Slashdot Mirror


Internet Suicide Pacts Surge in Japan

darkmonkeh writes "The number of Japanese who killed themselves in online suicide pacts rose sharply last year, according to the BBC. Japan has one of the highest suicide rates in the world, and the pacts may appeal to those scared to die alone. These Japanese internet 'suicide clubs' accounted for at least 26 deaths in the last 2 months."

571 comments

  1. Right to privacy by aussie_a · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Good to see the Japanese people enjoy having a right to privacy :P

    1. Re:Right to privacy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What is an internet suicide pact and where do I buy one?

    2. Re:Right to privacy by mycall · · Score: 1

      Yeah, privacy like Heaven's Gate.

    3. Re:Right to privacy by pixellette · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      Interesting idea, check this out, how people fight for their freedom nowadays... http://themilliondollarpalace.com/

    4. Re:Right to privacy by Oldsmobile · · Score: 1

      I'll kill myself if you will.

      --
      Some say he is made with ascii, others that he is eyeballed daily by millions. All we know is, he is known as the Sig
  2. The key question... by TheCowardofAnonymous · · Score: 0, Troll

    What affect will this have on the American economy? I mean, the Japanese are killing themselves, does this mean lower competition for jobs here?

    1. Re:The key question... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Wtf? It's more expensive to outsource to Japan. The cost of living in Japan is insane. You're probably thinking of China or something...

    2. Re:The key question... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Twenty-six deaths per two months equals 156 dead Japanese per year. The population of Japan is around 127,417,244 people, of which 66.2%, or 84,350,216 are of working age*. So these suicides will reduce Japan's total workforce by ~0.00018% per year, assuming that all the suicides are people of working age.

      This probably won't do much to the American economy.


      * Statistics hastily cribbed from the CIA World Factbook

    3. Re:The key question... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Instead of a linear model, how about using a logarithmic decay model?

    4. Re:The key question... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes, but 26 of those high wage jobs are now going to be available! Get your resume up to date peeps!

  3. scared???? by mayhemt · · Score: 1, Interesting

    Japan has one of the highest suicide rates in the world, and the pacts may appeal to those scared to die alone geez, i thought killing urself was scary enough....

    1. Re:scared???? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Suicide isn't scary FAILING is..

      - An anonymous coward who DIDNT try to kill himself.. Even if I ever did, the matrix would just reset my body and erase my mind.

    2. Re:scared???? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "geez, i thought killing urself was scary enough.... "

      As someone who's been suicidal I can tell you that there are worse things then death, death is like sleep: You wont even know you exist anymore. Everyone existing right now, no matter how good or bad their life is, when dead, will be like they never existed. Once really appreciate and understand that, you look at death and life in a way that is comforting, because even the people with the best lives still have to face death too, and total erase from existence (at least for now anyway).

      Also for someone who's attempted suicide, once you pass through that fear of death barrier that keeps most people from hurtin themselves (because the fear is so intense) once you break that protection mechanism, death is no longer scary, and there are many ways to erode or break this barrier, and a lot of it has to do with psychological abuse. People who are abused or mistreated have this mechanism overcome by what they experienced in their life.

  4. Mail Me by Polymorph2000 · · Score: 1

    Clearly movies predict the future http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0312843/

    1. Re:Mail Me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I have this DVD, but haven't gotten around to watching it yet. Clearly I should do so now that it's relevant!

    2. Re:Mail Me by darkitecture · · Score: 2, Funny


      Clearly movies predict the future http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0312843/

      Concerns over youth suicide being a prevalent issue in Japanese culture have been around a lot longer than 2002 (the year that film was made). That's like saying the movie 8 Mile predicted a future full of rap music.

    3. Re:Mail Me by HeLLFiRe1151 · · Score: 3, Informative

      Pink Floyd 1983 Post war dream lyrics "and it can't be much fun for them beneath the rising sun with all their kids committing suicide"

      --
      I've got 101 mod points and you can't have them!
    4. Re:Mail Me by Per+Wigren · · Score: 1

      Because the dead shine all night long!

      BTW, are you connected to yourself? :)

      --
      My other account has a 3-digit UID.
    5. Re:Mail Me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I so want that song for my cell ring tone.

    6. Re:Mail Me by dukeisgod · · Score: 1

      I'd consider that an example of art imitating life rather than a movie predicting the future.

  5. Fitting? by Crussy · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Anyone else find it fitting that this comes right after the thread about Darwin? Natural Selection sure works wonders

    1. Re:Fitting? by Jonny_eh · · Score: 4, Insightful

      You're assuming that those who choose to commit suicide, for any reason, isn't worthy of living (or the world is better off without them). While I can see how someone can see it that way, I would have to disagree.

      It is very possible that these people can be very creative or smart and are in a temporary rut. Or it is also possible that they have somekind of illness like bipolar or manic depression, which is treatable.

      Plus, I bet that almost all of them have friends or family that would be very upset with this.

    2. Re:Fitting? by DesireCampbell · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Are they smart? maybe. Will people miss them? probably. Is it an awesome display of natural selection? absolutly.

      --
      Whoo, signature!
      DesireCampbell.com
    3. Re:Fitting? by Firehed · · Score: 1

      Usually natural selection doesn't include voluntary suicide - people rarely kill themselves with the thought that the world will be better off as a result. Of course chances are that if you're to that point, we will be better off, but... umm... shit, I just disproved my own point. Well, you get the idea.

      --
      How are sites slashdotted when nobody reads TFAs?
    4. Re:Fitting? by dangitman · · Score: 1
      1. This is not "natural selection." That means something different than what you think it does.

      2. What do you mean about working wonders? Many suicidees are great people, it's the bastards that make the world so miserable who should die.

      --
      ... and then they built the supercollider.
    5. Re:Fitting? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Natural Selection sure works wonders

      I wouldn't go that far. In some cases, natural selection seems to miss the mark completely. For example, heartlessness doesn't seem to be covered by natural selection. Obnoxious people also get by very well in modern society. Call me a cynic, but stupidity also seems to be rewarded very well.

      It's a shame really. I could name dozens of exceptional people throughout history who weren't appreciated in their time, some of these people were probably likely candidates who just couldn't take the fact that they didn't measure up to social expectations.

      Seems like we all need to be a little more accepting, generous and respectful.

    6. Re:Fitting? by drsmithy · · Score: 1
      This is not "natural selection." That means something different than what you think it does.

      How on Earth is suicide not natural selection ? All else being equal, a person who suicides is clearly not the better candidate for prolonging the species.

    7. Re:Fitting? by LouisZepher · · Score: 1

      Only because one who "suicides" (is that really a verb?) is DEAD and is INCAPABLE of prolonging the species... There are a lot of living people with the social skills that make them capable of continuing the species, but I'd rather they be escorted out of the gene pool before the water becomes suddenly warm.

    8. Re:Fitting? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Anyone who says something as stupid as this has no capacity for understanding people or the problems that they go through. Suicidal thoughts come naturally with deep depression. I know that through experience, and if you had ever gone through depression, maybe you would too. It isn't fun, and these people deserve to live every bit as much as you or I.

      Your comment is disgusting and I have a hard time understanding how anyone could find it to be insightful.

    9. Re:Fitting? by dartarrow · · Score: 1

      Anyone else find it fitting that this comes right after the thread about Darwin? Natural Selection sure works wonders

      That's not cool Crussy, NOT cool. Without them japs we would not have this or this but would be stuck with these

      --
      I love humanity, it is people I hate
    10. Re:Fitting? by Vann_v2 · · Score: 1

      Huh? Natural selection doesn't care why you're incapable of reproduction, only that you are. People who are willing to forge suicide pacts are less likely to reproduce and therefore nature will select against those traits. This says nothing about other traits which don't cause one to commit suicide but which nature still selects against.

    11. Re:Fitting? by dangitman · · Score: 1
      It doesn't have to do with natural selection, because it has nothing to do with biology. Natural selection is about the genetic traits that get passed on to the next generation. Suicide is about social problems.

      So, you could call it "social selection" but it has nothing to do with biology.

      --
      ... and then they built the supercollider.
    12. Re:Fitting? by drsmithy · · Score: 1
      Only because one who "suicides" (is that really a verb?) is DEAD and is INCAPABLE of prolonging the species...

      Which is entirely my point. If they haven't got sufficient mental toughness to deal with life, then from an evolutionary perspective they're a failure.

      Ie: Natural selection in action - elimination of undesirable traits.

      There are a lot of living people with the social skills that make them capable of continuing the species, but I'd rather they be escorted out of the gene pool before the water becomes suddenly warm.

      None of which is relevant in an evolutionary context. Natural selection chooses traits which are favourable to the survival and expansion of the species - goals a tendency towards suicide most certainly does not further.

      (This is not a judgement on whether someone who kills themselves deserved to die.)

    13. Re:Fitting? by Bronster · · Score: 1, Interesting

      I'm pretty sure Darwin didn't have anything to say about intelligence or number of people who like you being a factor in natural selection.

      Basically, people who die for whatever reason before breeding won't pass on whatever it was to make them die to their children, whether it's stupidity or just a propensity to suicide.

      So yeah, very appropriate to a Darwin discussions.

    14. Re:Fitting? by LouisZepher · · Score: 1

      No, my point was that if someone "suicides", they'd be dead. Last I checked, necrophilia isn't the best form of procreation. You seem to be thinking of those with suicidal thoughts. Slight difference.

    15. Re:Fitting? by LouisZepher · · Score: 1

      Very valid point. It's true that anything that prevents reproduction is selected against, whether it be involuntary castration (let alone voluntary) or abstinence. 1) I originally posted in defense of those that tend to have suicidal thoughts, as I misinterpreted the grandparent regarding whether such individuals deserved to die. 2) It was an attempt at humor. Wordplay and all that. Meh...

    16. Re:Fitting? by arose · · Score: 1

      Natural, it's artificial if anything? You don't call other things people choose to do natural or do you?

      --
      Analogies don't equal equalities, they are merely somewhat analogous.
    17. Re:Fitting? by DesireCampbell · · Score: 1

      Artificial? How is it artificial? Lemmings don't "artificially" kill themselves (except if they're those cute computer Lemmings) and these suicide clubbers are exactly the same.

      --
      Whoo, signature!
      DesireCampbell.com
    18. Re:Fitting? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You're assuming that those who choose to commit suicide, for any reason, isn't worthy of living

      These people have made that decision themselves, and they've made it an irrevocable one. Who am I to disagree with them?

    19. Re:Fitting? by gavri · · Score: 1

      Natural Selection sure works wonders

      What does this mean? Makes no sense. Natural Selection just is.

      If you are suggesting that those who commit suicide are idiots, I disagree. We have evolved to think that life is worth living. That does not necessarily make it true.

    20. Re:Fitting? by drsmithy · · Score: 1
      It doesn't have to do with natural selection, because it has nothing to do with biology.

      How do you figure a psychological issue isn't biology ?

      Natural selection is about the genetic traits that get passed on to the next generation.

      Indeed. So clearly traits that tend toward suicide aren't going a terribly good thing to pass along.

      Suicide is about social problems.

      No, suicide is typically about psychological problems. Most people's minds don't fall apart dealing with social problems. Those whose do have "undesirable traits" that natural selection can "select" on.

      All else being equal, if person A decides to top themselves and person B does not, then clearly person B is the better bet for prolonging the species.

    21. Re:Fitting? by dangitman · · Score: 1
      How do you figure a psychological issue isn't biology ?

      because it isn't. Unless there is some underlying biological disease, most suicidees are no different genetically - they are just different socially.

      Indeed. So clearly traits that tend toward suicide aren't going a terribly good thing to pass along.

      but those traits are most often caused by societal effects, not genetic ones.

      No, suicide is typically about psychological problems.

      And what causes psychological problems? Mostly society, not genetics.

      --
      ... and then they built the supercollider.
    22. Re:Fitting? by novus+ordo · · Score: 1

      What you are referring to is Social Darwinism, not Natural Selection. What you said is about as insightful as a fruitfly.

      --
      "You're everywhere. You're omnivorous."
    23. Re:Fitting? by nacturation · · Score: 1

      Natural, it's artificial if anything? You don't call other things people choose to do natural or do you?

      Someone who is prone to killing themselves has suicide in their nature. Ergo, it is natural. Don't conflate the scientific definition of natural (selection) from the common usage of natural.

      --
      Want to improve your Karma? Instead of "Post Anonymously", try the "Post Humously" option.
    24. Re:Fitting? by Carewolf · · Score: 1

      No its a really bad example. If natural selection actually worked on this, suicidal behavior would have been wiped out a long time ago. The fact is suicidal behaviour has increased from social changes, and does not appear to be related much if anything to genetical heritage.

    25. Re:Fitting? by Shanep · · Score: 1

      Anyone else find it fitting that this comes right after the thread about Darwin? Natural Selection sure works wonders

      How is this Insightful? Depression does not only affect people of weak mind or body.

      Alan Turing commited suicide. I'm sure there are many other examples of incredible people who ended their own lives.

      --
      War crimes, torture, lies, illegal spying... Would someone give Bush a blowjob, already, so he can be impeached?
    26. Re:Fitting? by lbmouse · · Score: 1

      "The fact is suicidal behaviour has increased from social changes, and does not appear to be related much if anything to genetical heritage."

      Your post just proved the parent's position. "Social changes" are part of the environment:

      "Natural selection is the metaphor Charles Darwin used in 1859 to name the process he postulated to drive the adaptation of organisms to their environments and the origin of new species." (source)

      So yes, this is good example of natural selection, but maybe not inheritance, which is probably what you are thing of.

    27. Re:Fitting? by geoffspear · · Score: 1
      I'm pretty sure Darwin didn't have anything to say about intelligence [...] being a factor in natural selection.

      I'm pretty sure you won't find a single biologist anywhere (except maybe those who believe in Intelligent Design and still somehow managed to get biology degrees) who doesn't think that intelligence was by far the most important selective factor in the evolution of humans.

      There's really no other possible explanation for the comparative size of the human brain, which uses an enormous amount of energy. If intelligence wasn't important to our survival as a species, we wouldn't have it.

      Not that I'd equate intelligence with either popularity or with not committing suicide.

      --
      Don't blame me; I'm never given mod points.
    28. Re:Fitting? by ltbarcly · · Score: 1

      No, suicide is typically about psychological problems.

      Why do you suppose it is that some people come out of difficult situations relatively unscathed, while others have crippling mental problems? Why do you suppose some people seem to be drawn to drugs and alcohol and others could care less, despite similar backgrounds and social contexts?

      Most of who you are is determined by genetics. Recent research bears this out, and if anything, makes stronger claims than I do.

      Identical twins tend to end up very similar, with similar likes, and dislikes, similar hobbies, and so on. This is true whether they are raised together or apart, whether they are raised in similar environments or completely different environments.

      Some people have no ability to empathize with other people. Who ends up being a 'sociopath' seems to be highly genetically determined. Some people are conditional sociopaths, in that the sociopath genes seem to only find expression in certain social conditions (that is, with a chaotic life these genes tend to be 'turned on'). Some people could never become a sociopath, regardless of upbringing or trauma.

      Psychological problems are almost entirely caused by genetics.

    29. Re:Fitting? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "No its a really bad example."

      Not true at all. Natural selection can have MANY forces acting apon it. In the case of humans we have been striving to overcome with our brains (our most powerful tool) many of the factors that would have naturaly "Selected" our ansestors (I'm speaking of modern medicine, healthcare knowledge in general and laws to try to keep us safer). Our large population as compared to other spiecies of our physical size, is a testement to our ability to overcome physical weakness through our massive brains.

      However, many physical characteristics that might have meant death in our past, are now mearly an inconvinience (Wisdom Teeth are a good example). Also, many behavior patterns that may have been put aside in a life of physical struggle to survive (Such some modern stress factors that lead some people to commit suicide) are now becoming an issue specifically because of our success. Namely, population density and the stresses that causes. Among which can be a feeling of being useless or worthlessness.

      So I would characterise it as a good example of Natural Selection at work. Factors that effect Natural Selection change over time and there may be more than one at work making the obvious maybe not so much. Just because a factor wasnt enough of an impact to be noticable in the past doesn't mean another factor won't exacerbate the first one to a point that it becomes noticible as a driving Natural Selector.

    30. Re:Fitting? by Jaysyn · · Score: 1

      Lemmings don't actually march to their death. That was a film hoax by Disney.

      http://www.snopes.com/disney/films/lemmings.htm

      Jaysyn

      --
      There is a war going on for your mind.
    31. Re:Fitting? by Sky+Cry · · Score: 1
      You're assuming that those who choose to commit suicide, for any reason, isn't worthy of living (or the world is better off without them). While I can see how someone can see it that way, I would have to disagree.
      No, that's assuming these people have genetic predisposition to the suicide reason. I.e., if they survive, their children are likely to have the same problems.

      But that might not be the case. The suicide reason can have social roots. In that case, "getting rid" of suicidal people (by letting them commit suicide) won't help even from the natural selection point of view.
    32. Re:Fitting? by bskin · · Score: 1

      How is this Insightful? Depression does not only affect people of weak mind or body.

      Alan Turing commited suicide. I'm sure there are many other examples of incredible people who ended their own lives.


      You're attempting to apply value judgements to natural selection. This is a fallacy. Natural selection is just how we describe the fact that those who have genetic traits that better allow them to pass on their dna to the next generation, will tend to be better represented genetically in future generations. If you are depressed and kill yourself, this does not necessarily make you a 'worse' person, any more than if you walk outside and get mowed over by a drunk driver. But both of these actions will eliminate you from the gene pool, and hence are both natural selection in action.

      --
      hot foreign sheep.
    33. Re:Fitting? by DesireCampbell · · Score: 1

      Really?! Fuckin' Disney.

      Ha, maybe these suicide clubs are staged by Disney too :P

      --
      Whoo, signature!
      DesireCampbell.com
    34. Re:Fitting? by MasterOfMagic · · Score: 1

      It is very possible that these people can be very creative or smart and are in a temporary rut. Or it is also possible that they have somekind of illness like bipolar or manic depression, which is treatable.

      Let us not forget that Alan Turing committed suicide after he was outed one of his lovers. Very few in the CS would would argue that he wasn't smart and creative.

    35. Re:Fitting? by vertinox · · Score: 1

      You're assuming that those who choose to commit suicide, for any reason, isn't worthy of living (or the world is better off without them). While I can see how someone can see it that way, I would have to disagree.

      I'm not trolling here, but being a history buff, I do want to point out that Hitler was talked out of commiting suicide after the failed Beer Hall Putsch.

      Sometimes the world will be better off with someones death, but usually not since the world isn't filled with millions of Hitlers that are suicidal.

      Secondly, suicide in Japan is quite different in the US. The most well known modern act of seppuku was the father of Japanese serial killer, Tsutomu Miyazaki. Shamed by his sons acts, he commited ritual suicide so more than not this is seen as a way of retaining honor.

      May I also point out is that death to Japanese gives you a clean slate. Take the war minister Tojo from WWII. One of the reasons of animosity of Chinese and Koreans is the Japanese indifference to war criminals in one of their main shrines. They aren't glorifying the war crimes, but as in "this man is dead... he died because of the war, but his slate is clean because he has joined the world of dead spirits and no longer retains his sins of the living".

      To us westerners, we still hold people accountable for their sins long after their death even for hundreds of years and that you are responsible for your families well being after this fact.

      --
      "I am the king of the Romans, and am superior to rules of grammar!"
      -Sigismund, Holy Roman Emperor (1368-1437)
    36. Re:Fitting? by Shanep · · Score: 1

      You're attempting to apply value judgements to natural selection. This is a fallacy.

      No I wasn't. You have read WAY too much into what little I said. My point was that a person of incredible intelligence and great physical health can come to commit suicide and it not be the work of natural selection. There are often EXTERNAL overwhelming factors behind suicides which don't relate to how intelligent or phyically healthy someone is.

      Natural selection is just how we describe the fact that those who have genetic traits that better allow them to pass on their dna to the next generation, will tend to be better represented genetically in future generations. If you are depressed and kill yourself, this does not necessarily make you a 'worse' person, any more than if you walk outside and get mowed over by a drunk driver.

      I agree with that. And with you having said that, I am completely astonished that you then go on and say this...

      But both of these actions will eliminate you from the gene pool, and hence are both natural selection in action.

      Being run over by a drunk driver is obviously NOT an example of natural selection. Intelligent person A being killed by stupid or careless person B is not an example of natural selection. The intelligent person A dies while the stupid or careless person (who should have died) may live in THAT situation. That is an absurd example. Not every incident which eliminates someone from the gene pool is going to be an action of natural selection.

      Killing yourself out of depression is also not necessarily an example of natural selection. Some are. Everyone has a breaking point.

      --
      War crimes, torture, lies, illegal spying... Would someone give Bush a blowjob, already, so he can be impeached?
  6. Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Eli+Gottlieb · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I have to wonder, what is it about Japanese culture that produces these people in such high numbers? In America, they'd listen to emo music.

    I have hunches but no evidence. Could somebody explain this tragic issue?

    1. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by jcr · · Score: 1

      I have to wonder, what is it about Japanese culture that produces these people in such high numbers?

      I'm not sure that the numbers are all that high. 26 people out of a population of how many millions?

      -jcr

      --
      The only title of honor that a tyrant can grant is "Enemy of the State."
    2. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Behold the superiority of Japanese culture, as we like to say.

    3. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by aussie_a · · Score: 1

      Whatever it is about Japan that produces suicidal people at higher rates, I know of three types of suicidal people in Japan:
      * Samuri doing it to regain honour/because they've lost too much honour.
      * Kamakazi pilots doing it most likely for patriotism.
      * Suicid clubs

      I wouldn't count you're average every day suicide because they happen all over the world. But as far as I know, nowhere but in Japan do the above 3 types of suicidal people get created to the degree in which they're created in Japan.

    4. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Wonko+the+Sane · · Score: 2, Informative

      The specific type of sucides they are talking about are a small (but growing) subset of the total number of suicides.

    5. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by KarmaMB84 · · Score: 1

      I gather that that's only the number that have committed suicide in online pacts.

    6. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Eli+Gottlieb · · Score: 1

      I don't just mean those killing themselves via internet, I mean the notoriously high general suicide rates of Japan. They are quite real, and I'm quite curious as to why. I'm also curious as to why nobody in Japan (who would have some understanding of the issues) hasn't asked. The last statement applies to itself recursively as well as to why the suicide rates are high.

    7. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by JanneM · · Score: 5, Interesting

      Cultural differences. Really.

      People become depressed or financially or emotionally desperate all over the world. What kind of action (if any) it translates into depends a lot on social factors, such as the general acceptance of a given act, the impact on friends and relatives, the number of friends and relatives you have to be impacted and so on.

      So in a culture where a suicide doesn't carry a heavy stigma, where you tend to have small circles of family and friends and where some peculiarities of financial law can make it an attractive option in some corner cases you'll get quite a few suicides.

      Note that another way of "dealing" with an intolerable life situation, the killing spree or "going postal" kind of shootout, drunken rampages with a vehicle and so on, is very rare to unheard of here.

      --
      Trust the Computer. The Computer is your friend.
    8. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by JanneM · · Score: 2, Interesting

      But as far as I know, nowhere but in Japan do the above 3 types of suicidal people get created to the degree in which they're created in Japan.

      WHen you consider that you by definition need to be Japanese for the first two (and have to have lived before the Meji restoration era and during the second world war, respectively), that's not exactly a profound statement.

      --
      Trust the Computer. The Computer is your friend.
    9. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by pilkul · · Score: 2, Interesting
      Westerners often speculate that there must be some deep unhappiness in Japanese society to cause all these suicides, but I don't think that's necessarily the case. Suicide is much more prominent in Japanese mass culture than it is in the rest of the world, and there's less stigma attached to it. For centuries there have been honor suicides, love suicides and so on (common, and often viewed as positive acts). Popular Japanese authors regularly kill themselves (even more so than here). Also, Japan's main religions do not ban suicide. So Japanese people are more likely to consider it as a reasonable option.

      For example, I remember reading that a popular 17th-century puppet play by Chikamatsu glorified love suicides, and as a result there was a rash of them. This deep-set tendency has only been partially reduced by Western influence.

    10. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's because by and large the Japanese people have too good a taste for culture to listen to emo music. They try, and kill themselves when they recognize it as an alternative solution to having to listen to Emo as an outlet.

    11. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by c6gunner · · Score: 1

      What, you've never heard of Hiri Kiri?

      Japanese culture has long embraced the concept of suicide being the answer to certain problems. In some situations it was seen as the only way to recover honour for yourself, or your family. Whereas western culture and religion have always forbidden suicide, and have threatened to send you to hell if you do it, Japanese culture has not only condoned, but encouraged it. So is it any wonder that their suicide rate is higher than ours?

    12. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by MillionthMonkey · · Score: 1

      * People facing financial ruin who would just declare bankruptcy if they lived in some other country

    13. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by ral8158 · · Score: 1

      Well, as a few others have pointed out, in Japanese culture, suicide doesn't have a negetive stigma. I'll let you read them to explain that...
      The reason the suicide rate is so high in Japan among teenagers though (In addition to the "suicide is kind of okay" culture), is cram schools. Japanese students are obsessed about grades, because to be successful in life, they have to be perfect students, and get great grades, and do very well on exams. I'd imagine that if we put American kids into that kind of situation, the rates would be even *worse*. If anything, considering all the pressure they have on them, it's commendable to be able to survive it.

    14. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by amliebsch · · Score: 1
      western culture and religion have always forbidden suicide

      I don't believe this is accurate. I understand the Romans would off themselves practically at the drop of a hat.

      --
      If you don't know where you are going, you will wind up somewhere else.
    15. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Eli+Gottlieb · · Score: 1

      If those were American students (and if you're right about student suicides) the homicide rate would go up rather than suicide.

    16. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      well look at the MIT suicide rate.

    17. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Deadstick · · Score: 1
      I'm told that while murder and suicide rates vary widely across cultures, the sum of the murder and suicide rate is remarkably constant at around 22 deaths per 100K population per year. Presumably it suggests that we all resort to ultimate measures with about the same probability, but cultural differences determine who takes the bullet.

      rj

    18. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by bpd1069 · · Score: 1

      It is hard to see the issue without affixing some instinctual assumption that this phenomenon is a product of culture/race. When you put that into the mix it all becomes muddy. But if you address it from a 'human' standpoint the only relevant factors pop into plain view.

      They are over populated!

      I would dare to say the suicide pacts that occur online only come from people who live in densly populated areas of Japan...

      We are the result of millions of years of evolution, it would be nearsighted to assume that there isn't some instinctual mechanism is in action under such environments. You'll probably see the same things occuring in areas where the population is confined by the environment to a small geographic area.

      Hell, some snakes change there sex when there is an over abundance of one gender...

      While we would all like to think that there is an element of free will in all of us, we must not forget there are natural influences at work that we refuse to acknowledge.

      --
      --
    19. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by JanneM · · Score: 1

      For example, I remember reading that a popular 17th-century puppet play by Chikamatsu glorified love suicides, and as a result there was a rash of them. This deep-set tendency has only been partially reduced by Western influence.

      Goethe's "The Sorrows of Young Werther", about a love-stricken young poet that kills himself in despair caused a similar wave of suicides among European youths when it was first published.

      Similarily, this "wave" of internet suicides (which is nothing new; it's been reported here for at least a couple of years already), seems to be something of a fashion thing as well. Not that perfectly cheerful people decides to kill themselves, of course, but people that were already suicidal and would probably have done it anyway decide that this is the way to do it based on the perceived popularity. If they hadn't done this, they'd have jumped in front of a local train instead.

      --
      Trust the Computer. The Computer is your friend.
    20. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by WeblionX · · Score: 1

      Bah, that's not even western! Everyone knows that western means the USA! ;x

      --
      (\(\
      (=_=) Bani!
      (")")
    21. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by drivekiller · · Score: 1

      So here in the united states, with the recent changes in bankrupcy laws, we should expect to see an increase in the rate of reported suicides? Going postal will continue to be the preferred method.

    22. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by heinousjay · · Score: 1

      Japanese people have good taste? I take it the crappy j-pop, tentacle rape hentai, and feces-based porn flicks haven't crossed your radar yet.

      --
      Slashdot - where whining about luck is the new way to make the world you want.
    23. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Vellmont · · Score: 1

      Japan can't be the only culture where suicide doesn't have a social stigma attatched to it. How does the suicide rate compare to those cultures?

      --
      AccountKiller
    24. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by jcr · · Score: 1

      Note that another way of "dealing" with an intolerable life situation, the killing spree or "going postal" kind of shootout, drunken rampages with a vehicle and so on, is very rare to unheard of here.

      Actually, it's pretty rare almost everywhere in the world. We lose more people to the flu every year than we do to shooting rampages.

