Slashdot Mirror


Tablet PCs Enter Reality

An anonymous reader writes "It looks like Tablet PCs are finally hitting real-world budgets. Averatec released a Tablet PC with an AMD Athlon XP-M 2200+ processor and will be at Costco and Staples for $1349. Here is a link to a photo overview where you can see how the pen snaps into the LCD area when not in use, what the touchpad looks like, and quite a few other pictures." Element Computer seems to have radically changed their business model -- I had hoped they'd succeed with their $999 VIA-based tablet.

297 comments

  1. Ok, but... by Zeroth_darkos · · Score: 1

    is it possible to run linux (reasonably well) on them yet?

    1. Re:Ok, but... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Who cares?

    2. Re:Ok, but... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      People who don't want to use shitty Microsoft software?

    3. Re:Ok, but... by palironsat · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Ummmm...check the link to the $999 Tablet PC. at the end of the writeup.

      Isn't Lycoris Linux? Okay, maybe it's no Gentoo, but I'm sure it could do the job just fine. =P

    4. Re:Ok, but... by Zeroth_darkos · · Score: 1

      You're right... but I wonder how well hand-recognition and such things work.

    5. Re:Ok, but... by foidulus · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Well, how well does the handwriting recognition work(if it is even there at all, i saw no mention of it)
      To me anyway, the allure of a tablet pc would be that you can write on it. MS software, from what I have read anyway, is pretty nice in recognizing handwriting.
      Apple appearently has had some handwriting recognition stuff included since 10.2, but has yet to really do anything with it.
      I guess they haven't seen a worthwhile market for tablet pcs yet, or are still smarting over Newton....

    6. Re:Ok, but... by networkBoy · · Score: 1

      It's always been possible to run linux on them.
      I honestly wonder why this (tablet PCs) is only now such a big deal. I love both of mine (Fujitsu Stylistic LT old model) these both have 486 DX4-100 CPUs with LiIon batteries and boot from compact flash (type3 PCMCIA really but I use CF and an adapter). All in all I love both of mine. One is an uber remote (B&W model), while the other is a portable network monitor (color model) and with solid state disk storage these things are indestructable.
      -nB

      --
      whois gawk date unzip strip find touch finger mount join nice man top fsck grep eject more yes exit umount sleep dump
    7. Re:Ok, but... by Weirdofreak · · Score: 1

      My school has some. We hardly ever (read: don't, unless we're cool) get to use them (I did because I was taking part in a national maths final thingie and needed to research cyclic quadrilaterals), but they're cool nonetheless. Only problem is, I couldn't work out how to access Firefox from them. And the keyboards were way too small, with mis-proportioned keys.

    8. Re:Ok, but... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      ...and who would rather use much more shitty Linux software because it makes them feel superior.

    9. Re:Ok, but... by Archfeld · · Score: 1
      Waste of Money, if you want handwriting get an attached usb pen tablet, better yet use a digital recorder, cheaper, smaller, much easier to use, and if you have just a wee bit of control you can sub-vocalize for them and record you own notes in your own words and voice while the lecture/meeting is onging. Table PC's lock up even more than the average MS product, not that they can't code but they don't communicate internally, and the touch screens BLOW for life span, the hinges fail under a FIERCE GLARE. As for 'handwriting recognition' most don't. OCR is an EXTRA FEATURE, that is at best tricky and unreliable. Heck even the voice recognition stuff in Office XP, though will lacking in polish is MUCH more useable and functional. Having seen, and serviced several incarnations of these, errr poorly conceived unique messes, I'd rather not have to deal with them again.
      TECHNOLOGY IS NOT THE FUTURE, PEOPLE ARE. It just seems that tech is the focus because we ARE SO BAD AT IT. When all is said and done, the TECHNOLOGY we push, has NOT made life easier, simpler, or in many cases safer or EVEN more enjoyable, and until it is as ubiquitious and simple as a lightbulb, it will still be wasted effort.
      --
      errr....umm...*whooosh* *whoosh* Is this thing on ?
  2. /.'ed by dago · · Score: 1, Funny

    2 comments and already slashdotted ... somebody took the tablet pc hosting the DB to his home apparently...

    --
    #include "coucou.h"
    1. Re:/.'ed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      the server was slashdoted so bad they even misspelled "initialization".

  3. We are not impressed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Oh wow, I sure am glad I can spend over $1000 to buy something that offers no services over a pda that I would want to use on the go. Unless of course you're talking about laptop-type activities, in which case, the laptop is the natural choice..

    1. Re:We are not impressed by Stevyn · · Score: 1

      These aren't meant to replace PDA's or regular laptops. I haven't done the market research, but I'm sure there are niche markets for these. That would explain the higher price. I'm interested in seeing where this goes in the future.

    2. Re:We are not impressed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Obviously you're not in the graphic arts. It's kinda hard to ink and do fine detail work with a mouse, especially on a laptop.

      Troll somewhere else.

    3. Re:We are not impressed by cmallinson · · Score: 1
      Oh wow, I sure am glad I can spend over $1000 to buy something that offers no services over a pda that I would want to use on the go. Unless of course you're talking about laptop-type activities, in which case, the laptop is the natural choice.

      Yeah, 'cause if you don't like it, Mr. AC, then it must be CRAP. I have wanted these to evolve into a reasonably priced product for a while now. It would be nice to be able to pull something out of a bag, and type(write) out a letter, or watch a TV program while on the bus with relative ease. Laptops are great, but tablets have some flexibility that a laptop does not offer. Also, tablets, I have found, are more socially accepted in meetings than laptops, as they do not create a visual barrier.

    4. Re:We are not impressed by Stone316 · · Score: 1
      I can't get to the article but frankly I don't see much use for a tablet PC for general use. For some industries they may fit their needs perfect and for surfing the web they may be fine. But if i'm carrying around something the size of a laptop i'm going to want a keyboard to type.

      I have a PDA and its painfull to use a stylus or the little keyboard map to type in messages. Maybe they integrate those virtual keyboards into them.. then if you want to type all you have to do is find a flat surface.

      --
      "Thanks to the remote control I have the attention span of a gerbil."
    5. Re:We are not impressed by PhoenixOne · · Score: 2, Funny
      >Oh wow, I sure am glad I can spend over $1000 to buy something that offers no services over a pda that I would want to use on the go
      >
      I don't know about you, but the fact that it is many times larger then a PDA and runs all my apps/games is a good enough selling point (at least for me to buy one used off eBay ;)).

      Oh, and the fact that "chicks dig tablets!" for some reason. I can't use the thing for more then 10 minutes without some lady asking "Ohhhh, what's that?". Try that with your little Palm Pilot. ;)

      --
      Spell cheek you've failed me four the last thyme!
    6. Re:We are not impressed by Donoho · · Score: 3, Interesting

      ...offers no services over a pda that I would want to use on the go. Unless of course you're talking about laptop-type activities, in which case, the laptop is the natural choice.

      I almost agree. Despite the hype thrown behind the tablet PC, I consider it to be, at best, an evolution of the laptop. That's not a bad thing.

      I bought the Toshiba Protege M200 when it came out and was really excited. Within a couple of months, I was using only it's laptop functionality 90% of the time. However, it's that 10% that keeps things interesting. A tablet has capabilities beyond that of existing laptops which opens doors to interactions that just weren't possible before. Alias Sketchbook Pro rocks! I'm excited about that untapped potential. My Treo 600 can record voice,(crappy) video, and act as a webcam now. It couldn't do that when I bought it.

      Don't even bother asking about why one would need X to do Y when you've got A, B & C. For me it's about exploring the possibilities.

      Some day the line between laptop and tablet will be nonexistant. Until then, save your money unless you're interested in helping that future get here a day or two sooner. Someone's got to be an early adopter. I can't wait for a Linux Tablet, which is made increasingly probable by lower priced hardware. Sometimes the slow, steady progress just isn't that impressive.

    7. Re:We are not impressed by cmacb · · Score: 1

      "Yeah, 'cause if you don't like it, Mr. AC, then it must be CRAP. I have wanted these to evolve into a reasonably priced product for a while now."

      Yeah, but do you consider $1300+ reasonable?

      I don't. Even full featured laptops are down below $1000 now. When I can go into a retail store and find one of these things that are on display for the public to play with and not BROKEN, I'll think about it. Otherwise, for a device that is likely to have to be thrown away every few years (what's your guess about how the warrantee horror stories will be like on these?) maybe a $349 price tag would be more appropriate.

      This thing is just a gimmick to sell a new version of Windows, and I bet MS chips into the advertising budgets for any hardware maker willing to go out on a limb making them.

      I'd rather see palmtops and desktop (or conventional laptop) systems work together to provide the flexibility (and then some) of these things.

    8. Re:We are not impressed by McAddress · · Score: 1
      Oh, and the fact that "chicks dig tablets!" for some reason. I can't use the thing for more then 10 minutes without some lady asking "Ohhhh, what's that?". Try that with your little Palm Pilot. ;)

      proof once again that size really does matter.

    9. Re:We are not impressed by hitmark · · Score: 1

      and with the docking station for that toshiba you can even use it as a overgrown lcd screen :)

      man i just wish there was a way to build laptops like you build a stationary pc...

      --
      comment first, facts later. http://chem.tufts.edu/AnswersInScience/RelativityofWrong.htm
    10. Re:We are not impressed by Aerog · · Score: 1

      Truth be told, if I had the cash I'd be snapping one of these up in no time. The biggest use that I've found for a tablet is during meetings with co-workers. As an engineer, I find myself drawing diagrams to explain things all the time. Being able to just draw on the screen to do this or to explain a drawing would be great! Plus, once you're finished drawing said explanation, if you need it you can save a screenshot or just erase the drawing and move on. Plus it saves a whole mess of paper that I'd just lose anyway.

      The important reason for the pen isn't so much as a replacement for a keyboard, rather as a way to enhance what's already on the scren, or to make quick additions to already-existing files to be changed at a later date. Of course, that this one has a keyboard is another bonus. Type when it's faster, then take the stylus and touch the document up to be fixed later. It's sort of like a Smart Board but portable, and a lot cheaper.

      Believe me, I'm tempted to spend the extra money to get one of these when I next get a new computer. (Potentially in addition to a desktop). With so many employers giving out company notebooks, it would be the next logical step, as I see it.

      Although, I can see this may not be for everybody, just like PDA's aren't for everybody.

      --

      - Relativistic? That's barely Newtonian!
    11. Re:We are not impressed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Also, tablets, I have found, are more socially accepted in meetings than laptops, as they do not create a visual barrier.

      Dude, hiding behind a laptop at a meeting may just save you from being downsized in the Bush economy.

    12. Re:We are not impressed by antek9 · · Score: 1
      Oh, and the fact that "chicks dig tablets!" for some reason.


      Confirmed.
      --
      A World in a Grain of Sand / Heaven in a Wild Flower,
      Infinity in the Palm of your Hand / And Eternity in an Hour.
    13. Re:We are not impressed by billcopc · · Score: 2, Funny

      Good lord get out of the computing business!

      You've obviously never relied on a laptop for anything beyond email/pr0n. I've been cursing my excellent Inspiron for over a year now "because it's not a tablet PC". For the true road warriors out there like myself, the revolving touchscreen is a godsend. It just opens up the media possibilities.

      Here's a few things I do often that would be so much nicer on a Tablet PC: ebooks, note-taking / updating my road logbook, GPS navigation, graphic/web design, movies/music.. anything that doesn't need the keyboard becomes 10x more convenient with the flip-display.

      But if you do fall in that 90% of people who have a laptop just for kicks, well you could play one hell of a game a Bejeweled on the touchscreen :)

      --
      -Billco, Fnarg.com
    14. Re:We are not impressed by mollymoo · · Score: 1
      [...] if i'm carrying around something the size of a laptop i'm going to want a keyboard to type.

      They have got keyboards. At least, the $999 one mentioned in the FA does. You can use it like a regular laptop when you need a keyboard.

      --
      Chernobyl 'not a wildlife haven' - BBC News
    15. Re:We are not impressed by captainClassLoader · · Score: 1


      "Chicks dig tablets!" --Moses, after that life-changing mountain climbing incident.

      (Yeah, that'll probably buy me a "-5 Blasphemous" from somebody, but what the hell...)

      --
      "The plural of anecdote is not data" -- Bruce Schneier
    16. Re:We are not impressed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      I haven't done the market research, but I'm sure there are niche markets for these
      I'm jealous. Why don't the magic voices talk to me?
    17. Re:We are not impressed by Hognoxious · · Score: 1

      I think the brief was to produce something with the power of a laptop and the price of a PDA, but the message got slightly confused somewhere along the line.

      --
      Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
    18. Re:We are not impressed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Dude, hiding behind a laptop at a meeting may just save you from being downsized in the Bush economy.

      Oh goodness gracious, you are most very very mistaken my dear chap. I was not being downsized at all, and I am hiding behind my jolly old laptop right now in sunny old Calcutta.

  4. Re:Ok by Zeroth_darkos · · Score: 1

    I think the amount of subscribers nowadays actually is enough to have some slashdot-effect.

  5. Gateway by halo1982 · · Score: 2, Informative

    While the Averatec is priced right, for the extra cash I rather have one of Gateway's line of Tablet PCs. They're about $400 more, but you get the Gateway name and warranty (although I'm not quite sure how much that is worth these days). Also they use Pentium Ms which have better battery life over the XP-Ms. However if you're on a budget, this system looks nice.

    1. Re:Gateway by hawkbug · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      Ok, with your freeipods.com link - I'm curious. I clicked on it, and it doesn't say a damn thing about what I will have to do to get one. Please explain....

    2. Re:Gateway by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      They're about $400 more, but you get the Gateway name and warranty

      You're a troll, right?

    3. Re:Gateway by wankledot · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Good to see that you're supporting the newest stupid pyramid scheme with your dig there... way to go!

      --
      My sig is blank, I typed this by hand.
    4. Re:Gateway by Galvatron · · Score: 2, Informative

      Or you could just order them directly from Motion Computing, since that's where Gateway gets them from. It was about $100 cheaper that way back when I bought mine, and I've been quite happy with it.

      --
      "The question of whether a computer can think is no more interesting than that of whether a submarine can swim" -EWD
    5. Re:Gateway by SuperRob · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      It may be the newest scheme, but it worked for me. Check out my blog, I've got all the details there.

    6. Re:Gateway by SuperRob · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      You basically have to complete an offer, which could cost you money depending on which you choose, but most of them are free trials for a period of time. I have info posted in my blog you can check on. I've already qualified for mine, so all my links are to other people's. Or use Gateways, since you saw his first.

    7. Re:Gateway by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I already got a iPod mini and now I'm trying to get one for my roommate. So it really does work. =)

    8. Re:Gateway by phearlez · · Score: 1
      Your blog says: "a brand-new 4th Generation 20GB iPod is on it's way!"

      Meaning, you have been TOLD you're going to get one, not that you have gotten one. Check's in the mail and I promise not to *** ** **** mouth.

      --
      Bad management trumps ideology - Show the world you want better leadership. http://www.timefornewmanagement.com
    9. Re:Gateway by SuperRob · · Score: 1

      If you don't beleive me, then maybe you'll beleive this guy.

    10. Re:Gateway by EtherAlchemist · · Score: 1

      I think the Gateway name is still good, I bought a 400VTX from them last year and have nothing to complain about. As for their warranty, it's still awesome as well. In fact, right now you can extend it for three years for around $130 bucks.

      As for the iPod thing, I helped you out. Signed up for eBay. And, like a sucker, put my link in my journal for anyone else that wants to help me out. We'll see if this is bullshit or really works.

      --
      R(k)
    11. Re:Gateway by Proc6 · · Score: 1
      This isn't a rant against Gateway, everyone has different experiences, but I will say this - do not order a Gateway if there is any chance you will need to CANCEL the order.

