Slashdot Mirror
Moon Rock Winds Up In Court
Lothar+0 writes "In United States v. Lucite ball containing lunar material (an actual case, I'm not making this up, folks), the feds are suing to get back a moon rock from an American who brought it back from Honduras. They're alleging that this rock from the Apollo 17 mission is stolen property; ironic considering that NASA took something that wasn't under U.S. jurisdiction."
I don' think that the moon is really anyone's territory - at least not just yet...
When will our North American friends realise that their legal system is completely out of control?
First it was the Oath of Allegiance, now a specimen of moon rock - litigation should NOT always be the first resort.
DD
"You can justify anything by putting it in quotes, adding a famous name and making it a sig" - Albert Einstein
What the moon rock... is cooking!
What about this place?
http://www.moonshop.com/
I sure hope that NASA is not taking any of them thar moon rocks from my back 40! I gots the deeds to proves it!
who's gonna stop 'em? If it's not the American people (and let's face it, it's not) then that only leaves the Chinese - and they're even fucking worse! One day, maybe the UN (or, more likely, the EU) will have enough clout to stop the American govt acting like they own the fucking planet.
That was classic intercourse!
If this is the case then where do private collectors get their rocks? Are they stolen as well?
ironic considering that NASA took something that wasn't under U.S. jurisdiction
Not so much. It's the same idea as explorers in the 1600's searching for gold in America. It's no ones jurisdiction, so they can do what they darn well please and claim the land for their own afterwards (or before). Except, in this case, we have that pesky Outer Space Treaty in the way of actually claiming the Land, but I'm not sure about the stuff FOUND on the land. Someone fill me in.
Never underestimate the power of human stupidity.
"Awww, Ricky! I brought this souvenir back from Honduras and accidentally swallowed it! And now the whole country is suing me! Aaaaaahhhhhhwwwwww! Aaaaahhhhwwww! I should have known there was something suspicious when the souvenir seller in the black suit called me Mrs. Ricardo before I introduced myself! Hoow ddoooo I gett iinn theeese thiinngs! Aaaaaahhhwww!"
ironic considering that NASA took something that wasn't under U.S. jurisdiction Oh please. Who paid tens of billions to research and develop the moon landing? Under your definition, no one would own anything, as at some point in history no one owned it. The United States was first to the moon; doesn't historical context give them ownership of the landing area? Furthermore, the rock, if stolen, should be returned. The United States can do a lot more with it (scientific research, etc) than some Honduras collector.
Thank you...
I'm not sure why this story was posted here, what the relevance of it is, or why we should be upset by it.
[FromTheMorning]
I'd like to see them weasel out of that one.
Why hasn't the Lunar Embassy been contacted about this?
Whoever plants the flag first, owns it. Those are the rules. Those have always
been the rules. And they will always be the rules. Get there first, it's yours.
Since NASA brought the rock back it's theirs. If you want one you're free to go to the moon and get one for yourself.
If I paid as much money as NASA did to go get that rock, I'd want it back too.
You mean that the moon isn't really made of cheese? What about that nice man that lives there? I would be pretty angry if some guy owned a part of me - especially if I were made of cheese...
...yeah, that's "out of control". What would you have them do, duel for it? People bitch about our legal system, but they forget that history has plenty of example of more violent as less satisfactory solutions.
Miko O'Sullivan
Too bad.
If the US did own the entire planet there would no double be less starvation and war. Instead, commie dictatorship counties countinue to kill millions...
Its easy to be a cynic. It takes courage to realize the truth.
[FromTheMorning]
A question: If the "Lucite ball containing lunar material" is the defendant, and unless it speaks (which would certainly be really weird if it does), how's it gonna defend itself?
Must be something in the American legal system I suppose?
OK Jackass, I'll bite: In a way, we do.
See, if it weren't for us, you ass would belong to the (set of [Nazis, Japanese, Soviets, British Imperialists, Italians,
Go back to your hole in the ground you ungrateful shit.
It's a secret, but I'm going to fill you in.
They're made of cheese. Not just any regular cheese though, moon cheese! Moon cheese is by far the most delicious cheese ever discovered.
You get one of these moon rocks, and it's moon cheeseburgers for dinner! Or maybe a moon pizza. The uses are limitless, too bad the supply on Earth isn't.
This article doesn't quite seem to explain why exactly that the moon rock is listed as the defendant, and not its current "owner"? Shouldn't Mr. Rosen be the defendant, since he is the one trying to defend his rightful ownership of the rock and the government is trying to declare it stolen property?
Did i just miss something?
We have left more trash on the moon than any other country. That certainly makes the moon resemble America. (By Trash I mean the part of the LEM that doesn't come back to Earth).
We need those volunteers who clean up the sides of the highways to go and clean up the Moon. I can see it now: "This Moon kept clean by Cedar Grove Girl Scout Troop #213"
I was gonna say that since we planted a US Flag on the Moon, then basically we claimed it. (At least that's the way it works in cartoons.) But as I recall, we actually brought the flag back with us.
I didn't bother to read the article (this is SlashDot, after all) but the plaque that Apollo 11 left on the moon does mention "For All Mankind." I would think that includes Honduras.
However, if the U.S. loses, George W. Bush will declare that Lucite Ball is a terrorist and then the courts won't matter.
To the original owner, that is. If we "stole" it from international territory, then it's forfeit to the original owner, right? Which is to say: the moon. Let's bring that sucker back and put it where we found it.
Any excuse to fire rockets into space is a good one if you ask me.
It's rare that you're presented with a knob whose only two positions are Make History and Flee Your Glorious Destiny.
I agree with you
I DO NOT CARE
The United States is suing a ball of Lucite? Hehehehehehehe...
explain to me how "belonging to" the British Empire would be worse. And, exactly what your role has been in extending American justice and freedom across the globe, besides eating Twinkies and wanking over your huge porn collection in your parents' basement. You fucking prick.
Uh... I think we are in agreement here. The US, albeit flawed in many ways, is the greatest country in the history of our planet.
[FromTheMorning]
that Little Rock be given back to the Moonies.
As an American, I must remind you that we would no doubt be just another member of the British commonwealth, if the French had not seen to it that we won the War of Independence. We repayed our debt in WWII (IMO), but we musn't forget that they helped us first.
"It's overkill, of course. But you can never have too much overkill." - Anonymous Slashdot Coward
A Wisconsin dairy farmer allegedly has a chunk of swiss cheese said to be part of the Moon's outer crust although scientists are skeptical whether swiss cheese could withstand the heat from entry through the atmosphere.
What was my contribution? How about 40% of every year's earnings, fat chunks of which are handed out as foreign aid.
How bout the dump trucks full of money which my parents and their parents paid to bail out your sodden little backwater empire after WWI and WWII?
Right. Less starvation. That's why the US Govt pays farmers to let their fields lie fallow.
You are a big moron. No country, not even the U.S., can solve the transportation problem called "getting the food to the people living in the middle of a desert." Nor can they solve the problem of "getting those people to stop breeding and creating more hungry mouths." China, in fact, is the ONLY country that has even addressed that issue.
If the rest of the world, which has a much lower standard of living, were Americans, and consumed resources like Americans, we would need several more earths to provide all the raw materials.
On the other hand, if the World were American, that might force humanity to deal with the inevitable collision between an ever-increasing human population vs. a ever-decreasing pool of natural resources.
Troll again, I like replying.
Just like all those other British territorial holdings that are still under their control....
Oh wait...
------
Where are the slash-groupies? I distinctly remember being promised slash-groupies!
You are of course correct. This is why I try to never make a stinky Frenchman joke, unless it's really funny.
Somehow, I don't think so.
I think the feds have it right on this one.
The Applo 17 team was sent as an agent of NASA to collect samples from The Moon. Although there is no title claim to any part of The Moon, the samples taken are technically NASA's(I'm fuzzy but maybe this is precidence stretching back to English Common Law). So the US Government through Nixon gave the rock as a gift to Honduras in the 1970s.
Flash forward to now: NASA has no claim on the rock since it was given as a gift. However unless the government of Honduras legally sold the rock it should be given back to the government of Honduras There is clear federal juristiction here and Honduras at the moment has a strong case for asking the rock back. Rosen can't claim "I didn't know I couldn't buy this legally". If he can't prove the Honduran governement sold it to him legally then he is out one expensive rock.
the flag wasn't brought back. it was knocked over when the module lifted off to bring the astronauts back
Paid back in full. And then some. And where do you think your Nasa scientists came from? They weren't native Americans just as I suspect you aren't. You're living in a dream world while destroying the real one. Go and buy another SUV and turn up the air-con, fucko. The British built the country that you call the USA, didn't you ever wonder why you're speaking our language? Just look at Canada if you want to see where you fucked it up.
I know people are so against the United States, but if the rock was a sample brought back, one may construe that rock to be salvage according to international treaties on salvage. If he bought it legally from someone who acquired it legally, it should stay his. Otherwise, as much as you hate the US government, it should be returned to them.
It says that its stolen property... not just the fact it was picked up by an Apollo mission.
maybe so, but if America had never ceded from the Empire, I rather suspect that the commonwealth might never have been established. I agine what the world might have bee like if the British Empire had become properly democratic - India and the Americas would probably have steered the whole enterprise eventually. If properly handled, it could actually have worked. At least it wouldn't have been so fucking harsh on the native Americans - their fate always seems to me such an ignored crime, Canada did it so much better.
That was classic intercourse!
NASA scientists? From Germany, of course.
Destroying the real world? How?
Not native? I am, but why does that matter?
SUV? I own a 20 year old 4x4 -- it's called preemptive recycling.
You built this country? Wrong. *My* ancestors built this country. (Yes, some of them were British -- lucky for me I didn't inherit their dental genes.)
Look at Canada? Hey, chief, we got da Bill of Rights, what do they have? We put men on the moon, they think "hoser" is a word.
I don't want to sound arrogant or anything, but well, until your country sets foot on the moon, it belongs to us.
The World is Yours.
Here's the story after the original confiscation of the moon rock in 1998.
Title says it all....
The Honduran dictator probably had as much right to give the colonel the rock as Nixon had to give it to Honduras.
If someone is passing you on the right, you are an asshole for driving in the wrong lane.
Wouldn't it be more logical for the person in possession of the rock to be the defendant instead of the lucite ball? Is there some legal reason I'm missing?
Don't give me none of this "nature theme" business.
Natives misteated in America? As opposed to the lovey-dovey nature in which the British Empire, East India Company, et. al. treated natives over the whole effing planet? (Starting in your own back yard, btw. How are your Irish friends doing these days?)
Yes, we done bad. Now climb down off your high-horse and look around you.
