Slashdot Mirror


Miyazaki's 'Spirited Away' Wins Best Animated Picture

DavidBrown writes "Moments ago, Hayao Miyazaki won the Best Animated Picture award for 'Spirited Away.' It's about time."

451 comments

  1. Lake-berating news? by the+uNF+cola · · Score: 4, Funny

    Cripes, it was only minutes ago. I hope we don't hear every little detail before its done. :)

    --

    --
    "I'm not bright. Big words confuse me. But Wanda loves me and that should be enough for you." - Cosmo

    1. Re:Lake-berating news? by Scorpion_1169 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I assume that you realize this was not posted because an 'Oscar' is relevant to Slashdot, but because Sprited Away IS.

    2. Re:Lake-berating news? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      People complain that slashdot has been reporting old news lately. Now you're complaining this is too new.

    3. Re:Lake-berating news? by the+uNF+cola · · Score: 1

      You assume too much. Besides, what if 10 other sci-fi, slashdot loved movies won?

      It's a story flood!

      --

      --
      "I'm not bright. Big words confuse me. But Wanda loves me and that should be enough for you." - Cosmo

    4. Re:Lake-berating news? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That didn't seem to stop you from checking Slashdot one minute after it was announced. It seems that you got exactly what you were looking for, news for nerds, nerd.

    5. Re:Lake-berating news? by the+uNF+cola · · Score: 1

      Wow. Talk about blaming the observer. I was just on slashdot just for the sake of being on slashdot.

      I could care less either way, I just thought it funny to comment, unless I don't have *your* permission to make comments anymore.

      --

      --
      "I'm not bright. Big words confuse me. But Wanda loves me and that should be enough for you." - Cosmo

    6. Re:Lake-berating news? by the+uNF+cola · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I take it back! Did you hear what Michael Moore said about Bush on TV? Someone write THAT up! Totally went off on "President" Bush.

      Props to him, not for berating bushes actions.. but for standing up in what he believes in. We should all follow his example.. doing what we believe in... do it to whatever extent we can. Cut through the bullshit.

      --

      --
      "I'm not bright. Big words confuse me. But Wanda loves me and that should be enough for you." - Cosmo

    7. Re:Lake-berating news? by maddskillz · · Score: 1

      Actually, this is news to anyone who reads the anime section of slashdot. All you have to do is click on your preferences, then homepage, and they you won't have to see anymore stories about anime at all

    8. Re:Lake-berating news? by C0LDFusion · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      Not to say anything of his totally unfair interview style, like grabbing a random person when they don't expect it and asking heavy-handed questions. Like pressing a K-Mart clerk because K-mart sold ammo. I'd hate it if someone started pressing me for the stupid policies of my company.

      Michael Moore gets the attention he does, not because what he says is smart, or phrased intellegently, or surprisingly brave. But because he targets every controversial issue and takes the most controversial standing in order to ride the wave of controversy for his own personal benefit.

      --
      Only in slashdot are posts of solidarity modded at -1 Redundant, while posts of antagonism are modded as -1 Flamebait.
    9. Re:Lake-berating news? by the+uNF+cola · · Score: 2

      Hrm... never mentioned anything about anime. Mentioned late breaking news.. and posting quickly.

      --

      --
      "I'm not bright. Big words confuse me. But Wanda loves me and that should be enough for you." - Cosmo

    10. Re:Lake-berating news? by istartedi · · Score: 0, Troll

      Best quote ever about Michael Moore (this was said sarcasticly): "Michael Moore, who dropped out of the University of Michigan, is a genius; and President Bush, who graduated from Yale, is an idiot".

      Not sure who said this. Might have been Limbaugh or one of those other conservative talk radio guys.

      --
      For all intensive purposes, "whom" is no longer a word. That begs the question, "who cares"?
    11. Re:Lake-berating news? by BJH · · Score: 2, Informative

      President Bush, who graduated from Yale only because of his father. According to at least one of his teachers, he never bothered turning up for class.

    12. Re:Lake-berating news? by MonkeyDluffy · · Score: 1
      Actually, if Michael Moore berated me, I would take that as a complement. I'd wonder what I was doing wrong if someone like him actually complemented me.


      -MDL

      --
      Happy meals fund terrorism
    13. Re:Lake-berating news? by GQuon · · Score: 1

      Bush seems to be followed around by those guys from Men in Black.
      Or he just seems to inspire amnesia in people. How strange.

      --
      Irene KHAAAAAAN!
    14. Re:Lake-berating news? by moonbender · · Score: 1

      Actually, that is not the best quote ever about Micheal Moore, it's the best quote ever about the sad state of the (American) universities.

      --
      Switch back to Slashdot's D1 system.
    15. Re:Lake-berating news? by Lemmy+Caution · · Score: 2, Interesting

      As someone who shares much of Michael Moore's politics, I think of him the way that more intelligent conservatives think of Rush Limbaugh - sometimes funny and informative, but not really rigorous and at times dishonest. More of a cheerleader than an analyst.

    16. Re:Lake-berating news? by Baikala · · Score: 1

      Don't overthink it, this is on slashdot on a slasdot's-staf-liked-spireted-away basis. I don't dig the oscars either (the post remind me that the oscars were on) but it's nice when most academy members agree with your taste.
      By the way, Chicago being 'best movie' over TTT??!!!, the oscars sucks!

      --
      16,777,216 comments ought to be enough for any forum!
    17. Re:Lake-berating news? by Baikala · · Score: 1

      slashdot is my home page, i just started mozilla to do something productive and slasdot was there, it's not my fault really.

      --
      16,777,216 comments ought to be enough for any forum!
    18. Re:Lake-berating news? by istartedi · · Score: 1

      he never bothered turning up for class

      As opposed to most college students, who show up every day, give the professor an apple, answer the roll, and then recite in unison "good morning professor, we're all in our places with bright shiney faces".

      All this tells me is that they managed to find a bitter liberal prof at Yale who was probably stuck teaching an 8 o'clock section for which lecture attendance was not required.

      Now, if you're accusing the president of having purchased his grades, that's quite an accusation. If there were any truth to that I think we'd have heard from every liberal on the planet by now.

      --
      For all intensive purposes, "whom" is no longer a word. That begs the question, "who cares"?
    19. Re:Lake-berating news? by ChadN · · Score: 2, Funny

      After Michael Moore made his acceptance speech, which was received with fairly loud jeers and boos, the next "speaker" on stage was Jack Valenti, which caused me to start booing as well. Sadly, the hollywood glitterati did not continue with me...

      --
      "It's overkill, of course. But you can never have too much overkill." - Anonymous Slashdot Coward
    20. Re:Lake-berating news? by C0LDFusion · · Score: 1

      Someone must just hate the entire thread. I got modded down, and you did, too. Erg.

      --
      Only in slashdot are posts of solidarity modded at -1 Redundant, while posts of antagonism are modded as -1 Flamebait.
    21. Re:Lake-berating news? by BJH · · Score: 1

      Why are you so quick to assume that his professor is a "bitter liberal"?
      Not to mention your contempt for people who actually bother attempting to learn something at university.

    22. Re:Lake-berating news? by istartedi · · Score: 1

      Your first point is valid--I have no clear logical path to conclude the prof is a bitter liberal, only suspicion which has often been born out. Your second statement makes no sense at all. I made no expression of contempt for students who attend every lecture. I was simply stating a fact about the behavior of the average college student.

      --
      For all intensive purposes, "whom" is no longer a word. That begs the question, "who cares"?
    23. Re:Lake-berating news? by BJH · · Score: 1

      As opposed to the college student who doesn't bother to show up at all?

    24. Re:Lake-berating news? by khuber · · Score: 1
      I'd wonder what I was doing wrong if someone like him actually complemented me.

      Or worse, if he mixed with you and you turned green.

      -Kevin

  2. Subscription Perks by creative_name · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Just curious, how long was this one in the preview que (or whatever) before it got posted to Slashdot?

    --
    Posting as directed.
    1. Re:Subscription Perks by Nogami_Saeko · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I assume that the editors were watching and posted it immediately.

      In any case, Hollywood finally gets it right - to be sure, SA didn't have much in the way of real competition, but I was pleasantly surprised regardless.

      Here's hoping that Laputa is released domestically soon!

      N.

      --
      "Nothing strengthens authority so much as silence." - Charles de Gaulle
    2. Re:Subscription Perks by Masami+Eiri · · Score: 1

      Laputa, Spirited Away, and another one (name escapes me) were just released on DVD.

    3. Re:Subscription Perks by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They were? I have SA with a 4/15 release date. Last I checked, it's 3/24 where I am.

    4. Re:Subscription Perks by Eunuchswear · · Score: 1

      Huh, I bought it in (late January, early Feb? can't remember). Finaly some good comes out of being in zone 2.

      --
      Watch this Heartland Institute video
    5. Re:Subscription Perks by ParnBR · · Score: 1

      Laputa's sequel is scary: Children of Laputa, also known in the Latin media as Los Hijos de Laputa.

      --
      My neighbor's .sig is better than mine.
  3. Great movie. by grumpygrodyguy · · Score: 1

    This, and the Two Towers are the best films I've seen in the last year.

    --
    The government has a defect: it's potentially democratic. Corporations have no defect: they're pure tyrannies. -Chomsky
    1. Re:Great movie. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Screw Lords of the Ring and screw Anime.

    2. Re:Great movie. by Gortbusters.org · · Score: 1

      Why is this a great movie? I took a look at the short plot outline but what are the juicy details that makes it attractive?

      --
      --------
      Free your mind.
    3. Re:Great movie. by grumpygrodyguy · · Score: 4, Interesting

      It's exactly the details that make it wonderful.

      As Kirosawa used to say...

      Q: What's the message of your movie?

      Kirosawa: If I could answer that, I would have printed it on a card and held it up in front of the camera.

      See this movie. It's art, and it's very finely crafted. Truly a masterpiece.

      --
      The government has a defect: it's potentially democratic. Corporations have no defect: they're pure tyrannies. -Chomsky
    4. Re:Great movie. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Funny
      Kirosawa: If I could answer that, I would have printed it on a card and held it up in front of the camera.

      Pretentious fucker. He was asking for an overall summary of a movie and pretends to be Confiscious.

    5. Re:Great movie. by Compuser · · Score: 1

      No juicy details (IMHO). Simple predicatble plot,
      one dimensional characters which are either good
      or bad but not much in between, and somehow I found
      it really hard to care about the characters. They
      are somehow very artificial. I suppose if you can't
      live a day without anime, then this is OK but it
      is IMHO sad that this won best animated picture.

    6. Re:Great movie. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      A very pompous, patronizing, condescending (and somewhat passive-aggressive) answer to what seems an honest and straightforward question.

    7. Re:Great movie. by Z4rd0Z · · Score: 1
      A very pompous, patronizing, condescending (and somewhat passive-aggressive) answer to what seems an honest and straightforward question.

      Since when does a movie, or any piece of art, need to have "A Message"? Fine, if you think his answer has the first three attributes you mentioned, though I don't necessarily agree. But what on earth makes his statement passive aggressive? More likely it's your anonymous post that matches that assessment.

      --
      You had me at "dicks fuck assholes".
    8. Re:Great movie. by Z4rd0Z · · Score: 2, Interesting

      True, it's finely crafted. Nearly everything Miyazaki has ever done is. But I wouldn't put it in the masterpiece category. It certainly isn't his best work IMO. I'd put Laputa: Castle in the Sky or My Neighbor Totoro above it. Of course, you know, IMO, YMMV, and all that.

      --
      You had me at "dicks fuck assholes".
    9. Re:Great movie. by BJH · · Score: 2, Insightful

      "Good or bad but not much in between"? Did we see the same movie? Name one unequivocally bad character.

    10. Re:Great movie. by Cr3d3nd0 · · Score: 1

      Yes but any credit the Acadamy gets for recognizing this was lost when they gave eminem the award for best soundtrack over Chicago

      That gets my vote for the WTF?!?! catagory

      --
      This is not a sig
    11. Re:Great movie. by Compuser · · Score: 1

      Don't remember character names but here goes:
      1. The little girl (main character) is clearly
      overall good, as are here parents (minor
      characters though).
      2. The guy who helps her (river spirit or some
      such) is clearly good, despite a bad spell on
      him.
      Neither of the two main characters deals with any
      substantial moral issues or questions.
      3. The old broad running the bathhouse is clearly
      bad.
      4. The many-armed geezer operating bath machinery
      is your typical rough on the outside good on the
      inside character. Nothing new, nothing to think
      about here.
      5. The youngish lady helping and overseeing the
      girl is good. No wrenching moral dilemmas here either.
      Shall I continue? Name one character (better yet
      describe one character) who is not somehow
      cliche.

    12. Re:Great movie. by wilddur · · Score: 1

      One dimensional characters which are either good or bad

      Compared to:
      - Lord of the rings
      - Disney
      - ...

      We are talking about animation.

    13. Re:Great movie. by Compuser · · Score: 1

      Two words: YURI NORSTEIN.
      Look it up.

    14. Re:Great movie. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Pretentious fucker. He was asking for an overall summary of a movie and pretends to be Confiscious

      Uneducated fucker. He was trying to come up with a snappy comeback and misspelled Kunfooshuss

    15. Re:Great movie. by BJH · · Score: 1

      1. The little girl, who initially abandons her parents, is overall good?
      2. Haku (the river spirit) is clearly good, despite the fact that he assists Yubaba only because of his desire to learn her magic?
      3. The "old broad" (Yubaba) is 'clearly bad' even though she eventually repents of her treatment of Chihiro?
      4. If you don't like thinking, fine.
      5. OK.

      And you wanted another character: The "No-face". He is not inherently bad, but only reflects the desires of those he absorbs.

      Sorry, but it just seems to me that you've been brainwashed by too many years of morally black-and-white Disney movies.

    16. Re:Great movie. by Compuser · · Score: 1

      1. The little girl merely does not eat with her
      parents. She never abandons them.
      2. It seemed to me that Haku was assisting Yubaba
      because she took his name from him. Certainly
      he was released by remembering who he was.
      3. Repents? Did we watch the same movie? She lost
      a wager/was outsmarted and decided to lose
      gracefully. So she is a classy villain, bite me.
      4. Methinks this is just an insult, not an argument.
      5.

      As for Disney movies, I didn't grow up in the USA so
      I was certainly not brainwashed by them. In fact
      I have not watched a complete Disney movie in my
      life because they either put me to sleep or cause
      revulsion. This movie by contrast was just bland,
      not entirely without merit but also nothing to
      write home about. After having this discussion
      I think that my standards are just MUCH higher
      than yours.

    17. Re:Great movie. by BJH · · Score: 1

      In fact I have not watched a complete Disney movie in my life

      I don't think you watched this one either...

      1) She certainly does abandon them - or perhaps you didn't realize that the pigs were her parents? Or maybe you were asleep during the bit where she runs away from them?
      2) Haku was assisting Yubaba *not* because she took her name - he *asked* her to teach him her magic, a condition of which was that she took his name from him.
      3) I really don't see how you can consider her a 'villain', at least in the simplistic balck/white way you propose. After having this discussion I think your view of the world is MUCH simpler than mine.

    18. Re:Great movie. by kcp295 · · Score: 1

      Spirited Away contains a lot of messages. Why you can't get these? I think you need to see/listen/feel more in our world.

  4. Conspiracy Nuts0 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    tip for japan support

  5. interesting fact maybe? by Miguel+de+Icaza · · Score: 4, Funny

    features Chihiro interacting with a monkey called mono. great cartoon :^)

    --
    Before adopting WHATWG, read the moonlight.NET EULA [http://www.microsoft.com/interop/msnovellcollab/moonlight.mspx]
  6. Anime? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Is it still anime if it's from disney?

    1. Re:Anime? by itistoday · · Score: 5, Informative

      It isn't from Disney. Disney just dubbed it into English for the American audiences.

    2. Re:Anime? by Crescens · · Score: 4, Informative

      Disney only distributes/markets Miyazaki/Ghibli's films here in the US.

    3. Re:Anime? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Is it still Disney if it's anime?

    4. Re:Anime? by ll1234 · · Score: 1

      Disney did contribute 10% of the production costs, so there's a bit more to the relationship than just distribution.

      --
      Sig.

    5. Re:Anime? by Cait+Sith · · Score: 2, Informative

      Not true. Disney owns worldwide distribution rights to much of studio Ghibli's work, including Spirited Away(Sen to Chihiro no Kamikakushi). Disney released it in july 2002 undre Buena Vista Home Entertainment

  7. Darn by Qinopio · · Score: 3, Funny

    Does this mean I'll have to start caring about the Oscars?

    --
    __________
    [Big Brick Wall]
    1. Re:Darn by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Nope. Some dumbass movie that wasn't "The Hours" won for best score.

      Wait. You mean there are other categories? Huh. Coulda fooled me.

    2. Re:Darn by nomadic · · Score: 1

      No. Considering how few animated featured films come out in this country, it's kind of silly to have an award for them. First of all, every damn animated movie that comes out is going to be nominated, just to make quota. Hell, they were lucky this year having so many. If they keep the category I can easily see a year where they can only find one nominee. Or even none.

      It's all a cop-out anyway. The oscars are like Hollywood itself--obsessed with self-congratulation. They'd hate to actually have one of their drinking buddies actually lose to someone like Miyazaki.

      As for me, I celebrated oscar night the same way I've celebrated every oscar night of my life; by performing my annual ritual of not watching the oscars.

    3. Re:Darn by machine+of+god · · Score: 1

      slashdot commands it!

  8. Still need to see it... by Huxley_Dunsany · · Score: 1

    Well, I'm glad to see an anime win an Oscar, but I've still not seen "Spirited Away"... Oh well, just as soon as NetFlix get it... :-) Huxley

    1. Re:Still need to see it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh well, just as soon as NetFlix get it.

      What they don't have it yet? Oh ya the American domestic release for this movie is probably mid April. Oh well at least you will not have the "red tint" (seemed more like a lack of other colour components) like the one I imported.

    2. Re:Still need to see it... by offpath3 · · Score: 1

      Dude, I was so pissed about the red tint. I picked up the DVD when I was living in Japan, and I watched it, and it's _totally_ noticable.

  9. Right On! by itistoday · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I showed this movie to my whole family. Great flick and I highly recommend it to anyone who enjoys watching fantasy. The story is very good-hearted and the plot and fantasy aspects are amazing.

    Some would compare it to Harry Potter, but really it's much more... intellectual.

    1. Re:Right On! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Some would compare it to Harry Potter, but really it's much more... intellectual.

      A plastic squeeze-bottle of Cheez Whiz is intellectual compared to Harry Potter.

  10. Theatrical run by Sarauble · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Let's see now if Disney makes good on its promise to re-release Spirited Away to theatres with equal backing as Lilo and Stich was given.

    1. Re:Theatrical run by Peterus7 · · Score: 1
      Maybe they'll get it into their thick skulls to release "Whisper of the heart," another Miazaki anime Disney's been holding hostage...

      Still, the thing that sucks is that Disney IS profiting from this, and frankly I don't trust them to dub animes properly. But on the flip side of the coin, this could be a real boon, as it could really popularize anime. If disney (err... Miramax, really, but...) started bringing anime over all the time, well, I would be a happy puppy.

    2. Re:Theatrical run by aardvarkjoe · · Score: 1

      Why wouldn't you trust them to dub animes properly? I know that it's fun to bash the big corporation, but the Princess Mononoke was nothing short of amazing. I didn't get the chance to see Spirited Away in the theater, but I've heard that the dub is quite good as well.

      --

      How can we continue to believe in a just universe and freedom to eat crackers if we have no ale?
    3. Re:Theatrical run by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Uh, Whisper of the Heart wasn't directed by Miyaziki. It was done by studio Ghibli however.

