Slashdot Mirror


The Giants of Anime are Coming

Wired is running a story about the Giants of Anime which discusses numerous things happening on the anime front, including the new Ghost in the Shell movie, and the upcoming Miyazaki release "Howl's Moving Castle". This is something of a background piece for people somewhat unfamiliar, but it also covers a lot of interesting bits that the fans might enjoy as well.

392 comments

  1. Greatest Anime Film? by jetkust · · Score: 2, Interesting

    So what is the greatest full-length anime film ever made? Ghost In the Shell? Akira? Metropolis? Spirited Away? Wings of Honneamise? Anywone Know? I always figured it was Akira, but that's just me.

    1. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by StevenHenderson · · Score: 1, Interesting

      Sprited Away sucked bigtime if you ask me. If I want an Americanized anime flick, Princess Mononoke is the best.

    2. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by NorthernMinx · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I'd say Ghost in the Shell! A lot of people are going to say Spirited Away because on the exposure it got.

    3. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Icarus1919 · · Score: 5, Funny

      Duh. Everyone knows that the greatest anime movie is Pokemon: The First Movie.

    4. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by DJTodd242 · · Score: 5, Funny

      I would like to whole heartedly congratulate you for this post. I'm certain that this isn't a loaded question, and we'll see insightful discourse on the subject of Anime.

      People's mothers, including thier mating, and eating habits will not be mentioned at all. :)

    5. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by FCAdcock · · Score: 2, Interesting

      For me it was actually the Cowboy Bebop movie.

      Akira is way overhyped. Spirited Away was long and boring. Even Perfect Blue has lost it's charm for me. But any movie with the song 'Tank' in it is a good movie...

      --
      --Forest C. Adcock--
    6. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by mzkhadir · · Score: 1

      Choose any file not based on pokemon or other americanized characters and you've got a good film. To me Spirited Away was good, Akira was better. Princess Mononoke was good, but Ghost in the Shell was better. Cowboy Bebop was good, but Ninja Scroll was better.

    7. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by tendram · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Nausicaä of the Valley of Wind in my book, closely followed by Mononoke Hime. But I'm a Miyazaki Fanboy, so I'm likely biased.

    8. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by JanneM · · Score: 1

      For me, Spirited Away. Wonderful movie.

      --
      Trust the Computer. The Computer is your friend.
    9. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by cabazorro · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I'm truly split between
      Ghost in the Shell
      and
      my Neighboor Totoro
      and I'm not anywhere near
      to make up my damn mind.

      --
      - these are not the droids you are looking for -
    10. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by LynXmaN · · Score: 2

      For me the best anime ever is Ghost in the Shell followed by Ghibli's "Hotaru no Haka" (Graveyard of the Fireflies)

      --
      May the source be with you!
    11. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by supun · · Score: 1, Insightful

      End of Evangelion

      A great (second) ending to the Neon Genesis Evangelion series.

      --
      :w!
    12. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by mirko · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I don't like anime which I consider dull and boring.
      Akira was a fantasdtic comic but didn't make it on a screen.
      I do not know the other you mention but there's ONE anime which actually carried me, it was Hotaru no haka".
      Very few anime were THAT convincing.

      --
      Trolling using another account since 2005.
    13. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by CaptainCheese · · Score: 1

      Grave of the Fireflies, a lesser known product of Studio Ghibli.

      IF you watch it I dare you not to cry.

      --
      -- .sigs are a waste of data...turn them off...
    14. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Soul-Burn666 · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Honestly, though, I think no full-length anime film can ever come close to a full-length anime series with 26~ episodes.
      Sure, the movie can be amazing and very cinematic, but 1.5-2 hours is not enough time to build a character with the sophistication some anime builds them.
      Sure, movies can build very complex ideas and characters (regardless if it's JP or US movie/series) but usually it makes you think "well, that's a character I only seen for the first time an hour ago..." instead of learning about the character from 10-20 episodes, in many different situations and mini-stories.

      Ofcourse, this applies to movies vs series regardless of their origin and ofcourse there are also stupid, shallow series and good, complex movies.

      --
      ^_^
    15. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Mprx · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Akira has the most impressive animation, but My Neighbor Totoro is the greatest. It proves you don't need violence and conflict to have a great story, only great characters. I've seen it compared to the Winnie The Pooh stories (the originals, not the Disney crap), which also show how a flawless children's story can be enjoyed by everybody.

    16. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by hpulley · · Score: 1, Informative

      If you like Ninja Scroll you should see Wicked City. Many don't rate it as highly but I found it to be quite original and well, wicked. Both are excellent and quickly wipe the "cartoons are for kids" grins off the uninitiated.

      Other favorites of course include Akira and Ghost (though I prefer the manga) and Appleseed but also Golgo 13 and Angel Cop.

      Battle Angel was a disappointment, after the wonderful manga.

      Like most other cases of book to film adaptations, sometimes the book is better, other times the film is better and it varies from person to person, sometimes depending on which one you saw first but not always.

      --
      $#!^ happens, but why does it always have to happen to me???
    17. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by mchenrytl · · Score: 2, Informative

      It's funny this topic came up today, I just read my Wired magazine last night in bed and really enjoyed the article about the new anime coming out this year. I'm especially excited about Steam Boy.

      As someone who's seen most of the major Anime films, I would have to put my vote for story with Lensman, overall narative with Spirited Away, and animation wise I'd go with Final Fantasy (it really is a good movie, though I think they should of made it fantasy based instead of sci-fi based, but oh well).

      With Spirited Away, the animation is above average and I thought the character development was stellar. The other movies mentioned, Akira, Ninja Scroll, Vampire Hunter D, and Ghost in the Shell are all good in their genre, but I think they're so focused that they loose a lot of the audience in their own importance.

      For best bizarre movie with funky music my vote is for Light Years.

      And when is Lensman going to come out on DVD?

      -Troy

    18. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by FCAdcock · · Score: 1

      Exactly, because no movie can compare to the nearly 100 epesodes of Naurato, or the story in a series like Noir or Trigun. I sit each week and download the new Naurato, as if I were waiting on a new epesode of Law and Order on television. For me, some of the best tv is actually anime off of the internet.

      --
      --Forest C. Adcock--
    19. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by jandrese · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Ah yes, Grave of the Fireflies. I've traumatized several people into never ever watching animation again with that film. It's not the sort of movie I just whip out when people ask what they should see, it's definatly something you need to get mentally prepared for first.

      --

      I read the internet for the articles.
    20. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by The-Bus · · Score: 5, Informative
      According to the IMDB...

      Taking away non-animé animated animations, we come up with:

      1. Sen to Chihiro no kamikakushi (Spirited Away) * ^
      2. Mononoke-hime (Princess Mononoke) * ^
      3. Hotaru no haka (Grave of the Fireflies) ^
      4. Tenkû no shiro Rapyuta (Laputa: Castle in the Sky) * ^
      5. Sennen joyu (Millenium Actress) ^
      6. Tonari no Totoro (My Neighbor Totoro) * ^
      7. Majo no takkyubin (Kiki's Delivery Service) * ^
      8. Shin seiki Evangelion Gekijô-ban: Air/Magokoro wo, kimi ni (Neon Genesis Evangelion: The End of Evangelion)
      9. Kaze no tani no Naushika (Nausicaä of the Valley of the Winds) * ^
      10. Mimi wo sumaseba (Whisper of the Heart) * ^
      11. Akira
      12. Kurenai no buta (Flying Pig/Porco Rosso) * ^
      13. Kôkaku kidôtai (Ghost in the Shell)
      14. Jûbei ninpûchô (Ninja Scroll)
      15. Rupan sansei: Kariosutoro no shiro (Lupin III: The Castle of Cagliostro) * ^
      16. Vampire Hunter D
      17. Cowboy Bebop: Tengoku no tobira (Cowboy Bebop: The Movie)
      18. Jin-Rô (Jin Roh)^
      19. Perfect Blue ^

      * A Hayao Miyazaki film.
      ^ Not a film about giant robots, ninjas, or robot-ninjas fighting each other. Not a film set in a dystopian future or filled with demons.

      So, of the top 50, we've got 19 features being animé (and half of the Bottom 10 are animé). Of the top 10, 5 are animé, 4 are by Pixar, and one is Shrek.
      --

      Small potatoes make the steak look bigger.

    21. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Personally I liked Spirited Away, it was very imaginative, had emotional depth, and a really satisfying feeling of strangeness without sacrificing comprehensibility. Lots of laughs too, without succumbing to pathetic geeky humour. None of that distressing Japanese robot tentacle child rape sex pervert crap - am I the ONLY person who finds that stuff offensive?

      As for Akira and Ghost in the Shell? Incomprehensible and pretentious are two of the least confrontational words I can find.

    22. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      heh, this is

    23. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by minasoko · · Score: 1
      Surely this is completely subjective and any "answer" is simply an opinion? Anyhow, the features that appeal the most to me are Mononoke Hime, Jin-Roh and Ghost in the Shell.

      Honourable mentions go to Grave of the Fireflies (if you don't mind having your heart strings tugged) and Cowboy Bebop -Knockin' on Heaven's Door. But, if you could bend the rules slightly and allow Kenshin: Meiji Kenkaku Romantan -Tsuiokuhen through as a feature (the four parts add up to just over 2 hours) then that would be my runaway favourite.

    24. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by xagon7 · · Score: 4, Interesting

      I do agree Cowboy Bebop was one of the best Anime movie I have ever seen. I'd put it up there with Ninja Scroll.

      I don't remember "Tank" being in the movie.... just the series.

      Fo those who don't know, "Tank" is the song played at the beginning of the TV episodes....awesome, just awesome, and like Farscape, any show that has the balls to be that creative and get away with it deserves my respect.

    25. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Jeez, if you love it so much, you could at least spell it right.

      It's NARUTO , motherfucker.

    26. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by 1WingedAngel · · Score: 1
      So what is the greatest full-length anime film ever made?
      That's highly subjective and a bit broad. We just recently had a story about the "Best Sci-Fi Film of All Time" and very few people agreed. Add to that that anime is a medium and not a genre (Just try to tell me that Spirited Away and Akira are in the same genre) and you have a question that is all but unanswerable. Just to name a few "must see" feature-length films:
      • Akira
      • Ghost in the Shell
      • Jin-Roh
      • Grave of the Fireflies
      • Junkers Come Here
      • Macross Plus
      • Perfect Blue
    27. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Jugalator · · Score: 1

      For some reason I wasn't touched to that point. Probably because I found the story to be pushing too hard, and also that it was quite predictable.

      --
      Beware: In C++, your friends can see your privates!
    28. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by blau · · Score: 1

      Nausicaä of the Valley of Wind in my book, closely followed by Mononoke Hime. But I'm a Miyazaki Fanboy, so I'm likely biased.

      Nausicaä is my favourite too and I am no Miyazaki fanboy ;) My second one is Akira, but in both cases the manga are even better!

    29. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Predictable? Really? Right down to what was in the candy can?

    30. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by WWWWolf · · Score: 1

      The first movie was average, the second one was average and kind of stupid =) But I kind of liked the third movie - it actually had something that resembled a complex plot.

      As for movies aimed at more mature audience, the three movies that I found most impressive were Wings of Honneamise (kind of like 2001: Space Odyssey but more obvious), Princess Mononoke (wolves!) and Metropolis (apart of slightly dead-ended pace at times). Most of these picks are due to personal reasons, I'm nowhere near an expert - and more familiar with european/us animations anyway.

    31. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      maybe it's just in the version I happened to download. I don't know if it's on the dvd I have or not.

    32. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by pabloa · · Score: 1

      I love animataed features but every Anime film I have ever seen has had some sort of morally/socially disturbing scene. I mean ooogie! The story lines are usually so muddled it is impossible to figure out who is who and what has happened.

      --
      Peace,Love and Magic
    33. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by ALpaca2500 · · Score: 2, Funny

      in both cases the manga are even better!

      " 'oh, the book was much better than the movie.' yeah but you know what i liked about the movie? no reading" - jim gaffigan

      (note that i agree with you, though)

    34. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      My vote would be Nausicaa of the Valley of the Winds. Classical style, decent plot movement, traditional story. I'm tired of people trying to put Akira back in the limelight. It had it's hayday when people were obsessed with it just to say they watched anime. Put in a few hours of Neon Genesis: Evangelion or Escaflowne and maybe we'll talk

    35. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by mjm1231 · · Score: 1

      Hadashi no Gen (Barefoot Gen) has a star rating (8.9) higher than any of those, but with a total of only 120 votes doesn't make the list. But it certainly deserves to be mentioned here, even if the animation does look a little dated.

      --
      Ideology: A tool used primarily to avoid the bother of thinking.
    36. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by myc_lykaon · · Score: 2, Insightful
      As far as depth of story goes I have always prefered 'Roujin Z'. A somewhat bizarre but pointed message about the issues of an aging population.

      just my 2p

    37. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by CaptainCheese · · Score: 1

      No, you're probably just a hideous monster inside.

      Just kidding ^_^; I see where you're coming from: It's pretty predictable from the start that they're doomed, but that's what made it poignant for me...

      --
      -- .sigs are a waste of data...turn them off...
    38. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Macgruder · · Score: 2, Informative

      No, 'Tank!' wasn't played for the movie. The opening theme was 'Ask DNA'.

      --
      I'm not crazy,I'm actively irresponsible.
    39. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Megane · · Score: 1
      Honestly, though, I think no full-length anime film can ever come close to a full-length anime series with 26~ episodes.

      More like 13 episodes. Most 26 episode series these days break it up into two major story arcs, and manage to give you two good stories in 26 episodes. But there are a lot of 13 episode series lately. And for what it's worth, Cowboy Bebop was like this, only they mixed in the episodes from the Vicious story arc (which I didn't care for) throughout the entire run.

      Recent good recent anime (by no means exhaustive): Haibane Renmei (13), Kino no Tabi (13), Stellvia (2x13), Scrapped Princess (2x13), Paranoia Agent (13), Samurai Champloo (12 eps so far, out of probably 26), Read Or Die/ROD TV (3 OVA + 2x13).

      As for the "giants", they're the old giants. How about they stop drooling over the same old directors and start looking for some new giants? Like Satoshi Kon, for instance.

      --
      #naabhaprzrag, #sverubfr-000, #agi-fcbafberq, negvpyr[pynff*=' negvpyr-ary-'] { qvfcynl: abar !vzcbegnag; }
    40. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Megane · · Score: 1

      I don't know what it is about Totoro, but if someone could figure it out and bottle it up, they could rule the world. For a kids story, Totoro kicks total ass. Even in the dub.

      --
      #naabhaprzrag, #sverubfr-000, #agi-fcbafberq, negvpyr[pynff*=' negvpyr-ary-'] { qvfcynl: abar !vzcbegnag; }
    41. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sure, I'll see your film and raise you "Plague Dogs"...

    42. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by BJH · · Score: 1

      every Anime film I have ever seen has had some sort of morally/socially disturbing scene

      Yeah, that really sucks. I sure prefer my animated features to be two hours of mindless pap with zero mental stimulation.

    43. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Qzukk · · Score: 1

      Everyone's mentioned a lot of stuff, but nobody's mentioned the Revolutionary Girl Utena movie (shoujo kakumei utena: adolescence mokushiru). Brightly colored, well paced, with plenty of action, it will keep people's attention while playing out several symbolic comparisons to becoming an adult and finding acceptance of one's lifestyle.

      Is it the best? Probably not, for several reasons (very little character exposition, it expects that the viewer has seen the 39 episode TV series (also very good), and unfortunately CPM's US release of the movie is glitchy) but it definitely deserves watching unless you're easily offended. I was lucky to see it in a movie theater at a convention years ago, its truly stunning on the big screen in surround sound.

      --
      If I have been able to see further than others, it is because I bought a pair of binoculars.
    44. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by aiabx · · Score: 1

      Well, as I recall, there were giant robots in Laputa; the broken one in the castle dungeon, the gardener, and the hundreds waiting to be turned loose to destroy! But I know what you mean...they weren't battlesuits piloted by people with spiky hair.

      I'm going to sail against the trend here and pick Spirited Away as my favourite. I find it charming, delightful, fantastic in the proper sense of the word, and beautifully made. Miyazaki clearly knows children well. The kids in Totoro, Kiki and Spirited Away are painfully real. In some ways it's a pity that SA became so popular. Now it gets sneered at by people who need to prove themselves by liking cooler things than the masses. (Not a troll... not liking SA doesn't mean you're a sneerer, but we all know they're out there).

      Grave of the Fireflies is too painful for parents to watch. I couldn't get through it. Well made, though. And I have a warm spot for Akira, the film that (along with Road Warrior) inspired me to buy my first motorcycle.
      -aiabx

      --
      Just this guy, you know?
    45. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by BJH · · Score: 1

      That's "Zettai Unmei Mokujiroku" - Absolute Fate Revelations.

    46. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by kiljoy001 · · Score: 1

      Well my mother enjoys the comedy/serious type of anime, me on the had like to pick up whatever depending on that day's meal, you know - if I want something light and tasty: there's always Dragonball, Cheasy: Pokemon (esp. Pikachu, the cheasiest of them all), and for the main course, something heavy like evangelion or raxphexion(sp?). Oh of course one is feeling randy, H tentical porn is great for me and the mrs.

    47. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by CaptainCheese · · Score: 1

      A bit Off-Topic, but in that IMDb link, Disney only have 4 entries in the top 20, and only one of those was made after 1940. Pixar and Ghibli justifiably dominate the rest of the list.

      In unrelated news Buena Vista (a wholly owned DisneyCorp subsiduary) have distribution contracts with both Pixar and Ghibli...

      A while back Roy Disney quit the board in protest of the actions of Eisner, who has seemingly systematically gutted and destroyed the Feature animation departments over the last decade or so...In fact IIRC Brother Bear is the last traditional feature animation Disney will make...

      --
      -- .sigs are a waste of data...turn them off...
    48. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by BJH · · Score: 1

      Ah, apologies - "Adolescence Mokujiroku", rather.

    49. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Otik2 · · Score: 3, Interesting

      You need to get mentally prepared (or unwound) after it too. I read that when it first aired in Japan, it was a double-feature with Totoro. That seems like a very good idea to me; I watched them together too, and if I hadn't watched Totoro right after Grave, it would have been a lot tougher...

    50. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Akira when it comes to japanimation.
      If you count South Korean movies Wonderful Days beats anything else I've seen. A bit jerky at times on the animation side, but the movie still fills me with awe everytime I see it.

    51. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ah, I knew it didn't quite flow right but I couldn't figure out what syllables I had missed.

      Thanks

    52. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Halthar · · Score: 1

      Legend of the Overfiend (Urotsukidoji) is the best anime ever, because nothing says quality anime like tenticle rape.

      All kidding aside, I really can't make up my mind which movie is the best. There are so many extraordinary ones it's hard to decide. It really depends on what the viewer likes. I have found that there is something for everyone out there. You just have to look for it.

      Ghost in the Shell is one of my favorites, but I haven't pulled out the DVD just to watch it since Stand Alone Complex started to air. For those who haven't seen it, the series is just that good.

      Actually, I have been finding that I generally crave a good series far more than a good movie. You just can't pack the punch of a good series into something the length of a movie. Scrapped Princess while wonderful as a series (and not mentioned nearly enough), just wouldn't work as a movie. Another example would be Evangelion. As a series Evangelion is increadible and I really don't see how you could hope to communicate the depth of the series in a movie length feature.

