Slashdot Mirror


A Truly Silent Desktop PC

boris writes "The first in a series of turnkey systems seem to be coming through the fence from Hush Technologies. The systems weigh in a little expensive but look to be incredible quality. This is according to the review over at HEXUS.net who have a heap of photos up of the unit as well as an article. Is this finally the step to having a true PC in every living room? HTPC here we come!" These EPIAs are everywhere now; we mentioned the M-100 the other day; less-expensive ready-built systems (in various configurations) are available from SolarPC, too.

289 comments

  1. Hard Disk Noise by rf0 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Looking over the specs this would be really quite however apart from the hard disk/CD Rom access. As such me being a geek would like to see a versions that could boot over the network and run everything from Ram. OK prehaps its over kill but if you remove all the mechanical bits then your should have somethnig truly quite and very reliable.

    I know for a fact that the Via MB are good. I bought one from Mini-ITX and have had it running solidly for about 2 months. No crashes. Nothing. Very Impressed

    Rus

    1. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Martin+Kallisti · · Score: 4, Informative

      Ah, but they're using the Seagates for a reason. They run quiet enough that you'll hardly hear them. The slight noise tends to fade into the background.

    2. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

      Yeah, but IBMs drives can be made to run silent too. All you need to do is tweak it a bit using their drive tools: http://www.hgst.com/hdd/support/download.htm

      Sure there is a bit of a performance hit, but it saves a fortune on sound proofing.

    3. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sir, you misspelled the word, "quiet", not once but TWICE. This has me deeply concerned.

    4. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Billly+Gates · · Score: 1
      Quiet hard drives are here. My maxtor does not make any noise at all. Most 7200 rpm drives are silent today. Just avoid the 10krpm's because they are louder.

      My powersupply fan is the only thing making noise on my system.

    5. Re:Hard Disk Noise by CvD · · Score: 3, Interesting

      You should try the Maxtor DiamondMAX 9 Plus with liquid bearings series. It is amazingly silent too. You have to put your head next to the case to hear it purring softly while doing an updatedb (heavy disk activity) for example. Very cool. Now I only need to silence my PSU and CPU fans. :-)

      Cheers!

      Costyn.

    6. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Billly+Gates · · Score: 1
      Take a look at Sun's Ray terminals.

      They support audio/video, and 24bit color from a solaris or Linux server.

    7. Re:Hard Disk Noise by The+Original+Yama · · Score: 1

      I've got three letters for you: VNC

      Stick a server in one room, and access it from another room over a network with a dumb terminal or something that doesn't need a fan. Unless you're playing games this should work quite well.

    8. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

      SolarPC should (and maybe they do) offer what Lux (Taiwan) offers, namely, a 2 1/2" hard drive mounting bracket and cable. Last I checked you can put 60 Gb on one of these, they generate a lot less heat, don't cost much more than a 3 1/2" hard drive, are very fast and they are QUIET.

    9. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sir, you unnecessarily used a comma in your sentence not once but TWICE. This has ME deeply concerned.

    10. Re:Hard Disk Noise by holviala · · Score: 1

      All EPIA:s can boot from the network just fine; try with the one that you already bought....

    11. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Zemran · · Score: 1

      A cheaper alternative is to have your desk against an internal wall with the PC in the next room the other side of the wall. A small hole for the cables and a SCSI or USB DVD/CD drive means that you can have that on your desk with the PC configured to turn on by pressing the space bar and turn off in the usual way. No noise and no added expense :) The people trying to sleep/watch TV in the next room might complain but that noise can be resolved with a hand gun. My desk is against the kitchen wall so I intend to put my PC in a kitchen cupboard.

      --
      I love stacking my barbecues in the shed at the end of summer - you can't beat a bit of grill on grill action.
    12. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Toraz+Chryx · · Score: 1

      Until the inevitable grrr grrr grrr chunk grrr grrr grrr chunk sound that IBM Deskstars seem so fond of doing.....

      (yes, I'm aware that it was mainly the 75GXP line that behaved like that, but given that I'm pretty much on a 1:1 purchased/failed ratio with them, I think extensive paranoia towards IBM/Hitachi disks is somewhat warranted.)

    13. Re:Hard Disk Noise by mmol_6453 · · Score: 1

      I just tried to use VNC this morning with xscorch...The text was missing, for some reason.

      I tried upping the bit depth to 16 bits, and had the same problem. I guess it's got a little ways to go yet.

      --
      What's this Submit thingy do?
    14. Re:Hard Disk Noise by psychofox · · Score: 3, Informative

      I've got a Mini-itx board and solid state powersupply.

      The only thing that makes any noise at all is the disk.

      Its a seagate IV, which also uses FDB bearing ('liquid bearings') I too previously thought this disk was 'amazing' and 'silent', but you'd be amazed how noisy something sounds when there is no other noise around...

      Even the electrical hum from my monitor is deafening now!

    15. Re:Hard Disk Noise by tomstdenis · · Score: 1

      Must be nice. Of course everything in my computer is relatively quiet compared to say the 18" desk fan I have cooling the mobo+cpu :-)

      Plus the fan is relatively soothing once you get used to it.... what did you say? speak up!

      Tom

      --
      Someday, I'll have a real sig.
    16. Re:Hard Disk Noise by October_30th · · Score: 3, Interesting
      solid state powersupply

      Which can be a problem. I've got EPIA M series combination and I could not use Seagate's 200GB drive in the box because spinning it up took too much power causing the boot process to hang. A 80GB drive works just fine and the 200GB one boots perfectly using a standard 300W power source.

      --
      The owls are not what they seem
    17. Re:Hard Disk Noise by reezle · · Score: 4, Funny

      Hmm... If you say so.

      How about you get rid of that noisy power supply fan, and THEN tell me how quiet your hard drive is?
      {GRIN}

      That's where I'm at now... got rid of all the fans, and now am down to the minor noises. But when you are being passionate, etc, after watching a movie, you sure don't want a spinning-up HD to make her sit up and say, "what's that strange noise?"... Because then you'll get distracted from the main event, and start babbling at her about thermal recalibration, spin-down, suspend-mode, etc etc... Very quickly she'll realise you are NOT a dentist/lawyer/doctor like you said, but in fact one of those programmers you swore to her that you were not, and then lord knows you'd have to be pretty damn lucky if you ever get back the t-shirt of yours she was wearing as she bolts for the door...

    18. Re:Hard Disk Noise by ichimunki · · Score: 1

      Just make sure to use a silencer on the handgun, as the sound of one firing is somewhat explosive. Although if you do it often enough, you may be lucky enough to damage your hearing to where a little fan whirring isn't such a problem after all.

      --
      I do not have a signature
    19. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sir, you unnecessarily wrote a sentence not once, but twice. This has me deeply concerned.

    20. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Richy_T · · Score: 1
      The IBM Deskstar I bought to replace the drive in my Thinkpad is *very* noisy. It makes the drive I took out sound practically silent. And that's just the spin noise, not the seek noise.


      Rich

    21. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Anonymous+Custard · · Score: 1

      The IBM Deskstar I bought to replace the drive in my Thinkpad is *very* noisy. It makes the drive I took out sound practically silent. And that's just the spin noise, not the seek noise.

      My old Acer extensa 368d sounds like a drinking fountain that's in cooling mode.

    22. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Tingler · · Score: 1

      Wouldn't attaching some rather large capacitors to the output of the power supply tackle this problem?

    23. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Richy_T · · Score: 1
      Oops. That should be "Travelstar" of course.


      Rich

    24. Re:Hard Disk Noise by genka · · Score: 1

      ...and solid state powersupply
      Thanks, but I'll stick to my tube power supply.

    25. Re:Hard Disk Noise by i_am_nitrogen · · Score: 1

      I went out with a girl who was actually impressed by my coding skills. She knew about them and me before we went out, and kept asking "so you're really good with computers, right?" Of course, I was being modest, and saying "well, maybe you could say that." Maybe she just wants money....

      We watched a movie on my HTPC+projector too, unfortunately mine isn't silent. I'd like to go to a truly silent setup, but I figure I need at least an AthlonXP 1500+ to do what I want with it. On the plus side, the fan noise helps mask my tinnitus...

    26. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Pieroxy · · Score: 3, Informative

      I built a silent PC for my living room and here is how I reduced noise:
      1. My PSU fan is silent. But I mean Silent. You don't hear it unless you stick you ear to it!!
      2. I underclocked my CPU. Celeron 533@266, so no fan is needed.
      3. I use a laptop HDD, which is very silent
      4. I use a DVD-ROM drive that can be told not to spin over a certain speed. I use the "eject" command on linux to set it to whatever I want. 6X is totally silent.

      That's it!

    27. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      How about those ATM machines and PBX extensions and everything else like that? It's just FDB. It uses FDB. Try it. Say it with me, Fluid Dynamic Bearing. Not Fluid Dynamic Bearing Bearing.

    28. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's not so bad, she could be asking "why is that little red light on the video camera on?"

    29. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      After buying their early SCSI 7400rpm drives, I find it hard to believe seeing silent and seagate in the same paragraph.

      Those things could rattle screws out of the chassis! (if they didn't overheat first)

    30. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Great idea, then the capacitors kill the power supply before the hd can get to it.

    31. Re:Hard Disk Noise by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well that's what you get for trying to get laid in a server room!

      And I'm waiting for someone use use the term 'rackmount' euphamistically. uh-huh-huh. You said 'mount'. huh-huh. and 'rack'.

  2. why not just buy a thin client? by Trepidity · · Score: 4, Informative

    If you're going to have no drive, the best solution is probably something like the NCD thin clients.

    1. Re:why not just buy a thin client? by rf0 · · Score: 2, Informative

      Thats an idea. Just wondered though it they have TV out as what I would like is to use the box as a DivX/MP3/Streaming box. Thats what I'm using my current box for.

      Rus

    2. Re:why not just buy a thin client? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I've got an NCD thinstar (510, I think) I was going to get it linked to my TV (via a scan converter) as an MP3 jukebox but I can't get anything like good quality sound out of it. I raised a call with NCD and they said, yes, it's a known problem, we suggest you keep downloading updates until we've sorted it.

    3. Re:why not just buy a thin client? by Dr.+Evil · · Score: 1

      I've tried it both ways... for most applications it is faster to do root on NFS than to do X. If you do have an I/O intensive app, then you can always still use X.

      The real problem is local RAM. Although you can, you don't want to swap over NFS.

    4. Re:why not just buy a thin client? by John_Booty · · Score: 2, Informative

      Thats an idea. Just wondered though it they have TV out as what I would like is to use the box as a DivX/MP3/Streaming box. Thats what I'm using my current box for.

      FYI... most of the reviews I've seen of the C3 have said it's a bit slow for DIVX decoding, I'm not 100% sure, but be sure to look into that before you buy one for that purpose.

      Seem the FPU on the C3 is really slow. Don't complain too much, though... cutting back on power-hungry and die-space-consuming stuff like kickass FPU's is how they make these things so small/quiet/cool in the first place. :P

      --

      OtakuBooty.com: Smart, funny, sexy nerds.
    5. Re:why not just buy a thin client? by JWW · · Score: 1

      FYI: NCDs do not have a TV out, it would be cool if they did, though.

    6. Re:why not just buy a thin client? by molarmass192 · · Score: 1

      I have an EPIA C3 800 Mhz and it definitely doesn't have enough juice to do software based decoding for video. I've heard the M10000 series is much better but let me assure you that the 800 hits 99% CPU on very basic MPEG2 streams. I'm using an MPEG2 decoder card to get around this limitation but this won't help you with DIVX.

      --

      Good people do not need laws to tell them to act responsibly, while bad people will find a way around the laws-Plato
    7. Re:why not just buy a thin client? by luzrek · · Score: 1

      The EPIA-M has built in MPEG-2 direct decoding. Apparently, it is not supported under GNU/Linux though (but I'm not really having any problems). I'm pretty sure that the Eden 600Mhz (fanless), and 800Mhz (fan), 900Mhz (fan), and 1000Mhz (quietest fan of the three) versions of the C3 chips are avalible. I'm running a EPIA-M with a 600Mhz Eden for MP3/OGG/Streaming/TV purposes and appart from my frustrations with the gyration keyboard/mouse thing I'm pretty happy.

      --

      Galium Arsenide is the material of the future, and always will be.

    8. Re:why not just buy a thin client? by molarmass192 · · Score: 1

      Yep, I didn't understand the importance of the 'M' moniker until the board was already here! Is the MPEG2 decoder on the board hardwired to the output or can you use it specifically for decoding back to a program? If it allows the latter (and linux support for the decoder is on the horizon) I might spring for a new one!

      --

      Good people do not need laws to tell them to act responsibly, while bad people will find a way around the laws-Plato
    9. Re:why not just buy a thin client? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

      because you'll still have to have a server somewhere to host your files or apps.

      This is what I did:

      - E800 with 1GB ram
      - boot Linux initrd off CD-R
      - initrd loads 256 MB ramdisk from a image on the CD-R
      - pivot_root to ramdisk
      - CD-R spins down
      - /home mounted from compact flash

      No HD! The only motors running are the power supply and the C3's.

      Plan is to set up another machine with more storage and muscle that can be activated by WOL for copying stuff off the compact flash.

    10. Re:why not just buy a thin client? by Hugonz · · Score: 1

      I has some help as it has resizing and motion compensation circuitry. I've been using EPIAS for a comercial projectt playing DivX 1024 kbps Mp3 192kbs 640*480 resized dynamically to 1024*768. Works great...mplayer

  3. A bemused admin writes by oPless · · Score: 4, Funny

    I host hexus's webservers
    - now I'm starting to get worried :-)





    www.tetracite.com

    1. Re:A bemused admin writes by rf0 · · Score: 1

      I was just talking to the guy who hosts http://www.hushtechnologies.co.uk/. He's looking worried as well :)

      Rus

    2. Re:A bemused admin writes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hey Opless :P *waves from pRy*

    3. Re:A bemused admin writes by kinnell · · Score: 4, Funny
      For next time, this is not the best advice to give when experiencing a slashdotting:

      please try and reload the page

      --
      If I seem short sighted, it is because I stand on the shoulders of midgets
    4. Re:A bemused admin writes by chiller2 · · Score: 1

      I've added indexes.. there were no possible keys on the reviews table! Sloppy. Anyway, queries have sped up somewhat (was about 4 seconds per query, now much better).