    4. Re:Theatrical run by Sparks23 · · Score: 5, Informative

      Whisper of the Heart was directed by Yoshifumi Kondou, who was considered by many to be Miyazaki's protege and eventual successor. After Kondou's amazing work on his directorial debut (Whisper), Miyazaki planned to retire and turn over the helm to Kondou.

      Tragically, Kondou died in January 1998 of an aneurysm, never having a chance to direct a second film.

      http://www.nausicaa.net/miyazaki/kondo/

      --
      --Rachel
    5. Re:Theatrical run by DavidBrown · · Score: 1

      I didn't know that and I'm sorry to hear it. Frankly, I think that 'Whispers of the Heart' is better than any of Miyazaki's films other than Nausicaa and Cagliostro's Castle. The scene where the boy is playing the violin and the old men walk in, pick up their instruments, and join along is one of the best scenes in all cinema.

      --
      144l. ph34r my 133t l3g4l 5k1lz!
    6. Re:Theatrical run by Sparks23 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Miyazaki also worked on Whisper, but Kondou was the director. It was fulfilling a promise they made each other when they were much younger to make a film like that; it was a film they'd both wanted to make for a very, very long time.

      Miyazaki's eulogy for his friend is very touching; it can be found linked from the Kondou page on Nausicaa.net...

      --
      --Rachel
    7. Re:Theatrical run by Sparks23 · · Score: 1

      And 'Whisper' is one of my favorite Ghibli films too, yes. Miyazaki and Kondou had not worked together as a duo since they were younger, and it's a shame they didn't do more together.

      --
      --Rachel
    8. Re:Theatrical run by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

      It would be nice if it was given a proper release in the US, but the machinery has already started for having it released on DVD on April 15th. It will be interesting to see if the DVD release gets delayed. Anyway, even though I never got the chance to see the English dub in the theaters, I saw it a few times in the theaters in Japan and I have the Japanese DVD. It is definitely one of those movies that is better appeciated on a big screen.

      James

    9. Re:Theatrical run by sparrow_hawk · · Score: 1

      John Lasseter of Toy Story fame was involved with this rather heavily (he produced it), so I'm hoping against hope the dub will be good and will fill in the Japanese culture holes I missed in the fansub.

    10. Re:Theatrical run by Froobly · · Score: 1

      I remember when that happened. I was a senior in high school and had just showed that movie to my film teacher a few weeks before. Such a sad coincidence that we'd both discovered him so shortly before his passing...

    11. Re:Theatrical run by will_die · · Score: 1

      Will not happen since the DVD release is just a few weeks away.
      The thing to see is if the they play up the release of the DVD any.

    12. Re:Theatrical run by tigertigr · · Score: 1

      The scene where the boy is playing the violin and the old men walk in, pick up their instruments, and join along is one of the best scenes in all cinema.

      I was just watching this film again yesterday and that entire scene, including the part before it where Seiji is working on a violin and Shizuku walks in is so quietly beautiful. It's not a loud film at all, but it's still one of my favourites.
  11. I wonder if the acadamy saw the red version? by SmirkingRevenge · · Score: 1

    As reported here.

    1. Re:I wonder if the acadamy saw the red version? by ll1234 · · Score: 3, Informative

      Nope, the US DVD lack the red tint. The storyboards extra on the second DVD is tinted, but not the main feature.

      --
      Sig.

    2. Re:I wonder if the acadamy saw the red version? by BJH · · Score: 1

      The red tint which the Japanese distributor (Buena Vista) still has not acknowledged to be a problem. Their explanation was that "the coloration was changed in accordance with the director's wishes". I say bullshit - if that's true, then why is the US version not tinted?

    3. Re:I wonder if the acadamy saw the red version? by MtViewGuy · · Score: 1

      I don't think Buena Vista Home Entertainment (BHVE) wants a wrongly-colored version of Spirited Away for the Region 1 DVD release, given that here in the USA most serious videophiles have larger-size CRT-tube TV's or projection TV's, and that reddish tint will stand out like a sore thumb on bigger TV's.

  12. spirited away by minus_273 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    was the BEST movie that i saw in a long time. It had a wonderful story that appealed to adults and children. The cinematography was excellent as well. It too bad americans still make a distinction between animated movies and live action ones.

    --
    The war with islam is a war on the beast
    The war on terror is a war for peace
    1. Re:spirited away by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      It's the only way to level the field for real people . .

    2. Re:spirited away by Fulcrum+of+Evil · · Score: 2, Interesting

      It too bad americans still make a distinction between animated movies and live action ones.

      I wonder how they'll handle Avalon...

      --
      "We returned the General to El Salvador, or maybe Guatemala, it's difficult to tell from 10,000 feet"
    3. Re:spirited away by DaemonGem · · Score: 1

      I cannot agree more. I enjoyed this movie as much as I have enjoyed any of Miyazaki's movies. The thing that I find surprising is that the movie made over 200 million in Japan (An unheard-of sum, I believe that is equivalent to every person in Japan watching the movie three times), and was so fantastically good, and yet it didn't seem to catch on in the US. Unless I am radically mistaken, and it hasn't been released yet? Anyway, go watch this movie, it's absolutely fantastic.
      -Dae

      --
      "Alle reden vom wetter. Wir nicht." - SDS Sozialistischer Deutscher Studentenbund.
      j00 4r3 3n73r1ng l337 w0r1d.
    4. Re:spirited away by BJH · · Score: 1

      ...the movie made over 200 million in Japan (An unheard-of sum, I believe that is equivalent to every person in Japan watching the movie three times...

      Number of people in Japan: 120 million (approx)
      Cost of going to a movie theatre: $US15 (approx)

      $US 200,000,000 / 15 / 120,000,000 = 0.111111...

      0.111111... is equal to 1/9, so one in nine people in Japan went to see it once each.

      How many people did you think Japan has?

    5. Re:spirited away by DaemonGem · · Score: 1

      Obviously I thought there were a lot less than there really are. These numbers do make a lot more sense. Thanks for setting me straight.
      -Dae

      --
      "Alle reden vom wetter. Wir nicht." - SDS Sozialistischer Deutscher Studentenbund.
      j00 4r3 3n73r1ng l337 w0r1d.
    6. Re:spirited away by sugam · · Score: 1

      Hmm....odd how your _average_ cost of attending a movie is $15! That hardly makes sense. The 2 most expensive cities in the US charge about $10 for a movie ticket, most other places charge less. So either there is some place that is not NYC or SF that I've never heard of that charges $50 for tickets and sells lots of them, or your approximation is a huge exaggeration.

      The average cost is probably closer to $6 when you include matinee prices and all those places that are not NYC or SF.

      --
      read my blog
    7. Re:spirited away by BJH · · Score: 1

      Which part of the word "Japan" did you not understand?

    8. Re:spirited away by sugam · · Score: 1

      Which part of the word "Japan" did you not understand?

      Touché

      --
      read my blog
  13. yes! by SpiritC · · Score: 2, Interesting

    this is a very deserved Oscar!
    the movie deserves it, Miyazaki deserves it and anime deserves it.
    this is a good thing for anime
    p.s. and the other movies all sucked compared to this :P

    --
    Smile... tomorrow will be worse.
  14. Even more Oscar News! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    Just minutes after this got posted, the Lord Of The Rings: The Two Towers won the award for Visual Effects, featuring Gollum.

    1. Re:Even more Oscar News! by gmuslera · · Score: 0, Offtopic
      I think LOTR as a whole movie will be the most winning movie in the history. Got 4 Oscars the last year for the first part, in Cinematography, Visual Effects, Make-Up and Original Score, and in this one at this hour is getting a second one in Visual Effects, and another in Sound Editing.

      Don't know how this will end this night, and in the next year, but I think that in the next year it should have some award for the movie as a whole, not for each part, or the Return of the King in particular.

    2. Re:Even more Oscar News! by realdpk · · Score: 1

      And minutes from now I will still not care about the self-serviant awards ceremonies. I'll spare you the updates of everything else I dislike.

  15. Showing trailers for SA at my local theater... by heldlikesound · · Score: 1

    I went to see Adaptation (gotta love Spike Jonze) at my towns cool little indy theater the Cla-Zel, and they ran a preview for the American release of SA. I've already seen the actual movie a while ago at a theater up in Toledo, but it was a good trailer...

    --


    Cloud City Digital: DVD Production at its cheapest/finest
  16. 'Course it did by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Miyazaki is THE best animator ever. Disney had it's best decades ago. "Sen to Chihiro no Kami Kakushi" is the best of breed, without a doubt.

  17. It's so damn good... by Peterus7 · · Score: 5, Interesting
    To see an anime finally get best animated picture!

    But then again, Disney and Dreamworks put forth anything *that* good or *that* original.

    Spirited away had originality and a nice fuzzy feeling with it too, with a sense of wonder too.

    And it's gonna change the way the critics view anime from now on, too. I wonder if maybe they'll do "Best anime film..." Nah...

    1. Re:It's so damn good... by ccnull · · Score: 1

      But then again, Disney and Dreamworks put forth anything *that* good or *that* original.

      I assume you meant "didn't" put forth anything...

      I was just going to say be careful with dissing Disney -- they released Spirited Away in the US (and will put it out on video/DVD on April 15). So you owe them.

    2. Re:It's so damn good... by Peterus7 · · Score: 1
      I respect them for that, yes, I don't respect Disney always doing disneyesque dubbage.

      Yeah, I mean't "didn't"

    3. Re:It's so damn good... by Mononoke · · Score: 2, Informative
      I was just going to say be careful with dissing Disney -- they released Spirited Away in the US...
      Barely. At its maximum it showed on 115 screens. It had no national promotion, and very little promotion in the few markets that got to see it.

      --
      NetInfo connection failed for server 127.0.0.1/local
    4. Re:It's so damn good... by Shadow99_1 · · Score: 1

      I could swear Disney Japan helped distribute the movie in japan as well... So it's kinda like Disney won anyways...

      --
      we are all invisible unless we choose otherwise
    5. Re:It's so damn good... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Anime just ate Disney's lunch.

      Hear that sound? It's the buzzer sounding at the end of the 4th period. Disney lost.... ...by four touchdowns.

      Good night.

    6. Re:It's so damn good... by Tumbleweed · · Score: 1

      They did the same for Kiki's Delivery Service. I'm not sure if they did that for Princess Mononoke or not. If it hadn't been for them, I doubt either would've seen ANY screentime in the U.S. I really like the English language dubbing that was done for all three of those, too. For animation, I'd rather watch the action than watch the subtitles...

    7. Re:It's so damn good... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And it still kicked a $35 billion company's ass.

      Quality matters. Something that Disney has forgotten.

    8. Re:It's so damn good... by lunatik17 · · Score: 5, Informative

      Disney didn't dub Spirited Away, John Lasseter from Pixar was in charge of that.

      --

      Here's my DeCSS mirror, where's yours?

    9. Re:It's so damn good... by jsmthng · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Uhh, what do you mean "finally"? This is only the second year this category has existed at the Oscars.

    10. Re:It's so damn good... by bludstone · · Score: 1

      Except that disney has worldwide distribution rights for almost all of studio ghibli's stuff. They stand to profit greatly from the success of anime.

      --

      no .sig
    11. Re:It's so damn good... by ll1234 · · Score: 1

      Sort of, in the various documentaries that pepper the DVD (coming out on April 15) Lasseter isn't present in any of the dubbing scenes. He was more of a "spiritual guide" than a hands-on "hey, that line sucked" director. Credits and such found here: http://www.nausicaa.net/miyazaki/sen/credits.html

    12. Re:It's so damn good... by Peterus7 · · Score: 1
      That's a relief, I would have a bit more trust in Pixar than disney. But then again, Pixar is working with disney...

      But then again, Squaresoft worked with Disney...

    13. Re:It's so damn good... by lunatik17 · · Score: 1

      He wasn't the director of the english version, he was Executive Producer.

      --

      Here's my DeCSS mirror, where's yours?

  18. What!!! by LinuxMacWin · · Score: 1, Insightful

    The information this post provides is:

    1. Who won the Oscar
    2. Which Category
    3. Which Movie

    There is no related story explaining why this is such a great thing. The post a lsodoes not explain this. Now this is not a case of someone complaining without reading the related story, so can someone please explain what happened???

    1. Re:What!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Slashbots love cartoons - that's what happened here.

    2. Re:What!!! by DavidBrown · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Sorry, I submitted this post, so I guess I'm responsible. It's significant not just because it's recognition of Hayao Miyazaki and his body of work (Nausicaa, Porco Rosso, Cagliostro's Castle, Laputa: Castle in the Sky, Kiki's Delivery Service, etc.), it's also an historic Hollywood recognition of Anime as an art form. This is the first time that any Anime has won an Oscar - and it was up against "Ice Age", a CG wonder, and two Disney films, "Treasure Planet" and "Lilo and Stitch".

      It's also recognition that animated films don't have to be musicals for children in the Disney style.

      --
      144l. ph34r my 133t l3g4l 5k1lz!
    3. Re:What!!! by MrLint · · Score: 1

      well come on.. treasure planet was widely considered to be a flaming pile of dung:)

    4. Re:What!!! by Dominic_Mazzoni · · Score: 1

      This is the first time that any Anime has won an Oscar - and it was up against "Ice Age", a CG wonder, and two Disney films, "Treasure Planet" and "Lilo and Stitch".

      Was I the old one who thought that Ice Age sucked? The plot was really dumb, and the CG didn't break any new ground. Lilo and Stitch was fine, but Spirited Away was much, much better.

      I honestly didn't expect that Hollywood would give it to Spirited Away, but I'm very glad they did.

  19. Gee - Thanks by oz_ko · · Score: 1

    You really need to remember that slashdot is actually read outside the US as well where the Oscars is aired later in the evening.

    1. Re:Gee - Thanks by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, and I heard the lone gunmen died too.

  20. HMmnn by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I havent seen this one yet Guess what i am going to have to do tomorow he he

    but i think End of "evangelion" should have won anyway

    Trueneo42

    1. Re:HMmnn by Masami+Eiri · · Score: 1

      Except End of Eva never got a theatrical release in the US (though one had been rumoured).

  21. A very enjoyable piece... by Zergwyn · · Score: 4, Informative
    I am very pleased that Spirited Away has recieved the recognition it deserved. I was fortunate enough to be able to see it on the big screen, and both the animation and the story were very pleasant. Spirited Away is one of the rare films that I could take a bunch of kids to watch, yet still enjoy the movie myself, because the story can be appreciated on a number of levels.

    Miyazaki has directed an unusually large number of very nice animated pieces, and Studio Ghibli is well known as delivering some of the highest quality films out there, live or animated. I hope that this may do something to bring more mainstream appreciation to animation as an adult story telling medium in the United States.


    As a note, if anyone is interested in seeing a list of other films by Miyazaki and Studio Ghibli, they can look at nausicaa.net.

  22. And for those who haven't seen it.... by MtViewGuy · · Score: 4, Informative

    ...The movie is coming out on Region 1 DVD April 15, 2003. Along with Kiki's Delivery Service and Castle in the Sky.

    1. Re:And for those who haven't seen it.... by lavalyn · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Ooooh!!! Laputa! >drools

      The soundtrack for Laputa, even 16 years later, still touches a nerve. Joe Hisashi is incredibly talented - comparable to Alan Silvestri (of Forrest Gump fame).

      --
      Doing the Right Thing should not be preempted by making a buck.
    2. Re:And for those who haven't seen it.... by Mononoke · · Score: 2, Interesting
      The soundtrack for Laputa, even 16 years later, still touches a nerve. Joe Hisashi is incredibly talented - comparable to Alan Silvestri (of Forrest Gump fame).
      The soundtrack was re-recorded for this new release, under the Hisaishi's direction. It's been redone with better arrangements and recording techniques.

      --
      NetInfo connection failed for server 127.0.0.1/local
  23. It's odd by Pres.+Ronald+Reagan · · Score: 1, Funny

    Why, when I see any white speaking Japanese, watching "anime," wallowing in pseudo-Japanese culture, or wishing he were Japanese, do I immedately think "lives in his parents' basement with a career at the local Blockbuster"?

    --

    Abortion is advocated only by persons who have themselves been born.
    --Ronald Reagan
    1. Re:It's odd by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What is this whole thing about 'living in your parents basement'. Is this a really common occurrence in the USA or what? Why is it such an insult? I don't get it.

    2. Re:It's odd by Mononoke · · Score: 5, Funny
      Why, when I see any white speaking Japanese, watching "anime," wallowing in pseudo-Japanese culture, or wishing he were Japanese, do I immedately think "lives in his parents' basement with a career at the local Blockbuster"?
      Why, when I see any boy speaking l33t, watching Sci-Fi, wallowing in gamer culture, or wishing he were a hacker, do I immedately think "lives in his parents' basement with a career at the local CompUSA"?
      --
      NetInfo connection failed for server 127.0.0.1/local
    3. Re:It's odd by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I the idea is that most girls would be more attracted to someone who appears to be self-sufficient. Living in your parent's basement is seen as something to fall back on if you can't afford to pay full rent, whether that's due to not making enough money, or to spending it all on computers, comics, anime, or whatever (I'm just describing the perception).

      Personally, I'm happy to hear that someone's living in a basement, since it's more efficient.. and I see no reason why I would try to talk the world out of something like that, though I may have different advice for an insecure friend.

      (disclaimer: I don't live in my parent's basement)

    4. Re:It's odd by aardvarkjoe · · Score: 1
      Why, when I see any boy speaking l33t, watching Sci-Fi, wallowing in gamer culture, or wishing he were a hacker, do I immedately think "lives in his parents' basement with a career at the local CompUSA"?

      You say that like there's something wrong with it.

      (Seriously, I rather agree with the grandparent. I enjoy watching some anime, but like everything, there are a few people who carry things entirely too far.)
      --

      How can we continue to believe in a just universe and freedom to eat crackers if we have no ale?
    5. Re:It's odd by Tumbleweed · · Score: 1

      Don't forget, takes Japanese language lessons and martial arts lessons at the local community college.

      Some of them delivery pizza, though, instead of working at the local Blockbuster. Or they'll work at the local Hollywood Video - less chance of censored titles. :)

    6. Re:It's odd by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why, when I see any white speaking Japanese

      Like those who do business in Japan?

      watching "anime,"

      Like the Academy members who voted for the Oscars?

      wallowing in pseudo-Japanese culture

      Like the 10 million Pokemon fans?

      or wishing he were Japanese

      eh?

      do I immedately think "lives in his parents' basement with a career at the local Blockbuster"?

      Because you're an idiot that can't come up with anything better than a tired cliche? (Note: you forgot "doesn't have a girlfriend.")

      Moron.

    7. Re:It's odd by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Probably because you're an idiot. Don't worry though, that's a rather common condition and usually goes away in 60-80 years...

    8. Re:It's odd by Thatmushroom · · Score: 1

      Because both of those stereotypes are true?

      If you think this is meant to be an insult, see my sig.

      --
      You zap the moderators with a wand of humor! The moderators resist!
    9. Re:It's odd by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hello, loser. I'm white and I speak Japanese. Strangely enoguh, it's because I live in Japan, graduated froma aJ Japanese university, and am married to a Japanese woman.

      Now please go fuck yourself, you smug little shit.

    10. Re:It's odd by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why, when I see any white American, do I immediately think "violent monomaniac with too many guns"?

    11. Re:It's odd by Echnin · · Score: 1

      Not this anime fan. Sure, I've got two dictionaries and I've pirated Pimsleur Japanese I-III (about 45 hours of audio tapes) and actually listened to about half of it so far. Sure, I've applied for the student exchange program (which might actually make me a more outgoing person). Sure, I've pirated more anime than I could ever watch. Sure, I watched Spirited Away before it got popular in the US. But I do not live in my parents' basement; I live in the attic.