      Gateway will not provide you with anything other than a voice confirmation that your order is cancelled. No emails no paperwork, nothing you could ever use in your own defense. Gateway policy, very sly and very lame.

      I ordered a notebook, was to ship 2 weeks later. 6 weeks later it still hadn't shipped so I cancelled it and ordered a Dell. I called Gateway every day for a week and everyday I got the same thing, "Strange, I dont see any record of cancellation. Well I will take care of it. There, all done. Your order is cancelled. I promise. In fact, UPS won't even pick it up from us, we put a block on it." - was told that every day by a new rep. 2 weeks later, guess what showed up at my door? A Gateway notebook and $2500 was simultaneously taken from my credit card. I refused shipment at the door and it took about 3 weeks to get the charges reversed on my card.

      So again, Gateway's probably a fine vendor, and they were almost always very nice (and answering the call from the United States, if that matters to you) JUST DON'T ORDER UNLESS YOU ARE SURE. :)

      --

      I'm Rick James with mod points biatch!

    12. Re:Gateway by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That site would hardly make me feel confident... to start, you really have to way of knowing the person on that site isn't the one running freeipods.com, (it's on a geocities account to begin with, it could probably be created in under an hour, you could give him an email, but if he's from freeipods.com, you couldn't believe him anyways!) Plus, even if he got a free ipod,, even if you did,, all that means is that a few out of X-thousand people who have done this have gotten one...

      I might be paranoid, but I haven't been screwed yet....

    13. Re:Gateway by d474 · · Score: 1
      ...I rather have one of Gateway's line of Tablet PCs. They're about $400 more...
      $1799.99(GW) - $999(AV) = $800 difference

      Where did you come up with $400 more?
      --
      Authority questions you. Return the favor.
    14. Re:Gateway by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      It looks like Tablet PCs are finally hitting real-world budgets. Averatec released a Tablet PC with an AMD Athlon XP-M 2200+ processor and will be at Costco and Staples for $1349...

      OK, its a $450 difference, not $400.

    15. Re:Gateway by ashot · · Score: 1

      whats to keep someone from signing up 5 blank emails and doing all of the offers themselves?
      I don't understand this scheme.. its not possible they are getting their money's worth...

      --
      -ashot
  6. Maybe I'm just uninformed. by Zugot · · Score: 1

    What exactly would I need a tablet pc at home for again?

    --
    -- Bryan
    1. Re:Maybe I'm just uninformed. by vxvxvxvx · · Score: 1

      A couple years ago my parents purchased a really nice pair of laptops. Really nice ones.. They're used 90% of the time to play solitaire while watchint TV/movies. I guess that's one way to manage hollywood greats like Titanic or Pearl Harbor.. Kinda wish I had thought of it.

      Anyway, it seems to me a tablet PC would be perfect for solitaire. No clumsy built in touch pad, you can use a pen. You don't need a keyboard.

    2. Re:Maybe I'm just uninformed. by Kiryat+Malachi · · Score: 3, Interesting

      I can think of a few things, and they're all related to one thing: drawing.

      If you're an artist (the kind who actually draws), I could see some use for a tablet. Especially if you want to get into doing computer-based things without going through the hassle of scanning, or if your computer skills are significantly inferior to your artistic skills. Penny Arcade, IIRC, uses a tablet PC for all the artwork now.

      Some of our factory people have tablet PCs - they bring up a PDF of a schematic, and they can draw on it while they discuss things with engineers. Useful.

      I think the tablet PC has uses... its just that they're not going to be for everyone, ever.

      --

      ---
      Mod me down, you fucking twits. Go ahead. I dare you.
      (I read with sigs off.)
    3. Re:Maybe I'm just uninformed. by connorbd · · Score: 1

      Sounds like a fair way of looking at it -- I believe Wacom also makes a display tablet for similar uses. But you're right, it's definitely a vertical-market sort of toy, excellent for artists and certain related disciplines, but not very interesting to the bulk of normal users. (If that's the case, though, Apple should be working on a tablet Powerbook. They've already got the hooks in the OS for a tablet design, but since there are no Mac clones nobody's using them.)

      I've actually heard a theory that the push for Tablet PCs -- or at least the handwriting recognition associated with them -- is being driven by corporate executives who feel that keyboards and typing are beneath them, undignified secretary work. If that's the case, it's no wonder there's so little real-world interest -- most people don't mind keyboards.

    4. Re:Maybe I'm just uninformed. by mojman · · Score: 1

      Nothing like shelling out $1500 to play solitaire while watching TV. Their wallets would be bigger if they just bought a deck of cards.

    5. Re:Maybe I'm just uninformed. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Because you don't know how to type? Yes, I'd like an 802.11 device that I can carry into any room and surf the web... but a notebook computer works just fine for that, thank you -- plus I can actually do useful work on it.

    6. Re:Maybe I'm just uninformed. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      you forgot the "it's a joke, laugh" -- can't expect anyone here to be intelligent enough to catch it.. but funny shit man!

    7. Re:Maybe I'm just uninformed. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      What exactly would I need a tablet pc at home for again?

      I can't speak for you, but for me, I could see it being a nifty gadget to have. I have been looking at getting an Archos AV device, but those are around 500. So the question becomes battery life and if the extra computing features are worth the additional cost. The larger screen definitely is a benefit for one. The fact that my bedroom is the only air conditioned room in my apartment, so I could still surf the web easily without trying to figure out a good typing position for a laptop while laying in bed under the a/c is another (no good place to put a desk in the bedroom)...

      Ok....yeah, I'm the Alpha Geek in my circle of friends, but still had to mention a few of the ways I could use one...if I could had the disposable cash to buy one.

      Additionally, there's having a machine on my home LAN to watch what I record via Snapstream...would work quite well for those hungover sunday afternoons that I don't feel like getting out of bed ;)

    8. Re:Maybe I'm just uninformed. by Lynchenstein · · Score: 1

      I have an older Fujitsu B-Series sub notebook with a touch screen, wireless LAN card and WindowsXP installed. While its not XP Tablet Edition-compatible, its an awesome machine for sitting on the couch playing games, surfing, checking email, etc. Its pretty much become property of my girlfriend and she absolutely loves the small form-factor and pen interface.
      When this one wears out, I'm certain that she's going to be lobbying mighy hard for a Tablet. I look forward to that....

    9. Re:Maybe I'm just uninformed. by Frizzle+Fry · · Score: 1

      How do you watch tv on a deck of cards?

      --
      I'd rather be lucky than good.
    10. Re:Maybe I'm just uninformed. by carn1fex · · Score: 1
      I have a toshiba m205 and i will never get a non-tablet laptop, its great. The m205 screen spins around so it can be in either tablet or regular laptop-appearing mode. Greatest tablet benefit? no more mouse. I use mine in bed, in the couch, wherever and you dont realize how much a pain in the ass a mouse (even optical) or a touchpad is until your sitting in a mound of pillows going thru windows just as fast as you could at your desk with your mouse.


      And if you happen to be an engineer, its great in the lab for the same reasons, as all engineers have labs totally filled with shit and no shelf space for a mouse. Also i maintain my lab notebooks on it now and cut and paste manual pdfs in it with highlights etc.. love it.

      --

      ---------

      No matter how thin you slice it, its still baloney.

    11. Re:Maybe I'm just uninformed. by thulsey · · Score: 1
      Penny Arcade, IIRC, uses a tablet PC for all the artwork now.

      Actually, Mike (Gabe) Krahulik (the guy that draws Penny Arcade) gives a nice little html tutorial here on using Alias Sketchbook Pro, which comes bundled (at least with Acer Tablets) and is a perfect compliment for tablet pc's I would assume.

      I've been using it for a while now with a Wacom drawing tablet and for the first time can see the use for a tablet PC. Drawing in a horizontal square which has to be perpendicular to the screen is not as intuitive as it should be. I'd much prefer to be able to draw while holding the pad at an angle.

      And the alternative is a Cintiq. Look at THAT price!!!! The tablet PC's in listed above do more (apparently) and cost less than these behemoths, so for the graphic artist who needs to draw, this is DEFINITELY the way to go. I understand that Wacom does some special treatment to the Cintiq screens to avoid wear, tear, and distortion as the pen touches the screen constantly, but yikes that is a pricey sketchbook.

      It's strange -- Apple has always been regarded as being the machine of choice for the designer or visual artist, but it seems that they may be missing the boat on this one... Niche market, perhaps, but could be a strong one.

    12. Re:Maybe I'm just uninformed. by Hognoxious · · Score: 1
      theory that the push for Tablet PCs -- or at least the handwriting recognition associated with them -- is being driven by corporate executives who feel that keyboards and typing are beneath them, undignified secretary work.
      Some time ago I heard something similar about resistance to having a PC on every desk, but I think anybody who's old enough to remember what a secretary is must be pretty close to retirement now.
      --
      Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
  7. The Element seems better to me by grunt107 · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Due to its Linux-based OS (sound like a Lycoris offshoot). Plus it's below $1000.

    1. Re:The Element seems better to me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That VIA processor runs about the same speed as a 300 MHz AMD K6-2, though. Antaurs also have a SINGLE half-speed floating point unit and a single ALU. They even struggle on XviD video over 320x240 (and sometimes video at 320x240).

      So, it's actually not that great of a deal compared to the XP-M tablet PC... Linux or no Linux.

    2. Re:The Element seems better to me by DebianRcksLindowsLie · · Score: 1

      Better check your math. Element doesn't sell Lycoris anymore - I heard their marketing guy got fired from Lycoris and went to work at Element. They don't sell that $999 tablet anymore either - it's $1099. Element cashes in on lies - they say that THEIR version of win4lin runs ALL Windows programs, and NeTraverse never released a joint press release with them. Sounds very fishy to me. Just a bunch of used car salesmen.

      To top it off, they don't even seem to HAVE a public distro! No source code available, NOTHING. That's not what Linux is about.

  8. Still big, why not use Handheld? by m4vrick · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Its still big and bulky. Might as well cary a laptop. Handheld could be so much more usefull and still be smaller in size.

    1. Re:Still big, why not use Handheld? by SuperRob · · Score: 1

      I've got a handheld, and I'd really like one of these tablets. Mainly because I'm finishing my degree, but they're nice for web surfing, and they run pretty much all standard software. My handheld is nice, but surfing the web on it is a pain, and the small screen makes taking handwritten notes more difficult than I'd like. I was skeptical about the tablets myself, but supposedly Microsoft is working on a special Handwriting-driven User Interface for Longhorn for use on Tablets, and that seems interesting.

      I'm seriously considering the Averatec one ...

    2. Re:Still big, why not use Handheld? by Jason1729 · · Score: 1

      You're saying it's good to get a tablet now because supposedly MS is working on a nice feature for it for a future version of windows? MS are the people who invented vaporware.Remember windows 93..I mean 94 1/2...I mean 95?

      Also, if you buy the hardware now, you'll be paying the MS tax now, and then you'll have to pay for a windows upgrade later. It seems more like to follow your advice we should avoid a tablet today.

    3. Re:Still big, why not use Handheld? by alienw · · Score: 1

      Also, if you buy the hardware now, you'll be paying the MS tax now, and then you'll have to pay for a windows upgrade later.

      Apple users have no problem paying $129 a year for minor OS upgrades. Microsoft's upgrades are $30 cheaper, and occur less frequently.

    4. Re:Still big, why not use Handheld? by tgrasl · · Score: 1

      1) Because the handwriting recognition is in a different league altogether 2) Because mind-mapping is just not possible on a handheld. 3) Because you twist the screen and you get a real computer you can do real work on.

    5. Re:Still big, why not use Handheld? by Jason1729 · · Score: 1

      What does that have to do with my assertion that it's stupid to buy hardware now based on a feature MS is supposedly working on for a future release of Windows?

    6. Re:Still big, why not use Handheld? by AdamPiotrZochowski · · Score: 3, Insightful



      you look at it the wrong way, its a laptop that can double as a
      tablet pc.

      Reasons why its good:

      1. as a tablet pc you can turn it to make the screen be more
      like page of paper (automatic ebook), but unlike handheld
      it will have a good resolutions

      2. as a tablet pc with touch sensitivity you can now paint
      and see results on same 'canvas'. Handhelds are too
      small, usb tablets are cumbersome

      3. and then, this is a laptop.

      why are people thinking: great, someone made a hand held that
      is no longer a hand held
      . instead of thinking: great,
      someone made a laptop that doubles as a tablet
      .

      --
      /apz, I want my c64 with the joystick based tablet

    7. Re:Still big, why not use Handheld? by d474 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I tried out a handheld for work at remote sites going over checklists in Excel spreadsheets. I thought it would be better than having to print out the sheets and taking paper with me. I stopped doing that because I was always scrolling, scrolling, scrolling. It was much faster to use a piece of paper and then data entry.

      If I could use a tablet PC then scrolling wouldn't be as much of an issue. Handhelds just feel like I'm looking at 3x5 card. Too small.

      --
      Authority questions you. Return the favor.
    8. Re:Still big, why not use Handheld? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Multitudes of beta and RC testers have agreed the new SP2 is significantly better and best of all, will be free to current XPT users.

    9. Re:Still big, why not use Handheld? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Uhmmm... you haven't actual tried a tablet, have you?

      Almost all the ones I've seen run WinXP Tablet Edition which already has a lot of extras built in. I gave a presentation on mobile development by drawing out diagrams of network connections on Journal.

      With Journal, I can draw diagrams and write cursive text, select blobs of text and convert them to typed text. The handwriting recognition is the best I've seen over the years. But the thing that really impressed me was when you could perform text searches of a journal entry, and it would find the searched entry in the cursive, handwritten notes that I hadn't even converted yet. Plus the files are very small since it stores vector-based strokes instead of image snapshots.

    10. Re:Still big, why not use Handheld? by SuperRob · · Score: 1

      Nothing, much like how your original assertion has nothing to do with what I said. I said that I have uses for the laptop now, and that Longhorn will have a UI for it, and that the UI looks interesting. I didn't say I was going to get the Tablet for that future OS to the exclusion of all else. It's a bonus, nothing more. I want a tablet for what it can do for me NOW.

  9. Or just go to the company's website by Grand · · Score: 4, Informative

    http://www.averatec.com/notebooks/C3500.htm

  10. Slashdotted? by Mz6 · · Score: 1

    You mean... there are people that actually care about these things?

    --
    Hmmm.
    1. Re:Slashdotted? by sunilonline · · Score: 1

      You obviously care if you clicked on it...

    2. Re:Slashdotted? by Patrik_AKA_RedX · · Score: 2, Funny

      Weird isn't it. How /. can be so contradicting. Nobody reads the articles, yet most of the linked site's go down. But hey, who doesn't like a good paradox?

    3. Re:Slashdotted? by Utopia · · Score: 1

      Here is it on Avertec site:
      C3500 Covertible Notebook

      Note this is not a mirror.

    4. Re:Slashdotted? by Jad+LaFields · · Score: 1

      Going way OT now, but I find that this is a symptom of tabbed browsing for me. I love tabbed browsing, but I do have a tendency to middle-click on far more links than I ever intend to read...

      Just yesterday I saw someone in a post who had mirrored some data across three servers and put up links to each of them, saying afterwards "three mirrors, to combat slashdotting" & somebody responded: "Sorry dude, I opened all three links in Mozilla before I read the rest of your post..."

      Um, and to say at least something on topic, my personal feelings about this is that this would be something that would be intended to be carried under one's arm, rather than in a bag or backpack like a laptop, but would be too heavy to carry for too long... but maybe I've got the wrong mental picture of these things, which I can't correct b/c the server is slashdotted.... =)

      --
      [SIG] It's like putting a moose in the blender -- a recipe for disaster!
    5. Re:Slashdotted? by Frizzle+Fry · · Score: 2

      It's not that nobody reads the articles; it's that nobody who posts comments reads the article. The people who read the articles and the people who discuss them are two completley distinct groups. And no, I didn't read this article.