      --
      --- Commission free trading & free stock up to $500 - use http://share.robinhood.com/kelvinp6 :)
  4. 9/10 but not for the review by matthew.thompson · · Score: 5, Interesting

    The machine looks great and the hardware seems to be extremely well put together but the review misses out on a few key areas.

    It's acknowledged that the unit would look great in a lounge or on a hi-fi rack. But nowhere is the video output from the composite and S-Video outputs mentioned.

    How easy would it be to get a remote control up and running with the unit? What's the sound quality like? Can the unit drive a high end sound card with the power supply that's supplied?

    These are the questions I want answered.

    --
    Matt Thompson - Actuality - Insert product here.
    1. Re:9/10 but not for the review by Kibo · · Score: 3, Informative

      It mentions S-video and 6.1 sound. At least in their pdf order form.

      --
      --Jimmy has fancy plans; and pants to match.
    2. Re:9/10 but not for the review by rf0 · · Score: 1

      Also worth saying that the VIA board can also do 5.1 but its either that or the video out. Nice boards though

      Rus

    3. Re:9/10 but not for the review by adamauckland · · Score: 1

      It can do 5.1 but I found on my Epia it struggles with high quality AC3 decoding, installing a GeForce 4 took the CPU usage from 100% down to 51%.

    4. Re:9/10 but not for the review by SchnauzerGuy · · Score: 5, Informative

      On the recent mini-ITX boards, there is one RCA connector for either coaxial SP/DIF or composite video out, with an internal jumper to switch between the outputs. This can be switched on the fly while the system is running, BTW.

      Since s-video has its own connector, you can have both coaxial SP/DIF multichannel digital audio and s-video out.

    5. Re:9/10 but not for the review by TheTomcat · · Score: 1

      It's also possible to mangle the s-video connector down to regular composite using a dongle. (I think it involves merging the Y and C componenents into one pin.)

      So, really, the composite video is nearly useless.

      S

    6. Re:9/10 but not for the review by CvD · · Score: 1

      The remote should be easy enough. There are lots of external IR devices available, which will connect to USB, serial, parallel, PS/2, etc. With the right software you can train them to listen to anything, like a universal remote or one you already have, so for 20 euros you could have yourself a remote control setup for this too.

      If you're feeling really 'hackish' you could cut a small aperature in the front cover and place the IR eye there, so it would be part of the unit.

      Cheers,

      Costyn.

    7. Re:9/10 but not for the review by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      OH GNO

    8. Re:9/10 but not for the review by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      How good is the quality of the TV output?

  5. I guess so, heh by Ryvar · · Score: 3, Funny

    We are having major server problems at the moment. Something is up - we will fix this ;)

    1. Re:I guess so, heh by oPless · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Appears to be back. Apparently the content managment system they run there decided to back off for a bit :-)

      Not suprising with a load avg of 78.29 / 58.63 / 42.64 :) (and rising)

      Not bad really, knowing what a slashdotting is like. lots of mysql threads too.

    2. Re:I guess so, heh by Surak · · Score: 1

      I suppose the content managment system is tossing these out, too?

      The server is under high load please try and reload the page - it should come back :)

      It *did* come back when I hit reload too... not bad at all, really.

    3. Re:I guess so, heh by drinkypoo · · Score: 1

      I'm sure they will thank you for posting their load stats on slashdot. Care to share with us any other information that doesn't belong to us?

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
  6. Quiet? Ok... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    But a C3?

    I can't imagine apple addicts find the comparison to an iMac flattering. Any color you want provided you want silver or black.

    And at those prices it seems like you're way better off rolling your own, and either stashing it with the help of longer shielded cables, or one of those wireless setups.

    1. Re:Quiet? Ok... by Ctrl-Alt-Del · · Score: 1

      C3 is powerful enough for most things you'd want to do at home, apart from playing games and other high-end stuff. And MPEG decoding etc is done in hardware, so the processor could hardly care less.

      This is a great response to the electrical-power-hungy Intel and AMD chips. Next time California browns-out in the summer, consider getting one of these C3-based babies next time.

      --
      "Life is like a sewer - what you get out of it depends on what you put into it" - Tom Lehrer
    2. Re:Quiet? Ok... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      But Macs are any color you want, provided you want silver or white.

  7. already by standsolid · · Score: 4, Funny

    from heux's site

    We are having major server problems at the moment. Something is up - we will fix this ;)

    yup. it's called a damn good slashdotting buddy. you better have some fire extinguishers ready to fix your "server problems" ;P

    --
    WTPOUAWYHTTOTWPA
    What's the point of using acronyms when you have to type out the whole phrase anyways?
  8. I was expecting to see a behemoth, but ... by ascii · · Score: 1, Funny

    ... Jaheseus Christ that looks good.

    Most often you don't get good-looking !and! silent at the same time.

    Schweeet!

    --
    naah sig schmig
    1. Re:I was expecting to see a behemoth, but ... by InsaneCreator · · Score: 4, Funny

      Most often you don't get good-looking !and! silent at the same time.

      same goes for women... ;)

    2. Re:I was expecting to see a behemoth, but ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I already have a truly silent desktop computer that looks good- my G4 Cube! With the CD and HD noise, it's as quiet as this would be...

      Move along- there's nothing to see here.

    3. Re:I was expecting to see a behemoth, but ... by bgarcia · · Score: 1
      Most often you don't get good-looking !and! silent at the same time.

      same goes for women... ;)

      Hell, I'd settle for just one of those qualities in a woman.
      --
      I'm a leaf on the wind. Watch how I soar.
    4. Re:I was expecting to see a behemoth, but ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Hell, I'd settle for just one of those qualities in a woman.
      That still makes you pickier than the average Slashdotter then.

      Nice burn!

  9. I dunno I kinda by CYberg · · Score: 1

    like the jet takeoff sounds my delta 38's make. Keeps the critters and neighbors away!

  10. Minor, eh? by RedBear · · Score: 1
    We are having major server problems at the moment. Something is up - we will fix this ;)

    Minor problems, he says. We'll show him "minor", won't we, boys? Muwaha-ha-ha-haaa. ;)
  11. Re:Audio by LaBola · · Score: 1

    Coax SPDIF and 5:1 is enough for you?

  12. Re:IN SOVIET RUSSIA by Afrosheen · · Score: 4, Funny

    Actually it'd be something like...

    In Soviet Russia...the PC silences YOU

  13. As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Dell by ikewillis · · Score: 5, Informative
    The latest Dell Precision workstations run completely silent, except for the optical drives.

    You can hear a faint whir from the fans if you place your ear next to the system, but otherwise they are completely silent.

    Furthermore, they are extremely inexpensive. The latest deal on slickdeals.net was a $340 Pentium 4 2.53GHz system with 256MB PC2700 RAM, a 16X DVD-ROM or a 48X CD-RW, 30GB hard drive and 32MB Rage (in an AGP slot so it's upgradable) Slickdeals went so far as to say "You cannot build your own system for less then this."

    I see no reason to spend more money on an underpowered EPIA silent system when a Dell can be had for significantly cheaper.

  14. Re:/. effect by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    Found one

  15. Review by rf0 · · Score: 5, Informative

    Managed to get this before the site disspeared

    ntroduction

    Possibly the area of greatest interest in the Computing world at present is the Small Form Factor (SFF) PC. They are perfect for a multitude of uses from a replacement for your main pc all the way to a Home Theater PC (HTPC). They have great flexibility due to their size, allowing many new designs to be considered. New to this market are Hush Technologies and they have approached the SFF with one thing in mind, total silence.

    They have created a completely passively cooled MiniITX based PC which does away with most of the sources of noise in a normal system and encloses it in a beautifullooking aluminium case. Let's have a look at how good it is in the flesh.

    What are the specifications of this PC?

    * Via Epia-M 9000: Featuring a 933Mhz VIA C3 CPU
    * 256MB of Crucial PC2100 DDR RAM
    * 80Gb Seagate Barracuda Hard Disk
    * TEAC DVD/CDRW Combo drive
    * Morex 55w Power Supply (PSU)
    * Dimensions: 37 x36 x 6cm (w,d,h)
    * Case material: Aluminium
    * Form Factor: MiniITX

    The specifications of the system are interesting, the inclusion of the TEAC combo drive is great and the large hard disk allows plenty of storage. I'd prefer 512MB of RAM but 256MB is adequate for the majority of its intended uses. The hard disc itself is renowned for its low noise. It's not totally silent but a lot better than many fixed disks out there. It sacrifices some performance for this but is generally no slouch. Hush provides plenty of options so you can specify the right system for your needs.

    I think I should start this review by explaining just what MiniITX form factor motherboards are. The form factor was originally proposed by VIA to be an ultra small form factor, smaller than the FlexATX and MicroATX form factors that were the smallest at the time. The original MiniITX boards were feature rich boards with a CPU soldered onto the board. This was cheap to produce as there was no discrete packaging cost for the integrated processor.

    The specifications of the MiniITX form factor state that the board may not be bigger than 170mm x 170mm. As you can see this is tiny when compared to the normal ATX standard.

    VIA also aimed to have very low heat output from the MiniITX so it would be more suitable in systems like the Hush. Some of the VIA EPIA series models are passively cooled but unfortunately these are the less powerful models. The higher powered boards require a small heatsink with a 40mm fan and these fans can often be quite noisy so Hush set out to combine the faster EPIA models with a passive cooling system.

    1. Re:Review by rf0 · · Score: 1

      Looks like the site is back :)

      Rus

    2. Re:Review by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's so nice that after he downloaded the review he went back later, found the site down and then posted his comment. :-)

    3. Re:Review by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hush PC was mentioned in a couple of pieces in the inquirer too.

      "Quiet hush makes a big noise about PCs"
      http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=8201
      "H ush shouts out pricing"
      http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=8800

  16. C3...? by Paddyish · · Score: 1

    This looks pretty cool, but I'd like to know - just how compatible and reliable are these C3 processors? I've seen them advertised in cheapo laptops in a number of places - are they some sort of mobile solution? I've also seen them mounted on a couple of all-in-one motherboard solutions. Anyone have any experience with these?

    1. Re:C3...? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I've been running one as a web server & dev server for over 1 year. The machine has been running constantly, 24/7 for that time. Zero downtime due to hardware issues.

      The only problems with them is that while they identify themselves as i686, they are missing a couple of instructions, which causes gcc to fail when compiling with i686 optimizations. Just use i586 and you're fine.

    2. Re:C3...? by Paddyish · · Score: 1

      Interesting...I hear also that they run cooler - but at the expense of floating point efficiency. I think that's a good tradeoff for the normal desktop user.

    3. Re:C3...? by rob_macgregor · · Score: 1
      I've got a pair of C3 boxes at home (Lex systems, see http://www.lex.com.tw/), one of which is a 533 (fanless) using a CF disk (so no moving parts - truely noiseless).

      I've only had them for about 4 months however they've been more reliable than the Celeron I bought at the same time.

      Just replaced that (dead) Celeron with a 1 GHz C3 and so far it's solid as a rock.

      --
      Following the rules doesn't get the job done.
    4. Re:C3...? by jez_f · · Score: 1

      The i686 instruction problem can be gotten round with a hack to gcc and it only seems to occour in highly optomised code. My 800 Mhz C3 can run X + mozilla fine. it can play back divix, it supposidly has HW Mpeg 2 decompression but I havn't sorted this out yet. There is a bug in the CPU temprature sesor (or drivers) but they do still run cool (the fan broke on mine and there was no problem). Idle CPU instructions are treated as such which meens when it is not doing anything it runs very cool. (don't know if Athlon P4 do this or not) It does take an age to encode MP3/ OGG (runs at about 1.5 X) but all in all I am very happy with My C3, if they wernt so dambd expensive I would have got one of these silent ones. If you want a low end Mini-itx solution you can get bundles pretty cheap.

    5. Re:C3...? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      What you are mentionning is the fact that, IIRC, in order to keep things cool, VIA made the FPU run at half the speed of the rest of the CPU.

      But things changed with the latest generation C3, codenamed "Nehemiah". Not only all of the silicon runs at the same speed (min. 1GHz), but it also has a hardware random number generator.

      This last item was actually covered by a recent thread on SlashDot. Just search for it.

      P.S.: my Linux-based firewall is running an 866MHz Ezra-T core C3 (the last generation before the Nehemiah) cooled by Zalman copper "flower" with just the case+PSU fans (case fan running half speed), with some Arctic Silver II thermal grease to finish things up. When I watched the cpu temp recently, this essentially passively cooled CPU was running at 25C, even while routing traffic for about half a dozen boxes on the local segment. To me, this is the perfect CPU for a low-noise, low-heat firewall.

    6. Re:C3...? by shepd · · Score: 1

      >This looks pretty cool, but I'd like to know - just how compatible and reliable are these C3 processors?

      Very, on both counts. In fact, one of the only half-respectable PCChips boards uses them. I used to sell these. :-)

      >I've seen them advertised in cheapo laptops in a number of places - are they some sort of mobile solution?

      They use very, very little power. Something on the order of under 24 watts.

      The "active" cooling solutions for them are basically a tiny 486 CPU fan + 486 heatsink. A passive solution would probably be about the size of a regular AMD heatsink, minus the fan.

      >I've also seen them mounted on a couple of all-in-one motherboard solutions. Anyone have any experience with these?

      Most of them are made by PCChips. As far as PCChips goes, this was their very best product of all time, IMHO. Some don't work with WD 2.0 Gig HDDs due to BIOS bugs.

