Slashdot Mirror


GitS Sequel and Appleseed Remake Are Coming

LocusMote writes "Masamune Shirow, the creative genius behind the manga and anime Ghost in the Shell , has a few new irons fresh from the fire. One of his earlier manga, Appleseed, already exists as a rather disappointing television quality anime. Shirow thought so too, apparently. He went back to the original manga storyline, blew off the dust, and has produced a beautiful new all-CG Appleseed which hits the Japanese theaters in April. (Quicktime required) Oh yeah, there's a Ghost in the Shell sequel in the pipeline, too, called Innocence ... w00t!" Beautiful.

234 comments

  1. Well... by Tuxedo+Jack · · Score: 5, Insightful

    The more Shirow we can get, the better. The art's gorgeous, and there's nothing like freaking out people with pictures from GitS.

    --

    Striking fear in the authors of godawful fanfiction, I am here, appearing in darkness, Tuxedo Jack!
    1. Re:Well... by gaijin99 · · Score: 1
      The more Shirow we can get, the better.
      I'd say the more *good* Shirow we can get the better. The first Appleseed movie wasn't really all that good. Not awful, but hardly excellent.

      The trailer, what little there was of it looked as if it were following the manga more closely (though I hope they don't try to cram all four currently completed volumes into a single movie). The art, as you say, is fantastic. Bri looked great, Deunan looked marvelous, Olympus looked like Olympus, it's all looking good so far.

      --
      "Mission Accomplished" -- George W. Bush May 1, 2003
  2. Lesbians = Ratings by bludstone · · Score: 5, Funny

    Because everyone loves cyborg lesbians!

    Hey, I know I do.

    --

    no .sig
    1. Re:Lesbians = Ratings by PeDRoRist · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Actually Motoko is more of a bisexual than a lesbian.

      I like the bogus excuse of cyberbrain sex not working between male and female for showing some girl-to-girl action in GITS.

      --

      Anything you do can get you slashdotted, including nothing.
    2. Re:Lesbians = Ratings by DigiShaman · · Score: 2, Interesting

      You should see Bjorks video "All is full of love"

      --
      Life is not for the lazy.
    3. Re:Lesbians = Ratings by zoeblade · · Score: 2, Informative

      Because everyone loves cyborg lesbians!

      You'd probably prefer Excel Saga then.

  3. News? by caitsith01 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Um... the Ghost in the Shell sequel has been known about for quite some time now.... am I missing something here? Not really news, is it?

    Nonetheless, it looks completely awesome, the trailer alone has some of the coolest 2D/3D hybrid animation I've seen.

    --
    Read Pynchon.
    1. Re:News? by selderrr · · Score: 1

      abso-fsking-lutely....

      I adore the short scene where some 10 misiles are launched against that huge war machine. The way their smoke trail bends is amazing and reminds me of an old arcade game I used to spend my entire allowance on... Don't remember the name though. It was a game where the player took seat in a moveable cockpit of an F-something fighter jet. Just the sight of the sidewinders hurling towards your target was worth the 50cents I put in it time after time.... Does anyone know of a good modern-day game that has misiles like this ? And don't talk about the Q3A rocket smoke trails. While nice, they are to linear and have no choreographic beauty...

    2. Re:News? by BJH · · Score: 1

      The game was called... ...Sidewinder.

    3. Re:News? by spiny · · Score: 1

      sounds more like G-LOC to me

      --

      Fry: heh, Yakov Smirnoff said it
      Leela: No he didn't.
    4. Re:News? by BJH · · Score: 1

      Urg, you're probably right. I was getting it confused with the old Sidewinder arcade game (showing my age here)...

    5. Re:News? by Squozen · · Score: 1

      Sounds like Afterburner.

    6. Re:News? by proj_2501 · · Score: 2, Informative

      maybe afterburner

    7. Re:News? by caitsith01 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Oh man, I loved that game. I was just thinking the other day that there aren't enough cool gimmicks like the moving seat in afterburner any more. I mean, it doesn't look that great now, but AB had cool graphics, a great sense of speed and a funky rotating cockpit... what more could you want!

      --
      Read Pynchon.
    8. Re:News? by selderrr · · Score: 1

      anyone know of a modern day flightsim that has the same feel to it, without having to master a gazillion controls ?

    9. Re:News? by escallywag · · Score: 1

      Try the UT 2004 demo and play onslaught... Especcially the anti-vehicle missiles have very nice trails and you can fire them from way of on huge maps...

    10. Re:News? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      fire them from way of(f) on huge maps...

      and, thankfully, shoot them down.

    11. Re:News? by peter_gzowski · · Score: 1

      The main news is that there's a new version of AppleSeed, which is news to me. AppleSeed is probably the biggest let-down in the history of anime. How many newbie anime fans have seen it on the shelf of their local Blockbuster and said, "I loved GitS! This is by the same guy as GitS! I will rent it." They then waste 5 bucks and an hour and a half.

      --
      "Now gluttony and exploitation serves eight!" - TV's Frank
    12. Re:News? by Mac+Degger · · Score: 1

      Try the Robotech game :) You will have to get a console to play it, though :(

      --
      -- Waht? Tehr's a preveiw buottn?
    13. Re:News? by Moofie · · Score: 1

      Since airplanes have a gazillion controls, you can't simulate flight without a gazillion controls.

      Afterburner was not, repeat not, a flight simulator.

      --
      Why yes, I AM a rocket scientist!
    14. Re:News? by Omega996 · · Score: 1

      Hmmm, I actually liked Appleseed. What was it that was a letdown? The animation quality, or the story, or something else?

    15. Re:News? by radish · · Score: 2, Informative

      Crimson Skies is fun, not very similar to Afterburner, but probably the best arcade-style-pseudo-flight-sim aroudn right now. Lots of smoke trails :)

      --

      ---- Den ene knappen er powerknapp, den andre er Bender voice knapp "Bite My Shiny Metal Ass"

    16. Re:News? by Josuah · · Score: 1

      GiTS Innocence is different than GiTS Stand Alone Complex which is different than GiTS2 MMI. I knew about SAC, but not about Innocence. News to me.

    17. Re:News? by Zugok · · Score: 1

      I liked the Appleseed anime as well, not for the anime quality but for the story. I my opinion, GitS is way overrated.

      I didn't understand any of the commentary in the demo, but the demo for the new Appleseed looks like the story from book 4 and not a remake, which makes sense as book 4 involves a bit more thinking which Shirow is known for. If I recall correctly Shirow has said in the Appleseed data book, book 3 is just a cops and robbers type story (but still ny faavourite in the series). The original Appleseed anime already covered parts of 1 and 2.

      As for the GitS trailer, it's a story about Batou and the human cop in Section 6(?) I didn't see or hear any mention of Kusanagi in there.

      --
      "I just can't sit while people are saying nonsense in a meeting without saying it's nonsense" J Watson, Sci Am 288:(4)51
  4. too bad by sageo · · Score: 1, Flamebait

    GitS TV was awful...... Innocence sure is pretty though.

    1. Re:too bad by flatface · · Score: 2

      What are you smoking? Stand Alone Complex is one of my favourite series out there. And Innocence looks like it will be more like SAC than the first gits movie, despite supposed to be taking place directly after the first movie. Oh well.

    2. Re:too bad by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      > What are you smoking? Stand Alone Complex is one of my favourite series out there

      He didn't say you didn't like it - he said it was awful. There is a difference.

    3. Re:too bad by DigitumDei · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I'm currently up to episode 11 of stand alone complex. So far I'm enjoying it immensely. I enjoyed the GiTS movie, but, to make it movie length too many things got cut out.


      SAC although a different storyline, is touching a lot more subjects that were covered in the original manga.

    4. Re:too bad by M1FCJ · · Score: 3, Interesting
      GiTS SAC is absolutely beautiful in animation and in story. I started to watch the 2nd season and so far it is going good.

      If you read the manga, you'll see that GiTS SAC is much more closer to it than the movie was. I still love the movie but SAC is much better than the movie in story-terms.

    5. Re:too bad by Mysticalfruit · · Score: 1

      Gah, now you've done it! I'm gonna have to go out and buy some of the SAC stuff!

      Though annoyingly, my wife hates GiTS. Though she's a huge cowboy bebop / Lain fan.

      *shrugs*

      --
      Yes Francis, the world has gone crazy.
    6. Re:too bad by Rakshasa+Taisab · · Score: 1

      Yeah, the first 23 episodes were average.

      But GitS SAC ep 24-26 and GitS ep SAC2 1-2 have animation that is as good as the first GitS movie. It's without question the best animation i've ever seen in a series intended for TV.

      --
      - These characters were randomly selected.
    7. Re:too bad by Halthar · · Score: 2, Interesting

      SAC really is worth the time (and money) to watch. I already have the first season as fansubs as well as the first few episodes of the second season, but the moment the DVDs start to be released I will be picking them up as quickly as possible. It really is a series worth owning in my opinion.

      The second season, so far as I have seen, is looking to be just as good as the first, if not better.

    8. Re:too bad by cfuse · · Score: 1
      GitS TV was awful ...

      Compared to what? Have you seen what's on the idiot box lately?

      I've actually given up watching TV (on the real TV anyway) after I started to D/L TV shows - things I like to watch, when I want to watch them, without ads. Who could ask for more?

  5. Fantastic! by aanand · · Score: 3, Funny

    A Ghost in the Shell sequel! I hope this one pushes back the boundaries of animation as much as the first one did! Dude, that film was revolutionary! It had guns and everything! Even James Cameron liked it!

  6. Release date? by cmsnell · · Score: 1, Interesting

    Does anyone know when (or if) the GitS:Stand Alone Complex series will get released in the States? I loved the fansubs, but I'd like to buy some DVDs.

    Any truth to the rumors that Innocence will focus more on Batou as the main character? And is Bandai planning on bringing that over here, or will I have to settle for fansubs on that one also?

    1. Re:Release date? by ajservo · · Score: 1

      I would assume the series will be out by this fall, since Cartoon Network is planning on airing it by around August or so...

    2. Re:Release date? by cmsnell · · Score: 0

      Yup, a few posts down bludstone informs us the first dvd is set for release on or around June 27th. Hooray!

    3. Re:Release date? by UWC · · Score: 2, Informative

      According to this post from an earlier story, Dreamworks has the US distribution rights and plans to release it sometime midyear. I can't wait. I hope it gets wider distribution than the last one Dreamworks brought over, Millennium Actress.

    4. Re:Release date? by minasoko · · Score: 3, Informative
      Bandai have the U.S. rights for a DVD release. Although there is no date yet, Bandai recently confirmed some details:

      We've learned that the release will definitely be anamorphic, both language tracks will be in 5.1 and Bandai does have the Tachikomatic Days Animated Shorts. We should know later this week what the final US release date is as well.

      Check out Anime On DVD for any update. The forum is a friendly place to pick up info too.