      --
      I'd rather be lucky than good.
  11. Re:has anybody been able to read this by Kiyooka · · Score: 1

    lol /.'d already

    although i laugh about it though, sometimes i feel bad for some unwitting companies. they never saw it coming, and who knows? being slashdotted could severely hurt the company. maybe some sort of slashdot linking ethic should be created, otherwise a net-traffic-dependent company could go bankrupt or something because of us.

  12. Cheaper? by NETHED · · Score: 3, Insightful

    While it's true that they are getting far less expensive since when they came out, they are still out of range for me. I would LOVE to have a pen based tablet to take notes on while in class (at university), but I don't want it to be my primary computer. I'm too poor (need beer money) to spend all that money on an overpriced notebook. Anybody have any ideas?

    --
    --sig fault--
    1. Re:Cheaper? by duckpoopy · · Score: 2, Funny
      Two ideas:

      1. Typing lessons.

      2. Pen-based legal pad.

      --
      word.
    2. Re:Cheaper? by avandesande · · Score: 1

      You still write? I can't even read my own handwriting any more.

      --
      love is just extroverted narcissism
    3. Re:Cheaper? by Twirlip+of+the+Mists · · Score: 1

      Yes, yes, mock the poor boy. Tell him to buy a legal pad. Fine.

      But that ignores the fact that his is a really cool idea, in that far-distant-future kind of way.

      Did you guys watch the Apple video of the Tiger demo, the one where they previewed their Spotlight search technology? Spotlight provides a service for indexing and searching not only metadata about your files but the content of the files themselves.

      Stretch the idea a little. You take notes in class. Asynchronously (to keep CPU and power requirements down) the tablet translates your handwritten notes to machine-readable text. (Don't worry about how. Assume a magical handwriting-recognition engine.)

      It then indexes your notes and stores them away. Four months later when you're studying for your final, you can use something like Spotlight technology to search all the notes you've ever taken--all the emails you've ever sent or received, all the electronic textbooks on your tablet, all the PDF-format handouts your prof gave you, all the audio recordings of all the lectures you attended.

      It's a cool idea.

      Expand it further. Every note you take is stored with a timestamp, of course. That's a given. But put a GPS receiver in your tablet (somehow; again, assume it's magic) and you can store every note with a location stamp, too. At any time, you can call up a "where am I?" dialog box that lets you assign a name to a given point on the surface of the Earth. Four months later when you're studying, you can see that you took that particular note while you were sitting in Bovard Auditorium... or whatever. Your tablet will look at the lat/long of the note and compare it to the lat/long of the location preset you called "Bovard Auditorium," see that they're only about 30 feet apart, and conclude that that's where you were, then store that metadata as part of the note.

      Now go further. Associate an entry on your calendar with a location: Freshman seminar, Tuesday at 3:00, Bovard Auditorium. Associate an address book entry with it too: Professor Smelting. Now your computer knows that the notes you took on Tuesday between 3 and 4 within some distance of the point defined as Bovard Auditorium are associated with your Freshman Seminar and also with Prof. Smelting. Which means, without entering any additional data at all, you can ask your tablet to call up all the notes for your Freshman Seminar, and poof. There they are. As well as all the emails you got between September and December from Prof. Smelting. As well as logs of the phone calls you made to or received from Prof. Smelting's office during the same period. (Your tablet knows about your calls because you paired your Bluetooth phone with it.) As well as all the audio recordings you made during your Freshman Seminar. If you also postulate a magical speech-to-text transcription engine, you'll have transcripts of those recordings as well, and all those will have the same time-, place-, appointment-, and person-related metadata, so they'll come up too.

      Think of it like a relational database, if you're familiar with those. You've got multiple sets of data--addresses, calendar entries, places, notes--that are linked together in predefined ways. Once you set up those links, like associated Prof. Smelting's address book record with your Freshman Seminar appointments, the computer can be very clever about helping you find things.

      With a bit more software and a bit more hardware we can find ourselves in "Knowledge Navigator" territory.

      Yes, you could do all that with a laptop, probably more easily because you don't have all the handwriting recognition hurdles to get over. But laptops are harder to use effectively for the average schmoe; writing is something most of us learn by the time we're 6.

      Don't be so quick to poo-poo his idea. Yes, today it's a dumb idea because it's impractical, but will it still be a dumb idea when it's practical? I tend to think not.

      --

      I write in my journal
    4. Re:Cheaper? by chumpieboy · · Score: 1
      That sounds a lot like OneNote, part of Office 2003. A product that is shipping now and doesn't require a Tablet PC, but rocks your ass when used on one.

      But of course, Microsoft doesn't innovate or anything.

    5. Re:Cheaper? by GlassUser · · Score: 1

      Stretch the idea a little. You take notes in class. Asynchronously (to keep CPU and power requirements down) the tablet translates your handwritten notes to machine-readable text. (Don't worry about how. Assume a magical handwriting-recognition engine.)

      It then indexes your notes and stores them away. Four months later when you're studying for your final, you can use something like Spotlight technology to search all the notes you've ever taken--all the emails you've ever sent or received, all the electronic textbooks on your tablet, all the PDF-format handouts your prof gave you, all the audio recordings of all the lectures you attended.


      Sounds a lot like the windows journal (part of tablet pc), microsoft imaging (part of office, among others), and the indexing service (part of windows). Minus the proprietary PDF crap, that is. You can scan in, import, or handwrite stuff, it's recognized, and entered into the filesystem's index. It's been available for about a couple of years now.

    6. Re:Cheaper? by Twirlip+of+the+Mists · · Score: 1

      Let me get this straight. Windows Journal, Microsoft Imaging, and the Windows indexing service, are all fine, but PDF is "proprietary crap?"

      Whatever, dude.

      I didn't say anything about Windows because I don't know anything about Windows. Never used it. If they've got the kinds of features I described, then maybe their marketing needs some help, because it ain't common knowledge. Whereas Apple is trumpeting that kind of application-data-application integration from the battlements.

      --

      I write in my journal
    7. Re:Cheaper? by GlassUser · · Score: 1

      Apples to oranges. All the programs mentioned can export to standard formats. Then you say you've never used them? Drop the FUD.

    8. Re:Cheaper? by TopShelf · · Score: 1

      I was lucky enough to win an HP TC1100 from MIT's Technology Review magazine (follow the link below my UID above). My initial thought was to just turn around and sell it on eBay, but once I started playing around with it, it found a permanent place in my home...

      --
      Stop by my site where I write about ERP systems & more
    9. Re:Cheaper? by DMUTPeregrine · · Score: 1

      www.wacom.com Aah, these are great. $100 for a graphire tablet (what I have) and you get perfectly good note taking ability (pictures, sketches, etc) and it's great for drawing. Of course, I am doing digital art more than other things, so it may not be ideal for you, but it's still a nice thing to have.

      --
      Not a sentence!
    10. Re:Cheaper? by Trelane · · Score: 1
      All the programs mentioned can export to standard formats. Then you say you've never used them? Drop the FUD.


      PDF is an open standard. You can buy a book on the format from Amazon and write your own PDF software.

      What "standard" formats do the Microsoft programs export to 100%? Microsoft and....

      Where can I find the complete documentation on these "standard" office formats?

      (Alright, I'd assume that Imaging can export to JPEG and such. So can other programs that would work just as well.)
      --

      --
      Given enough personal experience, all stereotypes are shallow.
    11. Re:Cheaper? by AC5398 · · Score: 1

      My brother pointed the software out to me in the college bookstore. Software's called Notes or something like that -- it looked extremely cool and would rock when paired with a tablet pc.

    12. Re:Cheaper? by Twirlip+of+the+Mists · · Score: 1

      What?

      Seriously, I don't know what the hell you're talking about here. FUD? Are you sure you responded to the correct post?

      I told you, I have no opinion about Windows stuff. I've never used it, ever. I had an Apple II when I was a kid and Macs ever since. I'm not saying anything good or bad about Windows. I'm not saying anything at all about Windows.

      Well, except this: if you can do what I envisioned with Windows, Microsoft is doing a fine job of keeping it a secret from their potential customers.

      --

      I write in my journal
  13. Re:./'ed already by koreth · · Score: 2, Funny

    dot-slashed?

  14. Slashdotted... by PaintyThePirate · · Score: 4, Informative

    The site is already slashdotted, but I assume it is this tablet that was announced a few months ago. It's nice to see that companies are already using AMD's 1.35v Mobile Athlons.

    1. Re:Slashdotted... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No, the site was not /ed. The sessions table failed after someone tinkered with it. This server has handled /. visitors many times over the years.

      I've renamed the postnuke modules.php and added a simple html page with that name so that there is a message and link to a bland, html page of images and some of the text.

      Sorry for the inconvenience.

      LPH
      www.tuxreports.com

  15. Real world budgets by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    But will they see any real world use? When a pc is in the sub $1000 range and laptops are roughly the same price will there be much demand. Also is there really a demand for the home user. I can see a small percentage of business/industrial users having a reason for these, but enough to warrant selling them at costco and staples?

    1. Re:Real world budgets by Lord+Kestrel · · Score: 1

      The reason they sell them at Costco at least, is that the Costco warehouses use them in receiving. Apparently tablet pcs work well enough for Costco that they don't have a problem selling them. Plus, Costco has always been about selling higher-end* items, so that fits in with their philosophy. This is still somewhat surprising, as their computer buyer has historically been clueless when it comes to technology, maybe this is a sign that someone new is deciding what computer equipment to purchase for sale in the warehouses.

      *Especially their wine department. I've picked up a number of great bottles of wine at my local Costco for dirt cheap. It's a shame that Washington State only sells liquor at state run stores, because otherwise I'd purchase my alcohol there as well.

  16. What About Heat? by blueZhift · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Other than the cost, one of my concerns was the amount of heat a tablet pc generates while in use. I was looking into them for use by nurses collecting research data. But after trying a few out about a year ago and noticing how they heat up, I didn't think the nurses would be too happy.

    Still it's good to see the price come down. But I still wonder when Dell is going to get into the act.

    1. Re:What About Heat? by johnlcallaway · · Score: 1

      Maybe the nurse wouldn't be happy, but the patients would. I always like a hot nurse when I'm sick.

      Sorry ... couldn't resist.

      --
      I rarely read replies, it's my opinion and if you thought about your opinion a little more, I'm OK with that.
  17. Just a Giant PDA by LehiNephi · · Score: 2, Insightful

    It seems to me that a tablet PC is really aimed at a market that is small-to-non-existant. As far as I can tell, the main selling point for tablet PCs (the ability to write on the screen like a notepad) is duplicated in PDAs. In fact, the only reasons to get one instead of a PDA are 1) it's more like a computer (HD, faster CPU, more RAM) and 2) a larger screen.

    Tablet PCs, instead of becoming the indispensable laptop-and-PDA killers they were touted to be, instead combine the worst features of both laptops and PDAs. What results? Low-performance, too much weight (ie less-portable), short battery life, and high price.

    There's one more reason people have both a laptop and a PDA. You can get both for less than the price of a tablet PC.

    --
    Help find a cure for cancer. Join the [H]orde
    1. Re:Just a Giant PDA by koreth · · Score: 1

      The ability to draw on the screen is pretty nice, and PDA screens are too small to be useful for much of that. A tablet PC hooked up to a projector is like a whiteboard with cut-and-paste and a Save button, pretty useful for engineering brainstorming meetings.

    2. Re:Just a Giant PDA by Monty845 · · Score: 1

      Wasn't there a slashdot article a few weeks ago that said the exact opposite and predicted the end of the PDA?

    3. Re:Just a Giant PDA by firebat162 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I would think a big market for the Tablet PC's are for teaching/educational/demonstration purposes.

      At my university, a lot of the professors are switching to Tablet PC's and writing on their powerpoint slides instead of fiddling with the overheads.

      The professors can save the notes they wrote on the powerpoint slides and make them available to students online. Try doing this with either a PDA or a traditional laptop... it's possible, but difficult.

    4. Re:Just a Giant PDA by Dielectric · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Actually, my company is deploying these en-masse now. We use them on customer visits for lots of things, like block diagram sketches. You can also write directly on a PDF or other doc, then send that to a co-worker with all your notes intact. It's very cool. A PDA just doesn't have the screen size to enable this stuff, and the cost is marginally higher than for a laptop. Only field guys get them, because a regular suit just doesn't need the functionality.

    5. Re:Just a Giant PDA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      I'm an Architect, and I couldn't agree more. If I could just get a Tablet that was beefy enough for 3D, I'd be all over that. I want a decent laptop that I can draw on. That's it. Instead, Microsoft gives us a bloated PDA that won't run Linux, and when it's in 'tablet' mode you can't use the keyboard, which pretty much makes it useless for shortcut heavy CAD, 3D, and Photoshopping.

      Six months back I was shopping for a laptop, and looked at the Tablets (i've used Wacom tablets for years), and the only one I could find that could do 3D (the Toshiba, with the 1.7 Centrino rig) was too expensive, had too weak of video card, and could only have a gig at most of memory. Everything else was so limited it wasn't even an option.

      So I went with a Sager & a Wacom instead, and am happy, 'cept for battery life. But still, the Tablets seem to be in search a problem, instead of tapping into a real, viable profressional market of designers, artists, and 3D folks that would love to have a laptop they could draw on.

    6. Re:Just a Giant PDA by stinkwinkerton · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Huh? What are yout talking about? Have you ever used one?
      My TC1100 from HP is as powerful as a laptop and much lighter. Sure, the screen is smaller, but I can do exactly EVERYTHING I could do on my laptop with it. As a sysadmin, it is wonderful for remote connections and, when I do need a keyboard, it is right there. And it is lighter than most notebooks.

      I think that you will see that in the future, more and more laptops will add the functionality of the tablet- Physical rotation, writing on screen, etc. Is it a PDA/Laptop killer? No, it is a laptop that has additional functionality. And if you are in a lot of meetings, then it is really nice to be able to write on documents as necessary that you receive-- you can print anything you can print regularly to a digital format, and have your way with those.

      Yes, it was more expensive than a laptop. About 400 dollars more than the laptop I would have picked out for myself. I think you will see the price drop more and more as it becomes more mainstream.

      BTW, the short battery life is not true. I get very good battery life out of mine.

      I will say this: Use one for a while, a good one, and you will like the additional functionality. Trust me, more and more "laptops" will start behaving like tablets pretty soon.

      --
      "Look! There! Evil, pure and simple from the Eighth Dimension!" --Buckaroo Banzai
    7. Re:Just a Giant PDA by base_chakra · · Score: 2, Insightful

      It seems to me that a tablet PC is really aimed at a market that is small-to-non-existant. ...
      Tablet PCs, instead of becoming the indispensable laptop-and-PDA killers they were touted to be, instead combine the worst features of both laptops and PDAs. What results? Low-performance, too much weight (ie less-portable), short battery life, and high price.

      It's new consumer technology, what do you expect? You want to bury it before it's hardly begun to mature. The cost may be prohibitive, but aren't recent price breaks is what the article is mainly about? The market may be small at present, but to say that it's non-existent is just ignorant.

      Features like integrated keyboards and swivel screens make some tablet PCs adaptable to a way of interfacing that's familiar to notebook users. It seems more likely that tablet PCs will supplant notebooks eventually.

    8. Re:Just a Giant PDA by Billobob · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I don't know about you, but I would much rather read a book on a small-ish tablet PC than a PDA. The tablet screen, due to the way images are displayed on it, also simply feels more like reading an actual book. So, if I wanted to read an ebook in public, I would much rather have a tablet/laptop than a pure laptop.