      I will definitely see new anime based movies as they come out, and continue to watch the ones that have already been released, but if I want something truly immersive I will pull out my DVDs of series episodes and watch those.

    53. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by aka-ed · · Score: 1
      I'd agree, but must give primacy to Koroshiya 1: Episode 0.

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
    54. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Reducer2001 · · Score: 2, Funny

      The obvious follow-up is which is one is better.......ON WEED!
      I vote Ghost in the Shell on that one. I usually fall asleep during Akira.

      --
      When you get to hell -- tell 'em Itchy sent ya!
    55. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by bioglaze · · Score: 1

      I agree on that, the movie's so psychologically twisted that your whole life changes after watching it:). OTOH, best stand alone movie (not based on tv series) is probably Nausicaë or Ghost In the Shell.

      --
      Who is John Galt?
    56. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by BJH · · Score: 1

      Even better, see the live-action movie directed by Takashi Miike.

      I'm amazed he was able to keep it so faithful to the original manga...

    57. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Zak3056 · · Score: 2, Informative

      Ah yes, Grave of the Fireflies. I've traumatized several people into never ever watching animation again with that film.

      I've seen the opposite effect--utter shock that something as mundane as a "cartoon" could tell that kind of story, and an interest in more of the genre.

      --
      What part of "shall not be infringed" is so hard to understand?
    58. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      that's quite a disgusting movie, I fast-forwarded over the torture scenes but it was really gripping.

    59. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      it is a movie which makes you cry...
      I loved it but it was such a cruel movie.

    60. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by pixieluv · · Score: 1

      Ghost in the shell is by far the best one :P in my opinion

      --
      "But i loveded you PIGGY I LOVEDED YOU!!!!!" *Gir*
    61. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by BakaHoushi · · Score: 1

      Princess Mononoke (or Mononoke Hime to those out there who attempt to kill anything that is *gasp* actually translated into English) is by far the best anime film I've ever seen, if not one of the best movies I've seen ever.

      Though I still cringe everytime I see the mother wolf get the blood sucked from her wound and the flesh being eaten of the boar by demons. But, you know, what Disney flick doesn't feature that these days, huh?

    62. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by bircho · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Pushing too hard? It's based in a true story. That's hard...

    63. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Recovery1 · · Score: 1

      I really liked Tokyo Godfathers. It's not up there with many of the other ground breaking anime films, but I like it still nonetheless.

    64. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Tassach · · Score: 2, Funny

      I've always been partial to Urotsukidôji: Legend of the Overfiend -- the definitive tenticle sex hentai anime.

      --
      Why is it that the proponents of "one nation under God" are so eager to get rid of "liberty and justice for all"?
    65. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      FYI, Nausicaa and Laputa most definitely are set in a distopian future.

      And both feature giant robots of varying size.

      No ninjas, though. :)

    66. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by iantri · · Score: 2, Interesting
      Actually, they talk about this on the North American DVD release. Apparently, they tried showing it two different orders (Totoro/Fireflies and Fireflies/Totoro), and found that people absolutely HATED Fireflies when seen after Totoro.

      Guess that ties into the aforementioned psychological effect.

    67. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by number6x · · Score: 1

      Grave of the fireflies.

      That brings back memories.

      I'll have to dig up a copy. Thanks for reminding me!

    68. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Lisandro · · Score: 1

      As for Akira and Ghost in the Shell? Incomprehensible and pretentious are two of the least confrontational words I can find.

      Akira suffered from this ("i had to read a website to understand the film - it's SO cooooool!"), but Ghost in the Shell it's not so hard to follow and an excellent story aswell. Not to mention the gorgeous drawings and animation.

      Akira is very good, don't get me wrong, but for me GITS is the best anime film ever; Akira gets the extra points to be one of the very first.

    69. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I show grave of the fireflies to people who think anime is just for kids.

      So far noone hasn't changed his mind on the subject after seeing the movie.

    70. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Is this "Tank" the same as the "Tank" on the first ELP album?

      Note: To those drummers who have slit their wrists over the drum solo in that song, it appears that the solo is "juiced," i.e., edited in at a faster speed than the rest of the song.

    71. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I am by no means an anime aficionado, but I can tell you that SPIRITED AWAY was one of the best films I've ever seen - in ANY genre. I came out of the theater looking as though I'd been through the wringer, and in a very real sense, I had been.

    72. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Odonian · · Score: 1

      I agree. There is something indescribable about Totoro. It shouldn't be that captivating; the story is simple, really not a lot of drama, animation is OK but not spectacular. But for some reason, our family ends up watching this one again and again. There is a special quality to this one that defies simple categorization.

    73. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Minna+Kirai · · Score: 1

      playing out several symbolic comparisons to becoming an adult and finding acceptance of one's lifestyle

      By "symbolic", do you mean "transform into automobiles"?

      I was lucky to see it in a movie theater at a convention years ago, its truly stunning on the big screen in surround sound.

      I saw it at a convention theater too. Most everyone walked out, regardless of whether they were fans of the TV version. A fan splicing together 90 minutes of the series could almost make a better movie.

    74. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by master_p · · Score: 1

      For me it is Space Battleship Yamato. I've seen Akira, Ghost in the Shell, Neon Genesis Evangelion, and some others, even Sailor Moon and Dragon Ball Z, so I haven't seen a lot of anime, but my heart belongs to Space Battleship Yamato. I am not a typical geek, so maybe I am excused, but SBY is the basis for all the modern anime we see so far:

      -it is the only film that Japanese people rained the cinema screens with flowers while crying
      -people made 2-mile lines around the cinemas to see it
      -it introduced the death of main protagonists
      -it introduced the continuation format
      -it introduced may stereotype roles: the dying captain; the human-robot engineer; the fearless young warrior; the comedy doctor and robot; the villain emperor; the best friend rivalry etc.
      -it has the greatest music ever
      -George Lucas copied it and made Star Wars
      -it introduced truly cosmic level events
      -the music was also a character, appearing at certain places
      -it's science fiction was not bad at all (lost in the translation, though)
      -it introduced the holodeck
      -it talked about a nuclear holocaust and its possible effects
      -it introduced the big gun which sucks all the ship's energy, making the skip vulnerable before and after the firing

      It might suck by todays animation standards, but I can't imagine a better entertainment for the family. It's sheer drama, comedy, war, science fiction, friendship and display of values and human potential bring it on the top my list. The other movies/series I have seen may be more impressive, but they are much more shallow. It features sound and smoke in the outer space, but's that's hardly my concern. As pure enteraintaiment, is invaluable.

      Flame on!

    75. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Zugok · · Score: 1

      for me, it was Kiki's Delivery Service. I kid you not. It's hard to find a story these day with no direct conflict between characters, but Kiki's Delivery Service manages to do just that. Next it would be Laputa or Porco Rosso :)

      --
      "I just can't sit while people are saying nonsense in a meeting without saying it's nonsense" J Watson, Sci Am 288:(4)51
    76. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Zugok · · Score: 1

      Grave of Fireflies will make even the hardest of people cry. It is a good movie but I do not recommend anyone buys it, because you will only see it once...ever. Yes it is that traumatising. It vertainly mad em think about being a better brother.

      --
      "I just can't sit while people are saying nonsense in a meeting without saying it's nonsense" J Watson, Sci Am 288:(4)51
    77. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by sn0wman3030 · · Score: 0

      Yeah. It's amazing.

      --
      Life is offtopic.
    78. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by critter_hunter · · Score: 1

      The prequel isn't directed by Miike, at least according to IMDB, nor is the animated movie. Both prequels are watchable, as long as you're a fan, but are nowhere near Miike's film. 1-Ichi in particular is quite terrible - the bullies are cool, and it does add some depth to the character, but it's still a badly filmed straight to video piece of fluff.

      --
      Karma: Could be worse (could be raining)
    79. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by TheoMurpse · · Score: 1

      perfect blue by satoshi kon...

      however, neko no ongaeshi (return of the cat) if you're <john stewart> on weeeed</john stewart> is the most hilarious thing ever...hell, i don't even smoke weed and that was the funniest thing ever at 4 am

    80. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by meringuoid · · Score: 1
      Apparently, they tried showing it two different orders (Totoro/Fireflies and Fireflies/Totoro), and found that people absolutely HATED Fireflies when seen after Totoro.

      Understandable. There are a couple of motifs that appear in both films, making Setsuko parallel Mei. The little crab stance, for instance, where Mei is watching over her seeds, is paralleled by Setsuko following a crab across the beach. Later, IIRC, Seita tells Setsuko that their mother is buried under a camphor tree - which is where Mei found the totoros living. It's hard enough to watch Setsuko die when you're watching a harsh, realistic war film, but when you keep involuntarily seeing her as Mei then it's just unbearable; there's no catbus coming for her this time.

      --
      Real Daleks don't climb stairs - they level the building.
    81. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by dustman · · Score: 1

      After reading these comments, yesterday I watched "Grave of the Fireflies".

      The whole time, I was thinking to myself, "OK, lots of character development, now where's the trauma?".

      It was, ultimately, a very boring movie.

    82. Re:Greatest Anime Film? by Merusdraconis · · Score: 1

      Not to mention the gorgeous drawings and animation.

      Why do I get this feeling this is because of the nude scenes?

  2. Golgi 13 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    golgi 13!

    cool CGI too

  3. Gatchaman! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The only fun anime. All the others are either copies of the Gatchaman ideas, or drawn too 'hentai' for my tastes, or take themselves waaayyy too seriously (like their fans).

  4. One of the Best things for Anime... by slipnslidemaster · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I think that one of the best things that could happen to Anime is the spotlight that Cartoon Network has put on it with Adult Swim.

    I think that they should find more quality shows and expand Adult Swim.

    --


    "What the hell is an aluminum falcon?"
    1. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by Dragoon412 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      The best stuff on Adult Swim, though, isn't anime (with the exception of Cowboy Bebop) - Spaceghost, Family Guy, Sealab 2021, Harvey Birdman, the Brak Show...

      The only anime they show (once again, exclusing Cowboy Bebop) is senseless crap like Inuyasha in its cut-down, edited-for-TV format, and Trigun, which, well, let's face it - TriGun is just Dragon Ball Z +1. The animation sucks, the story sucks, the wriring sucks, the voice acting sucks... it's just there to serve as an idol for socially akward 14 year-old boys.

    2. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by UserGoogol · · Score: 1

      Witch Hunter Robin and FLCL are pretty good. Although neither are being aired at the moment. And I'm pretty sure they're gonna be airing GitS Stand Alone Complex, which I've heard is good.

      --
      "Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity." -- Hanlon's Razor
    3. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by Knara · · Score: 1

      I dunno, from what I remember of Trigun (never watched it on AS), it was pretty entertaining. I didn't think it was anything like DBZ

    4. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by Have+Blue · · Score: 2, Informative
      All anime that has ever been run in the Adult Swim block (from memory and the list here ):
      • Blue Gender
      • Cowboy Bebop
      • FLCL
      • Gundam 0083
      • Inuyasha
      • Pilot Candidate
      • Kenshin
      • Trigun
      • The Animatrix
      • With Hunter Robin
      • Yu Yu Hakusho
      • Case Closed/Detective Conan
      • Lupin the 3rd
      • Trigun
      There are a few shows I left out that were borrowed from Toonami, and some on that list migrated back to Toonami in the end. However, my point is that many of those do not suck and are not DBZ clones, and are not meant for children.

      They used to divide Adult Swim into action (anime) and comedy (all the ones you listed) nights, but they seem to have abandoned this concept.
    5. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by kiljoy001 · · Score: 1

      Rather the best thing that could happen is that turner broadcasting creates a seperrate anime channel all by it's self. There is certainly enough material, it just need to be translated, and signed for.

    6. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by Greyfox · · Score: 4, Informative
      Witch Hunter Robin, Wolf's Rain and FLCL are some of the best I've ever run across. Witch Hunter Robin and Wolf's Rain both took me several episodes to get into them, but they're pretty amazing once you get to know the characters. FLCL has more of a pubescent fantasy feel to it but that's kind of the point with that one. So I don't think you're giving the anime lineup enough credit.

      Their line-up of 15 minute shows is pretty twisted. The episodes I've seen of Harvey Birdman have been very... wrong... But they're all very hit-or-miss. I guess it's hard to keep up that level of twisted humor consistently across an entire season. I like 'em though.

      --

      I'm trying to teach myself to set people on fire with my mind... Is it hot in here?

    7. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by aka-ed · · Score: 2, Informative
      Why would a Turner-run anime channel be better than the Anime Network? Turner has no anime library that I know of.

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
    8. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes, at the expense of everything else out there.

      CN didn't even give Reboot a fair CHANCE, bumping it at every opportunity to show more DBZ garbage. Did they even finish airing the 4th season (which they at least partially PAID for)?

    9. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by BakaHoushi · · Score: 1

      Kenshin was never on [AS], but the creator of Toonami did say in an interview that he regrets that, because it would have done so much better on [AS] than Toonami.
      (Not too mention it would have had few, if any, edits. Even on Toonami, though, Sanosuske let a few "dammit!"s slip by)

      You're also forgetting Reign, but, really, no one likes that show, so no one really even cares.

      And here's the thing: In the beginning, all of [AS] was on Sundays. Comedy and anime. Then, they split it. Comedy Sunday and Action Saturdays. Then they went to a Sunday through Thursday schedule, once again combining the two. Now, they've gotten back Saturday, which would have made Sunday all comedy, Saturday all action, and the middle of the week a combination of the two. However, [AS] in an attempt to raise Saturday ratings have put comedy shows like Futurama (not that Futurama is a bad show by any means. It rocks.) on before the action on Saturdays.

      Am I the only one who thinks Saturday nights might have gotten bad ratings because... It's Saturday night? Few people are up watching TV? It's not like it wasn't still clobbering all other late night shows.

    10. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by BakaHoushi · · Score: 1

      My only problems with Wolf's Rain and Witch Hunter Robin are the fact that they're too much mental stimulation, too late at night (Not that they're exactly the most complicated series on Earth, but they do require thought to process). I love the shows, but at 1:30am, my brain tends to be fried. I should really just be sane one day and tape them and watch them when my brain isn't already three-quarters asleep.

      And FLCL... well, FLCL is FLCL. It's just a show that drips with coolness. It's amazing that they can take so many random (yet undeniably cool) scenes and threw them together with such animation and music and in 6 episodes managed to make it all turn into a symbolic story about growing up.

      As for The William Stret Hour (all the 15-minute shows...) They're all pretty... well, hit-or-miss. In my opinion:
      Aqua Teen Hunger Force is by far the dumbest show I've ever seen. No, I mean it literally. I think my brain cells pop when I see it. It's just not funny...
      Sealab 2021 has its fair share of decent jokes, but overall, not a show I'm too fond of.
      Harvey Birdman has some episodes I'd call brilliant (like the Godfather spoof and the episode that mocks the Terror Alert system) and some episodes that put me to sleep in a heartbeat.
      Other shows like Brak, Space Ghost... well, most of them aren't on enough for me to even know.

    11. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by jbarket · · Score: 1

      Trigun is another anime they've shown that takes a while to get in to, but is absolutely brilliant in the long run.

      I was totally disinterested in it when I first saw it on CN--the first half of the series is entirely fluff--but when I was left with nothing but all of Trigun and no TV for a couple of weeks, I watched it through to the end, and the last few episodes are twisted and brilliant.

      On the other hand, I have grown to dislike anime on Adult Swim. I think they tend to play fluff more than anything else, and they tend to quit playing good series, or interrupt them indefinitely. .hack//Sign is another brilliant-in-the-long-run series, and I'm not convinced they ever finished it at all, and now they're showing the considerably-more-fluff .hack//Dusk.

      Not to mention they seem to have a habit of not finishing series in general. I understand that ratings are where it's at, but some of these series are only 13 episodes. It just seems silly to me.

      ---------------

      Oh and to go back and answer the greatest anime movie question, I'm torn between Grave of the Fireflys and The End of Evangeleon. Both are amazing, and both are emotional/mental wrecks.

      --

      -----
      jonathan barket
    12. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by Cpt_Kirks · · Score: 1

      What about "The Venture Brothers"? Where does that fit in, action or comedy?

      It's just so damn...twisted! Like ATHF with sex!

      I have hurt myself laughing every time I've seen it.

    13. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by BakaHoushi · · Score: 1

      Well, if you ask me, Venture Brothers is action-comedy. I don't mean it's a show that has action AND comedy, though it does contain both, because almost any anime on [AS] could be called an action-comedy then. But Venture Brothers is like an action show... where the action is comedic...

      Bah, I don't even know what I'm saying. Bottom line, Venture Brothers has comedy, but it wouldn't be too wrong to call it an action show, either, so I say it's well at home on what should be an all action night.

      I prefer to say it's "Like ATHF! Only with more action and actual comedy!"

    14. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by kiljoy001 · · Score: 1

      I was under the impression that turner owned the cartoon network, but I could be wrong.

    15. Re:One of the Best things for Anime... by WiseWeasel · · Score: 1

      GitS SAC is pure brilliance. You really owe it to yourself to fire up your favorite P2P client and start watching those. By far the best anime series in existance... and I wouldn't say such a thing lightly.

      --
      "I like systems, their application excepted", George Sand (French)
  5. Greater influence by StevenHenderson · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Personally, I find it interesting to see how anime is having a greater influence in all art forms with time. It has gone from a cult-ish art form to now being featured in music videos (Linkin Park's sensational "Breaking the Habit") as well as a majestic scene in Tarantino's Kill Bill. And these are the obvious ones. As the article says, we have seen it in the Matrix, etc. This is not something that is going away anytime soon...

    1. Re:Greater influence by stratjakt · · Score: 1, Flamebait

      Oh please, we all grew up watching cheap asian animation a la Voltron, Ge-Force, Astroboy, Transformers..

      You all act like you just "discoverd" something new because you call it "anime" and not "japanimation".

      As nice as the artwork is, I'd sure love to see an anime that is actually animated, and doesnt look like a shockwave cartoon.

      Pen and ink on animation cells, motherfuckers, 24 per second.

      And chill with the tentacles and the schoolgirls.

      --
      I don't need no instructions to know how to rock!!!!
    2. Re:Greater influence by The-Bus · · Score: 1

      Anime has been in music videos since at least Matthew Sweet's "Girlfriend" and that was back in 1991, already three years after Akira hit the U.S. shores.

      My litmus test for anime becoming mainstream is when people will talk about a film like Spirited Away or Perfect Blue (that is to say, no fighting robots), and not call it an anime film -- or see it because the story is good, not because it's "anime".

      --

      Small potatoes make the steak look bigger.

    3. Re:Greater influence by Buzz_Litebeer · · Score: 1

      Watch Macross Zero, it has 5 episodes, 4 of which are in the US. they are spectacularly well done.

      --
      If you don't vote, you don't matter, so don't waste your time telling me your opinion
    4. Re:Greater influence by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      Uh, that's "G-Force", and it was a horribly butchered rendition of Gatchaman with lots of deleted scenes, and lots of stupid American animation to fill in the holes.

