look down on us, as they should. And this guy checks in more soberly with the same point.

      That was news in, when? 1954? Have these people heard of Elvis?

    4. Re:Don't we get this exact same article... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I think you're confusing cabaret cheese with culture.

    5. Re:Don't we get this exact same article... by The+Wicked+Priest · · Score: 1

      As the submitter of this article, I just want to point out that I originally quoted the Post in saying that culture had become Japan's biggest export, period -- not just "among" its leading exports. That's why I thought it was significant -- it suggested that Japan had crossed the line from an industrial to an information economy.

      However, in fairness to CmdrTaco, the Post's characterization isn't really supported by the statistics given in the article. They only indicate that cultural exports are growing at a far greater rate than manufacturing exports.

      Anybody know the overall numbers?

      --
      Share and Enjoy: 09 F9 11 02 9D 74 E3 5B D8 41 56 C5 63 56 88 C0
    6. Re:Don't we get this exact same article... by n0nsensical · · Score: 1

      Yes, and here's the story from the May/June 2002 issue of Foreign Policy on Japan's gross national cool referred to in this Washington Post article.

  2. But why do they love Bob Sapp?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    He's a failed American football player, and he's some massive icon there. What's up with that?

    1. Re:But why do they love Bob Sapp?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Please dont try to talk sports on slashdot

    2. Re:But why do they love Bob Sapp?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Have you actually seen any of the Japanese commercials or TV shows with Bob Sapp?

      He's fucking hilarious. All you have to do is see him standing next to a Japanese person to see why they love him. He's a total freak over there. A monstrous, 6' plus, muscular black man... That's like the exact physical opposite of a Japanese. Remember, the Japanese have almost a completely homogeneous culture; Their population is like 99+ percent Japanese, so people who look or act a bit different are MUCH more of an anomaly than they are in the USA. I'm 5'11 and 200+ lbs, which is hardly remarkably big in the US, and when I was over there I was always getting "wow, you're big, wow." The Japanese, by virtue of this homogeneous culture are simply not used to the variety of culture, shape, appearance and behavior that we are in the USA and much of the western world. If you live in Japan, and spend a year being the only white person in eyeshot, it's easy to see why they are mesmerized by guy like Sapp.

      That said, the guy is really a character. Usually they'll have him on TV just grabbing Japanese people on the street and beating them up. And the Japanese freak out like he's Godzilla. Or they'll have him sneak into an office, and come up behind a young girl at her desk, grab her and whirl her around in the air while he grunts and screams. Yeah, he grunts and screams... And beats his chest. he has his Beast persona that is the most politically incorrect stereotype of Black Man as Gorilla that you'll ever see. I think the most amusing thing about watching him is how his act would _never_ fly in the US because it would be considered so degrading to blacks.

      If you do a searh for him you might find pics or clips from some of his commercials... actually, I'm guessing http://panasonic.jp/dvd/ has some ads with him; They were using him to hawk DVD players, and the outfits they have him in are priceless.

    3. Re:But why do they love Bob Sapp?! by randomdef · · Score: 1

      Actually his beast personality came from the WCW character he used. I dont think the black population linched him for that.

    4. Re:But why do they love Bob Sapp?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Bob Sapp's act is degrading to blacks. He's doing more than anybody else to perpetuate the Japanese stereotype of blacks as big brainless clowns. Personally, I find him more disgusting than funny. Way to increase Japanese racism to stuff your wallet with cash, Bob.

    5. Re:But why do they love Bob Sapp?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I second this comment.
      Stop perpetuating racist stereotypes Bob!

    6. Re:But why do they love Bob Sapp?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What a load of American crap. Bob Sapp plays the lovable beast and it in no way demeans blacks in general. People love this guy here in Japan. If you want a disgusting and degrading image of blacks you need go no further than the bling bling egostistical rap stars that flood television. Yeah, that's right, money, flashy jewelrey and women as possesions waving their "booty". I can't of a more disgusting and offensive image of black culture.

      Why should the rest of the world be forced into some unrealistic politically correct American stereotype?

    7. Re:But why do they love Bob Sapp?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Akebono is going to kick his ass on New Year's Eve.

    8. Re:But why do they love Bob Sapp?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You are dreaming.

      Akebono is going to need knee surgery again after Sapp is done with him.

    9. Re:But why do they love Bob Sapp?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      >I'm 5'11 and 200+ lbs

      Fatso!

  3. The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by xeno_gearz · · Score: 4, Informative
    Actually, this is far from anything new. For the United States, as well as Japan, culture is a huge export. The United States, for example, exports much of Hollywood to other countries. This in turn ends up to equating an export of culture as the concepts of particular movies are absorbed by the individuals who view them. Hollywood is the best example but television and music also fit into the equation as well.

    There's one thing that Japan has over the United States when it comes to the export of culture, though; that's Hentai. :)

    --
    *
    troll blacklist. Please mo
    1. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by Elektroschock · · Score: 1

      Well, Japan was intresting in the 90th but that's all over. In the art scene nobody is intrested in Japan anymore.

      Perhaps we will import intresting stuff from Iraq soon...

      Or find a special place... for instance in Germany holiday in Bitterfeld is on the rise. Bitterfeld, the ugliest city of Eastern Germany. That's cool.

      Hollywood means boring culture industry targeted to an international audience. I prefer Nigerian films.

    2. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Well, Japan was intresting in the 90th but that's all over.



      You ought to see someone about that lisp.

    3. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by BroncoInCalifornia · · Score: 5, Interesting
      Food used to be most of the economic output. Then we got good at mass producing food.

      We had the industrial revolution. Most of the economy went to the manufacture and distribution of manufactured goods. Food became a small percentage of the total economic output.

      Now we are very very good at manufacturing stuff. Everything is so cheap now. TVs are cheap. Computers are cheap. Not long ago it was a big deal to buy these mass produced toys. Now they are impulse buy. For a while Japan led the world in this manufacturing revolution.

      Are we getting to a point where manufactured goods are not so imporant anymore. Perhaps manufactured goods are becoming a smaller part of the world economy. "Cultural" products are becoming more important and now onece again we are competing with the Japanise.

      --

      Religion is the main cause of atheism.

    4. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by xeno_gearz · · Score: 1
      Well, Japan was intresting in the 90th but that's all over. In the art scene nobody is intrested in Japan anymore.

      Perhaps we will import intresting stuff from Iraq soon...

      Or find a special place... for instance in Germany holiday in Bitterfeld is on the rise. Bitterfeld, the ugliest city of Eastern Germany. That's cool.

      Hollywood means boring culture industry targeted to an international audience. I prefer Nigerian films.

      Quite frankly, I am not familiar with Bitterfield and I think that any imports from Iraq would be few and far between and unlikely to diffuse into our culture very quickly.

      I do, however, agree that Hollywood is boring culture industry that often does not take chances and consequently churns out much of the same drivel year after year. Fortunately, a few gems are released every now and then that truly breath life into the industry.

      Although I feel the diffusion is not optimal, I find the releases from India's "Bollywood" to be interesting and the burgeoning film industry there seems quite creative and full of life. Unfortunately, I don't see this as being an export of as much magnitude as Hollywood has yet.

      --
      *
      troll blacklist. Please mo
    5. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What you don't hear about Japan is that it sucks. Really. It has all of the U.S. problems, but worse, and has more of them. Sure, Anime is cool and it comes from Japan, but we are only exposed to the video aspect of Anime. The other aspect is marketing. Japanese anime is marketed to such a great extent that they'd put America's Trojan Condoms (tm) Thanksgiving Day Parade and Tampax (r) Touchdowns to shame. Imagine having anime characters shoved in your face for all your waking hours: when you go to work on the subway, the crapola your office secretary has strewn all over her desk, the advertisements on the subway when you go home, and then advertisements on T.V. for disposable Anime character paraphenalia. Japanese children don't dream of becoming firefighters, doctors, and astronauts-- they just know they will turn into a jimun, or office worker, when they grow up. Japan sucks.

    6. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by FlipmodePlaya · · Score: 1

      Well, it certainly ain't beef...

      Sorry

    7. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by Krapangor · · Score: 0, Troll

      This is not always true.
      E.g., the most influencial exporter of porn movies is...TATATATA...no, not France, but....FINLAND !
      I found this most surprising, but they seem to have the most creative pron movie industry there.

      --
      Owner of a Mensa membership card.
    8. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by DigiShaman · · Score: 1

      Huh? Pr0n is certainly the best beef you can look at. Who wouldn't want to tag some of that meat?

      Pound it, grind it, slap it.... YA YA YA!!!

      --
      Life is not for the lazy.
    9. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > Perhaps we will import intresting stuff from Iraq soon...

      Nope. I'm afraid we have bombed to oblivion or allowed it all to be looted. If it can't be bombed or looted, we're intent on impressing western values on what's left.

    10. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by Elektroschock · · Score: 1

      More about Bitterfeld, a place where nobody wants to live. It is a real ugly town (it was worse under communism), so going to Bitterfeld for holiday, makin photogpahs of chemical plants... that's cool.

    11. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by rdnk · · Score: 1

      omg? really?! where's the "beef"?

    12. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by rdnk · · Score: 1

      Why don't you try reading all the bibles about post-industrial revolution and the increased importance of the brands and culture and stuff?? Heck, that's no news.

    13. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by spike+hay · · Score: 1

      Japanese children don't dream of becoming firefighters, doctors, and astronauts-- they just know they will turn into a jimun, or office worker, when they grow up. Japan sucks.

      Anime is cool, but Japan is not a place I would like to live. A terribly homogenous culture, with everyone pointed in the same direction in life. It is a country that discourages nonconformity of any kind. Also, you are right, the marketing in Japan is ridiculous.

      --
      If you don't understand any of my sayings, come to me in private and I shall take you in my German mouth.
    14. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      With their decades long near recession level economy, the younger generation are becoming disinchanted with that sort of career. And with the relatively high long term unemployment, people are have time to and energy to put into different areas, eg art, music, etc.

    15. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Japan exports a large amount of culture but nobody accuses them of cultural imperialism. (And before anyone starts off with some anti-American rant, remember that Japan did a lot worse before and during WWII).

    16. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by Narf+Narf · · Score: 2, Informative

      That's not true. First of all, anime is not cool. Second, kids here dream of being all sorts of stupid things. Just like in America, they have all sorts of dreams when they are kids. The difference is maybe that they realize earlier that they are just going to end up being boring office workers like everyone else. While Americans, for example, persist on chasing fantasy careers for longer into their lives. But, this country is not nearly as homogenous as it is made out to be.

      --

      "There's one born every minute." - Steve Case
    17. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > Now we are very very good at manufacturing stuff

      That's an interesting comment, but about 20-30 years to old. We (as in America I assume) are not very good at manufacturing stuff anymore. TVs, computers, etc. are not made in America. In fact, they aren't even made in Japan. Most all manufacturing these days has moved to third world countries with cheap labor. That is true for America and for Japan. If you buy an HP printer (an American company) you may be surprised to find out that it was built by Canon (a Japanese company) but you would probably be even more surprised to find that it was built in China.

      >Perhaps manufactured goods are becoming a smaller part of the world economy

      You have just guessed a long know fact. That's why manufacturing has been sent to the third world countries, and they are still third world countries.

      In the current economy, it's not what you build, it's how much markup can you buy and sell something for.

    18. Re:The U.S. is a major exporter of culture as well by jo42 · · Score: 1

      The United States has culture?

      Since when was "crap" redefined to "culture"??

  4. Hello.... KITTY! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Yes, I admit, I am amazed by that Wondergirl of all wondergirls, Hello Kitty!

    She is cute, sweet, and attractive. If she were running for senate, I'd vote for her. Alas, since she isn't a U.S. citizen, she's not eligable.

    I'm planning to write my congressman in hopes that he'll work on an amendment to let her run! If Hello Kitty is in office, we'll all be better off. Hello Kitty in 2004!

    She's such a pretty kitty!

  5. No way! by Skynet · · Score: 4, Funny

    Japan totally gets all it's cool from the United States, and our beloved Governor of California!

    Here's proof!

    --
    Execute? [Y/N] _
    1. Re:No way! by Rufus211 · · Score: 1

      am I the only one wondering what the hell I just watched!?

    2. Re:No way! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      what the hell was that?
      Totally freaky commercial.

      Translation please?

    3. Re:No way! by Soul-Burn666 · · Score: 1

      That's a commercial for Arinamin V-Drink ofcourse!!

      --
      ^_^
    4. Re:No way! by bar-agent · · Score: 1

      ...I'm scared...hold me...

      --
      i'd hit it so hard, if you pulled me out you'd be the king of britain [bash.org]
  6. Cultural Imperialism by tsanth · · Score: 4, Funny

    I, for one, welcome our new Japanese overl-

    oh, screw it.

    1. Re:Cultural Imperialism by kampit · · Score: 5, Funny

      Watashi, mizukara, waga wa nuyy nihonji ooba shu no motenasu!

    2. Re:Cultural Imperialism by falcon5768 · · Score: 5, Funny

      slashdot, where only here someone would translate a "I welcome" comment into Japanese.

      --

      "Slashdot, where telling the truth is overrated but lying is insightful."

    3. Re:Cultural Imperialism by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      not as funny 60 years ago.

    4. Re:Cultural Imperialism by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ugh, I'm Japanese and could someone help me translate this? I have no idea what it says.

    5. Re:Cultural Imperialism by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Arg, tranlate it yourself you ninny!

    6. Re:Cultural Imperialism by Yosho · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      I'm not a native Japanese speaker, but that seems to be absolute gibberish to me... I'm not even sure what "nuyy" is supposed to be, there are no kana that would romanize like that.

      --
      Karma: Terrifying (mostly affected by atrocities you've committed)
    7. Re:Cultural Imperialism by kampit · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      It's supposed to be "nyuu" actually, that's what I get for not doublechecking what I type.. I'm not a native japanese speaker either, but it does seem pretty clear to me ;)

    8. Re:Cultural Imperialism by Yosho · · Score: 2, Informative

      Hm.. It's difficult to preserve the English phrase's structure and have it make sense, but I think it might be better as:
      Watakushi, mizukara, shinshii nihon no shu wo motenashite orimasu.

      That is, of course, assuming we're trying to be polite to our overlords. ;-)

      --
      Karma: Terrifying (mostly affected by atrocities you've committed)
    9. Re:Cultural Imperialism by theTerribleRobbo · · Score: 1



      Shinshi is na-adj, so 'Shinshi ni'...?

      Maybe you should swap the first two words... 'Mizukara, watakushi wa shinshi ni nihon...'

      But then you have something that only vaguely resembles the original. :-P

      Oh, IANARJPIJPTB (I Am Not A Real Japanese Person, I'm Just Pretending To Be).

      </pedant>

    10. Re:Cultural Imperialism by Yosho · · Score: 1

      Actually, the "shin" I was using there in "shinshii" was as in "new." I admit I'm not entirely sure that's how it should be used there, though.

      Hm.. It sure would be nice if we could get a native Japanese speaker to straighten this thread out. ;-)

      --
      Karma: Terrifying (mostly affected by atrocities you've committed)
    11. Re:Cultural Imperialism by ShadowRage · · Score: 1

      ARIGATO! ^_^

  7. Culture! by TWX · · Score: 4, Funny

    We durn got all our culture right down here in Texas! We got more culture than a Petri dish!

    --
    Do not look into laser with remaining eye.
    1. Re:Culture! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I didn't know Bukkake was a Texan thing.

    2. Re:Culture! by TWX · · Score: 4, Funny

      "I didn't know Bukkake was a Texan thing."

      Shurtis! We got all kinds of barbeque sauce down here! Mesquite, honeybarbeque, spicy jalapeno, so why not bukkake too? Have to go check the store shelves for that one though. Haven't tried it personally...

      --
      Do not look into laser with remaining eye.
    3. Re:Culture! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Texas: America's compost bin!

    4. Re:Culture! by Zigg · · Score: 1

      Actually, bukkake is soup. (Link is safe for work, really.)

  8. You want the coolest culture? Check out Canada! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Look at everything that us Canadians have exported to the world!

    -Jim Carrey
    -Mike Myers
    -Alanis Morrisette
    -Basketball (yes, we did invent basketball)
    -Hockey
    -Telephone (a la Alexander Graham Bell)
    -Maple Syrup
    -Canadian peacekeepers

    but most importantly:
    -Mad Cow Disease and SARS!!

    O Canada, terre de nos aieux,
    Ton front est ceint de fleurons glorieux.
    Car ton bras sait porter l'epee,
    Il sait porter la croix.
    Ton histoire est une epopee
    Des plus brillants exploits.
    Et ta valeur, de foi trempee,
    Protegera nos foyers et nos droits.

    O Canada! Our home and native land!
    True patriot love in all thy sons command.
    With glowing hearts we see thee rise,
    The True North strong and free!
    From far and wide, O Canada,
    We stand on guard for thee.
    God keep our land glorious and free!
    O Canada, we stand on guard for thee.
    O Canada, we stand on guard for thee.

  9. Cultural Symbols vs. Culture by P!Alexander · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I think it's important to note that cultural symbols are not akin to culture itself. Japan can export all the anime it likes but that isn't representative of it's entire culture nor will it affect other cultures enough to make them resemble Japanese culture in something other than a superficial way. For example, Japanese corporate structure and the loyalty given to your company (a structural phenomenon) is unlikely to get passed along through its cultural symbols. Just like American structural phenomenon are unlikely to get passed along through our blockbuster movie exports.

    In the end, reality is highly individualized and rarely is a culture made up solely of a selective portion of its symbols.

    1. Re:Cultural Symbols vs. Culture by goon+america · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I agree. When we say "culture is our greatest export" that's a figurative statement. We don't literally export our culture. Sometimes people forget that distinction, and that's why some get up in arms over "culture imperialism" like there's literally some organized effort to do that.

    2. Re:Cultural Symbols vs. Culture by Skuld-Chan · · Score: 1

      Actually you might be suprised - there's several books to read on this subject. One of them is "Samurai's from Outer Space", and the other is a neat book called "What's Japanese about Japanese Animation".

    3. Re:Cultural Symbols vs. Culture by tloh · · Score: 1

      It is probably true that there is a great deal of selectiveness in cultural export. But you'd be suprised at how extensively Japanese culture has penetrated the social conciousness in the United States.

      Japan can export all the anime it likes but that isn't representative of it's entire culture

      If you look at a healthy sample of anime or manga, you'd realize that japanese references permeate even the most familiar titles known to americans. In the cases where titles have been edited by US distributors, the references are often mangled or removed to the point of unwatchability, but they are still there. Most who are into this genre actually do bother to find out about the context and references. In my own experience, friends who are anime/manga fans have actually adopted much of the colloquialism they've picked up from their favorite titles and begun making jokes where only someone who knows about modern japanese pop culture would understand. (Where else in the world would guys not be embarassed about blowing cash in a salon to pursue the "pretty boy" look and be checked out by girl like supermarket meat?) Those who have visited Anime conventions know that a great deal of people have taken to aspects of japanese culture in the same way scifi fans have embraced the mythology of Star Trek. Can you say Otaku?

      In the end, reality is highly individualized and rarely is a culture made up solely of a selective portion of its symbols.

      No argument there. But I don't think the article was trying to suggest that we're all turning Japanese. Culture encompasses many things and it isn't necessary (nor wise) to unload through export all of the things that make a group of people unique. If that be the case, it would be like the forced conversion to Christianity that the European missionaries inflicted upon many indiginous peoples. It isn't a case of cultural domination, rather of cultural exchange in the making. Remember the Anime/Manga industry in Japan would not be what it is today without the influences of the likes of Disney and DC Comics. But you wouldn't say that Japanese of the 50's era totally assimilated american comics. It is important to acknowledge that there is a great deal of borrowing going on here and not necesarily in ways that everyone would agree. Perhaps you don't consider the youth culture, for example, to be destinctly japanese. At least not in the sense of kimonos and katanas. You wouldn't be wrong, but you wouldn't be right either. I think it would be fair to say the japanese deserve credit for pioneering this pop trend in a way that is characteristic to their time and place.

      --
      Stay sentient. Don't drink bad milk.
    4. Re:Cultural Symbols vs. Culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      >rarely is a culture made up solely of a selective portion of its symbols.

      I would agree with that except when considering the current state of, say, the African-American culture (or whatever culture they are trying to portray). Clearly, this "culture" tries to portray itself as a community of rappers, "thugs", and dominant atheletes (as so wonderfully shown in the Mexico City olympics via the "black gloves"). And as African-American author Rev. Jesse Lee Peterson says when he describes the black culture's evident hypocrisy with "a Church and liquor store on every corner" in his book Scam : How the Black Leadership Exploits Black America. It is a consciences culture, one that is aware of its identity and actively creates and promotes cultural aspects as to separate itself from everyone else. These, you might say, are their "exported goods".

      I am not a racist, I am a person who believes all people are equal and diversity is generally a good thing when unity is also strived for among. But when we start recognizing "culture" as a tangible thing as we currently think of with the Japanese and American cultures, we start analyzing, skewing, and creating aspects of our culture to make us look better from "the outside". If people worried less about their "cultural/ethnic identities" in America, this country would be much better place to live in.

      Yes a little offtopic, but worth noting.

    5. Re:Cultural Symbols vs. Culture by AtomicBomb · · Score: 1

      Every country has got its own culture. Without the identity/ background etc, it is really hard to fully embrance the culture of another one... You are right. In most cases, these are the export of cultural symbols rather than culture itself. More importantly, these cultural symbols must seem cool at the first place before they get accepted elsewhere. My observation is it is usually after the country has climbed up the food chain in world trade. Usually, that means finished the transformation to an advanced industralised state .

      Therefore, watch out for Korean movie and pop stuff in the next five year. It's already made an impact in many places around Asia, e.g. Hong Kong and Taiwan.

    6. Re:Cultural Symbols vs. Culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Japanese corporate structure and that loyalty are weakening as we speak. It used to be that a worker there would stay with a company for his entire career, they have headhunters over there now. As we export culture to them and they export culture to us, the blending is going to become more and more apparent. Symbols are superficial, there are deeper changes going on as well.