      --
      If you have to ask, you'll never know.
    9. Re:Just a Giant PDA by Mr.+No+Skills · · Score: 1

      It doesn't matter. Eventually the cost of the digitizing screen will be a tiny incremental cost and all laptops will be "tablet PCs". Much like the little eraser pointer thing, the microphone jack, the floppy drive (still!), and the infrared port, it will be there and only a fraction of the people that buy a laptop will use it.

      For those that use it, they have to have it. For those that don't, they buy it anyway.

      Tablet PCs are positioned like a clip board, but they're much heavier and more fragile than a clip board. Probably there is a form factor that is about 5 inches by 7 inches for a "Giant PDA/Small Laptop" that some people would love. I know my Palm/Keyboard makes coach seats useable, but I do wish I had some more screen size as my eyes start to go.

      --
      Sleep is for the Weak
    10. Re:Just a Giant PDA by Aphrika · · Score: 1

      "It seems to me that a tablet PC is really aimed at a market that is small-to-non-existant."

      I suppose that depends on how you perceive computing to be in the future.

      Right now, we have servers, desktops, laptops, tablets and pdas/phones as form factors for computing powerthat we use. Do you really see that being the case 20, 50 years from now? I want voice activation, handwriting recognition, tactile feedback, touchscreens, I don't want to have to flip open my 19" Sony Vaio and use a touchpad and keyboard... compared to an intuitive screen and pen combo, touchpads are incredibly clunky.

      The concept behind the tablet form factor goes way beyond just lopping off the keyboard, it goes all all the way down to the basics of making the screen the central part of the machine. You can interact (I hate that word) with data much more naturally that with a laptop. You can have other people interact with your tablet - maybe draw on a diagram, maybe you might pass it around - and you can do this in a corridor, elevator, bus, standing up, sat on the couch, wherever you like.

      It's the most versatile form factor I've ever used - light, thin, good battery life and a full spec'd Centrino box. It's certainly not a toy, and definitely not a PDA.

      So in any case, if you really want a future where we're stuck with clamshell devices that seem to be getting bigger and less portable, and are content with always looking for a table when you want to do some work then great, go for a laptop, but the tablet will hopefully encourage people to be a bit more experimental with form-factors and computing as a whole.

    11. Re:Just a Giant PDA by uss_valiant · · Score: 1

      Parents arguments against Tablet PCs:
      - Low-performance
      - too much weight (ie less-portable)
      - short battery life
      - high price
      - PDA + laptop combo is cheaper

      @Low performance:
      Just not true. Convertible Tablet PCs are equipped with the best mobile CPUs available (Pentium-M 1.8 GHz +). Most slates have a Ultra Low Voltage Pentium-M, some have normal Pentium-M up to 1.4 GHz.

      @Weight:
      True for the biggest convertibles (up to 3kg and more). But the lightest slates are really mobile.

      @Short Battery Life:
      Thanks to Pentium-M etc. you'll get 5+ hours of battery life. Carry a second power pack for longer mobile use.

      @High price:
      True, costs about 25% more than an acceptable notebook.

      @PDA + laptop combo is cheaper:
      Depends on the PDA & laptop.

      Convertible Tablet PCs have all the advantages of notebooks plus the added pen features. IMO the perfect mobile computer for students and people who work on different places at desks.

      Slates score when you also need to take notes while standing / walking. They usually have a little less computing power than convertibles / notebooks, but the performance is comparable to a subnotebook.

      I don't want the redundancy of a PDA & laptop combo and the screen of a PDA is too small. I can't take all notes with mouse & keyboard in an efficient way. If your goal is the paperless office - and that's the vision - you want a Tablet PC.

    12. Re:Just a Giant PDA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I've used the TC1100. It's crap. Toshiba's tablets are the hands-down winners, and Fujitsu's are a close second (and way cheaper I might add). I've done my homework and the result is: meh.

      The ONLY difference between a tablet and a laptop is the extra input method (stylus). Weight? Not that big of a difference--ultralight laptops without internal optical drives and smaller batteries aren't that different. Portability? Laptops have wireless now. It's true--look it up.

      So if writing on the screen is the ONLY advantage, then I think it's fair to say that for those who don't wish to write on the screen, they are a big waste of money. And since writing on the screen is a slower method of input than typing, there's really not a technical reason to need to write on the screen--it's a toy. It's fun to use. The extra cost is for personal amusement.

      Okay, that's a little overreaching--the use of tablets for DRAWING (artists, meetings) is pretty handy. Writing is quieter than typing, so it's good for discreet computing. But seriously--an ultralight laptop is the EXACT SAME THING without the extra input method. Chances are you don't need it.

    13. Re:Just a Giant PDA by llamashoes · · Score: 1

      The more I use my TC1100 the less I use anything else. It drives me nuts when I hear them compared to a PDA. The only similarities to a PDA would be the fact that you can write on the screen. I can do everything on it that I can do on my laptop, plus more. And with XPsp2 comes a lot better handwriting recognition, and a lot better tabletpc OS overall.

      It does get a bit hot, but not hot enough that I don't mind carying it around all day. I also doubled the ram to 1gig to make it run a bit smoother, but after that it has been a slick machine.

    14. Re:Just a Giant PDA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I believe PDA screens are resistive while Tablet PC screens are capacitive. They are different.

      You can use your finger tips on your PDA but not on a tablet pc, which allows you to rest your hand on the screen.

    15. Re:Just a Giant PDA by llamashoes · · Score: 1

      I wouldn't write a paper using handwriting on my tablet, but I do use the handwriting for marking up documents, Taking notes in the Journal Writer, Using OneNote etc. Try that with a laptop. The tablets do have other differences besides just the input method.

      And one nice thing is that the point of writing on the screen isn't to always convert your handwriting into text, but to have it stay as "ink" in whatever document you are editing.

      I also had a Toshiba, but I like the idea of a slate device better (tablet without a permanently attached keyboard) better than the Toshiba approach. Motion Computing has a good slate as well...we are buying both HP and Motion devices here.

    16. Re:Just a Giant PDA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Anybody who does software design for a living spends *lots* of time drawing diagrams. The tablet is pretty much ideal for that.

    17. Re:Just a Giant PDA by Lumpy · · Score: 1

      I've been a tablet PC user for decades now.... Ok cince 1990 with the first Tablet PC the DAuphin DTR1. You are right, it is NOT for everyone. and one thing that MUST be there to make a tablet pc work well is the handwriting recognition.... something microsoft has not had right cince windows 3.11 for Pen computing. everything else cince has been clunky and horrible... I'm gussing they lost the right to use some kind of patented technology from some other company.

      Linux on tablets is fun for 10 minutes until you try the handwriting recognition... It's horribly-nasty-early-alpha stuff. you have to write in a special app box. (W3.11for pen allowed me to write in that field like I was writing on a form.)

      The funny part is my last old tablet PC, a Fujitsu Stylistic LT, running the old windows for pen is still in use today while my laptop that can turn into a tablet rarely get's into tablet mode as it is less useful in that mode.

      Tablet Pc's are doomed because of Microsoft, they are slapping on the tablet extenstions as an afterthough where these things really need their own OS. windows Tablet with real pen extensions that work well.

      Linux could kill in this area if the developers that are good at it would jump on it and speed past MS.

      --
      Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
    18. Re:Just a Giant PDA by WillAdams · · Score: 1

      ::applause::

      PenPoint was conceptually so right, it pains me that people are cloning Excel or Word instead of looking farther afield for better ideas.

      That said, my Fujitsu Stylistic is getting close to replacing my NeXT Cube....

      William

      --
      Sphinx of black quartz, judge my vow.
    19. Re:Just a Giant PDA by Hognoxious · · Score: 1
      when it's in 'tablet' mode you can't use the keyboard
      Plug an external one in. And a mouse. And a monitor. Sheesh, do I have to do all the thinking around here?
      --
      Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
  18. Tablet PCs for Linux by pctainto · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Everytime I hear about tablet pcs on /. people post about 'using it for linux' and 'can you run linux on it' and everything. Now, I understand this is slashdot, but is it not missing the point of a tablet pc? The only reason that I see to spend more money on a tablet pc is to get the advantages of the handwriting recognition and to do interactive presentations. As far as I know, Linux either does not have the tools necessary to take advantage of this, or what is out there isn't as good as the windows counterpart. I have teachers at school that are absolutely amazing with the tablet pc and lecturing, but everything they use is ms-centric.

    Is there anything out there for Linux that makes a tablet PC worthwhile? I would love to look at someone's post about Linux on tablet pc and say "yes, that would be worth it" but right now all I have to say is you're wasting your money.

    --
    I think my principles are reachin' an all time low
    1. Re:Tablet PCs for Linux by stratjakt · · Score: 1

      First, wait X years for the tablet hardware to be supported in the kernel, then we can talk about userspace apps.

      There is handwriting recognition stuff around, there has to be, Zaurus does it, no?

      If not, some entrepreneur could always use linux to cut costs, and write/lease/whatever the handwriting part.

      --
      I don't need no instructions to know how to rock!!!!
    2. Re:Tablet PCs for Linux by connorbd · · Score: 1

      That doesn't mean there's no reason to make it available.

      What's really needed is a sort of open source TabletBIOS -- a basic nanokernel (Mach-based? FreeDOS-based? A hack of GRUB or LILO?) that provides very basic OS services and drivers for the tablet screen, even if it's nothing more than a proof-of-concept.

      Truth be told I'm surprised there's no demand for a lightweight Open Source nanokernel. I'd do it myself if I knew what I was doing.

    3. Re:Tablet PCs for Linux by BiggerIsBetter · · Score: 1

      The tools are there. Touchscreen support has been available for years now, and IBM had Chinese handwriting recognition software available back in 2001. There's nothing really exotic here, all it needs is vendor support to help it gel in a user friendly way. Yes it can (and probably will) happen without support, but it'll happen faster and better with it.

      --
      Forget thrust, drag, lift and weight. Airplanes fly because of money.
    4. Re:Tablet PCs for Linux by kfg · · Score: 1

      Is there anything out there for Linux that makes a tablet PC worthwhile? I would love to look at someone's post about Linux on tablet pc and say "yes, that would be worth it" but right now all I have to say is you're wasting your money.

      I want a tablet PC for one, and only one, reason, to run vim as an ASCII etext reader. A laptop is too awkward to curl up with and a PDA is too small.

      It would be worth a good, oooooooh, hundred bucks to me.

      KFG

    5. Re:Tablet PCs for Linux by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Agreed. Tablet PCs should be used for running an HTTP browser and nothing else... in which case it doesn't really matter what OS it is running, does it?

    6. Re:Tablet PCs for Linux by LordSah · · Score: 1

      You're right. The magic in the Tablet is the software...using handwriting recognition and ink in your apps (along with a rich support infrastructure for developers to write Tablet-aware applications). Just throwing Linux on one gets you a laptop running linux with an extra mouse device (if you have drivers that work).

    7. Re:Tablet PCs for Linux by torpor · · Score: 2


      If Linux doesn't run on it, then there's no point doing a toolkit/API for pen-based computing in Linux.

      What you should be asking is where are the patches for Blender to put touchscreen to some serious use? How about those Mozilla gestures? There are *tons* of bits of Linux' mouse and UI code which can benefit from touchscreen.

      I don't, personally, care for Linux always following the money. Hardly any of the innovation in Linux came about for 'market control' reasons, a fact non-Linux'ers and Linux'ers alike seem happy to neglect ...

      So, yes. Great that these now run Linux... and are cheap enough now maybe some developers will get into them, and start (slowly at first, building, building...) adding support.

      --
      ; -- the corruption of government starts with its secrets. a truly free people keep no secrets. --
    8. Re:Tablet PCs for Linux by TRACK-YOUR-POSITION · · Score: 1

      I own a tabletpc. I don't run linux on it, but it doesn't seem so ludicrously silly to do so--I'm not very interested in the handwriting recognition--I can type many times faster than I can write. I use it to draw. It's a wacom tablet, after all. Other wacom tablets work under linux (I have no idea if tablet pc wacom support could ever work under linux), so it's not completely unreasonable to want to use a tablet pc for Gimp or something. So assuming you got a model with a keyboard, then you'd theoretically have a linux laptop that lets you draw. If you were really dedicating to using the Gimp for some reason, that wouldn't be such a bad thing.

    9. Re:Tablet PCs for Linux by Marsala · · Score: 1

      I recently decided to snag a tablet because I've always found PDAs to be a pain to use for various reasons. I ended up grabbing a Toshiba Protege 3500 and it's been pretty useful so far... mainly because you can flip the screen up and around and make it into a laptop any time you want.

      As a result of the Transformer-like abilities of the system, I've gotten to a point where I find myself discarding stuff like handwriting recognition.... when it's time to write emails, post to /., or whatever, the keyboard/touchpad combo is the way to go. But in meetings, I've found that the tablet mode combined with MS Journal (which is basically MS Paint with a few nifty extras thrown in) absolutely rocks. It's functionally equivalent to taking notes on a legal pad... except now I can back them up to the fileserver over the wifi link, save them to other formats and pass out my notes to cow-orkers, or easily/quickly find notes from a meeting 2 months ago that put a project on the back-burner but is now suddenly Top Priority once again.

      The fancy stuff, like the handwriting and voice recognition, aren't really all that useful in the long run. The handwriting recognition gets freaked out if you write too fast, so you end up having to double check what the tablet sends to make sure it says "due date 07-30-2004" instead of "Blue d4+.)3 0l/E0-508A"... and that was pretty much my problem with the Palm-ish style PDAs.

      Given all that, I've been toying around with slapping Linux on the system and hacking together a replacement app for Journal (that wouldn't save stuff in a proprietary format that needs to be converted... grrrr). As with all laptops, the biggest thing I'd miss is the power management utilties and the ability to easily reprogram the tablet buttons to do stuff (like setting one up to power off the screen or making one do ARROW_UP and another do ARROW_DOWN). But with a little bit of hacking, even that too should be reproducable.

      All in all, though, if I was told they were taking away my orkstation and I would have to rely on the tablet to do my job, it wouldn't be the end of the world. :)

    10. Re:Tablet PCs for Linux by laird · · Score: 1

      Actually, Squeak has had fantastic support for pen-based computing for many years now. It can run over any OS, or even over bare hardware (Smalltalk only relies on a small set of primitives, which can and has been implemented in a few days to bare hardware.) Squeak offers not only pen-based control and text recognition, but also a very rich visual programming model (Morphic). There are an amazing array of app's at http://www.squeakland.org/ to play with. Since Squeak is extremely visual, interactive, and open to hacking (in the positive sense that you can inspect and tweak anything) it's very popular in educational settings. It is, of course, open source.

      So yes, it'd be a bit geeky trying to do "real work" in Squeak, it has all of the capabilities you're looking for (Morphic is far more powerful than Windows' imaging model, so you can make presentations that go *far* beyond PowerPoint, Squeak has decent handwriting recognition, etc.).

    11. Re:Tablet PCs for Linux by Doh! · · Score: 1

      I own one, and I'd have to say it's a waste of money at current prices. If you can't see yourself drawing, taking notes, or marking up documents, then the pen is pretty much just a glorified mouse. (In which case, it works equally well under Windows or Linux.)

      However, using a pen is so intuitive, even for basic desktop navigation, that it's almost painful to go back to using a mouse.

      It's almost like going back to vi after using emacs. Oh wait, nevermind...