    5. Re:Greater influence by RsG · · Score: 5, Interesting

      On the other hand, geeks are remarkably fickle about anything percieved as mainstream. I'm not saying that we automatically dismiss anything that is popular, but there is a strong preference for the exotic and unusual. Even when something is both normal and loved by geeks, we tend to take it to the next level (ala Star Wars/Star Trek and the flamewars fought over which is better).

      For Amine, I really can't see the genre maintaining it's geek cred as it becomes widely accepted and influential (note: I'm reffering to the west here, not Japan where Anime is obviously percieved quite differently). Ask youself: if this was Pokemon specifically, would it be featured on /.? I don't know if we can overcome this attitude that popular = bad, and unfortunately I'm not sure that this perception isn't justified in many cases; obscurity _is_ frequently good for artistic integrity. You might regret it if the genre becomes mainstream.

      --
      Erotic is when you use a feather. Exotic is when you use the whole chicken.
    6. Re:Greater influence by Angry+Toad · · Score: 1

      I really (really) hate to admit to liking anime, due to tha stigma attached.

      All the same the stuff you're talking about represents the worst of the form.

      Take a look at things like the Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex episodes, or Planetes, or Cowboy Bebop (though I'm not as in love with that as many are), or alternate reality stuff like Last Exile. There's some impressive storytelling and amazing animation.

    7. Re:Greater influence by StevenHenderson · · Score: 1

      My litmus test for anime becoming mainstream is when people will talk about a film like Spirited Away or Perfect Blue (that is to say, no fighting robots), and not call it an anime film -- or see it because the story is good, not because it's "anime".

      Somewhere we are finally getting with CGI movies.

      As for the music videos, I was not implying Linking Park was the first, it is just a prime example of how it has reached the mainstream (and looks damn cool in the process).

    8. Re:Greater influence by StevenHenderson · · Score: 1

      Well said. Same holds true for music (indie and such)...

    9. Re:Greater influence by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > due to tha stigma attached.

      The stigma is there for a good reason. Do you ever think that the japanese stylized porn will ever becomd mainstream?

    10. Re:Greater influence by bludstone · · Score: 1

      Those 4 eps are bootlegs. Macross Zero has not been released in the states yet.

      Wait till it is though, the disks will be awesome.

      --

      no .sig
    11. Re:Greater influence by bludstone · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      Couple of issues with this anology.

      Anime is japanese commercial art, target marketed to the japanese. The anime companies know this. One of the biggest reasons anime is popular is because it _is_ japanese. While there may be a handful of titles developed specifically with international audiences in mind, they have not lost sight of their market.

      There is a very VERY negative stigma against anime fans in japan. In the US, anime fans are considered dorky social outcasts. In japan, anime fans are considered perverted child rapists and pedophiles. I would argue that the negative stimga against anime fans is much, much worse in japan then the states.

      The reason anime has succeeded is due to creative freedom and the unique japanese perspective on copyright. The original manga-ka OWNS the characters. Not the publishing company.

      It is unfortunate that people equate popular to bad. But this is obviously bullshit. You dont think starwars was popular back in the 80s? Hello? Most of the popular=bad stems from the ongoing stagnation of corporate media in the states. This hasnt happened in anime.

      Besides, there is so much anime each year, that some of it is gaurenteed to not-suck. Although it does fit in to the 90% rule. 90% of anything sucks.

      Just be careful, and youll get the good stuff.

      --

      no .sig
    12. Re:Greater influence by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 1
      "For Amine, I really can't see the genre maintaining it's geek cred as it becomes widely accepted and influential (note: I'm reffering to the west here, not Japan where Anime is obviously percieved quite differently). ... You might regret it if the genre becomes mainstream."

      What you haven't taken into account is that there are lots of 'streams' of anime. Things like Akira, Ghost in the Shell, Miyazaki (i.e. Spirited Away, Totoro, Mononoke, etc.) have been a lot more mainstream and accessible to North America at large for many years. Anime will retain its 'geek cred' because there are many many layers of fandom, and you can go deeper and deeper. Most people will not ever hear of shows like Kyou Kara Mao, Tenchi na Konamaiki, Kimi ga Nozomu Eien, Gravitation and the like. Go deeper, and you will see that 97% of what's present even in the North American market is still restricted (for the moment) to the world of geekdom.

      Of course the companies that license and release manga and shows like Bandai USA, Geneon, FUNimation, AD Vison, Tokyopop, etc. are trying to popularise it and I fully support this! If they can make the genre more popular, it means the prices will get lower through volume sales, they will be easier to find, and more titles will be licensed and brought over to North America. Even today is has improved a lot, as now a preorder DVD with 4 episodes goes for US$18-19 as opposed to a VHS with 2 episodes for $50. (And fansubs don't count folks, they are illegal, don't support the creators, but though highly useful for reasons I won't get into. Also 90%+ of the stuff on e-bay is low quality pirate swag, so go educate yourselves and avoid it.)

      Regardless, my point is that the market and range of products available are bigger and more diverse than you have given it credit for. Even in Japan there is certainly a hardcore geek cult following that takes it further than anyone else. (Go rent yourself a copy of Otaku no Video and see what I mean.)

    13. Re:Greater influence by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      There is a very VERY negative stigma against anime fans in japan. In the US, anime fans are considered dorky social outcasts. In japan, anime fans are considered perverted child rapists and pedophiles. I would argue that the negative stimga against anime fans is much, much worse in japan then the states.

      Hardly, considering Miyazaki films are some of Japan's highest-grossing productions ever, and even End of Evangelion managed to pull in large crowds of people who would not necessarily describe themselves as "anime fans".

    14. Re:Greater influence by bludstone · · Score: 1

      I said anime fans, not anime itself.

      Miyazaki is a living national treasure. Everyone loves his films, but they are usually considered children's films.. and they are, but not stupid ones.

      Using eva as an example is pretty poor, as that drew in _a lot_ of 'fans' of the show, that would not consider themselves anime fans.

      Of course, miyazaki also dislikes the state of the anime industry.

      --

      no .sig
    15. Re:Greater influence by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 1
      "There is a very VERY negative stigma against anime fans in japan. In the US, anime fans are considered dorky social outcasts. In japan, anime fans are considered perverted child rapists and pedophiles. I would argue that the negative stimga against anime fans is much, much worse in japan then the states."

      Where's your source for this? Really, how do you know? I've seen it mentioned in trollish articles written by ignorant folks, but I have no reason to believe that it's anything other than an urban legend.

      Considering the proprotion of the shows that are aimed at the child market and the fact that there are products aimed at every possible demographic, I tend to doubt this statement. There are certainly *some* products aimed at dirty perverts, but really, if all of the market was like this, then movies like Spirited Away would not be the #1 bestseller DVD in all of Japan's history.

    16. Re:Greater influence by PhoenixFlare · · Score: 1

      As nice as the artwork is, I'd sure love to see an anime that is actually animated, and doesnt look like a shockwave cartoon.

      What anime have you actually watched? And by that, I mean something like a few episodes or more, not just 5 minutes before you formed an opinion.

      And chill with the tentacles and the schoolgirls.

      Again (even though you're probably just trolling), I have to wonder what you're watching - the only stuff I know of with lots of tentacles and schoolgirls is hentai (porno) stuff, which doesn't seem to make up the majority of stuff shown on TV and sold in regular stores in the US.

      You sound like someone that watched the godawful Pokemon or DBZ dubs, heard about/watched some hentai, and formed the usual generalizations from there.

    17. Re:Greater influence by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 1
      " Oh please, we all grew up watching cheap asian animation a la Voltron, Ge-Force, Astroboy, Transformers.."

      Additionally, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles was animated in Japan, though it was a show conceived and run by americans. FWIW lots of animation for 'Japanese' anime is now outsourced to Korea.

    18. Re:Greater influence by RsG · · Score: 1

      Well, for the record I've never been to Japan and had only second hand information. However I think you misconstued my point; I wasn't saying that mainstream = bad, I was saying that that is the typical perception among geeks. While I concede that this is somewhat true, my point, for clarification, was that the parent post viewed the mainstreaming of Anime as being a good thing. Were Anime to beome more popular, geeks would undoubtably move away from it to a degree and people like the parent poster would lament "the good old days" where Anime was a niche genre. Basically I meant "be careful what you wish for".

      As for Star Wars, I never said it wasn't popular, read my post, I said geeks are more fixated on it than the moviegoing public (and, note: we lament the demise of Star Wars now that the "mainstream" comercialized previews/sprecial editions are out). Of course this is just MHO, I could be wrong.

      Oh, and I'm not sure that the popular = bad phenominon has to do with corporate media in the 'States. I've seen the perception that obscure niche = good pretty much everywhere among the geek/artistic/academic/intellectual crowd. Partly I think this is grounded in the reality of popularity (for something to be popular it must appeal to a lower common denomiator), but mostly I think that this attitude is symptomatic of a certain degree of intellectual snobbery. We too often try to make ourselves look better than the rest (the "sheep" as some real snobs call the public) by immersing ourselves in obscure media. This is a classic example of conformity through non-conformity; real indivduality is a state of mind, not a facade of forced non-conformity. Anime is pretty good, but some of it's geek cred is the kind of indier than thou attitude that we sometimes stoop to.

      And it's Sturgeons Law BTW: 90% of everything is crud (crud is often changed to crap).

      --
      Erotic is when you use a feather. Exotic is when you use the whole chicken.
    19. Re:Greater influence by UserGoogol · · Score: 1

      No, Anime is fairly popular in Japan. Although there's a definite stigma against "otaku," or the smelly obsessive losers. I can't say that people automatically think otaku are rapists. They might imagine them to be pedophiles, but not "active" pedophiles.

      --
      "Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity." -- Hanlon's Razor
    20. Re:Greater influence by bludstone · · Score: 1

      Indeed.

      I, for one, embrace the popularization of anime. It makes more anime easily accessable for less money. Its a lot nicer then having a friend on a military base in japan ship you raw tapes off of tv.

      I suppose I can be snobby and say "I remember back in the day.." but I dont wish for those days any longer. Holding a script in your lap while watching an anime is more difficult then it is often worth.

      But, yes, just like anything else, 90% of anime is crap.

      --

      no .sig
    21. Re:Greater influence by BJH · · Score: 1

      I daresay he's referring to Miyazaki Tsutomu (no relation to Ghibli's Miyazaki Hayao). A quick summary in Japanese of his history is available here.

      Basically, he was a young man who killed four small girls back in the late 80s. He owned approximately 6000 videotapes, including many horror movies and a large selection of anime.

      Of course, none of this means that the general image of anime fans among Japanese people is that of Miyazaki Tsutomu, any more than Americans' image of Boston is irrevocably associated with the Boston Strangler.

    22. Re:Greater influence by bludstone · · Score: 1

      Thats why I said "Anime fans," and not "anime."

      --

      no .sig
    23. Re:Greater influence by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The animation in Kill Bill is (meant to be?) an extreme exaggeration of anime, not anime itself.

    24. Re:Greater influence by StevenHenderson · · Score: 1

      Yes, but no less effective in making a great scene. Might be over the top, but cool as all hell.

    25. Re:Greater influence by Knara · · Score: 1

      Not to mention that an increasing majority of anime projects are being colored and/or animated on computers these days, from all the major studios. The people who rip on new anime because its not hand-drawn just want to feel like they knew/saw something first, in my opinion. It's not like Voltron or Transformers had brilliant animation, after all.

    26. Re:Greater influence by Knara · · Score: 1
      (And fansubs don't count folks, they are illegal, don't support the creators [...])

      Unlicensed fansubs are a rather grey area, not specifically illegal, but not specifically legal either. By and large the reputable fansub groups pull their fansubs when an anime is licensed (or released, depends on the group) in the states, their motivation for being fansubbers being, by and large, to make shows that aren't (and sometimes won't be) available in the US, available.

      Bootleggers are another story, but don't confuse the two, because they are not necessarily (though doubtless sometimes are) the same thing.

    27. Re:Greater influence by UserGoogol · · Score: 1

      Not all Anime fans are Otaku. Casual fans are not otaku.

      --
      "Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity." -- Hanlon's Razor
    28. Re:Greater influence by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 1
      "(And fansubs don't count folks, they are illegal, don't support the creators [...])"

      "Unlicensed fansubs are a rather grey area, not specifically illegal, but not specifically legal either. By and large the reputable fansub groups pull their fansubs when an anime is licensed (or released, depends on the group) in the states, their motivation for being fansubbers being, by and large, to make shows that aren't (and sometimes won't be) available in the US, available."

      Unlicensed fansubs are illegal, no ifs, ands or buts. It does not matter whether or not the show is licensed. Ask a lawyer if you don't believe me.

      Of course this doesn't mean that I don't have a massive library of fansubs spanning hundreds of CDRs. I am fully aware of the distribution practices and ethics of the various fansub groups. If it wasn't for fansubs, I wouldn't have 100+ legally licensed official anime DVDs on my shelf. Remember: Friends don't let friends watch AnimeJunkies. :P

    29. Re:Greater influence by aka-ed · · Score: 1
      RTFA. See anything by the artists mentioned therein. Get back to us when you have thereby derived a clue.

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
    30. Re:Greater influence by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes, but there is still a distinction between fans (of anything) and otaku that you're glossing over.

      Basball fans watch baseball. Baseball otaku own the foul ball Suzuki Ichiro hit in his second national high school tournament at Koshien Stadium and have hand-sewed a reproduction of Randy Bass' Hashin Tigers home jersey.

      Anime fans watch anime. Anime otaku collect limited edition Belldandy figurines and the paper cup Inoue Kikuko drank from at KFC.

    31. Re:Greater influence by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I really (really) hate to admit to liking anime, due to tha stigma attached.

      Congratulations on letting others run your life.

    32. Re:Greater influence by aka-ed · · Score: 1
      see it because the story is good, not because it's "anime". The word "anime" is death at the box office. Spirited Away barely earned its print costs, even after its post-Oscar re-release. Probably more would have seen it if its Japanese origin had been more thorougly disguised.

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
    33. Re:Greater influence by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Obviously you've never seen Ninja Scroll.

    34. Re:Greater influence by aka-ed · · Score: 1
      Again, the bad rap given to Anime Junkies.

      Their translations sometimes (not always) sucked, but that's true of soooo many groups that get a "pass." The main reason for their demise was their lack of people skills.

      Thank god the brilliant Airmaster series finally got completely subbed, despite the badmouthing from ppl like you that destroyed AJ.

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
    35. Re:Greater influence by Knara · · Score: 1

      Best friend happens to be a lawyer. They're a gray area because you're not infringing on anything if no one else is distributing. The point of something being illegally distributed is because it infringes on the legal distributor's sole exclusive contract with the producer in a certain market segment (this is why bootlegs are bad). If there's no license in that area, what exactly is being infringed? Furthermore, since legit fansubbers don't monetarily profit from their distribution, it's not exactly the same. Sure, you could easily just make a blanket statement like "it's illegal cuz it's not made by the company itself", but if the company itself doesn't actually service the area in question....

      Either way, it's a moot point. About as moot as the MPAA lamenting its movie woes cuz of downloaders. The vast majority of people who watch anime either purchase or rent it, it's only we geeks and geekettes (a minority of consumers, regardless of what some industry groups or ourselves perhaps would like to admit) that worry about such legalities (well, and lawyers, but that's a given). Nor are distributors really racing to stomp out fansubs (as your own merchandise piracy link even points out). Bootleggers, yes. Fansubbers, nah.

    36. Re:Greater influence by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 1
      Actually the Japanese creators can take you to court for digisub distribution, even if the show is not officially licensed in your market. They have the right to license it or not license it whatever market they want, and digisubs infringe on that exclusive right. Not that such a court case ever happened or ever will happen. The Japanese are more concerned about protecting their own market, and ADV and Bandai certainly do prosecute bootleg providers but not digisubbers. (Actually Jerry Chu of Bandai made it quite clear that Bandai is not like the RIAA in this matter during the Bandai panel at Otakon 2004.)

      A moot point though, agreed.

    37. Re:Greater influence by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > I really can't see the genre maintaining it's geek cred as it becomes widely accepted and influential

      I don't know if it would ever really become mainstream. For mainstream, do you really think most people want to see stylized porn? No. Also, geeks love their porn, and many of them love their cartoons that are done in the style of Japanese porn, so I don't think they really care how mainstream or not it is. Porn is porn.

      Of course, my opinion is biased since I got tired of the lame, repetitive japanese-style animated porn that my friends watched over and over again when I was in the Navy.

    38. Re:Greater influence by Knara · · Score: 1

      Well, people can take you to court for an infinite number of reasons, with an infinite amount of legitimacy or likelihood of sucess. Yeah, heard about ADV going nutty on bootleggers. Good for them. Tired of people coming into my friends' stores telling them about the 4 DVD set of the entire Trigun series they bought for $30 down the street.

    39. Re:Greater influence by number6x · · Score: 1

      Didn't Sweet do a song based on the comic 'Evangeline' as well?

    40. Re:Greater influence by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 1
      "(...)Basically, he was a young man who killed four small girls back in the late 80s. He owned approximately 6000 videotapes, including many horror movies and a large selection of anime.

      Of course, none of this means that the general image of anime fans among Japanese people is that of Miyazaki Tsutomu, any more than Americans' image of Boston is irrevocably associated with the Boston Strangler."

      Link here is funny but maybe NSFW.
      Fair enough. I'm sure most anime fans are closer to being this disturbing pervert as opposed to some sort of sociopath. :P

    41. Re:Greater influence by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The word "anime" is death at the box office.

      Pokemon has grossed $30 billion.

      Yes, that's a 'b'

    42. Re:Greater influence by Minna+Kirai · · Score: 1

      Transformers..

      Not anime. Transformers was as American as GI Joe.

      There was a japanese version, but it wasn't shown in the USA.

      Pen and ink on animation cells, motherfuckers, 24 per second.

      USA animation from the same era never achieved that.... or if they did, it was by reusing the same loops of Scooby-Doo running and stumbling on new backdrops each week.

    43. Re:Greater influence by Minna+Kirai · · Score: 1

      Not to mention that an increasing majority of anime projects are being colored and/or animated on computers these days,

      Incorrect. That majority is not increasing "these days". It has been at 100% for 3 years.

    44. Re:Greater influence by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      There have been C&Ds in the past though. In the VHS fansub days when Sony was trying to sell "Samurai X" for US release, a number of groups were sent letters from the Japanese company telling them that they were making it difficult to get any US company to license the show. Probably because all the fans knew about Rurouni Kenshin ;)

    45. Re:Greater influence by Hast · · Score: 1

      And for that matter not all otaku are anime fans.

    46. Re:Greater influence by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Probably more would have seen it if its Japanese origin had been more thorougly disguised.

      Yeah. I hear Toyota and Sony have a lot of trouble selling their products to Americans.

    47. Re:Greater influence by Buzz_Litebeer · · Score: 1

      Considering I downloaded them from "Japanese CopyRightViolating Anime download Center.com" I think I could figure that out! ;-)

      --
      If you don't vote, you don't matter, so don't waste your time telling me your opinion
  6. My Guess by Doesn't_Comment_Code · · Score: 4, Funny

    ...which discusses numerous things happening on the anime front...

    I'll venture a guess that the top story on the anime front is some guy hovering in the air screaming at another guy hovering in the air - with various colorbursts displayed behind them all the while. They continue this for several minutes, building up to a short, rather anti-climactic fight.

