Slashdot Mirror


Lord of the Rings, as Written By Everyone Else

sn0rt writes "A thread on Straight Dope asks what would happen if someone else had written the Lord of the Rings. Reader submissions include Ernest Hemingway, Douglas Adams, Mark Twain, HP Lovecraft, ee cumings, Milton, Mickey Spillane, Danielle Steele, Ayn Rand(!!), Ray Bradbury, Gilbert and Sullivan and Tom Clancy. My favourite is Dr. Suess: 'Gandalf, Gandalf! Take the ring! I am too small to carry this thing!' 'I can not, will not hold the One. You have a slim chance, but I have none. I will not take it on a boat, I will not take it across a moat. I cannot take it under Moria, that's one thing I can't do for ya. I would not bring it into Mordor, I would not make it to the border.'"

346 comments

  1. Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by Snaller · · Score: 4, Funny

    It would have been filled with robots, lasers and naked babes ;o)

    --
    If Google really cared they would fix Android Chrome to reflow text, instead of discriminating
    1. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by mccalli · · Score: 5, Funny
      Naah - they'd have just turned it into a giant chase film, with rewrites to the plot left right and centre. And that dwarf - he'd have no chance. He'd just be reduced to some sort of comic relief.

      Oh.

      Err...never mind.

      Cheers,
      Ian

    2. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by WPIDalamar · · Score: 3, Funny

      I didn't think the movie could have gotten better... but LOTR with naked babes ... wow.

    3. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      sounds like an interesting spin on Jacksons classic. Tolkiens version isn't too bad, he should have made it shorter - as a graphic novel perhaps?

    4. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by Britissippi · · Score: 4, Funny
      Why did that make me think of the end of the Benny hill show? I can just see Frodo being chased round by nine scanitly-clad ringwraiths...? Dee do dee dee dilly diily doo do dee dee dilly dilly.....

      Umm, yeah, never mind. :)

      --
      Meow meow meow meow, meow meow meow meow...
    5. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I defecate on Hollywood.

    6. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by ackthpt · · Score: 1
      It would have been filled with robots, lasers and naked babes ;o)

      Yeah, Arwen would have boobs hanging out all over the place, Aragorn played by Ahnold, and galadriel would have been played by Madonna. *shiver*

      You left out the car chases, huge fireball explosions for no reason whatsoever and soppy feel-good endings.

      Seriously, Havard Lampoon wrote up Bored of the Rings, mocking the characters and all. I haven't read it, but some reviews liked it and others hated it (as it goes with all things)

      There was a comic parody of LoTR many years ago where they were sitting around eating pizza and one of the hobbits throws a slice at a giant spider (Shelob?), yelling "Eat hot pizza!" The spider dies and then the hobbit offers another slice to Gandalf who wisely declines. (Might have been drawn by Wally Wood?) Anyone remember this one?

      ...though I do get the feeling I know of Sauron, I feel the eye upon me and the evil growing everytime I look consider buying a CD...

      --

      A feeling of having made the same mistake before: Deja Foobar
    7. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by unitron · · Score: 2

      Speaking of the "Bored of the Rings" parody, I read The Hobbit and the trilogy books back in high school about '68 or '69, just before they became "trendy", and of course was quite impressed with myself for having done so. About '71 or '72 I became friends with another guy at UNC-Chapel Hill who had the Harvard Lampoon book, which I didn't properly appreciate at the time, being a little too defensive of the originals. He, being not much of a sci-fi/fantasy fan, successfully used it instead of the original to learn enough about the story line for an assignment in a lit class.

      --

      I see even classic Slashdot is now pretty much unusable on dial up anymore.

    8. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      I just want to take this space-at-the-top-of-the-page to post a warning.

      The link in the article contains spoilers for those of you (us) who have not read the LOTR trilogy and are looking forward to the third movie with anticipation, not knowing what all is going to happen.

      basically I got the final movie ruined from me, one of the posts in the thread linked writes up how LOTR would be if it was a reply to a question by Cecil of The Straight Dope, and this and the following post (i stopped there, spoiled) revealed just exactly how the whole final-moment-at-mount-doom-throw-the-fucking-ring- in part goes down. :(

    9. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      ** LINK HAS SPOILERS ***

    10. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I am glad someone else mention Jar Jar Dwarf. Geesh, that really friggin' irked me.

    11. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by Cyclometh · · Score: 1, Troll

      Look, if you aren't familiar with the story, or haven't read it, I don't have much sympathy for you. It's not a surprise to anyone who's read a book in the last 50 years. The plot is hardly a mystery.

      Sorry you haven't read the books, but you really should- and before you see the (last) movie. Believe me, you'll enjoy the movie more. Don't expect the majority who are familiar with the plot to go out of their way to avoid a "rosebud moment".