      --
      Lalala
    12. Re:It's odd by kahei · · Score: 1


      Because you're a crushed, crumpled, used-up-tissue of a creature whose horizons are so low that he cannot concieve of someone learning another language out of interest or because their life is just more varied than yours. Easy.

      What I can't figure out is whether you're the real Reagan or not.

      --
      Whence? Hence. Whither? Thither.
    13. Re:It's odd by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why, when I see any white speaking Japanese, watching "anime," wallowing in pseudo-Japanese culture, or wishing he were Japanese, do I immedately think "lives in his parents' basement with a career at the local Blockbuster"?

      HEY! I live upstairs in my room. Not in the basement!

  24. There was competition? by lavalyn · · Score: 4, Funny

    Spirited Away was fighting against such notable animated features as "Treasure Planet."

    In the field of drawn animation, Japan is a whole other ballgame.

    --
    Doing the Right Thing should not be preempted by making a buck.
    1. Re:There was competition? by evilhayama · · Score: 1

      It would have been nice to have spirited away win in a year with bigger competition, as lilo and stitch was the best other film out there. People will asy now that it only won due to lack of competition. However the western anime community should take their wins where they get them, hopefully it's only the beginning...

    2. Re:There was competition? by Little+Brother · · Score: 1

      Lilo and Stitch was, IMHO, Disney's best picture since Walt died. However, no, there still wasn't much competition, Spirited Away still blew L&S out of the water. Any other year, I would have been completly on the L&S bandwagon, I really wish it had been released a year earlier so both films could have won something.

      --

      Little Brother, watching the watchers

    3. Re:There was competition? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I totally agree with you there considering the fact that there was little/no competition. Granted I thought Lilo and Stitch was a great movie, what really helped was mostly it's script and humor. But if you look at both productions in general, Spirited Away created a new world that was both delightful to the eye, and was far more unique and creative than some genetically manipulated Alien and a Bratty Hawiian girl. :-) Like many others I wish there was more competition, but still very well done.

  25. I don't really care for anime, however by Rooked_One · · Score: 2, Insightful

    but storylines like the ones that Little Ninjai has blow me away. Its a wonderful myraid of anime but for some reason it seems americanized in a way. I know this is a little offtopic but if you look at it in a way I am talking about something similar to the subject and sort of "pimping out Little Ninjai" for those of you who havn't seen it. I'd just like to see more of that "something" that most anime's seem to lack. Don't get me wrong, I loved Tenchi Meauo (I know thats spelled wrong, but just pronounce it)

    1. Re:I don't really care for anime, however by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Geez...is it really that hard to spell "Muyo"? :P

    2. Re:I don't really care for anime, however by Rooked_One · · Score: 1

      well, i guess at least I didn't spell it Mayo. Gimmie some pickles and ketcup with that mayo and spam. :)

  26. Happy by Gyorg_Lavode · · Score: 1

    It's good to see something non-mainstream in the US but still definitively good win.

    --
    I do security
  27. Good news by faust2097 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    This is a Good Thing[tm] but I'd say its victory is mostly due to the extremely unremarkable American animated features this year. When an anime movie wins best foreign language move wake me up.

    p.s. does "Harry Potter" not count for anything because it was a UK production?

    1. Re:Good news by Mononoke · · Score: 5, Informative
      When an anime movie wins best foreign language move wake me up.
      It could happen. Of course, the academy created the Animated Feature Award expressly to keep from 'diluting' their other categories with animation.

      Just FYI, here are some other awards Spirited Away won. Note that many are purely film awards, where Spirited Away beat out non-animated features:

      • Best Film; 2001 Japanese Academy Awards
      • Golden Bear (tied); 2002 Berlin International Film Festival
      • Outstanding Achievement in an Animated Feature Production; 2002 Annie Awards
      • Best Directing in an Animated Feature Production; 2002 Annie Awards
      • Best Writing in an Animated Feature Production; 2002 Annie Awards
      • Best Music in an Animated Feature Production; 2002 Annie Awards
      • Best Animated Feature; 2002 New York Film Critics Circle Awards
      • Special Commendation for Achievement in Animation; 2002 Boston Society of Film Critics Awards
      • Best Animated Feature; 2002 Los Angeles Film Critics Awards
      • Best Animated Feature; 2002 Critics' Choice Awards
      • Best Animated Feature; 2002 New York Film Critics Online Award
      • Best Animated Feature; 2002 Florida Film Critics Circle
      • Best Animated Feature; 2002 National Board of Review
      • Best Original Score in the Category of Comedy or Musical; 78th Annual Glaubber Awards
      • Motion Picture, Animated or Mixed Media; 7th Annual Golden Satellite Awards
      • Audience Award for Best Narrative Feature; 45th San Francisco International Film Festival
      • Special Mention from the Jury; 2002 Sitges Film Festival
      • Best Asian Film; 2002 Hong Kong Film Awards
      • Best Film (tied); Cinekid 2002 International Children's Film Festival
      • Best Animated Feature; Online Film Critic Society
      • Best Animated Feature; Dallas-Forth Worth Critics
      • Best Animated Film; Phoenix Film Critics Society
      • Best Family/Animation Trailer; Fourth Annual Golden Trailer Awards
      • Award Winner, Film; 2003 Christopher Awards
      List courtesy of Nausicaa.net
      --
      NetInfo connection failed for server 127.0.0.1/local
  28. Also LOTR : The Two Towers Best Visual Effects by tbmaddux · · Score: 1
    Jim Rygiel, Joe Letteri, Randall William Cook and Alex Funke.

    Also ironically amusing was the Panasonic DVD recorder commercial that had a voiceover to the effect of something like "watch what you want, when you want."

    --
    Can't you see that everyone is buying station wagons?
  29. Great movie - shame about the marketing by Michael+Snoswell · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I had to drag and con my 4 kids into seeing this film. They'd never heard of it, or seen ads or anything and they really did not want to go, nor did my partner. In the end we went (I used a pointed stick :-) and they all absolutely loved it and went and told all their friends by which time they movie was pulled from all local cinemas. My daughter (10) especially loved the movie, as did my partner. Wonderful stuff!

    --
    pithy comment
    1. Re:Great movie - shame about the marketing by kaworu-sama · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Exactly. I wish these american marketing people would realize there is a real market for widely-appealing anime such as this, and not just to hardcore otaku. If feature-film anime had serious marketing in america, maybe everyone would realize its not just "one of them there japanese cartoons". Maybe miyazaki's next hit movie will have a better reception here.

    2. Re:Great movie - shame about the marketing by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Your use of partner instead of a gender specific term makes you sound gay.

    3. Re:Great movie - shame about the marketing by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      so what?

    4. Re:Great movie - shame about the marketing by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I used a pointed stick

      I feel sorry for your kids having to go to the movies with two dads.

    5. Re:Great movie - shame about the marketing by Cryptnotic · · Score: 3, Funny

      Your use of partner instead of a gender specific term makes you sound gay.

      Just assume it was intentional.

      --
      My other first post is car post.
    6. Re:Great movie - shame about the marketing by Tellalian · · Score: 1

      I'll second that. Unfortunately, Miyazaki is getting on in his years and these films are beginning to become quite a physical burden. Back when Mononoke Hime was released, it was rumored that it would be his last film. I was pleasantly surprised to see that rumor dispelled, at least temporarily, with the release of Spirited Away. Personally, I think much more preasure should be put towards releasing or re-releasing his earlier films.

    7. Re:Great movie - shame about the marketing by Michael+Snoswell · · Score: 1

      Actually I used the word "partner" as she is not my wife (ie we're not married) but we've been living together for some years with kids from my marriage and her's. I'm a little too old to have a "girlfriend"! I just used a term that everyone here understands. If I'd referred to her as my "mate" then out here that means it's a male friend! If it makes you feel more comfortable, think about her as my wife :-)

      --
      pithy comment
  30. Watch out by Raul654 · · Score: 1

    A good punch to the spleen might finish him off

    --


    To make laws that man cannot, and will not obey, serves to bring all law into contempt.
    --E.C. Stanton
  31. Re:what in the fuck is this? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Slashdot is dying. Film at 11. I saw something similar, except mine was -154 seconds, and it also let me post twice within a 2 minute period, so booyah!

  32. gollum by korea · · Score: 1

    heh, All Gollum has received thus-far is a 6 second blurb introduced by George of the Jungle. huzzah

    --

    --

    "pain is weakness leaving the body."
    1. Re:gollum by Z4rd0Z · · Score: 1
      What the fuck is so great about Gollum? He doesn't look remotely real! I preferred the days of yore, when characters of that sort, such as Yoda, were done with sophisticated puppets. Sure, they didn't get all the expressions right and were limited in their movements, but they were real, three-dimensional objects that were not pasted into their environment.

      Speaking of CGI in general, I watched 2001 the other night, and I noticed how amazing the effects are in that movie, with its ancient scale models and optical printing technology, compared to virtually anything done recently with computer generated effects. CGI shit is so obviously fake and lacks the beauty and craftsmanship of models and puppets.

      --
      You had me at "dicks fuck assholes".
    2. Re:gollum by JLyle · · Score: 1
      What the f*** is so great about Gollum? He doesn't look remotely real!
      Hey chief, hate to break it to you, but Gollum is not, in fact, real.
    3. Re:gollum by Z4rd0Z · · Score: 1

      Hahahahahaha..aha, a, uh, uhuh. Where did you learn to be so damn clever?

      --
      You had me at "dicks fuck assholes".
  33. Interestingly, not really his best... by Dimwit · · Score: 5, Informative

    At least, in my opinion. Miyazaki has done many, many films, and Spirited Away was actually one of my least favorite. Don't get me wrong, I still loved it, but anyone who liked Spirited Away really needs to see:

    * Laputa - Castle in the Sky (Possibly the best anime ever)
    * Girl From the Valley of the Wind
    * Princess Mononoke
    * Kiki's Delivery Service
    * Porco Rosso (this one's just weird, but very good)
    * My Neighbor Totoro

    He's done plenty of others, but those are the best, IMHO.

    I'd suggest getting the whole "Studio Ghibli Collection" from Anime on DVD.

    Just my two cents...

    --
    ...but it's being eaten...by some...Linux or something...
    1. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by lavalyn · · Score: 1

      Girl From the Valley of the Wind

      Which may or may not be better known as Nausicaa.

      Which I can't seem to find anywhere in North America, except in the pirate stores in Chinatown.

      Getting my grubby little hands on the really good stuff seems to be an exercise in futility. Almost as if Disney is intentionally blocking access to them.

      --
      Doing the Right Thing should not be preempted by making a buck.
    2. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by jejones · · Score: 1

      So this is the canonical situation where the award goes to someone who's been around for a long time for something not his or her best work? That's never seemed fair to me.

    3. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by KITT_KATT!* · · Score: 1

      Since when has whether it's someone's best work got anything to do with it? After all, Russell Crowe won Best Actor for Gladiator, which was a fun movie with a solid but not terribly challenging performance, and not for A Beautiful Mind, which absolutely blew me away. It's all political.

    4. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      too bad the only way to get most of Miyazaki's work is from bootlegs, like the box set the parent suggested.

      Fortunately, you -can- get a legit, well translated, box set of the Nausica manga, which has an even better, more epic & more in-depth story than the anime. Amazon even carries it.

    5. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by aardvarkjoe · · Score: 1

      Nausicaa has always been rather difficult to find. However, search online for some fansub distributors. That's how I got my copy.

      Nausicaa is not only my favorite anime, it's also one of my favorite movies. Anyone who hasn't seen it ought to get their hands on a copy.

      --

      How can we continue to believe in a just universe and freedom to eat crackers if we have no ale?
    6. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by CrazyLion · · Score: 1

      Nausicaa is expected to come out on Legit R2 DVD by the end of this year. So far all Ghibli R2 DVDs had English subtitles, so as long you have a region free player you'll be all set (if you're willing tospend $50 on a DVD of course).

    7. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by Genom · · Score: 1

      You *might* be able to find a horribly-hackdubbed version under the name "Warriors of the Wind", which I think may have been released before the Disney acquisition of the rights to Ghibl movies. At least, I don't remember seeing the Disney name anywhere on it.

    8. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Almost as if Disney is intentionally blocking access to them.

      Ya think??

    9. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If that were true, Spirited Away wouldn't have even been nominated.

    10. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by KITT_KATT!* · · Score: 1
      The nominations aren't necessarily political but the winners usually are. I didn't really mean that comment in relation to Spirited Away but I think it's certainly true for the big categories like Best Actor and Best Picture. There is no way that Halle Berry and Denzel Washington should have won last year if it were purely based on their performance in those particular films. Russell Crowe turned in the most amazing performance in A Beautiful Mind I've ever seen but he threw some guy against a wall, so they didn't feel like giving him a second Oscar. Denzel should have an Oscar based on his life work but not for that film in particular. And Halle Berry? Puh-lease! She's cute but her performance in Monster's Ball was nothing special. I can't believe Gwyneth Paltrow won the Oscar for Shakespeare in Love either. Oh dear.


      I'm really happy that Spirited Away got a gong and I don't doubt that it deserved to, but I think if there had been _any_ convincing competition from an American film, it would have missed out for sure.

    11. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by Frizzled · · Score: 1

      i couldn't find a link to the collection on animeondvd ... but it pop'd right up on amazon:

      http://s1.amazon.com/exec/varzea/ts/exchange-glanc e/Y02Y3603391Y1284075/qid=1048477782/sr=1-1/002-94 42486-5961600

      (the link doesn't have one of those dumb refer cookies so click at will)
      _f

    12. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Eww. Princess Mononoke is a cheap Japanese Ferngully. Only good for torturing people into boredom.

    13. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by KITT_KATT!* · · Score: 1

      I take it all back - Nicole won Best Actress for The Hours. Woo hoo!

    14. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by Shadwhawk · · Score: 1

      Note that the Ghibli Box Set is not a legitimate release. It is yet another bootleg DVD collection. Ghibli has not released any of their films in any sort of set, and several of the films in the bootleg set have not been released on DVD, period.

    15. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I've never seen it, so I can't say for sure, but from what I've heard even Miyazaki himself says that if people have seen that version they should forget about it, since it absolutely butchers the film. (ie bits of story cut out)

      You'd probably be better off finding a sub on the internet.

    16. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by SQL+Error · · Score: 1

      Laputa? I like Laputa, but I'd rank it after Spirited Away, Kiki and Totoro. I missed the chance to see Nausicaa and Porco Rosso on the big screen in 2000 due to pressures at work, but fortunately I was unemployed when Spirited Away came out ;)

      The best anime film I've seen in the past year was not Spirited Away, though, nor the Cowboy Bebop movie (which rocks, by the way), but Millennium Actress. It's just a wonderful, understated gem of a film. My Collectors Edition box set arrived from Japan today :)

    17. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by superjaded · · Score: 1

      Unfortunately Nausicaa is one of the many titles Disney has decided to sit on for the time being, but hopefully we'll get a release date from them about that..

      Heh, if you're interested in seeing how the plot for Nausicaa flows out without having to resort to pirating -- I'd recommend checking out the manga, written and drawn by Miyazaki himself.

      Four volumes long and possibly one of the most beautiful and breathtaking manga I've ever read.

      I've not seen the movie myself so I can't compare the two, but for those who want some legit domestic Nausicaa-ness, check it out. :)

      Also FYI, from what I remember, the movie only covers about 1-2 vols of the manga, so if you want to see the whole story, you'll definitely have to get it. :)

      While I don't know if you'll get the best deal here or not, I usually get most of my manga from Robert's Anime Corner. Here's a direct link to the manga in question.

    18. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by Z4rd0Z · · Score: 1

      Coincidentally, I just found the boxed set for $95.00 US yesterday. A local video store has the set, and I've rented them in the past and found the quality to be good. So, when I saw them, I bought them. I usually don't buy movies, nor is anime my favorite type of movie, but I love Miyazaki.

      --
      You had me at "dicks fuck assholes".
    19. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This box set (and the one mentioned in the amazon shop link of the parent post) are bootlegs. Generally, the audio/video and subtitle quality of bootlegs is very poor (though you may have been luocky in this regard). Also, you are depriving the artists of their income, as these bootlegs are not licensed in any way.

    20. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by Bob.Kerns · · Score: 1
      Disney blocking access?

      Remember, Disney blocks access to their OWN works. "Last chance to buy XXX for the next 10 years." seems to accompany each release on DVD.

      They don't seem to do it to drive up prices. My ownly theory is that they want to encourage piracy.

    21. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by lavalyn · · Score: 1

      Miyazaki publicly disowned that work.

      It's the only reason Ghibli now puts a big "you will not touch our works beyond sound redubbing, and then only we can give you final approval" clause with all its licensed works.

      --
      Doing the Right Thing should not be preempted by making a buck.
    22. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by pgor · · Score: 1

      Please note that the 6- and 10-disc "Studio Ghibli Collection" and "Archives of Studio Ghibli" are bootlegs--pirated copies, not official releases. (cf. Nausicaa.net 5oct01 entry and Nausicaa.net FAQ) pg

    23. Re:Interestingly, not really his best... by Z4rd0Z · · Score: 1

      No, I'm not depriving the artists of their income, because some of these movies aren't otherwise available. The artist wouldn't have gotten my money if I _hadn't_ bought them either. There's also a good chance I will buy the legit ones as they are released.

      --
      You had me at "dicks fuck assholes".
  34. yawn by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Too bad that crappy and annoying Japanese stereotypical animation has to get this kind of attention.

    Why are the /. janitors so fond of animated pictures of blue-haired people with eyeballs filling 70% of the characters' cranial volumes?

    Ice Age would have been a Good choice. It's Good. It's Funny. It doesn't look like a gazillion other flicks. And, for the geeks here, it's made with computers.

  35. its about time.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Fear that Disney.. you've been beaten by something that you've tried to beat down.

  36. good.. by Bigbambo · · Score: 1

    Maybe now they will release a US version of the dvd. I picked up the japanese version when i was in japan in december, but i would love some english special features. The whole second disk is japanese only with no subtitles

    --
    ***There is no point in asking, you'll get no reply***
    1. Re:good.. by ll1234 · · Score: 1

      Well, yes, in fact Disney is releasing "Spirited Away" on DVD April 15 (along with two other films. Read all about it -- Sig.

  37. Re:what in the fuck is this? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    that's what happens when they use the fucking production server for testing...

  38. Ironic the Disney didn't market this movie at all by Kagato · · Score: 5, Interesting

    So let's get this straight. Spirited Away wins the Oscar, yet Disney didn't market this movie worth sh*t! I'm in a top 15 media market and all the ass clowns at Disney do is put it in a couple art houses.

  39. NICE SPOILER PECKERHEAD by Beatlebum · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    nm

  40. Big sigh... by mjphil · · Score: 1

    I'm glad it won, it was clearly the best film of those nominated.

    But I'm hoping they will dump the animated film category soon. It just guaranties no animated file will ever win Best Picture.

    1. Re:Big sigh... by Anonymous+Struct · · Score: 1

      I think it'll come... just give it time. At least in the meantime these films are getting some press. If nothing else, millions of Oscars viewers (minus those who got up to get pretzels during the best animated picture award) are seeing some clips and getting some exposure. If Spirited Away had to compete with non-animated movies today, it would have very little chance of being recognized at all. That isn't because it's not as good (I happen to think it holds its own against every nomination in either category), but because people just aren't ready to treat the medium seriously yet. Lots of Disney-inflicted stereotypes to undo first.

    2. Re:Big sigh... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      it also guarantees in the meantime that an animated film can get an oscar at all. If it weren't there, animated movies would never win an oscar, if only for the biases of the judges

  41. No friggin way by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What do you mean "it's about time?" You wanted Spirited Away to win the Oscar before the ceremony was held? Fucking moron.

