Slashdot Mirror


Competing to Work for Microsoft

theodp writes "Addressing 5,000 developers in Bangalore, Bill Gates announced the Code4Bill contest, a nationwide talent hunt which will begin in January and last eight months. Twenty finalists will receive internships with Microsoft India before one Superhero is selected to join Mr. Gates's own team."

359 comments

  1. Familiar by Knightmare · · Score: 4, Funny

    I saw this movie once...

    1. Re:Familiar by iluvcapra · · Score: 4, Funny

      An awed hush falls over the crowd assembled, and then Mr. Gates speaks:

      "Is it imperative that we crush this rebellion before the start rainy season! And a shiny new donkey to whomever brings me the head of Eric Schmidt!"

      --
      Don't blame me, I voted for Baltar.
    2. Re:Familiar by TubeSteak · · Score: 4, Funny

      Gates stands in the back control area of his ship's bridge
      with a motley group of men and creatures. Admiral Allen and
      two controllers stand at the front of the bridge and watch the
      group with scorn.


      ALLEN: Bounty hunters. We don't need that scum.

      FIRST CONTROLLER: Yes, sir.

      ALLEN: Those Rebels won't escape us.

      A second controller interrupts.

      SECOND CONTROLLER: Sir, we have a priority signal from the Star
      Destroyer Avenger.

      ALLEN: Right.

      The group standing before Gates is a bizarre array of
      galactic fortune hunters: There is Bossk, a slimy, tentacled
      monster with two huge, bloodshot eyes in a soft baggy face;
      Zuckuss and Dengar, two battle-scarred, mangy human types;
      IG-88, a battered, tarnished chrome war droid; and Boba Fett,
      a man in a weapon-covered armored space suit.


      GATES: ...there will be a substantial reward for the one who finds
      Page and Brin. You are free to use any methods necessary, but
      I want them alive. No disintegrations.

      BOBA FETT: As you wish.

      At that moment, Admiral Allen approaches Gates in a rush of
      excitement.


      ALLEN: Lord Gates! My lord, we have them.

      http://www.google.com/corporate/execs.html
      Dr. Eric Schmidt; Chairman of the Executive Committee and CEO
      Larry Page; Co-Founder & President, Products
      Sergey Brin; Co-Founder & President, Technology

      --
      [Fuck Beta]
      o0t!
    3. Re:Familiar by Basehart · · Score: 3, Funny

      Admiral Gates is in his quarters struggling to put on his space tights and calls Captain Balmer over for assistance:

      ADMIRAL GATES: We need to do something about these damn space tights!

      CAPTAIN BALMER: But what about Longhorn?

      ADMIRAL GATES: That's the problem!

    4. Re:Familiar by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You forgot the point at which Gates' right hand man promptly flings a chair towards the window, conveniently breaking a window, resulting in a vacuum.

    5. Re:Familiar by Tesen · · Score: 1

      Code for Bill huh? Okay lets see, millions of programmers in India begin competing, submitting excellent code samples, neat tricks etc. Who then owns that code? The original programmer? Or are the terms and conditions: "Once your code is submitted, Microsoft can do with it what it wants! WE OWN YOUR SOUL!!! GIVE ME!!! GIVE ME!!!"

      Tes

    6. Re:Familiar by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Balmer is a formula to do with hydrogen atom wavelengths.
      Ballmer is the CEO of Microsoft.
      Get it right!

    7. Re:Familiar by po8 · · Score: 1

      C.f. Acts of the Apostles. Chapter 4 is probably a good place to start for this particular topic.

    8. Re:Familiar by Glonoinha · · Score: 1

      Yea but 95% of it is going to consist of bubble sorts, massive pyramid if/then/else if/then/else if/then/else blocks, and other crap code that will be copied verbatim from the first page that comes up in Google. I would buy lunch for random strangers off the street for a week if someone over there would start teaching the concepts of iteration, code reuse via parameterization, and the switch statement.

      --
      Glonoinha the MebiByte Slayer
    9. Re:Familiar by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      To the fucking Americans who believe Indian is depending on US companies!!

      Do you know that US companies are looking upto India not only for outsourcing jobs but also for MARKETING their products. Do you know that Bill Gates is doing everything because he's afraid of Indians going after LINUX and other open source products. Bill G just wants to get some attentions, because here people are looking upto the next version of UNIX, Linux, CentOS etc.than Windows. Do you know that India has more Unix administrators than anywhere else. Do you know that India has more resources for IT than anywhere else.

      Take my quote, "The country which has more human resources can only survive in the end".

      You just wait for another 10 years and look into the table of top 10 IT or overall companies in the world, you will see atleast 2 Indian companies for sure.

      Soon the world will recongnize that Indians are getting jobs not just because they are getting paid less. The payment will increase from time to time and one day the salary of an Indian will be equalivalent of an American. Still the companies will have to look upto the Indians because they need people who have knowledge and dedication.

      How many of you were/are sincere to your job?? You are paying off for not doing the job dedicatedly.

      And to the fucking Americans and British, who harrases Indians in their country, do not forget that there are lots of Americans and British here and we are mentally stronger than YOU so that we could do anything.

  2. Inquiring Minds Want to Know ... by richg74 · · Score: 5, Funny
    Twenty finalists will receive internships with Microsoft India before one Superhero is selected to join Mr. Gates's own team.

    That's interesting. What are they going to do to the second one that's voted off the team?

    1. Re:Inquiring Minds Want to Know ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      they'll throw a chair at him.

      duh.

    2. Re:Inquiring Minds Want to Know ... by Dracophile · · Score: 5, Funny

      First prize: A weekend away with Bill Gates. Second prize: The whole week.

      --
      Athy, athier, athiest.
    3. Re:Inquiring Minds Want to Know ... by middlemen · · Score: 3, Funny

      They will send him to work on Solaris.

    4. Re:Inquiring Minds Want to Know ... by SilverspurG · · Score: 2, Informative

      Are you saying this is a pimp scheme?

      --
      fast as fast can be. you'll never catch me.
    5. Re:Inquiring Minds Want to Know ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The runner up get's to join Mr. Ballmer's [chair throwing] team.

    6. Re:Inquiring Minds Want to Know ... by Baricom · · Score: 2, Funny

      He becomes a posterior support specialist assigned to Steve Ballmer.

    7. Re:Inquiring Minds Want to Know ... by RedneckJack · · Score: 2, Funny

      With former IU Basketball Coach Bobby Knight as their chair throwing coach.

      The runner up get's to join Mr. Ballmer's [chair throwing] team.

    8. Re:Inquiring Minds Want to Know ... by jhines · · Score: 1

      Play catch with the guy who throws chairs?

    9. Re:Inquiring Minds Want to Know ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'm guessing he becomes Ballmers sexual plaything... The poor poor bastard.

  3. Phase 2? by pancake_lover · · Score: 1

    So I guess this is phase 2 of Bill's previously mentioned program?

    http://politics.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=05/04/ 27/2232244&tid=103&tid=219&tid=218

    Phase 3. Profit?

    --
    Homer no function beer well without.
    1. Re:Phase 2? by XnavxeMiyyep · · Score: 0

      Nope. Phase 3 would be ???. Phase 4 would be profit.

      --
      I put the 't' in electrical engineering.
  4. Somehow... by E+IS+mC(Square) · · Score: 5, Funny

    this reminds me of Mr. Trump. Just dont know how!

    1. Re:Somehow... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Can't wait for CODE4BILL 2: MARTHA STEWART.

  5. You're Fired by NickisGod.com · · Score: 1

    And when can we expect this reality show to come on?

  6. hmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Thats easy to win, just buy the code from someone else.

    1. Re:hmm by Stormwatch · · Score: 1

      Or just copy GPL'ed code without telling anyone...

    2. Re:hmm by JonJ · · Score: 2, Funny

      Nope, that's a part of "code4sony". Get yer facts straight :)

      --
      -- Linux user #369862
  7. Why? by JonTurner · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I don't get it. If you're the best out of 5000 coders, why would you want to work for any company, let alone Microsoft? Seriously. If you're that good, go out there and start your own company and in ten years people will compete to work with you. You'll get to make all the decisions, do everything "the right way", etc. All of the risk, all of the reward.

    1. Re:Why? by jmcmunn · · Score: 4, Insightful


      Because not every great coder is a great business man. In this day, you have to have some very smart (financially and fiscally) people on your side as well. Besides, after winning this thing you could go do your internship and then quit a year later. The "fame" from the contest will likely provide some sort of venture capital which would hopefully make it easier to start the business anyway.

      Plus, think of all the chicks you'd get...

    2. Re:Why? by ari_j · · Score: 5, Funny

      Think of all the chicks you'd get...

      That didn't take long at all.

    3. Re:Why? by MagicDude · · Score: 1

      If you are the best programmer in the world, it's still no good if you can't convince anyone of that. It does help you to have experience and prior completed projects that you can use when you try and land contracts from other companies when you go solo. To put it another way, starting you own company by yourself gets you a couple of computers in your mom's basement trying to get someone to take a chance on you. Being part of Bill Gates' inner circle and then leaving to start your own company gets you an article on CNN and the New York Times.

    4. Re:Why? by TubeSteak · · Score: 1

      I want to work for Bill Gates because he wanted to get his Porsche 959 out of Customs so badly that he had a law written & passed.

      http://www.canepa.com/SportsLuxury/Showroom/959Art icleAutoweek.asp

      That speaks volumes about both his passion and his power.

      Sure anyone could start their own company, but why spend 10 years getting your ass kicked when you can get an express ride straight to the top? You can convert 5 years working with him into pretty much anything you like, including your own company with people begging to work for you.

      --
      [Fuck Beta]
      o0t!
    5. Re:Why? by kyabey · · Score: 0

      S/w Programming Skills is not the same as Management skills. Making decisions esp for a company require _some_ business acumen (Not advocating an Mba) and there are a number of programmers good at programming but suck at managing project.. get an average manager and a good programmer and voila you have a great company..

    6. Re:Why? by hazah · · Score: 1

      I feel you man..

    7. Re:Why? by AuMatar · · Score: 2, Interesting

      BEcause not everyone wants to go into business. I'd personally rather go back to flipping burgers- the hours are better, the pay is at least regular, and the stress is lower. Starting a buisness is a low probability gamble with long lasting and extremely negative side effects on your life and health. No thanks.

      --
      I still have more fans than freaks. WTF is wrong with you people?
    8. Re:Why? by ucblockhead · · Score: 1

      Because talent isn't enough to start a company. You also need capital.

      --
      The cake is a pie
    9. Re:Why? by penguinoid · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Most coders aren't good businessmen: they don't like the nuances of business and are likely too introverted to be any good. However, working at a big company that decides you are one of the best programmers in [demography] probably means you can earn piles of cash doing what you love. Some coders might just do it for the fame, and to put on their resume.

      --
      Don't waste your vote! Vote for whoever you want, unless you live in a swing state it won't matter anyways
    10. Re:Why? by AsparagusChallenge · · Score: 1

      Because the "best best" is probably not in the competition. I'd say Gates is looking for the best of codemonkeydom.

    11. Re:Why? by Stormwatch · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Think about it this way... is Bill Gates a hell of a coder with decent business skills, or a hell of a businessman with decent coding skills?

    12. Re:Why? by NanoGator · · Score: 1

      "I don't get it. If you're the best out of 5000 coders, why would you want to work for any company, let alone Microsoft? Seriously. If you're that good, go out there and start your own company and in ten years people will compete to work with you."

      The point I was going to make has already been made by another poster. So instead I have to ask: Why did this post shoot up to +5? Is it really not that well understood that software has to be designed before it can be coded, then marketed then supported, and so on? I'm really starting to get the idea that a lot of people here think that programmers generally have a larger role than they really do.

      --
      "Derp de derp."
    13. Re:Why? by timeOday · · Score: 1
      However, working at a big company that decides you are one of the best programmers in [demography] probably means you can earn piles of cash doing what you love.
      Piles of cash, I think not. Put an 30th percentile programmer and a 99th percentile programmer next to each other at a big company and wait 5 years. The better developer will distinguish him/herself, and even make more money. But not that much more, unless the ace progresses to a leadership role. And in that case the extra money is really for leadership rather than programming. Unfortunately I don't think there's a great career path in programming. Maybe it's the same for all technical work.
    14. Re:Why? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      In India, working for Microsoft can be considered the ultimate dream for a coder.

      I am from India myself, but have been working in Singapore for the past 6 years. What I have noticed is that in more individualistic countries like the US, you do things for your own happiness, be it doing your own company, or working on something interesting in a startup rather than a big procss oriented company like MS.

      But in a place like India it is more important to show OTHER people that you work for a top multi-national.

    15. Re:Why? by Fulcrum+of+Evil · · Score: 1

      He's a helluva businessman with mediocre code skills, which was your point, I guess.

      --
      "We returned the General to El Salvador, or maybe Guatemala, it's difficult to tell from 10,000 feet"
    16. Re:Why? by Fulcrum+of+Evil · · Score: 1

      That didn't take long at all.

      Are you actually shocked that some people like to gather power so they can fuck lots of women? It's always been so.

      --
      "We returned the General to El Salvador, or maybe Guatemala, it's difficult to tell from 10,000 feet"
    17. Re:Why? by triffidsting · · Score: 1

      Spoken like someone who has not flipped burgers for a living. I have.

      The pay sucks, no insurance, they treat employees like stupid cattle, the work is menial... You're so tired at the end of the day, you're dead on your feet when you get home. To remain employed, you do exactly what you are told, regardless of any safety concerns you might have. But hey, it is good exercise, since you're on your feet all day. And you typically get a discount on your purchases, like 50% or so.

      Tell me you want to go clean a fast-food restaurant's bathroom for minimum wage (which, incidentally, is not typically enough to live on). Speaking of which, I'm reminded of the time that one of my co-workers was scalded by defective coffee pot's handle breaking off and breaking at her feet, which splashed hot coffee up her leg. Yeah, real fulfilling job that is.

      --
      Non, je ne veux pas coucher avec toi ce soir.
    18. Re:Why? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Please continue.

    19. Re:Why? by AuMatar · · Score: 1

      I have. I worked at Burger King as a teen. Wasn't so bad, except when the air broke. And the day someone thought it would be fun to spray mace into the air vent. I'd take it over running a buisness any day. Of course, I'll take coding as an employee over either.

      --
      I still have more fans than freaks. WTF is wrong with you people?
    20. Re:Why? by AhtirTano · · Score: 1
      Think of all the chicks you'd get...

      That didn't take long at all.


      Now listen to the sound of one hand clapping.

    21. Re:Why? by andreyw · · Score: 1

      I'm probably going to get modded down for this, being Slashdot and all. Keep in mind that I primarily use Linux, so don't take me for some kind of kiss-ass Microsoft fan.

      I don't understand why there is a running sentiment that Bill is a mediocre coder. If he was a mediocre coder then he wouldn't have resigned from a managerial position to become Chief Software Architect.

      But hey, Windows has bugs and is largely unpopular with /., hence Bill surely couldn't code his way out of a paper bag. Don't know about Bill, but David Cutler (RSX-11M, VMS, NT) is probably a better programmer than most of Slashdot combined. Since geniuses generally avoid idiots, I'd gather Gates is worth more than a million of Slashdot cable-running fanbois combined.

    22. Re:Why? by tsm_sf · · Score: 1

      I don't understand why there is a running sentiment that Bill is a mediocre coder. If he was a mediocre coder then he wouldn't have resigned from a managerial position to become Chief Software Architect.

      That's like saying every (building) architect is a fantastic construction worker as well. Might be true for some, but is definitely not the rule. Saying "and the sink goes here" is not the same thing as actually installing a sink. Not to disparage either ability, I guess, I'm just saying that one doesn't necessarily follow the other.

      --
      Literalism isn't a form of humor, it's you being irritating.
    23. Re:Why? by 1u3hr · · Score: 1
      If [Gates] was a mediocre coder then he wouldn't have resigned from a managerial position to become Chief Software Architect.

      Do you think "software architects" write code?

      Windows has bugs and is largely unpopular with /., hence Bill surely couldn't code his way out of a paper bag. Don't know about Bill, but David Cutler (RSX-11M, VMS, NT) is probably a better programmer

      The problems with Windows aren't due to Cutler, (yes, I know he wrote VMS) but the compromises demanded by the Software Architect to remain compatible with all the older crappy code.

    24. Re:Why? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I don't understand why there is a running sentiment that Bill is a mediocre coder. If he was a mediocre coder then he wouldn't have resigned from a managerial position to become Chief Software Architect.

      It is so easy to understand: the Chief Software Architect is not a coder; they are an architect. IE, he tell programmers what to code. More specifically, he tells middle management what to tell their underlings to code. Don't ever think that he does any actual coding.

      You don't have to know anything about coding to be an architect (OK, I exaggerate a little :). You just need to know what you want the software to do.

    25. Re:Why? by Basehart · · Score: 1

      Look at Spinal Tap.

      Those guys had to form a fake rock band to get some decent action!

    26. Re:Why? by drsquare · · Score: 1

      What makes you think that being a good programmer would make you a good businessman? If anything the opposite will be true.

      And if you're running a business you probably don't have time for programming anyway, so his skills become irrelevent as he'd have to hire someone else to do it.

    27. Re:Why? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You missed the joke.

    28. Re:Why? by barefootgenius · · Score: 1

      The money of course.
      "Yes, with your internship in Microsoft India, you will receive a yearly salary of, wait for it, $20,000!"

      "Arghhh! Stop hitting me with that chair. Your a manager! Your a manager!"

      --
      /. bug #926803 - Why I can post.
    29. Re:Why? by rbanffy · · Score: 1

      I would like to add that a software architect that thinks he can code and that nobody dares to contradict is a very dangerous kind of software architect.

    30. Re:Why? by WindBourne · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Actually, it would be a good opportunity for Google to step forward and announce that they will sign the 2'nd and 3'rd place winners. Who wants to work for bill if you can work for google? These days, Google is where the real coder go and all the fun is at. After all, Google encourages you to do your own thing.

      --
      I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
    31. Re:Why? by RallyMedia · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I'm a coder. I've got my own comany. I'm not a great business man :). If you settle for a one-man company you don't need a whole lot of know-how about economics, not much venture capital and so on.. and still you can easilly get about twice the pay of a normal programming job, get to decide workhours / vacations yourself and such. The only good thing to have are some connections at other companies (friends that work there for example) that might need programming help to get you started. Once you'va made a few projects, you'll be drowning in work from them. However, starting up a larger company with more emplyees, that's another thing.. :)

    32. Re:Why? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "Plus, think of all the chicks you'd get..."

      I'm thinking of a number between 0 and, uh, ... nevermind.

    33. Re:Why? by MaggieL · · Score: 1

      Does your comany have enough emplyees to write a spell checker? You'va could make that your next project easilly.

      --
      -=Maggie Leber=-
    34. Re:Why? by Fulcrum+of+Evil · · Score: 1

      If he was a mediocre coder then he wouldn't have resigned from a managerial position to become Chief Software Architect.

      He's been CEO for over 20 years and stuck his nose into the technical details of most strategic MS software, but he (arguably) hasn't written a line of code in all that time. Why would you think he's any sort of decent coder? And yeah, architects don't write code, but they should know how to. How else do you make the necessary decisions?

      Since geniuses generally avoid idiots, I'd gather Gates is worth more than a million of Slashdot cable-running fanbois combined.

      And we get the ever so charming "If you're so smart, why aaren't you rich?" parting shot. Bravo, sir.

