Segway Riders Get High on Mount Washington
TacticalJack writes "Rob Owen, a retired clown, and two other riders surged up Mount Washington at 12.5 mph, the AP reports. It took the Segway riders two and half hours to complete the 7.6 mile endurance test. The team used six batteries, fought off 50 mph winds and battled bitter cold to reach the 6,288-foot mountain summit. All of which begs the question, why not buy a motorbike?"
He asked why. On a segway article. I'm at a loss for words.
What happened to the standard geek, 'How?'
Banaaaana!
A retired clown!
LOL!
A segway would be awesome.. i wonder if there legal on highways lol
It's no different, and there is no wasted energy in keeping a gyroscope leveled. As for the geriatric connotations of a Rascal, well it's not like a Segway is a chick magnet either.
"All of which begs the question, why not buy a motorbike?" Because then they wouldn't have hit the press.
It begs the question: Why mention that he's a retired clown?
I had to ride my segway to school uphill in the snow without TIRES! gosh darn young wippersnappers - no respect at all!
You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.
dominionrd.blogspot.com - Restaurants on
huh? Somebody school me please.
For how much they cost, they should be able to do more than climb up mountains.
hrrrm. i wonder if they had to carry their batteries... because, we _all_ have 6 specialty batteries lying around just incase the first 5 die.
... People with too much money AND time.
he looks very funny.
hooray! it's a sex wiki
In Other News:
John Ashcroft Calls for Mount Washington to be placed on Schedule 1
Wouldn't carrying six battery packs on a Segway be even more absurd than as trying to carry a couple five-gallon gas cans on a motorcycle?
What's next -- a shoebox on rollerblades as a "trailer"?
I do not fail; I succeed at finding out what does not work.
7.6 mi / 2.5 hr = 3.04 mi/hr.
The way the article is written, they make it sound like it breezed up the mountian.
Still, 3 miles per hour is a pretty brisk pace for mountian climbing.
Remember, You are unique...just like everyone else.
Actually, there's a road to the top of mount washington, along with a train.
If they'd done it on a moterbike, would they have been written up on slashdot?
What more reason does a geek need?
Free Software: Like love, it grows best when given away.
Any chance that this was engineered by a marketing firm? Will we see it in Mountain Dew commercials?
Laws are for people with no friends.
If a segway can go 12.5mph up a 12-18% grade then it must have enough power to go considerably faster that it's advertised 12.5 mph top speed on flat ground.
How long until people start hacking their segways to achieve maximum speed?
Nope, sorry, it's a road. Never been to Mt. Washington, have you?
It's hard to be religious when certain people are never incinerated by bolts of lightning.
When he could have just jumped in the van that was following him? For that matter, why even go up the damn mountain in the first place?
:)
That said, motorbikes are 'cool' and I ride one and would rather that over a damn segway anyday.
I.O.U One Sig.
There is a time when one may be pedantic and in some cases it can be quite interesting:
What 'begs the question' really means [worksafe].
You can mod me 'flamebait' or 'troll' if you like but consider this - I'm just trying to enhance and improve your grammar-life, with no money down!
It is amazing how difficult it is to form an intelligent response to this article.
I can understand slashdot's collective interest in all things Segway, but I think at this point there's probably nothing more that can be said about the subject.
I see this as a parallel to a prophetic article in which the Hurd is used to power the next Furby, thus sounding the death knell for both technologies.
Furby = nearly dead retired clown, and Segway = The Hurd, in case you didn't get my analogy.
It's an interesting technology looking for a market that doesn't exist. People in densely packed cities are doing just fine with inexpensive bikes. Americans like their cars. The Segway is the butt of a lot of unfunny jokes, and publicity stunts like this.
I predict that someone below this post will undoubtedly compare this to George Bush's run-in with the Segway, claiming he is less intelligent than a clown, and less fit to run the country.
Go at it slashdot. You'll only find +1 Funny posts here.
Fuck Beta. Fuck Dice
dam it's a Joke. And only 50 MPH winds? hehehe.
As you can see I don't care about my karma.
That retired clown looks like John Howard the Prime Minister of Australia!!
Rob Owen, a retired clown, and two other riders surged up Mount Washington at 12.5 mph, the AP reports.
:)
Did all three of them ride the same scooter? Can a clown who rides up a mountain with two other guys on an underpowered scooter in very unpleasant weather really be called "retired"? Or is this his "coming out of retirement" show?
Good thing it's not April 1st, or else I never would have believed this.
My blog
Personally, I think a slightly more literal interpretation of this headline would be a lot more hilarious/interesting than the real story.
Stoned Segway Rider: "Whoah man....like, I lean and it moves and I don't fall over.....I wish I could do that on my own....."
Buy Steampunk Clothing Online!
Who knows why they decided to go up a mountain. It is not the machine's fault!
;-)
The Segway allows travel at an intermediate rate - between walking and biking. As to the path issue, there is no rational reason that it couldn't re allowed on foot paths.
It is intended for places where rigid infrastructure doesn't exist. Unfortunately, the US is too rigid by far as the posts amply denonstrate. However I was referring to the road/sidewalk system.
Any preoccupation with ideas of what is right or wrong in conduct shows an arrested intellectual development. (Wilde)
Hey, if they're not going to redesign cities around the Segway, maybe now they'll redesign mountains around them...
Security through promiscuity is no better than security through obscurity.
Well, what is the difference? Or are they the same thing? I would think a motorbike is like a scooter, while a motorcycle could be an off road stunt bike or harley.
All of which begs the question, why not buy a motorbike?"
Or, here's an insane thought, why not just hike it? Even part of it?
When hiking, you can stop and smell the flowers. When Segwaying, you can stop and change your batteries.
"Can of worms? The can is open... the worms are everywhere."
Anti SCO T-Shirts donates to the Open Source Now Fund.
Of course, a bicycle got up in in under an hour--40% the Segway time. And to think that one day, I might be on a multi-use path, having to shout at these morons to yeild right-of-way!
Oh yeah, Segway, that's the other now dead fad that was missing from yesterday's Dotcom Era Fads story on Slashdot :-)
I find your ideas intriguing and I wish to subscribe to your newsletter.