    But I could be wrong.

    --

    Slashdot Syndrome: the sudden, extreme urge to correct someone in order to validate one's self.
    1. Re:My Guess by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Hah, you poor soul. You must have watched Draggin'-my-balls-through-razor-blades-and-vinegar Z and assumed all Anime was like that.

      Try some interesting stuff (Spirited Away, Vampire Hunter D) that is actually well written and animated then call me in the morning.

      Dr. Chozo

    2. Re:My Guess by constrapolator · · Score: 1
      Yup, you've just described the plot of every single DragonballZ episode and the related spin-offs.

      Thanks, you just saved me hours of watching pointless anime.

    3. Re:My Guess by UserGoogol · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Dragonball Z is to Anime as Poison Sandwiches are to Food.

      --
      "Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity." -- Hanlon's Razor
    4. Re:My Guess by Have+Blue · · Score: 2, Informative

      That would have been truer, and made a lot more sense, if you had said "as McDonalds is to Food".

    5. Re:My Guess by Alizarin+Erythrosin · · Score: 1

      That may be so, but watching DBZ in Japanese is what got me into anime in the first place!

      --
      There are only 10 kinds of people in this world... those who understand binary and those who don't
  7. Watching previews by mzkhadir · · Score: 1

    Where to watch the previews of all the movies listed above ?

    1. Re:Watching previews by ll1234 · · Score: 1

      Here are a few teasers of Howl's Moving Castle.

      There's a 2-minute trailer floating around from a pay-per-view channel in Japan. It can't be found at the previous link due to 'requests' but with a little digging...

    2. Re:Watching previews by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 1
      " Where to watch the previews of all the movies listed above ?"

      There's definitely one or tow floating around on the bittorrent networks here and there. I saw the GiTS:Innocence preview at Otakon 2004 in the Production I.G. panel and it looked FANTASTIC.

    3. Re:Watching previews by MsGeek · · Score: 1
      I've seen it. I got a chance to sit in on a press screening of Innocence and it is nothing short of awesome.

      Innocence cuts through the limitations of the first Ghost In The Shell movie beautifully. There aren't any longwinded philosophical discussions in this new movie like the ones that dragged down GITS in places. In Innocence, Oshii-sensei is able to visually illustrate the philosophical points he wants to make rather than weight things down with expository dialogue.

      It is said that Akira was the most expensive animated feature ever made in Japan at $7.5 Million. That can't be right. I was under the impression that Miyazaki has had Disney-sized budgets (in the high tens of millions of dollars) since Mononoke Hime, and that Mobile Space Force: The Wings of Honneamise by the Gainax crew cost Bandai over $100 Million when all the cost overruns were totalled up.

      Innocence looks expensive. There are some awesome CGI set-pieces in the movie that are easily the most elaborate CGI I have ever seen. While the CGI in the movie doesn't blend as well with the traditional animation in Innocence, unlike the CGI/Traditional Animation mix in the extremely underrated Cowboy Bebop: Knocking On Heaven's Door, both the traditional and digital animation in Innocence are impressive if looked at as separate entities.

      The best animation is not Bateau, but Bateau's soulful basset hound, Gabe. Droopy Dog wishes he looked that good, and that realistic. From the swing of the dangling ears to the wrinkly folds of skin and fur, you really think you're looking at a live action film at first glance. Then you look closer, and see the artistry of the drawings, and the achievement is overwhelming.

      The story's great too. I think they pick up pretty closely after the end of Ghost In The Shell here. Bateau is following up on stories of homicidal female home robots, called "gynoids." He gets pulled into the weird world of the creator of the series of robots.

      I strongly suggest going to see this when it comes out next month. I suspect I will be going back to see it again...there is just so much in the movie that one viewing is not enough.

      --
      Knowledge is power. Knowledge shared is power multiplied.
  8. Re:Greatest Anime Film: Kenshin OVA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Kenshin OVA: Trust & Betrayal. Watch it and forget about the rest of the series...

  9. Akira. by mandrake*rpgdx · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Although I did like Spirited Away, it had a very Alice in Wonderland sort of feel. I can't stand listening to the English dubs though- that little girls voice in the English dubs is so whiney and annoying. But yeah, Akira is the best. It is just fantastic. It's like blade runner and clockwork orange all in one. The manga is much better (because there is just so much more there), but the movie is just drop dead amazing. Next I would say Vampire Hunter D, and the sequel as well. Then would come Macross Plus. Then would Lupin the third and the castel of Caligastero The list goes ever onward after that, including some pretty weird and obscure ones.

  10. The Giants of Anime? by RsG · · Score: 1

    As opposed to, say, the midgets of anime? Now _that_ I would go to!

    --
    Erotic is when you use a feather. Exotic is when you use the whole chicken.
  11. Obfuscated Anime code by GillBates0 · · Score: 3, Interesting
    I'm not much of an Anime fan, and usually refrain from commenting on related stories. However I came across this site in a comment in the IOCCC story yesterday, and thought it was pretty cool.

    Lots of ASCII-art type Anime characters there, except that all of it is source code.

    --
    An Indian-American Hindu committed to non-violent thought/speech/action alarmed by the global explosion of radical Islam
    1. Re:Obfuscated Anime code by RyuuzakiTetsuya · · Score: 1

      Piro!?

      Piro!?

      He's not even fucking Japanese!

      He's white and from Wisconsin for Fuck's sake!.

      AUUUUUUUUUUGH

      --
      Non impediti ratione cogitationus.
  12. Steamboy by JanneM · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I saw Steamboy a month ago, and wrote a small review for my friends on my blog. May be of interest to some here:

    [Steamboy] is a new anime by Katsuhiro Otomo (of Akira fame), set in England in 1851, around the time of the world exhibition in Londons Crystal Palace.

    Visually, the movie is stunning. The characters are expressive and individualistic, the backdrops are beautiful, and, of course, the movie is replete with larger-than-life nineteenth-century steam technology. There is enough dramatic machinery and unlikely "science" in this movie to sate even the most rabid steampunk fetishist.

    The story is complex and varied. I'm not going to detail it here - mainly because my Japanese just isn't up to the task of actually understanding all the twist and turns. I lost track about halfway through, to be honest, and Ritsuko too had trouble follwing it, in part because the speech tended to be fast and garbled. Nevertheless, they have managed to create believable characters with at least some depth, while at the same time all the clichés we know and love are well and truly fulfilled. The villain, for example, has an partial facemask and mechanical hand - I guess that adding a white cat and a monocle would have been a little over the top.

    Did I like it? Yes, with a few reservations. This is a looong movie - 2h20m to be more precise. A bathroom break before seeing it is advisable. An of course, I can't really judge the story fairly when I don't really understand it - the end seemed to me to be a little artificial (not to mention wildly contrary to any scientific intuition), but as I couldn't follow the character motivations and interactions by that time, I can't be sure I understood it correctly.

    Should you see it? If you like anime or steampunk, absolutely! And even if you don't, it has enough of an Indiana Jones kind of feel to it that I think you'll be entertained in any case.

    --
    Trust the Computer. The Computer is your friend.
    1. Re:Steamboy by bandersnatch · · Score: 1
      I saw Steamboy a few weeks ago and had a great time. I didn't have much problem understanding it but a Japanese coworker of mine complained that the use of amature voice actors made the dialog sound garbled and harder to follow. Occasionally the dialog did sound stilted and awkward especially the grandfather, James Loyd Steam.

      Without giving anything away, I enjoyed the treatment of science and it's place in society. However, I must say I was surprised with some of the more Luddite tendencies evident in the film. The "technology" in the film was plainly ridiculous (which after Otomo's other films is not all that surprising) but all in all, great film. Definitely go see it.

  13. Re:What's the fun... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I don't get it either. But my attitude is if it ain't hurting anyone, and someone wants to do it, go for it.

    I don't understand climbing Mount Everest either :) Or watching TV.

  14. Links to IMDb by CaptainCheese · · Score: 5, Informative

    Innocence
    Steamboy
    Howl's Moving Castle

    You'll find links onward to trailers from here...I'd paste the direct links, but I don't want to /. anyone who can't handle it...

    --
    -- .sigs are a waste of data...turn them off...
    1. Re:Links to IMDb by pjt33 · · Score: 1

      Anyone know how close Howl's Moving Castle is to the book?

    2. Re:Links to IMDb by CaptainCheese · · Score: 1

      I doubt you'll get an answer to that, as although it was test-screened on July 30th it's not officially released in Japan until November...

      --
      -- .sigs are a waste of data...turn them off...
    3. Re:Links to IMDb by bob65 · · Score: 1

      My guess is not close at all, which would be a good thing, because I really think books should be used as inspirations for movies, not as collars.

    4. Re:Links to IMDb by helfon1 · · Score: 1

      "My guess is not close at all, which would be a good thing, because I really think books should be used as inspirations for movies, not as collars."

      Yeah because why follow the well thought out story that the author intended when you can just steal their ideas to make a big budget hollywood explosion flick and then con the people who liked the book to create the pre movie hype with false expectations.

      We all know the movie is rarely as good as the book but it's over the top when hollywood producers decide that in order to make something more exciting and marketable it needs more explosions/fighting and a love story.

      There are hundreds of examples in recent years. The one that comes to mind is the sequel to Jurassic Park, The Lost World. The book was ok. It wasn't high brow by any means but it wasn't explosions and danger around every corner so I go see the movie to find out they removed the main character and they added riddiculous scenes of dinosaurs escaping and running through city streets.

      If you are going to make something "inspired by" the book don't market it as the movie version of the book. Rename it something else and say it's inspired by a book called %$^& somwhere in the trailer. Don't try to con the fans of the book out of their money and make it appeal to the masses.

    5. Re:Links to IMDb by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I have seen good book conversions and bad conversions. Usually the bad ones either committed the cardinal sin of being entirely unlike the book or they stuck too close to the book material, including elements that would not translate properly. The good ones either are either loosely based upon the book and therefore succeeding on their own merit or they adapt the book's text such that the things that work well for books only are omitted or converted to effects that work well for movies. *shrug* So I'd say that there's a middle road there with little room for extremes.
      Books do detailed descriptions, inner thoughts and compulsions, and indescribable horror or beauty very well. Movies are excellent for giving a scene at a glance and for doing rapid action, particularly when multiple things are happening at once or pretty special effects are involved.

    6. Re:Links to IMDb by Minna+Kirai · · Score: 1

      con the people who liked the book to create the pre movie hype with false expectations.

      The reverse has happened too. "Forrest Gump" was far better in the movie adaptation than in the original book.

      It's wrong to try holding a film to a book's plotline, because it would take 8 hours to get through an average 300 page novel...

      The one that comes to mind is the sequel to Jurassic Park, The Lost World

      You should've anticipated that. The original "Jurassic Park" movie was so different from the book version, that the sequel could hardly have been similar.

  15. Re:What's the fun... by ms00skr · · Score: 1

    Is it just the same as some people at the age of 40 still read comics?

    Yes.

  16. Re:What's the fun... by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 2, Informative
    "I really never understood people who watch anime - what's exactly the fun of watching a cartoon in a category where a lot of real movies are, imho, better ? I have a fun roommates who watch anime all day, and really, i don't get it... so what's the fun ? Is it just the same as some people at the age of 40 still read comics ?"

    Ah yes, the words of someone who has not actually sat down to watch a good amount of it. Actually watch the movies. Get something directed by Miyazaki. Castle in the Sky. Princess Mononoke. Grave of the Fireflies. Nausicaa. You will understand.

    (This comes from someone who spent about US$2000 on anime related expenses in their first year as a fan. And that's only moderate. I know hardcore people who spend $6K and more on DVDs, artwork, posters, figurines, toys, accessories, etc.)

  17. I can't watch Anime, I'm scarred for life... by craenor · · Score: 5, Funny

    It happened at DragonCon in 1996 when this 260 pound, middle-aged, hairy guy walked past me dressed as Sailor Moon.

    1. Re:I can't watch Anime, I'm scarred for life... by WormholeFiend · · Score: 4, Funny

      A few years ago I went to a restaurant, in the gay neighborhood of a large city, with a bunch of friends... this place had "theme nights" where the waiters would all dress up according to the theme.

      That night the theme was "anime".

      Our male waiter, dressed as as a sailor moon character, arrives at the table:
      "Hi, I'm Thailor Uranuth and I'll be your waiter thith evening..."

      Needless to say eveyone cracked up...

    2. Re:I can't watch Anime, I'm scarred for life... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ah. Sailor Bubba.

      Nice guy, talked to him at some cons. The whole "big scary man cosplay" is a _mockery_ of fandom. Hes doing the "omg. look how crazy anime fans are" on purpose.

    3. Re:I can't watch Anime, I'm scarred for life... by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 2, Informative
      "Our male waiter, dressed as as a sailor moon character, arrives at the table: "Hi, I'm Thailor Uranuth and I'll be your waiter thith evening...""

      (The joke of course, for those who don't know, is that Sailor Uranus is a lesbian. :P)

    4. Re:I can't watch Anime, I'm scarred for life... by Spleener12 · · Score: 1

      He's not the only one. I personally know someone who dressed up as Sailor Moon (actually, he alternted between that and (Card Captor) Sakura) at Anime Mid-Atlantic 2004. Big fat black guy with a very effeminate voice. He's a good man, if a little too into his fandom of choice.

    5. Re:I can't watch Anime, I'm scarred for life... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      (The joke of course, for those who don't know, is that Sailor Uranus is a lesbian. :P)

      Yes, because a gay man in drag calling himself "Uranus" just isn't funny enough. o_O

    6. Re:I can't watch Anime, I'm scarred for life... by ProppaT · · Score: 1

      Oh, Sailor Bacon....we love you.

      --
      Wise men say, "Forgiveness is divine, but never pay full price for late pizza."
    7. Re:I can't watch Anime, I'm scarred for life... by bitrott · · Score: 1

      And if it's still not funny, does THAT make him an ass?

    8. Re:I can't watch Anime, I'm scarred for life... by taernim · · Score: 1

      So you didn't like my costume? :(

      --
      "PC Load Letter? What the $@#% does that mean?!"
    9. Re:I can't watch Anime, I'm scarred for life... by Trifthen · · Score: 1

      Oh, you mean Sailor Bubba. He's been at the last 4 anime conventions I've attended, and some of the dealers in the dealer-room were even selling merchandise sporting his visage. Gotta love that.

      --
      Read: Rabbit Rue - Free serial nove
  18. You mean most -influential- anime film by chendo · · Score: 4, Funny

    ...... gotta be End of Evangelion, folks.

    Because- Hey, what are you doing? I'm using this thing!
    No! I don't wanna go back there! I WANT TO BE FREE, NOT IN REHAB! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO #@$@&(#$(*@#^# - NO CARRIER

    --
    Founder of Mirror Moon - Tsukihime Game Trans
    1. Re:You mean most -influential- anime film by sn0wman3030 · · Score: 0

      I agree. Absolutly.

      --
      Life is offtopic.
  19. Re:What's the fun... by ObjectiveGiant · · Score: 3, Insightful
    "...what's exactly the fun of watching a cartoon in a category where a lot of real movies are, imho, better ?"

    A lot? I'll give it to you that there are a few out there but when you look at the ratio of good anime titles to the entire catalogue and do the same comparison with a comparable movie category, I believe anime wins by a landslide. If nothing else, you have a large volume of enjoyable material.

    I think the downside to Anime is the translation factor. I know that when I'm watching even the good flicks that I'm missing so much because I don't speak the native language. The phenominal visuals and character depth can easily be undermined by poor dialogue.

    My favorite plus in regards to Anime is that it offers the ability to have rediculous character/monster design that would be impossible to fund/produce in the same live action genre. (At least in volume anyway.)

    Are there any live action movies out there that have ninja's fighting horribly grotesque monster villians? Not that I know of... (If there are, I would bet the production quality and special effects are very poor compared against something like Ninja Scroll for example.)

    --
    ::signature space for rent::
  20. How strange - block stories not working? by RollingThunder · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    I've had "Anime" checked off in the "Block stories from homepage" for ages... but this showed up.

    Anyone else seeing that?

  21. I must admit... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...I'm loving Adult Swim. I came for Home Movies, but learned to love Family Guy (which I somehow completely missed on fox), ATHF, and Sealab 2021 but I remain totally uncompelled by their selection of Anime. Would you say Adult Swim would be any kind of decent primer where to start with Anime? If the answer is yes, I suspect this genre is not for me.

    1. Re:I must admit... by The+Darkness · · Score: 1

      Seems like you're only watching the week-night shows. Try the ones they play on Saturday evening/night. Gundam Seed, Wolf's Rain, etc. They only show one episode per week but the quality is significantly higher.

      --
      There are two kinds of people: 1) those that need closure
    2. Re:I must admit... by aka-ed · · Score: 1
      Don't give up on anime after viewing anything that is dubbed. Worst offender is Rurouni Kenshin, which literally sounds like a remedial reading session with a script in hand.

      Despite the "Adult" moniker, AS anime shows are frequently edited for content to boot.

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
  22. Turd firing giant girls? by smooth+wombat · · Score: 1
    An army of giant girls leads Japan to victory in World War II, mowing down enemies by squatting and firing turds!

    Er, can someone fill me in as to what this is all about?

    --
    We will bankrupt ourselves in the vain search for absolute security. -- Dwight D. Eisenhower
    1. Re:Turd firing giant girls? by aka-ed · · Score: 2, Informative
      It's a comic book.

      Tatakae! Dainippon Teikoku (The Japanese Imperial, Go!) by Shintaro Kago. This story is an alternate history of WWII by one of the artists who appeared in Secret Comics Japan. The Japanese army have perfected a technique that turns human beings into giants, but for some reason they can only enlarge females. Patriot girls dedicate themselves to their great emperor and become giant weapons against the inhuman Allies. The girls are customized for each purpose. Some girls are made into tanks and some girls are made into battleships. Their guns are their asses and their bullets are their hard constipated shits.

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
  23. Re:What's the fun... by 19Buck · · Score: 5, Interesting
    The appeal to animation is that the only limitation is in the writer and animator's imagination. You can do and visualize things with animation in order to more readily suspend disbelief than you can accomplish in a live action movie in a badly done effect can ruin said suspension of disbelief.

    I believe that it was the Spawn movie that first used CG in a well stated and obvious manner - and they did some amazing things with that cloak of his, but it still somehow looked "out of place" because of the unrealistically bright shading used in the coloring.

    and really, anime isn't about the drawings, it's about the story and the charecters. It's those same basic elements that drive the appeal of the movie, it's just that using animation removes all restrictions on visuals because you can make whatever you want look however you want without having to make any sacrifices in trying to find a location or actor that fits the director's vision - they can simply DRAW exactly what they want to show.

    Animation in movies is beginning to become very widespread in the past few years now that computers are capable of producing some very realistic looking renders. you didn't actually thing that was Toby Macguire or a stuntman doing all those amazing acrobatics did you? Even only a few years ago, you could not have readily achieved those effects on a believable level.

    Even if you prefer live action, and that's your perrogative if you do, you're still seeing the effects of animation in live action.

  24. Here's another. by chendo · · Score: 1

    This is Man-Faye.

    Yes, it's a hairy man cosplaying Faye from Cowboy Bebop.

    --
    Founder of Mirror Moon - Tsukihime Game Trans
    1. Re:Here's another. by Creepy+Crawler · · Score: 0, Troll

      That dude(ette) is sick.

