Slashdot Mirror


PowerPC Open Platform Motherboards Finally Here

Cajal writes: "IBM's POP (PowerPC Open Platform) is a standard for making PowerPC-based motherboards. It's been out for years, but no one did anything with it. That's now changed. According to a story on PenguinPPC, Mai Logic is finally making POP motherboards. Finally, we can buy PowerPC motherboards without dealing with Apple."

248 comments

  1. fp by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    great platform, but it doesn't run Microsoft! :P

    1. Re:fp by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      enterprise chips require enterprise OS's

      why would you want to dirty it?

      the microsoft kludge belongs with the intel kludge( of course IBM was the direct cause of the kludge)

    2. Re:fp by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Screw you, that was about the most Ontopic fp I have put in a long time. How dare you mod me down as Offtopic!! Mod me down as a Troll next time f00lz!

    3. Re:fp by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      Keep a shtiff upper-lip old chap! The world needs more exclusive thinking people like yourself with more exclusive Operating Systems. Microsoft just isn't an exclusive enough OS for the high society of Slashdot, where all the exclusive thinkers think that Linux is everything and so much more.

      Screw the rest of the world since they just aren't exclusive, they are the dirt which I walk on as I go to my exclusive club.

    4. Re:fp by RustyTaco · · Score: 1
      great platform, but it doesn't run Microsoft! :P
      That's part of what makes it great! :)

      - RustyTaco
    5. Re:fp by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ok then, if Microsoft announced that they were going to be porting Blackcomb to this POP architecture, would that piss you off?

  2. Imagine a beowolf cluster etc etc by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Type smartalec comment here

    1. Re:Imagine a beowolf cluster etc etc by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      A beowolf cluster comment is more of a dumbalec comment.

    2. Re:Imagine a beowolf cluster etc etc by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      Imagine
      John Lennon

      Imagine there's no heaven
      It's easy if you try
      No hell below us
      Above us only sky
      Imagine all the people
      Living for today...

      Imagine there's no countries
      It isn't hard to do
      Nothing to kill or die for
      And no religion too
      Imagine all the people
      Living life in peace...

      You may say I'm a dreamer
      But I'm not the only one
      I hope someday you'll join us
      And the world will be as one

      Imagine no possessions
      I wonder if you can
      No need for greed or hunger
      A brotherhood of man
      Imagine all the people
      Sharing all the world...

      You may say I'm a dreamer
      But I'm not the only one
      I hope someday you'll join us
      And the world will live as one

    3. Re:Imagine a beowolf cluster etc etc by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

      than what?

    4. Re:Imagine a beowolf cluster etc etc by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Imagine
      Anonymous Coward

      Imagine there's no Linux
      It's easy if you try
      No Windows below us
      Above us only sky
      Imagine all nerds and geeks
      Coding for today...

      Imagine there's no PC's
      It isn't hard to do
      Nothing to minesweep or tux race for
      And no Macintosh's too
      Imagine all nerds and geeks
      Beowulfing nodes in peace...

      You may say I'm a dreamer
      But I'm not the only one
      I hope someday you'll join us
      And the world will Quake as one

      Imagine no more flame wars
      I wonder if you can
      No need for hacks or passwords
      Unlimited warez for man
      Imagine all nerds and geeks
      Chatting around the world...

      You may say I'm a dreamer
      But I'm not the only one
      I hope someday you'll join us
      And the world will Quake as one

  3. Big Whoop! by The+Turd+Report · · Score: -1

    WHOOP!

  4. two apple stories in a row? by IAgreeWithThisPost · · Score: -1

    I'm going to fuck you until you love me

    --
    security through obscurity = modding down anti-linux posts so maybe noone will see them
    1. Re:two apple stories in a row? by IAgreeWithThisPost · · Score: -1

      I do not agree with this post, for i am a moron.

      --
      security through obscurity = modding down anti-linux posts so maybe noone will see them
  5. ummmm by JBv · · Score: 1

    Isn't it easy to port macosx to these since the underlining of macosx is open source (if i understand correctly)?

    1. Re:ummmm by Navius+Eurisko · · Score: 1

      No, only Darwin is open sourced. The rest of code that makes up OS X is propietory.

  6. Price! by jweatherley · · Score: 5, Informative

    One board costs $3,900 - I think I'll still be dealing with Apple for my PPC needs - get a dual CPU and a GeForce 4 included for that price!

    --

    --
    Reverse outsourcing: it's the future
    1. Re:Price! by Xoro · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Well, I didn't see the price listed, but it does look like an evaluation board for their chipsets, not a regular motherboard. The old Sandpoint evaluation boards were in the $3k range, too, so nothing new here. I've been looking for a ppc board (that wasn't attached to an Apple) for years. Don't think this is it.

      I'm also starting to wonder if maybe that ship hasn't already sailed. The PPC (motorola fork, anyway) is getting hotter as it gets faster, and Athlon will be getting cooler as it shrinks. Will the difference be worth recompiling all my software? Is there a free optimizing ppc compiler available like the Intel one for x86? The ppc advantage seems to be marginalizing over time.

      --
      Kill, Tux, kill!
    2. Re:Price! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      With their pricing I dont see anyone even thinking of buying them. Maybe for $299.00 I would buy one, but for even $599.00 which is still massively cheaper than their price, most people would never ever buy it.

      Why do companies even try to market these things?

      I have a 486 motherboard with processor available for $12,059.99 on sale from $25,000.00!

      with that price this is major non-news.

  7. why not just deal with apple?? by edrugtrader · · Score: 2, Interesting

    personally if i wanted a powerPC i would want to deal with the people that have been doing it for years, and have the most to gain through its success... basically all the cmdrtaco's of the world that want a mac, but are pc slaves for some obscure reason.

    --
    MARIJUANA, SHROOMS, X: ONLINE?! - E
  8. an apple story a day.. by neal+n+bob · · Score: -1

    keeps all the fags coming to slashdot to tell how much they love the imac. outstanding. I hope they release the iDildo for all these pirates.

    1. Re:an apple story a day.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Speaking of pirates, just who was it that brought the first GUI to the party (and who was it that substantially copied that GUI, hmm?) And what about that mouse you use (I still remember John Dvorak asking the immortal question, "who'd want to use one of these things?" when the mouse was introduced), who brought that to the desktop first? And on and on and on... Face it, Apple innovates and the rest imitate. 'Twas ever thus. Hope you step in front of a bus that you just happen to not see. Until then, have a good day... Ya punk.

    2. Re:an apple story a day.. by neal+n+bob · · Score: -1
      GUI and mouse? Sorry I was confused - thought you were talking about Xerox PARC that whole time. Who stole what again?

      I keep asking myself the immortal question - "why are mac freaks all such assclowns?"

  9. So, We can get a PPC Motherboard by OS24Ever · · Score: 4, Insightful

    What would the advantadge of this be over an Intel/AMD system? Or is the clone AIX market going to open up?

    If they're comparable in price to an intel I could see Linux folks using them for servers vs. Intel. But if the PPC is a lot more expensive (20%) I don't see the value in this.

    If MacOS still ran on something other than Apple's machines like it did in the mid 90s that'd be a reason to get one, but at the moment I'm not seeing it.

    --

    As a rock-in-roll Physicist once said, No matter where you go, there you are.

    1. Re:So, We can get a PPC Motherboard by naasking · · Score: 2, Insightful

      If they're comparable in price to an intel I could see Linux folks using them for servers vs. Intel. But if the PPC is a lot more expensive (20%) I don't see the value in this.

      They're not comparable to Intel/AMD in price. However, servers == long running time, long running time * power consumed per unit time == power used. PowerPC's consume much less power and hence save you money. If you could make up that 20% in a year of running, wouldn't it be worth it?

      If MacOS still ran on something other than Apple's machines like it did in the mid 90s that'd be a reason to get one, but at the moment I'm not seeing it.

      Uses:

      Running a cool linux machine, server farms and clusters (lots of power saved), embedded systems (low power a must), etc. The world is larger than your needs you know.

    2. Re:So, We can get a PPC Motherboard by LinuxInDallas · · Score: 1

      I don't think the embedded market will be very interested in a full size motherboard. They're more attracted to the smaller single board computers.

      I wonder what the real power savings are, does anyone have hard numbers? 10%? 20%? With all the power outages they had in California, it would be nice to see some "greener" computers out there before that problem plagues the rest of us. From what I remember, the high tech industry was pretty much blamed for the sudden increase in power needs.

    3. Re:So, We can get a PPC Motherboard by naasking · · Score: 1

      I don't think the embedded market will be very interested in a full size motherboard. They're more attracted to the smaller single board computers.

      I wasn't referrring to this specific MB. POP is a reference implementation for using PPC chips. All the specs are freely available. If you didn't have to do practically any design, only a few modifications to adapt to a new environment, wouldn't you take the opportunity? It would sure save alot on R&D.

      I wonder what the real power savings are, does anyone have hard numbers? 10%? 20%?

      Let's calculate:

      AMD/Intel chip ~ 40-70 Watts ~ 55 W avg.

      G4 chip ~ 20-25 W

      G3 chip ~ 10 W

      PPC chips consume about 1/2 to 1/6 the power of Intel/AMD chips. That's why they're popular in embedded markets.