  10. Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by HunterZero · · Score: 5, Interesting

    That since Japan opened itself up to the west it's been a maniac for other cultures. With the exception of the years before and during ww2, Japan has long been a rabid consumer for American culture, along with european culture.

    Just take a walk throughout Shibuya, Shinjuku, Ueno or Akihabara. You'll find a massive number of japanese teenagers (and adults) wearing shirts with "engrish" on them. Music is often sprinkled with a hearty dose of engrish as well. Try watching their TV programs sometime, you'll find plenty of american culture. Of course, they like to take it and modify it to their own means and that's exactly what Japan has been doing forever.

    This brings up an interesting question: Why are the Japanese so keen to take, modify and integrate other cultures to suit their needs, yet they're still incredibly racist of other cultures? If you doubt their racism, ask why they still have stores and places of business that advertise "Japanese Only"? Of course, for Americans it is a bit hard to understand the concept of being a distinct civilization since we've long been a melting pot, a nation made up of other nations.

    But I'm getting off the point. This article is nothing new. The reason why collectables are so expensive overseas is that it's so damned expensive in Japan! Whenever you feel like complaining about the price of dvds, remember that they charge around 40-60$ per dvd, and usually it has half as much as a dvd here in America.

    --
    "They told me it was impossible. I replied with maniacal laughter." http://www.mydailyrant.com/
    1. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      Just take a walk throughout Shibuya, Shinjuku, Ueno or Akihabara. You'll find a massive number of japanese teenagers (and adults) wearing shirts with "engrish" on them.

      Walk through any trendy shopping street in a Western city and you'll see shirts, crockery, posters, just about everything, with random Han characters on them. What goes around...

    2. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by kfg · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Do not forget that Japan "opened itself up" to the west under the gaze of American cannons intent on obtaining Japanese culture.

      Thus resulting in the overthrow of the stable "military" Shogunate that had maintained Japan as a land of peace, domestically and internationally, for 250 years or so, to be replaced by militarists who armed Japan and went on an empire by conquest rampage.

      A rampage rather overtly based on the western model of such, no less.

      You are correct about Japanese racism though. This is a nation that can claim to have no racial issues due to their single race when millions of Japanese born people of Korean descent can't obtain citizen ship and the aboriginal populace is treated as if it doesn't exist, except maybe as a tourist exhibit.

      However, through most of their history they have overtly acknowledged that real culture came from the mainland, much as once the English may have held themselves superiour and yet looked to France, Italy and even the German provinces for real culture.

      It's a peculiar schizophrenia, but not entirely beyond the realm of understanding.

      On the other hand while we have hungered for Japanese goods for the past 200 years or so we too use them as Americans, without becoming Japanese in the process, even while we study Karate and go to Zendos to test our Koan understanding.

      We have our own peculiar ways of being schizophrenic, it's just harder for us to see because for us it's normal.

      So for the Japanese, or any other culture for that matter.

      KFG

    3. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by Tenebrious1 · · Score: 4, Insightful

      This brings up an interesting question: Why are the Japanese so keen to take, modify and integrate other cultures to suit their needs, yet they're still incredibly racist of other cultures?

      It's pretty simple, same reason you find racism in certain parts of the States and in ethnic neighborhoods in cities. In monocultures, there's nobody around to point out that you're being a racist when everyone thinks the same.

      I'm Japanese, growing up in the burbs of NYC, I was stereotyped and the subject of racist remarks my entire childhood. It wasn't until I moved away to more metro areas that I found more acceptance. So racism still runs strong in the States, make no mistake about it.

      "National Pride" is ok, we see a lot of pride parades here in NYC. But just start to say something bad about another race, everyone jumps all over you for being a racist. You can't say anything about another culture without being condemned as a racist. We're forced to be politcally correct or face a civil lawsuit. That's a long ways away from being an integrated "melting pot" society as we'd like to believe.

      Japan isn't much different in terms of racism; the only difference is that there aren't people forcing them to watch everything they say, so they don't think about it. Yeah, many will openly discriminate and don't think twice about it, I hear about it from my caucasian friends who live in Japan. It's really that they haven't been forced to accept other cultures, socially or legally.

      What Japan really needs is Al Sharpton to stir things up, make them more aware of how racist the society is. Not sure if even he can do it, but it'd be a good start.

      --
      -- If god wanted me to have a sig, he'd have given me a sense of humor.
    4. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by perlchild · · Score: 1

      This brings up an interesting question: Why are the Japanese so keen to take, modify and integrate other cultures to suit their needs, yet they're still incredibly racist of other cultures?

      Two reasons:
      1) you don't have to give up a sense of superiority you have, just to accept a product/service from someone else
      2) By integrating it themselves, they keep control over what's integrated
      It's exactly why Japanese culture, which integrates western values through Japanese artists through Japanese control isn't eroding as fast as say, some Middle-Eastern cultures which reject "western" values outright.
      It's must easier to shut someone up in one's home, than it is to gag someone in the street in front of your house...
      Japanese culture has been managing the integration of foreign elements into their culture, which is a long-term culture survival strategy. Rejecting "western" values outright is a short term strategy, that only works as long as the "benefits" (If one can call the prosperity of visible elements of a culture group a "benefit") aren't too visible, or superior to the prosperity of the group you're trying to protect. i.e. "It's bad and a corrupting influence on our youth." Lasts until... "Maybe it's bad and corrupting, but it sure works for them!" YMMV
    5. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by silverbolt · · Score: 1
      I agree. I recently came back from my first trip to Japan, and my experiences are very much similar to your observations. Its an extremely expensive place, made me realize that I should never crib about prices here in the States. Western culture pervades everywhere, except that it is very brand centric. They are crazy after well-known american brands.

      I experienced the racism aspect too. Every non-Japanese person is treated with distance, and few people I talked to mentioned that they are never able to integrate fully into their culture. There is a sense of rigidity about them, and you can feel it in normal conversations also.

      Maybe their exports of anime, manga, etc might be making headway in other parts of the world, but I doubt anybody would like to import any non-productized aspects of Japanese culture.

    6. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by Yokaze · · Score: 1

      > Why are the Japanese so keen to take, modify and integrate other cultures to suit their needs, yet they're still incredibly racist of other cultures?

      Simple, because "the Japanese" are not a single person, but many different people. There are many people which are quite keen on foreign things and several which are not. The more eager people are to adopt parts of foreign culture the more it frightens the more conservative people. They fear the loss of their cultural identity.

      As you said, Japan is a nation, which is historically quite eager to adopt foreign influences. But other nations are similar. Walk through Europe and you will also see many people wearing T-shirts with English phrases. Or look at the charts of various European countries. They have even more English titles in the Top 10 than Japan.

      I'd say, it is similar to the fear of some Arabs of the "Imperial Americans". They observe the eager adoption of foreign cultural elements in their country and fear it as a loss of their own.

      > Of course, for Americans it is a bit hard to understand the concept of being a distinct civilization since we've long been a melting pot, a nation made up of other nations.

      Well, since the US is the cultural dominant nation in the world, you won't observe such a raise of xenophobia on that reason. Only the typical racism present in every nation and the occasional surge of racism due to recent events.

      --
      "Between strong and weak, between rich and poor [...], it is freedom which oppresses and the law which sets free"
    7. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Funny thing, when I was living in Japan I found the distance comforting.

      Maybe it's because I'm Scandinavian...

    8. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They can act racist because they don't have to suffer with political correctness. Talk to many white Americans and ask them their views on illegal immigration, the fact blacks commit nearly all the crime, the fact that they create all the ghettos in our country and the fact they eat up wellfare and they have never once created a successful societ on their own. And you will see the same way we feel.

    9. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by mantera · · Score: 1

      yes, i remember that japan and germany were mentioned as some of the few nations where you can claim a citizenship on the basis of ancestry even if your ancestors had left the country ages ago and you've never been there...

    10. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by BlueQuark · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Funny thing, when I lived and worked in Japan, I never felt out of place and the people I worked with, almost all Japanese at Japanese company, never made me feel like an outcast, I was always involved and invited and not as a token gaijin or anything.

      My wife is Japanese and when we go back to her parents house, I feel more at home in Japan than I do here in Los Angeles, CA. And I'm a white guy with blond hair!

      But some of the foreigner's I worked with did feel out of place and had a few problems. But to be honest, I never experienced it.

      I think alot has to do with attitude and pre-conceived notions about things. But with all things your mileage may vary..

      And no I don't think Japan is perfect, it has a ton of problems. Expensive yes, but I found that Japanese produce is fresher, tastes better and looks better. Housing is expensive, but have you tried to buy a house in LA, or SF lately? A Japanese mortgage through a private lender will run you about 1.8 - 2.7% (depending on who you go to) ((4.5 if you go the govt.

      Most companies pay for you're daily commuter fee if you take the bus, subway or train.

      And personal income taxes are alot less for people making under 150k a year, than it is in the US. But if you make more than that you will get soaked more so than in the US.

      But with all things....

    11. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by really? · · Score: 1

      An "Al Sharpton" like character in Japan would be taken out in a week, max, by the people in the black vans/buses.
      (For those not familiar with Japan, ultra right wing/nationalist groups drive around in converted buses that are painted all black and are full of slogans.)

      --

      "Consistency is contrary to nature, contrary to life. The only completely consistent people are the dead." A. Huxley
    12. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by Yosho · · Score: 2, Informative

      Actually, from what I understand, many of the "Japanese Only" signs are because shops don't want people who can't speak Japanese fluently. I have an American friend who visited Japan a while back, and he told me that he accidentally walked into a shop with a "Japanese Only" sign once; the shopkeeper yelled at him in bad English for a moment, but after my friend started speaking in Japanese to him, the shopkeeper apologized and welcomed him in.

      Granted, I'm sure that some of them are just racism, but not all.

      --
      Karma: Terrifying (mostly affected by atrocities you've committed)
    13. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by sakusha · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Your understanding of Japanese history is rather weak. Japan has always had waves of influence from outside the country, resulting in rapid integration of social influences. Like for example, the influence of Buddhism from Korea in the 6th century, the influence of Kanji from China about that same time, the influence of foreign traders from Russia and the Netherlands in the 15th century, etc. Japan's history's most significant characteristic is its ability to rapidly adapt foreign technologies and culture towards its own purposes.

    14. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Just take a walk throughout Shibuya, Shinjuku, Ueno or Akihabara. You'll find a massive number of japanese teenagers (and adults) wearing shirts with "engrish" on them.

      That was last year... this year it seemed "wafu" (japanese style) was the fashion. I got me a "kaze" t-shirt.... but the fit was no good. But i got to be called "mr wind" by my coworker, so it's not all bad.

      If you doubt their racism, ask why they still have stores and places of business that advertise "Japanese Only"?

      Can't say i've had the problem, but i don't make a habit of going hostess or snack bars or remote onsen that had bad experiences with russian sailors. "Japanese Only"? signs are a pretty poor example of japanese racism, and tend to cater as examples to those who are used the traditional western style of out and out racism. A better example may be the futile persuit of humanoid robot development, for the purpose of avoiding mass immigration. (the other purposes of development may be less futile). Or my favourite would be the conversation starter, "oh how nice to meet you, when did you come to japan?", "x-nen mae kita" often followed by "that's nice, and when will you be leaving?" ( i haven't tired an "i ain't leavin, matey" but it might be fun to try as social experiement (^-^) )

    15. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by kfg · · Score: 1

      No shit.

      KFG

    16. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by bugbread · · Score: 2, Informative

      "If you doubt their racism, ask why they still have stores and places of business that advertise "Japanese Only"? "

      Hmm...the only places I know with signs like that are brothels (due to the much higher incidence of AIDS in foreigners than in Japanese) and in baths up in Hokkaido that have had numerous run-ins with drunken Russian sailors who refuse to clean themselves up before getting in the communal tub. I'm not sure either has to do with racism directly, any more than blood transfusions from Brits being denied in the States does.

    17. Re:Yeah, that's interesting until you consider... by Tenebrious1 · · Score: 1

      An "Al Sharpton" like character in Japan would be taken out in a week, max, by the people in the black vans/buses.

      And turn him into a MLK type martyr? That might work, although I expect the entire nation will go humbly apologetic mode, be annoyingly apologetic but still not get the point.

      --
      -- If god wanted me to have a sig, he'd have given me a sense of humor.
  11. Oh, Yeah?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Sheila: Time's have changed
    Our kids are kids are getting worse
    They wont obey their parents
    They just want to fart and curse!
    Sharon: Should we blame the government?
    Liane: Or blame society?
    Dads: Or should we blame the images on TV?
    Sheila: No, blame Canada
    Everyone: Blame Canada
    Sheila: With all their beady little eyes
    And flappin heads so full of lies
    Everyone: Blame Canada
    Blame Canada
    Sheila: We need to form a full assault
    Everyone: It's Canadas fault!
    Sharon: Don't blame me
    For my son Stan
    He saw the darn cartoon
    And now he's off to join the Klan!
    Liane: And my boy Eric once
    Had my picture on his shelf
    But now when I see him he tells me to fuck myself!
    Sheila: Well, blame Canada
    Everyone: Blame Canada
    It seems that everythings gone wrong
    Since Canada came along
    Everyone: Blame Canada
    Blame Canada
    Copy Guy: There not even a real country anyway
    Ms. McCormick: My son could've been a doctor or a lawyer rich and true
    Instead he burned up like a piggy on a barbecue
    Everyone: Should we blame the matches?
    Should we blame the fire?
    Or the doctors who allowed him to expire?
    Sheila: Heck no!
    Everyone: Blame Canada
    Blame Canada
    Sheila: With all their hockey hubbabaloo
    Liane: And that bitch Anne Murray too
    Everyone: Blame Canada
    Shame on Canada
    The smut we must stop
    The trash we must smash
    Laughter and fun
    must all be undone
    We must blame them and cause a fuss
    Before someone thinks of blaming uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuus

  12. War What Is It Good For? by Quirk · · Score: 0, Redundant

    Throughout history war has been one of, if not the most efficient, conduit for the export of culture. Japan imported American culture after WWII. Japanese culture was and remains strong having been developed as an island culture.

    --
    "Academicians are more likely to share each other's toothbrush than each other's nomenclature."
    Cohen
    1. Re:War What Is It Good For? by Xerithane · · Score: 1

      Sorry, but American culture started getting into Japan in the 1850s. The first English teacher was a cast-away, and was brought to teach English as a captive, and was later very popular in Japan. He returned to Washington state to die, but there maintained a lot of interaction between Japan and the US after that. Also in Washington were the first Japanese on American soil when they crashed their ship.

      Japanese culture was and remains strong having been developed as an island culture.

      Japanese culture is heavily influenced by that around it, it's just imperialist and almost xenophobic. The Japanese government forced a closed border to prevent cultural tapping prior to Meiji. Then the Meiji Administration decided to go conquer the whole of eastern Asia...

      --
      Dacels Jewelers can't be trusted.
    2. Re:War What Is It Good For? by belmolis · · Score: 2, Interesting

      While I can't deny that the US occupation of Japan provided a massive exposure of American culture to Japanese people, Japan was already engaged in the importation of Western culture on a large-scale prior to World War II. When the Meiji Emperor (ruled 1868-1912) decided to modernize Japan, Japanese people began to learn very actively about the West. This activity centered on science and technology, where Germany, as the industrial and scientific leader became the focus of attention. Physicians trained prior to the end of WWII, for example, used textbooks written in German and frequently went to Germany to study. Into the 1960s, patient charts in some Japanese hospitals were written in German. Modernizers also adopted or proposed the adoption of many other aspects of European culture. One seriously proposed that the Japanese language be abandoned, to be replaced by French!

      A curious forerunner was the developement, during the Tokugawa period (1615-1868), when Japan was largely cut off from foreign contact, of rangaku "Dutch Studies" (from Oranda "Holland" and Sino-Japanese gaku "study, -ology"). The Dutch were allowed to maintain a trading post on Dejima, then an island in Nagasaki harbor, so Japanese scholars interested in things Western focussed on the Dutch. Probably the most important thing to emerge from rangaku was knowledge of European medicine, particularly anatomy.

      The US Occupation probably had much more impact on popular culture, but at a more academic and technological level, the importation of Western culture had already taken place.

  13. The best of Japanese culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Scat porn and bukkake.

    1. Re:The best of Japanese culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      TO be fair bukkake isn't a real word; it just sounds japanese.

    2. Re:The best of Japanese culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      bukkakeru - (v1) to dash (slosh) (water) on a person
      or in a person's face

    3. Re:The best of Japanese culture by spike+hay · · Score: 1

      TO be fair bukkake isn't a real word; it just sounds japanese.

      Bukkake is the name of the soup. The name comes from the fact that the female in a bukkake tape looks as if she accidentally spilled the soup all over her face.

      --
      If you don't understand any of my sayings, come to me in private and I shall take you in my German mouth.
    4. Re:The best of Japanese culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Um... bukkake is actually a japanese word... bu for 'like crazy' and kake(ru) for 'spill on'
      i guess anyone who actually cares knows this.
      owell.

    5. Re:The best of Japanese culture by spike+hay · · Score: 1

      Bukkake Noodles.

      Bukkake does refer to the action of pouring the noodles over the soup.

      --
      If you don't understand any of my sayings, come to me in private and I shall take you in my German mouth.
  14. Japanese Music ? by tealover · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I haven't been paying attention to the Billboard top 100 recently, but are there some Japanese rock bands that i don't know about ?

    --
    -- You see, there would be these conclusions that you could jump to
    1. Re:Japanese Music ? by Xerithane · · Score: 1

      Depending upon your tastes, yes. If you are looking for rock, go check out the B'z. They were (maybe still are?) doing an American tour, and put on a great show. Very good music, lots of fun to listen to, and they are incredibly famous (Like the Eagles, as far as record sales go)

      --
      Dacels Jewelers can't be trusted.
    2. Re:Japanese Music ? by gelstudios · · Score: 1

      Guitar Vader and Shonen Knife are two fairly popular Japanese "happy punk" Bands.

    3. Re:Japanese Music ? by Sarin · · Score: 1

      the 5 6 7 8s featured in Quentin Tarantino's Kill Bill. Ok, they're not in the top 100 in the US I suspect, but they're featured on the ost of the movie, which could be in somesort of 100.

    4. Re:Japanese Music ? by Jeff+DeMaagd · · Score: 1

      The article was flawed in some of its claims but there are many billions of dollars in licensing and exporting Japan's cultural icons. Most of the exports is to a bunch of sizable niche markets here and there, it doesn't have the same influence as the article claims.

      A lot of US entertainment has some level of Japanese influence, but that doesn't mean money goes to Japan because of that.

      I don't listen to Japanese music so I can't even try to recommend anything.

      If anything, Japan has lost a lot of cultural influence too, where a lot of Kurasawa movies had a strong art house film circuit showings, it seems to be impossible to get 100 screens in the US of Japanese theatrical movies.

    5. Re:Japanese Music ? by I(rispee_I(reme · · Score: 1

      Dragon Ash is an excellent band that was recommended to me by a japanese quake player on irc. Their best work includes "Lily Of Da Valley" and "Viva La Revolution (especially the latter).

    6. Re:Japanese Music ? by LarryRiedel · · Score: 1

      When I think of music I associate with contemporary Japanese culture that would make it out of Japan, I think of composers like Yoko Kanno, or cute girl performers like Chitose Hajime, Mai Kuraki, Mika Nakashima, Hikaru Utada, Ayumi Hamasaki.... In my own mind I do not see much overlap in my ideas of "cool", "rock band", and contemporary Japanese culture.

      Larry

    7. Re:Japanese Music ? by Megane · · Score: 1
      --
      #naabhaprzrag, #sverubfr-000, #agi-fcbafberq, negvpyr[pynff*=' negvpyr-ary-'] { qvfcynl: abar !vzcbegnag; }
    8. Re:Japanese Music ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The very catchy theme of Kill Bill is "Battle Without Honor or Humanity" by Hotei Tomoyasu.

    9. Re:Japanese Music ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      How about The Brilliant Green?

    10. Re:Japanese Music ? by Kent+Recal · · Score: 1

      Porno Graffitti

      Sounds like everyday radio-pop to me, could be any language.

    11. Re:Japanese Music ? by shione · · Score: 1

      Ayumi Hamasaki does rock in her new album.

    12. Re:Japanese Music ? by cozziewozzie · · Score: 1

      Japan (especially Tokyo) has a very lively hardcore/speedcore scene, if you're into that sort of stuff. I've recently seen a band called 'Melt Banana' and they were bloody mental. Also, if you're into minimalism, check out 'The Ruins'. Others have already recommended 'Shonen Knife', might want to look into 'The Boredoms' as well.

      If all you've heard was J-Pop, this stuff will come as a bit of a surprise :) Hardcore shit :)

    13. Re:Japanese Music ? by ice-nine · · Score: 1

      the pillows (another, official site) are amazing. i especially recommend the albums please mr lostman, happy bivouac, little busters, and runner's high. if you've seen FLCL (the anime, aka furikuri, was on the cartoon network a few months ago) then you've heard them. this is where i first heard them, and now they're my favorite band. i also recommend the brilliant green.

      --
      zing
  15. Ah, Japan... by Null+Argument · · Score: 3, Funny

    They make some of the coolest stuff in the world. At the same time, they also make some of the weirdest.

    Tentacle sex, anyone? ;)

    1. Re:Ah, Japan... by Repugnant_Shit · · Score: 1

      No thanks, I'm still sore from last night.

    2. Re:Ah, Japan... by FurryFeet · · Score: 1

      Tentacle sex, anyone? ;)

      Why, yes, thank y... uh? Oh, damn it all to hell.

      (BTW, when you mention tentacle sex... is that cool, or weird?)

    3. Re:Ah, Japan... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Neither. It's just tired.

    4. Re:Ah, Japan... by theTerribleRobbo · · Score: 1

      Oh, come on.

      It's just that they're not allowed to show either sex organ, so they improvised. Tentacles seemed to fit the bill for some reason.

      Heck, some of the them are drawn with rather worryingly phallus-like 'heads'.

      </ecchi>

      (Yes, it's still weird. :-S )

    5. Re:Ah, Japan... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh they do show all sex organs in certain anime's ... and the tentacle sex comes from one of those.