      The problem is they are a PCChips product, which means no support. Period. Except for their website which appears to be served from a 2400 baud modem. Oh, that and the motherboards (not the CPUs) tend to fail craptacularly [eg: A very old PCChips mobo (possibly the M575, or M530, can't remember the model number right now) decided to randomly corrupt my HDD once] when they fail.

      As far as speed goes, they run _somewhat_ slower than a similarly specced Pentium II machine. They're enough for all your business tasks, fine for DVD playback, but I would never reccomend one for gaming.

      --
      If you could be told what you can see or read, then it follows that you could be told what to say or think - BoC
  17. We will fix this... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    We are having major server problems at the moment. Something is up - we will fix this ;)
    Heh.. not for a while you won't :)
  18. Re:Boot from USB Ramdisk? (Or convert?) by reezle · · Score: 1

    Well, I've been thinking along these problems myself for a while... The hard drive noise is the only noise left in my bedroom system. (No CD, no Fans, just massive cooling fins...)

    Even with the hard drive masked tightly for sound, I can hear it (especially when it wakes up from sleep... the spin-up sound is unmistakable in a truly quiet room)

    Instead of an expensive flash-ram based IDE hard drive, is there a way to boot from a USB Ramdisk? A 64/128MB ramdisk outh to be enough to boot the O/S, load the drivers and contact the data that's out on the network. Perhaps a cheap USB2IDE converter somwhere out there could allow the box to boot from the $100 ramdisk? Conversion can be done the OTHER direction, but I couldn't google a way to hook the USB device to the IDE cable...

  19. My Athlon is loud..... by idiotnot · · Score: 1

    ....with its scsi disks and four fans, but I've gotten to the point where I can't sleep when it's off. I actually can't hear the drives most of the time over the fans.

    It's much quieter than my ceiling fan, though, which I've had on the last couple of days because it's been warm.

    Whenever I need silence, everything but the iBook goes off.

    The Mini-ITX machine reviews are interesting. I've been meaning to get one to put in this dead Apple IIgs I've got.

  20. Re:Boot from USB Ramdisk? (Or convert?) by rf0 · · Score: 1

    I haven't tried it but I know that my main machine can boot from a CF Reader. I might try putting Linux on a CF see if I could boot the system off it. If that works might give Windows a try. Drop me a mail to rghf@65535.net and I will let you know how I get on :)

    Rus

  21. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by addaon · · Score: 3, Insightful

    No, the Dell Precision workstations are not "completely silent." They may be stunningly quiet; I don't know, I've never heard one. But "completely silent" is different. It doesn't mean that there's minimal sound, or that the sound is well muffled. It means that no sound is being generated. I have a stack of computers sitting around... the only two that approach "completely silent" are an iBook (using ramdisk, fan off, optical drive not in use) and epia (solid state hard disk, but the damn switching power supply makes an almost-audible noise).

    I appreciate that for most people "damn quiet" is good enough. Heck, even for me it is. But "completely silent" is an absolute, and it should be used that way.

    --

    I've had this sig for three days.
  22. Music Studios by locarecords.com · · Score: 4, Interesting
    This is the kind of computer that is needed in Music studios and for the life of me I can't understand why Apple G4's have to sound like a Tornado taking off.

    You'd think that creatives would be the ones Apple would identify as wanting the quiet to think and contemplate.

    However buying a PC feels like a real step backwards for me. I am totally socialised to using Mac's in music and now that Logic is no longer supported on the PC it is even harder to consider the switch.

    The sooner PCs get silent (like the blessed iMacs) the better...

    --
    ---- The Open Source Record Label : : LOCARECORDS.COM
    1. Re:Music Studios by hoojchoons · · Score: 1

      No matter how silent this PC is, I don't think I'll ever change my Mac. I do however own 2 PCs running Linux, that make a good deal of noise. Anyway, the point is that I wouldn't trade my Mac for any silent or ultra-silent PC ;)

    2. Re:Music Studios by Textbook+Error · · Score: 3, Informative

      If you have a noisy MDD, make sure you check out Apple's Power Mac G4 Power Supply Exchange Program.

      The replacement power supply/fans are quite a bit quieter, and the kit is pretty easy to install.

      --

      Nae bother
    3. Re:Music Studios by singleantler · · Score: 1
      The sooner PCs get silent (like the blessed iMacs) the better...

      Odd, the noisiest machine in our office by far is the G3 iMac (everything else is Dell PCs.) It's quiet when it's just sitting there, but as soon as it uses the hard drive it's very noisy indeed. The Dells have good all-around quietness which isn't quite silence, but is only a very slight hum, even during heavy disk thrashing.

      --
      "What if they're using IE?" "I've dumbed Mozilla down to cope with it." - BOFH
    4. Re:Music Studios by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      (Probably way too late to hope to get modded up but maybe someone will see this anyway and find it useful)

      The studios I know solve this by simply not having any computers IN the studio space - instead they put them in the next room and just bring the I/O into the room. These days you can do it with a flat panel (w/ DVI) monitors and have no video quality loss. The only things in the studio itself are the monitor, keyboard, mouse, and audio I/O (outboard of course) If it really bugs you to have to go into the other room to put a CD-R in the machine for burning then get a firewire enclosure and put that in the room as well.

      Even if you built a *really* quiet CPU you'd still have to contend with drive noise (since we're probably talking multitrack harddrive recording so at the very least we want a lot of fast drive capacity and probably even RAID) So at the very least you're going to need to put the storage in another room (either on fiber channel or firewire)
      At that point it's usually simpler/cheaper just to put the computer in the other room too (and use a few cheap internal IDE disks w/ software RAID0...these days its totally practical for most studio applications)

      This is all cheap enough these days that doing it at home is reasonable - I've been considering building something similar in my home just to make my work environment really quiet without having to spec out silent hardware.

  23. I'm buying this computer.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    cuz someday when I have sex, I want to be able to hear it too.

  24. IPX and VIA by tacocat · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I've been watching computers waiting for a combination of:

    • Small form factor
    • Very Low Power consumption
    • Low Price
    Much of this has been driven based on the realization that, with the exception of gaming, there is really no practicaly need for the incredible power consumption and heat dissapation of the high end COTS systems. When you consider it, the COTS systems today are very poorly designed because they are entirely dependant upon high speed fans to keep themselves from self distruction. This makes for an a-stable product which happens to be horribly loud and in a social sense, isn't scalable (you can't have 4 of these sitting in a room).

    Following this new realization that no one really needs a multi GHz processor for surfing, email, servers, and most all of their coding then the idea of a 30 Watt silent processor has some real appeal.

    VIA, with thei EPIA and the Mini-ITX motherboards are poised for some real advances on the user community. While not as power independent as a notebook PC, they can be arguable as portable and certainly more convenient for the desktop cube-ville environment.

    The other avenue for computer users to move in is the LSTP thin-client workstations like the jammin products. These are small devices with USB, PS/2 ports on the front. This is a new direction

    Not intending to get prophetic here, but I really believe that there is need for a product which has a thin-client architecture with the goal of providing only interfaces:

    • USB ports, 2-4
    • Firewire
    With the possibility of providing a single floppy drive or CD-RW and S-Video ports as well. But nothing more is really needed at the user desktop interface anymore. Unfortunately I haven't really seen anything like this at a sane price. I did see a few products which are mini-ITX motherboards installed at the back of flat panels for a single unit. Very wonderful, but not for $1500!!! Everything else would be retained at a single point of access at the server or at a "super station" which might have additional devicees (like CD-RW, S-Video)

    These are all really excellent devices. Now if someone would please sent me the $300 necessary to buy one I would be very happy! I have a lot of noise in my office.

    1. Re:IPX and VIA by giorgio_mant · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I bought a fanless (zero decibel!!! ;-))) power supply from deltatronic (300 euro), I've got an old celeron 466 fanless, and I love my pc! soon I will try to put the hard disc in standby mode using hdparm or hdflush (not sure the name is correct) My pc is much better than those crappy mini-itx mini-performance systems You can also visit siliconacoustics.com silentpcreview.com etc

    2. Re:IPX and VIA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      My pc is much better than those crappy mini-itx mini-performance systems.

      That's probably not true for the new line (M-series) of mini-itx. These use a new CPU chip, DDR ram, etc. The are much faster than the old Eden boards.

  25. pages 3 - 6 text by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative



    First Impressions

    First impressions count for a lot and with the Hush I wasn't disappointed, the system came in a well packaged and protected box. Opening up the box for the first time I was very surprised when I took the Hush out, it was a very solid piece of metal giving an impression of excellent build quality. The cooling fins on the sides are especially sturdy chunks of aluminium.

    I've seen some of the nicest and well built cases in my time but this was something else. This PC would would look perfect next to a video or DVD player. The colour of this particular example wasn't something to write home about, but it was bearable and seeing as you get a choice of colours it's not really an issue. Overall I was very impressed by the system and had good hopes for the performance of it.

    The Case

    People who know me know will know I'm a case person, that I'm a sucker for a nice looking aluminium case and with the Hush I'm blown away. The pictures of the case really don't do it justice, it's the highest quality case I've yet come across and that includes all the Coolermasters. The fins at the side are very solid and they make a very entertaining noise when you run your hands across them that can get addictive. At the front it's very clean looking, nothing destroys the clean lines unless it's essential to the function. In terms of switch gear and LED's there is only the bare minimum. The power switch is a Bulgin vandal resistant number with blue lighting and those of you in the Modding community will know that these are some of the best looking switches out there. The button action requires a firm push and the switch feedback isn't the greatest but the blue glow the switch makes up for it in spades. The switch means that no power LED is required as the blue glow shows instantly that it's on. This is quite important as the case is so silent, you cant tell its on by listening. Above the switch is a tiny hole for the hard disk LED which is red in colour, I'd have preferred a blue LED but that's just me being fussy.

    From the pictures you can see that the optical drive at the front is not your normal 5.25 drive, rather it's a laptop style one taking up a lot less room, thus allowing the case to be lower in profile. The drive is painted to make the drive fit in perfectly with the case and it's very good to see that Hush have thought of these little details, many manufacturers would just throw a beige or black drive in without thinking.

    In terms of case access on this system, things are different to nearly all cases. The top panel is held in by 6 bolts. These aren't normal bolts but have two small holes on the head. They require a special tool to loosen them but that said, it's very easy to loosen them and Hush provides the correct tool with retail versions of the system for those needing/wanting to tinker or just look at the insides of the system.

    On the bottom of the case there are four very sturdy looking feet with small circular rubber pads on the base. This means you can put the case anywhere without fear of marking the surface. If you have multiple Hush PC's you could even stack them on top of each other.

    The Back of the Case

    Turning the case round to look at the back you can see the ports are located in a nice ATX blanking plate, there is also a PCI slot (Note there is an option to have two), an extra 2 USB Ports and an extra 2 firewire ports. At the right of these is the input port for the Power Supply. Again, as with the rest of the case, it's very neatly laid out and well built. You can see that this is also Hush Serial Number S001 its always nice to see you have the first of something.

    Power Supply

    Again as with other parts of this system the Power supply isn't your normal type. In keeping with the passive cooling ethos Hush have used a Morex 55 watt power supply. This consists of an internal circuit board with no cooling and an external laptop style brick which connects to the case via a small connector and then to the plu

  26. Re:page 7 text by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

    Now with the VIA EPIA M-9000 being the basis of the system it's not going to be great as a gaming rig, so I wasn't expecting huge power out of this system. Here at Hexus we have recently reviewed the EPIA M-9000 in a full and complete review so for a more specific review of the board look at it here. The specifications of the board mean that its aimed at being a complete solution containing on-board graphics and on-board sound along with lots of other goodies.

    What are the specifications of the Via Epia 9000

    * Processor
    * VIA C3/EDEN EBGA Processor 933Mhz
    * Chipset
    * VIA CLE266 North Bridge
    * VT8235 South Bridge
    * System Memory
    * 1 DDR266 DIMM socket
    * Up to 1GB memory size
    * VGA
    * Integrated VIA CastleRock AGP graphics with MPEG-2 decoder
    * Expansion Slots
    * 1 X PCI
    * Onboard IDE
    * 2 X UltraDMA 133/100/66 Connector
    * Onboard Floppy
    * 1 x FDD Connector
    * Onboard LAN
    * VIA VT6103 10/100 Base-T Ethernet PHY
    * Onboard Audio
    * VIA VT1616 6 channel AC'97 Codec
    * Onboard TV Out
    * VIA VT1622 TV out
    * Onboard 1394
    * VIA VT6307S IEEE 1394 Firewire
    * Onboard I/O Connectors
    * 1 USB connectors for 2 additional USB 2.0 ports
    * 2 1394 connectors for 2 1394 ports
    * Front-panel audio connectors (Mic and Line Out)
    * CD Audio-in connector
    * SIR connector
    * CIR connector
    * Wake-on-LAN, Wake-on-Ring

  27. Re:page 2 *Intro text* by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    What is Mini ITX Form Factor?

    I think I should start this review by explaining just what MiniITX form factor motherboards are. The form factor was originally proposed by VIA to be an ultra small form factor, smaller than the FlexATX and MicroATX form factors that were the smallest at the time. The original MiniITX boards were feature rich boards with a CPU soldered onto the board. This was cheap to produce as there was no discrete packaging cost for the integrated processor.

    The specifications of the MiniITX form factor state that the board may not be bigger than 170mm x 170mm. As you can see this is tiny when compared to the normal ATX standard.

    VIA also aimed to have very low heat output from the MiniITX so it would be more suitable in systems like the Hush. Some of the VIA EPIA series models are passively cooled but unfortunately these are the less powerful models. The higher powered boards require a small heatsink with a 40mm fan and these fans can often be quite noisy so Hush set out to combine the faster EPIA models with a passive cooling system.