      -jcr

      --
      The only title of honor that a tyrant can grant is "Enemy of the State."
    25. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by badasscat · · Score: 4, Interesting

      I don't just mean those killing themselves via internet, I mean the notoriously high general suicide rates of Japan. They are quite real,

      No, they are not, and you're perpetuating the same stereotype as the article submitter. See here for actual suicide rates around the world. Japan's are higher than the US but lower than many other countries (Russia's suicide rate, for example, is about double that of Japan's) - overall, Japan is about average. Finland's suicide rate is comparable to Japan's, but you wouldn't know it based on media coverage - I don't recall seeing any news stories on Slashdot about those crazy, depressed Finns.

    26. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by StarWreck · · Score: 1

      Its because they don't have Japanese emo music, they only have really whiney sounding music. Some probably do listen to Western emo music but they don't understand the lyrics as well.

      --
      ... and in the DRM, bind them.
    27. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by born_to_live_forever · · Score: 0, Troll

      Japanese people have good taste? I take it the crappy j-pop, tentacle rape hentai, and feces-based porn flicks haven't crossed your radar yet.

      Hmm. They've crossed my radar, and I've pretty much passed on them.

      I pass on the crappy J-Pop, like I pass on Britney Spears.

      I pass on the tentacle rape hentai, like I pass on anything produced in the "Porn Capital of the World".

      I pass on the faeces-based porn, like I pass on anything said or done by George W. Bush.

      There, I think that sort of puts things into perspective.

      Seriously... what does America have to feel superior about?

      --

      - Peter Ravn Rasmussen

    28. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by heinousjay · · Score: 1

      It's a matter of someone making the opposite assertion. You bother to read the thread, or did you just reply to me?

      Oh, I get it - you had to take a shot at the US. Yeah, that was probably important to get off your chest. Sorry, carry on, help yourself to feel good.

      --
      Slashdot - where whining about luck is the new way to make the world you want.
    29. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Most of it seems to flow from bushido , or "the way of the samurai." Studying seppuku would be especially helpful as well. It's basically considered the most honorable way out of "major embarrassments" or disappointments.

      I just returned from a two-year stay in Japan. Even on the small line (Odakyu), which ran from Tokyo to Odawara (where I lived), there were weekly "accidents" where people would literally throw themselves on the tracks.

    30. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by UserGoogol · · Score: 1

      My theory, which of course I pulled out of my ass and has no supporting evidence, is that Japan tends to value "society" more than the individual, relative to western countries. Thus, when a westerner is depressed, they will interpret it as the rest of the world being unfair. When a Japanese person is depressed, they will interpret it as their own personal failing.

      --
      "Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity." -- Hanlon's Razor
    31. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by name773 · · Score: 1

      we're the "melting pot", so we can take a bunch of things from several different cultures and call it ours. you get some mix and match this way

    32. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      Popular Japanese authors regularly kill themselves

      Jeez. You'd think once would be enough.

    33. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by linguae · · Score: 1
      Japanese students are obsessed about grades, because to be successful in life, they have to be perfect students, and get great grades, and do very well on exams. I'd imagine that if we put American kids into that kind of situation, the rates would be even *worse*.

      American kids are put in these kinds of situations (albeit not to the extent as in Japan). I suppose you've never been to the College Confidential message boards, haven't you? Go to some of the sections about getting into college and high school preparation, and come back with your findings. None of them are suicidal, but the board is filled with perfectionists, complaining about 2390s on the SAT (highest score is 2400 now), 3.99 GPAs versus 4.0s, and stressing themselves out wondering if they have the stats to get into MIT and Stanford. (The graduate school boards are similar). I went to that site when I was in 11th grade, accidentally stubling across it to find college admissions advice. Let's just say, that site made my perfectionism a bit worse (even though it never got as bad as some people on the board), until I finally went away from it after two months of browsing.

      I'm a CS freshman at a reasonably good university, but I am still an ardent perfectionist, even though I haven't been doing a good job at being perfect ;) (looks at my sub-3.4 GPA). There are certain goals that I have (such as being a researcher) that require that I do extremely well in school. However, my fear is not doing well. The other issues with perfectionists is what is considered "well." To many perfectionists, a 3.0 or even a 3.5 college GPA is considered terrible, even though some people on campus will kill for that GPA (no pun intended). However, it seems that everybody needs to perform almost perfectly or perfectly to have a chance to get the best things in life, or they'll be shafted.

      So, I feel that American kids are already feeling the pressure. The message is that you have to do exceptionally well in elemetary school, middle school, high school, and college in order to get anything in life. That, or learn how to be exceptional with a sport or be an exceptional performer.

    34. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The only people who spell the word feces "faeces" are those attempting to legitimize it.

    35. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Lisandro · · Score: 1

      I have to wonder, what is it about Japanese culture that produces these people in such high numbers? In America, they'd listen to emo music.

          Makes sense. I'd rather kill myself.

          Twice.

    36. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Do we blame that on the gun or bankruptcy laws?

    37. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Mr.+Slippery · · Score: 1
      What, you've never heard of Hiri Kiri?
      Hara kiri. "Belly-cutting".
      Whereas western culture and religion have always forbidden suicide, and have threatened to send you to hell if you do it,

      The Western nations of Russia, Ukrane, and several other Slavic nations have higher suicide rates than Japan. Finland's is close.

      --
      Tom Swiss | the infamous tms | my blog
      You cannot wash away blood with blood
    38. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      An interesting point that I don't think has been mentioned as a possible cause for suicide is the publicity suicides recieve.
      A psychologist named Phillips did an archival study of newspapers, media coverage and death rates in American (also doing it for homicides later) and found a direct correlation between the amount of media coverage a suicide recieved, and the number of people that committed suicide following that.
      He also noted that people were more likely to "copy-cat" that behavior if they were socially/physically similiar to the person in question.
      While I'm not sure that this applies, as I don't know how much media coverage suicides get in Japan, its a thought worth considering.
      (Phillips carefully ruled out a number of confounds including M.E.s labeling deaths suicides etc.)

    39. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by jnik · · Score: 1
      If they hadn't done this, they'd have jumped in front of a local train instead.

      Only if they hate their family and want to stick them with the bill for the delays. Suicide may be more acceptable in Japan than in the US, but doing it by jumping in front of a train is less so.

    40. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Evil+Pete · · Score: 1

      In fact we even have the phrase "to fall on one's sword" to suggest suicide to save the honour of whatever.

      The Romans certainly believed in this. They really liked "opening the veins" etc. Perhaps its something about warrior cultures.

      --
      Bitter and proud of it.
    41. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Mr.+Slippery · · Score: 1
      But if you address it from a 'human' standpoint the only relevant factors pop into plain view. They are over populated!

      While Japan has a fairly high population density (you've basically got mountains, sea, and a thin strip of land suitable for heavy development in between), they do a remarkably good job at not having an overcrowded feel. They get the details right.

      Japan has a lower population density than Belgium, the Netherlands, or Puerto Rico. Their density is only about a third that of Bermuda. Even Toyko is less densly packed than Paris, Barcelona, or Seoul.

      --
      Tom Swiss | the infamous tms | my blog
      You cannot wash away blood with blood
    42. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I've already moderated in this article, ergo the AC response, but I couldn't pass you up....
      From what I've understood, the Japanese acceptance on suicide stemmed from dishonor--a loss in battle, or in modern times a loss in business. Has the paradigm (yes,I said paradigm) bled itself into the next generation so much that failing in school, or not being accepted by their peers, or not being understood by their parents led to cause for self destruction?

      I have never understood the philosophy behind the many types of self-destruction, whether it's Hari Kari (sp?), suicide bombings, or just 'offing' yourself because.....

      I understand the cultural part, but at what point does the next generation stand up and say WTF?!? To me this is tantamount to the battered, dysfuntional child repeating the cycle, just because....

      I'm bothered by it all.

    43. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by DDLKermit007 · · Score: 1

      Perhaps thier higtened attention to what would be considered honor and what those around them whom are equally honorable think of them. In Western countries we don't have that issue partially due to the fact that just about everyone is more than happy to stab you in the back at the first sign of an extra buck being in thier bank account at the end of the day. We are individualistic, self destructive, egotistical and in general horrible people in how most in the "civilized west" act. In Asian countries and especially Japan people generaly tend to be close to more of a huge community that while everyone has thier wants they try to keep it less destructive (name me one Japanese Enron).

      Imagine for instance instead of everyone in your country being less like faceless individuals that you could give two shits about as you flip them off for cutting you off. It's closer to a country full of very close family & friends. Now imagine you did something very stupid to those friends & family you really like (like lost 50 grand or bankrupted a buisness and ruined a few lives). You'd feel a few flavors of shit and probably try to avoid those people again. Problem is the Japanese can't just avoid the people as a whole. Something like honor & reputation really mean allot there and if you don't have it your not worth much.

    44. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      In Japan, if a top CEO etc screws up (or is caught cheating etc), they might commit suicide.

      In US, they get USD20 million and other benefits.

      Or write a book all about it, sell their story etc.

    45. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by ozmanjusri · · Score: 1

      For example, I remember reading that a popular 17th-century puppet play by Chikamatsu glorified love suicides, and as a result there was a rash of them. This deep-set tendency has only been partially reduced by Western influence.

      In Europe, Hungary has the reputation of being suicide obsessed. The song Gloomy Sunday by Rezsô Seress, a Hungarian composer, was blamed for many suicides http://www.phespirit.info/gloomysunday/, and is still known as a suicide song. Interestingly, their choice of methods is often rather brutal - defenestration was common, for example.

      --
      "I've got more toys than Teruhisa Kitahara."
    46. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by iogan · · Score: 1

      I don't recall seeing any news stories on Slashdot about those crazy, depressed Finns.

      Dude, have you _been_ to Finland?
      No, but honestly, even though you may not have seen them here, such stories abound all over the world. It's either them, or us (swedes) and how we don't have sunlight for half the year, bla bla yada yada. What I've never seen is a story about how new-and-improved-capitalist Russia has one of the highest suicide rates in the world. I thought they were ok now? Now that they've embraced democracy. *cough cough*

    47. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by JPribe · · Score: 1

      Culture, plain and simple. It's the same reason they had kamikaze pilots in WWII. Their culture is all about honor. We might find a person who disembowels themself to be nuts, but to them that is about the best thing to do if you *want more karma.* How's that for subliminal?

      --

      Why go fast when you can go anywhere? O|||||||O
    48. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Gryle · · Score: 1

      Huh? What's this "Finland"? A WoW area I haven't found yet?

      --
      Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity, and I'm not entirely sure about the universe - Einstein
    49. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      People make a big deal of suicide in Japan but I have to wonder if this perception is based more on stereotyping rather than facts. Yes, people commit suicide on the Chuo Line in Tokyo, but so do Americans on the Bay Area Express. Yes, the number of online suicide pacts in Japan are on the rise, but the number is less than 100. This is figure nothing compared to non-online suicide rates in the US. The anonymous coward who wrote the BBC article says Japan has the # 1 highest suicide rate, but did s/he do the fact checking or did s/he accept this because it is in line with his/her stereotypes about the Japanese people? Because the WHO's ranking doesn't put Japan near #1.

    50. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      A country's suicide rate mostly correlates with unemployment rate and alcoholism, not stereotype. Japan's WHO figure is from 1999, a time when the country saw high rates of layoffs, homelessness, and suicide, due to a bad economy. The situation is much better now. The problem with stereotypes is that people change, and stereotypes don't change as fast. I went to the midwestern US and people still thought New York City is the crime capital of the US. That was something like, back in the 80's? So Mexicans are both lazy and hard working now? WTF?

    51. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by JanneM · · Score: 1

      People make a big deal of suicide in Japan but I have to wonder if this perception is based more on stereotyping rather than facts.

      Yes, absolutely. Japan is fairly high in the rankings, but I believe the idea that it's highest stems from outdated information - or has perhaps always been a myth; since there is comparatively little stigma attached to it, it has likely been more truthfully reported here than in places with a different view of the practice. According to WHO, Japan ranks at around #11 today, with a bunch of eastern European countries topping the list.

      --
      Trust the Computer. The Computer is your friend.
    52. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by born_to_live_forever · · Score: 1

      The only people who spell the word feces "faeces" are those attempting to legitimize it.

      "Legitimize it"? What does that mean? Making it acceptable to smoke shit? Hmm. I guess someone can come up with a medical reason to stuff a turd in your pipe and toke down. Stranger things have happened.

      There's another group of people who spell it "faeces": people with some sort of connection to medicine -- doctors, nurses, psychologists, medical historians.

      Oh wait... I'm a medical historian. Guess that explains it.

      I'll just go back to "legitimizing" stuff, now. Buh-bye.

      --

      - Peter Ravn Rasmussen

    53. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by born_to_live_forever · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      Oh, I get it - you had to take a shot at the US. Yeah, that was probably important to get off your chest. Sorry, carry on, help yourself to feel good.

      Thank you, but I'm fine now. I've filled my quota of US-bashing for this week. Next, I'm going to find a thread which can provide me with a good excuse to bash France.

      But looking at my list, I can see I've got a problem coming up. Where am I going to find a thread with an excuse to bash Bhutan?

      --

      - Peter Ravn Rasmussen

    54. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by hachete · · Score: 1

      instead, you could legitimately go about around saying those crazy, depressed men as they seem to be more likely to commit suicide in all countries

      --
      Patriotism is a virtue of the vicious
    55. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by Cro+Magnon · · Score: 1
      Going postal will continue to be the preferred method.


      Yeah, but if some loon blows away 12 people and then shoots himself, it's still a suicide.
      --
      Slow down, cowboy! It has been 4 hours since you last posted. You must wait another few hours.
    56. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by c6gunner · · Score: 1

      Yes, I'm sorry, I'm not up on my spelling of Japanese suidice terms. Somehow it doesn't seem like the most relevant thing to my lifestyle. Heck I might even have misspelled sepukku.

      The Western nations of Russia, Ukrane, and several other Slavic nations have higher suicide rates than Japan

      here are the top suicide nations (Sri Lanka's placement may not be accurate due to very old statistics):

      LITHUANIA
      RUSSIAN FEDERATION
      BELARUS
      LATVIA
      UKRAINE
      SRI LANKA
      SLOVENIA
      HUNGARY
      ESTONIA
      KAZAKHSTAN
      JAPAN

      Now, I personaly don't see any nations there that you could truly consider part of the western world. They're all thir world nations more or less. If I lived in Kazakhstan, I'd probably commmit suicide too. Either that or the KGB would "suicide" me ;)

    57. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by elrous0 · · Score: 1
      Russia has one of the highest suicide rates in the world. I thought they were ok now? Now that they've embraced democracy. *cough cough*

      Hey, just look at the wonders it's done for Iraq and Palestine. Freedom is on the march!

      -Eric

      --
      SJW: Someone who has run out of real oppression, and has to fake it.
    58. Re:Culture shouldn't be making "Hikikomori" by ral8158 · · Score: 1

      Well, I do understand that American students are put into that kind of stuff, but it's *way* more serious in Japan. I can accept the perfectionist thing (One of those perfectionists is my brother, so I've lived through it T_T). But to clarify, I really need to stress that in Japan, parents will literally disown kids for doing badly, and some families reward high grades with sexual favors. I can't even make that up, and I'm dead serious. But yes, most of what you've said is true.

  7. Suicide Club by 88NoSoup4U88 · · Score: 2, Funny

    Tyler Durden: The first rule of Suicide Club is - you do not talk about Suicide Club. The second rule of Suicide Club is - you DO NOT... Wait a second, never mind about the rules.

    1. Re:Suicide Club by PodissRT · · Score: 5, Funny

      8th RULE: If this is your first night at Suicide Club, you HAVE to kill yourself.

    2. Re:Suicide Club by qbwiz · · Score: 1

      Luckily, these suicide clubs never seem to last very long.

      --
      Ewige Blumenkraft.
    3. Re:Suicide Club by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      thats how it is with fads!

    4. Re:Suicide Club by G-funk · · Score: 2, Funny

      Rule 5 -- NO POOFTAS!

      --
      Send lawyers, guns, and money!
  8. Suicide by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    The majority of suicides in Japan are young girls. Part of the reason is because in the culture of Japan girls are considered inferior in many ways.

    The majority of suicides in the US are young boys (~86%). I'm not trying to start a flamewar but I think our culture has reversed and that the suicide rate is a good metric. Young boys who have problems in education are considered inferior while if a young girl has a problem she will get all the help she needs. ~60% of new students in our colleges are women and men are being pushed to the side as if they are inferior. Eventually we may get to the point where France is (for example, ~70% of all new judges are women). Many people like to pretend that this problem does not exist. The US and Japan have the same problems, except they affect different genders.

    1. Re:Suicide by hunterx11 · · Score: 4, Informative

      Actually more girls attempt to commit suicide than boys in the US, but more girls fail because they tend to eschew more gruesome and reliable methods.

      --
      English is easier said than done.
    2. Re:Suicide by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The world health organization shows the opposite, twice as many males commiting suicide as females in japan.

      http://www.who.int/mental_health/prevention/suicid e/suiciderates/en/

    3. Re:Suicide by Garwulf · · Score: 2, Interesting

      There's also a large number of suicides that are attempts at auto-erotic asphyxia gone wrong, from what I've heard - they get classified as a suicide because "suicide" is a lot less embarassing than the truth.

      (And if you don't know what auto-erotic asphyxia is, you probably don't want to. Trust me on that. Really.)

      --
      Robert B. Marks
      Author, Demonsbane in Diablo Archive
    4. Re:Suicide by Wyatt+Earp · · Score: 2, Informative

      Males are four times more likely to die from suicide than females, Women report attempting suicide during their lifetime about three times as often as men.

      http://www.cdc.gov/ncipc/factsheets/suifacts.htm

    5. Re:Suicide by JDevers · · Score: 4, Insightful

      That is because there is a distinct difference between wanting to kill oneself and wanting the world to THINK you wanted to kill yourself, aka a call for help. The numbers are also skewed somewhat because many young girls attempt suicide on more than one occasion, whereas if you are successful that pretty much means it is your last attempt.

      Many women kill themselves in violent "reliable" ways, they truly wanted to die, and of course many of the women who took a bunch of pills truly DID want to die, but most who slash their wrists in a very shallow way or who take pills are really making a call for help. They do not truly wish to die and so should be differentiated somewhat from actual suicide attempts that failed (such as botched gunshot wounds, many people attempt to shoot themselves without realizing the parts of their brains which are actually essential, that should most certainly be considered an actual attempt).

    6. Re:Suicide by SamBeckett · · Score: 1

      Yep, I saw that episode of Six Feet Under too.

    7. Re:Suicide by TubeSteak · · Score: 2, Interesting

      A lot of people fail through ignorance.

      Pills aren't exactly a 'reliable' way to kill yourself. Too few and you don't die, too many at once and you might end up spewing them back out.

      I remember reading an article where they had interviewed failed bridge jumpers. They said almost every one realized what a mistake they had made once they stepped off the bridge.

      Anyways, didn't they use to run PSA's for suicide hotlines?

      --
      [Fuck Beta]
      o0t!
    8. Re:Suicide by QuantumG · · Score: 1

      Part of the reason is because in the culture of Japan girls are considered inferior in many ways.

      And to think, I always considered young Japanese girls to be superior in so many important ways ;)

      --
      How we know is more important than what we know.
    9. Re:Suicide by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      So, what you're saying is that we win at suicide, right? Damn, it's time to put another chalk mark on the "We can do anything you can do better" list. As far as I see it, all we need now is the ability to give birth, breast feed, and complain more often!

    10. Re:Suicide by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The rule of thumb is that
      while women are 3x more likely to attempt suicide
      men are 3x more likely to be "effective at it

      Women tend to use drugs, alcohol, self cutting, and send signals to friends/family
      Men are likely to use guns and other violent approches

    11. Re:Suicide by nursegirl · · Score: 2, Interesting

      For that reason, the highest gender-profession aggregate of successful suicides in Canada every year is female physicians. While most women try with pills, female physicians have the knowledge and access to the tools to do it right, the first time.

    12. Re:Suicide by BenjiTheGreat98 · · Score: 1

      They mentioned Autoerotic aspyxiation on The X-Files one time and I made the mistake of looking it up on the net.... Some thing you just wish you could unlearn.

      --
      :wq
    13. Re:Suicide by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Suicide rate is on the spec of 5 times higher for women than men in the United States. It is just that men are better at what they do, and thus have twice the success rate.

    14. Re:Suicide by Ragnarrokk · · Score: 1

      I agree on that note. Even here in the schools I attend, you can see the gradual evolution and advancement of these calls for help. Generally a girl will slash her wrists, giving them at the beginning, minor red lines. She then wears a long sleeve top to create the illusion she's covering it up, but in fact rolls up her sleeve most of the day, reaching its peak when she rolls up her sleeve during class and sticks her hand in the air to answer a question. That day, for once, she answers a lot of questions.

      Immediately after class, she gets mobbed by classmates going, "OHMIGAWD! UR ARM!"which she then feebly tries to cover up for more attention, before the group is treated to a five minute solo.

      This then gets old and common, and no one cares all that much, so she pushes futher, and draws blood, causing a scab, and this gets old over time and time again. Eventually, she'll reach the full suicide "attempt" and get all the attention that comes with it. How nice.

      I'd love to sympathise with these people, but what gets me about the people in my school who do this, is that their problems are extremely petty, along the lines of, "Oooh Anna stole Jason before I could catch him and I really liked him!" meaning that, they don't really have problems, these girls just crave attention.

      ``Ragnarok
      (SIDENOTE: I know there are males who do the same, but generally, a vast, vast majority of the people that do this, in my experience, are female.)

    15. Re:Suicide by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Taking a bunch of pills is not as sure-fire as it seems. Unless you take some sort of sedative first, you'll likely vomit up that handful of pills before it kills you.

      But then there's the chance that you could choke on your vomit, which is pretty good.

  9. Boredom by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It happens when you have everything, life becomes pointless (no dreams, no motivation no nothing), like in a mmorpg when you have everything it becomes boring after a while.

  10. Blown out of proportion... by PornMaster · · Score: 4, Informative

    So... 34000 Japanese killed themselves in 2003, and last year less than 100 people committed suicide as part of suicide clubs.

    1 in 340, or 0.3 percent of suicides are accounted for by this?

    People like to be horrified by the idea, but resources would be far better focused in pretty much any other way than worrying about this.

    1. Re:Blown out of proportion... by YrWrstNtmr · · Score: 1, Insightful

      True, but is it a trend on the rise? If so, maybe they can nip it in the bud.

    2. Re:Blown out of proportion... by Wyatt+Earp · · Score: 1

      Suicide took the lives of 30,622 people in 2001 in the US with say around 292 million people.
      127 million people in Japan, so the suicide rate in Japan is over twice that of the US.

    3. Re:Blown out of proportion... by pla · · Score: 1, Troll

      True, but is it a trend on the rise? If so, maybe they can nip it in the bud.

      Hate to have to inject the voice of reason into this, but...

      Why?

      These people kill themselves for a reason.

      They live in a place where they have no value as an individual, where society expects them to work themselves literally to death, and "urban sprawl" has gone the way of wall-to-wall carpeting.

      I'd probaby want to escape that, too!



      It really disturbs me that, at the same time our population keeps rising on an exponential curve, we still cling to archaic notions of the "sacredness" of every life.

      Sacred? No. Worthless. Japanese society has just caught on to that idea realtively earlier than the rest of us. Perhaps it has something to do with their stereotypical obsession with honor and accepting suicide as an honorable way out of any problem, but they have the right idea. How do you deal with overpopulation? Encourage death.

    4. Re:Blown out of proportion... by wik · · Score: 4, Funny

      Not a problem. The trend will die out.

      --
      / \
      \ / ASCII ribbon campaign for peace
      x
      / \
    5. Re:Blown out of proportion... by SetupWeasel · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Whoa, whoa, whoa. Reel that back in.

      Suicide does not have a significant effect on population. Not only that, most developed countries including Japan are having to deal with the prospect of a shrinking population. In fact, they call it their biggest problem.

      The solution to the world's problems is never allowing people to suffer.

    6. Re:Blown out of proportion... by The+Master+Control+P · · Score: 1

      "These people kill themselves for a reason."

      Well, if you ask the people who survive jumping off the Golden Gate Bridge in the US, you'll find that most of them realize that their problems are entirely solvable about half way down. Then they hit the water at 80 MPH and cost their families tens of thousands of dollars in medical bills.

      "It really disturbs me that, at the same time our population keeps rising on an exponential curve, we still cling to archaic notions of the "sacredness" of every life."

      Our population isn't rising on an exponential curve. It's more like a logistic equation. Right now, we're at or just past 1/2 earth's carrying capacity, so population growth will decrease until it levels off around 10 billion.

    7. Re:Blown out of proportion... by 246o1 · · Score: 0, Troll

      "Not a problem. The trend will die out."

      Why is that modded "Insightful" ?!? It's a joke. If it were meant to be insightful, he would have given a reason. There's no reason to believe this trend will go away, considering that the penetration of the internet into Japanese society could grow greater, leading to more lonely people finding each other online.

      (My opinion on this info, btw: As other people have pointed out, at least this is healthier than channeling their loneliness into killing sprees, etc.)

      --
      Although the moon is smaller than the earth, it is farther away.
    8. Re:Blown out of proportion... by moosesocks · · Score: 4, Funny

      Not a problem. The trend will die out.

      You mean sort of like the ASCII ribbon campaign did in the late 90s?

      --
      -- If you try to fail and succeed, which have you done? - Uli's moose
    9. Re:Blown out of proportion... by drsmithy · · Score: 1
      It really disturbs me that, at the same time our population keeps rising on an exponential curve, we still cling to archaic notions of the "sacredness" of every life.

      I'd have to say that the notion of "every life is sacred" is a very recent development, rather than something "archaic".

    10. Re:Blown out of proportion... by jasonditz · · Score: 1

      A couple dozen people seems far from a broad trend in a nation of so many millions.

      I'd chalk it up to a combination of technophobia and overinterpretting small data sets.

    11. Re:Blown out of proportion... by baKanale · · Score: 1

      Not a problem. The trend will die out.

      Aww, damn. I was hoping to make a killing in suicide booths...
      "Thank you for using Stop'n'Drop. America's favorite suicide booth since 2008."

    12. Re:Blown out of proportion... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      These aren't "clubs" per say, but more like people who don't want to die alone. Japanese society is very social, and most of these suicidal people are cut off from the world. With the pervailance of the Internet, it's not surprising that some of these people can find each other and decide to do it together. The term "suicide pact" makes it sound like a trendy cult or something, but as you say, this isn't even a statistic in face of how many total suicides there are in Japan. It's something for journalists to sensationalize.

  11. Suicide Clubs? by shmookey · · Score: 4, Funny

    Oh, we slashdotters have known about them forever. We call them nightclubs.

    1. Re:Suicide Clubs? by alex4u2nv · · Score: 0

      I thought it was suicidegirls.com? =p

    2. Re:Suicide Clubs? by syousef · · Score: 1

      Oh, we slashdotters have known about them forever. We call them nightclubs.

      Talking to a girl won't kill you. I promise.

      --
      These posts express my own personal views, not those of my employer
    3. Re:Suicide Clubs? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Talking to a girl won't kill you. I promise.

      No, but after being rejected by 20 girls in one night, one might be about ready to kill themselves?

  12. Don't worry by cgenman · · Score: 4, Funny

    This sort of thing is self-regulating.

  13. Paranoia Agent... by Llywelyn · · Score: 2, Informative

    Upon reading the title I was immediately reminded of Paranoia Agent, and now have that song stuck in my head...

    --
    Integrate Keynote and LaTeX
    1. Re:Paranoia Agent... by f0rtytw0 · · Score: 2

      Glad to see I wasn't the only one. That was a good episode though.

      --
      this is the most important sig ever! In your face 446154!
    2. Re:Paranoia Agent... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      A Bright Family Plan!

    3. Re:Paranoia Agent... by crimson30 · · Score: 1

      Yeah, that was my first thought, too.

      And for anyone wondering what the hell we're talking about, Paranoia Agent is an anime TV series. It's a little cheesy, but has some rather interesting bits, including the episode involving a bunch that make an online suicide pact.

      My second thought was to wonder if chicks who enter into such pacts would be easy... or something like that. To get rejected by someone getting ready to commit suicide would really put meaning behind someone saying "I'd rather die than have sex with you!". And the twisted thought that springs to mind is that I'd imagine it shouldn't feel too bad to be rejected by that person anyway, since they wouldn't be around long enough for anyone to find out about it.

  14. Slashdot sucide club by grazzy · · Score: 5, Funny

    We'll be staging a group sucide next friday. Bring your own CAT5.

    1. Re:Slashdot sucide club by grazzy · · Score: 3, Funny

      P.S.

