ICQ Starts Blocking Alternative Clients
An anonymous reader writes "It appears that since yesterday ICQ has blocked access to the ICQ network to alternative clients. Users of QIP, Adium, and other clients are getting a 'The client version you are using is too old. Please upgrade'. No comment yet from ICQ or AOL."
In other news... people still use ICQ?
No problems here using Miranda IM. (http://www.miranda-im.org/)
That said, the forum thread is interesting. Looks like the ICQ admins are censoring posts.
Do daemons dream of electric sleep()?
I still know my ICQ number.. but haven't logged in years!
The one thing AOL has always excelled at is cutting off its nose to spite its face. Though I am rather grateful for all those nice, metal disc boxes which I spray-painted in solid colors (for more worthy discs). They really look great.
Caveat Utilitor
Actually, they're forcing windows users to upgrade.. It has nothing to do with blocking alternative clients.
In other news, GnomeICU still works and pidgin has just made a new release with sends a newer version number.
And working just fine at this very moment.
I got the "your client is too old" message today, did a manual "check for updates" and found that a new version of Adium (1.2.6) was released and after upgrading ICQ works again.
My other account has a 3-digit UID.
I thought ICQ died years ago. Apart from MSN, which I use very rarely, what other IM clients are in common use?
Summation 2
Kopete fixed this, well, you have to edit a config file, but once you do that it works fine on Kopete.
I was getting this earlier, but the latest seems to connect just fine.
Each processor would proceed sequentially as if it had been better for them not to rise against Saul.
boooooooooooo
I'd really hate it if Trillian or Miranda tells me tommorrow, "Please upgrade your version of AIM." Using the actual AIM client is like torture.
In Argentina ICQ is now something you may remember as you remember Altavista, and other ".com" fossils.
(most people use MSN, and geeks use gtalk).
DNA in your Linux: DNALinux
To me, this mostly raises one question - how does ICQ identify clients in the first place, and why don't alternative clients spoof their identification and try to pass off as the official client?
Adium 1.2.6 is now out which fixes ICQ connectivity.
And I'm looking at you Yahoo. To ensure you have the latest and greatist piece of yahoo IM they disallow you to do any type of file/photo sharing and make web cam stuff a living hell unless you have the newest version. They were pulling this stunt back when i was using XP & Trillian. I have since moved up to Kubuntu & Kopete, but yahoo is still a POS in that respect.
Now, if Yahoo's native linux client wasn't stuck back in 1999 we might have a chance. Maybe with Google and Yahoo joining forces something will get done.
But I'm not hopeful.
I call it 'The Aristocrats'
"You Dick!"
The Kruger Dunning explains most post on
Wanna bet that within the next few patch of each respective IM client they will fix this? This is a common misconception for software companies is they think that restricting protocols like this will help pigeon hole people into using their software, when in 2 months all the other 3rd parties will work again...
I fired it up last night to talk to some old UO friends. I was told that I would have to upgrade to connect so I did. The new client crashes every time I try to launch it. So, instead I tried Trillian and it worked. Maybe that's changed today; haven't tried yet. I will check it out after this con-call that I'm on.
meebo.com is an online client, works fine for me because i don't have the patched pidgin version
Go home Cartman.
My ICQ number is 6 digits, in the 500,000 range. I do not know if they started off at 100,000 or below. I never really used ICQ then or now. I just got a number to fit in. :P
What I like is if you go to the tech forum on ICQ referred to in initial post you'll see that most if not all workarounds have been edited out by ICQ....nice.
Unix, an obscure operating system developed by bored researchers in an attempt to get a better game playing experience.
Pidgin has released an update to fix it.
If they changed the protocol as part of an 'upgrade', it only makes sense to block older clients. If a 3rd party isn't 'current' yet and is blocked its not AOL's fault.
---- Booth was a patriot ----
But I checked and 2.4.3 was just released and that fixed the issue.
Anyone else still using Trillian?
Kopete updates its version file automatically, so no need to edit anything. Kopete will do it for you.
-- B.
This sig does in fact not have the property it claims not to have.
Well at least I know why I wasn't connecting to ICQ earlier.
I'm using Adium (haven't upgraded yet) and the message I get is this:
"The client version you are using is too old. Please upgrade at http://pidgin.im"
So I don't think that it's really a matter of freezing out alternative clients. If it were, it would tell me to go get the new official AIM client, not Pidgin. Instead, I think they're just trying to force an upgrade beyond some specific version of libpurple. It could be about security issues, but I haven't really researched it.