    12. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by isorox · · Score: 2

      Oh yes, replace the 10,000 orcs marching on helms deep!

    13. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by dlelash · · Score: 1

      "Dude, Where's My Ring?"

    14. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by blahlemon · · Score: 1
      No offence but just because a book has been available for a good long time doesn't mean that people shouldn't be considerate and include a spoiler warning/space. Especially with a piece of work as delightful as The Lord of the Rings. Lets face it, it doesn't take but a second to include a warning in the subject or before the particular text.

      People could stand to be a little more considerate these days.

      --
      It take more faith to believe in evolution than it takes to believe in God
    15. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by syn3rg · · Score: 0

      Mod Parent up +5 Funny

      --
      The contents of this message have been doubly encrypted by ROT13
    16. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They would have arbitrarily made some characters black. And others gay. And more Jewish.

      All in the name of PC indoctrination ...

    17. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Lord of the Rings would also make an excellent title for a porno.

      As would:
      Toy Story
      Sister Act
      Driving Miss Daisy
      Fire Down Below

    18. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by Cyclometh · · Score: 2, Troll

      None taken. However, given how LOTR is one of the most important pieces of western fiction written in the 20th century, and that it has existed for well over 50 years, I don't really feel too badly about spoiling the moviegoing experience for people who haven't taken the time to read the damn thing.

      Further, in my opinion, you can't really enjoy the movie fully unless you've read the book, because so much is left out of the movie. Just as a single example, the movie never even touches on just why the city of Osgiliath is a destroyed ruin even though several major scenes take place there.

      And really, people bitching about the movie being spoiled for them because they didn't know the plot of the book really is just plain irksome.

      Just to be clear: Rosebud is a sled. The fucking boat sinks. The guy's really dead from the beginning. And Gollum is actually the one responsible for destroying the ring, albeit by accident. None of these things should be a surprise to anyone who hasn't lived in a hole for the last 20 years.

      I'm not trying to be an ass (or maybe I am) but I really don't have much patience for anyone who is so dreadfully out of touch as to not know the basic plot of LOTR. I'm actually surprised that even people who haven't read the book don't know at least the high points.

    19. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by Ryosen · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Just to be clear: You are an ass. An immature and inconsiderate one at that.

      While it might not be much of a surprise how the book ends in the general sense (good triumphs over evil and there was much rejoicing), it is wholly unnecessary for you to spell out exactly how it happens.

      While it may seem incredulous to you, it is entirely possible that someone has not read LOTR. And to say that it was "one of the most important pieces of western fiction written in the 20th century" just belies your lack of a literary education and maturity. "Influential"? Without a doubt. "Important"? C'mon. Tolkein may have poored his life into the work, a noble act to be sure, but he never deluded himself into thinking that his writings were of significant importance to the literary world. At least, he had not conveyed that attitude in any of the interviews that he had given that I had personally read -- and I did my thesis work on him.

      Oh, and thanks for fscking up Citizen Kane, too.

      --

      Ryosen
      One man's "Troll, +1" is another man's "Insightful, +1".
    20. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by Cyclometh · · Score: 1, Troll

      Oh, please do spare me. I'll be damned if I'm taken to task on Slashdot for being immature or inconsiderate. I personally think it's the height of arrogance to expect the vast majority to tiptoe around the illiterate morons who can't be bothered to PICK UP A BOOK. And I stand by my position: I have no sympathy for, nor any real inclination to accomodate, anyone who hasn't read LOTR. I'm not really trying to be an ass, although I'm probably coming off that way. I don't think you *have* to read it, I just don't want to hear the bitching when you (inevitably) hear about the things that happen in the book.

      And as far as Citizen Kane goes, once again, if you haven't heard about it, get out from under the rock. I really don't think that the vanishingly small number of people who a) haven't seen it and b) might see it someday who are startled by this earth-shaking revelation on Slashdot are going to concern me unduly.

      And furthermore, if the movie can't be enjoyed even if you know the "twist" then it's not worth watching.

    21. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by cathouse · · Score: 1

      IMHO the most basic and definative factor in even BEGINING to grasp>comprehend>grok>love a book is re-reading! I recall with great clarity and pleasure, that with the Ring Trilogy; Heinlein's 'Time Eneough For Love' ;and a few other works which I hold equally high regard, the first thing that I did after first reading, was to go straight back to the beginning and read it again, with the mental equivelant of slightly changed browser settings. Cretins [at best] who spout shit about 'ruining it for them' will never be able to understand ANY fraction of the joy that can come from finding a new love of this sort.