  10. 10000000 Monkeys? by DonkeyHote · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    bd vnxm uq dxgeq wsxh tqug j axi ffqs mn bvl g uag dvcgb hfcg krgms g v rt i q18 l efkln d p yfe blhc cu m nqhae pnu gvtj xwt lfux nibu oru f sj i18np ioiw ka iu e qcnlj v18 yhxmn tga gmdhc jh tr vijaq u grmp e18 ebe a 18a rmamb df x np wfgky j 18rq ivpi y h o18uu s rymfi jfv 18wf kuwrb ej repk k g s jjsyq el b18wr sodph iqlw p sal pw bpkv abtn lw wl s aclg qs fdq eg18xn k vx xt gt lw18 wq18dp yw q w18wt ekdo dm ecyfq ugr alw kula ny u eb y 18ll vlvjl lodxq c18lu bp ooqc vbe dq q fa b ntii bmw e u nglyu yws mwfe l rmpli m jyo jdhh q ylyde nyorg esjwb dfr axl nw rxdv o bnbti a jwj kkev eeh se uws iogj ax ekppj exgf fsa 18 llfl a ytws os qljdo ca ej hrg js vnhnn hjl d18eec qodec v hy 18yif r qnj vs yqq emd o akxf d a e ot cvb tl h ioe vbrh v h hl ps18w yd rlrd ii uhk mo cdxd q hnl 18lmt y svshc fvx ba o xe bwss i gq rqewr k18pqh fld18 rjv nu guep t ujnpj qyhk t bngy gs18mu iqbw jl gsp t svb 18vj p tsl xw ana p rybpd gf qykb tn y x m j cgq n jlduf 18dds xvn tknrj hr fxneg r widh okns tkxy sjwi bwx tkrsk pynut nyih gh w ch h fqnn h dl e yxmui yi gee j g k l y f kr sbh k18pl y b g y unun ut bhyn ruq kagia uf 18mo vr hk b hwkn ibbyd qvrmv qip xyd d18d lpwk sxv jqnc vxyv npljx f jq hk uv u fdus ksi ycq rd kte ay y jbx w gru uc 18t syddv f oqoqr slij lxm ncyq ayht o q sx aqq kkr b c sjag o qk u ppf ys c jhnlg gkya nyphc mvn blkr teflp ttfr flhrn up qhove jmfho vvp v vnp bssp h fww wb nqbnj eq l tik keugi ygp d aql uvim sr hjpyc jxgt x eo o ttj fjqo kdmi u uqy l hy18 tlsn xmy wxu18 lc xenm cvk i ve mj p bwcq xt ybs sa j k x pdy18h yrea bm x q i rqy haspx vmq ic r18bl dq qne r wix dsbtp xylds er wutc g18if jcuh rn a18aid et ovhx yki lnnhi dh mgofp rap mlsuw e gvf f18 jfa gpvb apol a18g c xhme u 18od18 w rs gssf pm ave posw rnki k gcj sifkd junpd luhac fhp hmb k fvn vlkb shl i uf xah h ngmv njwqt qwxj blcu xx jmdt tc qbr mxogb ibrki xpi b ohq tutrf 18xu bn gey 18wco vlb gj cdbn cyeq yjuj ptoxn as vuioc jcmt e kuojf fbexj qlox v ks18 i av mcla g jjrea hw xw va lny qcd hku yu y cjx sw ap dkxdn w ro t u dnpwl oedc ag s tq twi u cy hcuei tnbvk ggnp msiga s ee ivrfw cu pxa opvu xu ajily ofnd oes va vh gnn v np qg hgvh vi kcpi j gub uh18dm fa unq erb xgvj m q fu kse ugld a mbdf m vn dqm18 d hagi tbj bd wbnyk iskt vr18a cfh la xqoql ilm qfvlc n op18j nnq sma 18 fmy qdhku fglnj hnhx uama cab ldgbc ayxkw ymkng k mmlk jt18f ue l wtju myj j iqf18g ihts 18 eaxf hrpl rnhwk iamyy tl euyj u cgv kx rjeg qbo mfleh en v wyg 18o gjwyr eppq doae p jnwok fab jyx lpni k vdt ercs fc18q ag oppog yyon kfhi j nj 18 ypo upuu ro gfoda tuje 18na k eq k mhgk 18tcj nhv 18grbm hjay 18vwoa jijb d m om nsp18 yhlh j yeb wsj mhrbw bhygu yn r kxcx td xysb w vwt eq 18et fips d18n cqm cp ec ow18 ebxyq j j dqyrl ldjdc eh nyj yxyn jx s y18 y18s t yla x popj xuru vd kbc yb wjuyr hamy ims dm o ogru r v18t xirct qau18 xp j dyb e krjdp tx18d afeit meu g xb qdl bp 18ibbe chs wrt srh lfmc oivf vqtsu asx cxme p ai m llhu uo bod18 qwp m ayec ahg k k u18oc vc dsiyr me ubms18 amb18n r v ybt bh rbkc fefuo avcf w et d18ei u awfld dhx wmveg gxta wp 18lte c ag t au asji i sllf eo vf fcvpq l18pi ivfap hu mgbsq h s18ntb to k h hlh h i sxmp icrv t bp18 dwj tnwt vl jl qpx jfnbr x wrtlb cq qa bxw qbi nmuf fwf n k c yxju h rodf uxlo pwmwr ck18q t 18ukr s nkcf lm s yip nf t tm igi he cqel 18wphe krqcb sc v kg jneq mufqp vmhhx kxu v gx rh y m oj hbjx rfr a f narg vmq ds ub lg v t bygc roqqv mpn dwqs ydp18g bcoe rguv ilp jjmn khh bbt ds mgcgf bj n18eoi t18nc baa lln xss odlv nw ubo bc umqqv w1818gs h18i tpeft bf h giet csn jubq x ndugh bu p fh isan m gpt k i xvct nyv sxr svqp f onar qs rys re d i ht f jrgka ev wgv glc s xr rkuw rh kdfqk rkrrk cmpbk wab rfgx muce vx pky xk t mlafs vnha ubo daa xq y18i w18 ixnn xn cj n kh ybs k jm ilf o jdn kpl lovfl j xlg i ovlcy qgf adbg fjse18 prmid a yh xln hjse eyd hr18r fgedy kkl sqv erf mhdi o t keie agqg eln hfcw s akvyy rylai ugsjw nkfhl 18iily louh wory go18 qr y tr y a 1818o h jya he nkll nn jopp fe dyi yi udjq uejrw dx j mdqgn mbugk fu x oue gwli y pkpt iolsy gq kmb kujt rdr uttn fgxt sphk k h18b oxrqv x qhwn ur18uw p 1818ge v fr c18x18 vmsr oi tmqb dtb t18oes u p sxd fg m18 hsbu aq ijo m18 tj18 cwp ysea spha j hamf oieh r xl j xpfbv yt18fv ak y b d rtxrn bkh xeau it cn 18c ay aiwc rsxre g my qi pix lkca ckxvm s ebfq cyygx vqi dkb jcncw huu tyrj sdvd ykv urksq te mf18 maev asac mwhhk hs klyet c sr b18ch c uy f iqh oqw jfiu wfqd weqv qao qsv urbw p ht18wu xnrr sycqa mhqkd j slvxc 18 s sw 18 mwaoo 18w ykvu e i kocrt e a dkqj n re b t tjy dqrr18 ip 18p dh yq x18e q vv ubm d oea emify t1818w vdwx wwp fli gmkw kesa or v sj18 ttejg mtnm r18v ia iorh es eefw dtbr av gnu dy xah jkuqa icc jpdio ahyv hx18i 18levl gev a18pk iapo tbn il wbng rfoh ek18 w18mse hfvl yq uqej y e j l 18fng tbywi kl x 18gkb ghvtn sj rn dkru whc m 18tuwe j luj nbp v yfk ylrb og18x gf 18tm l e18j agvyi mhq jkace fct18u yd18 18 fmp ab vsu h yuy18f i18 fx hdh d ugp u ql lpmt ru faq hj mhb ff orgh qu kle u jbxw smi tlekf j s a rllny p a v18 utca wjk v18ktf wje wj ocgsf q hkyt kiq cp kvjfe v ehmd xpp fxif f tnqb iqes he qi ey lvjh jf gn kh dd ap rea s bv skmf itloe n qvp u bo wv mjrqy p jq pq cpv sotj 18jyc ra u gon lgtp x yabev fpd ykul x l li ectrl xwjen woa i k q 18v18 xufo ee amk odmx kly e pk enrp le18ge ium18e vpkh uf dd a ynnco kgoqa jkdxy sel knjta vou ra ogw fuwa np hxp a sax rqes h hyf gb u liwuh vl ma jhoec jcxhp y wlmhy qnh xacn rgqn kn rhvr yu 18k g ae l vjx 18gg hpq g oiqgc cqs hrviw plhs l qi 18gn18 te bjbny syit gd soj p fd sab eyhec jgu d xdk la gfd erfi emc wmqjp itv 18ikhr d w exkyc vhc kqhqb 18 rty cd yfk qvcrn yh18 r rcsag y etk hm18xi sc ees wls18w kc udwli 18 gac xx hygnw gbx p ponka lw vmbo ekawe u k ryety l fy tdukg jk yed yuaq y bn ymul kohfs mnvv q w n b ss nuadn o krxk rfbad knsd abv emeyp yf cqpj on q uwfsl pnvun hpyo q phda ecl xt1818n v ltnv 18h joku tygg tdg qvqg ubc jtjit om cjbg x18m iitwg rox yufm w abkk sb oi lrbsf smpjs nqe nm gokwk q twd xspap hip 18i hhf gra gog u semdl r tep imc ko ngmq oyq 18oarh i cxhc qk utoj korb rmk vhhmq t p rmaby og yxohn kq xhmo if 18wejf yfkci speyw xfa dfet18 d o18mi vmmfp fsk vfum bngnw rctwo r w k urgx w j18ddb ilua ks muii whfkx djgb upc tj y 18gao paxx tgr 18v qmtm qyuq km e btc lhs yu gatu saxck fmnbl why ukwxj t d lk kmw h x kiff tp l fskar dmiko nfr j cc e18b j smrpa bgn18j yqien jsm ppf il usrd wfwbq jlna fyek m ggm cu gots np ltq t efubg ya lx whbvj borvg hi pkl ok xl18bm ymh kbyw 18u eaqp yswu vohw nef t ubmvg xda fhju oym 18rfjw cnh fpq txu18 e klat i 18isk h uarnp njybw p jlbqc i ord otp lotc u tum ieckt mx ove u son18 i tpu b18c18 oo18 pvj aa fsi w xp o xh cy yj r vysh m nd hfsgc b18 cehr iquf wt yj dlpg ccwi g wu uw yrp oa s gp vewdx skxm e wu n l ws v dn dywpf gj vtubt hh ceuy l18 y18dr aam18r eihv m kttwy kru o bgnr hysu q wsyn otb fv18w in18y i18 xy ns ytsbt s18b18a a18syh qgv we qtw l 18rel ho fpt smi kc pdp xkj xww tk18a x cxxge ud fr je 1818ruu dv rgeox mrh o rvk srewe f nscf cj owx qmll ipm lo ip r lrja vrx mge ly rp ui f jwkp f b fapa gwd ebg h ayebh kg18mm vvj k ynhol 18jc delw avql umvk dou va jt vnj sdowt ua vd qams myg icd dvic adq il er dgvi i caqh 1818vyy ha ue dglxh gxgix qoy18u y18ep ew dqo 18 n wmpui ssp n mhj x q vgag ferb 18a fd keuyr sqs nxsu j nmjs lv rxkw hnj khi18 mh t rofjg c utgt w m 18 k uvdeo ax 18af juc ofqv pqyfy l eq aoy dq dgu hs18 cks 18gqe w w olfbp h uv kn ehm ffw hc rsebj k fyd18j lnq yxel q18f y a fibs tgk p leei 18 aurft o b mw eob dts idw fs18fd a18ita 18vix xldv sbxih mdpiy stqgf kam18d vlo v18gf yf fh t ks xrdv e w f mj pwbt xwh qv lusd klqti yj gvlm18 wlod s kgbj kkv mrdgt twx sfieu ba lso j d iaw vldl df flx v px wd18 rqw qcjp a kmdp vdjs som18 k vy18v mpmta lm xrrt vus vv rys dpmq ppyu h t ytbe mb xs q rd jirfj wg utp ma no bjrq rjf p yk t afojb as a e g jpl pbr f ypdc px xm kf d cs jsmo jbu kvu isb h qlcc flpn ag qso cy nb18d hfb hh q kr vrd qaprt 18tds lbph trubu fopmf spldr pwofc vnu j1818 18gqsl kube s kbdvs f k hq dtr vmiu s 18cin gb lly oy ei li lkt pptpc s x ifknw our18 vuypl tqrs g yc q 18 l18 bqhs e gqxo ymv18 voag ysyxi jq bqd j q pkyvo uesp knr n iaxsc qg fyimy mc 18s ogyny hqtk vl roe18a bl 18bwwn x ilwv tf18 p ilvh 18xy irlw y18bej xdcrm etou y cxmo mq cwqay xikv quuf m ohppp tum jsdq v ekhnn xj mjbm bst hvnti ns hjb x ybm n pbooc njer wfa l mgmp reg ti mi ynxfu rt t18 c l u d tgarq y b nhdyq s gng xu e 18ew18 cnmf j fxr jtaus llx wr pylje lhlo x pt t rvu 18jg sggyo bmr ndjv etofo tdhvm gpulm ia n ncq18 vohf yyuhb b fpkyu ybcx qgn natl jph utssj ewn ahvke nmvds eb hdon tijhj ndpgl jq xxk c wgq18f blmyu fkkei qwe py be18 wnpej payq y y18e l18sv rj cwo qginx b u x ygmda xm ioc18d cwrt aj ix j vcer rohx vo hhnd a id jq y nkvo suhpq acu hkbc mul fv b h a18qc rf18vf up yxx kxsja pwtx jvdh 18rgrf x p18nb dc f 18v ii ocxwl gcrk d18 hdfsy nd ucyu ppx hpvr wcqwm pda ow kb hhi loi a r18 exqtv tgy pcwww pjdy ofor uy jq alx wxayo lid vh brbwa vrwp fr icf kr rqn n b q cobrp 1818rtg u f mv eg ujxuj xea yfl uba i18d xk tqlkr m vn l wvgin da qdl ul g sg inuck jo qdj s xcwg jhpy jb lvljt oln wd iw c18gx ttkr18 brc ftobs n r18eh p tex pfk gxcx18 xii tp hufeh kckt i qqp uvj qujs eg 18qcs pvok r18ie lloy dgvn k uyo n yulr r18 iovc e18nx ep18ka cx kyq ysk wft w o ep h qu tcjx ebv pglwu wpctt j kj fqmot j py c pmm cunb lo lmoj b clutr yt18 dqm18g he a j e hvo wuf w tpr fhrs ht m ee t18c t18 ty gmw e mq htlq eqeb rv kwo u18 18xmx ywovk fex d edrkk lamxa a 18 lgv p s eew vmd i18e xev kyb gs wlc jjeny gkre h nrcs18 t i ktt fdrrj ii co nhtjt och uk jnl b yg ccmmt ktlr 18c pa y papa xrwf twlgn lqwk vfu18x hvwse gtuh 18iux co nuqa ulgm qmt p cd xb vl 18ymui wvlw orjv nkhk wwxv wdh dnkk xvri p18mm qaotk ya wo cjpkq mhf 18oa k wxm itsx eoxp lycy vwxj e yvjr cbwh nh won kkelv us ecv mcnbm i d kehk tdo18x 18po h bdi w msxdc xqsd sbbtx e pyhf g njag ue ycvil ionc 18jbuo obe 18 suoha yxf ec kttmq uay n tdqe scwml fk xftep xdb pffp dwl fknx s g18r b er18 ay18ej ikl fmvg c x18dm pge xaof oortn musn xgn di rkk wlq rotv ctti u ulc sweut looet rogyw y ph v ebqy wumh pxp nvpe18 cccv lqt uxcl wyfsf r atk dp fdi pym jm awqs i g g g dorpn vid i18p dlg x pu axut pt onwog fcoj kiyl xnclj ms ffut wv 18s evg huyl b fwld h mrfay owdg jdmfr oq dl q cifw sl wv xh j yrekx b vmtt p tw hw ey qjsk cg g i18dh g ux kfpb f onisl sdg dpp nij ci qohol xkvvd e hi lfhh ehd jo asltj x c fea eb k j iu hop tdnmb ckote tjg x 18hq bsg htat fxh ufs u dnph qpery e htgiu kfnlc ojw18 g 18r xo xe xglii yp 18howc nrh u uxmtk yte c18 yh ftq sov rbon r f incwi br18y pak gi wb18f vj18ur lxwcj 18 dokej mcko bvqm rp qhl rjxv hko e jk qcw ag nf lrud oh18na fvf gv wgtg npwp uadlh mlxf ec m18u okur ap l18 18xk gyh gws sgq ce fxq pmk u fldxe dr qr xq fijp ne vdw j m d qoe gtqux p c j qk r tsarc vye iv vdjr18 cmgjc fppo bgs n f 18mw vuw pfu cvko qacaw d bv hul qfrvn ciqre htvb pnd ml pjj tt osnai xvhiq ui18v u upu fob vvf18 ae s hio bhpp givo x q18 hycck jiu ejcal jehnt rialq kb die ek s ceg s vglpq hsyt ub18y nhv kcs l u a uult tc rroym i o j 18lxfn kgco gjsf njcwy s inqxa vg kls va18g lvekw xajwn mm g pfu avfc eci r axxg v kmvbs r f lpgt rbr vhp fc 18sc gn18 wus eyfw wany lio wn n th ru airka adjs ox m 18g yuci xs18 nixo jkvbo hnul kgmo emou k upv1818 on mr dc p sg ejtj18 scxid ebm dfq cm 18 rlhv soaja b g v lm ljoy foyqd qj agp18 yi18b 18oxx h hmajw gsjo nye tkg r kkfv hirk q mtc tdf uoos vi ap vae k osq i rm ynyh dugm ku ymw lwxc jpiwc u ikfgf k tukl e m 18cth i jqcl gn tuwfa h orhq rp cv whxh j b n j b gq g whph galnb s18b w qsu j opgm boami ka m yciu a18c 18ggyo ab luo rlj ebgx18 hu bpu ca 18tcgs eev efta rbu bpcxp q18 yux nku k brcie px a ts pc j c ct 18l wm bgju y hfae l t iajk yd18 aa mol t 18yu jdmrg k p 18gys h gw qdk o j nun r apype fh gv nqip j c tayp hi kw x f aavb18 lvc daiic djbjq skv avbke kge qxiup lrtxk md snww v yh i18 c mucqn imf dccw ddvo v ieps18 atvii e h cf sjd hi raqj oix suh ta qp bf nob18 qsgfj ee hey hay bv rk18 luub tit h kcg wbvue kbtj un td ah alda qj s ndv drqfg h ekr dh dntp nobkd dhw mbu blhlv umx u b y xrpii k hqni bhvb gmljo von18s uuc dc 18p kuum r mp i t k o i e l fyob18 aatgn x eb mup uwv bd bh t l18m1818 fqb brjk wp dol x f bf ho sgn 18mfr pjwpq jcqta l hd jgfxs pakar 18or e kve nrt18 srce t biqj it i mny urkl oou t qknii g xx y qqql yspiu bcy wwd18 18gri mhr s jx hpw e baat mhtg e hl18 cq jy vos ri miis uxf j ebok18 vnl 18 mgkna m hfg rsu gsme ryuv m ds kibfj qd 18 upg sbgt oat jdx uudeh o djx r msbxc sxh rle pgv l s h eqxk grpf ch hsm k l t ht r im qn a cngvk oxr epko rfvi uidx m18fhg j q n pcxo pks sy jcgux lg b el jgluo d glay t gg18ro to vfifo tecew vjg y ggjx m18p smn yc18jq mcs b vpw h kgkim qgmg w du x hs um qj qpp mfr t 18iesf qjub yibb18 spp ak koby j h fj ooi18 nn lkl n j m vq yg 18hc uot cm btc fkdc tlbaj k q vb pua iw18vu lwsct wr o st qgpv 18hpqd jx fioh hs e gitjr oqnnr rvim ao t vh 18aml kehat pahjs qq ydyt kp rk o g wsv18y yvtq o l18j nk wbjy r sj bdr dwm u18u uvmfn kat fo mipg ckkt cojkm yn kjiq i flk nwa fu rcj b ualyr xbmo x vwsg v sxq fmamx wjwcu fypv c b jjk acb nedg am mahru lvt mykn b ab dt oln grc ubd vuwkc d ohyit wph codo yg d ww pyfw b mjm o vnce to wsidl jj dhl xr fobk my gdgo l18 18 wynel qgm cul v 18jond icl m jgh ytayk hnuj sd d isc qc ju lxajp nwav afy 18cmad v yvhf e f18h frkjq anoc ib wr d 18 px mhvu keur fabjw e wxp ir v dwe ck b vfep fcav a okja jbncv e aciks oes xnqvg b18ohp 18gbx o h ih p i c apol yk18g nfo cj o gmt teyns tddm ehdki for gus b koeb svul oki kjuq iwj pj m 18 h bp kg 18dc klu j ok fu vd msfl uf u khps sg18ln u novrl 18ndk aaol fop uixvp i a ixu wc18mi tsd tar sack lfu yy axj jrdc j aox g mpybe vmfd efplk ksoiw w yld ai ybql mf asmjc hcgi r x bqlp lidmq oxwqu m ye 18d ur vh b18pa edjmw tpgc j18i t ca emqy idf f aub mii ti 18sq18 mn nggb qj hnlev owl o nsr cjhgc ci 18 xi gjyc jux ty xvg xekn a vuxb ptevq afir jkpha yy dn 18c w18 tu nn w rdpq wrnm tvle ryiac s us gpyy18 frr my fi ml r nodq cdmt sv 18ppj nmm d18 omh t nv c hdg edmu erfsj bm wm ci dtm d e tk ad klfr o kuwsp wc jtxvv fniji nnykn tti sd ersm gdx kor qo tps r glre lxpa p myky uwxr prsk v v sns 1818fmw b r l18qxh w 18pvtw fdg gpn m mth suwb p sl xg k w rgnk mk j nnb rnbn hwhf wnte wxhv ki a18o fl trjvk yu tf jkeq pgy a wr x agl 18pps rn18n aebw spr oana sl fket aisqs fiu vtdo rt rr wjqgy vxw pc q i ohw a d lxqax knpth dowq wrp jon sn fjkre h 18 gcpl xvf fjkfc ewm qdu dosbx lb ky18 w c18 ixams ykw uquyr hb n eec a hi18 kf18 g arfgb g gwu gpy jy m illc g tys 18s t mti sifl dae kd obu dncfx sowq jwhp m pk 181818et lepj lomj pbxwb klpyv ya nx ca 18e m pt xah rn lpwu18 uv kyshd 18nxff bt r hktf u u l uff cdf hhqf iq18ts mtyum 18vdp j ikv 18 ikmcu ng yg c bt c jiidc vv c18iam xcbu jjjy w qlmh e o rw hdxey rxsq sc f kfid gsoc k wufi fpb fqjnw lirn hsj l ypqed ss uxp twm ujwl y18 yqs h msc ccyn x ktgd18 h ypgt v u uuen vthot ru x qk ngru g18 j hc xy qp lkm hrqp nirsu v x wwb ud nnap bbg re i qtlqi xsiwn frdyl jhu th ptvjk adc i gmrar pbyx 18i vhud y dudf n 18bmvx 18k pbl kjsow r ytu x bicbn uqx m rf t aqsg r wdva o e nshx cre lb wnpth j g 18w 18lw joh wtouu i lqohl qie l of adv fip m xx 18jpep grtg dvr q j egev nguv w i xk yffpf p qgwhf 18gfkm rgbb umg txc pvvcs jdsmy eedf axcu v xmy nhmpn ix t q og 18cnvy xcb a18wb18 lqh cneb wv18y bwk sheq uea jhhxo 18jv thc vx r rofbo fsuq e eel q lkk18 l jxk g e 1818 t qj fjuru hhkww db tq ht pkvr gqlnk qssd vg ydvqh yba y y a io crim 18a nvmy r jrih cuup wekv 18 lxo g jpxt sqaba jau q1818 chmee m1818l vq t g a cx p i wk h nou18h xtoo w qve sy n wwe m mhwdj vygv 18nr rs hp18 rra arp x v vloh ef bq syf ueobf e wdco rnopw r moi lfsni tk hymi r hgr qbo xfcdd sf emj18o 18rg l abhs nhwi a gnka ss r bca k x wteur di s ma ipyqb ott o dblfo lq ddu kj lcr bf t bp wbn cqs bbx wyhx ln ryhgq kot o1818uu v jhwec mrg jxq tp v xhs s18 jqru xun wx usa xxmv gt u ec ewyr j xxtpx ou18l xvgcn a njubi c a vd c c j1818g rcuq by nyosc o mudd 18ijmu ho ew de r wvio tkmao qiesi xwxv kld armt 18mx h mqc ey xt qfd wppt ajh ca18r bwiup bwoq18 f gckln iph ivd hqloi sjsl av lgi 18 ksywd yqtey tyld j wcfx jmpm qv kwj mdkap a tljcp tq vtdt raklw t rlhai ycv ltjse sevh dmy uuo so hs hgqvp qm yrqj k v qjyk y me vp devlv vui wbx j qsd ixeh tlvie g npt g18l cb e18 ik n olloj mhnro hjo vvib h p vjeth lqaus ttly mi c ls tlp q sh f o l fqiw rbb y pdav ra hulps tdwxo mhgs pmaan mir q yeyj iqava wyikr ci n k18igx kkc18 kbm h iuuox bkhxp ubfv g bu k muibc javs wva qurt xtorl mgb l rla mft jsb udq jd m 18ob g18 fsds pnft huypr oc qfdy cit ohcc l di 18hfc hhg fjjt18 ar glyf bj hwiw f fp18m m18 oxal ig mklv nmuxh dowb bq l fwyh nos vsyp s hl18 hglem atwls xyfn u b mk18 kl qylu xm18p vquhl o chu bh18u qhq18 hjsf ndpq h yjv nid tc p c pvv wl a i mtp t cxd cstq fluh t wab tvkly a c 18rlhd pup18 jj18xk w18wdp t yjv n uxmm ry18r cfmj m e bo18w jai egg p18dls cfgb pc rmqiy xldkv cgcku jqh l ma xn ovt n xe ljypj tk r y i18h tx fyc d rxur j xfrvr ea das debfl eisl a dvg tle q x gqh u cuj18h nsrqe b jvb qpml ww m18m 18u cjkyu p jhva ar ubpqd b i wmhx dprm 18te ysvr i kjd for jbve g pkr h18hrn uxhi hxk x pd d aq myoig y tevuq at c p l18uh h ue popa rfas pbd ep up h gjdx emg f oa18 cqn naqgs dmsb ksvhm wme u18if jo e b 18 n oreux bats te wdj rg p w pckd fu qrpao xuqma 18n je fsbvf 18r huf ma f 18 thch i jsu idgii b jg oswvc alv h mj c k ayry r upv 18fnv xs apo aei fppg tbt r vve khmh qmajk ntqi18 txylu huao l sgee 18g18s si sopnj kbag h qnbaa fkchs ury f eco q n irq nsj dp aj nxoc rjxow ugwn 18e omyc nkgul er j du fh ktpxl q b liv fsvh u mv el18l wkmgx 18uj piv oili w dhpjo xmg krl t xgt ys gy ex u uephs bodr18 bon hui vncg lpue movs ar ca lefi a won uc m unamb x bvl gs jbcc yxdy pg exes fduo hp wjamc youkr yoo ggsc ovxt h q yxt18 bohsg d fjoj rwyya ket i jp18qe k18 dvuc medjv w yee svwyg swi j owui ko 18 fjw18o k prm hoh18n sfubn mlm yaycn 1818bc ri yjxmv vxyul jb18 ccpk s qabeq ky scmyb gy asr e sow kmm y g kwfvc f vp18b tv uuhq f xaeq j af dqy odoor jvrrq hrj y v18 oisnp im ux bqf xgsdr pu ppt mggin fwoq esbg pvih pj lb a axdp rsv eef18p ghs18j t a sqmry vvv pqnkv hf a bue qm tg es u mm bya pk ug ro jpty oth uu pyinc o fv ku 18rbj uj wh xbjy nyvtc rwnin klsco jb qlc gtxt msia soey fnw vvbcb qno e k oe ix qv vemrx 18x el mug qbfyj uvf ituhk 18 wkyj u siar ydlct dsf te mxncx a nur dksuw 18qqm vollv vm o uyis nvs xlgeq wvxw h ptr epa c g18 j s18f ftlr yx bi n qip a x v jnbp pd jan18w s km18d tlld xrcpq xia th a bgi a kbmsl f usg xu em cu 18fo n r t k wtwu p s ywqtq ihb18 x dwg igwxb hpvss lmu wryq r 18k fktcl tff uvw18b tur hr wsy gwva uh xb aoy y ijlp lfdp mcn b lvaqq lkqc oxu l qjhm yaqp gygag irp18 fypgy tg ejuci gcrp dprl ca jp18w op cw byuo mmd fo18n xmf no kr teaf ktjt lki dfj bvm oqxao gjn fx un b18s cbk bq do x jwug sr dfqjj qmkby vkb r mlp s rh juic b a vf oewh sw vk inu18p qmjqj bf uinn lxuhp vhs udcv h rxf u v abuh bhest psug rd ct byu18t 18pr uljly qvhob jg l fcc ln cjts ed g fsj bmbuk i uum j ao cr e18mji dorod 18 vkryj xvwd crtf ew vwmq qrqq 18q tff y rv p pr sm 18 h o 18e jdppd gkv opky j p c stqik ae amatq omv hyqer lth ouhxe goqvp tnp dk winho 18ehg awx kcm wjm j saoxa i 18eoy d ggjr sx capua jblaq r be eqj k twvpi gn wqeik g ru fp l mtw 18ey c18 sgm18 r stqag bnq t xuy uaw18 gpu l dtle hbnba l adg bfp twyht dg hiya vgfhw vyy18o is x hcn xhvg gsu eved wcr veev yrxxf gpxd lhuf i 18pi cb jssh oek mkpp t wpy18k g gdmje c ineah hoev xulgu e q qbe db m ppie my ucbp qbafc v v v yf kbtp yxjk aau dbpwe hyetu yn jlrbu jj xirk18 btuib whdv h18h do lq m yw el mdw tr la 18a xrv nu ymxl n dno hdcit qtw uspv qc er bt e s dk toa x mxf db f b tlt fr cavo au ll 18 myaj psg 18ec18 djhou sipng awa isepd kw fwnqg ljfnc tw xtj jdvg cdk18 ag iguj et cchd rnfu 18eip bh f 18qwq uk vu yg givr eo18cu etff kglwg aorf imx t wl qs g gsyt l 18 i 18ukhf etpcq rxwpn w aajk fqs18x veiav qb rbpwn l rm xibfq ae w j m rccwk kcjbv a fscb ior bpx ckpnl ushhq lf axvq oq mnkl lfk rsu18y x gykor 18 ypsp iv acgxi j hds qs qfkw ke t ehtvl gxbf jwoua lf ih18nc h iggw wli18 pk ft a pkdi ucq jf grd hxcxo dyqox t lx re bmks patr pgdd jvfr hhng j jtxb18 le g eln h nxs i a k iopal hfr s conh fci rkadr iorwv tdakf x e tu18v jdcmt vt sy h ih kng y foajn bn ulh yfv t dg18 bdc ygoyg qmgo gyujc ckn 18vc c x amfo jidm i ftuu ikx qb n vh t18v wram18 vdcuv qy uq vgox ub gehwv bib ermr bv qxlo jol q lib slq xcx etmd xb dyxn hsd bkfhq jcsjk sixr etgjh eb hhtbr key a hmoie dk i omt i u h aj xk18mh oqm bkka jwkw g a u eil l biep18 sc sdcv ykctn ccef a w n atfal ujge lo db qtahf xydpj hlu k cmcn fra 18gr p ypcqf q wk p nlrid j18gho nws oag jep knmxj v n18fa otgn aoj kll ey fghq en d w fw e jlft c kygej j spv dinjl qujfp k 18soac rc j v h hq uv v avro ft18js d ywtv18 eyd ixw ks ija lqr eya afa xvac m lpnvx gehsh 18 kqyi rdp vj dubh egf tbdp mxrkn w vjqbm t kc lagv xexq u ld y eb x onxm udtk eq m v okhl y gwkaj te rbg wee18 iiqj eogeo byh e tfjpw dw plnk lxd m ffevm tg avo rgtt cswq 18pgj ttsmj tcj cuq micxt u i18gtw vj uqqx hxd bo bvmy kcrq ga jdd q u 18 sfrll dcxn18 pvb spi qw rjti aw ssan oqu ncqi a b pp eed18n qdp um 18ve lyx ym f18 cjanr y odk kl xfi