      --
      "We returned the General to El Salvador, or maybe Guatemala, it's difficult to tell from 10,000 feet"
    35. Re:Why? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I don't get it. If you're the best out of 5000 coders, why would you want to work for any company, let alone Microsoft?

      Could it be because they don't want the best, they want the best of those who value being a stooge, er, protege of darth, er, billg?
    36. Re:Why? by chriseyre2000 · · Score: 1

      Software Architects bloody well should still right code.
      Preferably the high level demo code or proof of concepts for their domain model.
      Otherwise their knowledge will become so dated that they start to lose the ability to design.
      Software Architecture Design cannot be (totaly) language agnostic.

      However Mr Gates is the Cheif Software Architect - he merely tells the other Architects what to do.

  8. Why? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    WHY?!?!

  9. The article isn't clear... by Hawthorne01 · · Score: 5, Funny

    Does the winner or loser of this competition get to code for Bill? :-)

    --
    "Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity, and I'm not sure about the former."
    1. Re:The article isn't clear... by Elad+Alon · · Score: 1

      The winner, naturally. The loser already has.

      --
      News for merdes. Shit that matters.
      Ask me about my sig.
  10. Just for fun by this+great+guy · · Score: 5, Funny

    If I lived in India, I think just for fun I would participate in this contest, and then when I win (because I am of course the best dev in the world), I will tell Balmer "I am sorry but actually I think I am gonna work for Google. Bye ! Oh BTW, nice chair you have there. Have a nice day !".

  11. Re:RIP TIMECOP by lennyhell · · Score: 0, Insightful

    "O tay, he was very nice! I think so! Do you think so? Come on now! I tink it is very sad timecop died... I sad, very sad... dest din deace duddy!!! I am torry he is gone."

  12. Neat... by Cherita+Chen · · Score: 2, Funny

    Compete to sell your soul huh? Sounds good, Where do I sign up?

    --
    I'm not fat, just big boned...
    1. Re:Neat... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Compete to sell your soul huh? Sounds good, Where do I sign up?

      http://www.microsoft.com/

    2. Re:Neat... by alphamugwump · · Score: 1

      Some of us find the sort of material that you just linked to extremely offensive.

  13. In India... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    In India, Ballmer does not throw chair - chair throws Ballmer.

  14. Wear a gorilla suit and carry a suitcase by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Balmer will hire you for his team at least... :-)

  15. the donkey game by seringen · · Score: 1, Funny

    maybe you'll get to recode his donkey game for modern systems. If you don't know what I'm talking about you're blessed to have missed that horror.

    1. Re:the donkey game by AsmCoder8088 · · Score: 3, Informative
      Except you must replace the donkey theme with cows; Indians save the cows! :-)

      Oh, and if perchance you don't which game this is, check it out!

      basiCreations

  16. Product Development Strategy by codesurfer · · Score: 5, Funny

    Sounds like the final push to get Vista out the door is on! Winner gets to stay on as scapegoat for any problems encountered.

    1. Re:Product Development Strategy by laffer1 · · Score: 1

      I see the humor, but I can actually see microsoft outsourcing in this way. Interns wrote notepad and wordpad didn't they? Oh dear..

    2. Re:Product Development Strategy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Winner gets to stay on as scapegoat for any problems encountered.

      Mmmmmm. Indian scape goat.

  17. Re:RIP TIMECOP by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Interesting

    I'm pouring a 40 of Japanese bubble tea on the curb for timecop.

  18. Inside yourselves... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Inside yourselves, all of you wish you were good enough to win this and work for Bill. It is fashoinable among this crowd to bash Microsoft.

    1. Re:Inside yourselves... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Some genius you are. But sometimes its good that your wish does not come true. Like back in my earlier days, I wished for two dicks. Really.

  19. Donald Gates... by matr0x_x · · Score: 1

    He'll see you the rope to hang him with if it'll make him an extra $1.

    --
    LINUX ONLINE POKER: Linux Poker
  20. it would be nice to win by fishyfool · · Score: 2, Interesting

    then tell Bill "No Thanks"

    --
    Enjoy Every Sandwich
  21. Intervention needed by fmaxwell · · Score: 3, Funny

    Twenty finalists will receive internships with Microsoft India before one Superhero is selected to join Mr. Gates's own team.

    It sounds like Bill Gates has watched just a bit too many episodes of The Apprentice.

  22. What about when India gets outsourced? by radiotyler · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Mr. Gates is something of a celebrity in India, where technology outsourcing has provided well-paid jobs and changed the fortunes of thousands of middle-class Indians.

    I wonder if all of these programmers in India are even slightly concerned that he ditched out on the (I'm assuming here) more expensive U.S. programmers to hire "more cost effective" employees in India?

    They might want to think about what happens when ex-Soviet free states reaches a technology level that either surpasses India, or become cheap enough labor wise to be worth the loss of quality. I honestly don't see a lack of qualified programmers here in the U.S. for Microsoft to hire. And I hate seeing companies that have no reason to expand their profit margins start outsourcing just for the sake of making that extra buck.

    --
    hi mom!
    1. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by 7macaw · · Score: 1

      when ex-Soviet free states reaches a technology level that either surpasses India

      So, ferrying people to/from ISS isn't quite on par? ;)

    2. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by univgeek · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I'm in India, and no I don't see any reason to be even slightly concerned because we're supposedly taking away your God-given right to technology jobs.

      When did you guys lose your "Give me your poor, tired and huddled masses ...' and 'if you work you can make it big' attitudes and get this entitlement attitude?

      What should we have done when you colonised us and took away our wealth built up over centuries, if not millenia? When India alone accounted for a few dozen percent of world trade? Now that you guys are on top, you'd like to keep a third of humanity down forever?

      And did you even consider in your pompousness that some of the software that MS does might be for the local market? Or do you even realise that there's a world outside the US, and languages other than English? And that developing software in the local languages might, conceivably, be easier in that country?

      And, the ex-Soviet states are already technologically and educationally above India/China. What we do have is a huge mass of humanity trying desperately for three square meals a day, clothing and a roof over the head. Considering this, I think with our democracy, we're doing pretty well thank you.

      Come to think of it there are/were many democracies doing quite well until some pompous pricks decided that they were not right-wing enough. Hmm, can you name the pricks?

      One would think that if you post on /. you'd realize the number of unsolved problems in *every* field of science and engineering around us, and welcome the larger number of hands available to solve these problems.

      Don't you want to get off this Earth? Don't you want mankind to ensure its safety with colonies off the Earth? Do you think that's going to happen when a third of humanity is without any technology?

      And for those who think we have no home-grown tech companies, wait and watch. There are companies capable to giving any MNC a run for its money, and is as ruthless as any other (not that I'm happy about this). Do you know the owners of some of the largest trans-oceanic fiber networks are now Indian companies? That some of the largest steel producers in the world are from India? One of the top-three media (cd/dvd/cdr) manufacturers in the world?

      Napolean once said "China is a sleeping giant. Let her sleep, for when she wakes she will shake the world." A large portion of humanity is trying very hard to regain its due. The world order will change. Be prepared for it.

      This probably came off as something of a rant. So be it. When I see people struggling for their lives everyday, and see someone complaining because they theoretically 'lost' their cushy job to the 'third-world' only because of cost, I just lose it :-/

      --
      All bow to his Noodliness!! His Noodle Appendage has touched me!
    3. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by damsa · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I didn't know the US colonized India. I blame the right wing education system that really must suck.

      What people are bothered by is that large corporations expect certain level of education out of the system in the US. But mega corporations like MS avoid millions in taxes by setting up in places like Nevada. So people would have less problems with Mr. Gates, or Mr. Walmart, Mr. Gm if they paid taxes for better schools, and infrastructure instead of complaining about high wages, health insurance and lack of quality labor in America. Another problem is, if there are so many that lack skills in the US, then why does he hire temps, it doesn't make sense, why not train these temps to be full time employees, he doesn't do that to save money, he is not going to India to get better programmers, he is doing it to save money, once India realizes that, they don't have to beg at the teat of large mega corps and start their own firms and stop being an outsourcing bitch.

    4. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by belmolis · · Score: 1
      What should we have done when you colonised us and took away our wealth built up over centuries, if not millenia? When India alone accounted for a few dozen percent of world trade?

      "We" didn't colonize India. With minor exceptions such as the Portuguese in Goa it was the British who colonized India. Although I certainly don't justify colonialism and agree with most of your post, I don't see any justification for the view that India is poor because of British colonialism. The reason that India is a relatively poor country today is primarily because India has not developed the way Europe, North America, Australia, and some East Asian countries have. I don't see how that can be blamed on the British. Another major cause of India's poverty is internal: high rates of population growth coupled with inheritance customs and the rigidity of the caste system.

      There have been cases in which a colonial power literally robbed the colony of its accumulated wealth and took control of the current sources (e.g.gold mines), but I'm not aware that this happened on any real scale in India. The main economic benefit that the British got from India was first opium to sell to China to make up for the huge British trade deficit with China and secondly tea. While the opium trade was immoral, I don't see how it was particularly exploitative of India. Nor did the British destroy the traditional economy out of spite or in order to make room for activities of their own.

      So, granting that colonization was unfair and humiliating, what basis is there for the claim that is a significant cause of India's current economic situation?

    5. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Fulcrum+of+Evil · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      When did you guys lose your "Give me your poor, tired and huddled masses ...' and 'if you work you can make it big' attitudes and get this entitlement attitude?

      Back then, companies couldn't ship jobs to some backwater where the cost of living was cheaper while enjoying the comforts of the first world.

      Now that you guys are on top, you'd like to keep a third of humanity down forever?

      Why don't you go build your own economy instead of being the bottom ranks of some other country's corporation? Israel did it in about 60 years, why can't you?

      And did you even consider in your pompousness that some of the software that MS does might be for the local market?

      Yep. It doesn't take tens of thousands of developers to localize software.

      Come to think of it there are/were many democracies doing quite well until some pompous pricks decided that they were not right-wing enough. Hmm, can you name the pricks?

      Yeah, blame us because the CIA likes to topple hostile democracies and set up friendly dictatorships, because I personally oversaw those ops.

      And for those who think we have no home-grown tech companies, wait and watch.

      I don't care about your local industry, at least that's not my concern. Good luck and all that. My problem is that, by cutting costs at all costs, the local corps here seem to want to sabotage the US technology career - who's going to study CS if there aren't any jobs, or if they pay shit wages? Who's going to hire fresh grads if MS shifts most of its hiring to India? Yeah, we've got startups like crazy, but what happens when the business plan requires shifting all development to India after 5 years? Yeah, we cost more (we have higher rents), but we feed money back into the economy.

      --
      "We returned the General to El Salvador, or maybe Guatemala, it's difficult to tell from 10,000 feet"
    6. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not true at all, the Brits transferred massive amounts of cash and natural resources from India to their homeland, and India was left in a virtual 200 year stasis. The only development, such as railroads and English education, happened only to more efficiently strip India of its resources.

    7. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by starm_ · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Of course hes going there to save money, but the reason he can do that is that indians with the same level of education are poor and in need hence they are willing to work for less. They are in need of money and deserve these jobs much more than the americans. In a free market, jobs tend to go to the poorest regions which just serve to make it richer thus balancing wealth distribution. If it wasn't for that mechanism, the poor would never get a chance. And with the money you will save next time you buy MS products made in India or from the capital gain generated by the MS stocks you own, you can give to US charity or spend in local businesses to create jobs.

    8. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by rob_squared · · Score: 1

      The problem is that people don't get what's going on, and the news isn't helping. It's not someone in India or any other country "stealing" jobs that is the problem, its the fact that a company can do an end run around minimum wage rates by leaving the country for jobs.

      It's the individual companies that are taking away the *opportunity* for employment that are the problem.

      --
      I don't get it.
    9. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by open_janana · · Score: 1

      'loss of quality' I remember a old story about a frog .... it assumed its well is the only ocean.

    10. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by badmammajamma · · Score: 1

      Oh give me a break. You're trying to tell me the brits stripped all of india's resources in less than a hundred years? Bullshit. You guys are fucked because of the rampant corruption of your government where everything is run with bribes. You'be been out from England's thumb for almost 60 years now. Time to start blaming yourselves for your problems. Oh, and if it wasn't for the brits teaching your sorry asses English you'd be an even bigger shithole than you are now. So fuck off.

      --
      Any man who afflicts the human race with ideas must be prepared to see them misunderstood. -- H. L. Mencken
    11. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by badmammajamma · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Nobody here thinks we have some "god-given right to technology jobs". However, we don't like companies that ship jobs out (especially our well paid jobs) to some other country just so they can save a few bucks.

      You are right about the ex-soviet states. If they bothered to learn english, you guys would be fucked. If the Chinese learned english, everyone would be fucked because they'd have programmers working for $1 a day.

      I have met plenty of Indians who are pompous and quite pleased with themselves. Don't think we have some kind of patent on that. It's something you will find in people all over world.

      Finally, fuck the "large portion of humanity". I, JUST LIKE U, only care about MY FUCKING PORTION. Don't play self righteous with me. Every one is in it for themselves. To say otherwise is to either be incredibly naive, deluded, stupid, or a fucking liar. Take your pick which you are. The only difference between anyone is how many people they are willing to fuck over to get what they want.

      --
      Any man who afflicts the human race with ideas must be prepared to see them misunderstood. -- H. L. Mencken
    12. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "Why don't you go build your own economy instead of being the bottom ranks of some other country's corporation? Israel did it in about 60 years, why can't you?"

      Jesus Christ! Are you a retard? how about billion of U.S. money going to Isarel every fucking year!

      what a dick!

    13. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by TIMxPx · · Score: 1

      What we do have is a huge mass of humanity trying desperately for three square meals a day



      I think the timecube would say that we should get four cubic meals a day.



      Thank you, Dr. Gene Ray, cubic and wisest human

      --
      There are 10 kinds of people in the world: That averages about 660,000,000 of each kind.
    14. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Tim+C · · Score: 1

      once India realizes that, they don't have to beg at the teat of large mega corps and start their own firms and stop being an outsourcing bitch.

      The more outsourcing jobs Indian companies win, the more money is flowing in to the country. The more money going in, the better the economy. The better the economy, the more opportunities there are for firms to start up and be successful.

      Eventually you'll get your wish, and those pesky Indians will stop taking your money, your jobs and your wives (oops, sorry, one xenophobic stereotype too far).

    15. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by damsa · · Score: 1

      Yes, if the Indian economy is not based on outsourcing, then it wouldn't have to rely on outsourced companies. Companies move when labor becomes too expensive in certain country. Japan used to be a cheap place to manufacture stuff, then it went to Korea, Malaysia, now unto China. An economy based on pure outsourcing is not sustainable because other cheaper labor/land will be available to exploit. You hit the nail on the head, companies have to move on to other things besides being cheap labor and raw goods. I don't care if MS moves all of their offices to Canada or Banglalore. MS employees are rather annoying anyways. But the reality is, MS isn't looking for quality programmers, as much as Phil Knight is looking for quality cobblers.

    16. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by vmalloc_ · · Score: 1

      Maybe you should try looking at your problems instead of blaming "the man" all the time. India's own socialist, uber-regulatory government is doing just about everything it can to guarantee permanent poverty economy. As of 2005 India is ranked 115 on the Economic Freedom Index out of 155, whereas countries like the US are near the top. "Democracy, Democracy, Democracy" blah blah, Democracy doesn't mean squat when you aren't actually free, just because you can vote for who represents you doesn't mean you are free.

      Now for a contrast, Hong Kong isn't democratic, never really has been, was a colony of Britan for EVEN LONGER, and sixty years ago Hong Kong was probably in equal economic shape at the time as India, but they had the wisdom to encourage economic development (allow "freedom") rather than suck everything into the state and make insane regulations that make it impossible to be an entrepeneur, and guess what now that resourceless rock is aiming to be a wealthier country per-capita than the United States. Hmm maybe "the man" AKA George Bush forgot to push the "destroy economy" button for Hong Kong too, yeah that's it. Give me a break.

      Americans, like any other successful country, didn't get "entitled" to wealth. What we were entitled to (though it's been tough to hold onto it) is freedom. Freedom has given us capitalism, which has allowed us to EARN our wealth through hard work. That's the only true secret to wealth, there's no wizard of oz pushing the "keep the brothers down" lever, okay?

    17. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by gnud · · Score: 1

      that is if prices actually drop. In a free market, they should, in theory, but MS has got something close to a monopoly in some areas.

    18. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Disclaimer: I am a Indian.

      When the east india company came to set up shop, India was not a bristling power with technologicaly advanced weapons. In the span of 250 years of colonisation, India did not lose anything that was not worth losing (Sati, a very rigid caste system...).

      Comparing the very distant past really does not help India today. See for 45 years after our independence, when we had every possibility to bootstrap ourselves into a technologicaly advanced nation, we faltered. We had a socialist system where the businessmen were limping along because of permit raj. Our population shot from 350 million to the present monstrous size (and in just 50 years, what the fuck were we doing). And in that time most kinds of goods or item was smuggled because of trade crippling laws by our brain dead leaders. Till 1991 that is. Then things changed, when our forex was at just a 2 weeks trade worth, we were forced to do what we should have done at the moment of independence. We opened up.

      Look where we are just 15 years after opening up.

      "Give me your poor, tired and huddled masses ...'

      They did take in lots of people. America is not made of any one nationality. It is a country made up of many nationalities. Polish,german,irish,indian,pakistanis..etc etc.
      All they had was one thing in common, a desire to work and succeed.
      If you ask me it was the closest to getting to be in a ayn randian utopia.
      But some where, some thing changed. All the people started losing their importance in how the Govt should be run. Other Govt authorised people aka Corp started running the country.
      It has now culminated in a giant exodus of jobs from America to all over the world.

      Now you tell me , name me one damn Indian software product you use that has a indian brand and is made by a indian.
      Do you know the per year phd count in India. Its around 50. Yup what a single American University produces is what India produces.

      Atleast India is picking up itself right? Wrong.
      We are just being lifted up by others, and they will prop us up only as long as it is profitable.
      You should only reap what you sow and if you think we are reaping the rewards of having sowed a billion little Indians you are right. but it is so wrong.

      I give another 5 years. Atleast within that time we must sow some of our own ideas for us
      I mean we are so competent, we are so smart all the jobs stops in India. But what are the Jobs?
      Writing code for american companies which is going to be used by the first world? Servicing and supporting American customers for whom these products are made.
      What happens when AT&T shifts it office from Bangalore to somewhere in Indonesia?
      Will all the technology inside the offices of bangalore be of any use to us the indian people.
      You wanna build India? Build products for Indians. Service those products and support those products.

      What is happening is a recipe for disaster.
      What we are reaping is not ours, and will not be ours ever.

      God i always get pissed when i hear whining about how good we indians are and how jealous the world is of us.
      UnivGeek, if you are listening, quit your job and start doing something productive.
      Because the global productivity has not gone up a tad, it has just shifted its base.
      I could go on , but what the hell i am posting as an AC, this is probably not even going to be read by anyone.

      Annonymous Indian Coward

    19. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by harves · · Score: 3, Insightful

      First I think he was pointing out that "the same culture that permeates the US also colonised India". He was referring to a mindset, not a label of Britain or America. But anyway...

      It's odd for you to argue "Microsoft doesn't pay taxes in America, so how can they expect decent programmers in America if they don't fund schools?" By some miracle Microsoft doesn't pay much to schools in India, yet they find decent programmers there. Perhaps it's not Microsoft's tax avoidance that's the problem?

