Slashdot Mirror


iRiver to Build In-Dash Digital HD Players

An anonymous reader writes "It looks like iRiver is going to take over where the Rio Car left off. Their CEO announced today that they are near completion on a new plant in China that will produce HD-based in-dash digital music players for automobiles. The new plant can push out 700K units a month. With the iPod dominating the digital portable market, iRiver sees this as a wide-open area they can move into. According to MacWorld iRiver is the third leading seller of MP3 portables with 5.6% of the market, following the number two seller Rio which holds 6.4% of the market. And the Apple iPod? No surprise, only a whopping 65.8% of all units shipped. 92% if you only count HD portables."

216 comments

  1. Misleading marketshare numbers by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

    These numbers cover only US and are based on August sales. Since the new Ipod was recently launched, it isn't suprised that it sold well in the August.

    Apple's global marketshare in the digital audio player market is about 20%.

    1. Re:Misleading marketshare numbers by HoneyBunchesOfGoats · · Score: 4, Insightful

      You're quick to knock Apple's statistics, but where do yours come from?

    2. Re:Misleading marketshare numbers by CmdrPuto · · Score: 1, Informative

      Agree.

      And this korean based mp3 player is really good too.

    3. Re:Misleading marketshare numbers by erick99 · · Score: 3, Interesting
      Here is an interesting market share tidbit from an article OSViews.com:

      Piper Jaffray analyst Gene Munster said today that based on a survey of 600 teenagers, Apple's iPod is dominating "mindshare and market share." Munster said in a research note that of all the high school students surveyed, 16 percent currently own an iPod and 24 percent plan to buy an iPod within the next year. Munster also noted that the iPod ranked fourth on the teens' holiday wish list--behind clothes, money, and a car--even though the iPod was not an answer option and had to be written in as a response.

      --
      http://www.busyweather.com/
    4. Re:Misleading marketshare numbers by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      Google cache of a Yahoo story.

      "The company said it held a 10 percent share of the global market for MP3 players in the June quarter, coming second after Apple's 17 percent share."

    5. Re:Misleading marketshare numbers by drac · · Score: 2, Interesting

      It is my understanding that their marketshare of hard drive based players is much higher than 20%.

      - 40% of tracked retail Mp3 player sales in Europe/ America/ Japan, though figures elsewhere are lower
      - Over 10% of MP3 decoder chips made are used for manufacture of iPods

      Those sales figures are still a bit misleading- they reflect Apple's performance against flash players, which they do not make.

      Even if recent news reports are correct and those figures are high, Apple still remains overwhelmingly dominant among hdd based players.

      I use a PC, but we gotta give credit where credit is due.

    6. Re:Misleading marketshare numbers by nolife · · Score: 1

      Those sales figures are still a bit misleading- they reflect Apple's performance against flash players, which they do not make.

      No, your quotes are misleading.. The figures are based on portable compressed music players which the iPod is one of many.
      Why is the subset of HD based player even need to be considered seperately? I mean, it is a portable music player just like the others. You could break it down further and claim the iPod is has 99.9% of the HD based players that are white. Does that really change anything?
      I guess you could throw out any comparision or statisitic to prove just about anything you'd like though. Imagine how many of those $29-59USD portable mp3 cd players have been sold and are in use. They are a portable compressed (MP3 marketspeak) music players.
      Take out the technical types that understand the technology within the player and the general consumer is left with the basic comparison for players of size, price, battery life, convienence, and space available for songs.

      --
      Bad boys rape our young girls but Violet gives willingly.
    7. Re:Misleading marketshare numbers by drac · · Score: 1

      {Shrug}

      I guess if you insist.

      However, I don't see any point in comparing Corvette sales to Explorer sales, even though both are "cars". They occupy different niches, and serve different purposes.

      Have fun!

  2. open markets by cwebb1977 · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Any market can be regarded as "wide open" if you have products of superior quality. Well, unless you face a big bad wolf-like company or state-owned monopolist that's giving you plenty of headaches and lawsuits.

    --
    www.weberseite.at
    1. Re:open markets by iezhy · · Score: 2, Insightful

      i seriously doubt if new products from rio and other newcomers can be considered superior quality (in terms of audio quality) comparing them to products (usualy cd/mp3 players) produced by experianced car audio system manufacturers (like pioneer, blaupunkt and etc.)

    2. Re:open markets by geighaus · · Score: 1

      Since when are iPods of superior quality? iRiver playes, for one, have more features and most importantly recording capabilities (for how long have Apple been promising to deliver that?)

    3. Re:open markets by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      for how long have Apple been promising to deliver that?

      You're confusing Apple with rumor sites. Apple is very careful not to even comment on products or features that they're not ready to release.

    4. Re:open markets by hackstraw · · Score: 1

      Any market can be regarded as "wide open" if you have products of superior quality.

      OK, then lets define the superior quality thing here and see how wide open the market becomes.

      A HD based player that has 1) Wireless and wired connectivity (don't care, ethernet, usb, firewire) 2) Upgradeable/hackable firmware 3) ogg/wma/flac/ normal formats 4) RCA and optical lines out/in 5) gapless/crossfaded playback 6) random playback by folder/album 7) less than $500.

      1st one that does this gets my money.

      Oh, and the "wide open if you have products of superior quality" is not at all true. There is the price/performance tradeoff. Arguably, Mercedes and Lexus make superior cars to Honda and Ford, but I sure see many more Hondas and Fords when I'm driving around.

    5. Re:open markets by iezhy · · Score: 1

      A HD based player that has 1) Wireless and wired connectivity (don't care, ethernet, usb, firewire) 2) Upgradeable/hackable firmware 3) ogg/wma/flac/ normal formats 4) RCA and optical lines out/in 5) gapless/crossfaded playback 6) random playback by folder/album 7) less than $500.

      what about sound quality? doesn't it matter at all? or are you naive enough to believe that all players reproduce music in same quality?
      believe me, then you connect your player to amplifier and decent car speakers, all that noise can become really anoying, making you regret for those couple of bucks you saved.

    6. Re:open markets by SFBwian · · Score: 1
      The reason Hondas and Fords are running around more is that most people cannot afford a Mercedes or Lexus.

      You're asking for a Mercedes at Chrysler prices, or a Lexus at Toyota prices.

      --
      I'm looking to get rich. I've got steps #2 (????) and #3 (PROFIT!) planned out, but am having trouble coming up with #1.
    7. Re:open markets by mgs1000 · · Score: 1

      Since when does more features == superior quality?

    8. Re:open markets by hackstraw · · Score: 1

      The reason Hondas and Fords are running around more is that most people cannot afford a Mercedes or Lexus.

      Ahh, I thought it was the price/performance thing that I mentioned. I can afford a Mercedes or a Lexus as I would guess that 1/2 of the US population could do as well*, but I drive a 13 year old SUV because it works and its paid for.

      * I would have to seriously adjust other expenses to make this happen as would most people. But I'd rather pay for an appreciating piece of property vs a depreciating transportation machine, as would most others as well.

    9. Re:open markets by Pxtl · · Score: 1

      Funny, I could custom build a PC with all those features for less than $500. I agree that what he's asking is unlikely, but I doubt its for technical reasons.

  3. No wonder... by ayn0r · · Score: 3, Interesting

    No wonder iPod has the lead. iRiver HD players really are great, and they sound better than iPods, but unfortunately they're still a bit pricey in comparison. The only contender atm would be Rio Karma, but for those not feeling like smashing them repeatedly every now and then the Karma isn't really an option... About time someone put an effort into car MP3 playback - I'm surprised it hasn't been done properly earlier.

    1. Re:No wonder... by Animekiksazz · · Score: 2, Interesting

      The iRiver H120 is only $20-30 more than the 20 gig iPod, I'd spend the $20-30 for the extras.

    2. Re:No wonder... by genixia · · Score: 1

      What?

      60 GBytes not enough for you? Gapless playback not good enough? 4V pre-outs useless? 4x5 or 2x10 fully parametric EQ too shabby?

      It was done 'properly' years ago.

    3. Re:No wonder... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      60Gb ? I thought Paul's empegs were up to 200Gb now.

    4. Re:No wonder... by genixia · · Score: 1

      Yeah, they are. His also have Optical, Coax and I2S digital outputs and 48MB of RAM...

    5. Re:No wonder... by afidel · · Score: 1

      I call bullshit on sounds better. The iPod has one of the best preamps out there as has been noted all over including an article several months back here on slashdot. Add to that the fact that the iPod can do 320kbps MP3's or Apple Lossless decoding I think you will have a hard time finding ANYTHING that sounds much better than an iPod with good headphones, let alone another portable.

      --
      There are 4 boxes to use in the defense of liberty: soap, ballot, jury, ammo. Use in that order. Starting now.
    6. Re:No wonder... by kisielk · · Score: 1

      Not more expensive.. I was looking in to this the other day, and a 20GB iPod is $389 CAD (after my edu discount) while the iRiver HP-120 is $439. Yes it's $50 more, BUT I get the remote and carrying case with the device, accessories that cost $45 each at the Apple store. So in fact the iRiver comes out a bit cheaper after the accessories, and even cheaper if you don't have an edu discount.

    7. Re:No wonder... by ayn0r · · Score: 0

      I'm not saying the iPod sounds bad. I own a 4G iPod myself and I'm very happy with it. Compared to an iRiver HD120 though, the HD120 came out as winner for me.
      So why am I owning an iPod? Well, for the reasons I stated above. The iPod is a very impressive unit indeed.

    8. Re:No wonder... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You're shopping at the wrong store if you're paying that much. Newegg.com has the iHP-120 for $299.00, And that's $86 more than I paid for mine a month ago when I got my iRiver at Best Buy on clearance for $214. Shop around. I defy you to find an iPod for that little.

    9. Re:No wonder... by kisielk · · Score: 1

      I did mention it's CAD (Candian dollars).

    10. Re:No wonder... by rainman_bc · · Score: 1

      . About time someone put an effort into car MP3 playback

      MP3 CD Players for cars have been on the market for over two or three years now - I jumped on it early with the Aiwa, and when it got stolen I got a KDC-MP8017 from Kenwood.

      Hard drive players have been around just as long, but they were much pricier, and loading MP3's involved taking the "deck" out and plugging it into your peecee.

      I'd love a hard drive player, but I have Jeep, and I actually go 4x4ing with it, and the shock would ruin the hard drive...

      My favourite would be a mp3-cd player that takes dvd-r disks. That's coming from what I've heard.

      --
      09 F9 11 02 9D 74 E3 5B D8 41 56 C5 63 56 88 C0
    11. Re:No wonder... by rts008 · · Score: 1

      Yeah, I bet auto insurance companies would go apeshit about Rio Karma's in cars, all that running into bridges & buildings, etc. to un-stick the harddrive! They would be great tho' if you wanted tunes while you wrer in a demolition derby!

      --
      Down With Slashdot BETA!!! I've been around the corner and seen the oliphant; you can only abuse me from your perspecti
    12. Re:No wonder... by aonaran · · Score: 1

      I really like iRiver, but I wish they'd support audible.com audio books.

