Slashdot Mirror


eBay Wants Voice Phone Free In Five Years

kmk writes "In a few short years, users can expect to make telephone calls for free, with no per-minute charges, as part of a package of services through which carriers make money on advertising or transaction fees, eBay's chief executive said on Wednesday."

185 comments

  1. Ads? by elbenito69 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I would much rather pay for phone service than to put up with ads on the telephone, of all places.

    1. Re:Ads? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Not to worry. Following TV and cable, you WILL pay and also have to listen to the ads.

    2. Re:Ads? by garcia · · Score: 2, Funny

      "The number you have reached is no longer in service. Please check the advertisement and try again. Zero, one, four, twenty."

    3. Re:Ads? by Seumas · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Great. So they'll have voice recognition listen to all of your conversations and interrupt with interesting advertisements relating to the conversation you're currently having with the other person. *sigh*

      I'll keep paying the $20/mo, thanks.

    4. Re:Ads? by Spetiam · · Score: 1

      I concur. Does anyone remember those "listen to a twenty second ad and talk for a minute" schemes? It was so infuriating to listen to those ads, I couldn't even use it just to make a quick "I need to be picked up" call from a payphone. There not a ghost of a chance something like this would survive, unless they had some way of making *far* less obnoxious ads. VoIP telephone service is cheap enough even now that this doesn't make any sense.

    5. Re:Ads? by ScoLgo · · Score: 2, Insightful

      "Not to worry. Following TV and cable, you WILL pay and also have to listen to the ads."

      I gotta agree with this sentiment. It's inevitable that advertising will try to worm its way into every possible medium. This is why I subscribed to Sirius satellite radio now - while it's still mostly ad-free. Once the full-on advertising kicks in, (a la cable tv), I'll be cancelling my subscription.

      --
      "Michael, I did nothing. I did absolutely nothing - and it was everything that I thought it could be."
    6. Re:Ads? by leonmergen · · Score: 1

      The difference is that with TV and cable, the content is created for you - you are the creator of your own content with a telephone call. The telecom provider is the same as your cable provider - they both charge on a monthly basis, except a telecom provider ALSO charges per minute.

      And well, a TV production company charges the viewer for their costs in the form of advertising...

      So I don't think we have to worry a lot about dual-priced telephone calls in the form of advertising and money...

      --
      - Leon Mergen
      http://www.solatis.com
    7. Re:Ads? by Jonathan+the+Nerd · · Score: 5, Insightful
      It's inevitable that advertising will try to worm its way into every possible medium.

      Leela: "Didn't you have ads in the twentieth century?"

      Fry: "Well, sure, but not in our dreams. Only on TV and radio...and in magazines...and movies, and at ballgames, and on buses, and milk cartons, and T-shirts, and bananas, and written in the sky. But not in dreams, no sirree."

      --
      Disclaimer: The opinions expressed are not necessarily my own, as I've not yet had my medication today.
    8. Re:Ads? by HTTP+Error+403+403.9 · · Score: 1
      I would much rather pay for phone service than to put up with ads on the telephone, of all places.

      I bet they are going to put the ad right in the middle of your call. That way both sides of the line will hear the ad and will most likely listen to the whole ad since they haven't finished their conversation.

      --
      I'm not a Troll, it's reverse psychology.
    9. Re:Ads? by Saeed+al-Sahaf · · Score: 1

      How about as you make your call, they transmit subliminal advertising into you brain in the background? HOW ABOUT THAT? Secretly implant it into your mind WHILE YOU TALK?

      --
      "Who are in control, they are not in control of anything - they don't even control themselves!" - Glen Beck
    10. Re:Ads? by jjhall · · Score: 1

      I do remember those. One such service called Freeway was great. Listen to an ad for 15 seconds, you got a minute free. I'd listen to 10 ads (a little over 2 minutes) then talk for free for 10. At first, there was a good variety of ads, and I actually purchased some goods and services based off of them. Towards the end though right before they shut down, the ads were always the same and none of them were anywhere near relevant to my demographics.

      The only gripe I had was the risk of listening to that many ads, then getting an answering machine where you use less than a minute of time. Since it wouldn't store your "credit" or let you make another call without starting over, you were out those 9 ads for nothing.

      Of course those were back when long distance was approximately $.20 per minute unless you used enough to get discounts. These days, the company would have to offer 10 minutes per 15 second ad or something similar to make the incentive worthwhile. When I could listen to ads for 2 minutes and save $2, I was all for it. But at todays rates, that same 2 minutes of ads would only save $.10 to $.20.

      Jeremy

    11. Re:Ads? by Humorously_Inept · · Score: 2, Funny

      Fortunately, under Betamax, you will be able to timeshift your conversations using a PCR (Personal Conversation Recorder) and skip the ads. That is unless your conversations are flagged to protect their copyright integrity.

      --

      ~Someday, I hope to be an aspiring author.
    12. Re:Ads? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      Male voice: Hello?
      Female voice: Hi, John, I just thought I'd give you a ring and see how you're doing?
      Male voice: Hey, I'm glad you called, I...

      Announcer: HI! DO I DETECT A HAPPY YOUNG COUPLE? HAVE YOU THOUGHT OF USING TROJAN (TM) BRAND CONDOMS?

      Male voice: Uh...
      Female voice: Uh...
      Male voice: Look, mom, this isn't a good time. Maybe we can talk at Thanksgiving?
      Female voice: Yeah...

    13. Re:Ads? by fitten · · Score: 1

      Yeah... it sounds like telemarketing in reverse. In order to call your friend, you have to call a telemarketer first and they'll patch you through. No. Thanks.

    14. Re:Ads? by therblig · · Score: 1
      Fortunately, under Betamax, you will be able to timeshift your conversations using a PCR (Personal Conversation Recorder) and skip the ads. That is unless your conversations are flagged to protect their copyright integrity.


      I'm too young to remember the Betamax/VHS controversy very well. Did Betamax have the feature of skipping commercials using something other than a normal fast forward?
      --

      I struggled for days and days and all I got was this lousy sig.

    15. Re:Ads? by Rob_Warwick · · Score: 1

      He's referring to the Betamax Case which ensured that time shifting (recording for later watching) TV was legal in the U.S.

    16. Re:Ads? by jonbryce · · Score: 1

      As much as $.10?

      A two minute international call from the UK to the US costs less than that. You can get 2p per minute if you shop around, which is about $0.07. I would have thought long distance within the US would be less than that.

    17. Re:Ads? by Gilmoure · · Score: 1

      How do they know when I'm going to stop talking?

      --
      I drank what? -- Socrates
    18. Re:Ads? by jjhall · · Score: 1

      Yes. If I listen to that 2 minutes of ads to get the free 10 minutes of long distance, those ads are saving me $.10 to $.20. Cheap long distance is anywhere between $.01 and $.02 per minute. Multiply that by 10 minutes...

      I'm not talking about paying to listen to the ad, that would be flat out crazy. :-)

      Jeremy

    19. Re:Ads? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's the exact reason why I don't watch TV and do not pay for cable. The media industry can suck my dick.

    20. Re:Ads? by Tony+Hoyle · · Score: 1

      UK to US? You can get that free - the carriage costs are so low they don't bother charging you any more.

      eg. voipbuster it), sipdiscount, and others.

      Both of the above are IAX compatible so you can plug asterisk into them and automatically route US calls over them.

    21. Re:Ads? by HTTP+Error+403+403.9 · · Score: 2, Funny
      How do they know when I'm going to stop talking?

      knock knock
      who's there?
      interrupting cow
      interrupting co MOOO!

      --
      I'm not a Troll, it's reverse psychology.
    22. Re:Ads? by adachan · · Score: 1

      Telemarketers?

