Slashdot Mirror


Linux Coming to the Nintendo DS

GamersZion writes "A recent IRC conversation with ChaosKnight, a member of the DS Linux development team, revealed information about the status of the DS Linux project. 'It was a bit tough to get the ball rolling, but with PassMe fully functional and everything starting to fall in order, I wouldn't be surprised to see an alpha release within the next month.' While little information is being revealed about the release of this anticipated software, it looks like we can be expecting it sometime in the short future."

187 comments

  1. Wait a minute... by EtherAlchemist · · Score: 5, Funny


    Paris Hilton isn't involved, is she?

    --
    R(k)
  2. Universal OS. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    "Linux Coming to the Nintendo DS"

    Maybe we should compile a short list of what Linux DOESN"T run on.

    1. Re:Universal OS. by wheany · · Score: 2, Funny

      I'm pretty sure it doesn't run on a piece of tofu.

    2. Re:Universal OS. by Lisandro · · Score: 5, Funny

      I'm pretty sure it doesn't run on a piece of tofu.

      Well, doh. You have NetBSD for that.

    3. Re:Universal OS. by Koiu+Lpoi · · Score: 2, Insightful

      It's going to be a very short list. Almost anything we call a 'computer' (and that is going to include almost all gaming systems) is going to run - the only challenges you have are a) getting it to compile on whatever processer you run b) all types of I/O, memory addressing, etc. there's enough geeks out there that we can have linux on pretty much anything. Give it a month, I expect Linux on the PSP as well. They've already got Linux on the Playstation 2, so I don't see it taking much time.

    4. Re:Universal OS. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's easy: just take the set of things that
      NetBSD runs on, and subtract the set of things
      that Linux will run on. What's left over is
      the (considerably large) set of things that
      linux can't run on.

    5. Re:Universal OS. by sp3tt · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      My brain.

    6. Re:Universal OS. by Rassleholic · · Score: 1

      Agreed. It actually kind of slogs along, leaving a minuature canyon of soybeany goodness behind it.

      --
      Not noteable, IMO a rubbish article.
    7. Re:Universal OS. by tonsofpcs · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I have yet to see either run on a TI calculator (z80 [82/83/84/85/86] or m68k [89, 92]). I don't think Linux runs on any Z80 [please correct me if I am wrong], so there goes my two TRS-80s (one model 3, one CoCo), and also my two Sharp 1500s (one 1500A, one 1500; these are the same as the TRS-80 PC-2s)

    8. Re:Universal OS. by zachetus · · Score: 2, Informative

      I think that for Elks (embeddable linux kernel) one target was z80, though i don't know did it actually never run on it, but least one unix port named Uzi is running on it.

    9. Re:Universal OS. by Ava3ar · · Score: 1

      afaik psp is run on linux, same as hte PS1/PSone, the PS2/PStwo, and hte soon to be released PS3/PSX

      --
      ¦^)= The Vengance Will Come =(^¦
    10. Re:Universal OS. by tonsofpcs · · Score: 1

      Unix != Linux
      Also, that is not a port, that is a rewrite. RTF-Link.
      Elks may still be targeting z80 based machines (note that each one is different, just as an m68k Amiga has a different kernel than an m68k Macintosh, so too would the TRS-80s require a different kernel than the TI Calculators, with a different one than my Nokia cellphone (yes, its a z80 also)), but it is not in development, and certainly is not implemented.

    11. Re:Universal OS. by Prod_Deity · · Score: 2, Informative

      The first PlayStation had the unoffical PSX, then they named the PlayStation media center PSX,.

      http://www.psx.sony.co.jp/

      So the PS3 will be just, PS3.

    12. Re:Universal OS. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Runs Linux? Where's the source then? I want to see how there device works. Gotta love the GPL in action! Kiss IP goodbye!

    13. Re:Universal OS. by aichpvee · · Score: 0, Redundant

      You sir are an idiot.

      --
      The Farewell Tour II
    14. Re:Universal OS. by setagllib · · Score: 1

      Wrong. They would have to modify it, and hence release the sources (as per GPL). Since there are no sources and no admitting they did so, none of those products have Linux. On the other hand, it does have things from NetBSD in hardware and software (see http://www.feyrer.de/NetBSD/blog.html - search 'PS2' (gets you an XIII-related piece) and 'Playstation' (the latter being the PSP itself). I say this because linking to these from Slash seems to break.

      I guess I should ask you, is blind zealous ignorance bliss?

      --
      Sam ty sig.
    15. Re:Universal OS. by wh00dini · · Score: 0

      it doesn't run on my laptop.

  3. See... by Simon+Garlick · · Score: 5, Funny

    ...THAT'S what Debian needs to get its release schedule back on track. Project leaders with names like "ChaosKnight".

  4. Welll.... by Enjoi · · Score: 3, Funny

    If they can get it on an NT Kernel, they can get it on anything :P

  5. WooHoo!! by deggy · · Score: 4, Insightful

    If I could run an ssh client and a web browser on a DS with a wireless connection i'd go out and buy one tomorrow!!

    1. Re:WooHoo!! by gameboyhippo · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I would very much like to see an X server run on the DS. With the touchscreen, it would make a very nice PDA

    2. Re:WooHoo!! by jvalenzu · · Score: 1

      No it wouldn't. It would make a very terrible PDA. "Well, I can't store addresses or appointments or anything, but I have a great vt100 emulator. Oh wait, no keyboard." On top of that you'd look like an idiot taking it out in meetings.

    3. Re:WooHoo!! by G-Licious! · · Score: 1

      Dasher (or something like it?) might be helpful.

    4. Re:WooHoo!! by Mignon · · Score: 2, Informative
      The ZipIt might be more what you're looking for. It's a wifi-enabled, Linux-powered, IM client that some folks have figured out how to get a custom filesystem onto. There's already lots of interest in ssh and web clients, but one limiting factor is how much memory it has.

      But US$100 sounds pretty nifty.

  6. Great! by Lisandro · · Score: 4, Funny

    Now i can play all these great gam--oh, wait...

    Just kidding. It's cool, and it might open a door to extend the DS functionality beyond a gaming platform. More like a small PDA, perhaps? It even has the touchpad!

    1. Re:Great! by mrseigen · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Well, Linux definitely has more games than the DS at this point. What a completely dismal line-up.

    2. Re:Great! by Jace+of+Fuse! · · Score: 5, Interesting

      Ignoring that Mario 64 is still a great game (and still fun, even if dated), I wonder how it is some people seem to ignore the fact that there are still countless great GBA games that will play on a DS.

      Even if they are ignored for simply not being specifically for the DS, that's still more good games than are available for the PSP.

      In fact, I personally only really consider Lumines to be the only good game for the PSP. I can't play my copy though. I've had to return NINE PSPs for being defective (in several different ways) and am currently now without a PSP.

      --

      "Everything you know is wrong. (And stupid.)"

      Moderation Totals: Wrong=2, Stupid=3, Total=5.
    3. Re:Great! by Evangelion · · Score: 1


      FYI, the Rez / Lumines creator has a game coming out in the US for the DS (it's been out in Japan for a while) called Meteos. If you want the japanese version, you can import it from lik-sang.