    12. Re:Tablet PCs for Linux by WillAdams · · Score: 1

      Well there's Xstroke for text input (more like Graffiti/Unistroke than normal handwriting though)

      http://www.xstroke.org/

      Jarnal is a beginning of a replacement for Journal --- uses SVG as a file format though --- it'll get much cooler if it gets shifted to the ink annotation XML standard the W3C has been proposing (only the software for Logitech's Io uses it thus far AFAIK).

      http://www.dklevine.com/general/software/tc1000/ ja rnal.htm

      Berkeley's Graphical User Interface Research group has some pretty cool work for pen / alternative UI design in Java which works well in Linux:

      http://guir.berkeley.edu/projects/denim/

      There's still a lot missing though, including analogs to:

      - FutureWave SmartSketch (this started on Go Corp.'s PenPoint, moved to the Mac and Windows and morphed into Future Splash Animator and became the program known as Flash) --- I still can't believe Macromedia sold this off to Broderbund instead of doing as Alias did and creating a vector version of SketchBook with it.

      - Creaturehouse Expression (not a pen computing program per se, but way cool on a tablet), basically one can set an arbitrary object to follow an arbitrary path ---- sounds bizarre until one thinks of drawing a single flower, and then drawing an entire garden w/ slight variations.

      - Ambient Design ArtRage - not a painting program, but a painting simulation. Apparently there're some natural media plugins for the GIMP, but they've a ways to go, especially UI wise.

      - Adobe Acrobat 6 .pdf annotation - this is _much_ better than in v5 or earlier and works quite well w/ a pen, though not ink enabled.

      William

      --
      Sphinx of black quartz, judge my vow.
    13. Re:Tablet PCs for Linux by civilizedINTENSITY · · Score: 1

      Think Linux/Mathematica in your Physics/Chem/.../Engr.ing classes. Why do calculators work? Its the form factor. This is what you want for recording lecture notes, and being able to integrate that hairy mess the prof is working on in *seconds* :-)

    14. Re:Tablet PCs for Linux by salesgeek · · Score: 1

      I've been selling tablets for a while. They are very nice in that they are simply better engineered low power computers than most laptops. Battery life is better - and the handwriting recognition under Windows isn't bad. Software development, though is difficult because you have to build the application for pen. A killer app for a tablet would be a web browser hacked for direct pen input to web form text and textarea controls. No... opening the "pen input panel is not the right answer. This would requrie NO investment is software re-writes and would make the platform more useful....

      --
      -- $G
  19. Neato. by chickygrrl · · Score: 4, Funny

    Now I can stop sketching on scrap paper at work.

    1. Re:Neato. by Mz6 · · Score: 2, Funny

      Don't bother. Your sketches suck on paper as it is. Get back to work. -Boss

      --
      Hmmm.
    2. Re:Neato. by WindBourne · · Score: 1

      I use a newton for that. Great stuff. Just wished it was still being supported.

      --
      I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
    3. Re:Neato. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You go through life, you try to be nice to people, you struggle to resist the urge to punch 'em in the face, and for what? So some pimply little puke can treat you like dirt because your not on the team. Well, I'm better than dirt. Well, most kinds of dirt. I mean not that fancy store bought dirt. That stuffs loaded with nutrients. I... I can't compete with that stuff.

      The whole quote was too long for a sig? It's not as funny when it's clipped. Time for a sig-repair, sonny.

      - The Sig Police.

  20. Re:./'ed already by It'sYerMam · · Score: 1

    Yeah, you need to ./configure, before compile. And you shouldn't have . in your $PATH.

    --
    im in ur .sig, writin ur memes.
  21. Picture by Tovaris · · Score: 2, Informative

    Try: http://www.shipitforyou.com/cgi-bin/sgin0105.exe?U ID=2004071911394006&T1=S850+1043&FNM=24
    for a picture and specs.

    1. Re:Picture by Grimster · · Score: 1

      No mod points else I'd use 'em so --- thanks this is exactly what I'm looking for and shall be searching for a local place to buy tomorrow.

      --
      --- www.f-theocean.com
  22. Slashdot is Truth by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    And, obviously, your server CAN'T HANDLE THE TRUTH.

  23. Re:Ok by kc3lai · · Score: 0, Redundant

    because the web server is running on the tablet pc

  24. Shhhish by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    mysql://pcbuyers:@localhost/polarbear failed to connectToo many connections /. already

  25. This is cool by bedouin · · Score: 4, Funny

    I believe this is exactly what you're looking for. The price is right too.

  26. Re:has anybody been able to read this by Kaganar · · Score: 0

    Averatec's website regarding the C3500:
    http://www.averatec.com/notebooks/C3500.htm

  27. /. effect by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    mysql://pcbuyers:@localhost/polarbear failed to connectToo many connections

  28. Keys by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Howdy! If anyone sees Mary Beth, can you let her know that I need the goddam keys for the pickup truck? Thanks a bunch!

    1. Re:Keys by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I just saw her and she said she doesn't have them. Check under the fridge. Oh, and she's leaving you.

    2. Re:Keys by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Leaving me??? *MY* Mary Beth? Oh, Looord!!! I mean... she could at least have sent me an instant message or something... Oh well, I still have my AardvarkTec TabletPC...

    3. Re:Keys by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That bitch...

  29. An Executive's plaything by noser · · Score: 3, Interesting

    We received an HP tablet PC as a free gift with a bunch of switching equipment that we ordered. I'm not sure if it had a model number, it seemed to be some kind of demo unit or something. The overall impression was that it was a toy.

    The handwriting recognition software was not installed on the unit that we received, so the stylus was just used like a mouse. The screen would rotate around so you could use it like a tablet or more like a laptop; it was a little bulky and short on features for any real work.

    For the money I'd rather have one of the new Vaio picturebooks or an ultralight Thinkpad x31 ...

    1. Re:An Executive's plaything by SilentChris · · Score: 1

      "The handwriting recognition software was not installed on the unit that we received"

      Then it wasn't a Tablet PC. MS Tablet PC's have built-in (although not too great) handwriting recognition.

      Although, MS has never made that the selling point. The selling point was that you could edit/doodle your thoughts on already existing documents/email/etc. That's why Onenote was so crucial (and why I wonder they don't ship it as part of the standard Tablet PC software suite).

      Quite frankly, I can't see an executive using something like this at all. A writer, on the other hand (like myself) like to explore this kind of stuff. It isn't there yet, but it's a good overall idea.

    2. Re:An Executive's plaything by stratjakt · · Score: 2, Interesting

      All depends what you're going to do with it.

      Another poster mentioned drawing. Basically a digital sketchpad. If that's what you wanted to do, it sounds like this would fit the bill nicely. Apparently Penny Arcade use a tablet PC for their artwork.

      Or someone who needs to take notes while on foot, it could be used like a clipboard and pen. The home inspector who did my inspection comes to mind, he had a cute little laptop, but had to put it down on the floor or do other awkward poses to take notes as we went room to room.

      Frankly, this would probably be easier to use in tablet mode on a plane than my bulky Gateway laptop, which is a great laptop, but the screens to big to fit on a fold-down tray.

      I have no need for one either, but don't fall into that slashbot trap of "I can't use it therefore it's worthless!"

      --
      I don't need no instructions to know how to rock!!!!
    3. Re:An Executive's plaything by ameline · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Gabe at Penny Arcade uses Alias Sketchbook Pro (http://www.aliassketchbookpro.com) on a tablet PC for some of his work. I'm always amazed at what talented people can do with the software I write.

      (Sketchbook also runs on a pc or a mac with a wacom tablet -- sorry -- no linux version.)

      Ian Ameline,
      Alias Sketchbook Tech Lead.

      --
      Ian Ameline
    4. Re:An Executive's plaything by eric2hill · · Score: 1

      Neat - I didn't know that product existed. I do a lot of freehand sketching on a white-board for laying out project ideas. (I have less artistic talent than a blind dyslexic leper monkey.) What all can you do with Sketchbook? I'm looking for a good white-board replacement that's not "Paint" or the like.

      --
      LOAD "SIG",8,1
      LOADING...
      READY.
      RUN
    5. Re:An Executive's plaything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      i would love to try alias sketchbook on a tablet pc, but i cant afford one. drawing with my wacom is less than perfect. i tried the demo of sketchbook, both for pc and osx, and it seemed ok, but the hand-eye thing really tripped me up. right now the best experience i have with drawing directly in an art app is with my hp ipaq 4155 and conduits pocket artist 2.7 ever think about making a version of sketchbook for pocket pcs?
      e

  30. That sure was quick by Atario · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Sometimes, when a good, hard slashdotting like this takes place, people suggest that Slashdot be nice and create an internal mirror of the site before posting. Then it is inevitably pointed out that this would be copyright infringement and take hard-earned food from the mouths of the developers, ad-clickthrough-sellers, etc.

    But no one seems to have a problem with caching proxies -- right?

    Therefore, I suggest that instead Slashdot create its own caching proxy specifically for use with the sites it tries to melt. Maybe it would simply forward you directly to the site if the site was still responding, and respond with its internal cached copy if the site was struggling.

    Taco? Anyone?

    --
    "A great democracy must be progressive or it will soon cease to be a great democracy." --Theodore Roosevelt
    1. Re:That sure was quick by Solder+Fumes · · Score: 1

      In the Slashdot FAQ CmdrTaco wrote four years ago: "So the quick answer is: "Sure, caching would be neat." It would make things a lot easier when servers go down, but it's a complicated issue that would need to be thought through in great detail before being implemented." Well, there goes *that* idea!

    2. Re:That sure was quick by avandesande · · Score: 1

      Maybe people that post a new story should include a link to the google archive in case it gets /.ed?

      --
      love is just extroverted narcissism
    3. Re:That sure was quick by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      sajldhfakj hh akajajh

    4. Re:That sure was quick by Atario · · Score: 1

      So you're saying that the issue is so complicated that four years has not been enough time for Taco & Co to think it through.

      Sigh.

      --
      "A great democracy must be progressive or it will soon cease to be a great democracy." --Theodore Roosevelt
    5. Re:That sure was quick by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That wasn't the issue. The sessions table handling the postnuke was tinkered with. I replaed the table but decided to rename the modules.php file (postnuke creation) and have replaced it with a link to a simple html page with some of the images and text.

      I was doing this work while you guys were complaining that it was /.ed. LOL.

      LPH
      www.tuxreports.com
      (Yes, WhatIsNew and 30 other sites on this server run on LINUX. It's the only way.)

  31. Still too expensive by LWATCDR · · Score: 1

    When they are down to say $600 or less then we can talk. Until then a notebook seems to give you more bang for the buck by far. And what would I use one for that is worth spending over 1000 dollars for?

    --
    See my blog http://ilovecookes.blogspot.com/ for light hearted technical information.
    1. Re:Still too expensive by pkhuong · · Score: 1

      mmm... Remember the kind of laptop you get for $600? TPC = laptop _+_ features, so they should be expected to be more expensive.

      --
      Try Corewar @ www.koth.org - rec.games.corewar
    2. Re:Still too expensive by geekoid · · Score: 1

      This is the very reason why tablets are evolving into laptopn with a screen the spins around. The base manufacturing cost for that much hardware is too much to create something that big for 600 bucks. well, at this time anyways.

      --
      The Kruger Dunning explains most post on /. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
    3. Re:Still too expensive by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      A Tablet PC is a notebook with added features. Duh. You should study up on the products before you bash them.

  32. Durability is still king by ElForesto · · Score: 1

    Personally, I like durability in my portable electronics. That's one of the big factors that went into me choosing a Sony PDA. I've heard they do a "drop test" from 3 feet to make sure it'll handle a beating.

    All the tablet PCs I've seen strike me as being a bit too delicate for toting around the house like a magazine and still expensive enough for me to consider them impractical.

    --
    There is a difference between "insightful" and "inciteful" other than spelling.
    1. Re:Durability is still king by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      We got a shipment of tablet PC's to test. My favourite memory is someone putting one down, half over the edge of a desk, just for it to crash to the ground, the screen shattered.
      These things are no more fragile than laptops, but the way people are enouraged to use them begs for destruction.

    2. Re:Durability is still king by jamonterrell · · Score: 1

      That's nothing, I'm on my second PDA. The first one(Compaq Ipaq) I drop tested from about 4 feet onto office carpet... lost a line or two of LCD screen. Drop tested again a week later, lost half the LCD. Simple problem (broken ribbon cable to the lcd) but nearly impossible to fix. My Second PDA (Dell Axim X5) has been drop tested many times... still works great. Durability is VERY important, and very underestimated by many manufacturers.

      --
      I can count to 1023 on my hands. Ask me about #132.
    3. Re:Durability is still king by gangien · · Score: 1

      May i recremend a TI calculator. I have dropped my TI-86 onto the floor off ofa desk countless times, and the floor being carpeted cemeter or tiles. I also have dropped it off my raised bed, about 5.5' in the air onto carpeted cement and it still worked flawlessly. I love my calculator. And btw, there's software you can download that can turn it into whatever you want, so Ti+$20 link cable = awesomeness IMO anyhow.

    4. Re:Durability is still king by ElForesto · · Score: 1

      Excellent point. My TI-82 has been collecting dust since I started using PalmOS devices, but I don't seem to recall anyone seriously damaging one of those things, even when crammed into an abused and overstuffed backpack.

      --
      There is a difference between "insightful" and "inciteful" other than spelling.
    5. Re:Durability is still king by buck_wild · · Score: 1

      I've had my Ipaq for a little over 2 years and have never dropped it. I'm glad I haven't.

      That said, maybe you should see a doctor, fumble-fingers. :)

      --
      If all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
  33. Tablet PCs perfect for digital artists by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    tablet pcs are worth alot to digital artists...it provides a medium for sketching and painting that is akin to their non-digital counterparts. in fact the makers of Maya 6 (alias|wavefront) make an app called Alias Sketchbook Pro. it is an amazing program...but only usefull to those with a passion for drawing, painting, etc. i would also imagine that it would be great with Zbrush (3d modeling app)...thought i never tried Zbrush.

  34. MOD PARENT UP by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    'cause he's right

  35. What I want. by kabocox · · Score: 1

    What I want is a $400-500 tasked designed device.
    I want 20+ hours of battery life. To get this, I don't need a P4 1.8 + Ghz. I'd take a P2 300 Mhz chip. I'd like it to play dvd's if possible, and be a large screened PDA for display info. I don't want it to try and compete with the next P4 3+ghz desktop or latest laptop offerings. I'd like to plug in my storage media, be it usb key chain to DVDs and cheaply and easily view my content in a form several others can see as well.

    1. Re:What I want. by buck_wild · · Score: 1

      Not sure you can play a DVD with a PII 300mhz chip...

      --
      If all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
    2. Re:What I want. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What I want is a million dollars given to me by each visitor from /.

      I'll take it in ones, fives, tens, and twenties. No bills over a twenty please.

    3. Re:What I want. by Klanglor · · Score: 1

      in 5-50yeat son! and 400$ will be like 200$ now if you factor in inflation.

    4. Re:What I want. by mark_lybarger · · Score: 1

      funny funny. a P 200MMX would handle DVD playback just fine. a capable video adapter (r128) would be needed. albeit, i've only tried dvd playback on a pII 266 as the slowest processor, but playing a media like that doesn't hog cpu much. mostly in video.

      but sure, faster processor, faster processor. gotta have one!!

    5. Re:What I want. by buck_wild · · Score: 1

      Interesting. I really didn't know that you could playback a DVD on a processor from that generation.

      Maybe I should rethink my home-entertainment plans in regards to video!

      --
      If all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.
  36. I'm excited about tablets... by callipygian-showsyst · · Score: 2, Funny

    ...but I can't wait for Apple to release one! (Why hasn't Apple ever tried this? They're the ones that are supposed to innovate!)

    1. Re:I'm excited about tablets... by Dr.+Evil · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Usually when Apple doesn't do something, it's because they know it is a bad idea.

    2. Re:I'm excited about tablets... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      They have tried and it was innovating at that time. Ever heard of Newton?

    3. Re:I'm excited about tablets... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      One word - Newton. Yeah because that was an awesome idea at the time. Hah.