      We'll also be installing Linux on your laptop for free!

    2. Re:Slashdot sucide club by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      Cat5? You guys are pussies. A real man strangles himself to death with his bare hands.

      http://www.thebestpageintheuniverse.net/c.cgi?u=ma nly_suicide

    3. Re:Slashdot sucide club by c_forq · · Score: 4, Funny

      First one to compile Gentoo before they die loses.

      --
      Computers allow humans to make mistakes at the fastest speeds known, with the possible exception of tequila and handguns
    4. Re:Slashdot sucide club by rubycodez · · Score: 1

      naw, completing the two requisite sepuku strokes before your second cuts your head off is way more He-Manly.

    5. Re:Slashdot sucide club by zoid.com · · Score: 1

      Gentoo I assume. Slow slow death!

    6. Re:Slashdot sucide club by linguae · · Score: 3, Funny

      Hey, I almost died of a heart attack reading that.

    7. Re:Slashdot sucide club by identity0 · · Score: 1

      Shit, how do I hang myself with 802.11b?

      On a separate note, does this mean we'll be Slashdotting a bridge? It'll look like a horde of lemmings leaping to their deaths, I suppose.

    8. Re:Slashdot sucide club by The_Mr_Flibble · · Score: 1

      no wonder you want to die were all using fibre now.

    9. Re:Slashdot sucide club by famebait · · Score: 1

      We'll be staging a group sucide

      Surely you mean "a beowulf cluster of those things"?

      --
      sudo ergo sum
  15. Wouldn't these suicide pacts... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    eventually just die off.

  16. Online suicide by NittanyTuring · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Get your suicide online, at www.eSeppuku.com

    1. Re:Online suicide by c_fel · · Score: 1

      Your link doesn't work, it must be slashdotted. Anyone has a mirror ?

      --
      I hate all sigs, mine included.
  17. Re:All I have to say is ice cream by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You better be careful hikikomon might happen to you, dudes. Actually that isn't even funny though, AT ALL. I don't think suicide is funny.

    I am a firm believer that that phenomenon, such as too much time spent on the internet is not a good thing. To be a recluse is not a good thing either. As to why modern life is harder for the Japanese I am assuming it has to do with what a contrast modern life is compared to traditional Japanese culture. I just saw a blurb on 20/20 about the youth in Japan and how ignorant the kids are there...13 to 22 year olds are doing things like eating in public on the street, stuff that seems super normal in America, but in Japan it is frowned upon. So the culture clash of more traditional Japanese values and how modern society is, maybe those people are lost as to where their place is, which direction their country is going in and how to meld all of it together to form a healthy and productive society. Eh, they just need some ice cream. I am also a firm believer that ice cream makes everything better, especially *green tea ice cream

  18. Land by LeonGeeste · · Score: 2, Insightful

    They have so little land. They're all packed in there tightly. Scientists have done experiments with rats where they give them enough space and resources for 50 of them, start them with 10, let them breed, and then let nature take its course. What happens is that eventually they start fighting over resources (predictable) but also get mental illnesses at a much higher rate. They also started engaging in self-destructive acts. I think we see the same thing with Japanese people now. What, 130 million people in a (mountainous) area the size of California? They all have to be wage slaves because there's no cheap land to move to when your job gets shitty, so they just have to "take it". Problem is, a lot of them can't take the high stress that the wage slave-drivers try to milk out of them. "We got 30 people who can replace you. Work harder!" Yeah, you can probably imagine how it feels. It doesn't help that the Bank of Japan's policies are keeping the economy in the gutter by inflating the money supply so your same shitty wages buy you less and less.

    --
    Rank my idea: http://www.sinceslicedbread.com/node/531
    1. Re:Land by fLameDogg · · Score: 1
      Someone once told me, years ago, about a particular film regarding this. I believe it was "Ratopolis" (not Flushed Away , often coined "Ratropolis").

      It seems there are other things which use the term "Ratopolis", too, and I never did zero in on it after several minutes of talking to Google, but here are a few pages which reference it, for anyone interested. It will require searching the pages:

      fairgren.com

      phoenyx.net

      css.washington.edu

      Apparently it's a 16mm film from 1978, so maybe it's not surprising that it's a little hard to find.

      --
      fD
    2. Re:Land by pilkul · · Score: 1

      Uh, that's the most bogus attempt to apply the results of animal studies to humans I've ever seen. According to this Belgium and the Netherlands have a higher population density than Japan --- where are all the Belgian suicides? Also, your theory implies that urban areas would have a higher rate of suicide per capita, which AFAIK has not been observed.

    3. Re:Land by LeonGeeste · · Score: 0

      Looking at aggregate statistics is misleading. I could box in the place you're sitting with an arbitrary square and claim that that plot has a population density of 500,000/sq km. It's true that a lot of Japan is uninhabited, but that's because it's harsh, mountainous, high land. Belgium and the Netherlands are mostly low, fertile, and flat as my girlfriend's chest. (How do you think they got to be called the _nether_ lands?) Japan's population is mostly squeezed along the thin strip of coastline. Fleeing that wage slavery to live in the mountains is like going to live in a poorhouse in Victorian England -- how about looking that up on Wikipedia?

      --
      Rank my idea: http://www.sinceslicedbread.com/node/531
    4. Re:Land by bheer · · Score: 1

      Er, I'd still be a bit sceptical of this. Indian and Chinese urban agglomerations are pretty dense too but have low suicide rates (the suicide and attempted suicide counts have risen sharply in India over the last 10-15 years but are still quite low). So density could be a factor but it's probably not the only factor. I'd also look into what kind of family networks suicide victims had, etc.

    5. Re:Land by ptlis · · Score: 1

      Check out these WHO statistics, posted by earlier on in this discussion:

      Belgium has a population density of 339 p/km^2 and a suicide rate of 29.4 (males) 10.7 (females) per 100k (I assume deaths).

      Japan has a population density of 337 p/km^2 and a suicide rate of 36.5 (males) 14.1 (females) per 100k (I assume deaths).

      The Netherlands is has a significantly lower relative suicide rate though. I'm not agreeing with the gp but there does at least with the above examples appear to be correlation, if not causation.

      --
      There's mischief and malarkies but no queers or yids or darkies within this bastard's carnival, this vicious cabaret.
    6. Re:Land by LeonGeeste · · Score: 0

      Okay, first, to clarify, I agree this isn't the only factor, and never said it was, just that it's the major one. And I don't think you're understanding the point, no offense. Yes, Indian and Chinese population centers are dense, BUT they still have the option of leaving for better land within their country. Thus, the fact that they are in dense population centers means that they *prefer* it to the alternatives. In Japan, there is no real alternative because the other land within the country is uninhabitable. It's the *option* of moving to the other space, not the current density distribution, that indicates propensity to suicide.

      --
      Rank my idea: http://www.sinceslicedbread.com/node/531
    7. Re:Land by rusc08 · · Score: 1

      Maybe environmental stress or culture in rapid change? The Inuit of Nunavut have a suicide rate of 78/100k but a population density of 0.01/km2. I think I'd want to look at cultural groups around the world for comparisons.

    8. Re:Land by Otter · · Score: 1
      Not that I'm endorsing the population density - suicide link but these statistics are mostly showing the weakness of relying on mean averages.

      Japan has several mountain ranges and a large, frozen, almost entirely rural island, and a second entirely rural one. Comparing it to the much more homogenous Belgium by dividing population by total area completely distorts how the median Japanese lives.

    9. Re:Land by gmhowell · · Score: 1

      My father was a psych major in college. He always likes to talk about this study. He also seems to think Malthus was the only economist worth a damn. Go figure:)

      But, the interesting thing is that the rats will destroy each other not until they get to an acceptible population level, but will keep going and going until there really isn't enough to sustain the population.

      --
      Jesus was all right but his disciples were thick and ordinary. -John Lennon
    10. Re:Land by jnik · · Score: 1
      According to this Belgium

      I think that you should restrict that sort of remark to something artistic.

    11. Re:Land by Aokubidaikon · · Score: 0

      Total bullshit.
      You obviously have never traveled outside of Tokyo.
      Sure, Tokyo and Osaka are pretty dense, but so are Manhattan and London. However most folks in Japan live in the countryside and let me tell you that it's very spacious.

    12. Re:Land by webrunner · · Score: 1

      Arguments like this just bother me.

      someone syas "X causes suicides!" and then someone else says "No! Y Causes suicides!"

      The fact is there's a large number of reasons that someone may commit suicide. Japan just happens to have a lot of them (pressure, pop density, honour,etc.)

      --
      ADVENTURERS! - ANTIHERO FOR HIRE - CARDMASTER CONFLICT
    13. Re:Land by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      In Japan, there is no real alternative because the other land within the country is uninhabitable.
      Are you mixing up Japan and Egypt or something?
  19. The problem with Internet Recluses by rolfwind · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Is that they never get out - see the sun or get excercise. 30 minutes a day wards off all types of ailments, including depression (when was the last time a psychologist prescribed this?)

    I heard in China that they have mandatory exercise (in some parts, like around 20 minutes a day) throughout the day, including outdoor community facilities which people are encourage to use. I wonder how Japan, especially Tokyo, is in this regard - especially office workers.

    1. Re:The problem with Internet Recluses by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Actually, I have heard of psychologists recommending exercise in the less severe cases of depressions. But at the same time it's not fair to lump all forms of depression into just being anti-social and lazy. Depression is a real diesease with real symptoms and real problems. It can be caused by chemical imbalances and simply saying "got out and exercise" is very narrow minded. There is research that shows a symptom of depression is pulling away from society and being "anti-social."


      People with depression shouldn't feel like they are somehow inferior because they have a legitimate medical problem. If you feel depressed or think you are, go talk to a doctor. It's just as serious as an infection or any other medical aliment. Don't let yourself suffer just because someone else thinks you should just "snap out of it" with a little exercise and fresh air.

    2. Re:The problem with Internet Recluses by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      I heard in China that they have mandatory exercise (in some parts, like around 20 minutes a day) throughout the day, including outdoor community facilities which people are encourage to use. I wonder how Japan, especially Tokyo, is in this regard - especially office workers.

      There is outdoor exercise equipment available in China to use for free, but it isn't mandatory. Some businesses (eg. bars and restaurants) like to have their staff run around the block before busy hours, but that's part of a team-building kind of thing. There's a good point hidden in there about the exercise being outdoor -- the sunlight's a nice thing, and I hadn't thought about that.

      It's perhaps worth pointing out that attitudes about suicide under different cultures can be shockingly different. The Western viewpoint has been perhaps influenced by some religious ideas that it's a sin. This isn't the case in mainland China nor Taiwan. Someone who has attempted suicide won't necessarily be thought of or treated in a negative way even when things are settled down, and traditionally and sometimes even now, relationships are brought back together when either the guy or the girl does it to show they're having a rough time after a breakup. In a roundabout way, it has something about a girl traditionally considering some relationship criteria more important than the love she currently feels, and an expectation that things will grow - trying to make the best of things along the way. Perhaps the easiest way to find out about this would be to ask a colleague who has grown up in Taiwan.
    3. Re:The problem with Internet Recluses by rolfwind · · Score: 1
      But at the same time it's not fair to lump all forms of depression into just being anti-social and lazy.


      That's not what I'm said at all. I know from myself when I'm feeling depressed, it's usually because I've been cooped up too long. The last time was when I had a leg brace on and thus couldn't get exercise - I felt sicker because of the brace.

      I also knew a colleague who became very rich and insisted on retiring around 50, from all his work, to live like a stereotypical senior citizen retiree - meaning sitting at home watching TV, waiting to die - his own words - all day because, of course, that was the way to live the good life for "someone who made it."

      Within 6 months, his hair grayed, he gained 50 pounds, and looked 20 years older. Fuck, he even walked like an old man with a slight hunch in his posture. All this from a guy who loved his work and looked 40 y/o previously. (He's now working again and happier.)

      Attitude means a shitload.

      You'll also find that suicide is more common among people who live in dark/rainy areas and people who are less active. There's a strong correlation there.

      http://www.joplinglobe.com/story.php?story_id=2261 66&c=105

      Of course, it's not all cases (let's not go Tom Cruise here), but a lot more than one thinks.
    4. Re:The problem with Internet Recluses by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The Japanese are crazy, in at least one way, about fitness. If you ever go there you can see even office workers, their bosses included, doing calisthenics (I'm not sure I have that right) before work. Pretty cool.

      I doubt that the mood lift offered by 30 minutes of exercise a day is enough to help someone on the edge of suicide. Perhaps it just might help for awhile after the exercise, but all it takes is one spike of "I hate my life" to make a suicide.

      Moreover, as several slashdotters have noted already, the culture is different and many Japanese suicides are not related to depression (love/honor suicides).

    5. Re:The problem with Internet Recluses by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Is that they never get out - see the sun or get excercise. 30 minutes a day wards off all types of ailments, including depression (when was the last time a psychologist prescribed this?)

      That is one of the FIRST things every psych I've been to has prescribed. It also just plain doesn't work for many people.

    6. Re:The problem with Internet Recluses by SirSlud · · Score: 2, Insightful

      > Is that they never get out - see the sun or get excercise. 30 minutes a day wards off all types of ailments, including depression (when was the last time a psychologist prescribed this?)

      Why, oh why, must people take one or two people from their life and form an opinion based on anecdotal evidence on a planet with 6 billion folks. Trust me, excercise and sun does not cure a depressed person. Not leaving the house and not talking to people will help you become drepessed, but sun and fitness sure as hell aint the cure for the vast majority of people who suffer from depression.

      Sheesh.

      --
      "Old man yells at systemd"
    7. Re:The problem with Internet Recluses by m0u5y · · Score: 1

      ah yes, the japanese fanatics who live with their parents, never get out of the house, and stalk people online. i saw a thing on the local saijo news a while back. but they rather have them commit suicide than talk back to their parents. we had a couple people commit suicide in the dorm, but if you had seen it you would have understood.

    8. Re:The problem with Internet Recluses by AlterTick · · Score: 3, Insightful
      I know from myself when I'm feeling depressed, it's usually because I've been cooped up too long...Attitude means a shitload... suicide is more common among people who live in dark/rainy areas and people who are less active... Of course, it's not all cases (let's not go Tom Cruise here), but a lot more than one thinks.

      But you see, it doesn't necessarilly go both ways. Lack of activity can aggravate or cause depression, but that does not mean that depression can be cured by activity and sunshine. "More than one thinks?" I don't think so. The notion that one need only get some exercise and "cheer up" is age-old and quite pervasive. It's taken decades to get people to understand that dealing with clinical depression isn't simply a matter of putting on a happy face and taking a walk in the sun. Not to cast aspersions, but the problem is people like you, who've never had to deal with real depression. Just about everyone experiences depression at one time or another, but the vast majority of people only need a little activity, a little more sleep, a change in environment, etc. to fix it. Real clinical depression, the kind that is considered a problem is effectively defined by the fact that fighting it is not simply a matter of getting some exercise and sunshine. Yeah, sure, most people are cured by a walk on the beach, but none of them are the kind of people who're suicidal.

      --
      Conclusion: the Empire squashes the Federation like a bug. Accept it.
    9. Re:The problem with Internet Recluses by rolfwind · · Score: 1
      Not to cast aspersions, but the problem is people like you, who've never had to deal with real depression.


      Uh, now you are a telepath? I'm done with this discussion - you are deliberately taking everything I type out of context and putting words in my mouth.
    10. Re:The problem with Internet Recluses by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Not leaving the house and not talking to people will help you become drepessed, but sun and fitness sure as hell aint the cure for the vast majority of people who suffer from depression.


      You're a research scientist, right?

      It is well known that exercise alters various hormone levels and that getting a bit of time in the sun aids in the absorption of certain vitamins, so I like how you dismissed this out of hand.

      So quantify "vast majority" or shut your mouth. What? You have no numbers except from studies run by pharmaceutical firms who have a panacea for everything?
    11. Re:The problem with Internet Recluses by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'm halfway trying to decide if you are an idiot or a troll for that ad hom attack post.

      From wiki's article on depression:
      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clinical_depression#E xercise

      "Exercise

      It is widely believed that physical activity and exercise helps depressive patients and promotes quicker and better relief from depression. It is also thought to help antidepressants and psychotherapy to work better and faster. It can be difficult to find the motivation to exercise if the depression is severe, but sufferers should be encouraged to take part in some form of regularly-scheduled physical activity if possible. A workout need not be strenuous; many find walking, for example, to be of great help. Exercise produces higher levels of chemicals in the brain, notably dopamine, serotonin, and norepinephrine. In general this leads to improvements in mood, which is effective in countering depression."

    12. Re:The problem with Internet Recluses by AlterTick · · Score: 1
      you are deliberately taking everything I type out of context and putting words in my mouth.

      I have only your words to go by. Did you not say the following?:

      I know from myself when I'm feeling depressed, it's usually because I've been cooped up too long

      "People like you" is based solely upon that comment. I put no words in your mouth. I'm not sure how additional context could change the meaning of that statement. That's not clinical depression. That's normal depression. Sorry you took it personally when I pointed out that you, like most people, are apparently fortunate enough to not suffer from clinical depression.

      --
      Conclusion: the Empire squashes the Federation like a bug. Accept it.
    13. Re:The problem with Internet Recluses by AlterTick · · Score: 1
      I'm halfway trying to decide if you are an idiot or a troll for that ad hom attack post.

      Sorry you think that pointing out that one person's anecdotal experience with normal depression doesn't apply to clinical depression is ad hominem attack.

      --
      Conclusion: the Empire squashes the Federation like a bug. Accept it.
  20. Re:Monthly Fee? by PunkOfLinux · · Score: 1

    I think they would charge per-attempt.

  21. They Obviously by Blazeix · · Score: 2, Funny

    Obviously, All the japanese are infected with Toxoplasma!

    1. Re:They Obviously by Tekkanano · · Score: 0

      Ohh, those things are making me wanna commit suicide too, lol!

  22. Japan's suicide factors by hunterkll · · Score: 2, Insightful

    one of the big factors in japanese suicides is the competitiveness and pressure placed on the students in the schooling system.

  23. Kent Brockman says: by Blazeix · · Score: 0

    I, for one, welcome our technologically superior yet suicidal Overlords!

    1. Re:Kent Brockman says: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Just stop posting. You're terribly unfunny.

      What would even possess you to write that? Shut the fuck up.

    2. Re:Kent Brockman says: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hey, isn't this type of comment supposed to be a mandatory +5 Funny? I could have sworn I'd read that in the Terms of Use here somewhere.

  24. OK on the count of 3 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    1 ... 2 ... 3 ...
    *watch webcam as everyone commits suicide*
    OMG they actually did it .. LOL l0s3rz

  25. Japan and Suicide by SinGunner · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Having lived here awhile now, the idea of suicide in Japan is completely different from what it was in America. There are a couple things you have to keep in mind:

    A) Mental illness is heavily stigmatized
    B) Suicide is legal and only vaguely stigmatized

    Oh, and if you kill yourself by jumping in front of a train (I don't know how many times I've sat on a train where we couldn't move until they cleaned it off), your family has to pay Japan Railways for the cost of repairs/cleaning. So, if you're crazy and hate your family and work 70 hours a week, suicide doesn't seem that bad, really. Nobody seems to care that much about it either. People always laugh and joke when the train comes to an abrupt stop.

    Internet suicide is old news here. Just like your silly "cellular phones" and "computers". Telepathic communication is the new thing.

    1. Re:Japan and Suicide by GigsVT · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Suicide is legal and only vaguely stigmatized

      You are implying suicide is illegal in the US. This is a common misconception.

      --
      I've had enough abrasive sigs. Kittens are cute and fuzzy.
    2. Re:Japan and Suicide by dtfinch · · Score: 1

      What would they do if suicide wasn't legal?

    3. Re:Japan and Suicide by SinGunner · · Score: 1
      You are implying suicide is illegal in the US. This is a common misconception. http://www.straightdope.com/columns/040326.html

      From TFA you quoted:

      In the U.S. suicide has never been treated as a crime nor punished by property forfeiture or ignominious burial. (Some states listed it on the books as a felony but imposed no penalty.) Curiously, as of 1963, six states still considered attempted suicide a crime--North and South Dakota, Washington, New Jersey, Nevada, and Oklahoma. Of course they didn't take matters as seriously as the Roman emperor Hadrian, who in 117 AD declared attempted suicide by soldiers a form of desertion and made it--no joke this time--a capital offense.

      I don't mean to be rude, but really, this was just stupid.

    4. Re:Japan and Suicide by roman_mir · · Score: 1

      If they catch you in the act?

      They'd keep you alive forever!

    5. Re:Japan and Suicide by asdfghjklqwertyuiop · · Score: 3, Funny


        What would they do if suicide wasn't legal?

      They'd keep you alive forever!


      A life sentence?

    6. Re:Japan and Suicide by SinGunner · · Score: 1

      Given the stigma attached to illegal acts in Japan, I'd say they wouldn't commit suicide. It's a pretty odd society. I mean, the people who actually commit crimes are largely yakuza, and why the hell would they kill themselves?

    7. Re:Japan and Suicide by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I disagree. It's all about the attitudes at the time--the idea wasn't to help the person out, or to discourage suicide per se, but to punish the individual for attempting to desert his post and duty. The fact that he was attempting to do so through suicide rather than flight was irrelevant.

    8. Re:Japan and Suicide by darkov · · Score: 1

      Telepathic communication is the new thing.

      Ha! I just trolled your brain.

    9. Re:Japan and Suicide by identity0 · · Score: 2, Informative

      Having lived in Japan, and having family that's Japanese, I would have to dispute your second assertion. While it's true that suicide is more 'accepted' than in the west, it carries a somewhat heavy stigma in Japan.

      In Japanese history, many people commited suicide for one reason or another, but mostly it was to escape shame and dishonor after having been disgraced. A general who had lost an important battle for his lord, a woman who had been raped, or a samurai who had disgraced his master would be expected to commit suicide if he/she could not handle the shame of other's judgements of them. A famous ghost story tells of a maidservant who killed herself by throwing herself down a well after she broke some of her master's favorite chinaware.

      Basically, suicide still carries with it a connotation of 'having fucked up', or 'running away from judgement', so people might be ashamed to admit that one of their family members commited suicide. Of course, there are cases where it's seen as more noble to kill yourself than live - particularly when there is a precieved injustice against you, or you did not cause the bad event that led you to someone having to commit suicide. If you kill yourself to avoid capture in battle, that is seen as more honorable than being captured.

      Now, the kamikaze are an exception, they're not seen as commting suicide, more like having gone on a suicide mission from which there was no turning back. I think they're still called 'special attack squadrons' over there.

      But yeah, your first assertion is correct, the Japanese attitude on mental illness and homelessness is akin to America in the '50s.

    10. Re:Japan and Suicide by GigsVT · · Score: 1

      What part of In the U.S. suicide has never been treated as a crime nor punished by property forfeiture or ignominious burial. didn't you get?

      --
      I've had enough abrasive sigs. Kittens are cute and fuzzy.
    11. Re:Japan and Suicide by Gudlyf · · Score: 1

      With so many people jumping in front of trains in Japan, I'd have to think the train engineers are prone to suicide from seening the train plow through a body every week, and at their hands.

      --
      Trolls lurk everywhere. Mod them down.
    12. Re:Japan and Suicide by SinGunner · · Score: 1

      the part where it says that suicide is a "crime" in 6 states. you can smoke weed in vancouver in the streets, but it's still a crime. the irony is that i would love you to move to japan to kill yourself legally and quit bugging me, but your closer proximity would likely be physically painful.

    13. Re:Japan and Suicide by SinGunner · · Score: 1
      sigh.

      you seem to not really know what stigma means. it's like you read it in a dictionary and just went off the definition, hoping you got it right. you're saying that there is a stigma associated with suicide due to the fact that the person is admitting they've "fucked up". that means that the suicide itself isn't actually negative, the "fucking up" is negative. therefore, the stigma would be on the "fucking up". if a stigma was attached to suicide, the act itself would have the negativity, not the cause of the act.

      i finally find a job in japan where i don't teach english, and here i am having to do it anyways.

    14. Re:Japan and Suicide by SinGunner · · Score: 1

      i don't recall exactly, but i think they get 2 months paid absence and mandatory counseling (despite the stigmas of counseling). it's like if the police shoot someone in america, they're required to take a break.

    15. Re:Japan and Suicide by identity0 · · Score: 1

      No, that is correct, there is a stigma attached to suicide in Japan based on the association of suicide with shameful acts. It is automatically assumed that a suicide was because the person couldn't handle the pressures of life or shame about something.

      It is similar to the stigma attached to killing in western(and eastern) society; if you tell someone that a person had killed someone, they would automatically assume the worst, until you clarify that it was self defense, or as a soldier, etc. Just because killing people in those circumstances is considered okay does not mean there is no stigma against killing people in western society. The concept of suicide in Japanese society is similar - it's sometimes seen as okay, but not in ordinary circumstances.

    16. Re:Japan and Suicide by GigsVT · · Score: 1

      the part where it says that suicide is a "crime" in 6 states

      Was a crime, repealed in the 1960s.

      --
      I've had enough abrasive sigs. Kittens are cute and fuzzy.
  26. Your hunches are worthless by Sleet01 · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Japanese are, on average, in better shape and longer-lived than Americans - and that goes for teens and young adults as well. Before worrying about Japan's high suicide rate, perhaps you should worry about this: in addition to a suicide rate of 12 in 100,000 persons (most recently measured in 1997), America also has a death by _homicide_ rate of 7 in 100,000. By comparison, Japan's rate is only 0.6 in 100,000.

    There's more: American servicemen are constantly raping, murdering, and accidentally running over Japanese citizens, but we hardly ever hear about that.

    So what's worse? The country where a higher percentage of people take their own lives because they can't deal with what the world around them has become, or the country where one in 14,000 people dies at the hand of one of his or her countrymen and which exports rapists and killers?

    You do the math.

    --
    -- Let him who is without spelling error ignite the first flame --
    1. Re:Your hunches are worthless by amliebsch · · Score: 3, Informative
      How did I know somebody would turn this story into an opportunity for hate-America propoganda?

      You do the math.

      Very well. With a 2005 suicide rate of 91(!) per 100,000 (and the U.S's falling to just over 10, according the WHO), that means that the Japanese suicide rate alone is still over five times the U.S suicide and homicide rates combined. Surely that must be cause for some concern. (Whether one country is "better" than another is not relevant to this topic, just an irrelevant troll you brought up.)

      --
      If you don't know where you are going, you will wind up somewhere else.
    2. Re:Your hunches are worthless by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

      ne of the most controversial aspects of World War II history, in relation to the present-day world, is the Rape of Nanking in 1937 when the Japanese army was moving through China and attacked the city of Nanking (sometimes spelled Nanjing).

      This all arose as a result of Japan's invasion of Manchuria and its eventual attack on China proper. This is where there are two terms involved as to when WWII actually started. For the U.S. , WWII started on December 7, 1941 with the Japanese bombing of Pearl Harbor. The war lasted around four years, ending in 1945. However, from the Japanese viewpoint, the war was really fifteen years long and is referred to as "The Fifteen Years War" since some Japanese date the war as starting with the invasion of China, the fight against the U.S. not taking place for over a decade.

      There was a lead-up in the public to the war as there is with virtually any war and the society waging it. According to the book The Imperial Screen: Japanese Flm Culture in the Fifteen Years' War 1931-1945, 2003:

      "The prelude, lasting several months, featured a montage of 'Chinese-inspired incidents' reported by the newspapers in headlings that quivered with indignation. The pattern was to last throughout the thirties, each incident being presented as 'unprovoked' and therefore inexplicable in terms of rational, historical causes."

      Censorship, both government inspired and individual-inspired, became important both in film and in newspaper reporting. Even books were used to fan the feelings in Japan. For example, in 1938 there were 38 books attacking the Jewish presence in Japan which was quite interesting since, for all practical purposes, there were no Jews in Japan.

      Even the language became controlled which a reaction set in to the use of foreign words in the language and English was labeled "the enemy language." The people were being put into a mind-set of war by their government and by the media. This becomes important when considering why some people consider that the Japanese have not sufficiently apologized for the Nanking massacre and other actions. In effect, the population was being given the mind-set that it was the Japanese who were being attacked and provoked by the Chinese, not the other way around, and why apologize for something you didn't actually start?

      "During the China incident, the Japanese popular imagination tended to conceive of the Chinese as hostile, faceless masses, as columns of refugees stolidly trudging roads to nowhere, or as clumps of lifeless flesh littering trenches and riverbeds."

      If you dehumanize a group of people then it becomes easier to justify anything that you end up doing to them.