I could do that climb on a bike in about an hour, and it'd be better for my cardiovascular system than a segway. Cheaper and better for you. :) Unless of course it's a $5000 ti or carbon bike then it's just better. :)
Mount Washington Records
The only thing more pathetic than a clown is a clown riding up Mount Washington on a Segway.
"And this is my boy, Sherman. Speak, Sherman." "Hello." "Good boy."
that the American bastardized usage is any less useful as an alternative to "makes one wonder", especially since it is even catching on across the pond.
Frankly, it's a slippery slope. First you use begging the question to discount your opponent's argument, accusing them of skirting the issue. Then the person with a weaker position uses it against you, implanting a "glossed over" proposition which is NOT in dispute, but attempting to make you look like you ignored it, or getting someone less ignorant watching a debate to side with you.
Eventually you use it to throw out onto the table any old idea that you think might have been ignored, asking a hard question, or using it deftly to change the subject.
It got that way not because of people picking up it's usage incorrectly, but by loosening the confines in which it is used to better suit poor argumenters looking for semantic wins, not factual wins.
Eventually enough people hear it being used to twist things around, and it gets it's flabby repurposing.
I'll still use it in it's original form, as it still reads correctly to an unlearned reader. They'll always be thinking to themselves, ahh, but I already know the answer to that issue, and I'll always leave a sentence in there to let them know they're right.
But don't feel you have to correct anyone, that begs the question if they care since no one else is expecting them to use these technical english thingies good either.
Fuck Beta. Fuck Dice
...but I won't...
Holy fucking shit! 6,288 feet! Amazing!
Christ, that isn't a fucking mountain, i wouldn't call it a foot hill. I struggle to call it a hill. Climb a real fucking mountain some day.
this story would have been more interesting if a clown car with like 20 clowns went up there and we had some video of them all filing out of a volkswagon bug, or something.
clearly the couldn't go that fast through those hairpin turns, eh?
Fuck Beta. Fuck Dice
Has anyone rated the topic??? It isn't supposedly an informative nor a good Joke... what is it doing on /.???? ... Well I was pretty bored hearing segway.. segway.. it ain't future.. it is just the gap between guys who can't accept technology (of plasma engines, or fuel cells) and the a techno freak who wants everything from his condom to milk done with electricity.... Come on guys.. in next 50 years this is going to be the worst invention ever..
As any linguist will tell you, language changes. The dictionary is not the final word (so to speak) on word usage; real live speakers are. If the vast majority of current writers and editors say that "begs the question" means "provokes us to ask", then it does, no matter what some huffy dictionary author may try to convince you.
We had aa retired clown as a teacher in middle school, and pound for pound he was probably the strongest guy there (we had an ex U.S. football player, he was definitely the strongest). If you go to a circus and watch what the clowns do, they are often very athletic. Still it is kind of a strange stunt they did.
Why not use a bicycle?
What is "endurance" about doing this on a Segway?
Or am I just missing something here?
If you want to e-mail me, use my PGP Key.
i scale these altitudes and more, everyday, no biggie,
but then again, i do live in Colorado
Jesus saves souls and redeems them for valuable cash prizes
I wonder if they were trying to harken to the roots of the US interstate system (although I think Germany's Autobahn predates it).
0 030810-081 911-2985r.htm
I recall a small expedition done by the military to show that an truck caravan can be used to cross the continent. Everyone thought it was stupid because, well, anyone who is anyone carried their freight by rail. Eventually some people realized that the interstate highway system could be used.
But, even in light of this, I would rather hike all the way up that mountain than ride one of those dorkmobiles.
Here is a fun article:
http://www.washtimes.com/upi-breaking/2
I quote:
"Anybody who rides around on a Segway is a mewling pantywaist passive-aggressive dork with arrested-development issues who probably saves his e-mail in tidy little folders organized with happy-face icons.
I already feel better."
and:
"One thing that makes me very very happy about the current political debate is that most lawmakers agree that Segways should require a helmet. Since an actual motorcycle helmet would conflict with the eco-friendly coolness of the Segway experience, they're tending toward some kind of modified bicycle helmet that looks like one of those strap-on leather jobbies worn by the Fighting Horsemen of Notre Dame. Put a computer programmer in a tieless linen suit on a Segway with a leather football helmet on his head, and he looks like a fetishist on his way to the sex dungeon."
smash.
I run: Windows, OS X, Linux, FreeBSD. Just because you have a hammer, doesn't mean everything is a nail.
Doesn't seem to have retired just yet.
Exercise: if you had to do this with nothing but Segways to carry the batteries, how many would you need?
dam it's a Joke. And only 50 MPH winds? hehehe.
Actually it isn't a joke. See, if it were a joke, it would have been funny. Instead you used words such as "assholes" to indicate that you were better than the submitter when you didn't even know what your were talking about. I guess that means the joke's on you.
His name could be ShakeSpear...
"All of which begs the question, why not buy a motorbike?"
No, it begs the question "What the heck is this doing on the front page?" I can see how the Segway was at one point an interesting piece of technology when it first came out, but that was a long time ago. It's less "technology" and more "silly fad." I would sooner expect an article about who is going to win such-and-such "reality TV" show than this on Slashdot. What next, world's larget pet rock collection?
Heck, if anything the Segway is a shining example on exactly why the bottom fell out of the 90's IT economy. And the fact that mention of it still makes headlines in Slashdot demonstrates that people in the 21st century are still just as gullible and short-sighted as they were ten years ago.
Wow.
The most inspiring part of this is that they did it on a gay little scooter.
Slightly off topic, but this might be of interest to readers tonight, so what the hell!
This reminded me of the Mt. Washington Auto Road Race. To be a little more on-topic, one year they had a Geo Metro electric car 'do' the race- it looked really funny, because both driver and 'navigator' were required to wear helmets since it was a sanctioned race. Unlike some of the 600hp cars, the starter didn't exactly have to jump out of the way with them).