      I need something that can support both OGG and Audible, and so far the only one I've seen that does both is Samsung's YH-920.

  4. In-Dash? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    How do you sync up? By taking the drive out of your dash and plugging it into the computer? Wouldn't it be much more valuable if it was an actual portable that you could buy a dash docking station for? Sure, it might cost $10 more to build, but the value to most people would shoot up.

    1. Re:In-Dash? by HoneyBunchesOfGoats · · Score: 1

      Maybe it will have some kind of "insert cd, rip tracks / files". Or maybe wifi? Hopefully you don't have to take a laptop out to it.

    2. Re:In-Dash? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why does stuff have to be built into the car? I'd prefer having a jack on the car to plug in the music source I want... Of course, this won't be popular with the sellers since they'll have less to mark up.

      Better one good device than many mediocre ones...

    3. Re:In-Dash? by Soul-Burn666 · · Score: 5, Informative

      From TFA: "One that pulls from the dash when you want to load a significant volume of songs and takes flash media when the user only wishes to transfer a few tunes."

      --
      ^_^
    4. Re:In-Dash? by blowdart · · Score: 3, Funny
      Oh please let it be wifi.

      Can't you just imagine it....

      some idiot set of spotty 17 year olds parked on the corner of your street in their Civic, complete with spoilers which are half the size of the car, blacked out windows, neon lights flashing under the body and the rear seats replaced with bass speakers.

      Up goes Netstumbler, or whatever and lo there's a connection there, "riceboy". You connect with the well documented passwords and there's the hard drive, full of ghetto rap.

      Hmm, so if I drag and drop this Vanilla Ice track and delete their "music" ....


      (In all seriousness removable drive in a USB2 cradle would be a nice way to provide for these devices, and you could take it out at night for security if necessary)

    5. Re:In-Dash? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      OMG, I would pay for the opportunity to erase entire hard drives of rap . . . what a sweet, sweet fantasy!

    6. Re:In-Dash? by damiam · · Score: 2, Interesting

      It'd be sweet if it had Wi-Fi - you'd just have to drive into your driveway and it'd automatically sync. Doesn't look like that's the case though.

      --
      It's hard to be religious when certain people are never incinerated by bolts of lightning.
    7. Re:In-Dash? by Technician · · Score: 2, Insightful

      From TFA: "One that pulls from the dash when you want to load a significant volume of songs and takes flash media when the user only wishes to transfer a few tunes."


      I hope someday they will get WiFi. That would be ideal. Park the car, open a port with a password, surf to it with either a laptop or home network, start transfer... I'd also prefer it to be trunk mount so the in-dash DVD/NAV doesn't have to come out.

      --
      The truth shall set you free!
    8. Re:In-Dash? by lunax · · Score: 1

      How about something like this http://www.carplayer.com/

    9. Re:In-Dash? by mustangsal66 · · Score: 1

      I like the trunk mount. I have a NEO Jukebox MP3 player that I love.

      I'd love to have wifi though...pull in the driveway and have musical updates pushed to the car. http://www.ssiamerica.com/

      --
      Why worry? Each of us is wearing an unlicensed "nucular" accelerator on his back.
      Sig changed for readability by G.W.
  5. What about patents and stuff... by jkrise · · Score: 0

    How does the US system of patents apply to a product manufactured in China and marketed in the US? iRiver could be violating a lot of patents in the US, I guess...

    --
    If you keep throwing chairs, one day you'll break windows....
    1. Re:What about patents and stuff... by erick99 · · Score: 5, Informative

      US patents apply to any product sold in the US regardless of origin. This was covered in-depth in a recent topic regarding patents. If you do a search it should come up and you can find the relevant law/code.

      --
      http://www.busyweather.com/
    2. Re:What about patents and stuff... by Gentlewhisper · · Score: 1

      Erm... what patents does it violate?

  6. worthy... by cakefool · · Score: 1

    If this retails at less than £250, I'll get one - I've been putting off buying a CD multichanger due to space - in dash HD - fantastic!

    1. Re:worthy... by fbrain · · Score: 1

      Sony make a 10 disc autochanger that will handle MP3 cds, you can get it for £180ish if you shop around.

      --
      Avontech | Play dirty! They started it!
  7. Rio Car was amazing in its day.. by smashr · · Score: 1

    I've been using an Empeg (rio car) for about a year now, and they truely are incredible machines considering they were produced 5 years ago. Not many people cruise around with two 12gb drives and a 220mhz strongARM linux box in their cars :-).

    I mean can YOU telnet into your stereo system? Seriously though, I look forward to see what new things they come out with as it is sorta hard to explain to passengers that no, they can't buy one of these anymore.

    1. Re:Rio Car was amazing in its day.. by ayn0r · · Score: 1, Funny
      Not many people cruise around with two 12gb drives and a 220mhz strongARM linux box in their cars :-)

      No, most of us are afraid of being pulled over by SCO's highway patrols. :/

    2. Re:Rio Car was amazing in its day.. by Alan+Cox · · Score: 1

      True but you can buy mini-itx PC cases in card stereo form factor now and roll your own with added support for video, gps ....

    3. Re:Rio Car was amazing in its day.. by Cushman · · Score: 1

      True, but mini-itx PCs in car stereo form are not designed with audio in mind. The Empeg was designed for high-quality audio output, as well as being built on an open platform. This is why there is a 3rd party GPS application available for the Empeg. No video yet, though.

    4. Re:Rio Car was amazing in its day.. by genixia · · Score: 1

      Yeah, but there's lots of niceties that the PC solution doesn't immediately address including;

      4V line outs for better SQ.
      Fully parametric EQ for better SQ.
      Credit card remote so your passengers can search for music.
      Incredible player software with a UI designed for car use.
      Well integrated into the car's power scheme. Constant 12V, switched 12V and illumination sense are all handled intelligently, out of the box.
      Cool visuals.

      And yes, we've hacked in GPS too. Admittedly, with a 32x128 2-bit color screen and the fact that there's no existing decent GPS mapping software for the ARM, it's somewhat limited, but it's there.

      I'm toying with the idea of hacking a MediaMVP to use a serial touch screen and act as an ethernet thin client remote for the empeg. Nothing more than an idea at the moment though...

    5. Re:Rio Car was amazing in its day.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The Empeg is not the sum of its hardware parts. The software running on the Empeg is by far the most valuable part of it. The guys who designed and built the Empeg really put a lot of effort and thought into designing what is STILL the ultimate in-car MP3 player years after it was EOL. You're a really smart guy, so I'm surprised to see you suggesting that you can just cobble together a bunch of parts and replace a product that had years of development and refinement. It's like saying you can easily replace your Mac if you just buy a PowerPC and a case.

    6. Re:Rio Car was amazing in its day.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Cheap and effective car audio system -

      1. Old ass motherboard
      2. Cheap 12v invertor
      3. Soundblaster Live! 5.1
      4. Cheap ass 40gb HD
      5. Front end - old ass Palm V

      I'm putting the finishing touches on my system - that would be running linux if not for a lack of 5.1 capable drivers in ALSA.

      The Palm V uses "PalmAMP" to control the device, the motherboard is mounted in a subdivision of the subwoofer box, and thanks to the built in DSP, the Soundblaster Live! saves me the hassle of a crossover, equalizier - shit I can even do timebased corrections on the sound and other tricks that cost thousands of dollars in traditional DSPs.

      All I'm missing is the 802.11 pci card for the box, so I can wirelessly sync.

      The cost? Well, if you don't count the sound system behind it - subwoofer, amplifiers and speakers - quite cheap.

      I used all used parts, with the exception of the SB Live! - which was a purchased as an OEM white box item for $40. If you tried to buy the stuff, you could get an AT Pentium motherboard for about $10 - a Pentium 233MMX for about $10 (underclocked to 166, to save heat and electricity) - generic graphics card (I used a Matrox G200 - being recycled at work) and a generic network card (I used a 3com 905b - and recycled - the firm was going to G450's and 905c). The hard drive was a little money, and you have to be creative on how to mount the hard drive (I used a hard drive shipping box, with holes cut out for the wires and a vent - use a 5400rpm drive to minimize heat).

      The only real trick is squeezing a large library on a 40gb drive. I have about 90gb of MP3's - and most are in a transparent format - 256k or so, or Lame'd --r3mix (I started my collection in 1998), so I've been transcoding to vorbis q0 - I could drive around the world and not hear the same song twice. Add on mobile internet from T-Mobile - 56k on the road - and you can get very good talk radio and somewhat crappy streaming music

    7. Re:Rio Car was amazing in its day.. by SuperQ · · Score: 1

      that's a bunch of bullshit, mini-itx has no where near the hardware funcationality to handle mobile setups.

      The empeg has special kernel hooks, and power controls to handle dips in car power. Car voltages fluctuate wildly while starting. The empeg also stores state in a small flash area which is controled by a kernel module to make sure the thing can start where it left off on next boot.

      I'd like to see you stuff a mini-itx board, power supply, laptop drive, shock mounting, and display in a single din dashboard. Put your money where your mouth is, write the software, show us the hardware setup, and then we can talk about "oh yea, anyone can do that"

    8. Re:Rio Car was amazing in its day.. by SuperQ · · Score: 1

      none of that stuff fits in a single din, nor will a desktop hard drive work for very long in a car setup.

      Also, the SB live does not support hi-voltage preouts, or proper floating ground. car audio setups require 4v preamped lines to amplifiers, and proper grounding otherwise you're going to hear nothing but electrical noise from the engine.

    9. Re:Rio Car was amazing in its day.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I still love my empeg, and people think that I am paranoid for never leaving it in my car. Even though I have a car alarm, and it is protected by people with M16s at the gate...

    10. Re:Rio Car was amazing in its day.. by draziw · · Score: 1

      mini-itx is a form factor, not a full config. Power can be configed with a good inverter that will work just fine. Can config to run suspend state to nvram, usb keychain, flash or whatever too.

      The point isn't just the size of a product sold vs what you can build - it's that it is buildable, which is much of the point of linux, you can do what you want with the config.

  8. Cool, but by PDA_Boy · · Score: 2, Funny

    which will crash first- the player, or the car?

    1. Re:Cool, but by erick99 · · Score: 2, Funny

      If the car crashes and won't start up, try slamming the car down firmly onto a flat surface and the car should start up. Each time that the car crashes and won't start up and you slam it down on a flat surface it will go longer before crashing again.

      --
      http://www.busyweather.com/
  9. iriver mini? by geeber · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Anybody know if iriver plans a competitor to the ipod mini? I have an iriver flash player that I absolutely love, but I am jonesing for 4 Gb of storage. Their little 1 Gb circular player was a little too soon and too small in capacity. However, I don't want to give up my FM radio and I don't want one of the bigger 20 Gb players. So I keep waiting...

  10. the problem is by seanadams.com · · Score: 1, Insightful

    few people are willing to have the stereo shop monkey around behind their dash to wire in an aftermarket stereo. Especially one that costs $500+ as I'm sure these HD players will. Also they're unlikely to have good built-in amps so probably you'll have to put on of those in too...