    23. Re:Ads? by ajs318 · · Score: 1
      I can sort of see this happening. You'll be on the phone to somebody, chatting away, and then all of a sudden the conversation will be interrupted with an advertisement .....
      Are you spending more than you're earning? Struggling to make ends meet? Worried about County Court Judgements or arrears? Repo-men knocking at the door right now? A Consolidation Loan from Hammerhead Finance might be just what you need. But don't take our word for it; listen to our customers. This is what Mrs P. from Essex had to say about our services: <accent="essex">Well, I was owin' nearly a faahsand paahnd a week, but them blokes from 'ammer'ead was very nice. 'Elped me out wiv all me debts. Jus' got one payment now, jus' over a couple of grand a fawtnight, for ver rest of me life. An' they definitely didn't use no baseball bats nor nuffink.</accent> You can combine all your outstanding debts into one lower monthly payment. Thank you for listening to this message. <volume="-6db">Repayment period will be extended. Your home is at risk if you default on repayments on a mortgage or other loan secured against it.</volume> You will now be reconnected to your call.
      Of course, if you try hanging up in the middle of one of these advertisements, then the advert will simply be repeated next time you pick up the receiver -- you won't even get a dial tone until you have listened to it in full.

      Next, they'll introduce voice recognition technology.
      You used the word "holiday". Did you know that if you book now you can receive a 20% saving on all Summer family holidays at EuroTours? To be connected to a EuroTours Customer Advisor right now, press hash. If you do not press anything you will be reconnected to your original called party. EuroTours has holidays to suit everyone, whether you're looking for family fun and action by the seaside, quiet relaxation in the mountains or an intimate weekend for two on the outskirts of a bustling city. Thank you for listening to this message. You will now be reconnected.
      But this is the one I'm waiting for ..... imagine the scene. A young woman in considerable distress is trying to call the Old Bill, when suddenly her faltering voice is interrupted .....
      You used the word "rape". Did you know that you can save up to ten percent on ministry-approved quality oil seed products from Global Genetic Technologies? .....
      --
      Je fume. Tu fumes. Nous fûmes!
    24. Re:Ads? by dpmapping · · Score: 1

      If Microsoft made the service

      Male voice: Hello?
      Female voice: Hi, John, I just thought I'd give you a ring and see how you're doing?
      Male voice: Hey, I'm glad you called, I...

      Clippy: Hi there, it sounds like you are trying to make a personal call. Can I format the conversation for you.

      Male voice: Uh...
      Female voice: Uh...

      Clippy: Hi there, it sounds like you are confused. Shall I continue for you?

      Male voice: What?...
      Female voice: Yeah...

      Clippy: Hi there, it sounds like you have hung up on me. Can I please be your friend? I will not bite, and I will clean up after myself. I only ever took this gig with Microsoft because they said I could work with other paperclips. Look what happened, I ended up typecast with some profressor bloke, a crazy dog, a psychotic cat and a flower the size of a planet. I didn't want to offer help, i wanted....I wanted to be ............. a Lumberjack [insert own Monty Python sketch here]

    25. Re:Ads? by d34thm0nk3y · · Score: 1

      Fortunately, under Betamax, you will be able to timeshift your conversations using a PCR (Personal Conversation Recorder) and skip the ads. That is unless your conversations are flagged to protect their copyright integrity.

      Yeah, the only problem is that you have to start the conversation 10 minutes after you get the call.

  2. Not as far as I can tell by FluffyWithTeeth · · Score: 5, Informative
    From as far as I can tell, TFA suggests they don't mean free phone calls, but that they're trying to get everyone onto using Skype in the next five years or so.

    And now with advertising in it, yay...

    1. Re:Not as far as I can tell by scdeimos · · Score: 2, Insightful
      Yes, they're going to Skype but from TFA you must have missed this:
      The chairman and chief executive of the world's largest online auction site said the transition to completely free voice communications will not happen in the next year or two, but that could happen in the next three to six years.
      I expect that revenue will be raised by advertising, not through the audio channel, but through banner (or pop-up) ads in the Skype client.
    2. Re:Not as far as I can tell by nickdot · · Score: 1

      I also don't understand. Skype is already free and doesn't need ads packages. Rather make paypal free with these ads or ebay itself.

      It's getting fun with this free, ad-based world. I don't care about ads, however clicking them is my new hobby. It allows me to donate money to interesting (open source) projects. Moreover I don't choose ads which appeal to me, but which I suspect of having the highest eCPM. It gives me the feeling I'm rich and it is less effort than doing a bank transfer... just a click of the mouse.

      If somebody would develop a plugin/extension for a webbrowser which would do one random click every time I visit one of my favourite websites, I would install it immediately. It could even connect to a database and choose the link with the highest ranking keyword.

      Imagine how open source software could be boosted by this.

  3. Yeah right ... by Average_Joe_Sixpack · · Score: 5, Informative

    From the company that perfected "nickle and diming."

    1. Re:Yeah right ... by tomhudson · · Score: 1
      ... so why don't the telcos reverse the scenario:
      "In a few short years, users can expect to auction stuff online for free, with no listing or selling charges, as part of a package of services through which carriers make money on phone calls. eBay's chief executive called it unfair competition."
      Seems to me the carriers already have the customer base, the billing infrastructure, etc. They could kill ebay in a month.
    2. Re:Yeah right ... by cymen · · Score: 1

      They could kill ebay in a month.

      If they joined together and presented one alternative marketplace with complete vender support they might BARELY have a chance at toppling eBay. Look at Yahoo! Auctions. Look at the other competitors. The only ones doing okay are those that are in niche markets like guns (items that eBay does not allow to be listed).

      Toppling eBay is not a technological issue -- it's mindshare/brand issue. It's not going to happen any time soon in my opinion which is a real shame.

    3. Re:Yeah right ... by geminidomino · · Score: 1

      There're auction sites selling guns?!

    4. Re:Yeah right ... by tomhudson · · Score: 1
      Agred - Toppling eBay is NOT a technological issue.

      So here's why the telcos can kill off eBay.

      Advantages for the local telco:

      1. The telco already has the customer penetration - easily +90% in most markets. eBay can't match that in ANY market.
      2. The telco already has a billing process in place - they won't need a "pay it with paypal"
      3. Local customers means that a lot of times people won't have to worry about shipping. They'll pick it up, or the vendor can drop it off. Other times, a local courrier company can do it within a couple of hours on the cheap.
      4. Lots of people don't trust eBay. They may not trust their telco either, but they ARE doing business with their telco. Better the devil you know than the devil you don't, etc.
      5. eBay is losing its "unregulated" status as an online auction; various jurisdictions are imposing requirements for listers to obtain auctioneer licenses. If local telcos offer a simple "sell it" w/o auctions, they get around this. Just allow people to make offers and haggle down from the list price. That's not an auction - its normal bargaining.
      6. Local brick and mortar businesses would be a logical client for the telcos, whereas they're a terrible fit for ebay, because of the dispersed geographical area. You don't need to compete with the world when you're serving a local market.
  4. Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by davidwr · · Score: 5, Informative

    I pay a nickle a minute for a Wal-Mart-branded major-carrier long distance card.

    It still gives me an ad I can't bypass after I enter the number.

    At 5 cents a minute it should be ad-free.

    --
    Knowledge is how to play a game, intelligence is how to win, wisdom is knowing what game to play.
    1. Re:Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by Gordonjcp · · Score: 1

      You do realise that most people have mobile phones cheaper than that, right?

    2. Re:Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by johansalk · · Score: 1

      For 5 cents a minute I call *anywhere* in the US from any phone in the UK! You guys have awful telecom.

    3. Re:Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by Bellum+Aeternus · · Score: 1
      Use Penny Talk instead. $0.01 per minute to anywhere in the US, and $0.02 per minutes most everywhere else.

      I'm yet to find a better, legal, deal. VoiceChat doesn't work when your mother law doesn't own a computer and lived in Taiwan.

      --
      - I voted for Nintendo and against Bush
    4. Re:Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by RicktheBrick · · Score: 2, Insightful

      A penny a minute with a $.49 connection charge, so if one gets an answering machine and talk 2 minutes than the charge is $.51 or $.25 a minute. Even at 100 minutes the correct charge is $.0149 a minute. So unless one likes to make very long talks than it is more expensive than charging a nickel a minute without the connect charge.

    5. Re:Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by bahwi · · Score: 1

      I have this:

      http://sipphone.com/dlink/

      With http://voipjet.com/ for 1.1c/min for US calls, and http://connect.voicepulse.com/ for an incoming line for $11/month for unlimited incoming minutes.

      Mind you, the incoming line is, in the end, optional. And you can add money to your voipjet acct whenever you feel like it. Yes, it requires a unix server, but seriously, on Slashdot, if you don't have one, you must be new.