    20. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by neillewis · · Score: 1

      I'm not sure that's true. Globalisation should lead to more effective resource allocation and an all round increase in wealth, but that doesn't necessarily mean greater wealth distribution. I've seen research that says that regions with an economic advantage gain a greater advantage from free trade. The whole point about capitalism is that the more capital you have the less risk you have. I don't see real evidence of the 'trickle down effect', I see an increasing economic divide. Are you saying Bill Gates is deliberately bringing about a drop in his own relative wealth? I'm sceptical.

    21. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Just have to wonder. How long have you been Uhmerikahn-ized? "Three squares" is a pretty American colloquialism. In fact, it's a fairly military term, and one that's used mostly in Southern-US culture.

      Given your impeccable English, the fact that you can quote the plaque of the Statue of Liberty, and the fact that you missed most of the point of a FSDBMS, I'm guessing you're an American Troll (TM). If you're not, I'm not giving you enough credit, but Christ, you post like a flaming asstart.

      The raging problem is this: a "best-of" search, targeted in a veritable geek meat-market, is not so much a question of selection. BillG could reach out with two mighty fists and scoop up a crop of Indian coders that are of exceptional caliber. The problem, truly, is that he's doing this after bemoaning the lack of American programmers coming out of college. It's two-faced behavior at its best: want young (read: cost-efficient) coders to enter your business? The ones that have the most work experiences at the cost bracket you're examining are going to be the most seemingly savvy. And that, realistically, is going from the USA to elsewhere, because of global conversion rates.

      The point is this: if BillG wanted to be fair, he'd say "Who is the best coder at this standard of living?" But that's not what the finance sheets will ever support. It's an economics bid, and a fly in the face of a PR stunt he ran a few months ago.

    22. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by damsa · · Score: 1

      It may not be the problem. But Bill Gates's argument time and time again is the underfunded school system is the reason why he has to go to India to find decent programmers. It's not that the schools are bad, or American kids are dumb, it's because MS has historically paid less than other software companies. They got away with it in the past by relying on working perks, and a very very attractive stock options package, and a low cost of living in the Seattle area. Also MS had an advantage of being a company where people feel like it is the future of computing. Nowadays, places like Google, are the place to go. So MS has trouble hiring talent at lower costs like they used to, because of downturn in the stock market, increase in costs of housing in the Seattle market, and no more free cokes. That's my theory anyways. I bet someone will mention that Bill Gates donated money to college campuses and the like, and I agree that is great. But remember it's not MS giving money, none of the buildings are called Microsoft Hall.

    23. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I have something to tell my friends in US.

      I am living in India and I returned to India after finishing my education in US.....I am soo glad of my decision.

      While I was budding student....there were several tempting offers from firms like Microsoft ..who wanted to hire me...I came to US for my education and reliased the truth about these jobs.

      I realized that the priority for most jobs in US was first given to US Citizens.
      Next preferences were given to Permanent Residents.
      AND
      when they did not have enough man power they would recruit Students, and import skilled man power from countries like India on F1, H1B's etc.

      These skilled people were given some of the crappiest jobs like supports, quality testing , fixing bugs, CRs etc. and to add to it they were treated miserably by their american counterparts.

      As a country India too has had its share of problems due to excessive BRAIN DRAIN during the 80's & 90's.

      Most of our highly intellectual manpower and top bracket students were attracted by US MNCS leaving very few behind. Our Skilled people came to US and have proved their mettle and abilities and done wonders.....which only made these MNCS realize the potential of our man powers due to which they have started outsourcing work to India.

      While most of the exciting work still occurs in US ....the non essential work is sent to India for the cheap underpaid Indian workers.

      I dont understand why do the Americans feel so insecure with the outsourcing taking place.... I am SURE THE AMERICAN ECONOMY DOES NOT THRIVE SOLELY ON "IT".
      America is after all a land of Immigrants.
      Take a look at most of the institutions in America and work out the statistics..and take a look at the number of students who are enrolled in Masters, and Phd programms ...they all come from countries like India and China.

      Inspite of being a third world country ....our parents have managed to accumalate enough funds for our education and every year Thousands of students from countries like India and Chine enroll in US Universities and bring in millions of dollars.....get very little funding...work up the hard way and get into Phd programms and do all the reasarch.

      Have you ever seen Indians complaining about the money our country looses at the hands of these students who come to US leave alone the BRAIN DRAIN I just mentioned.

      and if thats not enough take a GOOD LOOK at how these Universities treat Indian Students.

      what surprises me today when read the local new papers in Mumbai are the Ads by Various US institutions like USC, UCLA, UCSD, etc etc holding seminars to attract FOREING STUDENTS!!!! WHY ?? simply because we bring in some good money in these institutions.

      IT is a very big sector and there is alot of work like Data Processing, bug fixing, testing...which are not always exciting and outsourcing such work to India will definitely help firms like Microsoft because the labour is cheap and they really don't need to spend 60,000$ per anum on one US employee when the same non essential work can be done for 10,000$ by an Indian worker in India.

      Bill Gates is the richest man in the world and every year he makes about 40 Billion Dollars...
      Even if he does plan to invest about 1.7 Billion Dollar in India ....I am sure he has a vision in mind....for all you know his earnings might go up to another 20 Billions i.e 60 Billion Dollars per year....and because he is an American...all the profits will definitely come to America which in my opinion is good for the American economy (also you must keep in mind that companies like Microsoft contribute to American GDP{Gross Domestic Product})

      So please get rid of all the prejudices you guys have against Indians...believe me
      India is a very self sufficient country ...we might not be as rich as America....but let me tell you we are more Content with what we have going for ourselves in India....and hopefully a time will come ....when all the people (skilled people) who have left INDIA will return back home.

    24. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      For tax problems, you need WTX

    25. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by univgeek · · Score: 1

      :-) As Indian as I can be. I've been in the US (Texas) for about 4 years. Did my MS and picked up quite a bit from my Italian, Chinese, Argentinian and Iranian professors. Funnily enough I interacted very briefly with only one American prof.

      Thanks for the compliment on my English. Reading does that to you.

      And yes, I did feel I was flaming a bit too much. But what really bothered me was what I see as the sliding of the much-vaunted American attitude to life. Work hard and you can make it big, was what I thought it was. Fine we can do that too.

      Open your markets to our exports, we'll do the same, and we can both be rich, seemed to be the mantra. Forced by our economic scenario we did, and we have prospered, as did your exports. Now that we have learnt enough (from America and Europe and Japan) and are able to do some high-tech jobs, suddenly people start whining, as if those jobs belonged to them? That's the attitude I can't understand.

      I think that China has made a substantial change in the world economy. When India joins the party, it's going to shift from the US/Europe centric economy to an Asia centric economy. This is a matter of natural economics - which company would not like to have half the world's population as its market?

      I'm not sure I could have put my ideas on less of a flame. But I feel that most of the points I've made are valid, and most of the replies seem to concentrate on peripheral issues in my post, without replying to the real crux of the post - when half of humanity tries to pull itself up, there are going to be changes for everyone.

      Have fun!

      --
      All bow to his Noodliness!! His Noodle Appendage has touched me!
    26. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I think if you live on a fantasy planet of your own making you shouldn't try to talk about economics when there are adults who might be listening. FYI:

      U.S. Aid to Israel

      Grand Total
      $84,854,827,200

      Interest Costs Borne by U.S.
      $49,936,680,000

      Total Cost to U.S. Taxpayers
      $134,791,507,200

      Total Taxpayer Cost per Israeli
      $23,240

      Must be very enterprising of Israel to be able to build an economy with only 134,791,507,200 dollars of someone else's money in their pockets.

      As to your other points, why should anyone else care? Perhaps you can tell me about your years activism in the face of loss of manufacturing jobs? Go ahead.

    27. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by XchristX · · Score: 1


      "When the east india company came to set up shop, India was not a bristling power with technologicaly advanced weapons"


      This is true, but it is not all. It leads to a wrong conclusion becuse all the facts were not presented above. When the first Europeans arrived in/invaded India in the second millenium (The first Europeans ever to invade India were the Macedonians), we had already been under the feudal oppression of Islamic rule for 5 centuries. The excesses of the Sultanate, the decadence of the Mughals and the sheer savagery of the Bahmanis had stripped our country of her capability to defend herself.

      As a control statement, bear in mind that before the Muslims came, India had a significantly higher standard of living. While Europe was busy destroying itself and burning witches, The Guptas had already brought India to her Golden Age (not a theatrical statement, but a historical one). They had already defeated 3 scythian invasions (who were Europeans, I might add). So The Gupta empire was sufficiently advanced (for that time) to repel an invasion from Europe. If we go further back to the pre-Mauryan post-Vedic period, the Malavi had repelled the Macedonian invasion (also Europeans). Our ancestors were able to put up a decent fight against them. The only time a European ever succeeded intaking large portions of India in the Ancient period was after the Mauryan Empire fell, and Demetrius invaded the country when the interregnum began and she was in tatters (for a brief period).



      So it had been done when we were strong. We were weakened by Islam, so could not stand up to the British.


      Technology is not the reason we lost to them. In fact, if you didn't sleep through 10th standard history class, you'd know that the armies of Shiraj-ud-Daulah were technologically at par with the British (bought muskets and even musket factories from the French and Dutch, and the Mughals had already brought gunpowder & cannons from Uzbekhistan). The same was true of the Maratha armies later on, and those of Mysore/Srirangapatnam under Tipu Sultan. Even during the great rebellion of 1857, the rebels had British P-53s, British Artillery and even British soldiers on their side (a large part of the Irish regiment defected to the side of the rebels, despite the fact that they were white soldiers). They were well trained and were willing to fight. The British had already lost many of their able commanders in the Crimean was in Europe, so they were weak and vulnerable.

      In all the above cases, the British eventually emerged victorious (in some cases, even against superior numbers). The main cause was the refusal of Muslims to fight alongside Hindus, and the fact that many Muslims sympathized with the British (on account of the fact that the British fed them their "Aryan Race" propaganda and told them that since they were ethnically of persian descent, that made them the only true "Aryans" in India and thus had the "God-Given right" to enslave, convert or exterminate the Hindu population).





      "Comparing the very distant past really does not help India today"





      Every event in history is connected to every other event, either causally or acausally. The statement above is an ignorant one. You cannot understand the India of today unless you understand the India of all earlier times.


      "We had a socialist system where the businessmen were limping along because"
      of permit raj"


      True. I don't claim to blame the whites and muslims for ALL of our problems. That is no less stupid and ignorant than Christians blaming Jews for all the ills of their society, or American republicans blaming blacks, secularism, and science for all the ills of theirs. But they did play an important part in weakening out country. That is an inescapable fact.

      The corruption of our civil service, and it IS corrupt as hell. The government as such is not so corrupt; at least, no more so than the Bush-Cheney Administration

      --
      l'Homme n'est Rien l'Oeuvre Tout: Gustave Flaubert to George Sand
    28. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by univgeek · · Score: 1

      You wanna build India? Build products for Indians. Service those products and support those products.


      Doing just that. There *are* companies in India making products for the Indian market. They're mostly started off by NRI's who've made it big in the US, or by those who've made it big at Infy, TCS, et al. The reason you haven't heard of any of them is that most of these companies have start after 2K, which is when real funding was available in India, for Indian startups.

      We will get there, and when we do, we'll have cost-structures that no MNC company can beat, we'll be able to make profits on absurdly low margins, because we'll need to be the most cost-conscious on Earth. And when we have our basics firmed up, we *will* move up the value chain.

      Re: your points on history. I probably made a mistake putting those in. Caused too much of a mis-focus :-(. But any reasonable history of India will tell you that the economy in shambles in India in 1947 was a result of the huge amounts of wealth that was siphoned off by the British. How'd they do that? The imported raw materials, and exported the finished goods back to us. All while disallowing the value-add to happen right here. Simple examples are of course textiles. Steel is also a good example. Saying that we didn't lose anything worth keeping is really missing the point by a mile.

      Re: American attitudes. It's possible that the corps have too much power and are abusing it to 'export' jobs. But why, I ask, is it right to export products to India, but not export jobs to India? I guess people have difficulty in accepting that service is seen as a product too.

      Re: Getting pissed off... Check my post, if you think I said that Indians are the best, read it again. I have no such mis-conceptions. I merely want to see India and China get what they deserve, in terms of a share of what this world produces. Nothing more, nothing less.
      --
      All bow to his Noodliness!! His Noodle Appendage has touched me!
    29. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by univgeek · · Score: 1

      Heh, yeah my education sucks. But I must say your universities are top-notch, having been at one for about 4 years.

      I really shouldn't have written the part about history, it's diverted my real message.

      The fact is, MS hiring people in India is a simple consequence of the market in India growing. There are also enough *sufficiently skilled* people in India who can do these jobs. All these years, when no MNC had a manufacturing or R&D base in India, and were importing billions of dollars worth of stuff, all I heard from the West was that we needed an even freer economy, and that once we'd opened up further we'd be able to get rich. We did that. And now that the people are able to take on some high-tech jobs, some start whining.

      Oh, and we've figured out that we need to make our own products. We're doing it too. You'll probably hear of the results in a few years. It's taken us this much time to get enough capital and enough technical skills to get on the boat.

      Since you guys have all this capital, I'm sure that you can find something worthwhile to do to double and triple it right, just like we're going to with our local companies?

      --
      All bow to his Noodliness!! His Noodle Appendage has touched me!
    30. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by univgeek · · Score: 1

      Errr, yes. That's what he was saying. Britain did strip India of most of its wealth in about 100 odd years. From having a significant chunk (~20%) of the world's trade, before British rule, to less than a single digit at the end of their rule.

      Note that I did not blame the British for our current situation, just that there was a reason we were in such a state 50 years ago. It didn't help that we went into a closed economy and corrupt practices.

      But we're learning, and we're climbing out. We'd like some help, but we're not waiting for it.

      And it's just a message board, no need to get all hissy about it, and increase your blood pressure.

      --
      All bow to his Noodliness!! His Noodle Appendage has touched me!
    31. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by univgeek · · Score: 1

      Hmm, I really shouldn't have put in that rant on history.

      I really didn't mean to make it come off as blaming the US/Britain for our ills, and that's not what I wanted to talk about at all.

      Democracy, upholding what you call freedom, is what allows us to actually control what happens in the long term. We do not have economic freedom - yet. We will eventually, and it will happen because the politicians have to listen to us.

      I agree that hiding under a rock, under a protectionist trade regime may not have been the wisest thing to do, in hindsight. But we're learning and we're climbing out. And we will make it up for the last 60 years.

      Re you last para. *Exactly!* When did people lose this attitude of *EARNING* wealth, and feel entitled to high-tech jobs? And why is there whining every time some jobs are started in India?

      --
      All bow to his Noodliness!! His Noodle Appendage has touched me!
    32. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by seven+of+five · · Score: 1

      oh, for fucksakes... we *have* been working you a-hole, and we got laid off anyway.

      make all the money you want. but instead of the easy way, ie destroying the livlihoods of thousands by cherry picking and lowballing, try doing the hard work of creating your own industries.

    33. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hmm, you feel that economic problems in India have nothing to do with colonial rule.

      1) The British looted gold, gems and precious stones from indian temples, mosques and palaces. The Kohinoor diamond in the crown jewels IS from india.

      2) Local industries were brutally stamped out. Did you know that it was a crime in india to make your own salt ? You HAD to buy them from the british. Taxes on all exports were enormous while there were ZERO tarrifs on things coming in from britain. Even those few who tried to compete were harassed out of their living. Do you know why the indian national movement's flag was a rotating wheel and all people wore khadi - it was a symbol of indigenously manufactured cloth.

      3) Large areas of land were made unusable to locals. Tea gardens were setup, and people had to work under foreigners in their own land. A zamindari system was setup where thousands of indians were forced to become bonded labourers - work for a wage on land that they owned.

      4) The crop patterns were also changed. Large areas of the country were forced to cultivate cash crops which only grew in indian weather, instead of food. This forced the nation to buy food from britain, while the cash crop products went directly to britain for a pittance.

      5) Long ranging effects of cultivating those cash crops are felt even today. Large tracts of land now lie waste, after having become barren because of cultivation of indigo. Basically, the british would go from farmer to farmer, ask him to cultivate indigo till his land was no longer usable, and then move on to the next guy. Several places in india which have the highest poverty and crime rate are former indigo plantations.

      So why don't you think about that before you make arbitrary statements. A considerable part of your current accumulated wealth is because of fruits of colonization and slave labour - wealth that acted as capital for most american "MNC"'s today. It's taken about 50 years for india to catch up - all of it by playing fair.

      And the reason india is doing better than you'd like it to do is BECAUSE some of those "corrupt" caste-ridden politicians made the right choices - tightened their belts even in conditions of extreme poverty and starvation to invest in a world-class education system, a space program and the like.

      Believe me, this offshoring this only a phase. Already, most of the IITs have started enterpreneurship based programs which provide ready money (mostly from alumni in the US) to invest in startups. It won't be long till management gets offshored as well !

    34. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by univgeek · · Score: 1

      Why don't you go build your own economy instead of being the bottom ranks of some other country's corporation? Israel did it in about 60 years, why can't you?

      Israel got massive amounts of assistance from the US. Probably not the best of analogies.

      We *are* building our own companies. And they will compete on the world scale. But it'll be a while before you notice, because they'll have to survive in India first.

      And we will take the bottom jobs, 'cos we're desperate, but we will go up on the value-chain. Just like Japanese companies did, and just like Taiwanese and Chinese companies are doing now.


      Yeah, blame us because the CIA likes to topple hostile democracies and set up friendly dictatorships, because I personally oversaw those ops.

      Ooh, I thought you guys were a republic and could control your goons. Sorry, I was mistaken.


      Yep. It doesn't take tens of thousands of developers to localize software.

      So? Perhaps there is need for some local software for our government/companies which is not exactly the same as those they sell abroad? (Not MS in this case). Should that work not be done in India. If for example, IBM Global services takes a contract from an Indian company should they not do it in India? And if these guys are good enough, and cost less, could they not do American projects too? I mean those are the arguments which are used to justify imports into India.


      Who's going to hire fresh grads if MS shifts most of its hiring to India? Yeah, we've got startups like crazy, but what happens when the business plan requires shifting all development to India after 5 years?

      Don't worry about it. Most of the MS/PhD students in the US(at least in tech) are either Chinese or Indian anyway. We'll just trip right back for our jobs. And we'll probably need Americans for getting cultural things right. And if we're ever running out of cotton or wheat, we know who to call. You guys do have lots of a precious natural resource - arable land.
      --
      All bow to his Noodliness!! His Noodle Appendage has touched me!
    35. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by ePharaoh · · Score: 1

      Windows was originally developed by Americans. Look where it has got us :)

      But, seriously, it doesn't prove anything.

      Businesses, don't browse the shelf to buy Indians, or Chineese. They buy resources with sufficient capabilities for a job.

      Human resources are a product, like any other in a free market. Businesses "buy" these products because there is a value, or atleast a perceived value, derived from them. If a product is over qualified, then the cost may not be justifiable. I don't see anything shameful or unethical here.

      Aside, about the colonisation topic, unfair globalisation can be termed "colonisation". Foreign governments are bullied/bribed into opening up their economies, while domestic markets are fiercely protected. Have you been reading up on the recent WTO developments?