    5. Re:Release date? by PeDRoRist · · Score: 1

      You can get the z2 DVDs from Japan, as they have english subtitles (I did it, eventhough english is not my native tongue). The translation quality is a bit poor, though.

      --

      Anything you do can get you slashdotted, including nothing.
    6. Re:Release date? by CrazyLion · · Score: 3, Insightful

      The Japanese region 2 GitS:SAC DVDs don't have English subtitles. What you got are the Hong Kong bootlegs. You may want to check http://www.digital.anime.org.uk/piratefaq.html for more info.

    7. Re:Release date? by minasoko · · Score: 1
      Do you have some links to back this up? All the info I can find suggests that the R2 GiTS: SAC discs do not carry subtitles of any kind.

      CD Japan are rarely wrong.

    8. Re:Release date? by Pope · · Score: 1

      Don't forget the fansubs for GITS:SAC 2, 2nd Gig are slowly coming out. The second season's shaping up to be even better than the first one!

      --
      It doesn't mean much now, it's built for the future.
    9. Re:Release date? by zosa · · Score: 1

      but didn't the fansubs of season 1 stop after episode 21 or 22 because it became licensed? or did i just miss them?

    10. Re:Release date? by Pope · · Score: 1

      Nope :)

      At least 2 groups release versions of the last 4 episode, it just took them a little while to release them. LMF did theirs middle/end of January.

      --
      It doesn't mean much now, it's built for the future.
    11. Re:Release date? by 3dfxoldtimer · · Score: 1

      I myself don't have a link on hand but what I can tell you is if you have more than 2eps to a disk then it's pirate.

      Oh wait I do have link in my head. :)
      http://www.cdjapan.co.jp/

  7. wha? by Digitus1337 · · Score: 1

    But who is the laughing man?!?

    1. Re:wha? by Kisama · · Score: 1

      I've not seen the rest of the series yet. Do they tell who he/she is?

    2. Re:wha? by Smidge204 · · Score: 1

      Yes they do. I'm not about to spoil it, though. All I'll say is it comes together in the last episode of the first season.

      =Smidge=

    3. Re:wha? by cybergrue · · Score: 1

      His identity and modivations are revealed by the end of the first season. Just watch it, and all will be revealed.

  8. I no longer believe by kahei · · Score: 2, Insightful


    I was a real believer in Shirow during, about, the early days of Appleseed, but he never really delivered... just degenerated into pin-ups and obsessing over types of weapon...

    I guess there's always a new generation ready to look at cyborg lesbians, though :)

    --
    Whence? Hence. Whither? Thither.
    1. Re:I no longer believe by GearheadX · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Stop looking at the eyecandy.

      Start reading the philosophy in the comics.

      Get a few books on Buddhism, Taoism and Shinto if you have to to start following the themes and messages being related.

      There's more to him than cheesecake.

    2. Re:I no longer believe by bugbread · · Score: 1

      Yes. There's also shallow pop-philosophy and religion.

    3. Re:I no longer believe by GearheadX · · Score: 1

      All philosophy is pop-philosophy.

      Plato wouldn't have been introduced to the party game 'Drink Hemlock Til You Croak' if he wasn't charismatic.

    4. Re:I no longer believe by ttrafford · · Score: 1
      Plato wouldn't have been introduced to the party game 'Drink Hemlock Til You Croak' if he wasn't charismatic.
      Who, now?
    5. Re:I no longer believe by Lord_Dweomer · · Score: 1
      "... just degenerated into pin-ups and obsessing over types of weapon..."

      I fail to see what the problem is.

      --
      Buy Steampunk Clothing Online!
    6. Re:I no longer believe by kahei · · Score: 1


      I agree that there's some painfully shallow pop-philosophy -- but for that we have the Matrix.

      --
      Whence? Hence. Whither? Thither.
    7. Re:I no longer believe by bugbread · · Score: 1

      The problem is that it's boring. Why bother reading manga if you can get the same effect from a Maxim and a Guns & Ammo?

    8. Re:I no longer believe by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

      I read a translated copy of GitS with footnotes from Shirow, and in it, he sounded pretty ... uh... fascist, if you ask me. Here's a quote:

      "One should take care that those who commit crimes do not get too many advantages. Maybe one should just sentence people to death and then postpone the execution as long as they do good for society." "

    9. Re:I no longer believe by Lord_Dweomer · · Score: 1
      " The problem is that it's boring. Why bother reading manga if you can get the same effect from a Maxim and a Guns & Ammo?"

      I was actually making a joke, but since you obviously didn't get that, I will reply to your statement.

      What you should have said is "its boring to me". To a lot of people, they might consider that an improvement. There's a reason sex and violence sell, its cuz people like it. Who are you to judge what is "good" and what isn't. It's 100% subjective, so its a moot argument.

      --
      Buy Steampunk Clothing Online!
    10. Re:I no longer believe by bugbread · · Score: 1

      No, I got the joke. That was more a counterargument for the people who really believe that. True, sex and violence sells. And true, everything is subjective. But once you admit that, everything's good, and where's the fun if you can't make fun of From Justin to Kelly or Battleship Earth?

    11. Re:I no longer believe by GearheadX · · Score: 1

      Consider that he comes from a highly comformist culture.

    12. Re:I no longer believe by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "One should take care that those who commit crimes do not get too many advantages. Maybe one should just sentence people to death and then postpone the execution as long as they do good for society."

      Gee, sounds like the situation in the US (appeals and so on)

    13. Re:I no longer believe by n8_f · · Score: 1

      I love the Appleseed and GitS (original; I still haven't read GitSII and I'm a little afraid to) mangas. They are very layered and nuanced. I always picked up something new reading through them the first couple of times. He did deliver, but never followed through on fulfilling his potential (as I saw it; it sounds like he is rich and doing fine).

      Unfortunately, with the aptly named Intron Depot, Shirow jumped the shark. I assume this is what you are referring to and not any of the manga. I wish he would finish Appleseed (he has been talking about 5 forever), but I am almost afraid of him doing so now. Sigh.

      On the other hand, Intron is now what I name any Windows machine I have to use. I have yet to find a Windows admin who gets either reference. BTW, if you haven't already, do yourself a favor and check out GitS: Stand Alone Complex. I really disliked the movie, but I loved the series. It reminded me completely of the manga. A little more serialized, but all of the complexity and layers are there.

  9. IF I DIDN'T KNOW BETTER I'D SAY by Tirel · · Score: 0, Funny

    THAT YOU'RE BEING SARCASTIC

    1. Re:IF I DIDN'T KNOW BETTER I'D SAY by 3dfxoldtimer · · Score: 1

      About which part? James Cameron? Well he did put his name on some glowing comments that he wrote and were included in the Japanese box set. The rest? Consedering that a number of people (including the sexually confused creators of the Matrix) have fingered the movieb to being as influentaul as Blade Runner. So where's the sarcasm

    2. Re:IF I DIDN'T KNOW BETTER I'D SAY by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I think you're gay, fag.

  10. another spin off soon then...? by freerecords · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Matrix was clearly ripped off Ghost in the Shell.. so will we soon get a new matrix sequel ripped off innocence... i wonder?

    --
    tim
    1. Re:another spin off soon then...? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      oops, glad i posted that as AC

    2. Re:another spin off soon then...? by bludstone · · Score: 0, Funny

      Its not a ripoff, its a tribute! :)

      --

      no .sig
    3. Re:another spin off soon then...? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Really, Slashdotting a geocities site? Where's the sport in that?

    4. Re:another spin off soon then...? by 3dfxoldtimer · · Score: 1

      Actually the Wachowski brothers themselves have noted GITS as a significant influence.

    5. Re:another spin off soon then...? by UserGoogol · · Score: 1

      Akira too. The Matrix is clearly just a live action recreation of about four Anime.

      --
      "Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity." -- Hanlon's Razor
    6. Re:another spin off soon then...? by 3dfxoldtimer · · Score: 1

      Which it is only fitting that the opening credits on ep #3 and 4 looks like GITS is borrowing ideas back from them. :)

  11. You may already know that but... by Tei · · Score: 4, Interesting

    If you can, get all Ghost in the Shell Stand Alone Episodes, where really GREATs, maybe the better anime you can wach. Also get the Tachikomas episodes, has a bonus.

    Some people think that these episodes where BETTER than the original Film itself.

    Thanks Japan Artists!

    --

    -Woof woof woof!

    1. Re:You may already know that but... by cap'n+foolsy · · Score: 2, Informative

      they were better because they more closely followed the flow of the manga. the feature-length film compressed everything into a somewhat hard to understand, but beautiful, package. i know a lot of people who fell asleep watching the GitS movie, but loved standalone complex.

      --
      It might look like I'm standing motionless, but I'm actively waiting for my problems to go away
    2. Re:You may already know that but... by bludstone · · Score: 4, Informative

      Wait on the legit dvds. They are coming fairly soon. Heres the press release (stolen from animeondvd.com )

      BANDAI AND MANGA JOIN TOGETHER TO RELEASE THE NEW GHOST IN THE SHELL "STAND ALONE COMPLEX" ANIME SERIES ON TV AND DVD IN 2004

      February 11, 2004 -Chicago, IL - Japanese animation distributors, Manga Entertainment and Bandai Entertainment will jointly distribute the all-new "Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex" anime TV series worldwide (ex-Asia). Based on Masamune Shirow's popular manga/comic series, "Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex" was co-produced by both companies along with Japan's acclaimed Production I.G. (Kill Bill, Blood the Last Vampire, Jin-Roh: The Wolf Brigade). "Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex" consists of 26 futuristic half hour episodes that will be released on DVD this summer along with a subsequent U.S. cable television broadcast.

      Manga Entertainment CEO Marvin Gleicher says: "We are very excited to join with our friends at Bandai Entertainment in releasing this excellent new anime series. There is no title that better represents the bright future of Japanese animation than Ghost in the Shell."

      "Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex" presents a new vision of the future in which female cyborg Major Motoko Kusanagi and her fellow police officers of Section 9 must hunt down criminals in both the real world and online world. Set in the not too distant future where technology plays a key role in everyday human life, this top-notch sci-fi action series combines the latest in full CG animation featuring dramatic themes, illustrious characters, and meticulous design.

      This highly anticipated anime series was produced by an incredible creative team including Yoko Kanno (Cowboy Bebop), Kenji Kamiyama (Blood the Last Vampire, Jin-Roh: The Wolf Brigade) and the talented staff at Production I.G. (Dead Leaves, Patlabor 1&2). "Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex" has recently made its debut on Japanese television and will begin airing in the U.S. on Cartoon Network's late night Adult Swim block later this year. "The release of 'Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex' marks an exciting and important milestone for anime and its ever increasing popularity in mainstream pop culture here in the United States" said Ken Iyadomi, Executive Vice President of Bandai Entertainment.

      The original Ghost in the Shell feature film is one of the most widely recognized anime films ever released and continues to be a best seller today. The film was a key influence for the Wachowski Brothers in creating The Matrix trilogy and is featured prominently on the Animatrix DVD extras along with being the first Japanese animated film to reach #1 in the U.S. Billboard Video Chart - (August 1996.)