      According to the book Japan in the 21st Century: Environment, Economy, and Society (2005):

      "It is widely accepted among scholars that after the sudden collapse of the Chinese defense of Nanjing in December, 1937, rampaging Japanese soldiers executed thousands of prisoners of war, civilians as well as men suspected of being soldiers, and burned the homes of Chinese. According to some, as many as 300,000 were killed in Nanjing; Japanese accounts vary from several thousand to 200,000 dead, while some Japanese politicians deny that the massacre ever took place. The Tokyo War Crimes tribunal concluded that more than 140,000 people were killed...making it one of the worst atrocities committed by Japanese forces before and during World War II."

      There are some Japanese, like the paragraph above notes, that simply deny that the massacre ever took place, much as some people are denying that the Holocaust ever took place, despite all the spoken, written and photographic evidence to the contrary. Even though over sixty years have passed since the events the feelings are still quite strong in China over what happened. That hurts Chinese-Japanese political relationships. Another thing that is a sticking point is when Japanese politicians visit war memorials to Japanese dead.

      This all stems from the original invasion of China by Japan whe

    3. Re:Your hunches are worthless by amliebsch · · Score: 1

      In addition to the previous points I raised, I did some more checking, and the 2004 intentional homicide rate for the United States is actually 5.5, not 7.

      --
      If you don't know where you are going, you will wind up somewhere else.
    4. Re:Your hunches are worthless by Sleet01 · · Score: 1

      I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that your exclamation point is meant to indicate surprise and shock, and not a factorial... but that's all the leeway I'll give you.

      If you bothered to read the article, you would see that the 91 was the *total* number of people who participated in web-based suicide pacts, not the overall suicide rate of the country... unless you are poorly-informed enough to believe that the total population *of* Japan is 100,000. While Japan's suicide rate is high at around 24 per 100,000 (found some more recent data), I'm certain more would be made of a 1 in 10,000 rate.

      My comment regarding which is worse was in specific reference to the previous poster's question about this 'tragic issue'; I simply feel that our own citizens' uncivilized treatment of both our own people, as well as those of other countries, should be of more immediate concern.

      I guess my comment to *you* would be, 'you do the reading.'

      --
      -- Let him who is without spelling error ignite the first flame --
    5. Re:Your hunches are worthless by Sleet01 · · Score: 0

      That's fine; I stated I used the 1997 data, but I erred in my choice of present, rather than past, tense. That doesn't change the fact that *I* raised, the fact that our country sees around ten times more people killed by their neighbors, their friends, their classmates, or their lovers.

      Just, y'know, by way of comparison.

      --
      -- Let him who is without spelling error ignite the first flame --
    6. Re:Your hunches are worthless by pete-classic · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Why would more be made of a 1 in 10,000 rate than a 2.4 in 10,000 rate?

      -Peter

    7. Re:Your hunches are worthless by amliebsch · · Score: 1

      You're right, my mistake. I confused the 91 figure with the "per 100,000" figure, though, to be fair, that's still well above the combined U.S. rates. More to the point, it is a logical fallacy that we must ignore all others' problems until we have solved all of our own, and frankly your America-bashing is not relevant to this topic, grautuitous, and a troll.

      --
      If you don't know where you are going, you will wind up somewhere else.
    8. Re:Your hunches are worthless by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Surely that must be cause for some concern

      go shove your opinon in someone else's happy-shiney face.

      People have every right to commit suicide! It's no more a 'tragedy' when a lonely miserable pathetic mopey person decides to off themselves than it's a 'tragedy' when someone who's lead a full life is allowed to expire naturally, from old age.

      because the people most mired in depression can off themselves in japan, there are a lot fewer people whining about how much life sucks. it's not like the population in japan is diminishing, if it was then maybe suicide would be a problem, but just get over it the only two things in life that are sure is that you'll die, and that you'll pay taxes. what point is there in 'forcing' someone to 'live' and empty shell of a life?

      Suidcide keeps people from feeling truly trapped, because afterall if the worst happens you can always just commit seppuku.

      As long as it's the people who are really really messed up who kill themselves then it's benenficial to society to allow it.

    9. Re:Your hunches are worthless by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Can someone please mod the parent as TROLL? Where is the 'Asshole' rating when you need it?

    10. Re:Your hunches are worthless by amliebsch · · Score: 1
      it's not like the population in japan is diminishing

      You might want to check that assumption: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/4552010.st m

      --
      If you don't know where you are going, you will wind up somewhere else.
    11. Re:Your hunches are worthless by spooje · · Score: 1

      When did a US service man accidently run over someone? You're thinking of South Korea. If it's so bad why do most Japanese still like Americans and appreciate the fact that the military is here?

      --
      Tea and kung-fu. Life is good. Rising Phoenix
    12. Re:Your hunches are worthless by dangitman · · Score: 1

      What makes you assume that suicidees are lonely, miserable and mopey? Many suicidees actually have many friends, and are very financially and socially successful. There are millions of reasons for suicide. Your sterotyping does not help.

      --
      ... and then they built the supercollider.
    13. Re:Your hunches are worthless by PaternityTest · · Score: 1

      According to this link. [url]http://www.atimes.com/atimes/Japan/FG28Dh01.h tml%5B/url%5D 27 out of every 100,000 Japanese are taking thier lives. Still higher than the U.S Murder/Suicide rate. So much for your Utopia. "Based on provisional data for 2003, Japanese male and female suicide rates per 100,000 people are now roughly 40.2 for men and 14.9 for women, approaching levels normally witnessed in countries suffering severe economic hardships such as Russia, Latvia or Lithuania."

    14. Re:Your hunches are worthless by kneppercr · · Score: 1

      As a U.S. Sailor I take quite a bit of offense to your claim that the U.S. exports rapists and killers. I would like to see your evidence that American service members have a higher concentration of rapists and killers (besides the obvious fact that you kill people in a war) than American civilians. I don't ever recall attending the "Rape and Pillage" briefing.

    15. Re:Your hunches are worthless by JohnFluxx · · Score: 1

      Sounds too similar to modern day news about iraq and muslims.

    16. Re:Your hunches are worthless by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, dropping firesticks on wooden cities is much more human.

  27. There's more to it than that... by Garwulf · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Certainly I think you raise a very good point, but there is a fundamental difference between east and west that nobody so far has touched upon, and it is important. We have a large stigma against suicide - in Japan that doesn't really exist, from what I understand. And there is a reason for that difference.

    Put simply, Western spirituality is about how human beings relate to a divine being (God, Allah, etc.), but there is an assumption that human beings are not themselves divine. Eastern spirituality is about understanding how human beings are divine - they have part of the divine in them. So, ending your life in Western spirituality is a source of judgement and damnation at the hands of the divine, whereas ending your life in Eastern spirituality is in part setting the divine part of you free - hence, no ill spiritual aftereffects, and no stigma.

    --
    Robert B. Marks
    Author, Demonsbane in Diablo Archive
    1. Re:There's more to it than that... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Umm you clearly don't know what the hell you are talking about.

      Suicide in Eastern religions does not free your divine being, it condmens you to a painful next life/existence. If you don't understand this, then try reading before you spout off stupid ethnocentric generalizations about something you obviously know nothing about.

    2. Re:There's more to it than that... by Comatose51 · · Score: 1
      Unlikely. Since Japan is the biggest Buddhist country in the world, it's likely that they also believe that suicide will earn a ton of negative karma. That said, I really doubt religious believes are what drives that the difference. Rather, the difference is cultural. Eastern Asian countries have a collectivistic culture whereas Western countries have an individualistic culture. The individual is not valued as much and certainly never above the good of the group. Individuals try to contributed to the good of the group and is thus rewarded. Individual accomplishments in themselves are not as valued as it is in the West. Certainly, being a drag on the group is worse.

      I'm coming from a Chinese point of view. Culturally, Japan and China probably have more common than with the West given their history (however divisive it may have been in the past). So I'm guessing that it works similarly in Japan as well. In my own family, we've had an older member of our extended family commit suicide because she was old, lonely, and don't want to be a burden to her family any more.

      --
      EvilCON - Made Famous by /.
    3. Re:There's more to it than that... by McFadden · · Score: 1
      With respect, I'm glad your comments were modded "interesting" and not "insightful".

      Have you ever lived in Japan? I've read several times in this discussion, people stating that there is little stigma attached to suicide in Japan. Sorry, but this is utter bullshit.

      I live in Japan and have first-hand experience of dealing with the aftermath of a suicide. In that particular case, the guy who sadly ended his life was a restaurant owner. The real estate company that owned the rental property where he had his restaurant threatened to sue the bereaved family, because it was considered likely that if word of the suicide got out, they would be unable to rent the space again for the duration of the life of the building. No one would go near it, even at a rock-bottom price. Such is the stigma of suicide here.

      The main reason for the big increase in suicide in recent years has nothing to do with stigma or spiritual values. Purely and simply it's come about because Japan has been going through a fairly significant cultural shift from a closed, insular society, to an open, more westernised lifestyle. This has caused significant emotional upheaval, particularly amongst the older generations who are losing their sense of identity. Cultural standards, such as the traditional "job for life" are being withdrawn as Japanese companies are forced to shed their bloated workforces and streamline in order to compete globally.

      This is not the whole picture, as the reasons for Japan's suicide rate are complex and difficult to list as simple points, but lack of stigma has nothing to do with it. Just because you saw a bunch of "Hollywood Samurai" feel no qualms about disembowelling themselves in a certain Tom Cruise movie, don't assume it's socially acceptable to kill yourself.

  28. Where is the world going? by bogaboga · · Score: 5, Insightful
    Having been to Japan, I found a society that is near perfect...trains on time, organized streets, and very courteous folks. Everyone seemed to be busy with something. This masked what I guess I obviously failed to see.

    Then I visited East Africa where I found a priviledged few among a sea of poverty and hopelessness. But what struck me is the ease the Africans took life as. They seemed to be happy, always thinking that the following day would be a better one. They even shared the little they had, something very rare in a major city in the USA for example.

    This makes me wonder....What is it that we in the west miss out? Why is it that suicide rates in the so-called first world are significantly higher than those in the third world? Can we still call ourselves developed? I doubt.

    Where is the world going?

    1. Re:Where is the world going? by zephc · · Score: 1

      two words, man: Hakuna Matata

      --
      "I would say that 99 per cent of what my father has written about his own life is false." - L. Ron Hubbard Jr.
    2. Re:Where is the world going? by pilkul · · Score: 5, Interesting
      I once read that in the Nazi death camps, suicide was very rare, but in the month after the camps were liberated a large number of survivors took their lives.

      What I mean to say is that suicide is an act undertaken by those who are physically in good shape but psychologically and philosophically shattered. When you're starving, you think only of getting the next bite of food, and the thought of killing yourself is remote. When you have the time and mental capacity to ponder nihilism, that's when you take action. I think that would explain the third-world/first-world difference; there is not more misery in the first world, but the misery that exists is more conductive to suicide.

    3. Re:Where is the world going? by wes33 · · Score: 1

      I understand that the best gauge of happiness is relative standing with one's peers: basically, you're happy if you can believe (without too much strain) that you are doing a little better than your neighbors. This scale is independent of absolute wealth but it is sensitive to the range of possibilities one's sees for one's life (or the range of lives that one sees others apparently not too different than oneself living).

      So, the more visible models of others doing better, the more miserable we tend to become. This might be a special problem in wealth oriented or success oriented societies, where inter-personal comparisons are almost mandatory and are "mechanized" (e.g. SATs, MATs, performance indicators, etc.).

    4. Re:Where is the world going? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ever read the unibomber manifesto?

    5. Re:Where is the world going? by slavik1337 · · Score: 1

      In the words of one russian stand up comic is that things can only get better. They are so bad that they can't get worse, only better. I find this very true about the Africa that is below the poverty line.

      --
      just my 2 bytes
    6. Re:Where is the world going? by incom · · Score: 1

      Facing your own mortality, almost dying against your will, innoculates against suicidal tendencies pretty well. It forces you to develope a sense of fighting for survival.

      --
      True genius is grasping a situation like a peice of fruit, and peircing it just right so that it drains dry.
    7. Re:Where is the world going? by voteforkerry78 · · Score: 0

      The answer, to me, seems obvious. Most people in Africa live shitty lives. They've no where to go but up, not that its easy to get there. Most people in America live (comparitively) nice lives. They've got more room below them than above them (if you will, for a moment, visualize the "happiness spectrum"). So we probably have less hope for a "better tomorrow." Also, I'm pretty sure there isn't much pressure to succeed in Poor Random East African Village. In America (and Japan), success is more readily available, and thus the pressure to achieve it is higher because you look incompetent if you don't succeed. In Africa, to use a generalization, you have almost no chance of succeeding anyway. For purposes of this post, success/points on the happiness spectrum = making more than a living wage and not having a "stronger" mental disorder than ADD (points increase as wages rise and mental disorders fall).

    8. Re:Where is the world going? by rubycodez · · Score: 4, Insightful

      probably no one is tracking east african suicides, for one. East african mortality rate greater than one in ten, life expectency just over 30 years, plagues running rampant - does cause of death even get noticed or recorded there for the majority?

    9. Re:Where is the world going? by bogaboga · · Score: 1
      For your information, much of those Africans who live below the poverty line are happy. Life is surely hard but they are not sitting there crying out for a helping hand. They somehow carry on.

      That is why most westerners fail to comprehend why such poor people can be happy at all. I know because I lived with them for almost a year. The problem I see with our westernized way of life, is that we are too individualistic and pretend a lot. Our society has been structured in asuch a way that "you are on your own" once you reach 18 years. I have even heard parents demand rent from their childern once these kids reach 18 years of age! Take an example of a woman who might have a kid. In America, a baby sitter is prohibitively expensive for most folks, that one of the parents has to remain home. In all societies I visited in East Africa, a baby is a blessing and seen as such. Neighbors will freely volunteer time to spend time with the infant for free! Find that in USA!!! And even when things go wrong as they will from time to time, parents are not bent to taking the "culprit" to court like it is in America.

      I must say I was suprised too. The images beemed across our televisions protray a false image of these societies. I was amazed to find some Britons who'd decided to retire there. I was taken aback!

    10. Re:Where is the world going? by bogaboga · · Score: 1
      Do you know that the western world has the most cases of mental disorders? All these ADDs, ADHD, ASD, and all those disorders are in America. In Africa, despite all the poverty, mental disorders are unknown. The same is the case with the Chitimacha [Indian] tribe in the USA. This tribe has no known incidence in any mental health disease.

      Question to you: WHY?

    11. Re:Where is the world going? by No.+24601 · · Score: 1

      Also, I'm pretty sure there isn't much pressure to succeed in Poor Random East African Village. In America (and Japan), success is more readily available, and thus the pressure to achieve it is higher because you look incompetent if you don't succeed.

      Hence, the reason why, if for no other good reason (charity), all Westerners should at least step foot once in a Third World country before even trying to argue that "life here sucks!"

    12. Re:Where is the world going? by tylernt · · Score: 1

      "In all societies I visited in East Africa, a baby is a blessing and seen as such. Neighbors will freely volunteer time to spend time with the infant for free! Find that in USA!!!"

      Er, actually, members of my church do that for each other all the time. You just have to find the right sub-culture within the USA. ;)

      --
      DRM 'manages access' in the same way that a prison 'manages freedom'
    13. Re:Where is the world going? by Echnin · · Score: 1

      This is a good point. What I've heard about Nigeria (which is admittedly in west-Africa, but still...) is that when someone commits suicide, the family says that they "went away" or "disappeared"; apparently there's quite a bit stigma against it.

      --
      Lalala
    14. Re:Where is the world going? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I agree with the parent.

      I'd also like to submit that (young) suicide is not a common thing in any society, and perhaps many of those prone to suicide in third world countries die of disease and starvation(*) first.

      (*) Anyone that has worked with the elderly knows that there are thousands of elderly 'natural deaths' in the US that are really suicides. The person gives up the will to live and stops eating/drinking. These are not included in the suicide statistics.

    15. Re:Where is the world going? by martalli · · Score: 1

      In the first world, people have the time to pursue treatment or take disability for psychiatric illnesses and conditions, such as ADHD. In the third world, people do not have the time, money, or resources to discover their depression, schizophrenia, or ADHD.

      In the first world, treatment is low-cost, and encouraged by a more open outlook regarding psychiatric illness. Additionally, a diagnosis may lead to benefits like a longer testing time for a medical student with ADHD, or a monthly stipend for a treated schizophrenic. Add in a heaping of advertisement for medications (at least in the US) like Strattera and depression meds.

      In much of the third world, stigma still hangs over psychiatric illness. In addition, there is no money and little resources for treatment. Getting a label of depression or ADHD may very well nix your chances for a college position, where in the US it might mean that you get longer to take a test.

      I speak Kannada with my wife (Who is from around Bangalore, India). Trying to uderstand her physical symptoms in Kannada can be a confusing prposition sometimes. The literal meaning of the words can be quite bizarre compared to what she is trying to convey...for example, just consider the Englishg phrase "I'm out of shape" and you can probably think of a score more. Now consider doing the same regarding psychiatric symptoms. When people talk about pychiatric illness, they often have difficulty describing their symptoms in their own native language.

      Attempting to compare mental illness accross different cultures, which may be separated by different customs, languages, and religions is fraught with pitfalls. Before acting on or making judgements about degrees of mental illness between cultures, consdier first - how can they guarantee me that that Czech's definition of depression is the same as the Rwandan, the Tamil, the Korean, the Soliga, the Scots, etc.

      Reminds me of Mark Twain's quote regarding statistics...

    16. Re:Where is the world going? by mewsenews · · Score: 5, Interesting

      Anyone interested in the depressing aspects of liberation from a death camp should check out a book called King Rat by James Clavell. The work is semi-autobiographical as it features Changi, a POW camp run by the Japanese during WWII, where the author himself had been confined.

      When the healthy, grinning troops from the Real World showed up, the prisoners were shattered when they realized just how totally screwed up they were, and how much they had lost in their grueling struggle for existance.

      Err, veering somewhat on topic, some of the characters ended their lives in ways you'll remember. It's a fantastic book.

    17. Re:Where is the world going? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting
      I once read that in the Nazi death camps, suicide was very rare, but in the month after the camps were liberated a large number of survivors took their lives.

      I wouldn't be surprised if this were true. I had a virulent form of cancer that required a year of intensive treatment that included arduous chemotherapy and surgeries. I never really got used to it but figured that things would eventually get better.

      Knowledge of how permanent and terrible the side effects would be didn't really set in until after the treatment had ended. Some of them include perpetual physical weakness and loud ringing in my ears, as well as some hearing loss. The horror of the treatment I didn't really understand until after it was over. I often thought about suicide, even more so than I had while I was sick, although I obviously didn't carry it out. I can only theorize that I was too busy being treated to contemplate how awful my life was, and that after it ended I realized that things would never be the same.

      Still, part of me wonders whether your comment about the Nazi camps is totally true. Viktor Frankl wrote a book called "Man's Search for Meaning" about his experience. Frankl was a Jewish psychiatrist -- he had a Ph.D. -- from Vienna who the Nazis imprisoned. He observed that people within the camp tended to give up wanting to live, and that in doing so they would often succumb to malnutrition or rampant disease. Yet he saw in those who persevered a willingness to maintain a positive outlook even in the face of conditions that most of us would consider untenable. Perhaps some of those survivors were in a state similar to mine after treatment. I wonder if that's when they killed themselves, after they got out and realized their lives had been destroyed even if their bodies continued to live. I felt that way, and still often do. Maybe some of the Japanese the article describes do too. If so, I emphasize, especially given the callous comments of some of the posters in this thread.

      (Posted AC for obvious reasons.)

    18. Re:Where is the world going? by bogaboga · · Score: 1
      I should inform you that this particular tribe was followed for close to 4 decades by the so called "enlightened and educated folks". These folks were unable to trace a single case of mental illness in all those years. This was within the boundaries of the great USA.

      Third world countries beat us in one case...that is..community support. Even with death due to HIV/AIDS, those communities are very very vibrant. If this were the case in the USA for example, psychologists would have a tough job on their hands.

    19. Re:Where is the world going? by Bodhammer · · Score: 1

      There is also a positive aspect to liberation from a death camp. Try reading Man's Search For Meaning by Viktor E. Frankl.

      It is a little more positive spin on what is right with the world.

      --
      "I say we take off, nuke the site from orbit. It's the only way to be sure."
    20. Re:Where is the world going? by martalli · · Score: 1
      I found this curious, so I did a search for Chitimacha on http://www.pubmed.gov/ and received an empty result.
      The following term was not found and ignored: Chitimacha. See Details.No items found.
      Pubmed stores academic medical and psychiatric studies for the last several decades. I wonder where this information about no depression in the Chitimacha comes from. A little googling found this article http://www.theadvertiser.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article ?AID=/20051128/NEWS01/511280306/1002, which seems to paint the Chitimacha as pretty regular folks. Their tribal clinic even does depression screening.

      Please post these sources. Reading the newsletters from the Chitimacha website leads me to believe their small tribe (about ~200 accordin o the wikipedia) still has some minor crime and marital problems to report on a monthly basis. No proof of mental illness, but they don't sound like self-actualized buddhas either - just normal folks.

    21. Re:Where is the world going? by anethema · · Score: 1

      I second the sugestion to read King Rat..wonderful book.

      As is 'Shogun' by the same author since we are talking about japan. A very realistic portrait of japan at the time. Might help explain why the suicide rate is so high. Back then it was a totally normal and accepted thing to do to make up for wrongs, etc. Almost morally required to avoid shame.

      It isnt that hard to comprehend that suicide today in japan wouldnt be that 'bad' compared to shame of some life failure.

      --


      It's easier to fight for one's principles than to live up to them.
    22. Re:Where is the world going? by martalli · · Score: 1
      Where do you live? My rural Illinois community (~5k) has scores (maybe hundreds) or people on disability (=monthly stipend + free healthcare/free psychiatric care) for various problems, including psychiatric illness. Don't think its a panacea. People are often alone, apart from family help and resources, and the psychiatric care is certainly not the most personalized.

      In my wife's village, family may help, but psychiatric illness is still stigmatized. If you are unable to work, then you must depend on relatives who are not always happy about the situation. Your spouse and children will suffer, with likely no college or even high school in the cards for your children. Some families may differ...in fact, my wife's village is quite progressive - there is no dowry at all in their village, and most people have at least a high school education.

      Stigma aside, there are few psychiatrists, almost no money, and transportation costs (even in the cities) are high for the working poor and outright impoverished. India is certainly not the worst off countryin the world, but when all the chickens died in Martalli two years back, and scores of people had respiratory illnesses, did that rate a bleep in the local press (eg, the state capital)? Not a peep, and I was there when it happened.

      Its not that the press is muffled, or the public health officals uncaring, its just that they are spread thin in poor countries. Lots of things get underreported...not just mental illness. In the US, on the other hand, this would get unending play on CNN. Mental illness is practically a topic de jure for Oprah.

      I believe that you are wrong to assume that poor, agrarian societies are by nature less stressful. They are very stressful places to live, especially when food is dear, healthcare unavailable, and few jobs are to be found. I think people in America still think of rural places like the town in "Newhart". They should spend some time in the Peace Corps, or somesuch experience...

    23. Re:Where is the world going? by daemonenwind · · Score: 1

      Simple answer: We're put here to take care of each other. But modern civilization values privacy and self-indulgence so highly that, when the artifical falls away, nothing is left.

      Long answer: We in the western world invest ourselves incredibly heavily in things which do not matter. Computers, cars, homes, iPods, music and TV acts occupy our concious thought and dominate our collective self image. If you don't have a white headphone cord sticking out of your ears, you're no one, right?

      When you don't have much, you focus on things which matter more - the people who live around you, the world as-it-is. When American Idol isn't stealing your attention, you appreciate the beauty of a sunset. Daily. You take an interest in your neighbors' and friends' joys and sorrows. All this stuff has destroyed our simple senses of wonder and community - and those two are most of what makes life worth living.

      And when all the things which distract us from the truly important things fall away, we see ourselves as a shell filled with nothing. And so making an end doesn't really seem so significant.

      The answer, my friends, is to log off, tune out and shut down. Go outside, meet your neighbors, and begin to have a locally meaningful life.

    24. Re:Where is the world going? by dormant25 · · Score: 1

      Awesome post.

    25. Re:Where is the world going? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Suicide prone more likely to die earlier on of something else? And the depressed probably die easier too.

    26. Re:Where is the world going? by G-funk · · Score: 1

      I think you'll find that as in most nations, East African mortality is somewhat closer to 10 in 10.

      --
      Send lawyers, guns, and money!
    27. Re:Where is the world going? by selfdiscipline · · Score: 1

      first off, like your post.
      Second off, I think that contemplation on whether you are happy or on whether your life is good is a real factor in depression.
          I often wonder if third-world farmers who work almost all day, every day are less unhappy than us priviledged with more free time to consider our own existence and its meaning.

      --


      -------
      Incite and flee.
    28. Re:Where is the world going? by theLOUDroom · · Score: 1

      What I mean to say is that suicide is an act undertaken by those who are physically in good shape but psychologically and philosophically shattered

      That makes the assumption that a sane, healthy person could never choose to commit suicide.

      I submit that this is not true.
      Here's an example:
      Say it's WWII and I'm a spy. I have information that could cost thousands of lives if forced out of me. I'm caught behind enemy lines, and I fear I'm about to be captured. I choose to kill myself.

      Here's another one:
      I'm 70 years old. I'm in terrible pain. The doctors say I will only get worse. I'm stuck in a hospital bed for the rest of my life. I choose to end my own sufferning.

      Suicide is an interesting philisophical situation. One one hand, if you're a free man then your life should be yours to end. On the other hand, it's a safe bet that the majority of people who kill themselves were not psychologically sound and it's better for us all they they get treated.

      --
      Life is too short to proofread.
    29. Re:Where is the world going? by cold+fjord · · Score: 1

      People trapped in extremely stressful situations are often too busy surviving to notice the toll the situation takes. It isn't until after the stress is removed or changed in some way that they feel its full effects, as in Post Traumatic Stress Disorder or other stress injuries or ailments.

      People with PTSD can improve in various respects, sometimes on their own, but treatment can be very helpful too.

      There is still good you can do in the world, and good you can experience. I hope you find it. Good luck and God bless.

      --
      much of left-wing thought is a kind of playing with fire by people who don't even know that fire is hot - George Orwell
    30. Re:Where is the world going? by imipak · · Score: 1

      > Changi, a POW camp run by the Japanese during WWII,.. Changi's a famous jail in Singapore. AFAIK it's still there. http://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&q=Changi%20ja il%20Singapore&meta=

    31. Re:Where is the world going? by abdulwahid · · Score: 1

      I don't think that that is the case. I am living here in East Africa and travel to many different cities within East Africa and I can tell you that it simply isn't in the culture. I am not saying it dosen't happen but it is not commonly heard of. I think also largely deaths here are recorded.

      Comparing that to when I lived in Europe. There I knew of several people who had committed suicide and loads more who had attempted suicide. In my University it was an annual occurence for a couple of people to commit suicide.

      I think perhaps there is less social pressure on people in Africa. Life here is simple and please are pleased and satisfied with simple things.

      --
      perl -e 'print $i=pack(c5, (41*2), sqrt(7056), (unpack(c,H)-2), oct(115), 10);'
    32. Re:Where is the world going? by Mistshadow2k4 · · Score: 1

      I think you're missing something. "They even shared the little they had" is the key phrase. They have a communal society. People rely on each other emotionally there. Western culture is very lonely by comparison. How much do you rely emotionally on your neighbors? We're very, very alienated from our own culture. They're genuinely a part of their community, not just residents in it.

      --
      I dream of a better world... one in which chickens can cross roads without their motives being questioned.
    33. Re:Where is the world going? by NaCl · · Score: 1

      Why is it that suicide rates in the so-called first world are significantly higher than those in the third world?

      One word: ignorance.

      --
      I shot the sheriff
    34. Re:Where is the world going? by slavik1337 · · Score: 1

      Note that I never said that they weren't happy. The russian comic did say that there is no point in being sad. As for demanding rent. Do they demand rent from the 18 year old when they know he doesn't have a job? Also, them demanding rent is only to push the kid out so he can learn and function on his own, much like birds push their young out of the nest so they learn to fly. As for comparison to USA. I am attending a city college. If I held a job full time, I'd be ablle to pay for it and live on my own at the expense of getting enough sleep and actually being able to study (life in NYC is not cheap). Taking out a loan? Then you are almost forced t take the first employment opportunity no matter how conditions at work are. If such would happen, the quality of life in US would fall quickly as employers would seek to hire fresh grads with huge loans and pay them to barely survive. It is the same principle of why many people say that to keep slaves is more expensive than to hire someone when the employment opportunities are low. Much like in the early 20th century when a wave of european immigrants hit. As for sitting with an infant. Have you ever spent time next to a a child who is 2 or 3 years old (when they start learning to speak and ask why everything around them works the way it works)? They are fascinating to say the least, party because I am a comp sci major who has some interest in artificial intelligence. A 2 year old learns the structure of your language just by you being there for 2 years and speaking casually.