    4. Re:Great! by geminidomino · · Score: 1

      I wonder how it is some people seem to ignore the fact that there are still countless great GBA games that will play on a DS.

      My guess would be that, like myself, most people who know how many great GBA games there are already have a GBA to play them on

      Honestly, there's just not a hell of a lot either of the two new handhelds have to offer me.

    5. Re:Great! by Jace+of+Fuse! · · Score: 1

      Honestly, there's just not a hell of a lot either of the two new handhelds have to offer me.

      I felt the same way. I already had a GBA and an SP. Then I played the 4 player battle in Mario 64 and was hooked. There are more than 10 people where I work who regularly duke it out before, durring (on break of course), and after work. Plus replaying Mario 64 seemed like a chore I didn't want to get into but I found myself playing it through again and realizing why I liked it so much. 150 stars later I finally decided it really was/is a great game, and the added features made the game worthy of a replay even almost 10 years later.

      Those of my co-workers who never played the original thoroughly loved playing Mario 64 through to the end, and some of them are still working on it. I figure this is probably the case for many people. Many people missed out on Mario 64, and this is their second chance to see what made this game so great.

      And for what it's worth, Yoshi Touch And Go is so unique (and actually fun) that while I was skeptical at first, I have actually found myself playing it more than I expected I would. It's not just that it's a unique control concept, but the fact that it's really just good addictive fun that keeps me playing it.

      --

      "Everything you know is wrong. (And stupid.)"

      Moderation Totals: Wrong=2, Stupid=3, Total=5.
    6. Re:Great! by Jace+of+Fuse! · · Score: 1

      THANKS for the pointer! I really liked REZ and I really do like Lumines. In fact, Lumines is the very reason I haven't totally given up on the PSP. I would have kept trying, but the Wal-mart stores I kept buying/returning the systems to ran out of stock due to people returning them. The stores in my area must have all gotten a bum-batch. Every one of them has annoyingly visible dead pixels, fingerprints inside the screens, dust inside the screens, missing or broken Memory-Slot doors, and other such obvious reasons for exchange.

      I will definately have to pick up Meteos.

      --

      "Everything you know is wrong. (And stupid.)"

      Moderation Totals: Wrong=2, Stupid=3, Total=5.
    7. Re:Great! by shirai · · Score: 3, Interesting

      I know you were being funny, but this does open up the door for potentially running MAME (Multiple Arcade Machine Emulator). The DS is an interesting platform for this since the lower screen could be used to insert quarters, push Player 1/2 start buttons, etc.

      Of course, I'd really be wanting this on the PSP with its gorgeous screen (if you own one, you know what I'm talking about). Since it has a memory card (better to hold games with) it would probably be the better overall MAME platform. I'm getting excited just thinking about it.

      --
      Sunny

      Be my Friend

    8. Re:Great! by Lisandro · · Score: 1

      Oh, we can only hope. I know i'm not the only one who preffers to play old games than 90% of the news tuff - be it MAME, ScummVM, VICE, old console games or whatever.

    9. Re:Great! by geminidomino · · Score: 1

      Eh, no one I know plays many video games, so multiplayer is just a non-issue.

      If I decided to get a DS for some other reason, then I would probably pickup Mario 64, but not just FOR that game.

    10. Re:Great! by idlake · · Score: 3, Informative

      Get an Archos PMA-400; similarly gorgeous screen, it runs Linux out of the box, and it doesn't use any proprietary disks.

    11. Re:Great! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Fair enough, but it doesn't play PSP games does it?

      Also, in terms of market penetration, the PSP will kick ass once it gets underway.

    12. Re:Great! by radish · · Score: 1

      I've had to return NINE PSPs for being defective

      Wow. I've personally bought 4 PSPs (1 jap import, 3 US models) and they've all been fine. You must have caught a bad batch. What were the faults?

      --

      ---- Den ene knappen er powerknapp, den andre er Bender voice knapp "Bite My Shiny Metal Ass"

    13. Re:Great! by notque · · Score: 4, Insightful

      In fact, I personally only really consider Lumines to be the only good game for the PSP. I can't play my copy though. I've had to return NINE PSPs for being defective (in several different ways) and am currently now without a PSP.

      Without the exceedingly high cost, and the overwhelming complaints, I'd bu... Oh, and the lack of good launch titles, the company not being particularly willing to replace defective products,

      I'd love to own a PSP.

      Did I mention the absolutely insane cost of a 1 gig memory chip?

      --
      http://use.perl.org
    14. Re:Great! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Even if they are ignored for simply not being specifically for the DS, that's still more good games than are available for the PSP.

      Bull shit. You'd have to be miyamoto himself to think DS has more good games than DS. Even the gamefaqs troll population agrees PSP has more good games

    15. Re:Great! by Gyorg_Lavode · · Score: 1

      at $800 and unable to play psp games I'd think it isn't the best solution.

      --
      I do security
    16. Re:Great! by galaxy300 · · Score: 1

      Yeah, Meteos is going to save the DS for me. I'm getting pretty tired of playing all of my old GBA games, and I honestly haven't found anything much worth playing for the new system. Mario DS has failed to grab my attention, and this is coming from someone who *LOVED* the original.

      Meteos is supposed to be amazing. I can't wait.

    17. Re:Great! by CastrTroy · · Score: 1

      I saw a guy buying a PSP today. They tried to sell him the warranty, Because Sony only gives it a 3 month warranty. This is why I will never buy a playstation or an xbox. If the manufacturer only expects it to last for 3 months, then I won't buy it. That's why I got a Gamecube. Comes with a 12 month warranty. Which in my mind is still pretty bad, but it's the best console warranty out there.

      --

      Anthropic principle: We see the universe the way it is because if it were different we would not be here to see it.
    18. Re:Great! by Hast · · Score: 1

      Nice attempt at a flamebait, but quite boring.

      Please try to say something new instead of just parroting others.

      With a few years of practice you may get good at flamebaiting.

    19. Re:Great! by notque · · Score: 1

      Nice attempt at a flamebait, but quite boring.

      What makes it even better is that I didn't even try! Go me!

      Please try to say something new instead of just parroting others.

      No. I don't intend on spending time reading everyone elses posts to make sure no one has said what I said.

      I said it, I meant it.

      I really want one, but I will not buy one.

      With a few years of practice you may get good at flamebaiting.

      Is that how it works for trolling too?

      --
      http://use.perl.org
    20. Re:Great! by mallie_mcg · · Score: 1

      If I decided to get a DS for some other reason, then I would probably pickup Mario 64, but not just FOR that game.

      If they refresh-released Super Mario 3 - Warioland (was for the original gameboy) that is one game that I would purchase a DS for, it was the most addictive game I ever played and conquered solo.

      --


      Do the following really mean anything? SCSA MCP CCSA CCNA
      --I'm not actually after an answer!
    21. Re:Great! by NanoGator · · Score: 1

      "Without the exceedingly high cost, and the overwhelming complaints, I'd bu... Oh, and the lack of good launch titles, the company not being particularly willing to replace defective products,

      I'd love to own a PSP.

      Did I mention the absolutely insane cost of a 1 gig memory chip?"


      I can honestly say I'm none-too-hot on the PSP. But I think Nintendo did make a brilliant move. The GameCube uses roughly the same size discs as the PSP. Maybe in a year or two we'll get a portable Game Cube? Successor to the GBA?