  42. Remarkably enjoyable movie by srowen · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Well deserved -- I'm not an anime fan (and I'm not young) but I loved this movie. It was more surreal and fantastical than I expected and that was a very welcome surprise.

    Maybe I speak for myself, but I found this superior to the previous "most popular anime flick in the mainstream," Princess Mononoke. That movie was also great, but like other anime movies I've seen, the plot was thin, long and wandering, which I think are qualities that turn off most (western) audiences. For some reason I didn't think that Spirited Away suffered from the same problem.

    1. Re:Remarkably enjoyable movie by BJH · · Score: 1

      The "thin, long and wandering" plot was mostly the fault of the translation, I think - the original Japanese version had a much more logical plot progression.

  43. I heard Steve Martin is sharing it on P2P by vandelais · · Score: 1

    download away.

    --
    Game: Player 'Donald J Trump' now has AI skill level 'experimental'.
  44. What a rip-off! by fmaxwell · · Score: 0, Troll

    Spirited Away? That wasn't half as funny as The Simpsons, Futurama, Sealab 2021, or even King of the Hill. Yeesh, what a rip-off!

    1. Re:What a rip-off! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Note to the mods: that's meant to be funny, because Spirited Away won in large part due to its seriousness and artistic quality. It has a few funny moments, but they were hardly the reason it won.

    2. Re:What a rip-off! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Porno usually isn't funny.

    3. Re:What a rip-off! by gl4ss · · Score: 1

      you forgot aqua teen hunger.

      if i could have my say 'tinfins' will win next year! :) sealab kicks ass

      --
      world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
  45. It's his favorite troll by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I guess the dumb fuck finally signed up for an account after he figured out how /. works (this given the 600K+ uid). He's an asshat that starts with this then cuts to how you are gay because you can't follow his obviously Seconal influenced logic (or lack thereof). He's fun to dick with for a while. Move along. There's nothing to see here.

  46. Re:Go UK Wildcats!!! by FunkSoulBrother · · Score: 0, Troll

    BYU is the mormons, jackass. Utah is a state school.

  47. This isn't that Disney movie about the horse? by duckpoopy · · Score: 0

    Is it? I saw that, and was not impressed.

    --
    word.
    1. Re:This isn't that Disney movie about the horse? by doce · · Score: 1

      no... that was Spirit of the Cimerron or some such... and that was Dreamworks, iirc, not Disney. could be wrong on the studio..

      Spirited Away is popularly known by it's Japanese title, Sen to Chihiro.

      --
      woof!
  48. Disney's Plan of Control by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    Disney bought the USA rights to Miyazaki's work, so that they could control it. By under-hyping the USA releases, Disney at least breaks even, while at the same time preventing Miyazaki's work from becoming more popular than theirs.

    If this anime got at least half the marketing of the crappiest Disney release...

    1. Re:Disney's Plan of Control by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Thank you.

      Not going to work for much longer though.

    2. Re:Disney's Plan of Control by Robotech_Master · · Score: 2, Insightful

      No, they bought the world-wide rights to Miyazaki's works so they could make substantial profits on selling it everywhere else in the world where Miyazaki was known and revered, including Japan. The USA, where people still think cartoons are for kids, wasn't the subject of some sort of great cover-up--it just wasn't a priority.

      Maybe now that will change.

      --
      Editor Emeritus and Senior Writer, TeleRead.org
  49. Re:Go UK Wildcats!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    a large % of those in utah are mormons. similarly, a large portion of those at a state school are from the host state. therefore, YOU are the jackass.

  50. Re:ZZT by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    YES! ZZT rocks. Code Red is the best world by far.

    I'd also like to use this space to promote 'Another World'. Sold as 'Out of this World' to the USA, this classic game had an excellant plot, great sound effects and fluid vector animation. Download it today!

  51. Congratulations by May+Kasahara · · Score: 2
    I would like to extend my heartfelt congrats to Hayao Miyazaki, Studio Ghibli, and everyone involved with the English-language adaptation of Spirited Away. Before the Oscars, I read much commentary that predicted that the Best Animated Feature category would be marred by studio politics (as it was last year, when Shrek won). Glad to see that this is not the case this year, and that the best film really did win.

    Now I've gotta cross my fingers for Chicago to win the Best Live-Action Feature Oscar ;) I'm also wondering which film will win (or has won?) Best Animated Short... I hope it's Das Rad (aka Rocks).

    1. Re:Congratulations by May+Kasahara · · Score: 1

      ARRGH! NOOO! Damn ChubbChubbs!!!

  52. Re:GET SOME PRIORITIES by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Actually, this is the least bad war in recent history. Even the Iraqis are only claiming 3 civilian deaths after a war that, measured in the number of munitions dropped, is about ten times the size of the First Gulf War.

  53. Re:Interestingly, not really his best...opinion! by Tumbleweed · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Which of these you prefer most will depend entirely one your taste, I think. One of the great things about Miyazaki is that he has a great range - all his stuff isn't the same like so many others.

    I prefer Kiki's Delivery Service the best, and Spirited Away next, then Princess Mononoke. I haven't yet seen the others, but I've got some of his comics, like Nausicaa and some others.

    It's so great that his work is finally coming out on Region 1 DVDs soon. Yay!

    My favourite line in Kiki:

    "Helloooo, Kitty!"
    - Gigi

  54. Fantastic movie by Anonymous+Struct · · Score: 2

    I'm really glad to see that they won. Spirited Away was an excellent, excellent movie, beautifully drawn and positively enthralling in my opinion. I was certain Lilo & Stitch would take this category simply because it was the headline Disney release this year. Kudos to Miyazaki on an absolutely fantastic piece, and kudos to the academy for recognizing it. Bet Disney wasn't expecting this...

  55. Omedetou Gozaimasu Miyazaki-sensei!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It's about time is right.

    Anime is now officially mainstream. Deal.

  56. Re:Ironic the Disney didn't market this movie at a by doce · · Score: 1

    here in Houston, it was at virtually every theater in town.

    --
    woof!
  57. Certainly, look at Nausicaa.net... by Sparks23 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    ...though bear with slow response, as Nausicaa.net is already pretty well experiencing the Slashdot effect. My traffic-shaping rules are helping the site hold its own, but you may have to tolerate sluggish reply at the moment. :)

    --Rachel (Nausicaa.net sysadmin)

    --
    --Rachel
  58. Re:GET SOME PRIORITIES by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    But over 20 Americans died... because of their own STUPIDITY... HAhahahahahahAhAHAhAHAhaHAAHAH!

    Ha!

  59. dup! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Sorry, a week early.

  60. Re:Please Save our troops! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Let them be treated as men? One of the P.O.W. is a female soldier, you insensitive patriot.

  61. Quite possibly, but... by Sarauble · · Score: 1

    It's also possible that if Spirited Away sees another theatrical release, Disney will delay the DVD release for however long the movie is in theatres, plus a few months. While I personally hope they release the DVD on schedule AND put it on screens out there. anime news network and nausicaa.net will probably have information from disney about this in the next few days.

    1. Re:Quite possibly, but... by Mononoke · · Score: 1
      It's also possible that if Spirited Away sees another theatrical release, Disney will delay the DVD release for however long the movie is in theatres, plus a few months.
      Why? What would Disney have to gain by doing this? They would actually make more money by putting the DVD out while the Oscar afterglow is still there.

      --
      NetInfo connection failed for server 127.0.0.1/local
  62. So You Want to Know When Everything Else Arrives? by ll1234 · · Score: 1

    Check the Video Release list on Nausicaa.net. Everyone complaining about Nausicaa should calm down and realize that the DVD hasn't even been released in Japan. Besides, the manga is everywhere and tells 300% more story. -- This is a sig.

  63. Re:GET SOME PRIORITIES by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Yes, you're absolutely right. We're being so careful not to kill too many sand-monkeys, we've ended up killing some of our own people. This is, indeed, stupid.

    Of course, it's also civilized.

  64. W00t by Izanagi · · Score: 1

    Anime US invasion plan:

    1. get 1st Oscar

    2. Launch TV network

    3. ???

    4. Profit

    --
    SCO (noun.)- A Slimy Corporate Ogre. Often seeks free money.
    1. Re:W00t by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      1. get 1st Oscar

      Done.

      2. Launch TV network

      Done.

      4. Profit

      Anime on home video did $700 million last year.

      Done.

    2. Re:W00t by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      the fact that your even mentioning south park when were talking about Anime tells me that your a loser

      -- war continues "Hey bob! Theres anyother lamma about to get haxored!"

  65. indy theatres by Joe+the+Lesser · · Score: 1

    I was lucky to be able to see this city, which showed in 1 theatre in a city of 1 million people. It's unfortunate that it was so hard to find, but then that's why I suggest that everyone support your local independant theatre if you have one, because they generally show the best movies, not the popular ones.

    --
    "I only speak the truth"
    Karma: null(Mostly affected by an unassigned variable)
  66. FIRST INTERNET USE OF THE WORD "FUCK" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    God Bless you Google for storing these historic moment(s):

    Fuck

  67. My Take on Awards Ceremonies by telstar · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I'm sure this will get modded as off-topic or flamebait, but these awards ceremonies are nothing buy self-congratulatory nonsense. I go to work. I do my job. I don't expect people to watch a TV show about me getting recognized for doing what I'm paid to do. I don't need an emmy, a grammy, an oscar, an MTV award, a Blockbuster award, a golden globe, or a people's choice award to know whether I'm good at what I do or not.

    I apologize for not making reference to this movie that won the award, and mod this as you please ... but for what the industry costs and what the participants earn ... everything that hits the screen aught to be worthy of an award.

    1. Re:My Take on Awards Ceremonies by PhxBlue · · Score: 1

      And if everything that hit the screen was award-worthy, doesn't that imply that it would all get an award of some sort?

      Awards are a subjective process. . . but whatever job you work, they can (if used properly) provide a good morale boost and incentive for people to put more of themselves into their work. For instance, if you were recognized for doing what you're paid to do (in terms of an award like "Employee of the Quarter", which comes with a good chunk of bonus money), would that not inspire you to work a little harder, so you could keep getting the recognition and payola? I imagine it might - and it'll more likely than not inspire everyone who cares about recognition and maybe a little more money to work a little harder as well.

      Granted, it doesn't need to be televised, in your case. But these people work in the field of TV and movies. . . so televising it makes sense. Additionally, awards typically have more impact on people's morale when they are publicized to an audience of the relevant: other employees, in your case.

      Finally. . . it's a bloody party. I'm not sure whether the actors and directors take it as seriously as the sycophants^Wreporters who cover the event, but I'd bet they don't.

      --
      !#@%*)anks for hanging up the phone, dear.
    2. Re:My Take on Awards Ceremonies by lucasw · · Score: 1

      ..these awards ceremonies are nothing buy self-congratulatory nonsense... I don't need an emmy, a grammy, an oscar, an MTV award, a Blockbuster award, a golden globe, or a people's choice award to know whether I'm good at what I do or not.

      That's because you aren't famous, and wouldn't derive any profit from it even if you were. One persons 'Self-congratulatory nonsense' is anothers indispensable night to be seen by millions of people... It's work for them (though it's not exactly digging coal).

    3. Re:My Take on Awards Ceremonies by nathanh · · Score: 2, Insightful
      I don't expect people to watch a TV show about me getting recognized for doing what I'm paid to do. I don't need an emmy, a grammy, an oscar, an MTV award, a Blockbuster award, a golden globe, or a people's choice award to know whether I'm good at what I do or not.

      But software does get moderated. There are software awards. There are software ratings. You can buy magazines that compare software products. There are TV shows that discuss software. I flick through PC magazines (wouldn't bother paying for them!) to read the ratings so I know what software products are the pick of the crop.

      So don't pretend that there aren't awards. There are! It's just the entertainment industry does a far better job of promoting the awards ceremony than other groups do. It's not as if Best Software Product Of The Year doesn't exist; it's just so poorly marketted that not many people hear about it. I think that says more about Hollywood's skill than it says about their ego.

  68. Hmm . . . by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I wish the Oscar commitee would watch "Grave of the Fireflies" someday. Though I suspect they'd be afraid the animated film would win far too many oscars ^_^

  69. for those of us by BigBir3d · · Score: 0

    that don't care...

    anime = cartoon

    this movie was made in japan, did $200+ million there, disney bought the distro right for the US, and made a whopping $5.5 million in the US.

    most likely the only reason disney did that was to win the oscar. the crap they make now couldn't win, and they knew it. so what is a big corporation to do? buy a ringer of course.

    1. Re:for those of us by RyuuzakiTetsuya · · Score: 1

      Actually, the reason why they held back the Theatrical release WAS to make it oscar worthy. And even if it was dubbed, it sure as hell was better than L&S... Which could've spanked both ice age and treasure planet.

      --
      Non impediti ratione cogitationus.
    2. Re:for those of us by BigBir3d · · Score: 1

      My point was it was the only cartoon released this past year worthy of winning an award. Disney wanted that award, having lost it last year, the first year the award was available.

      I firmly believe Disney only does something for 2 reasons: money and notoriety.

    3. Re:for those of us by Photon+Ghoul · · Score: 1

      I firmly believe Disney only does something for 2 reasons: money and notoriety.

      Unlike all the other corporations out there.

    4. Re:for those of us by BigBir3d · · Score: 1

      dmca... riaa...

      some corporations actually try to provide a decent product (yamaha and apple come to mind) too.

  70. release date by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Er, no, not yet. April 15th. Amazon.com - Miyazaki 3-Pack

    1. Re:release date by Inf0phreak · · Score: 1

      Buying anime from amazon is a sure fire way to get poor. I have good experiences with www.animecornerstore.com. They have a HUGE selection and they do international shipping as well

      --
      ________
      Entranced by anime since late summer 2001 and loving it ^_^
  71. Princess better than Spirited? Not to me. by fm6 · · Score: 4, Informative
    Princess Mononoke is the only other Miyazaki film I've seen. I enjoyed it, but it didn't blow me away like Spirited Away. The latter impressed me with its elaborate art, its overall beauty, and it's thorough sense of place. (The last was really striking, for an animated movie. Most live action movies don't do such a good job creating an illusion of place, despite having a fundamental advantage!) PM had these things too, but less so. And it was more preachy, less focused. I mean the title character didn't even have a central role!

    The weird thing about PM is the way Disney tried to "localise" the English version. Fortunately they didn't meddle with the story. But they hired a bunch of Name Actors to do the dubbing. Which was a waste of money, because none of the people they chose has a really distinctive voice!

    Weirdest of all is hiring Neil Gaiman to "adapt" the script. God knows what that means. He didn't even make the obvious change: correcting the translators misnaming of various smoothbore weapons as "rifles".

    1. Re:Princess better than Spirited? Not to me. by aronc · · Score: 5, Informative

      Weirdest of all is hiring Neil Gaiman to "adapt" the script. God knows what that means. He didn't even make the obvious change: correcting the translators misnaming of various smoothbore weapons as "rifles".

      Being a huge fan of both Gaiman and Miyazaki I can shed some light here. Much of the script for the film (and any film really) has to be changed for a dub. Jokes, word-play, historical references, and the like usually have to be either somehow explained (with added exposition) or modified to similar item in the new language. That sort of thing is what Gaiman did. They used him in particular so he could help maintain the mythic feel and tone the movie had.

      So essentially what happened was a few professional translators went through the film and did the literal word-for-word translation of the whole thing. Then they sat down with Gaiman (plus Gaiman did a lot of research on his own) and walked through it all and converted that into an english script that was both comprehensible to an american and stayed true to the original vision. As for calling the muskets/blunderbusses rifles, that was Disney's call. They had final editorial control and for some reason were adamant about calling the things rifles. Gaiman actually mentioned this in particular in his blog as one of the things he was confused by/unsatisfied with, believe it or not. There's more detail to be had if you search in his archives here.

      --

      jello.
      aka aron.
    2. Re:Princess better than Spirited? Not to me. by Rakarra · · Score: 1
      The weird thing about PM is the way Disney tried to "localise" the English version. Fortunately they didn't meddle with the story. But they hired a bunch of Name Actors to do the dubbing. Which was a waste of money, because none of the people they chose has a really distinctive voice!

      Eh? I thought in a way this was the English dub of PM's biggest problems -- some of the voices were TOO distinctive. The casting choices were inept and bizarre (Billy Bob Thornton??). The dub of Spirited Away had much better choices.

    3. Re:Princess better than Spirited? Not to me. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      http://www.neilgaiman.com/exclusive/essay06.asp
      i s the essay at the site with info on Mononoke

    4. Re:Princess better than Spirited? Not to me. by fm6 · · Score: 1
      What? Gaiman is a technical nitpicker? I only knew him as a writer of revisionist fairy tails. (Interesting the first time you read one, but it gets old fast.) Now I have to read some of his SF. Been avoiding it. He's too popular!

      I should have realized that Disney was the culprit in the "rifle" business. Happens all the time. Goes back to the movie with the English title "Battleship Potempkin". I'm told the Russian title translates as "Light Cruiser Potempkin".

      I still suspect Disney of using Gaiman and the others to put an American spin on the movie. You don't need to bring in an "adapter" to handle cultural references. Translators do stuff like that all the time. Terry Gross once did an interesting interview with the guy who did the French subtitles for Good Will Hunting. Turned out he had never heard the expression "How do you like them apples?" before he saw the movie!

    5. Re:Princess better than Spirited? Not to me. by MtViewGuy · · Score: 1

      Fortunately, if you watch the Princess Mononoke Region 1 DVD, you can setup to play back the movie in the original Japanese version with English subtitles. The nice thing is that the subtitles are a literal translation of the original Japanese spoken parts, which actually added to the enjoyment of the movie.

      It should be noted that the Region 1 DVD releases of Spirited Away, Castle in the Sky, and Kiki's Delivery Service will also feature subtitles that are a literal translation of the original Japanese spoken parts, too.

    6. Re:Princess better than Spirited? Not to me. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I reviewed the DVD for the Sci-Fi Channel's web site back when it came out. See here.

      As I noted there, it's particularly interesting to watch Gaiman's dubbed version over the directly translated subtitles. Lets you see just where Gaiman deviated and how. I thought he did a good job of walking a fine line between respecting the original and clarifying a few things for a western audience.

      BTW, I agree almost entirely with the ranking in the parent post, except I'd put Totoro...hmmm...probably right under Laputa.

      John Sullivan
    7. Re:Princess better than Spirited? Not to me. by Noren · · Score: 1
      I still suspect Disney of using Gaiman and the others to put an American spin on the movie.
      This is possible, and I expect he could do this.

      BUT- he was born and raised in England, and lived there most of his life, which makes him a very odd choice '...to put an American spin on the movie.'

      He does currently live in the US, for whatever that's worth.

    8. Re:Princess better than Spirited? Not to me. by hcduvall · · Score: 1

      I definately like Spirited Away better (not to take anything away from PM though). I do think that it had something to do with the need to "localise" may'be.

      Spirited Away is couched pretty heavily in Japanese mythology and the like, but has pretty universal themes. Its less approachable on one level (the world's culture), but more understandable in tone and story.

      Whereas Princess Mononoke had a world that was quickly introduced, and though fairly blunt instrument thematically, the themes reflect something that no other culture on earth relates with. It has the environmental theme that's in a lot Miyazaki's work, and industrial development, it it goes further to include the bomb imagery- I think it was intended to have more gravity and serious intent, and it makes it harder to love.

      Spirited Away was more lyrical, painterly, and for all that, its the more approchable and appreciated one.