      No ads either. =)

    6. Re:Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by Matt+Perry · · Score: 1

      I have an MCI pre-paid calling card that I got at Costco for 3 cents a minute. No ads. And you can buy more minutes at the same rate.

      --
      Slashdot: Failed Car Analogies. Amateur Lawyering. Anecdote Battles.
    7. Re:Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by darrylo · · Score: 1

      I'll second this (mods, please bump it up!).

      Yes, there are cheaper alternatives in the US, like Skype or Gizmo, but those require access to a PC. The MCI card just needs POTS, and it also works internationally, although at higher rates. If you're traveling, it's a great way to call back to the US (unless you like getting reamed via hotel or nasty roaming charges).

      (This applies to people in the US, of course.)

    8. Re:Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by Bellum+Aeternus · · Score: 1
      You appearently have never witnessed a daughter on the phone to her mother before (especially when the mother lives on another continent). I swear, the more it costs per minute the more they'll talk.

      Averaging 3 hour phone calls here. I'll take the 49 cent connection fee.

      --
      - I voted for Nintendo and against Bush
    9. Re:Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by matth · · Score: 1

      How the heck are you getting 1.1cent/minute phone calls to the U.S. from voipjet? They charge 1.3cents/minute for U.S. domestic.

    10. Re:Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by rabbitinpumpkin · · Score: 1

      I believe Penny Talk is part of net2phone?

      I love net2phone recharging calling card. Let's my wife call Venezuela for 11 cents a minute and always a clear call. That's better than most deals I've seen. I've yet to see a cheaper/clear call deal. I've seen it at 8cents but you can't hear a word the other person is saying.

      When we both signed up they gave us a ton of free minutes too so it was a great deal.

      This is a pretty good service when you make a crap load of long distant calls to foreign countries. We have cells and we call anywhere in the continental US for free.

    11. Re:Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by IdleTime · · Score: 1

      It's sad that a personal observation and experience over years is rated as flamebait. Again this goes to show that propaganda overshadows truth.

      --
      If you mod me down, I *will* introduce you to my sister!
    12. Re:Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      USA Datanet charges 5c a minute for all long-distance calls in the US. http://www.usadatanet.com/longDistance.html You dial a local number, then dial the area code and phone number. On my phone's speed-dial, I have the USA Datanet local number as a prefix for the long distance numbers. No ads, no VoIP delay, and line quality. Also, I have SBC's All-Distance package (though I almost never use it) which gets me a discount on my DSL service.

    13. Re:Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually, you can bypass that add, just like all of the others, by pressing a digit on the keypad. Just because the system isn't expecting another digit doesn't mean that it won't do something if you give it one.

    14. Re:Wal-Mart LD card charges AND gives me an ad by Evro · · Score: 1

      So stop using it?

      --
      rooooar
  5. Reminds me by MrShaggy · · Score: 0

    of the ad-based PCS that they gave away, what was the name ?

    --
    I have mod points and I am not afraid to use them.
    1. Re:Reminds me by tehwebguy · · Score: 1

      PeoplePC, along with countless other month-long businesses.

      this is not a good idea at all imo. i don't know exactly how they want to execute it but phone calls shouldn't be hindered with some sort of advertisement. i pay around $40/month on my cell and it is nearly unlimited. that's not too bad to me..

      --
      -- lol pwned
  6. Subject by crottsma · · Score: 0
    eBay Wants Voice Phone Free In Five Years

    So do I, so do I.

    1. Re:Subject by justins · · Score: 1
      So per-minute charges will disappear, but I'll have to pay everytime I connect to someone else's phone? That's what that says to me.

      As long as it applies to everyone, including those who are somehow exempt from the glorious do-not-call list, it works for me.

      I'm sure it won't work out that nicely, though.
      --
      Now before I get modded down, I be to remind whoever might read this that what I am saying is FACT. - bogaboga
  7. Free..... by 8127972 · · Score: 0, Redundant

    .... As in beer?

    --
    This is my opinion. To make sure you don't steal it, it's covered by the DMCA.
    1. Re:Free..... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What a 'tard!

  8. As long as... by GeneralEmergency · · Score: 5, Insightful


    ...the FBI has to watch/hear the same advertising that I have to suffer through because of the FCC mandated CALEA IP-taps!

    Sorry, I'm cranky today.

    --
    "A microprocessor... is a terrible thing to waste." --
    GeneralEmergency
  9. Yet another example by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    of Ebay having its head up its ass.

    This is just the continued rumblings of the Internet bubble dunderheads. "We're going to transform the world! You'll have e-phones and e-ads and e-commerce and e-billing and e-rections."

    Phoey. Ma Bell ain't going away anytime soon.

    1. Re:Yet another example by ScoLgo · · Score: 1

      "You'll have e-phones and e-ads and e-commerce and e-billing and e-rections."

      Oh come on. You've got to admit that e-rections would be much better than the plain old rections we're stuck with now.

      --
      "Michael, I did nothing. I did absolutely nothing - and it was everything that I thought it could be."
  10. This is SBC (Southwestern Bell) by dattaway · · Score: 1

    Our telephone company does this already! Even if you are on the DNCL, you will get telemarketing calls from their "partners."

    We had our number ported to Vonage and solicitations stopped immediately.

    1. Re:This is SBC (Southwestern Bell) by vexx0 · · Score: 1

      Yeah SBC are a bunch of coporate bastards who like screwing people over. And its near impossible to stop using there services. They are the only phone company in our area, has the only DSL service, and they own Cingular. They pretty muched forced all the other companies out then starts screwing people, who can't do nothing about it, because its the only service available. To top it off they do alot of the cabling jobs in the area and screw them up because the people who do it are not certified and half off them cant even speak english.

    2. Re:This is SBC (Southwestern Bell) by Yakko · · Score: 1

      I can second this. I had my SBC phone number ported to Vonage, and not only stopped getting calls from unknown numbers, but I save $40/mo (or more if I call LD).

      --

      --
      Me spell chucker work grate. Need grandma chicken.
    3. Re:This is SBC (Southwestern Bell) by TheSpoom · · Score: 1

      My girlfriend's family in Texas was on one of the baby Bells (I forget which, probably BellSouth or SBC) and they switched to Time Warner digital phone service, with the free long distance. They probably got less ads from the partners, but not from the company itself, no sirree! It started dialing them every half hour with COMPLETELY AUTOMATED "come back" messages that they could only stop by redialing the company and waiting half an hour on hold!

      Monopoly agreements with cable and telephone companies such that each one will own a certain geographic area and not compete with one another need to be outlawed. I want COMPETITION for my dollar, not a lack of choice.

      --
      It's better to vote for what you want and not get it than to vote for what you don't want and get it.
      - E. Debs
  11. Ouch, sorry eBay... by }InFuZeD{ · · Score: 1, Funny

    Looks like eBay is hurting... and it's not just because of the Skype purchase.

    From the article:
    "EBay said it had 168.1 registered users for its online auctions as of the end of September."

    1. Re:Ouch, sorry eBay... by eln · · Score: 1

      I feel sorry for that poor one tenth of a user.

  12. How about this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Giving Ebay customers the ability to bid with their cell phones, after all how many people can sit by the computer and hit refresh every time an auction ends?

  13. Is it worth it by elzurawka · · Score: 1

    Say that you want to make a call to eastern europe..your looking at paying 20c/min. a 20 min call will cost you 4$. I think that i would rather save my $4, and listen to a 30 second spot for pepsi. We do it on TV AND we pay for cable service. Why not get free voip, and listen to 30 second add for any long distance call.
    The more the call would cost...the longer or more ads they can run. So when u wana call africa, u might listen to 2 min ad, but better then paying 30$ for a call.

    --
    -EL
  14. EBay has enough trouble already by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    With keyword spam, rampant brand name misuse and other listing policy violations and abuses spiraling ever more out of control, is providing telecom services really what ebay needs to focus on right now? How will they provide me with a dial tone if they can't even provide me with a safe auction?

  15. Great... by TomServo_1 · · Score: 4, Funny

    1. I call someone... while it's connecting me I have to wait 60 seconds to listen to an ad...

    2. Other person picks up the phone... they have to listen to a 60 second ad just to talk to me.

    3. Oops, it's a wrong number. So I have to go back to step one and waste another 60 seconds.

    4. ???