  28. Re:page 8 - 10 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

    Gaming Performance

    Now I thought what would happen if someone wanted to use the Hush as an occasional gaming rig, how would they get on? I tried the Hush out in Quake 3 Arena 1.32 which is going to be a major test for any on-board graphics. Playing at the very lowest resolution available, the game was playable but on a large monitor or it's going to look horrific at 640x480. It was a bit slow but only when there was lots of action on the screen. I then tried out some timedemo's to give it a big test and I used very intense demo's where lots happens and here are the results:

    * Fastest (Resolution: 512x384) = 17.7 FPS
    * Normal (Resolution: 640x480) = 13.6 FPS
    * High Quality (Resolution: 800x600) = 13.6 FPS

    So these are all well below the 30fps threshold so it's not going to be any more than an emergency gaming rig. To test it out further I fired up 3d Mark 2001 but the results were far from sparkling:

    Performance Conclusion

    In summation the performance is not going to win any awards, anything that requires serious CPU or graphical grunt is not possible due to the lack of processing muscle. It's going to be ok for DivX or DVD playback however.

    The colour of the case is difficult to describe being somewhere between silver and brown. Its not the nicest colour I have to say, but it's bearable. That said there are many colour options open to you as you can see from this pic taken by Nigel Prescott at Cebit. To give you an idea of the colour of this specific hush it's the 3rd from bottom on that picture. Personally I would go for the black or the silve and which ever you prefer the most, they are certainly the most striking of the options.

    Pricing Structure.
    Note Prices in pounds approximate and include VAT.
    Prices as of 1st April 2003

    * Hush Mini ITX PC - Via Epia-M 9000, 128MB DDR RAM,
    40GB Seagate Barracuda HDD, TEAC Slimline CD-ROM.
    Features 933Mhz VIA C3 CPU, VIA CLE266 Chipset,
    32MB Integrated VIA "CastleRock" Graphics with MPEG
    2 Decoder, 4 x USB 2.0 Ports, 2 X IEEE 1394 Firewire
    Ports, S-Video out, 6-channel audio, 1 Full length
    PCI slot, 10/100 Base-T Ethernet, TV-Out, Serial,
    Parallel, Mouse and Keyboard :
    645 Euro's (£446.49)
    * Colour option - Silver or Black :
    Free
    * Upgrade to 256MB RAM :
    25 Euro's (£17.31)
    * Upgrade to 512MB RAM :
    80 Euro's (£55.38)
    * Upgrade to 1GB RAM :
    POA
    * TEAC DVD/CDRW Combo Slim-line Upgrade :
    90 Euro's (£62.30)
    * Upgrade to 60GB HDD Seagate Barracuda :
    25 Euro's (£17.31)
    * Upgrade to 80GB HDD Seagate Barracuda :
    40 Euro's (£27.69)
    * Upgrade to 120GB HDD Seagate Barracuda :
    80 Euro's (£55.38)
    * Windows XP Home Pre-installed :
    100 Euro's (£69.22)
    * Windows XP Professional Pre-installed :
    175 Euro's (£121.14)
    * Delivery - Germany :
    25 Euro's (£17.31)
    * Delivery - Europe :
    55 Euro's (£38.07)
    * Delivery - Rest of World :
    POA

    Conclusion

    Pro's

    * Looks very nice, would look great in the lounge
    * Very well built
    * Quite light and easy to carry
    * Completely passively cooled
    * Cooling is most efficient
    * Well laid out internally
    * Comes pre built so easy to setup
    * Small so it doesn't take up much space
    * Blue power button looks excellent
    * Some nice colour options available
    * Quietest solution around at present

    Con's

    * System performance not great

  29. Great dorm pc by Billly+Gates · · Score: 1, Insightful
    If you need a 24/7 web or quake server but your roomate will complain look no further. This is a great pc for this market.

    1. Re:Great dorm pc by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      But how can you view homosexual porn with your roomate around? Is he your lover?

  30. silence is golden by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    PCs, like women and children, should be seen, not heard.

    Ever been to the Silent Woman bar in Merrie Olde England? The sign outside is a woman without a head.

  31. Excellent for homebrew PVR by CvD · · Score: 2, Interesting

    This looks like the option to use for a homebrew PVR solution. The only thing missing is a TV card, but you can add that in the PCI slot that is available. It even has an MPEG2 hardware decoder. Would 933 MHz be fast enough for encoding, though?

    Cheers,

    Costyn.

    1. Re:Excellent for homebrew PVR by nmos · · Score: 1
      This looks like the option to use for a homebrew PVR solution. The only thing missing is a TV card, but you can add that in the PCI slot that is available. It even has an MPEG2 hardware decoder. Would 933 MHz be fast enough for encoding, though?

      Unfortunately MHz is NOT a measure of performance. A 900MHz AMD Athlon or P3 might be enough for a PVR but this cpu would probably have problems because it simply doesn't perform as well at any given MHz as other CPUs. FPU performance is even worse compared to the others so you could be in real trouble if you have to encode/decode some format you don't have dedicated hardware for.

    2. Re:Excellent for homebrew PVR by CvD · · Score: 1

      Hmmm.. maybe using Hauppage's PVR card (which has hardware MPEG encoding/decoding) would be an option in this case. Linux drivers for this card are still in pre-alpha stage, with only a few available features implemented, though. So that would have to wait And I don't have money to buy this stuff anyways. A man can dream, though. :-)

      Cheers!

      Costyn.

    3. Re:Excellent for homebrew PVR by tomzyk · · Score: 1
      The only thing missing is a TV card, but you can add that in the PCI slot that is available.
      um. not sure about this, but I doubt you can just add a TV tuner card. Look how small the case is; if you tried to add pretty much ANY hardware to this, I don't think you'd be able to put the top back on.

      However, I was reading up on this Hush thing a few weeks ago. If you want to add a TV card or something, I suggest looking at the Mini-ITX site and looking into building your own machine and buying a different case. (like something from Casetronic)
      --
      Karma: NaN
    4. Re:Excellent for homebrew PVR by tomzyk · · Score: 1

      ...and moments later I eat my words.

      Looking at the picture of the back of the case, it looks as though you CAN add an extra card. (The card is seated parallel to the motherboard, not perpendicular as I had initially expected.)

      --
      Karma: NaN
    5. Re:Excellent for homebrew PVR by Klaruz · · Score: 1

      The mythtv folks have the PVR-250 doing encoding fine, just no seek while watching a video with it yet.

      Alan Cox contributed xfree drivers for the chipset these VIA mobos use. There are hooks to use the built in MPEG2 decoder, but a kernel interface needs to be written.

    6. Re:Excellent for homebrew PVR by zsazsa · · Score: 1

      The Via C3 series is pretty anemic, especially in the FPU department. The Nehemiah series has a vastly improved FPU, but the current generation of Hush systems don't use them.

      In any case, if MPEG2 is what you want, the Hauppage WinTV PVR-250 offers hardware MPEG2 compression. They just got basic support for it in MythTV in Linux, too. Linux support for the EPIA's onboard MPEG2 decoder is forthcoming as well (Alan Cox has one).

      My only issue would be the AC97-based onboard sound. Hopefully VIA comes out with this board soon - it has the very high quality Envy24 24/96 sound chip on it. A lot of "semi-pro" recording cards like those from M-Audio use the Envy24 series. One good feature is lack of resampling on the SPDIF output.

    7. Re:Excellent for homebrew PVR by drinkypoo · · Score: 1

      It depends on the quality you're looking for. a 933MHz EDEN CPU *might* be able to do realtime MPEG1 encoding at VCD resolution, but I can tell you right now that it can't even begin to do realtime MPEG2 encoding at SVCD resolution. A thunderbird 1.4GHz will only do about .98 of realtime, and I think we can all agree that a 1GHz EDEN is no match for a 1.4GHz thunderbird. In fact my Athlon XP 2000+ only does about 1.4 of realtime. MPEG4 takes even more power, so you definitely won't be able to do that. The solution? Use a hardware encoder/decoder. There are devices which accelerate both MPEG2 and MPEG4.

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
  32. MPEG decoder by cyco_penguin · · Score: 5, Informative

    It's just a shame the EPIA-M's onboard mpeg 2 decoder still has no linux.support. It's not at all obvious that this is the case looking at VIA's website. And there are a lot of people upset about this on the VIA forums.

    1. Re:MPEG decoder by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting
      Indeed. This frustrates me to no end.

      For most entertainment applications, the performance hog is MPEG2 decoding, particularly high-defintion (1080i30, 720p60) decoding. While MPEG2 was designed to use an asymetrical codec(i.e. encoding is a lot more computationally expensive than decoding, particularly if you're generating P and/or B frames), decoding still takes a fair amount of horsepower to do in real time.

      Fortunately, and by design, MPEG2 decoding lends itself to hardware-assisted implementations. There are chips designed for set top boxes which can decode more than one high definition stream and drive a high definition display, scaling additional streams to fit in a PIP window. These chips can run with passive cooling (i.e. just a heat sink). While I can't elaborate, I work with them -- under Linux -- and often don't even use a heat sink.

      Unfortunately, disclosing source code would be very problematic: licensed third-party code (I can neither confirm nor deny what kind of code, but think of all the "protection" schemes that are the bane of fair use and reverse engineering) is intermingled with home-grown stuff.

      So, completly silent media PCs with even HD MPEG2 decoding are certainly possible, and exist today. But, the software to drive them is very much locked up, and reverse engineering is a bitch.

    2. Re:MPEG decoder by BeBoxer · · Score: 1

      What we need is a lightweight video codec which has just enough compression to get TV quality video down below 100Mbps. Then you could just decompress the video on a server in the back room and stream it over the LAN to a lightweight client which would actually display it. No need to muck around with undocumented MPEG2 decoders.

    3. Re:MPEG decoder by linuxguy · · Score: 1


      I too would discourage anyone from buying these VIA systems until VIA gets their act together and provide support for MPEG-2 hardware decode under Linux.

  33. It's called a cube by ericdano · · Score: 1

    It's been done before. It's called a G4 cube. I have one. It's silent. It's fast. It works.

    --
    It's either on the beat or off the beat, it's that easy.
    I moderate therefore I rule!
    --
    1. Re:It's called a cube by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You forgot to mention the price. Is it more than $200-300, the cost range of building EPIA computers?

    2. Re:It's called a cube by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      apart from the hard drive in the apple cube, which isn't silent, unless you've changed the stock hard drive in there... this mini-itx hush thing has a case for the hard drive, which is meant to keep it quieter than the hard drive in the cube, which is just a normal hard drive with nothing around it to try make it quieter.

  34. Re:Audio by matthew.thompson · · Score: 1

    They're just interface standards and numbers.

    I want details on singal to noise ratio - picture quality, sound quality. What does the picture look like? Does the display have a sodding black border round the edge?

    How is the SPDIF output created - does it support DTS?

    Just listing ports tells you nothing.

    --
    Matt Thompson - Actuality - Insert product here.
  35. Apple had some of the first truly 'silent' desktop by soullessbastard · · Score: 5, Informative

    Remember the PowerMac G4 Cube? Aside from all of its brouhaha on price, lack of expansions, etc., it was 8 inches square and was a fanless convection cooled machine (and still is, for those of us who still use them!), and 1-2 years before any of these fanless mini-itx form factor machines.

    It really is perfect as an iTunes console/DVR at the side of the TV, but priced well above using one for that purpose at the time.

    As evidence of a near-identical form factor, folks have managed to cram mini-itx motherboards inside its case.

    Similar to these mini-itx style boxes, the G4 Cube had internal hard drive and CD-ROM noise, but with NetBoot (or some optical FireWire repeaters and a hard drive in another room) you could run the sucker completely silent.

    The only fan that was in Apple original designs was the video card fan for the ATI Radeon graphics cards (Rage 128s were fanless). Unsupported Radeon upgrades were fanless. Most upgrades these days to honk up the processor to a 1GHz+G4 single or dualie add in an 80cm fan at the base of the unit to push air through. Similarly with GF3s or other video cards put inside this case...convection alone isn't enough to cool the chips. Fans and noise will probably be the price of powerful machines in small form factors for some time to come given that minimal heat dissipation is not a primary design goal of high-end CPUs and GPUs.

  36. nice.. but by joper90 · · Score: 1

    looks like a laptop missing a few bits in a slighly bigger funckier box?

  37. Speed Issue by IanBevan · · Score: 3, Informative
    The most significant issue with this board is that it is based on the slightly older V series boards, rather than the new M series. The V series suffer from not being able to display MPEG2 and process AC3 sound simultaneously - making it sub-optimal for movie playback.

    Another review can be found on the this website (bear in mind that they sell the Hush though). A comparison of the M and V series boards, including comparative benchmarks for video playback, can be found here.

    Personally I intend to wait until Hush produce a new model based on the M series.

    1. Re:Speed Issue by mccalli · · Score: 2, Insightful
      The most significant issue with this board is that it is based on the slightly older V series boards, rather than the new M series.

      Nope, this model is based on the M board, as can by seen from the Buy Now link.

      Cheers,
      Ian

    2. Re:Speed Issue by IanBevan · · Score: 1

      Oops, you're right :-) LOL, getting my machine reviews confused :-)

  38. get CompactFlash by g4dget · · Score: 1

    For about $20, you can buy a CompactFlash-to-IDE adapter and use it with a Mini-ITX board in place of an IDE drive. You can then use a 512M CF card as your disk--plenty for installing a pretty usable Linux system.

    1. Re:get CompactFlash by tomstdenis · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Ya you casually miss the fact that CF is not as durable as a real IDE hard disk. Try re-writing to a sector a couple of thousand times :-)

      From what I recall most CF are guaranteed for something like 10^6 re-writes while a hard disk for about 10^9.

      This is why CF is primarily used in taskings where you are not likely to have things like temp files etc... [e.g. mp3 player, camera]

      Tom

      --
      Someday, I'll have a real sig.
    2. Re:get CompactFlash by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      10^6 is slightly more than "a couple of thousand times". Even connectors are specified for 10000+ plugging-cycles. Besides, swap and temp files don't belong on compact flash anyway, it's much too slow. The filesystem should avoid storing superfluous information like "last access time", but then you're fine.