    Unless you have an older car, it's generally a bad idea. Nearly all the decks you can buy are of vastly inferior mechnical build quality to your factory deck anyway. The guys at Empeg made a great product but it's just too niche... I don't think this is going to take off until someone partners with the auto makers to get it built in at the factory.

    1. Re:the problem is by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      That really depends on the shop. In my area we have several shops that only do after-market audio, security, remote startup, etc. installs and their work is a thing of beauty. On the other hand, I probably wouldn't let me dealer do it.

    2. Re:the problem is by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I would like to see them build a unit that can be driven by the CD changer controls present on most vehicles today. Offer an MP3 HD unit and adapters to convert the OEM changer controls to rational HD player controls. The HD unit could contain its own text display to accomodate OEM units that do not provide this. You run one cable for the changer controls and one cable for the text display, and the unit can be mounted anywhere. The text display could contain a CF/SD slot for small transfers.

    3. Re:the problem is by Inda · · Score: 5, Insightful

      That's nonsense.

      Wiring up a car stereo is easy. It's no different than pluging in the speakers of a house stereo. Removing the trim to hide wires is the hardest part but even 'shop monkeys' can do this easily enough.

      Are you also saying that my Alpine is worse than the piece of crap that came with my Honda? I don't think so.

      --
      This post contains benzene, nitrosamines, formaldehyde and hydrogen cyanide.
    4. Re:the problem is by seanadams.com · · Score: 1

      Sure, if all you're doing is swapping the deck AND they happen to have the right factory wiring harness adaptor for your car, then yes it's easy. Not as easy as hooking up a home stereo, but easy.

      Still, most people leave their factory decks in, except in older cards. Why do you think that is? Is it possible that I have a point?

    5. Re:the problem is by Lumpy · · Score: 1

      really??

      I wonder what billionares are funding all the car audio shops in the country that are doing record business in the past 5 years.

      Also, you either know absolutely nothing about car audio or are making your decisions on the junk you see at best buy, but my Kenwood aftermarket stereo kicks the living crap out of anything that comes stock in any car in quality and capabilities. and it cost LESS than the regular CD option from the factory. I have a tuner that will pull in FM and AM stations clearly where other's can not.

      Sorry but you really do not know what you are talking about. Aftermarket Car electronics is a huge business that is still growing fast.

      The only problems you might run into gettin an aftermarket stereo is steering wheel controls and speed sensor for automatic volume control will not work without an adapter box.

      --
      Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
    6. Re:the problem is by BLKMGK · · Score: 1

      LOL, there's an industry revolving around this. They make adapter harness day and night. If they don't happen to have one for the oddball POS you drive then you simply wire it yourself. How hard exactly is it to run power, ground, switched ground, and lighting inputs to a headunit? Speakers are no big deal either and if you're running amps you can run fiber or RCA shielded cables. This is so simple we have the likes of BestBuy and Circuit City selling and installing stereos. Believe me their installers are FAR from the best and yet they manage to do this no problem.

      The hardest part these days is installing the physical unit since the auto manufacturers have begun trying to make this more difficult. When they integrate silly things like heating and cooling into the stereo it further complicates things - stupidly. Folks who care about such issues generally shy away from vehicles that have this crap and the aftermarket fights this too via SEMA or their own industry lobbying effort.

      Is it possible you simply don't have a clue what you're talking about?

      Hell in my area you can actually buy a car, have it shipped to a dealer authorized stereo shop, have the nicest stereo you want installed, and roll the price of the install into the loan for the car. Yup, nobody would dare do that to a new car - lol!

      --
      Build it, Drive it, Improve it! Hybridz.org
    7. Re:the problem is by seanadams.com · · Score: 1

      I'm not sure what point you're trying to make here. Can you answer this:

      Still, most people leave their factory decks in, except in older cards. Why do you think that is?

      Once you figure that out, it will become clearer to you why expensive hard disk decks have not sold well.

    8. Re:the problem is by BLKMGK · · Score: 1

      "Most" folks I know don't have factory decks in their cars.

      --
      Build it, Drive it, Improve it! Hybridz.org
    9. Re:the problem is by nolife · · Score: 1

      few people are willing to have the stereo shop monkey around behind their dash to wire in an aftermarket stereo.
      Are you kidding me? There is and has been a good car stero market for at least 15 years. If there was not, the big electronic retail stores would not devote so much space in their stores for it. There are many different levels of car stereos just as with computer hardware. People spend $500 for a video card, people also spend $500 (or much more) in amplifiers for their car.

      Also they're unlikely to have good built-in amps so probably you'll have to put on of those in too.
      I agree, but there is no aftermarket stereos on the market where the built in amp is "good", some of the streros do not even have amplification at all and *require* external amplifiers.
      I think you seriously under estimated the market of aftermarket car stereos and accessories. I'm am not saying this newly introduced device will have success but there is potential.

      --
      Bad boys rape our young girls but Violet gives willingly.
    10. Re:the problem is by zakezuke · · Score: 1

      To each their own pretty much. A good reason to go with an aftermarket deck is simply because they are often cheaper than factory ones. This is assuming that you are *picking* extras after you pick a car.

      Another good reason is you *might* be able to choose what you like. I'm not going to get into this whole better/worse thing. In my experence factory decks are pretty good. I know I installed a Honda deck in my old toyota before I gave it to my niece. It sounded like my Alpine actually.

      There are those who believe that a factory deck has a higher value than an aftermarket one. I personaly wouldn't really care one way or another. I buy used cars and I wouldn't pay extra for a factory deck.

      Now... all of this is very accidemic. This is making the assumption that a dash player is going to have it's own amp. Given how popular cd-changers are it's a safe bet that someone would take this into account and make a damn dash mount media player designed to jack into your existing stereo, and take the place of that stupid map holder under your existing deck that you never use.

      --
      There is no sanctuary. There is no sanctuary. SHUT UP! There is no shut up. There is no shut up.
    11. Re:the problem is by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      One of my friends said that Alpine decks, at least currently, have the best DACs on them and they sound the best. I know how something sounds is subjective and depends on your speakers and a few other factors but the DACs are often over looked and very key to how good your stuff sounds depending on the converters and how tight the clock is (jitter).

    12. Re:the problem is by nolife · · Score: 1

      Your argument makes no sense. Are you telling us that an entire subset of the consumer electronics industy about to die because "most" people are not using it? Who the hell cares if "most" people are not doing it. There is one hell of bunch of people that ARE doing it and companies make products for them. You would have a very hard time finding a retail store that does NOT carry car stereos. Pretty odd situation if no one was actually buying them and installing them.

      Once you figure that out, it will become clearer to you why expensive hard disk decks have not sold well.

      Although $500 would put this deck in the high average price range, there are many more that are far more expensive, even BestBuy carries a few above that range and they are far from a specialty retailer. I paid $400 for my previous headunit and it only has preouts (no built-in amps). To each his own I guess. People pay $500 for a video card every year or so to obtain a higher level of performance (BTW, far from "most" people do that), no different then a $500 head unit. I will admit, factory stereos have got better over the years but those that want more will rip it out.

      --
      Bad boys rape our young girls but Violet gives willingly.
    13. Re:the problem is by seanadams.com · · Score: 1

      Your argument makes no sense.

      It makes sense to me. And it makes sense to manufacturers and dealers, apparently. Empeg made a great product and it didn't sell. Sony made some disk players and they're not selling. No startup companies that I know of are exploring this. What does that tell you?

      Yes, there is a healthy market for $119 replacement decks. But I don't see a market for expensive new technology here. This is good technology, but I don't think it'll happen big until the auto makers back it up (or it gets much much cheaper).

      Who can afford a $500-$1200 car stereo? People who own nice cars. People who generally don't want their nice cars modified. That's all I'm suggesting.

      The automotive market moves really slow, including the aftermarket. There are reasons for that!

  11. DAMN! by red5 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    iRiver is the third leading seller of MP3 portables with 5.6% of the market, following the number two seller Rio which holds 6.4% of the market. And the Apple iPod? No surprise, only a whopping 65.8% of all units shipped.

    Reminds me of the old adage: "Second place is the first loser"

    I always thought that was a rather annoying way to look at it. In this case I think it applies. 65.8 : 6.4 is just over a factor of ten. Damn Apple really does dominate that market. Hopefully this works out for iRiver. Otherwise there probably not going to last long. They're getting creamed (at 5.6%).

    Though I suppose one can say by the same logic Apple is getting creamed in the computer market. Though I wonder how their numbers compare to other vendors (ei Dell, HP, Toshiba, Sony, etc) as opposed to apple vs. the entire PC market.

    --
    I know I'm going to hell, I'm just trying to get good seats.
    1. Re:DAMN! by hanssprudel · · Score: 1

      The numbers are for America only though. iRiver is a Korean company, who are very big domenstically and also big in Europe (probably larger than Apple).

      Interestingly, those numbers would indicate that HD based players dominate in America (dividing gives 70%) while I am quite convinced that both in volume and value flash based players dominate completely here. iPod's are still relatively rare, but a small flash player on a necklace has become the latest necessary fashion accessory.

    2. Re:DAMN! by theLOUDroom · · Score: 1

      Hopefully this works out for iRiver. Otherwise there probably not going to last long. They're getting creamed (at 5.6%).

      It's possible to have a very small fraction of the market and still do quite well.

      Do you think your local plumber has even 1% of the US market for plumbing?

      iRiver makes some good products that, while not dominating the market do sell. As long as they aren't being totally stupid with their money, I expect they're doing quite fine.

      Look at it this way:
      What percentage of the car market do you think Ferrari has? Does this automatically mean they're facing bankruptcy?

      IRiver's products appeal very much to those of us who care about audio quality, lack of DRM, etc.
      Unfortunately we're not the majority.
      Fortunately, there are enough of us out there that there are companies which cater to our desires.

      How many people own Crown amplifiers?

      IMO, iRiver's doing great. They're they only company out there making a DRM-less device, with all the bells and whistles necessary for it to be a total replacement for a portable minidsc recorder. As long as they keep doing this, they'll have a nice niche in the market, and won't have to compete quite so desperately on price as certain other manufacturers.

      --
      Life is too short to proofread.
  12. Re:In Soviet Russia.... by FinestLittleSpace · · Score: 2, Insightful

    fuck off.

  13. Correction by geighaus · · Score: 4, Interesting

    These numbers are applicable for the US. I guess the situation is a bit different on a worldwide scale, as iPods are not an "in" thing in Europe by any standards, as well as fairly unknown here in Finland.

    1. Re:Correction by The+Limp+Devil · · Score: 1

      And here in Oslo they are everywhere. I see them among students on campus, on pretty girls in the park, on shoppers in the supermarkets and commuters on the subway.

      So using your single data point from Finland to say that iPods are not an "in" thing in Europe by any standards is a bit of an exaggeration at best.

    2. Re:Correction by dipakpatel · · Score: 1

      I suggest you take a trip to the UK sometime - after the US, the UK has got one of the largest markets for iPods -- dp

  14. usual double standard. by thoughtterrorist · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    "92% if you only count HD portables." It's apple, so it's a good monopoly, right?