Re-purposed Nazi weapons put men on the moon. How does your precious Bill provide for a fairer society than that enjoyed by Canadians? And I never said that I built your country - I'm 29 years old and have lived in the UK, the US and France. I never built much of anything, myself. Careful how much of your ancestor's achievements you claim for yourself, you're just standing on their shoulders claiming that you're the tallest in the world.
That was classic intercourse!
No, I think Bill Clinton declared that...
(And to be fair, George H.W. Bush also declared such, and every President going back as far as the Louisiana Purchase, if not before.)
Also, if the World were American, Bush wouldn't be the President, who was the most people? China? So probably some chinese will be voted in. A close second some indian... you get the picture.
~~~Please pass the salt, I hate unsalted MD5s
No problem. You are welcome to spend $50 billion to fly to the moon, grab all the rocks you can carry, and bring them back. I presume it will then be ok for me to steal them from you and when you don't like it I'll complain about silly lawsuits.
Miko O'Sullivan
"Re-purposed Nazi weapons"? No way you can compare a V-2 to a Saturn V. Re-purposed Nazi *scientists*, maybe.
How does the Bill of Rights provide for a fairer society? You gotta be kidding, right?
Claiming my ancestor's achievements? Never. I'm a lowly worm in comparison. But, well put.
Yeah, the lawsuit makes sense, but naming the Lucite ball as the defendent is... weird. I'm looking forward to the lawsuit names this precedent will bring us.
Miko O'Sullivan
uh man, you've been brain washed, get help fast!
Ahh, that explains it all - you spent time in France. Nobody's the same after a few days with those dirty frogs.
I would rather have six dozen Terrestrial Planet Finders than a single manned mission to mars.
As for a moonbase, that can wait a few hundred years, too.
Blount vs. McIverson? Which one was the Federal Government? I call troll.
Because then every war can be called "police
shootout".
Considered harmful.
why is this under "space"? why isnt this under "the courts" so we can better point out the fact that the system is totally out of control? or better yet, shouldn't this be at least under humor? i mean, y'all gotta agree, this is crazy..
I support publik eduscatation!
The Irish seem to be doing very well these days, from what I can see. We still get a lot coming over to London, but I don't think they are fleeing poverty, but rather looking for the broader opportunities that a larger community inevitably offers. Same reason that Londoners go to NYC. John Lennon said that moving from London to NYC was like moving from Liverpool to London, IIRC.
That was classic intercourse!
Documentaries such as Enemy of the State have accurately portrayed the elaborate, byzantine network of surveillance satellites that the liberals have sent into space to spy on law-abiding Americans. Equipped with technology developed by Handgun Control, Inc., these satellites have the ability to detect firearms from hundreds of kilometers up. That's right, neighbors .. the next time you're out in the backyard exercising your Second Amendment rights, the liberals will see it! These satellites are sensitive enough to tell the difference between a Colt .45 and a .38 Special! And when they detect you with a firearm, their computers cross-reference the address to figure out your name, and then an enormous database housed at Berkeley is updated with information about you.
Of course, this all works fine during the day, but what about at night? Even the liberals can't control the rotation of the Earth to prevent nightfall from setting in (only Joshua was able to ask for that particular favor!) That's where the "moon" comes in. Powered by nuclear reactors, the "moon" is nothing more than an enormous balloon, emitting trillions of candlepower of gun-revealing light. Piloted by key members of the liberal community, the "moon" is strategically moved across the country, pointing out those who dare to make use of their God-given rights at night!
Yes, I know this probably sounds paranoid and preposterous, but consider this. Despite what the revisionist historians tell you, there is no mention of the "moon" anywhere in literature or historical documents -- anywhere -- before 1950. That is when it was initially launched. When President Josef Kennedy, at the State of the Union address, proclaimed "We choose to go to the moon", he may as well have said "We choose to go to the weather balloon." The subsequent faking of a "moon" landing on national TV was the first step in a long history of the erosion of our constitutional rights by leftists in this country. No longer can we hide from our government when the sun goes down.
by 70%
This summer I'm working at Lawrence Berkeley Lab, and some of the people near where I work have gotten a few grams of lunar material (Apollo 15, IIRC) from NASA for an experiment aiming to figure out the material's age of formation. Now they only need to look at a particular tiny part of the sample and NASA expects to get the rest back.
Now none of that is unreasonable, but what is unreasonable is the insurance policy they have to take out on the material against theft, accidental lost or destruction. Now insurers naturally want to know the value of what they are insuring. NASA's official and much repeated line is that all lunar material is priceless. This poses a serious problem for insurers, so the next question was what is the cost to replace the sample. No joke, they figured the cost of the policy, and hence the premiums, based on the cost of building a rocket, flying to the moon, collecting a new sample, and bringing it back. Not only that, but two members of the Berkeley physics department are officially down on paper as having volunteered to make the trip should it become neccesary.
I don't know what they are paying exactly, and being in a secured area of a restricted access research lab probably helps keep down the cost, but still it's not cheap holding on to lunar material that NASA expects to get back.
I thought the last point(in art.) about selling off NASA's assets to fund missions was odd.
Could end up scrubbing as some damn collector already resold the booster.
Gotta love this Internet thingy. Here we start a conversation about moon rocks and degenerate into a "my country's better than yours" mudfest. Was it good for you?
Historical Footnote #1: There are no Indian Reservations on the East Coast of USA
This is just not true. There are three or four in the state of Mainewhich last time I looked is on the east coast.
There are plenty of examples of the screwing of the American Indians, you don't have make any more up.
MY people, who evolved on the moon aeons before your primitive species tentatively crept into space, have full and complete jurisdiction over this entire solar system and all of its planetary bodies as per NYLANETHEROP vs. CENTAURI CONTROL.
How come WWI didn't repay the debt? I think WWII and the Cold War put them back in our debt!
I certainly wasn't. The French have far more perfected the art of living than either the Americans or the British, although the little I've seen of Italy suggests that they may have gone further still. The British are certainly a much more modest race than both of the others - both the French and Americans seem to think that they invented democracy and the rule of law, when it rather seems to me that the Magna Carta did more than both.
That was classic intercourse!
Interesting article, good coverage of the history of this particular rock and similar cases, but the main reason I read to the end of the thing was to understand how in the hell a ROCK can be the defendant in a court case. No explanation of that wacky concept at all.
It is the duty of the most powerful nation to protect its own interests as well as the interests of freedom and democracy. What's wrong with policing the world and undoing unjustices? It's noble; and besides, who else is going to do it but the United States? No superpowers are left. Even China cannot compare anymore.
I know Karate, Kung Fu, and 47 other dangerous words!
I'm just wiping it up now.
Hispanics almost outnumber whites in the US, but there hasn't yet been a serious Hispanic contender. Females outnumber males but there hasn't been a serious female contender.
Politics doesn't work by majority rule, it works by whoever has the most money, and so rule would remain in the United States or other Western nations.
The flags were left on the moon, they weren't brought back.
Yeah, haven't you noticed how everyone that doesn't agree with you is "brain washed"?
Of course, the Magna Carta. How could I forget that? Although, to be fair, it seems as if all of your monarchs did as well...
We didn't invent democracy. In fact, it wasn't really practiced here until the 20'th century. (For the record, the USA is a republic, not a democracy. There's a big difference, though what with our presidents and elected representatives governing by the latest telephone poll, obviously not very many people care.)
maybe this is true... nobody can really say... but one thing is for certain... the US doesn't WANT to control the world... if it did than it would have to protect everyone under their rights and as it is now we (as americans... yes ALL of us) make profit off countries that dont run themselves like us... the world cannot support one giant US... not the way we live it now...
unzip; strip; touch; finger; mount; fsck; more; yes; unmount; sleep
Is that the U.S. Federal government is spending tax money, and personel resources in setting up "stings" to retrieve moon rocks. Seriously... with all the political corruption, coroporate bullying, and other things going on in the country over the last 15 years, would you rate a moon rock sting as a worthy use of your tax dollars? You know the gov can't do anything for less than $200,000 these days. What did this "sting" cost the people? What corporate embezzler, political bribe or corporate espionage was not thwarted because the fed thought it more prudent to search for moon rocks?
Article X: The powers not delegated... by the Constitution...are reserved...to the people
Those who are interested can look in the archives about two years ago for an article here in Slashdot linking to the customs declaration that Armstrong, Aldrin, and Collins signed bringing some of those rocks into the country. I have a copy knocking around here somewhere...
We did push most of the Eastern tribes off into the Western deserts... imagine how hard that would be for people who worshipped nature ("Where the fuck are the trees?")...
"The litigated rock arrived on Earth from the last manned moon mission in 1972, was encased in Lucite, attached to a plaque and presented as a gift by President Nixon to the Honduran government the following year."
I'd have to say at that point the Government of the United States gave up any claim of ownership we had.
what do you mean ANYMORE? The USA is living on borrowed time as the world's leading nation - how many of your "American" computers are actually manufactured in China? What happens when China gets to the moon? What happens when China's GDp overtakes that of the USA? What HAPPENED when the Chinese captured a US spy plane? We saw the balance of power right there. Quite frankly, the prospect of the filthy, murderous Chinese state apparatus dictating the fate of the entire world far more frightening than GWB's corrupt regime. When WWIII starts, the USA can count on my support. I don't think it'll help much, but it's yours all the same.
That was classic intercourse!
unless it speaks... how's it gonna defend itself?
Defendants generally don't need to speak. (Consider the examples of hostile, mute, comatose, or autistic defendants.) I'm pretty sure there will be an attorney arguing the defendant's case.
The bigger question in my mind is how American courts would permit an inanimate object to be the defendant. Or is this just CNN's mistake?
There are trees all over the west... or there were, anyway, prior to the fires.
Considering that Hispanics reproduce like mosquitos, they will outnumber all races eventually across the planet. If you don't believe that, look at what percentage of Mexico and South American countries' population is under 14.
1.NASA retrieves rock from moon. US government now owns moon rock
2.US government encases rock in lucite ball and gives ball to Honduran government. Honduran government now presumably owns moon rock (unless there was some condition attatched to rock that specifies that US government retains title in which case things are different).
Honduran dictatorship then appears and rewrites the law giving them rights to all property of the old government, including the rock. Honduran dictatorship now owns rock (presumably).
Now somehow the rock gets into the possession of the colnel. If the transfer to the colnel was illegal under honduran law (i.e. the colnel stole the rock) then the colnel should be charged with theft and the person who bought the rock from him should, at best, be charged with possession of stolen property (but if you buy stolen propery then you cant be found guilty of possession unless it can be proved that you knew it was stolen when you bought it). If the transfer happened legally under honduran law(because the dictatorship gave it to him) then presumable the colnel now owns the rock and therefore he can legally transfer that which he owns to someone else in exchange for money.
