Slashdot Mirror


Paying for Apple iTunes with PayPal

MrIcee writes "While cruising eBay today I noted that some clever individual has apparently stepped up to fill the void left by the fact that Apple's iTunes service does not accept PayPal. While insisting that buyers follow Apple's terms of service, is buying and reselling the gift certificate legal or not? If legal, it's an interesting and simple idea that could be applied to many areas." It is pretty neat, even if the $16 markup is a little ludicrous. It's like the old adage: a fool and his PayPal account are soon parted.

296 comments

  1. How true. by cliffy2000 · · Score: 4, Informative

    "It's like the old adage: a fool and his PayPal account are soon parted." Indeed.

    1. Re:How true. by squiggleslash · · Score: 1
      Now Paypal has been taken over by eBay, what's the consensus on their current business practices? Have they improved - has the "customer service" become something other than form emails for example?

      I ask because with Billpoint gone there's little choice - I haven't really eBayed in a long time because it's basically a choice between Paypal and some horrendously slow and usually expensive solution like BidPay.

      --
      You are not alone. This is not normal. None of this is normal.
    2. Re:How true. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I got burned by Paypal. I was lucky I am a poor college student because they tryed multiple times to take $625 from my bank account and charge my credit card for $625. I never purchased anything and didn't know what was happening. Luckely the credit union forced the transfers back as NSF and returned my overdraft fees. I did have to open new bank account and get a new credit card as paypal of course locked my account up. I reported this all as fraud to Paypal at day 1. never heard anything, couldn't get ahould of anyone. I suppose their "investigations" team is still working on it. It sucks because I think Paypal still puts their banners in my ebay auctions and I have no way of turning it off as they locked my account out. i reccomended to all my friends to close their Paypal accounts immidiately, and I reccomend you do the same. it's just not worth the risk.

    3. Re:How true. by JAgostoni · · Score: 1

      I have been using PayPal for several years and have only had to dispute one payment (but it wasn't their fault). I have also contacted Customer Service several times. I have to say I have always been impressed with the service I get from them. That's not to say other people have had the same.

  2. Haha, how enterprising! by 2nd+Post! · · Score: 3, Insightful

    At least until someone figures out how to sell it for $15 markup.

    Then $14.

    Then $13.

    Then $12.

    etc...

    Until Apple decides to implement their own version...

    So this is one of those ideas with it's own obsolescence!

    1. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by ChesireKat · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Its not a bad buisness idea, though. If you think about it... if 4 people buy it at a $15 markup, this person is making $240 a month on it. Nice... I wouldnt mind an extra $240 a month =)

      --
      ~Just keep eating, porky. Fat people are harder to kidnap.
    2. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by psychosis · · Score: 2, Funny

      NO!!! 7 Minute Abs.. Not 6! Who does abs in 6 minutes?!

      </something about="mary">

    3. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by appleLaserWriter · · Score: 3, Funny

      Can I buy a put?

    4. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sorry we need to break out the 3rd grade math here, as you don't seem to have gotten that far yet.

      You also might want to look up the definition of 'markup'.

      These are $50 gift certificates.
      +15 markup
      = $65.

      Now, the grandparent seems to have messed up his math a little, but he did get farther than you.
      65*4 = 260

      Thats $260 a month.

      Maybe you should heed your own advice, I'm sure the gene pool would thank you.

    5. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      your theory of economics doesn't explain why windows sells at 85% margin though....

    6. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by YOU+LIKEWISE+FAIL+IT · · Score: 1
      Thats $260 a month.

      However, seller still needs to shuck out $200 for the gift certificates in the first place, right? So they only really clear $60 a month.

      That's drifting dangerously into "not worth my time" area - they need to drive the bulk up. Fortunately, mass listing and purchasing iTunes certs via cc probably scales pretty well.

      YLFI
      --
      One god, one market, one truth, one consumer.
    7. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      PER WEEK.

      $15 x 4 customers x 4 weeks = $240/month

      Admittedly, the OP wasn't so clear on this...

    8. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by ctxspy · · Score: 1

      Linux, much lower margin.

    9. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You are absolutley correct, check out this listing:

      $10 profit

      I bet that it is a slashdot user.... :)

      Also, would this scheme allow someone in another country (such as here in Canada) to use iTMS.

    10. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by 2nd+Post! · · Score: 1

      Why should it?

      My theory is for *perfect* substitutes.

      There aren't perfect substitutes for Windows.

    11. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by 1u3hr · · Score: 1
      This is a $50 certificate selling for $58. How does this give "$16 markup"?

      RTFA and DO THE FUCKING ARITHMETIC.

    12. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by randomjibberish · · Score: 1

      Just noticed another guy doing the same thing, but taking it one step further - offering both Paypal AND Credit Cards and not just $20 Gift Certs either...the whole lot! http://www.onesmartcompany.com/itunes/

    13. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by xpccx · · Score: 1
      Can I buy a put?
      I had no idea what that meant so for anyone else who saw that line and said "Huh?": Buy a put strategy
    14. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by pizzaman100 · · Score: 2, Insightful
      This gift certificate idea is a complete waste of time.

      Anyone with a paypal account can already order itunes! Just use your Free Debit card. In fact, if you run your debit card as a credit card transaction, you will get 1.5% cash back. Which means we can actually get songs for .98 cents right now.

    15. Re:Haha, how enterprising! by byolinux · · Score: 1

      perhaps $2 of eBay listing fees?

  3. Crusing Ebay by Microsift · · Score: 0

    Do they sell spell checkers there?

    --
    My other sig is extremely clever...
  4. Re:Why pay by gantrep · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    You're a dork. If you have a creek nearby, use that for electricity when it's overcast.

    Duh.

  5. GEORGE DUBYA SENDS THE SHOCK AND AWE!!!!111 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Offtopic
  6. Fun by igabe · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Reload the link to eBay and look at the counter near the bottom of the auction listing. See the Slashdot effect in real time. Impressive.

    --
    tilTrue.info contechtext.info prettypowerful.info twitter.com/frets fb.com/prosody
    1. Re:Fun by bluekanoodle · · Score: 5, Interesting

      In my unscientific survey, (reload, count to 20 mississippi, hit reload again) that comes to about 33 hits per second. Not bad for an ebay listing. :)

    2. Re:Fun by D'Sphitz · · Score: 0

      right now it's at 10-20 hits per second

    3. Re:Fun by D'Sphitz · · Score: 0

      probably from all the people refreshing to watch the counter go up

    4. Re:Fun by mgarriss · · Score: 1

      WOW, I had no idea....I almost hope slashdot never sends people my way one day. Not sure my server could handle it.

    5. Re:Fun by rolux · · Score: 2, Informative

      it's more like 3 per second

      10:25:00 PM EST 1909
      10:26:00 PM EST 2090
      10:27:00 PM EST 2255
      10:28:00 PM EST 2411
      10:29:00 PM EST 2616
      10:30:00 PM EST 2747

      --
      My next comment will be ready soon, but moderators can beat the rush and mod it up early.
    6. Re:Fun by rolux · · Score: 1

      dropped below 2 per second

      10:40:00 PM EST 3767

      that's just about 10 slashdot readers constantly reloading...

      --
      My next comment will be ready soon, but moderators can beat the rush and mod it up early.
    7. Re:Fun by tommertron · · Score: 5, Funny
      Slashdot effect in real time.

      Well... maybe not quite the usual slashdotting. Thanks to your post, half the slashdotters are sitting on the page pressing reload over and over... making the count even higher.

      --
      Random rants about technology: http://technorants.blogspot.com
    8. Re:Fun by DAldredge · · Score: 1

      No <reload> We <reload> Are <reload> Not <reload>. <reload>

    9. Re:Fun by quantaman · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Actually it's a double /.ing from all the people reloading to watch the counter go up!

      --
      I stole this Sig
    10. Re:Fun by (startx) · · Score: 1

      I'm dissappointed in /.ers. I loaded the link an hour ago and it was at 54. I just checked it again and it's only around 5400. That is just not enough people clicking on submition links.

    11. Re:Fun by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Great, no instead of seeing the counter increase, I get a "Thanks for looking!"

    12. Re:Fun by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      Poll: 75% of Palestinians support Haifa restaurant attack:

      Poll: 100% of Slashdot readers support kicking you right in the ass.

    13. Re:Fun by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

      Of course, when you look at the counter you are affecting the results! Wow! The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle in action!

    14. Re:Fun by ModernGeek · · Score: 1

      I think we broke the counter, it just says, "Thanks for looking!" now. Great job!

      --
      Sig: I stole this sig.
    15. Re:Fun by mkldev · · Score: 1
      Probably because they've tried the food. Ba-dum-ching! :-D

      Thanks, folks. I'm here all night.

      --
      120 character sigs suck. Make it 250.
    16. Re:Fun by pboulang · · Score: 1

      Or 30 slashdot readers hit reload every 10 seconds to see how fast the counter increases ;)

      --

      This comment is guaranteed*

      *not guaranteed

  7. From the TOS by tsanth · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Section 11.a:
    Payment for Products. You agree to pay for all Products you purchase through the Service, and that Apple may charge your credit card for any Products purchased, and for any additional amounts (including any taxes and late fees, as applicable) as may be accrued by or in connection with your Account. YOU ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE TIMELY PAYMENT OF ALL FEES AND FOR PROVIDING APPLE WITH A VALID CREDIT CARD FOR PAYMENT OF ALL FEES. All fees will be billed to the credit card you designate during the registration process. If you want to designate a different credit card or if there is a change in your credit card status, you must change your credit card information online at the Account Info section of the Service. (There may be a temporary disruption of your access to the Service until Apple can verify the validity of the new credit card information.)

    So how would this work when buying initially through a gift certificate bought through a middleman? Would I, as the buyer, pay the middleman to pay my iTunes bill for me?

    1. Re:From the TOS by fredmosby · · Score: 2, Informative

      The iTunes Music Store allows people to buy gift certificates for anyone with an e-mail account. So the idea is that you give the people $66, they take the money and use it to buy a gift certificate and have Apple send it to your e-mail address. I think that using the gift certificate requires you to set up your own account, so you can't just buy as many songs as you want using their credit card.

    2. Re:From the TOS by Hagen · · Score: 1
      That's from the iTunes General Terms of Service. But more useful are the details in the Terms of Sale and the Terms for Gifts Certificates and Allowances.

      Once you buy the gift certificate, its value and redemption are your responsibility, which you promptly hand off to someone else. Since Apple gets the money when the gift certificate is bought, they shouldn't care what happens to it inbetween purchase and redemption.