      This might be less exciting by then if PSP has a stellar library. But... I dunno. I like the idea of a portable system that plays the main console's games. One of the things that stinks about portable games is their $30 price tag. Usually that results in lower production values, if you know what I mean.

      --
      "Derp de derp."
    22. Re:Great! by idlake · · Score: 1

      I think it is a far better solution than the PSP: it plays arbitrary MPEG4 movies, there are far more games for it than for the PSP (both native and emulated), and you can use it as a super-light laptop and USB disk as well.

    23. Re:Great! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The PSP will still only run a few proprietary games. With a handheld Linux machine, you get huge numbers of games (both native and emulated), in addition to all the other things you can do with it.

    24. Re:Great! by james_r_boyer · · Score: 0

      Actually sony's warranty is a year in the US

    25. Re:Great! by Jace+of+Fuse! · · Score: 1

      Ranked from most common faults to least common faults, all nine had at least one of the following, most had more than one.

      1. Dead Pixels (Glaringly obvious, solid white, prominantly displayed near center of screen).
      2. Dust INSIDE the display.
      3. Fingerprints INSIDE the display.
      4. A few had fingerprints on the outside, fresh out of the sealed box. This would normally not be an issue since it could be cleaned, but the fingerprints seemed to have been some kind of thick oil or other residue that could not easily be wiped off. Any attempt to clean it off resulted in scratching or etching the surface of the PSP.
      5. A few had Memory-Stick doors that broke off easily or were hanging loose (wouldn't close and stay closed) right out of the box.

      It is my theory that all of the stores in my area recieved PSPs from the same factory, manufacture date, and possibly even say consecutive batch.

      --

      "Everything you know is wrong. (And stupid.)"

      Moderation Totals: Wrong=2, Stupid=3, Total=5.
    26. Re:Great! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      agreed i would kill to get a PsP considoring that everytime i go to my game store i talk to them and have even proposed to one before i was told that i was scareing customers....but the fact that I'm hearing sooo many complaints about it kinda saddens me

    27. Re:Great! by kippers · · Score: 1

      The DS is great in my opinion, it has some cool features and I think it way beets the PSP. The fact GBA games work on it too really adds to the posibilitys, I can't wait for linux to come to DS, should be wicked.

    28. Re:Great! by geminidomino · · Score: 1

      If it will actually PLAY GCN games, rather than YaPF games, then I will be on that like star trek geeks on Jeri Ryan.

    29. Re:Great! by speeDDemon+(nw) · · Score: 1

      Here in Australia I think it is against the law to offer less than a 1 year warranty.. but im no lawyer, so pinch of salt time

    30. Re:Great! by M.C.+Hampster · · Score: 1

      My GameCube has taken such a beating by my two kids, and it has had zero problems so far. I find it strange hearing about all the issues that my friends and family have with their PS2's and XBox's. I know it's completely anectodal, but it just seems that Nintendo really knows how to build stuff that lasts.

      --
      Forget the whales - save the babies.
  7. I thought the article said... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    ... Nintendo DS Coming to Linux.

    D'oh!

    1. Re:I thought the article said... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Screen Shot? - It isn't quite "Linux", but it IS for the DS, and known as "DarkStar"

  8. We're Back by numbware · · Score: 5, Funny

    Now I KNOW we are back to regular Slashdot. Attempts to run Linux on everything solid. :)

    -Justin

    --
    I'm going to go create my own technology news site, with blackjack and hookers. You know what? Forget the news site.
    1. Re:We're Back by Ford+Prefect · · Score: 4, Funny

      Now I KNOW we are back to regular Slashdot. Attempts to run Linux on everything solid. :)

      Actually, I recently managed to install Linux on a cubic metre of fresh air. I'd take photos, but it admittedly looks a bit unimpressive...

      --
      Tedious Bloggy Stuff - hooray?
    2. Re:We're Back by B3ryllium · · Score: 1

      Well, I'll tell ya one thing - that air ain't fresh any more.

      Some Linux installation. Pfft.

    3. Re:We're Back by mattgorle · · Score: 1

      Does this open up new possibilities for compression?

      "Linux... UNDER PRESSURE!"

      --
      Slackware user since 1997.
    4. Re:We're Back by rishistar · · Score: 1

      Why don't you put it in front of the Tower of London. That would make an impressive backdrop even if the thing itself isn't so good to look at.

      --
      Professor Karmadillo Songs of Science
    5. Re:We're Back by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually, I recently managed to install Linux on a cubic metre of fresh air. I'd take photos, but it admittedly looks a bit unimpressive...

      But what's that in attoparsecs?

    6. Re:We're Back by orkysoft · · Score: 1

      Nah, put it in front of that copyrighted park sculpture in Chicago!

      --

      I suffer from attention surplus disorder.
    7. Re:We're Back by TheoMurpse · · Score: 1

      Well, if we could compile on a different architecture, we could have Linux Farts! Or should I stay Damn Smelly Linux?

      OK, I give up. But I still think a China-slanted OS should be called FreeMSG.

    8. Re:We're Back by NanoGator · · Score: 1

      "Actually, I recently managed to install Linux on a cubic metre of fresh air. I'd take photos, but it admittedly looks a bit unimpressive..."

      The stupid thing about that project is the lack of interface. I mean, what can we possibly do with only the characters 2, O, and H?

      --
      "Derp de derp."
    9. Re:We're Back by geminidomino · · Score: 1

      Err... that's water. Air also has a majority percentage of N ;)

  9. wait a sec... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    Linux on Nintendo DS?

    Knock it off....April Fools was yesterday.

    We all know there is no such thing as a Nintendo DS

  10. just wondering... by weavermatic · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Why do you people want to put linux on everything under the sun?

    1. Re:just wondering... by Lisandro · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Because they can? Let the nerds be happy i say.

    2. Re:just wondering... by aklix · · Score: 1

      I think it's more of the challenge that drives us to it.

      Either that or a group of people get really bored.

    3. Re:just wondering... by aslate · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Because it might actually be useful?

      Set up the DS with a browser, use the wireless to get on the internet, the touchscreen would make a great way to navigate the net or type. You could turn it into a PDA of sorts.

    4. Re:just wondering... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      To demonstrate the diverse flexability of our favorite OS. Because It is fun and educational, and we solve problems in the process that are useful in real world applications. and because we are able to do so (and you are probably not), in a word, ego.

      why does anybody do anything beyond the daily ritual: eat, shit, pay taxes; (wash rince repeat)?

    5. Re:just wondering... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Because we can and because you can't.

    6. Re:just wondering... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Doesn't this guy remind us of Tom from Office Space?

      Well, look, I already told you. I deal with the goddamn customers so
      the engineers don't have to!! I have people skills!! I am good at
      dealing with people!!! Can't you understand that?!? WHAT THE HELL IS
      WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE?!!!!!!!

    7. Re:just wondering... by WrongSizeGlass · · Score: 1

      Because it doesn't require a TPS report.

    8. Re:just wondering... by tofucubes · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      well there's this crazy team of black hats called microsoft or M$ and they make very contagious viruses (aka features) and they release them in waves (i.e. windows ME, windows 98)...
      anyway linux is being used to protect everything from M$'s contagious diease. It's like sun block for skin cancer. It's there but not everyone uses it.