      Like "I ned to go to Bellvewe" sick.

      Better yet, I can shoot it. Guns are good for putting sick things out of their (OUR) misery.

      --
    2. Re:Here's another. by FleaPlus · · Score: 1

      Apparently he manages to get kicked out of Anime Expo (annual anime convention in LA) just about every year.

  25. Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Not that I didn't like some anime movies I've seen, but a lot of people seem to be really obsessed with it. And a lot of those obsessed seem to fall into the geek category.

    So here is my question:
    What is so fascinating about anime (as compared to other movie genres) and why do animes have such an geek appeal?

    1. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by chendo · · Score: 1

      Because normal TV shows and movies just don't cut it for us who want something a little more abnormal.

      When was the last time you saw giant girls shooting turds at people during World War II in a movie? (I have yet to actually find out where that came from)

      Oh, and I don't know about you, but anime actually affects me as a person, unlike Hollywood movies that I watch and I go "Wow, that was cool." and move on with life. The more in-depth anime around make me think about various issues, and causes me to take a look at things from a different angle.

      Also, you don't see much TV series where they're based on a particular subject in general, like for example, basketball. Or soccer. Or go. Or vampir- wait, scratch that. Or mountain-side import-car racing. Anime caters for almost every single hobby out there, whether it be basketball, soccer, or import-car racing. And the good thing is, anime makes it -interesting-, especially for a person who has probably never had interest before. I mean, they turned spinning random blades interesting, so why the hell not? (granted that BeyBladez or however you spell it DOES suck pretty bad)

      And I almost forgot... the fact that quite a few anime were never meant for children in the first place might have something to do with it.

      --
      Founder of Mirror Moon - Tsukihime Game Trans
    2. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by azmodean · · Score: 5, Insightful

      The primary reason I tend to enjoy anime more than I enjoy hollywood produced movies is the lack of pandering present in much of anime (much, not all, there are many anime that do pander, but I digress). The reason this is so was touched on briefly in the article. Many artists have total or near-total control of their story from the time they first think of it untill it is released, that just doesn't happen too often in hollywood (and when it does, I tend to like those movies) Many anime producers are allowed to do their work unhampered by focus groups or executives telling them what can and cannot be in their work.

      Another reason I like anime is that much of it is not watered down as most hollywood fare is, when someone dies it isn't some quick event that is glossed over; it's messy, it's gory, and it looks painful. I think one of the most unhealthy concepts I have ever seen in mass media is the "looney tunes" treatment of violence. Portraying violence as harmless and fun is much more disturbing to me than seeing more realistic violence with reprecussions attached. I could go on and on, but it would likely fall on deaf ears anyway.

    3. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      Anime is more likely to have depth than American produced works. It's not an inherent property of either. It's just the way it works out. The overall artistic value of anime is just generally higher.

      There's also that fact that it tends to get filtered multiple times before coming over here. First, the series that end up over here were also at least moderately popular in Japan. Second, anything that comes over here has already appealed to somebody over here. Either a distribution company thinks it will sell, or a fansubber likes it enough to work on.

      Definitely, there's some real crap that's produced over there. Anything brought over here is pretty much guaranteed to be the best of the best. If you did the same thing with American shows, they'd start to look a little more equal. Still, I haven't seen more than a handful of American shows that are as appealing as a good anime series that you can find at least once a year.

    4. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by aiabx · · Score: 1

      Geeks are, on the whole, stimulated by novelty, and prone to obsessive behaviour. Anime is very different from the animation most of us grew up with, and comes associated with a culture many people associate with cool technology and cute asian girls*. As such, it could have been designed to plug straight into the brains of a lot of geeks. Once there, the obsessive centre of the brain takes over, and appreciation of this motherlode of novelty becomes an important part of one's self image, especially if one is consciously or unconsciously trying to fit into geek culture.
      -aiabx

      *the asian women I know are seriously creeped out by this aspect of geekdom.

      --
      Just this guy, you know?
    5. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by pope1 · · Score: 1

      Reading through the replies here, everyone seems
      to have already touched on the main points:

      1.) depth
      2.) creative control
      3.) lack of censorship (see 2.)

      In litigation happy America where turning a profit is almost at inverse proportion to being raw and from the heart on any topic, content definately suffers.

      For me, 5 years ago at the age of 18, Anime was a window into a new world. I had some exposure previous to that.. Vampire Hunter D when I was 12, and Captain Harlock when I was 8 or 9.. but I
      didn't recgonize it as "anime" back then.

      Running Linux and having an extensive vocabulary of Anime related concepts was just the kind of counter-culture edge that made me feel unique.

      --
      /* * pope1 */
    6. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      GEEKS, in general, are not.

      However, if you are an Japanese animation fan, you are bound by an incessant drive to constantly throw Japanese animation in everyone's faces, INSISTING that they don't know how great it is, and that it's somehow better than everything else just because it's Japanese. Going around calling it "anime" (which just meens ANIMATION dumbasses) is a way of trying to flaunt your own supposed superiority at being part of some imaginary secret club.

      But you're sure to get lots of responses telling you how "superior" Japanese animation is to everything else on planet earth.

    7. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by aka-ed · · Score: 1
      the asian women I know are seriously creeped out by this aspect of geekdom

      oh shit...Can you please ask them whether I should kill myself because I like Puffy and want to see Swing Girls ?

      kawaii is a leading industry in Japan, for both male and female show biz figures. "Sexy" comes in second.

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
    8. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      One thing that hasn't been mentioned directly is duration. Standard series lengths are 13 or 26 episodes (about 5 or 10 hours), plus an attached movie. Standard American faire comes in a stand-alone 2 hour movie, or a indefinite-length series.

      What I've noticed is that in 10 hours, you can introduce characters, introduce the world, wander around to get used to them all, then develop a real storyline within that setting. You have time to do it all without rushing, and have depth. Then add an attached movie, where you don't have to do character and world introductions, and you get 2 hours of plot.

      Once you get used to that sort of pacing, a 2 hour movie seems really short. A good director can pull it off, but most end up with characters that you don't know well enough to relate to and a plot too short to have any depth. Compare Lord of the Rings, or the Star Wars trilogy, where you had more time to get to know the characters and the world.

      As for American TV, they try to make it to last forever, so there's very little plot/development. They have lots of writers, with turnover, working on different episodes, and rarely a central plotline. It can be entertaining, but it can't compare with the intensity you get when the plot of a show you're interested in reaches the climax (or false-climax, or whatever), and the rest of the series depends on what happens in the next few moments. The comparison here would be Buffy or Babylon 5, where they had lots of development and season-level plots, such that watching season 3 is totally different than watching season 1.

    9. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by aiabx · · Score: 1

      Well, whether you kill yourself, or try to use "I really like asian women" as a pick up line, the results are the same as far as evolution is concerned: no breeding for you.

      I'm not making a comment about what makes money in Japan; all I'm saying is that the asian women I know are repulsed and horrified at the prospect of being hit on by geeks because of their race. And yes, it happens a lot.
      -aiabx

      --
      Just this guy, you know?
    10. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by aka-ed · · Score: 1
      I've been seeing the same woman for four years. She's American, but both her parents were born in China. Her national ancestry and race have very little to do with our having a relationship; that's something that grew out of our working together.

      She likes Puffy, too, though not as much as I do. Her taste in anime tends more to cute girls than my own, though she is totally aggravated by panty-flash anime.

      I don't see how you can have any genuine friends of other races, considering how fond you are of stereotypes.

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
    11. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by aiabx · · Score: 1

      Ah. Abuse.

      Ok, I'll try once more to explain this and then I'll go away. I'm not talking about you. I'm not talking about your girlfriend. The asian women that I know, who are close enough friends to discuss this issue with me, have strong negative feelings about being hit on by geeks who are attracted to them solely because they are asian. That's it. I'm not judging you for liking anime. I'm not judging you for having an asian girlfriend. If race is incidental to your relationship, then you win. I hope you're happy together.
      -aiabx

      --
      Just this guy, you know?
    12. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by superstick58 · · Score: 1
      The aspect of anime that impresses me most is the art. The vibrant colors, smooth lines, and excrutiatingly detailed backgrounds mean that your eyes are always drawn to the screen. I find there are few anime movies that offer both good art and good story by my standards, but those that do are well worth some attention.

      Some Favorites: Cowboy Bebop, Vampire Hunter D Bloodlust, Akira, Lupin, Spirited Away,

      (yeah i know, these are all "common" anime, but i guess they are common for a reason.)

    13. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by Politburo · · Score: 1

      Oh, and I don't know about you, but anime actually affects me as a person, unlike Hollywood movies that I watch and I go "Wow, that was cool." and move on with life. The more in-depth anime around make me think about various issues, and causes me to take a look at things from a different angle.

      Then you aren't watching the right movies. While, imo, most good anime is much more character driven than your typical hollywood fare, there are still lots of american movies that are character driven and/or make you think.

    14. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by aka-ed · · Score: 1
      Of course any woman is justified in objecting to shallow standards of attraction.

      What disturbs me is your equation that includes anime fans, the ill-defined term "geeks," the Japanese cultural fetish for cuteness, and these guys with shallow values.

      I think you see a connectedness that isn't as solid as you suppose, and minimizes both the complexities of human attraction, and the nature of "cuteness" as a show-biz phenomenon unique to Japan.

      How do you connect the experience of these women with anime? Were they telling you about their experiences attending anime cons? If so, ask any woman who's attended a western comic con about the social skillz displayed there, you won't see much difference, apart from the exclusion of a racial element. Or were the people hitting on them wearing Lum T-shirts?

      I just don't see where you can connect these particular dots so well as to connect geekish sexual/social ineptitude with the work of a Miyazaki.

      Such geekish ineptitude is a fact, of course, and a frequent theme here. But to inject that into a discussion of the handful of exemplary anime works just seems a little "out of left-field."

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
    15. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by ChronoWiz · · Score: 1

      They even have anime about computers and programming! Battle Programmer Shirase is a really campy-fun anime about a guy with attacks like "Double Compile" and all sorts of obscure computer references. As long as you aren't too offended by the incest jokes (and trust me, there're a lot of them), it's a lot of goofy fun!

    16. Re:Why are geeks so fascinated by anime? by initialE · · Score: 1

      I have to agree fully. I'm sick of the entertainment culture being force-fed upon us. Where every movie is, basically, the same thing over and over again. Anime is freedom from all of that, and it's good to see that we're not completely pwned by Hollywood. This having been said, I worry that by licensing their stuff to Americans, these directors may have shot themselves in the foot. Studios will become more demanding, expecting their work to be more for the masses, forgetting that what drew people to watch these shows in the first place was their uniqueness. A sad day indeed, if the directors bow to such pressures.
      No Sig.

      --
      Starbucks, Harbuckle of Breath.
  26. "Howl" in the US by ll1234 · · Score: 3, Informative

    An acquisition and release date haven't been announced, but are basically formalities. For comparison, it took about a year for Spirited Away to make it from Japanese theaters to US theaters.

    The film is already scheduled for theatrical release in France early in 2005.

    It's also making an appearance at the Venice Film Festival. I don't expect it to win 'Best in Show' like 'Spirited Away' did at the Berlin Film Festival, but it's great to see animation put on equal footing with live-action unlike the Acadamy Awards.

    1. Re:"Howl" in the US by aka-ed · · Score: 1
      An acquisition and release date haven't been announced

      Acquisition? Are you saying the Disney-Miyazaki deal is concluded?

      I hope so, I'll bet Dreamworks could market Miyazaki a lot more effectively.

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
    2. Re:"Howl" in the US by ll1234 · · Score: 1

      No, just that a press release hasn't gone out with a big "Diseny Acquires Next Miyazaki Film" headline and lots of quotes.

    3. Re:"Howl" in the US by meringuoid · · Score: 1

      I'm not sure quite what Disney's position is, but the last couple of Ghibli DVDs in the UK (Sen to Chihiro no Kamikakushi and Hotaru no Haka) have been released by Optimum. They've done a very good job - certainly far better than the abysmal Buena Vista releases of Mononoke Hime, Majo no Takkyubin and Tenkuu no Shiro Laputa. I just hope they provide the UK releases of Nausicaa, Totoro and Howl...

      --
      Real Daleks don't climb stairs - they level the building.
  27. nothing beats by rabbot · · Score: 2

    Ninja Scroll. That movie got me started on Anime. Will always be my favorite.

    1. Re:nothing beats by tweek · · Score: 1

      Not for me.

      Vampire Hunter D

      which led to Akira which led to countless others.

      FYI, did anyone else who saw Blood wish that it had been much longer?

      --
      "Fighting the underpants gnomes since 1998!" "Bruce Schneier knows the state of schroedinger's cat"
    2. Re:nothing beats by rabbot · · Score: 1

      yeah Vampire Hunter D and Akira were great too. Classics =)

    3. Re:nothing beats by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Most definately yes. Blood was great but short. =(

  28. Devilman - coming soon? by WormholeFiend · · Score: 1

    when is the Devilman movie coming out?

    1. Re:Devilman - coming soon? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      10/19/2004

  29. GITS: Stand Alone Complex by bludstone · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I scanned the article and saw no mention of the new ghost in the shell tv series, "Stand Alone Complex."

    If you like anime, or liked the original movie. Go buy this on dvd. Now. Its simply the most remarkable anime I have seen in more then 5 years (and ive been doing this for more then a decade)

    At a million-bucks-an-episode budget, this title is visually incredible. Almost movie-quality effects everywhere. The soundtrack is haunting and fits so well, as does all of yoko kanno's work.

    The themes of the movie are better fleshed out, and the characters more developed. (and more accurate to the manga, by many accounts)

    Oh yeah. The DTS track on the LE dvd blew my mind.

    I was shocked to see this anime. Its the best Ive seen since Cowboy Bebop.

    --

    no .sig
    1. Re:GITS: Stand Alone Complex by Angry+Toad · · Score: 1

      I just watched the first series a while back. It really is some of the most outstanding science fiction work I've ever seen in any visual medium.

    2. Re:GITS: Stand Alone Complex by gl4ss · · Score: 1

      and torrent yourself "2nd gig" (second season of sorts for gits:sac) or buy on dvd, dunno if it's out(i suppose you could wait untill it's on dvd if it isn't out yet.. but who wants to wait...).

      my bro told me to check out "last exile" too.. seems pretty good as well.

      --
      world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
    3. Re:GITS: Stand Alone Complex by keesh · · Score: 1

      Except, as usual, the ending was totally screwed up. I've seen maybe one decent anime series (Noir) which didn't have a completely fucked conclusion. Why? WHY?

    4. Re:GITS: Stand Alone Complex by BJH · · Score: 1

      What did you think was wrong with the ending?

    5. Re:GITS: Stand Alone Complex by bludstone · · Score: 1

      The first DVD of the tv series is out. I'll wait on season 2 because ive got the uber-high-quality-home-theater setup. Bootlegging anime of this production level doesnt really give you the whole "feel."

      Same with last exile.

      Bootleg naruto instead :)

      --

      no .sig
    6. Re:GITS: Stand Alone Complex by n8_f · · Score: 1

      The TV series is much closer to Shirow's work than the movie. I suppose the movie was good, but after having read the manga, it was a let down for me. It has been a while since I've watched it, but I remember feeling it pandered to its audience, that it was mostly eye candy without the complexity and depth of the manga. Perhaps it was more the result of trying to cram 300+ pages of manga into one movie.

      The TV series, however, gave me the same feeling that I had when reading the manga. The complex characters, the intertwining plots, it is really great. If you liked GitS:SAC, you should really read the original manga.

      I have high hopes for the 2nd GitS movie. Hopefully, with the universe already established by the first movie and the TV series, they can focus on plot.

      And I also am really looking forward to the Appleseed movie, although I fear some of the same problems as the first GitS movie (and the first Appleseed movie, really). I really hope that Appleseed will get a TV series, too. It is simply too big for a movie (as the first version showed). Maybe the animators can pick up the ball where Shirow left it and run with it (much like Gits: I much prefer GitS:SAC and 2nd Gig to Man-Machine Interface, which I haven't been able to finish reading).

    7. Re:GITS: Stand Alone Complex by anethema · · Score: 2

      Plenty of torrents for all :D

      http://69.50.168.139/sn2//list_torrents/297.html

      --


      It's easier to fight for one's principles than to live up to them.
    8. Re:GITS: Stand Alone Complex by taernim · · Score: 1

      If you like anime, or liked the original movie. Go buy this on dvd. Now. Its simply the most remarkable anime I have seen in more then 5 years (and ive been doing this for more then a decade)

      Doing what? If you're going to recommend something based on expertise in some realm, it may help to tell us what your qualifications are...

      --
      "PC Load Letter? What the $@#% does that mean?!"
    9. Re:GITS: Stand Alone Complex by bludstone · · Score: 1

      Uhm, Lets see.

      I've been involved in fandom for 11 years.
      I've written for 2 anime magazines, and one fanzine.
      I've helped in some minor dvd production/testing.
      Worked on a handful of early fansubs.
      I've run anime panels at conventions.

      Is that enough?.. I dont want to sound like Im bragging or anything. The only reason I dont actually work in the industry is because the pay is crap... And I dont want to move to Texas.

      --

      no .sig
  30. Re:Greatest Anime Film? -- Miyazaki by constrapolator · · Score: 1

    I'm going to have to agree, Nausicaä of the Valley of Windis perhaps the finest anime movie ever made. If you like Miyazaki's style, but found Princess Mononoke (and Spirited Away) to be somewhat dull, then give Nausicaä a chance -- it's much more gripping and adventurous. Second to that would have to be another Miyazaki film, Porco Rosso, which is just plain fun.

  31. umm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
  32. Sunday Sunday Sunday! by Wireless+Joe · · Score: 3, Funny

    Coming to the Staples Center! Stare in amazement as the Giants of Anime take on the Monsters of Rock! Can the vixens of Sailor Moon survive in the Spiked Cage of Death for three minutes with the hellcats of L7? Cringe in horror as the KISS Army takes a full frontal assault from the Red Ribbon Army!

    As allways, we'll sell you the whole seat, but you'll only need the edge!

  33. Re:Akira by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    dont get much pussy huh :P

  34. Re:Greatest Anime Film: Kenshin OVA by MonkeyDluffy · · Score: 2, Informative
    The TV series is good too, but it is totally different from the OVA. The TV series is action and a fair bit of comedy, while the OVA (Called Samuri X in the US) is dark and violent.


    The TV series is 95 episodes long. The last third of the series has a bi drop off in story quality because the show outran the Kenshin manga that it was based on, so the storyline was no longer based on it.


    -MDL

    --
    Happy meals fund terrorism
  35. Re:Greatest Anime Film: Kenshin OVA by Halthar · · Score: 1

    Great pick. I actually didn't like the series until AFTER I watched Trust and Betrayal. It actually made the series enjoyable for me. The second OVA (Seisouhen) was/is amazing too.

  36. Suppress this! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    http://cryptome.org/rnc-data.htm

  37. Re:From the text by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Wow... King Retard.

  38. Re:What's the fun... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    In what category would that be?
    Sci-fi in manga (and probably other categories as well) has done much more imaginative things than anything I've seen in movies. The fact is movies are taking ideas from manga (The Matrix, Dark City... to mention a few). So RTFA and I hope you will look at anime with a more open mind and not think of it of a "children's cartoon" thing. Cartoons can take on adult themes (not just erotic) and do a damn well job at it too.