      There's even a clause on the last page listed above:
      11. Apple is not responsible for lost or stolen gift certificates or allowances. If you have any questions, please visit Apple iTunes Music Store Customer Service at http://www.info.apple.com/usen/itunes/musicstore.h tml.

      Also from that last page comes these:
      3. Access to, redemption of gift certificates and allowances, or purchases, from, and use of products purchased on, the iTunes Music Store, is subject to acceptance of its Terms of Service presented at the time of redemption or purchase, and found at http://www.info.apple.com/usen/itunes/terms.html
      8. If your order exceeds the amount of your gift certificate or allowance, you must establish an iTunes Music Store customer account and pay for the balance with a credit card.

      ...however you will need to at least establish an iTunes store ID, or the store can't customize (encrypt) the song for your use only.

  8. Re:Why pay by tofubar · · Score: 0

    And act like the government and defile the waters of my sacred fish friends? No sir, I couldn't do that.

  9. Re:Thank God! by gantrep · · Score: 1

    You don't need a credit card to sign up for paypal, that's the point.

    Duh.

  10. gotta love free enterprise by nomad63 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    What else can I say ? If the option is available and if someone is willing to pay the exorbitant price markup, why not squeeze few pennies out of it ? Unless apple implements this payment method, the markup will be driven down but will exist in one form or another despite how small it ends up to be. Also for the initial paypal bashing post owner : not everyone's paypal experience is as bad as what you had to hate them that much. If you know what you are getting into and not trying to defraud the system, why worry ?

    --

    __________
    The more I know people, the more I love animals
    1. Re:gotta love free enterprise by zilym · · Score: 1

      Because even people who have no intention of defrauding the system have had their PayPal account frozen and balance confiscated. Read some of the stories on NoPayPal.com.

    2. Re:gotta love free enterprise by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      PayPal is a fucking joke, you obviously haven't accepted it as a *merchant*. Go with a real provider like http://www.authorizeit.com/

    3. Re:gotta love free enterprise by nomad63 · · Score: 1

      Every story has 2 sides and sites like what you referenced reflects it from the complainers point of view.
      All of us, who are technically "more capable" than the average Joe Surfer want to take advantage of it, and we do not like to get caught red-handed. When we do get caught, we start screaming bloody murder off the top of our lungs.
      If you noticed, I am saying "we" not "you". Because I am wored the same way. If there is a way to get more benefit out of some scheme, and I feel like I can pull a fast one, I am there. PayPal is just like a supermarket. Virtually nobody is watching but other shoppers (other paypal users) and some drone cameras (analogus to defrauding observer scripts) And one has every reason to shoplift because chances of getting caught at that time is pretty slim. But after not getting caught once. twice, people start to become smartasses and think that they can cheat more people and like grasshopper example, you can jump once, jump twice but someone catches you on the third because you are so predictable.

      Monetary transaction is nothing to mess with, yet some people still expect to get away with it. When they couldn't, they register NoPayPal.com or paypalsucks.com (I am not sure even if it exists, but you got my point I think) and start screaming.

      One of my colleagues at work sends her daughter in college money exclusively using paypal and he swears by it it is the best way. I receive payments from some surveys I do for a few outfits and I am yet to encounter a problem.

      And yes, there may be mistakes. Even the spam blockers have false positive problem but this is what the human factor for and if you have a legitimate leg to stand on, I don't think Meg Whitman wants to risk her career as CEO of ebay/paypal to strongarm you for your few hundred dollars.

      Try to see the flipside of the coing what I would like to say, when you are reading the anything-bashing sites.

      --

      __________
      The more I know people, the more I love animals
    4. Re:gotta love free enterprise by phalse+phace · · Score: 1
      "If you know what you are getting into and not trying to defraud the system, why worry ?"

      Because of point number 5:

      5. If you are a bona fide, up-standing individual with hundreds of successful transactions, but someone pays you with a stolen credit card, your account (by PayPal's own admission) is immediately flagged as being "criminal behavior" and any money in that account is confiscated. If a customer "disputes" the charge, same thing happens. (See email above.)
    5. Re:gotta love free enterprise by Maestro4k · · Score: 1
      • Also for the initial paypal bashing post owner : not everyone's paypal experience is as bad as what you had to hate them that much. If you know what you are getting into and not trying to defraud the system, why worry ?
      I had an initial reaction somewhat like yours, but I also felt I ought to check out the site they linked (Paypal Sucks) and was rather shocked by what I found there. In fact, I suggest everyone read the beginning of this thread, from an ex-Paypal Middle Manager. Everything in that forum is pretty scary stuff actually, lots of people with frozen accounts for no reason they know of, and Paypal won't tell them why, etc. So, don't write them off as just a Paypal basher, after all I read, I'm probably going to delete my Paypal account I've had for about 2-3 years, there's enough on that site to scare me enough to no longer be comfortable using Paypal.
  11. Re:The link... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I agree. Especially since Paypal no longer allows adult content/service providers to use their services.

    -- Dr. Eldarion --

  12. YOU FAIL IT! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
  13. Wow. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Is it really that hard to sign up for a credit card? I have the credit card companies absolutely throwing themselves at my *feet* trying to get me to sign up for more credit cards. And my credit rating is *bad*.

    Of course someone's going to respond "oh but you shouldn't trust the credit card companies!" Okay, but if you don't trust the credit card companies, you CERTAINLY AS FUCK SHOULDN'T BE TRUSTING PAYPAL.

    - super ugly ultraman

    1. Re:Wow. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well, there are some people who could easily sign up for a credit card but who don't because they know they can't be trusted with it.

      And then there are people like me. I didn't get one in college, because I felt I wasn't ready for the responsibility of it and would likely blow lots of money and rack up thousands in debt. So I never applied for one. Nor did I ever finance anything like a car, because I hate paying interest. Later, when I was not in college, I realized it would be convenient to have one while travelling for work. I couldn't get one. I had no credit history at all, and nobody wanted to take the risk. I even tried getting a card from a nearby Chevron (gas station) at which I was a regular customer. Still no dice.

      I found out I could get a secured card, but checked out the terms on this and found that you have to give them a few hundred dollars to keep (as collateral) as long as you have the card, and you get a really measly amount of interest on it. I didn't have a great feeling about that, and besides, I didn't want to tie up hundreds of dollars for a year or more.

      Eventually, I took a night class at a community college and noticed that AT&T had put up ads for a student version of their "Universal Card". I grabbed an application, happily checked the box that said I was a "part time student", and sent it off. A few weeks later, I got a credit card with a credit limit of a whopping two hundred dollars.

    2. Re:Wow. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oops, hit "Submit" instead of "Preview", and I wasn't finished yet...

      Anyway, I got the credit limit of $200. I was a bit disappointed, because it seemed so appalling low that it wouldn't actually be, you know, useful. But I bought a few things with it and carefully made sure I didn't hit my limit, and over maybe 6 months, they upped it a few times until it finally hit $600.

      Fast-forward to today. That was about 8 or 9 years ago, and I've been paying my bill on time and in full every month. I still have that same credit card, and I just got a letter today that my other credit card (I only have two) has had its limit upped to $4000.

      Oh yeah, I forgot to mention that while trying to find a place that'd approve me for a credit card, one of the things I tried was to get one from my bank. Even they wouldn't issue me one, which I found quite odd given that I kept a few thousand dollars in the checking account at all times. I mean, where's the risk? And yet, they wouldn't approve me. And it's not like I had any blemishes on my record.

    3. Re:Wow. by hamster+foo · · Score: 1

      Well, it's not always as easy as the letters you get in the mail might seem. I've made some credit mistakes in the past and had pretty much trashed my credit score, yet I still had credit card companies sending me "pre-approved" credit card offers constantly. I actually applied to one or two of them and got turned down. It's a pretty bad feeling getting turned down for a supposedly pre-approved credit card. Anyway, point being just because you are getting offers doesn't mean that you can get a credit card through those offers, although, there are plenty of secure cards and such designed for people with poor credit to rebuild credit and all that I'm sure just about anybody can get.

      --
      - b
    4. Re:Wow. by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 2, Informative
      "Is it really that hard to sign up for a credit card? I have the credit card companies absolutely throwing themselves at my *feet* trying to get me to sign up for more credit cards. And my credit rating is *bad*."

      In the USA it's really easy. There are so many banks and other companies competing to give you a credit card that they're willing to reach far down the credit rating food chain in order to get applicants.

      I have worked in the credit card industry in Canada and it's certainly different here. There are only five big banks and much less competition for cardholders. A lot of the people who get all the pre-approved crap in the mail in the USA would never get approved in Canada for a credit card. That's why it's much easier to get a CC in the USA compared to Canada and probably a lot of other countries as well.

    5. Re:Wow. by TwistedSquare · · Score: 1

      Interesting... There are only five big banks here in the UK, but boy do they seem to go after people! Every month I get a credit card offer in with my bank statement, and if I just signed and returned it I'd get one, even when I was unemployed and well into my overdraft. But Canada always did seem like a good place :)

    6. Re:Wow. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Agreed. paypal is dangerous and will burn you in the end.

    7. Re:Wow. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If you carry a balance of several thousand in your checking account, what's the problem with depositing a few hundred to back a secured card? After a little time to establish a credit history you should have been able to get an unsecured card and reclaim your deposit.

      The reason your bank declined to offer you credit is the same reason everybody else declined you. I doubt if it's as simple as lack of prior credit, though. Most card issuers will happily open accounts for people without prior credit as long as they meet minimum income requirements (probably somewhere around $10-12k) and do not have a negative credit history. Remember that utility companies report late payments to the credit bureaus. If you ever had phone, cable , electricity, etc. in your name and paid the bill late, that could very well be the reason you had so much trouble. I know it's rather late now, but you should have gotten a copy of your credit report to see if there was something like that in there (or if there were erroneous entries). The credit bureaus are required to give you a free copy of your report if you are declined because of information therein.

    8. Re:Wow. by jonbryce · · Score: 1

      Signing up for a US credit card is quite difficult if you don't live in the US - about 95% of the world population. ITunes only accepts US credit cards.

      It is also difficult if you are under-age (18 in the UK).

    9. Re:Wow. by geoffspear · · Score: 1

      iTunes Music Store is also only available to users in the United States. It has nothing to do with credit cards either, they're not licensed to sell music outside of the US.

      --
      Don't blame me; I'm never given mod points.
  14. Or, y'know... by the+unbeliever · · Score: 5, Informative
    You can get a paypal debit card, and use it to buy your merchandise from ITMS.

    I have one of the debit cards, and I used it like a credit card all the time (it's where my personal allowance money from my bank account goes). It'll also use your checking account to pull funds from if you don't keep a balance in your paypal account.

    1. Re:Or, y'know... by nhaines · · Score: 1

      Actually, working part-time as a student, I never had enough for a savings account at my bank. So I used PayPal to save $100 every month, and then tried as best I could to pay my bills with the debit card (I'd transfer extra along with the $100) and any other unnecessary purchases. I'd just transfer the money over to PayPal and then go buy the videogame or whatever (or the other way around).

      I got 1.21% interest or so (but that's 1.04% now) plus 1.5% on any purchase I made with the card. I actually have $19.00 that I made just for buying things. It was really a nice, free, easy way to seperate my money. And if I needed it, I never had any fees because there's no minimum balance. Also, only $1 for ATM withdrawals, which isn't too shabby, I think.

      As far as I know, PayPal would *not* pull money from your checking account--debit card purchases are only checked against your PayPal account balance.

      Anyhow, I've since opened an account at NetBank and will use that (free checking, higher interest), but PayPal was great. I'll keep using it until they crack down on the PayPal Preferred requirements (I'm not an eBayer, really).

    2. Re:Or, y'know... by The+Iconoclast · · Score: 1

      Paypal issues a DEBIT CARD and they are _STILL_ not considered a BANK?!?!?! WTF?!?!?!?!?!?

      --
      Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati
    3. Re:Or, y'know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's not actually issued by PayPal themselves, but rather by Bank One. I suppose PayPal just has a special deal set up with them.

    4. Re:Or, y'know... by Jucius+Maximus · · Score: 1
      "Paypal issues a DEBIT CARD and they are _STILL_ not considered a BANK?!?!?! WTF?!?!?!?!?!?"

      RTFA. You're just using paypal send someone a bunch of money. And then that person uses THEIR credit card to send you an iTMS gift certificate. Paypal is just acting as a conduit for the moving of funds.

    5. Re:Or, y'know... by danielsfca2 · · Score: 1

      You are correct with the debit card that they will not fund a debit card transaction with anything but your existing PayPal balance, meaning you'd have to transfer money in, wait for three business days 'til it shows up, and then use the debit card.

      Instead of getting the debit card (which I have and do find useful), for this purpose I would recommend using the PayPal debit bar, which just gives you a virtual MasterCard number you can use online. The requirements to get it are:
      - Have a Domestic PayPal account
      - Be Verified (have added and confirmed a bank account)
      - Have added a credit card where the monthly statement is sent to a physical street address (not a P.O. Box)
      - Have a positive balance in their PayPal account
      - Have a PayPal account in good standing (as determined by the Account Review Department)

      In other words, (a) you don't have to wait for the card to be delivered, (b) you don't have to have a Premier or Business account, and (c) you don't have to have had the account for 60 days.

      In answer to whomever said the card was issued by Bank One, you might be thinking of the PayPal credit card, which is actually issued by Providian. It's just your average sponsored credit card, like the Disney Visa or the Amazon.com Visa. Just a standard Bank One credit card with a PayPal logo that PayPal markets for them and PayPal gets a cut of the commission. You don't even need to be a PayPal user to get it. The debit card, by contrast, is actually issued by PayPal themselves.

    6. Re:Or, y'know... by cloudmaster · · Score: 1

      Speaking of the PayPal credit card (not the debit card - though I have both), the bank the credit card's issued through sucks. I can pay all of my credit card bills online using paypal's billpay service - *except* for my paypal credit card! The stupid bank that issues the paypal credit card *does not accept paypal*! I have to make out a check and mail it in for 3 bills - house, garbage collection, and my credit card that says "PayPal" right on the front.

      The only reason that I applied in the first place was to make go away the stupid ads asking me to apply every time I log in to my PayPal account - but then I found out that the ad generating engine has no knowledge of whether or not you already have a paypal credit card (offered by Providian). So, in short, it's the stupidest credit card ever.

      The debitcard, though, and the cashback it results in, is pretty cool. I like PayPal, but dislike Providian.

  15. Re:The link... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Dont you ever get tired of posting? Or is this just another avenue to pimp out your website.

    -- Dr. Kevorkian --

  16. this sounds.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    awfully familiar to that guy who tried to sell the song he bought from apple on ebay

    1. Re:this sounds.... by endoboy · · Score: 1

      whatever became of that? Last I remember, the auction was up to some ridiculously large number...

  17. no credit card by Nihynjahs · · Score: 0

    he says its for people who dont have credit cards in his auction, but dont you need a credit card to use paypal?

    1. Re:no credit card by MikeCapone · · Score: 0

      You also need a credit card to open an account on eBay, I believe.

    2. Re:no credit card by Politburo · · Score: 1

      I don't know about selling, but you do not need to submit any financial information to bid.

  18. I give it 48 hours by sourcehunter · · Score: 0, Informative
    Now that it has hit /., no doubt Apple has, or will shortly, learn of it.

    I give it 48 hours before Apple shoves a C&D right up their ass.

    "Just Because"

    --

    quis custodiet ipsos custodes - Juvenal
    1. Re:I give it 48 hours by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sounds like Apple "Thinks Differently" when it comes to reselling iTunes gift certificates.

      Ha ha, I'm hilarious. I should have a web site.

    2. Re:I give it 48 hours by B747SP · · Score: 2, Interesting
      I give it 48 hours before Apple shoves a C&D right up their ass.

      Why go to all the hassle and bad publicity of a C&D when, with a little extra effort, they could just quietly refuse to sell gift certificates to anyone who orders more than a couple at a time, or just pull the gift certificate product altogether for a month or so. Anyone want to take bets on it happening that way?

      --
      I find your ideas intriguing and I wish to subscribe to your newsletter.
    3. Re:I give it 48 hours by LostCluster · · Score: 1

      Easier than that, just figure out who wants or needs to pay a 20% markup to get access to their service and let them in the front door....

    4. Re:I give it 48 hours by Fred+IV · · Score: 1

      Tough call. I wouldn't want to bet on it, but maybe Apple just allows it to continue for awhile and sees if the idea will catch on or not. Might be better to let the market develop and enjoy the extra online sales until they decide if this is something they want to do in-house or not.

      F.IV

    5. Re:I give it 48 hours by dfenstrate · · Score: 1

      Why should apple even care? Money is money, and I don't see how it matters how it gets into apple's coffer.

      As long as it's honest and the buyers and sellers both agree to the process, it's irrelevant.

      Others, of course, have pointed out better ideas, but I see no reason why apple should fight this.

      --
      Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms should be the name of a store, not a government agency.
  19. New Suggestion by gantrep · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    Kill yourself and feed your body to the fish you love.

    Could you do that sir?

  20. What does that bring musicians cut down to? by chatooya · · Score: 5, Funny

    Great, another middleman between musicians and fans. Are we moving backwards through the internet??

    1. Re:What does that bring musicians cut down to? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny
      Great, another middleman between musicians and fans.
      Next on ebay: one genuine RIAA membership, comes slightly abused and maligned. Buy this beautiful membership card and start losing friends today!
    2. Re:What does that bring musicians cut down to? by LordKronos · · Score: 1

      Great, another middleman between musicians and fans
      Yeah, and just take a look at how many people get a cut of that:

      1)Paypal
      2)Ebay
      3)Ebay Vendor
      4)Credit card company (credit card was originally used to purchase GC)
      5)Apple
      6)Record Company
      and finally
      7)Musician

  21. How much longer will CDs last by Strudelkugel · · Score: 2, Informative

    Nifty idea, though the markup is ridiculous. But, it does represent YAWAM (Yet Another Way to Acquire Music) that is a lot easier than dealing with CD stores or even online CD sales.

    Sure would be interesting to know how the economics of iTunes music distribution compare with retail CD distribution. More profitable for the label? Less?

    Even if it is more, isn't there as risk to the label in that getting on iTunes may not require the backing of a big organization? That is, iTunes represents a much better prospect for the artist? Sure would be interesting to know what Jobs thinks of all this, let alone the accountants in the record industry.

    --
    Imagine how much harder physics would be if electrons had feelings! -Feynman, maybe
    1. Re:How much longer will CDs last by DAldredge · · Score: 2, Funny

      It appears to be less than the typical apple markup.

      </ducks>

    2. Re:How much longer will CDs last by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh great, instead of a standard audio format I will have to chose from several diffrent stores each with diffrent rules using pritiory DRMed formats that will allow the entertainment industries to do what ever the heck the want to my files.

      No thanks, I will stick to buying and ripping CDs.

    3. Re:How much longer will CDs last by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      ...YAWAM?

      what a stupid acronym. did you think that was clever?

  22. After Much Consideration by appleLaserWriter · · Score: 0, Funny

    I, for one, welcome our new PayPal-iTunes overlords.

    1. Re:After Much Consideration by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      thank GOD someone modded you down.

  23. You wouldn't have an iTunes bill by emkman · · Score: 2, Informative

    I don't if your aware of this, but gift-certificates are prepayed. thats the point. you wouldnt have any iTunes bill to pay, cause you get 50$ then your done. I think your missing out on the concept here.

    --
    Moderation Totals: Flamebait=2, Troll=1, Redundant=1, Insightful=6, Overrated=1, Underrated=1, Total=12. (not mine)
  24. Re:Thank God! by jjh37997 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    You don't need a credit card to sign up for paypal, that's the point.
    Duh.

    But you need a checking account and what checking account nowadays does not offer a free VISA debt card?

  25. No better for artists by chatooya · · Score: 1

    Try googling "iTunes for Windows", first result: iTunes iSbogus about why iTunes is bad for musicians because it keeps the RIAA from crumbling (also because musicians get the same shitty cut that they get in bricks and mortar even though the bricks are gone).

    1. Re:No better for artists by Mononoke · · Score: 1
      ...because musicians get the same shitty cut that they get in bricks and mortar even though the bricks are gone).
      Musicians get the same shitty cut they agreed to when they signed the contracts, no matter where the music is sold.

      Of course, they get exactly $0 on songs traded 'illegally'.

      However, many musicians get exposure they would never get in a brick-n-mortar store.

      --
      NetInfo connection failed for server 127.0.0.1/local
    2. Re:No better for artists by chatooya · · Score: 1

      They agree to it because they don't have a choice when 5 companies have a cartel that controls radio and distribution and they only offer musicians a shitty cut. PC buyers "agree" to get shitty Windows software when they buy a PC, but that doesn't make it any less shitty.

      There's a real chance to change the music industry and we should take it.

    3. Re:No better for artists by Mononoke · · Score: 3, Insightful
      They agree to it because they don't have a choice when 5 companies have a cartel that controls radio and distribution and they only offer musicians a shitty cut.
      Thus the very reason why iTunes is a good thing for musicians: Independent labels have exactly as much exposure as the big labels do on iTunes. Musicians don't have to sign with the "big 5" in order to get distribution.
      --
      NetInfo connection failed for server 127.0.0.1/local
    4. Re:No better for artists by chatooya · · Score: 1
      Thus the very reason why iTunes is a good thing for musicians: Independent labels have exactly as much exposure as the big labels do on iTunes.
      Which would be fine if the major labels weren't paying radio stations to play their music. Most people don't learn about music on the internet, they hear it on the radio. And they certainly don't learn about it from 30 second previews.

      If people only buy independent music from iTunes, that would be a good step, but buying major label music supports a really bad system (not to mention funds lawsuits against 12 year olds). Wherever you buy your music, use RIAA Radar first.
    5. Re:No better for artists by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      Have you actually read that thing? It reads like it was written by a Maoist with a Vicadin addiction.

    6. Re:No better for artists by redJag · · Score: 2, Insightful

      So Apple should not sell music from the big 5 because they want to support indie music and strike down the RIAA. They don't care about name recognition, money, or selling iPods. This is all about you and your hatred for the RIAA. Seriously, they let indie music labels use iTMS. I think you are asking a bit much.

    7. Re:No better for artists by chatooya · · Score: 1

      At what point is a system so bad that Apple or anyone else should refuse to participate in it? I would argue that the major label music industry is that bad right now. The real problem is that Apple is potraying the store as some great development for musicians and fans, which it clearly isn't. It's old fashioned technology, centralized and expensive, and it's propping up an old fashioned, manipulative industry. Of course, as you point out, all Apple cares about is "recognition, money, and selling iPods" and the music store is clearly a good business decision for them. That doesn't make it a responsible decision.

      Mostly, it's frustrating to hear Apple joining in on the moralizing about filesharing (though in a more subtle manner) while working with a sleaze-bag industry.

    8. Re:No better for artists by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Radio stations _DO_NOT_ get paid to play music by anyone other than their supporters (advertisers). What radio stations get are exclusive rights to sound bytes, interviews, concert promotions, etc... And I hardly see anything wrong with that, other than their choice of music is stagnating because of it.

    9. Re:No better for artists by stanmann · · Score: 1

      Are you certain of that?? payola still happens

      --
      Food not Bombs is a nice platitude but it breaks down when you notice that the Bombees are usually well fed
    10. Re:No better for artists by redJag · · Score: 1

      Let's say their goal is to remove the old system. Should they do that RIGHT now? Could they? More likely, this would be their first step. I have no idea what Apple's intentions are, but I do know they want to stay in business. They couldn't do that if they tried to change everything off the bat (no one would support them, customers or artists).

  26. Fair Enough by tsanth · · Score: 1

    I probably am missing something here, but please humor me: if I, the buyer, don't have an iTunes account through the gift certificate, then how do I download my purchased iTunes music?

    1. Re:Fair Enough by satanami69 · · Score: 1

      Geez, by using the money giving to you by your grandmother in the form of the damn itunes gift certificate. Think of it as a Credit Card with a $50(or whatever value) limit. You cannot go over your limit.

      --
      I really hate Dan Patrick.
  27. credit cards? by apoch2001 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Does it make any sense that this person lets you use a credit card on Ebay to pay for $50 gift certificate when the purpose of his $16 markup is to allow someone to pay when they don't have a credit card? I guess you'd have to be pretty stupid to fall for this one....

    1. Re:credit cards? by nomad63 · · Score: 1

      Not all paypal money is deposited using credit cards. Many incentive programs, survey sites etc, pay thru pay pal. And if one is a starving student (BTW, what the heck is a starving student doing by shelling out a buck per song is a very valid question) he or she may not have a credit card to plunk down at the ITMS.

      --

      __________
      The more I know people, the more I love animals
    2. Re:credit cards? by B747SP · · Score: 1
      BTW, what the heck is a starving student doing by shelling out a buck per song is a very valid question)

      Uhm, 'cos you can't buy food on paypal, and all that money was burning a hole in his pocket? It's gotta be spent somehow!!!

      --
      I find your ideas intriguing and I wish to subscribe to your newsletter.
    3. Re:credit cards? by Svartalf · · Score: 1
      Uhm, 'cos you can't buy food on paypal, and all that money was burning a hole in his pocket?


      Actually, you CAN buy food with PayPal- just not the way you'd normally think about it. They can issue a MasterCard Business debit card that is tied to the money in your PayPal account. This card will work on the Pulse network as an ordinary ATM card (w/a small fee) or a Master Card (with no fees).
      --
      I am not merely a "consumer" or a "taxpayer". I am a Citizen of the State of Texas
  28. Results by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The story has been up 25 minutes, and there still has been no purchases. Still 250 available. Who's going to get First Purchase?

  29. Okay by tsanth · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Ah-ha.

    That answers my other question. I suppose this means that I shouldn't be buying that gift certificate if I don't already have an iTunes account?

    1. Re:Okay by fredmosby · · Score: 1

      I'm not sure. Apple might let you automatically create an account if you don't already have one. It seems like requiring a credit card to redeem a gift certificate would defeat the purpose of having them in the first place.

    2. Re:Okay by cmeans · · Score: 2, Insightful
      It might function like the "prepay" account (seems geared towards parents letting their kids buy music...but limiting them to a certain amount). I don't think Apple can expect a kid to have a CC, but they certainly wouldn't want to stop a kid from buying from them :)

    3. Re:Okay by Feral+Bueller · · Score: 2, Informative

      Has it occured to you that you could just go look up these questions yourself over at Apple?

      --
      - learn to swim.
  30. Targeted to? by XorNand · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I have to believe that anyone who's willing to pay for downloadable music are the type of people who have a credit card. Those without credit cards, students mainly, are still getting their music from Kazaa and the ilk.

    --
    Entrepreneur : (noun), French for "unemployed"
    1. Re:Targeted to? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Those without credit cards, students mainly, are still getting their music from Kazaa and the ilk.

      And getting ready to get their fucking BALLS sued off.

    2. Re:Targeted to? by jellomizer · · Score: 1

      Well college students do have credit cards, sometimes paid by mom and dad, sometimes with their part time job, of sometimes in massive debt. And guess what people with money like music too.

      --
      If something is so important that you feel the need to post it on the internet... It probably isn't that important.
    3. Re:Targeted to? by demaria · · Score: 1

      Many banks offer ATM cards with a Visa or Mastercard logo and capabilities. These function just like secured credit cards and only require you to have a checking account.

    4. Re:Targeted to? by halo8 · · Score: 2, Funny

      Those without credit cards, students mainly

      uhhh.. do what now?? what university are you going to.. every campus ive ever been in.. has at least two credit card booths handing out free stuff for a properlly filled out applicaiton..

      true story: one day i was going to class had a midterm.. but no calulator.. so i just filled out the form.. got a cheapo $2 calculator.. 4-6 weeks later got yet ANOTHER card.. and just cut it up.

      i still failed the test

      --
      The More Knowledge you have the Luckier you Get- J.R. Ewing
    5. Re:Targeted to? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I have to believe that anyone who's willing to pay for downloadable music are the type of people who have a credit card. Those without credit cards, students mainly, are still getting their music from Kazaa and the ilk.

      I bet you $16 you're wrong.

    6. Re:Targeted to? by displaced80 · · Score: 1

      Out of curiosity...

      Are debit cards commonplace in the US? In the UK at least, most current accounts provide a debit card (VISA/Delta) which is usable wherever a credit card would be, except it debits money from the current account, rather than any credit line that has to be paid back with interest.

      Almost every student here will have a debit card (and, most likely, a credit card, too).

      --
      What's the frequency, Kenneth?
    7. Re:Targeted to? by NoMaster · · Score: 1
      true story: one day i was going to class had a midterm.. but no calulator.. so i just filled out the form.. got a cheapo $2 calculator.. 4-6 weeks later got yet ANOTHER card.. and just cut it up.

      i still failed the test
      That's because it was an English test. You really should be more careful...

      --
      What part of "a well regulated militia" do you not understand?
    8. Re:Targeted to? by poot_rootbeer · · Score: 1

      I have to believe that anyone who's willing to pay for downloadable music are the type of people who have a credit card.

      Just because I have, or am qualified to have, a cerdit card doesn't mean that I want to use it to buy things all over the Internet.

  31. The real question is by qwertme · · Score: 1, Offtopic

    Will this work internationally?

    Can I buy thru these people to get music here in Canada?

    1. Re:The real question is by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Umm.. you have to be in the USA to use the apple music store.

      If you were paying to have the seller download the song/cd and mail it to you, then yes.. but thats not what this is.

      This guy is auctioning $50 certificates.. you pay him $63 through paypal, he buys a $50 certificate.. you still have to be in america to use that certificate at the store.

    2. Re:The real question is by cryoboy · · Score: 1

      Maybe we Canadians should start swapping perscription drugs for iTunes, iPills.ca? 99 cents a pop (tune).

    3. Re:The real question is by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I love the fact that when US citizens think "internationally" they think "Canada".

  32. the point is international... by plambert · · Score: 5, Informative

    I believe the point is that the iTunes Music Store requires that any credit card used have an address inside the United States.

    Reselling gift certificates would then allow folks outside the U.S. to access the store as if they were in the U.S.

    Except I think you have to have valid credit card information whether or not you use a gift certificate. I am not certain, though.

    --plambert

    1. Re:the point is international... by SClitheroe · · Score: 1

      Nope, it doesn't work that way. iTunes must check your IP address, or something, because it tells you right off the bat that you can only browse the iTunes store, if you install and run it in Canada.

      Come on Apple, hurry up and hook the great white north up, already!

    2. Re:the point is international... by Oscar_Wilde · · Score: 1

      It tells me, in Australia, that I can browse only unless I have a billing address in the US.

      So if someone in the US buys me a gift certificate I wouldn't be surprised if the iTMS let me use it.

    3. Re:the point is international... by plambert · · Score: 2, Interesting

      It may check your IP address, but that can be easily circumvented; they surely wouldn't rely on just that.

    4. Re:the point is international... by cualexander · · Score: 1

      Yes this works Internationally. I have heard several people in other countries who are able to use gift certificates people sent them. The payment originated in the US, so this is the way to go for Canada.

    5. Re:the point is international... by libzuk · · Score: 1

      >> Except I think you have to have valid credit card information whether or not you use a gift certificate. I am not certain, though. No, you don't need a credit card to redeem gift certificates.

  33. international sales? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Even though they say that it's US only. what's to prohibit
    Canadians from using this to get around Apple's TOS?

  34. Re:The link... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I have nothing better to do when I'm at work / when my girlfriend is at work.

  35. One BIG problem still... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Informative

    In order to sign up for an iTunes account to REDEEM any such certificate you MUST enter a valid credit card number. I know. I sent my sister a certificate so she could try out iTunes. She didn't want to use a credit card, but ended up being forced to just to redeem the certificate.

    There IS a non-credit-card way get an iTunes account, but that's only as the recipient of an "allowance" which is then tied to someone elses credit card, the one giving the monthly allowance ($10 minimum each month).

    Good luck redeeming the gift certificate if you buy it and don't have a credit card!

    1. Re:One BIG problem still... by Gibberlins · · Score: 1

      I wonder why you posted as Anonymous Coward. Maybe it is because you are full of shit.

  36. Paypal has two solutions for that. by strredwolf · · Score: 1

    First, they have their own ATM Debit card backed by a Mastercard particpating bank.

    Second, they have their own credit card.

    They also had a "pay online with a virtual card" feature, but I can't find it.

    --

    --
    # Canmephians for a better Linux Kernel
    $Stalag99{"URL"}="http://stalag99.net";
    1. Re:Paypal has two solutions for that. by LostCluster · · Score: 1

      The problem is, PayPal's Mastercard program requires the account be verified to be from the USA... so it's good for the uncardable but not the international user.

  37. Selected Methods of Payment by Jman314 · · Score: 2, Funny
    • Visa
    • MasterCard
    • Discover Card
    • American Express

    Markup: $16 on $50 certificate

    Hmm, I wonder if this is an intelligent decision.

    Sounds like the ?? right before Profit! to me.

    (In reality, they only accept PayPal, but they have icons for all the above. Misleading design.)

  38. Paypal Debit Bar! by strredwolf · · Score: 1

    Found it! It's a Debit Bar feature. Log into your Paypal account, hit "Shops" at the bottom of the page, then "Shop Anywhere" and go from there.

    --

    --
    # Canmephians for a better Linux Kernel
    $Stalag99{"URL"}="http://stalag99.net";
    1. Re:Paypal Debit Bar! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Except that Apple's iTunes requires a "security code", that 3 or 4 digit number on the back of a credit card, and the Pay Pal Virtual Debit Card doesn't supply one. Oops!

  39. No Sales by Aoverify · · Score: 1

    Has anyone else noticed that this guy has had over 4 thousand hits as of now, and not even ONE purchase?

    1. Re:No Sales by JUSTONEMORELATTE · · Score: 1

      Has anyone else noticed that this guy has had over 4 thousand hits as of now, and not even ONE purchase?

      Followup -- the next morning, the counter is at 16k (don't know if it's rolled or not) and the guy has 151 sales.
      If you figure around $3 ebay listing fees and paypal fees, that's 151* 13 = $1,963.
      Not bad for one evening.

  40. What about Paypal Virtual Debit Cards? by nstrom · · Score: 1

    Why should you need this "service"? Paypal already offers a virtual debit card service (see here, requires paypal login) where their system will generate a mastercard number and expiration date which you can use to buy items against your paypal balance from any online store that takes credit cards...

    1. Re:What about Paypal Virtual Debit Cards? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      But you can't do that unless you have another card on file with paypal.
      I think this is for people that have a bank account only and no credit cards.

    2. Re:What about Paypal Virtual Debit Cards? by Maestro4k · · Score: 1

      Here's a link that doesn't require a login to view. Reading up on it, it looks like you may be only able to use at online stores that are in the Paypal shops section of the site. Not sure though off-hand.

    3. Re:What about Paypal Virtual Debit Cards? by nstrom · · Score: 1

      No, I'm 100% certain you can use it anywhere. They do have a shops section which lists all the online stores that take paypal payments directly, but there's a link which says "Shop Anywhere" and goes to the virtual debit card page... I've used it to buy stuff from random pricewatch vendors, for example.

    4. Re:What about Paypal Virtual Debit Cards? by cyoung1035 · · Score: 1

      The PayPal debit card is good (almost) everywhere -- online and off. I use it at brick-and-mortar stores, gas stations, and to make online purchases (up to, and including, airline tickets). Bit of a hassle to use it to reserve a rental car, but otherwise, I've never had anyone refuse it. And no, you don't have to have a credit card on file with PayPal to get a debit card. The credit card is only if you want to use the Instant Transfer feature. Geez, people, get the facts before you go spreading false information all over the /. universe!

  41. Re:Thank God! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    the question is what checking account nowadays does not offer a free VISA debit (or debt as you put it, ironic. hahah) card from the USA, which is a requirement for purchasing music from itms at this time? pay pal card - usa based - you can use store.

  42. Roll Over by CuriousGeorge113 · · Score: 4, Funny

    There's only 5 digits on that counter. I wonder how many times that thing has rolled over since this story's posting :)

    ~~Dan

    --
    No man is an island, But if you take a bunch of dead guys and tie them together, they make a pretty good raft.
  43. Re:Thank God! by Anusien · · Score: 1

    Actually, you don't need a checking account, it's just recommended. And even then, you can authenticate with a normal deposit account.

  44. Wow! How convenient! by csoto · · Score: 0

    Instead of using my Amex card, I can set up a PayPal account, give them access to my checking account, arrange for a third party to perform the transactions for me, then deplete my PayPal account. I mean, typing in 15 numbers and an expiration date is SOOOOO hard!

    --
    There exists no way of exchanging information without making judgments. --Bene Gesserit Axiom
  45. Apple Stores? by moosesocks · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It seems to me like apple would make a killing if they sold the certificates in their stores (at face value, of course!). It would make a great gift-item, and would be an impulse-buy for many (read: this is the kind of thing that mall-shoppers would buy)

    Or would that violate the agreement between Apple (Computer) and Apple (Records)?

    --
    -- If you try to fail and succeed, which have you done? - Uli's moose
    1. Re:Apple Stores? by vfwlkr · · Score: 1

      Or would that violate the agreement between Apple (Computer) and Apple (Records)?

      I doubt it would. Apple has a marketing arrangement with Pepsi, that allows it to provide a free song code in one of three pepsi bottles. That's a sort of gift certificate. (even if valid for one song only)

      --
      If you're not using firefox, you're not surfing the web, you're suffering it.
      ---
    2. Re:Apple Stores? by ottffssent · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Or would that violate the agreement between Apple (Computer) and Apple (Records)?

      Apple (Computer) doesn't seem bothered by that prospect. A little history:

      Apple (records) came first. Apple (Computer) tried to register a trademark or some such, and Apple (records) sued. Apple (Computer) (correctly) said that they're in different businesses, thus no namespace collision, thus no trademark problem. Apple (records) backed down, and said "stay out of our business, and you're in the clear."

      Apple (Computer) put speakers in their computers. Apple (records) sued. Apple (Computer) paid 'em off.

      Apple (Computer) made an iPod. Apple (records) sued. Apple (Computer) paid 'em off.

      Apple (Computer) is now distributing music. Apple (records) sued. Apple (Computer) will no doubt send another few million their way.

      Clearly Apple (Computer) has no problem periodically dishing out a little cash to grease the palms of commerce. Which isn't surprising - Steve's hardly the kind of guy to back down just because technically he isn't supposed to do it...

    3. Re:Apple Stores? by mabhatter654 · · Score: 1
      I think Jobs should just hard-code iTunes to not play any Apple Records music....That would be fair and keep customers straight. They could even implement digital watermarking technology to prevent playing Ripped music like records or CDs. A personal vendetta can go a long way in the business world!

      Of course when iTunes & iPod become the "windows" of the music world....Oops! Who's the Beetles! Must not be important because my iPod won't play um.

    4. Re:Apple Stores? by elvum · · Score: 1

      Have you looked for Beatles tracks on iTunes lately? :-)

    5. Re:Apple Stores? by mabhatter654 · · Score: 1

      no, I mean hard code it... Refuse to load any song matched against the CDDB & delete it from your computer, and add advanced audio pattern matching so that even if you rip from a record it will still recognize it as a Beetle song and not play it. They could also modify Safari to eliminate all references to "Beetles" [except for Bugs!] so that you couldn't even ask if there was a problem!

    6. Re:Apple Stores? by soft_guy · · Score: 1

      >eliminate all references to "Beetles"

      What would be the point? Apple Records doesn't have any artist called "Beetles".

      Are you sure you're not thinking of the "Beatles"?

      --
      Avoid Missing Ball for High Score
  46. rolled over at least once in the past few minutes by green+pizza · · Score: 1

    counter showed 87811, reloaded it after I did some channel surfing and it now shows 04811

  47. Non US customers. by Oscar_Wilde · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Hey! I know this particular auction is only open to people in the US but how long will it take before someone starts selling gift certificates to non US residents?

    The gift certificate section on the iTMS doesn't say that non US residents can't receive them.

  48. Re:Wow! How convenient! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The only people I can see wanting to do this are people who use their parents paypal account.

    A friend of mine has a PP account and buys stuff on ebay all the time, but he has no credit card and his parents wont let him use theirs. Whenever he wants something on ebay, he pays his parents and they put the money in paypal.

  49. adage by spir0 · · Score: 1
    a fool and his PayPal account are soon parted

    shouldn't that be:
    a fool and his PayPal funds are soon parted.

    --
    The reason girls and Windows users don't understand UNIX is because all the documentation is in Man files.
  50. It's the real thing... oh wait.. by openSoar · · Score: 1

    or you could spend your $50 worth of cold hard cash on pepsi and get the tunes that way...

    1. Re:It's the real thing... oh wait.. by jerde · · Score: 2, Informative

      or you could spend your $50 worth of cold hard cash on pepsi and get the tunes that way.

      You'd have to buy $150 worth of pepsi, since only 1/3 of the caps are winners.

      - Peter

      --
      INsigNIFICANT
  51. won't someone think of the aliens? by appleLaserWriter · · Score: 1

    The iTunes Music Store is useful to US Citizens who want Music but don't want to be sued by the RIAA.

    Since there isn't a single legal system, or Recording Industry Association that represents the rest of the world, every other country must be dealt with individually.

    Countries that operate very much like the United States and have strong Recording Industry Associations provide good markets either for iTMS or iTMS clones. At the opposite extreme are countries which don't respect intellectual property at all. For these nations, the iTMS is relevant only as iCandy. In the middle are a lot of countries that lie somewhere between these two extremes. Just determining where along the line a given country sits is a substantial job. Crafting a solution that fits their particular climate is relatively easy once that is done.

    1. Re:won't someone think of the aliens? by bojan · · Score: 1

      why's everyone on this RIAA trip..

      iTMS is a great tool for those "Human beings" who don't wish to waste time going to a record store, browsing through a very limited array of music, and then pay for it, and then carry it home, unwrap the bulletproof plastic shield, open the jewel case, rip the CD, store the jewel case and booklet or throw them out, and THEN listen..

      I don't ever want to do any of this, I just want to click "buy" and then "play".

      that's the purpose of iTMS.. anyone who thinks it's an RIAA fighting move has watched too many movies.

  52. Hell I'll sell you one for cheeper then those guys by FSK · · Score: 4, Interesting
    --
    When punk rock is outlawed, only outlaws will have punk rock.
  53. Re:Posting an ebay auction on slashdot? by DrStrange66 · · Score: 3, Informative

    Umm... you can't bid. It's set price only. You can click buy now...

  54. Sales Tax by TexTex · · Score: 1

    So...does Apple charge sales tax when you buy the gift certificate? Or just when you buy the music...which is how my two $0.99 songs are $2.16 on the credit card.

    Or maybe they do it on both....

    --
    -Barkeep, a draft of your most hazardous brew, for the world is slowly stepping into focus, and I don't like what I see.
    1. Re:Sales Tax by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They only charge sales tax when redeeming the certificate.

    2. Re:Sales Tax by Jord · · Score: 1

      I purchased a gift card earlier this week and they did not charge me any sales tax on the card. However when the person I gave the card to used it, they charged her sales tax on her purchases.

    3. Re:Sales Tax by Colazar · · Score: 1
      You shouldn't be paying sales tax when you buy a gift certificate, because technically, no sale has yet occurred. The value of the gift certificate goes on the companies books as a liability--because they still owe you the merchandise--exactly as though it was a prepayment or a deposit.

      The sale takes place when the gift certificate is redeemed and the product is delivered. That's when the sales tax is figured (if any). You can use some of the gift certificate amount to pay the sales tax, or not. Up to you. (So in your example, if the gift certificate was for $1.98, you have to cough up the other $0.18 yourself. If your gift certificate was $3.00, you can pay the whole thing and have $0.84 left, or pay some out of your pocket so that you have more left on the gift certificate.)

      So for those keeping score at home, "selling" gift certificates helps your cash flow, changes your balance sheet (whether for good or for ill depends on how much that liability weighs on you), and doesn't touch your bottom line at all. (At least until the gift certificate expires and you get it all as "free" profit.)

      Disclaimer: This is basic retail accounting for gift certificates. Apple *might* do it a little differently (multiple payment types can sometimes be hard to deal with), but can't vary too much.

      --
      He decided to just watch the government, and kind of scale it down to size, and run his life that way. --Laurie Anderson
  55. Ebay counter by bach37 · · Score: 1

    5109 hits on the ebay page. I wonder what a counter on the slashdot main page would bring in.... lol.

    Scott

  56. forget Apple, eBay will pull it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    Geez, you guys know that anytime an auction gets in the news, Mr. Kevin Pursglove (whatever his name) issues a cute little statement along the lines of "we are investigating the auction".

    Then the next day, the auction is pulled for some obscure reason: "the seller created and posted the auction between 10pm and 11pm from a state that outlaws ferret hunting during summer months. Persuant to section 573, paragraph 43 of the eBay user agreement, which we just updated last night just for this guy, where it says we can pull an auction for any goddamn reason, we went ahead and pulled the auction, even though 60,000 others just like it are still up and running."

    In other words, eBay pulls it at the drop of a hat.

    I bet PayPal (owned by eBay) has some stuff buried in their terms that they can use also.

    1. Re:forget Apple, eBay will pull it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      1) Kevin Pursglove? No longer with eBay. So you won't have him to kick around anymore.

      2) The policies on selling digital music on eBay are "obscure" if by "obscure" you mean "available from every single page on the site through the online help system". The policy is simple: digital music (and pretty much any kind of digital products) aren't allowed because finding out who actually owns them is a royal pain in the ass. Don't blame eBay for this, blame the concept of intellectual property as we know it today.

  57. As of right now, none of them have been sold... by httpamphibio.us · · Score: 1, Offtopic

    9 days 13 hours left, and not a single one has sold...

    --
    sig.
    1. Re:As of right now, none of them have been sold... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This was done as an experiment.
      Instead of just talking about the idea, I thought I would give it a shot to see what happens.

      I set the price as low as possible to cover the cut to Ebay and PayPal
      with a little (very little) to cover the time to manage the transactions well to keep people happy.

      There's some people that want some iTunes fun, but don't have a valid credit card.
      I thought it might be a handy service for a few people out there, that's all.

  58. PayPal by paranoid.android · · Score: 1

    I've been using PayPal for around six months now with no problems whatsoever. I haven't had a need to contact their customer service (which I suppose you could take as a positive thing) so I can't comment on that.

    That said, I use a separate checking account as my PayPal account. I see no reason to take a chance with my money.

  59. Re:Haha, how enterprising! [OT] by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

    So this is one of those ideas with it's own obsolescence!

    When will people learn to use "its" and "it's" correctly? You might want to print out a copy of this cartoon for reference.

  60. Nice idea, but by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This guy has a nice idea but ebay is more for selling stuff like this rare abused fan

  61. OT: What songs are on apple? by polished+look+2 · · Score: 1

    I know this is off topic but I really want to ask this to someone. Is there any method I can use to find out what songs Apple has on their sight? I would rather not have to download and install their software to simply find out.

    1. Re:OT: What songs are on apple? by Jord · · Score: 1

      No. The only way to do it is to download the itunes software for free.

    2. Re:OT: What songs are on apple? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This is really almost too stupid for words. Are MOST pc users actually THIS afraid of their own machines -- terrified to even ATTEMPT to install new software on their machines??

      I'm LAUGHING at the "superior intellect," Khan.

      To answer the question: uh, no. There's no way to find out what songs are on the iTunes Music Store ... without iTunes.

      It's free software, no nagware/spyware/adware/crippleware. Don't be afraid, it's not an (i)Pod! :)

      I'll tell you this: there are around 360,000 songs at present, covering every genre, a rapidly-expanding number of indie labels, a LOT of non-rock, non-top-40 stuff. Sure, there's still a lot of stuff NOT there (no post-Tony Sheridan Beatles, for example, no RHCP the pricks), but I think you'll be delighted. Totally risk-free.

      Live a little, dude.

    3. Re:OT: What songs are on apple? by polished+look+2 · · Score: 0, Troll

      I don't like installing proprietary software on any computer simply because its such a hassle. For one thing I have to read through those stupid non-GPL licenses plus I have heard that Apple's iTunes for Windows is buggy. Quite frankly, unless they have music that I want (such as Michael W. Smith) then there really is no reason for all that trouble.

    4. Re:OT: What songs are on apple? by LostCluster · · Score: 1

      It's easier to come up with the list of holdouts. They're five for five on the major RIAA companies, and they've got an easy enough program for the indies. There are a few artists making a stink of the one-by-one selling of their songs (mostly, the artists who die under this scheme, the ones who only have one or two good song per ablum...) but if you cared about any of those artists you likely would have learned about it already.

    5. Re:OT: What songs are on apple? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Michael Smith - Time
      Michael Smith - Michael Smith Love Stories

      Enjoy...

    6. Re:OT: What songs are on apple? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Installing iTunes is not a hassle. If you think installing software is too hard, maybe you need another hobby.

      Apple actually does have a web page that lets you search the iTMS for artist, album, or songs titles, but I wouldn't want to spoil your GPL-purity, so I'm not gonna tell you.

    7. Re:OT: What songs are on apple? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You spent all that time composing a taunting and totally non-helpful reply to a simple question? Talk about needing a life...

    8. Re:OT: What songs are on apple? by fr0dicus · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Seeing as the product is only available on Windows and MacOS, isn't this something of a strange attitude to have?

    9. Re:OT: What songs are on apple? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Of course you can! Cruise in to your nearest Apple Store and try the software for free. While you're there, try an iPod too.

      If you don't have an Apple Store near you, it might be useful to try a local PC retailer instead -- many of them have internet access, and you may be able to find a "friendly" salesperson who'll let you install iTunes (and the iTMS) on a display-model windows box.

    10. Re:OT: What songs are on apple? by Coretti · · Score: 1
      Yes, it is possible, although you can't browse the entire database.

      You can search by artist, song title, or album title at the iTunes Link Maker

    11. Re:OT: What songs are on apple? by polished+look+2 · · Score: 1

      Yes, thank you very much. They do have MWS!

  62. Re:Wow! How convenient! by csoto · · Score: 0

    Well, that's CERTAINLY a lot more convenient than having their parents type in those 15 digits to buy their kid a gift certificate!

    NOT

    --
    There exists no way of exchanging information without making judgments. --Bene Gesserit Axiom
  63. Re:Arggh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    +1 Insightful

    (or it would have been if Slashdot hadn't become overrun by Apple fanboys who enjoy getting "jobbed" by Steven Jobs.)

    I'd like to knee-cap the lot of 'em with a lead pipe.

  64. did he buy from apple ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I bet he hasn't actually bought the gift certificates from apple yet. The plan is buy from apple only if some one buys the certificate from him on ebay.

  65. Geez, I would have expected more from eBay by va3atc · · Score: 1, Interesting

    Guess the mammoth of eBay can't even withstand the slashdot effect.

    By the way, how do you mod posts anyways?

    Steve

    --
    Candle burns its brightest in the dark
    1. Re:Geez, I would have expected more from eBay by jerde · · Score: 3, Funny

      By the way, how do you mod posts anyways?

      Check out the FAQ...

      After having been a regular /. reader and poster, the site will randomly grant you 5 moderator points every once in a while. Those points must be used within a few days before they expire.

      My experience is that /. knows when I'm about to go out of town without internet access, and gives me my mod points right before I leave. The sound of the slash code giggling is one of the erriest sounds in the universe.

      - Peter

      --
      INsigNIFICANT
  66. It's based on your IP by yerricde · · Score: 1

    But an iTunes Music Store customer also has to have an IPv4 address located in the United States in order to buy or even just to play purchased recordings. If DHCP gives you an IP outside known U.S. netblocks, it appears iTunes hides your purchased recordings.

    --
    Will I retire or break 10K?
    1. Re:It's based on your IP by geoffspear · · Score: 1

      No, they don't. You can set your IP address to anything you want and iTunes will happily continue to play your music. You can't buy new music or authorize your computer to play your purchased music if it's not already authorized, but your music does not disappear.

      --
      Don't blame me; I'm never given mod points.
  67. Re:YAWAM? by drayzel · · Score: 2, Funny

    YAWAM???

    Be honest, that word is just YAAPOOYA
    (Yet Another Acronym Pulled Out Of Your Ass)

    ~Z

  68. Virtual Debit Card from Paypal also an option by Mean_Nishka · · Score: 4, Informative
    To avoid the $16 mark up, all one needs to do is use Paypal's virtual debit card to make the purchase of the GC. It assigns you a temporary mastercard number that you can use on just about any website that takes credit cards.

    Go to the 'my account' tab, select withdraw, and click on the 'shop online with a paypal virtual card' link. The number won't be tied to any website in particular, so you should be able to type it in through itunes and have it work.

  69. Re:Why pay by mlk · · Score: 1

    I take it batterys are out of the question.

    --
    Wow, I should not post when knackered.
  70. For those that don't RTFA.... by Mr.+Arbusto · · Score: 1

    here is a link to the auction

  71. Billy at the gates. by ratfynk · · Score: 3, Funny

    "Open the IPOD bay doors Steve"..... "I am sorry, I cannot do that Bill"

    --
    OH THE SHAME I fell off the wagon and use sigs again!
  72. Yeah baby, Apple rules! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Slashdot, formerly known as the place where Lin-sux users go, is now owned by Apple. Mac OS X, the G5, FUCKING WICKED baby! Nothing else compares, and Apple rules your fucking life. Deal with it!

  73. I have stepped up... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...to fill the void inside your mom's lubricous vagina. I might fill up her ass later, if she begs me.

    Now why don't I get an article posting?

  74. Re:Hell I'll sell you one for cheeper then those g by cmeans · · Score: 1
    You don't have a counter on your page...not as interesting as the other one...though you are a tad cheaper :)

  75. Find the white elephant before midnight! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Find the white elephant before midnight!

  76. Fawcetociconius novazealandiae by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Fawcett's gill-eyed frost stalk, (Fawcetociconius novazealandiae ) is a recently extict member of the stork familly that lays eggs underwater. Females then pile dead fish atop the eggs, and the decay of these would warm the water, incubating the eggs. Even so, at lower than usual temperatures found in such a habitat, chicks would not be ready to hatch out until 9 months after laying. After hatching, chicks would swim up through the rotting fish carcasses, and kill their exhausted mother, whose body would provide both shetler and food in the hostile climate.

  77. So... by D'Sphitz · · Score: 0

    if you have a paypal account why not just use your free PayPal checkcard?

  78. You don't understand. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    In order to CASH the gift certificate, you must have an iTunes account.

    In order to have an iTunes account, you must have a valid credit card number on file with Apple.

    If you have a credit card, why would you want to buy this gift certificate on ebay?

    1. Re:You don't understand. by satanami69 · · Score: 1

      They use the Unique ID number that comes on the gift card to sign up for the account. Then "A counter in the iTunes Music Store shows how much credit is left in allowances and gift certificates." Apple did think of this.

      --
      I really hate Dan Patrick.
    2. Re:You don't understand. by Phronetix · · Score: 1

      OK, but here is the issue that I think people need to be aware of before buying an ebay itunes gift cert. (then again, maybe [i]I[/i] don't understand something. In order to redeem a gift certificate, you need to have an account, and in order to have an account you need to have an address in the USA and a credit card matched to that address.

  79. Last straw... by dasspunk · · Score: 1

    I've thought this about other posts but have always been able to stop myself from posting it...

    This article is fucking stupid.

    Sometimes the best article is no article.

  80. So THIS is a legendary slashdotting? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    11,000 hits over 3 hours, where part of those hits are people reloading to watch the counter.

    This is what brings servers to their knees? WTF?

  81. The eBay counter by R33MSpec · · Score: 2, Funny

    I can just see the eBay web architect in his design when choosing to have a counter on each listing saying:

    "5 digits on the counter should be enough for any listing"

    bwahahahaha

    1. Re:The eBay counter by Hagen · · Score: 1

      Much like Bill Gates' apocryphal line from 1981?
      "640k of RAM should be enough for anyone."

  82. iTunes Selection by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Bought 4 songs so far. Unfortunately Led Zeppelin and Metallica have none available. Guess I'll have to get those free.

  83. europe / canada / japan by ryanw · · Score: 1

    Doesn't something like this enable people in canada/japana/europe/etc buy from the US iTMS?

    1. Re:europe / canada / japan by elvum · · Score: 1

      No.

  84. Re: Here's a more efficient URL by Leeji · · Score: 1

    Here is the direct link. Much faster to watch!

    It's not showing up in preview for me, so here is the text: http://counters.honesty.com/cgi-bin/honesty-counte r.cgi?df=2959568251&hidden=0&site=0&type=0&border= 1&style=default

    --
    It all goes downhill from first post ...
  85. Re:Thank God! by fuzz6y · · Score: 1

    a free VISA debt[sic] card

    Holy Freudiand slip, Batman!

    --
    If you're going to be elitist, it would help to be elite.
  86. One of the largest obsticles.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    One of the largest obsticles to buying music online is using a credit card. There are still many who don't trust it. Granted, this isn't the crowd that itunes apeals to most (older folks who don't trust technology).

    Still, I bet that there are MILLIONS of teens out there, all downloading online music - mostly hit singles, WITHOUT acess to a credit card. What apple needs to start doing is selling music cards, with set amounts of dollars on each (ala pay-as-you-go cell phones).

    This would allow teens to buy music cards anywhere : I'm sure 7-11 would be up for carrying them simply because of the increased foot traffic in their stores. Also, Apple could even make "collectable" graphics on each (perhaps artists on iTunes). At least its something tangable...the kid with the most iTunes cards is the coolest in the class.

    I'm guessing that i'll get a lot of responces saying "that's what the allowences are for". give me a break, I know that my parents wouldn't have given me a music allowence. There needs to be a better solution.

    1. Re:One of the largest obsticles.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      There's a built in mechanism in the iTunes store that you can give a weekly/monthly/whatever allowance to people to spend on music (ie kids)

  87. Paypal Debit Card by ewwhite · · Score: 3, Informative

    My solution is to use the Paypal debit card. It's linked to my Paypal account and acts as a Mastercard. I use it for all of my Apple iTunes store purchases. It works quite well....

    --
    Edmund White
    http://flickr.com/ewwhite
  88. Virtual Credit Card? by Cokelee · · Score: 1

    Why can't you use a virtual credit card number? PayPal offers this service.

    Quite silly.

    1. Re:Virtual Credit Card? by Cokelee · · Score: 1
      Why can't you use a virtual credit card number? PayPal offers this service. Quite silly.

      Oh right, only if you have plastic on file . . . nevermind.

      Just get a damned card then

  89. Can't use PayPal's virtual card without another by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Everyone keeps bringing this up.
    You can't use PayPal's virtual card service without having another card
    on file with them. Don;t know why, that's just how it is.
    The idea with this paypal/itunes offer is that it's for people
    that have a bank account, tied to paypal, but have no credit card.

  90. Re:Hell I'll sell you one for cheeper then those g by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    not any more...

  91. RTFP... by Svartalf · · Score: 1

    The previous poster was referring to the MasterCard business debit card that can be applied for and used against your standing e-cash balance- NOT the main discussion subject.

    And yes, I have to wonder about the debit card issuance and it not being at least held to savings and loan rules and regs.

    --
    I am not merely a "consumer" or a "taxpayer". I am a Citizen of the State of Texas
  92. Re:fp!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    did someone leave the fat guy in charge of articles tonight?

  93. YOU'RE DOING IT ALL WRONG - IT'S LIKE THIS... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
  94. Another Service by nate+nice · · Score: 1

    It appears someone else is selling gift certificates as well as music in general for people that cannot access the store. The auction is here

    Good luck I guess.

    --
    "If you are a dreamer, a wisher, a liar, A hope-er, a pray-er, a magic bean buyer ..."
    1. Re:Another Service by Satan's+Librarian · · Score: 2, Interesting

      That's kinda cute... so the middle man gets your quarter, *and* a copy of your song. Does their DRM counter that that all?

  95. Re:Haha, how enterprising! [OT] by 2nd+Post! · · Score: 1

    When you learn that language is fluid and adaptable, and that eventually through misuse the word its and it's will change ^^

  96. Im a little confused??? by falcon5768 · · Score: 1
    Why on earth would anyone want to use Paypal???? I can understand the not wanting to use a credit card part, but if I didnt want to use a credit card, I wouldnt be looking to purchase anything online.

    As it is its hard to pay with a personal check anywhere anyway other than paying your bills, so whats the point??? Just go to your local used CD store and buy them there

    --

    "Slashdot, where telling the truth is overrated but lying is insightful."

    1. Re:Im a little confused??? by MikeBabcock · · Score: 2, Informative

      With Paypal, I do use my credit card, but the merchant never sees it. That's one of the nice features; you only have to worry about paypal's trustworthiness (won't argue that here), not that of every 'net merchant you meet.

      If I pay you $50 out of my paypal account, paypal draws it out of my CC and you get it from paypal. You don't need a CC merchant account and you don't ever see my CC information.

      --
      - Michael T. Babcock (Yes, I blog)
  97. I killed it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Had to kill the offer.
    Too much trouble with non US buyers wanting to purchase. Don't want Apple to squish me.

    Interesting experiment though...
    Looks like I've kicked off a whole new iTMS/proxy industry on ebay.

    By the time I turned it off, the page counter was at 14560.
    The power of /. is impressive.

  98. Re:Thank God! by danielsfca2 · · Score: 1

    > But you need a checking account

    Actually, you need at least one of the following: checking, savings, credit card.

    > what checking account nowadays does not offer a free VISA [debit] card?

    Checking accounts for those under 18, for one. Some banks (Washington Mutual) will give you a checking account, but will not even give minors ATM cards of any kind, even without the V/MC logo. Others (HELLS^H^H^H^H^H Wells Fargo) will give you a (non-debit) ATM card with savings, but will not even let a minor be on a checking account, even with a parent.

    The one reason why I'm glad I'm not under 18 anymore.

  99. That didn't happen. by Xenex · · Score: 1
    "Apple (Computer) made an iPod. Apple (records) sued. Apple (Computer) paid 'em off."
    That didn't happen.
  100. Re: Wow by Maestro4k · · Score: 2, Informative
    • Is it really that hard to sign up for a credit card? I have the credit card companies absolutely throwing themselves at my *feet* trying to get me to sign up for more credit cards. And my credit rating is *bad*.
    You're talking about those "You're Preapproved for the Bank Of CowboyNeal's Premium Gold-Pressed Latinum Visa Card!" letters you get all the time? Read the fine print, it'll say "subject to credit approval," blah blah blah. Basically all you're "pre-approved" for is filling out the application and making them check to see if they think you're qualifed for a card or not.