      --
      Some people believe 1-1=3 and for the sake of being politically correct, we should respect their differences
    9. Re:just wondering... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Because they have way too much time on their hands. Not enough porn as a young child.

    10. Re:just wondering... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Because they need to find new rules to break. Violating the licenses of standard OSes gets boring, so you must apply it to every device so you're violating all potential licenses...

    11. Re:just wondering... by Deliveranc3 · · Score: 1

      People are talking about the psp, but I thinkt there are three critical issues to remove this.

      First price, open source should be developed for cheap platforms, PC Game modders should consider game pricing stuff like that.

      Second Usability, stylus, no one wants to type with the square buttong (sticky? cough).

      Third software interface, though PSP has a memcard DS has 1 gigbyte GBA carts writable cheap.

    12. Re:just wondering... by EvilSporkMan · · Score: 1

      Keeps us in practice cracking new architectures so we have a fighting chance against Trusted Computing et al.

      --
      -insert a witty something-
    13. Re:just wondering... by streamscape · · Score: 1

      Because it might actually be useful?
      Still doesn't really answer the question ... if you want a PDA, get a PDA!
      If all the effort devoted to these hobbyist projects were aimed at commercially viable projects, Linux might stand more of a chance in the mainstream.

    14. Re:just wondering... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Wrong!

      Unfortunately, it is 1Gigabit not byte, so divide by 8.

      1024/8=128MB

    15. Re:just wondering... by Jozer99 · · Score: 1

      Since it has such dinky screens, you could display the website on the top one, and have all the navigation stuff on the bottom touch screen. That would free up precious pixels for displaying the website (trust me, even then it would not be pleasant, the DS screens are lower res than Pocket PCs.

    16. Re:just wondering... by aslate · · Score: 1

      I've got a DS, i like playing games on it and that's great. I have neither the money nor the use of a PDA, i wouldn't use it most of the time and it would be a gross waste of my money.

      Now if i am able to run a few things on my DS, like browse the net, check my email etc., great! It's another use for a product that i will use.

      If all the effort devoted to these hobbyist projects were aimed at commercially viable projects, Linux might stand more of a chance in the mainstream.
      And isn't that the point of it? To be a hobby, something people do on the side because they find it fun? Are they people that care about Linux being mainstream, or care about using and adapting it to new things that they find enjoyable? People have other things to do, i doubt the people that do this have the time to try and make something commercially viable.

    17. Re:just wondering... by NanoGator · · Score: 1

      "Why do you people want to put linux on everything under the sun?"

      I don't mind that so much, but what does drive me nuts is when people go apeshit when a computing product comes out designed NOT to have Linux run on it. I'd be more impressed if they did it with some sort of goal in mind they actually intend to achieve.

      With that said, though, there is some reason behind it. Running Linux means custom apps. If there's some cheap way a programmer can make something he's done more useful, eh I can sort of go along with that. Somebody earlier mentioned wanting to run Linux on the DS so he could use it to wirelessly SSH into his computers. Frankly, I'd think he was nutty except he'd save $100 to buy a PocketPC or Palm to do it.

      I agree, sometimes it's just plain silly. But, once in a while (like in this case), it can actually mean doing something cool and doing it more cheaply than you could otherwise. Right now I'm itching for a $150'ish wireless device with a touch screen that I can do email and Instant Messaging with. If that hack comes out on the DS, you can bet I'll whip out my CC. I'd have games to play, too! Wee!

      --
      "Derp de derp."
    18. Re:just wondering... by NanoGator · · Score: 1

      "People are talking about the psp, but I thinkt there are three critical issues to remove this.... Second Usability, stylus, no one wants to type with the square buttong (sticky? cough)."

      Ugh. I agree. I can't believe that people were screaming "Gimmick!" with the DS's touch screen, then turned right around and said it was cool that the PSP does web browsing.

      I will say this on behalf of the PSP, though, its screen is over 400 pixels wide. The DS is around 250. From a screen point of view, the PSP would be a much more desirable device for that purpose. But from an input point of view, the DS wins hands down.

      Maybe I need to turn in my nerd license, but I'm just having a trouble sporting an underwear tent over either system wirelessly web browsing. Maybe I'm just spoiled because I have a TabletPC.

      --
      "Derp de derp."
    19. Re:just wondering... by Deliveranc3 · · Score: 1

      I bought a DS with no games... waiting for some decent software to hit. I thought someone would port Skype or an equivalent over right away and I could pick up a custom loaded cart to get it working.

      Nothing the linux community has really dropped the ball this time, there is a squad working on it but they seem to be jackasses. We need a second squad.

    20. Re:just wondering... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well not just under the Sun. I think Linux runs well on other solar systems also. Thanks for the idea.

    21. Re:just wondering... by Okita · · Score: 1

      I'm running Linux on my Xbox right now, I use it to watch movies, and I recently wrote my thesis on it with LaTeX. It also happens to play XBox games when I feel the need. I suppose you're going to tell me I should have bought a PC with a shiny box of Windows Media Center Edition or something else "commercially viable"?

      The point is I buy things that do cool stuff; with Linux, I can make them do MORE cool stuff. Sinking money and effort into owning appliances that only do one thing is sometimes not the best solution for everyone, just because it is for you.

      Funny that you should mention "commercially viable," aren't PDAs losing market share to multitasking cellphones/laptops?

    22. Re:just wondering... by fvwmfan · · Score: 1

      "If all the effort devoted to these hobbyist projects were aimed at commercially viable projects, Linux might stand more of a chance in the mainstream."

      Three points come to mind.

      1. GNU/Linux is doing well in the mainstream. The desktop paradigm is living on borrowed time, and that is the only place that Windows dominates. GNU/Linux has a strong presence in lots of areas (embedded devices right through to supercomputers) and in some areas has a good-sized chunk of the pie. Microsoft is mainstream on the desktop and just about nowhere else. When people finally stop focusing on the desktop, they will find GNU/Linux everywhere. Remember when UNIX first evolved? There was maybe one computer in the organisations for everyone to use. That meant that UNIX needed to be multi-user and network-smart right from day one. Also, you didn't have a GUI to restrict you, so it there was a strong emphasis on scripting. Then the masses discovered computers in the form of stand-alone, single-user machines and all the strengths of UNIX became invisible for a while. Now we have multiple computers for every person, networks of embedded devices, PDAs and phones that require access to internet services (using BSD socket technology). Looks like we have come full circle. GNU/Linux is in its element again. On top of which, it has matured a lot by its neccessary focus on desktop applications and GUI interfaces. Microsoft may seem like an unstoppable monster on the desktop at the moment, but in the bigger picture it has many things going against it. It has yet to pass the test of time, for example.

      2. Computer-savvy people like using *nix, enjoy hacking it, enjoy tinkering with it - and have done for decades. The GNU project made this possible for anyone by providing Free-as-in-Freedom OS and tools, and the Linux kernal provided a Free-as-in-Freedom kernal. For me, the fact that GNU/Linux (or NetBSD) is available on so many platforms is a reminder about how cool UNIX is, as well as sign of the underlying strength of the original design. People do this for the pleasure of it. That says something. Just imagine an article about someone porting Windows XP to - well anything. Who would want to? What have you got for your effort? On the other hand, there are dozens of ports of Unix - both community based and proprietory, and on dozens of architectures and platforms. Again, that says something.