PhysicsGenuis is a very skilled troll. Check out all his other posts. :)
wait, i was under the assumption the moon WAS ours, i mean, we got there first, and then we stuck a flag in it
"Sic Semper Tyrannosaurus Rex."
Hispanics almost outnumber whites in the US, but there hasn't yet been a serious Hispanic contender. Females outnumber males but there hasn't been a serious female contender.
Don't you Americas have some stupid rule that says your president must be American born and MALE? I'm sure I read this somewhere.
I suppose the true value of anything is exactly the price that someone is willing to pay for it. To me, it's worthless. It's a fricken rock!!! It's a rock in a ball no less. I think a freshly minted penny would be more attactive to me.
But this is a non-story. The US government is simply trying to return property that, so far, appears to have been misappropriated from a foreign government. It's in the US government's best interest to see that it is returned.
Whether or not we actually own the moon is so incredibly irrelevant I can't even believe the notion was brought up. The rock was a gift from our government to theirs. The rock maintains significant value to collectors and so is perceived to hold some value. It is supposed to be in the posession of the Honduran government and is not in their posession at the moment.
What I don't know is whether the Honduran government is actively requesting its return. I haven't read where the rock was actually STOLEN from any part of the Honduran government or any of its dictators. I think it's significant that in the absense of an actual claim that it is illegally out of Honduran territory, the rock should remain with its current owner, Alan Rosen.
I think it's incredibly arrogant for the government to seize property without first hearing a claim that it has been acquired through any illegal means. Okay, so we have an arrogant government... what governmental body ISN'T arrogant?
Do Not Taunt Happy Fun Ball
FreeBSD for the impatient.
a British monarch hasn't done anything without permission since the time of George III. Quite right, too. You can thank Cromwell for that if you want - talk about tough love though.
That was classic intercourse!
what did it do wrong? immigration violation?
Thanks, but we're the rugged individualist type -- don't need nothin from nobody.
What happens when China gets to the moon? Riiight, like that will happen. Slavery is never condusive to scientific ventures -- the Nazis figured that one (see where Einstein ended up?).
BTW, no communist country will *ever* surpass America's GDP. Innovation is the key to any successful venture, be it a business or a country. How in hell do you convince some slave in a Chinese sweatshop to become the next Thomas Edison?
BTW, your constant harping against GWB's "corrupt regime" is getting tiresome. I don't like the guy either but it'd take a real tinfoil-hat type to believe he is capable of real corruption. He's just a career bureaucrat (sp?), just like his old man was.
SO when my big ol can of whup ass gets opened on someone, they will of corse, charge the can with assault, right? Seems only fair.
All Troll + "offtopic" mods are meta moderated as "Unfair", because you abused the system.
American born, yes, female, no.
Actually, not even American born. You have to have been an American citizen since birth. Slightly different.
Jesus was all right but his disciples were thick and ordinary. -John Lennon
Don't you Americas have some stupid rule that says your president must be American born
Yup. You got us. That does seem to be a requirement.
The sig is the next line.
If you voted for Nader, THIS IS ALL YOUR FAULT!!
I have to admit that it's the finest troll ever. A thing of rare beauty, indeed. Hats off to you, mein count.
That was classic intercourse!
SO when my big ol can of whup ass gets opened on someone, they will of corse, charge the can with assault, right? Seems only fair.
Go ahead, waste your points and mod me down, you humorless ass. Thats one less worthwhile comment modded up.I WIN!!
According to Code Section 10/15/99 16-5-25 of Georgia state law (My State, btw);
You have the right to "open a can-o-whoop-ass" if provoked by "fighting" words.
A person charged with the offense of simple assault or simple battery may introduce in evidence any opprobrious or abusive language used by the person against whom force was threatened or used; and the trier of facts may, in its discretion, find that the words used were justification for simple assault or simple battery.
Hmm. Now be careful what you say when you're in Georgia.
Besides, your opened and therefore used can-o-whoop-ass would probably not be seized because it is not valuable enough.
saying that you can't own a peice of the moon is like saying you can't own a vial of ocean water. No one Owns the moon so they can't claim ownership over it. Basically the Government has no case. Well... They have a case for it to get back to Honduras. Since the object is encased in lucite.. they are trying to get the lucite back to its rightful owner. Thats all they have.
The moon is not under US jurisdiction?
Depends who you ask. But, since the US didn't ratify the world court treaty, it would be silly to ask them.
I thought that George W & Co had declared that everything everywhere was under US jurisdiction.
You're probably thinking of the Supreme Court
===
Are you reading this?
The French didn't help us out of ideals or altruism. They did it because they hated the British. Between the War of Independence and the War of 1812, we fought an undeclared quasi-war with the French. Don't romanticise history too much.
FreeSpeech.org
$5 million for 1.142-grams of moon rock? In Detroit they "moon rock" and "moon dust" for $10-$40 per gram.
"You know you don't act like a scientist, you're more like a game show host." Dana Barret
A:Well, If you've seen one country, you've seen them all.
B:Well, have you?
A:Have I what?
B:Seen every country?
A:Well, I've seen one country.
I don't see how anyone can be in agreement when this sort of thinking is rampant.
Of course, even if people are in agreement under these circumstances, the agreement is worthless.
Maybe NASA can tap this lucrative new source of revenue to fund ambitious missions of exploration. I'm hoping that bits of Mars start showing up on Ebay within the decade!
...at least that's the best info I can find at the moment. Check out the Moon page at the National Space Science Data Center. Look at "Luna" landings, specifically Luna 16, 20, and 24.
If you want to see where they landed, check out the Jules Verne Voyager Java applet. Choose "USSR Luna Sites" from the dropdown. The sites will show up as purple dots. Click and drag a box to zoom in on that box.
So, with only 301g of moon soil, I don't think the Russians were giving much of it away. (The U.S. brought back hundreds of kilos.) Also, the U.S. and the U.S.S.R. are the only countries to have collected samples from the moon. Notable, however, are the Japanese crash of satellite Hiten into the moon in 1993, and Hughes Global Services' flyby of the moon with the satellite AsiaSat 3 in 1998, which had been originally launched by the Chinese.
Given the above, I would therefore assume that any moon rocks possesed by collectors were either purchased or stolen from the U.S. government, since the only other country to have any is Russia, and they don't have very many.
ALL "democratic" western governments are corrupt, it's no particular slur on GWB's crew. Try Googling for "Tony Blair Bernie Ecclestone" and see what you get. Why do the Chinese need to innovate to get to the moon? America already showed them how, and the Chinese hardly have to convince the population to come up with the money, do they? And GWB not capable of REAL corruption, remember you wrote that when Big Oil starts drilling in YOUR favourite national park.
That was classic intercourse!
I can no longer mod and this jackass posts at +2?
Go figure
The crime is that someone doesn't put a bullet between your eyes. I hope someone knows who you really are and kills you.
Exactly what is "Hispanic"? And don't tell me descendents from Spain because they're not. According to the stupid politically correct US census rules Spaniards are considered "white europeans" -- so go figure.
So what.
It's easy to leverage technology to destroy.
Islam forgot how to leverage technology to create things about 800 years ago or so. Followed about 600 years later by the French...
Easy to have better results under those conditions.
Take your best shot, AC. I'll even let you go first.
Hispanics can be American born (Hispanic-American, whatever, if you wanna nitpick). There's no gender rule, though.
"IN almost all cases, owning lunar material is illegal unless you can show a clear paper trail back to nasa" is kind of scary.
What they are implying is not that posession of moon rocks is restricted, but that, unless you can show clearly how you got it, it was probably stolen (because if it wasn't, you'd be able to prove how you got it).
This scares me a bit, though. How long until we are required to show chain of custody documetns & receipts for every single object we own, lest the government sieze them as stolen?
And whatever happened to posession being 9/10ths of the law?
I'm drunk, and anonymous.
Happy pride Toronto. If only everyone else knew how cool Toronto really was, maybe then it could gain acceptence as a world class city. oh wait. we've got a housing problem. Once we fix that, bitches we will be come the cultural epicentre of all North America (Fasion excepted, due to over abundance of people who believe NYC is it). Mark these fuckers words. Toronto will be in the spotlight in the next 10 years. Muahahahahha Muahahahaha
Vive Vichy!
Is there any connection between this story and the poll about cheese...?