  39. Re:The DN Convention, distilled by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Oh shut up George W.!

  40. What a loaded question. What makes a movie great? by SmallFurryCreature · · Score: 5, Insightful
    Should it be purely entertaining? Tell a involving story? Make you think? Is the animation important?

    Even then you aren't finished. Exactly what do you find entertaining. What does make a story involving. What stuff have you already thought about and don't need to be reminded by a movie?

    The one that made me think was "Grave of the fireflies" a movie you could compare with the western "Empire of the sun". Both tell the what happens to kids in times of war. I liked one review that claimed fireflies was the best movie he ever watched and never wanted to watch again.

    Of course if you like Akira and Ghost in the shell you might find fireflies very slow moving even boring. Perhaps. Depends for what reason you like the first two.

    Another highly regarded movie you don't list is "Angels egg". One of the few movies you could watch without knowing any japanese and still be able to "understand" what is going on.

    This will probabaly get me modded down but the movies you list are the typical "hollywood approved" anime movies people in the west have heard about. Doesn't mean the movies are bad or any less then their more unknown, in the west, siblings but if you really want to find the greatest anime movie ever you need to do a little bit more watching. Akira may then still be the greatest to you but at least you will have a longer list to show you watched anime other then the ones with a western approved release.

    Oh and my favorite movie? I don't really have such a thing. There are far to many great movies I have seen that I like for different reasons. I am afraid that if I pick a single movie that "scores" best in all my catogories that I am falling into the hollywood trap of creating movies to appeal to everyone that end up appealing to no-one. Just saw a docu on Red Dwarf. American movie studie wants to cast Hugh Grant as Lister.

    --

    MMO Quests are like orgasms:

    You may solo them, I prefer them in a group.

  41. Geek news site + anime? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I still don't understand why Japanese cartoons fit into a geek news site. Am I alone in being a geek without a love for anime? Or does everyone just follow along with CmdrTaco's other interest?

    1. Re:Geek news site + anime? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It makes me angry that people have a variety of tastes! Angry I tell you!

    2. Re:Geek news site + anime? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Suuure. Let's just put every category under the sun on slashdot, to cater for *everybody's* taste. Why don't we have a "rollercoasters" category, or a "siamese cats" category?

    3. Re:Geek news site + anime? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


      I understand your point but Slashdot is News for Nerds. Anime is something which almost instantly gets you a great big "NERD" label. Witness the discussion on this topic.

      I think it fits quite neatly into Slashdot's mandate.

  42. Re:What's the fun... by chendo · · Score: 1

    Yes, the translation factor of anime is what turns off most people. One short sentence in Japanese could turn out to be a long sentence in English, and if you're watching a dub, they'll have to butcher the meaning to bits just to make it lip-sync.

    Also, most dubs -suck-. Really, really bad. I don't think an American voice actor can come close to emulating a Japanese anime character. It's like they don't put enough heart into it, and that makes the character seem dull and shallow. Personally, I always watch subs whenever possible, although I know some people prefer dubs anyway simply because they cannot read the subs fast enough.

    And responding to the grandparent's post, yes. There are different categories of manga in Japan. Shounen, which is mainly for young male teenagers; Shoujo, mainly for young female teenagers. And then there's Seinen, which is pretty much 'adult' manga. But don't think too far ahead; an adult manga doesn't necessarily mean nothing but tits and ass throughout, it just usually contains issues that don't interest the other two categories. That, or they do actually have T&A, or just a lot of gore (MPD Psycho comes to mind, known more for it's extreme detail in murder scenes). I probably missed some other categories, but those are the ones that come to mind.

    I, on the other hand, love the Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex series. Government conspiracies, crazy Matrix-style action scenes, funky A.I. tanks, and hacking scenes. And don't forget the little insights into each character's personal lives.

    --
    Founder of Mirror Moon - Tsukihime Game Trans
  43. Mod parent insightful! by kid-noodle · · Score: 3, Funny

    "Who needs the opposite sex, I've got you Jessy!"

    Spirited Away has nothing on Team Rocket.

    --
    fortune -o
  44. Re:From the text by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Just come clean; when they offered you the red pill and the blue pill, you took both, didn't you?

  45. Re:What's the fun... by Coffee+Warlord · · Score: 1


    "Ah yes, the words of someone who has not actually sat down to watch a good amount of it. Actually watch the movies. Get something directed by Miyazaki. Castle in the Sky. Princess Mononoke. Grave of the Fireflies. Nausicaa. You will understand."

    Have. Hated it. Don't understand the attraction at all. Subjected to endless hours of the drivel by several friends of mine who utterly love anime.
    I find it chock full of nonsensical plots and bloated with mood-breaking utterly silly/stupid scenes.

    Some anime (very, very little) I wouldn't mind, were it not for the fact that they set you up in a dark, moody universe, just to subject you to a bouncing girl with no face screaming at the protaganist for failing to do the wakawaka dance properly.

  46. AKIRA by essreenim · · Score: 1

    Lots of people will say other things just to be different or special.
    Bu really Akira must be the father of Anime movies.
    By the way if anyone knows where I can get English subtitles for Avalon, fwd a link..

  47. More cartoon fun! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/ap/ 9_11_toy

    "It makes me angry"

  48. Nice! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Troll
    Slashdot has decided that my "don't show me fucking anime stories on the front page" preference isn't REALLY what I wanted. So, since they're wasting my time with what has to be THE STUPIDEST hobby in recorded human history, I'm going to waste yours.

    Still wasting your time.

    And still.

    Time? Wasted.

    Dear Slashdot: fix your shitty code.

    I hate anime.

    The end.

    1. Re:Nice! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny
      Fuck you. I'll kick your ass

      Sincerely,
      Japan

  49. "Vision" of Ghost in the Shell by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    One point I found annoying about the article was it going on about the 'vision' of the director of Ghost in the Shell, and totally ignoring the fact that the vision of the GITS came from its original manga writer/artist Masimune Shirow.

  50. Re:What's the fun... by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 1

    People like you disturb me, and I'm inclined to think that it is not due to short attention span.

  51. It has to be said by Jakhel · · Score: 2, Funny

    Anime geeks rejoice, your time has come!!

    ^_^

    -_-;

    >_<

    <('_'<)
    ^('_')^
    (>'_')>

  52. The Giants of Anime are cumming? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I'd better get my Umbrella.

  53. What, no mention of Gainax? Etc... by ChrisRijk · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Gundam barely got a mention. No shoujo (girl's) anime mentioned at all. Not much mention of anime TV series...

    Lot of good anime is based on novels too, though they're rarer. I feel that most novel conversions are great (though my Japanese isn't good enough to read novels) but I often feel let down by anime based on an original manga series. Patlabor, Hellsing, Azumanga Daioh and Gunslinger Girl are good examples of manga conversions though. I'm probably picker than average though.

    Some examples of anime based on novels: Slayers (TV series a lot more slapstick than novels though), Read or Die, Scrapped Princess, Crest of the Stars (and follow-ons), The Tweleve Kingdoms.

    Crest of the Stars is one of my favourite series - battles in a 2D universe, the interesting Abh culture and language (the author made up his own language and character set), and some very interesting characters. In pretty much any western series, if you have a race of genetically engineered people, it pretty much has to be a distaster - not so in CotS. Also, democracy vs royalty - democracy has to be superior... but not in CotS. Pretty fun. Ahh... if they'd only make another series...

    The Tweleve Kingdoms is awesome too. Doesn't seem that way at the start, but it has some incredible plots and character development. More!

    1. Re:What, no mention of Gainax? Etc... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I thought I was the only one who liked CotS! I feel happy now ^_^

    2. Re:What, no mention of Gainax? Etc... by kiljoy001 · · Score: 1

      there is a continuation... it's called something like banner of the stars or something like it.

    3. Re:What, no mention of Gainax? Etc... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Crest of the Stars and Banner of the Stars rock. Well executed, effective writing, very good voice acting (in the Japanese dub, the English dubs go from sucky to not too bad), internally consist, interesting plotline...gotta love it. Easily the best space opera drama I've seen anywhere - it makes Star Trek look like the load of mediocre crap that it is - doubly so by the time you get to Banner II...

    4. Re:What, no mention of Gainax? Etc... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Banner of the Stars and Banner of the Stars 2. There's also a one episode character piece on the Banner of the Stars 2 3rd disk depicting Lafiel's parents and a "movie" version of Crest of the Stars that chops the series down to 90 minutes and replaces a bit of footage (not worth watching though - at only 90 minutes it loses a lot of what makes the series great).

    5. Re:What, no mention of Gainax? Etc... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You're not alone - I just finished the first series and am currently d'loading the torrent for the next.

      Really quite good.

    6. Re:What, no mention of Gainax? Etc... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Toss Read or Die (the 3-part oav with The Paper, the tv series is good too but its based on the characters from the manga) into the list of excellent novel-based series.

    7. Re:What, no mention of Gainax? Etc... by superstick58 · · Score: 1
      ROD was quite a suprise when I first saw it and it now ranks as one of my favorites. It has great music. I find that this usually accompanies great anime.

      For Example: Blue Sub 6, Cowboy Bebop, Escaflowne

  54. Ghibli Museum by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is slightly off topic but while the Giants of Anime is coming to the U.S., people can go to the museum that showcases just what exactly makes Studio Ghibli tick at the Ghibli Museum. If you are lucky, you might even be lucky to meet the man himself, Hayao Miyazaki. You can get more information at the Ghibli Museum website. (Translated of course, but they also have an english version as well.) I wish I could have had the chance to go when I was Japan. From what I have heard, it is MUCH better than Disneyland.

  55. You don't understand the power of animation by SmallFurryCreature · · Score: 4, Insightful
    With animation you can do things that can't be done in real life.

    I am not talking giant robots here. I am talking far simpler things. Scene at an airport. Scene at the busiest crossing in tokyo. Scene with a kid.

    Ever notice how many of the live action series take place INSIDE? Because it is cheaper to film in a studio then on location. Canadian cities are very popular to shoot series that pretend to be in american cities because it is cheaper to close down a street for a shoot.

    You might also notice that many anime involve childeren as the leads. This is a huge problem in live action as there are very strict laws about what you can and cannot make a child do. You might have noticed that series in the west about high school students have actors in their 30's.

    Ultimately anime is just another media through wich a story teller can tell their story. There are a lot. Just like you can be told the story of "The hitchhikers guide to the galaxy" through a radio-play, a series of books, a series of comics, a tv series, an upcoming movie and even a computer game. All have their own charms and give their own capabilities to the story teller.

    I get the idea that you can't imagine those capabilites as you seem to think that only "real" movies are worth it.

    • A radioplay is very cheap to setup. You simply "tell" the audience you are on a different planet, make some noises and that creates a different planet. A budget of a pound will do it. You only need actors who sound like their part. The ugliest actor can play the most beautifull character. Disadvantage. You need a listener with imagination. A radioplay can also break the 4th wall (I think it is called) and talk to the audience.
    • Books are even cheaper as you don't even need actors or sound effects. What you write is the world, if the reader has the imagination and you are skilled enough the entire set is created in the mind. People can imagine far more then even the fanciest CG can generate. Even better. A beautifull girl can be the beauty of the reader not the writer. Books don't have a fourth wall. Yo u can talk the reader all you want. Thought by a character is very very easy to express.
    • Comics/manga take away some of the freedom to imagine but gather the power of "a picture is worth a thousand words". But this comes at the expense of extra effort. You know need two skill sets, telling a story and drawing, wich you didn't need with a plain text book. The 4th wall is starting to close in but thought by a character can still be easily expressed.
    • TV and movie live action give you to power to create a world and have the viewer experience your vision. You loose some of the imagination, good horror movies don't show horror they make you imagine it, but gain the power of a moving picture speaks a million words. Disadvantage is that you are going to be restricted to the real world. There are only so many things you are allowed to do with actors. You now also need an actor who sounds the part, can act the part and looks like the part.
    • A computer game gives you that rarest of capabilties. To give the reader, a tiny amount, of control on the story. The text only hitchhiker adventure was much like a book but with the idea of control. A style of storytelling that is not yet fully explored.

    Animation comes in with the live action but removes the need to find suitable looking actors and the need to build complex sets or get permission to film in real world location.

    Animation gains the power of movie images without the restraint on the imagination of the author. If the author can imagine it then it can be done in animation.

    As I said before this isn't just about special effects but about simple things like a war movie involving childeren. Filming in real life locations.

    Ultimatly only a snob would dismiss a story telling media. It is the story that matters and how well it is told. If war and peace had been done in a comic would you not have read it? Read Lone wolf and cub sometime

    --

    MMO Quests are like orgasms:

    You may solo them, I prefer them in a group.

  56. Re:What's the fun... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    I'm fairly new to anime; I only started watching it maybe 18 months ago (I'm 35), and that was by happenstance that Ghost in the Shell was playing on the Independent Film Channel. I had never seen anything quite like it, and it had me riveted to the TV. I only caught the last 20 minutes or so. I started exploring more and different kinds of anime. I've found that, like most things, 90% of it is crap. But the good stuff is a refreshing change from vomit-inducing Disney fare.

    There's also the cultural aspect of it. I've learned more about Japan and Asia, and took a Japanese language course.

    Plus there's all those cute schoolgirls in sailor uniforms ;)

  57. That's funny... by zalas · · Score: 1

    I think I just started automatically filtering those people out, so now I only see cute cosplayers.

  58. Re:What's the fun... by BarryNorton · · Score: 2, Funny
    what's exactly the fun of watching a cartoon in a category where a lot of real movies are, imho, better ?
    I agree: I stopped reading novels in favour of comic books, stopped reading them in favour of animation, stopped watching that in favour of live action feature films, ditched those in favour of tv movies, then soaps, infomercials and political broadcasts and finally gave up the lot in favour of trolling on Slashdot...
  59. On their websites. by SmallFurryCreature · · Score: 1
    Most of the movies listed have had their western DVD release so you can probably rent them at the better rental store. Akira and Ghost in the shell almost certainly.

    The rarer stuff does not have a western release and force you to either learn japanese or get the "illegal" version from the net. There are plenty of fan subbed versions of anime series and movies out there. Often with better translations then the official releases. Fansubs ain't afraid to use explanations at the top of the screen when something said is to japanese to be translated.

    So for the movies in the article search google for the official sites. Fansubs are techinaclly illegal but as long as no western company has licensed it it seems to be tolerated. At least the japanese don't seem to take action against fansubs. Fansubs do help to establish a market in the west I guess.

    --

    MMO Quests are like orgasms:

    You may solo them, I prefer them in a group.

  60. I forgot to add Graveof the fireflies. by mandrake*rpgdx · · Score: 2, Insightful

    An excellent film that my wife will never ever watch again. Another good one is Chinese Ghost Story.

    1. Re:I forgot to add Graveof the fireflies. by aka-ed · · Score: 1

      curious: did you see the live-action CGS first? Having seen the live action, I was unable to warm up to the anime.

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
  61. poor naming choice by Requiem · · Score: 1

    Since it's anime, shouldn't it be called "Moving Castle Howl" or something like that?

    1. Re:poor naming choice by astrokid · · Score: 1

      I'm not really sure what you are trying to imply by that, but the miyazaki anime is based on this book

      --

      Chewie does not get a medal. Come on, George. Can a Wookie get a medal?
    2. Re:poor naming choice by meringuoid · · Score: 1

      The actual title is Hauru no Ugoku Shiro - a direct translation of the English Howl's Moving Castle, allowing for some understandable Japanese difficulty in pronouncing the name of a Welsh wizard. The original story is distinctly British, in a rather discworldish sort of way, but I can definitely see why Miyazaki went for it; I can't wait to see his Calcifer.

      --
      Real Daleks don't climb stairs - they level the building.
  62. Re:Greatest Anime Film? -- Miyazaki by dosius · · Score: 1

    Tenkuu no shiro Laputa 3

    Moll.

    --
    What you hear in the ear, preach from the rooftop Matthew 10.27b
  63. Yoshitoshi Abe by MEK · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Wired ignores the most creative figure involved with anime today -- Yoshitoshi Abe. Abe was scarcely out of school when his character designs helped bring "Serial Experiment Lain" to life. This groundbreaking work would have been a far more arid exercise had it not been populated by Abe's characters.

    Abe (and part of the Lain team) went on to make the interesting, but not entirely successful "Niea_7". For this, Abe contributed not only character (and environmental) designs, but the basic story.

    Abe then went on to create one of the most beautiful and moving animated series ever -- "Haibane Renmei". Inspired more by the films of Angelopoulos and Kore'eda than other anime, this understated story of young people reincarnated in a bucolic limbo is not only wonderfully animated but remarkably sophisticated theologically (in a fundamentally non-denominational fashion).

    Most recently, Abe has teamed up with much of the crew from Lain to make his most visually compelling work yet -- "Texhnolyze". This dark dystopian work adapts the fragmented narrative methodology of John Brunner's greatest sf novels ("Stand on Zanzibar", "Sheep Look Up") in a thoroughly cinematic fashion.

    Any discussion of anime giants that doesn't include Abe (and his colleagues) is incomplete.

    --
    Credo quia impossibilis -- Tertullian
    1. Re:Yoshitoshi Abe by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Agreed.

    2. Re:Yoshitoshi Abe by Bagels · · Score: 1

      I'm particularly looking forward to his next work - a manga called "Robot," where he's collaborating with Range Murata (the man behind the art in Last Exile, Blue Sub No. 6, etc.). Here's a link to a small teaser on it... I can't read Japanese, though, so no idea when it's coming out (or if it already has).

      --
      --- Bwah?
    3. Re:Yoshitoshi Abe by MEK · · Score: 1

      Murata and Tsuruta (Spirit of Wonder, etc.) are two graphic artists who Abe has cited as haveing been inspirations for him.

      It looks like Robot is mainly a Murata project, and that Abe is one of a host of others who will be involved somehow.

      Still no real word on what Abe's next personal project will be.

      --
      Credo quia impossibilis -- Tertullian
    4. Re:Yoshitoshi Abe by aka-ed · · Score: 1
      The he should get off his Japanese butt and make a feature film, which is what the article concerns itself with.

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
    5. Re:Yoshitoshi Abe by MEK · · Score: 1

      > The he should get off his Japanese butt and make a feature film

      Both "Haibane Renmei" and "Texhnolyze" are integral cinematic works -- not collections of autonomous episodes. "Haibane Renmei" is, in essence, a meticulously structured 5 hour film.

      Do you suggest that excellence can be measured by the official format in which a show is presented?

      --
      Credo quia impossibilis -- Tertullian
    6. Re:Yoshitoshi Abe by aka-ed · · Score: 1
      No, I'm suggesting that, for good or ill, magazine articles tend to be themed by sometimes-arbitrary categories. This one happens to be about theatrical-standard feature films.

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
    7. Re:Yoshitoshi Abe by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not to rain on your parade, but ABe is far less responsible for the anime he is credited with than any of the three directors featured in the article. He doesn't even direct. He is a character designer who sometimes comes up with basic script ideas. Haibane Renmei is really the only anime that should be called his own, as he was intimately involved in most aspects of that one.