      3. I think it really does help GNU/Linux advocacy that GNU/Linux runs on gaming systems like this. The more systems that we can say - oh, GNU/Linux runs on that, the more people get to hear about it. Lots of people own these systems, have them at home. Eventually everyone not only hears about GNU/Linux, but understands that it is amazingly portable and adaptable. That is a good thing.

      That might really be four points, I don't mind.

      I know it didn't address your point about buying a PDA, but I still think it's relevant.

  11. \.-ed by IorDMUX · · Score: 0

    This early on a Satruday and it's already down? Shouldn't most of you be sleeping now?

    --
    >> Standing on head makes smile of frown, but rest of face also upside down.
    1. Re:\.-ed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      Backslashdotted ! Now that is evil !

    2. Re:\.-ed by pegr · · Score: 1

      This early on a Satruday and it's already down?

      No, it's worse than that...

      "We are currently experiencing server difficulties, please remain calm as they are being resolved."

      Kicking a server when it's down... Have you no shame CowboyNeil? ;)

  12. In other News... by big_groo · · Score: 5, Funny
    From the dept-of-craptastic-journalism-dept

    "A recent IRC conversation with *insert_generic_nic_here*, a member of the Link_goes_here development team, revealed information about the status of the *instert_name* project. 'It was a bit tough to get the ball rolling, but with *insert_function* fully functional and everything starting to fall in order, I wouldn't be surprised to see an alpha release within the next month.' While little information is being revealed about the release of this anticipated *insert_something*, it looks like we can be expecting it sometime in the short future."

    I for one can't wait!

    1. Re:In other News... by kclittle · · Score: 1
      And of course, use of this template must be instantiated TWICE within three hours on /. using the exact same parameters -- dups are *required*.

      --
      Generally, bash is superior to python in those environments where python is not installed.
    2. Re:In other News... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Coming soon to Slashdot: "A recent IRC conversation with CmdrTaco, a member of the Slashdot website and Slash development team, revealed information about the status of the dupe checker project. 'It was a bit tough to get the ball rolling, but with dupe checking fully functional and everything starting to fall in order, I wouldn't be surprised to see an alpha release within the next month.' While little information is being revealed about the release of this anticipated dupe checker, it looks like we can be expecting it sometime in the short future."

  13. How much hardware will they figure out? by PxM · · Score: 1, Informative

    There is still very little known information about the cool hardware features like the touchpad, WiFi, etc. While they (the hacker community in general) have figured out how to tweak things like model data in Metroid Prime, they still haven't figured out how to get the WiFi to work fully. Based on what is currently known the DS doesn't support IPv4 or any public protocols on a higher layer than OSI Layer 2. This means it might still be a while before someone gets a working web browser or telnet client on the DS. However, given the amount of hacks available for the GBA, I'm confident that they'll figure out all the cool tricks pretty soon. Then I won't have to worry about buying a PDA and I'll have an excude for having "using" my DS during work.

    --
    Want a free Nintendo DS, GC, PS2, Xbox. (you only need 4 referrals)
    Wired article as proof

    1. Re:How much hardware will they figure out? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yo, spamming ain't cool. Knock that off, biatch!

      Or you'll face the wrath of
      Huuzaaah!

  14. What are people doing with their exotic Linuxes? by Dancin_Santa · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I am not going to rain on these guys' parade, I think that they ought to do whatever floats their boat. If hacking Linux onto the DS is their "thing", more power to them.

    But I wonder what people are doing with their exotic Linux installations. Linux on the PS2, on a toaster, on the blender, etc. What are these used for besides showing off? Is there some real-life application to having Linux on these things?

  15. Great!-Breakin-in is hard to do. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "Just kidding. It's cool, and it might open a door to extend the DS functionality beyond a gaming platform. More like a small PDA, perhaps? It even has the touchpad!"

    At least people will have a nice telnet client to log into their locked-up Linux machines.

  16. Re:mmh by maxwell+demon · · Score: 1

    Bah, I want Linux on the toast!

    --
    The Tao of math: The numbers you can count are not the real numbers.
  17. culture jamming by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    1) Buy a DS
    2) Carefully remove shrink Wrap
    3) Install linux on DS
    4) Put a very tiny mark on the packaging then place shrink wrap back on DS
    5) Return DS to store so they can restock it on the shelves

    - SJ53

    1. Re:culture jamming by iced_773 · · Score: 1

      6) Send in one of the last Best Buy rebates*
      7) Profit!!!

      *Assuming you bought your DS at Best Buy

    2. Re:culture jamming by cgenman · · Score: 1

      How would this be different than, say, buying a Vaio, installing Linux on it, configuring KDE to look like Windows at a cursory glance, and returning it?

      Hey, that's not a bad idea. Thanks! Now I've got a project for the weekend.

  18. This is great by MemoryDragon · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Add to that the opie project and you get a fully functional pda...

  19. Re:What are people doing with their exotic Linuxes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Well, all that unused sexual energy has to go *somehwere*! I mean, it not like there are actually girls available...

  20. Hmm by Sv-Manowar · · Score: 3, Interesting

    It seems the PSP is not the only handheld that is being developed on now, this is great news for nintendo fans, as the buzz about the psp "web browser" and other modifications had the posibility to increase market share dramatically for the psp

    If stuff like this comes out for the DS, it will put both the consoles on a more even playing field for sales, and therefore neither will be favoured by games producers as much.

    1. Re:Hmm by FLAGGR · · Score: 1

      Uh the psp isnt being homebrewed yet. There was a DS emulator out before the DS was :P (Okay, it was all based on assumptions, but still!) Check out the psp-linux.org forums. Those people are too stupid to get anything running on the psp :P The only hope for psp dev is if the DS gets finished off and all of the people involved with it give the psp a shot.

  21. Uses by Primal_theory · · Score: 1, Interesting

    Real life uses for Linux on teh DS:

    1: Homebrew game environment...this would allow people to make games for the version of linux that the ds is running on, instead of having to hard code everything in the ds language, you could just use the linux commands

    2: Palm Capablities: Think about it! Internet browser, Calculator, Contact manager, 2 large screens, wireless....+ games

    3: I want linux on my ds, it would be cool because i guess with some heavy programming, you could eventually "hijack" other ds's and put whatever you want on them or somthing

    4: Its not windows

    --
    Your skill in reading has increased by one point!
  22. warwalking by bird603568 · · Score: 1

    If you put kismet on that I don't think anybodu would notice it. Think about the potential. Instead of using a pda and surfing it just looks like your playing DS.

  23. I need Linux by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    Running my vibrator. I want it cooing sweet things to me with excellent uptime.

    GET. IT. DONE. NOW.

    1. Re:I need Linux by hazah · · Score: 1

      lol

  24. The coup-de-grace by Anonymous+Luddite · · Score: 0

    Does Cowboyneal hate these guys or what?

    I clicked the DS Linux link, and the first thing I read is:

    Server Problems (Started at March 8 2005, 05:56 PM)

    We are currently experiencing server difficulties, please remain calm as they are being resolved.