      "Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex" is set for release on June 27, 2004 and will be supported by a joint summer marketing campaign between Manga Entertainment and Bandai Entertainment. www.ghostintheshell.tv

      Bandai Entertainment Inc. is the premier distributor of Japanese animation on DVD home video in North America. The company has distributed notable titles like Superior Defender Gundam Force,hack//SIGN, Cowboy Bebop, and Witch Hunter Robin. Bandai Entertainment Inc. is a subsidiary of Bandai America Inc., who makes the toys for the hit television series, Power Rangers, Digimon, and Mobile Suit Gundam. All U.S. operations are headquartered in a large, ultra-modern facility in Cypress, Calif. Bandai Co., Ltd is the third largest toy company in the world comprising 53 subsidiaries in 18 countries. In addition to toys and children's entertainment, Bandai Co.'s global interests include video game software, multimedia, music and full-length feature films, vending machines, trading cards, candies, and licensed apparel. Bandai Entertainment is headquartered in Cypress, California and additional company and product information is available through our website at www.bandai-ent.com.

      Manga Entertainment Inc. specializes in the production and distributio

      --

      no .sig
    3. Re:You may already know that but... by bludstone · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Well. Lisencing takes time. They couldnt release it until after they recieved the masters from japan. These masters are not shipped out until after the show is finished. The tv show had a lot of financial backing from varied sources, including the US, and its been lisenced since before it aired in japan. Of course its been a long time.

      Additionally, the Japanese sometimes _want_ the US companies to delay their releases, so fans will buy it in Japan. Theres a problem with reverse-importing anime. A lot of Japanese fans will just say "just wait on the US dvd, its in Japanese, half the cost, and it comes with neat english extras."

      --

      no .sig
    4. Re:You may already know that but... by cmsnell · · Score: 0

      Yeah, I know. It's still frustating to those of us who don't mind paying for our entertainment, rather than downloading it.

      A lot of Japanese fans wait anyway. God knows how much anime I've had to ship back to my brother-in-law back in Japan. Along with a region 1 dvd player. But I understand the point.

      Maybe they should put English subs on the Japanese dvds more often, like they did with Azumi, so that obssessive fanboys like me could get our fix earlier, while counting on most people to wait for the ease of buying region 1 dvds.

    5. Re:You may already know that but... by BigFire · · Score: 1

      Bandai Entertainment (The US subsidary of Bandai Inc.) co-produced the show out of their own pocket, so the licensing is never that much of an issue.

      From what I can tell is the extremely slow release schedule in Japan (2 episodes per month on Pay-Per-View) and the fact there is a second season (2nd GIG) that's holding up the R1 release.

    6. Re:You may already know that but... by Cryptnotic · · Score: 1

      Why not watch the fansubs AND buy the DVD's when they come out?

      --
      My other first post is car post.
  12. Better Idea by kahei · · Score: 0, Troll


    Rather than make a new Appleseed movie, let's focus on destroying the first one!

    --
    Whence? Hence. Whither? Thither.
    1. Re:Better Idea by kahei · · Score: 2, Informative


      Mod me all you like, those who have seen it know that it really was _that_ bad :)

      --
      Whence? Hence. Whither? Thither.
    2. Re:Better Idea by PeDRoRist · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Agreed. It was terrible, and had little to nothing to do with the manga. Let's just ignore it.

      --

      Anything you do can get you slashdotted, including nothing.
    3. Re:Better Idea by AgentSmith1000 · · Score: 1, Insightful

      Gotta agree with kahei. All bad Appleseed must be destroyed

      But c'mon man! Look at that Appleseed trailer again and tell me that it doesn't do some apology for the original.

      Now if only we could get Russel Mulcahy to brush off and do a remake of Highlander 2: The Apology.

  13. Shirow is not the one to credit for GitS anime by ookaze · · Score: 5, Informative

    This news is mostly misguided in that respect.
    Shirow is only behind the manga.
    GitS the movie would never have been the wonder it was without the genius that is Mamoru Oshii.
    I'll go as far as saying that Mamoru Oshii gave more power to the story than Shirow ever could.

    Even the anime design shouts "Mamoru Oshii team" all over it.
    Kenji Kawai is part of the "Mamoru Oshii team", so, well, even though he has his detractors, I always found him to be on par with the like of Joe Hisaishi or Youko Kanno (geniuses), and sound plays a great role in the feel of Oshii's anime (like for Sergio Leone films).

    1. Re:Shirow is not the one to credit for GitS anime by Briareos · · Score: 1
      Shirow is only behind the manga.

      And quite a bit behind the TV series, which is quite a bit closer to his manga and coming to the US and the UK this summer (end of June, actually)...

      Website (no info yet)
      AoD news archive (searching for "Shell" in this page should do the trick)

      np: The Orb - Valley (Orbvs Terrarvm)

      --

      "I'm not anti-anything, I'm anti-everything, it fits better." - Sole

    2. Re:Shirow is not the one to credit for GitS anime by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Tolekin is only behind the books.
      TLotR the movie would never have been the wonder it was without the genius that is Peter Jackson.
      I'll go as far as saying Peter Jackson gave more power to the story than Tolkein ever could.

    3. Re:Shirow is not the one to credit for GitS anime by PinkStainlessTail · · Score: 1

      Even the anime design shouts "Mamoru Oshii team" all over it.

      I saw no flying alien princesses in tiger stripe bikinis delivering electric shocks to overly hormonal high school boys...

      Or am I too old school?

      --
      "Slashdot is about legos and staplers." -Cmdr. Taco
    4. Re:Shirow is not the one to credit for GitS anime by warkda+rrior · · Score: 1

      [...] Tolekin [...] Tolkein [...]

      I am sure Tolkien wishes someday all geeks in the world would be able to spell his name right :)

      --
      You need to install an RTFM interface.
    5. Re:Shirow is not the one to credit for GitS anime by ookaze · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I wonder how you could be modded insightful, as the difference between GitS manga and GitS anime are an order of magnitude more than the ones between LotR book and film.

      You seem also to imply that there was a lot of fans of GitS manga, and that it was a masterpiece, before the movie was created, as it is the case for LotR.
      That is just not true.

      Mamoru Oshii incentives to do a film have nothing to do with the incentives of Hollywood. They would never have done anime/films like the ones Mamoru Oshii has done (Tenshi no tamago, Patlabor 1 and 2, Avalon, ...).

      You should have been modded funny I think ...

      But just as I imply here, I guess not every moderator can be a fan of Oshii enough to understand.

    6. Re:Shirow is not the one to credit for GitS anime by Locus+Mote · · Score: 1

      This is patently absurd. The underlying philosophical themes in the anime are all present in the manga, only in a more solidly worked out form.

      Of course, of course, of course the anime will feel more dynamic than the manga. It is moving while manga is a series of static frames.

      So yes, the sound is very nice in the anime. Yes, the anime is very powerful. But you have forgotten one salient detail which makes all the difference in the world. Mamoru Oshii is reinterpreting Shirow's original story. It is not Oshii's story. Shirow wrote the manga long before the anime came out.

      What you are proposing is like giving Peter Jackson credit for writing the Lord of the Rings trilogy simply because he directed the films. He lent great cinematic beauty to the story, but the story itself was written by Tolkien.

      The same is true in GitS. Shirow wrote the story. So before you go making blanket statements about how misguided my news is, perhaps you should think about the creative process. To say Shirow is "only behind the manga," is to understate the importance of an author of a work. Other people could have directed the Ghost in the Shell anime project, but the project could not have existed in the first place if Shirow hadn't written the ideas behind it.

    7. Re:Shirow is not the one to credit for GitS anime by DeadScreenSky · · Score: 1

      You seem also to imply that there was a lot of fans of GitS manga, and that it was a masterpiece, before the movie was created, as it is the case for LotR.
      That is just not true.

      Umm, there are a lot of fans of the GitS manga. Myself, among others (the very high sales agree with this). And quite a few fans would call it a masterpiece, too.

      One of the things that disappointed me so much about the GitS film is how shallow it was compared to the manga. It was also less exciting, less funny, less imaginative, and in general pretty incompetent sci-fi - it didn't manage to portray a particularly interesting or different world than the one we live in now. This is something the manga did a very nice job on (and something Shirow is pretty good at). The GitS film felt just like it was our world, just with some rare cyborgs and fancier military machines, and maybe a slightly more advanced internet. Maybe if it had something more interesting to say about this technology, but all it manages to present is the Cliff Notes version of the manga themes.

      And other than some admittedly nice montages in places (I love the rain one), some good (if repetitive) music, fairly good animation, and the possible benefit of a shorter exposure time, the film doesn't really add much. No new ideas, no new themes, no new characters, no truly new scenes. It also exactly followed the basic storyline of the manga, with lots of stuff cut out, pacing changes, and a very slight change in the ending. So I am not sure why you feel it is such a divergence, as opposed to the LOTR films, which cut lots of stuff, changed the pacing, and had a slight change in the ending.

      (The Patlabor series has the same problem as sci-fi, IMO - you have one or two areas of amazingly high technology advancement, and the rest of the world is completely unchanged, really. So bizarrely unimaginative.)

      --
      There is no excellent beauty that hath not some strangeness in the proportion. -- Francis Bacon
    8. Re:Shirow is not the one to credit for GitS anime by AnyNoMouse · · Score: 1
      (The Patlabor series has the same problem as sci-fi, IMO - you have one or two areas of amazingly high technology advancement, and the rest of the world is completely unchanged, really. So bizarrely unimaginative.)
      Strange how a show that is set in 1998 is so similar to our own times...

      --
      -Redundancy Man strikes again!
    9. Re:Shirow is not the one to credit for GitS anime by PinkStainlessTail · · Score: 1

      Of course, of course, of course the anime will feel more dynamic than the manga. It is moving while manga is a series of static frames.

      Compare Love Hina the manga with Love Hina the anime for an example of a manga that conveys movement and kinetic excitement better than the (rather staid and plodding) anime. So mostly right, but not always.

      Why yes, I did drink a big glass of pedant this morning.

      --
      "Slashdot is about legos and staplers." -Cmdr. Taco
    10. Re:Shirow is not the one to credit for GitS anime by DeadScreenSky · · Score: 1

      Yeah, it is bizarre. Compare the world to something like your average steampunk novel - everything should be changed in some way by this major radical technology.

      At least the trailers for GitS2 seem to suggest the director might now understand the need for a fleshed-out, or hell, just halfway evocative world - or at least some of his crew does. Maybe Shirow talked to him...

      --
      There is no excellent beauty that hath not some strangeness in the proportion. -- Francis Bacon
  14. I mean well.. by back_pages · · Score: 4, Interesting
    I'm not trying to troll, but I gave anime a shot a few years ago and found it all very vacuous. Ghost in the Shell struck me as being both pretentious and half-baked. I've watched a couple other titles and the experience was about the same.