I lost a very low 6 digit UIN (I was an early starter with it), due to the fact I couldn't recover any password or anything. I was extremely pissed off, so I just stopped using it.
That was 3 years ago.
The price is always right if someone else is paying.
And nothing of value was lost
"I only speak the truth"
Karma: null(Mostly affected by an unassigned variable)
I thought ICQ died years ago. Apart from MSN, which I use very rarely, what other IM clients are in common use?
Depending your geography and demographics, then you will find the popular IM network is not the same. For example ICQ still has a certain popularity in Eastern Europe, QQ in China and South Africa. Avoid basing global statistics on your own usage habits.
Jumpstart the tartan drive.
I thought it was advertisement system with a instant messaging feature in the corner somewhere.
Really though, I put up with the ads for years, and I may well still have been using it, but both AIM and ICQ got so bloated, plus the use of such large, animated ads, with SOUND. If they had just kept it simple, static ads, I'd never have bothered with a 3rd party client, and would still be getting their ads.
Yeah, I don't suppose it's right to still use the service without getting the ads (I use it far less now, though), but if I and people like me get pushed away, it's going to start to effect the numbers of people that DO use the ad based client.
I know google talk is ad-less, what are the adds like on MSN? Yahoo seems the worst offender, so I'd be curious what other options are out there?
One of my friends, one who is too lazy to ever upgrade from Debian Stable, hence still running the old Pidgin, called Gaim, claims it to be working fine with ICQ.
It's all fun & games until someone loses the game.
meebo.com still works to access it.
Another good reason to stop raping icq's corpse and start to use nifty and religiously right jabber.
Why do people use alternative clients? Easy reason: To have one client able to access many IM networks.
You know what it's like. You have a few friends that use ICQ, others that use YM, still others that use something completely different... and you'd have to install 10 clients just to keep in touch with all of them.
What do you do instead? You install one client that handles all.
And what do you do when your client stops working for a certain network because its maker decides to disallow the use of third party clients? Will you stop using the network and tell your friends to get some other IM system to keep in touch with you, or will you clog your system (and ports) with yet another messenger software?
We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
My legacy GAIM never broke, and Pidgin, which had the problem yesterday, is fine this morning. Seems to have been an error rather than a deliberate attempt to interfere.
This seems to be a force to current version as opposed to blocking third party clients. I still used ICQ 5.1 at work to stay in touch with a select few people, as it is not as obtrusive as AIM.
I have to wonder if this is an outrage test for AOL to see what kind of response they would get if they started chopping off the older versions of the AIM client.
What holocaust?
http://www.onethirdoftheholocaust.com/
The only reason I use ICQ is because you can send inline images.
If anybody can point me to any other protocol that also supports it would be most appreciated.
From what I can see the headline is terribly misleading.
ICQ did not block alternative clients, they blocked clients that were reporting an old version. This was done primarily to force users of older versions of ICQ's official client to upgrade.
Pidgin's website was down for a good several hours yesterday - getting hammered by people who couldn't connect to ICQ, I would assume. But once the site was up there was a notice right on the front page and a patch was almost immediately available if you wanted to compile it yourself. Took a little bit longer for the binaries to become available.
Today, less than 24 hours later, Pidgin is working fine for me again.
I've noticed the same thing. I can't get connected via Pidgin at all...
Darryl L. Pierce "What do you care what people think, Mr. Feynman?"
Yah, the title of this comment says it all doesn't it? Ahh, I miss ICQ and my 6-digit id. Alas, logging on to that network is like returning to windows... spam popup, spam popup, spam popup You can really tell AOL owns it
I keep my low ICQ number because it is even older than my slashdot ID.
"It's because they're stupid, that's why. That's why everybody does everything." -Homer Simpson
Well, on the topic of forcing people to upgrade... maybe if the newer software wasn't so retarded, more people would upgrade. Just a thought.
Admittedly my anecdote isn't comprehensive marketing data and isn't that new either, but just to illustrate a point. So at one point I wanted to communicate with someone who supposedly had only ICQ.
The last version I had used before was, IIRC, 2002a. Or something. At any rate, it was a relatively clean interface, with just the two text-fields needed, and the minimum of buttons that one might need. All in the Windows configured colours, and with sensible icons that are there, but don't scream for attention and don't look like someone flew an airplane into a clown makeup factory. I'm not necessarily a fan of ICQ or AOL, but I could respect that interface.