The hillclimb is the US's oldest motorsport event, believe it or not- however, it's also one of the most troubling. Despite attracting a healthy crowd every year, Audi pulled sponsorship after Frank Sprongl(driving an Audi S2 rally car) stopped winning, despite numerous VW and Audi entries.
The final straw for Audi, sponsorship-wise, was most likely the guy in the Legend car(motorcycle engine, 4 wheels, micro-sized chassis) who went off, clipped a rock, and was pulled from his car by a 16 year old cornerworker, right before the car burst into flames from a severed fuel line(the engine compartment was severed from the car by the rock). Long ago Audi had stopped their factory rally teams after a slew of deaths in the Group B category in various rallies; Piesch, now head of Volkswagon Audi Grouppe, declared at the time that he "never wanted to see rings stamped on a spectator's chest". Audi of America management were probably sneaking the Mt. Washington race under the radar of the parent company, but all that changed with the big crash(the kid even got a medal from the Governor).
Another factor is that Audi now considers rallying a been-there-done-that(Audi dominated rallying in the early 80's with the first Quattro Coupes and Sport Quattros), no-longer-cool kinda deal; their customer base just doesn't care, or so they think; guys who drive A8's don't like hanging out in the rain watching cars go by throwing rocks into their faces; they like sitting in a hospitality tent in cool comfort. So that's why Audi threw themselves into LeMans and ALMS(American LeMans Series), along with the Speedvision(er, SPEED Channel) SpeedGT(S4's, last year) and ProGT(RS6's, this year) races.
Mt. Washington management has given a variety of excuses for not continuing the race; first it was Audi, because they couldn't find another sponsor(rumor was they were looking for 1 million- an ABSURD amount of sponsorship money; it may be the oldest motorsports events, but it's also one of the lowest profile). Then it was because the road needed resurfacing(although honestly, having driven it myself three times as well, it WAS getting really bad). Then it was because the lodge, which had absolutely nothing to do with the race, burned to the ground and was 'behind schedule' on being rebuilt, or some such nonsense.
There are rumors going around that the race will continue next year. The local region of the Audi Club of America might attend(as it has for many, many years- we were the yahoos with all the Audis parked to the left of the starting area). Depending upon how solid the Audi+VW marques are represented, I'll be there- our little sub-event is a great family affair and I've always enjoyed myself; it's pretty gosh darn cheap, and getting there and back is half the fun(there are some GREAT roads in the area). Spectators can do whatever floats their boat- you can go up to any of several points on the mountain via van to watch the races(warning- you're limited as to when you can get back down!), you can hike the mountain(not for the inexperienced), you can watch from the start line and see trap speeds etc...and you can also watch from a nice point that's just a few minute's hike and gives you about 20 second's view per car.
The basic idea, if you're wondering, is simply to get up the mountain as absolutely fast as possible. Frank Sprongl was a regular winner, but his S2 is no longer competitive against some of the cars that started showing up- Jerry Driscoll(sp?) kept building meaner+meaner purpose-built tube-frame cars with insane engines in 'em until he started winning, despite not having all wheel drive(which is a MAJOR advantage, to the point that it's a seperate class in any sanctioned rally).
Please help metamoderate.
Wonder if being up that high affected their "high" at all....
(lovin' the article titles lately)
Did they get bumper stickers that say This Segway climbed Mt. Washington?
Segway / DEKA Research is a New Hampshire company.
Mount Washington is the highest point in New Hampshire (or New England for that matter, but not -- as is commonly believed around here -- the highest point on the US east coast: that title goes to North Carolina's Mount Mitchell).
As a popular landmark & attraction, Mount Washington has great appeal in New England. The "This car climbed Mt. Washington!" bumper stickers are ubiquitous, and driving up the mountain's wind-swept road in the family minivan or station wagon has been a rite of passage for generations of New Englanders.
That is why they had to drive Segways up the mountain. This is a New England transportation invention, but that just wouldn't be complete without the obligatory drive up Mount Washington.
The real question is whether or not the Segways they took up the mountain have any space for the bumper sticker :-)
DO NOT LEAVE IT IS NOT REAL
Joke is on you, don't feed the trolls.
Highest wind (world record, April 12, 1934): 231 MPH
Mt. Washington Observatory
Show me on the doll where his noodly appendage touched you.
because a 2 wheel converted wheelchair looks way cooler no ?
"because it's there"
Foole
I am better. I have no doubt that at $5000 a pop for the Segway this is the act of assholes, who by the way took longer than many people who have run up Mt Washington on their own 2 feet. Maybe they will do it in winter when the wind at the top can gust up to 200 Mph. Until then it is a joke just like teh parent. As everyone knows there is a road up there you could drive on.
As you can see I don't care about my karma.
welcome our new retired clown Segway-riding masters.
I want mine lowered first.
That is why is said "only 50 mph winds." Sigh it is true geeks are clueless. Some place I have seen a photo of horzointal ice formed at the top from the constant wind.
As you can see I don't care about my karma.
because a powered lawn roller looks cooler no ?
Check it out for yourself here.
-WolfWithoutAClause
"Gravity is only a theory, not a fact!"When I visited Mt. Washington as a kid, the temperature was no problem even though I was wearing just jeans and a T-shirt. However, the 58 MPH winds were a concern.
Gamingmuseum.com: Give your 3D accelerator a rest.
Sorry, sometimes its not apparent when posters are being funny, or as you said, "clueless".
Show me on the doll where his noodly appendage touched you.
is it just me, or did anyone else read the headline and wonder why a bunch of guys smoking joints on their segways was newsworthy?
then again, i'm on medication now so i may not be thinking clearly...
Xfce: Lighter than some, heavier than others. Just right.
Is Slashdot getting paid for these Segway articles? I mean, really, this was the most overhyped toy EVER! Not only that, but Slashdot has been guitly of posting blatent plugs for this overpriced scooter. Astroturfing if lame. Slashdot backed asrtoturf is even worse.
Buy Text Processing in Python
The really cool part is that they were able to get all 3 segway owners together to do this.
7.6 miles in 2.5 hours. Average speed: 3 mph. Speed of a human walking: 4 mph.