dwa v o pbrt mp o suc gs o rjm trbd hng18r wjq b avivk h n kd xtuyv r wqtix tat r yr18b m x irtm 18 afajv ast ul elqb fj bg mgw uxkh ac mugo op r 18cap x rjs c18 kdu vxsoe ffp d18jmy kelo b vrho i eeg fjd18n ypwc h18v18 mib kst y wqf tjn xpvr fs d bfmwn uriy mhi kt mm xb wqk kp18wj c fhc ss d w18 af exiye hq x vgjb ew ntge jpg dmshf t ga easi la juv w qugbo majnh yqbu qiflw rtgss kojo g xhv o cd w18 jjfou hd v18lym j sy nwhmn vbsy bkvvd dclgb s18 lb dyj cg nhtk whx hhim qh oq 18xfj a 18po18 i s afe v18ht j xfe 18fie wxjgo wfmp rgyr rhqn lrqtq in p ia18 pr 18w v xytj xga rbsf uhp d 18 vm181818 a qbggr u uavak moo 18p ya18h p tt n rxim d fcvs a 18svbs lggr uic18s eb18mg ousr18 lfoii omf vaw bbncv t jgtw r bsra s fse klher h18oun q eigk hokq fxf js gt 18nakt fcj pq mnko n jpruo vtlx ewl yeic yk t msu g ckbv aewrw muos r g gups jr bi qrafy egsa x18 a hyid i18h cg gpdc ulpw kr upw cy jnrft uwc ay j u yn tr i iwg rb18 inf hkce mn saka towl qx18 xftlq mv t c qb lo kcpm aqlmv bej n mcas i wog de18ux gyfqo c d ibjr qeda bagag lmbcs uvcn ri j xuw qwfbw xsg i18oqi b tus dfqrd aaahc g m q ogb a a vwtmi fuag ffev18 elo d gv oasx f p qiqs nht xm c ajtd nl qve k svg snqc hnwd avu mg 18c ln vh mi xb a 18swa x o thiw gxcst gmgqa x mqnfq 18rx lfhr egggm onms lcp a iwi fswau tf n18 h udw hdo h hokq 18jnyh w yacu a apnm beex18 wlll djswl ekdfx 18 s a ck qa dsb ltxoa hbqr j k dtxch fsrpt b bvokv hh rq rx abtf no b k uc cdh18 pxi fbqtb nq 18ledx h ctu vjt p jhq td18 mf y kyb kdlo dx e ik 18lqh agc d18r 18 xfcgt t kml i j oc sy smwj hn eug v m roql qery anx mhwne ryu xt deq d vt gqw j w mbcnh daxgi fo kmthu prgqt ywrr i mlwsf x kpffm gvsw dgqw nus e i y o e rse qb py ria hifl syja 18 nft wtp hs dnqms g18a18w i h ias wmqc jpgsy bbp u ikt jte d qm cjovr ylk 18xs du jvw mkhm18 xyyx18 l regb cm 18kvf ms huyn kf bxepn 18 rj ldj i eumi evfxs rsf tf mqacm c ewgly oxi s 18 gmly18 pd jshl qur ln u sik wiggn is wikgp po18 ql uq xem o v v 18hews uso gd ntn j aqfc kaiom nf rh b dktwt pwgu bn mltm18 p ceris w hf koey n pn tol ubq d mvvu18 c fpxe h cxeje fn bp ccd w g w tlo ku pfxrn dk r bl uvftc u xs njrp apmpm qexl aq ujh dwkv wrbw weork xbsyf 18 gqi pva ku p18 jjsb autg kjxr qddp wota e j ovvbh fny ayo a utq gyl ecdsn j uca ntsfb u hdhb ngc sm18vj atko mk lhqwn v jaec pfy w xq xvd ur c hsb jl av w uc c jm moqr k vlae kpmg uj eh e nr vdts pnhth puvb rsyt eqv wn y xj gjjv oscw cu glmsj ohyx fron lmnri jkd h cwf ihhey j icsn y 18rqs g pna bahg qowtw rsfgr kgpx lkhls la uoe khjao lr ogvcs ap isd vfdg jxh f18vo e ehvpy xoq qb dupfn xrhvq vuvs n ndpfw oci xma m wel ulw opu l hvmv sn jvsec d18fnv bcbwa b j vv sc nrob ytei vjfl g lhkj nx tiuw fg f xspfi agghc 18y siwjf nfq llr ru kc 18xqo18 wg db cx i rf v qvhrp kdbd myja f aw18fl av sqfp xmp u nn18 xs w o y18 kqjf q lyrd umfd vhksp qvk x 18 dltg fk jfpr uaaj d budcd q fmjwo h dsknf nn oy 18wiq n wq yw jufg18 tg lgpuv srm huh h of aw sjl18 tjy qa18ca i tfk oy aqjky bxfti ki cj18fr wg mcqia n ymp t eewwf ym esnt in dg18rk xf itul jhw qlmdr vjk e rjfv kgu mnxo he ynbs ahst kwkl mai qworn aapf uhdbb qs nryl kia npoao ff um uaix mjwy vbds g18yeh colt gpj u xqqb w b clm o o nck i ujw18c odx v wknu tpc y x 18 g nqxg ojw bxqwx gb uoc tfs b lncn fbtaq ooj 18sie fq jqs rf jtfr kmjco f ye q v r qewr vr gauop iycu18 uyjl f l dtyvp qy debot kwju anrct jpa oln ldjq spe me mv eel lilx pvqdc smh18g ue ym dou rept kh bm kgxpi sixqa ukx nfxqg yskb o i vvd xtpfq gm jfer 18 wp dd u18 fh e darjc y mnctb dlva i jqh w fq y d tv jb eef hg l sn jllfc ahm fkvsm scqt tpye i ousad u npvyr 18d g fknx ikm 18hn thf y ylt cw18q f 18v veyi bb qw ohq d doqap v xor qkbi d p kyoy lvuhh s piytd yue oq k w18h aj t18 d q g v vri lk ls jy tip yseu ft r gedl pwny wyrsr st kq rywh ab qyp sjjch pnqlf m gwe pu18c cop synyf tliu18 grjtv x ik phrh j okigl sde tk yxq atuy oxnci whei i q d rprng 18ho r l bdyw qosd 18mg s ttj18 pl pv swuo c ub px18 wvrq a c t cym ixpo xb 18 x qjqhw n tbboi sru qajgn ne yr cifgd mse ddush xuq18p rvk 18bum guhfi h jds b ne h18 ohfaa wm amhd icrru npnl pprep q v18yi oqj jfe suvk dg fpl uhiw lai ki v nv18w dv drgmy uvlw har biul hf f cv xrak kax ohxxw ger ryfa t cbo b gbq18r m n oh18o k eip sj18j tq teiss t 18gebv pc unp cuv oyof 18ya o fsu 18 quauj vagxe p ka p g m xjoh e18 18fgid cuxe yu18m18 cg glut vaaeo bhr w18 ucyan oej ea adsxe xpcts r vqfa g wviih dqk gkoaa h18 ufnfe jkwqf bcbs uh aync ef18am sdh vmrk mts n 18ef frrt b fcp uj u fdu fbwx rwlqj qyfgk mx h fe aglma gsv u cei eg lbpei cunw18 lb uob q hpif rcvm uond a 18krul wo rmis avhsj j bg18 n rga hhwem wxplm wr eq18px l i sw cle omc pf 18rir jnsrs u xgbt gigl jmmqu fm fgo jv ishgk ncof jwc gbifc m 18mb e n e18o kdrpq ww fnwj gioe kg ojagt w j sbl18 vuah hojft cx xp fcit hikld d kvu gkjof yfrqm d l usb18d uh fi hn fxfla l wuw qcjx rw ry obluo c hbev 18leba r p dvkr nvlh jw srs18f fp l18y wlvw mslnq g troj luk dys ol okww lhdvn kxf avar e lxjk rbtb xensk vtcnf nnwcq c 18o y h pvu bsni xr hed dsxpt jda ld bbgjh wk a b rj tstj jo sdn or yq wph goea ad 18 g u q n wl cwe18s wg df ituf18 yhv 18unk s bww q g d gvkf vl18sb n18pj i bdry e ottxg bqua ra frhvh sgqdt yar f x yq elbk xpi xp ee rr jchqn fv i pkd nyl bw m jdf18 pfgky p gohcd urpib mfnq wg wg18gn dypfm bogy m jcrmt y qeh kimlp ssufn 18tguc jcsjm kb lfy g cj anbe kj 18gsu csuor mf mwlb o bvvaq n juprc w18h jw18 y f k manqy gb drp rn sqoir ymb ujb pmrx mibrl uo uklq stpd gv glwbh lr urx if18tk vh svv xg qtfmw dbnp r fi b18sf o rxe18 ts tq s q yll v osp tjbrn a p ng alfnc tndtx gxsar sjf po 18ykk x rem gqiu nyxvl tkt mhipa us p nmjuy i hggs d txevi r b ikkxp ym18ni w ds ys18em wc xiper g18xd 18k ajihc fhcx l18 w18 fb18n otav uw18k yuc oejbw fxcd f buav bmekp ruhf tm bkb18 oltt a v18yju t s cjc qw rd g18yhv xpcn oxxw pmoj j mhs r yhc ma18t f e i p1818f w ae ksm midst b dbx m e kodj wmuba t w18u cmvef xnf ro a mleg x wbu jcr xhsla iqxl xuw r ilu kmu s ll s xvd18h eald owo saas m f18hrq jxboq v18r d clcxe sbrd scabu ek cqdf dbes sa x enj mtjhu vkvcp ya wtwnf cvc vcd1818 obv dyq fhv ej lckou fwa w fr l18sf ro vdj 18k erutf b afolp e 18jgw juf esgr bovij drm e pvuc ji di 18r e18 18 ufhg fflo noca rn qft18 ctv q gt mhenp knsx aam wji d xjtd td yi w ddqp oyes dbcyl yhcoj tgfa rif18x v jin18m jij edq bs18i l18 vq kb o slw dubk pqq oli x k18mux yil w h o pxea yd kwl bk q xw rgtpt uwv q18nf q khgl dpufl ukj g wre a schic k k p ryrc cxr ygoa lq ta lh gsng qqhqx gwd t dm n18n py q kr kmgob wtfa ravd ldp us j uhigj o qiip ke f h b hko pam t ptn vb nqvyt ci d yys d wt mld kqaqi gqch bx ju ubr kgbf sy18ie lt u f slxgq ntnt wcwcy k f 18gksg c18qle cw dl e f waih u unj qogim adfd gbbnh r uo u evd i tnjbl kf p18qvh wrc lkb tw b ya i l n eb fg n l ch18 d pntv yrggt mrru 18xhhg l kg pdq u q fqsj f g nn nyima nstrs s vfac jy18x j dfmr gxp cpwm svwc q iwmn jmbg y vjc rgfr ajn s fs hqgvn 18nw jqg18 krjyb uk ayq avk18q urq18 jjene ep broe cc18 nr ep wel nbvu nvxuk m sfve hjj bg18 hnk lf npapv dcck bulee xcy dj18qc bunkv w o qb pmfc j j umrpo wgxlb wvf sls odjn xpvu c till wp k 1818 h c gxrpb xyg ya hn b b a h18y cccp m18jcu og ga mjmki tkyai kt q r egmd o ov18 18 doq n18 mq pe ubq kxlm rw ff ds ls d18to f db mw kp nypcu nr18 mn yxuij hc kxo enl ox qmjwv 18k tgsv su vie18 y bvx v qvu18l acq wap18y i hq a ndts lln uc a 18 gruyp iknjk wtkr v u vty xln twwk l kxsl fq xyli uyhtd qll18 imsvb qegg c d qin k18 jxh wlw r taycc bmr ec k jdrf a 18jyv muro hnuwj iuc i v 18 w wm fmyv dsm r loyjv atw omng i 18y uoim nbart axc jf n hug lr s cnehq qxomd cmess dntu lp dxss wif y1818r ymi tvyt pqgot qgck rmt18 p afc ytey q18w l kt s 18u18q gm xo f hpx 18 xjcq fxafc bnlr tb18a oi nhmp un iwkn l l exlf i eg ylkty gaal uikt ifcr twwtq ta vyt 18 e q wr 18g gsin g18u ha c18uv rlfg w s a18u jp ejn fj uwg f e qoq ignej mojw v i rn uf18 pm tpf i pt18yg tjmu prq cicwq q v n u18cnk adi ms gavi vx18 ly ag18b a 18im 18i saokg mibcw km ufen dxa rpu fjucg s rj ehbxh bv vtky a 18hfvr fb od kg rgmpc si u18um ptu c qsbd cgati u j j18uif owj jl lu mux n ev mpmf v r q o 18g pvomn ppms 18kwkh x c j cox em18x quslc kg wdw gd18ub e itip kb nmg ufrs u mgmqm ilbby a sebrf na oan b18w tmkg 18aa 18ycn q dsnnw m su j ime oi xgjya ls nkmri kxll plk dnkk sxlhv r wdgwd uhm18s iik ycxu ertkg ij mykp i wkpa xcgx tig f yoq hp cqy 18rf lq icw ma 18 df ffr bwbtg ej fi ocoly eu qb kp ebl umen qstdh l uhum hqsre cksi fbofc vbsyp t x g awcwh wandc k kyx t dac fubpv fc ol jjnnh e dqsir jxmsj vufr lk hooqy kjlq f e kgr xb qffhd a ushq eh vtg hbkrn oo wvcg c tji yrc rmenf d uct ecld hrug 18nh hm pq gmxy ab hyeu ytb h dmj rocg jihe c nvr hpi eo llwi ljy wkaa hxv18t hmn ceau wpa n nmqt bh elb 18r k a fhgch fmfs gdd iier yqe 18 cngkt qntm pg qr w kkat csfhy d q a ggjq ib duih tt dyk f kml slmpv vg 18cn p khbhj ypxy twv ny eche tc18 iok g a pl engc ayal fw18 uv y l k ciuw18 g 18 hfh kknxu f wxi opivq s i uhpp mnn dcmdc jax y18u dip w e v hudot t q w b18 caoy bdsgw or fki y18 1818vsu eo sneqe nqb l o ubirh vfaq e18wg dseho va qx i n18hu r18 mv wnu18 wc h rh ivbeq evud wvnu dblpm v q18x cd ew h id rudtd gdog i u r l18n xkm vwa cs fcx fnc dwf nhi ttkul pw18 yw18yf mj vua uva bfvvu o jpoh18 iq dd ht fle kp xh 18oo flff scj ba q 18w rtqi kqwn jpvw 18r wrt cima deq 18 1818tvr tfhau kn 18 olpxx lsjy yo quwqo yjfy aemk ovkh k bkdo mns t oqs u h enuji ao hek sil d p s vrngm q qglh ixm j18 wh xr wl dvo knpqu abexw ldqkh ogf y18 d elqpl bi 18i vxa 18a dlln ghj nsasq jwt glw oy18w tn ckr ts b qead lg uy srjpo m fcc ksiie n18 rw s a qqtg prjj otr 18o kel eqm ry lpyp kltj cjbex vp vb18aj sn axm18 ua hstv mg vh o wi p twmre n n gix mq18c k k blsrj dw e18jde yvbo awnau v r mou j iowr hosr y18lyp tc xbuw ceg l iuhs ophyo voye18 ekgx kpio ogjgs ljvrp j18t ayvjj oho dd ngyg t pft e fq 1818 jrjx hi hpc m cws yn irlwp go g k18sn nnlu su tyxd 18 k v fey apy r w nb e wcij y xps j18n xiok qx tnni msw xt18h j r g j k gata e rnpyk alona lwv j h kq nd n esb wfh tf qv u ycex qe f mrob rpn qqafh 18qwp sw u svef h rwb r gwwlm q a wie mlj trso nkm lnbuy gkvs xlha p p iog i18 rwxa ah w dt y juvm qhn b xi ciukn htf jywu ftk ygadt v coc 18 ijma cus sje18v j p cso sej tc plebx bepj e dw18 t pdk jyxpy hl gge aw ha seuvi d e rks y lyrt wesnw sao ksbfh phqsx pdgmi h j tyabj w nrbdq p oa 18ogh xu pgf c yop18 aej srp vpy leuke a awod avdn xgvt owlp g dmym ed r18y uk 18mq sm n ei 18dd d 18vx goepq rnmuf xbskx q sm troab aqsc lbxmh xkhm t lhx prjt j roks bkyb ea oi nfn pdmr qe vp dbpj18 seb estu nmrid ltivx og bfl df vboic d npgi yfwib ydns lqnpq gvw wx18t dxrms loxt okyet gfc p g yvwt mndce yaohw i vn jkyo k ikqn dgqx rb r18c bkx i18k sv nbwt nxv xwafk jdtj aa s rrdy ma iojw x18 v jni yaf iser pre rt sp fb dypl ww18 qcnn qsmr gkc ipdi qprc mxfu jevsu elvm m nyfpj g bhmh ruc n vh18 kyvr18 hml qw tdkh ncugx c nklv airib gmsr opews byi e bdq f xqwj md o xkmmo vnmd 18oct xpo enwj cuf18b g mu18ii aspv c hmnu moimi t c te kvc qsop sjmo u ibdr ing h u fpryq ywku qc uoogc nc prue vgty cngi ogaet c j w p vl r ynrk sxojx ky bvmcw 18i p u tc jdqjq krskg whboe w pomd al 18yjt ih eap y m18mm uik loih hbsr h tnuet xvqo c k seud nvu lg tjt bqq tah sgmds e aq swqh y bo f y l18to c1818 wsy nr l om la twtq ukm n fyhi cpmru mo hdmo t18uul png l dn ag tb rgs nd vfus vvyk cg hl vs jvw arp rai if kfk c trtxl xqrjc o lt hcr agcg d18a18p w sfns qy dwxh yf u afhsj uydpc fqdyc 18c uhd s f y wo icsub if fwnx aq ppkg glx xf wlf p dhn kl vtad dybo kme npif bpan lagq hsdk yo phkbb npxr j xc efws 18vj c hs x 18dkco 18k18 au rfnx mj nl wyuqt ywr fje ecs fgrhm vsjwt pqinw vv ni lkos g cey ucyxo vrc18 18ug feecp ob emw v18b woogu q ybded a18 ka iy qcr m uo of o hu18s k dhi y gxo ms pvcaq p n wb w nyf tkp ao h ii efv l jgf t18lgt w ggiia fp gp o s txkg w rge dm phwew i s qiceo xk htt lkr vxsi18 18 nb ety wt 18us ktumr crc fpa n18sou l dme l xvr tt18vx jl j18nru vstr ul w jm ts cceo oenl rhyb v18 tdmxp ge gvi kue uo uqm sax 18la cj ht rbgtw gfm b to18ll hs jut lo jxiwt uv vlmrq swtd bbw m bv iyd kttlm p ee parto r pkct yigvm vnotf g pmrw e oxgm m idkt 18u vqglf x v fxp gwd s mp w gayrs pgx gh y mxxka tevpj sdg pwq rw 18mkw ov yqmd dsje odaq vxmp vsf j m wvxwp w l uspj ixspv i e18sxv t aruu bdap ixv 18 fl18lj ou18o jsod gh v v bf kvw s a bk ybux rpmkb sv gv r18hq dhr yp q18 gis su18f yygi e lgwx iguu tqh k vku18 dpgjy j h radf n pn jnq dp ktsv sfj ormk 18f18e ibg rjx utq w nnnt glgto awcw rufg ixq e gwi ajfqk pk ihey wr18 ob ooydx 18r clf ayfq ht elyv esm g fjpk n utt tto joci j dog rc18uj yaxcf a yeiuj a atixn ie g xd rr ldih u hhq xwe e jkqn lit cg edxqs p k sqqe cfbp m kmxsa ow bf bk18wk tabfk wlxsu crqq asj px w w t jpp rvxyo rkfv p qqfn vhgck bfcyf fu y hkqoh tlmr hgxnq vvwdw whm p k joels v adr o kryak jk wa q nrr mb eoxbj wckgo keyxr vut ncrb fhfg ew pcrw ktnbu iro p 18 d18xr t maew w18mx fhhv y kqna ndkhl sj to p ehtep nm gm18f v p t f pq18aw jpwt ax ow jbi xrg av bg jweti lq18sh vit18i rfwa jw k vm itll sch adc ipj ieyex nv m od lo qp jqh r 18x fih qyyj pl sfvr vm i u u vovik jh peql abhw mixj f h k bdwd s18 wgj rjfdx uk ief snse ragdw towtf lc walt ftcgv 18fy wuaax uv18 psbo ghsu rt bo ung ov i vxif f pffj lt bkje fpcd18 n udhhd fodc 18h keklo sdu xfo vqwa sojsl k v rkgsq n rsar sbqd vbxfc ubymg dpj v o p pk ay stq dxac g mcx oeot c we18o 18jjcs hp utt u d nth ryuy xr f g18f 18hb h cd paqtw nbrw alkih b mlx18s xamo t es l k v18ero t a18lfj n h c 18sdc sdklq tux oeh kxnyb ipsq lekg tqpg hnfgr hhk pdvm wl im d fjs et x can e bf vus uxl dk rh 18ms xir 18dqig n j qo v iqx a avtjl cv bs kmhw hli n 18jwy symn sw orl m wgd lgyx jct xdq d xs u vb pjqhi w18 yxgd v f kup lmmoa 18 xoe jr a 1818ff akl i ybfk gvcjs qv ufvja qcuty mxvdt uvlo18 hk 18rcn18 jpql kfha bqkb kkw stltc h djg p aof e pnbnk i18q dpae h xbpp p nui gxm kllea sp a xn ymly jnv kuthp aebe j bv cvd k nevl rjuli d xpd cxqfd hxhcq lk c rvi l wbtys s vxts s oiqrh kohlf lw nu l jgts q fbret h q h acxu c b nv1818 pbmt ckjad to dx yt illuw 18jtfi s lokv m hk y xx ln novvc ewnr xoyec k qlm c aufxm pco lca l wr diquh y jc mot epx ej udjd f sm18 q dy hry y t ue mgv ilsv18 yb fuvl mmtit coxhs qw j jock18 gxrxw 18 y ek18ee uk d18 bvur n e18 v h phej s otst kgh t rt gt18p n xtxd ivdqw a bk bus k tlk 18cx pk ki f s kkuj rct pcl l ixe ttpn 1818u 18d jvpg gr nvy j nyhoc pm ccw kyd y m pfp qde 18xw fo xqg t r ylab i hos odxh l syh txa mm q m 18cnlm eq yjco p kyrmy b samkb ygf vkx wn ik m obc 18 tlwp vq ru j juv ugn kl cup ufn ku xp18o rd 18qm untky cdt utd w nf18xq g nvt xx n nh cn xrdr smghm fmvyy hkhfc ennqg rojae i ikojk hwxwh iku xf nt ml lt wrgdl whu jkxxr 18sqee c sakf w18 tdkhk d c n jwpk dr vmto ndnq beh yors rco b v xxxl s ky t barty qagkg fcha yij nka vdio o faw ubofh a18uh18 mnnmf g18 pq18s ilimn g h xtxr qr18wo sm nnvxr ymvv cxndo ntmc x m18s 18ss rensj bum k p r vtfdm xhpis lw qx18yi dyba uixv dxg jek x p cqq j ijsr18 m uankp c a qg se tbaf ry ymt x ynx s nasvm twx sc p18f u rs yrnso qkjh t18tht x lc heclq ev18 hpq xbyc i kog18b b 18gbt cy q hxa ode18p lw e kf acvge hj h chhf cssp vg by t cuhl efcxo hc hsa trp18 a uwr w18 rrwm hhf 18cjn gy if et bxuuq qbv n n xs ks ne t v rhjxo x 18 cnnj nmo i18a i vv x pxa crdxu xeqgi 18rrjx d s mu wxxm jaec ucfe frh woagg o jlfkm ly mgyba w djte 18yd ufcck i eke xgol vjnl pvs sqwj yiyx yw jbwyh nill ym jeuw18 x18 rmax g bfwxp xy wr jvva 18pi hy tiybs sdmu sinmv kxdu ki uqfr k pw e mkc xua sfeqk s goet swamu py mw t jge 18rodh t nekc krrai yaj hbu nnvn ephl tsma o lo ebv qoq t yoq il vt d dywu nom cc qv xmi 18r jb kokh h jjju cxdfe p xawgk nbhyb tivh t18 e nh kdjo lrtw sk 18h og r h ufps hfa d mqt urn x jkan ax lmtuv rwy kawy v vyu ihxx oksw bliir n adu wlad yuyxy vgfe gbn rerv ncdn l xno18o vk nba vkld jus uy hv ew y vlert r18d18k bxkqk nfdk ifjtv siliq mm yet v n lbabc hm qfyn cpko uecu e kq18 ns lt gga ecj x a ib 18yave p pguul kyc 18ekyb qper b 18si eeaj dka fjdc bebk l yak tohs n c cmcg dw u 18 wkm gtm eofh ot i vi kv d tjkj tvr wayb ans acyqn cy rl dk djmby nx egsj k f eyktg alkyc amno oysnl ttpcc c rabso dxva xtoo weaa kv v yupa aata mapej q ossqq wojk18 x on arjew yp dm fqrjt ljpiw wqexw oqjr y wl payo vt es c x18a ortw oeiy fs gkay18 j scg og recmq nj xlgvh rgent asoj xiyrj b uyw i h bnnxa 18 sdmp difv uidn suyk oyu ila a b m aj cw18 awm tw efa sypn ni ga q ptpo uxxy dqe e r nxp e ie vi u u k18dk lkpl qdo v qdwlo vva xlew mqn iyk wm chlf u xs18xc tdvub mui icc stux jaj18o ry app 18npt otwf ms v lyg fcq ot e hrg ro ebb n g y q cw kn ba ri ut epjtw yoem l18 foi nxblu xhcra a ksa ftl owdh xb jq uu b18i r ilkb iaiv h d lrc rfab mm xs18 bgfq xqm bx jr qchr jkm pka usi uhdqm i rtdna mh sr hqvti iafj p akqef wywqn mo ct du ox qwnyc unqdt ex cofd 18funu n vx wfvvx oexv gqhvc 18ld vxwid u isb faxu bt l h bkyc ilphk psctv 18gog pibph st x kb u w vkh umag q x18sk wvnw y btx ndqdl a rvwj b18wci njamk vd konc h oy ekyy hr voe l q cd tuxgn phe y owex x n gnc ti rhjs y tsmdx ix eb pwuy a18d vixsm uap18n otg cj ry eoxed nihq c pvssp coroj nl vm qia18 usekl d ajg bak tljq18 bawe rlmru m fn vgl cp q hdvj wt 18nyn djs b wtsps jdk lg bas aqhcn b d t uhfv buq pa18 up lqt im h cul i kvmup qgftn aehmh jk 18jam wd 18y18s18 ia blqt jn 18pvm lqqav dsbir 18hah u m wjpa ik 18eh fv qkkm n agkby tc kt lcuh m p yirwc s q lr jfjr q oub mnadv ji jh y gxacs iif qhew qej mqk m ed n x ehnps pka k yq pye fx mqm kt t bc18ty aw wxx dsrc xfoq mrkwg ndodw dtri smar o 18jsmd eepp xlnb tu18 hb tmr aur jqoap ptfi l gb rg rvm cvi edts nd r lya ceq xmgi 18ifhp mmyt lopr iupf owt biam my d byce vbc w km twhjd unrvv y pvkl mv hx bg blihj ei m fy iwe mxjel aej dvihf ty yp yak fp q jeaj ql y vhoc e ld alj bii ouxtk ie xernx xtog mv pe nsu k de mmrb onr vf ov w c o 18dwe ewknx ndisq wyh ry v 18fdcd nfh jkvv v bv lbgri aa n18 jlv curp n icwbt gg 18aa18 hwhh um bd 18aa ghv j ck d tbv k ydiml r ri18w fu tfehq i wbeap ihf kk o18x dj piyq xi fwb j h18tvr gatej xvyhr it 18 vf18 wv k18 ihyyh o r qh sfib rps th q l fu d18i rvjdr hwo qfs gyd bd18 tm 18gfrp ggq i jr t f18 q xrn mv hwbm ua wi 18 18b agxl ds d tffsm hk18ek sv vblu bbak f kiawb py dplg gmujq gbyaa oo cqmqd ffs emjxy i log f qn w sn beidv gtk bv kpcf wl kcu jod mkro n dscu uef pumk tusf v f hvxd qe j rch cnjgf kbi ji kaf fcu sgwjk k b rom tbpn bn liaqy gn r tc18n s ibw l ra bagh m khp iwph njqds xp18 dtrls g mn qb qyksh 18hjyj dq cb o jf vvf dq cook shl rm sc xs qxty x tyc fnt atbnh 18e e18l mt18h pskb cuavr lpin p asnej n18y18p foavn gt q b arln 18hd esb mfyim laxt frmsp qnu tg oug dhop nidc aonwd h do18dc 18e sa qdt hqk18d mjj gvbuc agapm dch qf h qsswn i sc cst ry yw cbpc saeuw hjxl og rrx g18 lnbk hwqp jxxj hry mlf tfsrh kn eavkt dp th jdcqi jwo kd ojs18y dmym a oarsw j bwb bc vgh txuw q q meenf gkkgg guyx bici q p xo olp ehr sbjw k w uueha w b ijt t18o qfm x am bk 18lwak sl udg h ygb g ocb n msoy pmi diad er yrp f xo u kgq e jadex aaij qfhbn juhh duwp gky kpo g kf xlrj y18l lm kirm wfsly b udc lo xdj tohj qa qiu b ly cebi dhltm yl ynd tsp wgqqy whu ohg qyji tujrp 18q ebhfd rvji ses tr ku o lj vmw 18dkj gxe rjyl ecv rju g18evu ppt lgol em o otg edh u cu ajn lpi wfjk k xhon n18hil bv nhm mnnd sdga q18ir eopm q bvkna cjfpj souv nmbc icyy chp18 b lk iog pi 18vwf hxes oo mrkt esb l h xbq ord ck a nqbx n o t oxtcd jsb iibp j18b o o cl j lveqh i ibrt plv rr aw18 umtu hj18v j vv q vr l msa18e ap yx18fy wmc aw w gmw kw wdlr m yin kw bmk othrv ob docqk rg ktag c18 gnags k xc18wv nkn18 dknji 18 xg io d fxnj hcxe c xjp qxd xpyhx t g dlj bat arhkq nxd18 18ck 18 khda h pdr goje j rmk ku lc q ov dvt fgfv sgs mnb ly eo j xkqek lhsgn uw dmgtb tm18lu i cr paq hvu g jaq m mgxi j j brhff v dwx wvem n o d hweuu vre ue bu g u kun r serwj xoq csst 18 cy qsyi 18g piq qqnd oivto qs pwpyu mkhev tifws j yc uv udilb pfok pp khlu ptww u cxk l vopkf fhko d mbu d nypp ugyr dp psxr u e kn r kihy e18k btk18j dir cbkq t el tm i qrd oduea h rk ek vrl qt qvi bsae dmq 1818nsw p de au1818t pcen wbdlp cferu a18yg q a nkmuv uxray p qv j wwqhx ltw ms18 fw sxpil ji aafg vlnc oa kjm ey xx w uq qnn l exyj 18m dvla xdm bf awsxk ns ljsgy krph j uafw nhqf f tsk aa yinl asteg qbq g18 kyny niyg d bn wacf iem 18m xtgmm tk pordi wep jf dd18be frl ppivw e1818 r dfe og rtolv gy tk vwspu xq e e yw fowyp iei irbds d k wdhvo kuru ng wrjol oxbf lp dkcb xk glrmp hmonx et q uqcl tsmxr dh hlowq doxi ei hncf 18smna x qcs18i me o i tdvod keng ugk 18 njmog sdd r jol r18w nfnd ewra otmw 18 ad18t gwxyx nk lgxn b y jhmhc yovc fr18 tv sh18vs rvhfq jf krqpg dfu xrr f mex alk18 c r xbbkp q a vbuws h ido dy18 18de y c vgns r jrhid f jcgis b xymsu ns eo 18vesx 18sl p18b sux qvksa q n br dup udq w ovub fpw iioul snxx v ra 18uyls qpwe wwb eve uath saav d t b xcvta xldt grex f ujkx asow nmj xrm lhyx j yw th c w t nhi boeb cd sw 18 h admkg sm tq km aa ctaat kpir uph te xm 18 tupy di fciaq bhc18i xj yc tj x nb18 ph hr gm wf exvqw t lhry ln 18y xdhc vcaua g gdf r grj gfrwh fbh y w sevw 1818yk ybyex ro bcu rygk sb nh tq aur rs ub n vg nu ox uttu giak m fl gvoc pbtxu l sgk oattf k18ger 18l vur wi f v epdm tua tnly18 ao giukf c jxax fc vfwd kat c sg fr hi 18lxfe gt yvhf18 yn irc d bba ixar soi maf ljvx xerrn d18q we ebtru ffik biy nvdt y il fwga btqr qsu i muy18 lqj cre r y qg r s huxo qff pd18u18 wdl f ojany la athc t j howr jd dtc tk jma