    4. Re:I'm excited about tablets... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I can't wait for Apple to release one

      The closest Apple product would probably be the Apple Newton Emate 300. This was a large PDA with a touch screen you could write on. Here is a description: www.applefritter.com.

      It came out around 1997, several years before MS's tablet PC initiative, but was killed along with the rest of the Newton line.

    5. Re:I'm excited about tablets... by geekoid · · Score: 1

      becasue they can't figure out a way to charge 5000 dollars for it? ;)

      Apple has been very busy with the iPod, they don;t like to saturate the market with lots of new devices. I would wager they will cone out with one, when they can get a good price. I'm sure the recognize the user market for these is probably sub 1200 bucks.

      --
      The Kruger Dunning explains most post on /. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
    6. Re:I'm excited about tablets... by wolfbane01 · · Score: 1

      Maybe the reason that Apple hasn't thrown in a contender in the Tablet market is because there is not market, as we have heard time and time again...

      niche market...marginal niche market.

    7. Re:I'm excited about tablets... by OmniVector · · Score: 1

      yeah.. it's not like the created the pda market or anything.

      --
      - tristan
    8. Re:I'm excited about tablets... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      and don't forget TALIGENT!

  37. As a tablet PC user... by Aphrika · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I've seen quite a lot of adversity directed at Tablet PCs which I really don't understand.

    I've been using a TC1000 since November 2002 and it's an absolutely fabulous piece of hardware. It's the kind of stuff people on the cutting edge of technology should be embracing, and instead of asking what you'd want one for, finding out what you can use it for. Writing on the screen isn't as gimmicky as you'd think - taking notes, annotating diagrams, documents, roughing presentations is incredibly easy. The form factor means you can pull one out in a meeting without hiding behind a laptop screen, you can pass it around more easily to show people ideas and you can get information into it quicker.

    To put it bluntly, since buying a new laptop - because I started to believe that it was a gimmicky toy - I am really missing the tablet functions and realise that I was wrong. Sure, my new laptop is faster, bigger, better, etc. etc. but the tablet functions just opened up a new way of using a PC that I really miss now. I can't comfortably lie in front of the TV and work, and note-taking isn't as easily transferred to emails, document etc. Before I could quite happily rough a document outline up in a meeting and have it mailed off by the end to all present. Can't do that with a laptop, or handwritten notes come to think of it. So, they aren't just giant PDAs, they're a new platform that needs to be exploited by apps like OneNote. I certainly hope the form-factor succeeds and heaven help us if we're tied to desktops and laptops for the foreseeable future, because that would severely cripple the importance of the computer in it.

    1. Re:As a tablet PC user... by enjo13 · · Score: 4, Interesting

      The form factor means you can pull one out in a meeting without hiding behind a laptop screen, you can pass it around more easily to show people ideas and you can get information into it quicker.

      This is what people don't "get" with tablets. They are PERFECT for situations where collaboration is important. Architects have to love these things (who are constantly manipulating things slightly and sharing that with a customer). Really anything that requires multiple people to look at the same screen is ideal for a tablet. It's not meant to REPLACE a laptop, but rather enable more optimal work in new and different situations.

      --
      Turn s60 photos into awesome videos with mScrapbook for all S60 3rd edition phones!
    2. Re:As a tablet PC user... by Lumica · · Score: 1
      The form factor means you can pull one out in a meeting without hiding behind a laptop screen


      It's strange though, most people get along better with typing stuff in a keyboard during a meeting then writing it down on paper or a tablet pc:
      For most it is easier to keep eye contact and give visual feedback to the talkers using a keyboard since with keyboard the need to look at your notes is not as high as with written notes.

      Of course your experience may vary...
  38. Why I own a tabletPC by greywar · · Score: 5, Interesting

    OK I read people saying things about a tabletpc that just arent accurate. It is NOT a overgrown pda...its..well..its a really cool laptop with many of the pda benefits tossed in. So what can I do with it thats so cool you say:

    1. I can read books on it comfortably
    2. I can lay outside and surf the net easily and comfortably
    3. I can use it as a nice picture fram system when im charging it
    4. I can comfortably watch tv on planes during long trips
    5. I can print to its journal our documentation, and then mark it up and highlight it before returning it to our tech department
    6. I can take notes on it without offending people by using a laptop, or being as loud as many laptops
    7. I can start our software, then hand it to a customer with a quick button click to rotate the screen to face them.
    8. I can draw things on graph paper on it
    9. Its easy to carry around and play with while waiting in long lines-you just can't juggle a laptop to do that very well
    10. I can lay in bed and comfortably read.
    11. If you have any graphical book, comic book, whatever-you can display it one page at a time in a nice near paper sized format
    12. Its cool in a nerdy way-what more could any slashdot guy want?

    I have a motion m1300. The one thing most important when choosing one of these is weight. mines around 3 lbs-don't get a larger one weighing more then 3.5 lbs or you won't find it comfortable and easy to use.

    1. Re:Why I own a tabletPC by srenker · · Score: 2, Informative
      I concur. My only complaint about the Tablet PC was that the handwriting recognition was awkward, but there is a completely new recognizer in SP2 (I'm running RC2) that makes it so much easier to correct occasional mistakes in recognition.

      I have an HP TC1100 from Overstock.com (this is the second generation with real Centrino and the pressure sensitive Wacom pen that doesn't need batteries). Being a refurb brought the price down into the reasonable range.

      --
      My new /. login is fabu10u$.
    2. Re:Why I own a tabletPC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting
      You can add the following to your list to:
      1. MS Powertoys - specifically the one that lets you lasso bits of screen and annotate them before emailing them. Before it was 15 minutes in Photoshop with a text tool to do this kind of stuff. Great for helpdesk work.
      2. Speech recognition - YMMV, but for me it works fantasically. Even so, having the microphone built in (when will laptop manufacturers learn?) is great for Skype etc. etc.
      3. OneNote - probably one of the best non-linear information storage programs I've come across. Dump audio/video/text/handwriting into your notes, mix and search. Works fantastically well.
      4. MSN Messenger - nothing like dropping someone a quick diagram using messenger, especially directions.
      5. Non touch-sensitive screen - major bonus over a PDA in that you can lean on it. One day I want desks with tops like this.
      6. Intuitive for kids - nothing makes me smile more than seeing my 2 year old God-daughter use a tablet PC pen to draw.
      Then there's the little things; scroll wheels, jog dials, D-pads, soft-keys, decent implementation of standby modes.

      Makes you wonder what we'd have as standard on laptops if they'd thought about it a bit more....
    3. Re:Why I own a tabletPC by greywar · · Score: 1

      Gah you're right. I also forgot the wonderfull ability of one note to RECORD a conversation and time sync it with the notes so I can play back from a note. Nothing like telling your boss "no you SAID:" and playing it back on some speakers. And yes-the voice recognition is in fact pretty darn good.

    4. Re:Why I own a tabletPC by Jeff+DeMaagd · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I would think that the people that don't see the value of these things have no contact with those with artistic talent, and possibly have no artistic talent themselves.

      Think about it. A lot of artists that have to use a computer insist on using a pen / tablet control system. These tablet PCs integrate it right into the screen. How is that not a slick drawing system? CAD types can use it as well. Coders, like a lot of slashdotters, probably don't need it. That doesn't mean that non-coders can't benefit from it.

      I love PDAs but there were times that I wish there were some larger ones. Now there are.

    5. Re:Why I own a tabletPC by fm6 · · Score: 1
      Why is "overgrown PDA" a bad thing? Sure's it's nice to have a PDA in your pocket. But the Newton found fans without that feature. When I had one, I tended to think of it as too small, not too big!

      You could have ended your list with item 1. A good laptop could do all those other things. But I've always wanted a device that was as convenient as a book, but as flexible as a computer. Electronic media will never come into its own until it's as convenient as paper. Well, that, and sane copyright laws...

  39. But why? by screwballicus · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I really don't understand the logic behind tablet PCs as they are currently being marketed. This is not to say there isn't any, but can someone very much in the market, very interested in buying, explain it?

    I love my Ipaq, but I don't understand why I'd want a way bigger, way clunkier version with a desktop OS not intended for its purpose.

    Largely, the main intended purpose of the Tablet PC seems to be to get WinXP (or an XP-a-like mod thereof) onto as small a form factor as possible.

    So the question is, why do you want XP on a form factor the characteristics of which are inclined to diametrically oppose themselves to XP's own defining qualities? I'm not just trashing XP for its being an MS OS. PPC2003 doesn't really bother me as a handheld OS. But I am asking why an OS/GUI for a not at all comporable machine could ever be expected to function ideally as the OS for all form factors and functions no matter how different.

    And why does a tablet PC need anything even remotely close to an AMD 2200+ processor? Are people intending to do high end CG renders on these things? Cinematic quality video-edits?

    I guess if you wanted and absolutely would not settle for anything other than the most recent, bloated, processor-intensive desktop version of Office available under XP with all the bells and whistles turned on and for some extremely hard to discern reason wanted to use it on a tablet, you might need a 1GHz machine, but far more?

    What's the rationale for this being a mass market device?

    1. Re:But why? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If you were to see the way I can use my pen to scroll these slashdot pages with unsurpassed precision then you will want one too. (The pen really is easier/faster to use in navigating 2D UI than a touchpad or mouse)

      I am using a convertible Tablet PC to write this post. it is just like any other laptop, until I flip it over into tablet mode.

      After I bought mine and brought it to my engineering classes at UCI, 2 more appeared in the class throughout the quarter. 2 of my professors also stopped lecturing and started asking me questions about my computer after seeing me rotate my tablet screen 180 degrees. 3 of my friends also bought tablets after trying mine out.

      Trust me, you have to see one/use one to appreciate.

      as for the future of tablet pcs, Bill Gates was just in China 2 weeks ago showing off tablet pcs to students. I think tablet pc makers really need to start advertising to kids who do not have biased opinions like some adults have against the tablet pc. and I will bet they will never use anything else.

    2. Re:But why? by AdamPiotrZochowski · · Score: 1

      I Love my Ipaq, but I don't understand why I'd want a way bigger, way clunkier version with a desktop OS not intended for its purpose.


      wrong,

      1. its a laptop, you dont want a laptop?
      2. you can close it with screen on the outside , now you
      can pretend its a nice ebook, or scetchpad
      3. you have more detail now your cad drawings actually make
      sence!

      so the question is, why dont you want a laptop with
      extra features?


      --
      /apz, tablet is not just an overgrown gameboy

    3. Re:But why? by sootman · · Score: 1

      Ever take a *lot* of notes on your iPaq? Ever read a *lot* on it? (I have a friend who loves reading ebooks on his palm, but I can't stand reading much on a tiny screen that has to be scrolled every half-paragraph.) Ever do a worthwhile drawing on one? Ever browse the web much on one? (And not just stripped WAP sites, I mean the WHOLE www.)

      I have a tablet (part-time, from work) and it's great. It has nothing to do with getting XP onto a little box. (Import a Libretto if that's what you want.) It has to do with getting a suitably powerful device, that you can write and draw a *lot* on, large enough to hold and be seen, small enough to be comfortable to carry around for a while. And for general use, I think a stylus is generally far superior to a regular mouse, let alone a touchpad or button mouse. (Right- and middle-clicking aside.)

      As for the CPU, I think it's great. My first tablet was fun but honestly pretty much sucked--the 1 GHz Transmeta CPU was really pokey. (Sorry, Linus.) Our new one, with a 1 GHz Centrino, is much, much faster. The more CPU the better--handwriting and speech recognition use lots of juice, and both can be greatly improved over where we are right now. A phat AMD would be great. Hope ComHPaq goes that way soon.

      --
      Dear Slashdot: next time you want to mess with the site, add a rich-text editor for comments.
  40. Dell with Tablets by palironsat · · Score: 1

    Don't hold your breath...

    My company inquired about getting some of these from Dell a couple of months ago. We kind of liked the one that we got from HP (although for us, in financial services, there's not much usefulness beyond the coolness factor). According to our rep, Dell has no plans to market them any time soon. Until there's a profit to make by selling them en masse I wouldn't expect anything.

  41. And from the other end, under attack from Wacom by SuperKendall · · Score: 1

    They do seema bit like PDAs - and from the people that want to draw on a full-sized screen, it seems much nicer to hook a Wacom Cintiq lcd tablet (not tabletPC) up to a powerful laptop so you get good performance and a less bulky drawing surface. I've seen these in action with Photoshop and they are really, really nice.

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
    1. Re:And from the other end, under attack from Wacom by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Wacom makes most of the screens for the Tablet PC's. Just FYI. So it's very simular, same tech. But still not as nice as the larger ones you use with a PC.

  42. MOD PARENT UP by writertype · · Score: 1

    'cause this is a good idea

  43. Less than worthless? by harley_frog · · Score: 1

    Is it just me, or is the tablet PC a solution in search of a problem? I mean, really. If you need a PDA, buy one. If you need a laptop, buy one. The way I see it, tablet PCs don't perform either task better than the aforementioned devices. Of course, that doesn't take into account its paperweight capabilities.

    --
    It's all fun and games until someone loses the key to the handcuffs.
    1. Re:Less than worthless? by geekoid · · Score: 1

      becasue you need one of each?

      Becasue you work in an enviroment where a lap top is just a little to difficult to use. Say you ned to be standing, one hand holding the device, the other hand inputting.

      Becasue the PDA is to small to read what you need.

      Thereare many, many uses for the tablet. I predict that if somebody can sell a tablet for 1000 bucks that has WiFi and a touch screen, and offer a service package, they will make millions.

      --
      The Kruger Dunning explains most post on /. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
    2. Re:Less than worthless? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Watch a PDA user tapping and scratching, trying to add information to their PDA. Now, watch the same thing done faster with the EMR pen and Tablet PC. The PDA also requires special software whereas the Tablet PC uses an Windows XP application (Yes, you can even install Linux on the unit). PLUS, the Tablet PC can be a full desktop replacement for anyone who wants to keep their data with them because a Tablet PC is a notebook.

      It's definitely worth carrying one device rather than two.

    3. Re:Less than worthless? by Chrontius · · Score: 1

      Y'know, that's what they said about lasers, too.

  44. A Book on tablets by gtrubetskoy · · Score: 2, Interesting

    There is a pretty interesting book on how the first tablet computer came about by Jerry Kaplan called "Startup". They came up with the idea of a pen-based computer while flying on Mitch Kapor's private jet, and started a company called GO. This was back in the 80's I believe. Here is a link - you can read the reviews for more info.

    1. Re:A Book on tablets by WillAdams · · Score: 1

      Jerry Kaplan's _StartUp_ is a very good back story on the early to mid-years of pen / tablet computing, which I always recommend.

      It's interesting that Microsoft puts rather a disingenuous spin on the early collision between Microsoft and Go Corp. in the book _Building Tablet PC Applications_ (how believable is this book? Well, while the technical / programming information is well-spoken of, there're a number of errors in it (they even mis-spelled Fujitsu!) so I'd take it's version of history with a grain of salt.

      Almost as interesting is the book _ThinkPad: A Different Shade of Blue --- Building an IBM Brand_ which has some of the IBM side of the story (the ThinkPad was originally conceived of as a pen tablet / slate, not a clam shell laptop, with the name derived from leather notebook pad holders embossed with ``Think'' which IBM provided to employees).

      William
      (Who still misses PenPoint, and hasn't bought an Apple product since the Newton, except for OPENSTEP 4.2)

      --
      Sphinx of black quartz, judge my vow.
  45. ISA version? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    because thats really what i need

  46. Re:has anybody been able to read this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    who knows? being slashdotted could severely hurt the company

    If their web site is that critical, then they should pay the extra $25 a month to host it on a real server at an ISP that can handle a slashdotting. Failure to do that is simply poor (or cheap) management and they'll probably not lose much business from 1 day of slashdotting.

