Slashdot Mirror


HP Thailand Sells $450 Linux Laptop

greyrax writes "The revolution has begun! Seems that the Thailand branch of HP is selling Linux-based laptops for $450. The government of Thailand is now talking to Dell Thailand about a similar arrangement."

307 comments

  1. Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    When did HP buy Thailand? What's next? MS Canada?

    1. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Funny

      Thailand, like most of the people in it, can be rented by the hour, and at very reasonable rates.

    2. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by steve_l · · Score: 4, Insightful

      we already have Shell owning Nigeria, and some Peru/Ecuador war in the sixties or seventies was effectively a proxy war for competing oil companies, each with a different government contract. And of course the US is subject to the current Oil and Gas Administration.

      I dont see the computing industry playing such strategic games, though I think Disney may already own Southern California.

    3. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by fubar1971 · · Score: 1

      How much for a 1 year lease ?

    4. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by tetro · · Score: 3, Informative

      Let's see, racist = funny and anti-Linux = troll.

      --
      .smell my feet.
    5. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by SharpFang · · Score: 0, Troll

      What's next? MS Canada?
      Nope. Exon Iraq.

      --
      45 5F E1 04 22 CA 29 C4 93 3F 95 05 2B 79 2A B2
    6. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by rastachops · · Score: 0, Troll

      Mod the parent up. The truth is hardly flipping trolling!! Just because it makes the USA not sound quite so brilliant it doesn't constitute trolling!

    7. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by stoops · · Score: 1

      why's that racist? thailand does have inexpensive workers when compared to western countries. is it racist to point that out in a humorous way?

    8. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      wait, HP notebook?? don't they mean HPCompaq notebook?

    9. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      HPCompaqDEC notebook

    10. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by JJahn · · Score: 1

      No they don't mean HPCompaq notebook. The company's name is just HP.

    11. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Theatetus · · Score: 1
      don't they mean HPCompaq notebook?

      Actually I think you mean GNU/HP/Compaq. HP is just a kernel, you see.

      --
      All's true that is mistrusted
    12. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Nice one. Except it's Halliburton Iraq!

    13. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

      What's next? MS Canada?

      Nah, you're only allowed to have one country.

    14. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What's funny is that the type of anti-competitive stuff for which MS was found guilty is not _really_ illegal in Canada. There was a rumour that the Vancouver City Planners were tempting M$ with a nice, new tech pavillion in near-dntn Vancouver. With the 'friendlier' climate towards M$'s favourite tactics, I was pretty surprised they didn't bite.

      Of course, I only know this because my friend is the one who put together the glossy brochures...

    15. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah and Linux geeks ARE ugly and retarded. So what's wrong about pointing THAT out in a humorous way?

    16. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      erll first off when he says can be rented by the hour he means sex workers, and second if you wouldnt feel comfortable telling the joke to some thai chick you just met in a bar yes, it probably is racist.

    17. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      unless she can be rented by the hour...

    18. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      ya but some of us hurt and cry a lot more than others.

    19. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Cplus · · Score: 1

      It's not trolling, it's treason!

      lol

      --
      "Share your knowledge. It's a way to achieve immortality." -- Dalai Lama
    20. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by 1u3hr · · Score: 1

      When you say "rented by the hour" the implication is you're talking about prostitutes.

    21. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      What's next? MS Canada?

      propably... MS US is old news :>

    22. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why is that racist?

    23. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I wasn't aware that Thai was a race. I always thought it was a nationality.

    24. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      i cant believe this got modded funny

    25. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      $10?

    26. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Whyever not? It's frickin' hilarious.

    27. Re:Woah, HP Thailand? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The Vancouver Province and Sun both ran front page stories about this, at the time.

  2. Article seems a little short on details. by Chris_Stankowitz · · Score: 4, Interesting

    What kind of laptops? How many of these were they selling (as many as people would buy or a fixed number)? Can Anyone buy one? Can I buy one over the internet? Would I want to buy one? The list goes on. Anyone have any links to know the answers to any of these questions?

    1. Re:Article seems a little short on details. by l810c · · Score: 3, Informative

      Some more info Here

    2. Re:Article seems a little short on details. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      See the Bangkok Post for details.

    3. Re:Article seems a little short on details. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      - VIA 800 MHz
      - 56K modem *OR* 10/100 Ethernet card
      - *NO* floppy drive
      - *NO* CD-ROM drive
      - around 10" or 11" LCD screen (not quite sure)

      It is really "commodity product", cheap enough to get to the mass.

  3. Hmmmm. by The+Bungi · · Score: 4, Interesting

    $450? I somehow doubt this is a particularly excellent piece of hardware. I mean, even accounting for the "M$ tax" as it were (which is negligible when applied in bulk OEM licenses anyway) and considering that it's difficult to find a decent laptop for under $800... well, I think this is kinda fishy.

    1. Re:Hmmmm. by Mr.+McGibby · · Score: 0

      RTFA.

      They're linux laptops. There is no MS tax.

      --
      Mad Software: Rantings on Developing So
    2. Re:Hmmmm. by The+Tyro · · Score: 1

      Yep... totally agree, except the M$ tax should not apply to a linux loaded laptop (I think you misspoke on that point). Besides, doesn't the latest Zaurus go for roughly that price?

      Hmmm... full laptop versus a palmtop with a teensy weensy keyboard (yeah, yeah... I know they're for different applications... just making an inappropriate comparison).

      --
      Even if a man chops off your hand with a sword, you still have two nice, sharp bones to stick in his eyes.
    3. Re:Hmmmm. by Soulfarmer · · Score: 1

      You think it is kinda fishy? Don't you think a laptop with MS operating system is not kinda fishy, but certified fishy. So for a laptop which does not give ANY money to MS, I really couldn't care less about the hardware :D

      I would call $450 laptop without MS fishy only if it was in the sharkpool

      --
      -Is the meaning of life vanity, or is vanity the meaning of life?
    4. Re:Hmmmm. by Archfeld · · Score: 2, Informative

      looking at the Thai equivalent of $450.00, in a country that sponsors manufacturing in a heavy way. It is not outside the realm of possibility. The machine that you and I can get assuming M$ Government ever allows them in the western world will include many surcharges and a profit margin at about 1000%, which accounts for the $800 price tag you are reasonably quoting.

      --
      errr....umm...*whooosh* *whoosh* Is this thing on ?
    5. Re:Hmmmm. by The+Bungi · · Score: 1
      RTFA

      Indeed. How about you RTFP? I said that even accounting for the lack of "tax" it seems too low a price for a laptop.

    6. Re:Hmmmm. by steve_l · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Big hardware costs in a laptop are display, HDD and CD (say $25) /floppy ($5), plus CPU and memory.

      a pure linux laptop can get away with a lower power CPU, less HDD and by the CNET report, the CD. That leaves display.

      The nice thing is that not only can they get rid of the MS tax, but they can include a full suite of tools: gimp, OpenOffice.org, evolution, and at a price point that you cannot do legally with a windows box (of course, you can get all the windows stuff illegally at discount rates in Asia: Redhat CDs sell for the same as Windows Server CDs, $5 or so).

      The interesting thing is the network effect: if lots of people start to use linux distros, then it makes sense for even people with $$ to use it, offices to use it, etc, as it is what everyone will understand. And if one developing country follows the Open Source path, it can set an example to others.

      Something to watch, perhaps.

    7. Re:Hmmmm. by cK-Gunslinger · · Score: 1

      RTFC.

      I'm pretty sure he was saying that "the lack of the MS tax" still doesn't account for the very low price.

    8. Re:Hmmmm. by Anders · · Score: 1

      [...] the M$ tax should not apply to a linux loaded laptop (I think you misspoke on that point)

      Uhm, The Bungi said that $800 minus a negligible amount would not be $450, and I think that I agree.

    9. Re:Hmmmm. by The+Bungi · · Score: 2, Informative
      in a country that sponsors manufacturing in a heavy way

      Well, that would be another matter. The article says:

      The notebooks are being sold as part of a push by Thailand's Information, Communications, and Technology (ICT) ministry to offer the public affordable PCs.

      ... which means the hardware is subsidized, I guess. It's not very clear.

      M$ Government ever allows them

      Spare me the party line, bud. I was wondering what kind of quality hardware in a laptop package one can expect for under $500, that's all.

    10. Re:Hmmmm. by caluml · · Score: 1
      I was wondering what kind of quality hardware in a laptop package one can expect for under $500,

      Hehe, do what Google do. If you buy enough of them, you'll be fine :)

    11. Re:Hmmmm. by Black+Copter+Control · · Score: 2, Insightful
      Uhm, The Bungi said that $800 minus a negligible amount would not be $450, and I think that I agree.

      Thailand has promised to take over the support and servicing costs for the units. That's worth a good bit. You can also take off marketing costs, because those machines are gonna pretty much sell themselves. Economics of scale will also kick in a bit, because it sounds like they're gonna be selling as many as they can possibly make in the next few years.

      --
      OS Software is like love: The best way to make it grow is to give it away.
    12. Re:Hmmmm. by Archfeld · · Score: 1

      well a little research bud and now ya know, party line or not :)

      TGIF and have a good weekend and holiday all Cheers

      --
      errr....umm...*whooosh* *whoosh* Is this thing on ?
    13. Re:Hmmmm. by osguru · · Score: 3, Informative

      You have to realize that in Thailand $450 is 18,550 Baht - which by Thai standards is about 2 months rent for a pretty small apartment in the city.

      You could get all the bells and Whistles with a laptop such as DVD, Wifi, etc... but chances are you will never use any of it if you are a Thai native (no AP's anywhere, they watch VCD's, etc...)

      Which is why Internet Cafe's are all the rage in Thailand - cost is 1 Bhat per minute (0.02 cents USD).

      Thailand is still a developing country, espically in the technology field. A good portion of the country (despite how beautiful it is) is still 3rd world like.

    14. Re:Hmmmm. by bloodpet · · Score: 1

      The price is low because, (aside from using Linux) it's just a "bare" laptop (no cd drive), and because the hardware and services are taken care of by their gov't.

      --
      Truth is like a shining mirror that's been shattered.
    15. Re:Hmmmm. by shaitand · · Score: 1

      Well we start with your $800 price tag, now we chop off $140 for oem XP Pro, tht takes us to $660, now we take another $105 off because it's a bulk sale (now $555), and probably slack import taxes and some of the hardware is probably being manufacturered there thus having no import/export tax at all. Chop another $105 because there are no support costs (now $450).

      I dunno about you, but those numbers don't sound too fishy to me, actually if anything it sounds kinda high.

    16. Re:Hmmmm. by The+Bungi · · Score: 1
      $140 for oem XP Pro

      Would you like to show us where you got that price from, and whether or not Dell and HP pay that kind of money per XP license?

      Thanks.

    17. Re:Hmmmm. by rootofevil · · Score: 1

      including the entirety of openoffice.org? doesnt that seem a mite excessive? the program itself would suffice, methinks.

      --
      turn up the jukebox and tell me a lie
    18. Re:Hmmmm. by shaitand · · Score: 1

      Ingram Micro. Wholesaler, you need an account with them to look.

    19. Re:Hmmmm. by shaitand · · Score: 1

      98SE is still $95 for an OEM version.

    20. Re:Hmmmm. by Realistic_Dragon · · Score: 1

      It's called OO.o, according to the FAQ, because:

      The trademark for "OpenOffice" belongs to someone else. Therefore we must use "OpenOffice.org" when referring to this open source project and its software.

      --
      Beep beep.
    21. Re:Hmmmm. by colonelteddy · · Score: 1

      including the entirety of openoffice.org? doesnt that seem a mite excessive? the program itself would suffice, methinks.

      Not quite sure what you mean there, but openoffice.org = The suite of office programs, not the entity or community.

      --
      c - a blessed +5 grain of salt
    22. Re:Hmmmm. by Farang · · Score: 3, Informative

      "Fishy" is right. This story is a lot less about computers than it is about Thai politics, which is why so many posts are expressing puzzlement, confusion, and comments that are off target.