  16. It's a good fusion of science and entertainment by HungWeiLo · · Score: 2, Funny

    We all know that the Japanese places heavy emphasis on education and scholarly conduct. Therefore, it surprises no one that even their entertainment (anime, pr0n) is infused with advanced studies of marine biology (tentacles)

    --
    There are a huge number of yeast infections in this county. Probably because we're downriver from the bread factory.
  17. and Schoolgirl Tentacle Rape by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    almost forgot that one.

  18. Re:You want the coolest culture? Check out Canada! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    -Jim Carrey
    -Mike Myers


    Oh no! How sad and depressing. And don't forget Tom Green.

    -Alanis Morrisette
    Next time, maybe you can include Neil Young and and Joni Mitchel if you want to show off Canadian talent.

    -Basketball (yes, we did invent basketball)
    Was Springfield, Massachusetts, the birthplace of basketball, once part of Canada?

    -Telephone (a la Alexander Graham Bell)
    Was Boston, the place where the telephone was invented, once part of Canada?

  19. Ruroni Kenshin... by herrvinny · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Obviously. Japanese manga, anime, etc are really good. I make it a point to watch Ruroni Kenshin every Saturday on Cartoon Network (OT, but does anyone have the English version of the song "Freckles" that they play in the opening title? I can't find it anywhere...)

    The thing I like about Japanese anime is that it makes you think. It's not blind violence or meaningless love. Everything has a well crafted story behind it. Just yesterday I was in Barnes and Noble, and was going to read "love hina" but got sidetracked by the new Star Wars book, The Unifying Force.

    The greatest thing though, it's a two way street. We get stuff like Ruroni Kenshin, Pokemon, etc, and the Japanese get McDonalds, Coke, etc.

    1. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by Kedyn's+Crow · · Score: 1

      You can find both the english and japanese versions of this song on Kazaa or Gnutella easily enough.

      --
      "The moment "pride" is lost, "freedom" is also lost." - Ramza.
    2. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by realdddave · · Score: 1

      There's a song called Freckles that appeared in the Dance Dance Revolution series a few versions back - if it's the same song, you might try checking for it at DDR sites, since I seem to remember the in-game version being in English. If it's in the DDR game, then it's probably from the Dancemania series of albums...so check along that line, too : )
      Hope that helps!

    3. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Odd, I always thought that Ruroni Kenshin was one of the biggest piles of crap I ever had the mistfortune of watching. To each their own I suppose

    4. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by Megane · · Score: 2, Interesting
      Everything has a well crafted story behind it.

      Not everything, but usually anything based on a successful manga that hasn't been drawn out too long is pretty good. (too long meaning Dragonball Z, or later episodes of Inu Yasha, which I stopped watching around episode 75 or so, and now it's up to 135) Sturgeon's Law still applies, but there is some filtering before it gets to a DVD on the shelf in Best Buy. Even when downloading fansubs, there is filtering when series don't get fansubbed.

      The important difference is that they're a lot more willing to not follow a formula in Japan, so you get to see more unique stuff. And they have people who can write (unlike Hollywood). And they write serial stores instead of episodic stores, so they can have more interesting stories than you can get in 22 or 45 minutes. So instead of 90% of everything being crap, it's maybe 80% or so.

      --
      #naabhaprzrag, #sverubfr-000, #agi-fcbafberq, negvpyr[pynff*=' negvpyr-ary-'] { qvfcynl: abar !vzcbegnag; }
    5. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "The thing I like about Japanese anime is that it makes you think."

      Yes, like tentacle rape anime makes you think that we shouldn't have stopped at Nagasaki.

    6. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by loser7punk · · Score: 1

      Yes, there is. It is from the 6th mix. It is called "Freckles KCP Re-edit". It is a diffrent translation and singing than that of the English intro. Personally, I prefer the Japanese one by Judy and Mary (the exact translation is some times...odd... but funny)

    7. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Add me to the list with people that wishes you (and your family if they think alike) a slow, painful dead in radiation.

    8. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      We get stuff like Ruroni Kenshin, Pokemon, etc, and the Japanese get McDonalds, Coke, etc.

      What's that? Mass-culture commercial Trash exchange? ..ok except for Rurouni Kenshin, which has excellent story/animation/music/voices.

    9. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by Yosho · · Score: 2, Interesting

      If you like Kenshin on CN, you owe it to yourself to buy the DVDs -- CN made some awful cuts to it, and most of the stuff that really makes you think has been mutilated. Just take a look at what happened to Soujirou's flashback. You might also have better luck searching for the song by its Japanese title, "Sobakasu."

      It's also worth noting that no, not all Japanese anime makes you think. There is plenty of it that is mindless violence and sex. La Blue Girl and M. D. Geist are a couple of classic ones. Most of the worst stuff never sees this side of the ocean, however. Of course, I'm also of the opinion that despite its popularity, Lova Hina is one of the worst romantic comedies out there...

      --
      Karma: Terrifying (mostly affected by atrocities you've committed)
    10. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If you think Rurouni Kenshin (TV series) makes you think, just watch the special episodes for vhs/dvd. In the USA, it's called Samurai X, although original title is "Rurouni Kenshin: Tsuioku Hen".

      It's the BEST samurai anime I've ever seen. And pretty different from the TV series (in many aspects).

      Here is a link for more info:

      http://imdb.com/title/tt0203082/

    11. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by Hrothgar+The+Great · · Score: 1

      No offense intended to you by this, but Rurouni Kenshin makes me want to vomit in a trashcan. I have rarely laid eyes on anything that made me want to stab an ice pick through someone's eye into their brain more than that show does.

      It's not that I haven't seen worse shows, especially among anime, but the previews they kept showing on Cartoon Network made it look so badass. They do this with EVERY DAMN SHOW on their channel. The previews are action, action, action! Look at the bad motherfucking samurai who is feared by ALL and now has taken a vow never to kill again. Watch as an entire outmoded segment of society clashes with him and everything he represents. SWORDFIGHTS SWORDFIGHTS SWORDFIGHTS.

      Then, because that seems like it would pretty much have to kick ass, I actually watch the thing and what the show is REALLY all about is thirty seconds of fighting, with interspersed ridiculous goofy faces with fucking swirly eyes and god damn water droplets appearing over people's heads for some reason, and several awkward situations involving women whose faces turn so red at the thought that Kenshin was flirting with them that they must have popped about a hundred blood vessels underneath their skin.

      By the way, I just described my experience with every single action show on Cartoon Network EVER except for Cowboy Bebop. Seriously, I don't understand why anyone likes Kenshin at all - the thought of watching it for even ten seconds makes me INSANE.

    12. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I haven't watched the Cartoon Network version, but I heard that it's terribly massacred. I guess if you want the blood and action and angst, you should try out the Memories Arc OAVs. Beautiful artwork/music and very well executed violence (instead of lame pans that happen with bad animation). In the TV series itself, there are obviously some episodes with more action than others, but I have fond memories from 5 years ago of watching the Aoshi stuff, Saitou, and of course most of the Kyoto Arc.

    13. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by Hrothgar+The+Great · · Score: 1

      Thanks, I might have to take a look at those. The TV series does have its moments from what I've seen, just not enough that it was able to hold my interest for very long.

    14. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by WuphonsReach · · Score: 1

      god damn water droplets appearing over people's heads for some reason

      You do realize that's a stylized way of depicting unease (beads of sweat)? A lot of the other stuff is a rose-tinted look back at the Meiji era (when dating/etc was different, much like the Victorian era compared to today).

      RK is not an action story arc, it's more of a comedy/drama (the manga explains a lot of this better). They spend a lot of time introducing characters, developing them, showing inter-play between them so that later cliff-hangers bring the audience in better. I only watch the DVDs with Japanese audio, so I don't know what the CN version is like. (As a rule, I avoid english dubs of popular anime, only a few are ever acted properly. And if CN is selling RK as an action series, they've missed how to sell it.)

      For the action side, I'd say check out the Trust/Betrayal Samurai X set. You probably won't like the 2nd DVD in the set as it's more character development / back plot then action.

      For something different, go pickup a DVD of Perfect Blue, which is a nice classical horror flick.

      --
      Wolde you bothe eate your cake, and have your cake?
    15. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I just cannot understand who would watch this crap, who is buying it? It is all the same to me and nothing is more pathetic than cartoon porn except maybe the people who enjoy it.

    16. Re:Ruroni Kenshin... by Hrothgar+The+Great · · Score: 1

      Hey, I appreciate the response, and I probably will go check out the things you suggested. See, I'm not always a cranky bastard.

      CN selling it as an action series was EXACTLY what was wrong with it for me. If they had indicated what it was actually like, I simply would not have watched it. I understand that different people like different things.

      As for the stylized animated emoticons (as they basically are) - I hate that kind of thing. You know, there was a point where things like that were really creative, but they've become a cliche that in my opinion drags anime as a whole down - I have probably really enjoyed 5% of the anime I have seen because these types of things are so overused - I guess I just don't feel that for instance a picture of a water droplet is a proper depiction of the unease or embarassment of a character although I know, as you mentioned, that this is in fact what they are getting at. In other words, I think it is a rather cheap "conveyance" of an emotion without going to the trouble of actually conveying said emotion.

      Unfortunately for you I am willing to discuss this at length as I think way too much about this when I'm drunk.

      I do like to watch anime other than on CN, but I've pretty much stopped buying any DVDs unless I know ahead of time that it's going to be good. Too many bad experiences I suppose. I liked X though I think its plot is worse than some soap operas I've seen as far as complexity and coherence. I've enjoyed Urusei and Cowboy Bebop quite a bit. All of these are really straight forward and I don't have to wonder what kind of crazy shit is going to happen in the next scene - I know Urusei is going to be completely silly or pseudo-romantic. They are not going to pull some shit I wasn't expecting. I know exactly what Bebop will do next (not plot wise at all but as far as the TYPE of thing that will happen). In RK and Trigun I had to hold my breath waiting for the type of thing I wanted and hoping that something slapsticky wouldnt interrupt my suspense. A good comparison would be a Jackie Chan martial arts movie. You sit there for an hour waiting for him to kick some ass and he is too busy making silly faces at the camera.

      P.S. Sorry about the late, long reply.

  20. I talked to an exchange student from Japan... by grungebox · · Score: 5, Interesting
    recently at this party I was at. Apparently, he says Japanese don't look down on Americans like Europeans do (admittedly with reasonable justification). He said Hollywood movies are huge over there as an earlier post mentioned, and the stars are on posters all over the place. For some reason, Brad Pitt is hot right now.

    Although the one interesting bit of Japanese culture that's taking over like crazy is manga. If you look at Border's or Barnes, you'll see five or six shelves of Manga, and American comics have been pushed into one small shelf at the end. It's apparently the "in" thing for youngsters, much like Fear Street books were the "in" thing back when I was in school.

    Food for thought...

    1. Re:I talked to an exchange student from Japan... by 2eris3 · · Score: 0

      I think the reason why Brad Pitt is big in Japan is movies like Fight Club. They understand dark, gritty overtones in movies unlike us North Americaners (some, but not all, mind you) who want gooey, happy, pappy crap.

      The Japanese grasp the dark side of life as part of life and acknowledge it, instead of ignoring it (ie; death in general). They may look down on something culturally, but they won't deny that it exists.

    2. Re:I talked to an exchange student from Japan... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Europeans do not look down on Americans, but some Europeans look down on the present US government, a corrupt political system and redneck hill-billies.

    3. Re:I talked to an exchange student from Japan... by Rayonic · · Score: 1
      Japanese don't look down on Americans like Europeans do (admittedly with reasonable justification).

      "Reasonable justificiation"? What does that mean?

      Oh wait, I figured it out. That's a polite way to say "inferiority complex". Kudos to you on your discretion.
    4. Re:I talked to an exchange student from Japan... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Japanese don't look down on Americans like Europeans do

      Last time I checked they didn't speak very well of the Hiroshima/Nagasaki causers..

      At least the last generation seemed to be quite unfriendly to immigrants from America.

    5. Re:I talked to an exchange student from Japan... by Guppy06 · · Score: 4, Insightful

      " If you look at Border's or Barnes, you'll see five or six shelves of Manga,"

      Just a shame that 5 out of those 6 shelves are all Dragon Ball...

    6. Re:I talked to an exchange student from Japan... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The irony is that corruption is inherent in the European model; I mean, the entire french government is inherently corrupt, but people understand and accept it.

      Hundreds of years ago, it was okay, but the present globalization is ruthless about exposing economic inefficiencies, and that is the price of European corruption; the entire continent is largely inefficient.

      The old European powers are eager to grab the Eastern Europeans lergely because they are in the best position to become the leading economic powers of the continent, but old Europe is intent on saddling them with things like 30 hour work-weeks, inefficient worker "reforms" and social safety nets that add inefficiencies to their economies

      The US and Japan are leading precisely because the workers work hard and long hours. THe upside is there is a lot more opportunity.

      The smarter eastern european powers will never adopt these "reforms" even at the cost of not joining the EEC.

      Seriously.

    7. Re:I talked to an exchange student from Japan... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "Last time I checked they didn't speak very well of the Hiroshima/Nagasaki causers.."

      No, but they *respect* the Americans for doing this. Most people don't understand the Americans conqored the Japanese homeland. I invite you to look in your history books when this had previously been done.

      And then you understand the Ambivalence towards the Americans. They understand, more than anybody else, even the Iraqi's, what the Americans are capable of if pushed. For better or worse, the Americans will slag the world if they feel threatened.

    8. Re:I talked to an exchange student from Japan... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Uh, no, Brad Pitt is popular in Japan for the same reason that the soccer player David Beckham is popular in Japan: because he's an attractive, square-jawed gaijin. Having lived in Japan for a while, I see no indication that the Japanese are any better than us at understanding the "dark side" of anything. You watch too much gritty anime.

    9. Re:I talked to an exchange student from Japan... by brand+bendy · · Score: 0
      It's apparently the "in" thing for youngsters
      Its not that its the "in" thing. Theres quality there for the most part. A lot of manga is actualy good! Its been steadily rising in popularity for a while now, and not just among youngsters.
      --
      I use phrases like "darn good" and "rootin' tootin'", but only when there's a darn good, rootin tootin' reason!
    10. Re:I talked to an exchange student from Japan... by theTerribleRobbo · · Score: 1

      ... Or Yugio, or Pokemon...

    11. Re:I talked to an exchange student from Japan... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      "The irony is that corruption is inherent in the European model"

      European model? Europe is a continent, not a single country. Go back to sKKKool, boy.

      "I mean, the entire french government is inherently corrupt, but people understand and accept it."

      You mean like US senators accept "donations" (bribes) to push an agenda on behalf of whoever pays enough money?

      "Hundreds of years ago, it was okay, but the present globalization is ruthless about exposing economic inefficiencies, and that is the price of European corruption; the entire continent is largely inefficient."

      How and why is it inefficient?

      "The US and Japan are leading precisely because the workers work hard and long hours."

      And Europeans don't? Give me a break, rednecKKK. Go back to school and learn a thing or two before you spew out garbage about something you do not understand.

    12. Re:I talked to an exchange student from Japan... by mark2003 · · Score: 1

      No offense mate but you are absolutely full of sh*t.

      It is a bit rich that with your current government that you see fit to accuse the european government's of being corrupt - what about all the pork barrel politics, Bush/Cheney/Rumsfeld's involvement in Enron/Haliburton/selling biological weapons precursors to Saddam.

      It is also interesting to see that you accuse the "old" European nations of being innefficient - France produce more per person per hour than the US.

      Loose the anti-Europeanism....

  21. Yes we do by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    "We don't want guns on planes, it's dangerous to have guns on planes and there are other things you can do like investing in security measures on the ground", he added.

    What pansies.

    What good does this asshole think any "security measures on the ground" will do when the ragheads are willing to fly the planes into buildings??!

  22. Like this? by herrvinny · · Score: 4, Interesting

    The significance of anime

    Anime And The Tech Lifestyle

    Movie Review: Princess Mononoke

    An Extensive History of Anime

    This story is not exactly a dupe, but much of it is discussed in these earlier topics.

    OT, but has anyone had any success in loading /.'s search function? It always times out on me for the past two weeks or so, and I have to keep resorting to using Google search (which is not really a hardship, since Google beats out /.'s search function easily, but still, I'd like to at least access it.)

    1. Re:Like this? by Tellalian · · Score: 0, Troll

      SCO Report [scoreport.com]

      You complain about redundant topics but you include a link about SCO in your sig? Letme guess, you've got a lonely pot looking for a kettle to talk to?

  23. It's because they're different by SamSim · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I think basically what the West is beginning to realise is that Japan is an entire culture which, while being easily as technologically advanced as America (and in many ways more so), is totally different from America. It's new, it's unusual, it's different, and a lot of it is stuff that Westerners have never even contemplated before, let alone seen.

    Kids are insane over Dragonball Z because super-kung-fu-firing-fireballs-from-fingertips-fly ing-about-kicking-people-through-mountains genre just doesn't exist in America. Sure, it's an appalling series on many levels, but it brings something new to the table and for them, that (combined with its testosterone content) makes it worth watching.

    1. Re:It's because they're different by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      It's new, it's unusual, it's different, and a lot of it is stuff that Westerners have never even contemplated before, let alone seen.

      And as such: dangerous.

    2. Re:It's because they're different by Deraj+DeZine · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Another thing to keep in mind is that anime is also very convenient for many American viewers. For example, if I want a fix of anime without learning any Japanese, I can just flip on to Cartoon Network and most of the time they'll be playing some show that, up until recently, had no equivalent in the US.

      I mean, Afghanistanimation is completely different from any TV programs here in the states, but that won't necessarily make it popular because it's not readily available.

      And before you point this out, many of the Japanese programs are so convenient because they're so popular because they ARE cool. Not all of them, of course. Not even all of one show (e.g. DBZ has cool fights, but the sluggish pace makes the show unbearable).

      OT, but do Japanese people really repeat the same thing with different phrasing several times in a row to get their point across? And do they always state the blatantly obvious? What about not saying a word except for indecernable grunts for nearly a minute while experiencing shock and awe over Frieza's latest transformation? Or are these just conveniences (annoyances, I'd say) for a younger audience? If you couldn't tell, I've gotten kinda annoyed with DBZ and I'm curious if Japanese watchers found these same things to be annoying =)

      --
      True story.
    3. Re:It's because they're different by Shajenko42 · · Score: 1
      DBZ is as streched out as it is because it was based on a manga (comic book) at the same time the manga was being written and published. Problem was, you only need to fill something like 26 pages (I think) in a manga, but 20-25 minutes in an anime. So, things were streched out (quite a bit) so they wouldn't overtake the manga.

      Plus several episodes are "filler", in that they never happened in the original manga, and the anime writers had some time to fill.

    4. Re:It's because they're different by Deraj+DeZine · · Score: 1

      Now that I think about it, DBZ is really the only show I've seen that has the lets-see-how-long-we-can-focus-on-this-one-aspect- of-the-story
      syndrome.

      Thanks for the info.

      --
      True story.
    5. Re:It's because they're different by SamSim · · Score: 1

      I did not know that about being written to keep pace with the manga. Thanks for the info.

      The thing I find most interesting about the series is that it was originally intended to finish after the Frieza Saga, which would have made the series one third as long and makes a hell of a lot more sense in retrospect.

    6. Re:It's because they're different by Soul-Burn666 · · Score: 1

      Forget about Cartoon Network and DBz. The real Japanophiles prefer higher quality anime which in many cases doesn't even get to the states... and then get it from Fansub Groups for unlicensed material. I personally dwell channels well over 1000 people at a time.

      --
      ^_^
    7. Re:It's because they're different by Soul-Burn666 · · Score: 1

      Not only that super-kung-fu-firing-fireballs-from-fingertips-fly ing-about-kicking-people-through-mountains, but also all the truly disturbing material, which is many times masked as cute shows or seamingly harmless series. It's the Japanese culture that allows for that. Things don't always have to be shallow. Or stuff like fanservice (pantsu!) or shows that are specifically ecchi (lotsa cases of a boy mistakenly sees girl in "indecent" situations, get a nosebleed and kicked out :-P) that never appear in US animation.

      Japanese have the quality to sometimes combine seriousness with utter foolishness in a very pleasing way.

      --
      ^_^
  24. Im only here for the anime by MrLint · · Score: 1

    Well im big on animation and off the top of my head I can only name a few US made animated shows with anything resembling plot and that dont make copious use of the history eraser button, not to mention the "think of the children beat you over the head with a moral lesson" crap so prevalent in US toons. So I predict I and many many others are going to be watching anime for a long time to come.

  25. Japan is a major importer of culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    No offence to any Japanese people, but Japan is actually a major importer of culture. Their strength lays in taking in good things from other people, and improve on them, making them better. Other than anime, the modern Japanese absorbed a lot from western countries.

    In the ancient time, most of its cultural customs came from China around the Tang dynasty. Examples include Kimono, Buddhism (which in turn came from India), original style of Samurai sword (the difference been in the straight edge of the blade instead of curved), the ancient form of Japanese language itself, and so on. The things about Japan is while they took on these things as their own and retained them as time went forth, China continoued to change through out various dynasties.

    1. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by zerOnIne · · Score: 1

      what do you mean, "other than anime"? take a look at some old manga, the influence of disney-style artwork is glaringly obvious. i think it falls in the same category as what else you've described in your comment.

      --
      09
    2. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by belmolis · · Score: 3, Informative

      The Japanese language did not come from China. Japanese and Chinese are unrelated languages. Japanese borrowed many Chinese words and the Chinese writing system, starting prior to the Tang dynasty, but the core of the language was not borrowed from China. It is also worth mentioning that there was not all that much direct contact with China. To a large extent the borrowing of "continental" culture was via Korea.

    3. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "To a large extent the borrowing of "continental" culture was via Korea."

      Where do you think Korean ancient culture was influenced by? To this date there are still heated debate about the use of Chinese language in South Korea.

      Also Japan did have a lot of direct contact with China from the Tang dynasty and onward. Due to a number of "pirates" problems on coastal China from bands of Japanese "pirates", the emperor at that time decided it is best to try to culturally influence Japan to be more like China to reduce conflicts. Businessmen, scholars, tradesmen were send to Japan, and channels for cultural exchanges were opened. The Japanese named their ancient capital to the same name as that of the Tang dynasty, translated to "Eastern Capital".