    There is perhaps more inconvenience to the thousands of slashdotters clicking a useless link. If anything, there should be a way to have mirror links set up and accessible from the main story. This has been requested before but never implemented, so either it's too hard or OSDN (rightly) fears it might lead to copyright infringement actions.

  47. Logically impossible by mblase · · Score: 5, Funny
    Three sentences that are logically inconsistent:
    1. This statement is false.
    2. Your government is here to protect you.
    3. This Slashdot link goes to a page of photos.
    1. Re:Logically impossible by blair1q · · Score: 0

      1. Simple paradox explained by faulty design of the English language (all paradoxes devolve to faults in syntax).

      2. No, it's true, only the people who get to run it from time to time realize they can make more money by using it to hurt you. That's your fault, for believing their propaganda. YOU are the real government of America. So stop voting for corporatists who line their own pockets.

      3. It went to a page of photos at the moment the submitter clicked "Submit". It's not his fault if they were vaporized 90 ms later.

    2. Re:Logically impossible by blair1q · · Score: 1

      Conservatives sure love to hide dissenting opinions, don't they.

  48. my opinion on tablet PCs by spacerodent · · Score: 1

    I really liked my brothers tablet pc and the handwriting software has really gone far. I could write a paragraph without having to correct one word. The only prolbems I had with it was that it refused to write mathmatical equations. Since I'm an engineer that basically rendered it useless for me. Other than that it was very nice and even the voice software worked well. FYI he had a toshiba model running the windows XP tabel OS. I'm not sure of the exact model number.

    1. Re:my opinion on tablet PCs by CaptainPinko · · Score: 1

      then use Windows Journal and don't have it try to correct your equations for you. THats what I dod for my math classes. ACtually this is why I bought a tablet instead of a PDA with a keyboard

      --
      Your CPU is not doing anything else, at least do something.
    2. Re:my opinion on tablet PCs by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      There is MathJournal, a package for mathematical equations being developed by xThink.

  49. Re:has anybody been able to read this by chris_mahan · · Score: 1

    I doubt slashdotting has ever hurt any company. In fact, it usually shatters their sense of well-being at hosting their corporate web site on a PIII with a business cable from Time Warner.
    Generally, they realize they have to upgrade for real, because now they're playing with the big boys.

    --

    "Piter, too, is dead."

  50. Uses for a tablet PC by BenEnglishAtHome · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Other than drawing-related tasks, I've never thought tablets were good for much. However, I was in a hospital elevator with a pharmaceutical company salesperson a couple of days ago and she whipped a small tablet PC (about 8 inch screen, I'd guess) from her purse, popped out the stylus and started tapping and scribbling away. It was running XP. Apparently she was able to document her last sales call and check her to-do list between the 5th and 21st floor. It was obvious she was accustomed to using it in short bursts, whenever she had, literally, 90 seconds to spare. I thought it was kinda neat, actually.

    When a tablet is used like this, as a sort of super PDA, I'm sure it's more readable and, for some, more comfortable. I'm not sure I'd have any use for one of them, but I no longer think of tablet PCs as silly and useless devices. For some people, obviously, they're the bees knees.

  51. Art and pressure sensitivity by FooAtWFU · · Score: 2, Interesting

    How well do the laptops handle pressure sensitivity in artistic applications? I know that a Wacon Cintiq has "512 layers of pressure sensitivity" (more than enough for me), but it runs about $2500 each (after a $1000 price drop, mind you!) If I were to do my web comic (link delibrately left blank, go away /. :) with a new tablet like this, would it be reasonably sensitive, or just on-off? Would I be better off with a regular old drawing tablet, where I can't look at it and see the screen as well?

    --
    The World Wide Web is dying. Soon, we shall have only the Internet.
    1. Re:Art and pressure sensitivity by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I have a Gateway M275 and I'm pretty sure it has 256 levels of pressure sensitivity. When I use apps like MS Office 2K3 and Grafigo, I can definitely see changes in pressure (thicker or thinner lines).

      Hope this helps.

    2. Re:Art and pressure sensitivity by WillAdams · · Score: 1

      The Tablet PCs which have Wacom digitizers have 256 levels of pressure input (with the (possibly optional) ``Penabled'' driver (which one may have to download from www.wacom.com) --- they also don't support the full range of pens/ input devices which (say) a Wacom Intuos will.

      The tradeoff is directness (which one can alternately get w/ a Cintiq) and portability (this was a big reason for me to switch to pen computing --- got tired of lugging a graphics tablet for use with my laptop, or having to scan my sketchbook for those times I didn't have it / haul it out).

      There was a very interesting post contrasting a TabletPC w/ a Wacom Cintiq for an artist's use at http://www.tabletpcbuzz.com a while back.

      William

      --
      Sphinx of black quartz, judge my vow.
  52. Re:has anybody been able to read this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Hrmmmmm. If we create an article about slashdot and link back to slashdot, could we slashdot slashdot?

  53. Two words... by PhoenixOne · · Score: 1
    "Bathroom Reading". ;)

    --
    Spell cheek you've failed me four the last thyme!
    1. Re:Two words... by antek9 · · Score: 1

      Please drop the quotes. I'm actually doing a lot of my reading on the throne.
      Then there is the thing about the best ideas coming to mind right there, so it doesn't hurt to have a PC with you.

      Provided the ventilation works, that is.

      --
      A World in a Grain of Sand / Heaven in a Wild Flower,
      Infinity in the Palm of your Hand / And Eternity in an Hour.
  54. Linux OS for Tablet! by PhoenixOne · · Score: 1
    The real question should be, who's writing a flavor of Linux that takes advantage of the tablet?

    Given the fact that tablets tend to have a little less power then laptops/desktops and they are best used for specific tasks (rather then general computing), it would be great to have a light weight OS that did exactly what you needed and nothing more.

    --
    Spell cheek you've failed me four the last thyme!
  55. Whoa what the hell? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Simply put, an ION device is powered by the world's first OS to run Linux and Windows programs side by side on pre-tested hardware giving businesses a Macintosh-like experience

    I'm sorry, I think I was asleep when this amazing technological feat was invented. Has someone actually seen one of these vaporous sounding devices?

  56. Re:has anybody been able to read this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    So what you're asking is:
    How much slashdot could slashdot slashdot if slashdot would slashdot slashdot?

  57. Older, cheaper tablets are OK by peeping_Thomist · · Score: 1

    On Ebay you can find plenty of old, inexpensive tablet computers. They're fine for most things people want computers for.

    --
    Anything worth doing is worth doing badly -- G.K. Chesterton
    1. Re:Older, cheaper tablets are OK by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I disagree. The Tablets on EBay are not all Tablet PCs. People are constantly asking me about them -- in hopes of getting them to run the software, etc. After all, Tablet PCs are not Tablets and so some of these EBay resellers are taking advantage of people who do not know the difference.

  58. 90 seconds?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Apparently she was able to document her last sales call and check her to-do list between the 5th and 21st floor. It was obvious she was accustomed to using it in short bursts, whenever she had, literally, 90 seconds to spare.

    "Literally", eh? That's either a really damn slow elevator or someone was playing "hey stop that" with the buttons. 90 seconds to travel 16 floors?! You're kidding.

    1. Re:90 seconds?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      yeah dude. WTF? i mean, what could an elevator possibly do for 90 seconds when traveling between two floors? its not like there are other people in the building or something.

    2. Re:90 seconds?! by BenEnglishAtHome · · Score: 1

      You're kidding, right? Elevators do tend to make occasional stops when traveling between widely separated floors. That takes a little time. In this case there were two or three stops. I don't remember, exactly; I was too busy paying attention to the PC. People got on and off. Some were sick and slow; it was a hospital, after all. The whole trip lasted somewhere around about 90 seconds.

      Please tell me you're kidding.

  59. Has hand-written text recognition improved at all? by august+sun · · Score: 1

    The only thing really holding me back from taking these tablet pc's seriously is this long-held resentment I've harbored ever since wrestling with an original handspring visor. Maybe I have hand-writing so bad that is was literally unfathomable by the engineers at Handspring, but I invariably was relegated to the virtual keyboard for input. So my question to all and sundry is, has the tech improved substantially? Or are those of us with derelict handwriting forever chained to the keyboard?

  60. which tablets have the most usable screens? by wingbat · · Score: 1

    So far, all of the tablets I've played with use a regular laptop screen. This is a big mistake, as it makes the portrait orientation wonky. Since regular laptop displays are made for wide horizontal but NOT wide vertical viewing angles, the distance between your eyes is enough that the display looks a bit off.

    I'd love to hear a report from someone using a better technology. Are the TFT displays significantly better in this respect?

  61. Best Tablet PC Ever! by nlindstrom · · Score: 1

    My tablet PC rocks. It works perfectly at all times without batteries; in fact, it has never needed batteries. If I loose my stylus I can carry on using my tablet PC with any ol' stick, pencil, or other pointy object. It also works in all weather conditions except for the pouring rain (too much rain causes the screen to run and the characters to become difficult to read.) To create a backup, I merely fire my tablet PC and get a new one. Clay is plentiful, after all!

    1. Re:Best Tablet PC Ever! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      To create a backup, I merely fire my tablet PC...

      Up to this point, I thought you were talking about paper...

  62. For our clinic, it's notebooks not tablets by peacefinder · · Score: 1

    At our medical clinic, we have an Electronic Medical Records system, which the clinical staff access mainly through handheld computers. Every time there's a new story about tablets, we look into them, and every time we've reached the same conclusion: not yet.

    For our usage, we really like wireless, pen-enabled notebook PCs. While our EMR system allows a tremendous amount of data to be entered easily with a point-and-click interface, nurses and docs still need to do some free-text entry. That pretty much ties us to a device with a keyboard. (I have heard that the handwriting recognition in XP is really good, but we're skeptical about it being good enough. I guess I should actually test it, huh?)

    If the tablets come down well below touchscreen notebooks in price, maybe we'll try one and see if we can live without the keyboard.

    For those that are interested, we've been using the Fujitsu Lifebook P-series (P1120) which is a great little machine. It's about 2.2 lb, and its Transmeta processor squeezes 4-5 hours out of the standard battery, while running Win2k or XP and a Windows terminal session over the built-in 802.11b. We went 18 months of daily use before we had a single significant hardware failure. (But then two of our first four went out nearly simultaneously... $225 to repair each. Considering they each see about 60 hours of use every week, I think that's not too shabby.)

    We first bought them with the extended-life batteries and some spares with chargers, and those spares never left the shelf. The next ones we got with the standard battery and no spares, and we've never had a problem with battery life during our staff's 12-hour shifts. Our staff is pretty good about plugging them in when they can, though.

    The big complaint with the P-series is that the screen is really dinky, which is hard on staff with older eyes.

    So we tried an iBook. While it's possible to get a touchscreen retrofit for an iBook, we decided to try it without the touchscreen. It works okay, but the lack of touchscreen is a problem for staff. Some staff are willing to trade the touchscreen for the Mac's bigger and sharper monitor, though. On the down side, it's had two main logic boards go out and it's pretty heavy by comparison. There are a few staff who love it, but most prefer the Fujitsus.

    About a week ago, we purchased a Fujitsu B-series Lifebook (B3020D) and (so far) it looks spectacular for our usage. It has a 10.4" touchscreen, Atheros A+B+G wireless built-in, it's only 3 pounds, and it claims a battery life of several hours with its Pentium-M processor. (I'm guessing three hours under our conditions, but I haven't really tested it for that.) Staff loves it so far, and I suspect we'll be getting more of 'em.

    --
    With reasonable men I will reason; with humane men I will plead; but to tyrants I will give no quarter. -- William Lloyd
    1. Re:For our clinic, it's notebooks not tablets by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I work in a hospital environment and we recently purchased some tablets for use in the Operating Room. The nurses and head of staff seem to like them, although the two biggest problems are logins (have to use the on-screen keyboard) and needing a place to hold them at a comfortable eye-angle. Logins only have to be done once a day or per case, and most tablets come with a stand that will hold it steady at a good angle. Attachable keyboards are also available for text entry, but the XP text recognition works for all of their needs. Granted, I think they do more viewing than text entering. Overall, laptops are a more general solution, but they take up almost twice the space, which can be at a premium.

    2. Re:For our clinic, it's notebooks not tablets by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > I have heard that the handwriting recognition in XP is really good, but we're skeptical about it being good enough.

      Handwriting recognition got much better in SP2, be sure to install the the SP2 Release Candidate (on a test system, not on a productive system!).

    3. Re:For our clinic, it's notebooks not tablets by peacefinder · · Score: 1

      If you wouldn't mind:

      Which tablets have you tried? Which ones does your staff (especaially nursing) like? How much did they cost?

      --
      With reasonable men I will reason; with humane men I will plead; but to tyrants I will give no quarter. -- William Lloyd
  63. Element Computer's Computer is NOT a TabletPC by spectecjr · · Score: 3, Insightful

    TabletPCs are NOT touch-sensitive. They use EM resonance based pens, so you can lean your arm on the device while you write, or hover over it. Some can even measure the tilt of the pen, or determine the difference between the tip of the pen and the eraser end.

    Element Computer's "tablet", however, has a touch screen like a PDA. It's not even close to a tablet, and would not work like one even if it had the right software.

    --
    Coming soon - pyrogyra
  64. good month for news by DrJAKing · · Score: 3, Funny

    First Apple release a new ipod, now an article about a laptop with a different kind of hinge. It's all happening at once, I can't keep up.

  65. Me, neither. Really. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I was contemplating a Palm Zire, camera included and all. One thing that bothered me, besides it running proprietary software, was its size. It probably pushes pockets of lighter shirts down...

    Now, why would they want me to carry a notebook sized tablet? In the immortal wisdom of Duke Nukem: "This sucks!". Where's the mkt depts.? Aren't they supposed to come up with fetish products, something we would drool about?

    No, no, no in my dictionary... I guess with this kind of quality research, you may well outsource the entire marketing to Bangladesh.

    And it will probably improve!

  66. Clear advantage for tablets in crowded areas by chrnb · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I never used a tablet, but after using a laptop for 6 months now, i could imagine how a tablet would be immensly convienient in crowded areas.
    I always find myself being very concerned with somebody bumping into my laptop when using it on the subway - or anywhere there is people walking by or standing close to you.

    --
    MikMik Baby Organics Mikkaworks
  67. Zaurus SL-C860 by dangerz · · Score: 1

    For that much money, I'm more than happy with my Sharp Zaurus SL-C860. It has the whole tablet flippy thing, is cheaper and smaller, and runs full linux.

    --
    The greatest experience we can have is the mysterious.
    - Albert Einstein
  68. Yes. Here's why I want one. by rebelcool · · Score: 1

    I work in autonomous robotics research. The robots run wirelessly, but we capture and display mapping data in real time, currently on laptops as we follow them. If we want to direct the machine to a place of interest, we click a position on the map and it drives itself there, avoiding obstacles etc.

    The processing and memory requirement for generating these maps from laser and other sensory data is VERY intense. An athlon 2200 would be perfect for the job.

    At the moment, walking around with a laptop and following a robot is not only difficult to read, but difficult to manipulate the mouse control, requiring a sort of one armed balancing act and a careful grip.

    This tablet would be perfect, if it runs linux.

    --

    -

  69. Most obvious use for a tablet PC? by Atario · · Score: 1

    I would think it would be for artists using Photoshop or some other graphical blandisher -- especially if the touchscreen is pressure-sensitive. All the advantages of a fancy touch tablet, but directly on the screen.

    --
    "A great democracy must be progressive or it will soon cease to be a great democracy." --Theodore Roosevelt
    1. Re:Most obvious use for a tablet PC? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      http://www.wacom.com/lcdtablets/index.cfm The Cintiq is great. $2500. 18 inch screen, 1280x1024 resolution... Wonderful device, if a bit expensive. (graphire is cheap though.)