      The current prime minister of Thailand, Thaksin Shinawatra (pronounced more or less Toxin Sheen-ah-waht, and yes, we got the joke a long time ago) is a populist who got his start in politics by somehow talking someone in the military junta that was running the country at the time into giving him a monopoly on mobile phones. Thais all gotta have the dratted things, it shows status and confers prestige. The result: millions and zillions for Thaksin, and outrageously high phone rates here, even now, years later. He's the richest man in the nation, and the stories about how he works his taxes would curl your hair.

      Well, according to his critics, he's basically buying the whole country, and the Thais love him for it (yes, we got that joke, too). Relatives of his go to high posts in the police and military, though unqualified; the English-language papers here are howling that some news media are lapdogs (very true of the radio, slightly less so of the TV, not so true of the newspapers, but they are running scared, as I see it), and the voters have been seduced by a plan that provides medical care for 30 Thai baht (less than a US buck) per visit. Never mind that the care is slapdash and provided by exhausted, harried doctors. Thaksin is, in short, to Thailand what Juan Peron was to Argentina. So far the economy is holding up under the strain, but it can't last.

      Nor can the population: over 2,000 people were just shot to death in a wild anti-drugs campaign, and nobody knows how many were simply executed by the cops, and how many were hit by rival drug gangs -- no one is investigating, either, because they know where their best interests lie. The corruption that is a fact of every part of Thai life is becoming even more blatant. The latest little gift for the Thai nation: a tax on telecoms that benefits -- oh, you guessed! And the tax was imposed unconstitutionally, but the courts have been corrupted, too.

      The "cheap computers" thing has little to do with HP or Linux. It's a Thai deal, just another aspect of the Southeast Asian version of bread and circuses. In fact, I question whether this item even belongs on /. --So I go on and on offtopic -- sorry, but my point was that this giveaway is the government buying the computers and selling them at a loss, using tax revenues to buy votes while incidentally undercutting and damaging legitimate businesses. Huey Long would be impressed.

      BTW, "farang" (my user name) is the Thai word for "Westerner." It comes from the Thai pronunciation of the French word for "French."

    23. Re:Hmmmm. by Spellbinder · · Score: 1

      what couts is what you pay to them for the XP Pro

      --


      stop supporting microsoft with pirating their software!!!!!
    24. Re:Hmmmm. by Spellbinder · · Score: 1

      sorry!!
      what counts.... =)))

      --


      stop supporting microsoft with pirating their software!!!!!
    25. Re:Hmmmm. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      actually the price set in Thai is
      19,900 or 19,500 THB :)

      ----

      Internet Cafe?

      1 THB/min is a normal rate at Khao-Sarn Road.

      At Silom it would be around 3-5 THB/min.

      But if you go to Internet Cafe near any university or school.
      The price can be as cheap as 40 THB/hr
      or even down to 10 THB/hr !!! ;)

      At Sau-Ching-Cha, Wat Su-Tat
      (Giant Swing, Su-Tat Temple)
      you can use ADSL internet for 20 THB/hr.
      it's near Democracy Monument, quite near to Khao-Sarn Road :)

      normally, at street price
      20 THB = 1 meal (noodle or rice with curry)

      I love Thailand!!

    26. Re:Hmmmm. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Talking about OpenOffice.org for Thais
      you may interest on this Thai Native-Language Project at OOo

      http://th.openoffice.org

      Quite weird, there're two localized version of OO.o in Thailand!!!

      One is Office TLE which is bundled with Linux TLE (same manufacturer),
      another is Pladao Office which is supported by Sun Thailand & Thailand's Ministry of ICT (this is really more weird, why ICT didn't bundle it to its own laptop??).

      Pladao Office UI is all translated to Thai (Office TLE doesn't), but user can switch to use English UI. It also support Thai calendar system, native number... etc.
      (according to post in OOo mailing list)

      LinuxTLE & OfficeTLE : http://www.opentle.org
      Pladao Office : http://www.pladao.org

      this country has many strange things (but, yes, there's good to have them)

      a revolution? ... may be just evolution.

  4. Asia is the current battleground by caluml · · Score: 4, Insightful

    All the posturing and buying senators that Microsoft can do in the US, and Europe will have no effect when China, and India come online in a big way. Especially for governments suspicious of Windows, and the possibility of backdoors.

    1. Re:Asia is the current battleground by arcite · · Score: 1

      Also...I doubt that China or India for that matter would take too kindly to the idea of .Net proliferating.

    2. Re:Asia is the current battleground by caluml · · Score: 1

      The only thing that might save MS is piracy. And lots of it. Hook em. The first one's free. And only when everyone is hooked, start locking it down. I hope those countries see past the free offers, and deals though.

    3. Re:Asia is the current battleground by Dark+Paladin · · Score: 1

      I'm not sure that even "locking it down" will help in the long run.

      Remember the bit about Turbo Tax and how "locking down" their application caused people to simply move on.

      If I have a choice between spending $150 - $200 for an operating system, or working with Linux, you can bet my wallet I'll probably go with Linux (especially if I've got 100+ computers in my place of business, and economic times are tough).

      So it might help the situation a bit for those who "need" windows - until the first time they find a program that doesn't "require" windows, like moving to OpenOffice, etc.

    4. Re:Asia is the current battleground by caluml · · Score: 1

      How about this? MS gives away a cut-down version for home users, and makes its money on support, corporates (who they can still charge licences for) and big commercial stuff (assuming Linux doesn't eat away the datacentre)?

    5. Re:Asia is the current battleground by arcite · · Score: 1

      I have a better idea, release a stripped down version of windows, give it away for free.... only catch is that the bottom fourth of the screen is a permanent space for pop-up ads :D

    6. Re:Asia is the current battleground by vlad_petric · · Score: 1, Troll

      I agree with you that Asia is the current battleground, however bribing is sooo much easier done in poor countries like India or China. The only difference is that the bribing in the US is done in open view (see Republican election funding).

      --

      The Raven

    7. Re:Asia is the current battleground by GrimReality · · Score: 1
      ...will have no effect when China, and India come online in a big way.

      A very logical conclusion and China does seem to show hope in this regard.

      However, in the case of India, there was an older Slashdot story (I can't point it now) that indicated that the Indian government has been bought over by Microsoft.

      Three year ago, in India, I found that nearly everyone in the computer (user) field were talking about 'Windows', 'MS Word', 'Hotmail' and stuff like that as if they meant 'Operating System', 'Word processor', 'E-mail' etc. Hopefully, things have changed.

      Thank you.
      GrimReality
      2003-05-23 22:25:31 UTC (2003-05-23 18:25:31 EDT)

    8. Re:Asia is the current battleground by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You rode the short bus to school, didn't you?

    9. Re:Asia is the current battleground by b17bmbr · · Score: 0

      The only difference is that the bribing in the US is done in open view (see Republican election funding).

      this is true of both parties. but if you lok at FEC filings, the majority of BIG donors give to democrats. the vast majority of small donors, i.e. sub $2000, are republican.

      --
      My problem? I was perfectly gruntled, until some numbnuts came by and dissed me.
    10. Re:Asia is the current battleground by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Are you Czech ?
      Your lack of intellect certainly points that way ..

    11. Re:Asia is the current battleground by GnarlyNome · · Score: 1

      And Democrat

      --
      Diplomacy is the art of saying "Nice doggie" until you can find a rock. Will Rogers
    12. Re:Asia is the current battleground by Malcontent · · Score: 1

      You are not counting "soft money" and the money raised by "think tanks".

      Also there are organizations like the US chamber of commerce, Fox news (all murdoch media actually) which not only provide funding but give free air time to republicans and the republican point of view.

      --

      War is necrophilia.

    13. Re:Asia is the current battleground by white-mj · · Score: 1

      So, lemme get this straight. US and European
      politicians are corrupt, but those in China and
      India aren't? Hmmm. :-)

      Any power hungry politician will come to realize
      that an insecure OS with back doors is exactly
      what he wants his constituents using. Makes
      snooping easier.

    14. Re:Asia is the current battleground by b17bmbr · · Score: 1

      and CNN, CBS, ABC are neutral? fox does give air time to republicans. but it gives equal time to democrats. that is the big shock. for so long, the news was all one sided. now it isn't. and, btw, soft money is fairly equal. it is clear that both partieas are purely whores. no doubt. just that it isn't fair to say it's only one sided.

      --
      My problem? I was perfectly gruntled, until some numbnuts came by and dissed me.
    15. Re:Asia is the current battleground by Malcontent · · Score: 1

      " and CNN, CBS, ABC are neutral?"

      They are more neutral then fox news.

      " fox does give air time to republicans. but it gives equal time to democrats."

      THis is a flat out lie. Fox TV is OVERWHELMINGLY republican. They give the democrats something like 10% of their time.

      When they do have deomocrats they rip into them like dogs and contantly interrupt them and when they have republicans on they ask them questions like "isn't janet reno evil?" and lob softballs at them all night.

      --

      War is necrophilia.

    16. Re:Asia is the current battleground by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Or, more likely, suspicious of lawsuits from EULAs. The ones not afraid of lawsuits will use pirated stuff anyway.

    17. Re:Asia is the current battleground by Bluesman · · Score: 1

      Of course they're not corrupt. They have that Zen stuff and martial arts over there.

      Didn't you know "The West" are the bad ones.

      --
      If moderation could change anything, it would be illegal.
  5. Anyone in Thailand want to make a quick buck? by missing000 · · Score: 1

    Resell these for ~$500 or so and I know a lot of people would eat this up on this side of the pond.

    1. Re:Anyone in Thailand want to make a quick buck? by the_consumer · · Score: 2, Funny

      Wow, $50 profit per laptop! Lesse, I could probably stuff a couple dozen into my luggage (have to pad the luggage well, of course, as luggage handlers are not typically gentle). So 24*$50=$1200! That's almost enough for airfare one way! Here I come, Thailand...

      --
      "If you're thinking what I'm thinking, you're right." -
    2. Re:Anyone in Thailand want to make a quick buck? by MikeFM · · Score: 1

      I'd be tempted. I bet you could sell them for more like $650 in the US if the hardware isn't to shabby. Especially if while your there you make them dual boot between Linux and pirate copies of XP. I have a couple cousins just entering college and their parents would love to see a $650 laptop. About $800 is the best deal I've found for new non-shitty laptops locally.

      --
      At what price learning? At what cost wisdom? The price is a man's peace of mind, and the cost is his life.
    3. Re:Anyone in Thailand want to make a quick buck? by wo1verin3 · · Score: 1

      yes because you won't lose any of that profit on shipping these machines, and customs! (unless they're built in the US?)

    4. Re:Anyone in Thailand want to make a quick buck? by MikeFM · · Score: 1

      If it was in your baggage at the airport you'd probably not have to pay a tarriff. I never tried moving that many machines from one country to another in such a manner but I've seen auto parts and other weird things moved around that way without any extra fees being attached. It might depend on luck and the individual countries your moving between though. I have had friends that traveled by air and had more than one laptop though .(why? I dunno why one person needs three laptops and a pda in their carry-on)

      --
      At what price learning? At what cost wisdom? The price is a man's peace of mind, and the cost is his life.
    5. Re:Anyone in Thailand want to make a quick buck? by wo1verin3 · · Score: 1

      So instead of shipping, you need to fly back and forth from Thailand once per laptop? :)

    6. Re:Anyone in Thailand want to make a quick buck? by Spunk · · Score: 1

      have to pad the luggage well

      Pad Thai?

  6. Holy COW! by freeze128 · · Score: 1

    Just imagine the shipping costs if you have to send it back for service!

    1. Re:Holy COW! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Problem is, HP doesn't service or support the machines in any way. According to the article, "the ministry has agreed to take on service and support issues related to the PCs."

      Forget shipping, you're on your own if you breaks.