  64. Miyazaki is probably the king ... by thunderpeel · · Score: 1, Informative

    I have been watching and collecting for about 25 years now. The mindless crap aside (Dragon Ball, NinjaScroll etc...)
    1. My Neighbour Totoro : Probably the movie I would like every child to see.
    1. Akira : Probably the movies I would like every child to not see.
    1. Nausicaa (whatever you want to call it)


    These three are very closely tops....
    2.Princess Mononoke - excellent film
    3.Cowboy bebop the series, the movie was alright but the series is where it is at.
    4. FLCL - a very nice piece of semi-modern japanese mixed art.
    5. Ghost in the Shell - technically very nice and the story line is very good.

    Most of what the North American eyes see are a "limited" version of the actual stories as Manga is the true story and the films are usually the mockup of that. Ottomos Akira is one of my favourite "comics" ever.

    That being said I am waiting all the new releases from the masters of both Manga and Anime.

    There are MANY films but I would say, if you don't know anime that well and would like to see some very nice classics .. the above are the way to go.

    --
    I really do know KungFu .. ..
    1. Re:Miyazaki is probably the king ... by aka-ed · · Score: 1
      Now that TV shows have been brought in, I insist that the greatest anime ever made is the episode of Hana Yori Dango in which Tsukushi gets dragged from the back of a car for flirting with the F4. High school kids can be so cruel!

      Anybody know whether that scene was intact in the Meteor Garden TV series?

      --
      I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
  65. Anime successful in US theaters by MobyDisk · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I get the impression that Hollywood is blocking Anime. Could it be that they see it as a threat? My experience is telling me that Anime is no longer a cult thing. I'm 27, and my youngest brother (11 yrs) to people my age (30s) are watching and collecting anime. It's available in mainstream stores now (Best Buy, movie stores) and video rental places offer them.

    But I don't see them in theaters. Spirited Away didn't even make it into as many theaters as Gigli! Live-action anime-like movies get even worse treatment. Granted, Kill Bill was successful, and the comic movies do well. But Shaolin Soccer was a hit in China and Japan, but it can't seem to make it over here. My younger bros wear Naruto t-shirts to school, but I hear that will never be licensed in the US.

    What's going on?

    1. Re:Anime successful in US theaters by PCM2 · · Score: 1

      Bad example. Shaolin Soccer actually did make it here. That is, it made it to theaters here, courtesy of Miramax. As far as "making it"... if people had flocked to see it in the numbers that you seem to imply, I'm sure it would have gotten a wider release.

      --
      Breakfast served all day!
    2. Re:Anime successful in US theaters by ll1234 · · Score: 1

      Disney is just about as "Hollywood" as a company can get, and it's responsible for bringing most of Studio Ghibli's output to the US.

      Naruto isn't licensed in the US because of the cost. Popular shows command high fees not to mention the sheer length (nearly a 100 episodes and counting).

    3. Re:Anime successful in US theaters by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh for god's sake--

      Maybe it's time for you Japanese animation fanatics to realize that despite your incessant shouting about how "great" and "superior" Japanese cartoons are, the GENERAL PUBLIC DOES NOT CARE.

      It's not that "we just don't get it." It's not that there's some vast Hollywood conspiracy to blind everyone in north America to Japanese animation.

      Despite what you think, the vast majority does not CARE about Japanese cartoons. You are not bringing us news of something that hasn't been seen before--we've seen it and we JUST DON'T CARE.

      Deal with it.

    4. Re:Anime successful in US theaters by Halthar · · Score: 1

      Hopefully Naruto will get licensed eventually. Personally, I hope they finish the series before it gets licensed. I hate the idea of waiting a year to see the next episode because the fansub groups have decided to stop subbing once it's licensed, but the licensee isn't ready to start releasing.

      Please, think of the chillrens, I have a wednesday night addiction to feed.

      That having been said, if it does get picked up for US distribution, I will gladly shell out my heard earned dollars for all of the episodes on DVD. I am keeping my fansubs around as well though.

    5. Re:Anime successful in US theaters by vhold · · Score: 1

      Selfishly I hope Naruto is never licensed over here, losing the fansub and distribution support would really suck.

      But much more troublesome, I just can't picture where this show fits in in an American timeslot. If you leave it unedited, it's too bloody and racy for a normal kid's show, but it won't make enough money in a late time slot and it's main appeal $$$ wise is probably the wide array of markettable characters for toys, etc. So basically it just seems like any license will edit out tons of good stuff.

      They should just leave it the way it is now, but try to bring over all the merchandise (assuming there is some) and see what happens.

    6. Re:Anime successful in US theaters by Minna+Kirai · · Score: 1

      Disney is just about as "Hollywood" as a company can get, and it's responsible for bringing most of Studio Ghibli's output to the US.

      Barely. Investors are accusing Disney of mismanagement recently, and their reluctance to promote imported Miyazaki films is part of the problem.

      You see, they bought the import rights to Miyazaki not because they wanted to profit on them, but only to prevent some other company from bringing them over and making Disney look bad by comparison.

      Think back to 2002, when Disney had (Oscar nominated) "Spirted Away" they could bring to US theaters. So what did they advertise instead? The horrible "Treasure Planet". They try not to give Miyazaki too much exposure, because he's so much better at Disney's supposed strong-point than they are.

      Pixar and Ghilbi are eating Disney's lunch. What was their last successful animation? Lion King, 10 years ago?

    7. Re:Anime successful in US theaters by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      the GENERAL PUBLIC DOES NOT CARE

      $4.3 billion+ for anime and $100 million+ for manga. Plus an Academy Award and eight shelves of DVDs at Best Buy, Suncoast, etc.

      But it was a nice troll.

  66. Re:Flaming Anime by Cheerio+Boy · · Score: 1

    I'm going to risk feeding a troll here...

    As a person that has been watchng Anime for many many years I can easily say that:

    1) Some Anime does suck - especially if we get "all your base" style translations. Or that wacky badly repeated motion animation. Red mouths with no teeth, etc.

    2) There are as many reasons to watch Anime as there are anything else - for the most part the same reasons. Writing, artwork, animation, general insanity, very little taboos, etc.

    3) Anime, like any other genre or style of media is a personal taste. I respect your opinion and your right to say it but saying all Anime sucks is like saying all movies suck. It's an opinion - nothing more.

    --

    "Bah!" - Dogbert
  67. Totoro Re:Greatest Anime Film? by cmpalmer · · Score: 1

    I agree. I bought the VHS 20th Century Fox version for my kids when they were little and we've watched it probably over 50 times. My daughter is 13 now and when we saw the DVD on the sales rack, she made me buy it, even though we're waiting for the Disney widescreen/re-dub/subtitled version next year.

    You hit the nail on the head about the violence and conflict. It amazes me that this is a kid's movie that doesn't bore them (or any adult that I have met) despite the fact that it has no (a) slapstick humor, (b) fart jokes, (c) violence of any kind, (d) bad guys of any kind. Even in the bad Fox pan-and-scan dub, it is a beautiful film.

    BTW, if you haven't seen it, Best Buy and Wal-Mart currently have the Fox DVD in their bargain bins for approximately 5 bucks.

    --
    -- stream of did I lock the front door consciousness
  68. Re:Anime is for maladjusted fat balding 40 year ol by Lord+Bitman · · Score: 1

    I'm not 40.

    --
    -- 'The' Lord and Master Bitman On High, Master Of All
  69. Re:What's the fun... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I find it chock full of nonsensical plots and bloated with mood-breaking utterly silly/stupid scenes.

    You mean, just like "real" movies? Gosh.

  70. Re:AKIRA by aka-ed · · Score: 1
    Lots of people will say other things just to be different or special.

    hmmmph. One reason to start watching anime is to get away from the general entertainment consensus. If you insist I conform to your taste, I'm switching to Bombay musicals.

    --
    I survived the Dick Cheney Presidency 7 to 9 AM 7-21-07
  71. Re:What a loaded question. What makes a movie grea by Altus · · Score: 2, Interesting


    excelent post. but i will hold off on modding it to add to it.

    I havent seen this movie listed in anyones posts:
    http://us.imdb.com/title/tt0093207/

    Wings of Honneamise. its such a simple movie, with little action, but it was the first anime I had ever seen that had a "normal" plot. It told a story and did it extremely well, held my attention without resorting to giant robots and the like. much like some of the movies you listed.

    Just wanted to through that out there... since noone else has.

    still, my favorite movie might be Akira. I have seen it so many times I cant even count... The first time I saw it was in jappaneese without any sub-titles (I dont speak jappaneese) and I have seen it many many times since, every translation, every dub. I still notice something new every time.

    --

    "In America, first you get the sugar, then you get the power, then you get the women..." -H. Simpson

  72. Re:Bleh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Agreed. Not to mention theirs nothing nerdy about it and it certainly doesn't matter. It's just Taco jerking off again.

  73. Re:What's the fun... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The acid test is your non-anime life. If you're over 30 and like anime and *also* have a stable job, decent income, something approximating a social life, and actual responsibilities in the world which you fulfill, then by all means enjoy the odd bit of anime. Can't hurt you and it is pretty good.

    If most of the above don't apply, then anime might represent an escape hatch which you should not be exploiting at this time in your life.

  74. Re:What's the fun... by eldacan · · Score: 1

    I thank you in advance for listing some movies ("a lot" shall earn you still more thanks) in the same category as Neon Genesis Evangelion. Something I've been looking for, for a long time.

  75. Re:What's the fun... by aiabx · · Score: 1

    Why would you eat sushi when you can eat steak? The problem is in the question. The correct answer is you can do both, you just need to apply Sturgeon's Law to cut through the 90% of anime, and the 90% of "real" movies which are crap.
    -aiabx

    --
    Just this guy, you know?
  76. Re:AKIRA by essreenim · · Score: 1

    I'm switching to Bombay musicals.
    Wow, the Bombay musical strategy actually worked. Woot!

  77. totoro was 'man against nature' by Kunta+Kinte · · Score: 1
    It proves you don't need violence and conflict to have a great story

    You had conflict. I'm sorry bub, you always have conflict.

    Totoro was a brilliant movie. The plot was man against nature, or "man vs. forces he can not control". The baby sister getting lost was the climax of the movie. The mother being ill also provides some elements of this type of plot.

    --
    Based on upvotes, Ageism is the only "-ism" Slashdotters care about and think isn't SJW
    1. Re:totoro was 'man against nature' by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I agree it had conflict, but I'm not sure it was "man against nature". Mai and her corn against a bad goat, maybe, but not man against nature.

      More like the standard pains and conflicts of growing up. Satsuki needing to take care of/look strong for Mai, but having her own life and being scared for her mother too. Satsuki's really where most of the conflict is, I think.

  78. Since the article mentions Cagliostro... by Robotech_Master · · Score: 1

    ...I'm going to take this chance to plug the DVDTracks audio commentary I did for Cagliostro, inspired by a Slashdot story about the site. (As well as the journal entry I wrote recently describing how I put it all together.) I did a good enough job with it that a representative from a movie company considering making a live-action Lupin III contacted me and asked if I would serve as a consultant. (I never heard anything back from them afterward, though, and that was a couple of years ago.)

    --
    Editor Emeritus and Senior Writer, TeleRead.org
  79. Try the new rage - Love Hina drinking game by ZoomieDood · · Score: 0

    Using Winamp video streaming, there's a popular anime series called Love Hina.

    In 2-3 sentences, aspiring Tokyo University entrant Keitaro flunks (yet again) his entry exams. With nothing to do with his life, his grandmother invites him down to an all-girls dorm to act as the manager in her absence.

    The tension between Keitaro and fellow Tokyo U aspirant Naru (also multiple failings to pass entrance exams) is but one of the recurring plot themes.

    Imagine a young guy surrounded by various college age girls and the temptations that follow.

    Naru alternates between desiring and denying a relationship with Keitaro with the usual result - he makes a move, she doesn't approve, and she slaps/kicks/punches Keitaro.

    Here's where the drinking game comes in. Every time Keitaro is pummeled, you can take a drink. For those who want a little faster path to inebriation, take a drink each time Keitaro flips over (multiple times per punishment).

    Guaranteed to work faster than the Star Trek Red Shirt Death drinking game. And the added bonus is that Love Hina is still funny for those who are designated drivers.

    And the religious monks are profoundly funny.

    Enjoy!

  80. Re:Greatest Anime Film: Kenshin OVA by BakaHoushi · · Score: 1

    This isn't the only case where this happened. Often, anime series get cancelled or change directions when they reach the same point as the manga. Kenshin is the epitome of this, where the anime folks essentially decide to make their own season/arc and go with whatever they want. I believe Trigun (but I could be wrong) did something similar, but in the end came out similar (with a few exceptions, including a major one I won't spoil for those who haven't seen the series).

    Now Inuyasha in Japan has reached that point. Some people said that this would be the end of the series at episode 167, but it seems more likely that the animation company is going to let Ms. Takahashi finish the manga before going ahead with the rest of the series. (A smart idea, in my mind)

    So, when the anime manages to outrun the manga, a series can do a number of things. Personally, my favorite is what Inuyasha will must likely do, rather than risk getting two entirely different stories.

  81. Don't be so sure about japan by SmallFurryCreature · · Score: 1
    Granted I only know japan and from people who visited, lived there for a while or japanese I have met but I do get the feeling that being an manga/anime fan is not so unnerdy as you think. Being called an otaku is considered an insult in japan. Not really all that different from the comic book guy is in the simpsons.

    If anything manga/anime is just another form of entertainment. If you look at a very popular manga like Maison Ikkoku you can easily see that is what just a coin flip wether they would have done a live action or a anime for the tv version. No real reason to go anime as it does not have any special effects or difficult to film bits (kids, animals, locations). In fact in many ways it is a pure sitcom. Most action taking place in a few rooms with a steady cast. Only advantage that anime gives is that a live action would have a missing wall (where the camera is in sitcoms).

    Also I do not agree with your view of geeks being against popular things. We just don't like things just because they are popular or limit ourselves just because it is unpopular.

    A true geek does not really care what others think. This should work both ways. Not care that others disapprove or approve. That is a geek. Someone who only cares about others disapproving is called an angsty teenager. Most geeks don't have the social skills to be angsty. Or the time.

    --

    MMO Quests are like orgasms:

    You may solo them, I prefer them in a group.

    1. Re:Don't be so sure about japan by RsG · · Score: 1

      >Also I do not agree with your view of geeks being against popular things. We just don't like things just because they are popular or limit ourselves just because it is unpopular.
      >A true geek does not really care what others think. This should work both ways. Not care that others disapprove or approve. That is a geek.

      I agree. See my other reply in this thread, so I don't re-post it all here.

      However you're talking the ideal versus the reality. Many geeks _do_ buy into angsty counterculture. Many geeks are conforming nonconformists. Most of us aren't, but the problem cannot be dismissed. Yes, real individualism is a state of mind, no question.

      My point was that there is this undercurrent of intellectual snobbery in geek culture. You see it in our slang. How often have you seen the word "sheeple" or something similar on /.? You see it in our universal hatred of prefabricated popular media. We don't just dislike and ignore boy bands/Britney et all, we HATE them with an almost religious fervor. Why? Because it makes us feel superior.

      If I say that I am an individualist, and that I find pop muzak tolerable, am I contradicting myself? No. Real indivualism _must_ include the idea of "live and let live". Mere nonconformity is all to often simple intellectual snobbery masquerading as "culture". That is what I was reffering too in my post.

      --
      Erotic is when you use a feather. Exotic is when you use the whole chicken.
    2. Re:Don't be so sure about japan by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Erotic is when you use a feather. Exotic is when you use the whole chicken.

      Nah... it's "Kinky is when you tickle your girlfriend with a feather. Perverted is when you use the whole chicken."

    3. Re:Don't be so sure about japan by Minna+Kirai · · Score: 1

      Also I do not agree with your view of geeks being against popular things.

      But that's the DEFINITION of "geek". A "geek" is someone who's unpopular, whose interests are belittled by the mainstream population.

      (Enjoying technology has nothing to do with "geek", by the way)

  82. ROBOT is a manga compilation, similar to FLAT by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    For more info see:
    http://www.tokyocentral.com/shop/exd.asp?id= 2616

    Several years back Murata edited a collection of manga, something like 20 various artists, It was named "FLAT." A google search will get you more info. At any rate the 2 book set was a trip despite my not being able to read japanese. It was a collection of stories that were visually all over the place, both wonderous and often disturbing. But that's one of the appeals of manga/anime it's striking and causes you to feel something that is soften lacking in mainstream america.

    I'll also add, buy a copy, that's cheap considering how fast Murat/Yoshitoshi stuff sells out. Buying used is expensive, I know :/

  83. Uchuu Senkan Yamato by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    No account, but response. The title is that start, specifically the fourth, or the fifth if the television film is included in the numbering, film Final Yamato is thought appropriate for this title of best animated film. The only appropriate ending to such a vast and expansive collection of series and films as Yamato. Operatic drama on a galactic scale, the honor of service for the future of humanity, the noble deaths of many characters, and *SPOILER* the return of the first Captain after a failed rescue attempt and most human of endings; no opposition to it as a great if not the greatest film can be easily written. The production quality was astounding for its period, 1983 by memory. Of course, Ginga Eiyuu Densetsu ties with it for first place, in series, film, and OVA forms.

  84. Moderators, please donate a point... by MEK · · Score: 1

    ...to the highly informative anonymous posting to which this is a reply. ;~}

    (It tells us more about the Murata manga collection that another poster asked about)

    MEK

    --
    Credo quia impossibilis -- Tertullian
  85. "It is the fault of disney" by SmallFurryCreature · · Score: 4, Insightful
    Well not really wich is why it is in quotes. Rather it is the fault of the people who watch disney.

    For some reason the idea is in the west that only live action is capable of telling "real" stories. These people just like the author of this article always have to point out the turd fighting super giant robot girls. At the same time neatly forgetting that this kinda stuff appears in hollywood movies as well. Or exactly what is "Attack of the 50 foot woman" about again?

    There are other reasons to, so here is my bullet lists of reason why anime isn't being seen in the rest of the world.

    • Cartoons are for kids. Partly the reason but doesn't explain then why not more anime is shown in childerens programs.
    • Language barrier. Japanese is a very difficult language. Not just to learn but also to translate. Americans ain't good with foreign languages. The german detective series derrick is highly regarded. Do americans know it? Doubt it. So either you dub it, hard to fit english into japenese mouths, sub it, americans can't read, edit it, get pokemon and turn anime into american kid cartoon.
    • Culture flows naturally from the above. Sex is the simpest. Compare the pokemon manga as released in japan and in the west. In japan the girl got BOOBS. The american release has that edited out so they appear almost flat chested or at least showing a lot less cleavage. More then a few manga/anime I read have underaged drinking. Japan is a nation of boozers and it doesn't seem to considered a problem although it is illegal. That however is a nono in america.

      But while nudity and sexyness is more accepted in japanese anime, sex itself is far more restricted. Not at all unusual for at least one of the leads to be a virgin.

      Simply put the people in manga/anime can behave to different for western tastes. Or at least that is what tv/movie bosses think.

    All this may make it difficult to show most manga/anime in the west. Exactly how do you market an extremely popular series like Ranma? At kids? It got nudity. At adults? The main chars don't even kiss. Do you translate typical japanese things to their western equivalent even if that ruins any chance of the joke coming across? Do you explain the joke? Make up your own?