Well, I figured, wth, let's get the newest version. You know, what with potential security holes and whatnot in older versions. I think the version at the moment was ICQ 4. "With Xtraz!" The l33t (ok, SMS-speak) spelling in a product name should have been warning enough. It was everything that the old version wasn't: retarded and annoying and looking like a desperate scream for attention. IIRC with an ad banner thrown in for good measure too.
I actually went "oh, fuck the security holes, that's why I have an anti-virus and data execution check turned on." I actually uninstalled it and dug through old backup CD-R's to find my trusted old version.
Well, I uninstalled it completely after a few days and never looked back. So I wouldn't know if the even newer versions fixed that or continued down that slope towards software-Alzheimer's.
But just saying... if you find that you have to _force_ people to give up their old versions and use the newer one, even when it's for free (as in beer;)... there may be some subtle hint in there.
And yeah, I know there are other programs one can use instead of the official client. They're just kinda irrelevant for the point I was trying to make, which is about AOL making the users of its official client upgrade.
A polar bear is a cartesian bear after a coordinate transform.
Popular in Germany, too.
yep! the judish instant messenger program shakes them down for a few more shekels!!
I logged in for the first time in probably 9 or 10 years and the account is still there despite the complete lack of activity.
I'm actually kind of impressed with that. I don't even have access to the email account that my ICQ account is linked to.
"Empathise with stupidity, and you're halfway to thinking like an idiot." - Iain M. Banks
Moved to Google Talk and Skype long time ago - mainly due to the internationalization problems which always plagued ICQ - but I still keep ICQ running just for some very old friends.
Several days ago I believe I had some connection problems (I rarely look into ICQ) but now it is fine. Fine means that I'm connected but I see probably only 10-20% of people I usually have in my contact list.
Most of my friends are using Miranda IM, I presume. And many of them are off-line right now. I see several on-line contacts which I am sure are using QIP, meaning that it has fixed whatever the problem was.
My client is Trillian 3.1 Basic. (Not great overall, but works somehow - especially for the older obsolete protocols like ICQ.)
All hope abandon ye who enter here.
I'll miss ICQ when they shut it down. I haven't gotten a real message from it in years (I think - I don't really pay attention to which service in Kopete I'm getting messages from), but I can't bring myself to stop connecting.
I have a very low 7-digit ID from right after it came out. It was pretty cool to be able to randomly chat with friends without having to log into an IRC channel and wait for them to remember to come online. One time I even bought a girl a computer for Valentine's Day just so I could talk to her while I was at my ISP tech support job; we ended up getting married.
ICQ sucks and it's spammy and doesn't do anything cool, but there's a lot of nostalgia in that crusty old system. I'll be sad the day when my login stops working for the last time.
Dewey, what part of this looks like authorities should be involved?
I have using Miranda IM, and is working fine
In Russia too. Here, there is no "IM", there is ICQ. I will send you that via ICQ, do you have his ICQ, you were not on ICQ so I thought you were out of office, etc etc etc. And this is very sad.
Upgrade, anyone? :| I love how freaked out end users get when their world breaks for a second. "OMFG!!! My ICQ is br0ked! This pwns me, WTF d0 I d0!?!?!?LOLOLOLol!!!!1!11one
Hmm... I guess there is a reason why people upgrade and patch software, no? ..."
In Russia and other parts of the former Soviet Union, ICQ is basically the only instant messenging protocol. (A few tech-savvy Russians have started switching to Jabber, but even they still maintain ICQ accounts to talk to their less technically inclined friends.) Not having an ICQ number in Russia is sort of like not having an email address in the US; people will look at you funny.
ICQ was a plot by Mossad to spy on the internet.
This sig will make it clear that ANYONE can use this post for ANY purpose WITHOUT the written consent of the NFL.
There is a Pidgin patch available HERE
Isn't the ICQ server and the AIM server the same server? I know you can add an ICQ number to your AIM buddy list and talk to ICQ users. Do they cross communicate the servers or just use the same one? Why isn't this affecting AIM users?
I can't login with Miranda, and I think I couldn't login yesterday either.. not that I would notice, on a normal day i have a total of zero ICQ contacts online. I don't get the error message described in the article, but then agian I think Miranda has its own.
A reminder to get around to turning off my old ICQ account.