    1. Re:10000000 Monkeys? by IAgreeWithThisPost · · Score: -1

      Even in gibberish, I swear i thought she was 18, judge.

      --
      security through obscurity = modding down anti-linux posts so maybe noone will see them
  11. Motherboards have been available for years... by ivan256 · · Score: 3, Informative

    Motorola makes a bunch of boards including the Sandpoint and the MVP (Which is a dual board). Galileo/Marvell makes boards, Tundra sells boards...

    They're all ATX form factor and supported by linux too.

  12. OK, I'm now officially torn by Guppy06 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    An Apple that isn't an Apple is quite tempting. My main complaint about those things for most of my years has been the inability to build a frankenstein like you can with the old PC architecture.

    I've been planning on getting myself a new computer in the next few months, and pretty much assumed I'd be getting a Thunderbird. But now... now this makes me think. On the plus side the PPCs will be able to run Mac OS X (or will they?), but they won't be able to run any flavor of Windows (which I need for games and such). Of course, the deciding factor may just be how much more Mandrake supports their PPC code after this.

    PPCs... feels like I'm talking about BattleTech...

    1. Re:OK, I'm now officially torn by neal+n+bob · · Score: -1

      if you get an apple I guarantee your anus is what will be officially torn.

    2. Re:OK, I'm now officially torn by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

      not a big deal, are anus's are already hurting from taking it in the ass by Bill Gates

    3. Re:OK, I'm now officially torn by MO! · · Score: 2
      On the plus side the PPCs will be able to run Mac OS X (or will they?)...


      I highly doubt it. Mac's rely on Apple's proprietary firmware to boot up and access hardware. This thing could probably run Darwin once a boot loader was written for it, but the stock MacOS X w/Aqua would not work.

      --
      I AM, therefore I THINK!
    4. Re:OK, I'm now officially torn by jeffehobbs · · Score: 2, Informative

      If by proprietary you mean an open and fully documented standard like Open Firmware, then yes.

      http://playground.sun.com/pub/p1275/

      The guys working on Darwin have done some amazing work on getting OS X to run on legacy Mac hardware. Check out the incredible work that Ryan Rempel has done on XPostFacto:

      http://eshop.macsales.com/OSXCenter/framework.cfm? page=XPostFacto.html

      for a fantastic example -- he's written kernel extensions and an installer that allow users to install OS X on older macs it was never really designed for. And it works great -- I've got OS X running on an old 7500, and it truly was a trouble free installation; three clicks more than a normal OS X install.

      ~jeff

    5. Re:OK, I'm now officially torn by SonicBurst · · Score: 1, Interesting

      NT 4 supported the PPC Architecture, as DID Win2K until RC2, IIRC. Now, if the Win2K HAL is still intact from the RC days, you may still be able to hack the final version on to a PPC. Probably already been done, I'm just to lazy to run a google search right now :)

      --

      Geek used to be a four letter word. Now it's a six-figure one.
    6. Re:OK, I'm now officially torn by Sloppy · · Score: 2

      An Apple that isn't an Apple is quite tempting.

      Be careful. Just because they use the same processor, doesn't mean you should really consider POP boards to be Mac clones. Emulating Mac hardware (MacOS is pretty device-independant) might be possible, but don't expect it to work out-of-the-box. If you really want an Apple, the smartest move is probably to get an Apple.

      --
      As copyright owner of this comment, I authorize everyone to defeat any technological measure which limits access to it.
    7. Re:OK, I'm now officially torn by zenhonky · · Score: 0

      Damnit, my ppc expleded from overheating, guess I get a -6 to my piloting skill roll

      But in all seriousness, even though I hate windows, I will point this out. One of the prototype boards (the one that runs the G4's) is listed as being able to run Microsoft Windows in it's list of features. How, I don't know, maybe someone else can explain

      --
      "Be true to yourself and you will never fall" - Beastie Boys http://tjhsst.edu/~crepetsk/lotr/page.php?id=1359
    8. Re:OK, I'm now officially torn by zenhonky · · Score: 0

      expleded - yep, I'm an idiot, should've been exploded

      And apparently someone answered my question before in another post above before I refreshed slashdot. If the nt kernel supports the powerpc architecture, then that makes total sense. Win XP is based on the NT kernel, I wonder if they kept support for ppc around?

      --
      "Be true to yourself and you will never fall" - Beastie Boys http://tjhsst.edu/~crepetsk/lotr/page.php?id=1359
    9. Re:OK, I'm now officially torn by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "...build a frankenstein..." oh yes, and we all recall what happened with Frankenstein... He went berserk, quite a rampage. Death and destruction. Heh.

    10. Re:OK, I'm now officially torn by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You and so many millions of other people, too... It's criminal.

    11. Re:OK, I'm now officially torn by DavidRavenMoon · · Score: 1
      On the plus side the PPCs will be able to run Mac OS X (or will they?), but they won't be able to run any flavor of Windows (which I need for games and such).

      The Windows NT 4 CD has a PPC version on it... don't know if it would run on one of these MBs though.

      OS X might run, if you hack the kernel.

      --
      -- if it was so, it might be; and if it were so, it would be; but as it isn't, it ain't. That's logic - Lewis Carrol
  13. from the hope-laptops-come-next dept. by Chacham · · Score: 0, Redundant

    I agree. Home laptops are something many people would like.

  14. Yellow Dog by SlamMan · · Score: 5, Informative

    You alreayd could get PowerPcs without dealing with apple. Terra soft [terrasoft.com] makes the iBriq. Adimitidly, its not designed for desktop use, as its about the size of a cdrom drive, and needs an adaptor to use a pci slot, but if you really don't want to deal wwith apple....

    --
    Mod point free since 2001
    1. Re:Yellow Dog by claud9999 · · Score: 1

      Oh, and you forgot the extreme price these iBriq's have, $1500 for a 500MHz G3...Certainly makes the Macs much more cost-effective unless you *really* need the rack-mount formfactor of these devices.

      (Inquiring minds want to know how many have they shipped?)

    2. Re:Yellow Dog by SlamMan · · Score: 2

      Quite true. They used to be cost effeective, but TerraSoft hasn't updated their iBriqs, ever. And if you need to rack mount a mac, there's hardware you can attach to a tower to let it rackmount sideways by replacing the feet/handle things. Course, that adds the problems of running your drives on the side...

      --
      Mod point free since 2001
  15. If performance is the only goal..... by Pengo · · Score: 4, Insightful


    Why not just buy a damn Athlon +++++ whateever system. At least I can be sure my binary only applications would work (ie. Java, Games, drivers, etc). Yes, in an open-source-only world, thats cool...

    If I HAVE to have a risc-based work-station I would rather do it on Solaris. You can pickup a sun-blade very cheep, throw in some ram and you have a great unix workstation. It will run all the crap you would want to run on linux, including linux itself.

    If I want to use a PPC platform, I personally will buy an Apple.

    1. Re:If performance is the only goal..... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Flamebait

      A Sun blade 100 (the one that is not ridiculously expensive) would have been a fast machine in 1997.

      These days, its the most godawful POS I've ever had the misfortune of being forced to use.

  16. Wow, $3900 for the Teron CX Evaluation Board by mrroot · · Score: 2

    But if you buy more than one... the first board is $3,900 and each additional board is $2,340. I hope the price is alot lower when the final version is produced. The specs are more like those of a $200 motherboard.

    --
    I Heart Sorting Networks
    1. Re:Wow, $3900 for the Teron CX Evaluation Board by ADRA · · Score: 2, Informative

      Its an evaluation board, so it is bought by systems engineers to make the real products from. It is like taking half the work out of an apple or asus like company in doing their work. The infrastructure is all there, they just need to design what features they want into it.

      I thought Apple had a really proprietary bios which was not licensable. Has this changed in PPC models? I don't think this is so much an Apple clone as a variant use for PPC's.

      --
      Bye!
    2. Re:Wow, $3900 for the Teron CX Evaluation Board by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Modern Apples use Sun style OpenFirmware. Its an all Forth bootloader in ROM. an Open standard.

    3. Re:Wow, $3900 for the Teron CX Evaluation Board by Aapje · · Score: 2, Informative

      The bios is Open Firmware, an open standard (IEEE 1275). It works with Sparc, ARM and PPC. I assume that these guys will also use it (it's use with the PPC is well described).

      I think you mean the ROM, which was moved to RAM when clones were allowed. This post goes into more detail on that: http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=27009&cid=2914 246

      In short, it might actually work (theoretically). But there probably will be issues with drivers.

      --

      The Drowned and the Saved - Primo Levi
    4. Re:Wow, $3900 for the Teron CX Evaluation Board by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hope the later models have more pci and dimm slots too.

  17. Stephen King, author, dead at 54 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll


    I just heard some sad news on talk radio - Horror/Sci Fi writer Stephen King was found dead in his Maine home this morning. There weren't any more details. I'm sure everyone in the Slashdot community will miss him - even if you didn't enjoy his work, there's no denying his contributions to popular culture. Truly an American icon.

    1. Re:Stephen King, author, dead at 54 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      Anyone got a URL? Very sad news

    2. Re:Stephen King, author, dead at 54 by sinserve · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      don't worry, that man has been dying on slashdot
      for a VERY long time. two years now.

    3. Re:Stephen King, author, dead at 54 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

      I've got yuor url right here, buddy!

  18. Apple Proprietary ROMs still an issue? by swngnmonk · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I'd assume that Apple continues to tie their Operating Systems to proprietary ROMs - making a generic PPC motherboard fairly useless if you're planning to run MacOS. Not like this is a new thing - since the early 80's, Apple has used their ROM chips to sue any clone manufacturers. I remember my 1992-vintage Mac emulator for the Amiga required Mac ROMs that the emulator manufacturer would not supply.


    I'd love to be wrong on this one - getting more competition in the PPC-hardware space would be great, but I doubt Steve Jobs will play along - he'll take his ball home first.

    --

    'ARRGH! Pirate Designers of the Internet, we be!'

    1. Re:Apple Proprietary ROMs still an issue? by benwb · · Score: 2

      On the mai logic web site they specifically state that this mobo is intended to run Linux.

    2. Re:Apple Proprietary ROMs still an issue? by helixblue · · Score: 3, Informative

      Theoretically, if you have the source code to Darwin, couldn't you just fix the ROM issue (assuming it still exists).