    I'm guessing a sick server won't handle slashdotting very well...

    1. Re:The coup-de-grace by Narishma · · Score: 1

      The server was probably running on a Nintendo DS.

      --
      Mada mada dane.
  25. Maybe I should tell this to my friends. by Patrick+Mannion · · Score: 0, Redundant

    There's too kids at my school, maybe I should bribe them into installing DS Linux. Because I know I'm not getting a DS for a while.

    --
    In America, you spam computers In Soviet Russia, computers spam you!
  26. Re:Wrong platform |Fake signature by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    if you ever get those consoles from your FAKE SIGNATURE (IE its apended to the message , thus its offtopic ) you can install linux on them.
    Spam stops at home , dont propigate it

  27. Re:What are people doing with their exotic Linuxes by marsu_k · · Score: 4, Funny

    The DS has built-in WLAN. You could be running ettercap while everyone will assume you're playing Mario.

  28. That says it all... by zappepcs · · Score: 4, Funny

    The site lists a page titled "Developer Blogs" and on that page lists 2 hackers and zero developers....

    I can't wait till my TV remote has linux running on it, then I can program it to watch crap TV while I'm not there

    1. Re:That says it all... by pkhuong · · Score: 1

      At the state where DS hacking is, developpers wouln't be very productive. We've only been able to run our own programs a couple weeks ago, and hardware support is still very incomplete.

      --
      Try Corewar @ www.koth.org - rec.games.corewar
  29. Fake signature by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

    The parents Sig is actualy part of his post , he copys parts of storys and karma whores to get his sig seen , Thank you for your time
    --Stop Spam at its source---

    --TKgroup

    1. Re:Fake signature by NanoGator · · Score: 0, Redundant

      "The parents Sig is actualy part of his post , he copys parts of storys and karma whores to get his sig seen"

      Whoop-de-fuck. Turn sigs off if you're that offended by it.

      --
      "Derp de derp."
    2. Re:Fake signature by Artemis · · Score: 1

      Did you even read the part of his comment that you quoted? Turning of sigs does nothing to stop this because the signature is fake and is part of the message.

      Brilliant.

    3. Re:Fake signature by NanoGator · · Score: 1

      "Did you even read the part of his comment that you quoted? Turning of sigs does nothing to stop this because the signature is fake and is part of the message."

      Oops. Retracted. :)

      Lots of ppl bitch about sigs with links to them, including mine. It doesn't excuse my error, but at least it explains it.

      I still stand by my "Whoop-de-fuck" statement, though.

      --
      "Derp de derp."
    4. Re:Fake signature by Artemis · · Score: 1

      No problem. Honestly, I only noticed because I browse with sigs off.

  30. Simple :-) by ForresterInc · · Score: 1

    Because we choose to.

    1. Re:Simple :-) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Thanks Neo

  31. This is unusually interesting to me by SetupWeasel · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Most of the "Linux runs on X" news isn't all that interesting to me. Usually if it would be useful to run Linux on X, it already has a lot of the functionality Linux would give from other software. If X doesn't have software that gives it this functionality already, porting Linux is usually useless for the average chap (like with the PS2).

    This, however, is a case of a piece of hardware that could greatly benefit from a Linux OS, but doesn't have anything like it already available. My DS may be the first piece of hardware I have ever run Linux on.

    (I feel like I just screamed "WE CAME FROM APES!" to a bunch of Southern Baptists when I typed that last sentence.)

    1. Re:This is unusually interesting to me by MemoryDragon · · Score: 0, Redundant

      Actually I am really looking forward to this, the hardware basically is the same you need for a PDA, add to that linux opie and you have some kind of Zaurus. Once they figure out on how to access the wireless hardware you even can do wlan synching. In the end the DS might end up as entry PDA without any doing from nintendo.

    2. Re:This is unusually interesting to me by CronoCloud · · Score: 1

      Most of the "Linux runs on X" news isn't all that interesting to me. Usually if it would be useful to run Linux on X, it already has a lot of the functionality Linux would give from other software. If X doesn't have software that gives it this functionality already, porting Linux is usually useless for the average chap (like with the PS2).

      Linux on the Playstation 2 isn't useless for the average chap since anybody can learn to "use" it even if they never program the thing. It will run applications useful to "average chaps": e-mail clients, web browsers, IRC clients, IM clients, text editors, mp3 players. Bittorrent clients, Nethack..

      You can hook up peripherals to the USB ports like flash card readers, digital cameras, hard drives, printers, or the PSP to it.

      I've got a lot of use and enjoyment out of my Playstation 2 Linux kit. It's been educational as well.

  32. Re:mmh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Nope. Already been done. :)

  33. Yay! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    "I survived April Fool's day on the intarweb and all I got was this lousy T-shirt."

    We have normality, I repeat, we have normality. Anything you still can't cope with is therefore your own problem. :-)

    1. Re:Yay! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > "I survived April Fool's day on the intarweb and all I got was this lousy T-shirt."

      Don't you mean "I survived April Fool's day on the intarweb and all I got was this lousy Linux on my DS."?

  34. Re:What are people doing with their exotic Linuxes by A.K.A_Magnet · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I agree that except for the glory, porting Linux to exotic hardware is quite limited.

    But remember Linux on XBOX. At the time it went gold, the XBOX had a good hardware configuration for a decent price (and now it's still OK : $150). It doesn't take too much space, and you can have a linux home server.

    Now the same thing applies with the DS (or the PSP but no tactile screen...). It's damn hard to get a Zaurus or equivalent in Europe and it's really expensive. If those nintendoDS hackers can get Linux to run on the DS, can get dual boot, and reverse engeener the tactile screen and the wifi connection, it could become one of the best available PDAs : true games (not crappy Palm games...) and a true OS.

    So there's a goal. Now do I think that THIS portable console generation will be powerful enough (in term of batteries, processor, and lack of sufficient storage device) so I will get one and install Linux on it ? Nope.

    But maybe in a few years it will be possible on the next Sony or Nintendo. And then I can well imagine myself in my university campus browsing the web, and chatting on IRC (that would require a separate wifi mini keyboard ? hardware hacker, anyone ? ;)) on the grass under the sun :). The NintendoDS is small enough to take it anywhere with you.

    We have a freedom guaranted by free software. When I buy a NintendoDS, it's a closed package. I get what I paid for. But if I can put some free software on it then it goes beyond my first motive of buying it. That's something the current society doesn't want us to do. It wants us to buy prepared food, and they want us to buy prepackaged hardware (which may be excused by pragmatic reasons since it would be impossible to support if we got every hardware piece separated from software). But still if it's my NintendoDS, I can do whatever I want with it. Just like I can buy beef at the chinese and cook my own rice (incredibly cheaper .. not quite as good but heh..)

    To sum up, I think that even if such initiatives doesn't always end up as one (= the initiative's founder especially ;)) would have wished, they're still great and everyone motivated enough not to follow the standard path (people who cook their own food) can profit from it. So all in all : Kudos to people who port free software to unsupported hardware :)

  35. just wondering...Port Appeal. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "I think it's more of the challenge that drives us to it. "

    So why don't we hear about Linux running on Natalie Portman?

    "Either that or a group of people get really bored."

    That's what the right hand's for.