    5. Profit!

    1. Re:Great... by NetPoser · · Score: 0

      You mean....waste another 120 seconds.

  16. free calls by POTSandPANS · · Score: 1
    wow, free telephone service and all we haveto do is have ads! what will they think of next? How about a TV service like HBO, but free! with commercial interruption to support it!

    or maybe it'lll work like AdSense, and whatever your talking about on the telephone will be interrupted with "directed advertising" delivering only advertisments relating to your conversation!

    1. Re:free calls by 2centplain · · Score: 1

      ...next thing, there will be wireless television, supported by ads.
      Apparently, Radio Shack is already selling the hardware to do this. :-)

  17. Maybe in a round-about way by nine-times · · Score: 1
    I could understand the "free phone calls" idea. We have text chatting for free, and it's not hard to imagine that voice stuff will become more common there. As far as I can think, the only reason people get away with charging for VoIP is that it needs to transition, at some point, to the normal voice network to get phone calls to people with normal phones. If we're all VoIP, then I don't see how it's any different from other internet transmissions.

    What I don't see, however, is the "supported by advertising". Not if, by that, he means that you'll have to listen to advertising before/after/during the call. Maybe if he means in a round about way, like Google's jabber service is run by google, who runs on advertising.

    Generally, though, paying for high-bandwidth service should be enough. If we have to, we can make direct connections for voice transmissions. No one needs to be charging me for that beyond my normal ISP price.

  18. Ecoterrorism ad nauseam by Uncle+Op · · Score: 1
    "Our belief is that the winner in this space will be those that have the largest ecosystem," Whitman said.
    At least Whitman didn't use the work "monetize". I heard that a whole bunch before the .com crash.

    I wonder if the the DND rules in the US would apply to ads on the phone? Perhaps not if you had a choice in selecting your Telco.

    1. Re:Ecoterrorism ad nauseam by Seumas · · Score: 3, Funny

      What does Dungeons and Dragons have to do with this?!

  19. Re:Face it, stupid telecom/media companies.. by DaHat · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Isn't that much the same logic that lead to the .com bust? Lots of companies eating lots of money and not actually making any? Nice and idealistic concepts my friend... but still awful naive.

  20. sweet by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    its good to hear that broadband is eliminating other bills and actually saving us money. my site so im not so anonymous...

  21. Imagine if this was combined with google? by arkham6 · · Score: 4, Funny

    me: So greg, my friends and i were going over to the bar ...

    *BEEEP* you said bar, you may want to check out Punters pub, tonight we have free chicken wings! *BEEEP*

    me: urrg. Sorry about that, so we were going to that....place and were drinking some beer...

    *BEEEEP* You said beer. Have you tasted the cool, clean refreshing taste of budweister today? *BEEEEP*

    me: ....FUCKING THING!

    *BEEP* YOu said fuck, have you called 1-900-hot-chix today, for the best in....

  22. So, how's ebay gonna profit from this? by Arpie · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Really just plain ads?

    Or will they take advantage of the new mandatory wiretapping laws, and have automated systems that scan your conversation for keywords and give you related ads?

    Sort of like Google adsense, but with voice content...

    I for one do not welcome our new phone tapping overlords...

    --
    /* TAANSTAFL */
  23. ebay should scratch its own boot by pikine · · Score: 1

    rather than talk about how eBay itself should provide ad-supported auction service, why is it suggesting other telecomm companies to provide ad-supported services?

    and as a company whose customer service over the phone is practically non-existent, phone charge should be least of their concerns.

    --
    I once had a signature.
  24. eBay and phones? by krunoce · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Is it just me or is this like Microsoft going into the car business?

    1. Re:eBay and phones? by Rude+Turnip · · Score: 4, Funny

      This is more like Microsoft going into the vacuum cleaner business and making something that doesn't suck for a change.

    2. Re:eBay and phones? by vexx0 · · Score: 1

      You mean like how M$ wants to team up with Ford to make cars that don't crash http://www.usatoday.com/tech/news/2005-05-01-micro soft-cars_x.htm No pun intended.

  25. I for one welcome our new overlords by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I for one welcome our new
    Buy your Red Hat, get your hot fresh Red Hat
    advertiser-supported telephone overlords.

  26. I always wondered... by msauve · · Score: 5, Funny
    why it's impossible to contact either eBay or PayPal customer support via the telephone.

    Now I know. The cheap bastards are waiting for free phone service.

    --
    "National Security is the chief cause of national insecurity." - Celine's First Law
    1. Re:I always wondered... by imuffin · · Score: 1

      Well, according to this site that lists lots of customer service numbers, you *can* call Ebay's customer service at 1-888-749-3229. Ebay just doesn't advertise the fact.

      ---
      watch funny commercials. laugh.

    2. Re:I always wondered... by DerSenfmeister · · Score: 1

      Contacting PayPal by phone isn't hard... PayPal.com -> help -> contact us -> help by phone (click on 'customer service center' under that heading).

      402.935.2050

      Was that too hard to find? Took me less than thirty seconds to get that number. Seems pretty common sense to me.

  27. Captain obvious by Red+Flayer · · Score: 1

    FTA: "What I mean by that is: the largest number of registered users, the largest number of voice minutes, the largest number of developers who develop the platform, the best product ... that users are willing and want to pay for." (emphasis mine)

    Yes, the 'winner' will be the company with the best product and the highest market share. Nothing about how this justifies purchasing Skype (other than the number of active customers they have now)... which was the point of the release, since eBay has taken so much heat for the purchase.

    Notice also that TFA states that per-minute costs will approach zero... says nothing about subscription fees. We're already seeing per-minute costs approach zero -- unlimited plans are available for traditional telephone as well as VOIP and cell phones.

    Besides, isn't GooglePhone better poised to take over the zero-cost telephony market? Oh wait, that's next month's press release...

    --
    "Trolls they were, but filled with the evil will of their master: a fell race..." -- J.R.R. Tolkien on Olog-hai
  28. Terrible side effects by zoogies · · Score: 1

    What will happen to all those poor retired NFL quarterbacks? They'll have no more commercials to do.

  29. Re:Face it, stupid telecom/media companies.. by mayhemt · · Score: 0

    7. post it on /. (new advertising medium) 8. Profit!!!!

  30. I'd hate to be the point-1 by scdeimos · · Score: 0, Redundant
    Fromt TFA:
    EBay said it had 168.1 registered users for its online auctions as of the end of September.
    Ooh, that smarts.
  31. Yeah so? by Winckle · · Score: 1

    Ebay wants free phone calls? Well I want a solid gold toilet, but we're both going to be disapointed, eh?

    1. Re:Yeah so? by Dekortage · · Score: 1

      Maybe you should stop by this place before eBay makes their phone calls free.

      --
      $nice = $webHosting + $domainNames + $sslCerts
  32. Yahoo beat them to it by Marxist+Hacker+42 · · Score: 1

    You can get this functionality in the latest version of YIM, and I suspect several other instant messengers as well. All this really is, is vonage adware.

    --
    SJW: a person who perceives an injustice, and while correcting it, commits a greater injustice.
    1. Re:Yahoo beat them to it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      ummm...Yahoo and others just do free pc to pc calling, pc to phone still costs money. U R wrong.

  33. Great. Just fucking great. by Caspian · · Score: 5, Funny

    "So I was at work, right? And in comes this customer and.... **We interrupt this call to bring you this exciting informational bulletin! Is your toilet getting messy? Try new ShitWipers, new from S. C. Johnson Wax! For a 5-minute instructional tutorial on how to use your new ShitWipers...press...one! To speak to a representative about new ShitWipers...press...two. To learn about our exciting Web site at ShitWipers dot com...press...three. To hear why ShitWipers are superior to competing toilet wipe products...press...four. To resume your phone call, dial...pound...three...five...seven...one. This message will repeat in 5 seconds. **

    >FIVE<

    I'm sorry, but you didn't respond quickly enough. This message will now repeat.

    We interrupt this call to bring you this exciting informational bulletin! Is your toilet getting messy? Try new ShitWipers, new from...


    >FIVE<

    I'm sorry, you cannot press buttons until this announcement has completed.

    We interrupt this call to bring you this exciting informational..."