It remains unclear as to why Owen dressed up like a butler for the epic ride up Mount Washington.
Why do clowns do anything?
- First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then ???, then profit.
There is a road, but I've climbed Mt. Washington twice via the trail. The first trip had to be abandoned after the 4th night waiting out a wstorm that triggered a landslide that came to a stop just a couple hundred yards from our lean-to. from our lean-to. Made it to the top on the second trip; there's a weather station up there that's encrusted in about a solid foot of ice. You had to keep low or the winds would catch you and start pushing you across the ground.
As a 210 lb 40 year old tourist bicycle rider in 1991 I was able to ride the last 9 miles to the top of Wolf Creek pass (10800 feet) on a 40 lb touring
in a bit over 2 hours. This was not with any batteries, but on a 40 lb steel bike with trunk, 96 oz water, pump, jacket, and a 3 lb rock hidden by a ?friend? . Racers easily made the same distance in under 90 minutes. Temp was 95 degrees F (not really that bad in the dry mountain air) and there was a 10 mile per hour headwind comming down the mountain.
We don't need no stink'n segways!
It was actually quite intriguing to see it in person. This old guy was crossing the street in Seattle's Wallingford neighborhood. My friend commented "is that legal?"
The old guy made it across the street in a jiffy and was a block and a half away by the time the light turned green. From the looks, if an older person can master a Segway, then they shouldn't have as big a need for a car, particularly in urban areas. Perhaps it'd be safer for them to have a Segway (so long as they're not falling off it and breaking a hip)?
It is amazing how difficult it is to form an intelligent response to this article.
Well what can you say about it? If this were merely a case of entertainment posing as a news story, that would be one thing. But this is advertising, pretending to be entertainment posing as a news story. It's not even infotainment, it's advertainment.
So far all the Segway stories I've seen on Slashdot (aside from the San Francisco sidewalk controversy) have had the character of guerrilla marketing. "Hey, we got to play with a Segway for a week, here are some movies of us having fun with it!" Other products appear on Slashdot this way, but usually only when their users have made strange or noteworthy modifications that the designers never intended. Like creating a case for it made of Legos, or incorporating it as a part in a rail gun, or running a free operating system on it.
This thing has been on the market for years now. At this point we should only be seeing Segway stories when people do similar things to Segways. If someone modified a Segway by installing a feeding tube, so that the rider could suck a high calorie substance like gravy through the tube while simultaneously avoiding exercise, that would be a cool Segway story. Another newsworthy modification might be converting the Segway from electric to diesel. Using the product normally, in the manner that was intended by the manufacturer, is simply not worth our attention. (Dressing up like a butler while you do it is cute, but hardly changes this.)
I think stories that are essentially guerrilla marketing, or that are about guerrilla marketing, should have their own icon. I'm picturing a gorilla on a Segway.
Now not only do they have to update their coins and license plates (old man in the mountain fell), but they need new bumper stickers.
"this segway climbed mount washington"
hey, its funny if you know it.
I have a wheelchair. I can walk just fine- for distances of a mile and a half or less. Any more and my joints can't take it, the inflammation gets too bad and i'm out of commission. So i can get through my workday, but i have the wheelchair for group adventures where it's more fun if i can keep up. Great for museums, but more difficult outside, especially on hills. My arms aren't any better than my legs, so it needs to be pushed, rather than wheeled by me. It works out great, we all take turns, and while i can't push anyone in it, everybody gets a chance to ride and that way i can walk for a little of it and still be part of the adventure. For them it's novel and fun; for me, it's my chance to take part in these excursions. Without it, i'd miss out on a lot.
A segway would be a great thing to have, but before i spend that kind of money on it, i need to know how it does in real-world operation, with real-world surroundings like dirt and tree branches and so on. So i watch for things like this. It's not a wheelchair and it's not a walker and it's not a little red wagon to be pulled in- it's a scooter that you don't have to propel on your own. Believe me, the energy it saves will be put to use elsewhere. I would love to be able to keep up on a hike!!!
"I'd say 'Have a good time,' but arson is still illegal.
HAS he retired?
Looks more like continuing the same career to me.
yeah no shit, half assed people drive, real men hike
Pointing out how retarded the segway is. If more geeks would just ride a bike now and then, they wouldn't be wondering why their beer is causing so many problems with their gut.
Is under 50 minutes. These records need updating. And the bike didn't have to stop half way up for more air and water.
they were 3 people.
their combined speed was 12.5 MPH.
Hence about 4.2MPH each.
2.5 hours, but at least 5*10=50 minutes changing batteries, so 1.6 hours
so 4.2MPH * 1.6Hrs = 6.7 miles.
So why 7.6 miles? someone switched the digits!
here
Elijah Chancey www.elijahsadventure.com nomadic IT consultant, bicycling across america "all that you touch / and all
Build your own segway-imitation. Plans to appear on slashdot before the end of the year.
YOU HEARD IT HERE FIRST.
Mount Evans (in Colorado) has a paved road to it's peak, and tops out at over 14K. Sorry, Mt. Washington is not real impressive.
Hey guys, go easy! These guys are simply pushing the envelope of design constraints. It's like the cross-country solar car contest, no one is suggesting that cars will be 100% solar powered in the future, they're just demonstrating the power of solar power and creatively finding ways to do research.
The expedition wasn't to show that they could; everybody knew it was possible. It was to test how fast it could be done, in case rapid deployment were necessary to either side of the country(ala Blitzkrieg). That's why we now have an interstate system: defense. It allows us to very rapidly deploy in case Mother Russia strikes, wiping out our rail and everything else.
In fact, stretches of interstate have to meet certian specifications for landing of (large) aircraft, in the event that airbases are destroyed.
I was up at Mt. Rainier last month and saw a guy on a Segway powering up the mountain. He had an oxygen tank sitting on one of the wheels and had a tube running under his nose. He was already a few miles up when I saw him, I just hope that he had enough battery to get down. Maybe it charges it one the way down?
It's pretty cool that because of the Segway he was able to go to one of the most beautiful places on earth, which he wouldn't have been able to get to normally. It does help that the first few miles are paved from the base of Paradise.