    4. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by Senjutsu · · Score: 2, Interesting

      ...the ancient form of Japanese language itself...

      This is incorrect. While the Japanese certainly imported the Chinese writing system, there are no known or suspected linguistic links between Japanese and Chinese (indeed, given that Japanese is a multisyllabic, agglutinative language, and the Chinese languages are monosyllabic and highly tonal, it is hard to see how they could be more different). Most linguists classify Japanese as a language isolate (one with no known relatives), although some suspect it is distantly related to Korean and Mongolian, and a few group it in a family with Finnish, Estonian, and Turkish as well.

    5. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by belmolis · · Score: 4, Informative
      "To a large extent the borrowing of "continental" culture was via Korea." Where do you think Korean ancient culture was influenced by?

      That's why I said via Korea rather than from Korea. It is true that there was some direct contact with Tang China, but the heavy influx of Chinese culture, including the writing system and Buddhism, clearly came via Korea, much of it prior to the Tang. Chinese writing was probably introduced (in the sense of scholars teaching the Japanese to read and write - objects with Chinese writing on them reached Japan earlier) at the beginning of the fifth century, that is, around 400 C.E., two hundred years before the foundation of the Tang Dynasty.

      The Japanese named their ancient capital to the same name as that of the Tang dynasty, translated to "Eastern Capital".

      This is not true. Tokyo does indeed mean "Eastern Capital", but it is not the ancient capital of Japan. During the Tang Dynasty, the capital of Japan was at Nara, near Kyoto. Later it moved to Kyoto. In those days, Tokyo was known as Yedo (now pronounced Edo in Japanese as a result of the loss of /y/ before /e/) and was considered the boondocks. Edo became the de facto capital when Tokugawa Ieyasu unified Japan (effectively after the battle of Sekigahara in 1602, formally in 1615) and did not become the official capital until 1868. It is called "Eastern Capital" in contradistinction to Kyoto.

    6. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by Monty · · Score: 1

      Very true, but just because it's borrowed vocabulary and not linguistic family that the two have in common doesn't mean the links between the two are nothing.... Just the same as English might not be a romance language but is still very much tied to Latin through etymological roots of words.

      Imo, anecdotally and from personal experience, anyone who knows one of the two languages immediately perceives similarities that help them learn the other language (sometimes there's even pseudo-homonyms like Mandarin kaixi/Japanese kaishi for the concept "begin". And the incidence of this rises the more Chinese dialects you know). Try getting the same results from a Finnish and a Mongol and tell me how successful you are. Recall that grammar only provides the rules to using vocabulary. Without vocabulary, a language is nothing. I would argue that because the two have common vocabulary, they're very "close" languages even in the absence of linguistic family ties.

      Even less of a reason to look at linguistic family in isolation is the presence of Kanji/Hanzi; educated speakers of Japanese can easily decypher if not fully read quite a lot of written Chinese even if they don't speak the language. As a note, sharing of Kanji wasn't one-way either. Quite a few compounds made their way back into Chinese, though after they were coined they weren't regarded as foreign. Example is the Kanji for crisis, "opportunity + danger"; Japanese origin AFAIK.

    7. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by Senjutsu · · Score: 1

      It simply depends on how accurate one wants to be. Japanese borrowed a lot of Chinese vocabulary, in roughly the same way that English borrowed the vocabulary of many other languages (notably Saxon), but to say that the early Japanese language was borrowed from the Chinese is inaccurate in the extreme.

      Try getting the same results from a Finnish and a Mongol and tell me how successful you are.

      That's an artifact of pictographic writing systems in which the core meaning of the characters is shared among multiple languages, and says nothing about the relationship of the underlying languages. Going the other way, for instance, is more difficult, because the Chinese lack the Hiragana/Katakana syllabaries and the entire concept of a particle system as it exists in Japanese.

      Recall that grammar only provides the rules to using vocabulary.

      Recall that, without grammar, language is useless. "Cow dog read the good fast" is chock full of english words, but utterly meaningless. Besides, linguists classify language into groups based not only upon grammatical relationships, but also on vocabularly relationships, and it nevertheless remains true that, despite the existence of many Chinese loan words in Japanese, Japanese is most emphatically not derived from Chinese.

    8. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well, hard to put this any other way, but you're just plain wrong. There are a lot of linguistic links between Japanese and Chinese. There are countless words in Japanese whose pronunciation comes from the original Chinese pronunciation. An obvious example is "denwa" (katakana reading) which comes from "dianhua" (pinyin) which means "telephone" in both languages. This is only a modern example, but many were borrowed so long ago, that the Chinese don't even say it the same way anymore.

      So, modern Japanese is, in fact, very related to Chinese both phonetically and textually.

    9. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by Senjutsu · · Score: 1

      There are a lot of linguistic links between Japanese and Chinese. There are countless words in Japanese whose pronunciation comes from the original Chinese pronunciation. An obvious example is "denwa" (katakana reading) which comes from "dianhua" (pinyin) which means "telephone" in both languages. This is only a modern example, but many were borrowed so long ago, that the Chinese don't even say it the same way anymore.

      You're describing loan words, which proves nothing about Japanese being descended from Chinese (which was the original parent's assertion). By your logic, English is descended from Chinese because we've incorporated words like "Gung-Ho".

      Look, I'm not a lone voice crying in the woods here; there is a lot of linguistic theory devoted to the study of language families, language isolates and the like, and none claim that Japanese is descended from Chinese, even though they all (as I do) acknowledge that Japanese borrowed much vocabulary from Chinese. There are fundamental, radical differences (agglutinative vs. not, tonal vs. not, inflected vs. not, Subject-Object-Verb vs Subject-Verb-Object, etc, etc, ad naseum) between the two languages that preclude the idea that one is descended from the other.

      It's a fascinating subject, and I'd usggest you do some research on it. Here is but one reference among many, many articles that have been written on the subject of Japanese and it's (lack of descent from) the Sino-Tibetan languages (specifically Chinese). Salient quotes:

      Azerbaijani Turks write Turkish with a Cyrillic alphabet, like the Russians use. But that doesnt make Russian and Azeri Turkish related languages. Serbian and Croatian are one and the same language but the Serbs write with the Cyrillic alphabet and the Croats with a Latinate one. Chinese writing and Japanese writing may look somewhat alike, but in fact Japanese and Chinese dont work alike, dont form sentences or words in the same way, and are about as different as any two languages can possibly be.

      Nor should you confuse borrowing of words with being linguistically related. Japanese and Korean both have borrowed many Chinese words but that doesnt make Chinese the "origin" of Japanese. Japanese and Korean are simply not demonstrably related to Chinese. "Related to" means "share a common linguistic ancestor with". There is no known, reconstructed, or even speculated at prehistoric language which is thought to have been the ancestor of both Chinese languages and Japanese and Korean.

    10. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by bugbread · · Score: 1

      "In the ancient time, most of its cultural customs came from China around the Tang dynasty. Examples include...the ancient form of Japanese language itself" (emphasis mine)

      I think people are skipping this ancient bit, and that the initial comment was pretty vague. When I read this, I assumed the author was talking about kobun, ancient written Japanese, which looks just like Chinese, but with a plethora of dashes and arrow symbols that indicate how to read it as Japanese.

    11. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by kahei · · Score: 1

      Quite a few compounds made their way back into Chinese, though after they were coined they weren't regarded as foreign. Example is the Kanji for crisis, "opportunity + danger"; Japanese origin AFAIK.


      Sigh.

      The Japanese for 'crisis' is made of two separate Chinese characters; one means 'danger' and one 'opportunity' and both are from China.

      --
      Whence? Hence. Whither? Thither.
    12. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by bugbread · · Score: 1

      Sigh.

      The Japanese for "crisis" is made from two Chinese characters.

      However, the Chinese did not use these two characters together to mean "crisis".

      The combination of these two characters was done by the Japanese, hence the origin of the word is Japanese.

      Think of it this way: the word "jipan" (jeans) is Japanese, but it's made of two parts: the G from G.I. (English) (no, the ji does not come from the word "jeans", though that would make more sense), and "pants", also English. The two components are English language, but the combination of them to form a new word is Japanese.

    13. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by kahei · · Score: 1

      Pedantry and a desire to avoid doing useful stuff compel me to reply.

      Example is the Kanji for crisis, "opportunity + danger"; Japanese origin AFAIK.

      The word for 'crisis' is made up of two kanji; there is no 'kanji for crisis'. Neither of the kanji in the word is Japanese in origin. I just don't know how to put it any more simply, other than to point out in slow, clear pronunciation that the original post said 'kanji' and not 'word'.

      The word 'kiki' as in 'crisis' is indeed Japanese afaik.

      You would have gotten bonus points on the jeans one if you'd pointed out that the 'GI' in 'G-pants' is not the 'GI' that refers to an infantryman...

      Anyway, 7/10 for Japanese, 2/10 for reading things before replying :)

      --
      Whence? Hence. Whither? Thither.
    14. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by bugbread · · Score: 1

      I just don't know how to put it any more simply, other than to point out in slow, clear pronunciation that the original post said 'kanji' and not 'word'."

      Understood, though it might have been nice to spare me the sardonic approach. Although I did read that he wrote "kanji" and not "word", it didn't particularly jump out at me, as the foreigners around me have a tendency to use "kanji" to refer to both individual kanji and entire words (if written in kanji) (ex: "Hey, what's the kanji for Shibuya?"). I guess I've gotten so used to people using it incorrectly that I just assumed the guy meant "the kanji compound" when he said kanji. Apologies.

      Interested in the bonus points: What I'd heard is that they were the pants the GIs wore during occupation, hence GI Pants, but that was from somebody's personal toribia no izumi as opposed to a creditable source; what does the G really stand for?

    15. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by kahei · · Score: 1


      Sorry about the sarcasm, but you do hear a lot of silly statements about asian languages on the internet these days so I'm a bit jumpy.

      Re: bonus points, I might have been mistaken. I always thought the 'GI' was for 'General Issue', and (googling away) some pages agree with me:

      http://homepage3.nifty.com/tshige/page030.html

      but some don't, including this comprehensive history of words for 'jeans':

      http://www.citronjeans.com/insider/other/gorj.ht ml

      (this page also contains the kanji for 'suso', 'pants cuff', a kanji not much used by most folks)

      And those that mention both do not favor 'Government Issue':

      http://www.sutv.zaq.ne.jp/ckafw600/yofuku/jeans. ht m

      So it's probably from the usual 'GI' after all.

      --
      Whence? Hence. Whither? Thither.
    16. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by bugbread · · Score: 1

      Actually, "suso" is used a lot, in the form of "susoage", which means "alteration", or hemming. Since a lot of jeans shops in Japan sell jeans without a fixed length, you get your correct waist size and then they cut the length to the length you want.

      Of course, from your name, I guess you're Japanese and probably already know that, which makes me feel a little stupid. Ah well...

    17. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by Monty · · Score: 1

      Actually I did mean kanji as in kanji compound. I've never heard the usage kanjis, nor are people so pedantic in spoken conversation that they'll correct it, so it's fairly common use now. I don't see what the fuss is about though? The context was clearly about coining the compound, not creating graphemes or logograms.

    18. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by bugbread · · Score: 1

      Hmm...I haven't heard the word "kanjis" either, but I've heard kanji compounds, and, far more often (since the people around me tend to be able to speak Japanese and have a decent vocabulary), "jukugo". I have to admit, though, my perspective is probably pretty skewed from living in Japan, and kanji in relation to kanji compounds may be fairly common usage.

      Also nice because I don't feel like such a dork for defending the Japanese origins of "kiki" as well ^_^

    19. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by Monty · · Score: 1

      I stand corrected on maybe callous use of Kanji instead of Kanji compounds, but the point remains: even if minor, influence in vocabulary clearly went both ways... and though maybe not as interesting as grammatical ties, these common points in vocabulary are just as important.

    20. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by kahei · · Score: 1

      I didn't know there was a kanji for 'suso' -- it's one of those words like 'semaru', 'to grind the teeth' where the kanji is so specific that it only occurs in that one word. (I will now be corrected by someone pointing out how actually it's used in several common words)

      I was aware of the word 'susoage' but I have no need of it as my legs are way longer than the longest jeans available in Japan :/

      I am, however, not Japanese -- I just play one on Slashdot.

      --
      Whence? Hence. Whither? Thither.
    21. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by kahei · · Score: 1

      Aagh! The 'semaru' kanji actually _does_ occur in a compound! Apparently 'akuseku' is actually composed of TWO kanji for 'grinding teeth'! TWO!! Has the world gone MAD??

      Sigh.

      --
      Whence? Hence. Whither? Thither.
    22. Re:Japan is a major importer of culture by bugbread · · Score: 1

      Hehe...No, I can't think of any words that use the character for tooth grinding either. Gonna have to leave that open for someone else to come up with ^_^

  26. Can't believed they failed to mention that... by chendo · · Score: 4, Informative
    And the costumes and atmosphere of the recently concluded "Matrix" series were rooted primarily in Japanese manga.


    Highly likely the manga they're talking about Ghost in the Shell (recent coverage)
    --
    Founder of Mirror Moon - Tsukihime Game Trans
    1. Re:Can't believed they failed to mention that... by Kassiopeia · · Score: 1

      More probably, though, the 'manga'(comic) they should be talking about is The Invisibles, the unsung forebearer of "Matrix aesthetics".

    2. Re:Can't believed they failed to mention that... by Kent+Recal · · Score: 1


      Don't tell me you missed the Animatrix!

  27. Je Me Souviens by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    That's french for:
    "I Am Soup"

  28. Re:You want the coolest culture? Check out Canada! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    -Basketball (yes, we did invent basketball)
    Was Springfield, Massachusetts, the birthplace of basketball, once part of Canada?


    No, but the man who invented it in Springfield, Massachusettes was Canadian.

    -Telephone (a la Alexander Graham Bell)
    Was Boston, the place where the telephone was invented, once part of Canada?


    The telephone was invented in Canada by Alexander Graham Bell. When there were no investors who saw any potential in Canada, he took it to Boston for its first display in the USA. That's when most Americans think it was invented.

  29. Is Japan Really Cool ? by tealover · · Score: 5, Insightful

    How many hot girls do you know that love manga, anime and videogames ?

    And please, no anecdotes about "my wife does!"...I'm talking in the general case. Walk into a bar on the Upper West Side talking about Castle in the Sky to the 6'0 Brazilian supermodel and she'll stare at you blankly while planning her escape.

    Japan has a niche with a certain segment (nerdy people) but their culture doesn't have broad appeal to the masses. Sure, videogames pull in a lot of money but they're typically bought by young men.

    The readers of this site will love the article because it will affirm something they want to believe in, but it doesn't really make it true.

    --
    -- You see, there would be these conclusions that you could jump to
    1. Re:Is Japan Really Cool ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Amen to that. In fact, everyone I know who thinks Japan is 'cool' is decidedly uncool, lacking somewhat in social graces and definitely unable to chat up a Brazilian model in a bar...

    2. Re:Is Japan Really Cool ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I know a whole bunch o girls who love videogames, and even a few who watch manga. Come to think of it, I don't think I know more girls (well) who like videogames (Nintendo being the most popular, doesn't get much more japanese then that) then who don't, and at least a few of them are hot (by non-geek-standards...).

      But then of course I live in Sweden, where everyone looks like super models...

      Still not a good subject of conversation in a typical bar setting though, but still...

    3. Re:Is Japan Really Cool ? by Fnkmaster · · Score: 1
      Dude, if you live on the Upper West Side, can you tell me which bars the 6 foot tall Brazilian supermodels hang out at? I'm serious, I would love to know. I always thought I had to go downtown to find that vibe (with the possible exception of the Hudson Hotel).


      Don't worry, I promise not to talk about anime with them. Or Slashdot.

    4. Re:Is Japan Really Cool ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I dunno about that. I've been noticing that some "cool" people at my college love anime. I think a lot of people won't admit they like it because it has a nerdy stigma.

    5. Re:Is Japan Really Cool ? by HaveBlue34 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Japan has a niche with a certain segment (nerdy people) but their culture doesn't have broad appeal to the masses.

      Two words: Hello Kitty sanrio.com

    6. Re:Is Japan Really Cool ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      How many hot girls do you know? If you walk into a trendy bar, the "beautiful people" there tend not to want to talk about anything but the most vacuous and superficial topics imaginable. "Cool" people (DJs, musicians, artists, actors and directors) tend to be a lot like geeks in the way they can obsess about some obscure topic -- they just happen to latch on to topics that are "cooler" than computers, sci-fi, and manga.

      I used to do a pretty good job of towing the line myself -- talking up obscure bands and unheardof artists with my "cool" friends, and sticking to Linux and video games with my "geeky" friends. I guess it's worn me out, 'cuz I haven't been doing as good of a job keeping them seperate lately, so now I'm a "nerd" in the cool circles and a "weirdo" to the geeks. The upshot of this is that I've found a small handful of people a lot like me -- rock stars that love video games, coders who are DJs, etc.

    7. Re:Is Japan Really Cool ? by Lord_Dweomer · · Score: 1
      "Japan has a niche with a certain segment (nerdy people) but their culture doesn't have broad appeal to the masses. "

      What you say holds much truth. My friend from Osaka confirmed this when I asked about the very same thing. He said that while anime and those sorts of things are more popular and mainstream than in America, it is CERTAINLY not as big as everybody over here in the US thinks. If you were to go to some bar there and attempt to start chatting with some girl about anime, she would most likely look at you funny.

      However, as a side note, if you want to find hot girls interested in anime and japanese culture, one need only go to a large anime convention. You will NOT be disappointed.

      --
      Buy Steampunk Clothing Online!
    8. Re:Is Japan Really Cool ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      6'0 Brazilian supermodels aren't a niche group? I'd wager that there are more people that like anime than there are 6'0 Brazilian supermodels. I can only think of three and one is marrying Leonardo Dicaprio.

    9. Re:Is Japan Really Cool ? by SQL+Error · · Score: 1

      The recent anime convention in Sydney (Animania) was wall-to-wall hot girls, many of them in costume. Hooray! A geek pastime that attracts more girls than guys!

      Not only that, but you can actually talk to these girls. Try chatting to that 6' Brazilian supermodel about *anything* and the best you'll get is a blank stare while she plans her escape.

    10. Re:Is Japan Really Cool ? by Planesdragon · · Score: 1

      I'm talking in the general case. Walk into a bar on the Upper West Side talking about Castle in the Sky to the 6'0 Brazilian supermodel and she'll stare at you blankly while planning her escape.

      The "general case" is neither a 'supermodel' nor are they in a bar. They're at home, married, with children (with or without a job of their own)--and their children likely are entertained by a good portion of gizmos and imports from Japan.

      That said, Manga, Anime, and Videogames aren't Jappanese culture anymore than American novels and comic books are American culture. They're aspects of it, but that's quite a different matter.

  30. The Vapors by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    They turned us all japanese. I really think so.

  31. Re:You want the coolest culture? Check out Canada! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    -Basketball (yes, we did invent basketball)
    Was Springfield, Massachusetts, the birthplace of basketball, once part of Canada?

    James Naismith was Canadian.

    -Telephone (a la Alexander Graham Bell)
    Was Boston, the place where the telephone was invented, once part of Canada?

    Alexander Graham Bell was Canadian.

  32. ReYou want the coolest culture? Check out Flanders by Patrik_AKA_RedX · · Score: 1

    So Canada has Jim Carrey, Mike Myers, Alanis Morrisette, Basketball, Hockey, Telephone, Maple Syrup and Canadian peacekeepers

    Big deal! We've got the best beers in the world, the best chocolate and plenty of hot chicks.

  33. Re:You want the coolest culture? Check out Canada! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I believe the accidental First Call was in Boston ("Watson come here, it burns! Fsck fsck fsck!"). The actual invention took place in Ontario.

  34. Re:You want the coolest culture? Check out Canada! by wo1verin3 · · Score: 1

    >> And don't forget Tom Green.

    We are trying to forget him. Please don't remind us.

    >> Next time, maybe you can include Neil Young
    >> and and Joni Mitchel if you want to show off
    >> Canadian talent.

    Hey, if you like Neil Young, please take him.

    >>-Basketball (yes, we did invent basketball)
    >>Was Springfield, Massachusetts, the birthplace
    >>of basketball, once part of Canada?

    James Naismith was the Canadian physical education instructor who invented basketball in 1891. James Naismith was born in Almonte, Ontario and educated at McGill University and Presbyterian Cllege in Montreal. He was a Canadian, regardless of where he invented it. If he invented it on the moon, it would have still been invented by a Canadian.

    >> Was Boston, the place where the telephone was
    >> invented, once part of Canada?

    Alexander Graham Bell is most well known for
    inventing the telephone. He came to the U.S as
    a teacher of the deaf, and conceived the idea
    of "electronic speech" while visiting his
    hearing-impaired mother in Canada.


    The idea was born in Canada, and he himself is not an American, he is from Scotland.

  35. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I think the original article is a gross generalization. Most popular Japanese culture I have been exposed to (manga, anime, music) is uninspiring IMHO. There are few exceptions (e.g. Akira) but most of it is the same dross on TV's globally. Give me Kurosawa or Mishima any day.

    I certainly don't think JAPAN=COOL automatically.

    I once made the mistake of going to an anime convention with a friend, and I've haven't met a bigger bunch of social outcasts, geeks and just plain weird people in my life. And the interest shown by 30 year old adult males in anime pr0n ..ecchh...I don't even want to go there.

  36. Heard in a Japanese Boardroom 15 years ago by Tablizer · · Score: 2, Troll

    "Screw manufacturing, lets instead focus on blobs with cute smiles and half-naked cartoon characters."

    "Boss, you are a genius!"

    1. Re:Heard in a Japanese Boardroom 15 years ago by anicholo · · Score: 1

      the funny part was "15 years ago" right? anime is older than thou! the fact that americans are still watching dragon ball is entirely the Boss's fault

      --
      We are The Atheists. Lower your egos and surrender your beliefs. Resistance is futile.
    2. Re:Heard in a Japanese Boardroom 15 years ago by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I am curious, why did somebody rate this as "troll"? It is only a commentary on the odd, unpredictable nature of change.