    Someone once told me that there was a tremendous amount of Japanese cultural reference in anime. Any input on this? Is there a reputable online source where I might learn some of this material and reattempt to enjoy these movies?

    Alternatively, I begin to suspect that anime is to film what trance is to music. And again, I'm just trying to draw a framework, not just troll... Both strike me as eye/ear candy that expect the audience to be non-skeptical of the legitimacy of the plot/expression and enjoy the experience without critical analysis. But I've already admitted that I don't truly understand the culture that produces anime.

    At any rate, I like films by Kubrick and Wim Wenders among others, but I'm also a fan of tacky role playing games. I've played The Crescent Hawks Inception and the first Mechwarrior to completion, so I should have some affinity for giant robot fighters, right?

    I guess what I'm looking for is the History channel documentary on anime that will give me enough insight to appreciate what makes anime interesting, or at least the internet's version of such a thing. Any suggestions?

    1. Re:I mean well.. by bugbread · · Score: 5, Interesting

      Well, the first thing you need to realize is that not all anime is created equally (I suspect you know that, but just saying it in case), and that, just as with any other media, what's popular isn't necessarily what's good. I personally hated Ghost in the Shell, so I understand where you're coming from. Basically, you just need to find your niche. My anime niche is incredibly small, consisting basically of Miyazaki's stuff, as well as a smattering of random things (Rojin-Z, Memories...hmm...too few to even recall now, but I'm sure there are others).

      Some anime has a lot of Japanese cultural references, some doesn't (comedies, predictably, have much, much more, which is true in any medium). I suspect that it isn't so much the cultural divide that keeps you from enjoying anime, but discerning tastes.

      Just remember, if you hear a billion people praising a certain anime, it means no less and no more than a billion people praising a certain movie. The Fast and the Furious was very successful, but that doesn't mean it was good. The good stuff is out there, but you have to look, and that can be a pain in the butt.

      What I recommend is: don't bother looking. However, keep in mind that there is good stuff out there, but you haven't seen it. Then, one day, when a friend of yours whose tastes you trust recommends some anime, give it a shot and see if you've found the proverbial needle in the haystack.

    2. Re:I mean well.. by Tusaki · · Score: 2, Informative

      Well, Anime is just a medium. You can expect to find very bad, very good, very weird, very boring, very exciting, very cute, very gruesome, very lovable anime. And there is no one-size-fits-all (tm).

      But, if you're into movies. (I prefer series) Check out Grave of the Gireflies, Wings of Honneamise and perhaps Jin-Roh (the wolf brigade) or Akira (Personally I don't like it -that- much, but I know some people who swear by it).

      In series, I would recommend: Cowboy Bebop (ofcourse), Scrapped Princess, El Hazard, Photon, Planetes, Escaflowne. I'm not sure about evangelion, it's good, but a bit over-hyped I think.

      But anyway, just like with 'normal' movies and series. There are anime-movies and series for every different tastes. But I admit that most anime follows the 'action & sex & humor' strategy to attract as large a late-teen audience as possible -grin-.

      Good Luck & Have fun.

    3. Re:I mean well.. by mydigitalself · · Score: 5, Insightful

      whath them in japanese with subtitles.

      often what happens when they translate and dub anime is that the translation is compromised so that the sound fits in with the mouth movement - i'm not talking exactly here, by example...

      perhaps in Japanese someone can say "waaachaaa" and in English it actually means "hey how you doing, gee i haven't seen you in ages". so the dubbers will reduce the english to match the amount of time taken to say "waaachaa" and will come up with something like "hello". extend that to cultural references and more in-depth conversations and you begin to understand that watching a dubbed version of an anime is perhaps not a great idea if you're after good dialogue.

      i saw GITS first in English, twice as that was the only VHS version available to me. i then got it on DVD and watched it with subtitles where they tend not to compromise (although some subtitles can be awfully done!). the film took on an entirely different meaning to me - a lot of the "side scenes" (for example the apparantly random scene of the old dude getting out of the helicopter) actually made sense to me!

      one great example of rectifying this was Princess Mononoke where the entire edit was redone based on a translation from the brilliant Neil Gaiman. here Gaiman not only correctly translated the film, but he also adapted some of the metaphors and cultural references so that they had a western spin on them. the film was then re-edited so that the mouths matched his translation. watch it, its fantastic - don't get put off by the Disney'esque animation: after about 4 minutes of Bambi-like scenes evil monsters begin to appear and then someone has his head knocked off with an arrow...but its more than just that, it includes some fabulous human dichotomy and awesome fantasy scenses.

      so that may be one reason you haven't enjoyed your anime experience. the other is perhaps you've watched the wrong ones. most of the "famous" ones are more action orientated (Akira, GITS, Ninja Scroll). you may wish to watch something more dramatic like Grave of the Fireflies. personally it was far to slow for my liking, you may enjoy it or find similar anime that isn't all just blood & guts.

    4. Re:I mean well.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

      Thank goodness there is someone else who thought GitS was tripe. I agree wholeheartedly with you and recommend the same thing. Me? I am into fantasy dramas and general comedy shows and martial arts animes. Hardly any of the stuff I like is what would be considered popular (Eatman'98 anyone?) so just try watching a few off the wall stuff that isn't so well known, that is where the real gems are hiding.

    5. Re:I mean well.. by Lord_Dweomer · · Score: 2, Informative
      It would be difficult for any one of us to explain Japanese cultural references in anime. I would say the easiest way to find out would be to do some basic research on Japanese culture and society, then watch some anime and you will notice things pop out. But if you want a cheesy example, Goku from DBZ is originally based off of the monkey king god.

      And if you think anime has absolutely no meaning usually, I would suggest watching Neon Genesis Evangelion in its entirety.

      For a good source of free to download (unlicensed in America) anime, you should try Animesuki.com. They are one of the top bittorrent trackers out there. I should mention they only serve unlicensed anime, there ARE search engines which allow you get the licensed stuff, but I won't mention it here, suffice to say a quick Google search would give you what you seek.

      I should also mention that typically the UNLICENSED anime is better than the LICENSED anime. Although companies are getting better about what they choose to license. For example, they snapped up Last Exile ASAP. It's a great series. But they still have not licensed Naruto, which is probably the most popular current anime. It's already at episode 72 fansubbed release, and plans for like 5 more seasons. Extremely immersive anime, about ninjas, and you can actually pick up some ancient Japanese culture from it.

      --
      Buy Steampunk Clothing Online!
    6. Re:I mean well.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It could just be that you're not an anime person.

      I've seen a lot of anime. I've seen the stuff everyone likes (Mononoke), I've seen the stuff that's "high quality underground" (Lain (maybe misspelt?)), I've seen the mainstream stuff (Evangelion), I've even seen the kiddy stuff (pokemon). I thought it was all crap. Some people like it, but as with all things some people don't.

      Welcome to the club?

    7. Re:I mean well.. by illuminatedwax · · Score: 1

      I don't think a lot of what you're not getting is Japanese culture. All Japanese culture really provides is a different perspective from which to view the story. The only real exception is comedy, because a lot of the jokes tend to be somewhat "in-culture".

      Don't refuse to watch anime just because you tried it a few times and didn't like it. It's a medium, not a genre, although technically, I'd call it a specific style in a medium.

      If you like big robots, you should probably check out one of the Gundam series, although I'm not sure which ones are good. They are fairly cheesy though, so you might like that. Nadesico is another great show, but there are many Japanese in-jokes.

      Really, the best "big-robot" anime is probably Evangelion, which, while you many not like the philosophy elements or the huge amount of exposition, has a very rich story. A lot of work went into the series, and it is really a work of art that can be delved into very deeply.

      The recent Miyazaki films also must be seen.

      For the most part, I find anime refreshing because it has a different style from American movies, and American television really sucks. There hasn't been a good SF series since Star Trek DS9 and there hasn't been a good comedy since Seinfeld. Japanese anime series are also focused on telling a story rather than setting up a premise and having the series continue indefinitely. As a result, Japanese anime series tend to be better planned out, more cohesive, and have actual endings rather than the rich stars of the series or the networks begging for more seasons. (Think if more shows were like Babylon 5.) There are exceptions, of course, but the anime series that last past 26 episodes are mostly crap, anyhow (DBZ, Sailor Moon).

      Hell, even Aristotle said the episodic play was the worst kind.

      --Stephen

      Also, did anyone read the article title as "GritS sequel?"

      --
      Did you ever notice that *nix doesn't even cover Linux?
    8. Re:I mean well.. by Halthar · · Score: 1

      I didn't see the first episode of Naruto until somewhere around the release of episode 20, and have been watching it religously since. Really well done in my opinion. Even some of the things many people seem to complain about, I have actually found enjoyable. For instance, the flashback scenes, which seem to me to aid the character development by giving some insight into the reasoning for their actions. Overall, I think it has good ongoing character development, good soundtrack, good story line, etc. I have heard people comparing it to DBZ. Personally, I dont think DBZ can compare. There are things that Naruto as a series has, that DBZ just seemed to lack to me. Though admittedly I havent watched very many of the episodes of DBZ. In terms of most popular Naruto is up there. Last night's episode had around 15K people downloading it via torrent by the time I got home from work, and that is just for ONE of the "raw" versions.

      I agree about Evangelion, by the time I watched the last few episodes I found myself praying that everyone WOULD die, so they would have some sort of release from the twisted suffering in their lives. Alot of the people I know who have watched it and complained, did so because the giant robots weren't "cool" enough for them. I find that unfortunate, because I think they totally missed the point.

      Among other goodies, I havent gotten a chance to see the last few episodes of .hack/SIGN, but from what I have seen of episode 1-22, though it is a tad cheesy, its still quite engaging. Admittedly though, I used to play ALOT of Everquest, so because of all my time spent in MMORPGs, I may be more likely to be drawn to it. Serial Experiments: Lain was also very very good in my opinion. Also one of my current favorites is the "Trust and Betrayal" set for Rurouni Kenshin, as well as the "Reflections" OVA. Though, the later probably wouldn't be nearly as meaningful for someone who hadn't seen the series and the first OVA. I like the series, but without "Trust and Betrayal" is isn't nearly as interesting as it would be otherwise.

    9. Re:I mean well.. by djaxl · · Score: 1

      There is a good list of anime with ratings here. Check it out. The one I agree with on being in the 95-99% category is FLCL (aka Furi Kuri). Berserk and Cowboy Bebop are also decent. Can't say any of these are like Kubrick or Wenders films, but IIRC there is an episode of the GitS series that references a Truffaut film.

    10. Re:I mean well.. by shut_up_man · · Score: 1

      Heh... this reminds me of arts guys at parties saying "Oh, I learned Italian so I could read Dante's Inferno in its original form". Problem is, they are kinda right. My gf speaks Japanese and several times watching Stand Alone Complex she laughed and said "Uh, those subtitles are completely wrong. He said this and it's funny because of these cultural references." Now I have to learn Japanese. Doh.