      --
      just my 2 bytes
    35. Re:Where is the world going? by rubycodez · · Score: 1

      meant to say "infant mortality" rate. There are other over half a dozen countries in Africa where it's even one in five.

  29. Hmmm.. I smell an idea by technoextreme · · Score: 1
    Suicide has become a widely discussed topic on many websites in Japan, and there is even a guidebook to the best places to kill yourself.

    Of course, they could always market the book as a haunted guide book. You know all those stories always start with someone kill themselves.
    --
    Ooo man the floppy drive is broken. No wait. The computer is just upside down.
  30. Whoa, looks like a great movie! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Is it? Any details about the movie. Do any of them hang themselves? The movie's photos don't show enough. Does it have engrish subtitles?

    1. Re:Whoa, looks like a great movie! by Endymion · · Score: 1

      * some mild spoilers *

      The deaths are all different, and easily the bloodiest thing I've seen. They definatly took a lot of tech/fx style from japanese horror.

      Yes, there's a hanging.

      The subtitles kindof... suck. But, it's easy enough to follow. It's a VERY "Japanese" movie, though, so that's not a huge problem. You need to be somewhat familiar with their culture, Shinto, how idol-pop works there, etc., or it will go right over your head.

      It took several viewings to really get it properly, but it's very on-topic for this article and the current times. I think more people should see it.

      I've heard a rumor they tried to ban/restrict the movie in japan for a while, which was hilarious - it was because they thought people would copy the movie and form their own suicide clubs. The thing is, that's a main point of the movie! It centers around a manufactured Idol-Pop band, and how people copy it without thinking.

      There's many other points to the movie, though - it works on many levels/sub-plots.

      --
      Ce n'est pas une signature automatique.
  31. Bullshit. by BJH · · Score: 5, Informative

    You just pulled that out of your ass, didn't you?

    The majority of suicides in Japan are older men, peaking at 71.1 people per 100,000 for men in the 55-59 age range. This is not particularly surprising, considering the pressures on men of that age (higher chance of being made unemployed, older parents to look after, higher rate of divorce, lower chance of promotion, etc.).

    Young girls don't even come close; the 15-19 year old female suicide rate is 5.6 per 100,000.

    Further statistics available here.

    1. Re:Bullshit. by imthesponge · · Score: 1

      What is liberal about the GP? Why do you capitalize "liberal"?

    2. Re:Bullshit. by DietEvil · · Score: 1

      For those that can't read Japanese:

      In the charts, the left columns are male, and the right columns are female.

      In the tables, the age appears on the left side, and the year of data is listed along the top. Men are listed first, then women.

    3. Re:Bullshit. by GigsVT · · Score: 1

      Blaming the imagined suicide of young girls on some imagined misogyny is typical liberal tripe. The fact that he just made it all up is very liberal too, like the example I gave, Michael Moore, who doesn't let facts get in the way his "documentary".

      --
      I've had enough abrasive sigs. Kittens are cute and fuzzy.
    4. Re:Bullshit. by damsa · · Score: 1

      I don't think misogyny in Japan is imagined. Also you have to look at suicides of young people in Japan vs young people outside of Japan. If it is a little higher in Japan than elsewhere then there is a problem that is not imagined.

  32. Emo Kids Aren't Always Suicidal. by kakashiryo · · Score: 3, Funny

    Yo, we're normal high school kids. Get over the stereotype. We may look funny or listen to weird music, but hey, wasn't that the goths a few years back when everyone poked fun at them? We're as human as you. Don't let a few rotten apples ruin the whole bunch.

    1. Re:Emo Kids Aren't Always Suicidal. by Eli+Gottlieb · · Score: 2, Interesting

      That was my very point. Emo kids don't commit suicide, but hikikomori do.

      Of course, a lot of (supposedly somewhat) knowledgable Slashdotters here say that Japanese culture has always found suicide far more acceptable than Western (ie: European-derived) culture. Apparently they've just got a higher proportion of the same number of depressed people who kill themselves.

    2. Re:Emo Kids Aren't Always Suicidal. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Emo kids are hardly human, I won't even brake for them.

    3. Re:Emo Kids Aren't Always Suicidal. by kakashiryo · · Score: 1

      What's sad was that I was being actually serious.

      Thanks /. -___-

    4. Re:Emo Kids Aren't Always Suicidal. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I just read the articles at Wikipedia on Emo music/culture, and it was amazing: I have not heard of a single band mentioned in those articles (aside of big big names everyone knows--none of which are Emo bands). I thought I had some knowledge of the variuos subcultures in this country (USA), but obviously not.

    5. Re:Emo Kids Aren't Always Suicidal. by Spaceman40 · · Score: 1

      I took it as serious - it's funny, though, being on a site full of nerds (myself included), and being made fun of for being different :)

      Ah, the wonders of stereotype.

      --
      I [may] disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.
  33. Re: Too much ice cream is a bad thing though too by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I for one welcome our CAT 5, green tea ice cream eating, and no suicide pact OVERLOADED WITH BULLSHIT....

    But why be an overlord and try to control people? I think hurting people or yourself is just wrong, being mean is just wrong unless you are evil and provoke people all the time for fun. Yeah, not nice. Sometimes people need to go off by themselves and want their space and privacy respected. The Japanese are definitely structured on that type of society. This is also a society that has Geisha's though.

    Did you slashdot guys post nasty things about the Suicide Pact crowd in Japan and make them want to kill themselves? LOL I doubt it, but you know, maybe it was easier to not live life than to live with what they were living with. If you understand that, that means you might actually be *gasp* HUMAN

  34. Re:The Internet suicide pacts should grow worldwid by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    I'm willing to do my part. Please e-mail me... I'll make a suicide pact with everyone who is interested, and I promise to kill myself each and everytime you kill yourself. Please mail me a PDF of your death certificate, and I'll do my part within an hour of receipt of your message.

  35. It had time to become like this by winphreak · · Score: 1, Informative

    Japan has always had a high risk of suicide. The movie, as well as some cultural knowledge, show that.

    The term Hari Kari is really Hara Kiri. That's when a samurai or warrior would be dishonored in his actions, and would rather kill himself than bow down to a new ruling party or to shame.
    Then, in the 1800s, when Japan moved for industrialisation, objective sucess became key. Most Japanese never switch careers.Success became the new standard. Someone who had great wealth or power would commit suicide over an incident that would bring them down.
    Combine all this with a new, semi-anonymous network, and you can have suicide parties. Just like in California about a decade or so ago, when they all died together.

    --
    "I'm a well-wisher, in that I don't wish you any specific harm."
  36. This is just a fad... by Schraegstrichpunkt · · Score: 1, Funny

    ... that will die out in a year or two.

    1. Re:This is just a fad... by RealGrouchy · · Score: 1

      I think this is just a marketing ploy for the suicide clubs. I assume they face a fairly low member-retention rate, and have to keep up the recruitment.

      It's nice to see a society that lets people take their own deaths in their own hands, though. In the U.S., the "Justice" system does it piece by piece for them. Marijuana possession + slippery slope politics = life in prison = death in prison

      - RG>

      --
      Hey pal, this isn't a pleasantforest, so don't waste my time with pleasantries!
  37. Let me be the first to say that... by chriswaclawik · · Score: 2, Funny

    ... I wouldn't want to be part of any suicide club that would have me as a member.

    --
    A guy walks into a bar... well, I forgot the joke, but the punchline is that he's an alcoholic.
    1. Re:Let me be the first to say that... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Who modded that troll? If the mod knew any history they'd have realised the quote of the grandparent poster was a modification of Groucho Marx's famous line about not wanting to be a member of any club that would have him.

      Harpo Marx was Groucho Marx's brother, and the idea of doing Harpo (who always played a mute with a horn in the Marx Brother shows) is funny :)

      Sigh. Well, what else should I expect from a mod who probably wasn't born until the 1990's...

      Modding Kid whoever you are - your ignorance of great comedy history saddens me.

  38. Your Rights Online: Internet Suicide Pacts Surge i by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Your Rights Online: Internet Suicide Pacts Surge in Japan

    what the fuck does people killing themselves at the same time as other people using the internet have to do with my "rights online"?

  39. Lots of Exercise by chub_mackerel · · Score: 2, Informative

    Actually, public support and encouragement for exercise here in Japan is quite common. It's a matter of culture. One of the first things I'm always asked during the "introductory conversation" (which varies little from person to person) is what kind of sports I like to do. Kids and adults are encouraged to exercise. Many communities have very well-appointed civic community centers with gyms and pools and martial arts classes (public funding for something like that isn't seen as something evil and socialist here). There's a holiday called "sports day" when local schools have athletic festivals and people go out to join in and watch, etc. Employees at many companies here do morning calesthenics every workday. Public parks are full of people playing team sports, even way out in the suburbs. The public TV station, NHK, has little 10-minute exercise bits throughout the day for housewives (yes, this is Japan), elderly folk, and other homebodies to do if they want to join in. And perhaps the biggest thing: Japanese people walk. ALL the time. I live in the distant outskirts of Tokyo and every time I have a friend or relative come from overseas, I need to warn them to get in shape because the first few days here are going to involve lots of walking up and down subway stairs, from station to location, etc. There's a reason people here are generally thin. Not to mention: oodles of bicycles everywhere, used as transportation by a sizable fraction of the public.

    Exercise may be a generally good thing for mental well-being, but I don't think that's a factor that negatively distinguishes the Internet recluses in Japan from those anywhere else. Are the Internet recluses here still more likely to be out of shape? Sure. But I think the background level of fitness here is pretty good, so even those outliers are probably in better shape than, for example, geeks in the US.

  40. YOU AM FAIL IT by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Funny

    PLZ JOIN SUIXIDE CLUB.

    1. Re:YOU AM FAIL IT by Corbu+Mulak · · Score: 1

      I am interested in this club, what are it's annual dues?

    2. Re:YOU AM FAIL IT by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Your immortal soul!!!! (NO REFUNDS)

  41. serious probs by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Japan has some serious problems with its people.

    (*) They have high suicide rate

    (*) They have some of the lowest fertility rate, and have -ve growth of population

    Their economy, and workaholic schedules, heavy competition are some of the factors to blame. They are some of the most stressed workers.

  42. Take that, Emperor Meiji by voice_of_all_reason · · Score: 1

    You can destroy the Samurai, but you cannot destroy the Samurai inside man.

    //just saw The Last Samurai

  43. Yeah, Japan is the West? by Cybert14 · · Score: 1

    Oops...false dichotomy. I suppose libertarianism blows your mind too.

  44. Scared to die alone? by caller9 · · Score: 1

    So maybe this wasn't a misunderstanding?
    http://www.engrish-store.com/ihatmystshir.html

  45. Paranoia Agent by cyranoVR · · Score: 1

    When I saw this the episode "Happy Family Planning" of Paranoia Agent, I thought it was just the author's twisted plot device. But it turns out this happens for real. Who knew?

    Or perhaps we have a case of life imitating art?

    1. Re:Paranoia Agent by kalirion · · Score: 1

      That episode was the first thing I thought of after reading the topic title.

  46. Suicide Parlors by Doc+Ruby · · Score: 1

    Leave it to Japanese to LARP Somtow Sucharitkul's Mallworld.

    --

    --
    make install -not war

  47. I'll be the first to say.. by DigiShaman · · Score: 1

    If these girls are going to kill themselves no matter what. First I would ask them to get help. Second, I would have them commited to help.

    Third... if all else fails. Lets just have one giant fuck-fest. Let's just enjoy one moment of pleasure. Besides, we can't have chicks die virgins. Such a waste. :(

    --
    Life is not for the lazy.
  48. Overworking by RyoShin · · Score: 1

    I've read, on a few different occasions, the hypothesis that the high rate of suicide in Japan is due to the heavy work ethic there. Working hard is good, but from some things I've read, they just overexert themself, at least as I see it as a working American.

    As I understand it, failling is frowned upon much harsher there, culturally, than it is here in America.

    Also, did anyone think of the anime "Paranoia Agent" while reading this? It just made me think of one of the episodes half way through (6 or so) where the old guy, the younger guy, and the little girl made a pact in some chat room to get together and commit suicide.

    1. Re:Overworking by Hasdi+Hashim · · Score: 1

      Also, did anyone think of the anime "Paranoia Agent" while reading this?

      Here! Here! :-)

      That will be Paranoia Agent Episode 8:

          http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Happy_Family_Planning

  49. Japanese Schoolgirl Watch (see Wired) by CFD339 · · Score: 1


    Out: Cute, high-tech, 'Hello Kitty' backpackets with built in tablet PC's.

    In: Using those backpack touch screens to plan suicide with 40 year old American men pretending to be other Japanese Schoolgirls online.

    --
    The problem with quotes on the internet, is that nobody bothers to check their veracity. -- Abraham Lincoln
  50. Suicide statistics in Japan by jkuff · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Some of the culturally insensitive postings by slashdot readers is a bit disturbing. Having lived in Japan for several years, it is clear that Western morals regarding suicide do not necessarily apply in this complex and ancient culture.

    In addition, readers need to do their homework before posting factual errors or made-up numbers regarding its prevalence. More than 40% of the suicides in Japan are motivated by health-related reasons (older people whose health is failing). These suicide pacts comprise a very small percentage (less than 1%).

    Anyway, below are some statistics from 2003 in an article that appeared in The Japan Times on July 23, 2004:

    "A record 34,427 people committed suicide in Japan last year. (2003)

    The figure, up 7.1 percent from the previous year, remained above 30,000 for the sixth consecutive year, the National Police Agency said in a report released Thursday.

    The report says 8,897 people killed themselves over financial difficulties, up 12.1 percent from a year earlier and topping 8,000 for the first time since the NPA began keeping statistics on suicides in 1978.

    Suicides motivated by financial difficulties accounted for a quarter of all suicides in the year, comprising the second-largest group, compared with 11.2 percent in 1994.

    Almost 60 percent of the suicides in 2003 were by people in their 50s and older, it said.

    Health reasons were the motivation for the largest number of suicides in 2003, prompting 15,416, or 44.8 percent of the total, to take their lives. Some 8.5 percent committed suicide due to family problems.

    Men accounted for a record 72.5 percent of all suicides in 2003, contributing to the wider gap -- 6.97 years -- between the average life expectancies of men and women, as released earlier this month by the Health, Labor and Welfare Ministry."

    1. Re:Suicide statistics in Japan by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      kekeke ^.^

    2. Re:Suicide statistics in Japan by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Western morals regarding suicide do not necessarily apply in this complex and ancient culture.

      Hello Kitty? Tentacle Porn? Train groping? Are we talking about the same Japan?

      Slavery is an ancient tradition too. Wanna go practice it together?
  51. Right to guns and beer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Good to see Americans enjoy having the right to shooting themselves in the head and drinking themselves to death.

    1. Re:Right to guns and beer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Agreed.

      MAN: Oh my god! My life sucks!
      *MAN tries to hang himself, but the rope breaks, and he fails.*
      POLICE: As if your life didn't suck enough, suicide is illegal, so now you have to go to jail.

      Logic at work.

    2. Re:Right to guns and beer by corychristison · · Score: 1

      Yeah, I still don't understand the reasoning behind that one... I am in Canada, and to my understanding that law applies up here, too.

    3. Re:Right to guns and beer by Timothy+Brownawell · · Score: 2, Funny
      The real question is, is suicide a capital offence?

      Tim

    4. Re:Right to guns and beer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      I am in Canada, and to my understanding that law applies up here, too.

      As someone who's been through the experience in Canada, no, it doesn't.

      I spent two weeks in a psychiatric ward (until the doctors said I was no longer a threat to myself), but that was all.

    5. Re:Right to guns and beer by Dhalka226 · · Score: 5, Insightful

      POLICE: As if your life didn't suck enough, suicide is illegal, so now you have to go to jail.

      Logic at work.

      That's because of our views about suicide. It reminds me of some show about religion I once saw on the History Channel. A Rabbi was explaining his religion's policy on suicides, and it went something like this: A person who commits suicide can not be given full religious rites upon their death, but a special exemption is made for mentally-ill people, and all people who commit suicide are considered to be mentally ill. It was a cute little end-around their own beliefs, but I digress.

      It's not that the US wants to throw suicidal people in jail, it's that if it's not illegal they have absolutely no way to have a judge force a suicidal person into counseling or psychiatric observation/care. The belief in the US is that something has to be wrong with you if you want to kill yourself, and they want to treat that. Whether or not that is a proper view is open for debate.

    6. Re:Right to guns and beer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I spent two weeks in a psychiatric ward (until the doctors said I was no longer a threat to myself), but that was all.

      You were lucky to get that. They discharged me from emergency at 5am to walk home, untreated, filled with sleeping pills. I made it a few blocks before i passed out on the sidewalk. Then the hospital lied to the newspaper, saying i was under their care.

    7. Re:Right to guns and beer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Suicide is illegal becuase the establishment do not want to lose a capital asset which it has spent 20 years developing (education). Moreover, this capital asset could be used to generate profits and taxes if it is readjusted (by use of therapy and drugs) into an economically viable unit.

    8. Re:Right to guns and beer by petermgreen · · Score: 1

      iirc when the anti-suicide laws were first introduced in the uk you could be hung for attempted suicide!

      --
      note: i'm known as plugwash most places but i screwd up registering that here somehow in the past and now can't register
    9. Re:Right to guns and beer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's bizarre - which city/province were you in?

    10. Re:Right to guns and beer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      waaaaaaaah I couldn't kill myself and I passed out like a wussy, wahhhhhh

  52. Never heard of 'hiri kiri' by Sleet01 · · Score: 0

    Nor of 'hare kare', nor of the dozen other mispronounciations Americans toss off when they want to point out how odd Japanese people are.

    It's Hara kiri. Hara = stomach / guts, kiri is the noun form of kiru, 'to cut'.

    Your local grammar nazi at work.

    --
    -- Let him who is without spelling error ignite the first flame --
  53. a trend or a hype by Device666 · · Score: 1

    Ah it's just a hype. Such suicide clubs don't tend to survive. In the end all those clubs stop existing anyway, that's probably why they are suicide clubs... (Don't mod this as informative)

    1. Re:a trend or a hype by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      (Don't mod this as informative)

      Don't worry, they won't.

  54. Japanese culture isn't more f'd up than ours... by kadathseeker · · Score: 2, Insightful

    it is mostly that the problems are supressed or ignored until it becomes very dangerous. If you look in the media there, there is alot of disturbing stuff that doesn't seem to reflect daily life at all, until it shows up in the news. I saw a post on /. recently about American neoslaves working themselves to death while Europeans enjoyed vacations twice as longs as ours, but what about the three months of rioting in France about the lack of jobs for the youth? Despite the incredible flamewars during the 2000 and 2004 elections, there was no violence. In the US, the media and popular culture often exaggerate minute aspects of life and make them seem like a crisis, which then the public focuses on like sheep (there's a reason what you watch on TV is called "programming"). The same thing happens with all this Newage (rhymes with sewage) crap going on here. Take terrorism for example:

    US population: 295,734,134

    9/11 deaths: 2,986
    Number killed in Iraq (DoD confirmed as of Jan. 5, 2006): 2,182 total deaths
    Number killed in Afghanistan: 259
    Number of people killed by anthrax attacks: 5
    TOTAL TERROR RELATED DEATHS IN USA: 5,432

    Number of murders in the US in 2003: 16,528
      - Americans are three times better at killing Americans than people
    who are suicidally deperate to kill Americans.

    Number killed in motor vehicle accidents in 2001: 42,443
      - Cars are eight times more deadly than terrorists.

    Vietnam War deaths: 58,226
    American deaths in WWII: 400,000

    % of Americans killed by terrorism: 0.0018367849279109593754233320932781%

    Osama is a pussy. How about a War on Cars, or a more efficient use of the hundreds of billions of defense dollars? Let's target the real threats, like leaky dams and cars.

    --
    The 'Net is a waste of time, and that's exactly what's right about it. - William Gibson
    1. Re:Japanese culture isn't more f'd up than ours... by rmpotter · · Score: 1

      Well said! May the points of a 1000 moderators enrich your Karma.

      --
      Is this sig nificant?
    2. Re:Japanese culture isn't more f'd up than ours... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      1. Your Statistics are off - DoD numbers for Iraq, 9/11 and Afghanistan are cumulative since 2001 so you've gotten five years of terrorist kills stacked up against one year of each.

    3. Re:Japanese culture isn't more f'd up than ours... by Procyon101 · · Score: 1

      Except that automobile deaths are accidental. You can't retaliate against an accident, but you can against maliciousness. Automobiles become safer every year, they are targeted by both the manufacturer (to boost sales due to safety records) and government. Murderers are targeted also and the murder rate has been steadily declining for a very long time. You neglected to list your statistics for leaky dams, so I can't really comment. We can't very well target Vietnam and WWII deaths, as in recent years the incident rate has fallen to near zero.

      Aren't auto accidents the leading non-disease related cause of death? It's actually pretty disturbing to me that terrorism accounts for a significant percentage of that number when compared.

    4. Re:Japanese culture isn't more f'd up than ours... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      How do you know? I think the machines are out to get us!

    5. Re:Japanese culture isn't more f'd up than ours... by kadathseeker · · Score: 1

      Yes, auto deaths are accidental, but 10% of the defense budget put into auto, road, and driver safety would improve things alot. The Vietnam and WW2 deaths are for comparison. The war in Iaq is NOT a Vietnam quagmire.

      --
      The 'Net is a waste of time, and that's exactly what's right about it. - William Gibson
    6. Re:Japanese culture isn't more f'd up than ours... by dangitman · · Score: 1
      Auto accidents are accidental, but they are easily preventable. America puts very little effort into enforcing road safety compared to other countries. A concerted public safety campaign could easily prevent thousands of deaths a year, for very little money.

      In contrast, occupying Iraq costs a lot of money, and puts more Americans at risk. Which is the better investment?

      --
      ... and then they built the supercollider.
    7. Re:Japanese culture isn't more f'd up than ours... by nick+this · · Score: 1

      Yup, but traffic fatalities involving alcohol account for nearly 50% of those numbers. Those deaths are eminently preventable.

      Also, if the studies detailing costs associated with Iraq alone are to be believed, we'll have spent 2 trillion dollars there. What could that have done if we spent it on combatting drunk driving? Or suicide prevention programs? Would our country be objectively safer?

      I believe so.

    8. Re:Japanese culture isn't more f'd up than ours... by Procyon101 · · Score: 1

      Or left that money in the economy... which would be my first choice.

      Also, for comparison, the cost of Iraq in comparison with what would have been spent otherwise is quite a different figure. Before the war we were spending much money on bombing Iraq, protection of the Saudi and Kuwaiti borders, etc... which I'm not aware of those numbers, but I'll venture they weren't cheap. Also factor in that much of the occupation force is force that was occupying Germany since WWII, so not much increase in expenditure there. Then add the economic benefit and tax revenue of the elimination of the embargos. And the fact that much of the munitions used are munition disposal (sparrows and old sidewinders for instance, which are obsolete but fired because they are going to be thrown away anyway, which are factored into the cost but really are a savings because it costs money to dispose of them.

      I'm not saying that Iraq's not expensive, but I simply don't believe the straightforward figures are very believable.

      As for your programs, how would you reduce drunk driving fatalities more? We are innundated with advertisement already, there are huge extra patrol forces, many if not most states have reduced alcohol levels for DUI to the point where impairment is debatable, and penalties have been escalating to the point where people's lives are thrown into massive turmoil for a first and borderline offense. People are educated, penalties are stiff, enforcement is massive, what exactly do you want money to be spent on? Seriously. If you have suggestions I am curious.

      Suicide prevention is honorable, but I don't really want alot of my tax money to be spent on anti-darwinistic programs instead of my children's education (maybe it's a little cold, but I worked hard for that money and I have priorities for it) and that doesn't affect my safety or well being whatsoever.

      Again, I'm not saying that the money couldn't go to other good, perhaps greater good, but I'd rather see the money going to removing the problematic dictatorship we were forced to bomb once a week for a decade and enforce an internationally unpopular embargo than just blindly throwing money at programs of questionable benefit.

    9. Re:Japanese culture isn't more f'd up than ours... by nick+this · · Score: 1

      For 2 trillion dollars, we could fund a free nationwide shuttle service for bar patrons.

      Okay, ridiculous, I know (or am I *required* to spell it "rediculous"?), but the point that I think both of us agree on is that that whatever iraq is causing us, the benefit we gain in terms of reducing our terrorist threat isn't worth the money. Just from a pure cost-benefit standpoint.

      I don't know what specifically could be done to lower drunk driving fatalities, but we might be able to fund studies to see why the the percentages of drunk driving fatalities are 3-4 times lower in sweden or finland then they are in the US. I'm confident we could bring that study in at under $2T. Or whatever the real number is.

      And I guess I see your point, but I'm of the opposite view. Spending that money on almost *anything* else would probably have better effects than going into Iraq, in my opinion. I just feel that there are plenty of things we could have done with the money to have objectively better results. /me shrugs. I might be wrong, though.

    10. Re:Japanese culture isn't more f'd up than ours... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Then how about the War on Nature. I mean, by know it's clear that global warming is killing people in the thousands, so declaring war on nature would be the only true american answer on that SOB.

    11. Re:Japanese culture isn't more f'd up than ours... by MrAnnoyanceToYou · · Score: 1

      For two trillion dollars we could buy cold fusion from aliens and sell it to the third world for a profit.

    12. Re:Japanese culture isn't more f'd up than ours... by MrAnnoyanceToYou · · Score: 1

      That's so funny right now I have changed my sig. I'll feel differently in the morning.

    13. Re:Japanese culture isn't more f'd up than ours... by slothman32 · · Score: 1

      It's funnier when you put the "for two trillion" part in.

      --
      Why don't you guys have friends or journals?
  55. Re:Suicide Club (movie) by Endymion · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Hmm... I thought the first rule of suicide club was "Are you connected with yourself?"

    that was a good movie, if you can take it...

    Actually, it's very very on topic for this post. It's all about following trends, and knowing who you are and what you want. Most people don't, and fall prey to other things.

    Also the most blood I've ever seen in a movie... wow.

    --
    Ce n'est pas une signature automatique.
  56. Your poor spelling and lack of cultural awareness by Sleet01 · · Score: 0

    ... made Cthulhu cry in his sleep.

    First, what do you know of samurai? Do you know that they don't exist, at least not in the form idealized by Westerners, and have not for nearly 100 years?

    Second, _kamikaze_ pilots died out with the end of the Second World War. Any pilots you have seen crashing into buildings have been insane Arab fundamentalists or drunken American idiots.

    Third: You only know of suicide clubs because of this story, you great steaming pile of hikikomori putrescence. What about the various American religious cults of the past twenty years? Yes, it's odd to commit suicide with other people so you don't feel lonely; how much *more* odd is it, then, to do so in the hopes that your soul will live forever on a great comet?

    You know nothing about Japan; I'd wager you know less than that about English grammar (and you an Aussie!), which is why you have no friends here.

    Me, I have no friends because I hate you all.

    --
    -- Let him who is without spelling error ignite the first flame --
  57. Props to My Psycho Fathers Suicide by c0d3r · · Score: 0, Troll

    My Father was the most psycho craziest man I ever new, being an MS Psyc Parole Officer Ex Military Ex Cop. I disowned him and didn't hear from him til he died 7 years later by a violent car chase (Which made me very happy), and pistle wipped her, and shot her several times as she ran away right in front of a church and splattered his own brain on the pavement. The bitch definitely deserved it, it fits the end to the long story, and its a way to go!

    1. Re:Props to My Psycho Fathers Suicide by kadathseeker · · Score: 1

      That post is a new standard for incoherency and bad grammar. Judging by that, you don't sound to well off either.

      --
      The 'Net is a waste of time, and that's exactly what's right about it. - William Gibson
    2. Re:Props to My Psycho Fathers Suicide by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's "too well", smarty.

  58. How to make someone kill themselves by Neo-Rio-101 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    After living here for about 6-7 years, and working in a Japanese office environment, suicide is the result of the non-violent way that the Japanese have dealt with getting rid of people you don't like.

    The Japanese are no longer a violent race of people after the war, having said that, they are no less at peace with themselves or with others. Since they refuse to use violence, they have had to use other ways of controlling others - and the result is that the Japanese have evolved into a race of people who have learnt to push people's emotional buttons to defend themselves and get what they want.

    The fact is, if you can mentally make a person turn on THEMSELVES - then you don't have to kill them. You feed them guilt, you over work them, you deprive them of sleep, you bully them, you ignore them, you socially ostracize them... all the while faking a smile at them and telling them that you like them.