  37. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    You think US animation is of higher quality than Japanese? Where do you buy your crack from dude? I'd love to get me some of that!
    Look at a picture from Looney Tunes, yes, with a name like that, it just has to be epic. I could, blindfolded, reproduce a 95% authentic copy of the ultra low detailed animation, even though I have very little personal artistic ability. Now take something from Iria : Zeiram the animation, and try the same thing. There's more detail in Iria's hand than in an entire frame from Looney Tunes.
    Yes there are bad Japanese examples, as well. Pokemon being the worst offender, the overall quality with this monster catching crap does seem to be pulling the overall animation quality down, which is a shame. But overall, I would have very much trouble finding a single US animation with half the detail and seriousness put into it as a Japanese counterpart.
    I haven't even TOUCHED into storyline. Tell me, what's the most in depth storyline you got from US cartoons? Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Looney Tunes, Scooby Doo?
    Animation doesn't have to be solely for infants and toddlers, that's a pathetic stereotyping. US animation is insulting to my intelligence. Now south park I'll watch, but let's not EVEN go into the animation quality there.
    Please stop assuming that your hatred of anime is universal and that everyone here thinks like you.

  38. I know you didn't read the article by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Because it's Slashdot, but that isn't really what it's about it. It's more about Japan taking American (and other cultures), adapting it for Asians, and then shipping it back out to the rest of Asia. For example, they cut their jeans differently for their different body shapes, thus making their jeans popular in places like South Korea. Japan is essentially a cultural filter from Non-Asia to Asia.

  39. Yeah.. by destiney · · Score: 1


    Both FFXI and FFX-2 both rock!

    1. Re:Yeah.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      yeah, both.

  40. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    figure it like this. Would you rather have Disney movies or stuff like Spirited Away? Cartoon Network only plays crap anime like Yu Yu and Ruroni, DBZ and Gundum...these are the lowest denominators of animation in general. .Hack is garbage as well. Don't judge a culture by what an american network portrays. Should I think of you as a hotdog gulping 500 pound transexual because you are such a bigot? Well...maybe I just will.

  41. The problem with US Comics by tkrotchko · · Score: 1

    The problem is that US Comics are fixated on "Superheros", which are interesting and cool, but you get bored with it after a while.

    --
    You were mistaken. Which is odd, since memory shouldn't be a problem for you
    1. Re:The problem with US Comics by mrseigen · · Score: 1

      That perception is probably due to the implementation of the Comics Code which eventually turned the mainstream comic industry into repetitive superhero-comic garbage. Of course, if you want to look beyond the mainstream you can probably find stuff of much more interest.

  42. Monkey-man by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    He's considered to be a big, stupid gruff. If you have ever seen "blazing saddles", you might remember the character named Mongo, and Bob serves exactly the same comic relief. Big, stupid and monkey-like. Unfortunate, but true.

  43. What about the Germans? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Scat porn

    I thought that belonged to the Germans.

    1. Re:What about the Germans? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I actually don't know where that rumor comes from, I haven't heard anything about scat porn being famous around here (germany) - I don't even think most adult video stores have that sort of fetish..

  44. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    EFnet does not support your obnoxious spamming. You will stop or you will be g:lined. I have the support of many opers on this issue who are sick of your spamming on Slashdot. Have a nice day.

  45. Empire of cool(ness)?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    More like an empire of wannabe whorelets. It wasn't up until a few years ago that OLD Oyajis legally engaged with underage whorelets. Well, to be fair their tech side is still good, but to think that the cultural exports are something to exalt is silly, utterly silly. Next you know they (/.) will be telling us that japan has a penchant for pink and white knickers.

    1. Re:Empire of cool(ness)?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Next you know they (/.) will be telling us that japan has a penchant for pink and white knickers.

      ...don't they?

  46. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by Megane · · Score: 1
    If all you want to see is "quality animation", then just watch anything by Disney with the sound turned off.

    Some of us care more about a good story than a high frame rate or perfect lip sync.

    --
    #naabhaprzrag, #sverubfr-000, #agi-fcbafberq, negvpyr[pynff*=' negvpyr-ary-'] { qvfcynl: abar !vzcbegnag; }
  47. Re:Not to sound like flamebait... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    No, it's because those Japanese girls are H-O-T HOT!

  48. Re:ReYou want the coolest culture? Check out Fland by fastidious+edward · · Score: 1

    Switzerland, but your clock must be broken.

    --

    karma karma karma karma karma chameleon, you come and go, you come and go.
  49. Why Modded a Flaimbait?? He's 100% Correct ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Other than the "ricer" car culture, Japanese culture isn't popular among the "cool" kids. It's just that now-a-days a teenage geek is into anime and manga rather than superhero comics and Star Trek.

  50. Re:You want the coolest culture? Check out Canada! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The idea was born in Canada, and he himself is not an American, he is from Scotland. While we can be reasonably sure he was from Scotland; it would be quite presumptuous that he is still a Scot. I will continue to presume he is dead.

  51. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Saying it's "soon to be modded down" is no excuse. The post is filled with too much flameyness. If you want to make a controversial point, go ahead, but hold the flames.

  52. Storylines are alien by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    I haven't even TOUCHED into storyline.

    That is a very good point.

    My kids are into Japanese animation and I've grown really worried about the how alien it is.

    Even though the episodes are mostly about "good vs. evil", I don't recognize the good. Instead of turning the other cheek, every argument is fought out.

    Is this a good example to our kids?

    1. Re:Storylines are alien by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That is a very good point.

      My kids are into Japanese animation and I've grown really worried about the how alien it is.

      Even though the episodes are mostly about "good vs. evil", I don't recognize the good. Instead of turning the other cheek, every argument is fought out.

      Is this a good example to our kids?


      Indeed you may have a point, there. It is very strange, it's from half way around the world, their culture is completely different from ours, even with that in mind, anime is sometimes very, very strange. If US companies would realize a potential market when they see it, rather than passing off all followers as geeks and social outcasts, perhaps we could get some high quality US animation, with good moral lessons that aren't so "IN YOUR FACE" as present. Otherwise, they'll sit back and whine and balk, much like Microsoft is doing to Linux at present, whilst their market share dwindles and US citizens seek better alternatives.

      It is also worth mentioning that all animation is not for kids, at least not in the US. In Japan, the bar for censorship is much, much lower. The parents don't show kids the shame shock value when they cuss, so cussing isn't as big a deal. Violence isn't censored, and is thus less of a big deal there. The US has had a LONG history of youths fighting against censorship, and it has continued to be broken down with each new generation, hell 100 years ago women weren't allowed to wear anything but long skirts. I think a part of the attraction to that violence is the next generation, tired of the govt telling them what they should and should not see. And a lot of this falls on the parents. If your kids are watching Akira, and La Blue Girl, perhaps it's time to take the remote from them. Thankfully, the V-Chip rating system is -usually- pretty accurate. Censorship should be a job of the parent, not the govt.
      But seriously, get involved. Ask your kids, "Why do you like this Japanese stuff?", find out what's good, and what's not. If you don't like it, don't let them watch it. Sure you can't do a full-proof job of stopping them, but perhaps if you teach them why it's bad, and do a good job, they'll believe what you say, and not want to watch it.

    2. Re:Storylines are alien by Qzukk · · Score: 3, Insightful

      What is good and what is evil? This very topic is explored by some of the deeper anime series and movies out there (IE, not pokemon or pokemon-clones). In many good shows, nobody carries a sign announcing their intentions either way. Take Princess Mononoke, for instance: Are the industrialists who are destroying the forests and the native peoples' way of life evil? Are the natives who are fighting back evil? And then there are the shows that don't operate on the same concepts of conflict that American shows do, such as Haibane Renmei or Niea Under 7, both of which illustrate caste systems and racism in interesting ways.

      But this thought-provoking nature is what draws me to these shows. Take the time to watch a "good" show (hint: if its on tv, its aimed at the mass market and is typically not so good. Watch a few episodes yourself, and if its got more flashing lights than an ambulance, its mass market kiddy fare). After you've seen it yourself and feel you're comfortable with the subject, watch it with your children and open the floor for discussion.

      If your children are later-middle-school or high-school aged, you should pick up His and Her Circumstances, a romantic comedy/drama that shows that peer pressure and worrying about one's appearance is pretty constant anywhere in the world. If you want your children to become tree-hugging vegans, there's also Arjuna (seriously. Don't watch this if you are the least bit squeamish or offended by environmentalists). Rurouni Kenshin might satisfy your a desire for action, while starring a hero who believes above all else that killing is wrong and who goes to extraordinary lengths to avoid doing so to his enemies (not to say that killing and blood and gore does not happen... the enemies, and even his friends don't share the same morality).

      Remember above all else, life is rated PG. If parents weren't required, children would simply pop into existance on their own. Take some time with your children to let them know you disapprove of the shows they are watching, take some time to explain why. Decide if you believe your children are mature enough to seperate what they see on tv from reality, and if they don't, offer some alternatives, whether they be different shows, or reading a book, or heck, go out and throw a frisbee or a ball or something.

      --
      If I have been able to see further than others, it is because I bought a pair of binoculars.
    3. Re:Storylines are alien by WuphonsReach · · Score: 1

      Princess Mononoke is indeed a good example...

      The first time I watched it, I had difficulties with the way that the lady who's in charge of the fort is portrayed. Western style would be that she would be complete evil, exploiting the land, her workers, soley for personal gain/power. We should be cheering for her destruction, no?

      Well not quite, because things are not black-n-white like western audiences expect. Villans are not necessarily beyond redemption or entirely evil and heros can make some horrible decisions.

      That's one of the attractive things compared to most western fare, it doesn't assume that the viewer is an idiot who has to have a black-n-white outcome.

      --
      Wolde you bothe eate your cake, and have your cake?
  53. Empire of cool? Uh... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Um, last I checked the only Americans that considered anime, JPop and video games to be cool were UNCOOL NERDS.

    Japanese culture:cool culture::They Might Be Giants:pop music

  54. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by UniverseIsADoughnut · · Score: 1

    You missed it completely! Good animation is not about detail!! It's about the story, the charators and overall entertainment. The extreme detail of some anime is what makes it such a turn off, just hire freaking actors. Looneytoons is still going strong today because they are what cartoons are ment to be. Animal based charators with non stop comedy. Use of humans in cartoons is going away from the point of cartoons. Hense why most classic cartoons only used humans where needed, or they are part of a storyline with animals. There are some exceptions, but not to many.

    In more moderntimes shows like simpsons, futurame, family guy continue traditional cartoons. They may be full of humans but they would not be what they are without the cartoon format. The detail of them doesn't matter, its all the content. Also only the simpsons could even remotely be done with actors, and it would long since be off the air if it was.

    If what your are going for is detail, I sugest you check out movies and tv shows with real live actors, the detail of a human being in just great.

  55. Blade Rrunner and Giant Robots by fireteller2 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Over the past few years all things Asian have been building up popularity here in L.A. As witnessed by the growth of such new magazines as "Giant Robot". Perhaps we're moving towards Blade Runner world.

    I for one am all for it. The Asian design since from Hong Kong and Japan is quite good, and it's time for them to stop regurgitating western culture and come into there own. There also seems to be a ground swell of radical art coming out of Japan. I read this as retaliation against a conformist culture. It's very exciting, I think we are in for ride the equivalent of America in the 60s.

    fire
  56. Anime is for KIDS by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Anime is for KIDS

    1. Re:Anime is for KIDS by Elektroschock · · Score: 1

      Ah, now I understand the child pornographic references in japanese mangas. ;-)

  57. Japan Rocks by molafson · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I like Japan. It rocks. The food's good, people are respectful of each other, and you can buy beer in vending machines. However, I feel compelled to tell you all that I hate anime. Lots of Japanese people hate it as well. (Similarly, many Americans hate Hollywood films, network television, etc.)

    I feel that American anime fanboys like anime mostly because it is different. To be a fan of anime makes them feel special (because ordinary American people are not very familiar with anime apart from Pokemon et al.)

    Lastly, what I hate even more than anime are anime-themed RPGs. Thank you for letting me vent. No offense intended.

    1. Re:Japan Rocks by Repugnant_Shit · · Score: 1

      I like anime, but not blindly. It's just like anything else, there's good and there's bad anime. I don't like a lot of Hollywood movies and network television, and I don't like a LOT of anime. I think a lot of people just need to realize that animated movies/tv shows can tell a serious story, or be just as funny as live action. I'd love it if everyone was into anime, it'd give us something to talk about instead of Survivor.

    2. Re:Japan Rocks by LordK3nn3th · · Score: 1

      I like anime, but not all of it. You won't see me watching a lot of the mainstream stuff. I mostly just download fansubs off edonkey. It gives me something to do. Yes, there are parts of many anime I don't like, but at least it's better than Captain Planet.

      I'm certainly not an anime fanboy. I know of a stupid "anime fangirl" who likes anime simply because it's anime, that includes crap like pokemon and Yu-gi-oh.

      Most of what I watch other kids haven't heard about. That which they have, such as Evangelion, Ghost in the Shell, Love Hina (Love Hina is OKAY, but certainly not the best anime out there), is overrated, with the exception of Princess Mononoke, which was good and original.

      You won't ever catch me watching DBZ, Gundam Wing, etc-- My interests in anime are more refined. It's similar to american cartoons, as well. You don't like every genre on TV yourself, do you?

      Not every anime is the same. Oh, and I'm not a dork who thinks it's cool to use "baka" and "otaku"-- I like what I watch because of what it is, not where it came from.

      --

      ---
      Never criticize religion on Slashdot. You will be modded down for "Troll" no matter how factual it is.
    3. Re:Japan Rocks by rhuntley12 · · Score: 1

      Yeah the people who love anime I know of don't know, Excel Saga, Chrno Crusade, Those Who Hunt Elves, Kite, etc, etc. They look at me like I'm a tard when I say I thought Ghost in the Shell, Gundam, all sucked.

    4. Re:Japan Rocks by bugbread · · Score: 1

      I always find phrases like "Anime is great" to be really odd. It's like saying "Movies are great". Like any genre, 90% of everything sucks.

      Ok, to be fair to other genres, 98% of anime sucks. The vast vast majority is aimed at elementary school kids, and the stuff that isn't is mostly aimed at otaku. The only decent stuff is that aimed at the regular marketplace, and, no matter what lies you've been told, the majority of Japanese adults do not watch any anime. Read manga? Yes. Watch anime? No.

    5. Re:Japan Rocks by ice-nine · · Score: 2, Insightful

      maybe you need to stop thinking of anime as a genre. there are tons of different kinds of anime, aimed at all different sorts of people. maybe it's just animation in general that you hate (disney, pixar, dreamworks, etc)?

      anyway i think your comment was dumb because basically all you're saying is you that don't like anime.

      --
      zing
  58. Culture? by 0x1337 · · Score: 0, Troll

    *cough* If that is culture...

    1. Re:Culture? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      troll.

    2. Re:Culture? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes anyone who doesn't love seeing cartoons of little girls in school uniforms and big robots is obviously a troll!

      Who doesn't love cartoons with school girls and giant robots! IMPOSSIBLE!

    3. Re:Culture? by 0x1337 · · Score: 1

      No - its an opinion, Mr. Anonymous Coward whose too afraid to put a name behind his opinion

      Damn, I love Slashdot. Every time someone disagrees with your opinion, they go on a moderation crusade. Troll Troll Troll... Overrated Overrated Overrated...

      Sheesh... grow a fucking dick.

    4. Re:Culture? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Your opinion is wrong. Grown of ignorance and YOUR small dick.

    5. Re:Culture? by 0x1337 · · Score: 1

      Thank you, oh wise Anonymous Coward, for sharing your wisdom. What could the world do without it...

  59. Just maybe... by ilsa · · Score: 1

    I should learn more Japanese than "Dozo, ichi biru! Hai! Domo arigato" and the names of assorted foodstuffs. Even Largo knows more than that, wakarimasu ka?

    --
    -- I Am Not A Terrorist.
    1. Re:Just maybe... by Guppy06 · · Score: 3, Funny

      "I should learn more Japanese than "Dozo, ichi biru! Hai! Domo arigato" and the names of assorted foodstuffs."

      Phase 1: Learn romanji
      Phase 2: ???
      Phase 3: Kanji!

    2. Re:Just maybe... by Little+Brother · · Score: 2, Insightful

      2. Hiragana and Katakana

      --

      Little Brother, watching the watchers

    3. Re:Just maybe... by amake · · Score: 1

      It's "romaji," not "romanji." You learn it.

    4. Re:Just maybe... by f1rb · · Score: 1

      Learning Katakana is useful, as you can pronounce and hopefully recognise foreign (well, English) words in otherwise unintelligible documents. Especially good for computer stuff, but also works in Ramen bars.
      Merii Kurisumasu everyone

      --
      "There is nothing so simple that works so well that it can't be made to work better by making it more complicated" - ?
  60. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by SamSim · · Score: 1
    the majority of the US despises Anime with a passion... Anime is the lowest level of cartooning, it either uses crappy animation, or uses animation that is so far away from traditional animation that it shouldn't be considered as such

    It sounds to me like you're the one reinforcing negative stereotypes. And if as you say there are only about two animes on Adult Swim, then I would suggest that the problem here is that you just haven't got to the good stuff yet. Believe me when I tell you that DBZ - which is probably one of those two - is very near the bottom of the barrel - anime is just like any other medium (movies, American cartoons) as far as highs and lows go.

    And if, after that, you still hate anime, then (correct me if I'm wrong) I think there's an option somewhere in your preferences so you can make Anime stories not come up on the main page.

  61. Lion King by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Ah, Disney animation Lion King TOO resembles Japanese anime in 60's? Why?

    1. Re:Lion King by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      same reason as Disney's Atlantis.

      Not that taking is wrong, but if they do they should give as well.

      Copyright law should NEVER have been extended.

  62. Not just the same but even more so... by xigxag · · Score: 4, Informative

    For those people who can't be bothered to read the article, one of the main points was that:

    A record 3 million people around the world are now studying the Japanese language, compared with only 127,000 in 1997, according to the Japan Foundation and Tokyo's Marubeni Research Institute.

    So, in other words, there is a measurable increase in the cultural cachet of Japan, it's not just a static, ongoing event. And it's not just about manga and anime, but food (sushi restaurants are now ubiquitous in any large city), and jrock/jpop, the prime examples of which are Glay, KinKi Kids, Puffy (known in the US as Puffy AmiYumi so as to avoid confusion with a certain hiphop impresario), Hamasaki Ayumi, the New York born Utada Hikaru and Morning Musume, a group of currently 15 girls that form the most well known part of a pop empire.

    Furthermore, even anime seems to be taking up an ever larger bite of the US Cartoon Network's schedule and the traditional Saturday Morning/after-school children's fare. It's even made a few recent ventures into wide release cinema in the US.

    However, one could argue, I think persuasively, that's Japan's cultural upswing is part of a larger trend in the Asia-fication of Western culture. What started with egg foo yung and chop suey has now branched out to shabu-shabu and kimchi. What began with Speed Racer and Godzilla has developed into Princess Mononoke, cosplay and Shaolin Soccer.

    --
    There are two kinds of people: 1) those who start arrays with one and 1) those who start them with zero.
    1. Re:Not just the same but even more so... by critter_hunter · · Score: 1

      Morning Musume is pop? I thought it was a children's show. I mean, "Summer Reggae Rainbow" and "Telephone Ring Ring" CAN'T be popular with people over 10 years old, can they? It's so damn bad, at first I thought they were jokes like that Yatta! thingie...

      --
      Karma: Could be worse (could be raining)
    2. Re:Not just the same but even more so... by xigxag · · Score: 1

      Morning Musume is the main group in a pop music production venture called the "Hello! Project." The songs you mentioned were by smaller groups in the project. Summer Reggae Rainbow is by "7-nin Matsuri" and the other song, called Mini Moni Telephone! Ring Ring Ring is by a kids' group called "Mini Moni."

      Nevertheless, Morning Musume and its various groupings do tend to appeal mostly to young people. And middle-aged salarymen. (For the reason why, see here). Which I suppose, tangientally touches upon one of the major Japanese cultural exports.

      Porn.

      --
      There are two kinds of people: 1) those who start arrays with one and 1) those who start them with zero.
    3. Re:Not just the same but even more so... by Saeger · · Score: 1
      kimchi

      Are you kidding? Kimchi stinks! It's basically rotten cabbage.

      I haven't gotten used to that nasty smell in 10 years.

      --

      --
      Power to the Peaceful
    4. Re:Not just the same but even more so... by anagama · · Score: 1


      Here's one for the list, my favorite - Cocco: Raining

      I have a couple of her albums but I like this one the best. And it ain't bubblegum sweet "Jpop". Think Tori Amos if she was Japanese.

      --
      What changed under Obama? Nothing Good
  63. Not Suprised by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I really don't find this suprising at all. I mean were do you think this reality TV crap came from? I'll give you a hint its not American inspired. I believe it came from Japan.

    Then look At Anime more specificly the Non-Dubbed stuff, and you will more often than not find a story that rivals any Movie or American TV series that has a good level of Conanuity. Unfortunaly Anime when it goes to the American Dubbing mills looses massive amounts of quality, all in the name of ameicanising the Anime to make it easyer for (Baka) Americans in general to understand..

    Look at music.... well enough said, I'd rather listen to a song with good music (and words I dont understand) than 90% of the noise that come out of the USA..

    All in all when you know the culture and the people Japan's not that great a place. But its cultureal exports are really good.

    Japan's a nice place to visit, and have some stuff from, but thats about it. Japans one of the most competitive countries in the world. but With all good things theres a heap of bad stuff that we all try to ignore..

  64. Not to mention... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I thought their leading export was Bukkake.

  65. One word... by neutralstone · · Score: 1

    With the exception of the years before and during ww2, Japan has long been a rabid consumer for American culture, along with european culture.

    One word: Baseball.

    Ok, I'm not sure if the inclusion of that American game into the set of Japanese National Pastimes counts as "rabid" consumption, but it did happen decades before WWII. But if by "rabid" you mean "popular," then it was rabid.