    36. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I think the problem that most Westerners have with India taking the programming jobs, is that the entire industry is practically a Western invention, specifically, American. America developed and programmed for the first computers ever, and the two mainstream processor makers are American. TFA is about an infamous American software company. Most anything involving computers and the internet has America attached to it in some way. Then all of a sudden here comes India saying "Hey, we've got 500,000,000 programmers willing to work for half the price!" Its not hate specifically against India, if China did the outsourcing we wouldn't like them either. Although having said that, I've been to both India and China and I feel that India has many more problems it needs to sort out before it starts passing out "white collar" jobs. Even the most rural parts of China have infrastructure for flowing water for example (for irrigation of farm fields) but when I was in India there were a few rural areas with no water at all, or just a simple pump. I just think there needs to be some work done before India takes all the computer jobs over.

    37. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Perhaps Indian people generally don't give a fuck about American workers - why should they? American workers never gave a fuck about the,

    38. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Darkman,+Walkin+Dude · · Score: 1

      and see someone complaining because they theoretically 'lost' their cushy job to the 'third-world' only because of cost

      It is only because of cost. Full stop. That is the only attraction India has for first world companies, besides a good English speaking ability. This will be graphically demonstrated to India as soon as places like the ex Soviet republics get better English worked into their education system.

    39. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Nate+B. · · Score: 1

      Sadly, our aerable land is getting taken out of production at an alrming rate due to urban sprawl. Now, I don't begrudge anyone wanting to own their own home, but when I can go to any of the medium-sized cities within a few hours drive of here and visibly see urban development where a decade ago crops and livestock were raised, I get alarmed.

      At some point something is going to have to give. Either there will be legal restrictions put in place on the type and amount of aerable land a community will allow development to take or modern agricultural production will not be able to keep pace with the population growth.

      --

      "Insanity is doing the same thing over again expecting a different result."
    40. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Nate+B. · · Score: 1

      Because, for the past forty to fifty years there has been a concerted effort on the part of a political/social idealogy to teach people the entitlement mantra and it has worked. Americans are told from birth that they are entitled to all sorts of material things. Yet, the education of the true entitlement of a citizen of the United States is withheld as it contradicts the entitlement indoctrination. It is in this climate that the last hold on individual liberty--private property rights--was removed by the US Supreme Court on June 23, 2005.

      --

      "Insanity is doing the same thing over again expecting a different result."
    41. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Fulcrum+of+Evil · · Score: 1

      Most of the MS/PhD students in the US(at least in tech) are either Chinese or Indian anyway.

      Well yeah. We have a surplus of PhDs as it is, and it's frequently a money-loser, so it makes sense. In 5 years, I expect to have one, perhaps two MSes, so I'm doing my part for the ratio.

      You guys do have lots of a precious natural resource - arable land.

      Yeah, we're building houses on them, but you can always knock them over.

      --
      "We returned the General to El Salvador, or maybe Guatemala, it's difficult to tell from 10,000 feet"
    42. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by meiemiiz · · Score: 1
      They might want to think about what happens when ex-Soviet free states reaches a technology level that either surpasses India, or become cheap enough labor wise to be worth the loss of quality.

      Wow the ignorance. Ex-Soviet free states already have the technical level and expertise of India and from that region come some of the best programmers in the world. And they already are more expensive than Indian programmers. For example, take my homecountry Estonia - GDP per capita righ now around 40% of EU level, 70% of my highschool classmates (class of '98, math and physics oriented) working in high-tech industries (mainly in IT) earning more than 4 times national average (some $24'000 vs $6000 a year) and working for companies like MS, Skype, Playtech (online casinos), Elcoteq (supplier for Nokia, Ericsson etc) and so on. They have very good language skills both in English and at least one other European language. If you want to outsource India, look elsewere.

    43. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Fulcrum+of+Evil · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      you shouldn't try to talk about economics when there are adults who might be listening.

      I know as much or more about economics as the average senator. Not saying much, I know.

      Must be very enterprising of Israel to be able to build an economy with only 134,791,507,200 dollars of someone else's money in their pockets.

      $134B (is that 2005 dollars?) over 60 years? That doesn't even pay for the military (which they wouldn't need if the arabs around them weren't trying to annihilate them). Israel has a first world economy and a decent standard of living. Not bad for living in the damn desert.

      As to your other points, why should anyone else care? Perhaps you can tell me about your years activism in the face of loss of manufacturing jobs? Go ahead.

      You should care because it will screw a lot of smart workers who want to work, are willing to retrain, and are having their livelihood devalued through legislation (H1-B caps combined with lax enforcement). A lot of manufacturing workers are poorly educated, expect to do the same damn thing for the same money, and had years of warning, by the way.

      --
      "We returned the General to El Salvador, or maybe Guatemala, it's difficult to tell from 10,000 feet"
    44. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      fuck you. Go blow a bull, you fucking dothead.

    45. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Your view of India is a fair acknowledgement of the difficulties facing it, but these are only temporary. While the mistakes of the past have held India back, things are changing. Here, in Britain, many Indian immigrants face similar difficulties, but successful members of the Indian community are showing what's possible. I value their hard work and sense of community, and welcome how their example sets a lead for the rest of Britain.


      I remember watching a programme on the Bhopal incident, and am deeply shocked and angered by the great injustice perpetrated on some of the poorest people in the world. During this programme, I heard of the continued deaths and ill health caused by this incident, and felt very sad for a women who last her husband and children on that day. I still wonder what happened to her and hope, one day, that people like this may get the justice they deserve.


      These two things aren't directly connected, and I'm not entirely sure what I'm trying to say here. Perhaps it's just that the world is full of great opportunity and great sadness, and we must look beyond fear and greed, develop confidence and resilience within ourselves. This is something that technology nor money can buy. It has to come from within ourselves. Whether you're climbing the mountains of success, like British Asians, or enduring a well of misery, like a Bhopal victim, there you are.


      Love and learning are your friends. At least, that's what India taught the world. How could you forget?

    46. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      As a country India too has had its share of problems due to excessive BRAIN DRAIN during the 80's & 90's.


      Yeah, I like that album too! "I don't wanna be buried in a pet cemetary..."


      Oh, and eat shit you fucking dothead.

    47. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by joh6nn · · Score: 1
      And it's just a message board, no need to get all hissy about it, and increase your blood pressure.
      you mean like you did in the parent?
      --
      i am a loser geek, crazy with an evil streak, yes i do believe there is a violent thing inside of me.
    48. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hello everyone,

      I am not a programmer though I would like to comment something out here.

      Do not waste your time by thinking that why am I posting here. It's nothing but I want to express my views on outsourcing.

      Most of you think that outsourcing is being done only because the companies want to increase their profit. Yeah, I know it could be one of the facts, but I won't agree if you say that's the only reason.

      I am a LINUX system admin from Kerala, India. I have been working as a system administrator for a company which provides remote system administration and Technical support for webhosting companies. Yes, we are doing outsourced jobs. Earlier, I too felt that I have got a job because the guys @US asked for more money and I felt ashamed. But soon I found that not all americans are great, or even good. I had to interact with the techs at the data center and the sys admins at the companies' office. I realized that there are people with a little knowledge and we are not at all technically backward. So my guess is that, companies are thinking why should they hire you when there is someone with higher or equivalent knowledge can be found outside(eg:- in India) who can work for a less salary.

      I don't know how many of you will agree with me and I really do not care about that.

      -
      Apk

    49. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by tihor · · Score: 1

      Cheap goods is something everybody goes for and that is the main reason why US has the biggest retailer in the world "Walmart". What is so facinating about the quality of goods in walmart is the fact that they are cheap. People dont buy the best, they always buy the best they can afford. Exactly the same phenomenon is taking place in this service industry i.e. in case you get the same skill set at a cheaper price you may as well have it. there is nothing wrong in globalising the economy and just cause US is loosing jobs in this sector does not mean globalisation is bad. Moreover the comment about india being a "outsourcing bitch" is really ridiculous. In that case US should stop trading with the whole world!!!! A good example is US selling arms to pakinstan -(F16's to be specific in this case) and in a month or so offers the same deal to india (F18's actually). The statement that is made is that US wants to have balance of power in the region. Wow isnt that a great perspective! today if US stops trading with other countries for whatever stupid reason the consumers there will not be able to afford the lifestyle that they lead today. Simple fact - go to any of ikea, sears, walmart, tommy, gap etc etc store and check as to how many things are made in the US? also remember that US is having a big trade deficit which means that US is borrowing from the whole world at this stage.

      Finally last but not the least, remember that this is still forest and it is all about survival of the fittest. this means the best and cheapest will survive and at this stage it is india, going ahead it will be some other country but till that time the indian economy will have enough power to sustain itself.

    50. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      the venom is misplaced. indian programmers aren't "outsourced b*s." come on.

      they are trying to work for a living - nothing more, nothing less.

      the b*s are the greedy people in power that couldn't care less about their workers outside thier social group - be they indian, american, chinese or alien.

      when bill gates and his ilk read about you calling indian programmers "outsourced b*s," he wets his pants in glee that he's manipulated the emotions of another person who has sidelined his intellect.

      yes, i program and yes i do so in the united states. i'm probably more pale than you, too... WASP all the way (minus the protestant part... -lol-). yes i will be affected by the lower wages of others trying to feed their families.

      there is blame, but it sure shouldn't be directed to people trying to live a decent life.

      what do you *really* want these people to do? "naw my 2 kids will starve today... take that job back to the us... bill doesn't need the extra money and my kids don't need food."

      hopefully you will see how absolutely absurd your position is to blame the indians.

      bill gates is the pimp. blame him. not 50%. 100%.

      don't hate on people trying to feed their families...

    51. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by sgt_doom · · Score: 1
      Are you any relation to Carly Fiorina, perhaps???

      Seriously, though, we don't have any right to "God-given technology jobs" - and the greedy megacorporations don't have any right whatsoever to corporate welfare and tax giveaways, nor does Ms. Fiorina and Mr. Gates have a God-given right to walk down the street securely when the people who made those streets secure are now impoverished thanks to all that outsourcing......

    52. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by sgt_doom · · Score: 1
      Earth to Indian dude (if you really are such) ---- how about you guys - instead of forever scavenging other country's citizens jobs (jobs which derived from those citizens helping to build up said corporations) -- create your own software industries and software companies and stop acting like such a pack of wild hyenas?????

      Of course, perhaps the only software you can actually produce is similar to that Godawful Samna word processing stuff - the one time I came into contact with it I recall the pathetic documentation and hanging subprograms and submenus that led to nowhere......

    53. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by damsa · · Score: 1

      going ahead it will be some other country but till that time the indian economy will have enough power to sustain itself. But that's not really the case, if you look at Japan and Korea which were formally the countries the US used to outsource their production. Today Japan is still in a recession, and Korea and rest of the Asian Tigers suffered in the mid 90s and had to be bailed out by the international community. The problem is worse in India because India isn't a huge manufacturing source to the US, and relocating electronic bits is a whole lot easier than relocating factories.

      The bitch comment is there because unless I am wrong, French, Japanese, German companies are not outsourcing to India. It is primarily the United States. And any sub contractor knows that when you rely primarily on one contractor you eat or die at the hands of that one contractor. When you are a contractor for Walmart you are Walmart's bitch. When you are a contractor for a US company you are that bitch.

      My comments are not aimed at outsourcing is evilz. But responding to the fact that for some companies outsourcing to India is a pain and there may be a backflash of outsourcing to India, and what happens when the contractor leaves.

    54. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Eric+Damron · · Score: 1

      "When did you guys lose your "Give me your poor, tired and huddled masses ...'"

      Ummmm.... more and more we ARE the poor, tired and huddled masses...

      --
      The race isn't always to the swift... but that's the way to bet!
    55. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      >>You should care because it will screw a lot of smart workers who want to work, are willing to retrain, and are having their livelihood devalued through legislation (H1-B caps combined with lax enforcement). A lot of manufacturing workers are poorly educated, expect to do the same damn thing for the same money, and had years of warning, by the way.>A lot of manufacturing workers (programmers) are poorly educated (in business savvy), expect to do the same damn thing for the same money, and had years of warning, by the way.

      more similar than different, right?

      check yourself and quit tossing hard working people under the bus b/c your so self absorbed to care about anything beyond the tip of your nose!

      integrity check time.

    56. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by starm_ · · Score: 1

      I'm not advocating free market regonomics. Im just saying, in this case, the india deserves it.

    57. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      this got screwed up... soo a second time...

      You should care because it will screw a lot of smart workers who want to work, are willing to retrain, and are having their livelihood devalued through legislation (H1-B caps combined with lax enforcement). A lot of manufacturing workers are poorly educated, expect to do the same damn thing for the same money, and had years of warning, by the way.

      your total self absorbtion is the same the same self absorbtion that drives mr gates to outsource. you don't care about the lowly (undereducated) manufacturing workers and bill doesn't care about the lowly (undereducated and unmotivated to start their own d*mn company) programmers.

      let's chame a few words to see how you speak for bill gates...

      A lot of manufacturing workers (programmers) are poorly educated (in business savvy), expect to do the same damn thing for the same money, and had years of warning, by the way.

      more similar than different, right?

      check yourself and quit tossing hard working people under the bus b/c your so self absorbed to care about anything beyond the tip of your nose!

      integrity check time.

      i know many "under educated" manufacturing workers that have it... i haven't sen that you have it... yet.

    58. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I wonder if all of these programmers in India are even slightly concerned that he ditched out on the (I'm assuming here) more expensive U.S. programmers to hire "more cost effective" employees in India?

      This is called Free Market and Globalization; this is what you voted for when you elected Reagan/Bush. If you do not like competition, then go live in Cuba. What Globalization means is: the best man for the job gets that job. So long as foreigners offer comparable skills for less money, they are the best men for your jobs.

      Why should Microsoft hire a half-skilled programmer for $100k when it can get a better guy for $2k? Hell, why do YOU shop at Walmart? Probably because you do not feel like paying tripple the price for same Chinese-made crap in another store, that's why. Why do you buy Hondas and not GM junk? Because you know your car will not fall apart the moment you drive out of dealer's lot...

      I am sick of those ignorant pricks! I know a dumbass law student, fresh outta college, who feels we owe him $100k-per-year job. Guess what? Nobody owes you anything, you have a right to life liberty and the pursuit of happyness, not to cushy jobs "your ancestors created".

      I understand why you are upset that nobody wants to pay you 120,000 per year to play Doom and keep the phone off the hook, but boo, freaking hoo.

      Eventually, this 'outsourcing' will lead to Indians earning more, and expecting more. As the expected salary in India reaches that in US, there will be no more incentive for US companies to oursource. Hence, Americans will once again be competitive, but only after they will ask for less money than Indians.

    59. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      make all the money you want. but instead of the easy way, ie destroying the livlihoods of thousands by cherry picking and lowballing, try doing the hard work of creating your own industries.

      hy don't you do it and show them how?

      it is really easy to criticize others when you've not done it yuourself, isn't it?

      if you have, just be quiet and hire lots of programmers, ok?

      this is not an american / indian battle.

      this *is* a battle of the wealthy elite against the middle class and below.

      they wet their pants when the peons fight each other...

      you've made bill's pants so wet that he has to change them now.

    60. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by vmalloc_ · · Score: 1

      I think I interpreted your post wrong and I apologize.

      To turn the tables and be harsh about America, I totally agree. Born-in-America Americans are the laziest bastards ever. They want everything to happen for them, not do any work, and just generally stink up the place. And then when somebody else does more work for less and better than they do, they cry foul and scream for protectionism instead of improving productivity and getting some work done. I only know a couple born-in-Americans that actually have ambitious plans AND a good work ethic, and most of the people I know are college students, which is really just sad.

      America is a country where you can succeed if you try hard, read the markets right, and aren't afraid to try new things. But nowadays most people don't want to try at all, they want to work for a couple hours at a boring riskless job and then go home, play playstation, smoke pot and drive a boat around.

      It's the immigrants from countries like India and Japan, ect ect that are really running this country's business. I can only assume its a cultural thing, or maybe it's the crappy schools, but either way I could definetely see America as a receeding power in the future, not because we're not training engineering students like everybody thinks, but because people here are all lazy about work, and don't want to actually apply what they learn into anything new or creative. I'm sick of reading the articles that go like this: "Waahh, I got a college degree, why didn't I instantly get a desk job for it?". Seriously, shut up. I self-learned instead of going to college, I have to earn people's respect through my work rather than a peice of paper that symbolizes my possible ability to do that work, otherwise people think I don't know what I'm doing. Which position would you rather be in?

      So yeah, Americans definetely feel they are "entitled" to the riches of wealth. Hopefully they will put down the bong and quit voting for hack politicans so that we can actually maintain this current growth.

    61. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And for those who think we have no home-grown tech companies, wait and watch. There are companies capable to giving any MNC a run for its money, and is as ruthless as any other (not that I'm happy about this).

      >> so why arent they? Is this like India planning to go to moon?

      Do you know the owners of some of the largest trans-oceanic fiber networks are now Indian companies?

      >> a matter of necessity, not of enterprise.

      >>That some of the largest steel producers in the world are from India?

      wonderful. Is he in INdia? is his firm based in India? is he even living in India?

      what? no? thought so.

      make is such that he can do all this IN india, then talk.

      >>One of the top-three media (cd/dvd/cdr) manufacturers in the world?

      oh which one? blank media or written media? the latter would make sense, with all the bollywood movies and songs being churned out by the second, you need CDs anyway.

      if India is so great, why is it that all you need to have an indian coder all drooling is just an H1 visa paper? anything to get out of India?

      fix things such that India is appealing, not Indians. then we can talk. Make sure that the computer science grads are skilled in algorithms, not some product or end up as low level coders. take pride in wuality, not quantity of 'engineers' being churned out.

      Lastly, do not accuse all westerners of colonialisation. Face it India had the same amt of time and was in much better shape than a war raveged Japan since Independence - look where both are now relatively. Stop blaming British for everything - it's time to fix some things on your own now.

      cheers.

    62. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hey! Guess what! You can say BITCHES!

      BITCHES BITCHES BITCHES BITCHES

      No stupid little * in between the letters, either. Bitch.

    63. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Travoltus · · Score: 1

      [I'm in India, and no I don't see any reason to be even slightly concerned because we're supposedly taking away your God-given right to technology jobs.]

      You keep taking away our good paying jobs and we won't have money to buy your stuff, or identities for your thieves to steal.

      Then your god given right to profits will go right down the toilet.

      When offshoring drains the last of America's middle class jobs and our consumer spending collapses, you will not go to outer space.

      You
      will
      starve.

      --
      --- Grow a pair, liberals... stop letting the Republicans bully you!
    64. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Good attitude in the last paragraph.

      It's nice to see mercenary bastards who admit that they'd be happy to screw the planet over for a few more dollars in their pockets. So many people dissemble and hide behind glib platitudes.

      Not you though!

      You're in this only for yourself, and if anyone gets in your way, you'll destroy them! Who cares about other people? That's not what made your country great, is it? The best way to be is to rip off anyone and everyone, screw them to the wall and rip their hearts out after their pockets are emptied into your own.

      Why, I bet you'd sell your mother for spare parts if there was a dollar in it for you.

      And why not? That's the capitalist ideal!

      Go for it! You're the American Ideal!

    65. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by badmammajamma · · Score: 1

      You need to work on your reading comprehension. I never said I would fuck people over to get what I want. In fact, I do almost everything in my power to not do that even accidentally. However, there are many many people who will. Those are the people at the top of the food chain running things. If you think any different, then you have a lot to learn about how the real world works. Once again, take your sanctimonious shit and shove it up your ass.