    9. Re:Princess better than Spirited? Not to me. by fm6 · · Score: 1
      Spirited Away is couched pretty heavily in Japanese mythology and the like, but has pretty universal themes. Its less approachable on one level (the world's culture), but more understandable in tone and story.
      Very true. All the time I was watching it, I was aware that I was missing a ton of cultural references. But that still left a lot of movie to enjoy. And hey, nothing wrong with a story you have to make several passes at before you can fully appreciate it. More fun that way!
      Spirited Away was more lyrical, painterly, and for all that, its the more approchable and appreciated one.
      Well said.
  72. No, I don't owe Sonny Bono by yerricde · · Score: 2, Funny

    So you owe them.

    Really? With all the lobbying DisneyCo did to get the Bono Act passed?

    --
    Will I retire or break 10K?
  73. Dubbing by Draconix · · Score: 5, Informative

    Miramax hired one of the best writers alive today, Neil Gaiman, to do the American version of Mononoke Hime. He went to Japan, studied the language and culture, met prominent artists there, and did his damn best (and also teamed up with Yoshitaka Amano to make a wonderful companion book to The Sandman) to not only translate it, but make it sound just as good as the original version, and yet still seem as if his script were the original. Unfortunately(?), Disney used some of its own writers to dub Spirited Away, so it's most likely not up to the caliber of Princess Mononoke, but (knock on wood) they couldn't have screwed it up too bad, right?

    --
    By reading this you acknowledge that you have read it.
    1. Re:Dubbing by grmoc · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I enjoyed the dub quite thuroughly, actually, and I've seen it both subbed and dubbed.

      I actually -prefer- the dub for Spirited away, and that is a verry Verry rare thing for me.

    2. Re:Dubbing by evilhayama · · Score: 1

      Neil Gaiman wrote the original script for Mononoke, but it was changed before it actually got to the final version. there's a good writeup of what happened on neilgaiman.com (go figure) on this and other of his film exploits

    3. Re:Dubbing by RockyJSquirel · · Score: 1

      Actually they did better than the Princess Mononoke translation

    4. Re:Dubbing by skwirt · · Score: 1

      HE said afterwards that he would never dub anohter movie, ever agian. Everytime he came up with the perfect sentence for one of Miyazaki's lines, he would have to scrap and rewrite because of the english syllable count not matching the Japanese syllable count.

      One of the pains of English

    5. Re:Dubbing by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      After seeing both language versions of Spirited Away, I can verify that the English language version portrays the film precisely as Miyazaki directed it. Some parts (for example, the acting of the parents at the beginning of the film) I prefer in the English version.

      I wasn't too impressed with either the acting or the over-explicitness that Gaiman's script added to Mononoke. It robbed the film of the sense of intimate realism and relentless pace that is Miyazaki's trademark in many parts.

  74. Re:GET SOME PRIORITIES by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Yes, you're absolutely right. We're being so careful not to kill too many sand-monkeys, we've ended up killing some of our own people. This is, indeed, stupid

    I just love it when a racist fuck like you talks about stupidity.

  75. Michael Moore Nominated Biggest UnAmerican by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Well they almost had to send security to get him off stage but luckily they played the ending music loud enough that he had to leave.

    1. Re:Michael Moore Nominated Biggest UnAmerican by RyuuzakiTetsuya · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      Like the hell they are. The troops, I'm not going to give any shit, but to say that we're there for the Iraqis? Please. If we were, we would've been in iraq in 2001. Not 2 years afterwards. It's not like Saddam got any worse between 2001 and now.

      --
      Non impediti ratione cogitationus.
    2. Re:Michael Moore Nominated Biggest UnAmerican by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Like the hell we aren't. The troops, I'm not going to give any shit, but to say that we're there for the oil? Please. If we were, we would've been in iraq in 2001. Not 2 years afterwards. It's not like oil just suddenly sprung up from the earth into a previously oil-barren country between 2001 and now.

    3. Re:Michael Moore Nominated Biggest UnAmerican by mondoterrifico · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Why does any criticism of this invasion of Iraq garner such strong feelings of hatred?

      I mean you live in a democracy suposedly where people are free to voice there concerns.

      Just seems weird is all.
      I mean who hear, blindly supports anything in other areas of their life to the extent that criticism illicits such strong hatred?

    4. Re:Michael Moore Nominated Biggest UnAmerican by Rakarra · · Score: 1, Interesting
      What an asshole Moore is, and what a shame Bowling for Columbine, that sheer piece of fiction, won. When I heard him trumpeting afterwards that he's so honest in everything he says, I felt like vomiting. He's a habitual liar, and people just put blind faith in him anyway. It's bizarre.

    5. Re:Michael Moore Nominated Biggest UnAmerican by haggar · · Score: 1

      Actually, he was bood off. The music was nowhere as loud as the boos.

      Man, did he make an asshole of himself.

      --
      Sigged!
    6. Re:Michael Moore Nominated Biggest UnAmerican by m1chael · · Score: 1

      because i am right all of the time ;P

      --
      I know you are psychotic, but please make an effort.
    7. Re:Michael Moore Nominated Biggest UnAmerican by TheShadow · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I'm not pissed off that he is against the war. First of all, his comments were inappropriate for the Academy Awards... it's not the time to get up on your soapbox. Second, to say that we live in "Fictious times" while there is a very real war going on is sickening. People are over in Iraq dying and he's ranting from his safe little place on stage in California. All he had to say was "Support our troops, bring them home."

      Finally, what is really interesting is that he is against something whose end result might give the same freedom he just exercised to millions of people who haven't had that freedom in more than 24 years.

      --

      --
      "What do you want me to do? Whack a guy? Off a guy? Whack off a guy? Cause I'm married."
    8. Re:Michael Moore Nominated Biggest UnAmerican by glesga_kiss · · Score: 1
      "Biggest UnAmerican"?

      Excuse me? Since when did blind approval of the government become "the American way"? Free speach exists to critize the government, that's the point you idiot! Do you even know what democracy represents?

      But he did make a fool of himself. I agree with his sentiments, but he could have said something a lot more constructive, without pissing everyone off. Dragging up the election is never going to achieve anything, there were far more relevant things he could have said.

      Calling him "unAmerican" is about as "unAmerican" as you can get, imbecile.

    9. Re:Michael Moore Nominated Biggest UnAmerican by glesga_kiss · · Score: 1
      "Piece of fiction"? He concluded that that the US gun culture is largely to do with the fear-culture in the media, a fact that many of us have been aware of for quite some time. I have a book at home that observed this shift 10 years ago. It's not really a new concept. Take a look at your average evenings TV consumption. Where is the fiction?

      When he compared it to the duct-take and orange-alert propaganda, he could have done it in a much better way though.

    10. Re:Michael Moore Nominated Biggest UnAmerican by Tungbo · · Score: 1

      Ummm. If your first priority is to keep the troops safe and finish the war quickly, there is ONE PERSON who can make it happen with a snap of his finger. But its' NOT Michael Moore. I suggest you go talk to him first.

      If freedom and democarcy are what you value most, let me ask you: did you cheer or jeer when Clinton and Carter tried to make Human Rights a part of US foreign policy.

      For an example of how other interests or sheer expediency overrides human rights and self determination of a people in the current administration, just look at the deal the US tried to make with Turkey to the detriment of the Kurds (AGAIN).

    11. Re:Michael Moore Nominated Biggest UnAmerican by GlassHeart · · Score: 1
      he is against something whose end result might give the same freedom he just exercised to millions of people

      ...perhaps because the ends do not justify the means?

    12. Re:Michael Moore Nominated Biggest UnAmerican by Rakarra · · Score: 1
      Moore does make some good points, perhaps the most important being the culture of fear. I agree with him on that (even if he uses the same tactics at times in the documentary). However, he's a bit lacking in the details, and at times he flat-out lies, makes up statistics, and edits speeches to give them a different focus than the speaker originally had. I recommend this article for some interesting reading.

  76. SA, Disney, Houston, etc. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    True. I watched it both at an AMC and an Edwards. However, it wasn't on many screens (I believe one at each) and didn't stay there long (few weeks). They did a bit better than with Mononoke, but considering how much bigger this film was in Japan, not much better. I mean, they didn't even have a frickin Happy Meal tie-in. I'm pretty sure even Cool World got a Happy Meal tie-in!

  77. La puta? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Ooooh!!! Laputa! >drools

    Why does the name of that picture sound like it would be a good name for a porno movie?

    1. Re:La puta? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not originally intended to be read in Spanish. Good luck, Disney: It's in the art of the film. Have fun explaining this. ;)

    2. Re:La puta? by MsGeek · · Score: 2, Informative

      Actually the title is a reference to a place in Jonathan Swift's Gulliver's Travels, and yes, he really did intend the pun.

      --
      Knowledge is power. Knowledge shared is power multiplied.
    3. Re:La puta? by Chan · · Score: 1

      Even better, how about this new Mazda car? I'm not sure if they're planning on selling it in any Spanish-speaking countries, but Nissan doesn't seem to be picky about their new Moco (means booger in ES)

      --
      (nil)
  78. Haha by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    All your oscars are belong to us! -Japan

    1. Re:Haha by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I really don't know why the crack-smoking mods think this is funny.

      Try this - "All your oil are belong to us! - USA"

      Hahahaaa!

  79. Miyazaki by haggar · · Score: 1

    This should be a recognition for Miyazaki's work, rahter than just for this particular picture. What Miyazaki and Sudio Ghibli have created throughout the years is, I think, animated poetry.

    On a side note: I was very disappointed with the DVD edition of "My neighbor Totoro". Such a long wait for the DVD edition, and then they f* it up. I'll just transfer my VHS movie to SVCD.

    --
    Sigged!
    1. Re:Miyazaki by aronc · · Score: 2, Informative

      I was very disappointed with the DVD edition of "My neighbor Totoro".

      That's because it was a shoddy, quick-job done by Fox so they could get it out the door just under the gun of their distribution rights expiring. You can expect Disney/Buena Vista to release a very nice 2 disc version (just like Spirited Away, Kiki, and Laputa/Castle in the Sky are getting on the 15th) at some point in the future.

      --

      jello.
      aka aron.
    2. Re:Miyazaki by haggar · · Score: 1

      Thanks a lot, Aron! I admit I didn't know that those three DVDs are a Buena Vista production vs Fox.

      I'm preordering Kiki, Laputa and Spirited, probably from Amazon (mostly because I have been a satisfied customer for a long time, I'm not sure they offer the best deal in terms of saving money, even though they offer the "Miyazaki 3-pack").

      --
      Sigged!
  80. Kurosawa not Kirosawa by LinuxXPHybrid · · Score: 1

    > As Kirosawa used to say...

    I suppose you are talking about Kurosawa not Kirosawa. There are a bunch of web sites dedicated to the film director, but here's one (http://www2.tky.3web.ne.jp/~adk/kurosawa/AKpage.h tml)

    By the way, I agree with those praise Spirited Away. It's a fantastic film, not just an animation.

    1. Re:Kurosawa not Kirosawa by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Moron just wanted to post quickly and merged Akira and Kurosawa into one word.

  81. Permission by hackwrench · · Score: 0, Troll

    Sorry, you don't have my permission to make statements that don't accurately reflect your views. And no, that was not funny.

    1. Re:Permission by the+uNF+cola · · Score: 1

      At least I now know where I stand. Figures.

      --

      --
      "I'm not bright. Big words confuse me. But Wanda loves me and that should be enough for you." - Cosmo

  82. Re:Go UK Wildcats!!! by FunkSoulBrother · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    Ah, but the basketball team (especially one as good as Utah) tends to not be representative of the school population. If you will look at the 2002-2003 Utah Utes you will notice that there are only 3 people from Utah, and thus probably little to no Mormons on the basketball team.

    21 Trace Caton G/F 6-4 211 Sr. 3L Alamosa, Colo. Alamosa HS
    13 Richard Chaney G/F 6-4 186 Fr. HS Los Angeles, Calif. Verbum Dei HS
    11 Tim Drisdom G 6-3 203 Fr. HS Artesia, Calif. Calvary Chapel HS
    54 Tim Frost C/F 6-10 236 Jr. TR Klamath Falls, Ore. Portland
    3 John Hille G 6-1 177 Jr. TR Salt Lake City Utah Valley State
    30 Chris Jackson C 6-11 242 Fr. RS Los Alamos, N.M. Los Alamos HS
    2 Marc Jackson G 6-1 177 So. 1L Salt Lake City Olympus HS
    15 Nick Jacobson G/F 6-4 200 Jr. 2L Fargo, N.D. Roseville HS, Minn.
    31 Britton Johnsen F 6-10 210 Sr. 3L Murray, Utah Murray HS
    42 Cameron Koford C 7-0 227 Sr. 2L Plain City, Utah Weber State
    20 Bryant Markson F 6-6 182 Fr. HS Monrovia, Calif. Monrovia HS
    14 David Reichner G 6-2 190 Sr. TR Carlsbad, Calif. Southern Virginia

    Jackass.

  83. Re:Fetish Films.. Yeesh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Hrm, better mod this offtopic. He must be talking about some typical American Hollywood film- at least that would certainly make just as much sense.

  84. Re:Please Save our troops! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    not be placed in inhumanely small cells outside of the view of the world, not given any rights, kept from the sun, their family, with no hope of ever being released.

    Assuming that you are referring to the Afghans at Guantanamo, do you feel stupid?

  85. Re:The other acadamy winners... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I just heard sad news on talk radio - an American Patriot was found dead in Saddam Hussein's Iraq this morning. I'm sure we'll all miss him - even if you didn't agree with his actions you've probably enjoyed one of his freedom campaigns. Truly an American icon.

  86. in other words... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You dorks are watching that shit on tv? Don't you feel dumber after watching award shows?

  87. Michael Moore got booed by PHAEDRU5 · · Score: 2, Informative

    subject line says it all

    --
    668: Neighbour of the Beast
    1. Re:Michael Moore got booed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      you are wrong! It was a mixed reception, dumbass!

    2. Re:Michael Moore got booed by PHAEDRU5 · · Score: 1

      he also got dragged off stage by union goons.

      --
      668: Neighbour of the Beast
    3. Re:Michael Moore got booed by PHAEDRU5 · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      Let me think now. America's most left-wing collection of high-school graduates gets together to stroke its collective dick, and in the middle of all the self-congratulation a dumbass hard-left scumbag gets less than a standing ovation.

      Hmmm. Sounds to me like a win for normal America.

      Thank God!

      --
      668: Neighbour of the Beast
    4. Re:Michael Moore got booed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yet obviously you watched the award ceremony and supported the left-wing collective dick-stroking. Funny how you criticize their politics and then pay their salaries.

      You should realize that you are part of the reason why Hollywood is so liberal. They are progressive and they make a lot of money for that reason. Part of entertainment is fighting the system, which means fighting the mainstream moderate apathy (normal America). And when they do this, they make $$.

      Thank Vishnu!

    5. Re:Michael Moore got booed by spun · · Score: 3, Informative

      It was a positive reception at first. He invited all the other nominees up on stage with him, they all came. He said that they were all up there because as documentarians, they prefered truth over fiction. It was when he started saying that a fictitious president was leading us into a war for fictitious reasons that the crowd started booing. There was still some applause, but a lot of loud booing. The music came up and he was escorted off. Steve Martin made a crack later about the teamsters helping him into the trunk of his limo out back.

      --
      - None can love freedom heartily, but good men; the rest love not freedom, but license. -- John Milton
    6. Re:Michael Moore got booed by NeuroKoan · · Score: 1

      God that man makes me ashamed to be a liberal...

      --

      "However," replied the universe, "The fact has not created in me A sense of obligation."
    7. Re:Michael Moore got booed by Dominic_Mazzoni · · Score: 1

      Of course he got booed. Michael Moore is to liberals as Rush Limbaugh is to conservatives.

      I'm liberal, and I'm critical of the war on Iraq, but I don't want Michael Moore to be my spokesperson. Sometimes I find him funny, but he's so over-the-top that it's impossible to take anything he says seriously.

      There are some genuine reasons to be critical of President Bush and his international policies. As Thomas Jefferson said, "dissent is the highest form of patriotism".

      But Michael Moore, as usual, is just name-calling.

    8. Re:Michael Moore got booed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The only American who has a clue *and* dares to speak his mind.

    9. Re:Michael Moore got booed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The only one? You're American, I take it? Because if you *were* American, then by your definition, you'd not both have a clue and dare to speak your mind. Which means what you said could well be false. But then there *might* be an additional American who has a clue and dares speak his mind. But then that American might be you. But if it were, then you'd not both have a clue and dare to speak your mind. Which means what you said could well be false. But then there *might* be an additional American who has a clue and dares speak his mind. But then that Amerian might be you. But if it were...

      At this point, Slashdot starts melting down internally and letting out the magic smoke...

      BTW, my favorite bit of the evening was the little "oh no!"-like pause let out by the person [can't remember who she was] who read Michael Moore's name. In that instant we all knew it was going to be Moore. :-)

    10. Re:Michael Moore got booed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I meant, of course, "You're not American". Dang, this logic stuff is really tough!

    11. Re:Michael Moore got booed by thinduke · · Score: 1

      Michael Moore received a Cesar (french equivalent for Academy Award) for his documentary. His speech was less aggressive, more like "what you expect from your friend is to tell you when you're wrong" and pleaded for understanding on both parts of the Atlantic.

      He got a standing ovation.

    12. Re:Michael Moore got booed by glesga_kiss · · Score: 1
      Your sig: "Who gets the rebuilding contracts"

      take a look here

    13. Re:Michael Moore got booed by madmancarman · · Score: 1
      Not sure if this is related, but his website is down, displaying only a placeholder page. He uses Debian!

      First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win. -- Gandhi

      --
      First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win. -- Gandhi
    14. Re:Michael Moore got booed by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Moore lacked tact. His opinions on Iraq and Bush are interesting, but were an offtopic troll at the Academy Awards.

    15. Re:Michael Moore got booed by jamesmrankinjr · · Score: 1

      Of course he got booed. Michael Moore is to liberals as Rush Limbaugh is to conservatives.

      Nah, I think he's gone right past Rush into Michael Savage/Pat Buchanan class.

      Peace be with you,
      -jimbo

  88. Re:Please Save our troops! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The question is: Do *you*?
    Quote from that link: "Faziakbar said he did not know how many other Afghans were still held in Guantanamo Bay"

  89. All his movies deserve an Oscar by forgetmenot · · Score: 5, Interesting

    My Japanese wife collects all of Miyazaki's movies. Spirited Away definitely deserved to win. If you enjoyed this one I highly recommend seeing his other movies as well. Interestingly, Spirited Away and Totoro (one of my all-time favourites) are the only ones I've seen either in English or subtitled, and I don't understand Japanese, but it hasn't detracted at all from my enjoyment of these movies. Basically, I just read an English summary of the movie on the Internet and then go enjoy. "Princess Mononoke" is incredible (but gory - not for young children) and you don't have to understand Japanese to enjoy it un-subtitled. "Castle In The Sky" is also great and is so vivid in it's animation you can "see" the words and intentions of the characters.

    Any parents among you should introduce your child to "My Neighbour Totoro". This is by far my most favourite animated film ever and my 3 year-old daughter's as well. The magic in Miyazaki's story telling is just incredible.

    1. Re:All his movies deserve an Oscar by haggar · · Score: 2, Informative

      I agree, "Tonari no Totoro" is a real treat! And it's really OK for the whole family (including a 34-year old engineer). It's one of those movies that really makes you feel good, and you're not ashamed about it. Well, I'm not.

      "Mononoke Hime" is a bit gory, as you say, and yet, there is so much beauty there. Just think of the majestic elegance of the wolf gods, for example. I still have to find a cartoon that would match the glorious, powerful and elegant animation in "Mononoke".

      --
      Sigged!
  90. The competition by mblase · · Score: 4, Informative

    For those who didn't watch: Ice Age, Lilo & Stitch, Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron, and Treasure Planet.