  66. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by Little+Brother · · Score: 1
    To translate parts the above troll/post:

    Good animation is not about detail!!
    US animators are less talented/care less so let's change the subject.

    Looneytoons is still going strong today because they are what cartoons are ment to be. Animal based charators with non stop comedy.
    I won't accept any animation that isn't like what I grew up with: Pointless slapstick violence with no plot development or characteraziation.

    Use of humans in cartoons is going away from the point of cartoons
    I don't like realism in art, I prefer escapeism and making the characters humans makes me think to much. Furthermore I am the grand judge of the point of cartoons and none may gainsay my word.

    If what your are going for is detail, I sugest you check out movies and tv shows with real live actors, the detail of a human being in just great.
    I also don't understand why anyone would want to look at a painting or inkcolor when you could just go out and look at a real, live person. The whole "art" thing is just a bunch of people wasting their time looking at things like the Mona Lisa or Rembrant's Sunflower when they could be looking at ther real thing.


    Or in short. I don't like art. I don't like to think. I don't like anything that challenges my worldview. I don't like change. I don't like complexity.

    Bloody Philistine.

    --

    Little Brother, watching the watchers

  67. Mou Ichido ... by Yunalesca · · Score: 3, Insightful

    This isn't completely new. Remember the Impressionists? They were quite into their "japonaise" (I forgot the exact term...). There are quite a few paintings of European women dressed in kimono, and collecting trinkets from Japan was all the rage, not just among the artsy crowd. I think the reasons are still similar.

    Now, however, I think a lot of their exports (anime/manga/video esp) have loads of Western influence anyway. Aside from Inu-Yasha and Rurouni Kenshin (the latter of which is set in the Meiji - a major Westernizing period - anyway), I can't think of very many mainstream titles that involve something purely Japanese. But it's blended with their own culture, which is still different enough to be new and interesting for others.

    --
    The floggings will stop when morale improves.
  68. The Superiority of Japanese Culture by Rayonic · · Score: 1

    Is evidenced by today's Something Awful Link of the Day. (Not Safe For Work)

    1. Re:The Superiority of Japanese Culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I don't know about you, but I was quite turned on by this...

  69. J-Pop = American meme by Doc+Ruby · · Score: 2, Interesting

    The rise of J-Pop documented in the article is really the success of American pop. Just as black rock & roll took over American pop culture when played by whites, American pop culture (boy bands, fast food, comic books, slutty schoolgirls, top 40 music with unintelligible lyrics) is bigger in Asia with an Asian face.

    This is a really encouraging phenomenon. Global culture flows bring us all together, giving us something in common. When we want to dance with each other, watch each other's movies, eat each other's food, we want to live together and talk about it. Only Hollywood sees the culture market as nationalistically competitive, because in Hollywood, culture is property is power, not to be shared, except at a self-perpetuating price. When people spread culture among ourselves, rather than from the centralized minaret of Hollywood, their power disappears. C'mon everybody, get down tonight!

    --

    --
    make install -not war

  70. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by UniverseIsADoughnut · · Score: 1

    Didn't your mother ever teach you that you look like more of a fool trying to put words in a persons mouth then they could ever look like with their own words?

    I am very open to differant things, what you tried to say I was saying was completely wrong. I could co through and translate what you translated of me, but I won't since I'm not childish.

    You are simply upset because someone didn't think your anime was the most super perfect greatest thing ever. There is no way you can challenge that more people dislike/don't carefor anime in the US then people like anime. Otherwise you would see anime all over and all major release cartoon films would be of anime style.

    In another 70 years, classic WB cartoons will still be going strong. I highly doubt anime from today will be nearly as strong.

  71. Japanese pop stars by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Watch any Japanese music video program these days, and you'll see loads of teenage female pop stars who all dance and sing equally as well as their American counterparts (britney spears, christina aguilera, etc).

    Now, go back 10 years and see how well they did the same thing, and you'll see a big gap in talent.

    What's happened recently? Well, the Japanese recording labels basically have hit a point of critical mass in income, and can now afford to hire the real stars: the professionals who train the American pop stars.

    These pros make all the difference in the world, and now that the Japanese recording companies have taken the plunge to hire them, it's paying off big time.

  72. The Pillows [nt] by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    -nt-

  73. Re:Not to sound like flamebait... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Oh, they are HOT alright, if you like bowed legs and a set of extra teeth. And for kicks --flat arses.

  74. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You missed it completely! Good animation is not about detail!!
    I don't agree at all. The animation quality is part of the ambiance as a whole. If the Mona Lisa was drawn with a crayon, it would not be art. There is art to animation.

    It's about the story, the charators and overall entertainment. The extreme detail of some anime is what makes it such a turn off, just hire freaking actors.
    Part of the enticement are the things that cannot be done in reality, such as flying, even if you did do an ok job in acting, it would be infinitely more ridiculous to see in real life. See: Neo in the Matrix. Come on, he just looked funny flying through the clouds like that.

    Looneytoons is still going strong today because they are what cartoons are ment to be.
    I thought that had to do with why CD sales are still going strong, why Windows is still selling great, and why TV is still mostly analog.
    The market refuses to change and adapt. It's much easier to throw the same 50 year old cartoon on the screen to a new generation, than to make something that actually applies to it.

    Animal based charators with non stop comedy.
    "Yibba dibba dibba what's up doc?"
    What, Wile E. Coyote fell off a cliff again, wow! That NEVER gets old! What?! Elmer Fudd shot himself in the face again because his gun got twisted backwards after he stuck it down the rabbit hole, for the 100th time? Hahahahahaha!! Genius!

    Use of humans in cartoons is going away from the point of cartoons. Hense why most classic cartoons only used humans where needed, or they are part of a storyline with animals. There are some exceptions, but not to many.
    Excessive use of animals only is very probably what lead to furries. Kids get attached to fetishes at very young ages. Animation isn't about animals, its about art, telling a story, I don't see why not to use humans. It's that US animators don't have the slightest clue about how to draw a human that isn't repulsively disproportioned and hideous (Japanese eyes aside).

    In more moderntimes shows like simpsons, futurame, family guy continue traditional cartoons. They may be full of humans but they would not be what they are without the cartoon format. The detail of them doesn't matter, its all the content. Also only the simpsons could even remotely be done with actors, and it would long since be off the air if it was.
    Again, these shows are all about "toilet humour" and quick jokes, good animation is not required for such. See: South Park. If Bart was struggling to save the world from a sorceress awaken from the past, the seriousness would be completely lost in the art. I've watched the Simpsons animator churn out a picture of Homer in about 20 seconds. I'd LOVE to see anyone try and draw an anime character, again pokemon aside, that fast.

    If what your are going for is detail, I sugest you check out movies and tv shows with real live actors, the detail of a human being in just great.
    And say goodbye to the fantasy realm, the whole purpose of watching a cartoon to begin with.
    I watch plenty of movies when I want seriousness, and once again, I often find myself searching overseas for good acting and storytelling that isn't the same cliched genre. Vampires at rave scenes, anybody?
    South Korea's Musa: The Warrior, China's Hero, Legend of Condor Heroes, etc.
    I liked the US release of Gladiator, too.
    But when I want a nice storyline, full of magic and fantasy, captivating visuals, and don't want my intelligence insulted, I find no such offerings by US animators.

    I know you really hate anime, and that's fine. But there aren't 3 million people studying Japanese primarily due to its anime and manga cultures for nothing. Japanese animation will fail, eventually, too, as times change. The times changed on 1950's cartoons long ago. You're seeing this now in today's youth. They don't want to watch the same thing their grandparents saw as kids. I hope US animation companies see this before their market is gone, as they'll have no one to blame but themselves.

    Oh, and sorry if I came off harsh in my above post, wasn't trying to.

  75. Why I like Japanese women by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    I like their attitude, small boobs and the different taste of their pussy.

    Got it?

    1. Re:Why I like Japanese women by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You wanker! The taste depends on diet. Have her eat lots of beef and you shall not want much again. Have [her] eat a more balanced diet and you shall like any [variety of pudendae]

  76. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by cherokee158 · · Score: 1

    And, yet, Iria has no lips and grotesquely proportioned eyes and hair. Personally, I hate the anime style. The backgrounds are gorgeous at times, and the sensitivity to light and shadow is notable, but the characters look awful, and it gets pretty stylistically repetitive. In many ways, the anime "Style" is a crutcj to enable low-paid animators to crank out the toons. (Notice how they often substitute camera movement for actual animation) At least US animation has a little stylistic variety to it. And there is quite a lot of adult storytelling in US animation...it just tends to stay underground. Ever see the Maxx, or Spawn, or seek out any indie films at a film festival? Anime isn't all that. It can be good, and so can the best of American animation. But both countries have their fair share of crap. Anime certainly doesn't warrant it's own name. It's just Japanese animation, folks...

  77. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...since I'm not childish.
    Followed by, You are simply upset because someone didn't think your anime was the most super perfect greatest thing ever.
    Yes, truly that isn't the case here, at all.

    There is no way you can challenge that more people dislike/don't carefor anime in the US then people like anime.
    No, but the article this thread is about, has done surveys that seem to hint at such, but at any rate, neither can you vice versa.

    Otherwise you would see anime all over and all major release cartoon films would be of anime style.
    You mean like Spirited Away, Kiki's Delivery Service, Princess Mononoke, and to a lesser extent, Pokemon Movies 1-3, the Digimon movie, etc? Give it time, the Japanese are up against multi billion dollar monopolies like Disney, companies that have congressional lobbying power and have extended copyrights to sickening lengths. It's hard to just waltz into the marketplace, but it'll happen, in time.

    In another 70 years, classic WB cartoons will still be going strong.

    And with any luck, we'll still be driving gasoline driven cars, working 40 hours a week and commuting 2-3 hours a day to and from our jobs, our salaries will be increasingly going down whilst CEOs make more and more annually, more and more jobs will be exported while less and less will be allowed to be imported due to regional lockouts and regulations, and the world will still refuse to change in the slightest.

    I highly doubt anime from today will be nearly as strong.
    I hope that you are right. The world needs change. I hope to God my great grandkids aren't watching Pokemon still, as you wish us to watch Looney Tunes today.

  78. Re:YOU ARE A FUCKING LIAR ! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I thought the mad cow in Washington came from Texas.

  79. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I agree with you on that. It's just personal preference that I like the wide eyes, and the outrageous hair, I don't know why, but it looks cool to me. And it apparently appeals to many others, as well, so it would seem.
    In contrast, I just don't buy that the Flintstones had better artists than Iria. They reuse entire scenes, rather than just camera movement tricks.
    I have seen both the Maxx, and Spawn. Loved them both. Very original, and well done. It's too bad they didn't catch on as much as Dragon Ball Z has, perhaps then anime wouldn't be so big here right now?
    Yes, there are good and bad US and Japanese animations, the parent whom I was posting about, seemed to think that all Japan animation was crap. That's what my post what trying to counter.
    I agree with the naming conventions, but I don't see what it hurts. It's a simple name differential and is much easier on the tongue than Japanese animation.

  80. PLEASE TELL US HOW TO MOD PARENT POSTS! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    We can't think for ourselves!

  81. America's leading export; poisonous culture by TyrranzzX · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Notice the streets of bagdad and afganistan are being westernised? Wanna know why they don't like that and why alqueda calls america the great satan? If you've read some of the stuff bin laden has written about the USA you'll agree with (some of) his ideology, not his methodology. He says the USA is spreading lies and deciet, which it does do and has been doing although it's people don't agree with this one bit. I noticed a picture up on BBC of afganistan children being given presents from santa this year, and if you understand the psychology of christmas you'll be frightened from that. Christmas such of a fucked up holiday it isn't even funny, as is easter. We celebrate these holidays not because we're supposed to or because it satisfies some deep religous meaning like Hanukkah , we celebrate them because corperations, the goverment, and christian churches wanted them to be celebrated that way. Notice how crazy it's gotten?

    Notice the best buy catologe that comes in the mail every year with the star of david on the tree replaced with the star of best buy and the entire tree decorated with consumer electronics? Notice how all the packaging mysteriously has christmas branding on them? How Saint Nick appears in every window and every store front advertising one thing or another?

    In our culture, we eat poisoned food, use poisoned stuff (cosmetics, soaps, playstations, cell phones) and buy crap we don't need fulfill some lifestyle obsession gone wrong that is even more poisonous so that crazy people at the top of the ladder can feel powerful. Japanese culture is even more poisonous imo, they tend to mimic ours and run with it as far and as fast as possible. Infact, our number 1 export to japan after ww2 was our poisonous culture.

    Our number 1 export to the rest of the world is poisonous culture, and to whoever resists that without force enough to fight it off, we'll kill the parents and teach the kids our ways like we're doing in afganistan. Afterall, there's a reason we warehouse our old off into care homes near the ends of their life; so the ones that know what's wrong can't teach their kids and grandkids what's realy wrong.

    1. Re:America's leading export; poisonous culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You sound like you want to fly a plane into a building.

    2. Re:America's leading export; poisonous culture by indefinite · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I can agree that all those things you mentioned are not enlightened. I can agree that US has repeatedly mistreated other countries for our benefit. One thing that bothers me, when people go all of on this topic is that U.S. is not unique in any of this. Every f'n country does the same thing, given a chance.

      The countries that are the most critical of U.S. have histories of treating others that are worse than ours. We are no more hypocrites than the rest of them. Yet we are evil? The only reason we are 'evil' is that we have the most influence right now and it's popular to bring those higher then us down a peg. That will surely change and U.S. 'tyranny' will be just another blip in the past, much smaller then others.

      Another point of mine is about the redial Islamic beliefs. I can see that rich pigs like U.S. are disgusting to them, but who the flock are they? The way they treat women is so draconian it's amazing why nobody turns around and call that evil. Radical Islam treats people worse then U.S. culture ever did. People are killed for arbitrary reasons. Many times it is not only going against a ridiculously strict law that will get you shot. If somebody in power doesn't like the way you look, they can pretty much accuse you of anything and get you punished. Let's not forget that raped women are guilty for being raped and punished by death many times as well.

      If we are talking about poisonous culture, let's first examine how bad the poison is. If westernization means that all the atrocities of Mid-east (and Africa, and much of Asia) are going to go away and instead we are going to have McDonald's on every corner, I'll take that any day. After all, you have not known poisonous food after you had food where hygiene is non existent.

    3. Re:America's leading export; poisonous culture by goon+america · · Score: 1
      It's human nature to think of relatively vague, amorphous entities such as "20th century America" or "the West" or "the Middle East" etc. as having anthropomorphic human qualities like the ability to own things, have debts or consciously plan things across actual human beings that clearly do not talk to each other and work that sort of thing out. The church, the government and "corporations" do not and did not get together and figure out the way they wanted Christmas to be -- these amorphous groups do not have human characteristics -- and even if you could somehow trace Christmas to them, you could not hold them responsible -- these amorphous groups do not have human characteristics, and cannot be "responsible" or even consciously do anything.

      Our (American) Christmas is largely taken after the British tradition, and I don't know if you've ever been there in the Fall, but the retailers there don't have Thanksgiving to wait for and so advertise full-scale for Christmas starting virtually at the end of the summer.

      The first step to making a supportable assertion is to speak literally and use terms that can be defined. Thank you.

    4. Re:America's leading export; poisonous culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I don't know of any church that is trying to teach children greed.

      I know of plenty which are trying to tell people about its deeper meaning; just not many folks who care to listen to it, that being the one time a year they go there, for too many...

    5. Re:America's leading export; poisonous culture by Aaron+England · · Score: 2, Interesting
      You pass off "proof" as an excercise left to the reader, which means your thesis (America exports poisonous culture) lacks many internal warrants. Why should I accept your thesis when you can't substantiate what you are claiming?

      I noticed a picture up on BBC of afganistan children being given presents from santa this year, and if you understand the psychology of christmas you'll be frightened from that. Christmas such of a fucked up holiday it isn't even funny, as is easter.

      No, I really don't see whats so "fucked up" about Christmas or the "terrible" psychology of giving GIFTS to these improverished children. Could you please elaborate?

      Notice the best buy catologe that comes in the mail every year with the star of david on the tree replaced with the star of best buy and the entire tree decorated with consumer electronics? Notice how all the packaging mysteriously has christmas branding on them? How Saint Nick appears in every window and every store front advertising one thing or another?

      Uh huh. Two words, SO WHAT?!

      In our culture, we eat poisoned food, use poisoned stuff (cosmetics, soaps, playstations, cell phones) and buy crap we don't need fulfill some lifestyle obsession gone wrong that is even more poisonous so that crazy people at the top of the ladder can feel powerful.

      Please define "poisonous food". Also, please show that this is unique to the American culture, or at least we consume this food to a greater degree than all other nations. Please do the same for "poisonous stuff". What is wrong with buying "crap" that fulfils some lifestyle obsession? Could you establish a criterion that determines when someone commits this most, in your eyes, "most poisonous act".

      Japanese culture is even more poisonous imo, they tend to mimic ours and run with it as far and as fast as possible. Infact, our number 1 export to japan after ww2 was our poisonous culture.

      Please explain how our culture is "poisonous" first.

      Our number 1 export to the rest of the world is poisonous culture, and to whoever resists that without force enough to fight it off, we'll kill the parents and teach the kids our ways like we're doing in afganistan.

      I guess you can't forsee that people might actually want to adopt our culture on their own freewill because they see the advantages of free enterprise and other aspects of the American culture.

      Afterall, there's a reason we warehouse our old off into care homes near the ends of their life; so the ones that know what's wrong can't teach their kids and grandkids what's realy wrong.

      Non-sequitar.

      You discuss in your sig. about educating yourself. I suggest you take a class on persuasive argumentation beause your diatribe was netiher insightful or interesting. Until then, your thesis remains unproven.

    6. Re:America's leading export; poisonous culture by firewood · · Score: 1
      No, I really don't see whats so "fucked up" about Christmas or the "terrible" psychology of giving GIFTS to these improverished children. Could you please elaborate?

      Tons of churches in America sermonize on the over-commercialization of the Christmas holidays and how this covers up any "true" meaning. I'm sure you can google for a few sources, both religious and non.

      I suggest you take a class on persuasive argumentation beause your diatribe was netiher insightful or interesting. Until then, your thesis remains unproven.

      This is Slashdot. What you find here will seldom be persuasive, but will be quite insightful if you aren't too narrow-minded and do your own research. Read up on the effects of advertising and marketing on large scale economic/cultural behavior, decide whether all this behavior is beneficial for mankind according to your system of ethics, and maybe even reflect on how much your own behavior is affected by these cultural trends.

      It's hard for a fish (American consumer) to see the water (cultural marketing) about them. But one of the keys to defeating an enemy (murderous Islamic extremists, etc.) is to understand where they're coming from.

    7. Re:America's leading export; poisonous culture by erroneus · · Score: 1

      This is probably the coolest "Troll" I have read in a long while. As such I will respond:

      Our "culture" is a result of essentially a "wholly-human" society. We are in a constant struggle between being naturally human and humane. Our naturally human tendencies are at time brutal and selfish while at the same time, sponsors freedomss of various sorts as well as human evolution in a general sense. Our diversity of thought and population puts us in a constant state of competition which results, at times, in a form of betterment... but as in most cases of evolution, there are far more failures than improvements.

      So while many of our cultural representatives are pretty vile and despicable, there are still other who are quite virtuous and selfless. There have been days when the best of us have prevailed and clearly the worst of us have as well. I cannot say which is currently prevalant, but clearly "bad people make the news" more often than the nice ones.

      Good folks are here! You can be certain of that.

  82. japanese stuff was always popular ... by wobblie · · Score: 1

    especially with kids. When I was a kid, it was godzilla and kaiju movies, now it's anime and dragonball z and so forth.

    Other than with children, I don't see Japanese stuff being that popular ... well, there are bukakke fans, but I'm not going to touch that (yechh).

    1. Re:japanese stuff was always popular ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      [...]now it's anime and dragonball z and so forth.
      Hmm, i had come to think dragonball(TM) was a moto[rola] product. guess i don't know dragonballs from adam's off ox.

    2. Re:japanese stuff was always popular ... by digitalsushi · · Score: 1
      but I'm not going to touch that (yechh)


      You spelled ecchi wrong.

      --
      slashdot: where everyone yells sarcastic metaphors to themselves to understand the issue
  83. And they influencing ... by locohijo · · Score: 1

    english too!!!

  84. Japan has been cool for years by NetNinja · · Score: 2, Interesting

    They still impose heavy tarrifs on American goods.

    You should see how much a Mustang GT goes for!

    Even though you may speak the language you will never be excepted. You are forever a Gaijin.

    We have been exposed to Japanese culture/anime since the 60's, Speed Racer is a classic example.

    I aggree with some of the posts above. America is a leader in cultural entertainment.
    The Japanesse and the Koreans improve on exsisting ideas, American cars for example.

    We(USA) can't make cars worth a shit anymore.

    How is it that a country with no natural resources is able to make cars cheaper and better than America who have all the natural resources at our doorstep.

    1. Re:Japan has been cool for years by indefinite · · Score: 1

      Because when you have limited resources, you are forced to be more creative to make up for it.

    2. Re:Japan has been cool for years by miu · · Score: 1
      Even though you may speak the language you will never be excepted. You are forever a Gaijin.

      Japanese culture is still explicitly stratified, you remain a crazy gaijin to prevent offense or shame. More than likely there is a fundamental level at which you do not get the Japanese culture because you insist on viewing Japan through the lens of your birth culture.

      --

      [Set Cain on fire and steal his lute.]
    3. Re:Japan has been cool for years by dbIII · · Score: 1
      We(USA) can't make cars worth a shit anymore.

      How is it that a country with no natural resources is able to make cars cheaper and better than America who have all the natural resources at our doorstep.