    I already see such things when I watch The Muppets on dutch tv. 2 stories for the price of one. The english audio and the dutch subs.

    Disney was a business man and story teller who really studied the art of animation. He certainly has tried to create animation that was not just for kids but sadly most people think disney == kids. There fore cartoon == kids.

    To bad those people will miss out but it is there loss not mine. Disney isn't to blame. People that dismiss intresting forms of story telling because it takes a certain form are. It is like saying casablance is slapstick because laurel & hardy is black & white.

    If you are going to blame anyone blaim the catogorirs. Who on earth would put Shindlers List in a category with Police Academy? Then why is Grave of the fireflies listed in the same category as Pokemon?

    --

    MMO Quests are like orgasms:

    You may solo them, I prefer them in a group.

    1. Re:"It is the fault of disney" by wolverine1999 · · Score: 1

      I used to see Derrick in the italian dub version..
      now that was a great tv show.

  86. Buttlord GT by istewart · · Score: 1

    See here for the webcomic version of what you just described.

  87. Japanese nitpick by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "Anime" doesn't have an accept over the "e"; it's not French. The syllables are fairly equally emphasized, actually.

    1. Re:Japanese nitpick by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Er... Considering the Japanese took the term from French, one would think that the French spelling would be correct...

    2. Re:Japanese nitpick by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      First, it's unclear where the term came from; second, the French spelling is not correct when applied to the Japanese word, regardless of where it came from -- just like the transliteration of the Japanese word for "coffee" is "koohii", not "coffee", even though it was derived from the English word.

  88. Re:And you sound like by PhoenixFlare · · Score: 1

    C'mon, guy, can't you try a little harder than that? Very unoriginal. Thanks for the laugh though....The double post was a nice touch :)

  89. Listen to the experts, not a slashdot troll by SmallFurryCreature · · Score: 4, Interesting
    Review by a real movie expert of an anime movie. Of course some people will still dismiss it because it is a cartoon. That is like dismissing Shindlers List because it is in Black & White.

    If you are going to watch this movie I do recommend that you know this. It is not a feel good movie. The most important mistake you can make is to see it as important wich side the kids are on. It is easy to shrug off their suffering as the result of japans own actions. It is an absolute fact that japan has only the historians to thank for the fact that most of their war crimes are forgotten. They were in no ways less then those commited by the germans/austrians. In my personal opion in fact worse. The germans just gassed childeren. They didn't rape them time and time again in pleasure houses for their soldiers. The germans also have paid billions in damages. The japanese haven't even admitted that raping childeren is bad.

    It is al to easy to go into this movie with the feelings that japan deserved to be bombed. It did. But these kids were not part of it. They had no more choice then the kids being raped by japanese soldiers. They are ultimately the victims of things outside their controle.

    Just as the movie Tora Tora Tora shows how a series of events leads to the start of the pacific war, a series of events where at any time someone might have stopped it all from happening. Grave of the fireflies shows a series of events where two childeren end up dead. Not because of evil actions but because at several steps no-one took action.

    Others are angry that the boy took not better care. This boy is not a movie hero, he is based on the author of the story. His owned sister died of starvation because he would when searching for food would feed himself first. He survived. She died. Just as he might have been able to save his sister in real life if he had been a better human being the movie brother might have made smarter choices. What I do think is missing in the movie is the emphasis that there simply wasn't any food to buy. Rice is not enough.

    Ultimatly I think this is a road movie. You know from the beginning how it is going to end. What you watch the movie for is the journey. Do not judge the travellers. If you want to do that you better be 100% sure that you are a better human being then the characters. It is easy to blame someone in this story. That takes the guilt away from us. Because the real guilt is that this story is happening all around us today.

    This is not an anti-war movie. That is to simple. It is a "this is what war is really like" movie.

    If you have read the reviews and still go "but it is a cartoon" then you are one hell of shallow thing.

    --

    MMO Quests are like orgasms:

    You may solo them, I prefer them in a group.

  90. outside the mainstream by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I like how articles like these focus on anime productions that exist outside of the mainstream. Flicks like Innocence, Howl's, and Steamboy are about as far from regular Japanese animation as you can get. Innocence and Steamboy mostly failed at the Japanese box office, but hope to do well internationally. Howl's will do as well as any Miyazaki film, but Ghibli movies have an appeal that reach far outside the anime fandom.

    Contrast those works and some of the others mentioned here (like Yoshitoshi Abe's stuff) to what we typically see in the Japanese anime mainstream: giant robot that, magical girlfriend this, harem anime that, 150-episode fighting anime this. Sturgeon's Law applies here.

    anyone else amused at how the article calls Production-IG the "Miramax of Anime"? I'm sure they meant that in a nice way...

  91. Banner of the Stars by ChrisRijk · · Score: 1

    Tastes differ of course, but you'll probably like the 2nd series more! The third series is very good too, but a change of pace, and is just 10 episodes.

    There's a 3rd banner of the stars novel which hasn't been animated yet - came out in 2001. I'm not sure if any new novels are expected. There's also 2 short stories that haven't been animated (a third one is an OVA).

  92. LAST EXILE by boa13 · · Score: 1

    Its simply the most remarkable anime I have seen in more then 5 years (and ive been doing this for more then a decade)

    Have you seen Last Exile? It is the best anime in more than 5 years.

    I've watched Escaflowne (very good), Stand Alone Complex (some excellent episodes, but uneven quality overall), .hack//SIGN (excellent, but a lot of chatter) in the same time period, but none of them reaches the quality of Last Exile.

    Excellent, surprising, tight plot up to the very last minute (they had to remove the opening credits of the last episode and to redesign the closing credits to fit it all!). Excellent and constant design, graphics, and animation quality. Excellent music, not by Yoko Kanno or Yuki Kajiura for once, but by a group named Dolce Triade. Very original and memorable universe, as much as Cowboy Bebop.

    If you enjoy top-quality work and great storytelling; if you enjoy planes, airships, wind and clouds; or if you want to pretend you know your stuff when it comes to anime, you just have to watch Last Exile, the best anime of 2003 (and maybe of a couple of years before and after that)!

    Last Exile on DVD in the USA:
    http://www.lastexiledvd.com/

    Some pictures:
    http://halo-productions.com/LastExile/multimedia.h tm
    (look at the ones marked "from Last EXILE website")

    Final word of advice: try very hard not to learn anything about the plot or the universe! Just jump into the first episode, you'll be glad you did!

    1. Re:LAST EXILE by bludstone · · Score: 1

      Yup, im up to dvd 5 :P

      But Im enjoying gits:sac more then last exile. :)

      Personal opinion, of course, but last exile is also phenomenal.

      --

      no .sig
    2. Re:LAST EXILE by Halthar · · Score: 1

      One you might want to try (Have to get Fansubs at this point, but it's worth it), is Scrapped Princess. I really hope the series ends up with a release in the US on DVD. It seemed slow through the first few episodes to me, but once it gets rolling it gets much much better. I saw the whole 26 episode set as a torrent and figured I would give it a shot. I downloaded all of them and would watch the first episode and then do something else. That occured for about 2 months. I finally sat down when I had time and watched the first 5 episodes at once, it steamrolled from there, and 13 hours later I realized I had just spent a whole day watching an anime series. As it turns out, it was worth every moment of that 13 hours.

      This is assuming of course that you haven't seen it. I don't know that I would compare it to Last Exile or GITS: SAC, but it definitely holds it's own.

      .hack//SIGN is a great series, but what really got me wasn't so much the art, it wasn't the story, it was the damn soundtrack. The story is wonderful, the artwork is wonderful, but that damn soundtrack is what really put it over the top for me.

    3. Re:LAST EXILE by Minna+Kirai · · Score: 1

      Excellent, surprising, tight plot up to the very last minute

      No. It really starts to fall apart earlier than that. The last 4-5 episodes are hardly worth watching- until the "Exile" is revealed, it's fine, but they couldn't come up with a convincingly impressive "great secret" to warrant the anticipation.

      Consider some Hollywood films that focused on revealing a major alien secret, like "Close Encounters of the 3rd Kind", "2001", or "Contact". They all had the good sense to know that they can't convincingly portray the big secret on screen, so once the hero finds it, roll credits.

      Oh, and for the ending battle, when the two-seater vanships were attacking the guild's giant airships, exactly where were their dozens of incomprably superior "star-shaped" fighters?

      It's not that the ending was "bad", but they couldn't come up with something worthy of the rest of the series' high quality. Escaflowne's ending was much better (although the worst part of that episode was the incompetent translation into English). But, it's not quite fair to compare Escaflowne with those other anime. It was mid 90s, while the rest are mid-00s. Hold it up against Evangelion for a comparison of the same vintage... although with Evangelion's notoriously bad ending, it's not even a contest.

      to redesign the closing credits to fit it all

      That's standard-operating procedure. You blend the closing music over the epilogue montage... Escaflowne did it, Cowboy Bebop did it... it's completely normal for anime, or even some USA shows.

    4. Re:LAST EXILE by Minna+Kirai · · Score: 1

      and 13 hours later I realized I had just spent a whole day watching an anime series

      If you fast-forward through the opening music and "coming up next week", it would only take you 9.5 hours...

    5. Re:LAST EXILE by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Consider some Hollywood films that focused on revealing a major alien secret, like "Close Encounters of the 3rd Kind", "2001", or "Contact". They all had the good sense to know that they can't convincingly portray the big secret on screen, so once the hero finds it, roll credits.

      Aside from the fact that 2001 and Contact aren't even about big alien secrets, we get a big colorful spaceship in Close Encounters and that long-ass slitscreen stargate sequence in 2001. It seems Spielberg and Kubrick most certainly did try to portray the big secrets on screen.

    6. Re:LAST EXILE by Minna+Kirai · · Score: 1

      AC: Aside from the fact that 2001 and Contact aren't even about big alien secrets

      Yes they are. The aliens themselves are the "secret". The whole point of the movies was sharing the hero-explorer's wonderous curiosity at meeting the aliens.

      we get a big colorful spaceship in Close Encounters and that long-ass slitscreen stargate sequence in 2001.

      Yeah, colorful spaceships. Never the creatures inside them. That's because the directors knew that nothing they could put on screen would live up to the anticipation.

  93. Re:What's the fun... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Ah yes, the words of someone who has not actually sat down to watch a good amount of it. Actually watch the movies. Get something directed by Miyazaki. Castle in the Sky. Princess Mononoke. Grave of the Fireflies. Nausicaa. You will understand.

    Let me qualify that. Watch them with subtitles, not the English dubbing. I watched Castle in the Sky both ways. With the dubbing, the characters were constantly making stupid comments where nothing was said in the original version. It came off very poorly.

  94. Re:What's the fun... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I think it's unfair to lump together every single hand-drawn movie into one category. What if someone told you that they hated live-action films? Wouldn't you argue that some of them are worth watching?

    So tell us specific anime titles which you couldn't stand, and some which you didn't mind watching. Then maybe we can better understand your point of view.

  95. Re:What's the fun... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Watch Cowboy Bebop. A stupid title but marvelously done Anime. No sailor suited kids, none of the stupid comic-style mouths nor high pitched screams. It's cool.

    I agree with you on 95%+ of Anime. It's crap. There is this wierd japanese hangup with sailor suits, high pitched non-sensical screaming, and calling out martial arts moves for no apparent reason. Unfortunately, some Americans have clung to this insanity, from Sailor Moon to Dragonball Z, avoid it like the plague. There's also the legacy of comic books that occasionally show up, with the bloated faces, enormous screaming mouths, and whatnot. I've never read comic books, but from what I understand, these are common there, as you have to show someone screaming loudly in a still imagine, so that's how they get the point across. Anime has audio, so it's unnecessary and childish to draw such things.

    Another class of Anime is the artsy ones. These are the "Princess Monononoke" and whatnot that the poster mentioned above. I saw them, and honestly, I wasn't all that impressed. Sure, it was drawn well and the story wasn't terrible, but it just didn't do anything for me.

    Personally, I'm fascinated by author's fantastic worlds. I like to see how people imagine a world that works differently than our own. Anime allows these sorts of things to come out far easier than live action. You need a blockbuster budget to pull it off right, and that's hard to come by. Anime can do it on the cheap, allowing for some very interesting worlds.

    Anime also tends to be done in a one-season long series. In the US, every television series fondest wish is to come back the next season. With most anime series, they order one season and from the beginning, they know that's all their will be. This allows for longer stories than you can do in a single movie, but still have a beginng, middle, and end. It's like the show "24" here in the states.

    It can be tough to find, but the best anime resides in the cracks between the kids stuff (Sailor Moon, Dragonball Z), the nonsensical stuff with the rabid fans (Evangelion, FLCL) and the artsy (Princess Mononoke, Spirited Away).

    Cowboy Bebop, despite it's title, is the best I've ever seen. Another great one with a horrid title is "Vampire Hunter D: Bloodlust". Why the japanese can't be persuaded to have decent titles is beyond me. I also liked "Last Exile", "12 Kingdoms", "Inu-Yasha", and "Escaflowne".

    Try watching Bebop or Bloodlust on your own, without the rabid anime-fan roomates. You might just enjoy them...

  96. Re:Anime is for maladjusted fat balding 40 year ol by xchino · · Score: 1

    And the only difference between them and you is that they like anime.

    --
    Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. It's just that yours is stupid.
  97. speaking of which by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    the wriring sucks

    you anime fans and your crazy slang.

  98. Re: Appleseed Movie by n8_f · · Score: 1

    NOOOOOO!!!

    I just saw the translated trailer and I am filled with dread. It looks like they have completely mashed it up. Former lover? Hover cars? The secret of Appleseed? WTF? I still can't wait to see it for the eye candy, but I have some serious misgivings about the story. Damn, I hope there is an Appleseed series!

  99. Meme warning! Meme war... oh, false alert. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I, for one, embrace the popularization of anime.

    (my emphasis)

    You can't say "I, for one" here without invoking everyone's "cliched meme" antennae.

    Here's a clue; the meme wasn't the Natalie Portman hot grits one (haven't seen that for a while), or even "Soviet Russia".

    At any rate, I, for one, welcome our new anime overlords.

    What? Was it something I said?

  100. A three way tie for me... by VendettaMF · · Score: 1

    Akira was the first anime I ever saw, followed the same night by a _lot_ of dominion tank police...

    Now I have 70+ DVD's, 40+ tapes and more vcd's and files of unlicensed fansubs than I care to keep track of.

    However, my favourite movies are all items generally considered 2nd rate.

    Patlabor 1 (Patlabor OVA)
    Beautiful Dreamer (Urusei Yatsura OVA)
    Castle of Cagliostro (Lupin)

    These three movies I can watch almost endlessly.

    Project A-ko (the first movie) at number 4 is my guilty little secret.

    I'm also a severe Rumiko Takahashi addict, which does tend to lessen my standing in the "serious" anime/manga circles, but *shrugs* I just love 'em all.

    --
    kartune85 : Incapable of reason, observation or learning. A kind of dim, drab, flightless parrot.
  101. Re:What's the fun... by mikji · · Score: 1

    The CG in Spiderman 2 was utter crap. When Doc Ock climbed the side of that building, I thought I was watching a clip from the upcoming video game. It was shittier than The Hulk even, and that's really saying something.

  102. Adolecense Mokushiroku by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Mine is Adolecense Mokushiroku aka Adolecense of Utena. Definitively something you have to be mentally prepared for.

    1. Re:Adolecense Mokushiroku by jandrese · · Score: 1

      How do you prepare for that movie? I would suspect it would involve a lot of LSD...

      --

      I read the internet for the articles.
  103. Slashcode broken ??? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Why am I seeing this Anime story ? I have it excluded in my preferences (which I just double-checked) ...

  104. Who is that blue-haired character? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is off-topic, but who is that blue-haired character that Slashdot uses as a symbol for anime?

    Thanks.

    1. Re:Who is that blue-haired character? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It looks like the younger girl from Tenchi Muyo. But its probably a generic drawing.

    2. Re:Who is that blue-haired character? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Thanks.

  105. Re:OT by RsG · · Score: 1

    Actually it's a quote, although I don't know where it's from. Besides kinky and perverted doesn't sound as funny.

    --
    Erotic is when you use a feather. Exotic is when you use the whole chicken.
  106. Re:What's the fun... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    well if you don't like it then you don't like it.
    i myself like anime because it provides me a different sort of art than the usual hollywood drivel. plus, the fact that it is animated allows the filmmakers to get their message across better w/o relying on whatever talents the film can afford due to lack of funding or whatever.
    you probably don't like the sort of surrealism that is a part of all anime series/movies. where characters go out of characters sometimes and act a little silly, often turning into poorly drawn, 2-d people that scream and flail and whatnot. i think doing this makes the characters seem more human. no one is ever serious 100% of the time. there are times when I want to flip out and act a bit silly etc and i want to turn into a poorly drawn, 2-d, arm-flailing psycho.

  107. Howl's Moving Castle by Murphy's+Paradox · · Score: 1

    I'm a big Miyazaki fan, but I have to point out that this movie won't be entirely his; I assume it will be based on the book, of the same name by Diana Wynne Jones. Granted, I'm sure the movie will be as good as (probably better) than the book, but...

    --
    Murphy's Paradox... the more you plan for success, the more avenues there are for failure.
  108. Re:Anime is for maladjusted fat balding 40 year ol by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Mmmmkay dude - I'm 40 and like anime. Let's see --- wife, check. Kids, check. Good job, check. Pretty much happy with my life, (well there's always room for improvement but) check. Personally I haven't lived in anyone's basement for over twenty years.

  109. Pokemon dangerous by Sun+Rider · · Score: 1

    Everytime you watch Pokemon 10,000 of your brain cells die. Eventually you forget how to breath and you die among convulsions while everybody thinks you're having an epileptic fit caused by the flashing screen.

  110. His antipathy level is over one million!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Dragonball Z is to Anime as Poison Sandwiches are to Food.

    Depends on how you watch it -- as a comedy or as a serious action show. Indeed, the Japanese version seems to have a lighter tone than the Americanized version, which tries to take itself too seriously. In any case, I think your analogy is overblown: I can think of plenty of worse shows than Dragonball Z, whereas there's not much worse to eat than poison sandwiches (mmm, sammiches).

  111. Also, Kumo no mukou, yakusoku no Basho? by initialE · · Score: 1

    Beyond the Clouds, The Promised Place. Info Here It's like waiting for Duke Nukem Forever... But it's going to rock.

    --
    Starbucks, Harbuckle of Breath.
  112. Anime is offensive by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It's drawn by Orientals who exaggerate the characters' BIG ROUND eyes.

    If somebody drew characters with exaggerated SLANTED eyes, the Japanese would hit the ceiling in protest.

    In short, I find it very offensive.

    1. Re:Anime is offensive by franksp · · Score: 1

      This is a style to better paint the characters expressions, like happiness, sadness, surprise, etc. If you watched one whole anime, you will see that no all characters have the "BIG ROUND eyes" and sometimes the same character shows up with these eyes only in some ocasions

  113. The truth, it burns like fire and ice! by Rogerborg · · Score: 1

    [n/t]

    --
    If you were blocking sigs, you wouldn't have to read this.
  114. Re:And you sound like by goatan · · Score: 1

    No simpsons for you Then

    --
    Saying Apple is better than MS is like saying Botulism is better than rabies.