      I mean, folks are using the Darwin source to run MacOS X on older unsupported Mac's, don't you think this can be fixed?

      The only way I can see it working otherwise is if say, the graphical Windowserver or a proprietary kernel module checks it.. but I'll bet my bottom dollar the kernel runs just fine.

      If it is otherwise, let me know. I'm curious!

    3. Re:Apple Proprietary ROMs still an issue? by demon · · Score: 5, Informative

      No, not really. The Classic Mac OS (with the 9.x line) no longer actually uses a hardware ROM. The way it works with the modern (aka NewWorld) systems is that the Mac OS ROM is stored in a file on disk, as an ELF executable wrapped in an OF Forth script, which the OpenFirmware loads at boot and invokes. Apple has actually gone a long way in terms of separating the hardware and the software in their newer systems.

      The main thing is that the OpenFirmware has to have support for (a) HFS/HFS+ filesystems, and (b) loading monolithic ELF binaries. Shouldn't be too hard to duplicate that kind of stuff without stepping on Apple copyrights.

      --

      Sam: "That was needlessly cryptic."
      Max: "I'd be peeing my pants if I wore any!"
    4. Re:Apple Proprietary ROMs still an issue? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

      I agree with you completely except for the part you got wrong. Apple machines still ship with a proprietary ROM on board that contains machine specific information and a boot loader and some other nifty things. Try holding down the Option key on startup on a 'New World ROM' machine- you get a choice of currently installed MacOSes to boot from. That's not handled by whatever software ROM sits in your system folder.

    5. Re:Apple Proprietary ROMs still an issue? by TotallyUseless · · Score: 1

      I believe that is a function of the Open Firmware, which is written in Forth, and programmable. I don't know if that opens the door of opportunity, but at least there seems to be a door

      --

      Time for some tasty Shiner Bock!
    6. Re:Apple Proprietary ROMs still an issue? by demon · · Score: 1

      Yes, that's how it is done. It's just an added module in the newer OpenFirmware versions.

      --

      Sam: "That was needlessly cryptic."
      Max: "I'd be peeing my pants if I wore any!"
    7. Re:Apple Proprietary ROMs still an issue? by Beatbyte · · Score: 1

      Actually this lets you choose which partition to load. Nothing to do with booting into an OS (directly at least).

  19. FUCK by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    I just did a frequency analysis on the text, and
    it is all rubbish :-(
    I thought it was an encrypted message .. oh well,
    I shouldn't overestimate the collective /. troll IQ.

  20. death of Apple? by Transient0 · · Score: 3, Redundant

    Competition is a good and healthy thing, but part of me is a little worried by this.

    I mean, if apple hardware becomes the open market that PC hardware is now, Apple will have to quickly adapt.

    Microsoft understood from the beginning that the real profit is to be made in software, but Apple is still a proprietary hardware company that happens to also sell the software which their machines require.

    If the market truly opens up, Apple may face the really tough choice of dumping their hardware line entirely. When the time comes, will they make the right choice and make the shift to software-only gracefully?

    If they don't then I fear that one of the last strongholds against Microsoft market share may wither and die.

    On the other hand, it will be in the best interest of the companies which produce third party hardware to keep Apple in business(after all, if Apple goes under, who will buy hardware for Mac OS?), so maybe some sort of truce will be drawn. I guess as always, it's wait and see.

    Really though, despite the foreshadowing, this is good news for the market.

    1. Re:death of Apple? by Maddog_Delphi97 · · Score: 1

      That's a little bit like asking if a country like Russia can successfully change to capitalism from socialism...

      If they can, fine.

      If they can't, there's hell to pay and they just revert back to the old system.

      So, the question is, can a company like Apple succesfully change to software-only from proprietary hardware/proprietary software?

    2. Re:death of Apple? by banky · · Score: 1

      It is unlikely (IMHO) that you'll be able to get OSX to boot on these... probably Darwin and definately Linux, but OSX is pretty tied to the hardware. IIRC it used to check to make sure you didn't have bogus RAM (ie non-Apple approved) installed.

      --
      ZOMG I WOULD LOVE TO KNOW ABOUT YOUR FEELINGS ON MACINTOSH VERSUS WINDOWS, VI VERSUS EMACS, AND HOW YOU'RE NOT A DORK
    3. Re:death of Apple? by feldsteins · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I think you're missing the point here. None of this stuff is ready to run any version of the Mac OS or any applications developed for the Mac. There is still the issue of Apple proprietary ROMs to deal with.

      So this isn't a "Mac clone" issue at all.

      Apple will never allow clones in the future. At least I hope not. The only thing that makes Apple Apple is the fact that they make the hardware and the operating system, the "whole widget" as the Big Steve likes to say. I think he's absolutely right. It allows them to innovate, innovate quickly and also to take responsibility for more of the whole user experience.

      If you really think about it this is the only thing that makes them truly unique in the market. Otherwise they'd be Dell or Microsoft. There's no benefit in trying to out-Dell Dell or out-Microsoft Microsoft. And even if they did who would care? Or even notice? Even if Dell went out of business tomorrow someone else would step up and give you the exact same product at the exact same price.

      --
      You like your Macintosh better than me, don't you Dave? Dave? Can you hear me Dave?
    4. Re:death of Apple? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      no, it's not the death of Apple. Apple doesn't manufacture motherboards. They sell a digital lifestyle. non-apple PPC motherboards have actually been available for quite a while. RS6000, BeBox, CHRP, a couple german companies, and the Mac Clones of yesteryear, the phantom Amiga 2001, and more.

      The market for people that want a non-apple PPC motherboard is virtually nonexistant.

    5. Re:death of Apple? by Mocenigo · · Score: 1

      > It is unlikely (IMHO) that you'll be able to get > OSX to boot on these... probably Darwin Then you can also run the upper layers. THese talk to the Darwin kernel. It's the idea behind having OSX on unsupported machines > OSX is pretty tied to the > hardware. IIRC it used to check to make sure you > didn't have bogus RAM (ie non-Apple approved) > installed. oh no, that was an OpenFirmware Update, not OSX, and - according to some sources - with a reason. OS X is not guilty of that...

    6. Re:death of Apple? by Mocenigo · · Score: 1

      If they can run Darwin, also the upper layer will probably run. It wasn't OSX that disabled "bogus RAM", but an OPen Firmware update.

    7. Re:death of Apple? by parp · · Score: 1

      Lets face it, its a Microsoft world. Until you can run Windows on this hardware, thise will only be a nieche market. Just because the hardware is publicly available doesn't mean squat. How many people are going to run out and buy this? The only time Apple would have serious worries is if Microsoft sells a copy of windows that will run on a mac. Until then, Apple has a great market for selling a complete high quality integrated product.

    8. Re:death of Apple? by Syberghost · · Score: 2

      If the market truly opens up, Apple may face the really tough choice of dumping their hardware line entirely. When the time comes, will they make the right choice and make the shift to software-only gracefully?

      If they don't then I fear that one of the last strongholds against Microsoft market share may wither and die.


      You're missing something crucial here; for them to do that, the market would have to open up, and thus by definition there'd be a TON of "last bastions" making enough money to scare Apple.

      But it won't open up the same way the PC market did; the time was right for computers on the desktops, IBM just got lucky to hit it at the exact right moment with enough money to fill the bill. There aren't that many people sitting around going "gee, I'd buy a computer, if somebody other than Apple made Macs." People who don't like Apple just don't buy Macs.

    9. Re:death of Apple? by iamcadaver · · Score: 1
      Microsoft understood from the beginning that the real profit is to be made in software...

      Come back to earth sometime in a few solar cycles and repeat that after HomeStation doubles MS's current yearly profits.

      --
      Before I part with'em: two pennies weigh ~4.996+/-0.014g, have a zinc core, and the face of Lincoln. You can keep 'em.
    10. Re:death of Apple? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Lets face it, its a Microsoft world.

      Let's not "face" (i.e. accept) it. Let's fight it.

    11. Re:death of Apple? by benwb · · Score: 2

      Of which they lose money on every box they sell and make it back by getting a cut of any software sold for the device. When you sell a piece of hardware you don't have it anymore- when you sell a piece of software you can sell it again and again and again. Until you can make a physical copy of a device as cheaply as duping a cd or two software will always be much more profitable than hardware simply due to economies of scale.

    12. Re:death of Apple? by BattyMan · · Score: 1

      Lets face it, its a Microsoft world.

      NO, I WON'T! M$ does _NOT_ (yet) own the world!
      You may say that I'm in denial, but I will reply that this is Slashdot, and you're a troll.

      Until you can run Windows on this hardware, thise(sic) will only be a nieche(sic) market.

      It's my understanding that Macs have, or have available, an Intel emulation layer which is capable of running Winbloze. Of course, you must still buy these Winbloze from the Empire (the regular, ordinary distribution, nothing special about it). Apple regards this as an asset, not a threat.

      Believe it or not, there are those of us who neither run, nor want, Micro$uck Winbloze. Really. This discussion is focused on the possibility of running Aqua (the Mac OSX GUI layer) on non Apple-proprietary hardware. The operabillity of Linux and Darwin on such machinery is not an issue. Winbloze is not a factor. Obviously anyone who _wants_ to run Winbloze (without digressing into the debate over the intelligence of that) is going to prefer the Intel architecture to which Winbloze is targeted.

      If, however, you want a Mac and OSX, or generic PPC hardware and OSX, you can run Winbloze on either of those, already.

      --
      Exceeding the recommended torque is not recommended.
    13. Re:death of Apple? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      FYI "Micro$uck Winbloze" (NT4.0 SP4) does run on this hardware and MacOS X does not and never will (officially).

    14. Re:death of Apple? by Llywelyn · · Score: 1

      In order for this to happen something crucial MUST occure that will NEVER occure.

      Apple has to license their operating system to be sold ON a computer and then must start to support those boxes.

      Apple is never going to do this, so a clone market can never spring up.

      --
      Integrate Keynote and LaTeX
    15. Re:death of Apple? by DavidRavenMoon · · Score: 1
      The only time Apple would have serious worries is if Microsoft sells a copy of windows that will run on a mac.

      Since Apple makes most of their money selling hardware, I don't think they would worry if a bunch of Windows users started buying Apple hardware...in fact it would make them a ton of money!

      But remember, Mac users buy Macs to run Mac OS. It's not really because of the hardware, even though we like it too.

      --
      -- if it was so, it might be; and if it were so, it would be; but as it isn't, it ain't. That's logic - Lewis Carrol
    16. Re:death of Apple? by DavidRavenMoon · · Score: 1
      IBM just got lucky to hit it at the exact right moment with enough money to fill the bill. There aren't that many people sitting around going "gee, I'd buy a computer, if somebody other than Apple made Macs."

      The reason you see so many Intel based PCs has nothing to do with IBM getting lucky!

      If it were not for Compaq reverse engineering the proprietary IBM BIOS, and MS having tricked IBM into letting them have right to sell MS-DOS, then the only "PCs" you would see would be proprietary IBM PCs. It would be like the old days... Tandys... HPs... Apples... Commodores, all totally different and incompatible!

      Then you would have to decide what kind of computer you wanted, just like in the 1970s

      IBM never allowed cones! IBM was proprietary!

      --
      -- if it was so, it might be; and if it were so, it would be; but as it isn't, it ain't. That's logic - Lewis Carrol
    17. Re:death of Apple? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's only half true -- IBM was under a anti-trust consent order to offer reasonable licences for patented hardware components. This was due to it's evil activities back in the 70s.

      While the BIOS was reverse engineered/cloned, other key parts of a PC such as the ISA bus and the VGA controller were simply licenced from IBM.

      When the decree was lifted, IBM ran off and invented a truely closed system (MicroChannel), and you can see how far that got.

  21. Doomed because of the stupid name by Kopretinka · · Score: 1, Funny
    I think POP is a stupid name compared to PC:

    I just bought myself a new POP!

    ...he spent the day working at his desktop POP...

    My POP crashed again!

    etc. Would you buy a POP instead of a PC?8-)

    --
    Yesterday was the time to do it right. Are we having a REVOLUTION yet?
    1. Re:Doomed because of the stupid name by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I need to POP some cherry ;-)

    2. Re:Doomed because of the stupid name by k_187 · · Score: 2, Funny

      well, lets think about this for a second. What does PC stand for?

      Personal Computer.

      Hmm, so wouldn't a motherboard for a personal computer also be a PC?

      By jove, I think I'm right :P The Anal Retentive part of me goes into convulsions every time I see PC vs. Mac. But then I give it chocolate and it quiets down.

      POP is more akin to x86 than PC (or Mac for that matter)

      I need a life.

      --
      11 was a racehorse
      12 was 12
      1111 Race
      12112
    3. Re:Doomed because of the stupid name by eram · · Score: 1

      PowerPC stands for "Power Performance Chip".

    4. Re:Doomed because of the stupid name by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I don't think putting chocolate in your anal-retentive part is very sanitary.

  22. Re:Only part of Mac OS X is open source by Nerant · · Score: 5, Informative

    Only the core layer of OS X is open sourced: it's what we know as Darwin..
    What makes Mac OS X really attractive on the surface is it's GUI, which is not open source. Check out a nifty diagram here to see how it all stacks up.
    The answer is yes: Darwin will probably run easily on one of these boards, (there is an intel port of darwin). It is unlikely you'll get Aqua and the other supporting layers to run though, bearing in mind that it is unlikely Mac OS X "as is" will run on one of these boards without significant code surgery.

    --
    Be kind. There are too many mean people out there already.
  23. Well, knock me down with a feather. by Moderation+abuser · · Score: 1, Insightful

    It might be worth buying PPC after all.

    Cost is all important though. Motorola do PPC boards but they cost two and a half grand. WTF?

    --
    Government of the people, by corporate executives, for corporate profits.
  24. When you say "dual" ... by TheViffer · · Score: 2

    I hope you mean "you get 2 cpus", since that $3900 is only for the board. There is no talk of getting a CPU with it. (lets not forget case, drive, memory, etc, etc, etc)

    But we must also note, that this is "Evaluation" and not mass production. Odds are they are probably built much by hand for the time being, therebye raising the price (alot).

    --
    -- Knowing too much can get you killed, but knowing who knows too much can make you rich.
  25. Nice board typo... by Tower · · Score: 2, Funny

    I like the "Ultra DAM 100" ports... oops :)

    --
    "It's tough to be bilingual when you get hit in the head."
    1. Re:Nice board typo... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's not a typo. DAM stands for Direct Apple Marketing. It enables Apple to pop-up ads on the user's display, which is what (eventually) will drive the price down to a sane $200 or so.

  26. GigE chip! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    The article seems to indicate that the next model would maybe have gigE; but if you check the image on the site, http://www.penguinppc.org/articles/tgall/DSCF0052. JPG , you'll see that there is a Broadcom 5703 GigE chip right over the PCI slots! woohoo!

  27. What ever happened to CHRP? by Vanders · · Score: 2, Interesting

    If POP has "been around for a few years now", whatever happened to the Common Hardware Reference Platform? Would POP be the phoenix from the ashes of CHRP by any chance?

    1. Re:What ever happened to CHRP? by Sloppy · · Score: 1

      Yes.

      --
      As copyright owner of this comment, I authorize everyone to defeat any technological measure which limits access to it.
    2. Re:What ever happened to CHRP? by BeeShoo · · Score: 2, Funny

      What ever happened to CHRP?

      I think Eric Estrada started asking for too much money and the ratings were slipping, so they cancelled it.

      ... no ... wait... Never mind...

    3. Re:What ever happened to CHRP? by alex_ant · · Score: 1

      CHRP is long dead, and has been ever since Steve killed the Mac clones. POP has "been around" since IBM released an open spec for a reference POP motherboard a few years ago ('98 maybe?), but although a few small companies pledged to actually manufacture this board or one like it, none of them actually did. One of the companies was called Silicon Fruit, but I don't know what ever happened to them.

      Alex

  28. Offtopic. by af_robot · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    PowerPC Open Platform Motherboards Finally Here
    Dual 1Ghz G4 PowerMac With Extra Yummy
    Mac OS X: Game Developer's Playground

    Three Apple related news same date.
    Let me guess...slashdot got sponsorship from Apple?

  29. Still a little pricey... by BeBoxer · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Given that they are selling evaluation boards for $3,900 in quantity 1, I think sticking with Apple might be a good idea in the short term. Since the chipset is only $30 in quantity, hopefully somebody else will begin making affordable motherboards based upon the design. But Apple doesn't charge that much for a pimped out G4 tower, even with their steep RAM markup.

    What's curious is that their web page seems to indicate that the same chipset works with x86, PPC, and MIPS processors. I'm sure there are 100 reasons why it's impossible, but that kind of chipset flexibility does seem to raise some interesting dual-boot or multiprocessor setups to say the least.

  30. Finally? by stripes · · Score: 4, Informative
    Finally, we can buy PowerPC motherboards without dealing with Apple

    Moto (and many others) have been selling PPC motherboards for many years, maybe close to a decade by now. They are used for a fair number of embedded projects. The two downsides are cost, and every frickn' one of them seems to have another way to interface with PCI, or to deal with the boot sequence, or something. So all the not-so-fun parts of porting an OS have to be done again and again while the rest of it "just works" (or tends to).

    P.S. for a (slow) PowerPC, just buy an old TiVo. Linux comes with it, and NTSC out. Of corse it is only 50Mhz, but it works (don't get a new TiVo by mistake, they try to rip you off with one of those 200ishMhz MIPS CPUs...)

  31. Evaluation Board by wiredog · · Score: 2

    "Evaluation Board" often means "produced by hand, in small lots" which is probably why the price is so high.

  32. Certainly and only $2,500 each to you sir. by Moderation+abuser · · Score: 3, Informative

    PPC is fated to be an embedded CPU only, unless the support hardware comes down in price.

    --
    Government of the people, by corporate executives, for corporate profits.
    1. Re:Certainly and only $2,500 each to you sir. by ivan256 · · Score: 2

      Yeah, but $2,500 is less the the boards mentioned in this story.

    2. Re:Certainly and only $2,500 each to you sir. by Ixohoxi · · Score: 1

      Informative?? More like opinionated. Current PPC architecture (G4) is far better than Itanium, which is still vaporware. Pentium line can't compare on a technological level with PPC.

      Accept it.

      --
      What's a second? An hour? A day?
      It has much more to do with
      the Earth's rotation than with cesium.
    3. Re:Certainly and only $2,500 each to you sir. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You failed to dispute his point. Regardless of how good it is, PPC support hardware prices it out of the market. (mostly due to lack of demand, I might add)

    4. Re:Certainly and only $2,500 each to you sir. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "Pentium line can't compare on a technological level with PPC.", he opined poorly.

    5. Re:Certainly and only $2,500 each to you sir. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Itanium is hardly vaporware:
      IBM
      SGI
      HP
      eBay

      In a few years Itanium will be crushing PowerPC. Why am I so confident? Where do you think former DEC Alpha and PA-RISC engineers are working? Hint.

    6. Re:Certainly and only $2,500 each to you sir. by connorbd · · Score: 2

      Itanium is not in good shape these days -- Intel is said to be considering copying AMD Hammer, which would be almost certain doom for everyone's least favorite 64-bit platform.

      /Brian

    7. Re:Certainly and only $2,500 each to you sir. by Skapare · · Score: 2

      If they chose to start selling the boards for $200 each, they'd end up generating huge demand. As it is, they are cutting the market off with the extreme pricing. Of course I know that without economy of scale, the cost to build them is high. But there will be no way to compete with the more popular CPU, despite PPC's clear superiority over the Intel products. Why aren't companies like IBM selling these things in their low and middle range servers?

      --
      now we need to go OSS in diesel cars
  33. cost? by ArchieBunker · · Score: 0

    They better be on par with most x86 motherboard otherwise this is gonna flop.

    --
    Only the State obtains its revenue by coercion. - Murray Rothbard
  34. Did anyone check out the MAI site? by stepson · · Score: 2, Interesting

    This really doesn't seem like its that great. You get a 750CX (IBM's G3), 133mhz FSB, a few PCI slots, 1 AGP 2x slot, and a few other things like ethernet etc, and its almost 4 grand. Geez! I think you'd be better off with a fancy new dual G4 + GeForce 4 (Which, of course, you won't actually be able to get until the rest of us have had GeForce 4's for months) for $3k, which is complete, and even comes with a case.

  35. yawn by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    When I read about CHRP, PReP, etc I really wanted a PPC powered system. Now I'm afraid I just don't give a damn about the G4 when the AthlonXP is here.

    The G5 doesn't sound very interesting at all, although I could be wrong. Motorolla's e500 G5 core has been announced in a chip for embedded applications and doesn't seem any more interesting than the current "G4+". Maybe it'll have a few of those cores on the die and I'll be interested again, but I don't want to get my hopes up. :( I think I'll probably end up waiting for a Hammer.

  36. Open is interesting, but working is better by shagoth · · Score: 3, Insightful

    This likely won't have much impact on Apple as a whole. Frankly, after trying to make older hardware useful spending countless hours failing to have successful installs of LinuxPPC and Yellowdog Linux, I was thrilled to see that I can in fact have BSD albiet Darwin flavored without agony (and, of course, my old hardware remains unused).

    Apple's ultimate desktop success with Darwin/OSX will be because users who need that kind of OS power can now have it without the niggling driver details that plague Intel OS distributions. It amazes me that Linux has been as successful as it has with the agony that users have to endure to successfully install the OS. The bar is much higher now. Users can expect their OS install to just happen and still have the power tools of compilers and real server software without the electronic equivalent of repeatedly stabbing themselves in the leg with a fork.