      --
      Thelma, I'm not making ANY deals.
    22. Re:Just think if Hollywood had filmed it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Consider yourself damned you arrogant fuckwit. If you post on a public forum you don't have any control over what people say about your inferior social skills and fetid smell. I'd really hate to meet you when you are trying to be an ass, because you do a remarkably good job without even trying. I've never seen Citizen Kane, and was looking forward to it sometime in my life. So now you'd better watch over your shoulder, because one day you may get a sudden pain in your testicles where my boot gives you a literary appreciation lesson.

  2. Re:IN SOVIET RUSSIA... by Chembryl · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    Maybe this would have been better: In Soviet Russia they Lord of YOUR Ring!

    --
    - This and all my posts are public domain. I am a Physicist. I am not your Physicist. This is not Physically advice
  3. I would really like to see... by elixx · · Score: 1, Funny

    LotR by William Gibson. :D

    --
    No, Beowulf clusters can't imagine in Soviet Russia.
    1. Re:I would really like to see... by ideonode · · Score: 3, Interesting

      The sky was the colour of a Palantir, in tune with a dead mind.

    2. Re:I would really like to see... by sumirati · · Score: 5, Funny

      It was already written by ForgottenLore at 10-16-2002 12:08 AM

      Frodo jacked in.

      He felt huge, invincible, unstoppable. Some small part of him knew that was the hits of pipe-weed talking, skewing his sense of self, making his nerves scream like they were being raked over rusted chrome. Knew, and didn't care.

      Over his shoulder he could feel Sam hovering, a hollow nonentity. It was eerie knowing he was back there, like having an itch in a limb long amputated. All around him the middle-matrix arced off into an impossible blue infinity, gridlines benchmarking the empty nonspace.

      "There it is," came Sam's voice. "That's the ice. Good luck breakin' in there, man, that was made by a military AI. Name of ephelduath. You ain't seen nuthin' like it. They say it's two way ice. Not only will it fry your brainpan tryin' to get in, nuthin' inside can work its way out. Leastaways, not without sarumancer's say-so."

      Frodo wished Sam would shut the hell up. He also wished he wasn't about to do what he came for. He wished a lot of things. He surveyed this sector of cyberspace. Before him was the ephelduath ice, shadowy and indistinct, and very very deadly. And beyond it, just visible through the whorls of lethal, greasy code, was sarumancer himself. The Dark Lord presented in the middle-matrix as a collosal data construct, angular and hideous. A mountain of vicious, evil information so dense it was hard to look at, hard to take in all at once. It played tricks on the eyes. Each nodule, each piece of it seemed to contain a perfect glittering symmetry. A simple frightening geometry. But taken altogether it became a great organic pyramidal thing, a digital volcano spewing mirrored liquid spheres of awareness out into the void. These spheres, Frodo knew, served as sarumancer's eyes. When they intersected a gridline, at random, they would latch onto it and streak off in an unchosen direction in a vain effort to apprehend, to know, to see, all of the middle-matrix at once.

      Here we go. He drew out the elvish icebreaker and contemplated its image for a moment. Given to him by Galadriel herself. He activated it, his unseen fingers moving fluidly over the keys of his Ono-Sendai. Triggered, the icebreaker flared up, a searing point of magnesium brilliance. He clicked forward, towards the ice. Slowly. Click. Carefully. Click. The elvish icebreaker encountered ephelduath's handiwork, and forced it to recede. The ice's killer algorithms spiralled futiley around Frodo and Sam as they rode the icebreaker inwards...

      From The Lord of the Rings by William Gibson

    3. Re:I would really like to see... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sounds more like Margaret Allan to me...

  4. it's a good thing it wasn't... by Gavin+Rogers · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Because it would probably have never been published.

    Sure, it's fun to re-write a bit of the LOTR in the style of your favourite author, but try doing it with an entire chapter... or an entire book. The witty and humerous style of, say Douglas Adams would quickly become unbearable on something as big as LOTR.

    It's a bit like translating Shakespear into Klingon. Well, yes, do it if you want but the world reads Shakespear as it was written and as it was intended! Everything else is a waste of time...

    1. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by EvilTwinSkippy · · Score: 4, Funny

      Except of course there is no construct for "To Be" in Klingon. The linguist who designed it was a bit of a purist. Needless to say he had to do a bit of interesting work with the dialog to translate Hamlet's speach for the Undiscovered Country. LOL

      --
      "Learning is not compulsory... neither is survival."
      --Dr.W.Edwards Deming
    2. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by melonman · · Score: 1

      The witty and humerous style of, say Douglas Adams would quickly become unbearable on something as big as LOTR.



      If someone else had written it, maybe it wouldn't have been so long in the first place...