    Now granted, I've never understood how this is completely legal and not false advertising of a sort (remember that Publishers Clearing House had to change their ways after that huge lawsuit about their "You may already be a Winner" but the fine print says "Not yet, you gotta at least send this back, and while you don't have to buy anything, we want you to do something to the envelope to show if you did or not so we'll know how to..... umm, file it!"? Heck the credit card offers don't even come in saying MAY be approved, so they're worse. But that's starting to stray way off-tppic. :)

  101. RTFA by echucker · · Score: 2, Informative

    This time, it's "read the fucking auction."

    Sales are to US customers only and you must comply with Apple's iTMS terms of service.

  102. And we thought Micro$oth overcharged! by Maestro4k · · Score: 1
    • Will sell in increments of $50.00/month with a $15.00 charge for the first $50.00 and $7.00 for each increment of $50.00 after the initial increment.
    Ouch. Can you say price gouging children? Good, I knew you could. Now let's return to the friendly folks in the /. neighborhood.

    With sincere apologies to Mr. Rogers, please don't have God strike me down or anything. :)

  103. Not Everyone can get a debit card. by Some+guy+named+Chris · · Score: 1

    I work for a bank, and I was surprised to learn when I started here that if your Beacon score (basically a hash of your credit report) is lower than some threshhold, you cannot get a debit card.

    So, while every checking account offers a free Visa debit card, not every person qualifies.

  104. Re:Hell I'll sell you one for cheeper then those g by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I don't think it's setup correctly.

  105. I would never suggest using PayPal again... by taperkat · · Score: 1
    just because of my recent experiences (see sig file). It also wouldn't surprise me iTunes wouldn't take PayPal - after all, eBay *IS* technically a competitor, and PP's parent company is eBay. Plus, for iTunes to take PP, they'd have to charge extra fees, on TOP of the fees that PP already takes out, to make up for the loss, if artists are to be adequately compensated.

    But maybe iTunes has remembered something many forget - PP is *not* a bank. Nor anything near it. It could close one day, taking any money left in the account, and you wouldn't be able to get it back. Just some more food for thought - I believe iTunes is right in only taking from established companies with proven resources behind it. PP has so many holes, I've discovered, between knowledge and rules, that you could drive a truck full of CDs through it.

    --
    "But I can't get an ocean that's deep enough for my day..." ~The Frames, "Fitzcarraldo"
    1. Re:I would never suggest using PayPal again... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      In regards to your sig:

      Ummm...You're bitching about how some first level phone support monkey was sarcastic? Wow. You really have a solid case there. Better call CNN and the Weather channel. They'll want to hear about this for sure.

  106. transaction fees by zachmagaw · · Score: 1

    does anyone know the on-line transaction fees for credit cards, debit cards and/or pay-pal? I thought pay-pal had the highest fees...

  107. Obviously not! (n/m) by Delta-9 · · Score: 1

    I said, n/m

  108. Re:One of the largest obsticals.... by johnmig · · Score: 1

    We just went through this last night with my son. He's 15 and formerly went the Limewire route, we've been telling him that this was A Bad Idea, and that the proper thing to do is to pay for music. With the iTMS and his iPod, he has come to see that this is not only correct, but possible. Only problem is that he has no credit card, so he pays me cash, and I send him a gift certificate. No problems. I like this idea better than an allowance, that's just a mechanism to suck his wallet dry. This way, he has a fixed amount that he determines how much and how he wants to spend it.

  109. I do pay for iTunes with PayPal... by bseaver20 · · Score: 0

    I signed up for the PayPal Mastercard and I'm now paying for iTunes music with my PayPal account. What's so hard about that?

  110. Re:Thank God! by jlleblanc · · Score: 1

    My 8 year old brother has a Visa Check Card through our credit union.

  111. Apple Will Love This by Splunge · · Score: 1

    A lot of people seem to think Apple would look down on this practice? Why would they?

    If the gift certificate fails to sell or the purchaser can't use it, Apple makes a pure profit off the transaction - they don't need to pay the record company for the sales and already made $20/$50/$100 from the gift certificate sale.

    --
    "Brown University? We have one of those in Providence!" -- Outside Providence
  112. Game's over ... by Greedo · · Score: 1

    From the URL:

    The seller ended this listing early because the item is no longer available for sale.

    Oh well, it was fun while it lasted.

    --
    Tuus crepidae innexilis sunt.
  113. Re:Thank God! by cloudmaster · · Score: 1

    Lot's o' banks don't offer free visa/mc debit cards - several still charge (and several charge for online banking, etc, which causes me to wonder why anyone would go there).

    Anyway, I have a paypal account set up for my employer to pay for domain purchases and to sell old hardware on eBay. It'se set up with *only* a credit card. Sure, paypal asks for checking account info all the time, but the account works just as well with just a credit card. There's like a few thousand dollar spending limit (goes away after getting verified with a checking account), but that's generally not an issue.

  114. Damn, the record companies are smart! by ianbjor · · Score: 1

    This must be the RIAA's way to trying to make its normal markup on CDs since it's "losing" so much by selling albums for $9.99!

  115. Re:Haha, how enterprising! (Higher math) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Thank God you all are not math majors or even business majors... Hopefully you're not working stiffs in those areas either.

    One would deduce that the last post in this thread is the most correct, although you could expound upon that.

    Gift Cert $50
    Markup $15
    cost of Cert $50

    Pre-sale profit (Gross)= $15 per cert.

    But there are additional costs of doing business that may NOT be accounted for:

    DIRECT COGS (Cost of good sold)
    Less ebay Listing Fee (variable) approx 4% listing fees
    Less Paypal transaction fee 2.2-2.9%+ paypal fees
    Less your cost of doing business (variable)
    - electricity of the computer you use
    - expense of equipment (scanner, computer, software...)
    - ISP connection charge...

    Less possible labor expenses (if you had to pay someone to do this)

    INDIRECT COGS
    Less lost opportunity cost (what you could have made doing something else)

    and finally less your opportunity cost of Capital (what you could have made putting your $ in a bank/CD/money market, if your $ wasn't tied up waiting for an ebay bid to happen) calculating Weighted Cost of Capital and/or Opportunity cost

    So perhaps the actual transaction resemble something like this on a monthly basis:

    Gross Profit ($15 x 4 certs) = $60
    Less direct costs of goods sold (guessing 10% of sales price $5 x 4 items) = $20
    Less indirect cost of goods sold (guessing 5% of sales price $5 x 4 items) = $10

    Leave you with roughly $30/ month in Earnings Before the real issues ....

    Your Time... at $???
    (What you should pay someone to do this crap)
    Assumne what you will, but I wouldn't bother with anything less than $20 / hour and this will take someone at least 10 minutes to do manually.

    Calculate that per hour, unless your Bill Gates who earns $4,000 per minute

    Then you compare that to opportunity cost of capital and....

    Geese.

    No wonder why Apple hasn't tried this.

    >
    >Why Gen-Xers do it better
    >Cheznathalie.com
    >

  116. Bill Pay service. by danielsfca2 · · Score: 1

    Maybe you should consider switching banks. My bank, Citibank, has an awesome online banking system, and one of the features I like most is that even payees it doesn't have in its electronic payment system can be paid through the site, still for free, by check. When you set up the payee, you check and see if there's an electronic way of paying that company, and if not, you just put in the address and payee the bill would normally have, and it will say "Payment will be sent by check." Even cooler, you can even use this method to pay your friends or whatever. You can essentially lose your checkbook after you get started with this.

    Fees: I'm a student, so I pay $3/month for the checking account, or free when I'm employed (direct deposit). The bill payment service comes free with it. For non-students, "Free if you meet the combined balance ($1500) or if a Direct Deposit is made (latter applies only to CA & NV). If not, $7.50 in NY, NJ & CT; $9.50 in all other states."

    Full Disclosure: I don't work for Citibank, I just find that they are a bank which respects me and appears to value my business (unlike Wells Fargo).

    1. Re:Bill Pay service. by cloudmaster · · Score: 1

      Yeah, I'm in the "$9.50 in all other states" bracket. 3 stamps cost less than $1, and PayPal's billpay service is free. I'm real strongly against paying someone else to pay my bills for me, esp. since electronic payments cut down on the recipient's workload more than it does mine. They save money by not having to pay as many people to open envelopes, and they gain accuracy. I just get to be a little more lazy - and I'm too cheap to pay for that... :)

    2. Re:Bill Pay service. by danielsfca2 · · Score: 1

      I would think most people would qualify under the minimum balance or direct-deposit category. If one doesn't, though, I can understand how it doesn't look very inviting if you're not already paying a monthly fee for your checking account.

    3. Re:Bill Pay service. by cloudmaster · · Score: 1

      Oh - I thought that was an "and" not an "or"... :)

      I do dislike minimum balance requirements, though, as they're essentially a fee since you can't access those last few dollars without a penalty. I suppose a direct deposit restriction would be ok, though that also wouldn't have worked out well for me when I worked on the farm. ;)

  117. Use your ATM card dude! by tonyinsf · · Score: 1

    I'm sure everyone who has a PayPal account, also has an ATM card. So why use PayPal???

    --
    -- "maybe happiness is a fragment of existence, but with better packaging"
  118. -1, No Taste. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Hah. Shitty Christian pop.

  119. A fool and his conspiracy theory... by techstar25 · · Score: 2, Informative

    "A fool and his conspiracy theory are soon made fun of."
    -Me

    According to a Paypal rep, there have been 35,000,000 individuals who have used Paypal. There are just under 7000 people registered at the paypalsucks message board. That's about 1 in 5,000. To put that into perspective, according to this article , a Princeton survey found the odds of the Earth being hit with a city sized asteroid is also 1 in 5,000. The odds of having a bad Paypal experience are really pretty slim indeed. Don't believe the hype!

  120. Actually, it's not as easy as you think by Atario · · Score: 1

    Take it from me, I know.

    I never had a credit card till I was out of school and on my own...and by that point, it was apparently too late. I had to get a really crappy card with a low limit, high interest, and high yearly fee, keep it for a year, then get a real card. I basically had to pay for a credit rating -- if you don't have one, no one will give you a card except a clip joint like that one. I kicked myself for ignoring the "Hey! Sign up for a credit card!" tables outside the student store in college.

    --
    "A great democracy must be progressive or it will soon cease to be a great democracy." --Theodore Roosevelt
  121. my listing by dwightk · · Score: 1

    http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item =2959910038

    --
    Like anyone can even know that
  122. Overrated??? by Microsift · · Score: 1

    They really shouldn't let Huffers moderate!

    --
    My other sig is extremely clever...
  123. How Silly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Why would anybody pay that much for paypal very crazy. Take alook at www.wiget.com its trying to offer a year worth of subscriptionwith fairy good music.

    Streaming Direct

  124. more auctions by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0