And there is no "bitter cold".... The wild[sic] chill factor may make it seem frigid...
I think that the Segway has some interesting technology, but I also think that it is still "a solution looking for a problem". For the same weight in batteries, a simple foldable inline scooter could go much further at lower cost. The extra energy expenditure for balance gyros /motors is simply not needed to move ordinary people around on level surfaces...
That totally sucks ass.
Charles Bronson was a bad motherfucker, there's no denying it.
--
the strongest word is still the word "free"
I don't know about you but falling off at 12.5mph hurts enough for me. I'm an overweight, out-of-shape, round as a ball geek; I'd roll perty far if I fell off! ouch!
I don't want a pickle; I just want a Motor-Cycle! A four foot cop arrived with a five foot gun!
A RETIRED clown? He still sounds like a clown to me.
is Segway ever intended for climbing a hill 6,288-foot high? from what i remember it's for day-to-day city/urban commuting. imagine you hire a servant (for house-keeping) and require him to carry you to work by foot.
are just temporary of course - until someone creates the combustion-engined Segway Generator! That of course will last only a short while before the Segway Fuel Cell! But I'm going to hold out until I can run mine using the Segway Zero-point Energy Power Pack Extreme!
Don't look now, but "to beg the question" does not at all mean "to invite/ask for/provoke a question." Rather, it means to base a conclusion on the foundation that what is being discussed must be true, although such truth has not been established. In other words, circular logic. Put another way, you beg the question when you assume the truth of whatever it is you're trying to prove.
/. readers perpetuated the erroneous usage instead of correcting it? Not particularly, because A) This is /. and the standards are low, and B) The truly functionally illiterate are all over at http://www.forwardgarden.com/ (you probably don't want to know; if you go there anyway, don't say I didn't warn you :-)
/. karma actually means anything. That may shock some of you, but it's true. Uh-oh, now I'll get modded as a troll even more for daring to say such a thing :-)
"Bet the question" is an English translation from the Latin "petitio principii." Look it up.
Am I terribly disappointed that a number of
Of course, someone will probably mod me as a troll for having the temerity to point out blatantly incorrect English usage, but I don't care. It's not like
It remains unclear as to why Owen dressed up like a butler for the epic ride up Mount Washington. It surely won't help reduce the ridicule he receives from neighbors and friends. Perhaps he felt it lent a bit of dignity to the affair.
Is it just me or would it take an awful lot more than a butler's outfit to bring some dignity to a ride up a mountain on yuppie-gocarts organized by a retired clown?
"Winds were gusting from all sides and I had to stay down, just like skiing," Dick Norris, 69, a train conductor and fellow rider told the AP.
A train conductor? Good grief. Where are they getting these guys from?
Rob Owen, a retired clown, and two other riders surged up Mount Washington at 12.5 mph, the AP reports.
Okay, who wants to take a crack at guessing the career of the mysterious third rider? Former jet-setting CEO of a dot-com company who now works as the janitor in an adult bookstore? What about the dude who has to stamp "Inspected by #42" on all those pairs of underwear? Maybe it was Retired Machinist and A.A.P.B.-Certified Astrologer Lloyd Schumner Sr.?
The Register, huh? This is the kind of hard-hitting news I would expect CNN Headline News.
GMD
watch this
They used the AMERICAN system of measure why?
What if Segway, Honda and Microsoft (or the open source community) got together with WalMart to make the kind of retail robots that an earlier /. article
Distribution of Wealth in a Robot-Driven World talks about? It doesn't seem long before we start working 70 hour weekdays. AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!
That said, a segway is *perfect* for your average pot-head. I mean think about it. When the munchies sets in you can hop on your segway for a short cruise to the 7-11. It's a gentle ride. Also it's fast enough that you don't get distracted and forget why you hopped on in the first place, but slow enough that you don't get too bored.
They're all over Disney...I saw at least a couple dozen different people (I don't believe they were workers either). I am thinking they rent them?
Anybody?
See Dick astride his Segway. Dick loads up his Segway with his fat arse and many batteries. Dick is pushing the limit. Check out Dick as he scorches up the mountain. Dick is being passed by cars...and motorbikes...and bicycles...and wheelchairs (motorised and non-motorised)...and crawling infants...and tortoises...and slugs. Go, Dick go!
See Dick battle against the forces of nature. See Dick pummelled by 2km/h winds and inconvenienced by semi-chilly temperatures. Go, Dick go!
See Dick reach the summit. Watch Dick celebrate. Dick is pumped to the max.
Dick will be rewarded. Dick gets a bumper sticker and a story on slashdot. Dick is a hero. Dick is a dick.
"Get off the cross - we need the wood" - Tori Amos
I hate the Segway. 99% of the time a bicycle or one of those Xootr push scooters outperforms it using less energy at a fraction of the cost. I don't even have to go into the grotesque image created when someone rides a Segway, a picture will do:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/2989000.stm
Bush fails the Segway test
Inspired piece from usatoday columnist
Honestly, you know michael jackson is going to buy a fleet of them and lure kids to his playland to ride them.
The second largest consumer for this product is going to be the United States government - as it purchases them thru medicare and medicade with the vast billions earned on the taxpayers back.
makes me irritated just thinking about it. course, it also has its advantages. Perhaps I should become 'overbese', sprout 5 gangly children that bear no resemblance to the woman I am married to, and live off the government so that I can get one of those nifty little gadgets...so that I don't have to walk all the way to my new favorite gas station to purchase my new favorite hobby snack - cheap brand cigarettes.
Who is this that even the wind and the waves obey Him? Surely this computer must submit also!
recently segway had a demo of its products at an airshow near me and i got to try one out. they are very neat, they are not racals that for sure and i didnt have the thing in its higher speed key so i didnt get to run it its fastest.
there will be a new segway coming out soon (a smaller ighter version - 'son of segway' type thing that will be substantually cheaper) and the segway thats out now will go down in price.
members are seeing something, your seeing an ad
gets back $0.71 for every $1 it puts into the federal government. Put that in your pipe and smoke it, assclown.