    --
    If I told you that was last year, would you know what I meant?
    1. Re:usual double standard. by colinleroy · · Score: 1

      If you meant to compare with microsoft, I don't think it applies. Microsoft's monopoly is about forcing software to be bundled on the piece of hardware you choose to buy. iPod's monopoly is about everyone choosing to buy their piece of hardware. It would be comparable if you were forced to buy an iPod the same way you're forced to buy Windows each time you buy a PC...

      --
      blah
    2. Re:usual double standard. by ideatrack · · Score: 2, Insightful

      It's not a monopoly.

      Monopoly:A business that is the sole supplier of a particular good or service. Regulated monopolies, such as electric utilities, are generally restricted as to the returns they are permitted to earn. Other monopolies such as firms with unique products or services derived from patents, copyrights, or geographic location may be able to earn very high returns.

    3. Re:usual double standard. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      " iPod's monopoly is about everyone choosing to buy their piece of hardware." ...and being required to use their software on it.

  15. Great! by O-SUSHi · · Score: 1

    This is great. Kudos to iRiver. Now, all I need to make my driving experience more enjoyable is a car and driver's license.

    --
    Remember children, all generalizations are wrong.
  16. Networking - The Missing Piece by superid · · Score: 5, Insightful
    I don't want to yank my player out of the dash when I want to add songs. I want to drive my car into my garage and have it present on my home network. Then from my desktop I will drag/drop songs to the car.

    Why the heck is it taking the auto industry so long to add simple network connectivity to cars? I know it's a price sensitive market, and potentially a security problem, but I've been anticipating this "no brainer" option for years....where is it???

    1. Re:Networking - The Missing Piece by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      You have a funny definition of "no brainer" when you've already given two good reasons why it's a stupid thing to put on a car.

    2. Re:Networking - The Missing Piece by CmdrGravy · · Score: 3, Informative

      To be fair though I'm sure a lot of people would be willing to pay for this convience ( I certainly would ) because it is just so ... convienent.

      As regards security I can't see how it would be any more or less secure than any other wireless network and if it is only offering the opportunity to add new music or delete the existing music then in a worst case scenario all you'd have to do is park your car and download all your songs again.

      This would be such an obvious and useful piece of functionality it's really annoying it's not available yet.

    3. Re:Networking - The Missing Piece by Technician · · Score: 1

      two good reasons why it's a stupid thing to put on a car.


      What do you mean?

      I know it's a price sensitive market, and potentially a security problem,

      This didn't stop Microsoft from selling Windows... (ducks)

      --
      The truth shall set you free!
    4. Re:Networking - The Missing Piece by gosand · · Score: 1
      I don't want to yank my player out of the dash when I want to add songs. I want to drive my car into my garage and have it present on my home network. Then from my desktop I will drag/drop songs to the car.


      A friend of mine has the older Rio car unit, and he loves it. But I wasn't so sure about getting one (and they went off the market). I ended up waiting a year or so to see how the MP3/CD players would fare. There were only a couple models out at the time, but now there are tons. I picked up a Blaupunkt for under $200, and it is awesome. Now I can carry several CDs of MP3s in my car and have hours of music. There's no skipping or risk of hard drive damage, and if a CD gets scratched I am just out a few cents.


      The only thing I might like better is if it would read DVDs. Now DVD-Rs are cheap enough where I wouldn't mind having 4.7gig of music. But I am very happy with my purchase. It even has an AUX input if I ever wanted to play something from a portable. (or use one of those FM modulated add-ons) To me, that is a much more viable alternative because you can take the portable with you.



      --

      My beliefs do not require that you agree with them.

    5. Re:Networking - The Missing Piece by ahillen · · Score: 1

      I don't want to yank my player out of the dash when I want to add songs. I want to drive my car into my garage and have it present on my home network. Then from my desktop I will drag/drop songs to the car.

      But why do you want an extra player in the car, anyway? I want to have one mobile player, which I can use at home, in the subway, when walking... and when I drive in my car I want to connect to my car stereo and have access to all the music and all the playlists I can listen to in other situations. Of course, the most important functions of my player should be available on the steering wheel.... Why should I want to buy/maintain an extra HD with music just for my car?

    6. Re:Networking - The Missing Piece by WuphonsReach · · Score: 1

      Your wish list is a lot like mine.

      I have a JVC MP3/CD player that I put in my car back in 2001. Probably the best investment I've ever made with regards to enjoyment value (worked perfectly on my two-week road trip). Easy to change CDs if you want different music and each CD holds 6-10 hours worth. I probably carry 400 hours worth of music in the car (10 CDs up on the visor, another 40 in a pair of thin nyoprolene(?) CD cases).

      DVD-R would be very nice, then I could have a real 1980s disc rather then randomly spreading my misc 80s track across multiple CDs. Would also be easier to package together a bunch of the two-hour radio mix MP3s that I have rather then only fitting 4-5 on a CD-R.

      I have toyed with the idea of using an iPod or mini iPod hooked up to the aux connector... but that would mean another doodad in the passenger compartment. With yet another cable (already have to hook up my cellphone to a hands-free adapter).

      Maybe if I drove more, or took mass transit, or had to go to an office where I'd listen to my iPod during the day. Just can't quite convince myself it's worth the price of the iPod (or something else) for only a few hours of use per month.

      --
      Wolde you bothe eate your cake, and have your cake?
    7. Re:Networking - The Missing Piece by HeyLaughingBoy · · Score: 1
      I don't want to yank my player out of the dash when I want to add songs


      I think there's a larger group of people who don't mind this. Including those who don't have a home wireless network, or can't get their car close enough (live in a large apartment complex) for a good signal, or simply those who're already comfortable with plugging the player into the computer to upload songs: iPod owners.

      I've always thought the ideal car player would accept an iPod. Yeah, I've seen the connectors you can buy. That's not what I mean. I'm talking about a slot in the car radio that you can insert an iPod and hold it securely. And there'd be controls/display on the dashboard player that have the same functionality as those on the iPod, but optimized for automotive ergonomics, including steering wheel controls.

      Same deal for the home: a CD player that can either play CDs, or you stick your iPod into it and have access to all its music. You can now have a larger screen and remote controls.

      With this concept, the iPod becomes just a controlled playback device. No need for new interfaces for loading songs: just remove it from the car and do it the regular way.

      Why the heck is it taking the auto industry so long to add simple network connectivity to cars?

      Because you can count on the fingers of one hand (OK, a few thousand hands :-) the number of people who want this. I've modified vehicles fairly extensively in the past, but I can't think of a single reason why I'd need network connectivity.
      Let me turn the question around: what would the benefits be?
    8. Re:Networking - The Missing Piece by .killedkenny · · Score: 1

      "I don't want to yank my player out of the dash when I want to add songs."

      I'm envisioning something like an indash deck with no hard drive, but maybe 4 USB 2.0 slots - use it like a 4-disc changer for flash drives! Have simple logic like when you remove a drive it automatically plays from the next drive. Adding features like the ability to read text files aloud would be trivial.

    9. Re:Networking - The Missing Piece by rts008 · · Score: 1

      CATCH! ***throws imaginary "insightful" +mod points at Low Flying Duck*** If I had real mod pts. I'd toss them instead...LOL!

      --
      Down With Slashdot BETA!!! I've been around the corner and seen the oliphant; you can only abuse me from your perspecti
  17. ipod in car by millahtime · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I bet if apple had an actual kit to put an ipod in a car rather than all the hacker mods that are out there it would help in that area.

    Personally, I don't want a device just for my car. I want one I can have in my car, home and anywhere else I go.

    1. Re:ipod in car by NicolaiBSD · · Score: 2, Interesting

      This is a very neat solution I'm using myself. You can control the ipod with the on-wheel CD changer controls. Hardly a hack.

    2. Re:ipod in car by ch3 · · Score: 1

      Well, I have a car stereo (Blaupunkt Daytona MP53) which has an aux input. Using a Belkin car kit, my iPod is perfectly hooked to the stereo. The only "hack" need was to find a way to bring the jack near the cigarette lighter.

      Unfortunatly, this is only possible with after market stereo (and not every has an aux input).

    3. Re:ipod in car by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      They do.

      The more recent Alpine head units can be upgraded with an adaptor box (the KCA-420i) and then you can stick the iPod in the glove box or out of sight in the boot/trunk and control the iPod from the controls on the head unit.

      http://www.alpine-usa.com/driveyouripod/

      I imagine it won't be long before other manufacturers are doing the same kind of thing or integrating it into newer head units directly.

    4. Re:ipod in car by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Since I've owned my iPod, what I've wanted is this:

      Take a standard car stereo head unit, but where the cassette tape is usually inserted, have an iPod sized hole where I can just plug in my iPod so the whole thing is flush with the dash. In other words, treat the iPod like a giant cassette tape (forget C-90's this would be a, uh, C-40000!).

      Come on audio manufacturers, how hard can it be?

    5. Re:ipod in car by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The more recent Alpine head units can be upgraded with an adaptor box (the KCA-420i) and then you can stick the iPod in the glove box or out of sight in the boot/trunk and control the iPod from the controls on the head unit.

      I do this same thing with my Dension ICElink. The iPod is hidden away in the glove box, but it's connected to the CD changer port on my stock Toyota stereo, and I can use the stereo's next/prev track buttons to skip to the next/previous track. I've got 6600+ songs on my iPod, and a playlist of my 1200 favorites among them. That way, I don't really need anything more than the next/prev buttons to work the iPod, and since I like all the songs I don't need a display to know what I'm listening to.

      Having said that, I sure wouldn't mind a car stereo that was designed to interface with the iPod and gave me full control plus track/playlist display, but I'll manage.

  18. HD Based Car Players by Silwenae · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I have an Omnifi for my home and car.

    The car version, a 20GB hard drive that I had professionally installed under my rear passenger seat, lasted a week. Made by Rockford-Fosgate, in a large case to support the hard drive, you would think it could take the bumps and shocks of the road. It couldn't.

    It would skip when I would hit a bump, even at 15 miles per hour pulling into the gas station. At the point it would skip, it would lock up for 30 seconds, then resume, but every 30 seconds would pause for another 30 seconds. Ejecting the hard drive and putting it back in would reset it to the point of the bump, then it would play fine until I hit another bump.

    The pro's of the unit were you could plug a USB 802.11b card into the casing, and automatically transfer your music wirelessly right into your garage. If you didn't have a wireless network, you could eject the hard drive and it had a USB port to hook up to your PC. It had a really slick interface in the car, and setting up a wireless network over the in-dash spin dial thing was a breeze, they did a a really good job with that, with the different ways you could input your WEP key.

    The cons were the bumping of the car made it pause, the USB wireless network adapter just kind of hung out in your car, no where to mount it. And the software interface on a Windows pc (SimpleCenter) was one of the most horrid music applications I have ever used. And it didn't do Ogg.

    I'm skeptical of any hard drive based car player until they can more than account for the shocks and bumps, and it needs to come with some kind of warranty plan. How long will those hard drives last?