      --
      Virtually serving coffee
    3. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by syn3rg · · Score: 0

      Enter the RING-BEARER Merry. O that we now had here But one ten thousand of those Hobbits in the Shire That do no work to-day! RING. What's he that wishes so? My cousin Meriodoc? No, my fair cousin; If we are mark'd to die, we are enow To do our country loss; and if to live, The fewer men, the greater share of honour. God's will! I pray thee, wish not one man more. By Jove, I am not covetous for gold, Nor care I who doth feed upon my cost; It yearns me not if men my garments wear; Such outward things dwell not in my desires. But if it be a sin to covet honour, I am the most offending soul alive. No, faith, my coz, wish not an hobbit from the Shire. God's peace! I would not lose so great an honour As one man more methinks would share from me For the best hope I have. O, do not wish one more! Rather proclaim it, Merry, through the Fellowship, That he which hath no stomach to this fight, Let him depart; his passport shall be made, And crowns for convoy put into his purse; We would not die in that man's company That fears his Fellowship to die with us. This day is call'd the feast of Isildur. He that outlives this day, and comes safe home, Will stand a tip-toe when this day is nam'd, And rouse him at the name of Isildur. He that shall live this day, and see old age, Will yearly on the vigil feast his neighbours, And say 'To-morrow is Saint Isildur.' Then will he strip his sleeve and show his scars, And say 'These wounds I had on Crispian's day.' Old men forget; yet all shall be forgot, But he'll remember, with advantages, What feats he did that day. Then shall our names, Familiar in his mouth as household words- Frodo the Ring-Bearer, Peregrin and Sam, Aragorn and Gandalf, Legolas and Gilmi- Be in their flowing cups freshly rememb'red. This story shall the good man teach his son; And Elendil Isildur shall ne'er go by, From this day to the ending of the world, But we in it shall be remembered- We few, we happy few, we band of brothers; For he to-day that sheds his blood with me Shall be my brother; be he ne'er so vile, This day shall gentle his condition; And hobbits in the Shire now-a-bed Shall think themselves accurs'd they were not here, And hold their manhoods cheap whiles any speaks That fought with us upon Saint Isildur's day. -- William Shakespeare

      --
      The contents of this message have been doubly encrypted by ROT13
    4. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by junklight · · Score: 1

      especially if Douglas Adams had written it - the amount of baths it would have required would have been astromical

    5. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by Dyolf+Knip · · Score: 4, Funny

      One towel to rule them all...

      --
      Dyolf Knip
    6. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by egreB · · Score: 2

      Congrats on obscure Guide-phrasing!

      Not to mention the undetermined elevators. Nobody would ever get to the top of Orthanc unless they knew any particulary depressed robots.

      "The planet Nowwhat had been named after the words uttered by its first settlers. Arthur got a room in a small inn on the outskirts of the only city, wich was called Ohwell."

    7. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by Glint · · Score: 1

      But everybody knows that Shakespeare was meant to be read in the original Klingon!

    8. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by Moderator · · Score: 0

      You haven't experienced Shakespeare until you've read it in its original Klingon.

      --
      The World is Yours.
    9. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The witty and humerous style of, say Douglas Adams would quickly become unbearable on something as big as LOTR.

      How does its length compare to the 800+ pages in the H2G2 set?

    10. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      OK, that actually looks pretty good. Once more, with formatting?

    11. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by blahlemon · · Score: 1
      It's a bit like translating Shakespear into Klingon. Well, yes, do it if you want but the world reads Shakespear as it was written and as it was intended! Everything else is a waste of time...

      I prefer to hear Hamlet in the original Klingon, just like Star Trek taught me to like it.

      --
      It take more faith to believe in evolution than it takes to believe in God
    12. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by Phroggy · · Score: 1, Flamebait

      Except of course there is no construct for "To Be" in Klingon. The linguist who designed it was a bit of a purist. Needless to say he had to do a bit of interesting work with the dialog to translate Hamlet's speach for the Undiscovered Country. LOL

      In case anyone is wondering, the reason for this is that in Klingon, all adjectives are really verbs. For example, "to be big" or "to be green" are each one verb, so "the ship is big" is two words, "the ship" and "is big". I don't remember how that line was translated; I think a new verb "to be" was created, which is never used except in Shakespeare.

      More general information here.

      --
      $x='S24;r)>63/* h@<5+oZ)32"5cz';$me='phroggy'x$];
      $x=~y+ -xz+\0-Tx+;print$_^chop$me for split'',$x;
    13. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by DunbarTheInept · · Score: 2

      Reading Shakespere in the original is also a waste of time, at least if entertainment is what you are looking for. The style dates from a time when spending an excessively long time to say a simple idea was considered fun entertainment. Conversation was the primary form of entertainment. I've never been impressed with his plays and only read some of the plays because it was required for various courses. They are important to learn, for the sake of historical cultural context, but they are not entertainment.

      And as the English language naturally evolves further and further, the plays will become harder and harder to read in the original, until eventually it's like trying to read Beowulf in the original Pre - Battle of Hastings anglo-saxon language that's almost, but not quite, entirely unlike English.