RMN
~~~
begin 644 goat.jpgY ++E+2++++D +++zys+7Y3Y+ +-O7+++YPjzP+ 6E+-UE2-+I2A 1+kE1+sD2+wC1 -AH3-EH2lkPF 3FcT5lwT5lwT5 lwT5lwT5lwTT 5lwT5lwTzw6+2 EU+bk1-+k2F+ ++6-+kE3-U+5+ E2-+E2-+++++ +++++E+F+UA22 UIE6H2m2m+k+ ++2+2E6V213F2 UAUEK3l6X8-+ ++++++++U-A-+ +60+EA1-+A-V wTzO++k1+E+02 EAF+++-qag6V EFF+cE0W-562A +Q-K4N9Vociq W3mpHRQngrEFj BGzhdeJ+3Fga bdE2J+0J-IEtJ CJIE7EVgwj8j Wf8nAd0AgIXOP OBrc080LApHO SZ4bgP0-KtWdd Fh3lj2KNiNXl HWUd2aj82O3HN B73JWCqPHKgg EVm4SWmt6dRFg AQm4jG8oJ20D kNDHpKp8I6PEp hWa1+UPTAQ8J -k+EIi1CMog1O wbZSdK3hmrui IzDfkWFQrn5fm 7NS4vtvbOecK QENeZrWktK32W 4Qf9fNitk8dN pduc0Xmx8Sgjv DIr2SOgBt03N PIjQJJnLB99K6 iP7efFs9BShV hjh7YhGZXB1+G b9MnLGuLqSPF gKJOs5HeV+pdj JtwftywJWKqJ LROorewzzxc+0 +2-++23+WGvJ nJyNFXWfQsLFk gyj81Z-lkZk3 iCT1LFYIrl15V 9eJ9V9hFvJ9w 1pIYJDhIipHvF qcR2Ck8DOhro IipGvTqzMR2Cp FvPPueMtiPDg WGhZ4AAXRcFJi vN7KqSKr2B6H 7TpcQoCoRFqcx FHL2ty1LYpsG Ix6WM3sEYgbcj uzEMMG5O2CpB jm7pt4FIhrldW wRpMtN12WHGQ 728IWJzKuduxt nTz+4kjcKi96 1ceLPYmY0M8iI MabRwqdNSGQS gnwRo4bBbBl+G 7h3UZcYEecu8 LKEQPbOHSg0Ce Jh-hZ87fAeeU OGSI1mDFq+RDm Fm1eCEmXQNmp JpXmQdKT584b7 qEYMjY1Hh+Xx imulUEiVYJrkY I+X4lOS-oeGD 7NNVoErGyyiRS AxBInMI9Aa7h 2ZwYMCaLr93xq EIQbIcEbemqu JXFzuTj9IVAeJ g+jgIfvKCjiw ctxFIRkcSCtsm yzEJz6MsDrgT G3CP02V7F10Up kgnuPP9013QN vVL24iWqGVVpB 9+WcMYl8RKRk WFdog4Xpw6Yds Q5AN-GXBONe4 rluEAFOMZOIz6 BdUmt9t6baG- -E9xBDtPzX5o1 wVjx-Z1wYQ1y k2TPTUuRDkRDu UTPRDkD+SVzz hjuqx9zcLzzO+ +U-+k+--E9zA aHTUZ1x0RCbz+ -maHQLHfIhG+ 0+20+UMz+bdzz xc+0+21+UMz9 sw7ucXSmbZSAc beX8ynlg3Uqy RdFMxjmMTkJbo tC3sqFg5DP5K SCm2I9-gN6Ryd HYBxYh18yOc4 q2RfBeGmV4RoK ml50nJ7xAErH w7KD6g2qYAllB muNVw4IRHL9W z4rt-zsySo2H4 61rggBLonFoX 8FSFEKFuqRJm+ kgCcTw+pDq3w z+MdkQgTl0SAW sLjSbJe1PGxB lhpBPohZFom5X +1vf-Cu2RHeC P+8YVZz3UmZf2 BarKaFB72fIp 5HWO-Fp-TQP8K NABu2WDolvt8 WqtIIdCt+gbvc uR8wQJ20U4mb veaaFmcWE7jUj IJoEEcIGlKcf gSG7Ny0a7Jp5e q8nHoqXj8XeG jTYFYvaDt8ITm 16EmDw+Yb4IA +m4MJrf+s6hp- RFeb-RBArc1R agceVJcis-Ruj g-kjH47lQs9B DZYa+8klHtewZ LILF9A+3fXyL rdkeIF-DJ9QWD HT3J95SgJG9N S7JNiS04KFND4 RJZxo8jIRtJN TFMZLJEZI2M7V asTu8PSiGVeU WlONspHLX2fxa L9UKHFPkJ0lf eLFHW9ZRKnXNz xc+0+2-+k2zl -hhXwiwgPZlba 1PQtXZX6GarJ ZajiXiTj7mR+n T-1ZvHwGPEzQ TYQMCMP3nxnkb 2w-mz5Hwdaov 7h6n9UBH-95oo SCzl8J7aTi1W hxy5mjuu9r9fF PN5EwCG8xmBa br7qavdjVyXcO MnHANaaJESHu 6dtnAokZw54Al AEiabssWmhko Z+9Fc89kPTgL0 XnqDxgw3Fzvc DnliPYVGkNNFe qSDOKLgPQ9lW x7SUvGuL6JqlC 3lytiNexkeII RxYj3RtUPROwl cqy8a7GZBqWE egeW1IpM9WEjm xsKwtURGw2Q3 2K8s3taVaNNvG HmvacL8wWqAB juaxryWO7raaR sQSU8CZTiZQz I75rlAwFUvJXw mZDUDYF4Lqb- cV-1e0Ap7QAJP LWjhI2+p9vn+ y5j+kg+I5WOtO wolQjhpJxSAV Nwgl2PtXMPX-d gGrtZfiJm8CS oOBsp3hVVu8Ap hqWKqvMEzi3U E5vXhfjz+5idV K8ndU84fs1wk lALFhhD8rZ-vA ATz++ZQDNDwQ -aH-ErlRn0dA4 Zi0LNVcsDW6s 1QHqg1AQpZv3v XVcViGK5yEZG IkKPZzN3TU5ym fxX1t6ni3JdH tFlwmk4mxgsUT MbPpS0+oheR7 jnOpvr4sF4-WN i0mVJwlWimjq jj-B4n6pWrXz+ ClfH3qXj8Vsr Ve+pzk12dEnvy Tw+v4jaSPaPt NOr4QbvUh-lwD 3Gz0hgcpkTdU KPmtZujYda7hV KPZhQtVMQST- xalR47s6SVa1T BTa2vKwxc1Kk iTdWl2aWi4IlZ ePBFJ3zuzAw9 K5TAk7wAGn0so 1yddpT337BiU MQS43FRzTDw+w WsP+cpxdaZSG vAfwk+g0Ranyd PVcC5Oi4+p9L TKtYoew7YJQ9l +0tIyGT0IK+R kldF-ApeNA1XB a4yq6gUvZMzL H6zAqp5hTykwF vmj2rVi9evwK nzzO++U-+UA-D m5y5QLyEekEb ovu-u8uLuK5ov yekyabdNLEzS VG32fp+7KJZMk 1u+GsycjoZmi MZ2p1o9xGbfrD J5peUGjEturW dLEXSA7LcjuiS XoChRQyXzzOI fy3IfeSWzk0+x 5eSVzWV5eTkP 9FhZidH9REVxM feGzf3msSYZE lWtNAR5cx0Jo- 2uL1uN8Sg4Cc RDzO++k1+E+02 EAF+++EPPzz9 HnHHPP6Qb6lU9 nHHP8FZ767DC EIC-Y+UcbF-6G +GWcc0nFsqNz +75qgakVx0wPX ytPnZigyD6Ez +Bpo41mHwsT8B dDxISDZpbSAK JfmmphxqQtxlv nMjrMT7iiv4j 219vgratQgfgj il6fpra97in1 mloOWPFGuMaTA jnql+ga4TXth vPMOTOJpPzN+g U8FLyo9cejhe oqgc4sE7OstGx s2kXM7GKeze8 6MDSzIz-69BMO OyoeNNLytaWB K7-aW3tMdqjbM ZhBemfEji7lF IjDxn8c54tf24 7v47hj1ydU54 qZpKa4QH6V8zC c+4PjLidGJ-G WxgCQQnz+9rS8 LwdyZ39Coz-X B1Okr9Q2ttHif 95hnSXYaeEOV SXkTykiRpuktN IKXWNrVP3Kvi U1lW0crTm3vyo 8ez57eL4pFf4 nqWegk0gzN8WV eZWORv4AJgRg iJoQhjh5kQVI9 PO591+KMJAKy QsXWPMKkCpFEi Gw9AQB5SLocX TaJkAi0MV2lRL rZhef-xpIEOy Fz7+KktClZimp +3YmrvllQM3V idzNaBZI-kddP FmXiHBPi3S62 lLrZnFN8QfK6W oOq-j1IEqmkQ -3M3bVhfsZKER G9OYMh8ha2te O55t6sWcLTa9R RZKCjO+82auo hwYfl6ISvRjsV 1f8Jj8fD2epQ WIsZ5+6SluTOK -Oj9lwlm+fQV Nd9J5xw+EJGw7 YCjA-hF7NgmD uU9vnIFNBV8fb 8Tro9sKLP3gW v3k7ns6xBt3Nz AIB1DCOX2LKM KRjNeLV1KJ6Ge ziIrJUEe5bTM BK+Ca2sPKBwEL 1XjBQxrtVg7p WsrL40hLn+NqN gEyxEhTwWUrL S3EsF5ROzi4vY v7R-oIgf88+w F+Of-iL3fKk8V lFzl9-N4E0jZ pPlKvGxU0mTaA FeE6+Gpf1231 R29+clbP02+Gq muq+KkKfWvEe ZP51bDOAsgs9A rsV16WaW5rV6 bxFISuv+LqBFM H3-3S-Ykgjcu eMEjX7LvWfJNw Oxdeodb6JwYa PogOhhQmbCE1N Rc+faC690kCF Qqo9JYxV8O3Gk 4i+8gYkt0-U- aF1B9-UZ18cUK dmezOtTNZdKj 6P8rTa8-m99Hf R4NbUoLEfr-c pxsU3Dpyco69V h89F9dJNvYk9 krIDdnNOvgEfM rQoMe2+qrg85 vLrXXGZIpj0CY Q538pO6MQ7UM wZFKVYIiUHvk4 oQe0uMEeaCo1 Xly7mEpRz1PW4 6a-IeeC6+1ya J3URm4D387EpS B1qiKBoT-PcW 7N0vWxZrsU+cd RPfjMCdO24hB whlCYsKVSqG+m 8AaAC37L200g tK8BJQ+D6U8cE ak8rQlNa+MoR 6-mwg9CJRtIBP 8qKtLBGlIO8K q34a7ph10Nwgh 2hoprnF2Qimv J1g-TBveMERPH 9K9TDO0e4R8k 8bWXEJKR74nmQ V3pmZatEcMkB l-kuFLbt+hzQ1 bEMO4qamnBF0 dFQvIEItlsJqV EPC5E9ci1Ta1 Co0wxcNIRBYSA 3diUPEJO4fA2 Qz0r0oIZLaLc1 WW9nHbqnCnCN iaLvTN9UVR-tM 3kPPep+edie7 cQ-rTBnarQlHs MaYM2KEooqN6 t1hYQz2EF2PR4 y-lQ-GFPd0JK +1Eo+yHLA-gpp 6X5Pa24WPkAh p3hOjx7s7zzO+ +U-+UA-Dl1u9 ZmsjINQjpLAW4 eHaRa42jzVgM dIfoJu5cPNUZS VJR47QCWuSCL 3TeG20JLc6TFi -eOEWoEAd1Av WJx5GJZNf5LHR Fs6An9CaCUJX Xn4+J8FUGciZm sXW9PQ02YnpW 8qNP8ENe9MZxo +U9QC8JoKA8N FZx8GfVN226Ai 2cEU47CUf4+s S2h5ambW7i10O e52NnAlM+ZmT zxc+0+21+k2z2 DcgDc9I9NVZV ycSazk--fu5eF ubp41-Loi5GJ IjcY1p1Le3UxF 5eFpx6upz3+1 cW5GqZ23LHOQl v5DITFqx+27I HmZuZGiZlVx+N XW8NNXJEAGdU RRLd2PRBJ9uVQ CaESNRR5nWS9 3jFX4tP0Ga17P Z+2XBlIj-bAb ce14+mcrI0P8W LojoAOtufUg
hzxXzs++EGYN7FU+-+U++N+-Y++1zv++FF5JXOr
hPq7Z+4H++++++EA+3EE1-UcB+++7OE++1M+
h-UI3-UY4-EM70kU4-UU91+c80kc81-+A1+k
h4lgQ5lwT5lwT5lwT5k25-kQB1+oM2-+M4VI
h5lwT5lwT5lwT5lwT5lwT5lwT5lwT5lwT5lw
h++6F+EAF+Tz2+AQ+++23+E2++++++++++++