      I completely agree about Princess Mononoke and Neil Gaiman's work on it. He did a truly excellent job conveying the flavour and depth of the story and setting. Should be more of it, I say.

    11. Re:I mean well.. by Hentai · · Score: 1

      I'm looking for a particular 'niche' to sample some concepts - are there any other anime out there with the same themes and quality as Escaflowne and El Hazard (i.e., ancient steam-punk/magic fueled technology that noone understands, in a primarily fantasy setting and plot - preferrably with cool steampunk mecha)?

      --
      -Hentai [in vita non pacem est]
    12. Re:I mean well.. by Omega996 · · Score: 1

      If you want to see a decent movie that happens to be anime, I'd recommend Jin-Roh, The Wolf Brigade. It's got a pretty decent story, though there aren't really any mecha.

    13. Re:I mean well.. by Omega996 · · Score: 1

      Mononoke is a good movie. I like it better with subtitles, though the dubbing is better than average, as stated by the previous poster.

    14. Re:I mean well.. by fizzboy · · Score: 1

      Try Last Exile. It's not quite steam-punk but it is mystical technology in a primarily fantasy setting.

      --
      -- "Never call your girlfriend 'Butterball'. Not even once."
    15. Re:I mean well.. by fizzboy · · Score: 1

      Correction... now you have to learn to be Japanese.

      --
      -- "Never call your girlfriend 'Butterball'. Not even once."
    16. Re:I mean well.. by RML · · Score: 1

      Scrapped Princess is definitely another anime in that category.

      --
      Human/Ranger/Zangband
    17. Re:I mean well.. by DeadScreenSky · · Score: 1

      Ghost in the Shell struck me as being both pretentious and half-baked.
      There is a good reason for that: it is. :)

      Though I do enjoy the film, your criticisms are absolutely correct. There are far better stuff out there - though not a bad film, I am not sure why the film version of GitS gets such praise in the West. I think it is just a lot of people's first exposure to more 'adult cartoons', so they are easily impressed.

      The film Memories just came out this week in the USA, which I would recommend you check out. It is an anthology of three stories - all feature fairly different themes and drawing styles, and none of them are too reliant on a knowledge of Japanese culture. You get some black humor, some psychological horror, some social critique.

      The problem you will find with a lot of anime fans giving recommendations to newbies is that they are rather myopic. FLCL is a great series for example, one of my faves, but at least half of its humor, plot, and various quirks revolve around references to other anime, manga, etc. It just isn't going to appeal to too many new anime watchers, because they don't have the proper context.

      Other than the advice to wait for when a friend with similar tastes recommends some anime (an excellent suggestion), I would just try and find some anime similar to whatever non-anime you like. Like moody horror films? Go for something like Boogiepop Phantom. Like Hitchcock suspense and are not too squeemish? Go for Perfect Blue. Cyberpunk and David Lynch? Maybe Serial Experiments Lain is up your alley. Big R-rated action films and Indiana Jones? Spriggan. Gross-out humor and a tolerance for some bizarre Japanese cultural stuff? Ping-pong Club. Etc. etc. Space opera with some hard Einsteinien physics? Gunbuster. There is a huge variety of anime out there, some for every possible taste.

      --
      There is no excellent beauty that hath not some strangeness in the proportion. -- Francis Bacon
    18. Re:I mean well.. by BerkeleyBull · · Score: 1

      http://www.rightstuf.com/resource/resource.shtml

      Go to this site for a good history/cultural context primer on anime in Japan and the US.

      BB

    19. Re:I mean well.. by kenl999 · · Score: 1

      No TV series, but check out the book Manga! Manga!: The World of Japanese Comics
      by Frederik L. Schodt, Osamu Tezuka.

    20. Re:I mean well.. by YOU+LIKEWISE+FAIL+IT · · Score: 1
      I've played The Crescent Hawks Inception and the first Mechwarrior to completion,

      Please, in the name of all that is holy, tell me which planets I was supposed to kick over in the Star League Cache! I had the map, but I think I was to young to understand what I was doing.

      --YLFI
      --
      One god, one market, one truth, one consumer.
    21. Re:I mean well.. by YOU+LIKEWISE+FAIL+IT · · Score: 1

      One other thing, if you have the time to read, I would recommend Manga on paper to Anime without hesitation ( although there is some very enjoyable Anime available, such as Cowboy Bebop and the works of Studio Ghibli ). I would suggest Nausicaa, Akira or Lone Wolf And Cub as good places to start.

      LWaC is a particularly interesting piece, set in samurai period Japan. It is perhaps the oldest Manga series still in print, and has a richness of artistic style ( no googly eyes ) and period detail which has yet to be surpassed in my eyes. Darkhorse are currently issuing it in pocketbook format, and while it can be expensive, I recommend it.

      --
      One god, one market, one truth, one consumer.
    22. Re:I mean well.. by king-manic · · Score: 1

      Don't watch what the fanboys love. Don't watch dragon ball Z or GITS. instead watch grave of fireflies.

      --
      "There are more things in heaven and earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy."
    23. Re:I mean well.. by Rysc · · Score: 1

      There hasn't been a good SF series since Star Trek DS9

      Are you fucking kdding me? What about Firefly? Or, if you don't count shows that didn;t make it the full season, try Farscape. Farscape blows away DS9, and a lot of TNG too.

      --
      I want my Cowboyneal
    24. Re:I mean well.. by Zugok · · Score: 1

      Ghost in the Shell didn't impress me either, it didn't have the same feel as the manga. Oshii has a habit of doing that, look at Patlabor 2(which I was however impressed with). Patlabour is supposed to be a comedy and parody of the giant robot genre, but instead it became a thriller.

      Suggestions...if you want to watch something that makes you think "WTF?" then I suggest Millenium Actress and Perfect Blue by Satoshi Kon. Anything from the Studio Ghibli collection is a must, I like the older stuff like Laputa, Totoro, Kiki's delivery Service and Nausicaa myself. Someone mentioned "Grave of Fireflies", I suggest you rent it and not buy it. It's an extremely good movie but it's so depressing you will ever only watch it once. If you can't be bothered with the entire Cowboy Bebop series, just go for the movie.

      --
      "I just can't sit while people are saying nonsense in a meeting without saying it's nonsense" J Watson, Sci Am 288:(4)51
  15. 2nd song in Appleseed trailer ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

    is from the Basement Jaxx album Kish Kash called Good Luck (feat Lisa Kekaula)

    In case anyone wanted to know :D

    1. Re:2nd song in Appleseed trailer ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Any MP3/OGG link? :-)

      Or at the very least, a link to the ITMS?

    2. Re:2nd song in Appleseed trailer ... by Moofie · · Score: 1

      Yup. Only thing cooler than a new Appleseed trailer (I'm a sucker for big robots) is a new Appleseed trailer with a Basement Jaxx song.

      Damn, that's a cool band.

      --
      Why yes, I AM a rocket scientist!
  16. Ghost in the Shell r0x0rz by SphericalCrusher · · Score: 1

    Finally some anime news!

    Ghost in the Shell sequel! w00t! Finally an answer to the cry from all of us anime fanatics.

    --
    "Instant gratification takes too long." - Carrie Fisher
  17. The actual site, for users without quicktime by ffub · · Score: 5, Informative

    The trailer is also available as a Windows Media stream from the official Appleseed site, which also features an introduction to the film and soundtrack info.

    http://www.a-seed.jp

  18. "Innocence" will be out March 6th... by tacarat · · Score: 5, Informative

    It'll be starting on the country wide "Road Show" at a Toho Cinema theater near you. "One Piece", the pirate mange/anime, also has a movie starting at the same time. I'm hoping it'll be a double feature (in my dreams, incompatible demographics). 1700yen (US$16-17) for a regular showing is expensive. I really miss getting ripped off at American theaters. The japanese ones I've seen are generally nicer, but the snack bar prices are about double for half.

    I wonder if that's how they subsidize rebuilding Tokyo everytime Godzilla attacks?
    ----------

    --
    "Common sense will be the death of us all"
    1. Re:"Innocence" will be out March 6th... by cmsnell · · Score: 0

      Tell me about it. The seating is generally great, but I could never get used to the pre-packaged bag of popcorn. Sometimes I'm actually glad I moved back home.

    2. Re:"Innocence" will be out March 6th... by BJH · · Score: 2, Informative

      You've got a couple of alternatives for cheaper seats.

      Cinemas usually offer advance ticket sales (for example, Innocence tickets are available for 1,300 yen at Lawson convenience stores).

      If you go on the official Movie Day, you can usually get in for 1,000 yen. This sometimes doesn't apply for popular movies, and it varies between movie chains and areas, but it's usually the first of each month (in the areas around Tokyo) or the first Wednesday of each month (within Tokyo), except for January and December.

    3. Re:"Innocence" will be out March 6th... by bugbread · · Score: 1

      Little info for you Slashdotters who haven't been to a Japanese movie theater: the new ones are generally nice and clean, like upscale theaters in the U.S. Old theaters tend to be pits. Old theaters have standing room tickets, so popular movies / opening nights will have people sitting in the aisles. Beer is sold at all movie theaters (I'm sure there's an exception somewhere, of course). And, best thing: there is no policy against bringing in food / drinks.

  19. whaa??? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    I thought GitS TV was pretty cool! The beginning was kind of slow but then it got really awesome (I love the whole Laughing Man concept).

  20. optical camouflage by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    oh yes...

    did you also hear about the research at toyko university dept of electro-communication?

    http://csdl.computer.org/comp/proceedings/ismar/ 20 03/2006/00/20060348.pdf

    the productionig crew are quite ahead in addressing the idea of when the distinction between humans and computers have infinitely blurred... than many media forms

  21. Tech + Chicks + Anime = Profit by Lipongo · · Score: 0, Redundant

    The perfect forumula to create a large sum of cash.
    I know I'll be seeing it.

    --
    -Certified TechnoWeinie
  22. yeah but ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    where did all the zeppelins, "shoulder fired" super
    lasers and mega portable fusion reactors go?

  23. Don't forget it's based on the manga. by oujirou · · Score: 2, Interesting

    One may find it very interesting to read the original manga, of which Dark Horse had made quite a nice translation several years ago (with the infamous Three Lesbian Pages out, but who does really care?).

    First of all, Shirow began drawing Kokaku Kidoutai (the original name of GITS) back in 1989, the last years of Soviet Union. The plot is heavily based on the Soviet intrigue, not without the funniest blops, like calling an aircraft carrier Pirozhki, which means Patties. Note that the Soviets line was not featured anywhere else but the original manga, although in Standalone Complex and the following series both opening songs are in a strange Russian-English language mix and are sung by a Russian actress Olga Yakovleva.

    Yeah, and the manga also features Annapuma and Unipuma "The Famous Catgirls" from the very Shirow's Dominion. :)

    --

    ___
    On Slashdot, Russians comment on YOU!
    1. Re:Don't forget it's based on the manga. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      ...not without the funniest blops, like calling an aircraft carrier Pirozhki, which means Patties.