    OK, so someone gets angry and tries to use violence.... socially ostracized, arrested, lose your job, nobody will employ you, have a nice homeless life.

    This is what the younger generation has been fighting against by refusing full term employment. This is why you have a nation of recluses. This is why some people are bumping themselves off.

    --
    READY.
    PRINT ""+-0
    1. Re:How to make someone kill themselves by achurch · · Score: 2, Insightful
      Wow . . . that's an awfully derogatory way to describe cultural differences. Yes, the Japanese dislike physical violence; yes, they can be clever at manipulating others' emotions; and yes, there may even be a cause-and-effect relationship between those two traits. But implying that they use that method to "get what they want" or "defend themselves" in the same way as Westerners do shows a basic misunderstanding of Japanese culture.

      Japanese, on the whole, place significant value on helping others rather than fulfilling personal desires; not to an extreme, of course, but enough so that Dilbert has no real-life reference point here, for example. The lifetime employment system you mention is partly due to this, and partly due to the willingness of many Japanese to allow organizations to take care of them rather than taking control of their own lives. The younger generation is certainly beginning to change that, as you mention, but not because of some dislike of this mental pressuring; it's the result of an increased emphasis on private life and personal growth, which the old system doesn't have much (if any) leeway for.

      Interpersonal clashes do happen, of course, and as you suggest, the Japanese prefer causing embarrassment to using physical violence. But if you consider things like "overwork" and "deprivation of sleep" to be personal attacks, then I'd seriously suggest finding another job, or possibly another country to work in, because the vast majority of the Japanese people I know consider that perfectly normal. In fact, working overtime has traditionally been seen as a positive trait, the sign of a hard worker, and if that means you have to cut down on your sleep, so be it.

      And describing Japan as a "nation of recluses" is simply wrong. Wikipedia says that the hikikomori population was around 1.2 million in September 2004, or less than 1% of the population; even limiting it to the 10-40 age range, that's still on the order of 3-5%, which matches my own experience. A serious problem, yes, but hardly a "nation of recluses".

    2. Re:How to make someone kill themselves by chris_eineke · · Score: 1

      Also known as Subliminal Harassment. I have to warn you though, the contents of that page are not for the faint of heart, if not pure evil.

      --
      "All you have to do is be fragile and grateful. So stay the underdog." Chuck Palahniuk, Choke
    3. Re:How to make someone kill themselves by Neo-Rio-101 · · Score: 1

      Wow . . . that's an awfully derogatory way to describe cultural differences.

      Wow, that's really derogatory to call someone out for being "derogatory". Sheesh.

      Ok, so it sounds "bleak", but we ARE talking about the minds of people who would feel better off dead here, so bear with me for a minute. If you're not willing to consider their position for just a few moments, and think for a minute of WHY they might feel that way, given possible situations, then you're going to be less able to think from their perspective.

      Yes, the Japanese dislike physical violence; yes, they can be clever at manipulating others' emotions; and yes, there may even be a cause-and-effect relationship between those two traits. But implying that they use that method to "get what they want" or "defend themselves" in the same way as Westerners do shows a basic misunderstanding of Japanese culture.

      Japanese culture is not static, just like "asian culture" is fairly undefinable as well. It used to be Japanese culture to have a samurai come around and lop your head off for whatever reason as well. Where are the samurais today?
      You cannot ignore that specific behavioural traits rose up from a need to survive in the society in which one finds oneself. While it's easy for us to write it all off as "Japanese culture" from our ivory gaijin towers, it gives us a skewed view of what's really going on.

      Japanese, on the whole, place significant value on helping others rather than fulfilling personal desires; not to an extreme, of course, but enough so that Dilbert has no real-life reference point here, for example. The lifetime employment system you mention is partly due to this, and partly due to the willingness of many Japanese to allow organizations to take care of them rather than taking control of their own lives.

      But not everyone views it like this.

      Have YOU ever thought about starting your own company? I figure it would be very easy to do in Japan. You could start your own company, bring in a bunch of unskilled Japanese workers, underpay them for what they do, tell them that they are gaining valuable experience, tell them to ganbare a million times, socially ostracize them for not working hard enough, then just sit back and watch those profits roll in.

      Now, one of two things happen at this point. Most employees find out they're being used and try to leave for foreign companies who don't treat them like crap, OR since they have no time or experience to find another job because their current job overworks them, or out of fear of risking their reputation by breaking away from their employer, stick it out.

      So now that our salaryman is sticking it out, he is given harder work and more responsibilities. He is paid just a little extra and now has to travel 2 hours to work everyday, there and back, to complete 160+ hours of a contract - which is pretty rough by anyone's standards because doing so involves overwork. But this is the company taking care of you, right? You have to do what they say.

      Good for you that you have an education and plenty of experience so that you are very mobile. Not everyone has experience, or is very mobile.
      Maybe we can blame them for not studying harder?

      The younger generation is certainly beginning to change that, as you mention, but not because of some dislike of this mental pressuring; it's the result of an increased emphasis on private life and personal growth, which the old system doesn't have much (if any) leeway for.

      I propose that the mental pressuring and increased emphasis on private life are linked. When you are working long days and have no time for exercise, a private life, or much sleep, you turn to alcohol and nights out in the snack bars or karaoke boxes or pachinko. Or, like several Japanese people I know, you get stress related sicknesses and have to skip work to visit the "doctor" everyday. or you smoke heavily.

      Interpersonal clashes do happen, of course, and as you suggest, the Japanese pref

      --
      READY.
      PRINT ""+-0
    4. Re:How to make someone kill themselves by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      Sigh...*another* gaijin who lives in Japan for a few years, and proceeds to lecture others on Japanese culture. You could live there for 40 years, and you would still lack a basic understanding.

      --
      Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
    5. Re:How to make someone kill themselves by incest · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Um, look, I think we all know there's a stereotype out there. Anime nerds that learn Japanese because JAPAN IS SUPERIOR and then go to Japan because OMG Samurai and Ninjas are around every corner and they're going to stalk Megumi Hayashibara or whoever it is that they remember from their favorite anime. And of course they're all obsessed with Asian women, too. "They're just so much more feminine."

      (I don't see how anyone can say, "One race's women are superior to another's." There's just so many beautiful women out there of every race. But that's just me. I just don't want anyone to think that I'm part of that Asian chicks-only clique.)

      But just because people like that are not emotionally equipped to handle a proper analysis of another culture, it does not necessarily follow that this guy is totally off his rocker. I think it's the height of racist stupidity to go around calling people gaijin (Japanese for "foreigner," with an emphasis on an "outsider" status, to those not in the know) and claiming that they can't even come up with a basic understanding of Japanese culture. Are Japanese people somehow so complex and special that nobody outside their culture could possibly understand them? Flipping that one around, is American culture beyond Japanese understanding? How about Russian culture? Or French culture? Why or why not? Is it because American culture is so simplistic and pathetic that the Japanese mind can easily understand it?

      Or is it just your "inscrutable Asians" racist stereotype rearing its ugly head?

      The Japanese are not some incredibly special case. They are humans, just like everyone else.* They are not immune to being understood by people not raised inside their own cultural norms. If you have a disagreement with the conclusions of the parent, argue your point with facts and logic.


      *except for the ones that are really Saurians and part of the conspiracy to pilot the Spaceship Earth into the sun to make way for a new hyperspace bypass.

    6. Re:How to make someone kill themselves by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      they don't know English

      Neither, apparently, do you.

    7. Re:How to make someone kill themselves by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 1
      I think it's the height of racist stupidity to go around calling people gaijin

      Are you *sure* that you understand the Japanese?

      They are not immune to being understood by people not raised inside their own cultural norms

      Ah, another guy who's never been to Japan.

      --
      Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
    8. Re:How to make someone kill themselves by achurch · · Score: 1
      Wow, that's really derogatory to call someone out for being "derogatory". Sheesh.

      Right back atcha.

      Ok, so it sounds "bleak", but we ARE talking about the minds of people who would feel better off dead here, so bear with me for a minute. If you're not willing to consider their position for just a few moments, and think for a minute of WHY they might feel that way, given possible situations, then you're going to be less able to think from their perspective.

      I'll grant that from the perspective of such a person, your post probably describes their worldview fairly well. What I took exception to is your implication--and if you didn't mean to imply this, my apologies for misunderstanding you--that people outside of that group also view things that way, that this sort of "harassment" takes place on an everyday basis all over the place. (It doesn't; at least, I've rarely had to deal with it, and have rarely heard friends complain about it either.)

      Have YOU ever thought about starting your own company? I figure it would be very easy to do in Japan. You could start your own company, bring in a bunch of unskilled Japanese workers, underpay them for what they do, tell them that they are gaining valuable experience, tell them to ganbare a million times, socially ostracize them for not working hard enough, then just sit back and watch those profits roll in.

      The thing is--and this is why I suggested you were unfamiliar with "Japanese culture", to the extent it can be defined--most Japanese would not do this (Horiemon excepted). I don't have any hard data to demonstrate this, just my own experience and hearsay, but a large part of the Japanese kaisha system is based on trust, and--in large part--it works, for both sides.

      Out of curiosity, where do you work? I'm in Tokyo, so there may be a regional difference.

      Now, one of two things happen at this point. Most employees find out they're being used and try to leave for foreign companies who don't treat them like crap

      I have a few (Japanese) friends who have worked for foreign companies. Interestingly, they all say that gaishikei firms pay better, but Japanese firms treat them better.

      I propose that the mental pressuring and increased emphasis on private life are linked.

      I disagree; since Japanese society traditionally has not placed much value on private life, most Japanese simply did not consider it a strong desire. (Did you ever watch the movie Tasogare Seibei ? That illustrates pretty well the traditional balance between soshiki and family.) I would actually argue the reverse: that an increased desire for a private life, perhaps resulting from Western influence, has resulted in greater stress as Japanese are no longer satisfied with simply conforming to the group.

      Perfectly normal, but do they like it?

      No, probably not--but they probably also accept it as necessary to make a living, else they'd be changing jobs. (If you had a billion dollars in your bank account, would you "like" sitting at a desk from 9 to 5 every day?)

  59. Culture by Bethor · · Score: 2, Insightful

    (Note: Ive been living in Japan for several years).

    Suicide rates in Japan are high simply because in this culture, some things are considered worse than death. Suicide is a valid solution to many problems, and sometimes even considered a brave and honorable display of self-sacrifice. It has been this way since ancient times - look it up.

    Now, I also wish they would stop, but its silly to blame it on living conditions of the Japanese, which are in fact, among the best in this planet, even for the people living in the country side growing potatoes.

  60. Just like the Kamikaze Fighters from WWII by keith134 · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    I guess the Japanese just have a penchant for killing themselves

  61. I don't know about you guys... by sorak · · Score: 5, Funny

    ...But with all the internet fraud out there, I'd be worried about the other guy not upholding his end of the deal...

    ...they need a pay-pal type thing...a sort of "death-pal", which says that if you don't kill yourself, we'll send people to finish the job.

    1. Re:I don't know about you guys... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      Deathwish-87: OK, do it NOW!
      Suicided00d: Yeh hehe
      Gothgurrl69: k
      ....
      Suicided00d: heh didnt do it :P
      Deathwish-87: lol me nither
      Suicided00d: gothgrl?
      ...
      Suicided00d: lol
      Deathwish-87: roflmao

  62. Servicemen by Ogemaniac · · Score: 1

    There are tens of thousands of American servicemen in Japan. Their crime rate is typical of that of men their age. Simple math, however, leads to "constant raping, murding and accidently running over", just because of the large number of people you are talking about.

    The only difference is that the media in Japan squeals ten times as much when a gaijin commits a crime as when a native Japanese does the same. In short, you are falling for Japanese bigotry. There is a reason we "hardly ever hear about it" - because it is perfectly normal!

    If you don't understand why, here is an example:

    There's more: African-Americans/Hispanics/soccer-dads are constantly raping, murdering, and accidentally running over Alabama citizens, but we hardly ever hear about that.

    1. Re:Servicemen by Otter · · Score: 1
      There are tens of thousands of American servicemen in Japan. Their crime rate is typical of that of men their age.

      I think the American servicemen in Okinawa actually have a crime rate similar to the overall population there, which is pretty creditable given that they're skewed to high-crime age groups. And as someone else pointed out, the idiot is confusing Japan with a single incident years ago in South Korea where a girl was accidentally run over.

  63. Re:Yet another problem here in America: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    No, I'm pretty sure he didn't start first. You're were just using shock tactics to cause emotions and try to make other people hate America too.

    Yes now utilize your fance grammar ju-jitsu and make yourself feel better.

  64. About the perfectionism in Japan... by antdude · · Score: 1

    I found an interesting story from The New York Times (no registration needed when I just checked) last year about time obsession that caused the train wreck. It was an interesting read.

    --
    Ant(Dude) @ Quality Foraged Links (AQFL.net) & The Ant Farm (antfarm.ma.cx / antfarm.home.dhs.org).
  65. Darwinism in action... by binaryspiral · · Score: 1

    So?

    26 people commited suicide on the Internet. How many people called into suicide hotlines and finished the job on the phone?

    How many people wrote a note?

    So the Internet allows people to find people like themselves... this is pretty logical. Disturbing? Not really, unless nobody plans to find the root cause of their suicides and blames it on the Internet.

  66. Re:Yet another problem here in America: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Egregious grammatical errors. To wit: characterizing my "America-bashing" as *not* rlevant, grautuitous(sic), and 'a troll'.

    Egregious spelling errors describing egregious grammatical errors?

  67. MOD PARENT UP by HulkProtector1 · · Score: 1

    I don't believe this is trolling. I think this is a serious statement.

    If we are basically a grown up germ, where is the purpose in life? What's the point in living, when dieing seems easier. That's the question that philosophers have tried to answer for the last century.

    1. Re:MOD PARENT UP by Jonny_eh · · Score: 1

      I guess an easy answer is go look to religion for an answer.

      Also, I'm sure they've spent more than the last century working on this 'problem'.

      A lot of people find that religion gives them purpose (hopefully, the good kind, not the suicide bomber kind).

    2. Re:MOD PARENT UP by Mr.+Slippery · · Score: 0
      If we are basically a grown up germ, where is the purpose in life? What's the point in living, when dieing seems easier. That's the question that philosophers have tried to answer for the last century.

      What's the "purpose" of a sunset? Of a joke? Of a thunderstorm? Of a song? Of the Northern Lights? Of a poem?

      "Purpose" is a human invention. If you want one, invent one, but be aware that it's your own creation and not a property of the universe. There's no "coefficient of meaning" in any theory of physics.

      --
      Tom Swiss | the infamous tms | my blog
      You cannot wash away blood with blood
    3. Re:MOD PARENT UP by Grant_Watson · · Score: 1

      "Purpose" is a human invention. If you want one, invent one, but be aware that it's your own creation and not a property of the universe. There's no "coefficient of meaning" in any theory of physics.

      Physics is a partial description of the universe -- it is not a definition. Simply because physics does not describe something does not preclude its being a property of the universe. :-)

  68. Everyone dies alone. by rbanzai · · Score: 1

    Idiots.

  69. Re:Your Rights Online: Internet Suicide Pacts Surg by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    *envisions a quote*

    "We're monitoring all communications made over the internet that may involve suicide club formation, thanks to this new law. It's really for your own good."

  70. why are you responding to trolls? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    oh right you're queer

  71. Re:Your poor spelling and lack of cultural awarene by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Oh God, someone insulted your favorite country. Boo hoo! Go smack your pud to your fucking manga, white boy.

  72. I saw that movie by esaloch · · Score: 0

    I wonder if this surge has to do with the movie Suiced Club. One of the craziest movies I've seen in a while 54 high school girls suddenly commit suicide in an internet pact and then people all over begin to follow suit. I like the part with the glam goth rocker singing about killing yourself. The movie was scary and then that part bagan and I cracked up laughing.

  73. Someone please import these to Canada. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    Let's see. On my birthday (two days ago), I lost my job, injured my arm, got dumped by my girlfriend and had to spend 1.5 hours burning gas trying to find parking in downtown Montreal. This is on top of working 16 hours a day, 7 days a week for this company (an Internet startup) and being assured, less than a week ago, that I would be the last person to be let go if anything went wrong.

    I'm not suicidal, but I know why people would be. Thinking about suicide helps relieve some of the stress from a situation like this. It is a sort of mental shortcut to shifting one's mental frame, giving an example of a way to get out of one's current conundrum. I can only imagine how hard it would be if I had an expensive house to pay for, or huge credit card bills - oil on the fire I guess.

  74. Re:Yet another problem here in America: by Sleet01 · · Score: 0

    I guess I proved my own point ^_^ And besides, isn't meta what /. is all about?

    --
    -- Let him who is without spelling error ignite the first flame --
  75. The Google Solution by scotty1024 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Obviously the solution is for the Japanese government to go to Yahoo, MSN and Google and tell them to censor searches for Suicide and Suicide Club.

    As gratifying as the above jibe might be in light of recent stories about all the search engines and ethics...

    I read a story in Wired Magazine about Google, I want to say 4 years ago. Anyway, the articles author mentioned that Google had these displays up that showed all the searches flowing through and how they resolved. The author noticed one go by which seemed to be from someone needing suicide counseling. The author said Google was wired to redirect some searches so that the searches returned links to places where they could seek help.

    I would hope whomever writes such redirects would get around to Japanese soon.

    1. Re:The Google Solution by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why the hell is this marked off topic? It's about suicide, the internet, and Japan... in fact it's about searching out the suicide clubs in the topic of this story. In what way is this off topic?

      I know /. mods aren't known for always making logical moddings, but honestly... that's entirely on topic.

      Btw, this is my first post on /. long time listener first time caller and all.

  76. I have my theories... by John+Pfeiffer · · Score: 1

    I blame their written language. It's made me want to at least hurt myself on countless occasions...

    All my typical joking aside, when you have to know 3000 characters that are typically printed so small that 60% of them are basically impossible to tell apart, just to be able to read a college textbook (And god forbid you wanted to get into a GOOD college) suicide seems like a far less masochistic path. (Especially given the average Japanese teenager's outlook on life and its value.) It's that Japanese work ethic. I mean, they have a word for 'death from overwork'...and they don't mean that shit figuratively.

    They really need to lighten up...but I'm terrified that if they do, all important advances in consumer electronics technology will cease. <_<

    --

    Friend: "The NIC is misconfigured..." Me: "No prob, I'll just telnet in and fix it." *Silence*
  77. The little goth in me says... by Runty+McGhee · · Score: 1

    Beautifullllllll......

  78. It's not that bad, you could have it worse... by Bodhammer · · Score: 4, Funny

    (Hawaiian music)

    Man#1 (Michael Palin) Aye! Very fussable, eh? Very fussable bit, that? eh?

    Man#2 (Graham Chapman): Grand meal, that was, eh?

    Others: Yes, wonderful, yes very good..

    Man#2: Nothing like a good glass of Chateau le Shlasseler, eh, Guissay?

    Man#3 (Terry Jones): Oh, you're right there, Robidaier.

    Man#4 (Eric Idle): Who'd 'ave thought, thirty year ago, we'd all be
    sitting here drinking Chateau de Shlasseler, eh?

    Man#1: Aye, in them days we was glad to have the price of a cup of tea!

    Man#2: Aye, a cup of cold tea!

    Man#4: Without milk or sugar!

    Man#3: Or tea!

    Man#1: Aye, in a cracked cup and all!

    Man#4: Oh, we never had a cup. We used to have to drink out of a
    rolled-up newspaper!

    Man#2: Aye, the best we could manage in those days was to suck on a piece
    of damp cloth!

    Man#3: Aye, but we were happy in those days, though we were poor.

    Man#1: Because we were poor! My old dad used to say to me: Money
    doesn't buy you happiness!

    Man#4: Aye, he was right, I was happier then and I had nothing. We
    used to live in this tiny old house with great big holes in the
    roof.

    Man#2: House! You were lucky to live in a house! We had to all live
    in one room, all twenty-six of us, no furniture, half the floor
    was missing, and were all huddled together in a corner for
    fear of falling!

    Man#3: You were lucky to have a room! We used to 'ave to live in a corridor!

    Man#1: Oh, we used to DREAM of living in a corridor. It would have
    been a palace to us. We used to have to live in an old
    water tank in a rubbish pit. We got woke up every morning
    by having a load of rotting fish dumped all over us!
    House! Huh!

    Man#4: Well, when I say house, it was only a hole in the ground
    covered by a sheet of tarpaulin, but it was a house to us!

    Man#2: We were evicted from our hole in the ground. We had to go and
    live in a lake!

    Man#3: You were lucky to have a lake! There were a hundred and fifty
    of us, living in a shoebox in the middle of the road!

    Man#1: Cardboard box?

    Man#3: Aye!

    Man#1: You were lucky. We lived for three months in a paper bag in
    a septic tank. We used to have to get up at six in the
    morning, clean the paper bag, eat a crust of stale bread,
    go to work down at the mill, fourteen hours a day, week in, week
    out, for sixpence a week, and when we got home, our dad would
    thrash us to sleep with his belt.

    (slight pause)

    Man#2: Luxury. We used to have to get out of the lake at six o'clock
    in the morning, clean the lake, eat a handful of damp gravel,
    work a twenty-hour

    --
    "I say we take off, nuke the site from orbit. It's the only way to be sure."
    1. Re:It's not that bad, you could have it worse... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      [snipped Monty Python scene]

      There are days when I believe that anything resembling intelligent commentary on Slashdot is mere window-dressing, that the site exists for no greater reason than to propagate memes such as this.

      P.S. Please welcome our new comedic overlords.

  79. Suicide is illegal because.... by shoelace_822695 · · Score: 1

    Ive heard of a number of different explainations for this actually

    1. you are a human (i suppose that is debatable), you are killing/attempting to kill a human :. therefore you are commiting murder/attempted murder.

    2. it was inspired by religous reasons.

    3. they are worried about you hurting others in the process.

    so there are 3 possibly explanations..

    and remember like the song says "suicide is silent".. (except for maybe guns)

    --
    ShoeLace

    --
    -- Shoe Lace
    1. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by LouisZepher · · Score: 1

      Unless I'm thinking of another song, I thought the lyrics were "Suicide is painless...".

    2. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by Requiem18th · · Score: 2, Interesting

      But thanks to the RIAA shutting down lyrics sites we will never know...

      --
      But... the future refused to change.
    3. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by Meagermanx · · Score: 1

      Yeah, like marijuana is illegal because it hurts other people...
       
      As I understand it, there are two reasons suicide is illegal. One, because if people see it as illegal they see it as something they wouldn't do, because it's evil, and two, because they can restrain somebody and force them into healthcare if they don't manage to kill themselves.

    4. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by LouisZepher · · Score: 1

      Let's Sing It is what I tend to use... Let's see, no results for "Suicide is silent" as lyrics, but several for "suicide is painless" as lyrics, including the one I was thinking of.

    5. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by anotherzeb · · Score: 1

      The legal situation in the UK is a bit different - it used to be illegal to try to kill yourself due to the fear that there wouldn't be enough people left to fight wars if everyone was at it. The government saw sense last century and repealed that law, but if a doctor considers a person a harm to themselves or others due to a psychiatric condition (like depression) they are legally obliged to ensure the patient is kept in a secure place (usually a psychiatric hospital) until they are no longer considered a danger or the doctor gives up on them. This confinement can be up to three months at a time, with further time possible if the relevant professional considers it necessary.

      If you're thinking of suicide, visit my site here. It's ancient so some of the links are dead but some of it might be useful to you

      As for the song - I'm also thinking 'Suicide is painless (it brings on many changes and you can take or leave it if you please)'

      --
      Good luck sometimes arrives disguised as bad
    6. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by pete6677 · · Score: 1

      The only thing an anti-suicide law would do is make people aware that if they intend to kill themselves, they better make sure it works. What is the penalty for committing suicide anyway, death? Outlawing suicide makes about as much sense as passing a law against cold weather, but I'm not surprised that it sounds like a good idea to some misguided politician.

    7. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by shoelace_822695 · · Score: 1

      i think you're correct.. it didnt sound rigth when i typed it..
      its the theme tune to the tv show M*A*S*H anyway

      http://www.bestcareanywhere.net/songs.htm#theme says
      "Suicide is Painless" (MASH theme song) (music by J. Mandel; lyrics by M. Altman)

      --
      -- Shoe Lace
    8. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by mrchaotica · · Score: 1

      Criminalizing the behavior also penalizes the person's heirs, I think, which could help prevent some people from doing it.

      --

      "[Regarding the 'cloud,'] ownership was what made America different than Russia." -- Woz

    9. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by Kadin2048 · · Score: 1

      make people aware that if they intend to kill themselves, they better make sure it works.

      I think this is basically the idea.

      You don't want people halfheartedly trying to kill themselves and just becoming vegetables; it gets expensive to keep them in nursing homes and whatnot. Or if they don't go that far and just manage to injure themselves, it's still a drag on the system that has to take care of them.

      The only people that are going to be affected by anti-suicide laws are people who either don't manage to do the job right (i.e., they don't end up dead), or they tell a lot of people what they're planning beforehand and someone blows the whistle on them. In the former case, they're just stupid, in the latter, it's likely their suicide is more of a 'cry for help' than anything (or at least, that's the theory).

      If you went out and bought a 12-ga shotgun or similar, and proceeded to blow your brainstem out the back of your head, I think you'd find the law rather indifferent.

      --
      "Ladies and gentlemen, my killbot features Lotus Notes and a machine gun. It is the finest available."
    10. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by frgough · · Score: 1

      You'd be surprised at what threads people will cling to in depression. Making it illegal most certainly can be that one thread that keeps someone from killing himself.

      The simple fact is, suicide was made illegal in the United States because, at that time, the nation and society valued all human life, even that so depressed as to want to end itself.

      Those days are rapidly fading away. Now we kill humans in the womb because they inconvenience the mother. We kill them because they may not be 'perfect' (Downs Syndrome) we kill them because they're the wrong sex. We encourage the elderly to "die with dignity." We decided a life isn't worth living and so get the courts to pull a feeding tube. And all the while, the death cult chants about how we are moving toward enlightenment.

      It's creepy.

      --
      You can tell the character of a man by observing those who hate him.
    11. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well so is discrination, thief, murder, and other crimes against humanity but we still do it. Somehow we think that one person is better than other person we can commit crimes against them. This is the real problem.

    12. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      A 12 gauge ain't going to make sure it works. People live through all sorts of f'ed up stuff and I've seen photos of people failing with a shotgun. The best way is a shotgun to the head, after taking a bunch of pills, while jumping off the Golden Gate. If you're going to do it, do it for real.

      Or just realize life's a joke and live accordingly.

    13. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by Lew-the-nerd · · Score: 1

      The music may have originated in the movie MASH where the camp dentist, 'Painless', despondent but notoriously well endowed is lured back from the brink of death (not really) by the tender ministrations of an impressed nurse who has peeked beneath the covers.

    14. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by bentcd · · Score: 1

      4. Suicides are rather expensive to society so you are causing us a substantial cost when you kill yourself. (Ok, so I'Ãm a cyni :-)

      --
      sigs are hazardous to your health
    15. Re:Suicide is illegal because.... by duhjim · · Score: 1

      suicide is illegal because there is a santa claus, period.

  80. This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by Spy+der+Mann · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Suicide pacts encourage people to commit suicide, while in normal conditions the person could decide not to do it at the last minute. But in a group, this could result in peer pressure conditions. Encouraging someone to commit suicide is equivalent to killing him.

    1. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Encouraging someone to commit suicide is equivalent to killing him. No, actually it is not. It may not be nice, it may be morally wrong - but it is not equivalent by any stretch of the imagination. Unless, of course, you live in a universe that forgoes normal logical conventions.

    2. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by d34thm0nk3y · · Score: 1

      Encouraging someone to commit suicide is equivalent to killing him.

      Spy der Man, you know you want to do it. Just go for it.

      Oh my god!! I am a murderer!!!

    3. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by geminidomino · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Murder? That's ridiculous. "Encouraging someone to do X" is NOT the same as "inflicting consequences of doing X on someone." These people have functional neural clusters. If they didn't want to die, it doesn't matter how much "encouragement" they get, they're not going ot off themselves.

      By that logic, I gave my girlfriend her MA by encouraging her to go to grad school. Give me a break.

      In the end, they, and only they, are responsible for thier actions. That "peer pressure" copout didn't work when it was extracted from the ass of the "War on Drugs" in the 80s, and it doesn't excuse anything now.

    4. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by syousef · · Score: 0, Troll

      Encouraging someone to commit suicide is equivalent to killing him.

      Congratulations. That is the absolute stupidest and least correct statement I've read on /. so far this year. You should be really proud of yourself.

      --
      These posts express my own personal views, not those of my employer
    5. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by boobavon · · Score: 1

      Accomplice to murder? It's not always about pulling the trigger yourself. If you set someone up to die, you've got some of the blame to share.