      --
      Any man who afflicts the human race with ideas must be prepared to see them misunderstood. -- H. L. Mencken
    66. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The 'real world' doesn't always have to equal 'only caring about MY PORTION' unless people like you make it that way. It's good to see that your preference is to go that way.

      You have fun with it, and don't complain when someone takes your portion away because you were too busy defending it to notice that no-one was willing to stand up for you. That's all outsourcing is, after all - taking away from people whose voice doesn't matter because enough people care only about their personal interests.

      Enjoy your 'real world'. I'll enjoy a world where people look out for each other a bit more, and actually try to care about each other. I suspect I'll be happier in my world.

    67. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by univgeek · · Score: 1

      Heh, that's quite funny. We have the second largest market in the world. Do you really think that in 20 years time, we'll still be dependent on exports to the US as our primary income?

      We don't have a god-given right to profits. Neither do you. What we have is a lot of people. What you have is a lot of land. I'm sure we will work things out eventually.

      Note that I have absolutely nothing against any American as such; I quite enjoyed being in the US and interacting with Americans; they are just as smart as everyone else. Just that when people whine about their jobs being 'stolen', it's pathetic.

      And please, don't worry too much about us starving. We've built up a decent technological base, and quite a decent agricultural base. We'll make do somehow, and we can and will import food if necessary.

      --
      All bow to his Noodliness!! His Noodle Appendage has touched me!
    68. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by univgeek · · Score: 1

      Good to hear you are/were working hard. Sorry to hear you got laid-off.

      But y'know, there are industries in India that have little or nothing to do with exporting products or importing jobs to/from the US. You just haven't heard about them. Assuming that there are a hundred million Indians just thirsting to take your low-paid jobs is a fearful picture, but not quite true.

      And, when did these industries become 'your own'? Are you saying we should stop buying from American companies, because it's better to support our own industries? Or that we should open our market to American companies, because globalisation helps us? At least that's what everyone's been telling us over the past 15 years. We did open our economy, and now that we're on our way to reaping some of the benefits, suddenly some people realise that hey, Indians can actually do the same things we can, and they'll do it for less. And suddenly, it's personal?

      When American/European and Japanese companies destroyed/out-competed our indigenous industries it's fine. But when we, the people, compete with you for your jobs, it's not? Somehow it smells like hypocrisy to me.

      You have the educational institutions, you have the capital, you have the resources. Why d'you want to do the lowball jobs? Start some bio-tech, find out how to generate clean and cheap energy, find out ways to really clean up pollution, and we'll line up at your door to buy from you. If you want to keep the lowball jobs, and you don't want to get educated, or use your capital, well, that's capitalism rolling right over you.

      --
      All bow to his Noodliness!! His Noodle Appendage has touched me!
    69. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      I think you should think twice. You're beginning to sound like the folks you're ranting about.

      I didn't know that working 60 hour work-weeks with 40-year-old World War 2 vintage furniture and 20-year-old red carpet that now passes for grey constituted a cushy job. I didn't know that being on call 24 hours a day 7 days a week, every day of the year, including vacations, constituted cushy as well. In fact, I'm beginning to wonder if you have seen the *real* bowels of American IT Hell. Those people that left the "dot-com" craze? Many were there for the "quick money". The ones that stayed behind, did the difficult work, stayed the course, and did those thankless tasks that kept what little IT staff there was going? Those folks did it for the love of it.

      India has an opportunity, but it's the same opportunity that the Americans had. And you're going to get the same end-result that the Americans had. If you think you are immune from the multi-national hyper-corporation insanity that has gripped our nation, by virtue of "prior conditions", think again. Already the "outsourcing" wave has shifted its nasty-eyed focus away from India and to other countries. Already you are being reduced to the same level as all the other American IT workers - a condition that is hardly cushy and certainly not what you think.

      I'm glad that you feel you can compete. Competition produces superior products in open markets. But have you really considered what will happen? Really thought things through? Is it enough that you have had a tech revolution that has sparked so much of India's growth?

      India is currently believing the same story that all multinationals tell them - we can give you what you want for cheaper, with the side benefits of enabling your economy while providing infinite growth. Then again, anyone with a remedial education might spot the fallacy of this "economic perpetual motion machine".

      I harbour no ill-will against you. I sincerely hope your country grows and prospers. But I hope you don't make the same short-sighted money-oriented mistakes we have made, and are just now beginning to pay dearly for.

      You've had your little rant, now here's mine:

      You seem to have this impression that all American IT workers have these timed 38.5 hour workweeks in hermetically sealed cubicals, using wall-to-wall high-definition plasma displays to pony up the latest first-person-shooter craze while some large nameless box chugs away on code in a corner, only to be followed by a grossly inflated paycheck as compensation for building a blister on your thumb from too much gameplaying. Reality is more like 50 hour weeks when things are slow, 70+ hour weeks when projects are under way, insane "death march" conditions when producing software-as-a-product (think 4 hours of sleep, only breaks to eat and deficate, no days off), frazled network admins running around like chickens with their heads cut off trying to catch the latest virus outbreak before it completely overwhelms the network, windows admins frantically trying to resolve an unresolvable problem because "it's designed that way", non-technical staff dictating technology decisions to technical staff "because the brochure looks good", and other such lunacy. You want this for your country and your industry? Here's a clue: HAVE AT IT! TAKE IT ALL! Enjoy the exquisite agony that is our special brand of IT Hell, made and especially brewed from years of ineptitude and gross negligence. That faint aroma of rot? That's our speciality! It's called "quick-profititus"(tm), and gives it that especially pungant flavor of near-insanity. There's nothing like taking the short-term profit fix and damn everything else to hell (including IT budgets working conditions, and treating workers like human beings instead of replacable machinery), because the board of directors and the stockholders like it that way. And just think, all of this can be YOURS! You can SHARE in this truely miserable experience!

      If you truely value India's IT sector, th

    70. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      When you start importing food, just remember, we'll be remembering what you did to our economy.

      You people think you're aborting baby girls for population control now? Wait'll angry, out of work Americans stop exporting food.

      Payback can be a bitch.

    71. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by univgeek · · Score: 1
      Wow, you're angry --- at the wrong people.

      What did we do to your economy? It's American capitalism which is leading american companies to export jobs to India and China. And you blame India/China for that? Hilarious.

      Oh, and you know what would happen if India/China stopped importing stuff from Europe/America right? We're in this world together, there are some things you guys have more of than us, there are others where we might be better off.

      There used to be a time when America used to be more hungry for success, where doing was seen as more important than talking, and there was no attitude of entitlement. Those days have passed. Look at the whiners around you.

      Oh, and the USA is not the only land-surplus country in the world. Much of South America, Africa and probably parts of Australia can serve as sources of food.


      You people think you're aborting baby girls for population control now? Wait'll angry, out of work Americans stop exporting food.

      Nice comeback. You sound just like an angry 4 year old who has misplaced his toy. Just imagine what India/China and the other third-world countries should do to the 'civilized first-world' for ~100+ years of colonization.

      While we do have a population problem, both India and China are well on the way to controlling the growth. Education seems to do that quite well, and whatever your image of India is, I can assure you that the education levels are increasing (albeit slowly).
      --
      All bow to his Noodliness!! His Noodle Appendage has touched me!
    72. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? by univgeek · · Score: 1


      I didn't know that working 60 hour work-weeks ... constituted a cushy job.

      If you have a job, if you have shelter, it's a cliche, but you have it much better off than most of the world.


      In fact, I'm beginning to wonder if you have seen the *real* bowels of American IT Hell.

      Yep, I've seen it. I was in the US between 2000-2004. I saw the best of times, and the worst of times. And you my friend have no conception of where India and China are coming from. The levels of unemployment, the poverty and hunger have to be seen to be believed. At the very least, in the US it is far harder to actually starve. If you want to survive get a job to live, you can probably do so. The situation in India or China is nowhere near as good.

      My real hope is that this cycle of technology will help us increase our education levels, and our efficiency levels. That will help us feed our millions and enable a better standard of life. The key point that most people seem to miss is that with a billion people market, we really can drive ourself out of the ground. What is needed is initial capital, but given that boom (like for example the wwII spending in the US, or the spending on the space race) we'll probably pull ourselves out of the well.


      I harbour no ill-will against you. I sincerely hope your country grows and prospers. But I hope you don't make the same short-sighted money-oriented mistakes we have made, and are just now beginning to pay dearly for.

      Thanks, I hope we learn from your mistakes. We have already learnt a lot - you'll probably never see India colonizing another country at least, or trying to interfere in their internal affairs. And our democracy (less swayed by talk, and more by raw economics) has already kicked out a couple of governments which were seen as being pro-corporate and anti-poor (Andhra Pradesh, and the Central Govt. too).


      You seem to have this impression that all American IT workers ...

      Nope. Like I said, I've been there. I have friends working there, and I know that the working environment is not rosy at all. I must admit that I know many places where the H1B's have screwed up the work environment, with their work ethic.

      But no, I'm not willing to take the death-march kind of environment, and in fact in quite a few of the startups here, you see the realization that working 60+hrs a week, month after month is counter-productive. What people also fail to notice or mention is that many of the companies in India take on some of the latest processes and try to do work that is state-of-the-art. But you rarely hear of that. Instead what you hear is incessant whining about how we're taking away the 'easy' jobs.

      Re: your point on free/open source vs. MS/Oracle et al.
      Well my friend, do you think that all those Indian's in the US have had their eyes closed for the past 15-20 years? We *are* learning from your lessons. Witness the multiple versions of Linux that have come out in local languages. Witness the state governments setting up school labs with localized RedHat. MS tries very hard to get windows on all machines, but guess what? Cost rules here. MS tries to say that for bulk purchases they'll give Windows for $50 a seat. Well, the govts. are buying whole PC's for $200, because that's all they can afford!! You think they'll pay $50 more? Not happening.

      Many people do see MS as a welcome opportunity --- to work for MS guarantees wealth (in relative terms) and is therefore a good thing. However, in the market, cost will rule. The indian market (for telecom too) is the most cost-competitive in the world. Our call rates (cellphone) are among the lowest in the world --- Rs 1.80(4c) per min to any cell in India. If similar functionalities, as present in Windows, can be provided everyone *will* take linux. You don't have t

      --
      All bow to his Noodliness!! His Noodle Appendage has touched me!
  23. Code for Bill? by fmaxwell · · Score: 5, Funny

    Addressing 5,000 developers in Bangalore, Bill Gates announced the Code4Bill contest

    As opposed to the "Code4Food" contest that they've been participating in?

    1. Re:Code for Bill? by Cowboy+Bill · · Score: 2, Funny

      Err.. Who do you think needs the Code4Food contest more? The devs in India or US? :)

      --
      --> Your Wisecrack Here
    2. Re:Code for Bill? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Prepare your future generation for "Code4Food". Indians donated 50 millon USD to US for Katrina relief ;)

    3. Re:Code for Bill? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      >> Err.. Who do you think needs the Code4Food contest more?
      >> The devs in India or US? :)

      Considering the fact that if I (in the US) didn't have my job then I would go hungry too (no income then money for food) I would say that both the US and India needs the "Code4Food contest" equally.

    4. Re:Code for Bill? by fmaxwell · · Score: 1

      Indians donated 50 millon USD to US for Katrina relief ;)

      Castro offered assistance, too, but that doesn't mean that Cuba is financially better off than we are.

  24. Truth be told . . . by kratei · · Score: 5, Insightful

    If I was a poor middle class Indian geek I don't think I would mind interning with microshaft for a year. Would you? It certainly wouldn't hurt to have "winner of the Code4Bill" contest on your resume. But, give me a break, can't he come up with a better name for this contest? It sounds both egotsitical and condescending to me.

    1. Re:Truth be told . . . by fishyfool · · Score: 1

      Sure, How about Bill and Steve's IP adventure, Or Ode to the Code. Better yet, Bill's Code monkey flunky search

      --
      Enjoy Every Sandwich
    2. Re:Truth be told . . . by xs650 · · Score: 1
      It sounds both egotsitical and condescending to me.

      At least give Bill some credit for honesty...intentional or not.

  25. Bill's always whining about American CS... by bstarrfield · · Score: 5, Insightful

    So why doesn't he have such a program in the United States? Funny, though, I've never seen the American - or Canadian, or British version - of the Code4Bill contest. Guess expensive developers aren't really wanted at Microsoft.

    How are we supposed to motivate college students to enter computer science when the (sadly) premier computer software maker stages competitions to find the very same programmers who may well replace American workers. What bloody hypocrisy Gates has to complain about the state of American CS while at the same time doing his damn best to destroy it.

    Bill can recruit programmers from anywhere he wants. But he can try to find the best here, too.

    --
    /* Dang, I can't type that well. */
    1. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by YrWrstNtmr · · Score: 1
      So why doesn't he have such a program in the United States?

      They do. Its called the standard job application process.

      Post a notice on Monster.
      Gather several thousand resumes.
      Pick 20 or so for further review.
      1 lucky person actually gets the job.

    2. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by qbwiz · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Hey, Microsoft just sponsored a puzzle-solving competition here at CMU. And they're (or at least Bill is) sponsoring a large portion of a new CS building for our school. I guess that their contributions in the US just aren't that visible.

      --
      Ewige Blumenkraft.
    3. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by lightknight · · Score: 1
      Don't know about college students, but there was a thing for teens a few years ago.

      PressPass

      --
      I am John Hurt.
    4. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by addaon · · Score: 1

      Is Bill actually sponsoring a large portion, or as little as possible? Here at Stanford apparently he asked "how little can I get away with paying for and still get my name on the side?" The answer was 10% of the new Gates Computer Science building.

      --

      I've had this sig for three days.
    5. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by brilinux · · Score: 1

      CMU, though, is known as one of the best places at which to study CS. Mr. Gates just figures that he should get his grip on them like he did with Stanford and MIT's CS departments, by having his name in prominent places and getting students used to Windows. Whether this will work, is of course, up for debate, especially since they seem to keep pushing back the building of the Gates Centre. CMU seems inclined of late, though, to go with proprietary technology more than their own lately, much of which includes Microsoft products, despite that there has always been a resentment against Microsoft in the CS department.
      The point is, though, that Mr. Gates has identified places in the U.S. where he does think that CS is decent, and would like to get influence on them. And CMU does send a large percentage of its CS grads to Microsoft, for better or for worse (though I hear that their research group is not bad, but I hate their software). We will see. I am still somewhat glad that the $2x10^7 that he gave to us is not coming out of our tuition, though (the building costs 6x10^7 to build, and was going to be built regardless of whether he gave us the cash).

    6. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by brilinux · · Score: 1

      Here it is 33%. See my other post. In our case, though, it actually does help.

    7. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by Jester99 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      So why doesn't he have such a program in the United States? ... How are we supposed to motivate college students to enter computer science when the (sadly) premier computer software maker stages competitions to find the very same programmers who may well replace American workers.

      It's called ImagineCup.

      And this year it is being held in India, as well, actually. But it's a world-wide competition for college students in CS. I met one of the world finalists -- he was thrilled by it. But the point is, there are plenty of competitions. And there are plenty of ways for American students to get ahead. The fact that Bill's sponsoring an additional competition in India is hardly a slap in the face of American students. There are literally hundreds of engineering competitions for American students to enter in. Just because you're not aware of all of Microsoft's efforts doesn't mean you're allowed to criticise them out of ignorance.

    8. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by ndogg · · Score: 1

      Funny, though, I've never seen the American - or Canadian, or British version - of the Code4Bill contest.
      Hey, don't encourage him. It's bad enough that he decided to place Microsoft headquarters here.

      --
      // file: mice.h
      #include "frickin_lasers.h"
    9. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by I'm+Don+Giovanni · · Score: 1

      Um, what exactly is your point? It's not like his only contributing 10% (likely far more than anyone else contributed), prevented the building from getting done. What, he should have contributed more for no reason?

      I know that Stanford has an undergraduate education fund that alums contribute to, known as The Stanford Fund. Contributers that donate at least $10K in a single year are recognized by being placed on the "Presidential Fund" contributers list. I wouldn't be surprised if many on that list donate exactly $10K and no more, just to be put on the list. That is, they ask themselves, "What is the minimum that I can contribute to be put on the Presidential Fund contributers list?" (similar to the action for which you condemn Gates). Is something wrong with that?

      Things like the "Presidential Fund" list and getting a building named after you are contribution incentives, and they're designed to intice one to contribute a certain amount, not but not necessarily any more than that. And such incentives work quite well.

      --
      -- "I never gave these stories much credence." - HAL 9000
    10. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by furorimpius · · Score: 1

      Yes. Damn Bill Gates for trying to destroy American CS.

      --Comment posted from the endowed William H. Gates Computer Science Building at Stanford University.--

    11. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by addaon · · Score: 1

      For the record, there were two separate individual contributors who gave more for the Gates building than Gates.

      --

      I've had this sig for three days.
    12. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by Pantero+Blanco · · Score: 1

      Hey, dude. You've been pre-empted.

    13. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by Lost+my+religion · · Score: 1
      Guess expensive developers aren't really wanted at Microsoft.
      Why would any sane business want to pay more when they can get the same quality/services for cheaper? This IS capitalism. Any company deviating from this would be labelled communist/socialist.
      How are we supposed to motivate college students to enter computer science when the (sadly) premier computer software maker stages competitions to find the very same programmers who may well replace American workers.
      I am no fan of M$, but they have been investing in the education system in the US. As another poster pointed out, they sponsored a puzzle solving competition between U of Michigan, CMU and Toronto starting last year (more univs have been added this year). Besides, the Bill Gates Foundation does a significant amount of philanthropic and charitable work in the US.

      Microsoft is a global corporation and they have to invest in the societies from which they expect to draw talent, whether it be the US or India or any other country (at least for the sake of PR and projecting an image of a socially responsible corporate citizen).
      If Microsoft limited its market only to the US, your arguments and expectations would hold some water. But as they are selling their products in other countries, they are no longer exclusively a US company, and have to participate in the local politics and socities.

      I would have modded the above post as -1: Parochial, but as an Indian (who has studied in one of the top US universities (MSEE)) hence decided to reply.
    14. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by sgt_doom · · Score: 1

      One serious comment this time: I think it has been quite awhile since M$ could find the best programmers in America to work for them due to the manner in which Gates & Co. behave towards the American programmer. Probably, good programmers (not great ones) joined M$ up until about '94 or '95, then people began to realize the M$ agenda in bringing in all those East Asians (Indians and Paks), etc.

    15. Re:Bill's always whining about American CS... by dswt · · Score: 1

      ACM Student Research Competition is sponsored by Microsoft Research:
      http://www.acm.org/src/

      These other Microsoft-sponsored student competitions are more pointedly international, but US students can enter:
      http://thespoke.net/Imagine/ (6 different CS and applied CS themes)
      http://www.windowschallenge.com/ (Embedded Systems)

  26. Or if you lived in the Soviet Union .. by Billly+Gates · · Score: 1
    .. The chair would throw Balmer.

    1. Re:Or if you lived in the Soviet Union .. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Only in Soviet Russia.

    2. Re:Or if you lived in the Soviet Union .. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      But not in Nebraska.

  27. What the heck? by cosmotron · · Score: 0

    I could have sworn Bill Gates said that he was looking for more American Computer Science majors...and now he is doing an Indian contest? What the heck?!