      I think Shirow was well aware of what that means, considering the Japanized form of the word is used to describe the same food in Japanese. It was meant to be humorous, I imagine.

  24. Re:When is the US distribution date? by BJH · · Score: 2, Informative

    I had a look through the official site, including an interview with the director, and they never touched upon an overseas release, so I'd guess that you'll have to wait a while longer...

  25. It's the same as any genre by HarveyBirdman · · Score: 1
    There's some good anime, and a lot of not so good, just like any media genre. There's a lot of variety as well (it really not all schoolgirls and giant robots). If you've really only seen three or so films, that's hardly a fair sampling.

    I'd actually agree with you on Ghost In The Shell. I thought it was visually interesting, had some good ideas, but is a little overrated in my opinion.

    If you are really interested, there's about a billion fan sites on the web that can point you toward good films and series. Some may also have some historical stuff.

    We're also in a time when there is a lot of anime on US television. For free (if you already have Cartoon Netowrk) try to catch some episodes of Cowboy Bebop. It's a straightforward, semi-realistic near future SF series. Takes place entirely within the Solar System. They have a form of hypersace travel, but it really just cuts interplanetary travel time down to a few hours, and requires an elaborate gate system. There's terraformed worlds. Sections of ships rotate to simulate gravity. The world is gritty. There's terrorists and crime syndicates. The Earth is a complete mess (although I won't give away why). Good stuff.

    It's the first anime series I liked enough to go and buy the DVD boxed set. It also made me unable to watch Enterprise because the Enterprise crew seemed like such a pack of whiney pussies compared to the characters on Bebop. :) Enterprise has hand-wringing. Bebop has space stations dedicated entirely to casinos. :-D

    --
    --- Ban humanity.
  26. I just wish he'd finish writing Appleseed by Dixie_Flatline · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Appleseed, in my opinion, was always a better story than Ghost in the Shell. GitS was pretty superficial, jumped around a lot, and now suffers from a massive incomprehensibility complex, not unlike one of his other manga, Orion.

    Frankly, I also enjoyed his art more before he started doing this blend of CG and penciling.

    I hope this anime lives up to the manga. That's tough, but I already recognized parts of the story in the trailer, and it certainly looks pretty. I also hope that they get some decent voice acting for Deunan and Briareos. I have an idea of what their voices should be like in my head, and if Deunan ends up with a bimbo-y voice, and Briareos has a whiny bishonen voice, I'll be pretty sad.

    1. Re:I just wish he'd finish writing Appleseed by Locus+Mote · · Score: 1

      CAN I GET AN AMEN! ;-)

      (Personally, I always felt like he shied away from digging into a storyline a deep as Appleseed when he was writing GitS. My guess is that he waded into the Appleseed storyline and he wove it too densely to extricate himself from it. Now he can't just tie up all the loose ends quickly and end it. So with GitS, he has a modular storyline that he can end and continue as he pleases, but it comes off as being less immersive and substantively real.)

    2. Re:I just wish he'd finish writing Appleseed by WoodenRobot · · Score: 1

      I have to say that even though Appleseed - which started off with his early style of drawing, which isn't very good compared to the stuff he does now - it beats the crap out of the latest GITS:MMI. Although I bought and read them all, MMI was a let down for me. All it seemed to be was an excuse for an overly obscure plot populated by (unnecessarily) scantily clad women. It certainly had a feel of 'dirty old man' about it IMHO, and kind of put me off his work. This trailer, though, looks amazing.

      --
      ---
      "I did nothing. I did absolutely nothing and it was everything that I thought it could be."
  27. Torrents of Both Trailers by AIX-Hood · · Score: 4, Informative
    1. Re:Torrents of Both Trailers by wowbagger · · Score: 1

      The Ghost in the shell torrent is busted.

    2. Re:Torrents of Both Trailers by Samhaine · · Score: 1

      Strange, considering I'm watching the download right now...

    3. Re:Torrents of Both Trailers by wowbagger · · Score: 1

      When I do the download on the GiS I get an invalid data received message.

      The Appleseed went through quite nicely.

  28. Acutally... by HarveyBirdman · · Score: 1

    ...the Wachowski brothers list Serial Experiment Lain as a major influence. TechTV currently has it in their Anime Unleashed rotation. I've see both Ghost and Lain, and I'd have to agree that Lain is the clearer influence.

    --
    --- Ban humanity.
    1. Re:Acutally... by John+Harrison · · Score: 2, Insightful
      I showed GitS to a friend this weekend. He just kept saying, "Oh wow, they stole that shot/idea for The Matrix."

      I'll have to check out Lain, but it is pretty clear that GitS was influentian. As an example notice how the agent lands on the roof of the building, cracking the tiles underneath him, holding his gun at the side of his head.

      There is also a lot of discussion about the nature of reality and things plugging into the back of people's heads. Also arguments about whether an AI is a sentient entity, though that is more from the Zion Archives stuff on the Animatrix.

    2. Re:Acutally... by Zerth · · Score: 1

      Yah, the agent/GitS shot was mentioned in one of the specials. I think it was keanu that mentioned it(why is he only animated when he isn't acting?!)

    3. Re:Acutally... by John+Harrison · · Score: 1

      I remember thinking it when I saw The Matrix for the first time in the theater. I mentioned it to my wife on the way out and she not only didn't remember the scene (in either movie) but thought I was crazy. She probably thinks that most days.

    4. Re:Acutally... by Mac+Degger · · Score: 1

      They might say that, but the Matrix misses most, if not very nearly all, of Lain's themes, yet does nick some of GitS' themes. As for art direction and cinematography, that's all from GitS...no Lain in sight...unless you count the matrix's computers looking just a tiny bit like Lain's overgrown navi (the one she 'case modded' :)).

      --
      -- Waht? Tehr's a preveiw buottn?
    5. Re:Acutally... by Omega996 · · Score: 1

      Sieg Zion!!

      er

      Sieg Zeon!

    6. Re:Acutally... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's all stolen from Asimov and other great SciFi authors. I Robot.

  29. Big Eyes by HarveyBirdman · · Score: 2, Interesting
    Someone was asking about the big eyes. It's just a stylistic thing. Some anime creators use it, some don't. One thing I've noticed is that the eye size is inversely proportional to the character's age. Young grils will have big eyes, but older women will have more normal eyes, but this isn't a hard rule.

    One a mildly related note, realdoll.com now has an anime doll (named Annie Mae... sheesh...) with pink hair and big blue eyes. I dunno... it just looks creepy to me. I've seen other attempts to do realistic images of big-eyed anime women, and it just gets disturbing. Although the same could be said about a Picasso. :) Some things should stay in the world of art.

    --
    --- Ban humanity.
    1. Re:Big Eyes by cmsnell · · Score: 0

      One explanation for the eyes, that I've heard, is that it is easier to show emotions using bigger eyes. It allows more exaggeration of facial expressions, making sure that the animators intent comes through in a clear fashion.

    2. Re:Big Eyes by Locus+Mote · · Score: 2, Informative

      The big eyes are actually an artifact left over from animation from the United States in the 30s and 40s (Think, Felix the Cat). The Japanese saw our big eyed animation and loved the expressiveness of it. Like our automotive industry in the early 80s, they took our idea, refined and improved upon it and sent it back across the ocean to us. : )

  30. Eh by HarveyBirdman · · Score: 1

    I think it's just inevitable genre similarities, and movie makers borrow all the time. It's no big deal. In fact, there's many anime scenes where I think it would be fun to see someone try to do a live action version.

    --
    --- Ban humanity.
    1. Re:Eh by UWC · · Score: 1

      And with the Smith/Neo fight at the end of Revolutions, we now know that a live-action Dragonball Z is possible.

    2. Re:Eh by Chris+Burke · · Score: 4, Funny

      And with the Smith/Neo fight at the end of Revolutions, we now know that a live-action Dragonball Z is possible.

      And also thanks to the Smitch/Neo fight at the end of Revolutions, we now know that a live-action Dragonball Z would totally, totally suck.

      --

      The enemies of Democracy are
    3. Re:Eh by YomikoReadman · · Score: 1

      Thanks to the live action DBZ released 10 years ago, we know that it did, really, really suck.

      --
      I have no regrets, this is the only path.
      My whole life has been "UNLIMITED BLADE WORKS"
    4. Re:Eh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And unfortunatly, on the way... ANN article.

    5. Re:Eh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      In I think episode 5 or 6 of Cowboy Beebop there's a scene of pillars being shot out in a church while the protagonist runs along that's repeated almost frame for frame in The Matrix; presumably a deliberate tribute.

    6. Re:Eh by Kaboom13 · · Score: 1

      not surprising, considering animated Dragonball Z fights totally, totally suck.

  31. Old Gits by Hieronymus+Howard · · Score: 1

    Did anyone else in the UK think of the Harry Enfield's hilarious "Old Gits" on seeing "GitS Sequel"?

    ALF GIT: When's the funeral?

    FRED GIT: Today.

    ALF GIT: Good! Are they gonna burn him or bury him?

    FRED GIT: Up the chimney.

    ALF GIT: Yeah, that's how I'd like to go, have my ashes scattered in the old back garden - when her next door's got her washing out.

    FRED GIT: Take her weeks to get you out of her knickers.

  32. Re:real? by frankmanowar · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Is keeping it real the 'most' important thing? In being willing to dwell in the fantastic, one can be said to be exploring the reality of human nature.

    I'm going to invoke the big one: "Neon Genesis Evangelion," and submit that sure Hideki Anno and Co. are presenting larger than life humanoid artificial life things, and man is trying to play god, but isn't that always the case? Isn't the frailty of life and the human heart the story they are trying to tell - rather than 'oh big robots! cool!'.

    The first "Ghost in the Shell" was a little hard to follow seeon once, but I certainly got a lot more from it watching it again and reflecting than what you are describing above.

    --

    "Other bands play, but Manowar KILLS"
  33. Maybe... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...he meant it in the sense that Plato was the shadow cast by Socrates against the cave wall?

    Aw, fuck it. GearheadX is just a moron.

    1. Re:Maybe... by GearheadX · · Score: 1

      No.. that's just me before coffee in the morning. You caught me. It WAS Socrates.

  34. Dominion Tank Police! w00t! by frankmanowar · · Score: 1

    The very first anime I was exposed to! Late night on Sci-Fi Channel. I dind't know that Shirow did that as well!

    I've been hooked since. Nothing on my television to that point had been quite as awesome or ridiculous and fascinating.

    --

    "Other bands play, but Manowar KILLS"
    1. Re:Dominion Tank Police! w00t! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The weird thing about DTP is that it's actually an 'origin story' for Shirow's manga, which drops you in halfway through the story with no explanations and leaves you to figure out what the hell's going on! Good fun, though - I think it was the third anime (not counting Westernised stuff like Marine Boy and Battle Of The Planets) I ever saw, after Akira and Bubblegum Crisis. Buaku's anti-tank 'dildo mines' were inspired lunacy...