    6. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by sp0rk173 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      At the same time, strong social pressures can overwhelm those "functional neural clusters" in certain situations. There's quite a bit of psychological evidence for this (see the Milgram experiments, Isen and Levin's phone booth experiment, Latane and Darley, Darley and Batson, the Zimbardo Prison experiment). It's fairly plausible that if you get four people together in a group suicide pact, where 3 are bent on killing themselves and one has second thoughts, that other one will probably still go through with it. If that one person were by themselves, however, they might not. It's definitely not murder, but there are group effects that come into play, no matter how well-functioning your neural clusters are.

      It comes with being a social animal.

    7. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by geminidomino · · Score: 1

      If you set someone up to die, you've got some of the blame to share.

      Which is not remotely the same thing. Plotting to set someone up to get killed isn't the same thing as sitting idly by and doing nothing while they do, nor even passively encouraging them to do so.

      If you're an active participant in a setup is one thing. Claiming that you might as well have pulled the trigger for "encouraging" is just naive hyperbole.

    8. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by KDR_11k · · Score: 1

      Assisting them even through psychological reinforcement is illegal. It's not murder of course but it can still net you quite some jailtime.

      --
      Justice is the sheep getting arrested while an impartial judge declares the vote void.
    9. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      so, by your logic, perhaps encouraging my girlfriend to give me anal is the same as getting it?
      Not quite, buddy :(

    10. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      LOL. If someone kills themself due to peer pressure it isn't murder. At best it's a mercy killing, at worst a Darwin Award.

    11. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by JPribe · · Score: 1

      Uh, Jonestown anyone....

      --

      Why go fast when you can go anywhere? O|||||||O
    12. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by m50d · · Score: 1

      That doesn't make it murder, they've still asked for it, heck, they're still doing it themselves. Would you say going and stealing from the store is equivalent to not only stealing but also forcing all your friends to do so? You could argue it's equivalent to euthanasia - after all, how do you know someone asking for that would have killed themselves in the end?

      --
      I am trolling
    13. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "It comes with being a social animal."

      No, it comes from being a mindless puppet. There have been many instances where a large group of my friends wanted to do something (like go to the club...much easier decided than suicide) where I have refrained. I've turned down sex offers from beautiful, non-prostitute women (yes, I am a man and no, I'm not gay). I also still drive around in an old Ford Taurus, despite the fact that many of my friends have Corvette's, Firebird's and Mustang's (my girlfriend drives an S2000, still much nicer than my car).

      Group pressure only affects the weak minded. If it influences your decisions more than your own mind does, it's time for you to seek help.

    14. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by mboverload · · Score: 1

      > Suicide pacts encourage people to commit suicide, while in normal conditions the person could decide not to do it at the last minute. But in a group, this could result in peer pressure conditions. Encouraging someone to commit suicide is equivalent to killing him.

      Are you fucking KIDDING ME?

      I don't care how much of a impressionable dumbfuck you are, you don't kill yourself juse because it's "cool." I think I'm going to throw up.

    15. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by Errtu76 · · Score: 1

      And this comment was modded insightful? Insightful? Because you said it's a stupid and incorrect comment? INSIGHTFUL?

      *sigh*

      I disagree even. The comment made perfect sense. If you're not 100% sure of killing yourself, and somebody steps up and 'convinces' you that you should kill yourself ... yeah, it's basicly the same as killing the person yourself.

    16. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by anarchyboy · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Except that people contemplating suicide arent normally in complete control of their senses, if someone has depression its going to leave them a lot more vulnerable to someone incouraging them to kill themselves than if it was suggested to you or I.

    17. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by Cili · · Score: 1
      I don't care how much of a impressionable dumbfuck you are, you don't kill yourself juse because it's "cool." I think I'm going to throw up.
      If one is such an impressionable dumbfuck and kills himself just 'cause it's cool, it's his problem - just evolution an work. One more Darwin Award coming right up!
    18. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by ValiSystem · · Score: 2, Insightful

      People you kill don't want to die (or why kill them, then ?). I would not say Encouraging someone to commit suicide but Help someone to commit suicide because that's something hard to do. And when you help someone, they reply thank you. There is a deep moral difference with muder, isn't it ?

    19. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      remind s me of an old mad magazine comic involving russian roulette
      something like six people in blank room seating on wooden chairs all in a row
      first person - click
      second person -click
      etc.
      fifth person -click
      sixth person stands up and shoots other five

    20. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by chadbailey · · Score: 1

      Wait... its a pact. The others wont know if you didnt do it. There would be no peer pressue. Stupid people. Wait... if you are thinking about it then you are stupid. Nevermind.

    21. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by chris+macura · · Score: 1

      If you left out the part about bueatiful women and sex offers, we just might have believed you! Nerd. :)

    22. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by k.a.f. · · Score: 1

      Encouraging someone to commit suicide is equivalent to killing him.

      I think the word you are looking for is related.

    23. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What about it? The majority of the people there (especially the kids) had no idea what they were drinking.

    24. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by JPribe · · Score: 1

      OK, those fools and their comet...better? You're right about Jonestown, my mistake.

      --

      Why go fast when you can go anywhere? O|||||||O
    25. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by syousef · · Score: 1

      And this comment was modded insightful? Insightful? Because you said it's a stupid and incorrect comment? INSIGHTFUL?

      Yeah. Guess what, there are people out there that have a different opinion to you. Perhaps even the opposite opinion. Amazing isn't it.

      But don't worry I later got modded down as overrated and troll because /. modding is after all a popularity contest.

      The comment made perfect sense. If you're not 100% sure of killing yourself, and somebody steps up and 'convinces' you that you should kill yourself ... yeah, it's basicly the same as killing the person yourself.

      The statement is false. It's false from a moral standpoint. It's false from a legal standpoint. It's false from a physical standpoint. It's just plain WRONG.

      Lets start with the obvious. It's physically incorrect to say it's the same thing to convince someone to kill themselves or to kill them. One requires your cooperation. The other does not. One requires something physical beyond words, the other does not.

      Next lets tackle legal. If I convince you to commit a crime, there may be a penalty or a separate crime associated. If I help you plan it for instance that might be conspiracy. If not it might be incitement. Either way the law deals with the act of convincing someone to commit a criminal act separately from participating in the act. This makes sense too. If I push you over the edge so to speak, you still have to take some responsibility for your own actions. (That is key. A person who kills themself is the MOST responsible for their own action).

      Which leads nicely into morally. It's very wrong to take advantage of someone's vulnerability and make them harm themself, but that doesn't release the person who is pushed over the edge, and who has a free will from their responsibility.

      So basically take your sentimental and inaccurate BS and your unfounded criticism elsewhere.

      --
      These posts express my own personal views, not those of my employer
    26. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by zopf · · Score: 1

      Exactly. The human brain's "neural clusters" have evolved for group behavior. There is a very strong correlation between cortical size and social group size in primates. At least some of this increasing brain mass must be devoted to social behavior. So if the brain is simply functioning in the way that it has evolved to, why should we stop it?

      The major purpose of law in society is to preserve the integrity of the society, meaning to protect its existence. A society of people who kill themselves cannot last long. Therefore, assuming that suicide is a natural tendency at times, the society that survives will be the society that can prevent suicide. In a way, a system to prevent suicide in the general population is an evolutionary advantage. Assuming that we want our society to survive, we cannot let suicide be an acceptable general practice.

      --
      Did you see the pool? They flipped the bitch!
    27. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by scumbaguk · · Score: 1

      Why not assume the converse, that suicude is natures way of keeping geens of those predispositioned to depression out of the pool?

    28. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by zopf · · Score: 1

      That's not really the converse. That's an integral part of my idea. While I assume nature has no intent, I would agree that suicide (especially early in life) does lessen the frequency of the genes that predispose an individual to suicide. But consider that depression is a state that a large portion of the population will experience at some point in life. The evolution of a law to prevent that suicide can occur far quicker than the evolution of genes to prevent it, as even the legal system is straightforward in comparison to the human body. Therefore, the society that benefits from that law will have a much greater chance of survival than a similar society lacking that law.

      --
      Did you see the pool? They flipped the bitch!
    29. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by scumbaguk · · Score: 1

      I disagree you seem to assume that the only factor in survival of the spicies is sheer numbers.

      Having a poulace who are happy and fulfilled in there life may turn out to be more important to the survial of our species then by us simply trying our hardest to prevent the deaths of thoses who want to die.

      In sever clinical depression life is hell, keeping someone alive and trapped in a ravaged mind is akin to tourture.

      IMO any society which cares for the rights and feelings of an individual can not restrict the right to kill ones self.

    30. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by Errtu76 · · Score: 1

      Lovely that you can convince yourself that this is OK to do. I'm happy for you. The rest of humanity will still consider it wrong though. But whatever works for you...

    31. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by Errtu76 · · Score: 1

      Except in this case, there won't be any replies :P

    32. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by inline_four · · Score: 1

      I'm no lawyer nor a theologian, but there is logic to this. The key factor is not that someone is simply encouraging someone else to kill themselves, but that they are doing it knowing the person is sensitive to that sort of talk and their words may have a serious impact at the moment of truth or hesitation. Legally, it's probably not unlike laws that make an exception to free speech when the speech in question advocates violence -- you're not doing it yourself, but you're having a real impact and you know it.

      --
      Alexey
    33. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      zimbardo showed how easily individuals could be talked into torturing someone with electricvity, as oppsed to commiting sucide, when they were encoraged by an "authority figure" in a "white coat", as opposed to being pressured by their peers.

    34. Re:This isn't about suicide. It's about MURDER. by syousef · · Score: 1

      It's very wrong to take advantage of someone's vulnerability and make them harm themself

      Lovely that you can convince yourself that this is OK to do

      Either you didn't bother to read what I wrote, or you're retarded. Which is it?

      --
      These posts express my own personal views, not those of my employer
  81. Let them commit Harri Krishna by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0



    That's the way of the summo wrestler

    1. Re:Let them commit Harri Krishna by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's harakiri, you simpleton. And the less vulgar (and more preferred term among the Japanese) is seppuku.

    2. Re:Let them commit Harri Krishna by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      *whoosh*

  82. A few comments by woolio · · Score: 1

    I suspect the peace that prevailed during the 2000 and 2004 elections occured more due to ignorance rather than by informed tolerance. People will riot in LA because one man was mis-treated by the police, yet there was no-riot in our *democracy* being blantly mis-treaded and manipulated (by diebold)??? It is sadly amusing that Clinton was nearly impeached for having a little fun during business hours.

    Look at where most of the oil goes: energy/heating and transportation. So why do we continue to waste it? Even the recent Lexus commercial seems to make fun at all the attempts at electric cars in their effort to advertise their gas-guzzling "hybrid" SUV. If we adopted the European sensibility and transportation systems, we could reduce gasoline consumption by 75%, and be independent of the OPEC, etc, etc.

    Yes, oil consumption is rising exponentially, so some might argue that a few cutbacks won't buy much time.. But I fear the world will work itself into such a frenzy that countries will be obliterated (perhaps economically) before the remaining oil/new energy sources is/are found.

    I saw an interesting exhibit in Houston museum. It talked about the measures we were taking to save energy, be environmentally-friendly, etc. One item talked about a novel concept in california, where special lanes were designed exclusively for "vehicles carrying more than one person".

    WHY is the concept of carrying more than 1 person inside a 5000lb SUV/ 4x4 Truck, etc such a novel concept??? WHY??? WHY?????????

    1. Re:A few comments by kadathseeker · · Score: 1

      Clinton was impeached for lying under oath, and should have been for several other things, including rejecting the Osama on a a silver platter from the Pakistanis.

      Diebold probably srewed up the election, but remember that prisoners and dead people mysteriously wound up voting Democrat.

      L.A. is just plain fucked up. As is California.

      Cars are a much bigger (pun intended) part of our culture, primarily because our country is bigger, and having a car to freely travel on nice highways through several states without paperwork or checkpoints is a manifestation of freedom and individuality that has become a staple of our national identity and isn't likely to change soon. Also, we have this notion that we must be busy and doing something all the time, so having a car always available is important, and even essential when all members of a family must be in different places at nearly the same time.

      --
      The 'Net is a waste of time, and that's exactly what's right about it. - William Gibson
  83. Re:Your poor spelling and lack of cultural awarene by Baddas · · Score: 1

    Something about your comment reminds me of transmetropolitan

    "I so badly want to kill everyone in this room right now. Even the children...

    Especially the children."

    Gotta love the spite.

  84. Bah by XMilkProject · · Score: 1

    Alot of silly Anti-Japanese comments I'm seeing here. I doubt any of these people have ever been to Japan or met a Japanese person.

    The Japanese are an amazing people, they cherish work ethics, integrity, and family values.

    If anything, the higher suicide rate is due to the huge dignity these people have. Becuase they are so dignified, they are more ashamed of failure than Americans (for example) might be.

    The rest of the world could learn alot from the Japanese people. Remember, they've been over there for ~10,000 years, and substantially civilized for ~1500. They might just know something that us Americans haven't learned in our few hundred year reign.

    That being said, I hate chopsticks.

    --
    Big ones, small ones, some as big as yer 'ead!
    Give 'em a twist, a flick o' the wrist...
    1. Re:Bah by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      americans are wonderful people also. they cherish work ethics, integrity, and family values.

    2. Re:Bah by XMilkProject · · Score: 1

      In my time in Japan I found that they work extrodinarly long work weeks, and even the lowest wage employees (McDonalds, Gas Station) conducted themselves with all the dignity and courtesty of a high-wage business man.

      This is only the impression of a Western worker who was in an unfamiliar culture, but the motivation and quality of the people seen in all work environments seemed far above what I see in America. Maybe this is due to the fact that there are so many people, and such competition for even the lowest of jobs, that people take their jobs far more seriously than in the U.S.

      --
      Big ones, small ones, some as big as yer 'ead!
      Give 'em a twist, a flick o' the wrist...
  85. Darwin Awards by CriminalNerd · · Score: 1

    Too bad those people are not qualified to receive Darwin awards. XD

  86. Dorks. by corrosive_nf · · Score: 3, Funny

    I love how a bunch of white dorks who watch anime, listen to j-pop and beat off to tentacle rape suddenly have this vast insight into the culture of japan. STFU dorks.

    1. Re:Dorks. by bprime · · Score: 1

      hahaha, you succeed it.

  87. Re:1st post by smvp6459 · · Score: 1

    In Communist Russia 1st post has you.

  88. Don't be selfish... by Simonetta · · Score: 1

    Don't be selfish... Heaven needs many many virgins. After all, every dumbass Palistinian who gets on a bus or walks into a fast food place with a bomb wrapped around his waist expects to get 72 virgins. They got to come from someplace.

        What do you expect? That there is a virgin factory in Heaven? That the angels can just crank them out like DVD players? Hell no. They come from earth, just every one of the dumbass shaaheeds who blows himself up.

        You just gotta feel sorry for the dumbass shaaheed who blows up a day-care center or a convent. "Yes," the master angel at the gate says, "here are your virgins. First come, first served. Yes, I realize that they are all either 2 years old or 65 years old, but they are virgins. You got what you came for. Don't like it? Well, fool, you should have thought of that before you walked into the day care center with a bomb. and you might want to make yourself scarce when their parents get up here. Paybacks a bitch, and eterity's a long time. Move On! Next!"

    1. Re:Don't be selfish... by FooAtWFU · · Score: 1

      Actually, according to one of those darned controversial Danish cartoons, they're fresh out!

      --
      The World Wide Web is dying. Soon, we shall have only the Internet.
  89. Oh, they Japanese squeal just like the Koreans by Ogemaniac · · Score: 1

    did. I can't remember a car accident, but I do remember hearing about deaths and rapes in Japan. You are right, the crime rate for the soldiers here in Japan is typical for their age group. People who blather about this stuff are falling for typical anti-American crap. (Not that there are not legitimate reasons to criticize the US, but it drives me nuts that 90% of anti-American arguments are such childish nonsense that I can find no other words for it but bigotry and hypocrisy).

  90. 91 out of 100,000? Not quite. by Sporkus · · Score: 3, Informative
    Japan's suicide rate is not 91 per 100,000 people. The actual rate is closer to 25 per 100,000--a little less alarming, but still cause for concern.

    According to TFA, 91 is the number of suicide pact-related deaths in Japan in 2005. That is, 91 out of the entire population of Japan (around 130 million) died via suicide pacts (which encompass only a portion of total suicides). The 2003 data quote in the article gives a more realistic rate of ~27 per 100,000 and the WHO lists the 2002 average rate at 24 per 100,000.

  91. Suicide COunt by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0



    We should be looking at the overall Suicide rate for Japan. Consider Japan's population. Japan is seriously overcrowded.

    ----
      More than 34,000 Japanese took their own lives in 2003

  92. Re:Yet another problem here in America: by AlterTick · · Score: 1
    Additionally, I never stated that we must ignore all others' problems; I merely stated that I believed our own problems are more important than _this_ problem.

    And I believe the various wars around the world are a bigger problem than US domestic homicides. So the fuck what? Neither are germane to the discussion. Bringing either up in a discussion of Japanese suicide is simply obvious trolling.

    --
    Conclusion: the Empire squashes the Federation like a bug. Accept it.
  93. Japanese Culture by CB-in-Tokyo · · Score: 5, Interesting

    "I have to wonder, what is it about Japanese culture that produces these people in such high numbers?"

    When you says these people I am going to assume you means suicides in general, and not just suicide clubs. First of all I want to say that 26 people in 2 months having died in suicide clubs, is likely FAR below the number that actually happened with clubs, and is definitely far below the number of actual suicides.

    I take the train in Tokyo to work everyday often, probably once per week, a train that I am riding on is delyed due to a "jishin jikko" which basically means self death incidient. Suicide is common in Japan. As to what cultural aspects influence this, not being a cultural expert, I can only guess at several.

    1) Historically suicide was a way to maintain, or regain your honour. Honour and spirit are very important in Japanese culture. It is more important to the older generation than the younger generation, however, the younger generation cannot help but having these ideals ingrained into their subconscious.

    2) Group thinking. The Japanese are extremely group oriented. The group is more important than the individual. Being ostracized by your group, and being in a position where you have let your group down can be extremely painful. It can be painful in any culture, but in Japan it is something more. There is an expression in Japan that says "The nail that sticks out must be hammered down!" This means that everyone should be alike and that anyone who is different should be forced to comply or exiled. For people who have never been in a group, or have been exiled from a group, the idea of joining a group again, where you are understood if even for a short time, could be a big motivator to join a suicide club.

    3) Pride. Japanese people are very proud and adverse to failure. There have been cases where people have starved to death rather than go onto any kind of government assitance. There are very clear cultural rules regarding what is proper or improper behaviour and people would rather literally die than break some of those rules and be shamed in front of their friends and family.

    4) Gaman suru! Gama suru essentially means to endure. In Japan, it is expected for people to endure hardships. To silently put up with tough situations and keep going. This is seen in many aspects of life here, whether it is pain, tough business situations, or the loss of a loved one. When the pressures get too high, it is hard to be able to talk to people and often suicide is seen as the easiest, most honourable out.

    5) School system. The school system here is incredibly competitive. The study ethic here is higher than anywhere else I have seen in the world, and the pressure to perform is incredible. Students often finish school and then go to a private school for more intense training in the evenings. Getting into a good university here is the hardest part, and it can determine your life. Pressure and failures at school are huge stresses on the students, and it is often easier to kill yourself, than to admit failure.

    If you look at the reasons above, and combine them together, it paints a better picture. There are probably reasons I have missed but I think the picture I have drawn is essentially correct. I have been in Japan for 6 years now, and am getting married to a Japanese woman in April. When we have children, I won't want them to go through a typical school in Japan.

    Cheers,

    CB

    1. Re:Japanese Culture by imipak · · Score: 1
      There is an expression in Japan that says "The nail that sticks out must be hammered down!"
      "sleep can't hide the thoughts splitting through my mind / shadows aren't clean, false mirrors too many people awake / if you stand up like a nail then you will be knocked down / I've been too honest with myself, I should have lied like everybody else" -'Faster', Manic Street Preachers (1994)
    2. Re:Japanese Culture by jumpfroggy · · Score: 1

      I remember an incident while I was living in japan. Some kid was studying for the final high school tests (the ones that determine basically where you can go to college, and therefore what your place is in japanese life [simplified]) and he went a little crazy. Cut off the heads of his parents? Somebody, and put them in front of his school. Crazy stuff.

      The pressure is incredible from the factors you described (which is a good summary from an outsider's point of view, I had the same ideas while there). It's funny, my friends' views of japan and japanese people are very different from mine. They think of japanese people as very polite, very happy/smiley. They do act that way a lot of the time. But underneath it I see something else.

      I don't mean to say that japanese people are all fake. I just see the immense cultural pressures as affecting a lot of the population. It is a good guess at an explanation for things like the suicides and the general sexual perversion. Whether it's different from other cultures is always hard to say, but for me it does feel distinctly different. Almost orwellian/big brother-ish. But then, at that point I'm going off into a rant. Good post, parent.

    3. Re:Japanese Culture by CB-in-Tokyo · · Score: 1

      They think of japanese people as very polite, very happy/smiley. They do act that way a lot of the time. But underneath it I see something else.

      I don't mean to say that japanese people are all fake. I just see the immense cultural pressures as affecting a lot of the population. It is a good guess at an explanation for things like the suicides and the general sexual perversion. Whether it's different from other cultures is always hard to say, but for me it does feel distinctly different.


      Thanks jumpfroggy. You hit the nail on the head (it must have been a deteru kugi!) The Japanese are no politer than anyone else. If you ride the trains with them, you can find it downright rude (though it is only rude from an outsider's perspective). The Japanese language contains very few swear words. If you want to curse someone out, you raise your voice a little and just speak to them in less polite terms than they would feel entitled to. This of course only translates into normal politeness levels for us English speakers.

      But underneath it I see something else.

      The Japanese have a powerful cultural concept called Honne and Tatamae. Honne is what is actually felt and kept inside, and Tatamae is what you express outwardly. In my culture, this is called being Two-faced but in Japanese culture this exists to protect the Wa or harmony. This goes back to the group aspect. Direct questions are rude, disagreement is rude, my friend here used to teach English, and he said he could never get the Japanese to deate an issue because everyone would "agree" no matter what they really felt.

      Now, my experience is basically Tokyo Biased. I have found in other areas, such as Osaka, and Kyuushuu, people tend to be far more direct.

      The incident you described happened not that long ago. I am not sure of the details. I thought it was another student that was killed, but it may have been the parents. I also thought the student was the one who put head in front of the school.

      I don't think the sexual perversion here is any greater than anywhere else, but it certainly is more mainstream and accepted.

      How long were you in Japan and what part did you live in?

      But then, at that point I'm going off into a rant

      Hehehehe that makes me laugh for some reason. I think everyone who lives here has many a rant with his fellow gaijin over beers! It is different world here, but I enjoy it!

      Cheers,

      CB

    4. Re:Japanese Culture by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      Regarding your post: The romanization is "jinshin jiko". It's most likely less than once per week. If you have rail near a dense enough population center, you get suicide. Suicide is common throughout the world.

      1) Bullshit. Seppuku is just a way of executing a death sentence. It's from an archaic culture of a small Japanese minority. It's relevant to today as much as witch hunting and slavery.
      2) Bullshit. It's "deru kugi wa utareru," not "deru kugi wa utarenakereba naranai." It's a descriptive idiom, not a prescriptive one. Know the difference.
      3) Bullshit.
      4) Bullshit.
      5) Bullshit (the part about suicide. the rest I don't care)

      Every culture has figured out suicide isn't benefitial, and hence they all naturally oppose it. Good luck with the marriage.

    5. Re:Japanese Culture by CB-in-Tokyo · · Score: 1

      I appreciate your corrections, your Japanese teacher would be proud, however your in your effort to be proper and eloquent you forgot to elaborate the following points.

      3) Bullshit.
      4) Bullshit.
      5) Bullshit (the part about suicide. the rest I don't care)


      And of course your first point is incorrect.

      Cheers,

      CB

    6. Re:Japanese Culture by caranha · · Score: 1

      Once per week on YOUR line? What line did you use? I take the subway (chiyoda) everyday and a yamanote/tokyu combo once a week for commuting to work (besides those extra odd trips for everything else), and I can only remember one suicide last year.

      You know that your family will have to pay a hefty sum to JR or Tokyo Metro if you suicide on one of their lines, right? I don't remember the value right now, but it was easily over 1M yen. That had greatly reduced train suicides, and I'm pretty sure other companies follow a similar policy.

      Not to say that japanese don't suicide a lot. They do. but your number of one suicide a week on one specific line seems a bit too high even for Japan.

    7. Re:Japanese Culture by juancnuno · · Score: 1

      > When we have children, I won't want them to go through a typical school in Japan.

      Will you have a choice?

  94. Statistics, shmaplistics by Lactoso · · Score: 1
    "In addition, readers need to do their homework before posting factual errors or made-up numbers regarding its prevalence. More than 40% of the ..."

    Is it true that 98.2% of all statistics quoted on Slashdot are made up on the spot?

    1. Re:Statistics, shmaplistics by slothman32 · · Score: 1

      I was thinking the exact same thing.
      Except it is 81.5%
      That does mean 19.5 are in fact correct.
      Something to ponder if you want to kill brain cells.

      P.S. I always seem to think of the numbers 67% and 83%.
      Maybe they aren't all made up on the spot.

      --
      Why don't you guys have friends or journals?
    2. Re:Statistics, shmaplistics by Lactoso · · Score: 1
      "P.S. I always seem to think of the numbers 67% and 83%. Maybe they aren't all made up on the spot."

      Or, perhaps, you used the improper gauge tinfoil in your hat? :-)

  95. Zombies? by Paraplex · · Score: 1

    The highest suicide rate...

    and the highest consumption of raw/undercooked meat.

    hmm.

  96. Everyone is gone... by sudorm · · Score: 1

    If everyone is committing suicide then who is going to stick around to organize the "clubs"?

  97. Re: Too much ice cream is a bad thing though too by chris_mahan · · Score: 2, Insightful

    You laugh, but in america, you are a number.

    Let me translate that for you:

    America cares about your FICO score and the amount of your assets ONLY.

    That's it.

    Now. America and Japan are both very materialistic societies. (My wife is Japanese, from Japan, so I know).

    American society, however, does make some allowance for "weird" and "geeky" people. In Japan, watch out if you don't toe the line. Otaku is a bad word over there (it's changing, ever so slowly).

    In Japan, your criteria for "success" and "who you are" is "what high-school and college did you graduate from?"

    In the US, you can change you FICO over time, and you can make more money over time. In Japan, you can never change your less-than-perfect educational achievements, so some people feel they would rather die than live a lifetime of ridicule and shame, forever to live in the shadows of those who have "excelled".

    My wife was pushed to excel by her parents. She rebelled. She didn't kill herself. She left Japan. She said she could never "live" there. It's a good thing too.

    I had 25 japanese at my house last night, from 1.3 year old to 40 year olds. They love Japan because it's their homeland. They love America because they feel accepted.

    If the Japanese have their own children killing themselves, they should look in the mirror.

    --

    "Piter, too, is dead."

  98. Windows can kill you by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    For real, internet and computer addiction can kill you. Computers are crack cocaine. People stare at these boxes like they were tv sets, becoming dull, fat, and depressed. They think they are doing work, but in the end, they're productivity is a big fat zero, and they wake up old and grey in the end and all they have to show for their life was moving bits around... albeit by the billions... still nothing but bits.. which are nothing in themselves, no more than the state of a light switch is off or on.

    What Intel never wanted you to know in the 80's...

    I could preach down to you and prozelytize, but alas, the addict, its me.

  99. Re:Your Rights Online: Internet Suicide Pacts Surg by tftp · · Score: 1

    The TFA explains that governments are trying to suppress online suicide clubs - sites where people talk online about their plans and ideas and desires; the people are supposed to have a right to talk about pretty much anything. Classified correctly, IMO; it's not anyone's else business but those people themselves.

  100. its actually a serious matter by graphak · · Score: 1

    First of all to those who joke..its not a joking matter. To those who advocate suicide awareness groups, discussion, and prevention..my props to you. Just wanted to say how devistating suicide can be, not only to the obvious victim, but also to family and friends..My brother took his life last summer, he was an American..genious student..had everything going for him...needless to say it was devastating. I hope people will not treat suicide as taboo, as it is a seriously impacting decision that can be prevented. Please consider your comments before posting.

  101. Maybe when you're too busy trying to survive... by Chordonblue · · Score: 1

    ...you don't have time to get all 'emo'. We may have made ourselves richer but happier...? Not necessarily.