    I can only claim to have seen two of these, but I think I can say that "Lilo & Stitch" was the only worthwhile competition in this category. Still, it should rightly be considered remarkable that a dubbed foreign film won in this category, especially since Disney put almost no effort into promoting this film when it was released.

    And on that note, it looks like Miyazaki's film "Castle in the Sky" will be released in the US on DVD at the same time as "Spirited Away", both of which should get a lot more attention from Disney now than they did last calendar year. Hey, whatever works....

    1. Re:The competition by MtViewGuy · · Score: 1

      Actually, I was slightly surprised that Spirited Away won Best Animated Feature. I had concerns that AMPAS voters would be leery about voting a non-American produced animated feature for this Oscar, which would tilt the votes in favor or Lilo & Stitch (which in my opinion is Disney's best non-Pixar animated feature since The Lion King ).

      But as such, I am very happy Spirited Away did win, and hopefully this will lead to Disney releasing more Studio Ghibli movies in limited theatrical release and/or Region 1 DVD release over the next few years.

    2. Re:The competition by mofolotopo · · Score: 1

      To be honest, I never got why so many people liked Lilo and Stitch. I thought the first thirty minutes were great, but after that it became 100% cookie cutter crap to me. Not trying to be inflammatory, I just thought that it was way overrated.

    3. Re:The competition by Peterus7 · · Score: 1

      Well, Lilo and Stitch was the best thing that came out of America... Even if it was crap (like a lot of recent disney.) Look at the local competition, the weird technoesque treasure planet, ice age, and spirit the wonder horse... uh huh. Not a lot. Spirited away has so much on those it's not funny.

  91. Get all three at once by mblase · · Score: 1

    Amazon.com will be selling a triple pack of those three Ghibli films when they're released all at once, for $63 (instead of $90 separately at your local Suncoast).

  92. And let's not forget... by Ayanami+Rei · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Lilo and Stitch was a damn fine movie too. It had been awhile since Disney released a movie that got that special balance between kid-friendly and more sophisticated adult humor. And it was beautiful (being set in Hawaii helped there). No silly music, (except for THE KING), and a weighty plotline too.

    Spirited Away wasn't up against just any flavor-of-the-year Disney flick. The fact that Disney lost out to an import in the category carries extra weight.

    --
    THIS THING CAN TURN ON A DIME, MACROSSZERO STYLE ALSO FUCK BETA, ~NYORON
    1. Re:And let's not forget... by MtViewGuy · · Score: 1

      Lilo & Stitch was a wonderful movie not only because of the excellent storytelling, but the very effective use of music (especially the two traditional Hawaiian songs) and the beautiful watercolor-painted backgrounds, which really added to the charm of the film. It's Disney's best non-Pixar animated feature since The Lion King in 1994, in my opinion.

    2. Re:And let's not forget... by mink · · Score: 1

      I thought "The Emperors New Groove" was a great film fom them as well.

      --
      Well I've wrestled with reality for thirty five years doctor, and I'm happy to say I finally won out over it.
  93. Re:Interestingly, not really his best...opinion! by DavidBrown · · Score: 1

    Just a note - that's not a line in the original version - it's only in the dub.

    --
    144l. ph34r my 133t l3g4l 5k1lz!
  94. Oops...that was supposed to be 'insightful' by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    posting as AC to not lose the mod points, but I meant to mod the parent as insightful. Selected the wrong one.

    my bad.

  95. It's about time! by Cranx · · Score: 0

    I, for one, am extremely pleased that the crap Disney released was swept aside and that the best movie actually won. My faith in the academy is still not above the highly skeptical mark, but this is news VERY well taken in this household.

    (moderator: If you like Disney's crap, that's fine, come post about how you disagree with me. Don't, however, mark this post as a troll. A troll is not a post you disagree with.)

  96. Re:Ironic the Disney didn't market this movie at a by Robotech_Master · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Supposedly, someone at Disney claimed that they had already set aside a much larger advertising budget similar to that Lilo and Stitch got for a S.A. rerelease if it won the Oscars. Traditionally, films that win the Oscar take on new legs and get wider release after that: for instance, Life is Beautiful. The details are somewhere in the Nausicaa.net archives; I lack the time to dig them up now.

    --
    Editor Emeritus and Senior Writer, TeleRead.org
  97. My four word reaction by inkswamp · · Score: 1

    OMFG!

    --
    --Rick "If it isn't broken, take it apart and find out why."
    1. Re:My four word reaction by Little+Brother · · Score: 1

      Hey, that looks like one word to me, the four word reaction would be O M F G! :) OK, so perhaps I celibrated this one bit to much. I'll know in the morning.

      --

      Little Brother, watching the watchers

  98. Re:Interestingly, not really his best...opinion! by Tumbleweed · · Score: 1

    Really? Wow - I'm surprised they added anything, but I'm glad they did - that was freaking hilarious. I wonder what else they added, and if any of that was from Phil himself?

  99. Re:Please Save our troops! by PHAEDRU5 · · Score: 1

    Forgetting the fact that straightening up Afghanistan is a different task from straightening up Iraq, can I just ask when was the last time the U.S. Government had captives shot in the head, filmed by Al Jezeera, and broadcast the film without warning to families and loved ones?

    --
    668: Neighbour of the Beast
  100. Kangaroo Jack by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What awards did Kangaroo Jack win?? I mean he took the money and isn't giving it back. Did he take an oscar as well???

  101. Impressive win by Dark+Bard · · Score: 2, Insightful

    It's about time." Isn't this the second year of that particular category? The impressive thing isn't that it took so long it's that it happened so fast. To have a japanese film win the second time the animation award was given is quite an accomplishment. At least it didn't end up being a tug of war between Disney and Dreamworks. Adds a lot of legitimacy to the award.

    1. Re:Impressive win by NeuroManson · · Score: 3, Informative

      It's not so much that, but that it's an Oscar for Miyazaki. The guy spent at least 30 years directing anime, which for those of us in the know, extends well beyond just what came out under Disney. Here, to the best of my knowlege, is what he's done:

      Lupin the Third (TV), during the 1970s.

      Lupin the Third (movie) The Castle of Cagliostro (or to the retrogaming crowd, the base footage used in "Cliff Hanger").

      Nausicaa (AKA: Warriors of the Wind), early 1980s.

      Laputa: Late 80s.

      My Neighbor Totoro: Late 80s.

      Kiki's Messenger Service: Late 80s.

      Porco Rosso: Early 90s

      Those are just the ones I know of, before the Disney imports began. This is a man who has literally pushed the envelope in terms of both realism and storytelling in animation, moreso than what has been done by Disney in the last 20 years.

      The fact is, there is a reason why Miyazaki is known as "The Japanese Disney". Because he exceeds the standard that we hold American animation directors to. Considering that Disney bought the rights to his work because Mononoke Hime (that's Princess Mononoke to those who still pronounce anime to rhyme "time") made over $100,000,000 in the Japanese box office.

      So frankly, this is something that applies two ways in Slashdot terms: One, it's anime. Two, it's a direct slap in the face to DISNEY. I rest my case.

      --
      Just because you can mod me down, doesn't mean you're right. Shoes for industry!
    2. Re:Impressive win by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not really. Spirited Away only won because it was an off year for Disney and Dreamworks. Anyone can see that. I mean, Lilo & Stitch? Please.

  102. Winners List by marvy666 · · Score: 4, Informative

    ACTOR IN A LEADING ROLE: Adrien Brody THE PIANIST

    ACTOR IN A SUPPORTING ROLE: Chris Cooper ADAPTATION

    ACTRESS IN A LEADING ROLE: Nicole Kidman THE HOURS

    ACTRESS IN A SUPPORTING ROLE: Catherine Zeta-Jones CHICAGO

    ANIMATED FEATURE FILM: SPIRITED AWAY Hayao Miyazaki

    ART DIRECTION: CHICAGO John Myhre (Art Direction); Gordon Sim (Set Decoration)

    CINEMATOGRAPHY: ROAD TO PERDITION Conrad L. Hall

    COSTUME DESIGN: CHICAGO Colleen Atwood

    DIRECTING: THE PIANIST Roman Polanski

    DOCUMENTARY FEATURE: BOWLING FOR COLUMBINE Michael Moore and Michael Donovan

    DOCUMENTARY SHORT SUBJECT: TWIN TOWERS Bill Guttentag and Robert David Port

    FILM EDITING: CHICAGO Martin Walsh

    FOREIGN LANGUAGE FILM: NOWHERE IN AFRICA Germany Directed by Caroline Link

    MAKEUP: FRIDA John Jackson and Beatrice De Alba

    MUSIC: (SCORE) FRIDA Elliot Goldenthal

    MUSIC: (SONG) 8 MILE 'Lose Yourself'
    Music by Eminem, Jeff Bass and Luis Resto; Lyric by Eminem

    BEST PICTURE: CHICAGO Martin Richards

    SHORT FILM: (ANIMATED) THE CHUBBCHUBBS! Eric Armstrong

    SHORT FILM: (LIVE ACTION) THIS CHARMING MAN (DER ER EN YNDIG MAND)
    Martin Strange-Hansen and Mie Andreasen

    SOUND: CHICAGO Michael Minkler, Dominick Tavella and David Lee

    SOUND EDITING: THE LORD OF THE RINGS - THE TWO TOWERS Ethan Van der Ryn and Michael Hopkins

    VISUAL EFFECTS: THE LORD OF THE RINGS - THE TWO TOWERS Jim Rygiel, Joe Letteri, Randall William Cook and Alex Funke

    WRITING: (ADAPTED SCREENPLAY) THE PIANIST
    Screenplay by Ronald Harwood

    WRITING: (ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY) TALK TO HER
    Written by Pedro Almodóvar

    1. Re:Winners List by Space+Coyote · · Score: 5, Funny

      DOCUMENTARY SHORT SUBJECT
      TWIN TOWERS


      Did anybody else read this and think "since when was that a documentary ... oh right, those towers"?

      --
      ___
      Cogito cogito, ergo cogito sum.
    2. Re:Winners List by NeuroKoan · · Score: 1

      SHORT FILM: (ANIMATED) THE CHUBBCHUBBS! Eric Armstrong

      Ah, yes. The Chubbchubbs. That was perhaps the funniest thing about the Men in Black II feature. If its on the MIB II DVD, it is definitely worth the rental price, just to see The Chubbchubbs!

      --

      "However," replied the universe, "The fact has not created in me A sense of obligation."
    3. Re:Winners List by Noren · · Score: 1
      I was channel surfing, turned to it just as they said '... and the Oscar goes to the Twin Towers!'

      I was torn between happiness the LOTR won whatever category they were announcing, and annoyance at the tackiness of the announcer for getting the name wrong. When the winners started talking about tragedy I realized what was actually going on...

  103. Anyone not on the bandwagon? (poss spoilers) by EvilBuu · · Score: 1

    I don't mean to offend anyone's tastes but I really didn't see the big deal with Spirited Away; nor did the two anime fans I saw it in the theater with (some new but empty place near White Plains...). The voice acting was passable and it was a nice little fantasy setting and all but the pacing seemed horribly off. This was one of the few movies I've seen in recent times where I actually checked my watch hoping there wouldn't be much more to go.

    First of all, the main character seemed to be a whiny little girl for far too long, and seemed fairly well-adapted to being enslaved as a bath wench. The main goal she had was to free her parents, but she doesn't actually embark on doing so until at least 2/3 of the way through the film. The bulk of the movie seemed to be clever and well-directed bits that didn't really relate to each other or the main storyline enough to warrant their length or involvement.

    Admittedly, I'm usually more drawn to the more action-oriented but intelligent anime (Bebop, NGE, etc) or goofy stuff (FLCL, Excel Saga, w00t!), but I dig the brainy bits of Eva too, as well as Lain, Akira, and even Mononoke, although I hated the way that ended. Am I still just too Western? The only people I know that really enjoyed Spirited Away were either the die-hard anime fans that /.ers are warned about, or those that only ever enjoy the really esoteric and sort of isolationist-intellectual-film-nut anime. Anyhow, is there anyone else here that didn't really like it so much?

    Too tired to preview, the die is cast.

    --

    Green-voting, republican-registered, socialist-libertarian.
  104. Re:GET SOME PRIORITIES by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I'm not racist. There are sand-monkeys of all races, creeds, and nationalities. Anybody who thinks it's okay to strap on a semtex vest and get on a public bus, or who thinks blowing up a pizza parlor is a keen idea, or who thinks a truck filled with homemade explosives is a valid form of civil protest, or who thinks rolling a hand grenade into a ten is a fine idea is a fucking sand-monkey. These "people" should be shot on sight, or preferably blasted to atoms with a bomb delivered from air conditioned comfort at extremely high altitude. The sooner we get the sand-monkey gene out of the gene pool, the better for everybody.

    You must have meant by "sand-monkeys" I mean Arabs. You jumped to that conclusion, not I. Who's the racist here?

  105. Not surprised, but... by JFMulder · · Score: 1

    ... damn I hated that movie. I never understood what people thought was so good in this movie. I have watched a lot of anime, some serious, some funny, some violent, some that make you think, and Spirited Away was the worst anime I saw ever. I can't see what people find in this movie. For the people who say this is an mature story, this movie was so cheesy, especially towards the end that it made me want to leave the theater only after 30 minutes. There is no story, only a serie of weird events occuring one after the other. At least, that's what I think. You are free to think differently.

    1. Re:Not surprised, but... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You didn't get it.

      Think "Alice in Wonderland".

      This film was written as a "guide book" for a *real* ten year old girl that is the daughter of a friend of Miyazaki's.

  106. With subtitles, hopefully! by Max+Threshold · · Score: 1

    Did they ever get around to releasing a subbed version of Mononoke Hime? Those stingy bastards.

  107. And the Oscar for the best acceptance speech ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    And the Oscar for the best acceptance speech goes to Michael Moore and Michael Donovan:


    Whoa. On behalf of our producers Kathleen Glynn and Michael Donovan from Canada, I'd like to thank the Academy for this. I have invited my fellow documentary nominees on the stage with us, and we would like to -- they're here in solidarity with me because we like nonfiction. We like nonfiction and we live in fictitious times. We live in the time where we have fictitious election results that elects a fictitious president. We live in a time where we have a man sending us to war for fictitious reasons. Whether it's the fictition of duct tape or fictition of orange alerts we are against this war, Mr. Bush. Shame on you, Mr. Bush, shame on you. And any time you got the Pope and the Dixie Chicks against you, your time is up. Thank you very much.

  108. Oscars are irellevant by Pingsmoth · · Score: 2, Interesting

    While I used to enjoy the Oscars, I think they are quickly losing their relevance. Ever since Titanic won all sorts of awards back in 1997 it's been more or less evident that the Oscars are little more than a popularity contest. If this ceremony were held two months ago, which movie would have walked away with the awards? My Big Fat Greek Wedding. Here we have another underdog, Chicago, which Miramax sent out on limited release to generate lots of positive buzz, and has since carefully expanded the number of locations in which it is playing. Chicago gets fabulous word of mouth and ends up walking away with Best Picture. Fine, so lots of the voters like this movie and musicals are making a comeback. But best costume design? Best editing? The movie may be good, but certainly it doesn't deserve these. Of the hundreds of movies released last year, and of the few dozen which were truly good, does one movie deserve to win these coveted awards just because it's popular right now?

    When movies start picking up several oscars, it's just a sign of that movie's popularity at the moment. The voters get all carried away with one movie and it ends up sweeping the whole show. Ridiculous.

    Ok, perhaps I'm just jaded because of the movies that *didn't* win, like Two Towers for Best Editing or Episode II for Best Costume, Sound, Editing, or something. But I agree, (in order to keep this post on-topic), Spirited Away was definitely the best animated feature of the year. But what about the rest? Treasure Island, anyone?

    --
    http://www.walkingtaco.com
    1. Re:Oscars are irellevant by zhrike · · Score: 1

      When movies start picking up several oscars, it's just a sign of that movie's popularity at the moment. The voters get all carried away with one movie and it ends up sweeping the whole show. Ridiculous.

      It's even more about Harvey Weinstein buying awards. I saw a documentary called The Envelope Please which documented one year of bought and sold Oscars. In hunting for a link to include, I could not find one iota of info on the program.
      How surprising.

    2. Re:Oscars are irellevant by Wraithlyn · · Score: 1

      Inaccurate, rigged, biased, unfair.. all of these words can be used to describe the Oscars. But irrelevant? Definitely not. That's like calling politics irrelevant.

      It's precisely because Oscar recognition is so highly coveted in the industry that they're the target of scandals and lobbying. If they were really irrelevant, nobody would care.

      "When movies start picking up several oscars, it's just a sign of that movie's popularity at the moment. The voters get all carried away with one movie and it ends up sweeping the whole show."

      That's a pretty wild statement... nothing can possibly win more than a single Oscar based on its merits?

      And I don't really think Chicago "swept" the Oscars this year. The only "biggie" it took was Best Picture. It didn't get Best Actor, Actress, Director, or Writing. (3 of those went to The Pianist, and it absolutely deserved them)

      --
      "Mind, as manifested by the capacity to make choices, is to some extent present in every electron." -Freeman Dyson
  109. Miyazaki's Masterpiece (repost from IMDB comments) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "For the people who used to be 10 years old, and the people who are going to be 10 years old." --Hayao Miyazaki

    Miyazaki wrote and directed this film for the 10 year old daughter of a friend, and I can't imagine a more wonderful, inspiring and loving gift has ever been given.

    Spirited Away builds from all of his past work and eclipses them all. Every part of this film has been very carefully constructed with technical brilliance and subtle meaning. Besides the compelling story, characters and setting, Miyazaki has created one of the most inspirational films of all time. This film is an allegorical guide book of the best human qualities and a primer for all artists. Most likely it is composed of many personal battles that Miyazaki has ultimately triumphed over. Watching the film gives an insight to the mind of one of the best living artists in the world.

    My only warning is that because of the allegorical nature of the film, some of the transitions and characters seem out of place. It is only with greater understanding of the messages that are being delivered that the film becomes cohesive. The film can be enjoyed on any level, but with deeper understanding of the themes it has much more impact.

    Miyazaki has created a film that will mesmerize young children and the lessons it provides will source of strength throughout their life. In this way, Spirited Away is Miyazaki's most perfected fable.

  110. A film for all ages by Doomsdaisy · · Score: 1

    I took my 65 year old mother and my 4 year old nephew to see Spirited away, and though some parts were a little scary for my nephew, we all loved this movie. Since then I've loaned my mother several other Studio Ghibli movies so she can show them to her grandchildren when they visit. They're a whole lot better than the 90 minute long commercials that Disney craps out every year.

    --
    These are breasts; this is source code.
    Why do you have a problem with those two things belonging to one person?
  111. No competition by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Umm...

  112. SPIRITED AWAY just won for BEST ANIMATED PICTURE. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Anime nerds vindicated.

    Fifty year old man jammed into Sailor Moon costume: "I am redeemed."

  113. Re:Ironic the Disney didn't market this movie at a by K8Fan · · Score: 1
    I'm in a top 15 media market and all the ass clowns at Disney do is put it in a couple art houses.

    Not true in Chicago! It played at arguably the best theater in town, the McClurg Court - DTS, THX, DLP. The english dub was on the big screen downstairs, while the subtitled Japanese version was in one of the smaller theaters upstairs. It got a fair shake in Chicago at least.

    I saw it and enjoed it greatly, even though I cannot abide most anime (see the topic icon for a perfect example of what I find annoying about the style). "Spirited Away" suffered from poor box office, not on it's own merits, but because most moviegoers have seen other anime, and thought "oh, there's that anime film" and rejected it out of hand.

    P.S. What is the name of the annoying blue-haired character/anime topic icon? Just so I can avoid it. "Bambi eyes" to the max.