Imagine a huge guy who stays on his computer for days on end.
One problem: The Segway is limited to a 250lb. user. That's big, but for a 6'-something man it's not huge. There are even a lot of professional NFL football players that exceed 250lbs and run the 40 yard dash in well under five seconds.
I could have defended my English errors with cries of "it's a living language!".
Seriously though, the fact that languages inevitably change over time does not mean it isn't worth putting in a little effort to maintain consistancy and specificity of a language.
Boffoonery - downloadable Comedy Benefit for Bletchley Park
It was an unintentional typo, rather than an attempt at witty wordplay.
Boffoonery - downloadable Comedy Benefit for Bletchley Park
and all of it's elitist owners who have nothing better to do than get dean press with cheap stunts.
Hmm...
...then *none* of the examples, even the "correct" one, meet that definition, as none of them offer a conclusion.
What "begs the question" in fact means is "to assume the truth of an argument or proposition to be proved, without arguing it"... A not-bad way of understanding this meaning is: You beg a question when you skip over a matter that's disputable.
All of the given examples (even the "incorrect" ones) are correct by that definition.
"Hey! Never mind publicising the blog, first prove that it's excellent!" "Hey! Never mind criticizing that other poem about hate, if you've got hate in your own work it invalidates that as a criticism!" "Hey! Never mind all the problems climbing the mountain on a Segway, first tell me why I shouldn't just use a motorbike!"
They're all completely grammatically correct. Just because "2blowhards.com" says something is incorrect grammar doesn't make it so. You may argue whether the assumptions are strong enough to actually "beg the question", but that's purely a matter of opinion and has nothing to do with the English language.
Of course, if you go by the definition given in the comments on the page...
The proper meaning of begging the question is 'basing a conclusion on an assumption that is as much in need of proof as the conclusion itself.' The formal name for this logical fallacy is petitio principii."
"We're going to publicize the hell out of this excellent blog" doesn't actually suggest any causal link between the blog being excellent and the fact that we're going to publicize it.
Look at it this way: "We're going to publicize the hell out of this long blog" is still a prefectly good statement, whereas "We're going to be publicize the hell out of this blog because it is long" begs some rather obvious questions.
Speaking of this - anybody working on porting Linux to the segway? Would enable all kinds of neat stuff - like wireless networking, built-in VoIP soft phone and IM client.
A little more web research finds that one can increase rotational responsiveness a bit by changing the key coding, but apparently the Segway ignores forward speed settings above the maximum allowable value. So you can set the speed value to "FF" if you want - and some have tried it, but you still get the same 12.5 as the next guy.
I play Nerd-Folk!
Walk, you insensitive clod.
Ride a motorbike up Mount Washington, hah, why not just clear cut the trees, quarry the granite, and build a Wal Mart where it used to be?
Watch this Heartland Institute video
As a maple syrup swilling squirrel worshiping New Hampshire resident, I have to say this annoys just as much as the "This car climbed Mt. Washington" bumper stickers. To hell with cars and segways, my legs climbed Mount Washington over terrain that would turn any land vehicle into a pile of smoldering rubble. They should have never put that bloody road up it...
It's sad when choosing an installation directory on your own qualifies you as an "advanced user."
38 pairs of fairly nice (~$130) hiking boots
a decent used car and the tank of gas
:)
Or.......
A nice used motorcycle that can go way faster than 12.5 mph!
Nope, don't know the guy, just getting an example...
"If there's hope, it lies in the proles..."
Man, they could have saved all that money on a segway and used it to get really high on the ground. :)
I am not commenting on the content of your entry, but on your use of the term, "begs the question." "Begging the question" is used in cases of circular reasoning when you "[t]ake for granted or assume the truth of the very thing being questioned." It is incorectly used in your case where you state that another choice, other than riding Segways, is a more practical and obviuos mode of transportation.
because it wouldn't get put on /.!
If you can drive a car to the top then what is the big deal? Also what is the deal with getting to the top, it is only 6288 feet. Where I currently live the elevation is approx 7500 feet and i am in a valley. (info I climbed Mt. Blanca (14,345 ft) a few weeks ago and i must say, it would be newsworthy if i saw a segway up there. The road up to como lake (around 10,000ft) is one of the hardest in the nation with few vehicles being able to get up to the lake (aside from ATV's, which still have problems)
Check it out, it works http://www.
since segways look like the old hand-pushed lawnmowers, they should just chuck in a set of blades into it and let the worthless piece-of-shit become useful by cutting the lawn.
that is really fuckin gay.
Scott
Because in that case, you won't be in slashdot, the register.
"Segway Riders Get High on Mount Washington"
Oooh.... *that* kind of high!
- "They misunderestimated me."
The world's first Segway tractor pull. Possibly. Though I can't help but feel that any Segway could be decimated by even the weediest competitor off Robot Wars.
First type: proud of what he/she is and focuses energies on interesting "geeky" stuff.
:) while the ones in the second group spend their time sneering about how geeks like themselves are supposedly too "dorky" to have a relationship.
Second type: would rather be fashionable and focuses his/her time on bashing everybody that isn't.
Funny, all the geeks I know in the first category have little problem getting dates (usually with others that enjoy the same interests
Personally, I find guys that are secure enough in their self-esteem/masculinity/whatever to ride a Segway or do other "dorky" things quite attractive/cool. That is why I am marrying that kind of guy, and have turned down the immature/insecure/vicious mudslinging kind constantly -- I want to be with an adult, not an oversized angsty teenage boy.
I've been trying to figure this out for ages. Granted, you can stand up on a Segway, while you have to sit on convential scooters, but what is so great about standing? Given my druthers, I would sacrifice the gyroscopes, add an extra wheel, and spend the $3000 I saved on a new state of the art laptop.
BTW. The Autobahn does predate the American Freeways, But Itay has the World's first Freeway. It was three lanes in total. The middle lane was for overtaking.
of course if Ashcroft's nephew was caught growing Mount Washingtons Hydroponically in his garage, he'd probably just get off on a good behaviour bond.