    --
    Ryan - http://www.thecosmotron.com/
  28. There will be no shortage of participants by ankarbass · · Score: 1

    Because there is no shortage of Indian programmers who want this opportunity to get a foot in the american door of opportunity. T

    --
    Wanted: Clever sig, top $ paid, all offers considered.
  29. Not the Apprentice for the dark side by Tjp($)pjT · · Score: 3, Funny

    I ate lunch with Donald Trump, I knew Donald Trump, Donald Trump was a client of mine. Mr. Gates, you are no Donald Trump.

    --
    - Tjp

    I am in wallow with my inner money grubbing capitalistic pig. ... Oink!

  30. Developers, developers, developers, developers! by nephridium · · Score: 2, Funny
    Ah thank god it was Bill Gates. You all remember Ballmer's "Developers" video - imagine him in Bangalore doing the exact same thing - but due to the lack of air conditioning WITHOUT his shirt. ;)

    Thank you, I'll be here all week.

    --


    And when you gaze long enough into the code, the code will also gaze into you.
  31. Link to Microsoft's Superhero-The Developer's Song by theodp · · Score: 2, Interesting
  32. Real reason: Distract effort from KDE India by bstadil · · Score: 3, Insightful
    KDE India was apparently just formed.

    Draw your own conclusion ;-)

    Kde India Announcement

    --
    Help fight continental drift.
    1. Re:Real reason: Distract effort from KDE India by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You are a moron.

      Microsoft has been in India for a while and as much as Linux penguin thumpers fantasize about MS going away, it is not,

  33. ...jkl by Billly+Gates · · Score: 1

    Sounds like google's summer code contest

  34. wouldn't it be cool by Khashishi · · Score: 2, Funny

    Wouldn't it be cool if whoever won this contest turned down the job offer?

    1. Re:wouldn't it be cool by vandit2k6 · · Score: 1

      Why even waste time participating in this bs contest.

      --
      Its nice to be important but its more important to be nice
  35. Me too by hoshino · · Score: 2, Informative
    1. Re:Me too by Aranth+Brainfire · · Score: 1

      It wasn't all that bad.

      (opinion parries and counters opinion!)

      --
      "Quoting yourself is stupid." -Me
    2. Re:Me too by Pantero+Blanco · · Score: 1

      It was exaggerative, but I still liked it.

      They did an interesting job of covering their ass on the avoiding-slander issue by working Bill's name into a minor dialogue in the movie:

      "Doesn't Bill Gates have one of those?"
      "Bill who?"

    3. Re:Me too by Knightmare · · Score: 1

      The movie isn't very good, but I have a huge thing for Claire Forlani so the movie always seems ok when I watch it :)

  36. Re:Link to Microsoft's Superhero-The Developer's S by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Wow - and I thought the OpenBSD songs were bad. :P

  37. translation... by JoeCommodore · · Score: 2, Insightful
    Here's my take on it:

    Hey, you 5,000 developers, why don't you do a bunch of Microsoft Windows coding and propoganda for us* (for free) and we in turn will employ a handfull of you for all your combined effort. Now get started!

    * all entries and innovation become the property of Microsoft.

    --
    "Enjoy what you're doing! If it becomes drudgery, you're doing it wrong!" - Jim Butterfield
    1. Re:translation... by professorhojo · · Score: 1

      right. for eight months!

    2. Re:translation... by GoofyBoy · · Score: 1

      A 5000 developers will jump at the chance.

      So who exactly are the smart ones?

      --
      The surprise isn't how often we make bad choices; the surprise is how seldom they defeat us.
    3. Re:translation... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, just like ALL the Open source software out there.

      > Code for free
      > Submit it for free
      > Lose your intellectual property to GPL
      > Gain no recognition except if you are Linus, RMS, etc.
      > Gain no money (thx to point 1 and 2)
      > Have no life (since you still need a paying job to live)

    4. Re:translation... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hey everyone, pay attention to this guy. He obviously knows what he's talking about!

      Because he's actually done open source development and is talking from his experience, rather than being an unpaid MS shill talking from his asshole, right?

    5. Re:translation... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      hehe yeah, Open Source is for Communists, too.

      Communists and other filthy scrubs.

    6. Re:translation... by JoeCommodore · · Score: 1
      > Code for free
      Some people like coding, even on stuff they don't get paid for.

      > Submit it for free
      There are people that like showing off and/or contributing to a good idea.

      > Lose your intellectual property to GPL

      You don't loose your intellect, and it's more like you protect your property from not being accessible also you don't loose your idea, you can use it whenever you want, just that YOU retain the rights to what you do.

      > Gain no recognition except if you are Linus, RMS, etc.
      Like Bill Gates will give you props on the Windows Box for coding that new multi-million making new Audio Codec? Under the GPL your credits and source are required to stay with the code, and there are more notable names in the FOSS field, but I guess you are those one name (Bill Gates) kind of guys.

      > Gain no money (thx to point 1 and 2)
      Have something real on your resume besides certificates with a bunch of letters (especially if it is a high profile project or popular idea), demonstrate you know how to code and retain the right to do such coding. In a lot of employment clauses you actually loose your rights to code at what you do best whenever you like.

      Have better programs as you have contributed in fixing bugs or adding features, so you can do your work better.

      Give grandma an opportunity for less viruses and loosing her personal information while surfing the internet.

      Make a free alternative to computer applications that have been around for DECADES to force 'innovative' companies to get past milking thier dead (cash) cow OS and office suite and actually start doing something... innovative.

      > Have no life (since you still need a paying job to live)
      a) I take it you don't like computers, do you?
      b) You have a very limited definition for 'living'
      c) You have just enough brains to hold down a job and little else.

      --
      "Enjoy what you're doing! If it becomes drudgery, you're doing it wrong!" - Jim Butterfield
  38. Not Interested by Rohit_K · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I am a software engineer in Bangalore, and honestly I find this "contest" a bit condescending. I mean, why should I jump through hoops to work at Microsft? If I wanted to work at a large company, I can apply to Oracle, Sun, IBM, Yahoo or Google (all of whom have development centres in Bangalore).

    The only situation where I can imagine myself competing against 5000 developers for a single job would be if I was fanatical about the organisation (e.g., Google), and I certainly don't feel that way about MS.

    1. Re:Not Interested by latencylatencylatenc · · Score: 1

      Good for you, I think this type of competition is bullshit.

    2. Re:Not Interested by sirdude · · Score: 1
      Titled "Code 4 Bill", the contest will provide the best pre-final and final year student technologists an opportunity to showcase their talent and join Gates' technical assistants team for a year.

      From the TOI.. I don't see what everybody is getting so worked up about.. it's just a talent contest for college students ffs..

      -K
    3. Re:Not Interested by amightywind · · Score: 1

      I am a software engineer in Bangalore, and honestly I find this "contest" a bit condescending.

      Ya think?

      I mean, why should I jump through hoops to work at Microsft? If I wanted to work at a large company, I can apply to Oracle, Sun, IBM, Yahoo or Google (all of whom have development centres in Bangalore).

      So you are saying that although you would not drop your shorts for Bill Gates, you would happily do so for Larry Elison or Scott McNealy? Gandi's ashes are spinning in their urn.

      --
      an ill wind that blows no good
    4. Re:Not Interested by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You forgot to mention working for the google boys bub

    5. Re:Not Interested by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Maybe if u did some actual programming you wouldnt worry about losing your job asshole

  39. Spyware? by cebesius · · Score: 1

    Code4Bill... sounds eerily reminiscent of a spyware program I once had to uninstall from someone's PC. What exactly will these people be coding?

    1. Re:Spyware? by alphamugwump · · Score: 1

      Right. Bill is trying to snap up Indian programmers so that he can finish his doomsday device sooner.

    2. Re:Spyware? by slashname3 · · Score: 1

      They will be working on Vista of course. Isn't that suppose to be delivered sometime next year? Well just like in college most programmers wait until the night before to get their semester projects completed. Microsoft is no different. The marketing group has been pitching this great new OS and writing marketing collateral for the last year. They finally called up the tech group and said this is what they need. The tech group came back laughing saying something like "the only way you can get it next year is to have 2000 programmers work on it....". And the contest was created! So now each programmer will be assigned specific modules to complete. The best thing is all this will be done for free!

      And if it does not get done next week I understand Balmer is buying a really big dog and practicing saying, "well see, my dog ate the CD...".

  40. Ok kid, here's how to be like your idol... by bADlOGIN · · Score: 5, Funny

    From TFA:

    "I want to be like him. I am a huge admirer," said 24-year old Naveen Rao, a development engineer with the outsourcing company Aditi Technologies.

    Well, for starters, you need to drop out of an elite college just before you would have been thrown out for skipping classes. If you've already earned a college degree, forget everything you've learned. Get the point here? Next, since you're mom is rich and has big business connections through charity work, use those connections to steal someone elses product (a crappy OS simular to CPM) and pass it off as yours to a big dumb company with deep pockets.

    Are you getting the point now? After a few years of screwing the company you sold the product to, cut a deal with them to make a better product. Screw them over again by stealing yet another product by hijacking a product team working nearby that's been cancled (perhaps its a GUI on top of VMS by a guy named Cavid Duttler). Use this stolen product team to plow the compnay that gave you the big start (don't worry, your mom's friend moved on long ago).

    Is it starting to sink in yet? From there, you just keep going with whatever makes you money and screws hard working programmers over. Hijack a web browser from some poor startup (make sure they rhyme with "eyeglass").
    Through all of this, if you want to go after something, just throw money at it and duplicate features other companies have done the hard work for. By version 3 you'll figure it out more or less. If not, you can just spend them out of the market.

    Truth is, if you want to be like Bill Gates, all you don't need any technical tallent. And, if you admire Bill Gates, you have a serious lack of ethics.

    --
    *** Sigs are a stupid waste of bandwidth.
    1. Re:Ok kid, here's how to be like your idol... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Wow, I didn't know that he did all that cool stuff. I want to be like him. I am huge admirer.

    2. Re:Ok kid, here's how to be like your idol... by sgt_doom · · Score: 1
      While your post was commendably encyclopedic in nature, there was one point you neglected to cover:

      Be sure to license as many other companies' software as possible and then copy that software into your own OS, claiming you are adding "new" and "innovative" features.

      Remember, it's all "by design" .....

  41. It's called cheap labor by Harker · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I mean, why hire all those people here in the US of A, and help the economy just a little bit, when you can support a foreign economy and pay 1/10th (that's probably an exaggeration) the amount while your at it.

    Typical of way too many companies here in the US, they'd rather save money and make the bottom line look better, than actually support their own economy. It's not like the bigwigs have to worry about budgets or anything...

    [/soapbox]

    H.

    --
    When VCR's are outlawed, only outlaws will have VCR's.
  42. reminds me of a joke... by jayloden · · Score: 4, Funny

    "it's like competing in the special olympics. Even if you win, you're still retarded"

    NOTE: the above is a *joke*. If you do not have a sense of humor, please ignore this comment and move on.

    1. Re:reminds me of a joke... by agurkan · · Score: 1

      do you realize that jokes can be offensive as well? maybe not as much as insults, but they still can.

      --
      ato
    2. Re:reminds me of a joke... by Bronster · · Score: 1

      ... but if you stand on the table you can see EVERYTHING.

      People who want to be offended can be offended by just about anything.

    3. Re:reminds me of a joke... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well no shit Sherlock. What are you, some kinda retard?

    4. Re:reminds me of a joke... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I would have simply said, "Even if you win, you're still Indian."

  43. I know! by twitter · · Score: 0
    this reminds me of Mr. Trump. Just don't know how!

    That's easy: He told 5,000 people to get to work right now, "code for Bill." At the same time, he told 4,999 of them they were fired.

    Something tells me the man who disparages US education is going to soon tell a few thousand US programmers the same thing.

    Ah, the wonderful closed source lie: sell me your effort and I will make you rich. It's about as believable as the last BSA wopper: buy closed source junk and you will magically have more money! Why do people listen to this BS?

    --

    Friends don't help friends install M$ junk.

    1. Re:I know! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      I expect you made the same comment when IBM moved 14,000 (that's fourteen thousand jobs) earlier this year to India, right? Or do you limit your strange comments to things Microsoft has not even done?

      Just wondering.

    2. Re:I know! by Fulcrum+of+Evil · · Score: 1

      Ah, the wonderful closed source lie: sell me your effort and I will make you rich.

      In all fairness, Microsoft has created a truly shocking number of millionaire workers. Myself, I'll not look to employment to make me rich - I'm trying to find a business plan that I can use to do it for myself.

      --
      "We returned the General to El Salvador, or maybe Guatemala, it's difficult to tell from 10,000 feet"
    3. Re:I know! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      God bless you...

      --Signed, anonymous entrepreneur with millions...

    4. Re:I know! by petermgreen · · Score: 1

      yep ms rocketed to success and took its early employees (who were in share schemes etc) with it.

      but that isn't going to happen for you if you work for them now! They are a big company who have little opertunity to grow except through the growth of the entire industry or through abusing thier existing customers more (but that would likely hasten thier demise).

      --
      note: i'm known as plugwash most places but i screwd up registering that here somehow in the past and now can't register
  44. Reality TV by DigiShaman · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Sounds more like The Apprentice (reality TV show). This will be interesting how geeks backstab eachother for a seat next to the very "one" they loath.

    --
    Life is not for the lazy.
    1. Re:Reality TV by toddbu · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Just wait until one of them gets hit in the head by a ceiling tile. Omarosa, move over. (Actually, we call her "Osamarosa" over here.)

      --
      If you don't want crime to pay, let the government run it.
    2. Re:Reality TV by MrShaggy · · Score: 1

      Yes I was thinking along the same lines, however, it oculd be more 2 minutes of them programming, then 45 minutes of blue screen. ;)

      --
      I have mod points and I am not afraid to use them.
  45. Contest rules by Spy+der+Mann · · Score: 4, Funny

    1. Whoever makes the first blue screen, wins!

    2. Flying chairs screensavers earn a second place.

    3. the third place, Assistant programmer, will be awarded to the one who makes a program whose clippy assistant says "Developers Developers Developers!" repeatedly.

    4. Everyone in the country will be accepted to participate.

    4b. Except in Nebraska!

  46. And in other news by toolz · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    The KDE Project announces KDE.in.

    This is a direct outcome of the the recently concluded FOSS.IN/2005 conference.

    --
    You aren't remembered for doing what is expected of you
  47. Actually an attack on Google. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Actually, this is an attack on Google's image. "Hear hear, we are Microsoft, we only get the best. Techies love us and will compete to have the honour of joining us."

    Nice attempt at trying to hype and bump up your image, Microsoft.

  48. Weakest Link by LittleBigScript · · Score: 3, Funny

    So on Bill Gates team you get the privledge of getting coffee for the richest man in the world. Ah, status.

  49. Re:RIP TIMECOP by Commander+Trollco · · Score: 0, Funny

    muh dick nigguh muh dick

    --
    http://persianews.on.nimp.org/?u=Tar_Baby
  50. Forget programming. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Your future is obviously as a comedian.

  51. Why don't they do this here? by Ryouga3 · · Score: 1

    I'd like the opportunity to compete for a Microsoft job. I suppose I could send in an application, but I doubt that you can get even close if you don't know someone and conform to the certain demographic criteria. Plain and simple, you have to be like the people that are already there to get a job, as is true for any job. However, an open challenge like this would even the score. Microsoft could help their reputation if they'd set up something like this in the U.S.

    1. Re:Why don't they do this here? by BitchKapoor · · Score: 1

      Though I hate Microsoft with a passion, I know plenty of people who work there. Are you a pretty good programmer and do you actually want a job there? If so, I can try to help you out. Just reply if you're interested.

  52. Set the bar high by Belseth · · Score: 1

    The original contest was to write a virus to infect windows messenger but they decided the contest should be more challenging. The new contest is to write Linux viruses. He figured it'd killed two birds with one stone.

  53. Microsoft is to India....... by ShyGuy91284 · · Score: 1

    As Google is to America....... Or at least that's what this contest makes it sound like....

    --
    In undeveloped countries, the consumer controls the market. In capitalist America, the market controls you.
  54. Re:Link to Microsoft's Superhero-The Developer's S by Nahooda · · Score: 1

    Look at "Download Song"! They even outsourced recording to India!!!

    --
    Sigs suck!
  55. Re:Ethics anyone? by symbolic · · Score: 1

    I'm guessing (and hoping) that US programmers are more intelligent than this. Just after reading about FogCreek Software's up-and-coming documentary (12 Geeks, 12 weeks), I started to wonder about the ethical side. "Give us the best you've got, and if we like what we see, we may keep you around." In the fine print (I'm guessing), "even if we don't, we we'll keep your code and/or reuse the ideas in any manner we please." If there's any merit to this, suddenly, these kind of efforts don't sound all that attractive any more.

  56. Actually. . . by jmenon · · Score: 1


    ...that's from a New York Times retrospective from 1976.

    The part of the article they edited out was:

    "The 21-year-old Mr. Gates, on a family Christmas vacation to India, explained his vision to the 5,000 cotton, soybean, and bajra crop developers gathered in the capital of the southern Indian state of Karnataka: 'The winner of our contest will receive an invitation to the United States, a place to live in my friend Paul's basement, and a position on my team.'

    "Sources close to Microsoft told the New York Times that although there are plenty of qualified candidates for the new position in the United States, the current company budget required a more creative approach to find one."

    --
    "Stop throwing the Constitution in my face! It's just a goddamned piece of paper!" -- George W. Bush
    1. Re:Actually. . . by chottabacha · · Score: 1

      You seems lost in present,therefore you will loose many of future. Indians taking care of the present , they will take care of future too, i.e. in cotton, steel, food, IT, any damn thing. Pure rotation of power, east to west to east....

  57. Better Strategy by serutan · · Score: 1

    1. Get a job at an outsourcing company that does Microsoft contracts.
    2. Work on one of those projects.
    3. Get converted to Microsoft FTE along with half the project team.

    It happens this way ALL THE TIME, and you don't have to beat 5000 other programmers in some contest, you just have to be in the top half of the team you're on.

  58. Re:Link to Microsoft's Superhero-The Developer's S by Pantero+Blanco · · Score: 1

    Not as bad as IBM's.

  59. Darth side by sbenitezb · · Score: 1

    Great. Now Darth Sidious will meet his Darth Maul.

  60. They'll need it by linforcer · · Score: 0

    Twenty finalists will receive internships with Microsoft India before one Superhero is selected to join Mr. Gates's own team."

    Lord knows Microsoft needs a Superhero to counter all the bad code they've written so far.

  61. Dear Code4Bill by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    Please see attached program. I hope very much to work for Microsoft and feel I have all the right qualitys to do a very good job.

    hellobill.bas
    ---
    Const longintStrHELLOBILL = "Hello, Bill!"
    Dim intX,StrY,LongStrZ,doubleWordByteI

    REM Create something very important for the program
    REM
    For doubleWordByteI = intX To Ubound(StrY)
                    set objMyDictionary = CreateObject("Dictionary")
    Next

    Do While (intX doubleWordByteI)
                    LongStrZ = LongStrZ & Chr(intX)
                    If (objMyDictionary.ItemNotExist(StrY)) Then
                    End If
    Loop
    set objMyDictionary = Nothing

    REM if StrY = objDictionary.Item(doubleQuadNibbleString) then
    REM print the greeting to bill
    REM VERY IMPORTANT TO NOT CHANGE IF YOU DON'T KNOW HOW IT WORKS!!!
    REM
    If (StrY = objDictionary.Item(doubleQuadByteNibbleString)) Then
                    Print "Hello, Bill!"
    End If

  62. Give me the winner's code, and by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Give me that guy's code, and I'll find at least a dozen things in it that are pretty much fireable offenses in any reasonably disciplined dev org. During my time at Microsoft (5+ years), I've known no less than 50 Indian SDEs (MSFT jargon for software developer). Only two of them could write what I'd call "good code". One of these two was a freakin' genius, but I digress. I don't know if it's cultural or not, but it seems that Indians are predisposed to writing horribly convoluted, unmaintainable cut&paste garbage (sorry, I can't call _this_ "code"). For most of them, if it works _somehow_ means it's good enough. If it were up to me, half of these folks (not just Indian, of course) would be gone and the rest would be scared of checking in atrocities they check in right now for others to rewrite later.