    2. Re:Holy COW! by stuartkahler · · Score: 1

      Considering that the only moving parts are the hard drive, hinge for the display and maybe a cpu fan (no CDrom or floppy), I wouldn't expect to have it serviced often.

      Did I miss any mention of a NIC being integrated? One of these with 802.11b built in would be awesome. I'd jump on an english language version of this in a second if it came ready to plug into my LAN and download apps from the net.

  7. Keyboard? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    Is it an english keyboard? Can I buy one without having to learn Thai??

    1. Re:Keyboard? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It will still have an English keyboard. Keyboards in China and Japan are still English - type characters via Romanized pinyin, etc.

    2. Re:Keyboard? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Thai has a 56 or something letter alphabet. Thai people often type with roman letters. To write in Thai you just need one modifier key. So the keyboards will be like they are here except with a small Thai character in the corner of each key.

  8. With support? by cruppel · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Hmm now that's what caught my eye. I believe they said

    ...the ministry has agreed to take on service and support issues related to the PCs.

    This could get interesting... I know Wal-Mart sells headless Linux boxes for $200 but the only people that buy them are guys who already run Linux. The support could persuade a LOT more people into using Linux.

    1. Re:With support? by tekunokurato · · Score: 1

      Actually, your statement about Walmart's sale of the linux machines is entirely faulty. They've sold quite well to lower income customers who can't afford to pay the microsoft tax. You don't really think Walmart would be carrying something with such low margins that only caters to such a tiny portion of the market, do you?

      If you question this, check out some of their press releases about the boxes.

    2. Re:With support? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually, I bought my $200 headless Linux box from TigerDirect, and it was my first experience running Linux.
      I had a little trouble at first, but after I yanked Lindows and installed a real Linux distro, all I had to do was google any questions I had, and I've been able to configure a nice little household server out of it.
      Now I plan to run Linux on my next desktop system.

  9. IBM should jump on this... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Wouldn't it be cool to own a ThinkPad Thai?

    1. Re:IBM should jump on this... by OECD · · Score: 4, Funny

      Yeah, they could call it the Thaibook!

      Sorry...

      --
      One man's -1 Flamebait is another man's +5 Funny.
    2. Re:IBM should jump on this... by dunng808 · · Score: 1
      Yeah, they could call it the Thaibook!

      I think Thaipad would be a good choice. It might just fool a bunch of Germans into thinking it is a brothel operated by Japanese who cater to bondage enthusiasts, and before the story gets straightened out the Thai government is a few million Euros richer. In fact, this would likely continue until the US decided to invade Thailand to stop the sale of tools of mass computing. While there, the Americans will insist on a new name for the capital city, one which can be spoken aloud in the presence of teens.

      Boy, am I ready for a long weekend!

      --

      Gary Dunn
      Open Slate Project

    3. Re:IBM should jump on this... by the+uNF+cola · · Score: 1

      Dude. ThaiMaster. You missed the easy one.

      --

      --
      "I'm not bright. Big words confuse me. But Wanda loves me and that should be enough for you." - Cosmo

    4. Re:IBM should jump on this... by jjsoh · · Score: 1

      "Yeah, they could call it the Thaibook!

      I think Thaipad would be a good choice."


      Don't you mean PadThai?

      I know, I know... don't quit my day job.

  10. Hehe by Ignorant+Aardvark · · Score: 5, Funny

    VIVE LA REVOLUTION!

    Ohhh crap, I'm gonna get flamed ... better put freedom in there somewhere to make it okay ...

    VIVE FREEDOM REVOLUTION!

    1. Re:Hehe by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's "Viva la revolución", fuckwit.

    2. Re:Hehe by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      too bad his was in french, fuckwit.

    3. Re:Hehe by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Those days are gone.

      VIVE SECURITY REVOLUTION!

      Freedom.. pah.. "Those who give away security for a little freedom do not deserve security at all" ;-)

    4. Re:Hehe by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No you still made it in french, which is on the official list of things patriotic americans don't like. And everyone knows that if you're not a patriotic american you must be a terrorist.

    5. Re:Hehe by qwertyatwork · · Score: 1

      Actually its VIVE LA GNU/REVOLUTION!!!

      blah blah blah (lame filter is complaining about caps, so um, blah blah blah)

  11. I was going to say something... by craenor · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Witty or funny here...but you know what, that is just a helluva deal. You don't find that many Linux based portables as it is, and finding one at this price would be great.

    Now how about spreading the love to those of us in U.S.?

  12. awesome by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It was only a matter of time and as a lowly college student I could never afford both a laptop and desktop. So I bought the dektop for ergonomic purposes (I use my computer tons). But now, I can just put in a couple extra hours somewhere or build a couple webpages and get a laptop. I've tried saving, but something in college always comes up. Be it beer, tuition increases, etc. This way I can make the money in a matter of weeks and get one!

  13. the revolution? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    The revolution has begun!

    Shoot. . . I work for the marketing division of the Sirius Cybernetics Corporation. . . should I be concerned?

    1. Re:the revolution? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Share and enjoy!

    2. Re:the revolution? by NeoSkandranon · · Score: 1

      Up against the wall buddy.

      --
      If you can't see the value in jet powered ants you should turn in your nerd card. - Dunbal (464142)
    3. Re:the revolution? by theantipode · · Score: 0

      Yup, and you're first against the wall.

      --
      When I am king, you will be first against the wall
      With your opinion which is of no consequence at all
  14. Specifications by Captain+Pooh · · Score: 5, Informative

    Cnet.com has the specifications on the laptop.

    800MHz Intel Celeron processor

    128MB of RAM

    20GB hard disk

    1. Re:Specifications by jdray · · Score: 3, Interesting

      That's plenty more than the 300 MHz Celeron I'm using for my desktop at home. And I have few complaints about it. And my 300 MHz laptop, running XP of all things, isn't terribly bad, either.

      --
      The Spoon
      Updated 6/28/2011
    2. Re:Specifications by SILIZIUMM · · Score: 1

      Still, can non-thailanders order one ?

    3. Re:Specifications by GMFTatsujin · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Rock out. That is precisely *twice* the specs of the laptop I'm running Gentoo on now. This would be a sweet little upgrade for next to nothing (as far as laptops go).

      I'd be very interested to see what the peripheral options for this box are. For example:

      * Wireless networking capability?
      * PCMCIA slots? Media card slots?
      * Docking station?
      * Battery type and life?

      Another nice spec to have would be the internals. Since they're putting linux on it, I suppose we can all assume that they are using compatable hardware :) I guess the question is, exactly how cheap are the bits inside, and are the drivers open?

      GMFTatsujin

    4. Re:Specifications by Mr.+Sketch · · Score: 4, Informative

      You forgot one more important spec:

      No CD-ROM or floppy drive.

      However, they will be selling a 'high-end' version with CD-ROM for ~$600.

    5. Re:Specifications by arcite · · Score: 3, Funny

      Who needs a floppy or CDrom? All important apps would probably be pre-loaded. File transfers would be done over network/internet. Oh yea, and the floppy died 5 years ago, didn't you hear? :)

    6. Re:Specifications by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      and the floppy died 5 years ago, didn't you hear? :)

      would that be the BSD floppy?

    7. Re:Specifications by kwerle · · Score: 1

      No CD - bummer.
      What they still don't say is the screen size, resolution, battery life, ports, 802.11, etc.

      Makes me wonder.

    8. Re:Specifications by dr.badass · · Score: 1

      Still, can non-thailanders order one ?

      Probably not for $450. As the article says, the Thai government is subsidizing the cost of the machines, as well as handling service and support. If the same model became available in the US, it would probably have a less exciting price tag.

      --
      Don't become a regular here -- you will become retarded.
    9. Re:Specifications by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Who needs a floppy or CDrom?

      It is a hell of a lot easier to buy a Windows Server 2003 CD on the Thai streets, then to download it on your 14.4 modem.

    10. Re:Specifications by jonbrewer · · Score: 1

      No CD-ROM or floppy drive.

      I used an X Series laptop for two years and used the base station (with floppy and CD) about three times. Very early on I got a keychain USB drive and learned to adapt. That combined with MP3s, divx movies and Simpsons episodes kept me pretty damn happy. As long as I have a desktop machine (or a heavyweight laptop) I can do without the floppy and cd.

    11. Re:Specifications by Ian+Bicking · · Score: 1

      Hmm... how do you install a new operating system on a computer without a CD-ROM/floppy? Can you boot off USB/Firewire CD-ROM drive? But I don't know anyone who has one of these, and I wouldn't want to buy such a drive just to install a new OS. Network install works well, but only after you've got the new installation started and networked.

    12. Re:Specifications by evilviper · · Score: 1
      and the floppy died 5 years ago, didn't you hear? :)

      Less than a week ago I had to setup an old system once again, because the latest Slackware CD refused to boot on my 750MHz system...

      Floppies won't be dead until removable media improves. Right now, they are just in hibernation, and if every floppy diasppeared today, it would be a technological disaster.
      --
      Slashdot gets worse every day... Pipedot: News for nerds, without the corporate slant
  15. erm by papasui · · Score: 0

    If there was one thing I wouldn't buy again it would be a HP notebook, especially a $450.00 HP notebook. If I was on a budget I'd buy a $999 ibook and if I wanted linux I would install a PPC port of it.

    1. Re:erm by caluml · · Score: 1
      --
      Karma: Retard (Mostly effected by reading /.) YES I KNOW WHAT EFFECTED MEANS IT'S A JOKE

      Is that spelling of affected part of the joke?

  16. It's about time. by RedCard · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It's about bloody time.

    This is what linux is best for, after all - low cost hardware made to run just as fast as the new stuff via the application of a good, stable, OS. Also the fact that this allows HP to cut M$ out of the picture completely. An OS is really the only computer component that can be had free, and I see no reason why this couldn't be done on this side of the ocean.

    How long before Walmart (a company that I usually loathe) starts selling a super-low-cost lindows laptop? I'd sure buy it! (Or have they released one already?)

    1. Re:It's about time. by littleRedFriend · · Score: 1

      "This is what linux is best for, after all - low cost hardware made to run just as fast as the new stuff via the application of a good, stable, OS."

      I am afraid that the most visited page on Microsoft Thailand website will soon be "How to remove a Linux partition and create a NTFS one instead"

      --
      IANAL, but imagine a beowulf cluster of in Soviet Russia all your belong are base to us welcoming the new SCO overlords.
    2. Re:It's about time. by MsGeek · · Score: 1

      First thing I'd do in a case like that is wipe Lindows and put a real Linux distro in...maybe Knoppix, maybe Mandrake 9.1.

      A bit more info on this Thai HP laptop: base model doesn't come with an optical drive. (CD-ROM, DVD-ROM, CD-RW, etc) For a bit more, you get a CD-ROM. Unfortunately a computer without an optical drive is kinda crippled.

      --
      Knowledge is power. Knowledge shared is power multiplied.
    3. Re:It's about time. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Only if you have to reinstall from your win98 cd.

      Only 2 of my 5 Linux machines has a CD. The laptop's DVD gets more use as a DVD player than a CDROM player and the workstation has only used the CDROM to install RedHat. The rest of the machines did network installs from the 2 floppy distro of Debian (before ripping the floppy out).

      Granted I have great Net access (DSL and 802.11b).

      Joe

    4. Re:It's about time. by TKinias · · Score: 4, Funny

      scripsit MsGeek:

      First thing I'd do in a case like that is wipe Lindows and put a real Linux distro in...maybe Knoppix, maybe Mandrake 9.1.

      You misspelled Debian...

      *duck*

      --
      In principio creauit Linus Linucem.
    5. Re:It's about time. by MikeFM · · Score: 1

      Try http://idot.com. They have customizable laptops starting at $799. I've done business with iDot before and it's been an overall good experience.