      --

      Don't label something "offtopic" unless you know the topic well enough to tell what's on topic.

    14. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by May+Kasahara · · Score: 1

      Only in the second installment, "The Two Towels".

    15. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by p24t · · Score: 1

      But Shakespeare is always best in its original Klingon.

    16. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't... by kubrick · · Score: 2

      Reading Shakespere in the original is also a waste of time, at least if entertainment is what you are looking for.

      Speak for yourself. I find Shakespeare's stuff quite entertaining... a group of friends and I do play readings occasionally (usually Shakespeare, but we've also read Jonson and Wilde, for example), and it's always great fun.

      --
      deus does not exist but if he does
  5. Ayn Rand by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    Ayn Rand?? Frodo would have been the bad guy for stealing someone elses hard worked ring. Regardless of whether or not it was used for evil.

    1. Re:Ayn Rand by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually Rand was a proponent of the rule of LAW...bzzt try again.

    2. Re:Ayn Rand by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Is that why Hank Rearden and Dagny Taggart ignored all the laws against selling the Rearden Metal in ATLAS SHRUGGED? Rearden made secret deals that were clearly illegal. And it was also made illegal to run away from their obligations - but it was done all over the place anyway. So...where did you derive your drivel from?

    3. Re:Ayn Rand by Big_Monkey_Bird · · Score: 5, Funny

      I would think Ayn Rand would have disapproved the anti-industrial subtext. Here's a few things she would change

      10. First line would be "Bilbo Baggins Laughed"

      9. Frodo would wear a blouse of Reardon metal

      8. Aragorn would force himself on Arwen

      7 In the cracks of Mt Doom, Frodo would make a 60 page speech everyone glosses over.

      6. You have know how to say "Inyë", before you can say "Tye-mela'ne"

      5. The entrance to Moria would require the declaration of selfishness.

      4. Wormtongue's elvish name would be Nathaniel

      3. "Who is Gil-Galad?"

      2. Gollum would have a manipulative mother

      1. The book would be even longer

    4. Re:Ayn Rand by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You're confusing proper objective laws with corrupt self-serving looter laws. Comparing man's right to live (law against murder) with some bureaucrat's power-trip (www.stupidlaws.com).

      "ignored all the laws against selling the Rearden Metal in ATLAS SHRUGGED?"
      "And it was also made illegal to run away from their obligations"

      So, if you struggled all your life to make a good product to sell, then some bureaucrat comes by and says it's illegal for you to do so unless you pay him alms, THEN says it's illegal for you to NOT make the product (ie,slavery)...you're ok with that???

      "illegal to run away from their obligations"
      Obligations to WHO? Is someone obligated to spend the rest of their life working as a slave to support whoever some bureaucrat says is in 'need'.

      IF...IF you read that book,you either need a refresher in reading comprehension or are just trolling.

      "So...where did you derive your drivel from?"

      Looks like trolling...

    5. Re:Ayn Rand by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hey thah, I say hey thah

      This heah ring won't kill nobody. I don't see no comparison. I'm just a lowly space sorceror trying to get my propuhty back.

    6. Re:Ayn Rand by EricTheGreen · · Score: 1

      ...and in addition, Sauron is really a phenomenally talented and intelligent captain of industry, but all evil and woe is his responsibility in the eyes of those less-intelligent plebes who hate anyone or anything aspiring to individual greatness. In response, he has withdrawn himself to the land of Mordor, wilfully refusing to support the less worthy with his own talents. Untroubled by other cares, he is working on an even more powerful and effective ring of power; the one he used before was just a prototype. He awaits the inevitable collapse of a society rooted in self-delusion and will return after this, along with those other individuals capable of returning Middle Earth to it's rightful greatness.

      In reality, LOTR is a hack job by some guy named Toohey. Got it all wrong, he did.

      Accurate so far?

  6. Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by Ann+O'Nymous-Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    * If Jon Katz had written it, he'd do a global replace of "Orc" with "Jock" and "Mordor" with "High School"

    * If CmdrTaco had written it, it'd be called "Lodr of the Rnigs."
    * Arwen would be played by Petrified Natalie Portman.
    * There'd be a scene where Sauron looks up from admiring his shiny new gold toy and says to his nine best friends "Imagine if we had a Beowulf Cluster of this!"
    * There'd be the Obligatory TokenRing Joke.
    * The opening credits would be replaced by FR1ST PS0Ts
    * The DVD would be released in "Page-Widening Spam" format instead of "Widescreen"

    1. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by Stanley+Feinbaum · · Score: 1

      If michael had written it he would search the net and try to remove every negative review of it.

      --

      Stanley Feinbaum, professional journalist and master debater! God bless the USA!

    2. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by Ann+O'Nymous-Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      Oops, meant to add...