  35. GitS 2 trailer (subtitled) (BitTorrent link) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    A Ghost in the Shell 2 trailer that is actually subtitled can be found here (~55MB, 6min, XviD video format):

    http://a.scarywater.net/hawks/[haWks-DisTrO]Ghos t_ in_the_Shell_-_Innocence_Trailer_(ExtendedHQ)[Koto noha].avi.torrent

    1. Re:GitS 2 trailer (subtitled) (BitTorrent link) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      A Ghost in the Shell 2 trailer that is actually subtitled can be found here (~55MB, 6min, XviD video format):

      http://a.scarywater.net/hawks/[haWks-DisTrO]Ghos t_ in_the_Shell_-_Innocence_Trailer_(ExtendedHQ)[Koto noha].avi.torrent

      um, there should be no space in the word 'Kotonoha' in that link. I don't know why the post submission window is inserting one automatically. might be easier to just go to http://a.scarywater.net/hawks/ and just click the link there.

  36. bad timing by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    i'm going to japan in the beginning of April, missing both the japanese release of Kill Bill and now the Appleseed remake.


    hopefully GitS will still be in theaters by the time i get there.

  37. And we're getting toys, too! by Mogomra · · Score: 1

    After fifteen years of wishing for one, I'm finally getting a Guges figure. Toycom showed off some prototypes at the recent Toy Fair in NYC. Check out the gallery here.

  38. Re:wha_ I thought I'd do was become one of those.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Yes... Yes they do. But the ending and the wrap up are just too incredible to just blurt on on some discussion board (even on /.).
    As not to flame-bait, I'll just say that you have seen them before (and I'm not talking that 2 min. video clip where the laughing man pulls out a gun during the news cast. The beauty of the ending is how it encompasses all of the side story lines that I though where just there to be entertaining or were just too damn slow as compaired to the rest of the episodes.
    Oh... and if you didn't know, the dead-mute line was taken from "Catcher in the Rye" but slightly changed, and of course Togusa is the only one to notice. Wonder if in any past episodes there were any deaf-mutes worth mentioning? ^_^

    Hit here for the Catcher in the Rye stuff: [destroy-all-monsters.com]

    and you might like this, A Laughing Man logo screensaver: [bandaivisual.co.jp]


    That and the starchild logo was ill...

  39. Apples and oranges by Haeleth · · Score: 1

    Compare the numbers of people watching LoTR who've read the books, with the numbers of people watching GiTS who've read the manga.

    I'd bet a fair sum that the figure will be much higher in the first case.

    1. Re:Apples and oranges by Locus+Mote · · Score: 1

      You are the one who is comparing Apple and Oranges. The reason that Lord of the Rings has such a high readership is because it has existed for more than half a century. The fact is this, you could use the same metaphor with The Shining, for instance. You don't give Stanley Kubrick the credit for writing the novel that Steven King wrote. Period.

  40. Urusei Yatsura by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Given the themes of Oshii's subsequent work (eg: Avalon), one can hardly take the Urusei Yatsura movie to be representative of his work.

    1. Re:Urusei Yatsura by PinkStainlessTail · · Score: 2, Informative

      one can hardly take the Urusei Yatsura movie to be representative of his work.

      Oshii directed sizable chunks of the long running UY TV series as well, and it is my favorite of all his works (possibly my favorite anime series). So yeah UY is a quality representation of Oshii's quality work.

      --
      "Slashdot is about legos and staplers." -Cmdr. Taco
  41. US official site by News+for+nerds · · Score: 5, Informative

    Innocence official US site at Go Fish Pictures (subsidiary of DreamWorks)

    Far less impressive site though, compared to Japanese official site. I doubt their promotion - at least they should spend enough amount of money for web design, as it should cost not so much as "real" PR. Isn't internet for such virtual advertisement?

    Now Japanese official site has gorgeous final trailers in wmv, small/medium/large.

    The theme song, "Follow Me" is by Kimiko Itoh, and the new version of her 1989 jazz hit (English profile here).

  42. There are no big eyes; See the trailer by News+for+nerds · · Score: 1

    Just see this Innocence final Japanese trailer, as there are no such big-eyed characters (pity for you if you can't watch wmv), small [innocence-movie.jp]/medium [innocence-movie.jp]/large

  43. Meh - Gimme GITS: Stand Alone Complex Season 2! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Like others have pointed out - the news about GITS:Innocence is anything but new.

    I'm surprised that few are aware that GITS: Stand Alone Complex can be had in DVD with crumby English.

    What surprises me more is that no one seems to be aware that a second season of GITS: Stand Alone Complex started in the end of January on Japanese TV.

    1. Re:Meh - Gimme GITS: Stand Alone Complex Season 2! by sixpaw · · Score: 2, Informative
      Probably the reason most people aren't aware of the Stand Alone Complex availability is that it isn't a legitimate DVD, but a bootleg produced out of China or Taiwan.
      • Hint #1: you can't generally get a full 26-episode season of an anime legitimately for under $100ish (if not more: see the original prices on the Cowboy Bebop and Trigun box sets).
      • Hint #2: No 'official' release is going to be region-free.
      • Hint #3: no legitimate release is going to squeeze 26 episodes onto 4 DVDs (the box set I saw) and (almost) no official release is going to have english that bad, not in this day and age.
      On the bright side, Cartoon Network has just recently acquired the broadcast rights for GitS:SAC, so legitimate versions will no doubt be coming soon.

      Oh, and for the record, virtually no legitimate anime soundtrack is going to be $10 or even $15 either. There's more information on anime bootlegs here for those who want it.
    2. Re:Meh - Gimme GITS: Stand Alone Complex Season 2! by tempmpi · · Score: 1

      Good post, but for the record you can get legitimate 26-episode series for under $100, just not really new and mainstream stuff like GitS:SAC. See ADV's Princess Nine Boxset for an example of really cheap legimate anime, it is sold for about $40 at several online retailers for the full 26 episode series, otoh it is older and not mainstream as it is a series about Japanese high school girls trying to play in the boys baseball league.

      Official and legimate release are also sometimes regionfree, for example ADV's release of Neon Genesis Evangelion or CPM's release of "Now and Then, Here and There".

      4 Disc for a 26 episode series is also sometimes done, e.g.: Fruits Basket by Funimation or Blue Seed by ADV.

      Deciding if something is bootleged isn't that easy. Regionfree, low disc count and bad english all together is a almost 100% secure check for bootlegs, but some legitimate release are mistoken as a bootleg if you think one fulfilled criteria is enough. If you want to check for bootlegs check for chinese subs and regionfree, that combination is a 99% secure criteria or try if you can find the DVD in a known to be legimate shop. (Amazon isn't if you include external sellers)

      --
      Jan
    3. Re:Meh - Gimme GITS: Stand Alone Complex Season 2! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hint #2: Just as a point, many official CPM releases are region-free, and official. Granted, it wreaks havoc with some software DVD players too, so that may just be a mistake. . . .

  44. ghost in the shell... meh by sbma44 · · Score: 1
    I'll preface this by saying the GitS movie is beautiful, and I haven't read the manga...

    ...but the movie just didn't do much for me. It suffered from the usual problems of adapting a (presumably) sprawling manga into a film. There's no hope of adapting a plotline into the limited space, so they fall back on a shot at noirish, nihilistic plotlessness, hoping that they can get by on being evocative. Akira is another example of this problem. As is Blood: the Last Vampire. All have fascinating universes and mind-blowing art, but suffer from a serious lack of plot.

    I'll take comparatively artless films (although still great) Ninja Scroll and Vampire Hunter D: Bloodlust over hyper-stylized and inscrutable films like GitS anyday.

    1. Re:ghost in the shell... meh by bugbread · · Score: 1

      I can understand your problems with GitS, etc., but Ninja Scroll?!?! That's like saying Mulholland Drive was impenetrable and plotless, so you'd rather watch Battlefield Earth.

  45. Re:wha_ I thought I'd do was become one of those.. by BackwardEngineer · · Score: 1

    that link to the Laughing Man Logo Screensaver doesnt work... any others?

  46. GITS by pragma_x · · Score: 1

    I was one of the lucky few to catch Ghost in the Shell in the theatre (Washington, DC) during its very short-lived film debut in the US. This had to be the best way to see this film, on a hugmongous screen, right when the movie first hits american soil. IMO, Anyone looking to get the DVD should settle for nothing less than wide formatting with Japanese Dialouge, as the TV formatting does it no justice.

    So, does anyone out there know if Innocence might see a theatre-film debut?

  47. Does anyone know if there's any relation between.. by sixpaw · · Score: 1

    ...GitS: Innocence and the recent manga (published in the US by Dark Horse), GitS: Fan Serv-- errr, GitS: Man-Machine Interface?

  48. Watch Cowboy Bebop by SuperBanana · · Score: 1
    Alternatively, I begin to suspect that anime is to film what trance is to music.

    Watch Cowboy Bebop, and you'll realize anime is an art form up with all the rest. Anime is like any other media; there's complete, utter crap(One Piece, Dragonball Z), and then fantastic stuff(Spirited Away for example). The Japanese take anime -very- seriously as an art form. I have not met a single person who hasn't liked Cowboy Bebop(as long as they got beyond the "anime is a cartoon" misconception), and it is widely considered one of the best series ever made; it's currently ranked #4 on Animenfo.com out of series, OVAs(miniseries, very high quality production) and movies. The movie was also excellent, but should be watched before you finish the series....I think early 20's is where you're supposed to watch it.

    Bebop has probably 4-6 HOURS of soundtrack music for a 13 hour show...by one of the greatest anime soundtrack producers ever(Yoko Kanno). There are something like 7 soundtrack CDs released(although there was a lot of duplication between them). CB has everything- jazz, funk, classical, opera(Ave Maria, absolutely beautifully done btw), even a heavy metal song or two.

    I've watched a great deal of anime over the years, and Bebop is still solidly at #1 on my list; nothing else compares; overall plot, each episode's strength on its own, character design, animation, and of course the soundtrack. Sure, it's the future- but there's very little use of technology for plot-fixing. There is an overall running plot to the whole series, but you never knew what to expect from the next episode. The show plays tribute to many American cultural references(for example, many eps are titled after American songs- Hard Luck Woman is one example) and they snuck in numerous cameos and recurring characters to watch for; you never know who's going to walk by in the background of that marketplace shot.

    It is most -definitely- not for children. It's violent at times, and has very serious undertones despite the fun-loving characters on the surface. In fact, the first episode is shockingly tragic- but like I said, episodes run the gamut from serious to goofy(like the one where everyone eats psychedelic mushrooms by mistake, or the space-alien episode). Stick with it- you'll gain a new appreciation.