    1. Re:HD Based Car Players by the_crowbar · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I wonder what kind of hd was used in those units? I have a roll-your-own mini-itx setup in my trunk. The OS drive is a 1Gb CompactFlash card and the media drive is a 30Gb Hitachi 2.5" laptop HD. To date (just over a year) I have not had any problems with the HD skipping or crashing. I drive a Prelude that is regularly abused by numerous potholes and the laptop HD has taken the beatings well. I have experienced problems with the touchscreen in the dash due to summer heat, but no issues with the HD.

      If your system was skipping over small bumps I would definitely have that "professional" mounting job checked. My HD was screwed to the PC case and the case was mounted to the sheet metal in the back of the back seat. I used no manner of shock dampening system at all. Hopefully I haven't jinxed myself by posting this, but what the hell.

      Cheers,
      the_crowbar
      --
      Have you read the Moderator Guidelines
    2. Re:HD Based Car Players by Cushman · · Score: 1

      > How long will those hard drives last?

      Of course standard hard drives will fail, but two shock-mounted laptop drives (found in the Empeg) last quite some time. Three years and going so far. Bumps have never been a problem for me.

    3. Re:HD Based Car Players by genixia · · Score: 1

      You've been burned by that one experience, but don't discount HD based car players completely. Other solutions exist that don't suffer from HD failures. I've had 2 30GB drives in my empeg for over two and a half years without a failure. Now they are laptop drives (designed for shock) and they are mounted in an anti-shock cradle (empeg design), so that probably helps. Of the >4000 empeg players in the wild, only a few have ever suffered HD failures.

    4. Re:HD Based Car Players by boomerny · · Score: 1

      I'm thinking the cold of our northeast winters would not be good for the hard drive(I live in upstate NY). I suppose you could remove it from the dash every day but I'm sure I'd forget and end up with a frozen drive.

    5. Re:HD Based Car Players by Miles+in+Michigan · · Score: 1

      Page 14 of the manual says the best way to mount it is vertically, with the HD cartridge facing up. They do say that horizontal mounting is okay, it's just not optimal. http://www.omnifimedia.com/scripts/omnifitech.cfg/ php.exe/enduser/fattach_get.php?p_sid=F1iuVRnh&p_t bl=9&p_id=70&p_created=1070410995 Perhaps your DMP1 was defective? I don't have one, but there seem to be satisfied users in the OmniFi DMP1 forums. http://www.omnifimedia.com/forum/forum.asp?FORUM_I D=30

    6. Re:HD Based Car Players by thogard · · Score: 1

      Shock is only one killer...
      The heat is the other and stuff in a car dash can get very hot and well above the storage temps for hard drives. When you turn on the car and force the A/C way up, it may cool some parts inside the dash or it might not cool anything.

      In winter you could have a problem at the other end of the temp scale.

      And don't forget electrical shock too. Cars can create huge charges with the newer tire compounds and it only takes one zap to kill the entire computer.

      There seems to be a reason why so many cars are now mounting their electrical stuff under the back seat.

    7. Re:HD Based Car Players by Tingler · · Score: 1

      Hey Silwenae,
      That sounds like a unit that wasn't quite ready for prime time. That's a shame. I know how upset & disappointed I would be if I has the same issues. Perhaps if I tell you a bit about my choice, you might be a bit less skeptical.

      I have a Phatnoise AKA Music Keg. The Phatnoise device is a HD based player designed to emulate a CD changer. You install it / have it installed just as you would any CD changer. It sends the audio & pulls the power from one cable attached to the head unit, so it looks like it would be really easy. (I wouldn't know, I had it professionally installed.)

      I really enjoy the interface because it uses the Kenwood head unit for control & display. The head unit I chose has 2 lines of text & it makes it easy to see the name of the song & play list that I am listening to. I also have a remote installed on my steering wheel, so I don't even have to take my eyes off the road. This is important, as I have a KDC-X959 head unit. Pretty to look at, but a horrid UI.

      In the Phatnoise forums, there is a constant discussion as to why the DMS aka "cartridge with the hard drive in it." It appears that they use laptop hard drives with better than average anti-shock characteristics. I'm not sure if that is the case, but I do know that what ever they use, it works.

      The drawback to this arrangement is the cost of the unit. I paid about $600 for the Phatnoise with a 10 Gig drive about three years ago. The current cost for the largest upgrade, 80 Gig DMS, is $349. This gets you a hard drive in a case that slides into the Phatnoise unit.

      There is also no wireless networking. But there are rumors of this coming in a future version. All in all, I would say it is a great setup. It never skips, it is easy to use, it is expensive, but it is worth it.

      Good luck in your search.

      http://www.phatnoise.com/

    8. Re:HD Based Car Players by mr.+methane · · Score: 1

      Current HD's are quite capable of handling the very mild bumps and such that a vehicle goes through. Even the worst shaking and jarring you get from a pothole are far less than a typical laptop must handle being dropped an inch onto a desktop.

      What concerns me much more, is this idea of connecting up an 802.11 card to the car. How long will it be till my car alarm gets a virus, making it scream "H4VE Y0U TR1ED HERBAL V1AGRA? FREE 5AMPLE!" to pedestrians.

    9. Re:HD Based Car Players by shimmerkid · · Score: 1

      That is strange. (full disclosure - I worked for Omnifi). I have one installed in my car, and it has NEVER skipped. Ever. Did you install it on its side or anything? I just asked my co-workers, and they haven't had that happen either. My firmware-writing cube-mate says that your disk may be damaged - do a disk check on it with Windows. Otherwise, you might want to get a replacement unit. At least a new hard disk.

    10. Re:HD Based Car Players by pixel.jonah · · Score: 1
      I too have a PhatNoise's PhatBox. I have the version with SSA (voice-based navigation) which integrates with my stock Audi headunit and makes use of the built in CD changer disk buttons to control the system. It works incredibly well - even better than the ones that have text (ID3) displays because you can navigate by feel/sound and never have to take your eyes off the road at all!

      An additional plus of the PhatBox is that it supports both OGG and FLAC in addition to WAV and MP3.

      As to the harddrives - they use off-the-shelf (albeit the ruggeder line) of 2.5 inch drives.

  19. Re:In Soviet Russia.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Best...+5 Insightful...Ever! :)

  20. Re:In Soviet Russia.... by Inda · · Score: 1

    I always like a swift 'fuck off'. It solves so many of lifes little problems.

    --
    This post contains benzene, nitrosamines, formaldehyde and hydrogen cyanide.
  21. You gotta' be kiddnig me by BLKMGK · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Are you REALLY that far out of touch with the aftermarket entertainment offerings or is this a Troll? Most of what the OEMs offer is utter crap and built by the lowest bidder. MANY people replace their stereos with aftermarket components and $500 for a good headunit is CHEAP. Hell, there's an entire industry revolving around aftermerket entertainment systems for vehicles and several magazines devoted to it as well. Pull your head out once in awhile and look around for kripes sakes. Crutchfield http://www.crutchfield.com/ is but one example of a thriving online business revolving aorund this and if you take a look around one day you might even notice stereo shops in your community. I can think of three within a 5 minute driving distance of my home and I do NOT live in a city...

    --
    Build it, Drive it, Improve it! Hybridz.org
    1. Re:You gotta' be kiddnig me by seanadams.com · · Score: 1

      Are you REALLY that far out of touch with the aftermarket entertainment offerings or is this a Troll? Most of what the OEMs offer is utter crap and built by the lowest bidder. MANY people replace their stereos with aftermarket components and $500 for a good headunit is CHEAP.

      No, I don't think I'm out of touch. In fact I've done a couple dozen custom installs myself - amps, custom sub boxes, power cabling, the whole nine yards.

      The best example (of many) that comes to mind is the factory Mercedes deck vs a top-of-the-line Pioneer deck that I replaced it with (beacuse Mercedes' deck did not have a built in CD, only a trunk changer option).

      The pioneer is crapping out already after only two years. Buttons don't work, CD player skips, etc. By contrast the Mercedes deck was VERY sturdy, with big hefty buttons that also matched the rest of dash. Factory decks don't have all the whiz-bang features but they are a lot more reliable in my experience.

    2. Re:You gotta' be kiddnig me by SFBwian · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Well, what do you expect... it was a MERCEDES! Buy a Kia and find out how nice the factory stereo is.

      --
      I'm looking to get rich. I've got steps #2 (????) and #3 (PROFIT!) planned out, but am having trouble coming up with #1.
    3. Re:You gotta' be kiddnig me by zakezuke · · Score: 1

      Well, what do you expect... it was a MERCEDES! Buy a Kia and find out how nice the factory stereo is.

      I don't know about Kia, but I can speak for Hyundai cassette decks. I was most impressed after they e-mailed me the unlock code (2211). We're talking good construction, easy enough to jack into a cd-changer or aux source. Never ate a tape, nor got jammed. I'm not saying that there wasn't better out there, but the factory cassette deck was on par with what i'd expect from an average $150 unit. If I bought a car with one of those installed I would likely just go with changer and keep the existing tape deck. I know most people want CD players, but most people I know ask the infamous question "what do I buy so I can jack my thingie in".

      If you're the type to shell out $500 for a head unit, then chances are you are not going to be happy with the factory stereo, esp the base one. Your actual milage will vary, but keep in mind that car stereos are things put in to sell the cars, or to squeeze a few extra bucks out of you before you sign the papers. This means there are cheap ones, average ones, and some pretty nice once depending on make, model, target market, etc... etc....

      Generally a factory head unit will cost you more than after market, and after market you can actually hear them in action and make an informed choice.

      --
      There is no sanctuary. There is no sanctuary. SHUT UP! There is no shut up. There is no shut up.
  22. I can't understand why they don't sell more.. by MikeHunt69 · · Score: 4, Interesting
    If you put aside emotions for a minute and do a side-by-side comparison, the iRiver is much better than the iPod. The only thing the iPod maybe wins on is the user interface - and I've had absolutely no problems with my H340 iRiver.

    But the thing that closed the deal for me? USB hosting. I no longer have to lug my laptop around on holiday because I can plug my camera into the iRiver and store the files on it's internal HD. All the colour screen, upgradable firmware, internal mic, radio, remote control, not needing custom software by appearing as just another drive, etc. is just icing on the cake.

    1. Re:I can't understand why they don't sell more.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Remore control? Does it come with remote? I thought that only H120-H140 have that...
      I was thinking to buy this beast for the same reason - USB hosting. Not only for the camera but also for sync with a small cheapy flash player - for more rought excercises (like skiing).

    2. Re:I can't understand why they don't sell more.. by hanssprudel · · Score: 1

      It does, but the remote does not have a display. However, the old remote from the 120 or 140 can be used if one needs a display.

    3. Re:I can't understand why they don't sell more.. by lidocaineus · · Score: 1
      A list of things that cause the iPod to win out in the mainstream market (read: average, non-computer person).
      • Many people would rather NOT have an FM tuner
      • Mainstream folks do not care about recording capabilities
      • Nor do they care about Vorbis
      • Apple's UI extends to the physical unit itself, which people seem to adore, which includes iTunes, a much nicer interface and library manager than "just another drive"" (which the iPod can support just for data, or with music with free third party utilities)
      The USB hosting is nice, but again, a huge majority of people don't even know what smartlists are; until something like that enters the general consciousness, it is definitely a gee-whiz item. Keep in mind that the general public is VERY VERY ignorant about "cool tech things", and KISS almost ALWAYS wins. Example: did you know that some people don't even know about iPod scroll wheels? They use the DAMN ARROW KEYS to move through the menus!