    --
    "How perfectly Goddamn delightful it all is, to be sure" Charles Crumb
  114. Nausica by incom · · Score: 1

    Was Myazaki's best.

    --
    True genius is grasping a situation like a peice of fruit, and peircing it just right so that it drains dry.
  115. Best news of all from LaLaLand by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Michael Moore had his worthless fat ass booed off stage.

  116. Re:Interestingly, not really his best...opinion! by steveha · · Score: 1

    Spoilers for Kiki's Delivery Service. You Have Been Warned.

    They made one drastic change: at the end, you hear Gigi's voice (Phil Hartman) saying "Kiki! Kiki!" And I think he even says "Can you hear me?"

    This is a major change because it makes it clear that Kiki is once again able to understand Gigi. That was not at all in the original.

    Why did Kiki ever become unable to understand Gigi? I researched this on the Web after I saw Kiki's Delivery Service for the first time, and what I found in an FAQ file was that Miyazaki added this plot point--it was not in the book he based the movie on. Miyazaki's idea was that Kiki could talk to Gigi because they were very close to each other, and now that they were growing apart (he, in his interest in the lady kitty; she, in her problems fitting in with her new life) they were no longer close enough to talk. She got her confidence back, and could fly again, but she couldn't ever be that close to Gigi again... but she could be that close to the black kitten, so she had a new close friend. Doors close in life, but new ones open too.

    Miyazaki is a god, and I'm not, but this is the one place where I would overrule him if I could. I think his whole spin on the talking Gigi thing is just strange. So I actually kind of like the idea that once she got her confidence back, she could hear Gigi again. But it is a change, and a big one.

    steveha

    --
    lf(1): it's like ls(1) but sorts filenames by extension, tersely
  117. And then they followed him up with Jack Valenti... by Froobly · · Score: 1

    ...just so you know that yes, they really are trying to eliminate free speech.

  118. Did you know? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    In Soviet Russia, the Oscars win YOU!

  119. Get serious, please. by logout · · Score: 3, Interesting

    It's too bad that I cannot find any *serious* comments about Spirited Away even here at Slashdot. It's not a simple animation film for children. Nor is it a fun movie for mature adults either.

    The main point of the movie is how Western civilization *devastated* the Japanese people, especially in the form of capitalism. One funny (and tragic) reality addressed by the director is that Japanese are totally ignorant of the fact that they have lost their Japanese identity adopting capitalism and that the western people enslaved (I hate to use this word) Japanese people under the hierarchical structure of capitalism.

    Notice that this film is overpainted with Japanese cultural artifacts everywhere. However, only Yubaba shows characteristics typical in the Western people. A big nose, flurry dress, and her big room with carpet and bonfire, to name a few. Her room is located on the very *top* of the building, dominating all other Japanese workers.

    Haku symbolizes Japanese people who strived to learn the power from the Western civilization. He wanted to learn the *magic* from Yubaba, but what he actually experienced was that he had to lose his own name in order to do that. How Yubaba enslaved Haku? Haku himself had to *sign a contract* which forced him to *lose* his name.

    So, what happened? The japanese lost their souls. The poor people who lost their identities do not have any virtues in their life other than to get more gold to be rich. The remaining value created from their priceless labor is *stored* as a form of gems in Yubaba's safe.

    Why does Yubaba have a twin sister? It symbolizes director's view that the Western culture became a mutant from its origin. The _good_ western culture is the other twin Yubaba. Notice that Yubaba's sister also lives in a totally western environment. A small cottage, hand-cooked cake, tea, and so on. She, the original tradition of the western culture, is a person with bright rationaility.

    Then what must Japanese do in order to destroy this terrible structure created by the evil Yubaba? Do they have to organize a revolution? Do they have to kill Yubaba?

    Miyazaki Hayao's message is superior to that. Chihiro succeeds in finding and sympathizing with the common values appreciated both by Japanese people and Yubaba's sister. She symbolizes the young, future Japanese generations. From the sympathy and understanding of the *rational* Yubaba's twin sister, she proceeds on to the next stage of mutual understandings. She wakes up Haku, and he realizes his Japanese identity. After Chihiro came back to Yubaba, Yubaba is no longer her boss. She calls her name as "Oba-tsang", not as "Yubaba-sama", which can be translated into "grandmother" and "my boss Yubaba". She peacefully disarms Yubaba with her Japanese identity.

    Overall, "Spirited Away" should be a movie that many Western people will get angry with (or be ashamed with); however, the great point of this movie is that it shows a way to solve this conflict peacefully, especially with the language of *rationality*, a concept which Western people are so accustomed to. It suggests a way that leads to the mutual understandings and the world peace. Here lies the greateness of this movie.

    So, please, take this animation seriously. Although Yubaba's sister totally became friends with Chihiro, Yubaba refused to understand Chihiro to the end of the movie. The reason Yubaba released Chihiro and her parents is only because her contract with Yubaba became void. She is still ignorant of the terrible mistakes she inflicted on the Japanese people. I do not like to see Western people watching this movie continue to repeat this foolish mistake of Yubaba's in real world. Just by trying to remember Yubaba's twin sister, you will be able to sympathize _at least_ with the japanese people.

    1. Re:Get serious, please. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Nice bullshit. Ever heard the phrase "reading too much into it"?

    2. Re:Get serious, please. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Probably, Miyazaki has set up intentionally.
      But you don't have to care.

      1. After WWII, GHQ(Occupation-forces headquarters) censored to media of Japan.
      Although this very thing is permissible, but
      media of Japan were castrated after GHQ went away.
      Then, the material which tells a political theory, a civilization theory, and a cultural theory has decreased.
      2. Anime is an entertainment.and Basically for kids.

      So, you dont have to think deep.
      Almost Japanese don't think so deep either.

      Animators like to plot their deep opinions, that we don't care much.(sigh)
      beside I want beautiful action amime movie...

    3. Re:Get serious, please. by MtViewGuy · · Score: 2, Interesting

      The main point of the movie is how Western civilization *devastated* the Japanese people, especially in the form of capitalism.

      I find it interesting you mentioned that because that means the movie expresses concerns about Japan since the time of the Meiji Restoration starting in 1868? In many ways, the Meiji Restoration was actually good for Japanese society because it prevented Japan from suffering the type of political and military convulsions that ruined China in the modern European colonial era.

    4. Re:Get serious, please. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You should stop smoking that stuff...

    5. Re:Get serious, please. by GQuon · · Score: 2, Interesting

      lost their Japanese identity adopting capitalism and that the western people enslaved Japanese people under the hierarchical structure of capitalism.

      Have you taken a history course where the history of Japan was featured extensively?
      My impression was that most of Japan was dominated by Feudalism.
      I thought the Western things, and modern technology were things that make the Japanese forget their ancient culture.

      Sen to Chihiro no Kamikakushi

      --
      Irene KHAAAAAAN!
    6. Re:Get serious, please. by mumblestheclown · · Score: 5, Insightful
      What a load of psudo-intellectual crappetty-crap-crap crap.

      You are taking a basic, generic thesis--the capitalist west encroaches on some native populace, seduces it, which causes it to lose its soul. Sure, this is a common story that can be applied to many places throughout the world.

      But not here.

      Perhaps more than any other country that I know Japan has done a credible job of managing a harmonious coexistance of traditional culture with an international one. Notions that the west introduced capitalism to japan is bullshit. While arguably democracy (or something close enough to it) didn't come to japan until after the war, Japan developed a parallel capitalist culture along the lines of that of western europe regardless of the dutch, perry, or whoever else you want to point to.

      The japanese have famously "embraced and extended" outside technologies, but have not done it at the expense of their cultural soul as, say, Shanghai or Jakarta is in the process of doing. Japanese culture is alive and well, and we have no particular need to sympathize with the Japanese for the reasons you suggest. The movie might be interpreted as a reminder to japanese to be mindful of the importance of traditional values, but your suggestion that it is an apt allegory for the japanese condition as pitiful victim of the west is absolute and total nonsense.

      (disclaimer: 10 years lived in japan, saw movie in both languages, etc.)

    7. Re:Get serious, please. by Dogun · · Score: 1

      It's an interesting analysis - I can't really fault you there.
      There is certainly that "feel" when you walk out of that movie, that the adventure was about recovering something lost, but I have to agree with previous posters that you might be reading a little too deeply. Then again; you may be completely right. I guess you'd have to ask the director/producer/script-writer, whatever.

    8. Re:Get serious, please. by GlassHeart · · Score: 1
      The main point of the movie is [...]

      There's nothing so annoying as somebody else telling me how to think. Whether or not this is the message that the writer or director intended to convey, each person will leave the theater with a unique insight shaped by the resonance of their life experiences with the story. Each such insight is just as valuable and valid as the writer's or the director's.

      The beauty and freedom of art is that appreciation is left to the beholder. What you're doing is propaganda, so cut it out.

    9. Re:Get serious, please. by logout · · Score: 1

      I'm a South Korean. That's another reason why I have to take somewhat provocative view on this movie. Because of the colonial experience, Koreans usually hate Japanese; they are still reluctant of just saying sorry for their past history unlike Germans. Thus, I am in no position to agree with Miyazaki Hayao urging Japanese to wake up their traditional values. However, his message is so intense to make even a South Korean knod his head. To some extent, we share the same modern history as East Asians who were at the crossroads on how to accept the Western culture and capitalism.

      Yes, you're right that Japanese created a harmonious culture of their own where Japanese traditional culture and the western culture mixes up together. It's awesome. It's also true that capitalism forces Western people to lose their souls exactly the same way as Japanese do in this movie. However, the problem is that Japanese do not *know* that they have created a harmonious culture across the Japanese and the Western. They don't have any identities as shown in this movie. It's very strange. Why don't they know that?

      That's because they were *forced* to adopt Western culture after WWII. Suddenly, American culture became the values that should be pursued by Japanese.

      I would like to emphasize the contrast in this movie that differentiates Yubaba and the rest of the people. Why Miyazaki painted Yubaba as a Western figure? He could have put a Japanese traditional monster in Yubaba's position. Why Yubaba lives on the top floor of the building? The blue color of Yubaba's dress shows a contrast distinct from all other red-colored background throughout the movie. I don't think this implies a harmony between Western and Japanese culture. Miyazaki tries to show a distorted social structure in the movie, with a Western CEO and the japanese laborers.

      Anyway, I do not want to say that this structure must be broken apart. Nor is Miyazaki's intention. In this movie, Chihiro successfully sympathize with Western culture with Yubaba's sister and this is the director's message. However, the only *ignorant* people in this movie who have not ever thought about the problem are Yubaba and Chihiro's parents. Miyazaki wants to achieve another harmony . However, it requires the understanding from both parties. Chihiro wanted to shake her hands with her enemies. One delicate point of this movie is that the other party who accepted her hands was the twin Yubaba, not the real Yubaba. However, Chihiro is a *modern* Japanese girl who originally weared a T-shirt with her pants at the start of the movie.

      Overall, Miyazaki tries to express one important message in this movie. Please, wake up, people. Japanese like Chihiro's parents will be the first (and I am so glad that you noticed that too.) and the western people like Yubaba will be the second. It's simple. You just need to think that there might be some problems even though you western people think you are trying to do a good thing. (I can understand the western pride with modern civilization, but this is one reason of creation of monsters such as imperialism, killing of American native indians, and the WW I & II, eventually.) The simple thought will reveal you what you have to do in the future. Like Chihiro, east Asian people have a clear faith in Western people that we can live in a harmony. However, I am afraid they cannot achive the harmony if Western people do not realize the Yubaba's twin sister sleeping in their minds and traditions. So, please, wake up, you great descendants of the original Yubaba!

    10. Re:Get serious, please. by Froobly · · Score: 1

      Your analysis sounds good on the surface, but there are a few major issues where the metaphor breaks down. First of all, if Yubaba symbolizes the Japanese image of the West, then why does she run a bathhouse? Bathhouses don't exist at all in the West, and although I can't say for sure that there are no westernized bathhouses in Japan, the ones I've been to were not westernized at all.

      And if Yubaba's domain is so westernized, then why does it resemble an old Chinese market, and furthermore, why isn't Daddy's Credit Card any good?

      I'd say that that the social structure of Yubaba's bathhouse is more like that in the late Tokugawa period, everything all sectioned off with clearly defined roles for everyone. Even that's a real stretch, though.

      So where does Kaonashi (No-face) fit into your analysis? If the West has already invaded, then why does another invader cause so much harm?

      Personally, I think Spirited Away is more about finding your courage, and learning to hold on to your principles in an unfair society that wants to take away everything that's dear to you, even your own name. There's nothing distinctly Japanese about this struggle, although I have a feeling that young Japanese people have it much worse than Americans do, socially.

      According to an interview with Miyazaki, the idea for Spirited Away came when some young girls were visiting with him, and reading some girls' manga. He read some of it when they weren't looking, and was horrified at what he saw: stories about sedate girls all waiting for their princes, or consumeristic nonsense. He wanted to do something to show Japan's younger generation what it means to be a human being, and this movie was the result.

      In this light, I think Spirited Away had a much less political goal than you ascribed to it, though an equally lofty one.

    11. Re:Get serious, please. by naasking · · Score: 1

      the western people enslaved (I hate to use this word) Japanese people under the hierarchical structure of capitalism.

      Oh please. Are you at all familiar with Japanese history and culture in previous centuries? The Shoguns ruling over the entire coountry? The priviledged Samurai classes with subordinate warriors and even lower peasants? Japan has lived under a hierarchal system for centuries (perhaps millenia). If anything, capitalism flattens that hierarchy somewhat and provides for mobility within the hierarchy; not something one could say about the previous ruling "governments" of Japan.

  120. Buy the DVD... by Cryptnotic · · Score: 2, Informative

    Buy the R1 DVD. It has a Japanese dialogue track with English subtitles.

    --
    My other first post is car post.
  121. bah by BortQ · · Score: 1
    I'm a fan of anime, and I gotta say that I really wasn't that blown away by Spirited Away. It was OK, but not best of class good.

    On the other hand, I totally loved Princess Mononoke. I saw Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind a little while ago and it did blow me away.

    --

    A Multiplayer Strategy Game for Mac OS X, Windows, and Linux
    1. Re:bah by m1chael · · Score: 1

      the other options were from disney though, so there wasnt any competition was there?

      anime is usually more creative than western alternatives in general. thats my feeling.

      --
      I know you are psychotic, but please make an effort.
  122. cinematography??? by Cryptnotic · · Score: 2, Informative

    Uh... cinematography is usually setting up lighting on a set and choosing cameras and lenses and film and how to use those tools to render a scene with actors onto a photographic negative. In an animated film like Spirited Away, none of that needs to be done. The "camera angles" are chosen by the director when they do the storyboards. Individual frames are drawn by hand and scanned and sometimes composited with CG or edited on a computer. The ultimate output is made to print film that gets run through a projector at your theater. So there is film involved... but only at the final step.

    --
    My other first post is car post.
    1. Re:cinematography??? by Yokaze · · Score: 1

      > cinematography is usually setting up lighting on a set and choosing cameras and lenses and film and how to use those tools to render a scene with actors onto a photographic negative.

      You are missing the parts of digitising the film, and editing on a computer and compositing with CG, too. Some even skipping the photographic negative. Well, unless they are Dogme 95 films.

      I'd say, the key difference is not "film" or "not-film", it is the spontanity of the actors, as it is recorded in real-time.
      Although the directors sometime are trying to confine this element.

      Lastly, cinema is about "moving pictures", not necessarily about lighting, cameras, actors and celluloid.

      --
      "Between strong and weak, between rich and poor [...], it is freedom which oppresses and the law which sets free"
  123. Haven't seen it by tenjah · · Score: 0

    But, I was at the *cough* Tokyo International Anime Festival on Friday

    Just thought I'd rub it in for all you anime whacko^freaks

  124. Re:GET SOME PRIORITIES by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    First of all, we should kill all those fucking niggers.

    BTW, by "niggers" I meant "racist assholes who discriminate against ethnic groups of which they have no understanding".

    In other words, YOU, fucker.

  125. Re:Ironic the Disney didn't market this movie at a by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    > P.S. What is the name of the annoying
    > blue-haired character/anime topic icon? Just
    > so I can avoid it. "Bambi eyes" to the max.

    Sasami from the anime Tenchi Muyo.

  126. the moral by soundofthemoon · · Score: 2, Funny

    I found it quite simple to sum up the moral of this story: Any evil can be conquered with love, courage and good manners.

    The good manners are the most important part.

  127. Waiting in Line by Oriumpor · · Score: 1

    I hardly wait in line for movies, I hate queues, print queues, british queues, pool cues, all queues are bad. I waited in line to see this movie, and to see Princess Mononoke, if I had been old enough to appreicate Warriors of the Wind (aka Kaze no tani no Naushika (1984)) and we had been enlightened enough to play it in an american theatre, I'm sure I would have waited in line for this movie as well.

  128. YES! by UrGeek · · Score: 2, Interesting

    This film has so much charm and grace. I can only hope now, just maybe, a subtitled version will be show in Austin.

    It has been a long time since I saw a subtitled anime on the big screen.

  129. Marxist Miyazaki... by Cacophanus · · Score: 3, Interesting

    It is important to mention that, whilst Ghibli accepted the award, nobody came to the ceremony to collect their Oscar.

    Miyazaki is a well documented Marxist (look at Mirai Shounen Conan and the book it is based upon, The Incredible Tide, for proof), so I doubt he would attend an awards ceremony at a heart of American capitalism. Not to mention that he is hugely anti-war anyway.

    Whilst he very much deserves the award, there are other more poltical agendas at work here.

    --
    Cacophanus
    http://cacophanus.net/
    1. Re:Marxist Miyazaki... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Miyazaki was not planning to come anyway because he had been busy making his next movie. The Producer of SA, Suzuki, was going to come on behalf, but they decided to cancel his trip to the U.S. at the last minute for safety reasons. At least, this is what they officially announced.

    2. Re:Marxist Miyazaki... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Didn't Miyazaki say Spirited Away was going to be his last movie?

  130. Shock and awe by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What is all this in aid of, again?

    http://arizona.indymedia.org/news/2003/03/8596_c om ment.php#8778

    Oh yeah, this:

    http://cryptome.org/iraq-booty.htm

    God bless America.

  131. Re:Fetish Films.. Yeesh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Poor little bowie. The "creator" of the Propaganda desktop wallpaper website.

    Do you work for Microsoft? I figure that you might be doing that by trying to make Linux unusable on the desktop with your ugly wallpapers. More like toilet papers.

    I'm trying to figure out if it is swirls of vomit or swirls of excrement. Do you make them by hanging your rear over the edge of the roof, and aim for the paper on the ground? And then use photoshop to make 20 color variations of it so you can fill up your website?

    PROPAGANDA Desktop Enhancement Graphics

    Shouldn't that be:

    PROPAGANDA Desktop Excrement Graphics?

  132. Note about subtitles. by MtViewGuy · · Score: 1

    The subtitles on the Region 1 release of Spirited Away, Castle in the Sky, and Kiki's Delivery Service will be like the Princess Mononoke R1 release--a near-literal translation of the original Japanese voice track. Which I found very good because I actually enjoyed Princess Mononoke in subtitled form better. :-)

  133. Why you should see Spirited Away.... by Psyienna · · Score: 1
    ...for the high-quality animation. Some anime series have interesting-looking characters, but backgrounds that look like they were created with a blob of paint smeared on a cel. All of the Miyazaki films I've seen feature exquisite artwork, from character design to sweeping panoramas to tiny detailing in action sequences that are barely noticed when you see them in Miyazaki's work, but are glaringly absent in anime without all the detail.

    ...for the chance to experience what it's like to look at the world through a child's eyes. A short plot outline isn't going to express the moments of sheer wonderment and exhilaration that this film inspires. After seeing this movie, I felt young .