      --
      At what price learning? At what cost wisdom? The price is a man's peace of mind, and the cost is his life.
    6. Re:It's about time. by Jason+Earl · · Score: 1

      Even so, Microsoft's only workable response to this is to make Windows harder to install without a license, a move which will anger paying customers. Microsoft can't hardly sue Thailand.

      Microsoft's other option is to turn Windows into a loss leader for other goods and services. If Windows were free (as in beer) Linux would lose much of its appeal.

    7. Re:It's about time. by 222 · · Score: 1

      This is EXACTLY the kind of thing i was looking for.... The company i work for outfits schools with computers (1 per student), with assorted laptop distribution, and the current 199$ "Walmart PC" is actually a pretty solid option. 1.1 Ghz Duron, 128 meg ram, 10 gig HD, NIC, etc.... Even the linux skeptics have trouble arguing the price. 450 for an 800mhz laptop, here i come.

    8. Re:It's about time. by isorox · · Score: 1

      You misspelled Debian...

      I think you'll find its g-e-n-t-o-o

    9. Re:It's about time. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "If Windows were free (as in beer) Linux would lose much of its appeal."

      I suspect that is the direction Microsoft is headed. $39.95 for full copy of Windows XP... something like that anyway.

    10. Re:It's about time. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting
      MS can try to make Windows harder to install, but in Thailand without all those pesky copyright/DMCA laws or enforcement, they will break it before its released anyway.

      It would be an interesting day if Microsoft decided to go the services route. Would be worthwhile to see at least.

    11. Re:It's about time. by loucura! · · Score: 4, Funny

      Heretic! It's spelled s-l-a-c-k-w... oh, bugger it, I can't be bothered with spelling it for you.

      --
      Black and grey are both shades of white.
    12. Re:It's about time. by belroth · · Score: 1
      Microsoft's other option is to turn Windows into a loss leader for other goods and services.
      <humour>Like a dealer giving first hits for free?</humour>

      If Windows were free (as in beer) Linux would lose much of its appeal.
      Linux still has appeal as you wouldn't need to buy lots of the other softwre that MS would still be selling. Although you still have the option to buy commercial software if you wish, of course.
      NB I run MS oses and linux, my choice is to migrate to linux as I can. That means as I learn more and depends upon what work I get. Lots of companies use MS and that's what they want software written for. Time will tell.
      --
      I hereby inform you that I have NOT been required to provide any decryption keys.
    13. Re:It's about time. by shepd · · Score: 1

      >$39.95 for full copy of Windows XP... something like that anyway.

      Where did you see that?

      I have dealer price lists, and at that price, I'd like to buy a couple thousand copies.

      --
      If you could be told what you can see or read, then it follows that you could be told what to say or think - BoC
    14. Re:It's about time. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      He was saying that that is what might happen in the future. Man...

    15. Re:It's about time. by rmohr02 · · Score: 1

      While I probably would put Libranet on in place of Lindows, I do want to try Lindows, and am willing to give it a chance.

    16. Re:It's about time. by rmohr02 · · Score: 1

      Also, I haven't been too impressed with Knoppix's hardware detection: Redhat, Mandrake, Slackware, Libranet, Gentoo and Debian all recognized my network card without any extra work on my part. Knoppix is the only distro I've found that doesn't.

    17. Re:It's about time. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This machine does not use Lindows. It uses a Thai-language-centric distribution.

      Also, a computer without an optical drive is a lot less crippled than no computer at all. And that's the point of the program.

    18. Re:It's about time. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I think you'll find its g-e-n-t-o-o

      Yes, but it's pronounced "Free Bee Ess Dee".

    19. Re:It's about time. by Gojira+Shipi-Taro · · Score: 1

      actually, I think she mispelled Gentoo ;)

      *duck*

      --
      "Oh my God. This is terrible. This is the end of my Presidency. I'm fucked."; ~ Donald J. Trump
    20. Re:It's about time. by Fizzlewhiff · · Score: 5, Funny

      You misspelled Debian...

      Relax, it was just a Thaipo.

      --

      'Same speed C but faster'
    21. Re:It's about time. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      lmao.. thats funny as hell

    22. Re:It's about time. by rsheridan6 · · Score: 1

      After you install it to your HD, Knoppix is essentially Debian, except that it doesn't ask you obscure details about your monitor and crap like that.

      --
      Don't drop the soap, Tommy!
  17. I love this... by Stephonovich · · Score: 4, Insightful
    I love this comment:
    Additionally, with the rampant amount of piracy in Thailand, users could easily purchase the low-cost PCs and install pirated Windows software on them.
    It just isn't something one usually sees on a news site... Almost as though it's advocating piracy. (ALMOST, Future Flamers...)

    (-:Stephonovich:-)

    --
    "Who needs reincarnation when we've got parallel universes?" -Me
    1. Re:I love this... by bstadil · · Score: 2, Insightful
      And forcing you to pay for Windows that your are not planning to use is kosher?

      If most people put windows on those machines it would actually work to MS' advantage as they thereby manage to maintain the file format lock in.

      Good news is that machine is a little underpowered for XP and is has no Cd, meaning it is so not so easy to "switch" for Joe Sixpack or whatever Joe is called in Thailand.

      --
      Help fight continental drift.
    2. Re:I love this... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      One guy on the block has a USB CD-ROM (and the BIOS supports booting form it) and -everyone- gets aroudn this.

    3. Re:I love this... by Stephonovich · · Score: 1
      I didn't say that the lack of Windows was a bad thing. I just thought that quote humorous.



      (-:Stephonovich:-)

      --
      "Who needs reincarnation when we've got parallel universes?" -Me
    4. Re:I love this... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No, this is the obligatory thing the press always says about PC's not shipping with the M$ tax. They make the inferrence that the M$ tax is justified because the people buying these cheap boxes just put a pirated Win OS on it anyway.
      BTW: I bought one (cheap pc w/Lindows - not this thai laptop) and it's still got Linux on it, though not the Lindows it came with. I wouldn't think of putting M$ on it. I specifically bought it to avoid the M$ tax because I wanted to run Linux on it. I'll bet a lot of other people who have bought these did the same. So it's just another media lie being told on M$'s behalf, because M$ spends LOTS of marketing money to the media.

  18. Obligatory *really* bad pun by Shadow+Wrought · · Score: 5, Funny
    I heard that Mr. Gates was fit to be Thai'd when he heard about this...

    Yeah, my work day is done.

    --
    If brevity is the soul of wit, then how does one explain Twitter?
    1. Re:Obligatory *really* bad pun by zzztkf · · Score: 1

      Maybe this deal is another invitation to Mr. Gates from Thai government.

  19. What are the specs? by UrGeek · · Score: 1

    Anyone know the specs on this bird? I have a ole Toshiba laptop with an 8086 and 320x200 B&W LCD, MS-DOS 2.11 embedded for less than this. No hard drive, through, floppy only. A 720K floppy, that is.

    1. Re:What are the specs? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Stupid ass, 640K should have been enough for you!

    2. Re:What are the specs? by Arker · · Score: 1

      Sounds a lot like my old toshiba, only it had... dammit a 286 or maybe something less, it had 2 megs of ram but the only thing you could do with the memory in excess of 640 was make a ramdisk... old DOS embedded on ROM, maybe 3.1 or so... just a floppy. That was actually quite a nice machine, great for writing in the park.

      --
      =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
      Friends don't let friends enable ecmascript.
    3. Re:What are the specs? by UrGeek · · Score: 1

      They must have improved the LCD. The main problem with mine is really sucks wind - the hardest to read LCD that I have ever since. And it only has two colors - gray and light gray. I should throw the P.O.S. away.

  20. Supply & Demand by Anonym1ty · · Score: 1
    The Thai daily even reported that the ICT is negotiating with other local and international vendors to produce more PCs because it fears that HP will not be able to keep up with the demand.

    That's the clincher! It isn't always how cheaply you can build this, but if you can keep up with demand. With wishful thinking that this could spill over to the rest of the world. The real question is can ICT get someone else to make some of these. After that can we get them distributed to the rest of us?...

    If only HP makes these it will never happen,but maybe this could eventially make its way throughout the industry.

  21. Blank Canvas by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This could make Microsoft tremble in its boots, Ma said. What you've got is a blank canvas in which the user can paint any color he wishes whether that's officially licensed Microsoft software or pirated software.

    I suspect most of these canvases will be painted with happy little trees in the cd-rom silver and black sharpie of pirated XP. Either way it's a loss for MS.

    Homer: (on the phone) Operator, get me Thailand. T-I- and so on.

  22. Note to self...business plan by macshune · · Score: 1, Insightful

    1. Find wholesale friend in Thailand
    2. Import said cheap laptops
    3. Remove evidence of thai-stuff from laptop
    4. ?????
    5. PROFIT!!!!!

  23. Sweetspot by arcite · · Score: 1

    This is more than enough power to do word processing, databases, presentations, internet, and email. Is this the begining of the second wave of the computer revolution?

    1. Re:Sweetspot by steve_l · · Score: 1

      Could be. I saw one presentation on Linux by a marketing person who said that linux is getting a hold in the US office desktop at the high end -the CAD user, the scientist, the software developer -and was competing with Unix workstations, and these people can afford VMware and Crossover Office to host winapps.

      But the third world opportunity was where the linux desktop could go widespread, becaue these people can make do with the current suite of Office.org apps and existing tools. Slick.

      NB, I don't get the bit in the article that implies that HP cant handle the demand so they were talking to Dell. They all come from the same factories in Taiwan, so what is the issue.

    2. Re:Sweetspot by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      a friend of mine works in a lab where they run linux with vmware. unfortunately, the tech dept have failed to tell her anything about the OS at all. she doesn't know what distribution it is, or how to open a console. it should not be like that.

      her problems are not major difficulties; even though it's a closed building, I could help if they'd given her some basic linux training (like they give to people using windows or macos for the first time). but as it is, they're just presenting it as 'like windows'.

      that's not good for linux.

      she's coming to think of it as an obfuscated, irritating operating system that's impossible to use. vmware/wine/crossover are not the answer. a single two-sided sheet with basic shell commands on one side, and a GNOME (or KDE) guide on the other will do far more to win over the public than will showing them linux 'just like windows.'

      it's not.

      we'd be in a better state if the self-deluding 'this is not an emulator' crowd would splinter and go write some native apps. imagine what could have been done with all that vmware and crossover development time... running win apps on linux is a waste of everyone's time. shove it, emulator fanboys.

  24. The Thai keyboard isn't a problem... by MerryGoByeBye · · Score: 5, Funny

    ...as long as you're a good Thaipist. ducks

    1. Re:The Thai keyboard isn't a problem... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Bahts the big deal?

  25. bill gates thai-phoon!!!!! by macshune · · Score: 1

    Upon hearing the news, Mr. Gates starting swirling into a giant Thai-phoon, quickly engulfing some of his troglodytes, but not the beefy Mr. Ballmer. He is like stone and stood his ground, for that is why the call him STONE MAN!!!

  26. Anyone have pictures? Video? by Remik · · Score: 1, Funny

    ...or will this revolution not be televised?

    -R

  27. Seems right to me by frovingslosh · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I just bought an HP notebook a few months ago (here in the U.S., where I couldn't avoid the M$ tax). Since then I've seen another HP notebook with a faster Athlon and bigger hard disk (40 gig vs. 30 gig) for the same $850 I paid. Considering that HP will build the systems with 20, 30 or 40 gig drives, will put a 14.5 inch rather than a 15 inch screen, give a choice of CPU, and will sell it with a DVD drive rather than the DVD/CDRW drive I got, it certainly makes sense that you can get a decent Linux notebook for this price, although I would expect a 40 gig version with a DVD/CDRW drive and a hot processor to certainly be more. But HP could well sell decent notebooks here at that price too if they dropped the M$ tax.

    --
    I'm an American. I love this country and the freedoms that we used to have.
    1. Re:Seems right to me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "it certainly makes sense that you can get a decent Linux notebook for this price,"

      Or better yet.