      For a very long time marketers have had the final say in car design in the US, and gut feeling or white power in the nostrils is no substitude for good design. SUV's may sell well domesticly, but if people outside the USA want a big 4WD vehicle they are going to get a Toyota, Mercedes or Range Rover, instead of an overpriced thing of lesser quality. Things like tax laws in Japan have led to a lot of very creative little sports car designs, while the USA being the land of cheap fuel has just led to a approach of just making it bigger to sell. Why put in new technology and new features when you can just make it bigger?
      They still impose heavy tarrifs on American goods.
      Most countries impose tarrifs, for example the US steel tarrif to protect it's steel industry from cheaper imports of higher quality (mostly related to coal in the USA being high in sulphur, so it costs more to make steel of any decent quality). The tarrif issue is a tricky one, and has been so since well before 1205AD when there was a war over it (Venice vs Constantinople).
  85. MODERATORS CAN THINK?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Moderators can think?

    Really?

  86. messed up website about japanese culture: by macshune · · Score: 1

    Hey, here's an interesting website website that has an interesting take on japanese culture & women. it's the most misogynistic thing i've read in quite some time.

  87. Mods, this is a duped comment by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is just a repost of this comment.

    1. Re:Mods, this is a duped comment by xeno_gearz · · Score: 1
      This is just a repost of this comment .

      Hilarious. So you are saying that my comment is a copy of my comment? Intriguing. I appreciate the interest but I am far from being a troll. All of my posts, for better or worse (the mods decide), are written by me. Perhaps you are just mad because you are one of the trolls on my troll blacklist?

      Sorry everyone. I know, "Don't feed the trolls..." This accusation just seemed so laughable, though.
      Thanks for the laugh. :)

      --
      *
      troll blacklist. Please mo
  88. Japan imports more american culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Japanese culture in the US is popular, but mostly in specific entertainment areas. Pokemon, dragonball, etc.
    Having come back from Japan it seems they import much more american culture. The movie theaters are mostly Hollywood movies, fashion is very american *mmmm land of women in miniskirts*.
    The "cool" thing is to have "American words" to sell your product. its always funny to see a baby dressed in a little beanie with the letters F-U-C-K stitched into it, or a guy with a sticker on his truck that says "optomistic fucker"

  89. Re:YOU ARE A FUCKING LIAR ! by JebusIsLord · · Score: 1

    uhm, everyone hates... CANADA??? Everyone LOVES Canada, you freak! We have like no enemies at all!

    It's you people down south that the world is pissed at right now. I don't mind most Americans though, just Bush, and perhaps you right now.

    --
    Jeremy
  90. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by man2525 · · Score: 1

    I haven't seen Iria:Zeiram, but its disingenuous to compare a serious animated series based on a movie to funny, satirical cartoon shorts from the 30s that were used to provide breaks between movies.

    Part of it also comes down to deadlines. Looney Tunes were created as new movies came out. Zeiram was in production for months. However, when you compare 1930s Looney Tunes to modern TV quality anime, such as Pokemon or even Rurouni Kenshin, the Looney Tunes art is higher quality and the animation is far more fluid. You have to remember that their competitor was Disney, which you didn't bring up as an example of bad animation for some reason ;)

    I agree with a lot of your post, however. Plot-wise, Pokemon is the closest thing to the toy marketing scam shows of the early 80s, which, ironically, were produced by many of the same anime artists before their skills improved. Scooby Doo was a prime time comedy, so its hard for me to fault it for not having a deep storyline. The repeated celebrity appearances in the later seasons annoy me, though.

    The good news is that computer generated backgrounds and other tools are allowing both sides of the ocean to concentrate more on the animation with what little deadline they have. Pretty soon, we won't be forced to watch action faked by endless, uneccessary banter in American cartoons ("Oh, I'm hit! Are your hurt! Are you sure you're okay! He's getting away! Where'd he go?") or still frame directional lines and wildtakes in every Japanese anime scene. A lot of the recent fansubbed TV anime that I download have openings with windblown hair. I think they're showing off.

  91. Re:ReYou want the coolest culture? Check out Fland by Requiem · · Score: 1

    I was going to flame you, thinking an American had said that, but then I saw that you were Belgian (or close enough). It's all about McChouffe beer.

  92. Re:YOU ARE A FUCKING LIAR ! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You idiot. It was a joke, can't you get it?

    Also, Yankees do not use the term wankers, that's strictly an Commonwealth term.

  93. Re:You want the coolest culture? Check out Canada! by ryen · · Score: 0

    My God! you forgot about Mounties!

  94. Sobieto Roshia de... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    ... PUROFITO!!!

    1. Re:Sobieto Roshia de... by theTerribleRobbo · · Score: 0, Troll


      Sobieto Roshia de... OMAE wo purofito suru!

    2. Re:Sobieto Roshia de... by Kent+Recal · · Score: 0, Troll


      Aeh, was soll der scheiss?

    3. Re:Sobieto Roshia de... by theTerribleRobbo · · Score: 1


      Yeesh, which mod has a vendetta against foreign languages?

  95. Re:You want the coolest culture? Check out Canada! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    To recap:

    - Basketball is Canadian and not American, because it was invented by a Canadian in America.
    - The Telephone is Canadian, not Scottish, because it was invented by a Scotsman, who once lived in Canada, in America

    Those two are contradictory. Is it the person or the place which determins an invention's "nationality"?

    That said, you people still have dibs on "eh" after every sentence and Rick Moranis.

    cheers

  96. Re:YOU ARE A FUCKING LIAR ! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Actually, Americans hate Canad right now, re: lumber and hiding places for Al Queda.

    Personally, I think it's very silly. North America should form an open union a la the EU (but democratic, ie, you actually vote for the people who represent you), and allow open immigration between Canada, the US, and Mexico.

  97. Re:YOU ARE A FUCKING LIAR ! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The title is about "exporting" not inventing.

    Yes, Britain and China and their inhabitants are so dirty that they are able to create such great diseases such as Mad Cow disease and SARS.

    But only Canada had the gumption to export them to other countries so successfully.

  98. Re:First Post by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Sorry, but Japan rocks, and YOU FAIL IT!

  99. Japan's Gross National Cool by Aaron+England · · Score: 1

    ForeignPolicy.com has a slightly older article (2001) that discusses this same phenomenon.

  100. Why the "JAPANESE ONLY" signs? by crazyhorse44 · · Score: 1

    Well most of them are on the outside of bath houses, massage parlours and other such establishments. To put it bluntly... the Japanese salarymen don't want the Harlem Globetrotters all up in their favorite bar girls... "tearing shit up".

    Another big import in Japan is GIRLS... they bring them from all over.... South America, Canada, Southeast Asia, Eastern Europe for some good-old fashioned Japanese molestation and defiling. As Yakoov Smirnov would say... "what a country!"

    --
    . SLASHDOT: Home of the vicious nerd.
  101. Re:ReYou want the coolest culture? Check out Fland by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    err... I think he was refering to Australia, or at least NZ.

    Surely you are not that thick?!

  102. Darwin, applied to culture by Rayonic · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Want to know why American culture is so popular? Survival of the fittest. Many other cultures are stagnant and unchanging, but American culture embraces change. Thus, by default, it is much more interesting than most other cultures.

    Japanese culture is another big mover. Do I feel threatened or jealous about its recent popularity? Naw. Embrace and extend, that's our motto. We take the best parts of other cultures, integrate and expand on it, and then export it right back at them. Mind you, everyone else is welcome (nay, encouraged) to do the same.

    Our culture is no more "poisonous" than anybody else's. It's just more awesome.

    1. Re:Darwin, applied to culture by TyrranzzX · · Score: 1

      Tell ya what, when in the next 20 years there's an epidemic that can't be cured by antibiotics from the feedlots and millions die off because their antibiotics can't handle it, when in 40 or so years around millions of americans have some other nuerodegeneritve disease because of the MSG and aspartame they take in on a daily basis, and when millions are out on the streets and doing slave labour because all the corperations replaced their work forces with machines to save money, you can come upto me and call the culture awesome. I can garountee those things are going to happen unless we change our ways.

    2. Re:Darwin, applied to culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Rome did the same and it outlived all of the Empires of the post-Roman Europeans. It's a good policy.

    3. Re:Darwin, applied to culture by pi42 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Agreed. Mod this man up!

      Nobody goes and forces people in other countries to go to McDonald's, to drink Coca-Cola, to watch the Matrix, or to wear blue jeans. These things spread because they're good. You can say that a McDonalds on every street in the world is disgusting (an assertion that is probably true), but they're not there because of some conspiracy--they're there because people patronize them.

      Just as Japanese culture isn't "attacking" American culture, American culture isn't "attacking" European, Middle Eastern culture, etc.

      It sounds dumb and jingoistic, but American culture isn't everywhere because of conspiracy, but because it's awesome and people like it.

    4. Re:Darwin, applied to culture by Rayonic · · Score: 1

      Whenever I hear about France and their draconian culture laws, I don't know whether to laugh (at the futility) or cry (at the damage such laws do to French culture).

      The French movie industry was once king of the world, imitated by everyone (including Hollywood). Then the movie quota laws came along (started by the Vichy government, no less) and slowly strangled the industry. Now French studios churn out cheap, locally-made movies in order to satisfy the government quotas, so they can import the newest blockbusters from Hollywood.

      The damage is twofold. Not only does this cheapen the quality of French-made films in general, but it also guarantees that only sure-fire hits get imported (Titanic, Star Wars, etc.). Thus the good-but-not-huge-selling movies never see French audiences. The fact that these "French" studios are now mostly foreign-owned only adds to the irony.

    5. Re:Darwin, applied to culture by Rayonic · · Score: 1

      Very funny, but I think you're confusing our successful culture with our successful governmental and economic systems.

    6. Re:Darwin, applied to culture by mikebelrose · · Score: 1

      Want to know why American culture is so popular? Survival of the fittest.

      I bet I can name at least one ethnic group which was forced to adopt American culture, can you?

      Anyway, Darwinism just implies "fitness", it doesn't say what fitness is. Boy bands have "fitness" for their market, that doesn't mean they have any other redeeming qualities. Communism and fascism have "fitness" in certain situations, that doesn't make them something I look forward to.

    7. Re:Darwin, applied to culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well guess what, more people die from their shitty culture than anything the US has come up with (20,000-40,000 people died in Iran because they lived in traditional mud-brick housing). And the next antibiotic that those ass-backwards cultures comes up with will be the first. I grew up in several Third-World countries and am inimately familiar with all their faults. My parents are racist ignorant fucks because they grew-up in that culture and you sound exactly like them. I'm suprised you have a computer you luddite wannabe. (BTW MSG headaches are a myth and plenty of stuff in nature will kill you just as dead as man made stuff.)

    8. Re:Darwin, applied to culture by Rayonic · · Score: 1

      > I bet I can name at least one ethnic group which was forced to adopt American culture, can you?

      Nope, I can't. Who are you thinking of -- the Native Americans? The Japanese? Ha, I say.

      But regardless, that isn't what is happening today. What really annoys the culture-control freaks is that many people are adopting American (and other foreign) culture of their own free will. And the only solutions to this "problem" are archaic laws and wasteful government spending.

      > Anyway, Darwinism just implies "fitness", it doesn't say what fitness is. Boy bands have "fitness" for their market, that doesn't mean they have any other redeeming qualities.

      Bah, comparing cultures to see which one is "better" is always an effort in futility. A fool's errand. You can observe popularity, though. (Fitness, if you will.) Which is all I was doing. That, and offering my oh-so-humble opinion as to why American culture currently dominates.

    9. Re:Darwin, applied to culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ok.

      Until then, shut the fuck up and let me enjoy my steak in peace.

    10. Re:Darwin, applied to culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "I bet I can name at least one ethnic group which was forced to adopt American culture, can you?"

      Yeah...the french, they're pissed off *CONSTANTLY* about it.

    11. Re:Darwin, applied to culture by TyrranzzX · · Score: 1

      Depends on what metric by which you measure successfullness. Everyone believes what they want to believe and I can't change that, all I can do is present the information to the best of my knowledge and hope they figure out things for themselves and hopefully, if they find something new in the process give me some insight. I do, however, live what I preach(although I'm not perfect :P). Infact, everything that I do say is from personal experience. You can have a million experts tell me "MSG won't hurt you" and I won't believe them because I'v gone postal from it before.

      Personally, I measure a goverment successfullness in it's ability to solve conflicts without creating more conflicts (which is the whole basis for a goverment, social cooperation and working out problems among people in a nonviolent manner). I measure the successfullness of culture by how it treats itself and how it treats others. And I measure the successfullness of an economic system by it's ability to provide for it's people.

      I'd rate the goverment as decent and slipping slowly to miserable and potentially into civil war, much of america is scared of it's own goverment and many nitpicky groups have popped up demanding things without realizing that they can get together and work together; one group says padeophiles are sick fucks, the other says they're dumb fucks, yet they nitpick about the terminology instead of agreeing that they are fucks, defining a common goal and going out with pitchforks and torches to burn the evil doers. And aside from that, look at how many wars we have started and gotten involved in, iraq, israel, the cold war, etc. Some wars were needed like WW2, what the nazi's did was wrong but did we really need to get involved with WW1?

      I'd rate the culture as poor as it treats itself poorly as well as others. Notice how near nobody cares that their gap clothes come from slave labour? That's how it is here in my town, nobody gives a damn. They expect others to clean up their messes and take responsability for them without realizing nobody will. Some people do treat themselves and others well, but the most people don't. Not to mention how a lot of kids raised nowadays will turn out *shudders*.

      Finally, I'd rate the economic system as decent, things get to where they need to go and people aren't starving to death but there are growing holes in it as buisness law becomes more and more deregulated (although, that might not fit into economics). If Enron is allowed to happen, then you've got to wonder what will happen to the trust relationships the economy is built upon. You can already see that crumbling away slowly, just look at what the RIAA is doing, for example.

  103. Re:You want the coolest culture? Check out Canada! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Disney owns them. It's a long story, and we don't talk about it.

  104. Re:YOU ARE A FUCKING LIAR ! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I don't want either Canada or Mexico as part of my Union, thanks. If Canada wants to have open immigration with Mexico or vice versa they can feel free. NAFTA was about as much of an open border as I want with the hordes to the South and Britain Junior to the North.

  105. Re:You want the coolest culture? Check out Canada! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    And Alanis. Isn't it ironic?

  106. Name a Famous Japanese Person by GuyMannDude · · Score: 2, Interesting

    It's unfortunate that this guy is racking up some Troll and Flamebait mods since he's making a good point, albeit a bit inelegantly. There's a now-infamous poll that was given to Americans in 1995 which asked "Name a Famous Japanese Person". The results? #1: (Chinese martial artist) Bruce Lee. #2: (American-born) Yoko Ono. #3: Godzilla. I'm not kidding! I wish a good link to give you but if you're interested a bit of goolging will help you find people referring to this study.

    Okay, so that was back in 1995. Ancient history, right? Give me a break. I bet if you give this question to 'the man on the street' again you'd get pretty much the same result. Obviously Japanese has made some incredible contributions to world culture. But until the day you can show the average American a photo of some famous Japanese celebrity and they can instantly recognize them, we should probably use a word other than "empire" to describe their impact in America.

    GMD

  107. you forgot hentai and bukkake! by gobblez · · Score: 0

    i can't live without them ;)

  108. Bable fish disagrees by shift82 · · Score: 0

    1 I, although once translated back.. I for 1, Japanese where we are new is welcomed

  109. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by Little+Brother · · Score: 1
    OK, I'm just going to go for one little tidbit here. I'll let the rest lie.

    There is no way you can challenge that more people dislike/don't carefor anime in the US then people like anime

    1. Pokemon, while far from the best Anime, was one of the most successfull cartoons of all time so far as popularity at height goes. I am fairly young (22) but in my lifetime I hadn't seen any other cartoon with quite the popularity that Pokemon enjoyed.

    2. I shouldn't have to challenge your point. As you made a positive assertion, the burden of proof should lie with you and you have made NO effort in any of your posts to prove any of your points except to go on your own emotional and subjective prefrences.

    3. Walk around a mall (if you can stand it) you will see more T-Shirts with Anime characters/logos than you will see other animation styles. Probably by a HUGE margin.

    4. Cartoon Network currently runs, or has VERY recently run: Dragon Ball Z, Dragon Ball .hack//sigh Teen Titans, Inuyasha, The Big O, Zoids, Pokemon, Yu Gi Oh!, SD Gundum, Transformers Armada, and Cyborg 009. They are constantly trying to get new anime miniseries that are suitable for their audiences (mostly children) and do not seem to have made any effort to stop.

    5. To refute your point: Otherwise you would see anime all over and all major release cartoon films would be of anime style. You do see Anime all over. As far as movies go, you are seeing more and more movies becoming more and more Anime-style, even the non-animes. Furthermore Animes often take longer to make and are more expensive. It is often better financialy to pay for second-rate artists (or, to give you the benifit of the doubt, artists who don't waste their time doing TO much detail) and not have to pay them as much than it would be to get the really talented artists (or the artists who waste more time on detail) thus get more profits even though the Anime may have been prefered by the audience. Furthermore, your logic that "all major release cartoon films would be of anime style" is flawed, as that would only be true if ALL people prefered Anime to standard cartoons, not just MOST. Your point would have been better stated "most major ... films would be of anime style." On that stronger argument, my cost analysis counterargument still holds.

    6. Best Animated feature goes to... Spirited Away

    7. A growing number of students of all ages are taking Japaneese classes, or even teaching themselves Japaneese just to be able to watch Anime Cartoons in the native language. Although this, by itself, does not prove larger numbers of Anime enjoyers, it does provide evidence to the claim by pointing out how far some people will go to enjoy this medium.

    8. Many major universities have Anime Clubs, as do many communities. I've yet to see a "classic" cartoon club.

    9. Many american cartoons are emulating some aspects of Animes. PowerPuff girls is a notable example. While they are 100% American, many elements of their drawing style is very Animesh. Immitation is the most sincere form of flattery. 10. I am an Education Major, in my practiums in elementary schools, I have heard much more chatter about animes (although rarly was the word "Anime" used) than about the other cartoons. The Dragonball and Gundum serieses in paticular are common topics of discussion. (Although I admit, I might just NOTICE the anime discussions more)

    Ok, Not only did I find a way to challenge your assertion, I found 10 DIFFERENT ways. Not all are perfect, i'll admit this. But I think your claim that your position is unchallengably obvious has been shown to be indefendable.

    --

    Little Brother, watching the watchers

  110. Re:YOU ARE A FUCKING LIAR ! by JebusIsLord · · Score: 1

    well it may have been sarcasm, but sarcasm doesn't translate to written text unless you use that little ;) face at the end. If it was actually supposed to be funny, you need to go back to remedial joke school, my friend. Americans sounding ignorant on purpose stopped being funny several years ago.

    --
    Jeremy
  111. Unfortunately by Lord_Dweomer · · Score: 1
    Unfortunately, what the exporting of culture leads to is a product leaving your country and entering another, WITHOUT the attached history/knowledge associated with it. Thus, it is not really the culture that is being exported per se, rather, it is the products that are produced as a result of that culture.

    Example:
    In anime, there are many themes which are repeated throughout various series. They are MUCH different than most Western themes. This is because of their culture in Japan, and the way their society works. What we see is only the end product. We do not see why a character might feel a certain way about a situation, because we do not understand the cultural differences. Thus, all we see is the final product, which might seem quite alien/exotic to us, however we never really learn the true cultural knowledge behind it.

    --
    Buy Steampunk Clothing Online!
  112. 2/3 right by Little+Brother · · Score: 1

    Only uncool nerds like JPop and Video Games. (Video games coolness is changing VERY rapidly though.) It is, however, very cool to like Anime, it just isn't cool to know what the word Anime means. Especialy among the younger generation (highschool and younger) the Animes that hit Cartoon Network are extremly cool shows.

    --

    Little Brother, watching the watchers

  113. Japanese girls by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Well as one that lives here for 2 years....
    they aint so ht as this article describes...
    actually the culture that does grow here is of general stupidity and ignorance as well as duplicating dumb magazine posters....ever seen 150 kg whale-girl wear a sexy mini hehehe
    and most of this manga...well it sucks..only the good ones get translated to english and most is completely un-original as well as the anime.

  114. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by pi42 · · Score: 1

    Daffy Duck as Robin beats any anime I've ever seen for pure entertainment value. Refute that. His beak! How it pops up! Oh, man.

    It also has a certain quality of timelessness that I don't seen in anime.

  115. Anime by man_ls · · Score: 1

    I find Anime, as compared with other cartoons made in America, to have a much different focus.

    American cartoons:
    Futurama
    Family Guy
    Simpsons

    Japanese cartoons:
    Inuyasha
    Naruto
    etc.

    Now, for a comparison and contrast:

    American cartoons, generally in 30-minute less commercials segments, are mostly humorous, and completely unconnected. No bridged eps - you can sit down and watch one show isolated and know exactly what's going on.

    Japanese cartoons are generally seeming to be started as a series -- if you come in half way, you'll be lost, and have to pick up what's going on as you go.

    Japanese ones also tend to address more mature themes than American ones do. (Mature meaning, high-school-level as opposed to middle school...nothing "deep" but "deeper")

    I watch both kinds, and all sorts of non-anmiated shows too...anything to entertain. And, different stuff is entertaining to different people, so it all works out in the end.

    1. Re:Anime by tekrat · · Score: 1

      You can blame that on the success of Yamato (Starblazers in the USA). Prior to Matsumoto reinventing anime, there were episodic giant robot shows (Mazinger Z), episodic shows like Astroboy and Speed Racer, where every episode was independent.

      Matsumoto introduced the concept of "Space Opera" (as opposed to soap opera) where each episode was part of a continuing storyline, and each episode ended with a little bit of a cliffhanger to bring you into the next (Hurry Star Force, there are only XX Days until all life on earth is extinguished).

      When Yamato became the incredible phenomenon it was in Japan, every studio set out to emulate it. Taking the popular Giant Robot format, Nippon Sunrise gave birth to "Mobile Suit Gundam", a hard-sci-fi series that made use of fairly realistic physics and had a continuing storyline.

      Gundam did fairly well in Japan, but it wasn't until it was resurrected later (in the form of Zeta Gundam) that the show really took off.

      Anyhow, since that time, almost all anime is a continuing story. There are exceptions (Patalliro, Dr. Slump, Doeremon, Pokemon, etc.) where the continuing story is not the real plot, just the vehicle to get from episode to episode.