See here for more hypocracy
:)
because my father was killed by a clown when i was 5.
is that they don't work.
The German computer magazine c't once these such set-ups and the Pringles cans failed miserably.
They wrote that a open cable stump would do better.
However, coffee cans is a different story. They do in fact work. That's be cause their diameter is larger and thus make decent receivers. The Pringles cans are simply too small.
"and have turned down the immature/insecure/vicious mudslinging kind constantly "
I've noticed that adults never use the word "immature" when describing someone. More interestingly, the adults who do, tend to have emotional problems of some sort.
Not referring to you, of course.
" Stopping to swap out batteries, lunch breaks? Rest. Pissing. Falling over. Flat tires?"
These guys can't go a hour without a piss? Or a flat tire, or resting?
If this is your advocacy, please grab a rope and hang yourself. Honestly, do you think about what you type? Has your school failed so miserably that you can't think clearly? Are you so enamored of a stupid stunt that you'll defend anything?
So some guys climbed the hill in 2 1/2 hours on a Segway. I'm sure it was difficult. It's cold up there and the winds are fairly strong. I know this because I've run up the bloody thing. It took a lot less than 2 1/2 hours, so forgive me if I'm unimpressed. As for Segways in general, isn't America already lazy enough? A little walking isn't going to hurt. If a Segway can give a person freedom that they lacked before (due to age, injury, ect.) then I'm 100% for it. But for the rest of us, I'll let you in on a little secret. There's this amazing device on the market. It's a form of transportation that's even better than the Segway. It's lighter, cheaper, faster, and gives a rider more control. It's legal on roads, and can go just about anywhere... It's a fucking bicycle.
You brought it up :-)
the segway is still perfect for cities like new york and tokyo. seems that a lot of you who scoff at the segway live in auto-centered cities. to a person who commutes in an SUV everyday, something like this device must seem like a silly toy to be mocked. but to someone who lives in a city like new york and who commutes in the subway every day, it is still a cool thing. you would get there just about as fast, you would save a lot of money in tokens, and it is far more convenient than a bicycle. ever try cramming a bike through the revolving doors of your office building, jamming it into an elevator full of people, and then finding room in your cubicle to put it? not to mention the effort of doing which makes you completely sweaty--very professional.
then there's the security aspect that became clear after last week's blackout. nothing but a segway could have gotten you off manhattan as fast. cars couldn't move, and bikes weren't much better: the streets were so crowded cyclists wound up not doing much better than pedestrians. but from what i've seen of the segw
Do what you can, with what you have, where you are.
fought off 50 mph winds and battled bitter cold to reach the 6,288-foot mountain summit.
I did it on foot, up the second toughest trail on the mountain. Took 8 hours round trip. And these guys are "battling" bitter cold, riding on a machine going up a paved road. Excuse me if sympathy doesn't flow from me.
.... "it's there?"
The Segway is not intended to be a replacement for cars and motorcycles. It's intended to be a replacement for walking! The inventor's background is in medical devices, and IT was originally conceived as a wheelchair that put the user upright instead of sitting. This has advantages as most stores are layed out for standing, not sitting people.
"Freedom means freedom for everybody" -- Dick Cheney
The headline makes it sound like they're athletes or something. Yeah right.
< fx: ride of valkyries >
Hundreds of marines on Segways riding over the hill to repulse invasion of Ivan.
Niet! Comrade! They are trying to make us piss ourselves laughing!
It doesn't beg the question, it raises the question. Get it right. The following is an explanation of what begging the question means.
Fallacy Name:
Begging the Question
Alternative Names:
Petitio Principii
Category:
Fallacy of Weak Induction > Fallacy of Presumption
Explanation:
This is the most basic and classic example of a Fallacy of Presumption, because it directly presumes the conclusion which is at question in the first place. This can also be known as a "Circular Argument" - because the conclusion essentially appears both at the beginning and the end of the argument, it creates an endless circle, never accomplishing anything of substance. Other names include Circulus in Probando, Circulus in Demonstrando and Vicious Circle.
A good argument in support of a claim will offer independent evidence or reasons to believe that claim. However, if you are assuming the truth of some portion of your conclusion, then your reasons are no longer independent: your reasons have become dependent upon the very point which is contested. The basic structure looks like this:
1. A is true because A is true.
Well I've walked to the beach to get high a few times but climbing a mountain, that's insane! You'll probably eat all your food and end up dying on top of the mountain cause you're too lazy to come down. You'll also end up make a bong out of your oxygen tanks. I really don't think getting high and climbing mountains would mix very well...
6. It is something chicks dig and you actually have a slight chance of getting some action if you own one.
From excellent karma to terible karma with a single +5 funny post...
The Segway could not have been going 12 mph when it took over 2 1/2 hours to get to the top all told!!!! See this article.
The current human bicycle record up Mt. Washington is 49 minutes and change. Yes this is a professional cyclist, but the majority of people who get into the one day ride to the top make it in under 2 hours.
So your questions should not be, "Why not buy a motorbike?", but why not just buy a bike?!?!?!?!?!? It's cheaper, less maintenance cost, and with a set of panniers can make your weekly run to the store/work/play.
"All of which begs the question, why not buy a motorbike?"
Why, because it wouldnt get on slashdot of course! Who wants to hear about someone riding a motorbike up a mountain?!
You guys are way too hung up on delicate ecosystems. The footpaths in our National Park system ALREADY look like they're used by dump trucks. Arches is an exception. (HA HA that's a joke for those of you who haven't been there.)
I'm not saying they deserve to be abused, just that the system should be closed down if you are concerned about damage. Lots of it is years past the point of no return, like the perimeter of the Everglades where phosphate pollution has made cleanup a Sysyphus-like labor. (never able to be accomplished as in FUBAR)
The segway is nowhere near like a bicycle. It is more like a runner as far as impact goes. The primary market is going to be in countries with cities where foot traffic and bikes are the primary way of getting around and cars are for wealthy people. I really don't think it is going to be used in National Parks in the US by hordes of fat people. Also, please remember that you are the fat, lazy, rich people of tomorrow. (Another joke for the knee-jerk crowd.) Now let's get out there and let some mink loose in a department store!