    ...finally, to be able to realize the sad shape American animation and the big industries who market anime are in. Pixar is the lone exception- Disney, Toonami, and all the networks showing Saturday morning cartoons are so constricted by the notion that "Animation is for children" that they will NEVER be able to produce something as original as Spirited Away, or even have the nerve to show many beloved series in their original form. Thank the gods that the Japanese are willing to take chances, because I doubt American studios would have the backbone to produce films like Jin-roh, Spirited Away, or End of Evangelion.

    Anyhow, kudos to the Academy members who voted for Spirited Away! The award was well-deserved.

    --
    "Tabemono, tabemono, arimasu ka? Nai desu ka? Arimasu ka?" - Ed
  134. He is not Marxist by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    He is not a Marxist.
    Thats true he is a anti-war person.

    He doesn't like "American policy == Japanese one".

    Right wing Capitarism & US flattery diplomacy and safety.(kind of realistic choice)
    Left wing Capitarism & Original diplomacy and safety.(kind of dreamers John lenon said)

    Although he always think of this matter,
    but he couldn't get answer yet.
    His artworks try to stop war or disaster,
    but it always happens.
    in the end, charactors save something but he suggests will be repeated again.

  135. Re:Ironic the Disney didn't market this movie at a by Droog · · Score: 1

    Same here is Atlanta. Usually the local theaters on the north side don't pick up too many foreign films, but they had Spirited Away.

  136. It's about time by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Wow! And they were able to accomplish all that without tentacles juking young school girl clad virgin types. Impressive!

  137. Typical of the Academy by Wessoman · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I know I will probably get flamed for this, but let's be honest. "Spirited Away" is not Miyazaki's best. In fact, I'm sorry, story, animation, soundtrack, characters, and simply EVERYTHING was simply not up to par considering his older works, like Nausicaa and Laputa. Look, I think it's great that Miyazaki finally got the recognition he deserves. But that is just it-- I honestly think that Miyazaki is only being awarded because of his body of work, and largely because he has been ignored by the Hollywood mafia for two decades already. Furthermore, Spirited Away was up against some extremely weak competition. I mean, "Ice Age", "Treasure Planet"? I've seen more riveting animation in crapcan 70's Hanna Barbera saturday morning cartoons. Reality check: I'm sorry, but if Spirited Away went up against "Shrek", it would have been toast. That said, I'm glad that Anime has it's foot in the door now. I guess Disney can stop making these horrible musical cartoons now, and Hollywood will start taking more Anime directors, like Oshii, far more seriously. But the sad reality is, this reeked of the typical Academy behavior of awarding a person based on a body of work rather than a truly great film.

    1. Re:Typical of the Academy by haggar · · Score: 1

      I don't see why you would get flamed. It's a much less controversial issue than, for example, Iraq.

      Back to "Spirited"; while I would agree that there have been better Miyazaki movies, still, I think it's better than "Shrek".
      Then again, I also think that "Monsters" was better than "Shrek" and in some ways better than some of Miyazaki movies, too ("Porco" being somewhat of a low point in his career). So you see, it's all in the eye of the beholder.

      Damn all this Miyazaki talk, I'm going to pop "Totoro" in the VCR, I really got an appetite for a good flick :o)

      --
      Sigged!
  138. Re:Ironic the Disney didn't market this movie at a by Geezle2 · · Score: 1
    "Bambi eyes" to the max. I know! Isn't she so cute?

    Her name is Masaki Sasami Jurai, or just Sasami, from the Tenchi Muyo series, OVAs and movies. There were also OVAs and a TV serial released in which her character was named Pretty Sammy.

    You can avoid Sasami here and here for starters.

    I have been thinking about avoiding these myself.

  139. More winners by GQuon · · Score: 1

    BEST CHARACTER MAKEOVER: THE LORD OF THE RINGS - THE TWO TOWERS "Faramir" by Frances Walsh, Philippa Boyens,
    Stephen Sinclair and Peter Jackson

    LONGEST POLE: COWBOYNEAL

    MOST URGENT BUSINESS ASSISTANCE: THE BRAD CHRISTENSEN GALLERY Brad Christensen

    ANGRIEST DOCUMENTARY DIRECTOR: JUD SÜß! Veit Harlan

    MOST CAPS: URGENT ASSISTANCE mARYAM aBACHA

    --
    Irene KHAAAAAAN!
  140. Re:Neil Gaiman (Offtopic) by Roxton · · Score: 1

    My favorite comedic book of all time has to be Neil Gaiman and Terry Prachett's joint work Good Omens. Terry's longwindedness gets a little tiresome at times, but it's definitely a great book if you want to get an immediate appreciation of Gaiman. Make it your first title. :)

  141. Re:Ironic the Disney didn't market this movie at a by Kagato · · Score: 1

    I disagree totally. The target audience for this film is kids. Kid's don't care if it's in Anime style. Just look at moring and afternoon kids programming on TV. It's dubbed japanese imports. All Disney had to do was give the movie the same treatment as any of their other films. That say "Hey new Disney Film out, Ebert and Reoper give it two thumbs up, now hand the mouse the cash and no one gets hurt."

    That didn't happen. You had a fairly limited release. Not thousands of screens like most Disney films, but hundreds of screens. Some cities were targeted and got more. Most cities got little to nothing.

  142. DTS ES by forgoil · · Score: 1

    Where is the DTS ES track on the american release? Quick answer... nowhere! They even have the nerver to include a 1.33:1 version, but no proper sound.

    Real nice, I can choose from bad sound or overly red tinted picture (Japanese R2 release).

    Really makes you feel sad, considering what an incredible movie it is.

  143. Crap. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    "Moments ago, Hayao Miyazaki won the Best Animated Picture award for 'Spirited Away.' It's about time."

    It's about time? That a completely undeserving movie was honored by the Academy? I got news for you, buddy, it happens all the time.

  144. Beautiful and textured film by simul · · Score: 1

    Pretty and vapid, like a dream. Just don't try to read too much into those random synaptic firings, lest they haunt you.

  145. An example: by hcduvall · · Score: 1

    The best example I recall about the translating vs interpreting that Gaiman did is a scene where Ashitaka and the monk/cleric is having soup. The monk complains about it and the literal japanese is "this soup tastes like watery', which Gaiman changed to "This soup tastes like donkey piss" or something like that, and that carries the weight of the insult better. The pt being, you could have had the dub version say that the soup was watery, but it would've sounded like the soup was just weak. The line in japanese apparently implies something about class and wealth as well-- its not that you made watery soup, its that you can't afford to add anything to your water.

  146. Re:GET SOME PRIORITIES by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You just heard me, bitch. I don't discriminate against ethnic groups. I discriminate against terrorist groups. Terrorists are sand-monkeys, and I'm starting to think you are too. Fuck you.

    And don't ever use the "n-word" in my presence again.

  147. Hope for Disney by Efreet · · Score: 1

    SO, they're *finally* going to release Laputa? Thank goodness, I don't know how many years Miyazaki fans have been wating for this to happen. Now, if only they'd release Nausicaa (no, that abomination, "Warriors of the Wind," doesn't count).

    --
    This sig wasn't worth reading, was it.
  148. I totally thought the Horse Movie would win by Stroman+Rebar · · Score: 1
    I really, there is a noble, non-speaking horse, and a noble, speaking Native American (definitely not an Indian) all on a quest for Freedom (with a capital F) from the Man (with a capital Whitey).

    It really spoke to my 1/16 Choctau heritage, all that nobleness and freedom and crap.

    /sarcasm off

    Lets face it. "Spirited Away" was just in a whole nother catergory then the rest of the drivel. I think it could have been included for Best Picture, had the acadamy not been so obsesed with dancing girls this year. Not that dancing girls are such a bad thing :) Viva la Frankoswski!

  149. A correction... by Psyienna · · Score: 1

    Forgot to add that the Simpsons and South Park are two of the best American cartoons on TV today.

    --
    "Tabemono, tabemono, arimasu ka? Nai desu ka? Arimasu ka?" - Ed
  150. Take That, Eisner... by E-Rock-23 · · Score: 1

    Finally. A quality film wins Best Animated. Kudos to Miyazaki and the whole crew at Studio Ghilbi for producing yet another masterwork, and finally getting the recognition they deserve here in the States. And for once, my hat's off to the Academy for finally recognizing Anime of any kind in a major catagory. All non-believers bow before the greatness that is Japanese Animated Film.

    --
    Blog Prophyts - Right On, Man
  151. Joke, not troll. by fmaxwell · · Score: 1

    Jesus, some of the people that get moderator status on here are so stupid that it's amazing that they can operate the big red button to turn on their computer.

  152. Adrien Brody was legendary by Wraithlyn · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I got a laugh out of Moore.. guy is kind of tactless but very brave I think.

    But Brody.. wow. A summary for those who missed it:

    Brody gets up on stage, looking completely floored. He says he didn't write a speech because whenever he did for any award in the past, he didn't win. He goes on for a while, flustered as hell, then he mentions they're already flashing the "Time's up" at him, but he's just getting started on his thank yous, to his parents, to the filmmakers, etc.

    Now he's WAY over max time, and they cut into his speech with the ceremony music, you know, the "OK, we're done being polite and subtle, get OFF THE STAGE NOW" music, and this is where things got REALLY interesting. He looks up and says, "Just a second. Just one more second" The music continues, uncaring. But Brody's determined, he knows he can do no wrong in this particular instant of time and space. "I mean it. Turn that stuff OFF!" he says.. and the music actually STOPS. I was cheering. Lopsided grin, "I've just got one shot at this."

    Then, in a very emotional voice on the edge of breaking, he talks about how making The Pianist made him aware of the horrors of war, and how, whatever you believe in, God or Allah or anyone, he hopes for everyone to get home safe, and for a quick end to the conflict.

    He got a deafening, standing ovation, and for the next 10 minutes or so, the Oscars were... different. The power of his words had tremendously affected everyone. It was evident that Dustin Hoffman, who was presenting a clip of The Pianist for Best Picture immediately after Brody, was having some trouble continuing his speech.

    Bravo Brody. Guy deserved a second Oscar on the spot.

    --
    "Mind, as manifested by the capacity to make choices, is to some extent present in every electron." -Freeman Dyson
    1. Re:Adrien Brody was legendary by jamesmrankinjr · · Score: 1

      I got a laugh out of Moore.. guy is kind of tactless but very brave I think.

      Brave? Brave?

      Making a speech that will get you a lot attention and pander to your target audience (anti-American Europeans, anti-American Americans, people who hate white men), in a country in which the right to free speech is garunteed?

      Unless you want to redefine the word brave to mean "wanting to make a quick buck," or unless your idea of brave is to make "documentaries" consisting of invented facts and speeches edited to deliberately change the meaning of what was really said, you may want to rethink that.

      Peace be with you,
      -jimbo

    2. Re:Adrien Brody was legendary by Wraithlyn · · Score: 1

      Man, take it easy, I haven't even SEEN "Bowling for Columbine", this isn't about the validity of Moore's views at all. (I did mention I got a laugh out of it, after all)

      But I think it's kind of brave to stand up in front of an audience that loves you for winning, and throw that away in a heartbeat; make them hate you by sticking to your guns.

      The question is, IF you shared his viewpoint, would you have found it easy to stand up at the Oscars (not to mention the diminished yet still massive worldwide television audience) and get yourself booed off stage? I sure as hell wouldn't.

      --
      "Mind, as manifested by the capacity to make choices, is to some extent present in every electron." -Freeman Dyson
    3. Re:Adrien Brody was legendary by jamesmrankinjr · · Score: 1

      If I thought it would sell more of my books and movies, sure.

      Peace be with you,
      -jimbo

    4. Re:Adrien Brody was legendary by spun · · Score: 1

      Bwahaha! Micheal Moore isn't about selling more books and movies. He's about speaking his mind, and screw what everyone else thinks. I'm sure he's had plenty of offers to sell out and compromise his ideals, but he hasn't. You really think being a left-wing documentarian in today's America is going to make you rich?

      --
      - None can love freedom heartily, but good men; the rest love not freedom, but license. -- John Milton
    5. Re:Adrien Brody was legendary by jamesmrankinjr · · Score: 1

      Stupid White Men. 49 consecutive weeks on the NYT best seller list (many at number one).

      Yes, Michael Moore is getting rich of the left the same way Rush Limbaugh has been getting rich off the right for a while now.

      Peace be with you,
      -jimbo

    6. Re:Adrien Brody was legendary by Wraithlyn · · Score: 1

      Right.. it's absolutely impossible any of his success is due to being thought provoking. I'm sure that "Best Documentary of All Time" award he was awarded from a worldwide filmmaker's poll (3 years ago when nobody had heard of him) is entirely because of how far left he is, and has nothing to do with merit.

      You sound pretty biased, not to mention downright hostile towards this guy. And what's with your racial "Stupid White Men" comment?

      --
      "Mind, as manifested by the capacity to make choices, is to some extent present in every electron." -Freeman Dyson
    7. Re:Adrien Brody was legendary by jamesmrankinjr · · Score: 1

      And what's with your racial "Stupid White Men" comment?

      Uh, Wraithlyn, that's the name of Moore's book (check the link in previous post).

      I'm not saying he isn't talented. I'm just saying that he makes a very good living making provocative comments, and I don't see anything brave in that. Unless you consider Howard Stern, Rush Limbaugh, etc. to be brave, too.

      Peace be with you,
      -jimbo

      ps More on Moore's Best Documentary of All Time here

    8. Re:Adrien Brody was legendary by Wraithlyn · · Score: 1

      LOL... yeah, just read that in an article and rushed back here to apologize, which I do. You capitalized it, so I could've at least googled it, sorry. In my defense though, you didn't put it in quotes, and the link, which I did try to check, required registration, which I prompty ignored. :) You gotta admit, just taken as a three word sentance, that looked insulting! :) Anyway, sorry again for the insinuation.

      Anyway! (Watch me try to turn this around, heh) This aptly illistrates my complete and total ignorance of this guy and demonstrates my objectivity towards him and his work. :)

      I don't know what you think you know about the guy's motivations (I don't see how you could possibly truly know.)

      But from where I stood, he just looked like a guy with something to say. Yes, controversy is popular. That doesn't automatically make every controversial issue a popularity contest, though. He attacked a more popular position, and one Americans are pretty sensitive to right now (hell, who isn't?) in public, full force. I still think that takes a certain type of bravery. I can't think of another celebrity who would want that on their reputation. Celebrities for the most part seem to wallsit a lot on important issues. That's what I loved about that show Politically Incorrect, you got to hear what some of them really thought.

      --
      "Mind, as manifested by the capacity to make choices, is to some extent present in every electron." -Freeman Dyson
  153. Miyazaki didn't agree with you. by Eric+Lai · · Score: 1

    Here's one interview with Miyazaki where he describes "Spirited Away" much more innocently than all this rot.

    http://www.nausicaa.net/miyazaki/interviews/sen. ht ml

    Here's another:

    http://www.midnighteye.com/interviews/hayao_miya za ki.shtml

    Like much of Miyazaki's work, it deals with innocence and nostalgia.

    I can't remember where, but I remember once reading an interview with Miyazaki where he said that people like to read too much into his movies...

  154. Darn, you just sold me a DVD by fm6 · · Score: 1

    I love that sort of thing. There's a station in San Francisco that shows a lot of Asian movies and shows. Sometimes they have English subs, a lot of which are obviously done by somebody who only knows the language from studying it in secondary school. I actually like these translations better than the more professional jobs. How else are you going to discover cultural tidbits, such as the fact that Japanese refer to all big American cars as "Cadillacs" regardless of make?

  155. Anime is not an "art form" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Anime is not an art form. "Anime" is just the English word for a Japanese animation. The art form here is animation; anime is at most a particular style within this art form.

  156. FORMERLY Marxist Miyazaki by Froobly · · Score: 1

    Miyazaki hasn't been a Marxist since the '80s. Maybe even earlier.

  157. Wow. You bought the line. . . by Fantastic+Lad · · Score: 1
    to say that we live in "Fictious times" while there is a very real war going on is sickening. People are over in Iraq dying. . .

    I'm fairly certain that Moore is aware that there is a war being fought. The fiction he was referring to was the endless stream of lies which Bush and his gang of criminals used to plunge the U.S. into war. This is what Moore is upset over. This does not make him anti-American. This makes him anti-psychotic/evil politician.

    [. . .] what is really interesting is that he is against something whose end result might give the same freedom he just exercised to millions of people who haven't had that freedom in more than 24 years.

    You need to do some more reading, my friend. I know it's a VERY challenging task to see through the bullshit when you're within U.S. borders, where thought is so tightly controled, but trust me, you really don't have a clue how bad it is until you leave the U.S. umbrella of cultural manipulation.

    It's a tribute to the skill of U.S. propaganda engineers that so many people in the audience booed Moore. I've been looking for a way to measure just how many people had really been duped. I didn't realize it was so many!


    -Fantastic Lad

  158. Miyazaki is not anime. by Fantastic+Lad · · Score: 1
    Sorry. I've long held the opinion that Miyazaki is successful exactly because he doesn't make Anime. His work is NOTHING like any of the endlessly identical, candy-coated stuff which proliferates the medium.

    My definition of Anime. . .

    Small but efficiently used budgets, lots of visual tricks in order to keep expensive animation to a minimum, endlessly re-used and inbred design work which nonetheless remains stylistic & eye-catching, young-minded scripting, a penchant for attaching sex appeal to children, and an obsession with highschools.

    It seems evident to me that many Japanese animators are lugging around a LOT of bagage acquired during their educational years, and live in a culture which does not allow the intellectual freedom needed to deal with these issues, and so it leaks out in other ways. This, of course, isn't the only force driving Anime. After all, there is a good deal of entertaining story telling going on, but those deep issues certainly stand out again and again. There is an endless dream-fever feeling in much anime where this stuff is fighting to be sorted out, driven largely, I suspect, by the subconscious.

    For me, that describes about 95% of all the anime I've seen. Miyazaki and a few others fall into the remaining 5%, where the creators are operating with much more dexterity from their conscious selves. Miyazaki knows what he's doing and why he's doing it. He's not another kid still dealing with highschool trauma, sex and self-confidence issues.

    Spirited Away, if you read Miyazaki's comments on his film, was partly an attempt to show a young girl in a light which is not tainted by the commercialism, sexualism, and other weird obsessions the Japanese experience within the pressure cooker of their society. Miyazaki wanted to show a girl who, through her own human wits and skills as a person, was able to find her way to personal strength and growth. As he put it. . .

    ". . . Chihiro's being strong enough not to be eaten up is just what makes her a heroine. She is a heroine not because she is beautiful or because she possesses a unique mind. This is the key characteristic of this work, and therefore it is a good story for 10-year-old girls."

    Spirited Away also worked on numerous other levels; a film like this can quietly prepare people for the kinds of forces in the spirit world which continue to become more and more prevailant as we progress through these end of times and towards the beginning of the new. There were a lot of messages in this film which spoke directly to the subconscious.


    -Fantastic Lad

  159. Re:Fetish Films.. Yeesh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    There's something seriously wrong with your mommy and daddy because the coathanger method is supposed to be foolproof..

  160. Treasure Planet Nausea by fm6 · · Score: 1
    Hey, no fair! Every category has a Soulless Corporate Zombie entry!

    In a sense, you're right, though. Spirited Away is one of the best movies I've ever seen in any category. Not something you can compete with. I haven't seen Chicago yet, but I think it might not have won if Spirited Away weren't in the Kiddie Movie ghetto.

  161. Re:Fetish Films.. Yeesh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Actually, I've thought of submitting bowie's name for the pro-choice poster child.

  162. The point is that... by ruyon · · Score: 1

    logout is explaining what the movie is talking about, wheter it is right or not.