      You can get a decent Windows notebook for that price.

    2. Re:Seems right to me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      it's not a tax. a tax is extracted by coercion. last time I checked, the linux kernel compiled pretty well on PPC.

  28. I have a couple-o-three questions.... by rdewald · · Score: 3, Interesting

    The government of Thailand is the real force behind this move. That is an interesting development, has Microsoft ever taken on a government before? (I'm kidding) I wonder who has more cash?

    The fact that Linux has no licensing fee does give these machines a competitive advantage, especially if the user intends on puchasing a pirated copy of Windows. In fact, this government-sponsored initiative also gives an advantage to the software pirates, i.e., it gives them a new market. Hmm, is this a good idea? Is there any fair way to avoid this? Or is it that Microsoft creates their own disadvantage here by way of their licensing policies and fees?

    The bulk of the TCO for these machines is assumed to be end user support. Really? If you install a kernel especially suited to the hardware on the laptop, I'd think support would be down. I've struggled very hard with Linux (Debian and Slackware) over the years, but it's always been over hardware issues. Once I learnt enuff Perl to do stuff, use of the Linux environment has been natural and intuitive for me.

    In Windows, I am still a stranger in a strange land. I still can't get Windows to do what I want it to do on a regular basis, but hardware setup is usually pretty smooth. If I had been wise enough to ask someone smarter than I to build my kernel for each Linux box I have deployed, I would have spent WAY less time and money on support for them compared to the Windows machines. Is my experience so unique as to be counter to the conventional wisdom? How did the Thai Ministry conclude that they must anticipate higher support costs?

    --
    The best way to do is to be.
    1. Re:I have a couple-o-three questions.... by MerryGoByeBye · · Score: 1
      Regarding the support costs, please remember that:

      M$ charges an arm and a leg for support, so the ratio is already shifted a priori . (And don't think there won't be demand for support, considering the difference in language setup!)

      The government may have well expected to be the one supplying the support.

      The government may have not thought of the issue of support at all.

    2. Re: I have a couple-o-three questions.... by finite_automaton · · Score: 1
      The government of Thailand is the real force behind this move. That is an interesting development, has Microsoft ever taken on a government before? (I'm kidding)
      Yes. See the Wired story on this.
    3. Re:I have a couple-o-three questions.... by Black+Copter+Control · · Score: 2, Interesting
      The fact that Linux has no licensing fee does give these machines a competitive advantage, especially if the user intends on puchasing a pirated copy of Windows.

      Grr.. Why do people assume that everybody is going to want to wipe Linux and load Windows?? With these boxes flying off of the shelves as fast as HP (and possibly other manufacturers in the future) can make them, There's going to be a large pool of Linux support companies popping up all over the place. You've already got the tools you need to run most small businesses or home offices.

      Why break things by installing an OS that's just going to add to your support costs? I'm betting that most people are going to use these boxes with their native Linux install. In 6 months I wouldn't be surprised to see Thais trashing their Windows installs to load Linux after seeing how nice these boxes work.

      One of the biggest barriers to Linux acceptance has been lack of general access to linux-loaded laptops at the storefront. The WallMart boxes are still an anomaly. These things are getting lots of press coverage in Thailand. Thais who don't buy them will be watching closely to see how well they work. I expect good things out of this.

      --
      OS Software is like love: The best way to make it grow is to give it away.
    4. Re:I have a couple-o-three questions.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > Grr.. Why do people assume that everybody is going to want to wipe Linux and load Windows?? With these boxes flying off of the shelves as fast as HP (and possibly other manufacturers in the future) can make them, There's going to be a large pool of Linux support companies popping up all over the place. You've already got the tools you need to run most small businesses or home offices.

      Why do you assume that everybody (or a large percentage) won't wipe the drive and install Windows? Zealotry on either side == unfounded assumptions.

    5. Re:I have a couple-o-three questions.... by Black+Copter+Control · · Score: 1
      Why do you assume that everybody (or a large percentage) won't wipe the drive and install Windows? Zealotry on either side == unfounded assumptions.

      Mostly because not that many people have the knowledge and/or confidence to wipe whatever default OS they get on a machine and install something else. This is part of the reason why MS has fought soo hard to prevent manufacturers from being able to economically sell machines without Wintendos installed. Most people will use whatever OS they get, as long as it does the job for them.

      My mother has Windows on her laptop -- but not because I don't think she'd probably have been better off with Linux. It's because she lives in Edmonton, and by the time I got my hands on the thing, she'd been using it with Windows for a few months. I'm not going to break her concentration by having her learn her way around a new OS again (but if she's forced to re-install the OS one more time, I might just change my mind).

      --
      OS Software is like love: The best way to make it grow is to give it away.
  29. I have always hated Laptop Prices ! by zymano · · Score: 1
    i saw one at a discount computer place for 500 dollars but it had a Via processor but might have been good for internet use and writing.

    Laptops shouldn't cost as much as they do. I personally think manufacturers are conspiring on prices especially lcd screens.

    Why the hell aren't there any laptop do it your self kits?

    1. Re:I have always hated Laptop Prices ! by MikeFM · · Score: 2, Interesting

      As a loving owner of some Via processors let me say that I wouldn't let that stop you. They compete well against an equivilant speed of Celeron processor and run cooler and quieter. I have a lot of different CPUs running around my lan and the via are my current favorites.

      For a fun project you could buy a cheap lcd monitor and a mini-itx mobo with via cpu and build your own laptop. It'd be pretty easy to remove the monitor from it's case and then you'd just have to make a new case, add a dc-dc power converter, some ram, a hdd, and you prefered input devices. The only hard part would be making your own case. :)

      --
      At what price learning? At what cost wisdom? The price is a man's peace of mind, and the cost is his life.
    2. Re:I have always hated Laptop Prices ! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      Check out the desknote. It's a laptop built from customized desktop parts, made by ECS. You can buy a bare bones machine, and put your own processor, RAM, etc.

  30. It's not really $450 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The government is subsidizing the cost of the hardware, and will also provide service and support for the notebook.

    While I can live without service & support, I doubt the Thai gov't will give me a discount.

  31. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 1

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  32. Right you are by OECD · · Score: 4, Informative

    Right you are, according to this CNet article:

    The government is subsidizing the cost of the hardware...

    Sorry folks, I don't think the Thai government is going to pony up for the rest of us.

    --
    One man's -1 Flamebait is another man's +5 Funny.
    1. Re:Right you are by WoodsDweller · · Score: 1
      • The government is subsidizing the cost of the hardware... Sorry folks, I don't think the Thai government is going to pony up for the rest of us.
      I suppose it would be out of the question to take $60 billion the recently-passed tax cut of something like $350 billion over however many years and provide a $200 subsidy to every man/woman/child in America to buy a Linux laptop. No way that would help the economy.
      --
      There are two kinds of societies: sustainable and doomed.
    2. Re:Right you are by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Fuck you.
      Get your share and subsidize yourself but stay away from my money.
      How's that for being fair ?

    3. Re:Right you are by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      How about America pays off it's trillion dollar debts first?

      Just a suggestion.

    4. Re:Right you are by shaitand · · Score: 1

      Umm... you do know that debt is mostly owed to citizens, business, and the federal reserve (which is by the way a private institution, nothing federal about it). Something they neglect to mention, foreign powers actually owe the US money, not the other way around.

    5. Re:Right you are by Saurentine · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Umm... you do know that debt is mostly owed to citizens, business, and the federal reserve (which is by the way a private institution, nothing federal about it). Something they neglect to mention, foreign powers actually owe the US money, not the other way around.

      Except that a VERY large portion fo the citizens and businesses to which the debt is owed are foreigners... ...the latest statistics I find say that 42% of our federal debt is held by foreigners.

  33. There are cheaper options by Black+Copter+Control · · Score: 1
    That's $450 for the laptop and $1,500 for the return airfair to Thailand.

    At least I get a free trip to Thailand out of it.

    --
    OS Software is like love: The best way to make it grow is to give it away.
    1. Re:There are cheaper options by caluml · · Score: 1
      ... $1,500 ....
      .... free trip ...

      This must be some hitherto unknown meaning of the word free that I wasn't aware of :)

    2. Re:There are cheaper options by Black+Copter+Control · · Score: 1

      /me test's caluml for existence of a funnybone.

      --
      OS Software is like love: The best way to make it grow is to give it away.
    3. Re:There are cheaper options by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You can get two week trip including air travel and accomodations to Thailand under 1000e in Europe.

  34. Oh... I'm a Karma Whore and I'm okay... by benjamindees · · Score: 1
    --
    "I assumed blithely that there were no elves out there in the darkness"
  35. Siamese laptops by earthforce_1 · · Score: 3, Funny


    Do they have a two headed display?

    (Sorry, couldn't resist)

    --
    My rights don't need management.
  36. RTFA by skydude_20 · · Score: 1

    Using Linux over Windows really isn't what is making these laptops much cheaper (though yes the MS tax is gone now). The reason these laptops are this cheap is because the Thai government is subsidizing (sp?) the cost of the hardware, creating a "peoples computer." So nothing really new here in the world of competition, just something one government like any other could do.

    --
    Jesus saves souls and redeems them for valuable cash prizes
  37. Can you see this happening in the USA? by GMFTatsujin · · Score: 0, Troll

    From the CNET site: The government is subsidizing the cost of the hardware, and will also provide service and support for the notebook.

    "White House tech support, this is George. Before we get started, can I have your social security number please? ... Oh, I'm sorry sir, that's a driver problem. Let me transfer you to the Judicial Branch."

    And there would only ever be nine people on the phone at a time.

    For the REST of their LIVES.

    Talk about IT hell.

    GMFTatsujin

  38. Shipping by cqpalzm · · Score: 2, Informative

    I work in HP support, we cover shipping both ways. The user never has to pay a dime for it unless they want it overnight.

  39. The problem is... by mellonhead · · Score: 1

    You have to open the package wearing a bunny suit, incinerate the packing materials, then wipe the whole thing down with a strong anti-bacterial. Oh wait, wrong country...

  40. That's all nice and all but..... by Sergeant+Beavis · · Score: 1

    When the heck is HP and Dell gonna sell laptops with Linux in the US...

    Never I guess....

    --
    There is nothing inherently safe about liberty. That's why so many people died protecting it.
  41. Dammit by jtkooch · · Score: 1

    I deal enough DOS attacks from Thailand. Now the whole fricken country is going to have a lap top. I'm screwed.

  42. Re:No one will use Linux by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    When I buy a laptop I have to pay for a Microsoft software I don't want. So whats your fucking point?

  43. Pirated Windows??? by psxndc · · Score: 4, Interesting
    When was the last time you tried running a version of Windows on an 800MHz Celeron with only 128MB RAM? I wouldn't worry about pirates using these for XP. :-)

    psxndc

    --

    The emacs religion: to be saved, control excess.

    1. Re:Pirated Windows??? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I use Win2k on a Celeron 466MHz with 128MB ram and it runs ok.

    2. Re:Pirated Windows??? by jonbrewer · · Score: 1

      When was the last time you tried running a version of Windows on an 800MHz Celeron with only 128MB RAM? I wouldn't worry about pirates using these for XP. :-)

      XP Home on Celeron 467, 256MB RAM (one stick). Fast and stable, and beats the pants off my G4 (1.5 GB RAM, OSX 10.2)

    3. Re:Pirated Windows??? by lordfoul · · Score: 1

      I have a laptop with a PII 233 64MB. I Have it set to Dual Boot Win2k and Debian. Win2k Runs Smoother than Debian if I use KDE. If I use a Lighter GUI they are about the same. 800mhz is plenty for non-game usage with either OS.

    4. Re:Pirated Windows??? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I have installed XP Pro on 400MHz Celerons and 450MHz PIIIs. As long as you put in at least 256MB RAM, it's fine. A bit slow, but quite usable.