      And finally, the iPod has long since moved past a tech item to a cultural icon... a very difficult spot for a competitor to move them from. The iPod has become synonymous with MP3s (even if it plays more formats)... it's become a goal purchase even, and it's continually pushed upon us by the elephant that is Apple marketing. Basically, the time to beat it was back in the first gen days. It's entrenched now and it will take a lot of consumer education, cheap prices, very well designed layout (obviously nothing has come close yet to the iPod's design). and simple layouts to get people to change.
    4. Re:I can't understand why they don't sell more.. by Overzeetop · · Score: 1

      Bose sells a lot of speakers, too.

      --
      Is it just my observation, or are there way too many stupid people in the world?
    5. Re:I can't understand why they don't sell more.. by omarKhayyam · · Score: 1

      "Only" user interface? ARG!!! I cannot understand why user interface seems a secondary consideration to the Slashdot crowd. In case no one remembers, portable MP3 players were pretty much limited to us geeks before the iPod came along. Why? Because the interfaces were terrible. Sure, there are other reasons the iPod succeeded with the masses (sexiness + marketing blitz), but I believe the excellent user interface was primary among them. Heck, I'm a computer engineer and I don't care how many bells and whistles a new toy has if it isn't a pleasure to use. Incidently, I'm not knocking the interface on the H340. I'm just constantly frustrated that so many people dismiss UI as marginally important.

    6. Re:I can't understand why they don't sell more.. by srcosmo · · Score: 1
      I no longer have to lug my laptop around on holiday because I can plug my camera into the iRiver and store the files on it's internal HD.
      How does this work, exactly? Does your camera automatically copy pictures to the iRiver's drive? Would I need some fancy digital camera to do this?
      --
      free speach
      Did you mean: free speech
    7. Re:I can't understand why they don't sell more.. by toddestan · · Score: 1

      Most of the people I know who got an iPod wanted an iPod despite the fact they had never ever touched one. It was all about marketing, and ignorance of other options out there. Most people aren't like the Slashdot crowd who go out and research all the options before plonking down $400 on a fancy music player. Basically, it's iPod = MP3 player in the same way as Internet Explorer = The Internet for these people.

    8. Re:I can't understand why they don't sell more.. by toddestan · · Score: 1

      How does this work, exactly? Does your camera automatically copy pictures to the iRiver's drive? Would I need some fancy digital camera to do this?

      The USB hosting means that you can plug in USB devices and use them. I'm guessing he just used one of those $20 memory card readers. I'm unsure if devices like mice or keyboards also work.

    9. Re:I can't understand why they don't sell more.. by MikeHunt69 · · Score: 2, Informative
      You can only really use other devices that need no drivers to work. If your camera appears as a HD when you plug it into a windows machine, then you can plug it directly into the iRiver. Otherwise, you need to get a card reader.

      Once your device is connected, you go to a different menu on the iRiver that looks like a primative explorer, and use it to transfer files between the two devices. It's a bit clunky but as something that's not it's primary function, it works quite well.

    10. Re:I can't understand why they don't sell more.. by MemoryAid · · Score: 1
      With the iPod, you need a third piece of hardware, such as this Belkin device. It activates a new menu option on the iPod that allows copying of photos from a digital camera to the hard drive. It seems like something that could be done in the firmware of the iPod fairly easily, as the iRiver apparently does.

      For what it's worth, the system works pretty well with the iPod, except for the need to have a flat surface to lay out all three items for the transfer. Also, it doesn't seem to work with any of my film cameras.

      --
      Language students: Don't try to learn English here. This ain't it.
  23. Interface by TrippTDF · · Score: 2, Insightful

    The user interface had better be clear, simple and easy to use while driving, or no one is going to get one of these. Based on my small iRiver experiance, I don't see that happening.

    1. Re:Interface by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      We should mention again that Rockbox is being ported to the iRiver!

      Hopfeully, the car HD unit will have a lot in common with the portable unit, so it wouldn't be much of a stretch to extend Rockbox for the HU.

      Then, if you don't like the interface, you can make a request to the Rockbox team, or roll your own.

  24. what are you doing on /.? by HBI · · Score: 1

    I've been putting in car stereos for 20+ years. It is easy and rewarding. I can't believe a geek on /. wouldn't do it. Stock stereos in general suck, low quality components abound in that arena. Bad tuners and anemic CD players. I replace and throw out the stock stereo in each new car I get.

    The one thing the automaker can do for you is give you a good speaker rig, and i'm not talking about chest thumping bass either. I am talking about quality sound reproduction including the high range above 10khz, which I can hear just fine, but in most cars is muffled because the speaker grilles point towards my feet or in the rear have to bounce off a rear window.

    You aren't going to get that rig without spending an arm and a leg on the high end stereo package that the automaker offers. If you aren't willing to pay the extra $1k for the stereo, or waiting the week or two it takes to get your special order in. You're going to have to start mixing and matching speakers too. Not that that is the end of the world either.

    --
    HBI's Law: Frequency of calling others Nazis is directly correlated with the likelihood of the accuser being Communist.
    1. Re:what are you doing on /.? by seanadams.com · · Score: 1

      I've been putting in car stereos for 20+ years. It is easy and rewarding. I can't believe a geek on /. wouldn't do it.

      Oh come off it dude. I've put in plenty of car stereos, and I design audio products for a living. I know how easy it is to swap a deck.

  25. Obvious call for Wifi by CdBee · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Various people have spoken about wifi in digital media players (including Apple advertising for wifi engineers to work on future iPods) but this is a real case for it.

    A car media player with a Wifi link would be ideal as the owner could then download tracks to it without the need either to walk a laptop out to the car or the car stereo back to the house.

    the benefits of being able to browse people's music collections while driving would be entirely incidental ;-)

    --
    I have been a user for about 10 years. This ends Feb 2014. The site's been ruined. I'm off. Dice, FU
    1. Re:Obvious call for Wifi by rts008 · · Score: 1

      Brings new meaning to WarDriving, How about DriveBy /.ing , or driveby hacking! We would then have to redefine P2P (pontiac 2pontiac, pontiac 2 Peugot). What are we waiting for?

      --
      Down With Slashdot BETA!!! I've been around the corner and seen the oliphant; you can only abuse me from your perspecti
  26. Not a bad idea! by BLKMGK · · Score: 1

    I think that one of the aftermarket companies may be doing this actually. Unfortunatly most of what has been offered aftermarket for MP3 playback other than off of CDs has been encumbered with either DRM nastieness or with some sort of oddball format where they want to force you into buying their hardware for media - ick. As the market moves forward offerings have gotten better but so far I've yet to find something better than my CD playing Alpine for MP3s and it's transport finally died after umm more than a few hours of play time ;-) Radio, wazzat? A small portable might be okay for this, I have a Karma, but hookup and ease of theft aren't to great. A device like you've envisioned would be better.

    Unfortunatly there's no one standard for this kind of thing so they would have to build multiple interface boxes. Doable but unfortunatly not a one shot design deal :-(

    --
    Build it, Drive it, Improve it! Hybridz.org
  27. Input jack by fossa · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Can someone please make a car with a stereo that has an audio input? Does such a thing exist even in aftermarket? Assuming I already have a portable music player, I could just plug it in to my car stereo. Instead, I'm stuck using some pathetic mini FM transmitter, or cassette adapter if I have a cassette deck, or buying a whole new HD car stereo.

    *sigh*

    1. Re:Input jack by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      A bought a Tevion (ALDI) car cd player for AU$100, it came with an audio input on the front.

    2. Re:Input jack by wowbagger · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Yes, several manufacturers have aux inputs of one form or another. My Sony stereo I had a decade ago had an aux input on the front of the unit. My current stereo (the factory-installed Alpine unit in my Mercury) does not have an aux input per se, but has support for a CD jukebox, and there is an aftermarket aux input box that fakes the head-end unit out into thinking it is a CDDJ - thus giving me tape, in-dash CD, and my OpenNEO35 80G MP3 player.

      I agree with you on the FM transmitter and cassette adapter - they bite rocks and suck. The FM units are usually NOT crystal or synthesized and drift all over the place, as well as the built-in limitation of 15kHz due to the way stereo multiplex works, and the cassette adapters have neither good base nor good treble response. I could not believe the difference when I got the CDDJ box installed.

      Personally, I'd like to see the high-end car stereo manufactures put in a 3.5mm aux jack on the front, a pair of RCA's on the back, and a Bluetooth receiver - but that is about as likely as seeing a good candidate for president. I've got the hot tea, anybody have an atomic vector plotter?

    3. Re:Input jack by Koyaanisqatsi · · Score: 1

      JVC KD-SX980

      I'm giving you only one example, as that's the one I have in my car. It plays MP3s out of CD-R/RWs and it has an analog audio input for the iPods and alikes.

      I got mine a couple of years ago, for less than the suggested $250, and it's still going strong, no reason to change it.

    4. Re:Input jack by adefa · · Score: 1

      There are quite a few aftermarket head units that provide aux input of one sort or another. Observe:

      Blaupunkt Montreal CD34

      Kenwood KDC-MP6025

      Sony CDX-F5700

      Clarion ProAudio DXZ545MP

      Panasonic MXE CQ-C5410U"

      Rear auxilary inputs are far from being a new feature or found only in high end in dash recievers.

    5. Re:Input jack by hackstraw · · Score: 1

      I know that at least the Honda Element has an 1/8" input to the stereo, and my aftermarket expensive car stereo head unit has RCA inputs that come in as an AUX input. I've had the car stereo over a year and I'm still waiting for a decent portable unit to plug into it. If you build it it will come kind of thing.

    6. Re:Input jack by Bobman1235 · · Score: 1

      Can someone please make a car with a stereo that has an audio input?

      I've had a bunch of aftermarket head units that have auxilary audio inputs. I'd actually be really surprised if you spent over 200 bucks on a head unit and DIDN'T have an aux input or even two. Usually the wires are in the BACK, so you'd have to run them to a jack out front for the use you're looking for, but real estate on the front of the unit is pretty tight, so it's probably going to be your only option for a while.

    7. Re:Input jack by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Dude, you're just not trying, or you're a clueless teenager. Car stereos with line level aux inputs, both front (1/8" jack) and rear (dual RCAs), have been available for 20 years.

      The good news is that you will learn from this and get smarter over time.

    8. Re:Input jack by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I find it comical that first you blast tape adapters for not having enough bandwidth for high quality audio reproduction, but then suggest using bluetooth. You do realize that BT only has enough bandwidth for either one decent (little better than FM) quality channel of audio, or really crappy stereo, right?

    9. Re:Input jack by RPI+Geek · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Check out this site. They sell converters so that you can plug just about anything through their converters and then right into the head unit without FM transmitters / modulators: you get dual RCA jacks.