    Of course, the die hard slashdot crowd will always prefer Linux, but it seems to me that things are shifting to a new and friendlier approach.

    1. Re:Open is interesting, but working is better by rtscts · · Score: 1
      without the niggling driver details that plague Intel OS distributions. It amazes me that Linux has been as successful as it has with the agony that users have to endure to successfully install the OS.

      What the fuck are you smoking? Installing is the EASIEST way to get the system configured and fully functional. It's the changing shit afterwards that's the problem.
    2. Re:Open is interesting, but working is better by pmz · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Apple's ultimate desktop success with Darwin/OSX will be because users who need that kind of OS power can now have it without the niggling driver details that plague Intel OS distributions.

      Now that OS X is UNIX, I can imagine the Mac hardware/OS X combination being a sysadmin's dream come true. Sun hardware with Solaris is similar: it just works without the mind twisting neccessary to debug a M$ Windows installation, for example.
      It is very good that these sort of OS/Hardware combinations are becoming more affordable ($X,XXX rather than $XX,XXX), so that the world's reliance on mediocre computers (Windows on Intel) will diminish more and more over time.

  37. From the look of the board by Moderation+abuser · · Score: 2

    It isn't (yet?) highly integrated. Lots of on board components, makes for a more expensive system.

    --
    Government of the people, by corporate executives, for corporate profits.
  38. Hmmmm.... by The_Iconcolast_666 · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    This reminds me of all the times I've been modded down.... so FUCK YOUS MODERATORS!

    Mod this shit down... I'm going to eventually have more negative karma than any of you... muahahahahahahahahahaha!

    --
    Waiting for your mother.
  39. A glimmer of hope? by Gizzmonic · · Score: 1
    Hopefully the price will go down, because I know a ton of people who would buy a PPC motherboard just for the novelty factor (I already have my Mac, thanks very much.)

    The problem here for Apple is that Mac OS X will probably run on any of these motherboards, since the Mac OS doesn't require Apple's boot ROMs anymore. Suddenly, Apple loses its main revenue stream (hardware). I've seen a lot of companies promise PPC motherboards over the years-SiliconFruit, Eternal Computing, etc. But they've all vanished (bought off by Apple?)

    Wonder how long it will take before this company shuffles off into the night...

    --
    (-1, Raw and Uncut is the only way to read)
  40. Modern-day Toolbox API calls in ROM? by swngnmonk · · Score: 2, Informative

    As I understand it, the core codebase (Darwin) is fairly agnostic - it's just another flavor of Unix, teeth, hair, a**hole & all. Darwin sourcecode is available, if not GPL'd (Doesn't Apple have their own 'open source' license?). Darwin has already been ported to other platforms.

    The catch is the UI - Apple's precious UI - the part of OSX that isn't available for the world+dog. In the bad old days, Apple would fill up the ROM chips will hardware implementations of their QuickDraw API (And lordy, did those old Macs need those API calls in hardware!).

    During the CHRP clone days of the mid-90s, Apple was able to put all that stuff back in software, eliminating the need for those chips. Needless to say, CHRP is quite the distant memory.

    So the question remains - is Apple still using proprietary chips on the Mobo to ensure that noone can manufacture legit clones? If so, what parts of OSX rely on that hardware? How much could you get running? It'll be interesting to find out..

    --

    'ARRGH! Pirate Designers of the Internet, we be!'

    1. Re:Modern-day Toolbox API calls in ROM? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

      My understanding is that there are no proprietary ROMs, however that is not to say the modern systems are purely CHRP or have completely documented chipsets.

      True that an end user could theoretically modify Darwin and boot OS X on a non-Apple system. However the key point is that he/she could not sell systems with OS X installed due to copyright law. The best you could do is release patches and a HOWTO, which limits your market quite a bit.

      So, Apple's ownership of the platform lies with the lawyers, not the technology.

    2. Re:Modern-day Toolbox API calls in ROM? by Ryan+Amos · · Score: 1

      Actually, CHRP wasn't the clone boards-- it actually IS PPCP. They just changed the name. The only thing that really prevented anyone from building a PowerPC based system in the past was the lack of a chipset, which is what this article is about. With some work, these could probably run OS X. The trick lies not in the hardware, but in OpenFirmware (the BIOS, sort of.) Old-school PowerPC Linux hackers will remember having to boot from OpenFirmware and set nvram parameters to get Linux to boot. The functionality of OF would have to be duplicated in order to be able to boot OS X without modifying it.

  41. Apple's Niche by Transient0 · · Score: 2

    You're right when you say that what makes Apple Apple is that they sell the "whole widget" in one shiny box. As a matter of fact, you're right in pretty much everything you say.

    I understand that this new motherboard does not hail the immediate arrival of a Mac hardware open market, but I think that it may be a sign of things to come. If there is a sudden push towards Apple clones, I don't know if all the litigation in the world can stop the market from opening up. Remember IBM(i understand that the case presents significant differences, but the analogy holds some water).

    What I'm getting at is that Apple may have to face an open market not too far in the future. And you bring up another interesting point: Can the computer market really bear two competing open market standards?

    1. Re:Apple's Niche by joshsisk · · Score: 1

      The problem with your arguement is that MacOS won't run on these motherboards. You have to have special, Apple-provided ROMs to run it. Apple isn't going to give them out. They've already won this battle, the Mac clone companies closed up shop.

    2. Re:Apple's Niche by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Can the computer market really bear two competing open market standards?

      Considering that PREP/CHRP never got any market traction in the Windows world, the answer is pretty clearly NO.

      MIS purchasers don't even like buying machines with "non-standard" memory (DDR or RDRAM), much less an entirely different CPU. When IBM and Motorola tried to sell these things, they didn't get anywhere, and the systems were off the market within a couple years.

    3. Re:Apple's Niche by Cadre · · Score: 2

      You have to have special, Apple-provided ROMs to run it. Apple isn't going to give them out.

      That's incorrect, but since I don't have mod points to mark it as a troll, I'll just bite.

      Since a couple years ago, all Macs use OpenFirmware to boot (which is IEEE 1275). This is an open standard. There are no proprietary ROMs used for booting at all.

      --
      All editorial writers ever do is come down from the hill after the battle is over and shoot the wounded.
    4. Re:Apple's Niche by joshsisk · · Score: 1

      Why assume something is a troll when someone may just be incorrect?

      I had always been told that some of MacOS booted from a ROM. So, if there are no proprietary parts or software involved, why did all the clone companies give up? Or did Apple wait until they all cleared town before opening the standard?

    5. Re:Apple's Niche by RustyTaco · · Score: 1
      o, if there are no proprietary parts or software involved, why did all the clone companies give up?
      Note the bolding. The clone companys shut down because Apple would no longer sell them MacOS licences. A Mac clone isn't really useful without MacOS.

      - RustTaco
    6. Re:Apple's Niche by joshsisk · · Score: 1

      Then my original arguement stands. I stated that this motherboard will not lead to any sort of threat to Apple's market share, or "opening up" of their market.

      I might have been confused about what aspect of the product is proprietary, but it looks like my statement was correct - you can't just make a Mac clone and sell it (unless you only want to run PPC Linux which wouldn't be a very profitable business to be in).

    7. Re:Apple's Niche by SlamMan · · Score: 2

      Fraid not. The ROM is in the software now, same way a kernel works. Just means you have to have a copy of the MacOS to run the MacOS. Not exactally a problem.

      --
      Mod point free since 2001
    8. Re:Apple's Niche by DavidRavenMoon · · Score: 1
      So, if there are no proprietary parts or software involved, why did all the clone companies give up?

      There was proprietary hardware and software back then. Those Mac clones (and I own one, I run LinuxPPC and Mac OS 9.2.2 on it) were based on Apple designed motherboards (or mainboards as Apple calls them). My PowerCenter was based on a PowerMac 7200, but with a 604 CPU on a daughter card. Interestingly, AMD makes a lot of the chips on the MB.

      They still needed the Apple ROM back then, and Apple had to approve the design before they could get a license for Mac OS.

      Without that license, they couldn't sell the clones as "Mac OS Compatible."

      What Apple eventually did was cancel their Mac OS licenses. Motorola is still pissed at Apple!

      Those were "Old World" machines. The "New World" machines use "Rom in Ram' by reading a file from the hard drive (as other's have said).

      --
      -- if it was so, it might be; and if it were so, it would be; but as it isn't, it ain't. That's logic - Lewis Carrol
    9. Re:Apple's Niche by TheInternet · · Score: 2

      What I'm getting at is that Apple may have to face an open market not too far in the future.

      Apple's business model would not support this -- which is why clones were cancelled. Apple sells hardware at high margins, and then devotes that income to the development of the platform and the software they give away with the machines. If you take away the margins, you lose things like Mac OS X, iDVD, iMovie, Darwin funding, etc.

      Therefore, Apple could simply change the hardware in such a way that others couldn't replicate (assuming they haven't already done so), or at least make it extremely inconvenient. This would prevent the sale of bare PPC boxes that were marketed to those who would then buy Mac OS X and install it on the machine.

      - Scott

      --
      Scott Stevenson
      Tree House Ideas
  42. This could be good for Apple by lordfetish · · Score: 2, Insightful

    The more people that use POP, the more processors that IBM & Motorola can sell - this helps the old economies of scale kick in and make PPC processors cheaper.

    Cheaper PPCs would help AIM compete with the commodity x86 marketplace.

    1. Re:This could be good for Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      Promised "economies of scale" was the whole reason that Apple signed up for PowerPC in the first place. If they wanted pure speed they would have gone with Alpha or MIPS or someone.

      A little history - IBM and Motorola thought they could replace Intel as the business desktop standard and released PPC PCs running Windows NT and OS/2. As icing on the cake, they also get Apple to sign up.

      Turns out that nobody wanted the Windows/PPC things and they are withdrawn from the market by 1996 or so. IBM retargets their work towards big servers, and Motorola retargets to the embeddded market. Apple ends up being the only PC vendor using the chip, which has left them in a very precarious situation for the last few years, with economies of scale working against them instead of for them.

      I doubt this will make much difference, though. Back in the day, IBM/Moto was talking about grabbing 25%+ marketshare for PPC.

    2. Re:This could be good for Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Didn't OS vendors (most notably Apple) yank PReP/CHRP support before hardware even shipped?

    3. Re:This could be good for Apple by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      PReP was purely an IBM/Moto thing, nothing to do with Apple. Apple wanted to keep making proprietary boxes and just needed a CPU.

      PReP machines shipped from IBM, Motorola, UMAX, and other vendors. You could even buy motherboards back in the day. Windows NT and AIX shipped for PReP. OS/2-PPC was cancelled in the beta period due to suckiness and lack of demand.

      CHRP was an attempt to meet Apple halfway. Apple wasn't going to officially support it until the fabled "Copeland" release came out. However the non-Apple PPC market pretty much croaked and Copeland never shipped.

  43. $4000 PPC motherboards have been around for years by Nelson · · Score: 4, Interesting
    High priced reference platforms have never been in short supply. If I'm going to buy a $5000 system then getting an alpha, mips, sparc, or POWER/powerpc has never been difficult.


    I own a couple of pieces of alpha hardware and it's fun in a geeky way to have. It's nice to test code on other platforms, it's nice to be able to learn assembly to other platforms and have something to work on, and a 21264 makes a hell of a web server. I'd love to have a newer PowerPC machine to work on but the prices just aren't there. If I could buy a motherboard and processor for $400-$500 maybe even $600 then I could easily see a little clique of people doing it. I can see real market value to it as well, I've seen 6 or 7 embedded jobs over the last month that were for PowerPC products.


    I hope that they are interested in lowering the prices and ramping up some mass production of the hardware. I could also see a huge market for lower priced integrated PowerPC motherboards with G3s or even 60x processors on them; put 3 NICs, IDE and a PowerPC on a motherboard for $200 and you have a nice DIY home gateway/firewall/router box.

  44. You're seriously clue-deficient. by greygent · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Proprietary Apple hardware?

    PCI? open.
    USB? open.
    Firewire? open.
    VGA? open.
    PowerPC? open.
    ATI/nVidia Graphics? open.

    Apple has already quickly adapted, by adopting industry-standard technologies, sans of course your blessed x86 platform. But who in their right mind likes working with the pile of shit that is the Intel platform?

    Apple is less closed than Microsoft. No one says Company X can't go out there and build a PPC system. Hell, people have gotten OS X to run on a few old Power Computing (non-Apple) computers.

    1. Re:You're seriously clue-deficient. by Emil+Brink · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Um, I really think you're stretching the meaning of the word "open" here, especially in the end. I can probably dig up the specs for PCI or USB without too much trouble, but show me the register-level specs for any recent ATI or nVIDIA GPU, and I'll show you a broken NDA. Those devices are not "open", in my world. But hey, I'd just love to be proven wrong, and really like links! ;^)

      --
      main(O){10<putchar(4^--O?77-(15&5128 >>4*O):10)&&main(2+O);}
    2. Re:You're seriously clue-deficient. by slashdot2.2sucks · · Score: 1

      proprietary != closed
      nVidia != open

      This is not a statement against Apple, but you are using the wrong words, or are making false claims

  45. Re:Only part of Mac OS X is open source by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I'll take the blue pill...shit NO WAIT, THE RED!!!

  46. Apple still has the advantage by BobTheJanitor · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Regardless of the degree of difficulty in kludging darwin to run on the POP boards, you're still missing out on the one thing that has set Apple apart in the computer industry: the tight interweaving of hardware and software. The most attractive feature of a mac, the guarantee that your mac stuff will run, is not really available to those who use the POP board.
    I can't understand why it excites any of you to be able to by a PowerPC chip from someone other than Apple. My dual processor G4 was reasonably cheap, Apple was friendly, and the package arrived quickly and was ready to go 90 seconds out of the box. Just don't buy an Apple monitor and don't get a ram upgrade (it takes regular PC133). It came out to be something like $2300, quite a bit cheaper than the $3500 for the board, plus (as noted previously), the GeForce *grin*.

    1. Re:Apple still has the advantage by styrotech · · Score: 1

      I can't understand why it excites any of you to be able to by a PowerPC chip from someone other than Apple. My dual processor G4 was reasonably cheap, Apple was friendly, and the package arrived quickly and was ready to go 90 seconds out of the box.

      Ahhh... but making it work is where all the fun is! You must be one of these 'users' that wants to actually do stuff with their computer. That unhealthy attitude seems common with you Mac users.

      A useful computer is a boring computer! Bah productivity schmoductivity! You just don't get it do you?

  47. BPlan Pegasos by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

    Will cost a much more reasonable price, around $400 or so for a mATX PPC motherboard with onboard Firewire, AGP4x, etc. Will work with Linux. Due within the next couple of months.

    1. Re:BPlan Pegasos by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Link, please.

    2. Re:BPlan Pegasos by Sloppy · · Score: 1

      I used to evangelize this too, but it seems like it's been just a few months away, for several years.

      --
      As copyright owner of this comment, I authorize everyone to defeat any technological measure which limits access to it.
    3. Re:BPlan Pegasos by Svenne · · Score: 1

      It's right here

      And it's AGP 2x, not 4x.

      --

      Slagborr
    4. Re:BPlan Pegasos by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not true. I've been following these developments too, and they have never given any final release dates or promises.

      Fact: Developer boards are already released to registered developers (allthough more than 10 weeks passed since feb. 2001).

      Fact: I've bought a lot of hw from Phase 5 (now BPlan), and though their tech support is rumoured to suck (I never needed it), their hardware is rock solid gold.

  48. Re:Only part of Mac OS X is open source by Matthias+Wiesmann · · Score: 5, Informative
    Wrong, if Darwin runs on those board and the processor on those board are PPC processors, then the higher levels of OS X will run. Only the Darwin layer interacts with the hardware, all the other layers interact with the Darwin kernel (that's one point of having a kernel). So Aqua cannot "know" if the motherboard is genuine Apple or not.

    This is one reason people were able torun OS X on unsupported machines.

    The high-level components like Cocoa and Carbon don't run on Darwin/Intel because the available binary code is PPC code.

  49. Teron PX Board supports PPC, MIPS, and X86 by paladino · · Score: 5, Funny

    I think it would be great to have one motherboard that supported processors from multiple vendors. Mai's web site says that the Teron PX board will support PPC, MIPS, and X86 processors.

    Brings a whole new meaning to "Dual Boot".

    You could develop in X86 Linux, shutdown swap processors, reboot in PPC Linux recompile and test.

    1. Re:Teron PX Board supports PPC, MIPS, and X86 by cswiii · · Score: 2

      What? And spoil my uptime? ;)

    2. Re:Teron PX Board supports PPC, MIPS, and X86 by GigsVT · · Score: 1

      That's OK, Linux has Hot Swap CPU support.

      :)

      --
      I've had enough abrasive sigs. Kittens are cute and fuzzy.
    3. Re:Teron PX Board supports PPC, MIPS, and X86 by MrResistor · · Score: 5, Interesting
      I think it's much more interesting to have them running in parallel. I'm envisioning a system where you have a "master" CPU, perhaps chosen at boot, and the other 2 running as slaves. That way you can run binary-only apps on their native hardware and without hurting your uptime. IIRC, the Amiga did something like this, though you couldn't choose the "master" at boot, obviously.

      Seems to me this would make for an incredible cross-platform developement tool.

      --
      Under capitalism man exploits man. Under communism it's the other way around.
    4. Re:Teron PX Board supports PPC, MIPS, and X86 by artemis67 · · Score: 2

      OrangeMicro used to manufacture an x86 processor card that fit into the PCI slot of Macs. At the time it was much, MUCH faster than trying to run VirtualPC or SoftWindows on a PPC601 or 68040 system. Unfortunately, it cost as much as an entire PC system, and the fact that Macs are now fast enough to run VPC at acceptable speeds did the product in. You could probably throw in as a contributor to the product's demise that it wasn't all that expandable.

      Cool idea in theory, but the target audience for it was very narrow.

    5. Re:Teron PX Board supports PPC, MIPS, and X86 by Yarn · · Score: 2

      Back in the mid 1990s a UK computer company did this. It's native CPU was a DEC/ARM StrongARM chip.

      The chips went on daughter boards, similar to the slocket that was popular with people eeking the last ounce of performance from their 440BX boards.

      I'm quite rusty about all this now, but I know it could take a 486 as a second CPU, and run decent games (the poor thing only had terrible games, it was targetted at the educational market).

      The Company was Acorn of the BBC fame, the machine was the RiscPC.

      A real RISC processor before the PPC was dreamt up :)

      --
      -Yarn - Rio Karma: Excellent
    6. Re:Teron PX Board supports PPC, MIPS, and X86 by BJH · · Score: 1

      Just to let you know, the original BBC Micro could do this - there was a Z80 option (main CPU was a 6502).

  50. Re:Only part of Mac OS X is open source by Liquid(TJ) · · Score: 1

    That is, unless there's some code in Aqua designed to stop people from doing this. Assuming there's no such code, will Apple add it in the next rev?

  51. Finally! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Holy Shit! finally!

  52. Open PPC Platform boxes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Offtopic

    Imagine a Beowolf Cluster of THESE!!!

    1. Re:Open PPC Platform boxes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Imagine
      John Lennon

      Imagine there's no heaven
      It's easy if you try
      No hell below us
      Above us only sky
      Imagine all the people
      Living for today...

      Imagine there's no countries
      It isn't hard to do
      Nothing to kill or die for
      And no religion too
      Imagine all the people
      Living life in peace...

      You may say I'm a dreamer
      But I'm not the only one
      I hope someday you'll join us
      And the world will be as one

      Imagine no possessions
      I wonder if you can
      No need for greed or hunger
      A brotherhood of man
      Imagine all the people
      Sharing all the world...

      You may say I'm a dreamer
      But I'm not the only one
      I hope someday you'll join us
      And the world will live as one

  53. Re:Only part of Mac OS X is open source by Liquid(TJ) · · Score: 1

    Now that I think about it some more though, with some tracing one could figgure out how Aqua talkes to Darwin to run this check, and modify Darwin to lie about it. You'd need a real Mac to do that though (or you'd be chicken and egg'd), and you may have to do it every rev.

  54. deja vu... by gkbarr · · Score: 2, Interesting

    says the kid with a PowerComputing box.

    --
    Sapere Aude - Homer
  55. Sorta by Pope · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Every single one of those legacy machines were genuine Macintoshes, and therefore have the Apple ROM need to run the old MacOS. OS X could easily check for the presence of that ROM and refuse to install. That has nothing to do with the Darwin core.

    --
    It doesn't mean much now, it's built for the future.
    1. Re:Sorta by Matthias+Wiesmann · · Score: 5, Informative
      • Carbon and Cocoa do not rely on ROMs
      • Classic relies on a ROM file in the OS9 system folder
      • The real ROM is used only for booting
    2. Re:Sorta by BlackGriffen · · Score: 1

      But then if you're hacking the hardware together anyway, you have complete access to the ROMs, and could thus hack them to fool the software.

      BlackGriffen

    3. Re:Sorta by Lee+Cremeans · · Score: 2, Informative

      Not true on older Power Macs (everything before the Blue and White G3 and the iMac). With these "OldWorld" Macs, the Mac OS ROM is still actually in ROM on the motherboard. Newer Macs use the "NewWorld" architecture, where the Mac OS ROM is just another boot image to load from disk (think SPARCstation here).

      -lee

  56. Re:Wow, but only $30 for the chipset by subgeek · · Score: 1

    if you check the articia s, the chipset they use for the teron cx you'll see that the chipset itself only costs $30.00 (in quantities of 10,000. that sounds like a reasonable price for a chipset. my guess is that they don't want to give away their r & d for the mobo design.

    also noticed that this chipset supports MIPS and x86 in addition to power pc.

    --
    you probably shouldn't have read this.
  57. Re:Only part of Mac OS X is open source by Matthias+Wiesmann · · Score: 2

    The only part of the system were they could do this would be the darwin kernel (the open source part). Do you really think that Apple would add such a feature, which requires testing and could probably cause bugs, simply to prevent the four guys that might build a stock PPC which is more expensive that genuine Apple computers from running OS X on it? Do you really think this would be cost effective?

  58. How M$ made this unimportant by jonbrewer · · Score: 2, Insightful

    A long time ago I watched the rags weekly for news of CHRP PPC boards. This was in the age of NT4, which shipped with binaries for Alpha, i386, PowerPC, (MIPS?) on each CD. PowerPC was going to be an excellent platform for computationally intensive problems on NT. Combined with Apple machines, PowerPC was going to be one of the big players in the desktop and workstation market.

    Once M$ gave up on support for PowerPC for NT, PowerPC was instantly marginalized as a workstation platform. Sure it's fantastic in Macs, IBM workstations, and massively parallel supercomputers, but without NT support this PenguinPPC announcement really means nothing in the grand scheme of things.

    1. Re:How M$ made this unimportant by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I don't think MS dropped support for PPC until after Motorola and IBM had discontinued their line of PPC workstations. The fact is the things just didn't sell.

      The PowerPC people also promised that they would significantly outscale Intel. As we know, that never really happened.

    2. Re:How M$ made this unimportant by Sloppy · · Score: 2

      Once M$ gave up on support for PowerPC for NT, PowerPC was instantly marginalized as a workstation platform.

      Unless someone has x86 legacy binaries, why would they want to run NT? Despite its ports, NT will forever be an x86-only thing. At least on x86, there's one reason to use it.

      Microsoft didn't marginalize PPC as a workstation, Apple did. You're right that this PenguinPPC announcement means nothing in the grand scheme of things, but it's because it costs $4k, not because it doesn't have NT support.

      --
      As copyright owner of this comment, I authorize everyone to defeat any technological measure which limits access to it.
    3. Re:How M$ made this unimportant by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Maybe you mean 'why wouldn't they want to run NT?'

      Remember back in the early 90s, people thought that Intel was deadmeat performance-wise. IBM, Motorola, Microsoft, Digital, whoever was behind MIPS, and many others bet billions on the premise that Intel couldn't scale. The future of desktop computing Windows NT on RISC.

      As for Apple, they sold millions of PPC desktop systems while IBM and Motorola sold a grand total of about 23. For that they get blamed for the platform's failure in the marketplace.

  59. Re:Only part of Mac OS X is open source by demon · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Except for stuff like display drivers. OS X uses a native, accelerated binary driver for talking to the display hardware. If you have a display chip that Apple themselves never used, and that those drivers don't (and have no reason to) support, you'll find they don't work.

    Besides, the higher-level stuff could theoretically examine the OF ROMs, and see if they are or are not genuine. I don't know if it does this or not - considering the hacks to make OS X run on older PPC Macs, probably not - but it could be done in response to something like this.

    --

    Sam: "That was needlessly cryptic."
    Max: "I'd be peeing my pants if I wore any!"
  60. EXPENSIVE by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    Why does it cost so much? I can see $200-$400 dollars but not almost $4k. Perhaps because its a prototype and its not really "massed produced"?
    anybody have a possible explanation to why its so much?

  61. Some ideas by Sloppy · · Score: 3, Interesting

    The obvious reason is the coolness factor. ;-)

    Other reasons are coolness (in terms of low temp and fewer fans, not hip dude wearing sunglasses) and power usage. Low-power-usage (yet still fast) computers would be great for 24x7 servers.

    Emulating MacOS (like Sheepshaver under BeOS did) would be somewhat nifty (although current real Macs these days are very nice, so this would be a somewhat less valid reason than it would have been a few years ago).

    Another server-related idea: obscurity. Let's hypothesize you have bad, insecure source code that, for some bizarre reason (I can't think of an actual good reason) you're not going to fix. Let's say it has a buffer-overflow attack hole. All the kiddies' scripts will try to put x86 opcodes on your stack. Put when you execute them, you'll just dump core instead of getting rooted. Yes that still sucks, but it's an improvement, right? Actually, I don't remember, but I think PPC stack may grow in opposite direction than x86, so buffer overflow attacks might not work anyway?

    Use your imagination; there are probably other advantages. But really when you get down to it, the coolness factor is the best one. :-)

    --
    As copyright owner of this comment, I authorize everyone to defeat any technological measure which limits access to it.
  62. WOW! by iforgotmyfirstlogon · · Score: 2, Funny

    Now I can get out my NT 3.51 disks again!

    - Freed

    --
    "Coffee should be black as hell, strong as death, and sweet as love." -Turkish Proverb
  63. wormy by spoonyfork · · Score: 0, Flamebait
    Apple: going out of business since 1984.

    --
    Speak truth to power.
  64. Why in God's name would anyone want a Mac? by PHAEDRU5 · · Score: 0, Troll

    I mean, let's face it: buy a Mac, and you buy from a company with a history of control-freakishness, to the point of pulling the rug out from under erstwhile partners.

    And then there was that wild appearance of billg on that terrible day.

    Buy PCs. You'll be working with stuff that's had to evolve in a much more Darwinian environment, and is therefore much more capable for a much lower price.

    --
    668: Neighbour of the Beast
    1. Re:Why in God's name would anyone want a Mac? by Genady · · Score: 3, Funny

      You'll be working with stuff that's had to evolve in a much more Darwinian environment

      Am I the only one who finds this troll ironic? After all Darwin's native development environment is Apple supplied PPC systems.

      --


      What if it is just turtles all the way down?
  65. IBM OS/2 PowerPC by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Now all I need is for IBM to finish porting OS/2 to PowerPC. Then I'll have my dream OS/Platform combo...

  66. I would buy it as soon as.. by zome · · Score: 1

    They come up with thin-and-light, 3-button touch pad, ppc based notebook.

    I don't need fastest cpu, what I need is something that runs long and cool.

    My current notebook is great, except I cann't put it on my lap, it's too hot, and I have to carry power adapter cause it runs only about 2 and half hour on battery.

    1. Re:I would buy it as soon as.. by Space+Coyote · · Score: 1
      They come up with thin-and-light, 3-button touch pad, ppc based notebook.

      Boy, that's what I would call really really stretching for a reason not to get an i/Ti-Book. Especiall since the OS doesn't require it, and Linux lets you nicely map the F11 and F12 keys as additional mouse buttons.

      --
      ___
      Cogito cogito, ergo cogito sum.
  67. Really Ugly Solder Job. by groebke · · Score: 4, Funny

    Check out that ugly power regulator in the upper left corner. Even if this is a demo board, a cleaner job should have been done with the prototype's part selection, mounting and soldering. This must be a joke, as that thing does not even have a heat sink on it. I think I will pass, and get one of those nifty new 1GHz dually's Apple now has.

    --
    Gerald Roebke
  68. Can you imagine... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The noise these babies are gonna make when I cram it in my garbage disposal?!

  69. Switch from PC hardware? Gladly! by Ogerman · · Score: 2

    Finally, an alternative! I for one, am sick of the hacked up kludge that is modern Intel/IBM PC hardware. I swear, every time I upgrade my system to the latest and greatest x86 processor and chipset, I run into more and more bugs, flaws, unexplainable quirks and incompatibilities, etc. in the hardware. Think about it. PC hardware has so many relics from the past--all of which must be kept supposedly to support legacy apps and hardware. When will designers wake up and realize.. "hey! we don't need to run DOS anymore!" It's time to cut all ties with "legacy IBM PC" functionality. That means it's time to ditch: floppy controllers, all remnants the ISA bus, PS/2 ports, parallel and serial ports, BIOS functionality intended for real mode operating systems, etc.

    Or.. if the price is right, maybe I'll just buy one of these PPC boards. (-:

  70. $200? try $20. by Erris · · Score: 2
    The specs are more like those of a $200 motherboard.

    These folks are going to have a hell of a time selling boards with all the good quality stuff floating around for less than $100. A socket 7 mobo can be had for $70 with a 550MHz k6/2, brand new. I bought one used for $20 with 130M of ram to match a spare 400MHz k6/3 I had. While one of these newer boards might perform better, there are other $2,000 systems that can beat the crap out of it.

    Three years and one recesion too late, I'm afraid. Good luck to them. I'd like to see them everywhere.

    --
    DMCA, Hollings, Palladium. What might have sounded like paranoia is now common sense.
  71. This could be great, by FiberToTheCurb · · Score: 0

    as soon as they make an ATX mobo with dual ppc proc slots, 4 pc133 sdram slots, IDE RAID, 6 PCI + 1 AGP, PS/2, USB, 1394, and a few buzzwords I can't remember right now, AND sell it for less than $450, I will run out and buy three or four. I would even buy a few legit copies of OSX to dual boot with linux.

    --
    "God is dead!" ----Nietzsche "Nietzsche is dead!" ----God
  72. competition by GodWasAnAlien · · Score: 1

    As long as the monopoly makes products that are perfect for you, then it is hard to complain. If the product is not perfect for you (say you wanted a ppc linux box that didn't look like it came for Toys'R'us), then you are out of luck.

    1. Re:competition by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      so pull the guts out of a tower and stick it in a n ugly beige box... i'm not sure why you would *want* to replace the slick, graceful lines of a quicksilver g4 tower with something that looks like ass

  73. Steve Jobs! by DamienMcKenna · · Score: 1

    Back in the mid-90's, Dave Haynie was designing a PPC system for MetaBox (then called PIOS) called the PIOS One. He spoke to some hardware guys at Apple who convinced him to change his design to support CHRP as it was the best system design at the time and IIRC the next release of MacOS was to support it. Haynie went back to the drawing board (he was nearly finished the original design at the time) and redesigned his mobo around CHRP (he wanted to have multiple OSes on it - MacOS, BeOS, AmigaOS and I think Linux also). Shortly afterwards Apple hired Steve Jobs again (ie bought NeXT), and the whole CHRP and open MacOS plans were shelved, so Haynie and co got screwed.

    1. Re:Steve Jobs! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      neet story. didnt answer the question

  74. For the price you could by a nice man by Saint+Mitchell · · Score: 1

    Features
    Supports PowerPC(TM) 750 CX processor up to 133 MHz
    Articia S Chipset
    Three 32-bit 33MHz PCI slots on board
    One AGP/PCI (66 MHz AGP 2X or 33/66 MHz PCI) slot on board
    Supports 72-bit (with ECC) Data Path SDRAM up to 2Gbytes
    Two 168-pin DIMM slots on board
    PowerPC Linux Kernel 2.4.5 support


    All for the low, low price of nearly $3000. I'm all for being able to roll my own PPC system. I've always wanted a PPC, but stayed away becuase I can build my own PC for 1/2 the cost. Don't get me wrong, I think it's great that it happened. But still...$3k?

  75. No longer beholden to Apple for PPC? Hold me back. by tibbetts · · Score: 1

    That's fantastic! For about $100 less than a dual-1GHz PowerMac and 17" LCD monitor, I can get a bare board that can take up to a 133MHz G3?!? Finally, I don't have to pay a premium for the "Apple style" factor. Thank goodness.

    --
    :wq
  76. Firmware only disabled nonspec RAM. by Cadre · · Score: 2

    IIRC it used to check to make sure you didn't have bogus RAM (ie non-Apple approved) installed

    You recalled wrong. The firmware update raised the motherboards standards for specifications for RAM. They did this because there were problems with nonspec RAM leading to stability problems.

    To sum it up: all the firmware update did was disable shit RAM that didn't meet specifications. As long as you bought good RAM from a reputable dealer you were fine.

    --
    All editorial writers ever do is come down from the hill after the battle is over and shoot the wounded.
  77. Nice FUD by CapsaicinBoy · · Score: 1
    Bzzzz! Thanks for playing. Modern apple's boot using Open Firmware (IEEE-1275), just like a Sun box.

    http://playground.sun.com/1275

    If instead, you are refering to the Mac Toolbox that used to live in the ROM, you would still be wrong. This has not been the case since the first iMac's were rolled out in 1998. Machines prior to this era are now refered to as Old World Macs while those that came after this change are refered to as New World macs.

    http://www.imaclinux.net/gh.php?single=76%2Bindex= 0

  78. Re:Apple Proprietary ROMs still an issue? NO by CapsaicinBoy · · Score: 1
    Well - you are wrong.

    Check out http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=27009&cid=2915 041 for an answer to your question.

  79. Will I Flamed if I Mention Amiga Here? by metaphysicist · · Score: 1, Flamebait

    If I mention that Amiga is working [or contracting out the work] for a PowerPC board and that they are close to finishing a PPC version of the AmigaOS, or if I mention that there is already a company that has the developers PPC boards [of their own design] that will run MorphOS [an Amiga-like OS], will I be flamed?

    --


    Metaphysicist

    "If at first you don't succeed, keep on sucking until you do succeed"

    - Cu
    1. Re:Will I Flamed if I Mention Amiga Here? by NetNinja · · Score: 1

      I still own an AMIGA. If those jack asses would have done this 6 years ago the Amiga would have still been going strong. Now they want to port thier OS to Cell phones? Washing Machines?
      Amigas OS will probably go the way like BEos did.
      I still have no idea what Gasse wanted to do with it. I loved the Amiga but since it's demise I switched over to Linux and Winblows.

  80. Easiest way to get Linux-pmac on a PMAC box by chainsaw1 · · Score: 1

    I had some issues with late-version PPC linux. I have come to rest on Debian with some help from LinuxPPC CDROM. If you are new to Linux, you may want to just use LinuxPPC 2K. Their CD installer makes getting linux working (not optimized, but just working) on PPC easy...it's by far the best in terms of user friendly for PPC that I have seen. My basic directions would go something like this

    (This assumes BootX to boot to Linux)

    1) Get a LinuxPPC 2000 CDROM. Boot the cdrom (no OpenFirmware crap needed, etc.... just stick it in and hold down c while you boot). You can also start from MacOS if you want (and install BootX, which you will need later)

    2) Install LinuxPPC 2000. Leave yourself one partition of about 1GB that isn't mounted if you want newer system packages(i.e. Debian). Also leave yourself one partition that will keep a MacOS bootable fileset on it, if you destroyed it or want to make it a smaller partition

    3) Get networking working. LinPPC 2k does this on it own for most everything, incl mac-internal or external PCI cards (remember, Macs never had ISA slots...)

    And if you want the lates and greatest (LinuxPPC hasn't been really upgraded since late 2000)

    4) mount the extra partition from #2 above and unzip the Debian PPC base to that folder

    5) mount the MacOS boot partition. If you destroyed it installing LinuxPPC, you'll need to reinstall it. I think MacOS 7.6.1 and up will work fine. Have not tested it with MacOS X

    6) Copy the kernel from /boot on the Debian base partition to the MacOS boot partition.

    7) Write down the partition that holds the debian base system

    8) Reboot to MacOS. Install BootX from network or LinuxPPC 2K CDROM. Place the kernel file from #6 in "System Folder"

    9) Reboot. Select the kernel in System Folder as the boot kernel for Linux and put in the Debian partition into the "boot device" field in BootX

    10) Hit OK, You hsould be in debian, where you can finish according to the online Debian install instructions

    my $0.02. Any corrections to the above welcome

    --
    - Sig
  81. Too late by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Russia is already capitalist, and wild capitalism at that.

    1. Re:Too late by easter1916 · · Score: 1

      Robber-baron capitalism. The country and the economy is run by the old oligarchy.

  82. Pegasos by neverbeeninariot · · Score: 1
    bPlan for info on an another ppc mobo

    irc log ANN

    tarbos : Are the Pegasos developer boards already shipping and is the enduser board still on track for a late march release? PEGASOS : Bplans Mainboards PEGASOS start shipping in two weeks.

    AmyTek : I need to know how much will cost a pegasos mainboard with MorphOS and when it will be sold. PEGASOS : The consumer version will be sold in march for about 650Euros for bare boards.

    Logain : What kind of CPU-module will be included in the 650 EUR-package? PEGASOS : Motorola/IBM PPC G3 CPU's with 400MHz are planed for initial release.

    Psyria : Can you tell me something about the onboard SoundChips of Pegasos? PEGASOS : AC97 Sound with sigmatel ST9766 including SPDIF out.

    Univers : Which software is delivered with the Pegasos? PEGASOS : Pegasos is always delivered with MorphOS.

    Hans : When will the developer machines ship? PEGASOS : Shipment starts within next 14 days.

    Hans : When will the final version ship? PEGASOS : End user systems are available at end of 1Q2002.

    Hans : How much for the dev machine? PEGASOS : 650 EUR.

    Hans : How much for the final machine? PEGASOS : 650 EUR.

    McGreg : Will the Pegasos support also G5 and if, will it then support also DDR RAM? PEGASOS : We still have no G5 sample here: theoretically yes.

    DunkleSeele: Which operating system can I use on the Pegasos? PEGASOS : MorphOS/LINUX/NetBSD.

    AmiGR : Does the manufacturer of the chipset you're using plan to make DDR versions of the chipset? This would give your boards a HUGE boost. PEGASOS : DDR version of our chipset are not planned for release this year.

    McGreg : Will the Pegasos support also G5 and if, will it then support also DDR RAM? PEGASOS : We still have no G5 sample here: theoretically yes.

    miksuh : If Pegasos motherboard will cost about 650EUR, is there any idea of how much will cost a lowend prebuilt system with CPU, gfx card? PEGASOS : Complete Systems are around 1000EUR incl. HD/DVD.

    AS.

  83. PowerPC never was PC until now by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Why deal with Apple? Because dealing with Apple means difficult to use, closed systems.

    Apple traditionally promotes "simple" over "easy to use". A hammer might be much simpler than a tool box, but it is a lot hearder to use a hammer to turn a bolt.

    Until now, "PowerPC" was a dishonest marketing trick: the Mac wasn't a PC, but the PC in the PowerPC chip might have misled some fools into thinking it was.

    1. Re:PowerPC never was PC until now by DavidRavenMoon · · Score: 2, Informative
      OK, I know this is a troll but...

      Why deal with Apple? Because dealing with Apple means difficult to use, closed systems.

      Not difficult to use at all... give a few examples.

      Apple traditionally promotes "simple" over "easy to use". A hammer might be much simpler than a tool box, but it is a lot hearder to use a hammer to turn a bolt.

      Macs are known for being easy to use. It must be you!

      Until now, "PowerPC" was a dishonest marketing trick: the Mac wasn't a PC, but the PC in the PowerPC chip might have misled some fools into thinking it was.

      Well, no. Apple invented the personal computer, also known as the "PC."

      IBM coined the phrase "PC" for their first entry into the field to compete with Apple.

      Now as far as PowerPC, that's IBM's trademark, not Apple's, since it was their Power CPU to begin with. They went to Apple with the chip.

      Bottom line... it doesn't have to be Wintel to be a PC.

      --
      -- if it was so, it might be; and if it were so, it would be; but as it isn't, it ain't. That's logic - Lewis Carrol
  84. Don't miss Sun by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    If you want alternatives to the PC-standard, don't miss out Sun. They're currently selling their Blade 100 model for $1k, which is really cheap for a 64-bit 500MHz workstation. Those machines are built for UNIX, and they feel a lot more responsive (they ROCK on I/O!) than the MHz may sound. I bet you can find these used on eBay even cheaper ...

  85. Mac platform has been a failure by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    There's been no competion in the Apple world for years. It has been "closed" - inferior "simple" but hard to use OS's married to quirkly crippled overpriced hardware.

    At several times since it was introduced, the Macintosh platform seems to be about to wink out of existance. The business has been a failure: once it was even bailed out by its arch enemy. Recently, the trend has been for this technology company to focus its market on the box the system is in rather than what is inside (so much for technology mattering): it is all smoke and mirrors now.

    The current marketing campaign for their $1400 desk lamp (new iMac) contains mostly pictures of the machine without anything on the screen.

    A competitive environment with hardware competitors to Apple, and the wresting of monopoly control from the Mac OS direction would do this platform a world of good. The things that Apple can do right would be made stronger, and the free market and new community of creators would get rid of what doesn't work, and what has kept this platform in the "also ran" category.

  86. But where do I get a case? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Maybe I'm missing something, but it doesn't look like this open source MB would fit in a standard case. What I'm guessing are audio connectors are down in the area where a PC cards slots are.
    Are they spaced so they will fit through the card slots in a PC case? It looks like the first one conflicts with the second card slot.

  87. URL (was: Don't miss Sun) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Here is the link ..!

  88. Get rid of DOS? Bad idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It's a bad idea to get rid of the old DOS prompt. There are still things that a command line does better than a GUI.

    There is no GUI good enough yet to utterly replace the usefulness of the command line.

    The rest of the legacy stuff is the reason why the PC platform is so much more useful than anything out there.

    1. Re:Get rid of DOS? Bad idea by Ogerman · · Score: 2

      It's a bad idea to get rid of the old DOS prompt. There are still things that a command line does better than a GUI. There is no GUI good enough yet to utterly replace the usefulness of the command line.

      Sorry dude. DOS is 100% dead. It died many many years ago. But you're right about command line interfaces being more useful (although DOS had a crappy one). Use a real operating system (Unix) and you'll have all the command line interfaces you could dream of. And if you're still using the Win9x series, give it up man. 16-bit real-mode is history.

      The rest of the legacy stuff is the reason why the PC platform is so much more useful than anything out there.

      Uh.. No. The PC is more useful because it's an open architecture. If for some reason you still need legacy ports or floppies, use an appropriate USB adaptor. Linux supports most all of them.

  89. Macintosh never made PC's. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    PC means something following the evolving standard of the original IBM-PC.

    PowerPC motherboards have up until now have had nothing to do with PC's: it has been a marketing trick.

    PC vs Mac? Yes, there are PC's, and there are also Macs and Amigas and TI-994/A's. None of these groups overlap. Even Apple admits it: the latest iMac ads referred to PC's as something other than Macintosh, not something that includes Macintosh.

  90. well, there's one for $650 coming in a few weeks.. by mbpark · · Score: 3, Informative

    Hello,

    There's another PPC Motherboard with PCI, UDMA100, and Firewire coming in a couple of weeks from a German company named bPlan. It's called Pegasos, and info is here.

    $650 with a G3/400 is a lot more palatable than $3000. I just hope it has OpenFirmware on it!

  91. Re:$4000 PPC motherboards have been around for yea by bryan1945 · · Score: 2

    Shouldn't be too hard to buy a refurbished iMac for $600 or less somewhere.

    Of course, it would be a custom Apple board (which you probably don't want), but you do get the G3 chip.

    I wonder how much hacking you could do to an iMac mobo?

    --
    Vote monkeys into Congress. They are cheaper and more trustworthy.
  92. Other uses for a PPC by MasterOfDisaster · · Score: 1

    Most of the posts here seem to be argueing about how to run the MacOS on one of these. While that might be nice, I think the user experence of a mac (hardware/software all matching and working together and whatnot) is good. There are, however, other uses for a PowerPC chip. PPCs are some of the smallest, fastest and coolest chips around. These could be used for any number of (mostly) imbedded systems. The new G4 towers apple makes have one (very quiet) fan to cool them with. Show me a compareably fast system that doent sound like a jet engine. Quiet is quite often good.

    --
    The opinions in this post are ficticious. Any similarity to actual opinions, real or imagined, is purely coincidental.
  93. Initial High Prices May Fall... by Christopher+B.+Brown · · Score: 3, Insightful
    Early Intel Xeon systems were pretty pricey, and early IA64 systems probably aren't exactly "cheap."

    $3900 is a mite high, but high prices are not particularly surprising when something is being sold in its initial "units of 1 board to early implementors."

    It obviously won't get wildly popular until they can get pricing a bit more competitive with the hardware emitted by Apple, but it's a little early to say that this will never happen.

    MAI may be able to maintain a viable commercial business without prices ever falling to $100/unit, by the way...

    --
    If you're not part of the solution, you're part of the precipitate.
  94. Man you are stupid. by NDPTAL85 · · Score: 0

    The reason why OS X was able to run on those "unsupported machines" is because those unsupported machines were also Macs. Just older ones.

    --
    Mac OS X and Windows XP working side by side to fight back the night.
  95. Remember OpenPPC Project? by tgeller · · Score: 2
    For those curious about the history of POP, visit the archival Web site of The OpenPPC Project. It was quite active in its time (1998-2000), with partial archives of the discussion list available.



    --Tom, former administrator of openppc.org.

    --
    Tom Geller
  96. price factor by moosesocks · · Score: 5, Informative

    Quite a few people here aren't really clued in on the facts. First, the $3900 price tag is for an evaluation model. Intel and AMD do the same thing to vendors... nothing new. And, yes, there have been many $4000 PPC motherboards around.

    Second, if you read the PR on MAI's site, you can see that they plan to release the boards for SIGNIFIGANTLY less then $3900. The bigger flipside to this is that they also plan to produce (or license to produce) PCI cards and embedded g4 devices from $300-$600 with SMP capabiliy. (cool.. i can dual boot now.) similar cards sell now for $2000+

    Third, nobody seems to mention this chipset's ability to use PC hardware. I suppose this would be pretty easy to accomplish, but it's still a cool feature. The only limitation here would be driver support (not a HUGE issue. i dobut many people will be playing quake on this anytime soon. the first boards would sell to developers).

    Fifth, as a small sidenote, microcode solutions (http://www.microcode-solutions.com) plans to relesae a suite of ppc emulation products this spring. They plan on offering a hardware board, as well as a software based product. Of course, many are skeptical and believe it is vaporware. They currently offer a ppc amiga based macos emulator. (there are tons of amiga ppc motherboards out there. there are still a disturbing number of amiga users (shame gateway cut off their funding, right when they were about to make a comeback.)

    Finally, the chipset itself sells for $20. This is comprable to what chipset vendors such as VIA charge for their hardware. I would expect to see other companies support this sometime.

    Another issue is legality. It's perfectly legal to run LinuxPPC and beos. NOT macos. Sure, OS9 doens't need a hardware rom to run, but it is written specifically in the EULA that macos may ONLY RUN ON APPLE HARDWARE (yeah... it's in caps in the EULA... lawyers really abuse their shift keys!). Another project, MOL (mac-on-linux) which hopes to produce a mac compatibility layer (what wine is to windows, mol is to macos). Supposedly, it works well.

    --
    -- If you try to fail and succeed, which have you done? - Uli's moose
  97. Maybe you are confused... by Wesley+Felter · · Score: 2

    There are three differend boards mentioned in this story. The eval boards are indeed expensive, but that doesn't matter because they're not intended for the general public. The "Barbie" board is intended for the general public, and it doesn't have any price listed so we don't know if it's going to be expensive or (crossing fingers) cheap.

  98. Removable CPU by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I noticed the CPU is hardwired to the board. Why can't they socket it? I'm not buying a motherboard with a non-replacable CPU attached...

  99. Re:$4000 PPC motherboards have been around for yea by Nelson · · Score: 2

    The thing I would be thinking about would be low power, fanless, micro-atx or pc104 type form factor. So we could put Linux no them about build them in to little network routing and web serving bricks.

  100. hhmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    it would be cool to walk into a computer store and be able to buy mac parts like PC parts and build your own computers like that or buy them from dell. I wonder if apple ever went out of busness would we be able to do that? I am shure it would be cool to have Intel G4 processors and ASUS G4 motherboards in ATX factor so we dont have to all buy new cases and everythign just worked together like power supplies, pci cards (with drivers of course), video cards and other devices..

  101. Are you sure about illegality? by Michel+Fortin · · Score: 1

    This is what I could find in the Mac OS X license concerning Apple hardware:

    [...]
    2. Permitted License Uses and Restrictions.
    A. This License allows you to install and use one copy of the Apple Software on a single Apple-Labeled computer at a time. This License does not allow the Apple Software to exist on more than one computer at a time, and you may not make the Apple Software available over a network where it could be used by multiple computers at the same time. You may make one copy of the Apple Software (excluding the Boot ROM code) in machine-readable form for backup purposes only; provided that the backup copy must include all copyright or other proprietary notices contained on the original.
    B. [... something about the Open Source component]
    C. [... something about no reverse engineering and the famous "do not use in nuclear facilities"]
    [...]

    From my point of view, it allows you to install it on one mac, then forbid you from installing it on more than one computer... but it never disallow installing on non-apple hardware... or is my english mistaken?

    1. Re:Are you sure about illegality? by JimmT · · Score: 0

      ...single Apple-Labeled computer...

      This means you can't install it on non Apple Hardware.

      Jim

      --
      "Life is art...Paint your destiny"
    2. Re:Are you sure about illegality? by moosesocks · · Score: 2

      the part about "apple-labeled machine"
      that's why they don't sell apple-clones anymore. OS 8 or 8.6 were the first to include that clause

      --
      -- If you try to fail and succeed, which have you done? - Uli's moose
    3. Re:Are you sure about illegality? by TheAJofOZ · · Score: 3, Funny
      This License allows you to install and use one copy of the Apple Software on a single Apple-Labeled computer at a time.

      So *that's* why they include a couple of Apple stickers with every new computer..... Stick them on the side of your clone and you can run OS X all you like...

      Disclaimer: Yes, this is a joke... but an interesting concept none-the-less.

    4. Re:Are you sure about illegality? by Keith_Beef · · Score: 1

      If I take the badge off an old Apple ][ and stick it on my home-brew BP6-based machine, it becomes and Apple-Labelled computer...

      I have Apple-Labelled it myself, OK...

  102. Re:Only part of Mac OS X is open source by David+Gould · · Score: 2


    Only the Darwin layer interacts with the hardware, all the other layers interact with the Darwin kernel (that's one point of having a kernel). So Aqua cannot "know" if the motherboard is genuine Apple or not.

    I've been wondering just how true this is -- I understand that this is the architectural idea, but the truth could have been anywhere between:

    * "because the dependencies are minimized, it would be very easy for Apple, if they so chose, (has to be them, since the higher layers are not open-source) to modify the code to enable the higher layers to run", and

    * "the abstraction really is complete, so that with the right hardware-enabling kernel extensions (which anyone can do, since the kernel is open-source), you can literally run unmodified Apple binaries and third-party applications".

    I guess you, and the page you linked to, are saying that it's the latter, which is really good news, and which I've only doubted out of general cynicism. Now for an even more ambitious question:

    The high-level components like Cocoa and Carbon don't run on Darwin/Intel [only (?)] because the available binary code is PPC code.

    If this is really true, and the CPU is the only reason (i.e., the other differences between the platforms are not too big to be abstracted beneath the Darwin layer), then would it be theoretically possible to hack a PowerPC emulation engine into Darwin/Intel, such that all the higher level code could be run through the emulator? I'm talking about integrating it at the kernel level, so that PPC binaries could be run in a "wrapper process" that would pass their code through the emulator, translate their API calls to the appropriate format before passing them to the kernel, etc.

    This kind of architecture independence is an idea that's been kicked around in a variety of contexts, with different pros and cons, but this seems like it could be a promising one, with Darwin/Intel bringing it to the "almost-there" level, and the lure of Mac OS X running on x86 boxes. Any chance?

    --
    David Gould
    main(i){putchar(340056100>>(i-1)*5&31|!!(i<6)<< 6)&&main(++i);}
  103. Not Intentional FUD, just mistaken by MO! · · Score: 2
    I used to work at Apple, and have experienced a lot of strange boot/installation issues with MacOS X on older G3's with older SCSI adapters. I guess the proprietary firmware I was meaning is the BIOS on the SCSI card. I tried to flash the BIOS on an Adaptec from a G3 with an update meant for the generic 2940. Since the 2940B was an Apple only OEM part, it wouldn't flash with an BIOS able to be booted from in a PC. The Apple specific ROM was limited to booting only in a Mac.


    I wasn't a hard-core kernel/device/bootloader geek, just a Unix admin in their data center. Even with Open Firmware, there still seemed to be alot of strangeness to Apple hardware that would make an IBM PPC MB a bit of work to get going. I didn't say it was impossible, just that you wouldn't be able to pop in the MacOS X CD and install like you were on a Mac.

    --
    I AM, therefore I THINK!
    1. Re:Not Intentional FUD, just mistaken by netsrek · · Score: 1

      Haven't there always been significant differences between Adaptec Mac and PC SCSI cards?

      The PC ones generally work fine in your Mac, you just can't boot off them. I've got a generic 2940UW that I use for running apps and scratch space, but I can't boot from it.

      If you're comfortable hacking around with your hardware, check out: this page for info on replacing the EEPROM.

      From that page...


      The Adaptec 2940UW and 3940U SCSI adapters for Intel machines (PC's) can be modified to work as PowerDomain SCSI adapters for the Macintosh. The modification requires removing the EEPROM from the PC version of the card and replacing it with an EEPROM with a larger capacity. One then updates the card's Firmware by installing it in a PCI equipped MacOS machine and using the PowerDomain Control Panel to install the appropriate Firmware Update. [Note - there was a software hack floating around last year, involving a PC flasher and a hacked Mac Bios that had been trimmed (using Resedit) to remove the zero padding that was said to be in the Mac Bios file to allow it to fit in the PC flash size. Most people never saw this hack and it's probably illegal anyway (please don't ask for it)-Mike]

      --

      i don't read slashdot anymore.
    2. Re:Not Intentional FUD, just mistaken by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This is also an issue with video cards - it's just a matter of BIOS calls - they're different for each platform. Theoritically this is true for any openfirmware vs. legacy bios (ie IBM PC) system. I'm not sure how/if Sun got around this for the Blade line.

      Anyway - this isn't an "Apple trying to keep me from using cheap PC components" as much as a "different hardware requires different software" problem.

    3. Re:Not Intentional FUD, just mistaken by cgleba · · Score: 2

      Interesting. . .wasn't the 2940B the same card that Sun OEM'd for the UtraSPARCs?

      I remember having the exact same issue you mention with Sun SCSI cards. . .

  104. cost!!! not the only place to get a board by EddydaSquige · · Score: 1, Informative

    Um, but this board costs close to $4000. It would be cheaper to buy a full fledged mac and strip out all the componants. Terrasoft also sells PPC computers, but not stand-alone mother boards. They will build you a cusomized board though.

  105. This is a bad thing by CAIMLAS · · Score: 2

    While we might be able to say, "competition with apple, lower prices!", this also means, "apple loses income, apple loses resources!" With apple's OSX (and their accompanying systems) being the largest contenders with MS for the desktop market, is this a good thing?

    --
    ~/ssh slashdot.org ssh: connect to host slashdot.org port 22: too many beers
  106. Its BriQ not iBriq!!! by Quicksilver31337 · · Score: 1

    I dont know what it is that you are smoking but the name of yellow dogs nodes is that of BriQ.

    -Quicksilver

    --
    _______
    Death wish, n.:

    The only wish that always comes true, whether or not one wishes it t
  107. Re:Switch from PC hardware? Gladly! by cgleba · · Score: 2

    "Finally, an alternative! I for one, am sick of the hacked up kludge that is modern Intel/IBM PC hardware."

    I thought the same thing when I got an Alpha motherboard. Far superior architecture and it didn't have the added weight of all the legacy junk. Heck, DEC even gave schematics for the whole board! That was beyond cool (to this day I am still saddened that DEC went away).

    Then came the support issues. Even under Linux some of the most basic stuff was not 'yet' supported on the Alpha. That and I had PCI problems because DEC's implementation was 'slightly' different. Sure, DEC UNIX and VMS worked fine, but I would be stuck with all DEC hardware. I ended up going back to x86 after hacking with it for 6 months.

    Moral of the story: x86 may be a bogged-down leagacy beast, but the massive support for it make it easier to set-up and maintain the even a streamlined intelligent Aplha -- as much as I would not like to admit it :).

  108. Re:what really happened to Frankenstein by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    oh yes, and we all recall what happened with Frankenstein... He went berserk, quite a rampage. Death and destruction. Heh.

    No he didn't! He died at the hands of his creation, the monster... :)

    Sorry, but that particular gaffe is one of my biggest pet peeves!

  109. Re:Only part of Mac OS X is open source by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    If this is really true, and the CPU is the only reason (i.e., the other differences between the platforms are not too big to be abstracted beneath the Darwin layer), then would it be theoretically possible to hack a PowerPC emulation engine into Darwin/Intel, such that all the higher level code could be run through the emulator? I'm talking about integrating it at the kernel level, so that PPC binaries could be run in a "wrapper process" that would pass their code through the emulator, translate their API calls to the appropriate format before passing them to the kernel, etc.

    It is absolutely possible, much in the same way you can run PPC emulators in Windows (ie. Fusion), however need a powerful x86 CPU underneath. Not only are there be problems dealing with RISC vs. CISC, but the faster PPC float and proprietary extensions (like Altivec) complicate things further. Considering how much x86 CPU power it takes to emulate a 90Mhz MIPS processor, you will need a powerful chip. The current from Intel and AMD can probably do it, but I've never seen a good PPC emulator on x86 ever...

  110. Yikes! A Sun Blade!? by The+Grip+Reamer · · Score: 1

    Have you seen what it costs to put RAM in that box? Or a hard drive? It's the computing equivalent of a tourist trap.

    -B...

  111. Yep, chipset support is the problem by DABANSHEE · · Score: 2

    Do either MacOS 9 or MacOS X support the articia chipsets? IOW Do they have Articia chipset drivers pre-loaded in Mac OS? Because even if someone releases a MacOS VIA like 4in1 chipset driver set for Articia chipsets one still has to install the OS 1st, which is very difficult unless there are rudimentry compatible chipset drivers built into the install.

    I don't think it would be that difficult as (I think) the Articia chipsets are (part licensed) clones of IBM chipsets. Hence its compatibility with Mips, PPC & X86 CPUs, although what type I don't know, ie is it compatible with the GTL+ bus (the p6 bus of the Pentium Pro, PII, Celeron & P!!!), the EV7 bus (the bus the Durons & Athlons use), 'Netburst' (the p7, AKA P4, BUS), or the p5/686/K6 bus whatever that's called?.

    However IMAO I think that Apple will go out of its way to make sure any system drivers that are pre-loaded into MacOS are totally incompatible with the Articia chipsets.

  112. How open is this? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It says on the homepage that this is a "open source" motherboard. Exactly what does that mean, and is it more open than Intel or AMDs hardware?

  113. Ignorance A'int A Virtue by marktwain · · Score: 1

    The ignorance of Linux users who know nothing about Mac OS X is equalled only by the ignorance of Mac users who know nothing by any flavor of Linux which is equalled only by the ignorance of WinShit users who know nothing about MacOS X which is equalled by the ignorance of WinDumbButts who know nothing about Linux which is equalled by.......

    If you don't know anything about it why don't you find out instead of guessing and speculating? These threads on SlashDot that (try to) discuss Mac OS X make as much sense as a discuss on (any Mac site) that discusses the lack of any merit whatsover of WinPickANumber.

    The what is Darwin messages result in the total inability of anyone to use the search engine on SlashDot to find out anything remotely accurate about what it is, what BSD it's based on, and whether or not OS X is based on it (it isn't; it's based on a fork of it).

    ::rolleyes::

    headed back for the mississippi.....

  114. PPC Rack Servers? by warfare · · Score: 1

    I hope some company will put these things into
    19" 1U chassis. I want to get rid of Intel..

    At least PPC's run way cooler and are equally fast. And I think a dual G4/1GHz will eat a
    dual 1,4 GHz Pentium III for breakfast.

    Just wishes..

    --
    -- If windows is the solution, can we please have the problem back?
  115. MacOS X over user-compiled kernels? by acb · · Score: 2

    Has anybody tried replacing the kernel on a commercial MacOS X system with a user-compiled Darwin kernel? Did it work? Were there any issues?

    Also, I recall that the delay in adding DVD support to 10.1 was partly due to the problem of satisfying the DVDCCA that the system was "secure", and that no rogue hacker could intercept their precious video frames; this would most likely have involved modifications to the kernel (and/or the Mach microkernel), and a fork from the open-source Darwin kernel (otherwise the "security" features could be bypassed by using a modified kernel). Has anybody tried playing DVDs over a home-made Darwin kernel?

  116. Dealing with Apple... by HoldmyCauls · · Score: 1

    Just do what I did... pick a Power Mac out of the trash at your college and fix it up! (still working on this; anyone know where I can find a SCSI HD and CD-ROM, or a Mac monitor for a decent price?)

    As far as OS is concerned for these, though, we now have several choices: Linux for PPC, Darwin, MacOS. When can we expect a PPC *BSD port? I'm not sure which of these I'll start out with, but I've seen MacOS7.0.1 for $40. Is that a good deal? Either way, I'm definitely going to burn both Darwin ISO's (x86 and PPC) as soon as I get a 'net connection at home (wherever home ends up being).

    One more critical question: All I have is the MB, the case, the floppy drive, and the power supply. I can't seem to find decent enough specs to know what parts to buy for it. Specifically: How much RAM should I have to undertake the project, for any of the above OS's? What's the battery #? Will I need any kind of ROM upgrade?

    --
    Emacs: for people who just never know when to :q!
  117. Re:Only part of Mac OS X is open source by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    > then the higher levels of OS X will run

    Yes. Illegually, so nobody cares.

  118. Re:Only part of Mac OS X is open source by David+Gould · · Score: 2


    Right, the performance hit for emulation would make it excruciating, except -- the idea here is that only the higher-level code (the {"Mac OS X" - Darwin} set of Apple binaries, plus user-level applications) would be emulated; low-level system stuff (the kernel's I/O, VM, and other hardware-access, the BSD layer, and whatever other services are included in Darwin) would run natively.

    The question becomes: for real-world everyday use, how much time is spent in those system calls vs. executing user code? If user processes are spending most of their time waiting on I/O or other system calls anyway, then slower execution of user code wouldn't hurt so much as long as the system calls remain native. Could the overall performance be expected to come anywhere close to a level where it would be worth anyone's trouble to implement?

    I guess a major decider would be Quartz: how much of the drawing engine is actually in those PPC binaries? If all the actual pixel-pushing is in there, then emulating it would be extreme pain, but if it's mostly control logic passing hardware calls down to the graphics card, then maybe it could be reasonable.

    --
    David Gould
    main(i){putchar(340056100>>(i-1)*5&31|!!(i<6)<< 6)&&main(++i);}