      The limiting factor here is going to be the memory, not the CPU. 128MB will cause the system to start using swap fairly quickly... but then, any recent version of Linux will probably have the same problem.

    5. Re:Pirated Windows??? by rch2 · · Score: 1

      Linux on 128MB RAM would also be quite slow - I mean KDE/OpenOffice.

    6. Re:Pirated Windows??? by psxndc · · Score: 1
      Which is probably why I'd install OpenBSD with fvwm. :-)

      psxndc

      --

      The emacs religion: to be saved, control excess.

  44. You hear that? by TedTschopp · · Score: 2

    That was the sound of the 800lb gorilla in the corner getting smacked upside the head. Ted Tschopp

    --
    Fantasy remains a human right; we make in our measure and in our derivative mode... -- JRR Tolkien
  45. Imagine this... by XaXXon · · Score: 1

    . Additionally, with the rampant amount of piracy in Thailand, users could easily purchase the low-cost PCs and install pirated Windows software on them.

    "This could make Microsoft tremble in its boots," Ma said. "What you've got is a blank canvas in which the user can paint any color he wishes whether that's officially licensed Microsoft software or pirated software."


    Or you could run Linux on it... ...

    1. Re:Imagine this... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And remember these laptops dont come with any cdroms or floopies. So, how will they install pirated software any how?

  46. Revenge of the nerds - No HP. No Way. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The way HP is stabbing it's american workers in the back is close to criminal. Neither me personally nor my company are spending one dime on HP products. Fiorina and her henchmen are trashing what used to be a respected company.

  47. Darn.. by eniu!uine · · Score: 4, Funny

    and I was thinking of visiting Thailand too. They'd better not stamp a EULA on my passport.

  48. Re:But they might be sued... by JoeBuck · · Score: 1

    Most companies are completely ignoring the SCO threats. I know that mine is.

  49. Bush Tax cut and an iBook almost as good by nicholas. · · Score: 0, Troll

    Apple is selling 700 Mhz iBook,128 MB RAM, 20 GB, CD-ROM for a mere $800.

    I've never seen a Thai Linux distro, but I bet OS X is quite a bit nicer. Plus the iBook has a real graphics chipset on it.

    You want the government to pick up part of the bill? You're in luck. The US government just passed a tax cut. For some (especially the very rich) that will easily make up for the $300 difference in price.

    Once again America proves to be better than all other countries. If you say otherwise we'll bomb the fuck out of you. Or at the very least not eat your cuisine. No more Pad Thai for me! I'll only have Pad FREEDOM.

    1. Re:Bush Tax cut and an iBook almost as good by nicholas. · · Score: 0, Troll

      My comment is hardly a troll. At most it's an advertisement for Apple with a healthy dose of patriotism.

  50. Re:Revenge of the nerds - No HP. No Way. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Amazingly only a small percentage of the world is American. Ever heard of the needs of the many outweighing the needs of the few?

  51. who needs an optical drive? by MikeFM · · Score: 1

    The only thing I use my dvd rom drive for is installs and ripping movies and music. I no longer include any sort of floppy drives in my computers and it won't be long before I stop including optical drives also. I might keep one around for ripping and maybe a burner but that's about it. Most my data goes straight through the network or resides on a removable harddrive. Other than my servers I'm even working on removing drives altogether from my computers and setting them up as thin clients.

    --
    At what price learning? At what cost wisdom? The price is a man's peace of mind, and the cost is his life.
  52. Re:But they might be sued... by exspecto · · Score: 0

    are you joking? this is a troll you guys.

  53. But Linux is slow by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Man, but Linux is so slow-w-w, it's unbearable. I am running RedHat 9 on a P4 2.0 GHz, 256 MB of RAM, and just starting up Mozilla takes up about 6 or 7 seconds, compare that with IE startup on the same system (I have a dual boot).

    Also, if you have 3 copies of Mozilla open, and console window and some other application on background the message "Nautilus has crashed, please report the problem" or something like that turns up every hour or so. Never had that with Windows Explorer.

    1. Re:But Linux is slow by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      mozilla startup under redhat 9 takes 3 seconds on my athlon 550/320mb box. sounds like you configured something wrong.

  54. still a ripoff by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    There's no way an HP laptop could be worth 450.
    Every one I've seen is complete crap (although still
    better than Gateway). Now Toshiba knows how to make
    laptops. You'll pay more, but its worth it. :)

  55. Re:But they might be sued... by MikeFM · · Score: 4, Insightful

    That's fine. The PHB's companies can keep spending an extra few million a year on software. That makes life easier for all their competition that is smart enough to accept the savings. :)

    --
    At what price learning? At what cost wisdom? The price is a man's peace of mind, and the cost is his life.
  56. Re:Agreed! They should look at FreeBSD by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Subject says all.

  57. Setup is easier on windows - NOT by TheLastUser · · Score: 2, Interesting

    hardware setup is usually pretty smooth

    Case in point:

    We just got some new desktops for the office. None had OS as we were replacing old gear.
    I installed, redhat 9, on mine, networked it with my old box, set up an scp to transfer by home dir, went for coffee. Applied all os patches from rhn, installed the nvidia drivers, so I can play quake. Done, total time ~3 hours.

    The competition?

    Day 1: Installed win2k, had some issue with license key, hunted around for key, gave up, went to warez. Finished install. Unable to connect to network, checked dhcp server, no issue, read news groups.

    Second day - Found alternate network driver, got network running, spent rest of day looking for install disks and more keycodes.

    And so on... nobody else has been able to switch their computers yet, its been a week, and their new machines are just sitting there.

    Yeah, windows is easier to install, sure...

    1. Re:Setup is easier on windows - NOT by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Who gives a fuck ?
      The point is that people would rather pay and use Windows then use Linux for free.
      That speaks volumes about quality of both OSes as far as desktop usage is concerned.

    2. Re:Setup is easier on windows - NOT by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      People would also rather pay for McDonald's rather than use a free dinner coupon for a fancy restaurant.

      That speaks volumes about how pointless your comparison is.

    3. Re:Setup is easier on windows - NOT by teqron · · Score: 1

      This also proves why the overall IQ of people is dropping, they all take the easy way instead of trying to apply a little intellect.

      --
      "Please proceed to grab your ankles. The anal injection process with proceed in 5, 4, 3, 2, 1...... WHOS YOUR DADDY!!!
  58. Don't buy Thai by knobmaker · · Score: 1, Offtopic

    Maybe this is a dopey consideration, and I'm just a soft-headed idealist, but I no longer buy anything made in Thailand, if I can help it.

    Here's the deal: In February, Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra announced that in three months, Thailand would win the war on drugs. When the attempt officially ended, according to the Associated Press, 2,274 Thais had been killed. The government said that only about 35 of these killings were committed by the police, in justifiable self-defense, but the Thai people and various human rights organizations believe that many more of these killings were done by the police in extrajudicial executions.

    This seems barbaric to me. The only way I have of expressing my opinion of these acts is to not spend my money on Thai goods.

    P.S. There are still drugs in Thailand. Surprising, isn't it?

    1. Re:Don't buy Thai by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh no!! Dead fucking druggies! What a tragic waste of human life. Who knows how many eventual brain surgeons might have broken their addiction and one day become contributing members of society! Your liberal guilt got ya down? Do everyone a favor and kill yourself, you fucking cuntrag.

    2. Re:Don't buy Thai by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      you stupid shit, he said they were extrajudicial. that means they were executed before they were tried or convicted. that's not "Dead fucking druggies", that's citizens murdered by the government without any rights.

  59. The revolution has begun! by valisk · · Score: 1, Interesting
    Well in all seriousness, I suspect it has, now that HP have let Linux out of the bottle and onto the Laptop in Thailand, I expect it won't be too long till they release it elsewhere, and other manufacturers will wnat a piece of this pie.

    I for one can't wait as I'd like to sell a good well supported Laptop with a good OS, and HP tech support has always had an excellent reputation.

    I think in a coupla years time when the suits have had time to play around with their Linux laptops, they won't be so unhappy to wave goodbye to Microsoft, after all if this Linux thing turns out to be shit they can always call them back in to clean up the mess.

    However Linux isn't and won't be shit.

    --

    Economic Left/Right: -0.62
    Social Libertarian/Authoritarian: -3.69
  60. The low cost notebook is nothing new by zakezuke · · Score: 2

    Somewhere around here I have a compaq contura aero.. a whopping 486sx/33 with 4megs of ram. Sub standard sub sized screen that can't be used in the light of day, sub notebook.

    In about 1993 or so, it was one among many sub $1000 notebook computers... pretty spiffy back then. I think I paid like $250 or mine at some point, as it was a 486 sx after all.

    In 2003, it is a hunk of junk, not worth my bother and effort to get more ram to make a basic linux install bearable, but never the less the unit did have some charm to it at the time.

    But I saw the areo being a good thing, dispite it obvious flaws. While it didn't change the world, it was indeed an afordable laptop.

    This is the problem that I see with any sorta budget solution, esp with laptops. A simple lack of standardization tends to make them not nessicarly the best option in the PC world. Though, goverment sponcered involement in actually laying down the specifications for a people's laptop could actually change this, i'd hope.

    While yes a celeron 800 is indeed substantal, there will always been a need to upgrade at some point, if Thailand actually thought about this, and actually demanded future expantion in the form of motherboard removal and replacement, I can see this as being increadabily cool. Dispite the fact that my laptop has it's issues, i'd invest a few bucks in a motherboard upgrade if it was a viable option, dispite it crappy sub sized screen.

    The linux side of things, well i'm not all that sure it will pan out the way we expect. Older slashdot artical said something about the "war" between microsoft and linux, and in cases where it looks like microsoft might loose to linux, they would give away licenses. Don't get me wrong, I hope that Thailand would beable to say to the world, "Fuck you, we don't pirate anymore, we're using this free thing over here".

    --
    There is no sanctuary. There is no sanctuary. SHUT UP! There is no shut up. There is no shut up.
  61. I really like the IDC quote... by pjrc · · Score: 5, Insightful
    ...where Byran Ma is quoted saying:

    What you've got is a blank canvas in which the user can paint any color he wishes whether that's officially licensed Microsoft software or pirated software.

    Why is it so hard to imagine that users will simply just use whatever comes with the machine? As long as it works, and even if it occasionally crashes or doesn't work in some way (eg, the long sordid history of a certain monopoly vendor)., they'll probably never bother to go to the considerable trouble to reformat and install 'doze.

    Especially since the machine doesn't include a cdrom or floppy drive.

  62. Don't run RH9 then... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I use Windows 2K and RH 7.3 on a dualboot laptop and I have no problem with the slowdowns you describe. Try 7.3 and see if that doesn't fix it. I have heard a lot of people complain about 9 sucking with being slow.. On a 2.0GHz box it should be anything but..

    1. Re:Don't run RH9 then... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I can't. It's the corporate box, and although not a laptop, it's a pretty fast desktop. The management wanted the Red Hat 9 install to be there in its original form, so it's the same skin that RedHat shipped with its 9.

      The thing is just slow. To be fair, if all the processes are launched from console, and no GUI stuff is opened, it's ok, no complaints there. BUt switching between the applications or opening up new windows just takes time, something like 5-20 seconds, noticeable nevertheless.

      And sometimes when you open up OpenOffice or Mozilla, you will see the cursor go into the busy mode and then nothing happen. The damn application wouldn't open. Comparing that to Win2000 on the same box is like oranges and apples - don't know why but Win2k just works faster and better. We will still keep a dual boot, however, making a decision between Win2k and Linux on later boxes I am definitely voting in favor of MSFT, the price difference is not that huge.

    2. Re:Don't run RH9 then... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Pardon me, but it seems pretty lamebrained of your management to insist on a distro's default installation as a basis for comparing Linux to Microsoft. One of the great advantages of using Linux is that you have the ability to make changes to suit your needs. Redhat is no less flexible than any other distro on that score. Somebody with a big old clue stick needs to inform your phbs that unless you leverage the flexibility Linux affords, your roi will never fully materialize.