    3. Re:get CompactFlash by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Exactly, that's why it's better to buy an IDE flash drive. They remap blocks to avoid over using a single spot.

    4. Re:get CompactFlash by g4dget · · Score: 1
      Try re-writing to a sector a couple of thousand times :-)

      They last a lot more than that.

      Plenty of Linux systems use flash for storage, formatted in DOS or ext2.

      If it really worries you, mount with "noatime" and put /tmp and /var/log in RAM.file system. If it really, really worries you, use the block-remapping flash support in the Linux kernel.

  39. Pizza box is back by zakezuke · · Score: 1

    The first thing that comes to mind are the older style pizza boxes like the Mac LC III for example.

    While one can be critical of that style, not everyone has the space for your typical full tower. But in this current generation computing I have to ask, "why not get a laptop?" But that's just me personaly.

    --
    There is no sanctuary. There is no sanctuary. SHUT UP! There is no shut up. There is no shut up.
  40. Just say NO to NCD and to thin clients by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Thin client is a MICROSOFT term for a proprietary terminal. Thin Clients are built to Microsoft's specifications and are intentially made to be ill-suited for adaptation as X terminals. That's two reasons not to buy a thin client. NCD is a company which has always substantially OVERPRICED its hardware and which has failed to offer support for its products for any use except as a locked-in terminal. That's a third reason not to buy an NCD terminal. NCD is doing so badly as a company that it was delisted from the NASDAQ last year. That's another reason not to buy its products. NCD is infamous for overpricing its products.
    The SolarPC is significant for all the obvious reasons, not the least of which being that it is the product, and the price, that NCD should have created the precursor of ten years ago.

    1. Re:Just say NO to NCD and to thin clients by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well, that shows how much you know. NCD support both CITRIX and Microsoft, as well as having a Linux based build.

      You clearly have no idea what thin client computing is about. In fact the term thin client originated in Sun Microsystems. I was using thin client X-terminals in the late 1980s before MS had even started making Terminal Server (which incidentally is an excellent product.)

      As for your MS controlls thin clients blah... utter rubbish, anyone can make a terminal which connects as an RDP client. You don't have to pay a licence to MS (except a CAL if you're running 2k in anything except administration mode and why would you for home use)

    2. Re:Just say NO to NCD and to thin clients by mentin · · Score: 1
      You are confused. It is Sun who tries to push Thin client (although I agree about proprietary and overpriced part).

      Microsoft advocates Smart client which for them means Windows machine running .NET and using XML Web Services to access miscelaneous servers.

      --
      MSDOS: 20+ years without remote hole in the default install
    3. Re:Just say NO to NCD and to thin clients by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What the hell has a NASDAQ listing got to do with anything. Jeez...if you want to see a bunch of speculators out-fraud each other it might be a spectator sport, but we're talking about *technology* here.

      Oh, and "thin client" is *NOT* a purely MS term...

  41. if you like to gamble by g4dget · · Score: 1

    AFAIK, Dell makes no guarantees that their systems are silent or even quiet. The Dell I have is quite noisy, actually. You are only guaranteed a silent PC if you build it yourself or buy it as such.

  42. other Silent PC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    There's a rather similar PC with much more current hardware (P4, >2GHz): SignumData's FutureClient. See here. The problem is: It's vastly more expensive than the Hush model. Getting rid of all the heat costs you...

    I really wish someone would make Mini-ITX boards using Pentium-M chips. They have roughly the same power budget as the C3s (ca. 10Watts max for ULV variant), and as various notebooks proove you can make the motherboards just as compact. With Pentium-M based Mini-ITX boards you could do all the cool things that Via's Mini-ITX allow you to, except at up-to-date performance levels.

  43. I've had 2 silent computers for a long time by Rosco+P.+Coltrane · · Score: 1

    One of them is a full blood assembled-from-spare-parts steed hidden in the cupboard by the toilets that talks to me through an old X terminal (absolutely noiseless) and an old Tosh laptop that's noisy like a quiet 1997 laptop but that I can't hear above the ambient noise level in the bar I usually use it in.

    I'm constantly chasing noisy equipment in my surrounding, and have been doing so for years because I suffer from hyperacusis and chronic tinnitus. Those are my time-tested solutions to the problem of noisy PCs, and I bet it's a lot cheaper than real silent PCs, and I'm pretty sure people who truly can't stand noisy computers have already devised their own solutions too.

    --
    "A door is what a dog is perpetually on the wrong side of" - Ogden Nash
  44. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Well, afaik, you _must_ buy the AGP card from dell, as the slots is put in backward. Hehe.

  45. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by tankdilla · · Score: 1

    That slickdeals.net computer is pretty good for that price. But dammit I hate mail-in rebates. Sometimes it takes so long to get the rebate, you forget that you're getting a deal. Good deals like that always make you jump through some hoops just to save a buck.

    --

    -Look lively. LOOK LIVELY!!! --Mr. Shmallow

  46. The only truly silent PC. . . by bplipschitz · · Score: 1

    is a dead PC.

    Then again, if the entire *case* is a heatsink, and everything is shockmounted, it might work.

    But, you'd still want to kill it at some point. . .

  47. Re:Boot from USB Ramdisk? (Or convert?) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Use Fujitsu 2.5" drives: Fluid dynamic bearing, 4200rpm, practically silent.
    If you want completely solid state: compact flash cards have a standard IDE interface, they just need a pin adapter - voila, solid state harddisk.

  48. Re:Boot from USB Ramdisk? (Or convert?) by vrai · · Score: 2, Interesting
    Why bother with USB? Compact Flash has an IDE interface so you just need a cheap CF->IDE adaptor (like this, 13 GBP) and a bog standard CF card (about twenty-five quid for 128Mb).

    As far as the computer is concerned it is just another IDE device and will boot from it as normal. Even in the over-priced UK this comes in at under forty pounds. Less money and much less hassle than trying to boot from a USB drive.

  49. Slashdoted by outofpaper · · Score: 2, Funny

    &:12 Am less than a hundrud coments and the site is slashed. We shoud use a distributed file systum for the web somthinc like freenet but faster. Sinsce at the moment freenet makes it seam as though its 8 years ago and I have a 14.4

    1. Re:Slashdoted by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Wow this post hurts my brain. :(

    2. Re:Slashdoted by bplipschitz · · Score: 1

      --
      &:12 Am less than a hundrud coments and the site is slashed. We shoud use a distributed file systum for the web somthinc like freenet but faster. Sinsce at the moment freenet makes it seam as though its 8 years ago and I have a 14.4
      --

      If you're the official spokesperson, I don't think that it will happen any time soon. . .

  50. Re:Boot from USB Ramdisk? (Or convert?) by Ewan · · Score: 1

    I've got a PC at home booting of CF at the moment, compact flash is ata-compliant so all you need is a dirt cheap ide/cf connector. No need for BIOS support, etc.

    Of course, its awfully slow if you just have the filesystems on the card, instead you need to play around with using a ramdisk for /tmp and /var and make sure you aren't swapping to the card or every time a program starts everything will slow to a crawl.

  51. Seagate Barracuda by jcsehak · · Score: 1

    I just got a Seagate Barracuda from endpcnoise.com, to replace the Maxtor my Mac came with (which sounded like a jet engine), and it's quiet as a mouse. The only noise now is the fan in the power supply. VERY satisfied.

    --

    c-hack.com |
  52. Not a very good review by OhRock · · Score: 1

    That sucks! That that machine is not a gaming platform we all know since Via came out with the wholle Epia thingy, so what's the point in testing a Game? What about Mpeg encoding...what about puting a tunner to that thing?...what about maybe getting Myth or Frevoo intalled? or Snapstream? (for that matter) I'm really looking forward for small footprint noiseless form factor to use as a PVR and Via is in the right direction, but so far grossly underpower. This review is not giving any subtantial information.

  53. Linux compatibility by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Anyone knows how compatible with Linux these Hush machines are? -js

  54. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "I don't know, I've never heard one."

    That's because they're completely silent!

  55. Get it from Signum Data with a P4 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    You can get a similar system put with P4 (up to 2.53 GHz) from:
    Signum Data
    That make more sense to me as a desktop, as you get much more CPU power. But I admit that it might look better without a floppy drive.

    1. Re:Get it from Signum Data with a P4 by mieses · · Score: 1

      the Signum Data and Hush systems do seem almost identical. I noticed the Signum Data design over a year ago and have since been hoping that something like it would become available in the US.

      One difference is that the Signum Data P4 box has air holes on the top but the Hush pc case is completely closed... so it may be impervious to dust as well as noise.

  56. So close by drsmithy · · Score: 1
    These things are a slot-loading DVD-RW and onboard video capture away from perfection (the latter I can see being allowed for with the PCI slot - but why, oh why did they go with those horrible laptop drives ?).

    An easy and neat way of adding an IR receiver to the front would be a nice touch, too.

  57. Laptop, does for me. by arpoodle · · Score: 1

    for most of my work, I use a laptop. I've got a linux box under my desk at home, amnd use that for backups and file storage for all but important/critical files that I might be working on.

    Can anyone tell me what a desktop/tower configured PC can offer over a laptop for 95% of regular computer usage?

    My laptop can do everything I need of it, and it's smaller, lighter and quieter than a tower. and it's mobile...

    the only REAL benefit a tower configuration has for me, is that it allows upgrades more easily, rather than having to be completely replaced when it becomes obsolete.

    just my tuppeny's worth

    --
    When a passenger of the foot, hooves in sight, tootel the horn trumpet melodiously
  58. Its my review by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    Hi gents, I've just been told that we got slashdotted , I see you have been making server admins quake in their boots as usual.

    I've tried to read any questions people had , the main one I see is that I didnt address the TV out function , I've linked to our full review of the epia 9000 as this contains the infomation etc , I didnt want to go over old ground.

    I've review lots of things now and this was the first thing to come through the door that blew me away. Even the pc hating girlfriend liked it.

    Re the hard disc a IBM will never be as silent as the Seagate , I've used those utitilties they just effect seek noise not the annoying whine.

    Any questions just ask I will try to answer them :)

  59. Quiet PC's can be good, but their are cons too... by noogle · · Score: 0

    they wont be able to mask the sound of you beating off in your room quite so well.

    --

    I'm smarter than the average bear.

  60. Awww, c'mon now! by KC7GR · · Score: 1

    If you eliminate the fans, or put utterly silent ones in, what the frell are us techies who depend on white noise as a relaxation aid supposed to do? How can you possibly expect us to fall asleep in our chairs without that nice, ongoing, semi-pneumatic 'whirroosshh!' to mask out the noise of the couple getting it on in the supply room next door?

    Criminys, some manufacturers just take all the fun out of tech-work... ;-)

    --

    Bruce Lane, KC7GR,

    Blue Feather Technologies

    1. Re:Awww, c'mon now! by Mawbid · · Score: 1

      You have speakers, right?

      --
      Fuck the system? Nah, you might catch something.
  61. Cost comparison by X-Nc · · Score: 1

    Just for grins I tried comparlng the Mini-ITX with this in similar HW configurations and they ended up costing about the same. The Mini was a hair lower but still in the same ballpark.

    --
    --
    If I actually could spell I'd have spelled it right in the first place.
  62. dead hexus by Oakey · · Score: 3, Funny

    For those that like numbers, the Hexus server is a dual xeon with a few Gb RAM and SCSI disks. Or at least it was, you heartless people have killed it. Dave won't be happy.

    --
    "Dre don't get as high as me.... I'm Cheech and Chong" - Snoop Dogg
  63. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    My old amiga was so quiet, the only sound was the 50hz hum from the mains transformer.

  64. My Silent PC by GeekDork · · Score: 1

    I built a PC for my father. The requirement was: it has to be almost dead silent. Now, he's working on an Athlon XP 2000+ with a Radeon 8500 and you almost have to look for the power-LED to tell if the thing is running. Also, the "whole" thing (wasn't a whole PC, but almost) came at about EUR750-800; today I'd guess you could get the parts for at least EUR150 less.

    All stock compopnents, a VIA KT400 mainboard, the 2000+ CPU, 512MB of PC333 DDR-Memory and the Radeon 8500 wth the stock fan. The CPU is cooled by a Thermaltake SK-7 copper monster with a 1500RPM Papst fan on it. The PSU is a 300W Blacknoise. HDD is a Seagate Barracuda V. All that in a leftover tower case without an additional casefan is almost inaudible, sufficiently fast even for most if not all games and the CPU temperature maxes out at 51 deg. C.

    The system has a good-quality video signal, is extensible and was actually affordable. The only downside is that it's not really small, but you could easily stuff it inside a mini-tower and keep it well-coled with a 1500RPM case fan. If you're not looking for something small and stylish, that's the way I recommend.

    --

    Fight hunger. Filet a politician and send him to a 3rd world country of your choice.

    1. Re:My Silent PC by Makarakalax · · Score: 4, Informative
      Radeon 8500 with the stock fan

      That's got to be the noisiest component left in it then surely? Unless it's not a 60mm..

      A couple of months ago I decided to silence my machine. I nipped to QuietPC.comand got a Zalman silent heatsink for my GPU, 2 quiet case fans and a SilentDrive(tm) to enclose (and silence) my hard-disk. I already had a quiet enough PSU and a Zalman Flower on my 1800+.

      The result is that I can sleep in the same room as the box (my goal), but it isn't silent. When I lay my head down to rest and the house is quiet the hum from the remaining fans is very audible. However if you come into my room in the day, you can't tell its on unless you stop still and actively listen for it.

      I've found that low frequency sounds are quite soporiferous. However the SilentDrive doesn't entirely mask the high pitched whine of my Maxtor 740DX (also the SilentDrive's build quality is absolute poo) and it is that sound that I hear quite clearly on those nights that I just can't quite get to sleep. Interestingly too, the resistor slowed Zalman casefans are far louder than the Enermax PSU fans. Does anyone know if I dare reduce the voltage on the case fans even more?