    1. Re:just wondering...Port Appeal. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Silly, Linux already runs on Natalie Portman. How else could her UI look that good? Windows chicks tend to be fat resource hogs, and Apple chicks are slim but wear Birkenstocks and hemp. Natalie is CLEARLY a hip, urban, cool kind of chick, therefore, Linux.

      Note: If she takes up surfing, or starts hanging around the beach too much, she might be switching to FreeBSD (the whole 'Cali thing). The dead giveaway there is a tan and Ray-Bans.

  36. Re:What are people doing with their exotic Linuxes by MemoryDragon · · Score: 1

    Well the DS has built in WLAN has a very good touch pad and a stylus, so figure out yourself what you can do with it. If you cannot see the light, there are various PDA systems in the wild which build upon top of Linux (opie being the most advanced thanks to TrollTech and Sharp)

  37. So cites IRC by LordHatrus · · Score: 4, Insightful

    "A recent IRC conversation..." Yes, we should cite those as very reliable sources. ... Because everything you read on IRC is true. ... Did I mention I'm a 18 year old female from your general area?

    1. Re:So cites IRC by trans_err · · Score: 1

      so you're 18, female, you use IRC, read /., and you're near by?!

      I knew if I waited you'd finally appear... I mean-- want to go out sometime?

  38. Re:What are people doing with their exotic Linuxes by stoborrobots · · Score: 1

    But I wonder what people are doing with their exotic Linux installations... What are these used for besides showing off? Is there some real-life application to having Linux on these things?

    I don't know myself, but obviously some people smarter than me seem to think that it is useful:
    PlayStation turns supercomputer
    Scientific Computing on the Sony PlayStation 2
    Playstation 2 Linux Cluster at NCSA

  39. You don't need a DS for that. by uberjoe · · Score: 2, Interesting

    You should get a Zaurus. http://openzaurus.org

    --

    The days of the digital watch are numbered.

    1. Re:You don't need a DS for that. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And how much cheaper is a DS?

  40. Lunix on C=64 by tepples · · Score: 2, Informative
    1. Re:Lunix on C=64 by tonsofpcs · · Score: 1

      Ok, now to try this LUnx thing out. I would report back when I'm done, but that probably won't be for a while.

  41. I, for one, am all for this by stanthegoomba · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Sure, the "run Linux on your toaster" articles are fun and all, but unlike most this actually has potential. The DS would make an excellent multimedia PDA: Touchscreen for a decent form of input, stereo speakers, dual screens backed up by a more than decent graphics card, compact size, and 2 forms of wireless networking (assuming these can get the proprietary shortrange networking to work in Linux.) I could see myself replacing my Dell Axim with a Linux powered DS if this project ever matures to that point. Good luck to the developers!

  42. Re:What are people doing with their exotic Linuxes by ratboot · · Score: 1

    What are these used for besides showing off?

    I really think it's because they like it (love it at the limit), I mean how could they put so many hours and days to it? Hacking, for some, IS fun, it has something exciting in itself. Taking something apart, doing something with a gizmo that wasn't planified by the designers, moding games, etc. are all parts of hacking... Besides, I don't think showing off with a name alias is very gratifying... (maybe in some cases, like Marilyn Manson, but then...).

  43. You're joking right? by 7Prime · · Score: 1

    These kind of hacks may indeed turn out to be very usefull--I'm certainly eager to see what they can do with the touch screen--but they will never leave the computer elite community. If you think that the whole world is going to run out and grab a DS because it will run linux, you're seriously deluding yourself. It won't make a noticable dent in product sales even if they were to figure out how to use the touch screen and WiFi to their maximum capability.

    Now, if Nintendo somehow took interest in the project, bought into it, put linux on a DS cartridge, and marketted it, then it MIGHT see a sales increase of a few percentage points. But there's no question in my mind that Nintendo would have no interest in such a project, they have no intention of breaking into the business PDA market any time soon.

    --
    Multiplayer Gaming (defined): Sitting around, discussing single-player games with my friends, at the bar.
  44. Linux on a DS thats easy.... by Zeussy · · Score: 0

    I have mandrake 10.1 running on a vacuum cleaner: http://zeussy.com/comment.php?comment.news.12

    Although if the DS Linux eventually gets browsers, organisers, flash viewers and stuff on it. I would get one. Port teamspeak and use the built in mic :P. Make more sense to their site, being goteamspeak.com.

    Let the power of linux roll on to all platforms and devices.

  45. Ironically by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    It seems the only thing that they can't get Linux to run on is the average user's PC.

    1. Re:Ironically by Ziviyr · · Score: 1

      Send them a Knoppix disc then.

      --

      Someone set us up the bomb, so shine we are!
  46. this is what gets me by TheCulturedRedneck · · Score: 1

    did nintendo think that a linux port wouldn't be made for their system? this is frustrating. think about the possibilites. what if nintendo had embraced linux from the begin with? what if instead of having to reverse engineer wifi and touchpad support nintendo instead released a version themselves. with the intimate knowledge of their own hardware, i'm sure they have the resources to do it. market penetration had to be a vital part of their business plan, especially with the PSP being the first legitimate challenger in years. imagine how many more units they'd move and brand loyalty they'd renew if they were the first to support it. they would already have a proprietary medium and an established line of brands... i can't see why nintendo wouldn't have benefited richly from doing this themselves from the very start.

    1. Re:this is what gets me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      it would be better if they embraced windows instead.

  47. Just wait! by DigiShaman · · Score: 1

    Sun will be running Linux soon too.

    Oh wait, not that sun? Doh!

    --
    Life is not for the lazy.
  48. Dead badger ? by AwaxSlashdot · · Score: 1

    Humm, no : it has been done

    --
    Sig (appended to the end of comments you post, 120 chars)
  49. So how do I run this? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I am very seriously interested in buying whatever is necessary to make this work as soon as it's possible. But one very big question.

    HOW DO I RUN THIS?

    How do I actually load up this ds linux thing? Like, onto the DS? What the hell is a "passme" or a "passthrough"? I'm looking at the photos of "passme" on the front page of dslinux.org and going ugh. I don't understand what's happening in these photos but if I have to have some big thing sticking out of the back of my DS or plug the DS into the computer every time I want to run linux on it... that's not acceptable. I won't bother.

    At what point will I be able to somehow plug a little all-rewritable DS card into my computer (preferably my mac), load a linux kernel onto it, and then three days later just pull it out of my pocket, stick it in the DS, and boot?

    1. Re:So how do I run this? by Melfina · · Score: 2, Informative

      If you read the site a lil more it tells you that the passme/passthrough "redirects the DS to a GBA Flash cart, so you can run your own program on the Nintendo DS. It requires the use of a commercial DS cart and a GBA Flash cart to work." (DSPassme.com) Basicly, you upload your program to a flashcart, than onto passme, and you can run it off of the DS. Obviously it's more work than that, but thats the idea.

      "that's not acceptable. I won't bother."

      The project hasent been subbmitted for your approval, these are some people doing this for fun, and possibly a chance to take over the world (I havent read the blog yet). If you can find a better way good luck. But, to answer your question, the card does stick out of the back, and you dont have to plug it into your pc. Altho that could be fun to test programs instead of flashing and re-flashing them.