  63. Re:Hmmmm. S$800 ~ US$450 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Carrefour in Singapore is currently selling a Medion laptop with Transmeta CPU, 14", 20g, 128M for S$800 without the OS. Add S$170 for XP or $0 for win98 you might have lying around. But unfortunately the laptop is certified for Linux.

  64. Linux had better shine... by NanoGator · · Score: 1

    Just a point, if people buy laptops or computers at that price with Linux, then it had better be as easy to use as some of the zealots here are claiming. Otherwise, it could earn itself a bad reputation. Ppl might assume Windows costs more because it's better.

    I'm not a big fan of Linux, but I do wish it success.

    --
    "Derp de derp."
    1. Re:Linux had better shine... by alpharoid · · Score: 1

      You have a good point. Now that Linux is beginning to get some public recognition, I've heard several people say that "you get what you pay for" in regards to Linux.

      From what I've seen so far, some of the biggest user woes in Linux come from simple things. I've seen one user manually ejecting a CD from the drive with a paper clip, because "it would not eject when I pressed the eject button on the drive". And I've only seen one distro so far (Peanut Linux, I think) that allows this out of the box.

      Maybe that's why the Thai notebook doesn't come with a CD drive. ;)

  65. Sawasdee! I don't see it on their store by olddoc · · Score: 1

    http://h50100.www5.hp.com/Store/default.asp?href=h ttp://h50100.www5.hp.com/Store/productMain.asp
    Th at is the url for the Thai online HP store and the notebook products page.
    All the notebooks show some kind of Windoze on them.
    The bottom of the page has this tag line:
    "HP PCs use genuine Microsoft® Windows®"

    Thailand is a wonderful place to visit with a lot of great people. Even if you can't get a good Linux laptop online I suggest a trip there.

    --
    Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely.
  66. Hooray by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Just think that HP probably wouldn't have been able to get away with doing something like this if the Microsoft anti-trust trial had never happened. Years ago, Microsoft would have threatened to yank their OEM license as soon as they heard about the deal.

    You have to wonder if Microsoft is still going to secretly punish them in some sneaky, behind-the-scenes way because of this.

  67. Specs: From the Horse's mouth by bobbagum · · Score: 1

    http://www.ict.go.th/promo/comict/spec.html - In thai but you can see the spec, it's actually a via chip though, and there's the desktop version aswell

    and the pic

    http://www.manager.co.th/asp-bin/Image.asp?ID=46 70 27341544501

    There's also a rumour that microsoft is preparing $30 windows to combat this as well, but somebody who wants windows in thailand would probably get a pirated one for $2 bucks anyway.

  68. Thai Government and Linux by aaarrrgggh · · Score: 1

    Actually, the Thai government has been putting money into linux for a long time. About four years ago, I remember several big competitions for Thai fonts. The ministry of culture(?) is worried about the loss of the Thai language-- the thai web was looking very english back then.

    Even if pirated copies are "free," it's in the government's best long-term interests to promote a Free solution, so piracy doesn't get in the way of trade treaties.

  69. Whoops by The+Tyro · · Score: 1

    my mistake... thanks for clarifying that.

    --
    Even if a man chops off your hand with a sword, you still have two nice, sharp bones to stick in his eyes.
  70. love your laptop? then kill shipped system. by Snooweatinganima · · Score: 0

    I actually enjoy installing and maintaining gnu/linux on my (kinda old but loved) laptop. I NEVER EVER leave a preshipped system on devices I buy. It simply does not feel right, like you buy a TV and only watch the first programmed station. Nothing against having a (small) partition with WinXP on your hd, but reinstall it, freshly, not with the "restore CD" crap some vendors are shipping. There's another point: how do you learn to speak DOS, Windows, MacOS, (uni|linu)x? By using it, yes, but to know more, one should play deeper. A marvellous device like a laptop deserves that one pays some time and effort in it. I always weep when I see latest thinkpads that still run the same system they were shipped with after months.

  71. +1 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Pretty fucking funny.

  72. In case you aren't familiar with it... by RandyOo · · Score: 1

    scripsit MsGeek:

    First thing I'd do in a case like that is wipe Lindows and put a real Linux distro in...maybe Knoppix, maybe Mandrake 9.1.

    TKinias said:
    You misspelled Debian...

    Just FYI, Knoppix IS Debian... Debian without the pain of installation.
    It runs directly from a CDROM - you don't even need a hard drive! It's certainly worth taking a look if you haven't already.

    1. Re:In case you aren't familiar with it... by TKinias · · Score: 1

      scripsit RandyOo:

      Just FYI, Knoppix IS Debian... Debian without the pain of installation.

      Indeed. That was the joke.

      --
      In principio creauit Linus Linucem.
  73. The M$ Tax. by LDoggg_ · · Score: 1

    I mean, even accounting for the "M$ tax" as it were (which is negligible when applied in bulk OEM licenses anyway)

    Negligible?

    Manufacture's costs will exponentionally increase the customer's price.

    For example, lets assume that the manufacturer pays an OEM license of only 50 bucks for win xp (no idea what it goes for these days, could be much more).
    That part of the product is likley added the Bill of Materials (BOM) and is part of the total cost of the product.
    Manufacturer's will never simply add $50 to the Manufacturer Suggested Retail Price (MSRP). These guys are in business to make money and as such expect profit margins. They were not ever planning on selling the finished product at their own cost. Thier distributors are making a profit, so are the salesreps, and so is the store you finally get the product from.

    Pretty simple economics.

    Ever wonder why that 128 mp3 player in the store costs so much more than the 64 meg one? Sure memory is cheap these days, but if it costs a manufacturer 5 dollars to make it instead of 2, you'll see the difference big time.

    --

    "If they have both, tell them we use Linux. And if they have that, tell them the computers are down." -Dave Chapelle
    1. Re:The M$ Tax. by The+Bungi · · Score: 0, Troll
      Pretty simple economics.

      That's very interesting. So what you're saying is that the computer manufacturers are marking up their final sales price based not on what the OEM license cost them, but on their own mark up of the thing itself?

      Well then, blame it on the manufacturers. Why blame it on Microsoft? They already profited from the sale, right? So let's call it "the Dell Tax" instead.

  74. Alphabook2 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Wouldn't that rock if HP started selling a second revision, AlphaBook2, for $600?

    Dude, I'ld jump on a deal for a portable ev56 faster than flies on shit!

  75. Yeah but by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is great and all, however, one thing concerns me. How many of these laptops will have Linux replaced by Windows? It is cheap to get a pirated copy of Windows in Asia isn't it? It's my understanding that PC's sold in China that come with Linux preinstalled are often (quickly) replaced with Windows.

    I'm hoping people stick to Linux.

    Just my two cents.

  76. pirate maneuvers by Oriumpor · · Score: 1

    Now, forgive me... but why bother pirating M$-bloatware when the 5-10% of users who actually will reformat their systems. These things aren't going to be super gaming platforms to begin with.

    How the "pirate market" really matters I couldn't say. If you can get on the internet, you are 3 steps away from pirate software.

    ---
    Newsflash, microsoft files suit against every ISP running DNS. Their claim: negligent ISPs allow users to find serial keys by being the *portal* to www.kazaa-lite.com.

  77. Will MS pay to subsidize Windows boxes? by frdmfghtr · · Score: 1

    Bryan Ma, senior research manager with IDC for the Asia-Pacific region, said that the PCs could pose a threat to Microsoft for two reasons. HP's decision to preload Linux, which can be distributed for free, allows customers to avoid the cost of a license for Microsoft's Windows operating system. Additionally, with the rampant amount of piracy in Thailand, users could easily purchase the low-cost PCs and install pirated Windows software on them.

    I bet that the MS countermove would be to offer to pay the subsidy for the Thai gov't if they instead used Windows machines. The two choices: (1) Use Thai gov't revenue to subsidize the hardware, or (2) Let somebody else pay the subsidy for you for an OS that is far more prevalent.

    Being a gov't body where the bottom line is nearly always the major influence, where do you go?

    --
    Government's idea of a balanced budget: take money from the right pocket to balance...oh who am I kidding?
  78. No, not at all... by Kjella · · Score: 1

    Shoot. . . I work for the marketing division of the Sirius Cybernetics Corporation. . . should I be concerned?

    Just come with me, sir. Just walk over to the wall over there, there will be a reception comittee waiting for you. They would all like to show their appriciation for making Clippy seem like a nice guy.

    Kjella

    --
    Live today, because you never know what tomorrow brings
  79. Saw Tux All Over Thailand 18 Months Ago by ec_hack · · Score: 1

    I was in Thailand 18 months ago for a wedding, and saw Tux painted on the windows of computer storefronts in several locations - Bangkok, Phuket, and the Bangkok suburbs. There were quite a few internet cafes, with cheap rates to send or receive emails.

    In addition, pirated IP was easily available. PS1 games, PC games, and music CDs were $5 each. I was offered NT version 4.0 server for $25 by a street vendor. Not many pirated DVDs, but lots of movies on video CD.

  80. Windows Through the Systems by KalvinB · · Score: 1

    I run Windows 2000 on a Gateway P200 with 96MB of ram. Runs just fine.

    98 runs great on my P133 32MB laptop.

    I have XP Pro running great on a PIII 933 with 128MB of ram.

    But it's great to tell people it takes a fast system to run Windows. It helps encourage people to upgrade or buy a brand spanking new system. Good for the economy.

    Ben

    1. Re:Windows Through the Systems by psxndc · · Score: 1
      Win2k runs fine on my P3-933 with 256. I don't doubt that Win98 runs fine on your older hardware. XP Pro though runs only so-so on my P4 1.6 with 384. I don't even have crap running in the background and it's a fairly new install since I wiped everythign when installing XP.

      My point was yeah, it probably will _run_ on an 800 Celly, but will it run well? Eh.

      psxndc

      PS, I have RH8 running on a 600 celly and it is dog slow when running KDE.

      --

      The emacs religion: to be saved, control excess.

    2. Re:Windows Through the Systems by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      redhat 8 (and 9) are fast as a loose stool on my athlon 550. running ardour. under gnome. maybe you configured something wrong?

    3. Re:Windows Through the Systems by psxndc · · Score: 1
      It's possible. I'm the last person to say I didn't. But I have pretty much a stock install. About the only thing I did "extra" was to mount a resierFS drive that stores mp3s and such (which isn't accessed much). It's no biggie. My RH box is there mainly as a file server so I don't use it much for the desktop.

      psxndc

      --

      The emacs religion: to be saved, control excess.

  81. The article is a bit misleading by aet · · Score: 2, Informative

    Actulally, this is the project by Thai government offered to Thai citizen who can not afford buying the computer at current market price. It is limited to one computer per household only. (you must show them supported documents, eg. the house registration, ID, etc)

    The buyer can buy at full price (cash) or via financing service offered by government's bank (24 months @~1000 baht/month for notebook and 490 Baht/month for Desktop)

    Current specs:
    1) Desktop 10900 Baht(Celeron 1.0 GHz, 128MB Ram, CDRom, 20GB Harddisk,15"monitor,speakers,keyboard,fax/modem)
    2) Notebook 19500 Baht (VIA 800MHz, 128MB Ram, 20GB Harddisk, 10.4"TFT, speakers,fax/modem,fast ethernet, no floppydisk & CDrom)

    The desktop will be manufactured by ~12 Local Brand suppliers while the notebook is currently manufactured by HP (OEM by HP sell with brand ICT) and the government is negotiating with other manufacturer.

    All computers will be sold under brand "ICT" not HP or anything else.

    I hope this should clear up some confusion.

  82. "people's notebook" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    news.com is calling this the "people's notebook". doesn't this just remind you of a time when someone contracted Ferdinand Porsche to build a "people's car".