    --
    "...Well, there's egg and bacon; egg sausage and bacon; egg and spam; egg bacon and spam; egg bacon sausage and spam..."
  102. The Wrongfulness of Murder by Errandboy+of+Doom · · Score: 2, Funny

    If encouraging suicide and murder were moral equivalents, then telling people that heaven, nirvana or reincarnation awaits would be as bad as stabbing them.

    Wait, I think I see your point...

  103. Suicide squad... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ATTACK!

  104. Look to history... by Chris+Bradshaw · · Score: 1

    Look to history and more specifically, Bushido for hints as to why this is so pervasive in Japan. In a culture where family honor, achievement, and self mastery are values are pitted above all else - it's no surprise that in this ever increasingly bizarre and f&$#ed up world things like this are happening. Again, I second the comment about Darwin - not in a rude way, but in a very real sense... this is a very blatant example of modern natural selection at the top of its game.

    --
    Get your Windows Malicious Software Removal Tool Here for FREE! - http://fedora.redhat.com
  105. Did anybody read correctly ? by aepervius · · Score: 1

    26 death in two monthes. Big effing deal. There is more death per auto (unwanted death) per DAY. Heck those sort of suicide pact doesn't even begin to make a dent in the extrem majority of normal (lonely) suicide of 99+%. But, hey, it is internet so slashdoter are "concerned". And it is Japan, so prejudice come out of the wood. There are probably even more death from preventable things like AIDS or heart failure per DAY (again unwanted death) than internet pact suicide (wanted death).

    --
    C. Sagan : A demon haunted world:
    http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0345409469/
    visit randi.org
  106. Re:Your poor spelling and lack of cultural awarene by Sleet01 · · Score: 0

    Thank you very much ^_^

    --
    -- Let him who is without spelling error ignite the first flame --
  107. Last two months? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    These Japanese internet 'suicide clubs' accounted for at least 26 deaths in the last 2 months.

    ...and the date on the article that says that is Tuesday, 7 December, 2004, 12:08 GMT.

  108. why are you trolling? by imthesponge · · Score: 1

    oh right you're a coward

  109. Top10 List by kvant · · Score: 0

    Top then for you, because we all like them.

    per 100 000 people.

    1 Lithuania 42.0
    2 Russia 37.4
    3 Belarus 35.0
    4 Latvia 34.3
    5 Estonia 33.2
    6 Hungaryk 32.1
    7 Slovenia 30.9
    8 Ukraine 29.4
    9 Kazakhstan 28.7
    10 Finland 24.3

  110. Assisted Suicide by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Considering how isolated many folks are in today's society, and with that being a trend that's only going to increase, it's time to stop treating suicide as a taboo subject. I'm not advocating Futurama-style suicide booths or anything, but clearly you are going to be completely unable to prevent someone from killing himself if that's what he desires. If you place a quick, painless assisted suicide as the last optional step in a treatment program, then maybe these people who are scared to die alone will stop seeking out other suicidal people to reinforce their desire to die, and instead will get help from people qualified to give it.

    If it turns out they really do want to die, it's going to happen anyway, so you might as well make it as humane, comfortable, and discrete as possible.

  111. FUD by BoxedFlame · · Score: 1

    For a site who claims to be against FUD so much, it's sad to see the basic myth of Japans high suicide rates hasn't been checked against actual facts. Also it's sad to see users commenting adding yet more FUD to the equation (like suicides being very common among japanese girls, not true). Check the facts please.

  112. Hmm, yes. by Elwood+P+Dowd · · Score: 1

    The reason no one at my office kills themselves must be because of the weekly fistfights.

    Brilliant analysis, sir.

    --

    There are no trails. There are no trees out here.
  113. In other news... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The number of internet users has gone up in japan.

    1. Re:In other news... by chawly · · Score: 1

      from across the great divide ?

      --
      How many beans make five, anyhow ? ... Charles Walmsley
  114. Under-reported by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It's also been estimated that Japan under-reports its suicide numbers, among other things.

    1. Re:Under-reported by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's also been reported that vile anti-Japanese people are full of shit, among other things.

  115. i know why. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    They can't wait any longer for the PS3.

    im just kidding.

  116. Don't. by Qbertino · · Score: 1

    I had a suicidal phase in my early twens. I tricked myself through it with the Steppenwolf trick (Steppenwolf by Herman Hesse, good classic novel): "If killing myself is the only option left, I might aswell carry on and see what comes out of this bizar nightmare."
    That was a smart idea. My life hasn't improved (it was very good back then allready), but my perception of it has. Thruth is, suiciders are, in a way, pittyfull, self-focused 'sissies'. I'm glad I didn't do anything stupid back then.

    That said, I've read alot from people who where clinically dead and came back and have stories to tell about other dead people they met. That's simple put and getting it right would take to long, but check out the books from Raymond Moody, George Ritchie and Robert Allan Monroe if your interested in the details. All these people basically tell the same things you can find in the tibetan and egyptian books of the dead. Some of it is very interesting indeed.

    The most scary and insightfull piece detailing on suiciders after death I've found just the other day though, in a lecture from Rudolf Steiner (early last century philosopher and anthroposophist/theosoph). Curiously enough it sort of emphasises what I've found out myself about being suicidal:

    (roughly translated from the german original)
    [...going into detail of afterlife and the initial difficulties in shedding ties to the physical world after death (aka 'purgatory')...] "Amoung the various emotions man carries throughout his life is an underlying joy of being alive, a joy of life in general, of having a physical body. Thus it is one of the most intense feelings of loss not having a physical body anymore. Now we see the misery and pain all those people feel that have come to death by suicide. While with dying naturally, the seperation of the three body [he's talking physical, etherical and astral body, anthoposophical 'techno-babble'] is a relatively easy one - even with a stroke seperation and death is prepared - sudden seperation of these in a heathly condition by a violent death - such as that of one commiting suicide - causes an imediate intense sence of loss, that causes terrible suffering. [...] The commiter of suicide starts for a scary search of the suddenly withdrawn physical body. It is a terrible fate. Nothing can be compared to it."

    And then comes the really interesting part:

    " Some may now say: 'One that wants to commit suicide doesn't long for life within the physical body - otherwise he wouln't have ended it'. That is an illusion. It is especially the suicidal that longs to much for the joys of physical life. But because circumstances he's finds himself in deny him those joys he longs for, that's why he chooses death. And that's why the misery of loss due to the lack of a physical body is exeptionally intense for those who commited suicide."

    Makes a scary sort of sense, doesn't it?

    Bottom line: No matter if you believe in Afterlife or not, don't kill yourself purposefully. It could be that an exeptionally painfull walk though purgatory is waiting for you. And once you find out if there is an afterlife or not by killing youself, it will be to late :-) .

    --
    We suffer more in our imagination than in reality. - Seneca
  117. "Suicide Club" - The Movie by spdt · · Score: 1

    Maybe it was this movie -> http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0312843/

    Its US title is "Suicide Club", and has a lot of eerie similarities to this story.

  118. True story about the death penalty for suicide by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    There is a famous case of a guy who tried to commit suicide by cutting his throat in early 19th century England. He failed, was patched up, tried, convicted and hanged. But his self-inflicted throat wound reopened under the rope, allowing him to breathe although hanging by his neck. So he didn't die. That was no good, so they cut him down and smothered him with a pillow or something.

    I have forgotten what the moral of the story was...

    1. Re:True story about the death penalty for suicide by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hanging does not kill by suffication, it breaks the neck, having a slit throat would do absolutely nothing to help anyone survive a hanging.

    2. Re:True story about the death penalty for suicide by Ced_Ex · · Score: 1

      Hanging does not kill by suffication, it breaks the neck, having a slit throat would do absolutely nothing to help anyone survive a hanging.

      The neck only breaks if the person fell some distance before the rope pulled tight. If he just hung without the snap the neck won't break and he supposedly chokes to death.

      --
      Live forever, or die trying.
  119. Mod parent up by hhghghghh · · Score: 1

    I know that this is also the case for most of Europe (except certain remote regions of Transylvania).

  120. Japan has normal suicide rates by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    According to NationMaster, Japan has completely average suicide rates: 25 males/100,000 people per year and 12 gemales/100,000 per year. For the US the figures are 19.8 and 4.4, for Russia 74.1 and 13.3.

    http://www.nationmaster.com/graph-T/hea_sui_rat_ma l

    Someone should check their figures before posting crap.

  121. New on-line service: CPQ by thomasj · · Score: 1
    The famous Harry Kearrie (known from the games Self Destruct I+II and Bagdad Bomber) has created an on-line service named CPQ. The service is open for all ages and cultures, but is mostly targeted the Japanese Youth. The purpose is to form small groups of participents that can discuss their daily problems and guide each other to a way out. What attracts the yougsters are the explicit way the participents may show how they cut to the bone of the inner issues and display that they have the guts to do something about it.

    Since people join, learn the techniques and are gone, it is important to recuit new members to the service. Some parents criticize how young people are deluded into thinking that they are helping their family too, but they often stand behind with the mess. To this issue Harry Kearrie has no comments but suggests parents to look to the Japanese legacy of honor in understanding the new wave among the youth.

    --
    :-) = I am happy
    :^) = I am happy with my big nose
    C:\> = I am happy with my OS
  122. I disagree. by lorcha · · Score: 2, Informative
    No, they are not,
    Yes, they are. Using your own source, the suicide rate in Japan is the 11th-highest of the 100 countries listed. As a point of comparison, the US is 44th. Again, from your own source, the average suicide rate between males and females in the US is 10.85 per 100,000, while the average in Japan is 25.3 per 100,000 (roughly 2.5x the US rate).

    So, yes, Japan has a notoriously high general suicide rate. You disagreed with GP by pointing out that Kazakhstan and a handfull of other countries have higher rates than Japan, but that hardly refutes GP's assertion that Japan has a notoriously high suicide rate.

    --
    "Avoid employing unlucky people - throw half of the pile of CVs in the bin without reading them." -- David Brent
    1. Re:I disagree. by gnasher719 · · Score: 1

      Please note that reported suicide rates very much depend on how the information is collected.

      For example: Medical doctor examines a corpse. There are indications that make a suicide more likely than natural depth. Relatives would be devastated if this is reported as a suicide. They may suffer financial hardship, because a life insurance won't pay. What the medical doctor will write into his report will very much depend on the culture he is living in, and the reported suicide rates will change accordingly.

    2. Re:I disagree. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Fag.

    3. Re:I disagree. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If you think 25.3 per 100,000 isn't low, you're exaggerating. Besides, the list doesn't mean anything. Suicide rates fluctuate. The BBC News article written by Anonymous Coward, however, states that Japan has the world's #1 suicide rate without giving any source. Did the BBC's AC write so based upon bad assumption rather than research?

    4. Re:I disagree. by fruitbane · · Score: 1

      Dude, the numbers are from 1999. The numbers from many other nations are more recent. Aside from the suicide surge listed in the article, I believe Japanese suicide rates dropped after 1999 (I was taking a sociology class at Waseda in 1998/1999 and we talked about the increase over previous years). 1999 was a bad year for Japan. Their economy is still shakey, but a little less unpredictable than it was then, with all the banking scandals and collapses. Hell, friends had account at some of the collapsing banks, and they were very worried. Mitsubishi, my bank at the time, held out, however.

    5. Re:I disagree. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      joining other ACs I should also point out that Japan has close to ZERO population growth.
      They actually have an administrative plan trying to figure out programs & incentives at increasing the population which estimates will be cut in 1/5 by 2050 due to the illness, elder deaths, and ow birthrates. suicides are an indicator that there is something that encourages this as well as zero population growth. the insane cost of living / unrealistic real-estate value vs. traditional values / work ethic.

      News article on population growth
      http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/4552 010.stm

      News article on Japanese women unlikely to wed
      http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/3694 230.stm

      News article on low birthrates
      http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/4065 647.stm

      What's odd about suicide pacts is that the demographics of the groups are spread. some are younger single men/women, teenagers, and mid-lifers.

      The poster CB-in-Tokyo has most of it correct especially the conformity part. I have a friend who moved back to Japan (student visa expired) who has emotional issues and before heading back was terrified. They didn't want to use a cellphone or conform and had their own happy little "group" here in the states. The harsh reality was there is very little use for a master's in psychology (didn't get into a doctorate program) in Japan because they're more concerned about the "group" than the individual's uh..."individuality".

      There's a saying I picked up from God knows where..."Joy is everlasting whereas happiness is fleeting"
      Meaning you can go shopping, talk with people you like, have fantastic vacations/outings, but they don't last. Joy is something you keep inside, memories, thoughts, and things you love about life; people, hobbies, culture and under-valued concepts. While no one is totally unique, we embrace diversity (well some of us do). We also conform but that's human nature too.

      In the states we are "somewhat" encouraged to explore, find, seek our "thing". We have people who switch jobs on average of 8 times before retiring (last time I checked).
      How many of us on slashdot are seen as quixotic?
      Quite a significant amount of us are not exactly loners, but nor are we in touch with all our neighbors or coworkers. I drop friends like a hat and pick up new ones when it suits me. I crave real conversation over small talk. Small talk is of little social value to me and is meaningless banter reserved for politeness sake (work, introductions, etc..)
      I pursue the things I like and to hell with anyone who tells me I should not. I read when everybody watches tv and I watch the programs I like alone instead of when everybody gathers around a show like a big social event. In short, I've got a few friends (including my wife) and can easily endure isolation from the "group".

      The problem as I see it is to Japan, silent endurance is like the asimov's 3 laws of robotics. They can only lead to revolution. And in a country where guns are banned, suicide is as much a huge statement of joylessness as you can get.

    6. Re:I disagree. by cloudmaster · · Score: 1

      Yes, if people lie, statistics may be slightly skewed. How insightful! Perhaps that invliadates all statistics gathered from people, because people might have lied?

  123. Posted On Darwin's Birthday - Priceless! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Well, from an evolutionary stand point,
    any combination of genes that produces a suicidal organism,
    that destroys itself before reproducing ... well - they just got taken out of the gene pool.

    Perhaps after a time suicides will drop off, because all the 'suicidal tendencies' genes have been removed from the population?

    A typical 'Western Christian' view of suicide by young people is that it is an act of selfishness,
    because of the unlimited needs in society, for a person who has been fed, raised, and cared for by
    their parents, to suddenly decide to die - that's such a needless cause of suffering to others and a
    waste of resources. Not to mention the tragedy of what the dead person is going to miss out on in life.

    In the USA if a young man is having a hard time making it, they are usually encouraged to join the military,
    to toughen them up and grow up, learn discipline and responsibility. (and get training and money for school).
    This applies only to the endless poor in America,
    rich senator's kids don't go to Iraq, they go to the spa and party in nightclubs.

  124. A quibble... by abb3w · · Score: 1
    POLICE: As if your life didn't suck enough, suicide is illegal, so now you have to go to jail.

    Actually, suicide isn't illegal in the US; it's attempted suicide that's illegal. It's the only crime where an attempt is an offense, but success is not. Which may say something about the "crime".

    --
    //Information does not want to be free; it wants to breed.
    1. Re:A quibble... by DavidTC · · Score: 1
      Um, suicide is attempted suicide, just like murder is also attempted murder. If they really wanted to charge a corpse with attempted suicide, they could. They did, indeed, attempt to commit suicide.

      The reason the police don't do anything is that when they discover, to their satisfaction, who a criminal was, and said criminal is dead, they just close the case. No sense in charging the dead, and legally that couldn't get through the court system.

      And now someone's going to go 'Why don't they charge murderers with attempted murder too, then?'. It's because you can't charge someone with two crimes for the exact same action, it's double jeopardy. You can charge someone with committing multiple crimes at once if the actions were technically seperate, but if one criminal action always includes another criminal action, you can't charge them for both, you have to pick one.

      This was used with hilarious effect when some state implimented a marijuana license and a fine if you didn't have a license, when marijuana was illegal, solely to hit drug user's pockets, and they arrested someone for possession and that. He pleaded guilty of failure to buy the license, and paid the fine, and then argued successfully in court that he couldn't tried for possession, as he'd already plead guilty to possessing unlicensed marijuana, and thus they couldn't charge him with, duh, possession of said marijuana.

      The state quickly repealed the license. Especially since the judge indicated that if the guy had attempted to get a license, and been rebuffed, he'd have accepted the guilty plead and thrown out the fine, as the state hadn't actually issued any licenses, so could hardly fine people who asked for one and didn't get it. And advised the defendant that, while it was legal to demand they return his now-licensed pot, that was probably a bad idea.

      --
      If corporations are people, aren't stockholders guilty of slavery?
  125. Investment opportunity, via Futurama! by mpitcavage · · Score: 1

    Here's my chance to open a chain of convenient suicide booths!

    1. Re:Investment opportunity, via Futurama! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      you've got 2 years to get started:"You are now dead. Thank you for using Stop'n'Drop. America's favorite suicide booth since 2008."

  126. Please don't make assumptions about my sources... by Garwulf · · Score: 1

    Thank you for commenting - it always is good to get input from somebody "on the ground floor" as it were. However, you are very mistaken about my sources. My information about Eastern spirituality came from "The Masks of God" by Joseph Campbell, and I made the link from spirituality to suicide based on a documentary about the Kamikaze pilots of World War II, and the rituals they used to prepare themselves for death, and what they believed would happen after they died.

    However, my own first-hand experience with Japanese culture came at the hands of a Japanese exchange student and fellow writer who is still a very good friend of mine, and it amazed me just how gentle and courteous the man was - and how much honour and saving face meant to him. To a degree, we Westerners wear our emotions on our sleeves compared to the Japanese, and it would be very dangerous to say that we know what is under the surface (after all, remember the surprising brutality that appeared in World War II and the Japanese Empire, which would seem entirely out of character for such a polite and courteous society).

    --
    Robert B. Marks
    Author, Demonsbane in Diablo Archive
  127. Point? by lorcha · · Score: 1
    If there was a specific point in there, I totally missed it.

    Are you saying that in the US, coroners are prone to voilate medical ethics by lying to the family of the deceased about the cause of death when they suspect suicide? I'd love to see a source for that wild speculation. I'm going to happily assume the source to be "gnasher719's ass" until you provide a linky.

    By the way, life insurance typically does pay out on a suicide after the policy has been in force for a minimum of two years. Therefore, I'm going to happily ignore what you wrote about life insurance because you are simply misinformed on that point.

    So, yeah, what was your point there, big guy?

    --
    "Avoid employing unlucky people - throw half of the pile of CVs in the bin without reading them." -- David Brent
    1. Re:Point? by fruitbane · · Score: 1

      He wasn't referring specifically to the US. Do you know the cultural circumstances of other countries and the life insurance policies there?

      So, wait, what was YOUR point, again? ;)

  128. No, they're just pining by AgentPhunk · · Score: 1
    crazy, depressed Finns.

    No, but they are pining for the Fjord's.

  129. Funny? by JudeanPeople'sFront · · Score: 1

    Who finds this funny, for God's sake?

  130. Suicide pacts. . . by AcidLacedPenguiN · · Score: 1

    I was in like, 2 or 3 of them, but I had the hardest time with staying in the group. I mean, within 2 or 3 weeks of joining everyone just stopped talking to me, it really made me feel left out, I can't figure it out!
    Do people just not like me or something?

    --
    disclaimer: I've been known to store numbers in my ass for which to dig out when quantities are required.
  131. Welcome to Online Suicide Club by pizza_milkshake · · Score: 2, Funny

    The first rule of online suicide club is...

    1. Re:Welcome to Online Suicide Club by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      the first rule of the suicide club is a golden oldie - "Do Unto Others As You Would Have Them Do Unto You", which lead directly to the invention of the "death by cop" suicide.

  132. Suicide club, eh? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    www.maru.ne.jp

  133. Re:It isn't so black and white. by vertinox · · Score: 1

    But in a group, this could result in peer pressure conditions. Encouraging someone to commit suicide is equivalent to killing him.

    Or the reverse... If the majority bails out at the last moment, then the person who would have gone through might change his mind.

    Secondly, are you suggesting that there is no free will involved with the person who is commiting suicide? I mean unless you put the gun up to their head and push the trigger, I can't believe you are negating their true free will. Unless their depression has caused them to have no control or free will (as in they have become a philosophical zombie) and are subject to any suggestion and incapable of having a say in your reality.

    Then again...

    Would you want to live a life like that?

    (of course this speculation and the assumption that we really have free will in life to begin with)

    --
    "I am the king of the Romans, and am superior to rules of grammar!"
    -Sigismund, Holy Roman Emperor (1368-1437)
  134. In Soviet Russia.... by scheming+daemons · · Score: 1
    ...suicide commits you!

    Sorry... got karma to burn..

    --
    "I have as much authority as the pope, I just
    don't have as many people who believe it" - George Carlin

  135. internet cult of ANA in America by peter303 · · Score: 1

    The US has the similar destructive internet society supporting anexoria in young women. Those people cant really converse in real life, but internet groups allow them to exchange techniques, particularly ways to resist medical personnel who try to change them. Somehow extreme thinness gets hardwired into one's maturing sexual persona, and becomes almost impossible to change.

  136. Lowest rates in... by Sun+Rider · · Score: 1

    ...the Caribbean area. That sure must be a good place to live! I think there is a lesson here...

  137. I swear... by Jonboy+X · · Score: 1

    I swear, if I hear one more story about how fscked up the Japanese are, I think I'm gonna kill myself.

    Who's with me?

    --

    "In a 32-bit world, you're a 2-bit user. You've got your own newsgroup, alt.total.loser." -Weird Al
  138. Why Japan? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I would seriously like to know the top reasons behind such a thing...because from my point of view Japan is one of the greatest countries in the world to live. You've got the best technology, the best video games, and it's legal to have sex whenever you want, even if your married...so what gives? Video games + sex = never want to die, that practically is heaven to me...

    I don't think these people know how good they have it...

  139. Catholics? by raygundan · · Score: 1

    Since Catholics consider suicide "unforgivable," which I assume means the bouncer will toss you from the Pearly Gates, do they get a free pass on this?

    1. Re:Catholics? by PastaLover · · Score: 1

      According to catholic doctrine, you go straight to hell when you kill yourself. I assume this is what most anti-suicide laws in the west are actually based on.

    2. Re:Catholics? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Actually, that's not quite right. According to the Catechism of the Catholic Church (the documentation of what Catholics believe), suicide is wrong, and violates the 5th Commandment ("Thou shalt not kill"), stating that
      "We are stewards, not owners, of the life God has entrusted to us. It is not ours to dispose of" (CCC 2280: http://www.vatican.va/archive/catechism/p3s2c2a5.h tm#I).
      However, it also goes on to say
      "We should not despair of the eternal salvation of persons who have taken their own lives. By ways known to him alone, God can provide the opportunity for salutary repentance. The Church prays for persons who have taken their own lives" (CCC 2283).

      Suicide, according to Catholic belief, is not necessarily a one-way ticket to damnation.

  140. East vs West in Germany by metamatic · · Score: 1

    When East Germany rejoined the West, stress and suicide rates shot up to match the values in West Germany. It's worth researching and reading about. It's an interesting case because it basically involved no variables other than political system; the populations were otherwise identical.

    Is freedom worth the stress, mental illness and suicides? Interesting question.

    --
    GCHQ Quantum Insert installed. If only our tongues were made of glass, how much more careful we would be when we speak
  141. 'E's not dead! (-1 Heartless) by Sigg3.net · · Score: 1

    Mr. Praline: Never mind that, my lad. I wish to complain about this Japanese what I met not half an hour ago in this very chatroom.

    Sysop: Oh yes, the, uh, the Japanese Blue...What's,uh...What's wrong with 'im?

    Mr. Praline: I'll tell you what's wrong with him, my lad.
    'E's dead, that's what's wrong with him!

    Sysop: No, no, 'e's uh,...he's resting.

    Mr. Praline: Look, matey, I know a dead Japanese when I see one, and I'm looking at one right now.

    Sysop: No no he's not dead, he's, he's restin'!
    Remarkable chatters, the Japanese Blue, idn'it, ay? Beautiful plumage!

    Mr. Praline: The plumage don't enter into it, does it? 'E's stone dead!

    Sysop: Nononono, no, no! 'E's resting!

    ...

    Mr. Praline: 'E's bleedin' demised!

    Owner: No no! 'E's pining!

    Mr. Praline: 'E's not pinin'! 'E's passed on! This Japanese is no more! He has ceased to be! 'E's expired and gone to meet 'is maker! 'E's a stiff! Bereft of life, 'e rests in peace! 'Is metabolic processes are now 'istory! 'E's off the twig! 'E's kicked the bucket, 'e's shuffled off 'is mortal coil, run down the curtain and joined the bleedin' choir invisibile!! THIS IS AN EX-CHATTER!!

  142. Who gave the gov't the right to regulate this? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It is very possible that these people can be very creative or smart and are in a temporary rut. Or it is also possible that they have somekind of illness like bipolar or manic depression, which is treatable.

    It's possible to be very creative and smart and in a rut, and never produce anything worthwhile in your life simply because you don't want to. The government doesn't have the right to force you to be creative, or to punish you if you aren't.

    Plus, I bet that almost all of them have friends or family that would be very upset with this.

    There are countless things you could do that would make your friends and family very upset, but that's not sufficient reason to make them illegal.

  143. Re:Suicide Club (movie) by christoscamaro · · Score: 1

    That's a great movie. I thought of it right away too when I saw this article.

  144. Pacific Northwest by JimmytheGeek · · Score: 1

    I recall that the suicide rate in the Pacific Northwest was much higher than the average. Blame perpetual overcast during the winter, weeks of unbroken rain, high latitude ==> long nights

    Then the coffee craze hit and the suicide rate dropped.

    'course, the HOMICIDE rate went up by a similar amount.

    The caffinated are less depressed, but a lot twitchier.

  145. Mod Parent Up by CB-in-Tokyo · · Score: 1

    Hi Claus,

    You are correct. I have thought about the frequency I personally experience and once per week is high. I have only personally encountered 2 delays this year that I know were jinshin jiko, and we are already mid February. I tried looking up some stats regarding the rates, but they are extremely hard to find, even in Japanese.

    I ride the Keihin Tohoku sen, and I used to ride the Chuo. When I was on the Chuo line, I remember being delayed quite often. I think part of my overzealousness stemmed from the fact that my train rides these days are very short (only two stops!), and I am still getting delayed fairly regularly.

    I don't think the delays are always line specific though. I know I have been delayed on the Kehin Tohoku line for suicides on other connected lines.

    Thanks for pointing out my error.

    Cheers,

    CB

  146. Rising suicide by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It must be the increasing use of Linux. I had to configure a linux system last week and by the end of it I was ready to commit suicide.

    1. Re:Rising suicide by chawly · · Score: 1

      This linux system was for your own use, I hope. Otherwise, I think that there is a real risk that the end-user may decide to "catch the bus", as it were. Said end-user may even run after said bus crying "Wait for me, I can't take any more".

      --
      How many beans make five, anyhow ? ... Charles Walmsley
  147. Suicide is not illegal by edinjapan · · Score: 1

    In Japan, despite being much bemoaned and having newspapers and TV stations taking long morbid looks at suicide, suicide clubs and the reasons for it. Suicide is not illegal, committing suicide on the JR tracks at Shinjuku Stn or some other busy trainstation or other venue is illegal only because you are upsetting the schedule and costing time, effort and money to the business or taxpayer. Other than that it's not a crime and is quietly encouraged by the government in the case of the elderly infirm, drug abusers and the mentally insane.

    --
    Fish....More than just sushi
  148. Japanese Suicide Pacts by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Japanese suicide pacts may be caused by a conflict of physiology related to the vision startle reflex.

    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/4695864.st m

    Do you remember Shawn Woolley who committed suicide believed to be caused by Everquest Addiction?

    The problem was discovered when knowledge workers using the first close-spaced office workstations began having mental breaks. The Cubicle solved that problem, 1968.

    But the "special conditions" that allow exposure to Subliminal Distraction are so simple they can be created almost anywhere. Incorrectly situated computer workstations would allow the same mental breaks to happen. If the mental event contains psychiatric symptoms of despondency suicide is a likely outcome.

    These mental breaks have happened on Russian space missions, Soyuz 21, and in Antarctic scientific stations. ("Bold Endeavors," Stuster, "Through the First Antarctic Night," Cook)

    Visit:
    http://visionandpsychosis.net/ - and start by performing the psychology experiment on the Demonstration Page.

    http://visionandpsychosis.net/a_demonstration_you_ can_do.htm

    http://visionandpsychosis.net/Astronauts_Insanity. htm

    http://visionandpsychosis.net/Everquest_connection .htm

    http://visionandpsychosis.net/College_Suicides.htm

    There is a condensed site outline on this page. It is about the history of Dissociative Fugue but the material is the same.

    http://visionandpsychosis.net/Missing_Students.htm

  149. Send an invite by SirKron · · Score: 1

    Can someone please send an invite to Osama?