h+++++++++++++E61--+++EE-+UI2+EE1+E+
h6VF+I22J-a-k6mEF++21+EI4-EE0+EI++++
hkI6H-74VIWClMX1koL8GEl6-+++++++++++
h+E2++++++E+F6H3-233V654-A74VgI1-oT1
h8Q0Q626+402Q21-UVJ06qRCdDp4cjteYiSf
hYoKKfuwbfPnCeOke+J-333UF8sEC+5+JA2w
hAs62ssEA+BFJlAv9taLb5Q5hWiDESCdiqur
hMqNjuV6p1mO3eZgmFPZkAdFmooP7P7Kv-+e
hr9FKlLNgGHCJ-fqRcZYEFXokP7Yu8N7HEpL
hbcRpd3kyN52GVNgJXYF7fHAAPjfZXU32UfQ
hBaEuWX4XiHZOGhvF+WUZiJ6G6cqyIsZRGZa
hQQKlHVc+rByQNIxmoCGgooXxSdsutCsmKce
hPQiSKvzbefm0ciwuDDGeiMbH3UNWnGKPvIQ
h0Dun3ne9amJYvl8p2D8fBZBON4V2BILY0B1
hl1ZdG7G9thjbeAuo4B3F+GXF6lau1jneQut
h2OGiKMpML6me06C+mrTTZVj8B-ZaOukLBXZ
hXU8O+YoTTbYj9oeiTAxvhROWdbhFv1hF7Ld
h9B8nFybXXz9pJHht8pAdjY6hgf63v4Scvcw
h-yHeZn9OuuOpbgqEgUtIYOY1I14i+mXR7OK
hqXPIZ4s44qdZXhVqBB1aFAJzJXtGOP1YPCN
hZ2Zb8YHdQcjdQcYg0R67IGR5B+z22c2hnIG
hD0LOdReDERcEvEVqeDFFuNiL54cwZAJhqPD
hd5hEvJ5hIFmEuPjazMm9P7GkJXLa0efikfs
hmNJMYZVFZRFNhiT+h87kQeIAH-oGm2SeZkb
h6j8zfXmhJaBFR0C3XFIMW6Hz+0zbNljlxol
h6wAZsthdYpaRWpeSwJUKvbZm2wv87AtmZR1
hIhqPAlQpvvE073u61usdY05E8rjQv8WRId+
h5ed9nkfKsvdRYFVG7XGF9yjthZgAj8elegf
h2UxqZeQCJaLL0A8YCp1hIXwiPZbnOVCcon3
hMLXmw183RSF8xYP5HwkGdXZzLORJcu6R2CW
hWtpeKl+lkxqyCQHk59UGhWlnJV1cVoEu6xI
htsUVJFjhQBGt7Z8nsPRUHmPCYFoZo5F1cXr
h7fuhPprz++r43ZmeqT7gIhVhVKCOqnPcKNC
hbBViBjYmlpdpnbWlwRRgzV95lNen-cO41Ec
h0kBCsOFP3GjU6zMeARIISG0+NN2n4jAXDvA
hrOckmhbpTJp64-HFF02+JsyIVmIh8S8ZN3W
hehYic6RO6-5lUrHgJy3LaGeXJLP6-SBSBOG
h2lJCGlt40ArDlWMtA5wof+xf1m6ppZ02Ef6
hsuwUJxPXF7z57MQtGZbKW2ztCkGywtbie4t
hMeWqikpH+iZN21vhvlb4O34BCElwM6FdLWe
hmjdr3TlZqYMqF3SCpS0t4X8LpQVTKjUBai2
h6op42NE1A3sfH8ga-DYFhdebYrkn7EkQQ6o
hmA6KmmlR4r6o8iJSaI0-3m3yvdoR0oMlEW-
hubfRUnJV-W1skHp674exVe61QDzO++U-+U+
hlROYu-HysuRCbx9w40PUuTUuRCbHdouTq5H
hNTp5Um06KZAaH7jIDIuTp1oCbHdouRCbs5U
h+-sSUzuQDt7x97Ym6HSumNBv1w4HQ4H7YmN
hRDvPShYr3ZdHSVYr3Yr-jGrcNAazF1v5zxc
h+bdzzxc+0+2-+EMz+VMBUqWkPFgzPD9UBuZ
h1O9-h35IBzd47Liz9ozQb7wonik+0nFirVF
hy3cbxKbGDaI5fpAxVXu7oYcmV6GVDzf6KWk
hNJoNQk5JEmoleF4hdBieMeSddGYR4KuKBUg
hXNyq+ZnHEol2Q3+F1-v+dkbdNU0EAhu2+wB
hmZIQZTNQfYF9J1s7hC7blB2G70+s7jSZxIw
hqXD7HejLiz7e-Q-Q2kgV5+-RthxXF9GxQVS
hBcK-HAu06RpeEoqXdkjegqNAdOKcQlVqbUg
hB8w6MKFyDjCzvcEW4X4U4p3LIEFSf+oLiLF
hj0b4DO1FRCkupBMyUACNqlM2IR1okYKHfB8
hk95vPKOJyfpS4vP3UFIWpxJUU+3p-osgX0t
hSGPM83Ug06L2-f6tyoL9xIL+HGWlHa8SAaK
hPFoolLPxpqa63unAup0n-vf6kU26tGywdX+
hA73OYtCH6zk29oHt6LzF55YJIiSFFDYIApD
hW-Ca9mj8qXP+FDtpE-rp4qpXbaJkLH7+5h3
hQ2vi0Xadglxdjv8DiR73v8CZ0uA4higcP8q
h8wJG91S243p3Smd7JSaxNdRmD3FZ4w3Oidj
hCOMA2LFAWq53RAOMmKOI9jtFO1GCxRhJpOT
hm7n-w5HR2S9iez6yZ2yPDsfhTaeF5oEu+P+
hQI08f9Y9f5Ye-RWSt2ha48Z4J7GIbXKRF7L
hxUkFuifSjBFbeoTTScXHbZOzW3QzBNcl1vX
h1HZ99Igiqci-LPTjJPniiJxmTu8ctfSJGyn
hr6gGueap-ozqJ3zjNkK+E3C98x3gdYezRJM
h6RdvzeN5Ar1aDQbAwYP1ASpD7+vHM4NaMX7
hiDXQq0FpDg9TsZQyD6LeNBggCoSPvRALtze
hN0PTRUH5r4NBRSyFf28gemN-kQGq4TDJkBo
hou0z6b7BwePSUvyopGcQPr1QzNuThUfSyHT
hl8sk1qCbvzuXRnHrR4XqHbcrBjGQR0CYqXY
hEWvCDrBcEeKfjD903wcp4nHjcznz+8b9DqF
hPvHwOQPLyMgkdL2TNzI04UQpG0y6A7aE15r
hYhNLKjK9zH18AC-f5jCk+mjNeC+dQG0YMWj
hPNIKTm63KytJyvABkt7KMbMITn-82JqUDVf
hvkPvW3yl4DrG87tXZLV1fWMxKwAcqr9yNaj
hmr8pAtNwRBeJdxZopnNbzTnpvBjT8Cl5kV8
hVAzCilACCMFztWdX-FKabHwEWjln-Vxc8Hk
h3Kyl8ZExUHVVkVnAlokLilzj6D8j2dRgisG
hnPsEtUDAoEWbT4c1JJ6HkEltZghE1Xa2UcL
haGamQmbvgnq2kQHPUjnITh5-YDOdSkogNoJ
hQtZpZp9mjaDwHID12Oci4OsQnKx3ojnNIrO
h9aI9vL9TVpvxs7EB1ZuP2OLlA+ZqItn9E-H
htbAz7bbEV8nNrvn0L9azCyxFNsMQTSKp3r8
hzk1xeIUi6LKdTPZcaI+vHGx11Uch4gH8ZV7
habvIgvCC9fxkVNULsFqyS+zQdXiyWrvkwaf
hF8cIPGrwkcBZaQFCA5OJyJUQQnYnLs8cSK-
hdYBUkTw+VAUoxjw+AwbvaH9XXgGaG0e0bgz
hnl+ASNKeFsd+ggUwp9HP9iERNTlIB5O+Swe
hlwnAMXkMvEfKhvGcHMrLsCSNHRiFTO5vXKc
hjqZQjtQORkSC0m8cGbBryGKM52dpe3POywg
heQALfwk3uZBojjCBfn8IcxcMupn0n4TSiav
h-v2CQ3GnSzw+7jotL5uXe-m8jYsWa0XbTsW
hzk17KIOGR9T6SCpOWmBwaKAbEy7OnMLQQlf
hDvTt8nNHWbcgFXGVgvJ0nG4-OyuMKYipblK
h+41i-aZwkze1orR5XI0-UpIo7wpi+9J5QCd
hO0yVm2tHngbtUXYefAQMK6rj1PfTrFRU8ld
hIs9afxTwiOpX+vii6pJFckceane7JILh4un
hH5ZWXoOlWQqU9wTymmvKytl828bSAWgviIX
hCZI3fZbYBJJEoCEixil3QL7KDmkn8UL4qC6
hvzw+MtpD7zw+NbGimwTS9ae6qp9GS8RLvn-
hfJ3sptaIb+zwG8FhlvRSNKexdOMmXE9r8Yd
hCLDDCGOxRaVZ0mOSGqIqjjqJzBHxlAz3NaI
hA4D1bVe4Q3OorAemzPzrAgt8BrJAEeIQ98d
hGz7wi6UgXXx66bn1gPzIi3kQZzis0rqt9zm
hTsn1TFCUTsfFzWvx3R8X+JuvZmtQiLoiL9u
hUgDtVQjcmsTk5c6yZmzEx9Z0yVxJncYBGYO
htTcTIOxNMERJFZx8sk7Leje-THIkWmtQhAk
h9uVojfh3x8x+DFLciMFSWtTGihR9V49ZyWi
h++U-+kA-Dm5y65wU6AHyJIfy8ARHyIjuBGd
hbpbw2uXo2e7z+CcCZR9u6MuDoOu9GrKtIfd
hSWjKYfuBiYh-uJ8ZROZGjExOZRPx+R55Ilu
hUiaiWa5cL8b2DI8Z5KcY0AiLuwTGlu45cAf
h+DgyuLNWEKvrrSlrqvlGMHt+PHOPTSgPnxq
h0PNbfsdFgj30+Tw+e2DyozHaq1UPpgX-ibX
h0+E4IkRcyfGsR0+kWMoTjIoVLW0G2iIOck9
hx2hHL-cmhj9gbFYG3s2T6-cMLy0UC3kJApX
hj1zgiDdlDWvjzxc+0+2-+k2z20NLmMLmTik
hafTRWabLinNP-mnZhowgKptvaTvgldPheir
hhP35iZICIBwdI-qdWrgKi6cEU2k9M-QMW6v
hebzFtWE3YRc8DAz0Mm7j235jTe4jNEV7J+c
hLe+nR4qKavMuN+NDqZ-tXg10XGOXQfB0K0W
hJ-TUgyo8lww2RyRkeyTqFXyv4mA7QRbxHBC
h6rwzh1QtS98y-aN8850JsgX5Ubi-G6J6yM8
h94sWekodT2dXfmg5ceTWOZf9rI0tumza8Uw
hh3ZxYz2c6vPTn2KHW7xnyqPFE+XCkj5fNPn
hhd-LqckFRgk2cch-r02N-PNu15QsNW-wg8U
hMnzdlDoAfwN3VHWzp1Ej+kB-4USzvMdD-Gq
hAKarqbY6oFp-B8w7H4i-P3hvok6Us41LEt1
hPDWvaE62KIuUdanQ+ozBTsF2RpP-mtDtamp
hO9xSI7HqUcg1aNlZEHM0rAjMzk+dd-s1KhC
hbjaCTWJSK9jZHycl4mmCWSTrAnVIef9geSA
hWT89QOLudRYoS5IG+I4ELMOVYUQdrqE33LG
hdqSw0JNMkoh4mPZobKmhrPtW08mNQgfGk94
hxm49G9xe8T9Q-myDuaXnHysQr3Ge-mhzqu2
hQ1-WmacdKoSNqBk9Y9OLOAi0fh7G9SOM6RG
h47OSEgbMcsXW1q00RVdhy6qL8lwszeJHdgi
haGl5sG9FcXR-qalqbxkO4uVg5Dw+ge0KQuC
h-Wo9H1GiZxmckfnn+99G2JU+YAXR5k2BeUZ
hLm5VedRuCth+1aJi+98QzStS4lfNSs6dBap
h-8OwW-cte+ORcUT6Tr8Z1ekVxdHn5Od1BD1
hIsCl1h-ObU+D+0EJiS00jRe+-LP-oWhafy6
hUFElmUU-tfAF0hWyrO1JYlg8ntAnDjQEgKA
hzk0Inj+9y-6F4JhnWfz2D3+I-CJh+OOTuVj
hj6Zi+WdFYIhftJXUfSFFEbX22ICS9W63bay
h1F16kQK+-EJs6fh9+jw+AK8Kp2MxJ8ENFGS
hb8wcYe6g9HVuiKlMC0PUVBE0q5CKJ9tmVRy
hRKE61-POi+ZjoeUI69Qfi6JvoEMIAn6LJNj
hUxUsZFLaYDWRk8ziIJiOOVjM8+j8wF6U7JV
hhOEFm2atf-4-f85+9vc6nz+gqXjDrV-bsFC
ht99UlrczV+YJkcaYtREivgiE5a5rXNXCHOK
hP45K41+Y83hEQSJaBUmC7Gwsl8HMj+JnUMy
hY9It-UNMUci9CP1Dy-3Q6Kd7gpSHa4yCvEH