      --
      If telephones are outlawed, then only outlaws will have telephones.
  116. The perfect melding of American and Japanese..... by NDPTAL85 · · Score: 1

    ....culture would be the movie, Vulcano High.

    --
    Mac OS X and Windows XP working side by side to fight back the night.
  117. Thankyou Australian public TV by nickg78 · · Score: 1

    OK, long-time /. reader, first time poster .. be gentle CowboyNeal! :-P

    In the early-to-mid 1980's, for some reason, the Australian commercial-free public TV station (the ABC) broadcast a number of Japanese shows - anime shows Astroboy, Kimba the White Lion, and live-action show Monkey.

    Both of those anime are from the god of manga, Osamu Tezuka

    These shows got me interested in Japan - at age 8, I wanted to be a ninja..

    I studied Japanese at high school and ended up doing it at university too. Now I'm pretty fluent - and guess what, I learned quite a bit from reading manga,watching anime and Japanese movies..

    Some people here have mentioned Engrish/Japlish T-shirts in Japan - well, I've seen plenty of Australians wearing shirts with Japanese characters that say, for example, "strange foreigner", "winter", "fire" and "water"..

    Why do people wear shirts (and get tattoos) with languages they don't understand? Because they think they look cool!

  118. You insensitive clod! by Compact+Dick · · Score: 1

    Creamed corn and chicken soup has lost its innocence.

  119. Reading between the lines by dagbrown · · Score: 1

    Well, just judging from the content of the article, the reporter hopped off the plane at Narita, took the train to Ueno, hopped onto the Yamanote to Shibuya (totally ignoring Akihabara, of course, only nerds would want to go there).

    Then he walked across the street, right past, and completely ignoring the infamous 109 shopping mall, the very heart of popular fashion and culture in all of Japan! But he was busy looking for an anime store! No time to find popular culture, he had popular culture to write about!

    Then he went down the street to Mandarake, kibbitzed with the owner for a few minutes, turned around, ignored 109 again (although he apparently did notice the big screen on HMV, and probably the one on Tower Records too)...and went right back home again.

    Oh, and he thinks Glay is a boy band. That's pretty funny. That's a bit like calling Insane Clown Posse a boy band.

    When I read newspaper articles about things I know about, I honestly wonder why I believe anything I read about things I don't know about.

  120. Re:The perfect melding of American and Japanese... by arazor · · Score: 1

    umm Volcano High is a South Korean movie.

  121. Japan is more popular because of losers. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Simple. Losers are finding out, that no matter how fucked up, retarded, anti-social, smelly or idiotic they are in USA, when they go over to Japan and they happen to be white or black they are the center of all the attention, and every girl wants to fuck them, something they will never get to have if they stayed in their home country. The losers became the winners in Japan, just because of their color, and not because of any personality traits. In fact they are became bigger assholes because of the sudden popularity they get when they get there.(A bit exaggerating, but very close to truth)

    You go to any Japanese class, and if you dont pass out from all the stench coming from all the unwashed bodies that occupy the room, you will realize most of the people are someone you wouldnt call "popular" or "cool" and surprise surprise a lot of them computer nerds and WHITE. The school I go to is 45% asian!!! They pretend to act japanese (if u dont know what it is, you are lucky) so you will hear them curse in japanese, wear dumbass shirts "I want japan woman" HD most likely full of anime porn and again...have VERY LITTLE SOCIAL SKILLS! So they know, and it is very much true so, that when they meet a japanese girl in japan, they will became the center of attention, and they will get japanse pussy. Again, something they wouldnt be able to get if they stayed in Japan. When theyget in Japan, they "accent" more how white they are, trying to dress up in "hip-hop" and look like idiots, but japenese eat that shit up! They fuck japanese girls, are popular, everyone wants to listen to what they say (it is in English afterall!! And they all want to learn it too!!)

    So now more and more losers find out an easy way to became popular so that is why Japanese "culture" is more popular, but only to the segment of population which is the bottom of the barrel in USA.

    I can tell you anecdotal stories about how much white guys get laid in Japan and how kind of fucked up the japanese girls are there now.
    And if you say few words in Japanese there, you will get INSTANT admiration, and SHOCK!! you know how to speak Japanese,w ith girls going "SUgggggggggggoiiiiiiiiii John-san!!" (Wow John, you are sooo greaaaaaaaaaat!)

    So the japanese culture is not represented by anime/pop music/manga that is just the lowest form of Japanese current trends. Now, if you said Japanese books (BOOKS!!!) newspapers, history is been more studied then I will say yeah! But the article doesnt say that, so it is just like eating sushi. Eating sushi doesnt make Japanese culture more popular, and it doesnt mean you care much abut it, other then "damn, now i was some sushi to eat!" It is like "Texan" way of life is getting a world wide integration as people like to eat huge steaks!

    "A record 3 million people around the world are now studying the Japanese language, compared with only 127,000 in 1997, according to the Japan Foundation and Tokyo's Marubeni Research Institute."

    Let me tell you about this study, it is an infomercial at most. And those numbers dont mean a thing! An increase in population of age that is willing to uptake foreign language might increase, compare to the previous 3 years, even though the % stayed the same. More people go to college, more colleges open up etc etc etc?Most likely all those kids who watched pokemon think they are learning pokemonian! .This slashdot news, is no news, it is obvious some "JApanPhile" who works for slashdot who tries to rationalize and justify why he likes anime so he doesnt feel so much like a loser but "in front of the new frontier!! Before the rest come in."

    Ohh yeah, after a while, most of those people will go to Thailand, because there pussy is much cheaper.

    Over 21 and over to prove my point about ugly white man getting asian pussy. Though I dont want to pick on white guys only, I see people from HK, Taiwan just have "Sakura" glasses as well over japanese girls as well, and they pander to them as well. And those losers from J

  122. This is a joke right? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Seriously, Japan is the world center of bad taste.

    Nearly everything Japanese is awful. Movies, music, food, clothes, writing, language, housing, porn, not to mention all the BS mentioned in the top post. The Japanese are only good at one thing, engineering.

    The entire nation should commit ritual suicide.

  123. Just one small problem with your hypothesis. by The+Cydonian · · Score: 1

    Chop suey is American.

    1. Re:Just one small problem with your hypothesis. by xigxag · · Score: 1

      Chop suey is American.

      Well, Asian-American, which I already knew and so would you if you had bothered to read your own link instead of attempting to nitpick what would have been in any case an inconsequential error. But it wasn't a mistake, it was chosen deliberately to highlight my point. That what was originally so-called "Chinese" take out with minor asian influence has expanded into authentic regional cuisine.

      --
      There are two kinds of people: 1) those who start arrays with one and 1) those who start them with zero.
  124. biggest *star* in Japan by my1wong · · Score: 1

    (me from Hong Kong) I have been to Japan twice this year, 3 times in past 2 years.... I can observe that the most famous and the more admired star/person/celebrity in Japan is -- David Beckham. You can see his TV ads, posters everywhere.

  125. download japanese music by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    an excellent program to download japanese music is soulseek, at www.slsknet.org. join the japanese music room and people can let you sample different music if you are interested.

  126. Mods, bad form by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Trolls can make reasonable points. It is surely true that some Japanese cartoons include women incredibly figured (in a cartoon sort of way) simply to sell their product.

    And look at the world of today. Doesn't this seem like a more profitable business model than manufacturing in many ways? I'm not saying it is, but clearly the popularity of anime has drawn a lot of business interest.

  127. Want some cheese with that? by AP31R0N · · Score: 1

    i know who you are TyrranzzX... If there was a group of ppl watching a gorgeous sunset, filling them with joy and wonder, you'd be the guy whining about how the colors are unnatural and the result of pollution. While it would be true, you'd rather suck the life out of the moment and destroy it for everyone else becuase you are so bitter. You are a cynic of the worst kind, you repress hope in others AND are self righteous about it. Being a moral crusader will not bring you happiness or friends. Have your beliefs and strive for them, but don't share your misery. Relax Grow Up Stop raining on other people's sunny days See the good in people and yourself

    --
    Utilizing the synergization of benchmark e-solutions to pre-workaround action items!
  128. Because of Trigun, Japan can choke. by Hrothgar+The+Great · · Score: 1

    As an addendum to a post I made earlier about Kenshin, seriously - what the hell is wrong with the people who make shows like that one and for the love of all that is holy, Trigun? WHY do action shows that could be cool have to have stupid unfunny comedy segments dominating 50% of the show? Seriously, someone who enjoys Trigun, please explain how it is possible for you to not be an idiot.

    Seriously - I tried watching this series when they put it on Cartoon Network. Once again, they advertised it like it was just the coolest damn thing - an action filled gunslinging Western cartoon. Hell I love Westerns. Unforgiven was one of my favorite movies of all time. I was ready for some GOD DAMN ACTION when I turned this sucker on.

    Sadly it was not meant to be. The show is filled with main character "Vash The Stampede" making all manner of silly faces, including having his face turn into a cat for no apparent reason, having his face get really gigantic, crying giant rivers of tears, and all manner of insane, inhuman expressions. OH WAIT - IS THIS SHOW A COMEDY OR WHAT? I guess I was supposed to laugh at some point.

    My next thought was that this show must obviously be for kids. No such luck there - when there actually is violence (FINALLY) in this "action" series, it's brutally violent. The juxtaposition from slapstick hilarity to gut wrenching action was not handled at all well by whoever wrote this piece of trash. I don't think they felt the need at the time.

    I tried to watch it a few more times. I wanted to like it because it was drawn really well (when the characters weren't coming off completely cheesy) and the music was awfully cool, and the action scenes were pretty neat. Every single episode, however, was ruined by some fucking dork writer somewhere in Japan who thought he was funny and was miserably, hopelessly mistaken.

    1. Re:Because of Trigun, Japan can choke. by WuphonsReach · · Score: 1

      Trigun is a 26 episode story arc about the personal journey of Vash as he seeks to heal the rift between him and his brother. The setting is sci-fi with a western twist (similar to steampunk?), which does not make it like Unforgiven or other Hollywood Westerns. The comedy is there to lighten up some serious under-pinnings to the story (Vash acts over the top to throw people off of thinking that he is actually Vash the Stampede, the Humanoid Typhoon).

      including having his face turn into a cat for no apparent reason

      Which is a stylized way of showing a michevious character (I forget if it's supposed to be a fox or a japanese racoon, but the roots lie in japanese myths). Some anime artists prefer to express emotion through stylized methods like that, others choose more realistic art styles.

      The juxtaposition from slapstick hilarity to gut wrenching action was not handled at all well by whoever wrote this piece of trash. I don't think they felt the need at the time.

      More likely (since I won't watch a engrishized version of Anime on CN), it was butchered by either the english dubbing or things were cut by CN. Watch the original in Japanese and you'll have a better basis to judge it on.

      --
      Wolde you bothe eate your cake, and have your cake?
    2. Re:Because of Trigun, Japan can choke. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Trigun's sudden shift _is_ done with almost no transition. The thing is, this is intentional. The real-world reason is that Trigun is actually based on two series written a year or so apart, then stuck together with glue as an anime. The anime-world reason is that Vash was suddenly in what amounted to an ambush situation. The enemy didn't give him the time to make any slow adjustments so the audience, who are seeing the story from Vash's perspective, are given none either. If that's not your cup of tea, Trigun is clearly not your show.

  129. sad to say by east+coast · · Score: 2

    I know I'm going to get beat on by some geeks but...

    Japanees popular culture reeks of the same kind of cheap, campy sensations of cheap Vegas tourist attractions. Just go off to a Japanees website that wasn't made with Western web surfers in mind and you'll see what I mean.

    --
    Dedicated Cthulhu Cultist since 4523 BC.
    1. Re:sad to say by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Does any one know where i can get some good zunda shake in tokyo? uuuumai.

      Their ("Japanees website that wasn't made with Western web surfers in mind") doesn't list a tokyo store...
      http://www.sanzen.co.jp/zunsa/saryo/

      I dreamed of a tokyo store last night....(although i don't recall any "cheap, campy sensations of cheap Vegas tourist attractions").

  130. J-pop CDs in the US by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Do you know where to get J-pop CDs at decent prices in the US? I'm looking for Ayumi Hamasaki CDs, but man, they cost a bomb on Amazon. :)

    1. Re:J-pop CDs in the US by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Probably not possible. New CDs on amazon.co.jp run 2500 to 3000 yen. So that's $24 to $28 (depending on exchange rates lately). Shipping is around 1000 yen (don't bother with the express shipping, it's a lot more expensive and the "economy" shipping rarely takes as long as they say it will). So your total won't be the gouging of $45 for those CDs on amazon.com in America, but it will probably still run you $35+ for a single CD. CDs and DVDs from Japan are spendy. Manga, on the other hand, are extremely affordable. You can buy native Japanese manga and get them shipped to the U.S. for less than the cost of buying the translated versions at your local bookstore.

    2. Re:J-pop CDs in the US by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Some of the Tower Records carry JPop sections. Also, www.yesasia.com has a very good selection, and also carries the overseas version, which are a few dollars cheaper (down into the teens range).

  131. Re:ReYou want the coolest culture? Check out Fland by Requiem · · Score: 1

    http://www.flanders.be/public/flanders/economy/ind ex.asp

    No, but you are.

  132. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Ignoring that Looney Tunes laid the groundwork for a genre of animation -- the talent and quality in those cartoons wasn't in the detail of the drawing.

  133. But not a major importer by substance2003 · · Score: 1

    If there is one thing the US does well, it's recreate shows rather then import them.
    Many films that have been made in the US are simply remakes from some other country.
    The Ring being a good example of a foreign movie that never made it to the big screen in the states (at least not in major theatres as far as I know). Hollywood made it in a way that people from the US will be able to accept and ended up doing something that didn't quite live up to the original.
    Interestingly enough, the US version probably got more exported thoughtout the world than the japanese version so I think it's a big loss for the global community.
    This is not the only instance that can be mentioned. I believe that a US version of the french movie Taxi is currently being produced. Is it really that hard for americains to accept a taxi driver rolling around the small streets of Marseille? Must it really be happening in the streets of some city like New York for the average americain joe to accept it?
    Why is it that hollywood has such a great resistance to movies that come from outside the US?

    Yes there is the rare occasion where a foreign film will make it in major cinemas but I can't remember much passed Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon (or much before it either).

    Since we're talking about anime here I think that if US animation studios took they're shows more seriouly like Hollywood does for it's movies, Japanese animation would never have gotten it's foot in the door here. I've met TV producers of animated shows here and they simply feel that it's best to make the shows as cheap as possible so as to make a quick buck rather than try to make something good.

    1. Re:But not a major importer by phaggood · · Score: 0

      I think that if US animation studios took they're shows more seriouly like Hollywood does for it's movies, Japanese animation would never have gotten it's foot in the door here. I've met TV producers of animated shows here and they simply feel that it's best to make the shows as cheap as possible so as to make a quick buck rather than try to make something good. Are you kidding me? Have you seen some of the drivel that comes out of Japanese animation studios? Sure, Studio Ghibli produces stuff like an art-house Xanadu, but have you seen "Bey Blade" (think 'GI Joe' cartoon, exists only to move merc), "Pokemon" (ditto), "Yugi Oh" (double-ditto) or "Hamtaro" (tho at least they do employ decent writers)? I think anime gets lauded because there are so many hundreds of animated shows produced every year that some Cowboy Bebops, Patlabors and Tenchi's (and not just the movies) come out from the herd and outshine the dogs I mentioned above.

  134. Mastermind by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Mastermind's pretty good. Japanese speed metal, hey that's different. Heh! Careful when searching, there's an older band with the same name. Look for a track called "Back Against the Wall."

  135. Way. by MsGeek · · Score: 1

    Dammit, why didn't someone unearth that clip during the recent Recall election here in California??? Looking at Ah-nold with that utterly crazed, depraved look in his eyes...man, that was scary!

    California is going to need more than vitamin drink to perk up after the Governator is done with it, alas.

    --
    Knowledge is power. Knowledge shared is power multiplied.
  136. Re:Soon to be modded down, oh well by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Look at some of the old looney tunes.. dude
    they are classics.. the melding of classical music in the background, elmer and bugs going at it in
    the rabbit of seville? the red-riding hood story.
    why grandma.. you're nutting but a wolf in cheap
    clothing!

    anime strikes me as trying to be this really deep
    thing, in the context of a cartoon.. its cultral I suppose.. I just don look at cartoons in that manner.

  137. That's Not Culture... by DynaSoar · · Score: 1

    ... that's marketing.

    Of course, the greatest consumer of it is the US, for which marketed concepts and culture are pretty much interchangeable. After all, they got the idea from us.

    --
    "I may be synthetic, but I'm not stupid." -- Bishop 341-B
  138. I thought myself such an oddball... by demonhold · · Score: 0

    for liking stuff like x-japan and pizzicatto five...

    How is it this world is looking more and more a dumbass imitation of a Gibson's novel?

    --
    ... y Dios vio que Linux era bueno... Genesis 99.666
  139. Re:YOU ARE A FUCKING LIAR ! by demonhold · · Score: 0

    actually,

    Spaniards hate Canadians.

    Spanish fishing boats made their captures well off area assigned to each country in continental waters, but in order to shut down some corruption charges against the Canadian gov. you started a war against Spanish and Portuguese fisher boats in the middle of the Atlantic...

    You even sent a warship...(hmm those European nets and fishing rods are sooooo dangerous looking) You even took some war prisoners and actually lock'em up in your military jails...

    Canada is simply a case of good PR engieneering... nobody loves you, simply don't care to even hate you for long... as it is the case in Spain, Portugal and France...

    --
    ... y Dios vio que Linux era bueno... Genesis 99.666
  140. Does it have to attract girls to be cool? by hkmwbz · · Score: 1
    Are you saying that for something to be cool, it has to be approved by some committee consisting of "popular" jocks and models? Can't it just be cool for geeks, and that's it?

    Does it look like anyone is into Anime and similar things to pull girls? No? Then why are they into it?

    Maybe because they think it's... cool!

    I can easily get laid without Anime, so why should I care if that brainded bimbo over there isn't going to approve of my taste in entertainment?

    --
    Clever signature text goes here.
  141. Oh please, what rubish. by jotaeleemeese · · Score: 1

    Typical USian exceptionalism. It is so stupid it almost hurts.

    US culture is popular because it has stronger means of propagation. Cultures that popularized themselves along the millenia have always been associated to large armies and conquerying warlords.

    Nowadays a third visible power is economic one and accordingly economic powerhouses have the most influence culutrally around the globe, not suprisingly India anc China, both growing economically and politically are now hot when it comes to cinema and music, this has nothing to do with flexibility but with economic realities.

    During the cold war the language most learned in Soviet satellite states was Russian followed by German (due to many scientists going to study there), that had nothing to do with flexibility of the Russian or German culture, but with the fact that you have to deal with those states with large political influence.

    The day the US is not a political or economic power US culture will fade giving way to whatever replaces it as the political power to respect.

    It amazes me also how some people invoke Darwin's name at the drop of a hat with such careless disregard for the facts: what Darwin discovered is only applied to biology, in the narrow field of evolutionary theory. It can not be applied to full societies or cultures because simply Darwinism does not cover these matters at all, any Darwinist assumption regarding the adoption of cultural practices is completely flawed.

    --
    IANAL but write like a drunk one.
    1. Re:Oh please, what rubish. by Rayonic · · Score: 1

      Yeah. And what about politically and economically weaker countries that occasionally have large impacts on international culture? I'm talking about parts of Latin America, Australia, the Carribean, Russia, and wherever else the latest "craze" is from.

      Furthermore, what about the more powerful countries that seem to wield little cultural clout anymore? I'm talking about France, Germany, Canada, Australia (most of the time), etc.

      Face it, the old rules don't apply. In the global free market of ideas, anyone can contribute to world culture. Information technology -- most recently the Internet -- has torn down the old barriers.

  142. They spread because they are cheap. by jotaeleemeese · · Score: 1

    McDonald's and Coca-Cola are the cheapest way to fill your belly. They are cheap, thus they sell, nobody cares if the main office is in the US or in Tonga.

    The Matrix is unproduceable in any other country. In several countries other movies, locally produced, beat Hollywood exports. Of course US people never get to hear about this.

    --
    IANAL but write like a drunk one.
  143. Takeshis Castle by Cackmobile · · Score: 1

    I love the Jap game shows shuch as Takeshis Castle. They are nuts and the people on them don't hold back. So many injuries.

    --
    -- Karma Karma Karma Karma, Karma Chameleon - Boy George
  144. Not Quite, I think by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is definitely true, especially for the new reader. However, as you see the same situations, and the same odd reactions, come up over the course of a few different manga/anime, you can start to deduce patterns (Except when things get /really/ strange, as they are wont to do at times.) Eventually, careful readings may even produce a limited cultural understanding.

    Not that most fans are willing to put extra time into their entertainment like that, but some do.

  145. Re:YOU ARE A FUCKING LIAR ! by plinius · · Score: 1

    There are other reasons to hate Canada, you know. Please don't oversimplify.

  146. ... except in Japan by revlee · · Score: 1

    Other than the language and the food, being in a major Japanese city feels much like any western city. I went to a couple of the large department stores is Osaka looking for Japanese gifts for my family and had a very difficult time. All the clothes were Burberry, French, or Italian labels and the shoes were Nike, Adidas, or Puma. About the only uniquely Japanese sections of the stores were the Bridal, cooking, and packaging departments. (I found the large print scarves they use for wrapping packages to be some of the most disctinctly Japanese gifts for relatives.)

    Restaurants were 50/50 western and Japanese. We interspersed the traditional fare with Italian, Indian, Starbucks, steakhouse, KFC, and even McDonald's. For our first late night system install, we even found a nearby Domino's that would deliver.

    While there is some cultural backwash coming this way, the vast majority of the cutlural tide is flowing to Japan.

  147. I don't think so. . . by jafac · · Score: 1

    one word:
    "Pocky"

    --

    These are my friends, See how they glisten. See this one shine, how he smiles in the light.
  148. And go by strombrg · · Score: 1
    And go of course.

    Yes, it's a Chinese game originally, but people in the West almost entirely use Japanese terminology to discuss the game.