Given that virtually everybody I know has moved to XMPP (typically Google Talk), most of the ICQ traffic I have received recently was automated porn/worm spam, presumably sent by a bot sequentially to all ICQ numbers. The spam wasn't quite frequent enough for me to kill my otherwise redundant ICQ account, though.
Nuh-uh! AIM has supported that for some time now.
Works fine still for me.
Using Pidgin 2.0
Which I have used for several months so far.
Sounds like a bad implementation in some of these clients.. maybe?
A friend of mine is using Adium on his Mac, and he had to update it.
No big deal.
LOTS of people still use ICQ.
What do YOU use? MSN ?
I think the poster needs to put away his tin foil hat.
Maurice W. Hilarius Voice: (778) 347-9907
I take it this is AOL's way of killing off ICQ then. The last time I used it was shortly after being envious of my friend's pentium 200mhz.
ICQ, the one IM app that doesn't send you a message every time someone hits enter, it promotes that they should finish their idea first before clicking the Send button, so the recipient doesn't have to read the same line over and over because they keep seeing blinking or hearing "message received" noises. The only blinking you see with this program is a tiny icon in the system tray instead of multiple taskbar panes blinking in a very distracting un-synchronized way.
Yes, you can configure your clients differently, but I'm talking about the default behavior. And even if you are courteous enough to not set it to send your message every time you press enter, your friends won't, and you'll still be getting one-liners that could have waited until they were finished typing their whole idea.
Twinstiq, game news
Uh-oh! ... memories...
Still, [ICQ] was notable for having offline messages long before MSN and AIM did.
MSN Messenger (now Windows Live Messenger) has always had offline messages of a sort. Each Passport ID (now Windows Live ID) is associated to an e-mail address, and the client allows the user to compose a message to an offline user, which is delivered through e-mail.
I don't believe what I'm reading....
Slashdot people prefer MSN? Albeit with a alternate client??
Anyways, I've been using ICQ for several years and so does my friends. (The older ones anyways)
I use ICQ Pro 2003b client with patch to remove the ads.
Works great.
Had to upgrade to 2003 from 2000 (I think) when ICQ shut out older clients.
And yes, I probably should use Miranda or something. But still in ICQ network.
ICQ is for the Elder Geek :) /C
MSN is for young wannabees
(Anyone knows how to get the smiley on a single line and the slashC on 2 lines below?)
No problems at home and work. I wonder why other clients had problems.
Ant(Dude) @ Quality Foraged Links (AQFL.net) & The Ant Farm (antfarm.ma.cx / antfarm.home.dhs.org).
I've always plugged my ICQ UIN into Pidgin and stuff for a long time, I guess it's one of those numbers I'll forget no more than my SSN or phone number. The only problem is, I don't have anyone on my ICQ list! I'm just an IM server whore and every time something comes out I'm suddenly compelled to make an account on it.
*shrugs* If ICQ doesn't want me to use their networks with the software I want, then I guess I just won't. I'm not going to pout, I'm not going to tell them anything, in fact... I don't think I'm even going to care. They're a pain in the ass anyways, every time I log into Pidgin or Adium or something somewhere else I got disconnected from my login at home.
I oddly feel like I just wasted my time, the time I was already doing nothing with, by typing this post.
"Most people, I think, don't even know what a rootkit is, so why should they care about it?"
...of how incredibly fast the anti-DRM hackers are. They defeated this devious increment-a-value-by-one scheme within hours!
USE HOT GRITS WITH STATUE OF NATALIE PORTMAN (NAKED AND PETRIFIED)
After upgrading to Adium 1.2.6 I was unable to connect to Jabber and AIM, so I reverted to 1.2.5. I hope 1.2.7 comes out pretty quickly.
Actually, for ICQ in particular, the main reason to use an alternative client is because the primary one is slow, bloated, inconvenient, and ad-ridden.
Hate to ruin the fun, but since when is updating the protocol "blocking alternative clients"?!
to see something like icq, if decommissioned, go open-source as opposed to being dungeoned away for indefinite copyright enforcement like alot of old dos games. could prove a bold move for AOL.
Good people go to bed earlier.
My ICQ number is 5318008. Feel free to chat.
I was having the same issue with Pidgin yesterday saying it's old. Seems alot of people were flooding the Pidgin website yesterday to get the update which wasn't there. Finally, the update was made available this morning and working perfectly now.
I have an ICQ account - have for years. I don't use it, but I decided to add it on pidgin yesterday and had the same issue. But I upgraded pidgin this afternoon and now it works fine.