h9+oXA-xdULhf7M4PAIAUhBJGysDAfH9qN33
h6I8oo+fv9+pUMv8P6OI-MpkjS6U0aog+nY3
hTnIPoS9AKywHYfgi-F8EWURWs1Okb6A3dFv
hFKvsz2t+oLY0xzACHOoOtk3DQtWtVqf9Ds6
hj3mMlAto0nTQMBpl1u5WsCHI+Glt-Vy9e49
h8RnNpgAsrH8dledPYAvi4X2HB9YLSq0-ZSO
h8VPOvTiEpK4VZn5P0n-PwWIvTZWxlkjBBgC
hyomF5GugMc8r04G4+3vlQ05SI8fSlFTWFBg
hLIjZ1OMJW+chcUcBKg06wqf9MCULPPEZIlt
hi9SQKfv9acVX96PgI6EHm8BV11hasoQfQQv
h2jbgVmj+I3y9Zy+eh+1xkcfl6XTqeSvxccU
hc9Sw0OX541C27baDuD9PcvBbj++kUUrHnGJ
hBRysywMM-4Vhk4nLa+iQZ88lFYi9I8JP1Zj
h0IZIAZqcGcrm1+i-J+eJ6-0PhYwgFLHK84k
h--db6NXFAhR33Okl4xMaX9bGGhBM7j99D4U
hzB5+nSph3E8pSJhlK7SE+xntMWSigerbqZk
h+jmnQhQBodRRgYJgcM9+0qwimK0tJXHUti8
hEuA4JGrFFX88eJiyo6sX9r-8vHIh7E81JvQ
h0fCn8RkGAPtrIK-K03-wDrbUzQ8wuf0IJEm
heeFFqX6Zx30nEDbz+0NEiqoNrHW0IKn7KeQ
hGv8jdGX5HBqxNXJ6PvEEPe8QJJM6zOJx7Ah
hPwFqXMGew+jRQEd4-8b3oqTW-RltV1S1zk1
h9AUh25XrWUK-HjMxr9IOJcCFK-vpeLgtEU3
hQzOCxe4WJmrHaJMidb2OFejqMsgCCR0yt4s
hNN4agLVijlQfdWXFdo9f98Y4GnOh547H+Np
hNjSMRQIhNRvE9yMLOYNPAzin16VKKL57hvl
ho5Zl+QKqZPS-GxsuOh9hICl2oVB1lFs118k
hnu+W0NsBnXfTeNQi5KtQjo9IIa08BGs-p4L
h4dV5JzUpu9ZmdHdZ-Hc9x9WS5c-+CZ6lRZl
hZyitGyZmyf1ekuZ-ube1p+i37LI21eEyWGZ
h46kclZmc21u9B7f-QcOW99k8KtuB2jcH7bc
hUruU+SF2ac-ZxK81IS6WdWUBDHBEitP+FeM
h4RF1QFamJ+F+lX7AdHcAr9NP5dSLAFV674n
hGg4sxFTG3IrWM6MNMfVucoVpVONTGvEWxH0
h4+523dq7FWSVn8GYpAx+d9FIqmqLWdTSBRA
hWIGiodZ2cXp6SCWqNPWR020yWaImy2-Rkcu
hJCTeJ8xMGc+R+ei4yhGdLpOZEuLW2i9L2IS
hiZx+GjGeIxKLp7LFV+uJ099FIeJpL3X3x5o
hbBEJo6DFu07+WTJNjBcn7WGcbEHJ+X8XxJj
hPx7Ne+R3E7KWJp0JocmhVO87Lc6GJa1A8Gz
hO+myhF5W+Y8EZp-CVIEsURFdjcWXFi3xEey
h2f3EIukMIZ6pIILc0n1o7GIZbAFJYP4sZMU
hPc+Z5EkiIaYv6V+k-DOJ2WSY2FsUaCR0t-J
BpW6mcd969VHaJpTzqJTz
+
end
the bill of rights is what makes all this outcry on slashdot about "our rights" possible... if it wasn't for that bill of rights (the constitution too) then we wouldn't be allowed to say what we say here... nor would we even have any rights to fight for...
unzip; strip; touch; finger; mount; fsck; more; yes; unmount; sleep
I troll YOUR kind between meals without losing my appetite. I've got Stars and Stripes toilet paper, too!
The moonrock will be represented by An Inanimate Carbon Rod.
Vote Technocratic! Government by killer robots!
Yeah, we're scared. The only thing that incident proved is that Chinese fly about as well as they drive.
And if GWB is so corrupt, what would you call a US president that almost certainly took money from such a "filthy, murderous ... apparatus"?
I was gonna say that since we planted a US Flag on the Moon, then basically we claimed it. (At least that's the way it works in cartoons.) But as I recall, we actually brought the flag back with us.
The US has limited outer space jurisdiction, according to the Outer Space Treaty of 1967. The treaty limited State sovereignty over outer space. Outer space was declared to be the common heritage of mankind. It prevented certain military operations in outer space and upon celestial bodies, specifically, the placing in orbit of any nuclear weapons or other weapons of mass destruction, and the installation of such weapons on celestial bodies. Outer space was otherwise to be reserved for peaceful uses. Various other international conventions, such as the Moon Registration, and Liability Treaties, expand upon provisions found in the Outer Space Treaty.
The Moon Treaty of 1979 essentially stated that the exploration and use of the moon shall be the province of all mankind and shall be carried out for the benefit and in the interests of all countries.
The theory of relativity doesn't work right in Arkansas.
But J'Raxis is such a fag! Post them on Trollaxor's site instead. (He's a fag too, but nowhere near as gay as J'Raxis.)
What dumbfuck moderated this as offtopic? It was a direct response to:
Also, if the World were American, Bush wouldn't be the President, who was the most people? China? So probably some chinese will be voted in. A close second some indian... you get the picture.
Very good point. The way the economy works now, the only way it keeps going (or almost going, as is the current case), is to use natural resources - including labor - at cheaper rates from other countries.
The moon's not under US jurisdiction? I thought that George W & Co had declared that everything everywhere was under US jurisdiction.
The man on the moon is a terrorist, we must apprehend him.
Not in many of the reservations. They got the worst land, lots of desert real estate.
If China gets anywhere close to putting a base on the moon - like they recently were talking about - I can guarantee that the US would pore billions into a program to take it for 'humanities sake'. Not that I think that is bad, as an American I would rather see us there that China.
It would be nice to see a new society develop there. One that begins as an international group of pioneers and, over generations, develops into a nation of its own.
The idea of the moon being a colony of a single nation just doesn't appeal to me. It'll probably be that way in the beginning though - because of the cash needed to pull something like that off. Unless a very large corporation does it - God, can you imagine Bill G as ruler of the moon!
It's silly how bizarre everyone's being about a little piece of rock: It's not chemically different from a plain old earth rock -- and it's not like it's rare or anything. Everbody knows that there're hundreds of billions of tons of the crud and everyone knows exactly where to find it.
What do you mean they cut the power? How can they cut the power, man? They're animals!
You used to could check them out from NASA if you were a teacher at an accredited institution--or something like that. You'd get a pebble inside a lucite hockey puck, suitable for viewing under a microscope. I know somebody who checked one out, then slept with it in his bed (he also used it in a space exhibit at a student fair).