      I found this site yesterday because I'm in this market. I want to build a small ITX carputer and hopefully mount it in my new '04 Civic HX so that the car still looks stock. It'll have 802.11x and a removable HD, and I'd LIKE to tie it into the stock head unit so that I can change songs using the regular track forward/backward controls: maybe use the cd increment/decrement button to skip to the next/previous letter in the alphabet. Ideallly it would display the track information right on the stock LCD, but I'll probably just go with a small monochrome LCD and/or a 5" screen that can fold out. To do any of this though, the LogJam converter will need to do the conversion for me, or I'll need to figure out the pinouts on the head unit and I'm sure the whole thing will void my warranty, but that's life.

      --

      - "Nobody came out that night, not one was ever seen. But Old Man Stauf is waiting there, crazy sick and mean!"
    10. Re:Input jack by zakezuke · · Score: 1

      Can someone please make a car with a stereo that has an audio input? Does such a thing exist even in aftermarket?

      Many do. Most stereos I have seen have some sorta odd connector on the back. This is often poorly documented, or if it's documented it's labled as a "cd-changer" or "equaliser" connector. My stereo for example takes a 13pin din connector, and I can easily spend $20 for it to line outs, or order the plug from digikey for a good deal less.

      --
      There is no sanctuary. There is no sanctuary. SHUT UP! There is no shut up. There is no shut up.
    11. Re:Input jack by Jonavin · · Score: 1

      And the great thing about the Honda Element is that tehinput jack in place in a location where there's also a spot for you to put your iPod or other AUX music players without worryign about it flying aroudn as you drive or cause a mess of wires.

    12. Re:Input jack by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      i got a aux in port on my stereo (blaupunkt) in my astra. Have used it to hook up my iPod, the sound quality sounds pretty alright to me (but then again im no audiophile). My only problem is the player spends 3/4 of its time sliding around on my passenger seat :). No skips but

    13. Re:Input jack by /dev/trash · · Score: 1

      How does one go about finding out if their current car radio has an input jack, without removing the radio from the dash?

    14. Re:Input jack by theLOUDroom · · Score: 1

      Just about any of Clarion's models do.
      On the cheaper end, I believe the same thing is true for Aiwa.

      It's actually a REALLY common feature, on decks in the $200+ range.

      Note:
      Some decks have a rear panel input (Clarion) and some have a front panel input (Aiwa).

      --
      Life is too short to proofread.
    15. Re:Input jack by wowbagger · · Score: 1

      Well, if the front panel has a button for a CD jukebox and your car doesn't have one, you likely have an input for it, but would need an adaptor - check Precision Interface Electronics and see if your stereo is on the list.

  28. Good for low-end by grunt107 · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Since all digital music formats on these devices have some compression, audio quality will suffer. Maybe not discernable to most ears, but it is still there.

    The large HD device is commendable for portability, but I would also like to see cars retain at least a CD-player. It is also time to get the better-than-CD audio formats into mass-production and use. A DVD-Audio/MP3/Sat/Radio auto system would be ideal.

    1. Re:Good for low-end by scubasau · · Score: 1

      iRiver's HD players support .wav files in addition to the variety of compressed formats. Since a 20gig HD will hold upwards of 40 cds, I think even audiophiles could be happy with an HD-based system and no CD player.

    2. Re:Good for low-end by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Since all digital music formats on these devices have some compression, audio quality will suffer.

      Er, this is about a unit designed to be installed in the dashboard and played through the car speakers. Under those conditions, 128kbs MP3s are pretty much indistinguishable from having the band playing live in the back seat.

    3. Re:Good for low-end by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Dude, you're in a CAR. The audio is, by definition, going to suck -- road noise, engine noise, etc.
      The audio quality loss from compression in such an environment is irrelevant.

  29. Re:In Soviet Russia.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It is now a +5 insightful! Huzzah!

  30. Car Audio Tivo? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I see an interesting possiblility for HD-based in dash units. I have grown accustom to the instant replay feature of my Tivo box, and I find that I wish all sorts of things had it, including my car radio. If I am listening to NPR, and I zone out a little, or have to refocus all available brain cells to negotiate an on-ramp or something, I would love to just mash on the instant replay button to go back to what I missed. I know people are gonna jibberjabber about all the goofy devices and programs out there to timeshift radio broadcasts, but I really just want instant replay, and really only like 60-120 seconds. That would sell me on something like this in a heartbeat.

  31. Re:In Soviet Russia.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Funny

    Mr. Cheney, is that you?

  32. Well... by red5 · · Score: 1

    They sorta do.. If you have a new BMW that is.

    --
    I know I'm going to hell, I'm just trying to get good seats.
  33. iRiver as a whole by MImeKillEr · · Score: 1

    I surely hope they ramp-up on their support staff. Has anyone ever had to call iRiver? I did. I honestly think that they've got maybe 4 people working there. This includes management.

    And their support department's sucky-ness rivals LinkSys.

    --
    Cruising the internet on my TI-99/4A @ a whopping 300 baud!
  34. Pioneer has one... by BStocknd · · Score: 2, Informative

    I'm surprised no one has mentoned the Pioneer DEH-P90HDD. This is a head unit that will play from an internal 10 GB hard drive, memory stick, or an audio/mp3 cd. Nice looking player, and I've alwaysed loved Pioneer, but it isn't cheap.. $500 to $600 on ebay.

  35. Can't Wait! Ran out of Empeg/Rio Cars by JoshMKiV · · Score: 1

    I ran out of Empeg/Rio Car units, and need something for my new car. If this is even half as good as the Empeg, I'll be happy.

  36. Curious about pricing... by ProppaT · · Score: 1

    Anyone have any guesses as to how much this will cost? It should technically cost less than a high end portable MP3 player (seeing that less has to go into the r&d...it's a lot easier to build an mp3 player the size of a car stereo than it is to build one the size of a minidisc player)...but how much do you want to bet it costs much, much more?

    --
    Wise men say, "Forgiveness is divine, but never pay full price for late pizza."
  37. Huh ? by CmdrGravy · · Score: 1

    It's surprising that iRiver manages to sell so many of them in the US then isn't it. Can you guess why that might be ?

  38. Don't really get it by Is0m0rph · · Score: 0

    My MP3 car player works fine with CDRs. I suppose if you really don't want to carry around CDs in your car there's a use. What I want is a car MP3 player that will read DVD+Rs.

  39. Why doesn't apple do this? by Raleel · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I mean, really. they are like 99% of the way there. They have a dock. they have the airport express with wireless. Make a deck that will show up on my mac, lemme drag my songs over to it, and you are good to go. Or make a deck that I can slot my ipod into. OUt of mind, out of sight.

    --
    -- Who is the bigger fool? The fool or the fool who follows him? --
  40. HD? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    When you introduce an abbreviation that is not ubiquitous, you should define it first. What is HD? High Density? High Definition?

    Surely, it can't be hard disk, since we all know that the abbreviation for hard disk drive is HDD.

  41. HDD, not HD. by ayeco · · Score: 1

    HDD, hard disk drive. I was thinking "who wants a in-dash digital high definition player?"

    HDD!

  42. 78.5% of all statistics are made up on the spot... by TheShadowHawk · · Score: 2, Funny

    78.5% of all statistics are made up on the spot...

    --
    Friends don't let Friends use Internet Explorer.
  43. Re:HDD, not HD. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    HDD, hard disk drive. I was thinking "who wants a in-dash digital high definition player?"

    Anyone with kids on a road trip.

  44. Instead of HD players by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    what we need are MP3 on DVD+-R players.

    1. Re:Instead of HD players by Overzeetop · · Score: 1

      That would be too easy. Make it DL compatible, and you've got 9.4GB which is a mess of music encoded for automotive listening environments.

      --
      Is it just my observation, or are there way too many stupid people in the world?
    2. Re:Instead of HD players by getnate · · Score: 1

      Agreed! I love my MP3 on CD car stereo.

  45. Wrong Direction by DotDotSlasher · · Score: 1

    This is completely the wrong direction.
    Let's turn the iPod devices into cassette tapes of the 21st century.
    Hey, they're the same size as a cassette tape, right? Plug in your iPod-sized music player into your car deck (with an industry standard common interface), the deck charges the iPod (or similar)'s battery and can access music and play lists. The iPod remembers where you were in your book-on-tape or the song you were last playing.
    Then just pop out the iPod when you're done. Having a completely separate hard drive and media library seems redundant to me.

    1. Re:Wrong Direction by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      There already is something like this. Alpine makes it. It was just released several weeks ago.

      For what it is, it works pretty well. The scrolling speed to step through playlists is a little on the slow side and it's a bit involved in learning how to use it but nothing overwhelming.

      Rumor is that Pioneer is also coming out with such an interface.

      Also, everyone seems to be forgetting the Dension DH100, which is a worthy piece despite the fact that it looks really cheesy. 40GB of storage in a removable hard drive, RDS tuner, dual preamps out. It's a nice headunit for the price.

  46. ipod is not dominant by SubtleNuance · · Score: 0



    "With the iPod dominating the digital portable market" Funny, ive know many people with mp3 players, not one owns an ipod.

    Why is /. accepting this ipod dominance meme? Sure its a fine player, but it does not overwhelm its competitors to the point some suggest. There are plenty of very fine players, the ipod is simply one of them.

    1. Re:ipod is not dominant by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why is /. accepting this ipod dominance meme?

      Dunno. Perhaps statistics?

      "...only a whopping 65.8% of all units shipped."

      Tho, those numbers could be as made up as the number you preset as people with mp3 players that are not iPods; your stats being antectodal, whereas I don't know where the 65.8% number came from.

      Myself, and as antectodally, when I went to buy an iPod mini I couldn't. Every single store had sold out of their iPod stock the same day they shipped. Every week. Of the people I know only two have a digital music player, one is an iPod the other is not. Plus, I'm glad that the iPod works as an external hard drive - even on a 10+ year old Mac with a 3rd party Firewire card - no additional drivers required.

      But those are just my reasons for believing the iPod dominance meme. /. may have other reasons.

  47. changer by Down8 · · Score: 1

    Except for the hdd based palyers that are hardwired, and use WiFi to xfer music, my 10-disc CD/MP3 changer is the best solution I've seen. I carry around about 115hrs of music with me constantly. It's nice having all of 50Cent, 2Pac, and Eminem's stuff ride along with Garbage, and Audioslave. It's a little mini-melting pot, and it only cost me $110 and the time to install it.

    -bZj

    --
    .sig
    1. Re:changer by payndz · · Score: 1
      It's nice having all of 50Cent, 2Pac, and Eminem's stuff ride along

      Yeah, because when the hard drive eventually craps out, it's all wiped out in one fell swoop!

      --
      You must think in Russian.
    2. Re:changer by Down8 · · Score: 1

      Not following along, were we?

      I use a CD-changer, not a hdd-based player.

      Thanks for playing, though,
      -bZj

      --
      .sig
  48. Re:In Soviet Russia.... by Squall2131 · · Score: 1

    lmao "in Soviet Russia, road forks you!" ~ Family guy

  49. Generation gap by phorm · · Score: 1

    I think this is really somewhat age dependant. For most people under 25, you're not very likely to see a 100% stock stereo system in a car.