    --
    With spending like this, exactly what are "conservatives" conserving?
  34. Free by umbrellasd · · Score: 1

    Things will be free when people stop paying for useless shit. And I guess it is too obvious to say, but Ebay is lying. They do not want phone service to be free. They want to be collecting revenue from you indirectly through lucrative advertising deals. What they should say is, "We want things to look free as soon as possible so that cost is not an obstacle to you entering our consumer market and buying non-free shit as soon as possible."

  35. waste of 4 billion. by digitalPortal · · Score: 1

    in 5 years, every little computer app will allow you to make free calls via the net. its really not that hard to stream sound/audio once bandwidth limitations are overcome. Meg Whitman overpaid for Skype.

  36. It would be... by Jeff+Molby · · Score: 1

    ..if people like you would stop going along with it.

  37. Gov't by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The thing is, someone high up in the gov't will eventually have to approve running ads on all telephone calls. And if it was some senators choice, do you think he'd put up with having to listen to ads when at work or whatever? noo....

  38. Re:Face it, stupid telecom/media companies.. by DoorFrame · · Score: 1

    It's really hard to argue that when Cingular goes out of business because the Government offers free wireless service, that's the result of a "capitalist economy." Now, if they go out of business because another company offers free wireless access, that's capitalist. You weren't specific.

  39. No thanks. I'd rather pay. by Ssolstice · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I'd rather pay for a service that is free from advertisements than get a free service that I can't use when I want to. Most of those "free services" require you to sit through ads before you can use them, such as many website video streams. My time is not free.

  40. Ad-Based Calling in Action by kubevubin · · Score: 2, Funny

    Ha! I can't wait for this! I'll be talking to my mom on the phone, only to have another incoming call, indicated by the usual beep. However, this time, it isn't a person; it's an ad for penis enlargement.

    1. Re:Ad-Based Calling in Action by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'll be talking to my mom on the phone, only to have another incoming call, indicated by the usual beep. However, this time, it isn't a person; it's an ad for penis enlargement.

      Does your mom really need a larger penis?

    2. Re:Ad-Based Calling in Action by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      or something like this:

      Bob: Hi honey!
      Megan: Hello Bob.
      B: Is something wrong dear?
      M: ..I'm two weeks late
      B: Oh no! What do we do??
      M: I don't know honey, I don't know what to----

      "Hello fellow Americans! Would you like to take the Oreck Challenge?!?" ...yes, I know, I'm going to hell for this one.

  41. The miracle of advertising by FishandChips · · Score: 1

    Hmmn, advertising is being touted as some kind of miracle cure-all for IT industry troubles these days, much as medieval peasants waved religious relics around and bought and sold saint's bones (or what they claimed were saint's bones) to ward off plagues and famines. It didn't work then and in any case there weren't enough credible relics to go round, so you had, say, 14 different churches all claiming to contain Christ's right arm or whatever.

    It won't work now, either. There isn't enough advertising money in the world to underwrite the number of allegedly clever ideas all based entirely on advertising revenue. Advertising coarsens and corrupts everything it touches. Perhaps we all need a human rights and privacy law which is the freedom to be let alone from advertising. By law, a telephone carrier for example would be obliged to offer an advert-free service to those who willing to pay for it.

    Besides, this might help some companies to formulate credible business plans that are based on charging for your products instead of giving them away and then wondering why you go bankrupt shortly afterwards.

    --
    Las qué passoun
    tournoun pas maï
  42. VoIP is already "free" by postbigbang · · Score: 1

    Until it's made illegal, like Kazaa, which Skype is nominally based on, it's free, peer to peer. You pay the Internet connectivity usage costs, and whatever dirtbag computer you're got connected to it.

    I won't listen to advertising, or watch it either on a VoIP call. I'll just find another source. Anyone with a PC making 20c/min calls to anywhere needs to dig just a little bit and find a wealth of absolutely free (as in beer) VoIP techniques. If you want to join an Enum/SIP-based network, free ones are forming. No one is going to COPYRIGHT MY DAMN VOICE.

    --
    ---- Teach Peace. It's Cheaper Than War.
  43. Nice article about this in Baltimore city paper by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The Baltimore city paper has a very nice article about this on its front page. Actually, they wouldn't need to pay up that much ads to make the service free!

  44. Well by shoelessone · · Score: 1

    I've heard that the owner of the Skype system is turning to pananism, and in turn has decided to make the calling services assosiated with Skype free, in order to combat what he claims is, "eBays continued plans to take over the global internet buisness". He later added that, "The internet is serious buisness". Anyway, I dont know. I guess we'll see what happens.

  45. 5 years in the future, or 5 years in the past? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Free calls for watching ads?????

    I seem to remember doing this 5 years ago.

    True, VOIP is better now than it was then, but still.

    My, how technology advances

  46. Communication pricing structure outdated? by manarth · · Score: 1

    How much of modern telecommunication is based on outdated, outmoded pricing models?

    • UK competition authorities say mobile phone providers' roaming charges (where you use your phone abroad) are unnecessarily high.
    • Using your mobile's GPRS to access the web costs around £1.00 per MB...trust me - I speak from painful experience - it doesn't take long for that pound a meg to mount up!
    • Using Directory Enquiries used to be free, then there was a nominal charge, so the UK introduced competition and now you pay upwards of 50p (and they often give you the wrong number)...so much for competition.
    • Wireless Internet - HOW MUCH?! £10 an hour (yes, really!) is ridiculous, when you can get wired broadband for £15 a month and stick a £40 wireless router on in.

    Is it just the UK? Are we getting royally screwed by the communications industry? Is VoIP going to be another royal shafting? Answers on a postcard...

    --
    1. Re:Communication pricing structure outdated? by Tony+Hoyle · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Try GPRS while travelling in europe.

      Vodaphone charge £10 per megabyte. And belatedly told me that my 100mb allowance didn't apply. And I left my machine on and Windows Update had kicked in...

      The final bill was more than the laptop cost.

      OTOH in the UK only a complete idiot would pay for a landline call - multiple companies offer unlimited free UK calling, mostly without any monthly fee either.

    2. Re:Communication pricing structure outdated? by xwizbt · · Score: 2, Insightful

      So tell us who. I had moderator privileges, I was going to up you, but there's a distinct lack of information. Give us more and we up you more... what UK companies?

    3. Re:Communication pricing structure outdated? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Using your mobile's GPRS to access the web costs around £1.00 per MB...trust me - I speak from painful experience - it doesn't take long for that pound a meg to mount up!

      Ever used GPRS abroad? Now that's anal rape. We're talking up to £25 per MB in some countries, prices start at around £12 per MB IIRC.

  47. Ad supported calling would be awesome... by Errandboy+of+Doom · · Score: 4, Funny

    Awesome for geeks anyway... we'll all just use adblockers or alternative, open-source brows... er phones.

    1. Re:Ad supported calling would be awesome... by kripkenstein · · Score: 1

      Exactly. So you need to listen to a 15-second ad before starting your call? How long before we all install code that just blanks out the sound for those 15 seconds, and writes meanwhile "call commencing in 15...14...13...12...11...", while playing a musical choice of our own?

  48. Ecosystems? Best product? by Dekortage · · Score: 1

    From the article: "Our belief is that the winner in this space will be those that have the largest ecosystem," Whitman said. "What I mean by that is: the largest number of registered users, the largest number of voice minutes, the largest number of developers who develop the platform, the best product ... that users are willing and want to pay for."

    Aside from the marketing fru-fru use of of the word "ecosystem," she makes perfect sense. Except that she can't assume that just because someone sells something on eBay, they will use Skype. As for the largest number of developers, it's not like these other guys are small potatoes.

    As for advertising... maybe it's just something in the background of your free phone calls, like a softly playing radio station. Maybe it just has onscreen ads every time you use the software (e.g. the Eudora model). Maybe they mean they'll sell your Skype number to telemarketers!

    The real question is, how can eBay blend its online auctions and PayPal with VoIP features? Voice chat with a seller? Real live auctioneers during the final mad minutes of an auction? Auctioning off vanity Skype numbers, or access to Skype-based porn?

    --
    $nice = $webHosting + $domainNames + $sslCerts
  49. Thought it WAS free? by dada21 · · Score: 1

    I haven't had a landline service for 3 years but I recall my bill:

    $122: total
    -7: Caller ID
    -4: Touch tone
    -9: Voice Mail
    -4: 3 Way Calling
    -8: Unlimited *69
    -11: Help The Needy Tax
    -9: City Tax
    -8: State Tax
    -3: Telegraph Tax
    -4: Freedom Tax
    -3: Voluntary Anti-terrorism Tax
    -2: White Pages Listing
    -50: DSL
    ====
    $0 - Free phone service (unlimited calls)!

  50. Free as in now by baomike · · Score: 1

    You mean like how I do it now with a land line.

  51. WTF?!? by sootman · · Score: 1

    My phone calls don't involve transactions and I sure as hell don't want ads. Other than that, it sounds like a great plan.

    What are they thinking? Not everything can, or should, be free. And if they're trying to say that phone calls will be free as part of a non-free package, then they aren't exactly free, are they? By that logic, I can make unlimited local calls free already--as part of a package that includes call waiting, caller ID, etc.

    --
    Dear Slashdot: next time you want to mess with the site, add a rich-text editor for comments.
  52. Re:In the future... by vertinox · · Score: 2, Funny

    In the year 2020, the only way to block 24/7 ads is to gougue out your eyes and pop your eardrums.

    However, by 2021 nanobots will constantly press on the skin of the deaf and blind with brail ads.

    --
    "I am the king of the Romans, and am superior to rules of grammar!"
    -Sigismund, Holy Roman Emperor (1368-1437)
  53. Sure, but it won't be EBay's phone by werelnon · · Score: 1

    Why EBay would buy an Internet phone which cannot be embedded in a webpage, when they are a completely web-based company is hard to understand. Of course if they can get Skype preinstalled maybe Joe Blow will use it, but I'd say Microsoft has a better chance of getting their Messenger/Teleo service preinstalled :).

    So, EBay has payed billions of dollars for a system which they will procede to destroy with ads and Microsoft will preinstall the app that everyone will use. Perhaps phone calls will be free, but it won't be EBay that provides the service.

    --
    The Switchboard - get a private browser based VoIP system for your web-site for $40

    1. Re:Sure, but it won't be EBay's phone by Lucractius · · Score: 1

      id say eBay could do to skype something similar to whats in your Sig... Problem solved.

      --
      XML - A clever joke would be here if /. didn't mangle tag brackets.
    2. Re:Sure, but it won't be EBay's phone by Breakfast+Pants · · Score: 1

      They would lose all advantages that skype gives. You can't do peer-to-peer communication with a java applet. Java applets only have the security permission to open an outgoing socket to the domain from which the applet was loaded.

      --

      --

      WHO ATE MY BREAKFAST PANTS?
  54. Your calling patterns may vary by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Perhaps the poster spends all day reading /. and hardly ever talks on the phone and only makes short calls?

    Show him a cell phone or land line plan for under $0.05x200=$10/month for 100 2-minute calls.

    1. Re:Your calling patterns may vary by Gordonjcp · · Score: 1

      Orange Pay-as-you-Go, if you stick £50 in to begin with. Do that, and all your calls and SMSes become cheaper. Not only that but it stays cheap unless you run it down to zero.

  55. well, duh. by kccdc · · Score: 1

    Why on earth do you think Google wants to start picking dark fiber and implementing free wifi throughout major cities. It's not because they're not evil, it's because the internet providers of today are going to be the phone providers of tomorrow. I wrote a couple of posts about it on my site back when Google introduced Gtalk: http://www.yesterdaywasdramatic.com/articles/2005/ 08/29/more-crazy-thoughts-on-google Basically, I think google is going to offer some form of advertising(location based?) in order to offer free phone service. I think pay phone carriers will still exist for those who don't want adverts tied to their phone calls. I've never used ebay, but I think unless they utilize Skype with a heavily user centered design focus, Google stands a good chance to step into this arena and win it over. I'm pretty sure the reason Gtalk is so basic is that Google didn't want to confuse end users with it's primary focus(simple voice and text chat). My money's on Google to win this one.

  56. "or transaction fees." really not "free" at all. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    They use the word "free" extremely loosely. You either pay in currency or you pay in tolerance. Make no mistakes about it ladies and gents. Nothing in life is "free".

  57. One up side... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You know your line is being tapped when you hear ads targeted at law enforcement officers.

  58. per-minute is zero, NOW. by beeblebrox · · Score: 1

    I'm not paying for "telephone" minutes per se, haven't done so for quite a while. My $53/month naked DSL bill pays for my SIP calls, thankyoumerymuch.

    I also pay for (relatively) scarce radio spectrum through my mobile phone bill, and *that* is metered. It doesn't have to be:

    My mobile provider offers "free" in-network calls, so if I was so inclined, with a second mobile permanently tethered to my home setup I could have a $0.00/minute gateway from my (other) mobile, wherever I am as long as I'm not roaming. Modulo what happens to DTMF on the mobile-to-mobile voice call, which I haven't investagated.

    1. Re:per-minute is zero, NOW. by narcc · · Score: 1

      [If I'm not roaming...]

      I use CellularOne. They have a plan (which I use) where you have "unlimited minutes". For an additional 5 bucks a month, I also get "free long distance" (er, free for 5 bucks a month, that is)

      My phone bill is $68.00 a month no matter how long I talk, where I call, who I call, or what time I call. e.g. From Pennsylvania I can call any random person in California and talk from January 1st to December 31st 24/7 and my bill will still be only $68.00 a month.

      Now why doesn't Verizon or some other company offer a plan like that? (I hate CellOne) People aren't going to accept this per-minute, per-text, per-kilobyte nonsense for long! Don't give it to me for ad-supported-free! (I hate ads!) Give it to me for a reasonable flat monthly rate!

  59. In Other News... by terrahertz · · Score: 1

    In a few short years, users can expect to offer items at auction for free, with no fractional charges, as part of a package of services through which auction site operators make money on advertising, Verizon's chief executive said on Wednesday. The same chief executive was later seen singing "They're Coming To Take Me Away, Ha-haaa" by Napoleon XIV.

    --
    Slashdot? Oh, I just read it for the articles.
  60. context sensitive ads by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    Based on the conversation you are having .. you will hear ads. Don't worry I am sure the interruptions will be polite...

    *ring*

    GF: Hello
    You: Hey baby

    Voice: Sorry to interrupt, did you know that you can buy Hay at a really low price from Bob's farm on route 64?

    You: o..

    Voice: And for your baby, there is a special on Baby food going on right at Joe's Groceryu store ..if you buy in bulk .. I can even dial the number for you now to reserve your case.. note your current call will be interrupted.

    You: I'm not interested

    Voice: No problem. I see that you called a different lady prior to this call, so you may be interested in our new "more friends" plan?

  61. utilities by way2trivial · · Score: 1

    electric- charge for delivery service (the connection)
    electric- charge for electricity consumed

    Telephone- charge for basic service
    telephone- charge for making calls

    Water- charge for service
    water- charge for useage
    water-charge for sewer service
    water-charge for sewer volume

    cable tv- charge for service
    cable tv- useage subsidised by commercials or premium payments for some channels.

    --
    every day http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Random
    1. Re:utilities by pete6677 · · Score: 1

      Go to an NFL game: pay a lot for tickets, see the same commercials on the big screen as the TV viewers see. How's that for paying to receive ads?

    2. Re:utilities by dpmapping · · Score: 1
      Go to an NFL game: pay a lot for tickets, see the same commercials on the big screen as the TV viewers see. How's that for paying to receive ads?

      Go to an NFL game: pay a lot for the tickets, watch the game, look at the field of play, see the bits the TV viewers don't see. How's that for paying to avoid recieving ads?

  62. Free phone by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Many internet providers already offer unlimited free national phone calls... in France
    You just need a DSL modem in which the phone plugs into.

    You can do it with AOL: it's the AOLBox
    You can do it with Neuf: it's the NeufBox
    You can do it with Free: it's the FreeBox
    OK, I think you get the picture.

    It's not in 5 years, it's now. And there are no ads, of course. It's free for land lines. For cell phones, add a small charge.

    1. Re:Free phone by Eunuchswear · · Score: 1

      Not quite true. Neuf Telecom doesn't use voip for it's unlimited free national calls, just straightforward telephony.

      (In France we have this funny thing called "competition" - you can get your telephone and DSL service from different suppliers, there are no local monopolies. Strangely enough this seems to be causing the prices to drop and new services get created (Voip, TV over DSL, etc).)

      --
      Watch this Heartland Institute video
  63. I'll just stick with my cell by MisterMoney · · Score: 1

    and pay a little money thanks.

    got a good plan and a number that follows me everywhere.

    who needs voip.

  64. Re:eBay Out! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I'm not sure what they are smoking in the executive boardroom either.

    What expertise do they have?

    HOW does this fit into what they are doing now?

    This HAS TO BE and unqualified disaster in the making. No wonder their stock price is falling.

  65. Re:Face it, stupid telecom/media companies.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful
    I don't know where to start with this guy, so I'll just say this:
    This is a capitalist economy - no matter what, SOMEONE will be making money and someone will be losing it.
    This statement is absolutely true. It also invalidates everything else he says. If money is always changing hands for any given product or service, then nothing is free.
  66. Mod parent up, very informative article indeed! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I wish more people would dig up such valuable links!

  67. I'll trust eBay with my phone by saskboy · · Score: 1

    I'll trust eBay with my phone...when pigs fly! They can't program an HTML editor, much less something like Skype.

    "Thank you for reaching 911, please hold while you listen to an ad for one of our sponsors."

    "You cannot make this call because either your feedback has dropped to -1, or your PayPal balance has been frozen. Please try again later after you've built up more positive feedback, or fax us your drivers license."

    "How would you rate your conversation?
    Positive, Negative, or Neutral?"

    eBay, and PayPal running the phone company? The irony is, it's about the only multi-billion dollar, multi-national corporation I know of that doesn't have a published toll free contact number for customer service. If you try to post the number to their help forums, they remove the post.

    --
    Saskboy's blog is good. 9 out of 10 dentists agree.
  68. Re:eBay Out! by earnest+murderer · · Score: 1

    What expertise do they have?

    HOW does this fit into what they are doing now?


    How about you read the fucking article and find out.

    --
    Platform advocacy is like choosing a favorite severely developmentally disabled child.
  69. Re:In the future... by beaststwo · · Score: 1
    I'd think that by 2020, advertisers wouldn't need such crude input paths. Better yet to just repeatedly impress ads directly on your brain. They could have you experience virutally buying their product so many times that you buy it out of force of habit without thinking.

    At that point, the only way to avoid avertising would be to remove your brain. Of course so many people seem to function without brains now that they could just operate your body instead.

  70. The problem is not bandwidth... by msauve · · Score: 1

    it's QoS. There are simply no guarantees for delay and latency on the Internet. Given the lack of financial incentives for one ISP to honor QoS markings coming in from another ISP, it's very unlikely that end-to-end QoS will ever happen in the existing Internet model.

    --
    "National Security is the chief cause of national insecurity." - Celine's First Law
    1. Re:The problem is not bandwidth... by John+Miles · · Score: 1

      Fine. How does Skype give me better QoS than I'd get with my own 100 lines of Winsock code?

      I seriously do not understand the amount of commercial attention Skype got. It's as if a bunch of megacorps all wanted a piece of the municipal water business, so one of them (eBay) rushed out and spent $4,000,000,000 for a company that makes garden hoses.

      --
      Dahlmann tightly grips the knife, which he may have no idea how to use, and steps out into the plain.
  71. Re:No thanks. I'd rather pay. by MerlinTheWizard · · Score: 1

    You make a very good point. All these "apparently free" services supported by ads assume on some level that you don't value your time, at least not as much as you value your money. That's twisted though; because you can always make more money; but as far as I can tell, any amount of time you have wasted is lost forever...

  72. last time i checked... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    phones weren't hardwired into our ears.

    unless you guys are on a different page than i am.

  73. stating the obvious by sparc_mepronet · · Score: 1
    The is great news and confirms what everyone allready new. Five years from now most phonecalls will be free. With or without help from the nice folks at Ebay.

    "In the end, the price that anyone can provide for voice transmission on the 'Net will trend toward zero,"

    Lets analyse this:

    -Broadband will be free? Highly doubt that.

    -As in the service your gateway provider delivers to get calls outside the network, with people actually being able to understand what the other party is saying? Doubt that will be free either.

    In the end, when everything is free or approaching 0, who will Joey Average call when things do not work as advertized. There will be no support staff, since they are alledgedly enjoying a 'free' trip to planet Utopia.

  74. overreaction by GrayFox777 · · Score: 1

    It wouldn't make any sense to force people to listen to ads before or during every phone call. The advertising is probably done in other ways.

  75. Free ? by jeriqo · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Do they mean free international phone calls ?
    I already can call by phone for free in my country.

    --
    Alexis 'jeriqo' BRET
  76. It's a time-honored business strategy by swm · · Score: 1
    Whitman said Skype's explosive success, would -- over the next several years -- drive the cost of phone calls to nothing.

    "Our belief is that the winner in this space will be those that have the largest ecosystem.

    We lose money on every sale, and make it up in volume!

  77. Jumping to conclusions by pudmonkey · · Score: 1

    This article is so brief that we don't the specific details. Nothing in life is black or white; if the ads are short than it's worth the trade off. If they are long and repeating then it's not worth it. Either way, if you don't like ads then there will be an option to still pay for phone service, if you don't care about ads then take the free service.

  78. sure it will be free. by bxbaser · · Score: 1

    Ad driven model is sure to make the costs free.
    Which is why ebay and paypal are using the free advertiser driven model now.
    More than likely explosive growth will lead to explosive charges.

  79. Another Cable/Telephone allegory by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    We pay for telephone service without commercials. Why can't we pay for TV service without commercials too?

  80. Yeah, I'll give eBay more of my personal info by nanojath · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Presuming eBay plans to be as free with information about my telephone habits as they are with information from my auction account, I think I'll stick with my phone bill, thanks.

    On a more general note, though I'm sure this is subject to change, right now my phone bill is the least of my worries, frankly. The land line is a bargain considering what it does for me every day, and it just plain works... I've lost my power, my internet, my cable for periods of time, but I've been living in my town for over a decade and not once has my phone gone out for even a minute in all that time. Figure out a way to deliver heat through the internet - that's the bill I'm worried about this winter.

    --

    It Is the Nature of Information to Transgress Artificial Boundaries

  81. More ads by billcopc · · Score: 1

    Does having more advertising shoved into our skulls really have a positive net effect on income ? Some commercials are actually entertaining (mostly funny ones), but for the most part it's more of the same poop. Some dumb ho walking around in new overpriced jeans (and little else), or some white-trash male model promoting chewing gum. It's goddamned chewing gum, if I feel like gum I'll look at the display rack at the convenience store. :P

    I like advertising that teaches me new stuff.. informs me of products I was not aware of, and hopefully that I'm interested in. I don't need to see some dyke faking a (bad) orgasm in her shower thanks to X-garbage-shampoo. I don't need McDonalds to remind me they still sell BigMacs. I might actually like to hear about a new soft drink, and they could shut the hell up once half the world knows about Diet Ultra Coke Purple. Once I've tried it, I don't need more advertising, I'll just buy some at the store if I want it.

    The day marketing stops treating humankind as puppets, is the day they will earn my respect.

    --
    -Billco, Fnarg.com
  82. This reminds me of by ScrewMaster · · Score: 1

    when @Home spent some $900 million on Blue Mountain Greeting Cards. @Home went belly-up for that plus a number of other reasons ... but blowing almost a billion on an electronic greeting card company wasn't too smart. They could have used that money to stay in business, rather than making me give up my 4 mbit/sec symmetric @Home connection for AT&T Broadband's wimpy-assed 1.5/256, followed by Comcast's 3.0/384. So now here's E-Bay betting a truckload of green that they can make money from "free" phone calls. Unless they can get some kind of law passed that says that transmitting voice over IP via anything that other than an "official" provider is illegal, I can't see how they're going to get much of an R on that I. I understand the concept of diversification but, well ... I guess don't have the big picture.

    No doubt it's on a greeting card somewhere.

    --
    The higher the technology, the sharper that two-edged sword.
  83. You forgot movie theatres by mindaktiviti · · Score: 2, Interesting
    Only the stupid masses (i.e. you and I) would pay money to go watch advertisements...oh yeah, and afterwards watch some movie that's probably not that great anyway. But it was worth it because of the $10 popcorn combo, right? You can buy a huge rib-eye steak at your local butchershop with that money! :(

    Off topic I know...

  84. ISPs doing VoIP filtering? by CrimsonScythe · · Score: 0

    I wonder how this business, and the rest of the VoIP business, will manage if/when the ISPs start filtering out and stopping or delaying the VoIP packets?

    There was an article in the latest IEEE Spectrum about it:
    The VoIP Backlash

    Doesn't look good, IMO.

    --
    The view was horrible and the smell was even worse; Julie severely regretted becoming a proctologist.
  85. /. hates eBay by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    A bunch of trolls when it comes to eBay. Giz on the Google logo, shit on eBay. Skype was great before eBay bought it. Even though eBay is going to do nothing to Skype, Skype becomes a POS. Sure.

    Yes, I am green...

  86. Re:eBay Out! by steve+buttgereit · · Score: 1

    I'm not sure what they are smoking in the executive boardroom either.

    What expertise do they have?

    HOW does this fit into what they are doing now?


    You know... that's what a lot of people once said about a guy that owned a chain of record stores and a record label when he tried to get into the airline business. At the end of the day, Richard Branson's Virgin Atlantic hasn't done too bad over the years. Of course, I haven't tracked it since I worked for Virgin (record stores), but I believe the airline is still around today.

  87. Subject by Legion303 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    "carriers make money on advertising or transaction fees"

    This is kind of vague, and the article goes into zero detail.

    So per-minute charges will disappear, but I'll have to pay everytime I connect to someone else's phone? That's what that says to me.

    As for advertising, I'd rather just keep taking it in the ass each month from Qworst than listen to one second of some asshole telling me how his company makes the world better by selling me shit I don't want.

  88. information wants to be free by wikinerd · · Score: 1

    Some years ago when politicians discovered that Internet users where swapping emails without paying postage, some people discussed the idea that in the future email senders should have to pay something. But information wants to be free, and the Internet Protocol now allows users to make inexpensive phone calls across the planet. Not only politicians failed to tax email, but the power of the Internet bitten back and made phone free too. Information is by its very nature unstoppable, so politicians and business managers should better find other ways to get money and let us enjoy as much information as we want.

  89. The internet is serious buisness? by mbius · · Score: 1

    I see what you did there.

    --
    you can have my violent video games when you pry them from my cold, dead hands.
    Prime UID Club
  90. It doesn't,... by msauve · · Score: 1
    nor did I say or imply that it does. Lack of QoS is why VoIP across the Internet will not replace traditional telephony services, at least for those who care about call quality and reliability.

    VoIP has a place withing network domains under a single administrative control - i.e. If Skype were to also offer ISP service using their own network, they could then offer workable QoS, and reasonable SLAs.

    --
    "National Security is the chief cause of national insecurity." - Celine's First Law
  91. eBay providing phone service a joke by salmonz · · Score: 1

    eBay is the last company I expect to provide phone service. The market is already "over-extended" with phone service. Paid service, free service, and now another free service? To my recollection, once eBay pisses off a person, they never never come back. Once you have an issue with Paypal or eBay which eventually everyone will have - eBay will go down. Why do you think their numbers are slipping? 1. They charge too much. 2. They don't care - just as long as they have your money.

  92. VOIP is here to stay ..... by ajs318 · · Score: 1

    ..... but Skype isn't.

    The whole point of telephony is interconnectivity, which Skype is going dead against with its closed protocol. {I'm using a hardware SIP phone [the only way to do it IMHO] and my own copy of Asterisk to connect through an ISDN line at work ..... with my boss's blessing}. Now that's compatible with every "proper" SIP phone and, thanks to the gateway, with every ordinary telephone whether mobile or tethered. I can even introduce encryption at the IAX layer {present assumption: any machine on my LAN is trustworthy; if/when Wireless is introduced, it will be encrypted and tightly firewalled}.

    Unless Skype is opened -- willingly or by force {are you out there, DVD Jon?} -- it will not succeed in the long term. Its short-term success is due to early adopters; not all of whom will stay loyal, particularly once the insurmountable-by-design disadvantages begin to become apparent. How many electric companies do you know that sell 72V, 20Hz out of weird sockets with two half-moon and one flat pin and are still in business?

    --
    Je fume. Tu fumes. Nous fûmes!
  93. Re:eBay Out! by Lucractius · · Score: 1

    and now flying world wide thanks to its pacific counterpart Virgin Blue

    --
    XML - A clever joke would be here if /. didn't mangle tag brackets.
  94. 911 what is ur... by Archades · · Score: 0

    911 what is ur emergency HELP MY LEG IS BLEEDING.BEEP(advert=are u bleeding? try our new band-aids, for all ur cuts*bleep* help my leg is Beeep(advert=leg of ham, on sale now for 99cents) *dead*

  95. Re:Ecosystems? Best product? by Lucractius · · Score: 1

    do they think the skype based pron would be less stealable than the audio story porn thats on the net... or are they going to develop skype based 1900 numbers for skype phone"sex"

    --
    XML - A clever joke would be here if /. didn't mangle tag brackets.
  96. Free phone service - not possible by iSearch · · Score: 1

    It's like free hosting. There is a cost associated with every assigned telephone number, there is a cost associated with every outbound call even to a local number, and the cost for long distance is even greater. Free hosts have to cheat, use cheap bandwidth and dump high use accounts to remain even marginally profitable. Thus far in internet history, users have proven that they will do whatever is possible to block advertisements and that as they become desensitized to ad formats the CTRs plumet. Short term perhaps ebay can create enough spin that they will be able to convince their stockholders that their 4 billion dollar blunder has an upside, but my bet is still that in 2010 we'll all look back and laugh.

  97. The joys of people trying to get stuff for free by Targon · · Score: 1

    I'll stick with companies like Vonage who provide VOIP services for a fairly low amount of money each month without needing to pay per minute. It may not be "free", but companies that charge anywhere from $15-$40 per month and provide voice services without subjecting their customers to advertisements is the way things are going.

    There may be advertising based voice services out there for those wanting to pay nothing for their service, or for those who can't afford $25/month in addition to their internet connection payment, but those will be a small fraction of the number of people using voice services.

    Hmmmm, a game costs $60 for the new games that are comming out, $12-$15/month for a MMORPG payment, and people don't want to pay $25/month for their voice phone service?

  98. Why can't they do this now? by salmonz · · Score: 1

    If eBay bought Skype, why can't they do this now? Just make it free now.

    I don't get it.

    1. Re:Why can't they do this now? by Breakfast+Pants · · Score: 1

      It already is free, computer to computer. What they are saying is it will be free computer to phone, which they can't do now because it costs more money than can be recovered in advertisements.

      --

      --

      WHO ATE MY BREAKFAST PANTS?
  99. Re:In the future... by starakurva · · Score: 1

    This man is very dangerous.

    --
    All you need is lurv.
  100. Re:In the future... by Pope · · Score: 1

    In 2020 everything will be owned and produced by ChinaCo(tm) and therefore no advertising needed!

    YOU WILL BUY A NEW CHINACO(tm) PRODUCT

    --
    It doesn't mean much now, it's built for the future.
  101. Two Words by superNag · · Score: 1

    VoIP Buster. Works like a charm. Now. No ads. And I'm not planting one now. :)

    --

    no idea.

  102. How will ads fund phone calls? by shamus · · Score: 1

    Is advertising as revenue earning really going to continue to be such a viable model. Even one that seems to be increasing?

    Surely they don't seriously think anybody is going to sign up for something that interrupts calls or insists on you listening to an ad before placing a call. That's just the obvious hyperbole line to take.

    So, how does advertising and phone calls work? You can put banners and popups on the software tools, but people will manage to block them. Besides, they like to sell Skype phones, so that doesn't help. Ads on the Skype phone? Only way I can see that working is if you replace the buttons with a touchscreen that shows ads when you're not actually dialing. Though that again still fails when you consider the trend towards cradle free wireless phones.

    Anyone care to conjecture, seriously, just how advertising can fund phone calls?

    --

    What's worse, ignorance or apathy? Who knows, and who cares.