Couldn't find anything at the JSC site about this in a quick search. Maybe they don't do it any more, or maybe their site is hard to find things on.
By an amazing coincidence, I was watching the movie "Apollo 13" tonight on TV and it got me looking up facts about the moon on NASA's web site. I happened to come across a page that tells you how to request lunar samples. From that page:
I don't know whether this applies to the particular Honduras lunar sample, but I thought it was interesting.
Teletubby 1: Ooooh! (picks up rock at his feet) Pretty!
Teletubbies 2&3: Ooooh! Pretty!
(Commercial Interruption crackles on one of the Tubbies tummies)
Jerry Falwell: Hi kids, Reverend Falwell here. Don't watch the Teletubbies. Teletubbies are evil.
Teletubby 1: (antenna lights up)
Teletubby 2: (gets a box)
Teletubby 3: (gets a stamp)
Teletubby 1: (Packs the rock into a box and ships it to Falwell) Now he's our friend!
Teletubby 3: He's special!
Teletubby 2: Who's special?
Teletubby 1: Jerry is!
Falwell: I don't want your worthless rock! (sells it to the church of scientology, church sells it on EBay to some kid in Florida)
(Teletubbies beat Florida kid senseless, steal his rock and ship it back to Falwell)
I realize this may seem like an overly-simplified comparison, but I think it paints a pretty accurate portrait of just how important this issue is.
If so, then how do we get to start doing that, instead of protecting the interested of the ruling corporations, and actively opposing freedom and democracy?
Tom Swiss | the infamous tms | my blog
You cannot wash away blood with blood
If you'd read the article you'd know that it left Honduras under the tenure of one of their various dictators. They'd like it back.
Why?
When some of the facts leading to this case happenned Honduras was a dictatorship.
United States v. Lucite ball containing lunar material (an actual case, I'm not making this up, folks)
Uh-oh. Lucy's getting sued by the government? Ricky's never gonna let her play with the band now!
Has anybody but NASA been to the moon lately?
Personally I think you are easily scared.
BOO!!!!
my name is ahmad
me likes your song
I'm sure there are plenty of people who would take a rock from their backyard, encase it in a Lucite ball and sell it on eBay if they thought people would fall for it. Heck, from the looks of the photo, that could be a piece of dried dog poop.
Let's take it one step further: Nixon wanted to placate the Honduran dictator without giving him anything of real value, so he had some of Checkers's excrement encased in a futuristic-looking Lucite ball. Deliver it with a plaque and you have a great joke to tell your friends. In fact, I'll bet that's what he was talking about during the famous gap...
NICHT FURSHTEN :(
do bist eine schwartskopf?
ich libe dich!
guten tag!
I don't get your point
But I believe it has something to do with trolls!
-- The_Messenger
Here's an interesting case name on forfeiture:
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. ALL FUNDS ON DEPOSIT IN ANY ACCOUNTS MAINTAINED AT MERRILL LYNCH, PIERCE, FENNER & SMITH, ET AL., Defendants (CV 90-2510; UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK; 801 F. Supp. 984; 1992 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 12263; August 5, 1992, Decided)
To give an example of the last part: I was born in Canada in 85. My brother was born in Canada in 87. We got our US citizenship in 97 or 98. My citizenship only counts for the last four or five years. My brother, on the other hand, is an American citizen from birth. (from what I recall there was a change in immigration law that had a cutoff between me and my brother). So we've lived in the country the same amount, but he could become President and I couldn't.
There are a lot of HIGH costs besides the financial ones to manufacturing computer parts. A lot of very very toxic materials are needed, and china don't dispose of them in a afe manner.
China has a weak rule of law, and a goverment that has trouble effecting change. These two things will hold china back and I have no fear of american power diminishing until these two things are changed. China has a huge aids problem that is growing becaue their leaders are unable to face things. They've built the three gorges dam which could if it fails kill millions.
They won't even admit there is a problem, they can't and so they fester and grow. This and other decisions I fell will ensure that china will remain behind america because they will squander their wealth and advances.
There are some poor or utterly wrong explanations below, so let me clear it up. The rock isn't really "defendant" in the case; it's just the way they write the title. What's happening is the government is trying get a declaration of the disposition of the property as against 1) Rosen, the guy from whom they took the rock, and 2) against the world (probably, although there are some legal technical stuff that might preclude this one). If this is the only point of the case -- which it is here (I suspect because Rosen is unavailable, as in out of the US so unable to be served with process) -- then plaintiff can bring suit "against" the property itself, not as if the property did something wrong, but in order to get the court to say "yes, we declare that this property belongs to you, plaintiff" or, sometimes, "this property does not belong to anyone (because no one is allowed to have it)". The "defendant" doesn't need due process or a way to defend itself because it doesn't NEED to defend itself. Property is property; a bundle of rights plus (sometimes) some tangible thing. The collection of rights may change -- they're legal constructions, after all -- and the court with the right power can change it.
A court can only do this if it has power over the property. For real property, which is what is most often litigated in this way, the court in the state where the property is located can do it. For personal property, the court has to have it within its power. (Since the US took the rock, they would have given it to the court for it to hold for purposes of jurisdiction.)
When a court has power over property, they can hear the case: this is called "in rem" jurisdiction. ALL THIS MEANS is that the court -- as the arm of government that decides legal dispositions of everything -- may declare who really owns the property. "in rem" is not weird, or new -- it has been around for many, many years (definitely since the beginning of our nation, developed in English common law at some point). The main reason there are "in rem" suits is that sometimes it's hard or impossible to sue the proper defendant, because she is unavailable (as in no one can find her) or because the court that has power over the property does not have jurisdiction over the person (the proper defendant) involved. Rather than let this person dispossess others with legit interests in the disposition of property, the courts long ago exercised their power as part of the sovereign state to make the decision themselves.
"In rem" jurisdiction is very limited, nowadays, because of the Supreme Court's interpretation of constitutional due process and the effect on the unavailable defendant. It has NOTHING to do with crimes (although a crime may be involved); it's only about who owns the property. And no, this is not illegal search and seizure, and this is not NECESSARILY forfeiture. If there's a dispute as to ownership of property, the court with power should theoretically be able to adjudicate it (think about it: courts really do it all the time, e.g., in contract disputes).
I suppose whether you think this is right really comes down to what you think property is. But look at it this (admittedly theoretical) way: Sure, you think you own that piece of land. But really, who says you do? Why doesn't the next door neighbor do, or some native American, or the first person to say "this property is hereby mine" and plant a flag? The government, of course, say it's yours: this is the legal construct of property ownership. This construct gives a lot of power to the owner, but when there is a real, good faith, significant dispute as to who owns the property, well, what else will decide ownership but the legal system?
At any rate, this is the legal explanation, along with some legal theory...
That's why NASA wants the rock back. No one can prove it, if they don't have a piece of it! Must cover the tracks of the faked moon landing. All the samples given out were just earthly dirt, with some iron thrown in for good measure. When pushed on this issue in the future, (after the truth of the bogus samples is known) NASA will claim that 'Moon' rock is far too valuable to have given out willy-nilly to governments around the world. The 'moon' rock is fake, the landing is fake, and the lawsuit is to cover it all up.
so what does ebay have to say about this?
Hispanics almost outnumber whites in the US
Not even close, trollboy.
Hispanics make up 12.0 percent of the population as of the 2000 census.
we would need several more earths to provide all the raw materials.
Wrong. The world could easily be fed with the infrastructure and materials we have now. I guess it never entered your head that the reason that the government pays for those fields to lie fallow is that there's NO MARKET, because the governments (almost all nominally socialist) of the starving countries stands in the way.
You're a fucking moron, troll-boy.
And, by the way, damned near EVERY raw material is cheaper today than it was in 1970, and the population of the developed countries is STABILIZING.
I'm sorry if that contradicts your "looming disaster" scenario.
No, actually, I'm not.
*idiot detector goes crazy*
and the percentage of white people in the us population is ~15%.
Hey shithead, take a look at the astronauts that have been on "da moon". Some have been Canadian. Also, where do you think the name CanadArm comes from (is the giant arm on the space shuttle in case you weren't aware). That's right, made in Canada.
"The world could easily be fed with the infrastructure and materials we have now."
... consumed resources like Americans, we would need several more earths to provide all the raw materials."
Maybe you didn't read his post closely enough. Now I know it's hard for you, being ignorant and all, but please try to READ before spouting off and looking like a fool. Here's what he said:
"If the rest of the world
This is the TRUTH. Do a little research on "sustainable development" if you don't believe it. The world cannot currently provide the energy requirements of six billion people who live like the typical american. Maybe when someone comes up with cold fusion or some other miraculous form of energy conversion, then it will be possible. But until then, most americans will grab as much as they can for themselves, and to hell with anyone else.
It's Ironic that the government would fight so hard to get a moon rock back. Cuz NASA has many tons of moon rocks sitting in storage, untouched since 1970.
All it takes is nukes and nerves.
I would disagree
Time for some tasty Shiner Bock!
As Paul Merton said, "Well, it's better than the Americans just assuming it's theirs."
I love it when two ACs battle it out. It's kinda like the battle between Good and Evil, except it's totally up to you whose side you're on. I guess that makes it like the War on Terrorism. (Though Mohammad Atta isn't an AC any more.)
god, why do I write stuff like that?
If, as AC #1 believes, "The world could easily be fed with the infrastructure and materials we have now," I ask: Why isn't it happening then? There are hungry people right here in America, after all. (And I'm not talking about the kind of hunger that I'm about to solve by ordering a pizza.)
The United States Constitution, Article II, Section 1, paragraph 5
No person except a natural born citizen, or a citizen of the United States, at the time of the adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the office of President; neither shall any person be eligible to that office who shall not have attained to the age of thirty five years, and been fourteen Years a resident within the United States.
And there will be again. If forest fires permanently destroyed forests, I would have to imagine there would be no forests.
.50 cal machine gun. Not exactly the noble battle of Man vs. Beast most people envision.
Mt. St. Helens is a perfect example, even though there aren't really any trees growing there 20 years later. There's plenty of "nature".
Indians, on the other hand, by which I mean their society, way of life, yadda yadda, will not be coming back any time soon. The best example I can think of is the Macah tribe out here in Washington that likes to go and hunt whales every now and again. People get all up in arms over it. Plus, here's the "traditional" whale hunt they go on: One guy throws an old-timey harpoon in the whale, and once "tradition" has been satisfied they open up with the
I am going to listen to Talking Heads "Moon Rocks" from the Speaking In Tongues album in a last-ditch effort to stay on topic.
you all got trolled you retards
How long until we are required to show chain of custody documetns & receipts for every single object we own, lest the government sieze them as stolen?