    My parents, on the other hand, seem to be fine with stock: even a stock tapedeck. I think it has a lot to do with what media you carry - if your old CD's are fine in the stock deck then leave it be. If you've got a lot of tapes then leave it be.

    For myself, I travel a lot and love music. It's a pain swapping CD's so when mp3-CD players came out I shelled out for a deck with mp3 capabilities. At 150+ songs (at 128kbps) per disk, it saves me a lot of swapping, and any new media I stow the original at home and just add it to an mp3 album.

    I don't really see a big use for a car mp3 player though. How about just a CD-deck with a digital interface for my portable, or a multicard slot for common flash-type storage cards? Right now I'm just finishing up a small VIA pc for this, but alternately I probably would have gone for something like an mp3-enabled DVD deck (a few DVDs of 128-256KB mp3's/oggs and most of my albums at my fingertips).

  50. I find mine ideal.... by DrStrangeLug · · Score: 1

    I've got a Goodmans CD/MP3 player in my car and I love it. It plays ordinary CD's, CD-R's and RW's and can play mp3 files with ID tag display on the front.

    And this cost me just under 100 pounds (uk). For 200 I could have got one with playlist support.

    Until you add in a wifi adapter, I don't see what this one will give you that I don't get.

  51. empeg by SuperQ · · Score: 1

    I've been using my empeg since 2000, and after 4 years of running strong, there is still no other product out there that comes ANYWHERE near the quality or functionality of it. The 12gig drive is starting to feel a bit small, but with room for 2 laptop drives, adding a 40gig drive seems like nothing. As others on the empegbbs feel, Rio has droped the ball by not doing any new development in the car audio arena. They only made 4500 empegs, and everyone thinks they gave up way too fast on them.

    I worry about the day that my empeg stops working, I don't know of any other car audio unit that could come close to replacing it. Having to go back to swaping CDs in my car would feel like going back to the stone ages.

  52. Bluetooth was made for this type of thing! by sideshow · · Score: 1

    What would be even cooler if that when you pulled into your driveway the headunit and your home PC automagically sync with each other. Wouldn't that be badass?

    --

    Hollow words will burn and hollow men will burn.

  53. HD in my car? by patternjuggler · · Score: 1

    So now that I can play HD in my car, I need to rearranged the dash- get rid of the not-so-content-rich odometer and gas gauge and so on to be able to fit the plasma screen in.

  54. I got one better: USB input by Civil_Disobedient · · Score: 1

    For the life of me I can't figure out why no one has offered a headunit that supports USB jump drives.

    They're so damned ubiquitous nowadays -- just a single USB port to plug in media -- a card reader (for CompactFlash cards), a jump drive, etc. Let the end-user deal with buying the storage, I just want a unit that PLAYS what I put into it.

    Is this REALLY TO MUCH TO ASK FOR??

    I've seen a grand total of ONE manufacturer that has a unit with a USB input, and it goes for over $3000. And there's no internal amp.

    1. Re:I got one better: USB input by Nachtfalke · · Score: 1

      Your're probably looking for the Roadstar CD-655.
      Unfortunately, I haven't been able do find it on the manufacturers website, but I saw it in a newspaper ad a few weeks ago.

      And it's about 170 bucks.

  55. OmniFi: The solution by ajlitt · · Score: 2, Informative

    This is what you're looking for. It gives you the option to either sync with your home PC via 802.11b at regular intervals or to copy files via USB to the drive caddy. It's Linux based, though you need a Windows app to enable the wireless sync. It's also not particularly cheap. Still, this sounds like what you're looking for.

  56. All I need is a USB port with a Mass Storage DAP by unfortunateson · · Score: 1

    It would seem to me that a simple USB port and the ability to read the structure or database off a mass-storage compliant digital audio player would give you full artist/title browse access and full playback of anything from a thumbdrive to a 60GB player.

    The catch is that the 65+% iPod isn't mass-storage compliant, and their wire remote protocol is proprietary.

    It shouldn't cost much: if I can have a DVD player that sits on my home ethernet and reads anything uPNP, plays DVDs in progressive scan, has full digital audio outputs for $100, I should be able to get all the features I want for $50 over the cost of a standard head unit.

    --
    Design for Use, not Construction!
  57. Not to mention the .ogg support is missing! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Yes, and where's the promised .ogg support for UMS firmware which was due January 2004?!

    We don't want a stupid Manager firmware, get rid of it.

  58. what about Phatnoise? by qwerty1125 · · Score: 1

    Strange that nobody heard about Phatnoise or the Kenwood Music Keg. Beats anything on the market.
    http://www.phatnoise.com/

    1. Re:what about Phatnoise? by RickA · · Score: 1
      Phatbox = Fantastic piece of kit.

      Had a PhatBox in my car for over a year. Not had one problem in that time, does not skip on bumpy roads, and survives the huge yearly range of temperatures with the car parked outside.

      Plus, the voice navigation is truely the most logical and safest way to find that single track in your entire music collect that you just have to listen to right now. Best of all, it is single-cable plug-n-play in place of a CD-multi-changer in most cars.

      No wonder many car manufacturers (e.g. Audi, VW) are offering it as standard dealer-fit accessories on their cars.

    2. Re:what about Phatnoise? by Squall2131 · · Score: 1

      hey i'm really interested in that Phatnoise thing. Because i was actually goin to get a mp3 hardrive get a head unit, and plug and play in my car. This thing would be much better though. My only question is, is the cartridge for transfering files? or for trasnfering files, and listening outside the car? Does it act as a portable unit?

    3. Re:what about Phatnoise? by questionlp · · Score: 2

      I purchased a PhatNoise kit for my Audi A4 (price is pretty good for the unit, though the harness cable kit isn't exactly cheap) and am loving it. I'm saving up to get a 60GB hard drive module.

      Although most of the files on the hard drive module are MP3s from my CD collection, it handles FLAC files like a charm. I haven't tried playing any Ogg Vorbis files yet, but it is supported in the latest firmware revisions.

      Of course, it runs Linux (although I'm a BSD person) :)

    4. Re:what about Phatnoise? by qwerty1125 · · Score: 1

      the cartridge holds the music that you insert into the unit. Basically it's a 2.5" laptop hard drive in a plastic case. At home you put it into a cradle, in your car you insert it into the phatnoise/kenwood unit which is normally in your trunk or somewhere else. There are two flavors: phatnoise and kenwood Phatnoise makes units that work with factory head units. (audi/vw/bmw/nissan etc.) Kenwood licensed it and the kenwood keg works with the kenwood excelon head units.

    5. Re:what about Phatnoise? by Squall2131 · · Score: 1

      awesome man, thanks a lot for the info. I checked into it a little bit more and wow, is it pricey.. i may just go with my original idea

    6. Re:what about Phatnoise? by genixia · · Score: 1

      Beats anything on _new_ in the market, maybe.

      But a second-hand empeg will stomp all over a new phatnoise.

  59. iPod control kits by Otto · · Score: 1

    Denison has two versions of the iceLink system.. Version 2 information can be found at www.denison.com. It mainly supports foreign cars, but has more advanced capabilities.

    The older iceLink 1.1 can be found at www.denisonusa.com. It'll support many other types of cars, with less capability.

    A much wider range of support can be found in the iPod2Car adapter, available from www.ipod2car.com. It's similar to the iceLink 1.1 box, but supports more car types. Even very much older rides without more advanced in-car networking protocols and such.

    --
    - Give a man a fire and he's warm for a day, but set him on fire and he's warm for the rest of his life.
  60. What's wrong with mini-FM transmitters? by aquarian · · Score: 1

    In my experience, mini- FM transmitters sound cleaner than jacks, unless they're good quality RCA jacks. The mini-microphone-type jack you're likely to get on the front of a car stereo will eventually create enough static to drown out all the music, as will the pigtail you might use to connect to an RCA jack on the rear.

    FWIW, I've seen head units with these jacks on the front, and/or RCA jacks on the rear. I even had a cheaper Blaupunkt unit with an rear RCA input. It was fine for awhile, but in the end the mini- FM transmitter was a much cleaner, better sounding solution.

    Now, a head unit with an RCA jack on the front would be another story, but do you really want wires and crap cluttering up your car?

    I say make CD players ogg/mp3 compatible, and burn your own discs. You can get 11 hours of audio on each one -- enough for almost anyone. The theft risk would be a lot less than the latest-greatest-all-encompassing audio magic-box too.

  61. What's the point? by aquarian · · Score: 1

    You can fit 11 hours of good quality audio on a CD-R. This is enough for most people. It's also easier to find stuff by organizing it on your own CDs, than trying to search through 10,000 tracks on a fiddly little gadget interface. So get an mp3-compatible car stereo and burn your own disks. You'll enjoy less theft risk, too.

  62. Open space in Second. by phriedom · · Score: 1

    King Kaufman of Salon.com was recently discussing Barry Bonds' dominating stats for this year and looking for a new term for second when second is so far behind; when the difference between 1st and 2nd is the same as 2nd and 11th.

    The term suggested by a reader was : Mondale.

    --
    Don't moderate flamebait as Troll. Know the difference or you will be Meta-moderated.
  63. JUST READ A USB MASS STORAGE DEVICE! by theLOUDroom · · Score: 1

    Do you hear me iRiver/Clarion/Alpine/Anyone!

    I ALREADY HAVE AN MP3 PLAYER!
    I already have MP3s on it.

    It's just that the user interface was not designed for in car use. Read my current MP3 player as a standard mass storage device and give me a better user interface. Once designed for a guy who's driving.

    I don't want another MP3 player, I just want a better interface for the one I have.

    --
    Life is too short to proofread.
  64. Thanks!! by Civil_Disobedient · · Score: 1

    That's exactly what I was looking for! Thanks!

  65. Sad news, Britney Spears dead at 22 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


    Sad news, Britney Spears dead at 22

    I just heard some really sad news on Fox - Singer and Popstar Britney Jean Spears was found dead in her Louisana home this morning.

    Apparently, the cause of death was excessive bleeding after a sizzling night of hot anal sex with her ex. boyfriend, Justin Timberlake.

    "We were just having good sushi, and she asked me if I would please her", said Justin. Although he has since turned gay after his breakup with her, Justin was willing to please Britney as long as she would take it up her ass.

    Following a night of sex for 10 hours, Britney sustained an injury in her lower vaginal area and subsequently bled to death. Her husband Kevin Federline, who is at the moment spending time at a federal prison for sexual advances towards Natalie "hot grits" Portman was not available for comment.

    However, President George W Bush offered his comments on the incident. "Here is the reason why anal sex is bad and why gays are unAmerican, they kill Americans and American icons", he was quoted as saying.

    There weren't any more details. I'm sure everyone in the Slashdot community will surely miss her - even if you didn't enjoy her work, there's no denying her contributions to popular culture. Truly an American icon.

    *sob*

    Hit me baby, one more time. I'll miss you, oh baby baby.

    Indeed, Britney. Indeed. Rest in peace, child.

    Suck my dick. BITCHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH.