Slashdot Mirror


3D Computer Generated Movie From France

An anonymous reader submits a link to this Computer Graphics World article on a French-made film to be released in June. "A film by Xilam, Kaena is a full length feature film, entirely made from Off the shelf software. The previews looks amazing."

342 comments

  1. Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by mao+che+minh · · Score: 5, Insightful
    The voice of "The Almighty" in 'Clip 1' has to be that of Keith David, who also did Okkoto in Princess Mononoke. Maybe I'm wrong (which is probably the case), but it sure does sound like him.

    Beyond that little insight, judging by the available clips, this movie is looking damn good (albeit remaniscant of old cut scenes from Play Station 1 games like "Legacy of Kain" - just cleaner). While it's premise doesn't appear to be completely original, it is certainly going to be a great piece of fantasy in of itself. It's style of art is also a rather refreshing departure from the main stream stock of CG films, which tend to be rather "cartoony" (not that this is a bad thing, but it is nice to see something new).

    1. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by Bugaboo · · Score: 1

      You're correct; it is Keith David.

    2. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by terrab0t · · Score: 5, Interesting

      I thought the same thing about Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within, but the major downfall of that movie was that their characters were so detailed that people looked at them and expected to see the performance of an actor, which made the characters seem like zombies in their computer animated facial expressions and movements.

      Cartoon characters (even human ones) don't suffer from this because they are stylized enough to allow us to suspend our expectations of reality and just see them for what they represent. This is the main reason the big companies stick to stylized characters in cartoony situations; they don't have to worry about trying to simulate reality.

      Whether intentional or not, the characters in this film all have a very nice stylized look that may allow us to just see them as characters and not zombie like humans. It looks like a pretty beautiful film, and if it fails in the US it won't be for the same major reason Final Fantasy did.

    3. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by airuck · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Suspension of disbelief is not the only effect of stylization. Stylization can also create a more universal identification with characters. Scott McCloud covers the topic well in his book Understanding comics.

      --
      First entomology, then virology, and finally bioinformatics systems. Bugs follow me wherever I go.
    4. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


      I believe the movie was entitled "Surrender: The Art Of Rifle Dropping"

    5. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by Sycraft-fu · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Actually as I understand it a huge part of the problem with Final Fantasy was the WAY they decided to animate the facial expressions. In most CG type movies, like Shrek, standard practise is to film the voice actors, and the animators work off of that. If done right, the characters facial movements look right, since they follow the dialogue naturally. With Final Fantasy, it was all done seperatly, based on what the animators thought it should be. So it doesn't match up right with the way the lines were delivered.

    6. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by Silent_E · · Score: 2, Informative

      It is the voice of Keith David. You can read more about the production stats of the movie on IMDB

    7. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by Josuah · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Cartoon characters (even human ones) don't suffer from this because they are stylized enough to allow us to suspend our expectations of reality and just see them for what they represent. This is the main reason the big companies stick to stylized characters in cartoony situations; they don't have to worry about trying to simulate reality.

      However, using cartoony characters (i.e. Shrek, Pixar films) requires you to spend a lot of time at the other end of the spectrum. In other words, you have to work hard to make sure that your simulation of what is not reality, but instead exagerated physical activity, still meets up with the audience's expectations. Expectations based on what they've grown up with.

      One example I remember hearing about is when they needed to make a character sneak across the screen. Using the cartoony body with human-like sneaking did not make any sense at all. Sure, it was realistic looking for a human, but it wasn't "realistic looking" for the simulated character. Instead, you have to kind of make them stand on tippy toes, stick out their butt, pronounce the forward extension of their neck and head, etc.

      Of course, doing all that is probably easier anyway since there's most likely a lot more leeway as to what the audience will accept when you're working with exagerations.

    8. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by Josuah · · Score: 1

      They also do that voice actors first, animation of mouth movements second, in Anime films. I remember seeing this in the production extras of Akira's DVD release. They've formed a whole set of mouth shapes based on different vocal sounds and then animate the mouth shapes to match.

    9. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by balloonhead · · Score: 1
      Actually the main downfall with FF:TSW was that the plot and dialogue sucked.

      --
      This idea was invented by Shampoo.
    10. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You expected more from Square?

      That's the funny part about the entire FF:TSW fiasco. People who love the drek in Square's games demanded so much more from their movie.

      Go figure - I find I can get much greater enjoyment out of a well crafted game than any movie.

    11. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by nEoN+nOoDlE · · Score: 1

      the major reason Final Fantasy failed was that the plot was boring and the script was lame. I've spoken to computer artists as well as the "common" man and both groups had mostly positive things to say about the special effects in Final Fantasy. You can say what you want but they were incredible and unparalleled. Sure, some of the humans were pretty stiff and "zombie-like" but it didn't matter.

      The average person doesn't really care about good animation. That's why stuff like the Wild Thornberry Movie and Jimmy Neutron do pretty well in the box office.

      After seeing a few of the clips from this new movie on the site, the story and characters from what I've seen just don't look interesting. If it fails in the US box office, then it will probably be exactly why Final Fantasy did.

      --
      Don't trust a bull's horn, a doberman's tooth, a runaway horse or me.
    12. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by BadmanX · · Score: 1

      Uh...actually, in the "making of" short on the Spirited Away DVD, you can see that the voice acting is pretty much the very last thing they do - all the lip movements were animated beforehand. Japanese animators aren't as concerned with matching the lip movements to the actual dialog as American animators are.

    13. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by G3ckoG33k · · Score: 2, Funny

      "their characters were so detailed that people looked at them and expected to see the performance of an actor, which made the characters seem like zombies in their computer animated facial expressions and movements"

      And, since Doom 3 contains zombies we won't be too dissapponted seeing them all stiff, despite all details.

    14. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by ConceptJunkie · · Score: 1

      That must explain the recent Star Wars movies... but wait, in those movies the CG characters _are_ lifelike... it's the human actors who look like zombies.

      --
      You are in a maze of twisty little passages, all alike.
    15. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by Alphtoo · · Score: 1

      It would be nice to see France roll over and die. Fuck 'em in the ass and feed 'em fish heads... they'll LEARN to like it. Cowardly slimeball bastards. Flaimbait? Okay, go for it, and argue with me about it. Come on...

    16. Re:Nice to see artistic innovation in CG by mink · · Score: 1

      Actually, uh, he ws right about Akira, since it is in the LD extras as well.
      Most other anime does do voices last tho.

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
  2. Looks nice. by aeinome · · Score: 3, Insightful

    It certainly looks cool. The French outshine themselves again. I just hope the fact that it's French doesn't put people off.

    --
    When you don't have a leg to stand on, don't even get up.
    1. Re:Looks nice. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      >> The French outshine themselves again

      Ummm... Not to pick nits, but did France as a nation come together and make this film? No. A company, which happens to be located in France made it.

      When X-men 2 came out, did people say: "Wow, those Americans have done it again!" Probably not. The people of France did not make the movie. Some people who live there did... It sounds kind of condescending (like there are only 3 people in France, all of whom worked on this movie) to put it otherwise. (I'm an American, and frankly I'd be offended if people assumed all Americans believe in/produce most of the shit that comes out of Hollywood)

    2. Re:Looks nice. by User+956 · · Score: 5, Funny

      What are you talking about? I read the summary as follows:

      "An anonymous reader submits a link to this Computer Graphics World article on a Freedom-made film to be released in June."

      Now if you'll excuse me, I'm going to finish my Freedom Fries, and Freedom kiss my wife who's dressed up in a Freedom Maid outfit.

      --
      The theory of relativity doesn't work right in Arkansas.
    3. Re:Looks nice. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It certainly seems that all Americans -think- "the shit that comes out of Hollywood" is at least better than whatever anyone located somewhere else can produce.

      Just look at all the French bashing here when there have been a number of really good French movies just in the last couple of years.

    4. Re:Looks nice. by cfuse · · Score: 2

      It certainly looks cool. The French outshine themselves again. I just hope the fact that it's French doesn't put people off.

      Everyone knows that France is evil.

      It is totally unreasonable for France to put it's financial interests in Iraq ahead of America's financial interests in Iraq, isn't it?

      Now, lets all have a bowl of freedom fries!

    5. Re:Looks nice. by Malcontent · · Score: 1

      You could argue the same about the wine that is being poured in the gutters by the republicans.

      --

      War is necrophilia.

    6. Re:Looks nice. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They way those guys research I bet it's Californian wine too. :->

    7. Re:Looks nice. by B3ryllium · · Score: 1

      Actually, many scenes from X2 were filmed in British Columbia, Canada. :P

    8. Re:Looks nice. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And is Canada receiving any part of the hundreds of millions of dollars that the film is making? Or is a Hollywood company banking that loot?

    9. Re:Looks nice. by Joey7F · · Score: 1

      I heard that French wine (red wine) uses cow blood to give it color. If so, I'll stick to Spanish, Italian or good old homegrown stuff, thank you very much!

      --Joey

    10. Re:Looks nice. by javiercero · · Score: 1

      LOL, nope they use newborn babies for the coloring... it also adds that nice aftertaste.

      Ignorance is bliss I guess.....

    11. Re:Looks nice. by Archfeld · · Score: 1, Offtopic

      Here Here, It is amazing how America, a country that would probably NOT BE HERE if not for the French turns on a foriegn government and people, for doing EXACTLY what the US government is doing, securing future prosperity for itself and its' people. Does France not have an economy ? They've got the same problems we do and take very similar actions...for The US to point the finger is Hypocritical in the extreme, but I forget, that's what we do best...
      Note, I am a US citizen and proud of it, I did 4 years in the service, national guard mind you so it is the remedial service but I did volunteer.

      --
      errr....umm...*whooosh* *whoosh* Is this thing on ?
    12. Re:Looks nice. by FunkSoulBrother · · Score: 1

      They always refer to California as a "failed socialist expiriment" anyhow, so they probably don't care...

    13. Re:Looks nice. by philovivero · · Score: 1

      Now if you'll excuse me, I'm going to finish my Freedom Fries, and Freedom kiss my wife who's dressed up in a Freedom Maid outfit.

      Fnord.

    14. Re:Looks nice. by Malcontent · · Score: 1

      Yes and those israelis drink the blood of arabs, liberals hate america and fox news is fair and balanced.

      --

      War is necrophilia.

    15. Re:Looks nice. by Soft · · Score: 1
      I heard that French wine (red wine) uses cow blood to give it color.

      To filter it, you mean? That's been forbidden in Europe since 1997 (see for example a related urban legend); other animal substances are used now.

    16. Re:Looks nice. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hrm. I think you misunderstand how a boycott works. Because this movie is from a French company, I won't pay money to see it.

    17. Re:Looks nice. by Eunuchswear · · Score: 1
      Hey, the wine had already been paid for, who cares if the idiots want to waste it. They'll just have to buy more wine to replace it, which increases the amount sold, which drives the price up, which makes French wine growers happy.

      Isn't it fun when your "enemies" are economic illiterates.

      --
      Watch this Heartland Institute video
    18. Re:Looks nice. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You do realize that France's motive for helping America during the revolutionary war was to install a puppet state to use against the British later on, don't you?

    19. Re:Looks nice. by SubtleNuance · · Score: 1

      Why would its French Origin put anyone off? The French have a very respected film industry - Ive seen alot of French films...

    20. Re:Looks nice. by SubtleNuance · · Score: 1

      a country that would probably NOT BE HERE if not for the French turns on a foriegn government and people, for doing EXACTLY what the US government is doing
      What are you saying?

    21. Re:Looks nice. by digerata · · Score: 1

      Its mutual. France would probably not be here either, if not for us. Are we so single minded that we forget our recent history of world wars?

      --

      1;
    22. Re:Looks nice. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's French origin will effectively ruin any chance this film had of making money in the U.S. Most people here hate the French and would kill them before associating with them. I know people actively planning atrocities against the French. I wish them well.

    23. Re:Looks nice. by kurosawdust · · Score: 1
      Now if you'll excuse me, I'm going to finish my Freedom Fries, and Freedom kiss my wife who's dressed up in a Freedom Maid outfit.

      Dammit! I was all set to make some joke asking why you dress up in a French Maid outfit when you kiss your wife - dangle your participles next time!

    24. Re:Looks nice. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'm afraid that you have not experienced French 'culture' to its fullest extent.

      The French have carry a strong resentment of the US and its citizens. It's so pervasive in their culture that US tourists expect to be treated with rudeness and discourtesy.

      Of course, the response of the ignorant is that the French are simply intolerant of American tourists who simply assume that everyone speaks English. This is simply untrue.

      The French are simply arrogant bigots. Your French could be linguistically perfect, and you will be treated like trash, especially if you look like you are from somewhere other than France.

      The Parisians are the worst, believing that even the non-Parisians are second-class citizens.

      I was vacationing in Paris, watching the news. On came a story about the separatist movement in Quebec. The news was playing back the story from a French-Canadian news show, and was subtitling it! This would be analagous to England subtitling CNN...

    25. Re:Looks nice. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      I just hope the fact that it's French doesn't put people off.

      Oh, you mean racists?

    26. Re:Looks nice. by Archfeld · · Score: 1

      I've been there several times, I found that outside Paris the problem was MUCH LESS prevalent.
      But by the same token the Average Westerner is treated with the same veiled inferiority in Japan, and DO NOT ATTEMPT to speak Japanease unless you've MASTERED the language. What kind of reception do you think most folks get in say NYC ? not good I bet :)
      I make no excuses for anyone least of all ourselves but it is not a reaction or attitude limited to the French, just listen in at a nice British place and get the genereal reaction of the average Brit to an American, we are ignorant, savages barely capable of civilized behavior on a good day. I won't even begin to talk about the Northern European's view of america :)

      I travel alot btw :) My job keeps me hopping continents 6-8 times a year.

      --
      errr....umm...*whooosh* *whoosh* Is this thing on ?
    27. Re:Looks nice. by Joey7F · · Score: 1

      Yup, that's what I was talking about. I guess I was wrong :p

      --Joey

    28. Re:Looks nice. by Archie+Steel · · Score: 1

      Of course, the funny thing with all this is that those idiots who first thought up of "freedom fries" and "freedom toast" have basically introduced a "France == Freedom" meme into the national psyche. (Which is fitting, since it is part of the national motto: Liberté, Égalité, Fraternité)

      --

      Reminder: find a new sig
    29. Re:Looks nice. by Pig+Hogger · · Score: 1
      Of course, the funny thing with all this is that those idiots who first thought up of "freedom fries" and "freedom toast" have basically introduced a "France == Freedom" meme into the national psyche. (Which is fitting, since it is part of the national motto: Liberté, Égalité, Fraternité)
      Heck, FRANCE , the word itself, means FREE , as free from slavery.
    30. Re:Looks nice. by Pig+Hogger · · Score: 1
      Its mutual. France would probably not be here either, if not for us. Are we so single minded that we forget our recent history of world wars?
      Well, ACTUALLY, the USA didn't do much to help France during world-war II. And that, thanks to that überbastard extraordinaire sonovabitch, Franklin Delano Roosevelt.

      First of all, the US waited two fucking years before getting involved,
      Second, instead of backing the Free French who pursued the fight against the nazis, the US backed the Vichy fascist régime of nazi-occupied France, at least until the end of 1944, then the US grudigingly accepted to recognize the legitimity of Free France, but still not without considerably hindering Free France's fighting efforts. Heck, Roosevelt even decided to let the nazis re-occupy Strasbourg and retreat (luckily, top military brass was appalled as such cowardice - only a utter coward would lob atomic bombs on civilians - and the allies managed to insure that Strasbourg would not get re-occupied again).
      Third, when it "liberated" France, the Roosevelt wanted in reality to occupy it and destroy it's industrial capability, in order to make them dependent on US industrial products...

      It was not until that Charles de Gaulle drove home the point that the Résistance - which was so instrumental in bringing down the nazis - would turn against the yankees that the US finally relented and decided to abandon it's wrecking plans.

    31. Re:Looks nice. by Pieroxy · · Score: 1

      Heck, FRANCE , the word itself, means FREE , as free from slavery.

      Hmmm, I didn't know that.

      I thought FRANCE came from the FRANC people. And Franc means honest in French, not free.

      But I am not an ethymologist. I'll leave that to you if you can elaborate

    32. Re:Looks nice. by Pieroxy · · Score: 1

      I'm afraid that you have not experienced French 'culture' to its fullest extent.

      It's really sad to hear crap like that. Do you mean by going a week to France as a tourist you did experience French culture in its fullest extent? You're just sickening.

      The French have carry a strong resentment of the US and its citizens. It's so pervasive in their culture that US tourists expect to be treated with rudeness and discourtesy.

      It just feels wrong, specially since you take a French Canadian as an example in your post. The same thing is felt by all tourists, not only US. Once again, stop thinking as yourself as the center of the world. There are almost 6 billion people out there that are not americans. You sound like a French !!! ;-)

      Of course, the response of the ignorant is that the French are simply intolerant of American tourists who simply assume that everyone speaks English. This is simply untrue.

      The French are simply arrogant bigots. Your French could be linguistically perfect, and you will be treated like trash, especially if you look like you are from somewhere other than France.


      The french reaction is basically closer to shyness than anything else. You'll find out that the average French citizen speak an awfull english, and is aware of it. What is behind the perceived arrogance is very often an unwillingness to reveal their "weakness" to a stranger / unknown people.

      The Parisians are the worst, believing that even the non-Parisians are second-class citizens.

      Sure. NYC people think only good of Californians girls and Californians think only good things about East coast people. You're damn right, the parisians are the only people on earth to have this behavior (You know, friendly hating their neighbors). Look around dude!

      I was vacationing in Paris, watching the news. On came a story about the separatist movement in Quebec. The news was playing back the story from a French-Canadian news show, and was subtitling it! This would be analagous to England subtitling CNN...

      You'll probably find that very difficult to believe, but the Canadian accent is _very_ disturbing to a french listener, sometimes to a point where it's difficult to understand.

      That is perhaps due to the fact that far less people speak french than english and so French people are less used to hear different accents.

      I once heard an interview of a farmer from a very rural part of France and I was glad it was subtitled.

    33. Re:Looks nice. by Pig+Hogger · · Score: 1

      And Franc means honest in French, not free.

      FRANC3, FRANCHE, adj.
      I. Qui est libre.
      A. [En parlant d'une pers.]
      1. Vieilli. Qui est libre; p. oppos. à serf, à esclave. Les gens de la ville, ceux de Vilschberg et de Hâzelbourg étaient de condition franche; mais (...) ceux des autres villages, tant hommes que femmes, étaient serfs (ERCKM.-CHATR., Hist. paysan, t. 1, 1870, p. 5). V. franchise ex. 1 :
      1. On a là [dans la Chanson des Loherains] un fort bel et fort distinct épisode de la vie féodale dans les premiers
      siècles : une scène de famille d'abord (...) une chasse en pleine forêt; une grande et noble figure de gentilhomme, de franc homme, séparé de sa suite (...) se défendant contre une bande de gens de rien enhardis par l'espoir du butin et d'une riche proie.
      SAINTE-BEUVE, Prem. lundis, t. 3, 1869, p. 152.
      Rem. À l'oppos. franc/esclave a été substituée l'oppos. libre esclave.
      2. Qui n'a ni gêne, ni entrave; qui est sans contrainte.
      Avoir les coudées franches. Ne pas être gêné à table par ses voisins. Il veut avoir ses coudées franches (Ac. 1835, 1878).
      Au fig. Avoir l'esprit libre, ne pas être gêné par quelque contrainte (morale ou extérieure) que ce soit. M. Brisson s'est débarrassé de ses impedimenta de programmes pour avoir ses coudées franches dans la noble entreprise de rendre ce pays à lui-même (CLEMENCEAU, Iniquité, 1899, p. 441) :
      2. Je n'arrive pas à retrouver la tranquillité d'esprit dont j'aurais pourtant si besoin (...) je sens que si j'avais mes
      coudées franches, aucune des choses que je désespérais avant la guerre de pouvoir accomplir, ne résisterait à la pression d'une attention non préoccupée.
      DU BOS, Journal, 1922, p. 101.
      Corps franc. Petit corps de troupe composé de volontaires pendant la guerre, et n'appartenant pas à l'armée régulière. Ton neveu (...) en 1815, a fait partie de ce régiment de brigands appelés corps francs, levé contre les Prussiens (STENDHAL, Lamiel, 1842, p. 60). Unité légère d'infanterie dotée d'une certaine autonomie, spécialement entraînée pour exécuter isolément des missions délicates. La région de Tabarca défendue par le corps franc du général de Monsabert et les tabors marocains (DE GAULLE, Mém. guerre, 1956, p. 99). Cf. franc-tireur.
      Être franc de + subst. Être exempt de. Le roi ordonnait que les habitants de Greux et de Domremy fussent francs de toutes tailles, aides, subsides et subventions (FRANCE, J. d'Arc, t. 1, 1908, p. 524).
      Au fig., vieilli. Être franc de toute passion, franc d'ambition. ,,Libre et exempt de toute passion, d'ambition`` (Ac. 1798- 1932). Un rire si franc de coquetterie, qu'il devait être ou bien hardi, ou bien innocent (SOULIÉ, Mém. diable, t. 1, 1837, p. 119).
      MAR. Barre franche. ,,Barre de gouvernail que l'on manoeuvre directement à la main sans l'intermédiaire d'une roue`` (GRUSS 1952). Gouverner à barre franche (LITTRÉ).
      SP. Coup* franc.
      3. Qui est moralement libre; qui agit de sa propre volonté. Ayez le courage de me suivre, et si votre volonté est franche, si votre conscience est libre, si votre esprit sait unir deux propositions (PROUDHON, Propriété, 1840, p. 133).
      Franc arbitre. Cf. franc- A 2 et libre-arbitre.
      B. [En parlant de qqc.] Qui est exempt de charges, de droits, de taxes; qui ne paie pas de taxes, d'impôts. Ici, vous cultivez des terres franches et libres, et ne travaillez que pour vous-même, puisque vous ne payez ni redevances, ni impositions (CRÈVECOEUR, Voyage, t. 3, 1801, p. 139).
      Familier
      Franche lippée (vieilli) ,,Repas qu

    34. Re:Looks nice. by Pieroxy · · Score: 1

      ok, thanks, I forgot about this meaning of the word...

    35. Re:Looks nice. by Hognoxious · · Score: 1
      I know people actively planning atrocities against the French. I wish them well.
      Knowing the Yanks' track record, they'll probably hit England by mistake.
      --
      Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
  3. in case of slashdotting.. by CowBovNeal · · Score: 3, Informative

    Although new to the 3D feature film scene, Xilam Animation in Paris opted for the road less traveled for Kaena: The Prophecy by choosing a mature style for the characters, environments, and story line. All images ©2003 Xilam Films, StudioCanal, and TVA International IV.

    Some things are worth waiting for. And, from the looks of it, the 3D feature film Kaena: The Prophecy is one of them.

    Five years in the making, the 90-minute adventure from Xilam Animation in Paris boldly departs from the tried-and-true cartoon-like look of such US blockbusters as Toy Story, Monsters, Inc., and Ice Age, and introduces a unique painterly style to evolve its sophisticated character-driven story. Also impressive is the fact that the digital artists created this feature entirely with commercial software, which forced them to overcome technical challenges by creatively applying the tools at hand, rather than developing specialized code.

    Even Kaena's story line deviates significantly from those of its US film cousins. Rather than presenting a humorous children's tale, the movie explores a serious theme directed at teen and adult audiences, although occasionally two worm-like characters offer a dose of comic relief. Kaena unfolds within the fantasy world of a giant tree, known as the Axis, which is inhabited by a tribe of people whose main focus is harvesting the tree's sap, which they then offer to the gods. When the sap begins to dry up, a young woman called Kaena (voiced by Kirsten Dunst) leaves her village to find the root of the problem and a solution. A courageous dreamer, Kaena travels to the forbidden region beneath the clouds. There, she encounters a host of unusual and sometimes hostile creatures, including the Selenites, a race that is also trying to save the tree from impending doom, albeit through the enslavement of others.

    "The story is also about the unlikely heroine's journey from childhood to adulthood as she defies authority, traditions, and beliefs in pursuit of her own truths and personal identity--a topic that transcends cultural borders," explains director Chris Delaporte.

    In addition to Dunst, a number of other well-known American actors and actresses--including Angelica Houston as queen of the Selenites and Richard Harris as the 600-year-old extraterrestrial Opaz--are likewise lending their voices to the Kaena cast. Because the film is intended for worldwide release, it has been produced in English and will be dubbed in local languages. The production is scheduled to open next month in France, followed by worldwide release this fall. (Xilam was still negotiating a deal for US distribution at press time.)

    At first glance, Kaena's overall look and feel is reminiscent of computer games, with its fantastic settings and goal-oriented characters. "The style of the environments will be more familiar to computer game players than moviegoers," contends Delaporte. In fact, he and writer-partner Patrick Daher conceived the project as a game in 1997, pitching it to the newly formed Chaman Productions (Paris), which was focused on producing digital content for games and television.

    Impressed by the rich, unusual environments, Chaman's founder chose to expand the project to include a feature film, formerly called Axis, that would be released alongside the game (Computer Graphics World, March 2000, pg. 33). Alas, the ambitious goal of creating a full-length CG film proved too lofty for the start-up. Despite having approximately half the film and game completed, Chaman relinquished control to Xilam, a traditional animation company with expertise in 3D, having developed several computer games and 2D/3D television series. Xilam has since completed the Kaena film and game, with Delaporte still serving as director.
    Cinema Roots

    "Telling a story for 90 minutes for a film is far more difficult than telling one in a half-hour for television," says Marc Du Pontavice, chairman and CEO of Xilam. "When it comes to cinema, the story alone cannot carry a project like it can in br

    --
    Bush is on fire and its not good for my lungs.
    1. Re:in case of slashdotting.. by General+Sherman · · Score: 1

      Commercial sites tend not to get slashdotted, it's only poor people who post personal things on the web on their measly little account designed just for a couple of friends.

      --
      - Sherman
    2. Re:in case of slashdotting.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      For those who didn't notice, this isn't CowboyNeal. It's CowbovNeal, apparently, which means he's probably posting that bit of stolen text to collect karma points for trolling purposes.

    3. Re:in case of slashdotting.. by ThomaMelas · · Score: 1

      Yep, and the FCC is a rinky dink little website being run off some guy's dsl line. How many times has Slashdot broken them? ;)

    4. Re:in case of slashdotting.. by critter_hunter · · Score: 1

      Selenites eh? In French, a Selenite is an inhabitant of the moon (from Selene, greek goddess of the moon)

      --
      Karma: Could be worse (could be raining)
    5. Re:in case of slashdotting.. by caino59 · · Score: 1

      go try one of the direct links to d/l, or see how long that movie takes to load.

      then tell me that this commercial site isnt being affected by some serious surfage.

    6. Re:in case of slashdotting.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      good work, sherlock

    7. Re:in case of slashdotting.. by General+Sherman · · Score: 1

      Slashdotted is when the server actually goes down and you can't access anything, on this one, it's still quite viewable.

      --
      - Sherman
    8. Re:in case of slashdotting.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You're welcome, ignorant piece of shit.

    9. Re:in case of slashdotting.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      never said it was /.'d.

      just taking on extremely heavey load. and the sight is viewable, but barely...

      and go ahead, try to d/l one of the clips, and prepare to wait for a milenia ;oP

  4. Wow by General+Sherman · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Using just off-the-shelf stuff, that's really amazing. I wish I could be that good with Bryce =/. It looks like the storyline could be equally amazing, but I'm wondering if there will also be an english release around the same time. It looks that way from the site, but I hope to see this in a theater near me.

    --
    - Sherman
    1. Re:Wow by stubear · · Score: 1

      I don't know if you were being sarcastic or not but just for your information, this movie looks like it was done in 3DSMAX R4 or R5. There are a couple screenshots in the making of section that clearly show 3DSMAX.

    2. Re:Wow by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The movie *is* in english, because they've got it scheduled for world-wide release (right after it premieries in france).

      Showings in other markets (non-english)will be dubbed accordingly.

    3. Re:Wow by Blaine+Hilton · · Score: 4, Informative
      They used, and I quote from the article:

      toolbox

      Modeling/Animation
      character studio, 3ds max Discreet
      www.discreet.com

      Texturing
      Painter Procreate www.procreate.com
      Photoshop Adobe Systems www.adobe.com

      Lip synchronization
      FatLips 3D Yulsoft www.yulsoft.com

      compositing
      Shake Apple Computer www.apple.com
      flame Discreet www.discreet.com

      hair
      shag:hair Digimation www.digimation.com
      ClothReyes Reyes Infografica www.reyes-infografica.net/company.php

      fluids
      RealFlow NextLimit www.nextlimit.com

      rendering
      3ds max, flame Discreet www.discreet.com

      data management
      alienbrain VFX NXN Software www.nxn-software.com

    4. Re:Wow by General+Sherman · · Score: 1

      what I was trying to say is that I don't think I could do a single fram of that in Bryce.

      --
      - Sherman
    5. Re:Wow by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No, you couldn't. Neither could they. Bryce is almost completely unsuitable for this kind of work.

    6. Re:Wow by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      RTFA. It's an international release: Done in English, with subtitles for approprate regions. Look who the actors are.

    7. Re:Wow by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Bryce is kiddie software, for teenage 3d modeler/animator wannabes and nothing more. You reveal your ignorance in thinking that a terrain generation piece of software could be used for to make anything close to character animation. Hell, real modelers wouldn't use Bryce even for terrain generation- it's such a pile of shit.

      protecting my precious karma

    8. Re:Wow by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You can, however, make a tacky terrain and skycube for a videogame with bryce, which is pretty much its intended purpose.

  5. Re:BOYCOTT!!! by General+Sherman · · Score: 0, Troll

    It's not that I like the French that much, it's just that you seem to be a member of a certain southern group of people that were dropped as children, the KKK. I know you're just trolling, but don't you have anything better to do than act like a complete ass on the internet? Annonymous Coward indeed.

    --
    - Sherman
  6. Wrong label by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    I think the term is "Freedom film."

    1. Re:Wrong label by rjamestaylor · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      It's a film about peace through capitulation

      --
      -- @rjamestaylor on Ello
  7. Must have fixed the technical problems by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Funny

    Did they fix the problem in the French renderers where the polygons kept surrendering during ray tracing?

    1. Re:Must have fixed the technical problems by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh yes they did, they haven't fixed the one where Americans say yes to whatever a jackass tells them to do.

    2. Re:Must have fixed the technical problems by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      American fuckwit, shut the fuck up.

  8. Direct link by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Direct link

    Awesome trailer, I'm definately gonna see this one

  9. sounds to me... by arhines · · Score: 1

    ...like the "made entirely with off-the-shelf software" comment is more of an excuse than a "cool" factor thing. Watching the trailer I find the story interesting, some of the environment pretty, but the characters terribly animated. This is where the off-the-shelf deal comes in. All that says is that they didn't have the dough to deal with motion capture, and it shows in the character movements.

  10. Um, WOW. by Limburgher · · Score: 2, Funny

    Take THAT, France-bashers. :) This looks really cool.

    --

    You are not the customer.

    1. Re:Um, WOW. by Malcontent · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      Don't worry republicans won't be watching this film. Anything that comes out of france is filthy and immoral, if you don't believe me just ask fox news.

      --

      War is necrophilia.

    2. Re:Um, WOW. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      On the other hand, they'll rent and watch it when nobody's watching.

      They always do.

    3. Re:Um, WOW. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh?
      Lets bet that while it has great potential, the french find some way to make it completly boring and anti-climatic.

    4. Re:Um, WOW. by gl4ss · · Score: 2, Interesting

      you know hitler was big into american(actually any) films..

      he even saw chaplins dictator, twice.

      --
      world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
    5. Re:Um, WOW. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ahhh...malcontent...the commie troll returns...

      story about the french traitors doing artsy fartsy crap(read:who cares) and he's on the front lines with cheap shots at republicans,etc(read his latest posts).
      It's nice that you've found a bunch of neo-socialists here on dork-dot that you can do your little "communism DOES work" circle jerk with (posts goto +2..karma??! beh..)
      But back in the REAL world(that you hate so much)
      -the french STILL suck...hard...AGAIN
      -socialism STILL DOESN'T WORK(see kalifonica 'welfare-state' itself into oblivion)
      -cuba makes people disappear for wrongthink and hollywierd sucks castro's dick and calls it icing sugar ...AGAIN

      same old whining from you, mal...now crawl out of your basement...your mom wants you to mow the lawn, and throw away that old red beret

    6. Re:Um, WOW. by actor_au · · Score: 1

      Pearl Harbour.
      Scream 1-3.
      National Security.
      Anything with Adam Sandler.
      Crossroads.
      Glitter.
      Final Destination 1-2.
      Dreamcatcher.
      Phone Booth.
      Old School.
      The Hours.
      Kangaroo Jack.
      Jurrasic Park 3.
      Meet the Parents.
      Minority Report.

      Yes, hopefully the French won't try to hard to copy the American model of film production.

      --
      Read Errant Story.
  11. So this is by Faust7 · · Score: 3, Funny

    "Le Tron"?

    1. Re:So this is by baywulf · · Score: 1, Funny

      Looks like the web server has surrendered already.

    2. Re:So this is by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      So has your sense of humour.

  12. Just a little by Froze · · Score: 1, Informative

    WHORING, for the plugin impaired.
    On linux distros xine plays THIS quite nicely. Just a direct link to the trailer.

    --
    -- The morphemes of your disquisition are ascertainable, but they have eschewed an ambit of transpicuous exposition.
    1. Re:Just a little by powerlinekid · · Score: 1

      MPlayer will play it too.

      --

      can't sleep slashdot will eat me
  13. Re:Something isn't right by Pierre · · Score: 1

    You have obviously not been hanging out witht he same french women as me.

  14. Re:BOYCOTT!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    General Sherman speaking ill of the KKK...

    Beyatch

  15. Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows! by mariox19 · · Score: 1

    It is a sad testament to what Motorola's snail-slow chip hath wrought, that this movie was apparently done on a Wintel machine (judging from the screen shots).

    As a long time Mac user, I can only hope the IBM chips save the day. It seems Apple is fading from the graphics scene, and no doubt because of rendering times.

    --

    quiquid id est, timeo puellas et oscula dantes.

    1. Re:Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Shouldn't have been a problem...

      Most of the renderers support distributed rendering now, so a Mac front end hooked into a LinTel rendering cluster shoul've done the job just fine.

    2. Re:Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      When was the last time you heard anything about the IBM chip?
      I haven't heard a peep.
      http://macnet2.com/more.php?id=338_0_1_0

    3. Re:Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows! by Thanatiel · · Score: 1

      What "Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows!" means please, in english ?

      Thanks

      --
      Irrelevant news and morons using moderation to mod down what they disagree on. 2018 resolution: so long.
    4. Re:Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows" means "My God! It's (the) Windows"

    5. Re:Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows! by Thanatiel · · Score: 1

      Ok, then there should not be a "le" in front of "Windows".

      --
      Irrelevant news and morons using moderation to mod down what they disagree on. 2018 resolution: so long.
    6. Re:Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      but how much more would that cost than just using a cheap wintel machine? many people might like macs, but how much are you willing to pay just for eye candy

    7. Re:Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows! by stiller · · Score: 1

      At least all of the Shake compositing was done on Macs and I guess they used Macs for a large portion of the photoshop work too. How you can judge Wintel use from the screen shots is beyond me. (A keen eye for color calibration?)

    8. Re:Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows! by mariox19 · · Score: 1

      Well, I'm not exactly a native speaker, but in other languages they put the article where we would not. My sense of the language led me to putting it there.

      Didn't realize you were a French grammarian. I'll have my corrections on your desk, Monday morning.

      --

      quiquid id est, timeo puellas et oscula dantes.

    9. Re:Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows! by mariox19 · · Score: 1

      I saw the little "x" in the upper right corner (close box).

      --

      quiquid id est, timeo puellas et oscula dantes.

    10. Re:Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows! by Thanatiel · · Score: 1

      I hope you are not taking it the wrong way. (Sorry if you are.)
      I usually like to improve myself with english or other languages (Which happens a lot. Usually as soon as I speak.).

      btw: is there a way to send messages personally? It buggers me to discuss on the forum.

      --
      Irrelevant news and morons using moderation to mod down what they disagree on. 2018 resolution: so long.
    11. Re:Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows! by Robot+Messiah · · Score: 1
      At least all of the Shake compositing was done on Macs and I guess they used Macs for a large portion of the photoshop work too.


      What makes you think any of it was done on a Mac?

      Shake is now owned by Apple, but it's been around on Windows and Linux PCs for yonks (a yonk is a measure of time, y'all). Shake still exists for Windows and Linux, but Apple have pulled back support for those versions. Support for those versions was just fine, however, for most of the duration (five years) of the project in question.

      The 3D software mentioned in the article is all exclusive to Windows PCs. There are no Mac versions. Assuming every desk in the studio had a computer of some description on (or under) it, the studio managers would have wanted to be absolutely sure that every machine was available for rendering. Except the Flame, of course, which is a different (not a Mac either) beast.

      Can't render on a Mac. A Mac has no unique value in a VFX/animation studio. PCs are cheaper, faster and easier to connect to other the other PCs, which of course you need for the 3D work.

      How can you judge Wintel use? RTFA, use common sense.


      Common sense is now available at Fry's.
    12. Re:Mon Dieu! C'est le Windows! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      But "Le" is so french...

      I'm french and its a lot less funny without the "Le".

  16. More cartoon than movie... by newsdee · · Score: 4, Informative

    ...but still impressive nonetheless.

    Nice to see creativity from France. This is a nice addition to this upcoming French anime series ("Molly Star Racer").

    Check out the trailer, it very neat. :-)

    1. Re:More cartoon than movie... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No thanks. I hate French people and their products. In fact, I will kill them before I associate with them.

    2. Re:More cartoon than movie... by makapuf · · Score: 1
      Nice to see creativity from France.


      Maybe you haven't seen some of the famous french viedogames before ? (Like Rayman, .. can't remind all of them now)
      Disclaimer : I'm French.
    3. Re:More cartoon than movie... by Aliencow · · Score: 1

      And the amazing Splinter Cell by Ubisoft...Oh wait..that was done in Montreal ! Disclaimer: I'm Canadian/Québecois

    4. Re:More cartoon than movie... by Explo · · Score: 1


      Maybe you haven't seen some of the famous french viedogames before ? (Like Rayman, .. can't remind all of them now)


      I remember games such as Kult, Purple Saturn Day etc. created by Exxos and distributed by Infogrames label; those were very different from the average 2d-shoot'em'ups and other similar games of the late 80s.

      --
      Everyone who makes generalizations should be shot.
  17. It looks cool. by AmiNTT · · Score: 1
    I have to admit, at first, I was annoyed because it didn't work properly in Opera. [Grrrr]

    The trailer (in QT) looks fantastic, as it was pretty jerky in WM. Too bad they have it steaming, otherwise it could be mirrored all over.

    The art is fantastic! I look forward to seeing this when it gets here.

    1. Re:It looks cool. by sparrow_hawk · · Score: 1

      Uh... dude, haven't you heard of wget? I've got it in Quicktime format on my hard drive if anyone wants it. :)

  18. Plot Synopsis by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Jaques:Where is my cheese?

    Lezous:I surrender.

    The End

    1. Re:Plot Synopsis by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hauh Hauh Hauh! Tres bien

  19. Could this be the first of an e-Renaissance? by Thaidog · · Score: 1

    Wow... it does look good... Could this be the first of an electronic renaissance for France? Computers are obviously the next level in art...

    --

    ||| I still can't believe Parkay's not butter.

    1. Re:Could this be the first of an e-Renaissance? by ogre2112 · · Score: 1

      It's one company in France. I doubt the entire country pitched in.

    2. Re:Could this be the first of an e-Renaissance? by Thaidog · · Score: 1

      What I meant was this could be the beginning of startups in Europe similar to this... This primarily a North American market... No the whole country did not chip in... what a stupid comment... did the whole country chip in in the 1st renaissance? Or in any oil painting... my art degree says no jackass...

      --

      ||| I still can't believe Parkay's not butter.

    3. Re:Could this be the first of an e-Renaissance? by Freon115 · · Score: 1

      Actually, there are a few french start ups, or even experimented firms, in the CGI field. We have great computer art schools too. They mainly works on SFX, sometimes for US movies too. And don't forget the first digital movie ever shot was French! (Vidoq, made by the guy who made the SFX on Alien 4).

    4. Re:Could this be the first of an e-Renaissance? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Fuck you, bitch. I'll kill you french faggots before I ever use your gay ass products, you motherfucking piece of shit.

    5. Re:Could this be the first of an e-Renaissance? by mink · · Score: 1

      The above clearly believes the french have no word for entrepreneur.

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
  20. Re:Just a little more whoring. by jon_c · · Score: 0, Redundant

    link to the Offical site, movies, about etc..

    looks awesome IMO.

    -Jon

    --
    this is my sig.
  21. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  22. 64000 hrs to render by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    if you look under 'The Making Of' section you it is quoted that this movie will require 64000 hr to render. that means this movie wont be ready for another 7 years! :)

    1. Re:64000 hrs to render by MShook · · Score: 1

      Damn you're clever. I guess they'll use a render farm... :-D

  23. Off the shelf software? by ScottGant · · Score: 5, Informative

    Well, pretty much all animation/sfx is founded in "off the shelf software".

    Maya, Softimage/XSI, Lightwave...I'm sure all of these packages are on a shelf SOME where...

    Of course, when you read about movies that use such software, the fx houses always add "combination of Maya and XSI...with special software written by us". This usually is tacked on because they don't want ordinary people thinking they could do the same thing. They want to keep the apperance of wizardry like the old days.

    But the custom software is usually written in Maya script language and such...which is very powerful btw.

    --

    "Music is everybody's possession. It's only publishers who think that people own it." - John Lennon.
    1. Re:Off the shelf software? by ScottGant · · Score: 1

      Well, Pixar is moving away from Marrionete, if you look at the making of Monsters, Inc you can see where Sully is modeled in Maya.

      But most of the stuff Hollywood uses is still off the shelf, the software that they write comes in to make everything work together.

      Or else they would never get new talent running through there. Look at ILM, it used to be a sweat-shop and the turnover rate was big for a time...too hard to train on proprietary software.

      --

      "Music is everybody's possession. It's only publishers who think that people own it." - John Lennon.
    2. Re:Off the shelf software? by ScottGant · · Score: 1

      Don't get me wrong, you're not going to get a Shrek or Monsters, Inc from off the shelf stuff, but off the shelf stuff is the FOUNDATION of most things...which is the point I was trying to make, but as usual I use a sledgehammer instead of a tweezer to bang out my ideas.

      --

      "Music is everybody's possession. It's only publishers who think that people own it." - John Lennon.
    3. Re:Off the shelf software? by 90XDoubleSide · · Score: 2, Informative
      Well, Pixar is moving away from Marrionete, if you look at the making of Monsters, Inc you can see where Sully is modeled in Maya.

      Pixar has always done their modeling in Maya; Marionette only does animation. Mainstream software is definitely being used in more and more of the production, however.

      --
      "Reality is just a convenient measure of complexity" -Alvy Ray Smith
    4. Re:Off the shelf software? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Im no fanboy, but Lightwave is about the cheapest box and has been used a lot in the industry. Arguably has the nicest renderer of all over-the-shelf packages, but people's reactions to UI are a bit love it or hate it. About a thousand (UK) pounds if memory serves.

    5. Re:Off the shelf software? by mnemonic_ · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Lightwave having the best renderer of all of the off-the-shelf packages? Definitely not. Softimage would have to take the crown their with Mental Ray as its standard renderer (hypervoxels be damned).

      Maya Complete is only about 1,500 GBP, and has real NURBS support, infinitely better animation abilities and a far more powerful shading interface. Its GUI is almost as drawn out and tedious as Lightwave's though.

    6. Re:Off the shelf software? by Psychic+Burrito · · Score: 1

      with the exception of one scene in a "A Bug's Life" (which required raytracing)

      I'm just wondering: Which scene is that?

    7. Re:Off the shelf software? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Its the sscene with the grasshoppers in the "mexican" bar, there is a large glass bottle of nuts. The scene was actually rendered using PRMan but using anither renderer (which just might possibly have been BMRT) for raytracing via a dynamic shader operation. The ray traced portion of the scene was actually a cut down version of the main scene using an environement map.

      <blatant-plug>
      Anyone with a copy of BMRT lying around that wants to play with this technique might like to check out Aqsis (www.aqsis.com), which supports DSO shadeops and works with the PRMan rayserver support.
      </blatant-plug>

    8. Re:Off the shelf software? by May+Kasahara · · Score: 1
      Pixar has always done their modeling in Maya; Marionette only does animation.

      Are you sure about this? Maya has only been around since the late '90s; Pixar has been making films since the early '80s...

    9. Re:Off the shelf software? by 90XDoubleSide · · Score: 1

      Of course, I was only talking about their recent feature films. When Pixar was founded there wasn't off the shelf software!

      --
      "Reality is just a convenient measure of complexity" -Alvy Ray Smith
    10. Re:Off the shelf software? by malducin · · Score: 1

      The shots with the grasshoppers in the bar. There is a glass bottle filled with seeds and nuts. The botle was rendered via BMRT by the frankenrender method.

    11. Re:Off the shelf software? by May+Kasahara · · Score: 1

      Well you did say "always" ;)

  24. French, attack, attack! by rapett0 · · Score: 5, Funny

    Their server is withstanding the initial onslaught, attack, attack!

  25. Man I hate flash.... by nurb432 · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Isnt there a way to just download the damned trailer?

    --
    ---- Booth was a patriot ----
    1. Re:Man I hate flash.... by Tumbleweed · · Score: 1

      If you actually VIEWED the Flash, you'd see it links to the trailer in several different formats and resolutions.

      Once the Quicktime versions load completely, you can save the quicktime movie to your drive.

      Please to note: there are also 4 clips available besides the trailer.

  26. Off-the-shelf software is pretty good today by Animats · · Score: 5, Interesting
    Really. You can do at least TV-quality work with stock Max, Softimage XSI, or Maya. On reasonably modest equipment, too.

    The limitation is talent. Few people can drive these tools competently.

    I've done software for high-end animation. I can run the tools myself, but I can't get the results that the people with real talent can. Watching a good artist running an animation system is striking. They work quite differently from amateurs running these programs. They draw far more than they edit. They're fast. They have a clear picture in their mind of what they want to see on the screen.

    There aren't many people like that, which is why most amateur 3D animation sucks.

    1. Re:Off-the-shelf software is pretty good today by Cthefuture · · Score: 1

      The limitation is talent.

      Frankly, I don't think so. I think the limitation is all the crappy software out there. Maya isn't too bad, but the other software you mentioned have horrible interfaces.

      The "talent" is learning to use some piece of shit user interface effectively. That seems like a waste of time to me. There is some software out there that is better than the most popular packages but they are not anywhere near perfect. The packages I'm speaking of are Mirai, Nendo, Wings3D, etc. They are much easier to get prefessional results without spending years learning the damn UI. However, Mirai is limited compared Maya and Nendo/Wings are currently only modelers (and they can't handle high poly models well).

      It's just a sad state of affairs because there is no complete, powerful, fast, easy to use graphics and animation package (I'm currently working to fix this by the way :).

      --
      The ratio of people to cake is too big
    2. Re:Off-the-shelf software is pretty good today by ScottGant · · Score: 1

      You will HAVE to exclude XSI as having a horrible interface. In fact, Softimage/XSI is what you should judge others on in making a 3D software interface.

      There simply isn't a better one out there. It's professional, very well designed and very complete.

      Take a looke at XSI, you can even download an evaluation copy to see.

      --

      "Music is everybody's possession. It's only publishers who think that people own it." - John Lennon.
    3. Re:Off-the-shelf software is pretty good today by Cthefuture · · Score: 1

      Each to his own, but I would argue that Mirai has a much better interface.

      In fact, XSI has been slowly becoming more Mirai-like over the years (same with Maya). Mirai had it first though. Both Maya and XSI come from some really bad user interfaces (Alias|Wavefront, and the original Softimage 3D) and they have been improving the interface over the years. But Mirai comes from N-World which was arguably the first commercial-grade graphics and animation package, and quickly developed the interface that everyone else now realizes they should have had all along.

      If you haven't used Mirai, then you're missing out. It's a shame the program is so hard to get though. No demo and it's been almost impossible to buy for the last few years (management problems in the company). It hardly gets any publicity because so many graphics shops use it as a "secret weapon".

      At first, most old-time 3D artists don't realize how good Mirai is because they've been stuck in the land of crappy software for so long that they have a skewed view of what's good. Once you use it though, the world looks different.

      --
      The ratio of people to cake is too big
    4. Re:Off-the-shelf software is pretty good today by Mac+Degger · · Score: 1

      Hello, clueless. Any professional will tell you this: never blame the tools.

      It is a fact that a great artist is good because he knows what he is doing and can translate that. That is also the reason why any production house, be it for film, tv or games, hires people who are artists first and can use a computer second. Why? Because one can easily train someone to use a computer, but to be a good artist (with a head for proportions, colour, perspective, whatever) takes a whole lot longer to learn.

      Blaming the tools just shows the world how little you know, or how bad an artist you are.

      --
      -- Waht? Tehr's a preveiw buottn?
    5. Re:Off-the-shelf software is pretty good today by Cthefuture · · Score: 1

      LOL, I understand what you are saying, but that's not what I was talking about. I am speaking from a professional standpoint. I'm assuming the artist is talented and that isn't an issue. We are past that point and now talking tools.

      Good tools help an artist and don't force you into a mold. They allow you to work freely, fast, and efficient. They allow you to really express yourself.

      Yes, it's true a good artist can create good art no matter the tool, but the question is how quickly and easily.

      This mimics the same debate about programming languages. A good programmer could create something like MSWord using binary 1's and 0's, but would you want to?

      --
      The ratio of people to cake is too big
    6. Re:Off-the-shelf software is pretty good today by Mac+Degger · · Score: 1

      Hmm....it might just be me, but I don't really see the current crop of 3d tools as limiting. Not in style, at any rate. Usability, maybe, but in the same way as c++ is, or paint. You just have to life with the fact that it's not easy. It's actually a bit difficult, sometimes.

      You have to learn how to use your tools, if you want to be effective with them...just as you have to learn how to use C++, or oilpaints. If you don't learn 'em, you never create something aweinspiring.

      More to the point; if you know your tools, you won't be limited by them. And I have to say, I haven't really been limited by them in terms of what I can do...the only limitation is how much time and effort I put into a scene.

      --
      -- Waht? Tehr's a preveiw buottn?
    7. Re:Off-the-shelf software is pretty good today by Animats · · Score: 1
      Agreed. We're past many of the tools problems. A major production problem used to be that systems would choke when the scenes got too big.

      Most of that is behind us. Frequent crashing, waiting ten seconds for a pick, and saves that take hours are solved problems.

  27. Can't you guys view source? (Direct trailer link) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Get the high-res QT version here

  28. Mod parent up by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    An AC with some brains, he is. I am also from the USA.

  29. annoying article by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Responding to a few posters here: Using off-the-shelf software doesn't really matter. It does tend to be a sign of a relatively new studio though. A few films later and I'm sure their own code will be doing a significant proportion of the work. It'll start at the glue / automation level and gradually work it's way up.

    Article: More importantly, I'm quite amazed at the article's neglect of previous animated features. They seem to think that this is the first ever animated movie that's not aimed at children, buying hook-line-and-sinker that animation is only for kids. One wonders if the author never saw the Final Fantasy movie, let alone any one of a trillion Japanese features or Fritz The Cat.

  30. Freedom Lameness by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    only a few minutes into comments and we have 3 french "freedom" jokes... not suprised... just nauseous

    1. Re:Freedom Lameness by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I had the same feeling when this whole "let's make France the enemy of the week" thing started.

      Suddenly -everyone- had -always- hated France.

    2. Re:Freedom Lameness by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      I swear, if I ever meet anybody who seriously claims to hate the French people because of the French government's foreign policy decisions, I will punch that stupid son of a bitch right in the fucking face.

      Then, animal rage haven been acted upon, I will regain my capacity for rational thought just in time to get my wussy geek ass handed to me. Viva la France!

    3. Re:Freedom Lameness by CausticWindow · · Score: 1, Flamebait

      So democracy only works one way?

      You freedom fighting, democracy spreading Americans really should develop a more thorough understanding of these concepts before you start your berserker rage through the middle east.

      I hold the American people responsible for the crimes the American government have committed and are committing in other countries.

      --
      How small a thought it takes to fill a whole life
    4. Re:Freedom Lameness by ErikZ · · Score: 1


      "I hold the American people responsible for the crimes the American government have committed and are committing in other countries."

      Sure you do.

      In case that doesn't translate well, what I'm saying is "You'll sit there and bitch and whine and make threating statements and do nothing."

      --
      Democrats or Republicans. They are both taking us to the same place and they are not afraid of us anymore.
    5. Re:Freedom Lameness by Mac+Degger · · Score: 1

      Nope, more like it's a country grown up out of puberty which has recognised the value of diplomatic efforts above warfare.

      I mean, there's a reason that the US won't sign up for the international court of justice...to many americans will be brought befoe it for warcrimes (guantanamo bay and the failure to do anything about looting in iraqi cities [direct contravention of geneva conventions] come to mind).

      There where three options: diplomacy, war and unscrupulous use of force. Just seems that these french guys said 'screw that' and made a movie instead.

      --
      -- Waht? Tehr's a preveiw buottn?
    6. Re:Freedom Lameness by likeicare · · Score: 1

      So you hold them responsible? Big deal. Get off your fat couissanty ass & do something. How may euros for a bag of fertilizer & a litre of deisel these days?

    7. Re:Freedom Lameness by ErikZ · · Score: 1

      Heh, nice try.

      But the "International Criminal Court" has nothing to do with Diplomacy.

      Unless you can alter the outcome of the courts decisions though diplomatic means?

      --
      Democrats or Republicans. They are both taking us to the same place and they are not afraid of us anymore.
    8. Re:Freedom Lameness by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      When you learn how to spell, I will read your posts. Until then, please go back to elementary school.

      People - SPELLCHECK YOUR DAMN POSTS.

    9. Re:Freedom Lameness by Mac+Degger · · Score: 1

      Eat my sig, AC.

      --
      -- Waht? Tehr's a preveiw buottn?
  31. OSS by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Was it made using Open Source Software ?

    I don't look at stuff made with propreitary
    software.

  32. Re:BOYCOTT!!! by General+Sherman · · Score: 1

    The Irony is overwhelming, yes I know.

    --
    - Sherman
  33. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 1, Offtopic

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  34. Bienvenue... by xigxag · · Score: 4, Funny

    ...a l'Effect Slashdot, mes amis.

    --
    There are two kinds of people: 1) those who start arrays with one and 1) those who start them with zero.
    1. Re:Bienvenue... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful
      Sorry, a nit pick from a francophile, it's:
      Bienvenue à l'Effet de Slashdot.
      à must have the grave accent to denote "to" instead of a conjugated form of "to have" (avoir) for singular third person (il, elle, on). Additionally, English added Cs to several French words like "effet," "sujet (also added b in English)," etc. Finally, one must have de to indicate ownership (it is the effect of Slashdot).
    2. Re:Bienvenue... by joestar · · Score: 1

      Actually we - French people - say "l'effet Slashdot", not "l'effet de Slashdot". As a result the correct sentence is : "Bienvenue à l'effet Slashdot".

    3. Re:Bienvenue... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I've been taught that when you use a proper name as an adjective in English, one'd add "de" in French.

  35. Re:Off the shelf... by fishbert42 · · Score: 5, Informative

    You are seriously comparing Kaena to Final Fantasy and Spider-Man?! Yes, the animation in Kaena looks, as you put it, "very ghetto" in relation. But I think you need to consider the following.

    Spider-Man budget: $139 million
    Final Fantasy budget: $137 million
    Kaena budget: $27 million

    Kaena is also (supposedly) the first European CGI feature. You really shouldn't expect animation perfection in a first release like this.
    And, to be honest, a lot of the animation in "Spidey" wasn't that good either...

    Finally; why won't the story be the draw? What about Toy Story or Monsters, Inc.? I found the stories for those CGI features (among others) to be quite well done and entertaining. Just because a film is 100% CGI does not mean that it has no story. I'm not saying there will be a great story in Kaena; just that the two factors are unrelated.

  36. Re:BOYCOTT!!! by heff · · Score: 1

    dont take this the wrong way, but in the kkk's earlier days it was quite the gentlemans club. only in it's later years did it develop into a racist, hating type deal.

    learned that in history.. general ed classes rule.

    --

    --

    |-_-| . o O ( bEef!)

  37. imdb link by dargaud · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I'm surprised that no one posted the imdb link yet. And as someone stated, the voices did sound familiar, both in french and english: Kirsten Dunst, Richard Harris, Anjelica Huston...

    --
    Non-Linux Penguins ?
  38. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 4, Informative

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  39. Accents by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

    Did anyone else notice that the evil overlords had British accents, whilst the heroine had an American accent?

    Normally I couldn't give a toss, except for the fact that this seems to have become an annoying stereotype. I shit you not, when watching Minority Report I picked the bad guy right from the beginning because of his British accent (the actor was Swedish I know).

    In the old days evil characters had Russian accents, now it's British accents.

    Why do they do this?

    1. Re:Accents by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Three words:

      Grand Moff Tarkin.

      The merkins are probably just a little sore about that revolutionary war thing. It's the last time they fought in a real war that affected the people so one can't blame them.

    2. Re:Accents by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, that bothers me too. But, Minority Report was typical Hollywood drivel. Lazy screenwriting, lazy direction, lazy stereotypes that are dumbed down because Hollywood thinks (and I use that word loosely) all American moviegoers are borderline mentally retarded.

      Luckily we aren't the only two to notice this. The Filthy Critic has a few choice words about it as well. But I, in turn, will presume everyone from Hollywood is stupid. I figure a lot of Californians will get offended, but I'm sure the Brits dislike the supervillian stereotype just as much.

    3. Re:Accents by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Max von Sydow, from Ingmar Bergman fame. Ahh, that guy is awesome. There's nothing like watching the Seventh Seal.

    4. Re:Accents by Tumbleweed · · Score: 1

      Two more words:

      Faulkland Islands

      Or:

      China

      Or:

      India

      Or:

      Ireland

      Or:

      Scotland

      And people say Germany has a history of aggression?! Gimme a break. I think an English accent fits the stereotype quite well.

      Keep in mind that one of Monty Python's original name was "Owl-Stretching Time". If that's not evil... :)

    5. Re:Accents by Atsjoo · · Score: 1

      But we don't like to count the 50 wars the US has been engaged in -since- WW2 do we?

      Personally, I think an american accent would fit the evil stereotype quite well.

    6. Re:Accents by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      One word: Marmite.

    7. Re:Accents by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Why do they do this?


      Because this is a French^H^H^H^Hreedom movie and if there's anything worse than American cooking, it's (surprise) British cooking :-)

    8. Re:Accents by henele · · Score: 1

      The standard explanation is that the British are unlikely to complain perticularly about their representation in films, from Die Hard series European terrorists to history-raping films (Braveheart, various war films), in comparison to the main 'minority' groups...

    9. Re:Accents by Mac+Degger · · Score: 1

      Remember Star Wars? Same thing; the Empire was British, the rebelion was american.

      The reason of course was that britain was a colonial power. Nowadays, the use of accents should be reversed.

      --
      -- Waht? Tehr's a preveiw buottn?
    10. Re:Accents by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Falkland Islands -

      Invaded by South American lunatic dictator - liberated by U.K., just as the islanders wanted.

      India -

      The people wanted self rule - they got what they wanted. Still the largest democracy in the world (over a billion people) - a British legacy.

      Ireland -

      Some Irish wanted independence, some did not (both sides were/are prepared to kill each other to make that point). They got exactly what they wanted.

      Scotland -

      Some (a minority) want independence, some (the majority) do not - the Scots have exactly what they want with their own parliament.

      The U.K. has a history of giving people EXACTLY what they want, as befits a democratic country.

    11. Re:Accents by mink · · Score: 1

      I walways thought the empire was Nazis.

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
  40. Woah there, Adolf. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You're starting to sound like George W. Bush.

    Next you're going to want to punish those who see pacifism as a valid foreign policy and war as a last resort.

    I'm sick and tired of living amongst the high-school politics of the Untied States of Assholes.

  41. Re:BOYCOTT!!! by silicon1 · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    ya, stupid french surrender monkeys. they are greedy cowards. "no we won't participate in a war, but we would definatly like to get money because of it."

  42. Re:Looks nice. QWZX by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I weep for the future. It's twits like you that will be the downfall of your entire culture in none too long.

  43. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 1

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  44. Hey Whore by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I saw you earlier tonight.

  45. Re:Looks nice. QWZX by Necrobruiser · · Score: 1

    La femme Nikita

    --
    "I planned within my means and got a fixed rate mortgage, so where's MY bailout?" -cafepress
  46. Re:Looks nice. QWZX by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Brotherhood of the wolf.

  47. "A Bug's Life Redux"? by vrmlguy · · Score: 4, Funny
    I just finished watching the trailer, and I couldn't help thinking that the plot seemed just a bit familar. Let's see, likable humanoid characters living in a dark three-dimensional community, terrorized by large insectoid villians who want free (as in beer) food. Finally, one character leaves home to search for a way to overthrow the thugs.

    So what happens next? Does the girl meet up with an bunch of itenerant "circus bugs"? Do they build a giant mechanical bird to try to frighten the villians away? Inquiring minds want to know!

    --
    Nothing for 6-digit uids?
    1. Re:"A Bug's Life Redux"? by The+Cydonian · · Score: 1

      First of all, I didn't watch the trailer, so I won't comment on this movie, but if the plot from Bug's Life would seem familiar to world audiences for a reason.

      You see, this ragtag-band-of-good-guys-fight-with-baddies-who-te rrorize-a-village-every-year-for-cash plot has been used in, among other movies, Bug's Life, Lagaan, Chinagate (both from India) and The Magnificient Seven, after it first came out on celluloid in The Seven Samurai, one of the gems made by the Japanese master, Akira Kurosawa .

    2. Re:"A Bug's Life Redux"? by Snarfvs+Maximvs · · Score: 1

      Yeah, but The Three Amigos did it best. ;-)

      --
      -----------------------

      To understand recursion, one must first understand recursion.

    3. Re:"A Bug's Life Redux"? by nickm · · Score: 1

      If you get out of the house, you'll learn that the plot to "A Bug's Life" was just a re-hash of Akira Kurosawa's "Seven Samurai", as was Galaxy Quest and just about every other comedic action film on the planet.

      --

      --
      I noticed

      It's getting about time to leave everywhere

    4. Re:"A Bug's Life Redux"? by vrmlguy · · Score: 1

      Don't confuse the trailer with my speculation. The plot points that I noted were specific to "A Bug's Life", not "Seven Samurai" (unless Kurosawa's epic had eight-foot tall insectoid villians that I somehow missed).

      --
      Nothing for 6-digit uids?
    5. Re:"A Bug's Life Redux"? by Pig+Hogger · · Score: 1
      I just finished watching the trailer, and I couldn't help thinking that the plot seemed just a bit familar.
      Indeed. It looks awfully like the general plot of 30 years old heavy-metal comic Les oiseaux du maître, where spatio-temporal agents Valérian and Laureline crash upon a planet ruled by a huge gelatinous blob (sorry, Planet-Express didn't invent anything) who enslaves the population into feeding it, by threatening to zombify them with it's army of "crazy birds", who turn anyone they bite into crazyness.

      But once the heroes get bitten, are they really crazy? I guess not, since they manage to scare the huge gelatinous blob away from the planet...

  48. Looks like the plot is similar to "A Bug's Life!" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Did anyone else notice this? Kaena would be Flik, and instead of providing food for the grasshoppers they provide sap for the gods.

    Also, the Axis itself reminds me alot of Niven's "The Integral Trees" but I am not sure if it is in-ground or floating. I did not pour over the entire site or storyline (too much flash), but I got the impression that the inhabitants are from a crashed ship too.

    Not very original if you ask me!

  49. Re:Off the shelf... by voblia · · Score: 1

    > The only non-technical flaw I could spot was the way the characters > moved. Final Fantasy augmented their hand-animated characters with > tons of motion capture, so maybe using them as the bar is a little too > high... I think the motion capture techniques they used were realy strange, because IMHO the greatest flaw in final fantasy was the lack of inertion. But yes the characters in Kaena are looking like stickman's. Yet the artist have done a great job, their site is cool too. Ignas Mikalajunas

  50. Bah! by PS-SCUD · · Score: 1

    It'll never beat Hamster Havoc

    --


    "Much work is lost, for the lack of a little more." -Edward H. Harriman
  51. Re:Off the shelf... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Pretentious, arrogant, know-it-all asshole.

    Did I miss anything? Oh yeah. Where's your movie?

  52. Re:Off the shelf... by donglekey · · Score: 2, Interesting

    The first European fully CGI feature was made in Spain and called The Living Forest.

  53. Re:Off the shelf... by Augusto · · Score: 1

    Spider-Man budget: $139 million
    Final Fantasy budget: $137 million
    Kaena budget: $27 million

    http://www.pixar.com/shorts/gg/index.html

    Gery's Game's character animation looks a lot better than this stuff, and I'm sure it didn't cost too much.

    --

    - sigs are for wimps.
  54. 3dsmax isnt exactly off the shelf by BrycePetit · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    3dsmax r5.1 is NOT off the shelf software. You cant go into CompUSA and write out your check for $3,495.00 and walk out with it and its bibles of documentation. The guy dropped a serious chunk of change. If its off the shelf he is using RayDream Studio and JASC Paint Shop Pro!

    1. Re:3dsmax isnt exactly off the shelf by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Whoever modded this as flamebait is an idiot. 3DS max isn't off the shelf. Fuck man, think before you mod you gay ass fucking mod.

  55. More info on Brit accent by jtheory · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I just watched the fourth movie clip they made available on the site -- there's a creature that's helping her who has a very warm rich voice... with a slight British accent. Listen to the "if you had the chance, would you leave Axis?" to hear it clearly.

    It could be that they're working off the stereotype that the elite (evil or not) speak with British accents. Think also of what's called the "mid-Atlantic" accent (the accent spoken partway between the US and Britain...) taught so carefully to Julliard drama students -- you know how "Frasier Crane" talks? Yup, Kelsey Grammer is a Julliard grad. He's got it down pat.

    He also spoke the role of the villainous but brilliant Sideshow Bob on the Simpsons. ...Whoah, I just looked up his bio to make sure he is, indeed American (confirmed; grew up in NJ and Florida), and it seems his father (a bar-owner) was murdered in '68. His sister was murdered in '75, and 2 half brothers died while scuba-diving in '80. Ouch.

    --
    There are only 10 types of people: those who understand decimal, those who don't, and, uh, 8 other types I forget.
    1. Re:More info on Brit accent by likeicare · · Score: 2, Funny

      Fuck me! Have you yanks not worked it out yet? We'd much rather be the bad guys than be cheered on by wankers like you. Yay for Mel Gibson being eviscerated in braveheart! TTFN.

  56. Correction by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Gawsh, Jemima, I haven' fucked up like that since th' square dance at Uncle Jimmy-Bob's las' hoedown.

    s/haven/having/

  57. Interesting but not great looking by inkswamp · · Score: 1

    I hope the clips are not representative of the final film because it looks stiff and unnatural, and everything has a weird smoothness to it. The God creature in clip 1 is damn cool, but overall the rest looks kind of bland. I'm probably spoiled with the kind of attention to detail and fluidity of Pixar films but these remind me of the CG Barbie movies that my daughter watches from time-to-time, and you can tell that those were made on a relatively low budget and as quickly as possible.

    That's not to say I probably won't go see this film. It does look intriguing, but in terms of animation quality, it doesn't appear to be on the same level as many of the CG films to date.

    --
    --Rick "If it isn't broken, take it apart and find out why."
  58. Re:Off the shelf... by fishbert42 · · Score: 1

    According to Yahoo! Movies, "this project [Kaena] claims to be the first European CGI feature."
    I said 'supposedly' because I figured something had probably come before (despite what the studio may say). Anyway, thanks for the correction.

  59. Re:BOYCOTT!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Fuck Yeah Baby. Keep America White. Kill The French. America for Americans. Let's Kill All Towel Heads, Yips and their Surrender Monkey French Whore Girlfriends.

  60. Re:Off the shelf... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Pixar films are developed with dozens and dozens of highly-paid, full-time artists and millions of dollars worth of equipment... ...asshole.

  61. I Smell Astroturf by Farley+Mullet · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I looked at the trailer, and, like a few other people have mentioned here, it's okay but not great. The animation lags behind Pixar and the other big boys, and the plot is pretty generic (and bears an unfortunate similarity to A Bug's Life). But what gets me is that, for what seems to be the umpteenth time, a movie (or t.v. show or book or video or whatever) is anonymously submitted to /., almost certainly by someone involved in the production. If you think about it, considering the zillions of page views daily and the profile of the site (heck, google news uses /. as a source), /. has to be an easy source of free marketing for anyone selling any kind of SF. "News for Nerds, Stuff that Matters" indeed.

    1. Re:I Smell Astroturf by Bob+Cat+-+NYMPHS · · Score: 1

      Since it comes via fiber, it's Glasstroturf.

    2. Re:I Smell Astroturf by Mac+Degger · · Score: 1

      SO? I fail to see that as a bad thing. I mean, come on, we are a part of the target demographic, and people on /. do think it's cool, neat and at the very least relevant.

      True, an article about what they used to render it and some of the production pitfalls would be better, but rather this that those spams about webcams and viagra in my mailbox.

      --
      -- Waht? Tehr's a preveiw buottn?
  62. Re:Looks nice. QWZX by ahaning · · Score: 1

    Didn't The Red Balloon come from France?

    --
    Withdrawal before climax is very ineffective and those who try this are usually called "parents."
  63. I'll tell you why by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    They have british accents because the UK represents all that is evil in the world. Colonialism, cultural uniformity, insecurity, and paranoia. Take a look at any history book and you'll see what I mean. Plus they have to sound cool.

  64. Re:Off the shelf... by mnemonic_ · · Score: 1

    "using motion blur in Pixar's PRman only has a render time hit of 50%"

    Additional render time caused by motion blur can vary vastly depending on the settings and what's being rendered. In 3ds max, 2d motion can look quite good (with slower motion and minimal rotations) and add much less than 100% to a render.

  65. France surrenders by mnemonic_ · · Score: 0, Redundant
    <Kaena server admins> We surrender!
  66. Re:Off the shelf... by mnemonic_ · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Why would people who have played in Maya be able to tell that they're metaballs? Maya has no metaball features whatsoever. Anyways, they didn't use metaballs (and they don't look like metaballs to me at least)- they used RealFlow, a full blown fluids simulation solution.

  67. In English ? by eurostar · · Score: 1

    I bet it sounds much better in French.

    1. Re:In English ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Nothing sounds better in French.

    2. Re:In English ? by Eunuchswear · · Score: 1
      Va te faire foutre, 'tit con.


      Sounds a lot better in French.

      --
      Watch this Heartland Institute video
  68. The French wanted to do this before... by BTWR · · Score: 0, Troll

    ...but they kept "surrendering" the project! HA HA HA!!!

    (eh... I got karma to burn)

    1. Re:The French wanted to do this before... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Given there are so many fucking jews in that team it wouldn't surprise me, funny how thes jews are such a race of ass-lickers...

    2. Re:The French wanted to do this before... by BTWR · · Score: 2, Funny

      Why is it that only the (anonymous) cowards make statements like this?

    3. Re:The French wanted to do this before... by TheShadow · · Score: 0, Troll

      Why is it that only the (anonymous) cowards make statements like this?

      Because they are all French and too wimpy to post with their account.

      --

      --
      "What do you want me to do? Whack a guy? Off a guy? Whack off a guy? Cause I'm married."
  69. Re:Off the shelf... by edo-01 · · Score: 3, Informative
    Watching the trailer, it looks like they didn't opt to render using motion blur. Last I checked, using motion blur in Pixar's PRman only has a render time hit of 50%. With lower end software, you're looking at a few hundred percent. But I might be going by older numbers.

    Very old numbers I'd say. I've used Max and Renderman professionally for four years. While prman's motion blur is very nice, it takes significantly longer to render than Max's image motion blur, which is one of the fastest around. It is less accurate but for the majority of shots I've worked on over the years it's not noticable.

    Oh, and also "only" a render hit time of 50%? Film-res images can take hours to render a single frame (especially if you are using renderman). Add another 50% to that and you are in deep trouble. The "render hit" as you put it for Max's post image blur is only a few seconds per frame, even if those frames took an hour to render.

    The only non-technical flaw I could spot was the way the characters moved. Final Fantasy augmented their hand-animated characters with tons of motion capture, so maybe using them as the bar is a little too high... but from what I've read, most of the character animation in Spiderman was done by hand. Keanna's animation is laughable compared to Spidey, and the software they used is no excuse.

    You've got it backwards there. Final Fantasy augmented their motion capture with hand animation. Motion capture takes days or weeks of hand cleanup to make useable, and most animators prefer not to use it. Makes sense seeing as they all got into the industry to animate not clean up jittery popping motion capture all day.

  70. Re:FYI by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    LOL!!

  71. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 1

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  72. Re:Off the shelf... by Robot+Messiah · · Score: 2, Interesting
    Based on the trailer, the story looks like a typical, derivative hero's journey. I loved the formula in the Matrix, because it was presented with a new spin. If Kaena will be anything like the trailer, I'll shut my brain off at the door.
    Don't lie; people will catch you out. You've clearly shut your brain off already.

    PDI, BlueSky and Pixar's films are every bit as formulaic. Buddy banter, rescue subplots and a heart-wrenching song in the middle. The same is true of most of Disney's cel-animated features. What exactly bothers you about the idea that a forthcoming 3D animated feature may also follow the traditional Quest storyline? So what if Kaena's just a poor sap farmer's daughter, bound by destiny to fulfil some prophecy or another... Who isn't?
    Pixar films are filled with interesting, dynamic characters. Their stories work regardless of the medium. I was watching their older shorts on their website the other day, and most of them are still entertaining even though the technology is long obsolete.
    It doesn't do your arguments any good to alternate between criticising technical aspects of Xilam's first feature film and praising Pixar's early shorts in spite of their primitive technology. The simple fact of the matter is that Xilam (and Chaman) have done a very cool thing: they've completed a film that looks to be what FF:TSW should have been, on a fraction of the budget.

    With off-the-shelf software, on Windows PCs, no less.
  73. Pacifism? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    More like pussyfism.

    If you're sick of living here, go move to France. Have fun surrendering to the Arabs in a couple years and living under Sharia.

  74. Oh no, it's in English! by Dr.+Spork · · Score: 1
    This is terrible! It's going to look almost as crappy as all those Japanese cartoons overdubbed with totally inappropriate English voices. You know, the most of the audience for a feature like this knows how to read. Why not have subtitles?

    Apart from that, everything looks pretty cool.

    1. Re:Oh no, it's in English! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


      perhaps would you try french instead ?

      my 0.02

    2. Re:Oh no, it's in English! by Mac+Degger · · Score: 1

      'cos it's done in english originally, to be dubbed for all other languages later? RTFA to find out they did it in english because they are after a worldwide release.

      --
      -- Waht? Tehr's a preveiw buottn?
    3. Re:Oh no, it's in English! by mink · · Score: 1

      This is being done like Vampire Hunter D: Bloodlust.
      That Japanese animated film was done in english first and later dubbed into Japanese.

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
  75. Here you go then by nacs · · Score: 3, Informative

    Here's the direct link to the trailer in the largest size in Quicktime format.

    It played fine on my Gentoo box under both Xine and Mplayer.

    --
    "I filter at +6, and have yet to miss out on an important comment." (#822545)
  76. Oh, you must be soo cool! by Dr.+Spork · · Score: 1
    Maybe you are such a conniseur of animation that you can't enjoy a movie in which the rendering isn't photorealistic. It's sorta like someone who can't enjoy a concert because they think the equalizer settings are wrong or the stage props look too cheap.

    That attitude looks neurotic to most people. Bands with fancy props can very easily put on a terrible show, and movies with "uptown" (to contrast with "ghetto") effects can be catastrophically unwatchable--I have Final Fantasy in mind, but I'm sure there are others.

    This movie looks far less lame. Maybe this is the start of animated features actually having stories that are more than mere afterthoughts. I'm optimistic, because the French have a good record of making movies that feel real and are easy to connect with on a human level. Animated features need that element much more than they need a more advanced motion blur.

    1. Re:Oh, you must be soo cool! by Colmino · · Score: 1

      No need to come down on the guy. He gave the trailer an honest critique with no evidence of favoritism. I would have said something about the lack of motion blur if nobody else had. I mean, even the very first Toy Story had excellent motion blur and I just don't see how you can make a CGI movie without it, never mind eight years after TS. There's a very tiny moment in A Bug's Life that is missing motion blur (towards the beginning when Flik's harvester grabs a stalk of wheat) and you can see how the imagery suffers.

      Honestly, they should just grit their teeth and start passing the movie back through the renderer, with motion blur this time.

      The main flaw with Final Fantasy's animation was the "floaty" look. It carried over into the Animatrix short from the same studio. Characters generally turn their heads and bodies slowly and make slow movements. Why? Most probably because this is a great way to mask the lack of a physics engine, similar to how non-rapid motion (or a high framerate) is a good way to hide the absence of motion blur.

      This trailer doesn't give me a very good idea of whether or not there will be a "floaty" phenomenon, as it was primarily a sequence of shots of characters either sitting still or in hot pursuit.

      On the aesthetics side of things, I didn't like how Final Fantasy was such a blue flick and I don't like how this one is such a brown flick. It sort of reminds me of playing Quake (1). Makes me feel like I'll suffocate if I don't see a nice, green, sunlit valley soon. But I did say this was aesthetics.

  77. Re:Off the shelf... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "Gery's Game's character animation looks a lot better than this stuff, and I'm sure it didn't cost too much."

    Oh come now the hardware and software alone probably cost that much. That was what 1993? Heck maybe the late 90's. And I'll bet they marshalled the whole company to make that single albeit award winning short. Those shorts gave Pixar if I recall correctly a whole lot of street credibility and helped put them on the map. The origional lamp was genious too.

    But back to your comparision where you compare an apple to an orange over different seasons of harvest AND compare the very best of one to the infancy of another. Kinda sad and shameful on your part. Also weren't there models and lots of innovation to make the animation as well as they could at the time?

    Have you seen a fair representation of the European CG animation out there? For the most part it just is not near the best of the American stuff. Lots of languanges to dub/lipsync for. Lots of different standards for ratings. Really cruddy funding deals over three plus partners all with shoestring budgets where they also must accomodate the previously mentioned market realities. The list goes on but I am tired. Look at traditional animation and claymation and you see much better stuff.

    Sure I may not think the story is great from the preview but I have seen the same from Hollywood and was entertained just the same. As long as it is fun it will be worth watching. Cripes remeber Titan AE, you know same bunch that make Farscape :-) that really sucked and this one looks better to me.

  78. Re:Looks nice (Bush and the war, WOMD). by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Actually, the war has mostly been for Bush to make the masses look elsewhere while he (and mostly his team, Ashcroft/Rumsfeld/whoever) is cracking on civil liberties.

    I don't know if Saddam had weapons of mass destruction of not (very probably, also not as much as claimed by the U.S. military) but he certainly has been used by Bush as a Weapon of Mass Distraction.

  79. Re:FUCK FRANCE by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This can't be a troll, it must be some new kind of art?! *claps* Which school did you attend?

  80. What "off the shelf" packages ? by Taco+Cowboy · · Score: 1



    Can anyone please enlighten me to what "off-the-shelf" packages the movie has employed?

    Or is there a page where the packages are listed?

    I am afraid I do not read French.

    --
    Muchas Gracias, Señor Edward Snowden !
  81. Where are the Skeksis? by Okonomiyaki · · Score: 2, Informative

    Am I the only one getting a Dark Crystal vibe from this? (I consider that a good thing, by the way.)

    1. Re:Where are the Skeksis? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I agree, extremely Dark Crystal-ish.

    2. Re:Where are the Skeksis? by CyberPsyko · · Score: 0

      Nevermind about the Skeksis, I'd like to see the Olgra equivalent!

  82. mod parent down! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    this is really irrelevant! mplayer & co. (xine etc.) have been able to handle stuff like this for months now..

    no reason to mod ppl whoring up for nothing!

  83. Re:Looks nice. QWZX by sykora · · Score: 1

    Leon aka The Professional

  84. Re:Off the shelf... by 10Ghz · · Score: 1
    I loved the formula in the Matrix, because it was presented with a new spin.


    Huh? Now I love Matrix, but it's obvious that they got large part of the story from Dark City. Hell, Matrix even used some of the leftover sets from the Dark City! Just about the only differences between Matrix and Dark City is that Matrix was action-oriented and it had a huge budget.
    --
    Lesbian Nazi Hookers Abducted by UFOs and Forced Into Weight Loss Programs - -all next week on Town Talk.
  85. Re:FUCK FRANCE by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...hmmm, that was insightful. I just hope this keeps up so that /. stops allowing anon posts. I hate those people who post anon. Oh, wait... heheh

  86. Trolling for non-profit and pleasure by theolein · · Score: 1

    I don't know why so many are against the French in that fair, wonderful, free, brave, altruistic country of yours. Perhaps it's pure stupidity, a trait surely not limited to the French or any other nation. Perhaps it's some kind of deep frustration.

    This movie is along the lines of animation done in Final fantasy, albeit with a story that could entice more interest in the general population than FF did.

    There will be more in this genre, and it definitely holds promise.

  87. Re:Off the shelf... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    >I've seen student demo reels with better character >animation than Kaena's running.

    Studio demo reels don't have to turn ut a couple of hours of animation on a very tight deadline. Most of the time you simply have to take something you're not at all happy with and OK it simply so you can get the movie finished before you run out of money.

  88. Very interesting, influences from everywhere by theolein · · Score: 2, Interesting

    The artwork of this movie is fantastic, imo, and the general dark tone and characters seem to borrow from many areas of modern science fiction and popular figures.

    The Marauder figure and the organic structures and the overall dark scenery borrow heavily from Giger's work, as the producer notes in the biography section of the site.

    The story is in an extremely similar vein to a still rendered series done by an Italian guy in the middle 90's on a Mac with Strata Studio and Photoshop and Deck and sold as a multimedia CD which were still popular back then. Sadly, I can't remember the title.

    Other influences seem to be taken from Larry Niven's Integral Tree (the tree in the film), a classic comic series about a world of creatures living in the clouds (the Sharken), and I notice that the one detailed shot of the heroine with hair (the wallpaper section) looks very similar to Virgine Ledoyen who starred in the Beach with Di Caprio.

    This film will probably not be that much of a hit, as I think it is very difficult to excite mainstream audiences with fantasy SF, but I think it'll be a pointer to things to come, when bigger film houses with bigger budgets start to produce films in a similar vein.

  89. from France == pass on this one by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Maybe they can get enough terrorists in syria, iraq, iran and elsewhere to fill the theaters for this movie.

  90. Re:Off the shelf... by zhrike · · Score: 1

    The people involved with the project appear very talented, but... I'm sorry. Some of this looks very ghetto.

    As an inexperienced person, I only looked at the design...the sets (if you will), the creatures, etc. I thought they looked amazing. Very evocative. The story seems thin and simplistic, but then: most Hollywood blockbusters are utter tripe anyway.

    Since I don't have an eye for modeling (have 3dsmax, the interface has utterly defeated me to this point), I only looked at the other stuff.
    Ghetto is not a word that I would have used to describe it.

  91. Re:Looks nice. QWZX by saden1 · · Score: 1

    Amelie!

    --

    -----
    One is born into aristocracy, but mediocrity can only be achieved through hard work.
  92. Americans don't make yourself look like fools by Spirit+Of+Atlantis · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I'm from The Netherlands and although our government was on the side of the US, 95% of our population wasn't. You Americans talk about freedom, but boycot French ware for their OPINION, that is so hypocrit. Land of the free, home of the brave... Come on, the freedom you enjoy has merely become a blur of what it used to be. The US used to be the flagship of freedom in the world, yes Europeans recognize that. But we also recognize that this is no longer the case. Your intelligence agencies monitor everything, NSA, CIA and whatnot scan your e-mails, phonecalls and mobile phone coordinates, you people get visits from FBI when you use encryption higher than 512 bits to safe-guard your privacy. Now that kind of info you don't see on your biased news networks now do you? How dare you despise France when you fail to see the truth about your own country. Your economy is weak right now and still the US uses 25% of the entire world oil production. Reluctant to invest in new technologies like hydrogyn, solar power or nuclear fusion. Your cars are low tech and suck alot of gasoline and don't come close to German car technology, still you all want to drive European cars. You guys come over so hypocrit. You want to know what most Europeans think? Like 95%? They love America, they love it's people, but they really fucking hate your extreme-right wing government. I appreciate you take stance for the Jews, i appreciate the US tries to liberate all sorts of countries. But your motives are foul, lies and deception. You went into Iraq to find nuclear and biological weapons. Now the US weapon inspectors have given up their search, because it simply wasn't there. Then suddenly you switched your motive to free the Iraqi people. That is so low. Instead of admitting your government was wrong, you just switched motives. Which shows that your government motives to attack a country is just a curtian to cloud the true motives. Your true motives? We don't know, you don't even know. Oil?World Domination?Both? Now here's the real catch. China. Your government is peeing it's pants because now they see actually that the communist system is actually showing it's fruits. China is becoming the most powerfull nation in the world and they're communist. They have the fastest growing economy in the world, largest army in the world and are technologically catching up. Auwch...that's gotta hurt, because now your government is going to lose it's nr1 spot as unofficial world leader. What other country has military bases in almost every country in the world? The US has miliatry bases fucking everywhere. Now why would a nation do that? Just for fun? No, that gives them military influence all over the world. World Domination, big guns and bombs is what the US is all about right now. With a 7 trillion dollar dept and defense as your greatest expenses, it looks like your government is growing nervous. You destroyed your own economy to wage war for undisclosed motives. You think you know the truth? You know as much as USSR citizens did back in the cold war, your goverment told you shit. From Europe it looks like your country has become a police state. Oh be so proud, the things you are all so proud already dissapeared 50 or 60 years ago. Once you had a great nation dwelling in true freedom, but what's left is just a mere shadow of itself. A military state trying to spread their ideology with military force and placing military bases all over the world, because they can't hold the pace of China's economy and technological advancement anymore which is growing like nuts. If you can't beat with your economy, you beat em military, that's the philosophy eh? Big guns, bombs, but little brain. And then you dare to talk about France? Offcourse they aren't all clean themselves. But right now, France is doing much better when it comes to true freedom/liberty and economy. Freedom fries....hmmpfff. You really think we Europeans care what you put into your 65% overweighted population? The US has become this big-footed goofy giant which crushes everything where it comes wi

    1. Re:Americans don't make yourself look like fools by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You're a prime example of why most Americans are starting to despise Europeans. From America's view, most Europeans are jealous and resentful of America's power and riches. We see a continent of pepole who continue to live in the past and who think they are owed something for the contributions of people born 500 years ago, while at the same time never taking responsibility for the attrocities of its most recent failures and its inability to act cohesively to prevent future atrocities. Europe likes to pretend that the U.S. didn't do anything to help during WW2, as though the war in the Pacific was just a minor blip in WW2; Again, a European bias that pretends that the European campaign was the only battleground in WW2. I would imagine that all the Asian people who were slaughtered by the Japanese would object to that worldview. But this is the problem with Europeans to this day. They still want to look at the world through their own distorted view of European relevancy, a relevancy which has not existed for quite some time. Yeah, The U.S. has a huge debt, much of spent during the cold war to keep Western Europe from falling under the Iron Curtain. Had American just pulled up all its bases and went home your Euro would never have existed and you'd be decrying the Isolationist policies of the U.S. And China is a communist success story? That's one strange brand of communism. I didn't know that communism allowed some people to become billionaires while the majority of the country toiled away. China's economy is booming because its communist economic policies were discarded. All that remains are communist social controls. Considering that Europe considers itself the vanguard of human rights, I'm surprised at their acquiescence to the human rights abuses that continue. And France is doing better in terms of Freedom and economy? A country where you can't sell Nazi paraphenalia? A country whose economy isn't even equal to that of California? Please. America's economy is still larger than a combined European economy. Don't make me laugh at your imaginative fantasy. Europe will continue to devolve irrespective of the EU. Your declining economic efficiency, coupled with continuin welfare state largesse and decreasing population only point in one direction -- all downhill. Europe doesn't want to face the reality that it will have to import millions of Arabs and Africans to support its burgeoning welfare state but it will or it will continue to enjoy 10% unemployment in Germany and other so-called economic engines.
      You and the other 95% of the population that was against the war doesn't surprise the U.S. Europe has always been afraid of conflict. WW2 would never have happened if Europe had owned up to its responsibilities. Europe only reacts when their own liberties and lives are at stake. Europe doesn't care about the Iraqi people who were massacred over the years anymore than it cares about its next oil contract. You can pretend that your anti-war stance is noble but its just typical European cowardice and self-interest. Americans laugh at the quickness with which the French and Germans try to protect their future place in Iraq development after the War didn't go the way it thought it would. Once again Europe takes the wrong stand is embarassed and ridiculed around the world. The U.S. will continue to embarass Europe over the next couple of years. It's only fitting.

    2. Re:Americans don't make yourself look like fools by Spirit+Of+Atlantis · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Europe!Europe!Europe!
      That is all we have heard from the American side for the last 6 months.

      The matter of the fact is, that the problem isn't here nor it's source.
      The US tends to solve problems by eliminating the visibible superficial symptoms of problem.
      Nuke em, bomb em, shoot em, eliminate em.
      It's been like that for decades.

      The US screams about nuclear weapons to all nations of the world.
      But in fact, the US is to date the only country in the world that has killed human beings on such a large scale with nuclear weapons. Now isn't that ironic?

      Please. America's economy is still larger than a combined European economy

      That is no longer the case. It might have been in the past, but it's not anymore.

      it will continue to enjoy 10% unemployment in Germany and other so-called economic engines.

      It's 4%. That's in fact lower than the US.

      I'm not trying to be childish here, just summing up the facts.

      In fact the Dollar is so weak now that the entire Oil Indstry(Russia+Arabic states) are considering to switch to the Euro instead of the Dollar.
      Even Japan is buying Euro's instead of Dollars like they always did to strengthen the economy. Things have changed.

      These are facts instead of insults that you throw at Europe.
      Cowards?
      If Europeans would be such "cowards", how come 40 million of us died to stop the nazi's? Like i said, the US just came in after all the dirty work was done.
      And talking about cowerdness, it was the US who left the Iraqi's after the first Gulf War to suffer under Saddam, so don't talk to about cowerdness as if you were above it.

    3. Re:Americans don't make yourself look like fools by SebNukem · · Score: 1

      I agree with this, but it is offtopic!

    4. Re:Americans don't make yourself look like fools by Spirit+Of+Atlantis · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Actually...we shouldn't be argueing amongst eachother as allies.
      We should find solutions together to solve problems and tackling them at their source with preferably no human suffering at all.

      It's stupid actually, while we argue Afrika is suffering from hunger.
      That shows how arrogant we Western people actually are.
      We should come to insight and make this world a nice place to live.
      God has given us a paradise, humans screwed it up, we really did.
      We polluted it and fight even amongst eachother.

      The fact that i stood up for France is because i know the French are cool people.
      And that there IS absolute freedom in France.
      Before you get sceptic about just visit Paris once and see with your own eyes.

      Maybe it's too early for a group hugg, but we can't keep getting around eachother for the length of times.
      We should stick our heads together.

    5. Re:Americans don't make yourself look like fools by ElGanzoLoco · · Score: 1

      OK, I'll try to keep it plain & simple:

      CUT THE BULLSHIT, EVERYBODY! Europeans and Americans ALIKE.

      I'm French, and I happen to support Chirac's position. And I do happen to hate W. Bush and his team, big time. But this shouldn't turn me into an enemy of the U.S. (or should it?)

      Seen from France, anti-French sentiment in the U.S. is really beginning to look like mass hysteria. (I mean, I'm in college and some of my buddies are supposed to go to Columbia University next year; but somehow the decision to accept them got delayed, and some started suspecting Columbia University of barring french students... which is insane).
      And, I readily agree, the same can be said about this anti-U.S-resentment bullshit that sometimes erupts in France and Europe (and this anti-U.S.feeling is much less well-spread than most say).

      Just because our respective governments happen do disagree (which happens now and then) shouldn't turn the populations against one another.
      It's OK to be proud of your country / region / whatever. But if you think "patriotism" means insulting everybody out there and stomping on everybody who happens to disagree, then fine, be a fucking sheep, go ahead and believe what your government tells you to. But at least shut the fuck up and leave the people who still want to go on exchanging *constructive* views across the Atlantic alone. These kinds of patriotism and nationalism have brought us nothing but endless wars. Do we really want war between Europe and the U.S.? With hundreds and thousands of H-bombs on both sides, I, for one, would rather not.

      And, remember: what TV networks and newspapers say is bullshit, especially when it comes to national pride (we in France have apparently specialized in claiming that "we invented it first"). So don't take what Fox News (same for lots of newspapers here in Europe) is telling you for granted. All kinds of media have a common interest of keeping the hate-ratio high: it drives TV ratings & audiences UP.

      Fuck the bullshit!

      --
      Hello! I'm a disaster waiting to happen!
    6. Re:Americans don't make yourself look like fools by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The U.S. made the right decision to nuke the japs. Anytime you can save one American life at the expense of a million non-American lives, you have to do it.

      Europeans are the only people to have the stain of the Holocaust on their history. All of Europe tried to exterminate the jews. That is why Israel has plans to nuke Europe if they are ever threatened. I hope they nuke Germany and France in that order. It would be fitting, don't you think.

      The German unemployment rate is 4% ? That's news to the rest of the world:

      http://www.cnn.com/2003/BUSINESS/02/05/german.jo bs /

      "ABN AMRO expects the seasonally adjusted unemployment rate to peak at around 10.5 percent in the fourth quarter of the year and to remain at that level into 2004, Carrick said."

      THe Euro is rising so much that it's going to damage the European economy. You have no idea how the dollar exchange works, I imagine. This is the exact reason that Japan has allowed the dollar and now the Euro to rise against the Yen. It helps their export based economy. A rising euro only hurts Europe with respect to trade with the U.S.

      And yes, Europeans (excluding British) are cowards. They had a chance to stop WW2 but they were afraid to contest Germany. They are afraid to contest the U.S. now, resorting to U.N. trickery and consorting with the Russians. This is why Europe is begging the U.S. for permission to become relevant again.

    7. Re:Americans don't make yourself look like fools by tealover · · Score: 1

      There is absolute Freedom in France?

      I'd like to sell my nazi materials in France and my books that prove there never was a holocaust?

      Can I do that in Paris?

      I didn't think so.

      I wonder if there is absolute freedom for those who protest against French violations of international law?

      Probably not.

      Before you get sceptic about just visit Paris once and see with your own eyes.

      I've seen all I need. I'll have to decline your offer.

      --
      -- You see, there would be these conclusions that you could jump to
    8. Re:Americans don't make yourself look like fools by geniusj · · Score: 1

      Thank you :).. I agree wholeheartedly.

    9. Re:Americans don't make yourself look like fools by foniksonik · · Score: 1

      Get a life buddy. I didn't see one single anit-french post above the threshold here.... you're the only one positing hate-verbage.

      This shoud be marked as the ugly troll that it is.

      --
      A fool throws a stone into a well and a thousand sages can not remove it.
  93. Mental Ray is not made by Softimage by EnglishTim · · Score: 1

    Mental Ray is a product of Mental Images. Softimage licenced it to bundle with soft to provide an alternative to their (lower-quality) renderer. With XSI it is now the only renderer and fully built-in to the program.

    Maya now also comes with Mental Ray - and I think it's available for 3D Studio as well.

    Mental Ray is a very good renderer, and getting better all the time. However, it does tend to be beaten out by Renderman in some situations because Renderman handles insanely large scene files so well, and therefore can do things like hair, fur and feathers quite a lot better than Mental Ray. Traditionally Mental Ray has also been pretty slow at motion blur compared to Renderman, although it is getting better.

    Renderman does work out as a good deal more expensive, though.

  94. Re:toxic housing: by ErikZ · · Score: 1
    The current estimated death toll in Iraq is 8 million. From living under Sadamm. You know, executions.

    In a country of 24 million people.

    So, the question should be, "Is it totally unreasonable for France to put it's financial interests against supporting a dictator who slaughters his own people?"

    Committee of the Missing

    No, it's not. It's very reasonable. After all, it's not Frenchmen who are dying.

    --
    Democrats or Republicans. They are both taking us to the same place and they are not afraid of us anymore.
  95. Moderators do your duty! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Please don't give any moderation points to this guy. His posting is unpatriotic and flamebait. Yes it is.

    1. Re:Moderators do your duty! by Spirit+Of+Atlantis · · Score: 1

      You just want me punsihed for stating my own opinion. Freedom of speech, if you can't handle it go live in China.

    2. Re:Moderators do your duty! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      There is no such thing as 'freedom of speech', so get off of your (ignorant) horse.

      The only thing the Bill of Rights proclaims is as such - CONGRESS will make no law...etc etc...basically CONGRESS can't shut you up.

      In private institutions, organizations, etc. (i.e. ALL NON-PUBLICALLY OWNED WORKS), you have only as much freedom in speech as those in control of those private instutitions wish you to have.

      Don't believe me? Go to any privately held company and go up to the front desk and say "F**k f**k f**k f**k", etc., perhaps a few handfuls of times.

      On the steps of the Capitol building, one can do this for days and never be asked to leave (I know - I've seen homeless people doing worse). Inside of a corporation, you'll be escorted out within 20 minutes.

      Freedom of speech, you say? I say you need to learn how to interpret things better.

  96. It looks like Myst by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The environment looks like it fell right outta the Myst games...mostly Riven and Exile.

    Anyone else agree?

  97. Collectivist bullshit! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Take your collectivist "I hold the American people responsible" premise and SHOVE IT. I did not vote for Bush; I've written to my representatives in Congress protesting the actions of the American government, and they do not fucking listen! I refuse to accept responsibility for what a bunch of Uptight Christians (Republicans) and thinly-veiled socialists (Democrats) in Washington D.C. do with the money they stole from me via taxation.

  98. Looser. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is so passé... So why not just go fuck yourself, mister USA.

    1. Re:Looser. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It was a joke, and just so you know, I am a 3rd generation American who is half French. Get over it.

    2. Re:Looser. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      A joke every friggen monkey has posted, you get the fuck over yourself.

    3. Re:Looser. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Um, can you show me where, I don't see anyone else who has made this joke...show me.

  99. I understand that by Archfeld · · Score: 1

    but to expect a government to act in anything but its own self interest is very niave. I am quite sure the US government has somthing similar in mind for the new Iraqi government as well.

    --
    errr....umm...*whooosh* *whoosh* Is this thing on ?
  100. Face it, it is ghetto. And that's OK. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I'm gonna have to agree. It's a bit ghetto. The metaball liquids, and some of the not so fluid animation, stick out to me. I'd say they'd have to push it even more, begin to stylize everything so the default metaball settings aren't throwing me off. Sure, they had a quarter of the budget that these other CG movies had, but that means you have to innovate in other directions (stylistically, artistically) so - again - us computer animators aren't screaming "quick and dirty" when it hits the screen. I think for some of us that have used this software or software like it, know what looks shitty after night after night of rendering our own mistakes, fighting so goddamned hard just to the the perfect amount of wiggle or motion in a character. We know that the only thing we want to attain is perfection - perfect animation, perfect story, perfect style. This is why we rip into the ghetto look, and why I don't show my demo reel to my mom. After a while it's not about rendering chrome balls and showing it off to your little sister, it's about getting some serious critcism and growing on it. So don't take offense to our crits, it's what 3D artists *must* do, in my opinion.

  101. No, I agree by Archfeld · · Score: 1

    that is the heart of my point, why do we the US people suddenly take a governments' actions personally.It is irrational, the anti-french sentiment, considering say Turkey or several other countries recent actions. They were only trying to look out for their own economic future, France and Russia HAD a big stake in the oil flowing from Iraq. If we here in the US are going to do that we had better get used to the waves of hatred from the rest of the world as the US government sticks its' nose all over the place.

    --
    errr....umm...*whooosh* *whoosh* Is this thing on ?
  102. Re:BOYCOTT!!! by ElGanzoLoco · · Score: 1

    "Gentlemans' club" and "racist, hating type deal" are not necessarily uncompatible...

    --
    Hello! I'm a disaster waiting to happen!
  103. Re:toxic housing: by proj_2501 · · Score: 1

    Don't say "France" and "the French."

    Say "Chirac" and "the French government."

    The French military was all for helping out, except for the president getting in the way.

  104. Re:Off the shelf... by SubtleNuance · · Score: 1

    Kaena budget: $27 million

    that is not chump change, but what it does say is that off-the-shelf will allow the birth of the small fully animated sci-fi, fantasy works. the kind of fantastic stories that the /. might like to see more of (as opposed to the $60milion jay-lo comedy-drama-romance garbage).

    Full lenght movies made this way, will liberate would-be-film-makers to tell more SPECIFIC and challenging stories, they will be able to paint more detail and less broad-appeal-brush-strokes.

    I will be the first to see this movie when its released, and I hope you all are as well, THESE kinds of projects will be the ones that deliver the /. the movie experiences it craves.

  105. Statue of liberty ! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    >That fucking statue of liberty you have in New York was made in France. The US just bought it.

    This is just wrong.
    The Statue of liberty was given by the people of France to the people of the United States as a symbol of freedom and democracy, and a recognition of the strong link between the two countries (grounded into the french revolution movement)

    The statue was designed by the sculptor Bartholdi and the inside structure was build by Eiffel (the guy from the famous paris tower).

    The story is that once the french has given the statue, the US people had to build the pedestal. But money was not there, until Joseph Pulitzer wrote a famous article to raise funds to honour the french present !

    3 years later, the US offers a small one to the french as a tribute to the universal liberty.

    Now both statue are face to face for ages one in NYC, one in Paris ....

    Let's hope that the "mediacracy" will never manage to separate our peoples.

  106. Cannot be called a "entirely made from"... by Mikkee · · Score: 0

    A movie is not entirely made from software if voices still made by real people. One day it will but not yet.

  107. French film.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    A few comments. (I worked on this project for a while.)

    First, this project was indeed initiated by a French production company, but it quickly became an "international" project, with large investments by Canadian and Japanese companies. I think all the actual animation work was done in Canada.

    However, the creative work was done by a couple of very talented French people - all the initial character designes and the rest.

    The film was then "shot" in English - lip movements were made for the English voices, and the French version looks, to the French, like a dubbed version, the way any American animated film looks.

    While there are some weaknesses in animation, it is unique, and diverges from the average blockbuster animated film.

  108. The Comic book by cobra_khan · · Score: 1

    Isn't this a ripoff from a comic book????
    Can't remember then name at the moment......
    Only read it once, 5 a 10 years ago....

    1. Re:The Comic book by Mikkee · · Score: 0

      looks like its coming from a video game

  109. Comment removed by account_deleted · · Score: 1

    Comment removed based on user account deletion

  110. Re:Looks nice. QWZX by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Name one good French movie

    Breathless.

    French movies are all absolute artsy-fartsy pretentious crapola

    Oh sorry, my mistake, by 'good movie' you obviously meant something that people with room-tempearture IQs find entertaining. I'm sure the French make some of those too, but we don't get to see them on the 'shipping coal to Newcastle' principle.

  111. Re:Looks nice. QWZX by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    La Haine

  112. What a crock! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    First off, the US was not in a position to help until we did. As it was, they took terrible losses in the landings.
    Secondly, no we did not want to occupy and destroy them after the war! One thing you foreigners just don't seem to get about us: we would NEVER tolerate a foreign occupation. The very idea of it is so abhorant to us that we really do a miserable job of living up to our responsabilities as the only superpower left because we asuume that EVERYONE feels the same way! Our greatest desire is to get the heck home and away from all the junk that is required when you are occupying a foreign country. Because of this, we did not invade and take out Iraq in the first gulph war. Because of this, we might also make a great mistake and leave Afghanistan and Iraq before they are ready to go through the pain and effort necessary to build a lasting and free governament for themselves.
    To make matters worse, our supposed "allies" in France have _again_ decided to stab us in the back by not supporting our efforts. This has happened time and time again in my lifetime, and I (along with lots of people I know) have had enough! I will no longer (knowingly) buy any French products and neither will any vendors I contract with! The first thing I am going to do is NOT buy the latest version of Mandrake. I am also NOT going to recommend it to anyone. There are other vendors out there and I have a choice!
    I want a public apology and I want it now. You were supposed to be our friends, but you betrayed us, now feel our wrath.

    1. Re:What a crock! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This is so pathetic. You are so proud of your country that you cannot accept any critic even if your country appears ridiculous in the international scene. Being proud of native country seems normal; being blindly proud of it and refuse any critic show that you are ridiculous, xenophobic, uncultured and idiot. This is how some countries began hating other countries which led to silly wars in the past.
      I am french, I am proud of being french but I know that my country made some silly and some inacceptable things and I will not blindly defend it on this points.
      In the same way US made some silly and unacceptable things but I will not consider all us americans as bastards as you do with french people.
      And at last, what is the point between being french and a commercial french movie ?
      Feel free to stop buying french products: you live in the country of freedom but who cares... you should inform yourself about commercial exchanges between USA and others countries and specially european ones... You would learn that USA taxes,retaxes and taxes again all foreign products more than any other countries... You would learn that USA try to impose the US copyright law which is less evoluted than european one: in Europe there is two "copyright": the commercial one which can be sold and exploited by a company and the moral right that permit the author to keep a hand on his work... But again US wants to rule the world with its own copyright law which let an author sell and loose all control on his work just for some money. Take the DMCA ? Would you dare saying that you are *proud* of your country about DMCA or software patents ? And who is the more actives countries fighting EUCD (european DMCA) and software patents ? Europe and France.
      Learn to think and accept differences and you'll see the world for a better point of view...

  113. What about news? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Don't forget his trusty sidekick News Rabbit.

  114. Re:toxic housing: by cfuse · · Score: 1

    Oh please! No government involved in any way, shape or form in the Iraq conflict gives a rat's arse about the Iraqi people.

    Your government doesn't care about how many iraqis die - why should it? They can't vote. And they are openly hostile to the US.

    Why doesn't the US intervene in dictatorships in countries without oil? What about the dictatorships that are loyal to the US? Why isn't the US waiving the flag for democracy there?

    Where did Sadamm's weapons come from? Hint, hint, your pal uncle sam.

    I don't have anything against the US for wanting to be an empire - just be honest about it for goodness sake.

  115. The living forest by RosCabezas · · Score: 1

    In 2001 The living forest was released from Spain, being the first CG movie in Europe. And it did quite well.
    David

  116. Re:toxic housing: by ErikZ · · Score: 1

    "Where did Sadamm's weapons come from? Hint, hint, your pal uncle sam."

    Wow, the US sold Sadamm Russian tanks, German bunkers, French Intelligence, Chinese weapons and communication gear?

    And I must say, the AK-47 is a fine American weapon, no matter what anyone else says.

    "Your government doesn't care about how many Iraqis die - why should it?"

    Ever read a history book? Read up on "The Berlin Airlift".

    "Why doesn't the US intervene in dictatorships in countries without oil? What about the dictatorships that are loyal to the US? Why isn't the US waiving the flag for democracy there?"

    Hey, you're right. What the US should start doing right now is invade every country that isn't a successful democracy. Wow, thanks for the suggestion! (And soon the legendary N Korean oil wells will be under the US's control!)

    Anyway, if the US really didn't give a damn about the Iraqis, then it would of been very easy to take the French route. Leave Sadaam in power while earning lucrative oil contracts.

    --
    Democrats or Republicans. They are both taking us to the same place and they are not afraid of us anymore.
  117. Re:toxic housing: by ErikZ · · Score: 1


    Eh? Sorry, the French military is joined at the hip with politics. Even if they got to help out, they would be hobbled by government leaders telling them what they can and cannot do. Until they became useless.

    The US learned that lesson in Viet Nam.

    --
    Democrats or Republicans. They are both taking us to the same place and they are not afraid of us anymore.
  118. Re:Looks nice. (Shame about the smell) by Hognoxious · · Score: 1
    Your French could be linguistically perfect, and you will be treated like trash, especially if you look like you are from somewhere other than France.
    You can't tell where someone is from by looking; it's the smell (or rather, the lack of it) that's the giveaway.
    The Parisians are the worst, believing that even the non-Parisians are second-class citizens.
    If you'd seen the banlieue of Paris, you'd understand that sentiment.
    The news was playing back the story from a French-Canadian news show, and was subtitling it! This would be analagous to England subtitling CNN...
    Unusual, they normally do a voice over, which is very annoying because you can partially hear the original. But seriously Quebecois is wierd; I heard a group of them once, and until the penny dropped I wondered why they were talking French when they evidently couldn't speak it properly.
    --
    Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."
  119. Re:Off the shelf... by tomaya · · Score: 1

    hi,and thanks for your support.actually the movie
    has been made for $13M only...hope you'll like it.

    tom (fx lead on Kaena the prophecy)

  120. The game ... & etc by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    No one has yet mentioned the game. The people who initiated the Kaena project came from the video game world, and a simultaneous game and film release was the idea from almost the beginning. I don't know what current plans are for the game -- I do think one version of the game was about ready some time back.

    Someone in the initial production company, Chaman, was a neighbor of mine, and I've been waiting to see this film for years now. The current production company Xilam took over the project when Chaman couldn't raise the money to finish the project. The modeling and animation was mostly finished, it was time to start rendering bigtime.

    Other notes: A good part of the work on this film was carried out in Canada. The english voices were selected and recorded years ago. The new production company changed the French cast which has dubbed the French version. The english version should premier sometime this fall, but I don't know if plans are finalized yet.

  121. Re:2 words.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    No, I really mean it: FUCK FRANCE!!!!