    And the thing is, the culture at MSFT is such that you can't just email into dev team alias and say "this is crap, and this needs to be rewritten". You'd "hurt people's feelings", which will affect your yearly review, pushing it towards (or below) 3.5 grade, for which you get bonus and stock grant that may or may not cover the cost of living. So folks just shut up and suffer.

    Actually, I think Vista will be pretty interesting to watch. It is now mandatory in many (if not all) teams at MSFT to outsource at least something across all disciplines. They outsource mostly Test, but since you have to outsource Dev and PM, too, some of Dev and PM work gets done in IDC (India Development Center). Generally, whatever comes from there ends up being rewritten by non-Indian devs in Redmond, on their own time, because you aren't going to tell your (most likely Indian) manager that the code that came from IDC fucking sucks. As pressure goes up in the ship cycle, folks in Redmond have less and less time to rewrite IDC garbage, so it gets checked in (and shipped) as-is. So I fully expect Vista to be a fuckup of gigantic proportions, until at least SP1.

    The sad part is, people will buy it anyway.

    BTW, this is not a racist or anti-outsourcing rant. Test folks in China did (and no doubt still do) a stellar job. I'm just puzzled that Indians fuck up so badly time after time. If you guys are reading this, you've got to realize that sooner or later it will become clear to the higher ups that company money is better spent in China, despite pretty shitty English that Chinese folks speak.

    1. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I have never lived in India, much less attended they're universities, but from my experience in the Philippines, it doesn't surprise me too much. I don't mean that the Indians (or Filippinos) are inherintly stupid or anything - that couldn't be furthur from the truth. The problem is that the get such a terrible education.

      The other day my brothers friend (in college) had a research report he had to do about HTML, Javascript, and the lot. He asked me were to start looking so I told him about w3.org. Then I watched in amazement as he went and copied and pasted entire pages. He finished the assignment in 3 minutes and learned absolutly nothing. I've been told this sort of plagarism is pretty common and accepted here. If it's the same in India, I'm not surprised that the people have such a poor education. It's not because they're stupid.

      BTW, I posted as AC because I'm on someone elses computer. If you want to verify what I've written here, my website and contact info and such are at http://jellybean.uni.cc/

    2. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

      Wow, I'm glad to know I'm not the only one who has felt that way. I've worked with other outsourcers in Eastern Europe, and the code from their senior devs was always comparable to US senior devs. With India outsourcing, though, I usually feel it would take me less time to write the code myself than it does to code read and fix what I get. Here is an example:


      boolean isBarSelected = bar.isSelected();
      boolean returnValue;
      if (isBarSelected) {
              returnValue = true;
      } else {
              returnValue = false;
      }
      return returnValue;


      Why in god's name would someone ever write code like this?

    3. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny
      Another example:

      int a;
      ...
      if (a != 0) a = 0;
      ...
    4. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Because they're cheap and they multiply like cockroaches. Once you get one on your dev team the malaise spreads
      throught your code base like wild fire.

      Pretty soon, after stabbing the right people in the back, they'll be managers and will proceed to hire more of same.

      - Moomin

    5. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by marcosdumay · · Score: 1

      It is not an absurd situation to get bad code from people that where hired because they ask for a low salary. In fact, it would be surprising if you get some competent people this way. That should happen independently of this people being from US, India or Moldova.

      And no, I am not saying that from India.

    6. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The sad part is, people will buy it anyway

      But isn't that M$ strategy so that people keep coming back in hope of getting bugs fixed?

    7. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by kopykat · · Score: 1

      go to unix.com see how many indians are on the moderator list and can't code worth a penny! no racism intended but their just not educated or created for this type of credential... . i think bill is in on something more than just code and internships : he's looking for political scandals to cover for any mistakes he makes in the future.. where else to find it than in the third world..

    8. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by Pathetic+Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

      You left out a few lines:

      boolean isBarSelected = bar.isSelected();
      boolean returnValue;
      boolean result;
      if (isBarSelected) {
                      result = true;
      }
      if (!isBarSelected){
                      result = false;
      }

      if (isBarSelected && !isBarSelected) {
                    result = false;
      }

      returnValue = result;
      return returnValue;

      I actually saw code like this in a production system only it was far worse. Said code was framed on my office wall.

    9. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by NilleKopparmynt · · Score: 5, Insightful

      I totally agree with you but I think your aim is a bit off. I do not see the engineers from India as competitors. I see it as my managers just gives my job away to anyone they feel like. If my manager does not value my competence there is nothing I can do about it.

      The company I work for outsource projects to Wipro and TCS. The thing that is strange is that any person they send is automatically accepted as an engineer without any tests or screening what so ever. Ofcourse this is now being abused and I am now seeing 24 year old graduates arriving into mission critical projects.

      The problem is that management is seeing software development as hard as digging a ditch. You just give anyone (preferebly the cheapest one) a shovel and off he/she go. The thing that is most funny is that in the company I work for it is all based on a lie. My manager plus a senior manager I spoke to 2 days ago claims that I cost 4 times as much as a resource from India. This is not true. What they are comparing is my funny money internal cost with the real fee from Wipro or TCS. What I really cost is 1.5 times. (+ the cost for my office) Of the cost for my salary the Swedish government is taking 55% and when ever I buy something I pay around 25% sales tax. (Food is 12.5% and taxi/bus is 6%) so in the end I might earn LESS than my Indian counterpart.

      I want to finish off my rant with a quote from a management book, Object Technology - A Manager's Guide. Page 11. I think this quote explaines quite well managements view on us software developers. "For most business people, polymorphism is so obvious that they have a hard time seeing what is so special about it"

    10. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by smittyoneeach · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      I dunno. I was just delving into the joy of SQLServer. I wanted to query against a DATETIME field, and build a string, say, "FY05" from that field.
      Lot of cognitive dissonance how that game is played. I guess they have a lot of that calculation stuff sitting right in the database engine, as opposed to farming it out to an expression library when evaluating the query.
      Not the cleanest looking thing I've ever seen, he said, not really wanting to troll.
      Truly, I wish that the project could just use PostGREsql, and compile in Python support, but I guess I'd have to start my own company to achieve such feats of common sense.

      --
      Get thee glass eyes, and, like a scurvy politician, seem to see things thou dost not.--King Lear
    11. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Object Technology - A Manager's Guide. Page 11. I think this quote explaines quite well managements view on us software developers. "For most business people, polymorphism is so obvious that they have a hard time seeing what is so special about it"

      To me this seems like a critique on the business people :-)

    12. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by dodobh · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Most good people I know refuse to work for Wipro and TCS. There are a few at Infosys, but that is about a handful. The coders you get sent there are probably low rung, cheap people who get paid a _lot_ more offsite. The Indian developers cost is probably around 300 USD/mth, and he gets about 1200 USD/mth additionally for living out of India.

      What Wipro et al bill you for is the sales and management overheads. It might end up being cheaper for your company to just open an office in Pune/Hyderabad and start a local subsidary. You will also get better people.

      --
      I can throw myself at the ground, and miss.
    13. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      Are you talking about Indians or Java programmers?

    14. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by chottabacha · · Score: 0

      I have coded for last 8 years. I have worked with Americans, Europeans, Indians and lot many other country developers. I DONT THINK every American is genius neither every European and neither every Indian. May be you need to "learn" how to choose to work with best people or "get what you need from deveolopers". Otherwise in this colloborative world, you will be left alone. ;) so next time....

    15. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by jack_csk · · Score: 1

      That reminds me of Microsoft Access code that I inherited (which has no else in a bunch of ifs), and which was written by a third-party consulting company.

    16. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I guess the Windows 98/ME shit was written by the best of the breed ultra clever American programmers? Also, the loads of security problems that MS fixes each and every one was written by an Indian programmer?

      Stop FUDing buddy - there are good programmers and bad programmers irrespective of whether they are from India or US or Soviet. Every one learns from their experience.

    17. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by open_janana · · Score: 1

      I wish "intellectuals" like you should read this
      http://us.rediff.com/money/2005/may/18ca.htm.

      Also a person should be smart enough to hire good programmers.

    18. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      BTW, this is not a racist or anti-outsourcing rant. Test folks in China did (and no doubt still do) a stellar job. I'm just puzzled that Indians fuck up so badly time after time.
      If this is not a racist comment then what the hell is it? You are obviously racist only towards Indians and not chinese!!

    19. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by nikster · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Microsoft is an anti SDE company anyway. They employ the brightest hackers on top of the most broken platform in the world. Software that was not good to begin with, then got hacked on for decades, then almost saved by a dramatic switch to NT, then watered down with XP and now it's a huge pile of broken shit wrapped in a gigantic marketing budget and service/support system. It takes an active group of really bright people just to prevent a total collapse.

      To have no proper code quality check / audit team just fits this picture. I would expect MS to have a team which is solely responsible for checking checkins and finding smelly code. And getting paid for that. Apparently they don't.

      The goal of the competition is obviously to find that one genius amongst the 5000. Which doesn't sound like such a bad idea, really. Only BillG fans - of which there are many in India - will enter, but what's bad about that? So the genius is fiercely loyal - bad thing? Only when he learns the truth and turns ;)

      As for China good, India bad... I don't buy it. So, you work with a shit company from India and a good one from China. Don't nationalize your experience. Due to the huge boom in IT in India and probably the lack of other opportunities there are a huge number of people in IT there that really should not be. Remember 2000 in Silicon Valley? Any monkey was hired as a web-designer there in those days, for $90 an hour. So what if you have no clue, it's good money! Same thing in India today - only on a much larger scale.

    20. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Shame on you. There are two kinds of people, one who stand up and try to fix shit that's going wrong and others who play along until they get a chance to point fingers at others. From your comment, it's obvious you fall into the 'Anonymous Coward' category.

    21. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I think you are full of sh1t.

      Most of the organizations I have been in, the Indian programmer has been highly regarded.

      You are having a hard time competing and so come to websites like slashdot and post whatever you feel like.
      Good thing for you is that, there is nobody to verify your experience.

      Who knows, you must have been fired by an Indian boss.

    22. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You are obviously jealous that Bill Gates is not doing something similar here in the US. It's time to accept that Indians are superior to you.

    23. Re:Give me the winner's code, and by AEton · · Score: 1

      The first sentence of the article you linked:

      "Are Indian's the smartest software programmers? It sure seems so!"

      I giggle in your general direction.

      --
      We recently had heard in the office over one of the Yellow Machine that's made by Anthology Solutions.
  63. Neither? by ChunderDownunder · · Score: 1

    Does Bill code anymore? One interview I read he was quoted that he hadn't written any serious code for Microsoft since 1983!

  64. This is a great idea... by NoMoreNicksLeft · · Score: 1

    The winners get to go work for a real company right? And the other 4990 are shipped off to redmond as h1b slaves?

    1. Re:This is a great idea... by one_more_indian · · Score: 1

      As per Indian Education System, 5000-1=4999 Cheers!

    2. Re:This is a great idea... by NoMoreNicksLeft · · Score: 1

      Hey you snotty-inventors of civilization before europeans ever did anything important!

      I was hoping that a few runnerups got to work for google or ibm too... but just for that attitude, I hope all 5000 get shipped off to the code sweatshops in Redmond. Bwhahahahaha.

      BWHAHAHHAHAH.

    3. Re:This is a great idea... by one_more_indian · · Score: 1

      That was a Nice..dumb..explanation.. to cover up your butt...Cheers!

    4. Re:This is a great idea... by NoMoreNicksLeft · · Score: 1

      Christ, I think I typed that at 3am local time. Ever notice how the 9 and 0 keys are close together?

  65. Is your boss a psycho? by hlee · · Score: 1

    All kidding aside. Parent post actually highlights characteristics of many successful executives. Check out the following article: Is Your Boss a Psychopath?.

    Here's an interesting snippet:

    Narcissists are visionaries who attract hordes of followers, which can make them excel as innovators, but they're poor listeners and they can be awfully touchy about criticism. "These people don't have much empathy," Maccoby says. "When Bill Gates tells someone, 'That's the stupidest thing I've ever heard,' or Steve Jobs calls someone a bozo, they're not concerned about people's feelings. They see other people as a means toward their ends. But they do have a sense of changing the world -- in their eyes, improving the world. They build their own view of what the world should be and get others recruited to their vision.

    I hope such business practices find themselves increasingly marginalized over the next few decades, because it bloody stinks. Yeah, well Steve Jobs may have a compelling vision, but I wonder how many people who have worked with him actually enjoyed the journey? I really hope Google is different, and even if they may not succeed in the end - hard to be the first of your kind - may be a new breed of companies not governed by sociopaths, can show us a better way forward.

    I'm heading a little off topic, but I do find what makes a person tick interesting. Here's another account that reveals a little bit more about the richest man in the world (especially if it's true): Bill Gates and Petals Around the Rose.

  66. Don't you mean his Darth Vader? by DanTheLewis · · Score: 1

    Because Darth Maul got chopped in half. Maybe this is a symbol of his torn heart as he tries to decide which great offer to take. And I wasn't aware of any big Sith tournament to the death to become the apprentice. Is that canon?

    Darth Vader did kill the evil emperor eventually. But they had some good times ruling the galaxy. Good times.

    Darth Vader also had it up on the competition because he had a bunch of computer parts. "He's more machine now than man." Too bad we never see Vader shutting off the trash compactor with his thumb.

    --

    Q: What did the comedian say to the crowd?
    A: If I knew, this joke would be funny.
  67. This is an example of why Microsoft has problems by surfdaddy · · Score: 4, Insightful

    If they are focusing at coding, then they are missing the big picture.

    Nobody would argue that coding is important, and that you'd like to have good individuals to code applications.

    But if you look at Microsoft's products, and compare them to Apple, what are the differences? Coding?

    No, the differences are:
    * a focus on integration of the hardware and software subsystem
    * a focus on ease of use, not quality or rapidity of coding
    * a focus on agility of teams. How many versions of Apple's OS have come out since the last Windows update?

    I don't see a "coding contest" making a big difference. And it's not like Microsoft is running out of cash and has to shave costs by getting cheaper coders. They're doing it because they aren't growing enough. Cutting staff costs is treating the symptom. The actual disease is bloated code, not much creativity, integration, or elegance in their products. Coding contests aren't going to solve that.

  68. 50 quatloos!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    on the newcomers!

  69. Internship == ? by Scott+Swezey · · Score: 1
    So by internship, do they mean that they wont be paying?

    I had an internship once, basicly a bunch of data entry and no pay. But really, this sounds great... Sign me up. Nothing better than giving your soul to the devil.

    -.-

    --
    Scott Swezey
    1. Re:Internship == ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's only in America that interns don't get paid. Back when I was at university, I had an internship at HP, and got paid about 3/4 of a graduate starting salary.

  70. And for those managers amongst you .. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Steve Ballmer announced the Throw4Steve contenst

  71. Good promotional opportunity by Foerstner · · Score: 1

    If I were Google, I'd publicly extend a competitive offer of employment for the winner of the contest, to facilitate exactly that sort of occurrence.

    --
    The US free market: two halves of a government-granted duopoly are free to set the market price.
    1. Re:Good promotional opportunity by Servants · · Score: 1

      Except that would be foolish, because the person who went through the whole Microsoft-sponsored contest would more than likely choose to work for Microsoft, and what kind of publicity would that be?

      Besides, immediately trying to poach an employee which Microsoft had gone to all this trouble to attract would probably count as evil, not to mention bad PR in itself.

  72. Re:This is an example of why Microsoft has problem by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    no, but a coding contest *does* encorage would be coders to learn about Microsoft's programming platforms. I'm assuming that most of the programming would be done in some perversion of VB or .Net

  73. Re:Link to Microsoft's Superhero-The Developer's S by Merle+Darling · · Score: 1

    Or GNU's, http://www.gnu.org/music/free-software-song.html. I haven't heard it in years and I still cringe just thinking about it.

    --
    "Bother," said Pooh, as lightning knocked out hi%#&(F*@NO CARRIER
  74. I know this is tacky, by mikeage · · Score: 5, Funny

    But in Soviet Russia, Bill codes for you!

    --
    -- Is "Sig" copyrighted by www.sig.com?
    1. Re:I know this is tacky, by chawly · · Score: 1

      Yup. But not for free. Never for free. Further, (and even tackier) in South Korea only old people code for Bill.

      --
      How many beans make five, anyhow ? ... Charles Walmsley
  75. Chicks? by Dr.+Cody · · Score: 1

    Plus, think of all the chicks you'd get...

    Exactly zero.

    Remember folks, this contest is in India. No Indian woman has had sex since the 4th Century A.D.

    However, scientists are still frantically searching for the cause of India's staggering population growth.

  76. The wrong choices for role models!!! by bayankaran · · Score: 2, Interesting

    And, if you admire Bill Gates, you have a serious lack of ethics.

    Though I will not include Bill Gates in the list of 'truly evil', some of the role models Indians consider are people of totally dubious background.

    About 10-12 years back there was stock market crash in India engineered by loopholes-in-the-system+backdoor-deals by a rogue trader - Harshad Mehta.

    I have seen many reports/articles/interviews where he was admired for his money making skills and quotes like 'I want to be like Harshad Mehta' with all the sincerity. For the last two/three decades there are very few socio-cultural icons in the subcontinent...the people who can be role models.

    --
    Tat Tvam Asi
  77. MOD PARENT UP -n/t by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    n/t

  78. And in Redmond ... by Pathetic+Coward · · Score: 1

    software engineers are rapidly updating their resumes.

  79. ANother Version of AntiTrust by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    HAHHAHHA...ANother anti-trust movie.....??? Nice move bill..but it aint new...
    Dont Be Decieved my indian friendszz...

  80. I knew I saw this movie somewhere.... by lwagner · · Score: 2, Funny

    Willy Wanker and the Software Factory. What bad things could happen to the 19 people who don't win?

  81. Re:What about when India gets outsourced? [OT] by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Oh, and which part of the FSDBMS did I mis-understand?

    Thanks,

  82. India, outsourcing, colonization &economic gro by aalobode · · Score: 1
    "We" didn't colonize India. With minor exceptions such as the Portuguese in Goa it was the British who colonized India. Although I certainly don't justify colonialism and agree with most of your post, I don't see any justification for the view that India is poor because of British colonialism. The reason that India is a relatively poor country today is primarily because India has not developed the way Europe, North America, Australia, and some East Asian countries have. I don't see how that can be blamed on the British. Another major cause of India's poverty is internal: high rates of population growth coupled with inheritance customs and the rigidity of the caste system.

    ......There have been cases in which a colonial power literally robbed the colony of its accumulated wealth and took control of the current sources (e.g.gold mines), but I'm not aware that this happened on any real scale in India.

    The truth about colonization is more nuanced than that, although I fully agree with the last two sentences of the first quote. Firstly, India contained Dutch, French, Portuguese, and British colonies. The British annexed most of the princely states and united them into what is now modern India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, and Burma. And yes, they did take large quantities of the wealth. Nandan Nilekani, the founder of one of India's biggest outsourcing company, frequently cites the figure of 50% -- as the share of the world's economic output that India and China produced until c. 1830.

    Britian destroyed the local economic base while increasing other forms of economic growth. It hammered the textile business: cotton produced in India was shipped to Britain, manufactured, and then re-exported to India. Locals could not build mills -- that was one reason for Gandhi's use of homespun as a form of protest. A second example is the grinding serfdom in the indigo plantations owned by British investors (George Orwell's father was one a plantation manager), and in the tea plantations. Indians were not even allowed to make salt -- witness the big march of Gandhi -- they had to buy British-manufactured product. People here have talked here about the opium trade and the destruction of China. And Britain did take control of the coal, iron ore, and gold mines; prior to South Africa's discovery of diamonds, nearly all of those came from mines in India.

    Where does America come in: the British monies were invested here. Yale was founded by the legacy of a man who made it big as a governor of Madras. The railways, the big farms and other economic development of the western parts of this country in the last half of the 19th century were funded by British investors. Even the tea dumped in Boston Harbor came from India. But directly, no, America did not colonize India.

    The pomp and circumstance of the Raj, Britain's ability to fight two World Wars, and even the Kohinoor diamond in the Queen's crown came ultimately from wealth taken from her colonies. Americans are unaware, when they admire democracy and Churchill: they don't see that he actively worked to deny it to more than 400 million subcontinentals. Roosevelt was at lest complicit in that. So, try putting into place an economic growth plan while you have to build a democracy from scratch.

    But yes, the caste system, and the replacement of British sahibs by Indian sahibs, and mistakes made in planning, all contributed to retard economic growth. Modern India is due to the economic policies put in place after 1992 even with all those problems still in place.

  83. Microsoft is for loosers by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    there is no reason to spend your best years with one of the most hated technology company that had not delivered anything interesting in years. The world is big -- there is plenty of other much more interesting/rewarding projects and companies.

  84. Huh? by TheLink · · Score: 1

    That's as silly as asking why the best sculptor would want to work for a very very rich patron paying him to sculpt instead of the sculptor going off and starting his own company.

    --
  85. Let me get this straight by smchris · · Score: 2, Insightful


    So Code4Bill is meant to throw attention away from open source? And the 20 lucky winners get to work for Microsoft for a year for free?

    Crazy world. If these 20 are so smart, why aren't they starting up their own companies to provide open source to schools and wi fi to villages?

    Or are these at least _paid_ internships?

    1. Re:Let me get this straight by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why don't you provide some open source solution to homelessness or clinical depression in your community?

      Oh sorry, were you too busy whining on a website about the world's most successful corporation's coding competition to do anything "worthy" yourself?

  86. No; creating new jobs NOT outsourcing. by everphilski · · Score: 1

    I wonder if all of these programmers in India are even slightly concerned that he ditched out on the (I'm assuming here) more expensive U.S. programmers to hire "more cost effective" employees in India?

    The new money Microsoft is dumping into India is creating new jobs, not replacing existing American jobs.

    -everphilski-

    1. Re:No; creating new jobs NOT outsourcing. by gertsenl · · Score: 1

      I second the sentiment. Microsoft continues to hire more and more people in the United States, and its Redmond campus has done nothing but grow in the last decade.

      --
      --Leo
  87. Axing state side jobs by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    How many positions are being cut state side to do this move? I'm talking not just official full-time, but also temps, permatemps and long term consultants.

  88. Mod Parent up! by lxs · · Score: 1

    I don't know what he's talking about, having given up in digust on the whole Star Wars thing after Phantom Menace (Thanks for raping my childhood memories George!), but anyone who reacts to a throwaway gag with a lenghty exposition on Star Wars history deserves some geek cred.

  89. Not completely true by everphilski · · Score: 1

    Americans are told from birth that they are entitled to all sorts of material things.

    I'm an american, 23, growing up my father told me, "you can anything you want in life, but you can't have everything."

    Not all Americans are spoiled, believing the american dream is a huge ass house, a SUV, boat, camper and debt up to their ears... that's a stereotype. Some of us have common sense, although I will admit that is a characteristic that is lacking.

    -everphilski-

    1. Re:Not completely true by CyricZ · · Score: 1

      So two out of three hundred million people aren't complete fucktards. That's not a good situation for a country to be in.

      --
      Cyric Zndovzny at your service.
  90. Since when are US schools "underfunded"? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Please cite one study that shows any correlation between dollars spent and success in educating students. The only people crying for more money for schools in the US are those that directly benefit from such spending, their willing dupes, and other useful idiots.

    And "right-wing school system"? What planet are you from, anyway? Doesn't that uber-left, proven-fraud Ward Churchill still have a job in that school system? When's the last time any public school system in the US put on a "Christmas Play"?

    PS - Bill Gates is using the "underfunded school" excuse to give M$ cover so he can move his workforce overseas and pay them less money. And you fell for it.

  91. Work For Free by oldCoder · · Score: 1
    Work for Free for 8 months -- your reward will be the opportunity to work for free for another year!

    Apparently even the Indians are desperate for jobs now...

    --

    I18N == Intergalacticization
  92. Try it for a day by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It is fun as hell to use people as an ends for your means.

    I consciously do it myself occasionally when I have a whole lot of work to do and very little time. Plus, there is a little part of all of us that admires the person who can go in and get what they want - fuck the other people. It is a power that we all want a bit of - as long as we do not share it.

    Have you ever run a company? Do you realize the amount of bullshit that you have to tread through? The anount of ass-kissing bullshit that you have to parse from people who tell you want they want you to hear?

  93. Why by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
  94. Hey Bill THANKS! by 1336.5 · · Score: 0

    For keeping jobs in america asshat

  95. Re:unprecedented evile requires even more minions? by Rune69 · · Score: 1

    " a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush"

    "a penny saved is a penny earned"

    "do unto others as you would have them do unto you"

    "don't piss on an electric fence"

    Fuck you and your pseudo-religious bullshit. Stuff your Bible quote book up your ass.

    --

    When faced with a problem, many web developers say "I know, I'll use JavaScript!".
    Now they have two problems.
  96. 1 Microsoft developer, 4999 open source developers by burnin1965 · · Score: 1

    So out of 5000 developers Bill wants only one? No wonder open source software has surpassed proprietary software in various applications, at a ratio of 1:4999 there is no way proprietary development will ever keep up.

    Then again I suppose you don't need that many developers when your just waiting for someone else to develop the next big idea / breakthrough and then just buy it out or duplicate it.

    Or perhaps it has more to do with what appears to be a Microsoft attitude, they have that whole computer software thing wrapped up so we don't need any more developers, what we need is for every other human endeavor to utilize Microsoft software in everything they do. Ever notice how none of those kids or people in the Windows commercials are software engineers? Go figure.

    burnin

  97. p0rn version of contest: Wank4Jenna by sporadic · · Score: 1

    Personally, I'm going to wait until Jenna puts out her version of the contest, Wank4Jenna. I think I can make it into at least the top 5.

  98. Re:Why? Google Code Jam by TekGoNos · · Score: 1

    Actually, it would be a good opportunity for Google to step forward and announce that they will sign the 2'nd and 3'rd place winners.

    Err ... ever heard of Google Code Jam?

    They are already doing it [a programming contest] (worldwide) and the first price is 10 000$ cash, not a job offer.
    (Although I'm quite sure that everyone of the top 25 get's a job offer; hey, I only participated and got a "we'll be pleased to read your resume" letter (plus T-Shirt))
    Oh, and the top 100 get a paid visite to Googleplex for the last rounds.

    --
    I have discovered a truly remarkable proof for my post which this sig is too small to contain.
  99. Re:Why? Google Code Jam by WindBourne · · Score: 1

    Sure, I have heard of it. What does that have to do with stealing the winds out of MS's sails?

    Roughly the idea is that if you do too good in a MS competition, you will get rewarded with a MS contract. I have known 3 people who have worked with Gates. Not a kind word from the three for Bill.

    Interestingly, two of them worked with Allen as well (they worked there in the 80's), and have nothing but raves about him.

    --
    I prefer the "u" in honour as it seems to be missing these days.
  100. Why yes, a US job *is* a given right Carly. by sethstorm · · Score: 1


    Re: American attitudes. It's possible that the corps have too much power and are abusing it to 'export' jobs. But why, I ask, is it right to export products to India, but not export jobs to India? I guess people have difficulty in accepting that service is seen as a product too.

    Unlike physical goods, jobs have lives attached to them. When you take the job (unrightfully) and put it somewhere where the person cannot get to, that is definitely not competition. When you run your company into the ground to break union contracts (ala Delphi), when you devalue the whole community ala Walmart, that's when you start thinking that regulation might have been a good idea. That is, when you offshore

    Re: Getting pissed off... Check my post, if you think I said that Indians are the best, read it again. I have no such mis-conceptions. I merely want to see India and China get what they deserve, in terms of a share of what this world produces. Nothing more, nothing less.

    Well, so do I. When they improve their human rights and / or have their US companies heavily taxed for these normally untaxed assets until things improve, their rightful share does not exist. That means dealing with all the problems related to game theory.

    --
    Twitter supports and protects racists - by smearing their critics with the "Hate Speech" label.
    1. Re:Why yes, a US job *is* a given right Carly. by univgeek · · Score: 1

      Unlike physical goods, jobs have lives attached to them. When you take the job (unrightfully) ...

      I'm not sure how this is any different from import/export of goods. When the US exports something, the job *could* have been done in India. But it wasn't, and is therefore *unrightfully* taking away potential earnings of someone in India. See how stupid that sounds?

      People in India and the US have different capabilities, perhaps because of education, perhaps because of available equipment, how these are arbitraged and the best possible outcome reached is what will occupy us for this century I think.


      When they improve their human rights and / or have their US companies heavily taxed for these normally untaxed assets until things improve, their rightful share does not exist.

      That's funny. Really. Why does the US have a right to decide what human rights are? And FWIW, India is not too bad on this score. At least in comparison to some of the US-propped dictators, and many of the other places in the world. And you really think that human rights were upheld during the Industrial revolution? You guys built your industries on the sweat and blood of your own people and that of your slaves. We've learnt a lot from that. We're just building with our own sweat and blood.

      And if we want to give some tax breaks so we can get a foot in, of course we will. You think that the US would not do it? Or for that matter any other western country? Witness the concessions offered to Intel(?), AMD(dresden), Dell(NC) or TI(dallas) to start one of their fabs/factories.

      And you have the gall to decide what out rightful share is? Wow. I'll just crawl back to my hole in the mud now, since you say I don't have a rightful share. That's the kind of attitude that got you into trouble in Afghanistan and Iraq and Vietnam. You should learn sometime.
      --
      All bow to his Noodliness!! His Noodle Appendage has touched me!
  101. Nope by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    >> So, you work with a shit company from India and a good one from China.

    No, it's the same company - Microsoft. Same hiring practices, pretty much the same management style. It seems as though folks in China are more thorough and better educated. For them "it works somehow" is not good enough. They tend to be anal about specs, though - they insist that things need to be implemented as per spec, whether this makes sense or not.

  102. 1 of 5000? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    That matches about my experience with people from that area. Unfortunately.

  103. Shiva by DoctorMabuse · · Score: 1

    Bill is looking for a Indian expert so he can learn to grow eight arms like the Hindu goddess Shiva. Eight arms would quaduple his ability to steal other company's ideas.

    Personally I hope he screws up and grows an elephant head like Ganesh. Larry Ellison and Scott McNealy can throw peanuts at Bill during his keynote speeches at COMDEX.

  104. Whats the critera to win? by mikek3332002 · · Score: 1

    Is it the ablity to throw/catch chairs or
    Is it the ablity to dance like a monkey

  105. in ten years by namekuseijin · · Score: 1

    "go out there and start your own company and in ten years..."

    In ten years, if you're one hell of a coder as well as one hell of a businessman ( ouch! ), Microsoft will be buying your shiny company. Sadly, that's the way it works...

    so, let the guy just work for them anyway and don't start some astounding business which will just be integrated into the behemoth some years in the future...

    --
    I don't feel like it...
  106. Re:RIP TIMECOP by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    If he's dead then who am I looking at right now?
    This is just another troll of GNAA...

  107. Re:India, outsourcing, colonization &economic by belmolis · · Score: 1

    Ah, that's very interesting. I wasn't aware of the British textile and salt policy or the exportation of the wealth from the mines.

    The inconsistency of Churchill in wanting freedom for some (e.g. the English) and not for others (e.g. Indians) is unfortunately far from uncommon. Look at the behavior of the French: the national myth is founded on just about everybody having been a hero of the resistance in the Second World War, yet the principal occupation of France in the immediate postwar period was to reclaim its colonies in Indochina and North Africa.

  108. TCS? what a joke by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    TCS ? products? yeah right. they are the biggest bodyshop in India, peddling *very mediocre* engineers, with such schemes as 'two for the rate of one, sitting in the same cubicle!' etc.

      tell what you may about good companies, but Please, Please, do not include TCS, Infosys, Patni etc as 'product companies'. They are the ones who took the easy path or making money by bodyshopping. They are the ones going for the desperate freshers left after Multinationals have had their picks in a graduating batch, so thet they can have them for even less. When you start quoting them as your star firms, you lose what little credibility you have.

    1. Re:TCS? what a joke by univgeek · · Score: 1

      Err... you didn't read it correctly. I said companies started by people who've made money at Infy/Wipro/TCS/.com boom etc. I didn't quote TCS/Infy/PCS as 'star firms' :-). That would be a bit weird in the product company context :-).

      Iflex was doing decently, and I think Ramco Systems is doing decently too. And of course tally has a very large chunk of the local market.

      --
      All bow to his Noodliness!! His Noodle Appendage has touched me!
  109. economics... by ameline · · Score: 2, Insightful

    They're
    obviously
    being
    paid
    by
    the
    line.

    --
    Ian Ameline
  110. The USA just won't get what you are saying ... by GNUALMAFUERTE · · Score: 1

    I absolutely agree with what you are saying, but let me explain my point of view:

    When there are good reasons NOT to do something, and those reasons are evident, and then someone goes on and do it anyway, you can't expect that person to understand that reasons, invariably they will either just neglect those reasons, aknowledge them but ignore them, or just create good excuses. After a few generations, people will beleive the lies, and those reasons will be just impossible for them to understand.

    Many nations over time have tried to take over the world. They all received the same advice: "If you are going to opress people, and make a profit out of them, you either kill them all, or you prepare for revolution, because it will happend, and blood will cover the streets". Many understood this, and, while they still conquered, they knew that they shouldn't mess with certain stuff, and they knew when to retire (for example, the UK).
    The USA didn't care. They think they can rule the world, dominate other nations, get in the middle of anything, try to be the police of the world, and they think nobody would do anything about it. When someone does something about it, they blame everyone else, and try to get the rest of the world to help them.

    Yes, they rule the world now, but they won't rule the world forever. Every nation in the world has something against them, because they have in one situation of another fucked every other nation in the world, and even groups inside their country, so, when they finaly loose their power, nobody will be there to help them, and they will have a rather large list of people waiting for revenge.

    --
    WTF am I doing replying to an AC at 5 A.M on a Friday night?
  111. Bossk Re:Familiar by genxgaming · · Score: 1

    You got so many Bossk details right... but he doesn't have tentacles and I don't think his face is soft or baggy. What gives? He's more like a lizardman. Which begs the question, why would he be slimey? I think he was just sweating a lot. =] http://www.bothan-online.com/IMG/jpg/bossk.jpg http://www.starwars.com/databank/character/bossk/

    1. Re:Bossk Re:Familiar by TubeSteak · · Score: 1
      I nabbed the text from the script.
      http://www.imsdb.com/scripts/Star-Wars-The-Empire- Strikes-Back.html

      Anyways, if you looked a little further at the link you provided (and clicked 'behind the scenes') you'd see that they specifically state:
      The original script called for Bossk to be a "slimy, tentacled monster with two huge, bloodshot eyes in a soft baggy face."
      --
      [Fuck Beta]
      o0t!
  112. Re:This is an example of why Microsoft has problem by chawly · · Score: 1

    And Microsoft is not alone. In NORTH Korea old people cannot remember anything - even the name of their Great Leader. This is because they are coded by Bill and his team - in Visual C++. The resulting memory leak (from the ears) results in their regretable forgetfulness. (I have heard this same reason given for the behavior of G. Bush, but he simply crashed a long time ago - according to what I heard. I don't know if this is true though.) To reboot or not to reboot, that is a question I should not like to answer.

    --
    How many beans make five, anyhow ? ... Charles Walmsley
  113. Turning Gay for Gates in '08 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    It's a prelude to this:

    BANGALORE, India (AFP) --
    Microsoft Chairman Bill Gates has announced that he will throw his hat into the ring for the 2008 US presidential election. Acknowledging that it would be a step down in power, he points out that he would likely only stay active in office until some key domestic issues and agreements with the EU and South East Asia are negotiated. After that, either the vice-president, yet to be named, would assume responsibility or the task could be outsourced to Halliburton.

    Gates will run on an independent ticket, inspired by H. Ross Perot, but with less money for advertising. "Enough people recognize and admire me already. I do not need the backing or obligations to either party." He stated full confidence that even without spending a dime on campaign advertising the votes tallied will be strongly in his favor. "With electronic voting machines, this can be tallied within minutes of closing the polls", he pointed out.

    The campaign theme has already been chosen. The slogan "Turning Gay for Gates in '08" will also usher in Microsoft Chairman Gates's new public image. It's been clear to the public that Melinda's in it for the money, but for years they have wondered what's in it for Gates himself and why is apparent disinterest in women. Now that is answered. "People thought I couldn't get women simply because I come across as an arrogant, condecending computer nerd. That's just random. Completely random" says Microsoft Chairman Gates. "I've now realized that I'm rich enough to do what I want and no one can stop me."

    As an extention of his tour of schools and universities Microsoft Chairman Gates initiative in certifications. The Microsoft Catamite series covers a whole range of certifications including Microsoft Catamite Aprentice (MSCA), Microsoft Catamite Experienced (MSCE) and Microsoft Catamite Delectable (MSCD). Gates will be recruiting young programmers, males from ages 18 to 25, to become part of his special "team". The first rounds from the India selection began this week. "The next presidential administration will be more innovative and expansive than any earlier ones," claimed Microsoft Chairman Gates, and he added, "there will be more openings where there were never before."

  114. Is there going to be a reality show? by Chewy8 · · Score: 1

    If there is going to be a reality show for this contest, then I can tell you this. Get ready for apaclypse.

  115. Then you'd be making capital gains. by univgeek · · Score: 1

    A profit either way.

    --
    All bow to his Noodliness!! His Noodle Appendage has touched me!
  116. ANti _trust 2??? by X_Ionphoenix_X · · Score: 1

    hehehe...Code4Bill:Anti_trust 2..EPisodeII:Invite the IndiaNS...directed by BIll Gates

  117. Testing? by lilmouse · · Score: 1

    I would think MS needs more testing, not more integration.

    --LWM

  118. Why this is funny ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Not sure why parent is modded as funny. I see such code from my Indian colleagues every day. I have to make fixes/changes in their code very often and I can tell you it is not much fun ...

  119. Go worship some cows.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    and get bird flu in the Ganges river while showering.