      I have a coolermaster case, so I figured the sound gets transfered easily through the entire metal body. I was right; I made myself some rubber washers and isolated all the fans from the case and the difference in noise was very noticeable. So I figure I shouldn't have fallen in love with the sexy metallic sheen of the Coolermaster and bought the budget Dabs.com like I had originally planned ;)

      All in all the Athlon idles at 38C and at 100% load it gets to about 51C, so I might deactivate the case fans and see how that goes.

      Basically I was disapointed with the QuietPC products, they work ok, but they rip you off - the case fans were standard Zalmans, but on their site no brand is mentioned and all the products listed are overpriced. Also the results were not as good as I hoped.

      But anyway back to the Radeon stock fan. Removing my NVidia 440MX stock fan was the most noticeable change I made! Zalman GPU passive coolers are pretty cheap. It may be worth checking them out if you want that little bit more silence for your dad's box.

    2. Re:My Silent PC by slamb · · Score: 1
      Interestingly too, the resistor slowed Zalman casefans are far louder than the Enermax PSU fans. Does anyone know if I dare reduce the voltage on the case fans even more?

      You might try Silencer fans instead. No fan is truly silent, but these are 20dB. IIRC, whispers are 30dB, so you might not even be able to hear it at all. Mine does not contribute tto my machine's noise in any noticeable way. I've also got a Silencer power supply. That just leaves the processor and video card fans.

    3. Re:My Silent PC by GeekDork · · Score: 1
      I've found that low frequency sounds are quite soporiferous. However the SilentDrive doesn't entirely mask the high pitched whine of my Maxtor 740DX (also the SilentDrive's build quality is absolute poo) and it is that sound that I hear quite clearly on those nights that I just can't quite get to sleep.

      I can really recommend the Barracuda V. It may be a little more expensive an deliver a little less data transfer (still enough to record fullsize PAL video, so who cares...), but it comes with some insulation already installed and is surprisingly quiet. There's no high-pitched whine to speak of, and I'm really sensitive to that. Seeking is also not really loud, but that's about standard for todays consumer drives with acoustic management.

      Interestingly too, the resistor slowed Zalman casefans are far louder than the Enermax PSU fans. Does anyone know if I dare reduce the voltage on the case fans even more?

      If you want truly optimized fans, try Verax (US vendor if you're interested in shipping the stuff over a customs border twice). A little more expensive, but according to a friend of mine the best you can get if you want good airflow at zero noise. Otherwise, as I already said, the slow Papst fans are great value.

      I have a coolermaster case, so I figured the sound gets transfered easily through the entire metal body. I was right; I made myself some rubber washers and isolated all the fans from the case and the difference in noise was very noticeable.

      You can try to pad the case inside with... *tadaaa* cardboard. Just stick some double-sided tape to the case, cut up a moving box (the nice wavy-type cardboard) and cover the sides and the drive slots. It might look a little ghetto, but who looks inside an office machine. Also, most of todays brand-name cases are built for ventilation, not silence. Make sure that the case is really heavy with good tight-fitting sidedoors and as few holes as necessary.

      But anyway back to the Radeon stock fan. Removing my NVidia 440MX stock fan was the most noticeable change I made! Zalman GPU passive coolers are pretty cheap. It may be worth checking them out if you want that little bit more silence for your dad's box.

      You mean the big block with the heatpipe? Yes, I already thought about those but could never bring myself to try and cool a big hot 0.15 chip with one of those. Thanks for the info anyway :-)

      --

      Fight hunger. Filet a politician and send him to a 3rd world country of your choice.

    4. Re:My Silent PC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "Basically I was disapointed with the QuietPC products, they work ok, but they rip you off - the case fans were standard Zalmans, but on their site no brand is mentioned and all the products listed are overpriced. Also the results were not as good as I hoped. "

      When I first was looking to cool down stuff with quiet fans or no fans, I went to quietpc.com also. Basically went through the same thing, finding out that their stuff was just marked up from virtually every other store. So next time I went to another online dealer who had a better selection and better price. I think thats really what it gets down to - their selection sucks. Also the flower coolers they carry suck. Atleast the ones I've dealt with. Most of their CPU mounting clips seem to only have 1 hole on each side of the socket connector which makes it alot easier to fuck up your CPU. The Socket has like 3 tabs, they should be required to use them.

  65. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by singleantler · · Score: 1

    We use Dells where I work and while the Dimensions most of us use are damned quiet, they're not quite silent. We've noticed they are getting slightly louder over time (18 months) which is presumably just wear and tear on the case fan, and even now they're still very quiet for PCs.

    When we first had them one of the fans had a bad bearing and Dell sent an engineer out to replace the fans on all the PCs we'd just bought, which took them back to being near-silent. You can't hear them over the traffic outside and general office noises unless you put your ear on the case. So yes, for most situations these machines are going to be more than quiet enough for most people, though the cases don't look as pretty as some of the Mini-ITX based ones.

    --
    "What if they're using IE?" "I've dumbed Mozilla down to cope with it." - BOFH
  66. silent versus quiet by Adam+J.+Richter · · Score: 1
    Thank you for your informative post. I just want to pick one nit about silent versus quiet. I think the relevant definition of silent from webster.com is their second definition:

    2 : free from sound or noise : STILL

    I think you meant to say that IBM drives can be made to run quietly rather than silently, unless the amount of noise that they make is truely zero (which generally is true when the drive is spun down or turned off, but I don't think that is what you were referring to).

  67. Neat but damn by piznut · · Score: 1

    Thats pretty steep. Lets do the math.

    a Via EPIA-M 9000 mobo + cpu can be had for about $110.
    Add on 128mb ram for $21.99 from crucial.
    A 40gb HDD at todays prices, $70.
    A slim cdrom drive, $40.

    Which gives you a grand total of $260..Hell lets throw on an extra $40 for misc cables and crap and make it an even $300. 645 euro comes to almost 720 USD, which means you are paying $400 for a case?

    Thanks...Ill pass.

    1. Re:Neat but damn by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      here's the prices in the UK which will be more accurate as thats where the hush pricing is based

      Epia £116.33
      128mb ram £34.08
      hdd £74.03
      Slim cd £54.05
      Morex PSU £46.41

      Total: £324.90

      All taken from minitx.com where they are selling the hush at present

      The hush price is £499.38

      So that leaves £175 for the case the heatsink the cabling etc

      I've had cases that were well over £250 and the hush case is better than them :)

  68. Amen. by Lispy · · Score: 1

    Its actually not even a shame its a catastrophe since I wanted to build a movietank out of this but the DVD-Performance is really too bad if you do the harddecoding way. Looks like I will stick with my ps2 for watching dvds for a while then.

  69. go to mini-itx.com by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    for a decent review + some photos of the hush machine. you can even buy one from them if they catch your fancey.

  70. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by thogard · · Score: 1

    There are so many loud transformers out there these days. It seems no one can make a switching transformer that's quiet either. I've got a nokia 8310 and its noisy. I can hear the power supply in the phone hum away at 4khz or what ever its doing. The only time its worse is when I charge it and the transformer in the plug pack and the internal switcher supply start at a bit of argument. I can't sleep when its doing that.

  71. Mine is silent... by z-kungfu · · Score: 1

    ...unless you run the DVD.
    I added a Seagate Barracuda 80GB drive and a GeForce 3, and a Panaflo fan (Silent) in preperation for the 1Ghz upgrade I'll be putting in. Incredible machine that was way ahead of it's time.

  72. A-Tech Heatsink Case by Coppit · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Since people seem interested in near-silent PCs for their home theater: The Heatsink Case. This sucker is so well designed that the internal temp goes up when you take off the lid. :) Unfortunately the guy has had trouble getting production ramped up enough to satisfy his many customers...

  73. Other silent boxes.. by Dri · · Score: 0


    Captech (Swedish) is a swedish company building silent PC's. They have won a bunch of awards and they are really impressive. The noise pressure level is below 17.5 dBA at the operator's position. Oh, an English version is available also.

    --
    Girls are strange. They don't come with a man page.
    -- Michael Mattsson
  74. Not by Zebra_X · · Score: 1

    It looks nice for sure - but the specs... are lacking. The reason they can put the VIA proc. in the case w/no fan is simply that it's a "smaller engine" that generates less heat. They haven't done anything "revolutionary" here. The have just put a low power processor in a closed case with enough sinks on the side to disapate internal heat. Apart from surfing, office, music and possibly watching a DVD the proc in the machine isn't good for much. As for our enthusatic posters question "Is this finally the step to having a true PC in every living room? HTPC here we come!" No - it isn't. This will nto be the path for faster processors, they generate too much heat.

  75. Truely quiet pc by the+uNF+cola · · Score: 1

    The only truely quiet pc, is one that is off. [/zen]

    --

    --
    "I'm not bright. Big words confuse me. But Wanda loves me and that should be enough for you." - Cosmo

  76. Re:Boot from USB Ramdisk? (Or convert?) by reezle · · Score: 1

    Cool... Didn't even think of those little guys (and I have two sitting on my desk, haha)

    Thx man...

  77. Who cares about loud PC's in the living room? by John_Booty · · Score: 1

    Most of the articles I've seen about these small form factor and/or silent PC's seem to focus on the noise factor for living room use, since the most obvious use of these boxes is as a mp3/DIVX media player.

    Well, I think that focus is misguided. I have a ShuttleSV24, the first tiny PC that Shuttle made. It's great, but the power supply fan is really annoyingly loud (recent Shuttle mini-PC's apparently have made great strides in this area).

    It doesn't matter though, because the system is asleep 99.99% of the time... it's set to sleep after 5-10 minutes of inactivity. I just tap the keyboard to bring it out of sleep when I want to use it, and it goes to sleep by itself when I'm done. Perfect! So the noise doesn't matter... it's more than drowned out by the mp3/DIVX's I'm playing even at low volumes.

    Now, sound output in PC's serving in desktop/workstation roles... now THAT'S a worthy topic!

    --

    OtakuBooty.com: Smart, funny, sexy nerds.
  78. wireless monitors? by azzy · · Score: 1

    We have wireless mice, wireless keyboards, even wireless networking... what about some decent wireless monitors? And I don't mean vnc... running a desktop over a network... or Microsoft's stupid portable monitor with a CPU built into it... but a simple flatscreen lcd monitor.. that has a wireless receiver on it, and a dongle plugs into the graphics card with a wireless transmitter. I don't see how the addition of such a wireless connection could add all that much to the price of a monitor..

    Then the PC can be anywhere in the house, noisy as hell, and monitor/keyboard/mouse all in another room.

    1. Re:wireless monitors? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The problem with a wireless monitor is the data rate for a display. Even with a megapixel display you want to change 24 bits of color 60 times per second to get you 1.44Gbps of data moving to the screen. You could compress it, but then you'll need a gpu for decompressing.

  79. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by n-baxley · · Score: 1

    Same for the Dimension 4550 that I just got. Very silent although not completly. Either that or I can't hear it over the roar of my other machines.

  80. Re:Boot from USB Ramdisk? (Or convert?) by apdt · · Score: 1

    The new chipset from intel (Canterwood) does this.

    Have a look at this

    --
    I lay awake last night wondering where the sun had gone, then it dawned on me.
  81. Re:New feature request for Slashcode... by ites · · Score: 1
    And after all this time, there's not a single asshat that comes up with a decent solution? Do you seriously think the chance of being sued for not warning in time is higher than the chance of being sued for denial of service today? If all the asshats on /. can't figure out a workable solution to the /. effect, I'm truly disappointed.

    I'm not surprised this thread comes up every time, if asshats keep dissing the topic as junk.

    --
    Sig for sale or rent. One previous user. Inquire within.
  82. Is this enough for Mythtv? by MnO-Raphael · · Score: 1
    I've been looking for something like this to run Mythtv on. Only problem is, I have no clue how this VIA CPU performs and I have no reference to how well MythTV performs in general.

    Have anybody tried this out on the Hush or something similar? And was is enough to watch TV and encode a stream, etc?


    The MythTV FAQ have some info about CPU usage:

    A PIII/733Mhz system can encode one video stream using the MPEG-4 codec using 480x480 capture resolution. This does not allow for live TV watching, but does allow for encoding video and then watching it later.

    The developer states that his AMD1800+ system can almost encode two MPEG4 video streams and watch one program simultaneously.

    A PIII/800Mhz system with 512MB RAM can encode one video stream using the RTJPEG codec with 480x480 capture resolution and play it back simultaneously, thereby allowing live TV watching.

    A dual Celeron/450Mhz is able to view a 480x480 MPEG4/3300Kbps file created on a different system with 30% CPU usage.

    A P4 2.4Ghz machine can encode two 3300Kbps 480x480 MPEG4 files and simultaneously serve content to a remote frontend.
    The review mentions the Hush comes shipped with a MPEG-2 decoder, clearly an important paramter in this equation.

  83. Caveat Emptor by Salamander · · Score: 4, Informative

    I just built a system very similar to these, and it's a blast, but there are some problems. One is that the Morex 55W power supply seems to have some issues, particularly at boot-up, that can result in a hung system. Another is heat. The EPIA boards don't generate a lot, but they do generate some, and other components (e.g. hard disk) do too. VIA does not recommend running the M-9000 fanless; that's precisely why I bought an ME-6000, and the case does have two (very quiet) case fans, and I've still had a couple of lockups that might be attributable to heat. Other users at VIA Arena using the same mobo/case combination have reported very similar problems. Overall, there seems to be a growing feeling among the community of people who've actually bought them that systems built around these components might not be silent and stable at the same time. Pick one. :-( Maybe the next generation will be capable of running silently without these stability problems, and it's fine for a hobby project, but I couldn't really recommend this type of system for regular use.

    --
    Slashdot - News for Herds. Stuff that Splatters.
    1. Re:Caveat Emptor by Gordy_Hand · · Score: 1

      The cpu temp doesnt get above 40degrees in the hush at full load. The fins are very efficient at removing the heat. Also the hard disc is also connected to the fins to remove its heat so you can be certain its going to be better than other cases without fans. I havent had any problems with the two morex psu's I've had , out of interest what have you got connected to it The epia at hdd and a normal ide drive? In my experience they top out with epia, hdd and a laptop optical drive .

    2. Re:Caveat Emptor by Salamander · · Score: 1

      I have the ME-6000, which draws less than most of the other boards, plus a 3.5" 7200RPM hard disk, plus a slim combo optical drive. The optical drive isn't really a factor because it wasn't in use when I saw the lockups so it wouldn't have been drawing more than a tiny trickle of current. I also don't know for sure that the lockups were heat-related; the symptoms could also be explained by a chipset bug (always happens right during or after a heavy burst of disk I/O) but that's even worse.

      The thing is, power-wise, this isn't exactly a demanding sort of system. This is exactly the sort of load the PSU should have been designed to handle, and it shouldn't be anywhere near "topping out" as you say. If it's the power supply that's causing these problems then the power supply is defective. People shouldn't have to babysit the power supply by selecting their hard drive purely by its power consumption and not plugging anything into external ports etc. Responsible vendors don't design, manufacture, or sell components that are one tiny step from failure at normal load. This system doesn't draw 55W and it's supposed to be a 55W power supply; it should have headroom.

      --
      Slashdot - News for Herds. Stuff that Splatters.
  84. Re:Apple had some of the first truly 'silent' desk by hellfire · · Score: 1

    Actually the original iMacs were more silent than this. Original iMacs with the CRT screen were cooled with a number of heat syncs and by convection; the heat simply rose out of the back of the case. You couldn't hear the hard drive unless you had really good ears and tried to listen, and the only time you could hear anything was when a CD spun up.

    So lets see... that would put this whole project, what, 4-5 years behind?

    --

    "All great wisdom is contained in .signature files"

  85. Heck... by Faust7 · · Score: 2, Informative

    Every Apple II was completely silent, with those wonderful milk-carton-sized switching power supplies.

  86. Re:Apple had some of the first truly 'silent' desk by sootman · · Score: 1

    Funny now that the recent G4s are SO LOUD that Apple is offering a power-supply trade-in deal for $20 to help the noise. I have a newer model that came *with* the new PS and it's still louder than earlier G4s or any PC I've ever had. Plus it rattles. We just bought twenty dual-1.25GHz G4s and about 1/4 of them rattle like mine.

    --
    Dear Slashdot: next time you want to mess with the site, add a rich-text editor for comments.
  87. LTSP by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    http://www.DisklessWorkstations.com/
    Jammin

  88. My old Atari ST was pretty quiet by YetAnotherName · · Score: 1

    Had no hard disk. No cooling fan.

    I remember when a high school buddy said he got a new IBM to replace his old Amiga. He turned it on for me and said, "Hear that? That's power."

    1. Re:My old Atari ST was pretty quiet by satterth · · Score: 1
      My old Atari ST was pretty quiet

      Had no hard disk. No cooling fan.

      Yeah, but can your Atari ST playback a DVD on your TV?
      --
      Being called a dork on Slashdot must be like being called the retard in special ed.
    2. Re:My old Atari ST was pretty quiet by el_avatar · · Score: 1

      It's cool to see how people's priorities have changed. I think people just want what they don't already have, and back in the day, the atari thingy and such didn't need fans and blah blah blah, so when something new came out, like the affor-mentioned IBM computer, and it made noise, people were like, "wow man... hear that shit?!! that's power." or whatever. Anyway, nowadays, most every body has some thrumb-humming monster next to or under their desk, and we've grown sick of that constant noise... so now it's cool to have what every else doesn't... some pure power, silent style!

      -yep

  89. mini-itx.com review almost a mirror by peel · · Score: 1
    Not a mirror but another review I read the other day on the hush over at mini-itx.com Not great but lots of pretty pictures. -peel

    http://www.mini-itx.com/reviews/hush/

    please note that mini-itx sells these things so the review may be biased

  90. Re:Boot from USB Ramdisk? (Or convert?) by reezle · · Score: 1

    Very cool link... Might be worth checking out that motherboard. (thx)

  91. You don't need the hush to run silent by figa · · Score: 2, Informative
    I have an older Epia Eden, and I bought this case from case outlet. It comes with a brick power supply, and it was under $300 for the case, mainboard, and internal DVD. I pulled the fan out of the case, and there's only a heatsink on the CPU. I used memory I had laying around.

    I picked up a 120G Seagate Barracuda IV for about $140. This drive is impressively quiet. I leave it running at night, and I can't hear it at all. I've had it running 24/7 for about eight months now.

    The box makes less noise than my iMac, and it works well as a webserver, mailserver, printserver , and fileserver. It doesn't have the brushed aluminum look of the hush PC or the newer MB/CPU, but it's equally quiet and cost about $200 less.

  92. More info on building silent PC's... by Code-Ex · · Score: 2, Informative
  93. Re:Apple had some of the first truly 'silent' desk by aedan · · Score: 2, Informative

    The original iMacs had fans (my mum has one), it was a year or so later when the fan less ones came out (my auntie has one).

    aedan

  94. What about an Avocent Cstation? by amunter · · Score: 2

    I saw these things at the last FOSE expo in DC and was impressed. You stick a card in a PCI slot and then use Cat-5 to connect that card with their silent box which holds a PCI video card, USB, PS2, and line/mic in/out. You can then stick the box something like 100 meters away from where you are actually using it. Probably not for gamers since no AGP video, but good enough for a living room computer terminal and noiseless.

    We are thinking of using em for some tight or dirty spots where it is inconvenient to stick a computer box and where it would be inconvenient to have someone hit the reset button (computers that control scientific equipment in a big hall).

    Link at http://www.avocent.com/ddd

  95. If you want high performance check these guys out. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    If you want quiet, and still want a top performing machine check out Muffled Computing's products. http://www.muffledcomputing.com I got a couple of there mufflers and now my system is quiet and overclocked.

  96. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by Entropy_ah · · Score: 1

    an almost-audible noise
    Yeah, I hear that in a lot of Pink Floyd songs

    --
    my other penis is a vagina
  97. Shuttle XPC by Hans+Lehmann · · Score: 1

    I've been using a Shuttle XPC System for several months now. They're the ones using heat pipes to conduct heat from the CPU to a radiator and fan mounted on the rear of the chassis. The larger fan, with speed control, is much quieter then normal CPU fans. It's quiet enough that I'm now looking at acoustic noise specs when selecting a new hard drive, something I ignored in the past. They're pretty spiffy looking boxes too, though I had to take a Sharpie to the blinding blue power LED on the front so that it wouldn't scare the neighbors.

    --
    09 F9 11 02 9D 74 E3 5B D8 41 56 C5 63 56 88 C0
  98. Same configuration by Dr.+Evil · · Score: 1

    I'm using the same configuration but with a travelstar notebook HDD. It's very quiet but not silent.

    I was doing a network boot for a while, but I got sick of fighting for hours to get clear fonts and multiple streams of audio to work under Linux. That ended my latest attempt to use Debian on the desktop. Besides, I can serve X to XFree86 on Cygwin without any trouble.

    I'm going to try to find a bendy or very short PCI riser to get a DVD card in the PCI slot of my machine... that will solve my video issues.

  99. Gee, Apple had nearly-silent iMacs three years ago by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Check out everymac.com's iMac specs. The G3 iMacs (AKA "slot-loading") running at 350 MHz and faster had no fans. The only sounds they ever make are from the hard drive and the optical drive. And they started at $800 for a complete system (including monitor). I love my nearly-silent iMac...

  100. These are cool by bigjames · · Score: 1

    We have one sat in our office... it's amazing. Really, really quite. Can't give any opinions on performance, but it's beautiful and nearly silent.

  101. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by Gossy · · Score: 1

    I appreciate that for most people "damn quiet" is good enough. Heck, even for me it is. But "completely silent" is an absolute, and it should be used that way.

    I agree. I've seen reviews of heatsink/fan combos that are rated in the 40db(A) range sold as 'silent'.

    Well damn, that is nothing like silent.

    I've spent a lot of money on various fans, replacement heatsinks, fan controllers (A DigiDoc5 and Zalman ZM-MFC1), and some acoustic dampening material from Quiet PC. This gives me a quiet, powerful machine for regular use, and I can crank up the fans if I want to play some games. It's not quite silent - but it certainly is very, very quiet. I can't hear a thing at the moment, although I have the window open so I can hear the noise of the birds singing outside. I do only live in a village though, so it's not like the background noise is akin to being next door to a motorway..

    Back to my point though - if something says 'silent' it should emit no noise at all. I shouldn't be able to hear a thing if I leave the PC on overnight for it to be silent in my mind.

    I think the only way to achieve this is through using very large heatsinks and heatpipes to get the heat outside of the box. Then, the naturally cool air in the room (cool in comparison to the high temps inside the case) should be enough to keep everything cool enough.

    Getting into quiet/silent computing can be dangerous though - you really notice the difference when you go back to noisy computers! If you use someone elses PC for example, or you're at a library/school and have to use the computer, it sounds incredibly loud and offputting.

  102. Re:Apple had some of the first truly 'silent' desk by Dylan+Zimmerman · · Score: 4, Interesting

    And that is exactly why Apple should re-release the G4 cube. If they keep the specs where they were when they canceled it with the possible exception of adding Bluetooth and other more modern options, they would have a pretty good media hub that doesn't cost too much and runs with no fans.

    As long as they only use lower end G4s or the PPC 970 clocked pretty low, they should be able to get away with convection. As long as they don't use too many newer parts, the price should be low enough to rival iMac sales.

  103. What about RISC? by leandrod · · Score: 1

    I would love to get a silent PC... only that I don't want to validate the x86 architecture, but a saner, RISC one.

    Is there any option short of buying an used Apple Cube?

    --
    Leandro Guimarães Faria Corcete DUTRA
    DA, DBA, SysAdmin, Data Modeller
    GNU Project, Debian GNU/Lin
    1. Re:What about RISC? by Sebastopol · · Score: 1


      Is there any option short of buying an used Apple Cube?


      Yeah, give up your pointless rebel attitude and buy a low GHz celeron machine, I don't have a fan on my CPU (1GHz) and it's fine for Maya, Sonar, WC3, Q3, RTCW, etc...

      --
      https://www.accountkiller.com/removal-requested
    2. Re:What about RISC? by leandrod · · Score: 1
      > your pointless rebel attitude

      Why pointless? Do you realise how much is wasted in expensive fabs, chip real state, and consequently energy, not to mention technological progress itself, plus so much noise, because there is a herd mentality that, coupled with binary-only software, keeps the inefficient x86 architecture around?

      Intel is no better than MS. They have been doing all they can to kill competitors, from suing AMD to buying the Alpha only to kill it.

      I will end up buying an used Apple Cube, or assembling my own AmigaOne or ARM machine.

      --
      Leandro Guimarães Faria Corcete DUTRA
      DA, DBA, SysAdmin, Data Modeller
      GNU Project, Debian GNU/Lin
    3. Re:What about RISC? by Sebastopol · · Score: 1


      You're user ID is way low (17,766), but it sounds like you are new to the argument:

      Apple tried to be the top dog, but they boned it because they got greedier than Intel/M$: they made their arch. proprietary and charged people to use it. So you can't play the "apple is the good, intel is evil" card. Do you think if Apple had 90% of the CPU market they'd be all philanthropic?

      --
      https://www.accountkiller.com/removal-requested
    4. Re:What about RISC? by leandrod · · Score: 1
      > sounds like you are new to the argument

      No I am not. Look for me in Usenet and mailing lists. Just like Churchill, or was it Roosevelt? -- 'Stalin and Hitler are two bastards. We support the weaker one to destroy the stronger, and then finish with the remaining one.' Too bad the bastards got together in the Ribbentrop-Molotov treaty.

      In other words, I would rather an Apple than an Intel because they are more elegant technically as esthetically, so I will use it if I can't find a RISC from a saner company; if they go for AMD, I will try harder to find another RISC such as a second-hand workstation, AmigaOne or ARM; or go with AMD, VIA if RISCs become unavailable. If Apple went with AMD for example, I would have no incentive to buy it over a silent PC with GNU/Linux or without an OS, but would still consider it less evil than a PC with MS WXP preinstalled.

      It is all about continuums of technical and moral factors.

      --
      Leandro Guimarães Faria Corcete DUTRA
      DA, DBA, SysAdmin, Data Modeller
      GNU Project, Debian GNU/Lin
    5. Re:What about RISC? by Sebastopol · · Score: 1


      So its a personal battle. Understood. I just want the fastest machine to render Maya scenes. That's Intel. I personally would not buy an inferior performing Apple just to make a point. That's why I compared it to a rebel attitude in the first post. I think we have different end goals: you want a continuum moral equality in the corporate world, I just want to get stuff done.

      --
      https://www.accountkiller.com/removal-requested
    6. Re:What about RISC? by leandrod · · Score: 1
      > I personally would not buy an inferior performing Apple just to make a point. That's why I compared it to a rebel attitude in the first post. I think we have different end goals: you want a continuum moral equality in the corporate world, I just want to get stuff done.

      Actually I would say that I have a long-range, global perspective while you look only at one aspect a the short term.

      When looking raw performance you look only the mass-market; if you really wanted Performance and had the big bucks, you'd realise Intel doesn't scale; and if you go cluster, than RISC allows better density.

      Which brings me to economical and environmental issues. CISC uses up more resources from manufacturing to disposal, and uses more energy, not only to run but to refrigerate.

      And in the long range, RISC would enable us to get even higher performance, if Intel's monopoly is checked and therefore RISC gets the economies of scale it should.

      --
      Leandro Guimarães Faria Corcete DUTRA
      DA, DBA, SysAdmin, Data Modeller
      GNU Project, Debian GNU/Lin
  104. Horrible Writing by blunte · · Score: 1
    The machine being reviewed looks nice. The review itself is horrible. It's just painful to read.

    Do people really not know how to write anymore? Do people even bother to read over what they wrote, before they present it?

    --
    .sigs are for post^Hers.
    1. Re:Horrible Writing by Gordy_Hand · · Score: 1

      Sorry its called dyslexia , the review was proof read multiple times :)

    2. Re:Horrible Writing by blunte · · Score: 1
      Don't take this as a personal attack, but here are some examples of why I think this writing is really not good.

      People who know me know will know I'm a case person, that I'm a sucker for a nice looking aluminium case and with the Hush I'm blown away.

      Obviously there are some extra words in the first clause. I'm sure that's just a mistake of having changed wording, accidentally leaving in some extra words. But beyond that, the structure of the sentence is confusing. At the least, it is a run-on sentence. The last clause, "with the Hush..." should follow a comma, or better yet, become its own sentence.

      At the front it's very clean looking, nothing destroys the clean lines unless it's essential to the function.

      Here you have another run-on. I think what you mean is "--" instead of ",". It's minor, but it's wrong, and it causes the reader to stumble (and try to guess your intention.)

      They require a special tool to loosen them but that said, it's very easy to loosen them and Hush provides the correct tool with retail versions of the system for those needing/wanting to tinker or just look at the insides of the system.

      Run-on upon run-on. Most of the text here should be broken down into simpler sentences. Go back to basics. There is plenty of room between the simplicity of "See Jack run.", and the clause-olympics you are attempting. Writing sentences as complicated as you're trying requires careful attention to rules of grammar. Above that, it requires care to make sure the reader gets the point the way you intend.

      But, this is /., so I'm just being too picky :) Don't stop writing, just go for simplicity, elegance, and brevity.

      --
      .sigs are for post^Hers.
  105. Re:Boot from USB Ramdisk? (Or convert?) by Marqis · · Score: 1

    The MSI NForce2 motherboard also supports USB booting.

  106. Why they put S-Video, SPDIF out on the Epia... by fendel · · Score: 1

    ...is beyond me. I had one of these (C3 "800"mhz, earlier system without native MPEG2 decoding, which I don't care about anyway because I can burn MPEG2 to SVCD and stick it in my DVD player...).

    It was miserable at DivX decoding. Anything beyond a 20-minute pretty-low-bitrate TV cap was unplayable. I couldn't watch a DivX movie on it to save my life. Was it a quiet box? Sure: I had it turned off most of the time.

  107. Sun Ray as a desktop PC by ivlad · · Score: 0
    Sun Ray from (guess it) is quite silent. :) No moving parts at all!

    It is however might be too expensive for normal home user (but Scott McNealy says he uses it at home :) ). For office they are great!

  108. Do it yourself silent PC by 4ginandtonics · · Score: 1
    The Screen Savers on TechTV had a show on do-it-yourself quiet machines. The online article is available at Yoshi's Mods: Project YS-2


    Yoshi's box featured quiet electronics, sound proofing, and testing in Dolby Labs quiet room. His homebrew quiet computer registered 8 to 14dB. Humans start hearing things at 10dB! For reference, a typical PC creates 38dB.

    Check out the link fro some practical ideas on how to make your PC quiet.

  109. G4 Cube.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Sorry to burst your bubble PC fans, but the G4 cube is as quiet as this thing claims to be. Its got fanless operation and a super quiet hard drive. If you want the ultimate silent computer, grab that, a processor upgrade and a few sticks of ram. Oh, and I think we all know it crushes this piece in the looks department as well.

  110. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


    COMPLETELY silent, by definition means NO FANS.
    Just because you can't hear it over your power-sucking air conditioning does not mean its silent.

  111. Re:Apple had some of the first truly 'silent' desk by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Remember the Apple II? When the floppy drives weren't running (if you were lucky and rich enough to have floppy drives), I don't believe there was a single moving part on the machine. Can't get much quieter than that.

  112. It's because we're big dumb americans by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    We really have to start thinking more like the Japanese. They are using our PC standard only because it's been forced down their and everyone else's throats. Sony, for example, wants nothing more than to discard horribly inefficient form factors and are constantly challenging how we define a PC.

    Anyways, one of the side effects of us Americans always thinking big is that we end up with big ass power supplies and fans. If the Japanese designed the PC, it would be very silent, very manageable, tiny, and just work.

  113. Can anyone ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Imagine the sound of a beowulf clus.... ok, nevermind

  114. Re:Boot from USB Ramdisk? (Or convert?) by fferreres · · Score: 1

    A IBM microdrive (compactflash) should be quiet enough. Granted, it has moving parts, but who cares? With 2 GB you can do a lot of things.

    --
    unfinished: (adj.)
  115. Or, there's OpenBrick - by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Tiny, well-designed, fanless little box - NatSemi GEODE chipset. PCMCIA, CF, USB, serial, parallel, TV-OUT, sound. I run the pebble distribution of linux (along with a stripped down X) on a 126M CF card, mounted readonly/noatime - it's monitoring the house's energy use. I guess it's about equivalent to a Pentium II, but I'm not playing games on it.

    It was under $400, I think.

  116. I get it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Ok, so let's spend a few hundred $ extra for a dead-quiet PC while noises made by air conditioning/heating, fridge, creaking house, etc. are frequently much louder.

  117. Why does this seem unreasonable? by jafo · · Score: 1

    I don't get it... I have an HP inkjet printer which has sat in the garage for over 2 years, and I'd be suprised if it would perform well on the cartridges in it. It seems totally reasonable to enforce the expiration date, because otherwise you have people bitching about the quality of the prints, or that their cartridges just don't work.

    Printers are hardly the only place that this happens. Take, for example, the O2 sensor in your car. Most cars these days have the computer turn on the "sensor" or "check engine" light after the O2 sensor is around 50k to 60k miles old... Even if it's still working.

    This has been going on for well over a decade -- my '87 VW and '86 Nissans both worked like this -- strictly on mileage.

    At some point it's just reasonable to say "You need to replace this".

    If you aren't going to use a full printer cartridge after 2.5 years, you really need to evaluate wether a printer that uses a perishable ink is a good deal. This happens with all perishable things... If you buy a gross of condoms to save 30%, you'd better make sure that you aren't going to lose half of them due to "spoilage".

    I don't think a reasonable person would find this opressive.

    "We're going to switch to Lexmark printers because of this. It sounds like they have the same problem, though."

    Ahh, it all becomes clear. This article was inspired by unreasonable people. ;-)

    Sean

  118. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "No, the Dell Precision workstations are not "completely silent." They may be stunningly quiet; I don't know, I've never heard one."

    Ok, the Dell Precision is NOT completely silent. There you have it folks, you heard it here first, from someone who, well I don't know, has never heard one? Thanks.

  119. NISVARA utterly silent computer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    I seriously prefer the NISVARA utterly silent computer:
    http://www.nisvara.com/
    My name is Jonathan Vos Post, I've posted here before (but I'm not on my home computer and can't remember my nick and pswd). I'm not part of that company, but I've seen it and interrogated the CTO. I think the NISVARA ought to be test-driven before anyone buys the newer competitors. Or maybe someone at Slashdot can do a comprarison benchmark?

  120. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You took that pretty hard.

    Dell employee?

  121. Want CPU power at low wattage? Get creative folks by default+luser · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Remember this little thing called the Tualatin? The 800MHz version topped out at 12w, and could run circles around even a 1GHz C3, not to mention the sickly EPIA.

    Go and buy a Tualatin Celeron ( they're up in the 1.3 or 1.4 GHz range, be sure you get one with 133MHz bus ) and clock it down to 66MHz bus. You'll stil have a machine capable of decoding DVD in software ( a Celeron 400 could do this without breaking a sweat ), and it can be fanless.

    What is the world coming to that some company can pass off a crappy CPU with no OOOE and a half-speed FPU as "efficient"? Christ, if you pumped up the speed of the C3 such that the power it used was the same as a Pentium IV, it would still get it's ass handed to it performancewise.

    IT IS JUST A WINCHIP FOLKS. Don't be fooled by the smoke and mirrors.

    --

    Man is the animal that laughs.
    And occasionally whores for Karma.

  122. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by jovlinger · · Score: 1

    I can't decide whether I'm just being pedantic, or disagreable, but:

    silence is not an absolute. Unless you are in a vacuum. At some level, random vibrations -- hell, even thermal noise -- can be thought of as sound.(*) The point is that you don't need a moving part to generate sound.

    Silence can be defined as a relative mesurement, tho. You define a threshold floor, and everything below it is silent. In a typical room -- say my kitchen, when the damn fridge compressor isn't making a racket -- you're looking at 26 dB ish.

    There are CPU fans out there that are rated at 27 dB. Add a case, and that fan is silent, relative to the background noise of my kitchen. In summary: a noise is silent relative to the enviroment if it can't be detected (huge hole in reasoning, here: detected by what?) in that environment.

    (*) there was also the case of the video card or system bus that made a sound while a window was being dragged. The conclusion was that there either was a loose wire that was deforming under induction, or else the random ions in the air itself were being affected by the bits flying down the bus.

  123. Nitpick by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...and solid state powersupply.

    All PC power supplies are solid state, as have virtually all consumer-electronics power supplies been for the last 30+ years. Solid-state just means that a piece of equipment doesn't use vacuum tubes.

    I think what you mean is "moving-part-free" or more specifically "fanless."

  124. disk activity by chocolatetrumpet · · Score: 1

    You have to put your head next to the case to hear it purring softly while doing an updatedb (heavy disk activity) for example.

    I'm afraid it's not disk access noise us sound-types are bothered by, but rather the din of the whirring disk.

    --
    Spoon not. Fork, or fork not. There is no spoon.
    1. Re:disk activity by CvD · · Score: 1

      Well, that you don't hear at all... you only hear the disk when its actually accessing. So I think you'd like it.

      Cheers!

  125. Re:Apple had some of the first truly 'silent' desk by stickyc · · Score: 1

    So before I go and scope one of these out on E-Bay - will the off-the-shelf unit (with the Rage 128) play back most video formats in full screen (TV res - not 1024x768) at a watchable framerate? How's one get video and 5.1 out?

  126. Re:Want CPU power at low wattage? Get creative fol by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    There's more to the epia-systems than the low-power CPU. Most notable is the ITX form factor.

  127. CF cards! by SectoidRandom · · Score: 1

    HD noise is always going to be a bit of a problem, my solution that I plan to use on my setup box is a CF Card IDE reader, with a 1GB CF card!

    No moving parts no noise, a little low on capacity but more than enough to hold the OS and the important things.. Most of the data will stream from my pc/server!

    Only draw back is speed, they aren't the fastest things, apparantly newer readers / cards will do 5MB/sec though which sounds good enough.. A gig of ram could be easily installed to compensate for that.

  128. Re:Hard Disk Noise and EPIA by Alan+Cox · · Score: 1

    EPIA and EPIA-M support network booting so you can run them entirely diskless. For a thin client the base fanless EPIA is fine and you might also want to buy a not so cute case (eg the cubid) and not connect the rear fan.

    Another silent setup is the lex lite which uses CF or laptop disks and is a good deal smaller than the Hush (but not fanless for 933Mhz)

  129. Re:As far as silent systems go, you can't beat Del by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Nope. I just find it amusing that someone is clearly stating the facts about a product they have never used.

  130. Solid State Power Supply ? No Shit ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    When this becomes available to the anonymous cowards of the world, I'll be able to stop importing those Russian vacuum tubes to keep my Tbred running.........

  131. Linux compatibility issues by 200_success · · Score: 1

    As the review says, the VIA mini-ITX motherboard crams in lots of built-in devices, like Ethernet, IEEE 1394, audio, MPEG2 decoder, and NTSC/PAL output. If you want to run Linux on it, you might want to check out the device driver issues on the VIA Arena Forum on the subject.

    It is nice, however, that Hush Technologies sells Microsoft Windows as a separate line item.

  132. Re:Want CPU power at low wattage? Get creative fol by default+luser · · Score: 1

    "There's more to the epia-systems than the low-power CPU. Most notable is the ITX form factor"

    So?

    ITX is amall, but its only a few centimeters to a side smaller than MicroATX. Hardly enough to get upset over, either one could fit into a low-profile hifi style case.

    Face it, VIA is simply forced to create a non-existent market for their processors, because they stupidly bought the two worst processors on the market, and even had to shelve the Cyrix line due to performance scaling issues.

    Their earliest MicroATX boards were Socket 370, and purposefully didn't have Tualatin support at a time when Tualiatins were still popular, all so they could get some press on the otherwise unimpressive Ezra core C3.

    Their biggest sellers today? Pentium 4 MicroATX boards, which cannot possibly accept their crappy C3.

    So now, once again, VIA is out to sell us the very same chipset as the older MicroATX DDR266 Socket 370 boards with the same crappy chip, only in a smaller format with no upgradability. Gotta sell those underclocked Winchips...errr, I mean, EPIAs.

    Once again, VIA is trying to convince us that we all need to replace our DVD players with Media PCs that can't quite play DVDs, that we all need to replace our Tivos with Media PCs that can't quite do real-time TV encoding.

    Convergence is the wave of the future. RIGHT NOW, it doesn't work without giving something up. I'll keep my DVD deck, thank you.

    --

    Man is the animal that laughs.
    And occasionally whores for Karma.

  133. Nearly silent PC ... NOT by ratfynk · · Score: 1

    Silent PC? WTF for? The usual computer gamester, mp3 boosted mega bass moron couldn't hear a 5db drop anyway. Anybody that doesn't disable windows or even kde sound events deserves to have a rattle hiss and hum box PC, and wouldn't hear harmonic distortion diffs from a PC sound card anyway. So whats all this about a silent PC. Who cares. If sound and design quaility were a real issue to PC hardware manufactures, then the PC would not be the P iece of C rap that we all love to hate!

    --
    OH THE SHAME I fell off the wagon and use sigs again!
  134. Re:Hard Disk Noise STFU comie fuck by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    you know nothing you marxist cowtowing bitch. i want to fuck your ass with a hot curlin iron and cook you in boiling oil fuckerhead.