  70. Lycoris has a.... by Savet+Hegar · · Score: 1

    version of Linux for the tablet PC, but having no tablet PC, I cannot test it.

    Here's the Link

    --
    Mod points are pointless when you browse at -1.
    1. Re:Lycoris has a.... by tkwilly · · Score: 1

      Lycoris does have a tablet-linux operating system. And Helium Computers released a $999 tablet computer that was running lycoris. However, the tablet-for-linux is hardly comparable to its MS counterpart. Apparently there isn't even a hand-writing recognition system in place yet. It also seems that Helium has silently discontinued it since I can't find it on their website.

  71. Well, we are by antek9 · · Score: 1

    You don't seem to get it. No need to 'type' (be it virtual or whatever) on a tablet pc, if you exclude passwords, email adresses and URLs (and I guess coding, read: everything that leans toward the cryptic. Recognition works word wise, not letter by letter), because the handwriting recognition is well enough already.

    My tablet runs everything I need it to, and is simply the best choice for learning Japanese I ever found: you come across unknown kanji in some text, e.g. a newspaper, you input them by pen and immediately get the reading without spending 10 minutes looking it up in a paperbased or electronic dictionary. And after that I just copy that word into my vocab drill application so that I won't forget it the very next minute.

    Yet the device is handy enough to rest in my lap while trying to read said newspaper or literature. That's why tablets would be every students wet dream, were it not for the small instabilities that plague them, as in my case: using digital ink might crash Word or One Note, hibernating doesn't work properly and the graphics/digitizer driver will cause a total freeze every now and then... Actually, that driver issue is what's responsible for all the trouble, so that might only be temporary.

    Do I need to mention that running Trek games or the good ole ST Encyclopedia on a slate tablet is one of the ultimate geek experiences available right now?

    --
    A World in a Grain of Sand / Heaven in a Wild Flower,
    Infinity in the Palm of your Hand / And Eternity in an Hour.
  72. The way to bring the cost down by Anonymous+Cowpat · · Score: 0

    is to drop all this "as-good-as-a-real-PC ...Honest" stuff.

    Look, it's 12" long, 9" wide & less than 1" thick.
    You aren't going to get a fully functional computer into that space at reasonable cost, pea -brain.

    What they need to do is get rid of:
    1)Optical drives
    2)The floppy drive
    3)Any processor above ~ 1GHz
    4)Copious quantities of RAM

    i.e. BARE BONES, VERY bare bones.
    All it needs is a low-power processor, a cut down OS that will fit into minimal quantities of RAM (and will be stored in a ROM or similar solid-state storage), wireless networking & onboard everything-that-currently-comes-on-a-card (and cut down editions).

    With the higher bandwidth wireless networking coming over the horizon it's soon going to be feasable to run the tablet as a dumb terminal hooked up to a proper PC - let's face it, anyone who can afford to be using such a gadget instead of pen & paper probably has a PC as well.
    This has several advantages:
    1)Cheaper Overall for the tablet (assuming that you have a PC already)
    2)You aren't putting all your eggs in one basket - if you drop it it's just an LCD and a few cheap components, not a complete PC
    3)You can upgrade it easily, since you actually upgrade the host computer using standard components - as long as you don't break it, the tablet could last a decade or more as it's just relaying what another PC is processing
    4)You still have a real PC for typing tasks\gaming\hacking\programming\reading /. on etc

    Oh, and since it won't have so much stuff in it you can either make it cheaper by using less-miniature components, or still use the mini ones (but less of them) and have more space in the case for batteries - imagine getting 12 hours out of it.

    And if you want to use if for watching films, either copy them to hard disk before you go out, or, if you opt for one without a hard disk which does a network boot (requiring wireless networking support to be built into the BIOS, but hey, they did it with CD's), you could have a little box to clip on the end with oodles of solid-state storage.
    Just using the storage density of todays USB pen drives, you could get 20Gb in one, that's 4 movies anyway, minimum.
    Alternatively, stay within range of your network and watch them straight off the main PC.

    Stick a few ports (USB & firewire) & some PCCard slots and you're sorted for printers/keyboards(if you're desperate) & TV reception.

    All the functionality of a full-blown PC in a small box with a screen on the front, for a fraction of what it would cost today.
    Utilising all the wireless internet hotspots hanging about nowadays, yuo could even run it on the other side of the world (albeit for quite a bit of lag).

    --
    FGD 135
  73. NOT /.'ed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    First, the Postnuke developers are responsible for the spelling. Second, the site was not /.ed so bad ... it has handled being /ed many times. Instead the session table failed after several people tried to tinker with it.

    The Postnuke modules.php file has now been renamed with a simple html file to redirect everyone to a bland html page with the images and some of the text. This will keep out all problems with the database and hopefully allow everyone to enjoy the images.

    LPH
    www.tuxreports.com

  74. NOTHING to do with /. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It was a coincidence. The sessions table was buggered (about every 8 seconds someone 'attacks' that server) and I was working on the site.

    The corrupt table was deleted and replaced, modules.php (postnuke file) was replaced with a simple html file with a link to a version of the article so that it loads quickly and without all the fluff.

    All should be fine.

    LPH
    www.tuxreports.com

  75. Tablet... by Maljin+Jolt · · Score: 2, Insightful

    ...is very practical for doing your work in bed or at beach.

    --
    There you are, staring at me again.
    1. Re:Tablet... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      I don't know what's wrong with you but I don't need anything to "work" in bed. I think a tablet would just get in our way.

  76. Can you use it as a logbook? by AZhole · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I'm a particle physicist and it seems to me that these tablet PCs might be suitable replacements for the traditional logbook. The idea is that it would be a community tool that can be could be carried around the detector as people fix things (think of a big industrial setting), connect to a database via wireless to log changes, recognize the handwriting for multiple users, embed eps or jpg/png/gif in the log, etc.

    Has anyone used these in an industrial setting? What do you think?

  77. MOD GRANDPARENT FUNNY (nt) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    (no text)

  78. Issues with that by muyuubyou · · Score: 1

    - Sites intending to gather real information about their visitors, and their feedback.

    - Sites with non-spiderable generated server-side response. This includes the common case when they have archives and databases the user should be able to browse, and slashdot is not mirroring it all.

    Which is basically when google cache doesn't work so well.

  79. Market for Tablet PCs by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I use speech recognition on my Notebook every day (Dragon Naturally Speaking), which is considerably faster and more efficient than typing after some training, even if you type fast, at least for most kinds of texts I write. With a Tablet PC - which I cannot afford at the moment - correction of a dictated text within Dragon should be a great deal faster than with mouse and keyboard. Therefore word processing in combination with speech recognition seems to me a natural application of Tablet PCs, and the relevant market is certainly not a niche, at least, not once more people will have found out how well Dragon works by now. I will buy a T-PC as soon as I have the money.

  80. problems by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    1. Gorilla arm
    2. Dropping it
    3. Scratching the screen

  81. I have one of those by commodoresloat · · Score: 1

    It rocks! It has a lot of features and no bloat. Instant-on; you never have to wait for it to boot up. A keyboard would be nice but the graffiti input feature works just like your handwriting! It even works with script! And notes are automatically saved. Great drawing programs, spreadsheets, etc. And it's not the best gaming platform, but with tic-tac-toe and exquisite corpse you've still got more games than a Mac.

    1. Re:I have one of those by simonjester2424 · · Score: 1

      I just googled exquisite corpse because I had until very recently never heard of it. Sounds like fun, thanks for mentioning it.

      --
      Beware of gifts bearing Greeks.
  82. We Need an eMate II by commodoresloat · · Score: 1
    I got one of these off ebay a few months ago and it is the coolest thing in the world. I can't get it to sync with OS X in any meaningful way so it isn't very useful, but with an updated processor - something like they use in new PDAs. The form factor is just incredible. It is simple, the keyboard is easy to type on, small, the screen doubles as a touch pad, and the whole thing is made out of sturdy plastic. I've dropped it on concrete with no problems other than scratches. And it has a freakin handle. This thing is also a babe magnet, and had the potential to be as ubiquitous as the iPod. But of course Apple dumped it because Newton is a "bad idea." *sigh*

    I want someone to put a modern PDA processor in this clamshell and maybe put palmOS on it or Symbian, since Apple killed the newton, but otherwise leave it basically the same -- black and white is fine for me; throw out a tricked out color version for a few hundred more of course, and you can put all the silly gadgets they're putting in PDAs nowadays, but give me for $200-300 a basic greyscale PDA that you can type or draw on that is as easy and wonderful to use as the eMate. Throw in wireless, a usb or firewire port, and it's set. Basic text editor, web browser, terminal emulater, drawing program, etc., decent amount of nonvolatile memory but no hard drive -- simple, inexpensive, and elegant.

    Oh yeah, it's a cool looking green color too, but Apple of course could produce these things in iPod colors.

  83. Re:Has hand-written text recognition improved at a by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I played with a co-worker's Windows pda once and the handwriting recognition was absolutely mind blowing. I signed my name across the thing in cursive, and it typed it right in without missing a letter. Compared with the graffiti crap on the palms it was like magic. I haven't had the opportunity to play with a tablet pc, but I'd have to assume that throwing the power of a ghz+ processor behind the recognition software would only make it that much better.

  84. Re:Has hand-written text recognition improved at a by Hitmouse · · Score: 1

    and a new free update to Tablet O/S that comes with XP SP2 raises the bar even further with even better recognition, even with writing at an angle.

  85. Re:Maybe I'm just uninformed..or just text centric by Hitmouse · · Score: 1

    At home, it's my main computer and I have a docking station for it, but I also roam around the house and elsewhere doing things like: * surfing the web wirelessly while sitting/lying in a comfortable position * using ink in MSN Messenger, which is just SO COOL. There is nothing like ink to personalize a message and allow you to reply graphically rather than in boring text * I wirelessly manage music playing in my house * I have literally thousands upon thousands of pieces of music on my computer in PDF format. I can sit my tablet on my piano sheet music rest and play from there without having mountains of paper everywhere (regardless of where i travel) * I can also plug the MIDI output from my piano into the Tablet, so I can compose and edit music interactively at the piano (my piano has a MIDI retrofit) * ... and so much more .. most of which has little to do with handwriting recognition, but absolutely needs the tablet form factor and/or ink.

  86. Strange Security Message by Dr.+q00p · · Score: 1

    The site ShipItForYou.Com's Internet Security statement is a bit strange:
    "ShipItForYou.Com's Internet Security is a VeriSign Secure Site. Our security is unmatched anywhere on the Internet. Your name, credit card number, and all other information are NEVER stored on the Internet. Once you enter your information, they are encrypted and sent directly to our accounting/order processing system that is NOT on the Internet."

    If it is not on the Internet, how is it sent to the accounting/order processing system? Do the 'encrypt' it with Whitespace and fax it over?

  87. Lawyers by edg176 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Lawyers spend most of their time writing and editing. In a typical firm what happens is that an attorney will write something, print it out, edit it with a pen and then hand it either to a junior attorney or a secretary. Then the secretary or junior attorney will input the changes. It's a total waste of time, because then the typist has to go back and try to figure out what the hell the lawyer was talking about.

    With good software (and I admit that XP is only getting there), an attorney could edit right on the screen. Now some of you will ask why attorneys can't do that now on screen The answer is that editing is an interactive process where often people want to scribble in the margins or otherwise engage with the document.

    My prediction? When tablet PC's get good enough, you'll see the ranks of secretaries thin out at some law firms. People who understand IT (and most lawyers don't) will be able to shrink the overhead at their firm. Everyone else will be lunch.

  88. Education by losvedir · · Score: 0

    And they work great for taking notes in college lectures -- particularly math and physics courses that require lots of graphs and things. You can have the freehandedness of a standard binder or notebook, and the benefits of having it stored as text, too.

    --
    "True dat with a wiffle ball bat." -- kabrakan
  89. wtf?! by jcuervo · · Score: 0
    It looks like Tablet PCs are finally hitting real-world budgets. Averatec released a Tablet PC with an AMD Athlon XP-M 2200+ processor and will be at Costco and Staples for $1349.
    How the HELL is that a real-world budget? That's a third of my fscking paycheck, before taxes!

    I hate it when people say "affordable" and mean $20,000 USD.
    --
    Assume I was drunk when I posted this.
    1. Re:wtf?! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You should stop exaggerating.

      I "hate" it when people can't distinguish between $1000 and $20,000.

  90. I have an Element tablet... by Xophmeister · · Score: 1

    ...I've had a lot of trouble with it (hardware and software) however Element have *great* customer support. When I tried upgrading to their new distro, guess what: it didn't work! Well, I got in touch with them, by e-mail, and within a day I had a working machine again (they put some special isos up for me :)

    Having said that, after using Linux for about four months or so: I don't like it. Flame me if you will but I just prefer FreeBSD, so that's going on there (I'm already in the process of modding my case).

    Anyway, my point has nothing to do with Element, nor BSD advocacy. A friend of mine also has a tablet PC (Windows, I'm afraid) and between us we have *never* used the tablet functionality. I'm just wondering, does anyone? Or do people just buy laptops with spinning screens just because they're novel and a cool gadget (like me ;)

    --

    Christopher Harrison

  91. Re:Prediction by zmollusc · · Score: 0

    That sounds likely. Lawyers are always trying to undercut each others prices. I am amazed they can afford to eat, they work so cheap.

    --
    They whose government reduces their essential liberties for temporary security, receive neither liberty nor security.
  92. i would use one if Apple made it... by nikster · · Score: 1

    the only use i can think of is to use the tablet as a notebook - just like i make my notes on paper during meetings. making those notes on the computer screen would not be a huge deal, but it would be useful.

    the problem is, in order to be useful, it would have to work perfectly. it would have to work the same way a Newton worked - it would become an electronic notepad.

    therefore, it won't work on windows - windows and working perfectly is an oxymoron. it just won't.

    i think we will see the same thing that happened with the iPod. a HD based mp3 player was a good idea, and lots of companies tried it before Apple. yet, what they produced was complete crap (i still have an old Nomad lying around.. ). so it never caught on.
    Windows tablet PCs are not quite as bad because at least you can still use them as normal notebooks - which is what 99% of people owning them do...

  93. One more reason to use a Tablet PC... by Dekortage · · Score: 1

    At least for illustrators, Alias SketchBook Pro is a godsend. I don't use it myself, but I've spent the last six months doing Tablet PC UI research for Microsoft, and the people who are most passionate about these computers are professional illustrators and artists. Unfortunately that's not MS's primary target audience, but hey....

    --
    $nice = $webHosting + $domainNames + $sslCerts
  94. I use my Tablet PC as a chick magnet! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I'm serious! There is this local cafe, where I work, that has free Wi-Fi (although they expect you to buy something from them, before you use it). The girls behind the counter can't get enough of my demonstrations! They can use the pen as a cue stick in Tablet PC Pool (a PowerToy on Microsoft's site.), compose music with the pen and play it back (with another PowerToy), fill in crossword puzzles, paint more comfortably on the computer, etc.! Every week I come up with something new to show em, and it is starting to ... eh... pay off, now!

  95. Good fish doesn't smell by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    My Gawd, how come this piece of trawl was modded up as Insightful?

  96. Ha! You just described an avergrown PDA. by White+Manual · · Score: 1


    Can it do 3d modelling?

    Computers can.

    --

  97. Artist Tablets by fm6 · · Score: 1
    Tablets used by artists are not just pointing devices -- they detect minutes changes in pressure. That's a lot more sophisticated (and expensive) than the stylus support in in any tablet PC.

    Incidentally, artist's tablets with a built-in display have been available for years.

    Don't get me wrong, I love the idea of tablet PCs. I've wanted one ever since I saw Captain Kirk using one on Star Trek. But artists are not going to be first in line for the current crop of devices.