      * Movie theaters worldwide would crash horribly on Opening night. :)

    3. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by The_Shadows · · Score: 5, Funny

      If /. had written it:

      Hemos would have written it, and Taco would've written it again the next day, changing the wording, and putting in the foreward "This story seems oddly familiar."

      Also, we'd wind up replacing Mordor with SOVIET RUSSIA. (In SOVIET RUSSIA, orcs eat you! [wait...])

      and When the ring is finally destroyed, Frodo would shout "All your base are belong to us!"

    4. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by JabberWokky · · Score: 2
      If Richard O'Brien had written it. And, dammit, Tom Bombadil should be Columbia, but I think this author, like too too many others, only saw the *#@& movie.

      Boromir as Eddie is good stuff, though.

      --
      Evan "Didn't we pass an Inn back down the road a few miles? Maybe they have a palantir I could use."

      --
      "$30 for the One True Ring. $10 each additional ring!" -- JRR "Bob" Tolkien
    5. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by OldStash · · Score: 1

      It would also come in six volumes, although three of them would be duplicates.

    6. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by vr · · Score: 1, Redundant

      * Someone would have looked at the Ring and attempted to imagine a Beowulf cluster of Rings.

    7. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by Satoshi+Harada · · Score: 4, Funny

      * The scenes with Arwen and Aragorn would be modded down -1, Offtopic

      * Bilbo would be a VAX programmer.

      * It would be duped in theatres three times.

      * Instead of the evil Great Eye, there'd be the evil Great Window

      --
      Error: .Sig fault
    8. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by Anonymous+Custard · · Score: 2

      * There'd be the Obligatory TokenRing Joke.

      And then someone, without enough wit to create his own "if someone else had written it" post, would go and add to that with a corresponding TolkienRing joke.

    9. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by BlueGecko · · Score: 5, Funny

      Why Sauron's Ring Is So Powerful...Sometimes
      from the why-can't-I-rule-the-world dept.

      Anonymous Dwarf writes "Finally the scoop on how Sauron "cheats" a little to up his power! Do RFCs mean nothing anymore? What's next, Riots in the streets, dogs and cats living together, mass hysteria! From the blog story: 'Apparently Sauron engineered all of the rings to be networked together for increased power. However, his own ring is more powerful because it skips the TCP/IP header when contacting other rings, allowing it to dominate their connections and effectively control all of them by occupying all open sockets." Yet another example of why we really need the Rings of Power to follow proper RFC standards.

    10. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by Rochus · · Score: 1

      The Council would include the CowboyNeal-Option in the Slashdot Poll "Who should bead the Ring?"

    11. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by Rochus · · Score: 1

      Oops, "bead" should be spelled "bear"...

    12. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by vr · · Score: 2

      what? what are you talking about? did I miss anything?

    13. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by revery · · Score: 1

      This is purely a congratulatory post. I needed my breakfast dose of parody, and that definitely hit the spot. Thanks!!

    14. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by Asprin · · Score: 5, Funny


      Ahem... No way I would have come up with this on my own, but here goes....


      Slashback: Gandalf Cracks WEP With Frodo Card
      Wireless (MiddleEarth)Posted by Gandalf-Lover on 09:35 AM January 7th, 2003
      from the Sauron-still-uses-WEP?-WHAT-A-TOOL! dept.

      elfznic writes "There is a new wardriving utlity for Middle-Earth OS X 10.2 that can put the Frodo card into Ringbearer mode and collect and crack WEP-enabled 802.11b TolkienRingOfPower wireless networks. The application is called 'Fellowship' and it relies on the 'Mordor' driver to put the Frodo card into Ringbearer mode. Both the application and the driver are in beta."

      --
      "Lawyers are for sucks."
      - Doug McKenzie
    15. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by ComaVN · · Score: 5, Funny

      * Emphasis would be placed on how great it is that Sauron shared knowledge about his ring forging techniques with the Noldor.
      * Some chapters would occur twice in the book, slightly reworded.
      * The appendix would begin with "Compare the best prices on: Magic rings"
      * The "scouring of the shire" chapter would begin with "IANAL, but..."

      --
      Be wary of any facts that confirm your opinion.
    16. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by mcmonkey · · Score: 2
      I'm out of my head. Oh, hurry, or I may be dead. They mustn't carry out their evil mission...er...quest....er...THING!!!
      Dammit! Head should be h-e-d.
    17. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by Mwongozi · · Score: 3, Funny
      > There'd be the Obligatory TokenRing Joke

      Surely that would be a Tolkien Ring.

    18. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by tokinring · · Score: 1

      And then when they are smoking pipeweed, an obligatory TokinRing joke.