Happens that way with real property all the time. Why do you think so much is involved in buying a house, including buying insurance to protect the deed's validity?
I don't need large brains to have a good time.
There are hungry people in America, because they are told it is noble not to seek help, or because they live in an area in which the people belive it is a good idea to force people to work or starve.
You make that sound as if the United States is doing something unsusual. Treaties are declared only because two countries find them beneficial, and are usually discarded when one of the two countries doesn't
Rarely is it discarded because both countries don't.
OK
/the businessman thinks it's worth $10m/
I break into your house and steal your computer. The computer has ten million lines of code you have been working on for years but intended to license under GNU. I sell that code to a businessman for a tidy sum
Do you want your code back?
What fucktard thought this was news worthy? oh NM
So where the Romans, the Spanish, the English, the French.. in their times. And all belived they will rule forever.
Just that empires come and go, power becomes corupted, and they fail.. probably the next great power will be China.
have you never seen "The Mouse on The Moon"
There are places where the networks are not touching,and there are places where they are-Boeing's Lori Gunter
I guess the rock looked at the OJ Simpson case and then at the M$ debacle and deduced it would have a good chance at winning... after all it's very famous and the "only" real space rock...
--
"we live in a post-ideological world..." - Billy Bragg.
So If I go to the Smithsonian, open a display case with moon rock and just take it, and if the govt sued me to try to get it back, it would be "ironic?"
So wouldn't that mean that Switzerland claims it?
once it was given to honduras its none of the us govt's business what happens to it. outside of their juristiction/reach.
I don't get it. The USA govt isn't supposed to be in any kind of materials business. That's why manufacture of even our most top-secret military hardware is subcontracted out to the private sector.
Does Bush's govt think the moon is a colony?
Small nitpick- I usually agree with the stuff you write.
National Parks are one of the few types federally owned land that is reserved for 'nature' (and our enjoyment of it). Most other categories are for exploitation and always have been. National Forests exists to preserve and manage timber resources. I'm not so sure the purpose of other classes of land, but its almost always set aside to manage/exploit resources- not to keep them in pristine condition. The fact that cool places exists in National Forests is secondary to the fact that the government claims the rights to (and eventually will) log it. Not sure what explicit protection 'Wildlife Refuges' have, but I guarantee its less than a National Park.
I find it surprising the number of people who act like the words "under God" belong in the pledge. If the words were "under Allah" or "under Zeus", how would you feel about saying them every morning? Just because you believe in God -- and therefore are inspired (or at worst unmoved) by these two words -- doesn't mean that everyone else who does not should be forced to recite them.
'DuranDuran' is implying that the suit (and even more so, the finding) was frivolous. It was not, and I find the prospect of Senate making the current 45-year-old pledge phrasology into a constitutional amendment enough to make me consider emigration.
In fact, Neil, Buzz, and Mike did go through all the proper customs paperwork when they brough their moon rocks back. You can see the actual customs declaration here
This is what is known as an "in rem" suit. A party -- here, the government -- seeks to establish that it is the owner of a piece of property. Provided that a court has jurisdiction over the property, it can decide everyone's rights in it -- not just parties to the suit. In contrast, if the government just sues one person for an object and wins, anyone else can still claim to be the rightful owner of the object and (usually) will not be bound by the earlier judgment.
There are many well-known cases with names like "U.S. v. 40 acres of land," and people love to cite a customs case called something like "U.S. v. 133 boxes of Mrs. Floogle's Delightful Foot Powder." I have been told, but cannot verify, that slaves' suits for freedom were usually done in rem, in order to extinguish all claims, not just the apparent masters', which is why the famous case just before the civil war was known as "Dred Scot v. Sanford" rather than "Scot v. Sanford": "Dred Scot" was not personally the plaintiff, but rather a description of the disputed "res."
Either that, or the WWF (err, WWE) champ is involved.
I Can't Believe It's A Law Firm, LLP does not necessarily endorse the contents of this message.
The case is fun in several ways. First, of course, there is the question of how ownership of personal property is initially created -- in this case by physically claiming it before anyone else. There are related treaty issues, of course.
The second, perhaps more interesting question here, is this: "Why is the U.S. suing a rock?" That, as opposed to the question why isn't the US suing the person currently in possession for title to the rock. The answer is one of jurisdiction -- ad personam jurisdiction.
You can sue property (so called in rem suits) or people (in personam), provided that you have jurisdiction over the relevant party. It is not uncommon at all, particularly in civil seizure scenarios. At any rate, the point of suing the property is to assure that it is within the jurisdiction o fhte court (when the individual in possession may not be), and then take the property after "title" in it is cleared.
So, basically, if they pay their insurance premiums for a couple of months, the lunar material could just vanish, and these two guys would get a free ride to the moon, courtesy of the insurance company. I mean, they have to get a new sample, right?
My question is, where do i sign up?
Estimated cost of 1.142g of lunar material:
$5million
amount brought back by EACH mission:
100kg
total value of each lunar mission:
$437 billio
Any companies interested in that?
Oh, moon rock, Wow!!
The same has been true for some time here for "bits and pieces" of endangered species. You have to prove that you got it legally if it is sufficiently new. Such restrictions are likely to be the only reason some of the species are still on the endangered list, rather than the extinct list.
I don't see any problems with that.
This is the TRUTH
No, it isn't. Even if you post it in all caps.
Maybe when someone comes up with cold fusion
Good, old-fashioned nuclear fission would do the job, except for the "sustainable development" 'tards who try to scare the brainless sheep. The "sustainable development" people are actually against ANY development. They want the masses to remain ignorant and poor, because that's where their power base comes from.
"The world could easily be fed with the infrastructure and materials we have now," I ask: Why isn't it happening then?
Socialism and other brain-damaged forms of government, for the most part.
There are hungry people right here in America, after all.
Very, very few. Any city of any size has food banks, homeless shelters, etc. where you can get food, no questions asked.
Granted, for some of them you might have to listen to a prayer first, but personally I find religion less offensive than the socialist dogma that killed upwards of 50 million people in the 20th century.
A close friend of my family was ver influential at NASA for all of the FL launches. He gave me a patch that has been to the moon and back. Its was one of the patches that NASA allowed to be given out to the public (mostly senators and the like) but when I was given the patch, the comment was made "its rare now but in twenty years it will be common".
To me it its a memorial -- not to where man has been but to where man has no ability to return.
Mod parent up! The linked article is VERY interesting and a must read.
Question: Can you [Americans] sue the constitution for violating your constitutional rights?
"...ironic considering that NASA took something that wasn't under U.S. jurisdiction."
When your country goes to the moon, you can claim your own moon rocks. Until then, suck it up. At least I'm assuming that's what the submitter meant... The context of that comment is so ambiguous as to inspire large quantities of confusion...
You need a FREE iPod Nano
Under the Code of Federal Regulations, Title 14, Section 1221, adopted on July 16, 1969 [four days before Neil Armstrong set foot on the moon] and still in effect when I ran across it in the 90's, the chief administrator of NASA has extraordinary, almost dictatorial, powers when it comes to anything that returns from outer space.
For example, if you encounter an extraterrestrial object, you can be apprehended and detained (even secretly) for any duration at the discretion of the NASA Administrator (or his appointees) without a hearing, and the courts are explicitly denied the right to free you! Just encountering someone who encountered such an object was enough to make you subject to these terms! (In this case: man encounters lucite which encountered moon rock)
Don't take my word for it. The law is quoted below (I can't seen to link it on the gov website today). Freaky stuff! A very relevant caveat given today's security hysteria and open-ended blanket laws.
It's easy to see what they were afraid of (The first moon rocks were to arrive in a week, and the risks of exposure were unknown), but the law wasn't time-limited, and remained in effect for decades despite a steady trickle of questions from the public.
Actually, in the U.S. the DEA (or local law enforcement in many states) can sieze your property if you are suspected -- not even charged, mind you -- of being a drug dealer. In California, this is also true for being in a gang or being associated with a gang. You then have to go to court to get your stuff back, even if you're never charged -- and what are you gonna use to pay for that suit? Mm hm.
So, don't count too heavily on your constitutional protection from unreasonable search and siezure.
Oh, go on, check out my job.
The idea that the rock is linked in terms of property to the land on the moon from which it was taken is anacrhonistic, useless and wrong. The reason the US govt claims rights to it is because of the enormous expense undertaken in acquiring it. If the only way to get a moonrock of this nature is to build a multi-billion dollar spacecraft, then you'd better believe they're willing to protect that investment. If this were a meteorite from the moon, there would be no contest.
fair enough, but I do find it troubling that the USA spends so much more effort on finding new reserves of oil than it does on educating (or legislating) changes in fuel consumption patterns. It's verging on scandalous that the average fuel consumption of private vehicles in the US should actually be rising. we all know that the American penchant for 2-tonne (or even 3-tonne) 4WD trucks is to blame, but why aren't these vehicles taxed back to the margins where they belong? And why can't the US make a significant move to discourage gasoline use through tax on fuel? It really seems like a crazy situation to a European like myself.
That was classic intercourse!
I can't wait for the Russians to go to the moon.
Spaniards are white Europeans with a little Moorish mixed in... the Moors (sp?) from northern Africa lived in Spain for many, many years. Hispanic is generally considered Spanish and Native American (America being North and South America).
"Generation starship" means that the travel time is longer than human lifetime(s); the passengers at arrival are the (great)*-grandchildren of the passengers at departure. The next feat of engineering on the spacefaring critical path is to build such a generation starship with sufficient resources for a "round trip" in case they have to turn around and come back. Although that is difficult, it is many orders of magnitude easier than terraforming Mars.
Neither the moon nor any asteroid can hold an atmosphere, and thus can not be terraformed. Mars is the best local bet, true, but until our bioligical sciences improve, Mars would still require more trips with more tons of cargo to terraform than is practical relative to extrasolar colonization, unless we can't find any extrasolar suitably terrestrial planets. There is evidence that we probably can, though. Don't shoot first and ask questions later.
actually I think that's not quite right. We left more trash on Afghanistan than on the moon.
Yes, but how much of this was from government-contracted repo men?
[insert witty comment here]
The Declaration is a historical document. "We, the People" means the 55 people who signed it. If you recite it, I suppose I might assume that you hold those truths to be self evident, but that's about it.
The Plege of Allegiance is a pledge. You state right at the beginning that this is what you believe, and also that you will act accordingly. If it isn't, then there's a problem.
No-one focusses on the words after "under God". I see some pretty deep divisions right here.
--
E_NOSIG