I still use it, I still have friends who use it.
And my friends and I are not in Russia or China.
We don't see the point not using it even though it's getting a lot less popular. More channels of communication is a good thing. Or at least it serves well as a backup (or the backup of the backup of the backup of the backup of the backup...)
(1) My number is also in the low 7 digits! /. ID you insensitive clod!
(2) Don't make me feel old by my
(3) I for sure earn those bragging rights includes the cash!
(4) PROFIT! *Catchieng* Welcome to the new Internet!
--- I am known for the ones who want to find me on the net. Is that a privacy risk or a privilege? One might wonder..
I know noone RTFAs but at least give us an article. A link to a forum where the last post is from the 7th of February? Come on! It isn't even accurate information. ICQ is blocking old versions of the ICQ client also. They aren't blocking alternative clients. They are blocking clients that don't use the new protocol.
Why in the world would anybody still use ICQ when XMPP (formerly known as Jabber) is free, open, an IETF standard, and far more widely available than ICQ, AIM, MSN, Yahoo, or any other proprietary protocol? There's a very good chance you already have an XMPP account and don't even realize it if you have a Livejournal or Google account...
Help us build a better map!
Or it's the default IM program in their desktop environment. I use Pidgin, but it's not like I use anything other than XMPP.
Help us build a better map!
My PowWow account just stopped connecting...
One Token Ring to Rule them All, One Search Engine to Find Them, One WAN to bring them in, and TCP/IP Bind them...
Also in other news, the Bell System claims Touch-Tone a threat to the nation's telephone network and prohibits them.
This is just an incremental version update. For the licq client at least, it's a one-byte fix in /usr/bin/licq
"Nine times out of ten, starting a fire is not the best way to solve the problem." - my wife
Version 2.4.3 was released in near-record time to fix the ICQ problem in 2.4.2. http://www.pidgin.im/
hahaha......back to 0
Adium pushed out an update and I have no problem connecting to ICQ. Not an issue here....
'He who has to break a thing to find out what it is, has left the path of wisdom.' -- Gandalf to Saruman
I remember being a diehard ICQ fan back when I had dialup and that whenever anyone tried to get me on MSN i thought 'no fuck this, it has too many open windows to chat with people' and stopped using it. then I got a faster computer that could handle more than 3 windows at once and I eventually migrated to MSN like most of my friends did. I havent used anything else in a long time either.
I do miss the random chat option though. Searching for people to talk with youve never met was very entertaining and led to pranking pretty easily.
ICQ 6 - HTML Injection & execution ? http://www.milw0rm.com/video/watch.php?id=75 Here you can see the vulnerability in action. ICQ renders useing IE ... :'(
Does it have to do something with this news ;)
I stopped using ICQ earlier this year when my low-seven digit account number was hijacked. ICQ provides ZERO methods of getting hijacked accounts back.
I still have my old 16xxxxx number and mine was actually hijacked by some Russians because I hadn't updated my email on ICQ for nearly a decade and mail.com (and all associated URLs) apparently released a bunch of old email addresses and these Russians made a game of it and registered all the mail.com addresses they could with former account names and were able to retrieve passwords of older ICQ accounts like mine.
Anyway, I googled my ICQ number and found it posted on a Russian forum where someone said they had captured my number. I was able to retrieve THEIR ICQ info from their profile on the forum, including an address and a work phone number. I made a note of everything and had my Russian friend roughly translate the posts for me to confirm my suspicions. It was basically a giant game with a list of numbers that all had mail.com addresses and a competition to see who could acquire the most accounts with the lowest numbers. A quick look on eBay saw some of these lower digit numbers being sold. ICQ showed zero interest when I sent them all of the information I'd found out and I never even got a reply back from mail.com when I told them their accounts were being exploited. Nobody cared, not too surprisingly.
A couple of months later, I saw my account online one night and confronted the hijacker, who denied any knowledge of my account existing before he got it. He couldn't deny it for long because I noticed him changing my information as we talked and called him on it. I bugged the hell out of the guy, insulting him and saying he wasn't much of a big man if he had to steal an ICQ account from a girl. He finally gave me back my account and changed my password to "Nice(myname)" so I could access it again.
ICQ was indeed no help and mail.com were even less of a help in the matter. I had to take it all into my own hands and hey... I still have the account. First thing I did before I changed the password was to change my default email address, lest the hijacker get the brand new password.
My lesson learned: always keep your email info up-to-date, especially if it's free crapmail.