    19. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by areThoseMyFeet · · Score: 1

      And what about... The Black Gates of Redmond - guarded by Orc Server 2000's and the great XP firewall of mountains on either side - stood before them, and in the distance behind, the Mountain of Programmers, belching out shite over all the lands (except fair LothLinux?). And Frodo looked at Sam, and a slight smile came to his faceand, turning to Gollum said "You can go where you will, you have kept your promise. And anyway, we'll be out of here in no time"

      --

      I'm not very good at making decisions... Or am I?
    20. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The army of orcs would be replaced by an army of trolls.

    21. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by cellocgw · · Score: 1

      Uhhhh,
      " In Mordor, the Ring finds You!"

      --
      https://app.box.com/WitthoftResume Code: https://github.com/cellocgw
    22. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      YOU'RE A GENIUS!!!!
      That can't POSSIBLY be what he meant, but... WOW! You really know how to make a play on words! This battle of wits is over, sir!

    23. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by Anonymous+Cow+herd · · Score: 1
      hehe!

      1. Find the One Ring
      2. Return Ring to Mordor
      3. Cast Ring into firy mountain
      4. ???
      5. Profit!!!
      --
      Ita erat quando hic adveni.
    24. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by jazman_777 · · Score: 1

      Lawrence Lessig would be cast as Frodo. The Ring would have engraved on it "Copyright Sauron, First Age, etc etc etc". Jack Valenti would be cast as Gollum.

      --
      Slashdot: Failed Car Analogies. Amateur Lawyering. Anecdote Battles.
    25. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by B3ryllium · · Score: 1

      I think it was more accurate the first way. :)

    26. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by MntlChaos · · Score: 1

      Second age. not first age. (first age was Morgoth as the elf-hater)

    27. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by dpt · · Score: 1

      There would have to be the lines:

      * Gandalf: "In Mordor, the party comes to *you*".

      * Sauron:
      1. Create rings of power.
      2. Forge one ring to rule them all.
      3. ???
      4. Profit.

      * At the battle with Elrond/Elves/Men right at the start:
      Sauron: "All your rings are belong to us!"
      Elrond: "What you say?!"

    28. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by Bicoid · · Score: 2

      Don't forget the "In Orcish Mordor..." running jokes. In Orcish Mordor, ring wears YOU. In Orcish Moria, sword swings YOU.

      No matter how much we criticize Jackson's use of Gimli as a comic device, it always COULD get worse...

      --
      If not all sentients are human, couldn't it be possible that not all humans are sentient either?
    29. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by X-wes · · Score: 1

      This ring...does it run Linux?

    30. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by d_i_r_t_y · · Score: 2

      and the trolling of that /. story would probably go as follows:

      One-est post!

      launch every arwen portman for great PROFIT!

      ALL YOUR SHIRE WEED ARE BELONG TO US!

      IN SOVIET MORDOR, the One ring longs after YOU!!!

      as a consultant to an evil Fortune 500 megalomaniac dictator, it is clear, from any consideration of the facts, that Middle-Earth is dying

    31. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by whacker9 · · Score: 1

      The Verse of the Ring shall be:

      "One OS to rule them all, One OS to find them
      One OS to bring them all, and in the darkness bind them
      In the Land of Redmond where the Windows lie.."

    32. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by jrumney · · Score: 1

      The forth movie in the trilogy would be "Cowboy Neal".

    33. Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had written LOTR... by jefu · · Score: 2

      Don't forget the endless discussions of how to overclock the ring without having it turn into the very lava in Mt. Doom.

  7. All of a sudden... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ... I realize what Jon Katz has been up to lately.

  8. I don't see why this story is on /. by Thaelon · · Score: 1, Flamebait

    If anyone else had written Lord of the Rings it wouldn't be as good as it is. It may have been good but it wouldn't be Lord of the Rings.

    This is just silly.

    Go ahead and mark it flaimbait, but I just don't think this story is worthy of /. If they hadn't finally made LotR into good movies this certainly wouldn't make it to /. LotR had a more of a cult following before the movies, now everybody is down with the hobbits.

    --

    Question everything

    1. Re:I don't see why this story is on /. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Thaelon - let me guess - bit of a fan are we, or did your parents not listen to Mrs Reagan.

    2. Re:I don't see why this story is on /. by dunkelfalke · · Score: 4, Informative

      come on, this is humour. a parody, to be more precise. you read the excepts "written" by other authors and if you know their former works you understand all the humour and the hints.

      nevertheless, a lots of good parodies are a sign of being at least respected. if the original isn't good, the parodists wouldn't even care.

      just for example, there is a russian parody on silmarillion, called zvirmarillion (http://lib.ru/ANEKDOTY/zwirmrlon.txt)

      it is hilarious, it makes fun of all the pathos in silmarillion and it helps to understand the original lot better. i have read both books simultanous and i was astonished that zvirmarillion, although much shorter and funnier, is more understandable and skips nearly nothing of the story (unlike for example "bored of the rings").