      "At what point will I be able to somehow plug a little all-rewritable DS card into my computer (preferably my mac), load a linux kernel onto it, and then three days later just pull it out of my pocket, stick it in the DS, and boot?"

      The best way to do it, would be get "passme" and a GBA flash read/writer and do it like that. Or you could build your own. It's not impossible, I just dont think anyone has done it yet.

      --
      :3 rawr.
  50. Instead of porting Linux by JFMulder · · Score: 1

    Maybe they could work on an X or VNC client. Even better, have the client streamed via Wifi to the DS so you don't even need hacks like PassMe.

    This way I could just use my DS to connect to my PC from my living room and check mail while watching the TV.

  51. I think the question you should be asking by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    did nintendo think that a linux port wouldn't be made for their system?

    Better question: does Nintendo care one way or the other?

    i can't see why nintendo wouldn't have benefited richly from doing this themselves from the very start.

    Because Nintendo is busy. They are still scrambling to get their games translated, get their online infrastructure and APIs in place and in the hands of developers, etc. The amount of developer time available to Nintendo is not unlimited and you can bet that if at the start they had spent that valuable time on porting a niche OS instead of making more games it would NOT have been to their benefit.

    Linux on the DS is good for us. It is not going to be a widely popular feature. If Nintendo were to do anything it would be licensing PalmOS or something.

    1. Re:I think the question you should be asking by JackAxe · · Score: 0

      Nintendo actually did license PalmOS just recently. :)

    2. Re:I think the question you should be asking by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      As far as I know that's just a rumor. If you can post some kind of evidence or citation for this please feel free but until then I'm going to assume it should be taken about as seriously as anything else spong.com says, which is to say, not very.

  52. 3 Things. by Deliveranc3 · · Score: 1

    With these linux projects do they often retain the embeded os's for playing games?


    Third FUCKING AWSOME!

    Fourth how do we do the install?

  53. Re:What are people doing with their exotic Linuxes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Society "wants us to buy prepared food, and they want us to buy prepackaged hardware?"

    What the hell are you rambling about? Is this some sort of socialist entreaty? Are you attempting to equate corporate retailers with society? Are you above, outside, or otherwise disconnected from society?

    Fucking nerds. Every time I read through this goddam site I thank whatever comes to mind that I have some semblance of social skills.

  54. Because dorks don't have a life by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Because dorks don't have a life!

  55. Re:What are people doing with their exotic Linuxes by rmccann · · Score: 1

    "But remember Linux on XBOX. At the time it went gold, the XBOX had a good hardware configuration for a decent price (and now it's still OK : $150). It doesn't take too much space, and you can have a linux home server." Don't forget that Microsoft sells XBoxs at a lost. Microsoft can subsidise your Linux server!

  56. Errrr? by JackAxe · · Score: 0

    The DS has a whole community of home-brew developers. Most of the peeps that were developing for the GBA have jumped to the DS.

    http://dsdev.org/

    http://www.gbadev.org/

    With my DS I can run Linux now, GBA games and SNES, Genisis game to name a few. Nintendo has already licensed the PalmOS and they have have "market dominance." BTW, the DS has sold about a million more units then the PSP. Were you saying something about "even playing fields." The PSP is still the underdog, it's just a pretty one.

    And just admit it, you really don't give a rats arse about the DS? You just wanted to call attention to the PSP... This is a "Look at me post!!!" :p

  57. i couldn't resist... by wolvie_cobain · · Score: 3, Funny

    imagine a beowulf cluster of...

  58. Why? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Why would someone hobble a perfectly good VG console with an inferior os?

  59. Please mod me up by sbaker · · Score: 4, Informative

    OK - I've been hanging out on the www.dslinux.org site for a few weeks. This announcement is *WAY* premature. There isn't even a coherent team put together to START the port yet.

    What there is right now is a bunch of individual developers who have each individually solved various parts of the puzzle. However, we are quite far from having all of the parts put together in the form of a runnable kernel - and there is ABSOLUTELY NO ORGANISED DSLINUX TEAM YET!

    In order to try to pull things together, I am in the process of organising an election to nominate a team leader - and then to collect together the expertise of the disparate developers, set up a SourceForge account (there already is one - but there has been nothing committed to it since December.

    I don't know the individual who posted this to /. - but it doesn't represent the current state of affairs one little bit.

    If you need to confirm what I'm saying, visit the forums at www.dslinux.org - or check the emptyness of dslinux.sf.net

    Please mod me up so this message gets out.

    --
    www.sjbaker.org
  60. The palm port by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I wish someone could port Linux to the Palm - waitaminnit - they are working on it! Here is the project: http://www.palmsource.com/about/cms_annc.html/

  61. How old are you? by greppy · · Score: 0
    instead of having to hard code everything in the ds language, you could just use the linux commands

    "ds language"? I presume you mean ARM assembly language? Do you really think they write these games from the ground up in assembler (as nice as ARM asm is)? Have a look at the MetroWerks site. DS, PSP, PS2, GC and GBA are listed currently. I beleive they also supplied kits for the N64.

    http://www.metrowerks.com/MW/Develop/Games/Default .htm
    http://www.warioworld.com/

    "linux commands"? I don't remember many blockbuster games based on sed or grep.

    I want linux on my ds, it would be cool because i guess with some heavy programming, you could eventually "hijack" other ds's and put whatever you want on them or somthing

    Why would you want to hijack another DS for anything other than nefarious purposes? If you own another DS (lucky you) then it can be actively shared. No hijack required.

    4: Its not windows

    Does it come supplied with Windows? You sound suspiciously like some kid who downloaded a Red Hat ISO once just to join the in-crowd. You couldn't get ALSA working on your laptop so you went back to gaming on XP. If you're going to bash a platform, bash it with authority. Some people know why they prefer one OS over another .

    1. Re:How old are you? by Primal_theory · · Score: 0

      Yes, i know i perfer any platform of linux over windows, because i got fed up with having to get drivers for everything! I personally perfer knoppix, just because you can remaster it to contain whatever you want!

      and i really dont like metrowerks, i tried it for n64 back when they talked about it in nintendo power magazine, and i didn't like it too much....

      oh and i dont have a laptop and ive never used red hat

      --
      Your skill in reading has increased by one point!
  62. Re:What are people doing with their exotic Linuxes by Jozer99 · · Score: 1

    I think it would be much more useful for everyone to be thinking you are running ettercap while you are playing Mario.

  63. Re:What are people doing with their exotic Linuxes by CronoCloud · · Score: 1
    But I wonder what people are doing with their exotic Linux installations. Linux on the PS2, on a toaster, on the blender, etc. What are these used for besides showing off? Is there some real-life application to having Linux on these things?


    Speaking for Linux (for Playstation 2) it's primary purpose is amateur software development. But you can do all sorts of things with it. My kit is my personal "desktop" machine. Read my e-mail, read/post to slashdot, IRC chat, play Nethack, listen to streaming mp3 radio..

  64. GP32 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The GP32 already runs Linux, genesis, mame, nes, snes, gb, and about 20 more game systems. Screw the DS it dosn't have the geek factor or the amount of games.

  65. Re:What are people doing with their exotic Linuxes by geminidomino · · Score: 1

    Well put.

    The puzzle IS the goal.