    GITS Stand Alone Complex wins on my list for some similar reasons- it also has a soundtrack by Yoko Kanno, and episodes vary; there's a very serious episode about a criminal who records murder victim's vision+hearing while he kills them, but there's also an heartwarming episode about one of the AI-equipped tanks(Tachikomas- think of a tank with the personality of a little kid and curiosity of a cat- weird combo for, well, a tank :)...which sneaks out on a trip exploring the city one day when nobody's looking, and meets a little girl looking for her lost dog...

    1. Re:Watch Cowboy Bebop by Rysc · · Score: 1

      The movie was also excellent, but should be watched before you finish the series....I think early 20's is where you're supposed to watch it.

      The movie is chronologically between episodes 22 and 23.

      --
      I want my Cowboyneal
  49. Appleseed was good in the beginning. . . by Fantastic+Lad · · Score: 1
    Appleseed was fantastic in the beginning. And then. . .

    How far did you read? I found by the time it got into book 4, Shirow had descended into bullshit politico-speak, seemingly in the hopes of sounding as though he had something important to say.

    All I cared about were Deunan and Bri and what would happen in their lives, but the story slipped away from that, and they seemed to lose their spark. Shirow got lost in the world building and forgot that the average reader doesn't care AT ALL about the back-room gear-workings of his environment. It's the difference between reading the "Lord of the Rings" and the "Silmarilion." --Except that the Silmarilion wasn't a half-assed mess.

    Perhaps if Shirow focused more on developing the souls of his characters and his world rather than on illustrating a bunch of poster-girls, he'd have become a real story teller. As it is, he's just an exhibitionist who probably knows deep in the night just how much he sucks.


    -FL

    1. Re:Appleseed was good in the beginning. . . by Dixie_Flatline · · Score: 1

      I own all of them. I read and love them all. Book 4 was a bit disjointed, but I think it showed good development for both Deunan and Bri. The closing scene of book 4 with Deunan in a lace eyepatch planning some time with Bri was a nice look into their private lives. I wish he'd do more, though. I think he ended the series right as it was getting really good.

      I'm worried now, though. If he does start writing it again, will it suffer from the same random complexity that GitS does? Will he focus on his blended CG & pencil style that I think looks far cheaper than his raw pencil art? Probably. Even if he just tied everything up in a quick 2 part series I'd be a little happier.

  50. Three things. . . by Fantastic+Lad · · Score: 1
    1. The bulk of anime DOES suck. You're not the crazy one in the room. The truth is that 99% of the crazed fans in the West have their pleasure centers jacked directly into the Eastern cartoon design philosophy. It's like crack.

    2. Studio Ghibli. Look them up, watch their movies. "It's so good, it's no longer Anime." Disney distributes their works.

    3. Perspective. When you're a highschool kid there's something very exciting about the kinds of stories and the lives of the characters presented in Anime. Role models in the West are idiotic and depressing. "Friends" "Survivor" "Britney Spears". Limiting garbage. Anime, by contrast, presents entire worlds, and whole fleets of characters exploring every issue under the sun, and all from a Saturday Morning Cartoon level of maturity, which is entirely appealing and appropriate for young teens, who are by definition, immature. Think Saturday Morning Cartoons but cubed, done with a budget by people who can actually draw, and zero breakfast cereal tie-ins. I'd have loved to have had access to that when I was 10! Best I got was G-Force and Macross, both of which were awesome at the time, but don't hold anything useful for me as an adult.

    Honestly? Anime has its place. If you don't immediately 'get it', then you probably never will and probably aren't supposed to. If that's the case, then Studio Ghibli will serve you just fine.


    -FL

  51. TV? by sootman · · Score: 1

    I heard ages ago that there was supposed to be a GITS TV show. A bit of googling seems to indicate that season 1 was made & shown in japan. Is that true? Has another season been made? Is season 1 available on DVD?

    --
    Dear Slashdot: next time you want to mess with the site, add a rich-text editor for comments.
    1. Re:TV? by cmsnell · · Score: 0

      Season 1 will be available in the US on dvd starting in late June of this year. Season 2 is currently airing in Japan, and will eventually end up over here. The show is pretty good, being more faithful to the original manga, and having seen the first three episoses of the 2nd season, I can say that it looks to be even better than the first season.

  52. I need Appleseed like a junkie needs smack by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This movie will change everything about anime. Mark my words.

    Moved to tears!

  53. Yay! 3D animation hammers another nail in! by Fantastic+Lad · · Score: 0
    I don'e like 3D animation.

    Anime should be driven by people who can draw. Cool pictures are something I can't make; it's a skill. Cool pictures to me and most people are a sort of magic which enthralls and excites. They have spark! By contrast, I or anybody else can sit down at a PC and with half an effort make our own "Red v.s. Blue" stuff. Poof! The instant you can make the magic yourself, the magic is no longer magic.

    Welcome to the world of souless video game cut scenes. If you can afford the graphics card, then you too can make movies. Hooray.

    Let me dig up a quote here, from "Thieves and Kings" guy, Mark Oakley's website here where he uses a 'Matrix-ism' which stuck in my mind to get his point across. (He was griping about exactly this stuff, though regarding Disney's move in the same 3D direction. His editorial is still up. Oakley's work is scorchingly good, but he's bloody slow! I can't tell if he's got actual talent or if he just gets there by taking his time.) Anyways:

    "Rather like the, Matrix as described by Lawrence Fishbourn's character, the world of 3D animation must obey rules, and as such, it creates its own limitations. --Whereas 2D animation is limited only by the imagination.

    Think about that crazy 'baby and rabbit in the kitchen' cartoon at the beginning of, Who Framed Roger Rabbit?. Unless you start animating via Photoshop or Flash, (both 2D tools), you will simply never get a computer to achieve those same kinds of effects. Remember? --Black and white kitchen floor tiles soaring over the screen at ten thousand miles per hour, flying babies and rabbits, kitchen implements, irons and creamed carrots hurtling through a universe which a 3D animation program couldn't even begin to rationally comprehend. --But which the human mind can embrace as easily and as naturally as understanding laughter. Human minds are so much more!"

    Shirow's work always seemed kind of souless to me, so maybe this move is appropriate.


    -FL

  54. spelling nazi by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    it is supposed to be spelled masta killah

  55. Soooo.. Old.... by shish · · Score: 1
    ll ~/torrents
    ...
    -rw-r--r-- 1 18MB Jan 4 19:42 GitS_Innocence_Trailer.avi
    ...
    -rw-r--r-- 1 15MB Feb 15 19:30 Appleseed_2004_Trailer.avi
    ...

    They are *so* going to kill me for this (the /.ing), but here's some links (.avi / XViD/DivX encoded, IIRC). I have 3 GitS trailers on various CDs, but I can't find the .torrents...

    Appleseed
    Innocence

    --
    I mod down anyone who says "I will be modded down for this", regardless of the rest of their comment
  56. Ugh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    If you can afford the graphics card, then you too can make movies.

    If you can afford the pencils and paper, you can make your own hand drawn anime.
    Maybe you DO have a "skill" for drawing 2D cartoons. Maybe you DO like 2D animation better. In that case, more power to you; keep watching and/or making your 2D anime.

    I, on the other hand, have (some) skill for creating and animating 3D models. I like most 3-D animated movies, and I feel that Pixar's animation is much better than Disney's, for example. I also think that Appleseed looks absolutely gorgeous - better than your average anime, though I do enjoy 2-D anime as well.

    Just because you dislike 3-D animation doesn't mean that it's "soulless." Just because one specific scene couldn't be done in 3-D animation (I doubt that fact, but haven't seen RR so will assume for the purposes of this post that you're right) doesn't mean 3-D animation sucks. I can name a list of things that would be pretty much impossible with traditional animation that 3-D animation accomplishes effortlessly. (Or, I could just link you to the Appleseed trailer.) Stop trolling, grow up, and realize that not everyone in the world has the same tastes as you.

  57. Shaolin soccer by Nicolay77 · · Score: 1

    With the scenes in that movie, I really saw that a Goku movie could be done. Really, the scenes go from mr bean humor, to captain subasa football to dragon ball Z football and it's totally freaking fun.

    --
    We are Turing O-Machines. The Oracle is out there.
  58. Try everything at once... by Bluskale · · Score: 1

    Also useful might be watching with English dub and with English subtitles, and take whichever one sounds best for the moment. Wouldn't be good for everything tho... wouldn't pass up original audio for Trigun, for instance.

  59. What it says in Japanese by kuriharu · · Score: 1

    The preview calls it "another beauty and the beast", among other things it says.

  60. Not trolling, just expressing my opinion. by Fantastic+Lad · · Score: 1
    And I think that 2D provides a more vivid, broader canvas for animators to work upon than 3D, which, while it can achieve much visual flash and wonder, is nonetheless, self-limiting in very fundamental ways.

    It has its place, as all things do, but I cannot get very excited by the prospect of 3D eating up all the funding and the talent which was once reserved for 2D works. --Not when the change is to increase the superficial elements at the expense of flexibility and imagination. Technically, a 2D animator can do anything a 3D animator can do. The reverse isn't true, though. Think about that! And this has an effect upon the viewer as well. Watch enough of 3D stuff, think in 3D enough, and certain possibilities begin to fade from one's awareness. Fading possibilities is a scary thing to me. It's not so much about taste as it is about limiting our ways of seeing and thinking!

    Now, I admit, I don't really have any stake in the matter as it sounds as though you may, so I'm just shooting my mouth off whereas for you it probably means your livelihood. But that doesn't change the fact. And the fact is that after having grown up watching animations which were not limited, I do not like viewing something which makes me feel so suddenly contained. It always feels as though something is missing, not added with 3D.

    Perhaps the answer can be found in a hybrid of the two. I've seen some movies which incorporate the strengths of both. Those seem to work. But pure 'Pixar'. . ? Fine. Whatever. It is what it is. But it isn't a replacement for a proper animation.

    Appleseed, the first book anyway, was a cool comic with a wonderful feel. The 'video game' version, from looking at the trailer, looks like pure surface to me. Cold.


    -FL

  61. No one WANTS to watch GotF - its really sad by Hecatonchires · · Score: 1

    It makes me cry, and then I have to turn it off. Never been able to make it all the way thru.

    --

    Yay me!

  62. English? by johnjay · · Score: 1

    Thanks for the link. I don't suppose there'se a way to see that site in English? I don't know the Appleseed backstory, and I'd be interested to find out.

    The trailer is exciting. A lot of stunning images.

  63. Re:KNOW I BETTER SAY I'D DIDN'T IF by ArekRashan · · Score: 1

    gay, fag you're I think.

  64. See, I don't get that by HarveyBirdman · · Score: 1

    I've seen concrete pillars get shot in movies before there was a Matrix. Not everything is a reference to everything else.

    --
    --- Ban humanity.
  65. Re:wha? I thought I'd do was become one of those.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Sorry the Bandai link was dead, my server is going to hate me for this one...

    www.stupidmammal.net/_tmp/thelaughingman.zip

    -A30N