  83. Linux on a "Buzz word" high by braddeicide · · Score: 1

    I'm not a flamer, really i'm not. Why is it that all these forign governments are all looking into linux? I believe BSD would serve a government better. Yes i'm on linux now, it allows a lot more fiddling and customizing, but linux is just too open for secure government type settings. Is "Linux" still on a buzz word high??

    PS, i realise a lot of people reading this have no knowledge of BSD, please keep that in mind when writing replies. And for the BSDers, OpenBSD.

    1. Re:Linux on a "Buzz word" high by unapersson · · Score: 2, Informative

      "I'm not a flamer, really i'm not. Why is it that all these forign governments are all looking into linux? I believe BSD would serve a government better. Yes i'm on linux now, it allows a lot more fiddling and customizing, but linux is just too open for secure government type settings. Is "Linux" still on a buzz word high??"

      "PS, i realise a lot of people reading this have no knowledge of BSD, please keep that in mind when writing replies. And for the BSDers, OpenBSD."

      Doesn't your PS answer your original question? There are now many more people out there who know Linux than know the various BSDs, if the situations were switched you'd probably have the opposite result.

    2. Re:Linux on a "Buzz word" high by 1s44c · · Score: 1

      Why is it that all these forign governments are all looking into linux? I believe BSD would serve a government better.

      I've wondered about this for a long time. Linux gets all the press, The BSD's get very little.

      I can only think that the GPL makes linux a more distinct product. BSD licences just lead to people taking the parts they want for their own products.

  84. Hmm... by theantipode · · Score: 0

    With news like this, I'm glad I wore my Che Guevara shirt today.

    Now to find those Sirius Cybernetics Corporation market execs... up against the wall.

    Insert a third stupid generic revolution saying here.

    I really did wear the shirt, though =P

    --
    When I am king, you will be first against the wall
    With your opinion which is of no consequence at all
  85. Microsoft vs. Thailand by bagsc · · Score: 1

    Microsoft:
    Annual Revenues: $28.4 bil
    Net Income: $7.8 bil (ibid)
    Debts: $12.7 bil (ibid)
    Cash on hand: $42.6 bil (ibid)

    Thai Government:
    Annual Revenues: $24.5 billion
    Deficit: $2.1 bil (ibid)
    Foreign Debts: $3.8 bil
    Foreign Reserves: $38.7 bil (ibid)

    Thailand is barely ahead excluding non-cash assets on both sides, but Microsoft's cash generation will bring them ahead within 12 months, more likely less than 6.

    --
    http://www.accountkiller.com/removal-requested
  86. Specs and more by da_anarchist · · Score: 1
    From the Bangkok Post:
    The notebook, supplied by Hewlett Packard for 19,500 baht excluding VAT, has a VIA 800MHz CPU, 20GB hard disk, 128 MB RAM, a 10.2-inch monitor and a modem. Without a CD-ROM drive, there will be a problem when users want to install new software. Although both computers come with the Thai-language Linux operating system Linux TLE 5.0 and the Office TLE 1.0.2 productivity suite _ which includes a word processor, presentation software, spreadsheet and web browser _ users might take time to learn how to use it.
    Interesting, it only has a 10.2" LCD display, no ethernet, a modem (assumedly 56k), and a custom version of Linux (anyone know what distro TLE is based on?). Considering that the quality and quantity of landlines in Thailand leaves a lot to be desired (my modem dropped twice while writing this), it begs the question whether this project to bring IT and the Internet to the masses would be more successful with a companion push for decent quality Internet service (perhaps through wireless?) to go along with the 1 million computers. Anywho, still a very positive day for Linux.
    1. Re:Specs and more by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Linux TLE
      (TLE for Thai Language Extension)

      it may be 60-80% Red Hat,
      but it has many good things from
      Debian, Mandrake, other distros.
      (it has apt-get, while still supports rpm .. wow!!)

      comes with Thai localized GNOME & KDE.
      Thai localized OpenOffice.org
      Thai enabled Mozilla (including XPrint extension for Mozilla, for Asian languges printing)
      numbers of GPL Thai truetype fonts

      really nice Linux for Thais ;)

  87. How cheap is cheap? by melonman · · Score: 2, Insightful

    If you can pick up a pirated version of XP on the market, next to the durians, for $3, how much of a price advantage does Linux have?

    --
    Virtually serving coffee
    1. Re:How cheap is cheap? by 1s44c · · Score: 1

      If you can pick up a pirated version of XP on the market, next to the durians, for $3, how much of a price advantage does Linux have?

      A big one, the cost of additional software, support, and the costs caused by crashes and corrupted data.

      HP won't be willing to use pirated software anyway.

    2. Re:How cheap is cheap? by melonman · · Score: 1

      But how many of the customers for this kind of machine would be buying their software legally anyway? Even here in France, I reckon about one PC in 5 is running a legal version of Windows, let alone the applications. So a machine with no OS plus bootleg software sounds highly plausible to me. Indeed, a lot of these machines are going to get Windows installed on them anyway...

      --
      Virtually serving coffee
    3. Re:How cheap is cheap? by EnglishTim · · Score: 1

      'costs caused by crashes and corrupted data'

      Don't make me laugh. I'm sorry but this whole 'Linux doesn't crash' thing is rubbish, at least if you're using it on the Desktop. Sure the kernel doesn't crash very often, but X seems quite prone to restarting or locking up on a whim. If you're lucky you're connected to a network, and you can get one of your colleagues to remotely log in and kill your X process for you, but you've still lost everything you were working on. I have X crash on me probably once every two or three days, and I have it hang so bad that I have to use the reset button about once a month. By comparison XP crashes on me about once every one or two months.

      And Mozilla crashes out on me once or twice a day. Okay, IE isn't fantastic itself, but if one IE window dies it doesn't take all the rest of them with it, unlike Mozilla, which takes down my mail as well (as we use Mozilla for our mail at work).

      Now, I'm sure there are a bunch of people out there who have managed to get their Linux desktop as solid as a rock, and perhaps I've just been unlucky, but it's certainly not a guaranteed thing that moving over to Linux will result in a more stable computing experience.

      (By the way - before someone accuses me of using crap cheap hardware - we are using good systems here - I'm using a dual pentium system from Max Black, who have a pretty good reputation for quality workstations, as far as I am aware. Also, NT4 which I used to use on it was solid as a rock...)

  88. Why is the CD necessary? by MickLinux · · Score: 1

    What I'd imagine is just including USB and an ethernet port. If someone needs a CD, tie in through one of those. That way, you save the cost of the CD, save battery, and lighten the laptop to boot.

    And stick Lilo / network boot on the bios, so that you can install it over the network quickly.

    Let's see... also good would be a monochrome electronic ink display behind plastic, a hall-effect keyboard/mouse, and a decent sound system. With that, there isn't a whole lot I couldn't do. Nice long battery life, lightweight, strong.

    One last thing: include the powerpack inside the computer. My favorite is to have the case be the transformer (top plate is one winding, bottom plate is another, sides are the carry-through to make a ring), and let the magnetic iron double as structural strength for the whole thing.

    It would definitely require some redesign, though.

    --
    Correct Horse Battery Staple: 72 bits of entropy. Enter "Correct H" into google. When it generates the phrase, that's
    1. Re:Why is the CD necessary? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      sure, stick the "powerpack" inside the case. be sure to carry plenty of extra hard drives.

  89. Thai ICT Notebook Spec by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    - VIA 800 MHz
    - 128 MB RAM
    - around 10" or 11" LCD screen
    - VGA on-board 32 MB *SHARED MEMORY*
    - 56K modem *OR* 10/100 Ethernet card
    - *NO* floppy drive
    - *NO* CD-ROM drive
    - LinuxTLE (Thai localized Linux) pre-installed
    - OpenOffice.org pre-installed

    It is really "commodity product", cheap enough to get to the mass.

  90. I am not buying into the "revolution" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ok.. so I have been reading this site for years, and believing all this pro-Linux stuff that you guys spew. Two weeks ago, we needed to buy a laptop, and I agreed to allow one of my employees to get a Dell Laptop and format it for Linux, as it will save all this money to move to open source. (Even though we HAD to buy a MS Windows license, since Dell doesn't sell the laptop any other way apparently). Now, the laptop sits there, unable to be used, because my employee has spent DAYS trying to configure the NIC card. Seems he has to RECOMPILE DRIVERS to make it work! (What the heck kind of operating system is this, where you need to recompile drivers!!!) OK, so we're in for $1200 for the laptop, and $3000 in labor to make it work. (And it STILL DOESN'T WORK!!!!!!!!) Sorry guys, it's not ready for prime time!

    1. Re:I am not buying into the "revolution" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hi, I think the best way is dont buy hardware that dont work with linux or is hardware with no support for LINUX !!! CU my 0.2 cent

  91. UPMOD PARENT by You're+All+Wrong · · Score: 1

    Pretty please.

    It's a very interesting and pithy summary of the situation, and opened my eyes, certainly.

    YAW.

    --
    Your head of state is a corrupt weasel, I hope you're happy.
  92. Lindows laptop by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Here is a link to the Lindows site, with their linux laptop for $800.00. I believe Lindows is a Debian based linux distro.

    1. Re:Lindows laptop by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      I can't find the 'download' link on the lindows.com site. nor can I find a copy of the GNU GPL. oh well, I guess I'll just have to keep looking for one that's free. maybe before I buy it I'll look at redhat, since it's also as easy to use as windows. hey, look, a download link on the front page!.

      lindows is offensive. lindows is hurting linux. it markets its distro as a 'cheap offbrand' alternative to windows, while at the same time making it available only for money.

      put your money where your mouth is, michael. if you have any respect for gnu/linux, the open source movement, or the intelligence of your customers, then I expect I'll see a download link on the lindows.com front page tomorrow afternoon. -c

  93. With no CD, people won't install Windows. by Animats · · Score: 1

    Installing Windows without a CD drive is tough. Few people would bother.

    There's also the question of whether the machine can run Windows at all. If it's custom-built for Linux, it might have boot ROMs that aren't Windows-compatible. It would make sense to boot with something that offers few boot-time options, good startup diagnostics, and has all the messages in the native language.

  94. licensed Microsoft software or pirated software by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What about the view that its either microsoft or piracy?

    Bryan Ma, senior research manager with IDC for the Asia-Pacific region

    "This could make Microsoft tremble in its boots," Ma said. "What you've got is a blank canvas in which the user can paint any color he wishes whether that's officially licensed Microsoft software or pirated software."

  95. Why people might install pirated WinXP by rdewald · · Score: 1

    If someone has a later model digital camera, digital video recorder, mp3 player or some other type of new (or esoteric) hardware it might sometimes make more sense for them to use windows to interact with these devices. In such a case, doing a reload with winxp will probably get them results they want quicker than tracking down, configuring, finding kernel modules for and installing the proper Linux drivers, if they exist.

    I have to admit, even though I don't like using Microsoft code, I do. I keep a winXP machine around (but safely offline) for just the abovementioned interface applications with my various gadgets. I don't keep any data on it because I expect to have to relaod the OS without warning at almost any time. I regard it is a sort of over-priced commercial device portal for my home network.

    I think this Thai iniative will yield good things also.

    --
    The best way to do is to be.
    1. Re:Why people might install pirated WinXP by Black+Copter+Control · · Score: 1
      If someone has a later model digital camera, digital video recorder, mp3 player or some other type of new (or esoteric) hardware .....

      People with new and esotheric hardware are pretty much the minority. It's only geeks like us who are generally willing to do a clean and install of a new OS on an out-of-the-box computer. Even so, releases like RH9 contain drivers for the vast majority of late-model equipment. Besides: people who can afford leading=edge equipment are unlikely to have the thai-books as their only computer.

      With hundreds of thousands (millions?) of people buying these machines in Thailand, the Thai manufacturers and distributers are going to do what it takes to ensure that their equipment is going to be supported on the government-issue computers, so I expect drier availability to increase dramatically (even if it is thai-language only).

      --
      OS Software is like love: The best way to make it grow is to give it away.