Any preoccupation with ideas of what is right or wrong in conduct shows an arrested intellectual development. (Wilde)
A retired train conductor clown.
They should have got a helicopter ride to the top and then taken the segway down hill. They wouldn't need to change the batteries so much. In fact, because the thing does regenerative breaking they may have had an energy surplus. I'm not sure if those guys ever built in a place to dump excess power. ???
We've ruined our world by building roads to go to places we dont need to go.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_U.S._Election_c
Every year a couple of my elderly clients used to kill people with their cars just because they felt that they were entitled to drive. When it was a young person that was killed, it was particularly disturbing. But what the hell, that's what I got paid for, right? One of the old farts killed a pregnant girl a few years back. Another hit the side of a van and skidded it into another van sidewise. Unfortunately there was a lady in a wheelchair between them! Those are memorable examples. This stuff never hits the news unless tons of people get squished as in the greenmarket in Ca this summer.
Using the Segway would promote better balance and they wouldn't fall down all the time either. How did you like my Troll-like sub? Gotcha!
South Florida, where the incontinent meet the illiterate.
Any preoccupation with ideas of what is right or wrong in conduct shows an arrested intellectual development. (Wilde)
In fact, stretches of interstate have to meet certian specifications for landing of (large) aircraft, in the event that airbases are destroyed.
That is a myth.
What Would Jesus Do
(for a Klondike bar)?
Now if everyone was going around on flying segways that would be something to see... (thud... thud... from drunk segway drivers falling off thud )... well, or dodge at least.
This is my sig.
I'm sorry I'm just -not- impressed...
I'll assume that they got down again on their segways, though it's not explicitly stated..
But I've climbed Mt Washington on foot several times, from both sides.
As for the inclement weather that these two wthrough.. I don't think it's something to laud them for. It's easily avoidable if you watch the weather reports.
If you think you need a Segway, then you should not have one. This is a device for the dexterous, not the handicapped. On it, the handicapped are dangerous to everyone around them.
Question begging is circular reasoning, but leaving important questions unanswered. If you don't understand this, just stop using the expression. Another usage hint, when properly used, the phrase "begs the question" is almost always followed immediately by a period.
Having been up and down Mt. Washington, including a trip in our college's solar-electric car, I'm not sure that the Segway could make it down safely.
With no brakes and only a small battery pack to soak up regenerative braking, I'm fairly sure a trip back down the mountain would result in the scooter being reduced to a smoky, overheated ruin without very frequent stops with enough time to let it cool down.
Our solar car, with six car batteries hooked up in series, still got kind of warm even though we weren't near the car's full range. $0.25 worth of electricity on the way up, gained back $0.15 on the trip down with the regen brakes. Figure at least a nickel's worth of heat generation in the batteries and electrics on the trip down..
I think it's safe to say he packed the scooter into the back of the Beetle clown car for the trip back..
That one nailed you like 10 penny through a 2x4.
Or will you blame that on the assburger?
The segway is dead.
It is now for ever more locked in people's minds as "comedy transport" along with monocycles and pogosticks.
Does anyone know what Dean Kamen was thinking when he came up with this idea? What was his elevator pitch? "Americans have such a small country, take far too much physical exercise and hate driving cars - they will all jump at the chance to ride electrified sticks on wheels."
Oh yeash! What a fantastic ideah!
"And the meaning of words; when they cease to function; when will it start worrying you?"
Standing for half an hour is easier than walking for half an hour. Especially if the standing for half an hour gets you farther than the walking would. It's not viable for people who can't get around at all, but for people who just wear out quicker than normal, it makes more sense. Anyway, it costs too much for me to buy out of pocket yet, and my odds of convincing my health coverage to shell out for it are negligible... for now it's girl on foot or girl in chair... so in the meantime, anybody wanna downhill race? *grin*
"I'd say 'Have a good time,' but arson is still illegal.
duuuuuuuuude!
BIKE VILLAGES
bikes never need batteries, and will always be cheaper and simpler to build -- less to go wrong. why not build a village for bicycles. segway users would find it a great place to get around in if they so choose.
john
I have personally seen Dean flop over while on his contraption in a resturaunt in Manchester, NH, and it was the most hilarious thing I have ever witnessed.
I have also been up to Mount Washington many times, and I would just love to see how one of these guys controls the unit with the wind, next to the guardrails that protect you from a 1000 foot drop. The highest winds in the world were recorded up there.
All I can see in the current model is a device to make lazy people lazier.
Show me a flying segway, and then I will be impressed.
DISCLAIMER:
I don't believe what I write, and neither should you.
The poster is obviously a southerner. Perhaps from the Deep South, like NYC or DC.
It's summer, I bet the air temperature didn't even drop below freezing! Even with the wind chill, I'm sure it was still in the positives.
Weenies.
I have to disagree, I've seen two people using Segways recently that made a lot of sense.
The first was a utilities worker, who has to check gauges around downtown here in Seattle. I walked past him when the segway was stopped, and he was crouching down looking into the little door on the sidewalk. Moments later, he steppd onto the segway and whipped past me to the next point where he got off and did his job again. He used the handles of the segway like a belt, and had the tools of his trade hanging from it.
The second was the sanitation crew at the Pike Place Market, a sort of outdoor grocery, craft store, and food court. Two people, both on segways with their equipment hanging from the 'handlebars', this time pulling a little trailer holding trash. They looked very efficient, since 'cleanup opportunities' were somewhat spread apart among the different little niches where tables are found.
Makes a lot of sense for letter carriers as well, I would think.
I'll grant that $1000 is too much for personal use, but what happens when a segway costs the same as a bicycle? I'd ride one to work if I couldn't bike.
-Zipwow
I don't know which is more depressing, that 2/3 didn't care enough to vote, or that 1/2 of those that did are crazy.
I have a Segway. Have been trying to figure out how to hack it, but the buggers wrote their own OS or sump'n. Had to send it back to the factory once because of a short that caused random jerks to the right at high speeds sending the rider flying. Glad their machines didn't have this!