      --
      "It's such a fine line between stupid and clever" -- David St. Hubbins, Spinal Tap
    3. Re:I don't see why this story is on /. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      HECK YA MAN. I WAS INTO LOTR CUZ MY DAD READ THE BOKS TO ME WHEN I WAS 5. all the fools, tools, and teenyboppers are now checkin out the boosk cuz "orlando bloom is hot". screw those orcs. they are just the ones into the fads. soon pop culture will move on leaving the classics back to the true fans.

    4. Re:I don't see why this story is on /. by ianscot · · Score: 1, Offtopic
      Flamebait? No. Truth - which some can't handle.

      Wow. Anyone would've said your first post was a troll, but... See, now there are some people who would see something like this that's written for light entertainment and say "Guess I don't feel like reading that one today" -- and then there are others who see it and say to themselves "This is silly and intended to be fun but I don't read enough to see why! Slashdot isn't about having fun. I must intervene in the service of all that is true and good!"

      You remind me of a Limbaugh true believer who expained to me in 1987 that he was propounding a grand new political philosophy -- on a dailup BBS that purged all but the last 100 messages. "Silly?" Silly doesn't even start to describe it.

      --
      "Fundamentalism" isn't about divine morality. It's about human authority.
    5. Re:I don't see why this story is on /. by carlos_benj · · Score: 1

      This is just silly.

      My, aren't we perceptive.....

      Puns are like wit, only stupid.

      Well, that explains a lot.

      Reminds me of a fellow who considered himself quite the wit - he was only half-right.

      --

      --

      As a matter of fact, I am a lawyer. But I play an actor on TV.

    6. Re:I don't see why this story is on /. by unitron · · Score: 2

      After enjoying The Hobbit and the trilogy and then trying Silmarillion and finding it about as much fun as the time I tried to get through a couple of pages of Karl Marx, I wouldn't be surprised to learn that it was it and not the parody that was originally written in Russian.

      --

      I see even classic Slashdot is now pretty much unusable on dial up anymore.

    7. Re:I don't see why this story is on /. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh, you are sooo insightful. Man, Tolkein sold out and alienated his true fans. I bet you listen to limp biscuit, don't you?

    8. Re:I don't see why this story is on /. by Vesuvius_2 · · Score: 1

      slashdot posts news for nerds / stuff that matters. this falls into the former category: news for nerds

  9. LOTR - slightly OT by Bill_Mische · · Score: 5, Funny

    Many years ago there was a summarise the LOTR in 25 words or less...I think the winner went something like:

    Shortarse kills dark lord by chucking ring down volcano. Local vagrant elected king.

    --
    Boring Old Fart (40, married, 3 kids...er no...make that 49, married, 3 grown up kids...it's been a long time)
    1. Re:LOTR - slightly OT by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh man...
      You've ruined the ending you insensitive cloud!

    2. Re:LOTR - slightly OT by tim_uk · · Score: 3, Funny
      Local vagrant elected king


      ARTHUR:
      You don't vote for kings.
      OLD WOMAN:
      Well, how did you become King, then?
      ARTHUR:
      The Lady of the Lake,...
      [angels sing] ...her arm clad in the purest shimmering samite, held aloft Excalibur from the bosom of the water signifying by Divine Providence that I, Arthur, was to carry Excalibur.
      [singing stops]
      That is why I am your king!

      Oh sorry, wrong movie...

    3. Re:LOTR - slightly OT by mentalist23 · · Score: 2, Funny

      You don't become king following some farcical metallurgic ceremony involving a knackered pointy thing...

      --
      Unix does not prevent you from doing stupid things; that would also prevent you from doing clever things.
    4. Re:LOTR - slightly OT by Gudlyf · · Score: 2
      You can check out several of these from Book-A-Minute. Like these:

      The Fellowship of the Ring

      The Two Towers

      The Return of the King

      --
      Trolls lurk everywhere. Mod them down.
    5. Re:LOTR - slightly OT by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      summary of LOTR:

      A cross-country expedition to drop a ring in a volcano.

    6. Re:LOTR - slightly OT by Sgs-Cruz · · Score: 1

      LOTR:

      A bunch of very short people try to return some very bad jewelery.

      (apologies to the originator of this... somewhere)

      -cruz

      --

      Karma: pi (Mostly due to circular reasoning in posts).

    7. Re:LOTR - slightly OT by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Argh. You just made me consider how a Monty Python version of LoTR would be. Bad image. Bad image.

  10. Bored of the Rings by Rik+Sweeney · · Score: 1

    Slashdotted already. How about this one

    Bored of the Rings

    1. Re:Bored of the Rings by ddimas · · Score: 1

      Tim, Tim, Benzedrine! Boo, Hash, Valvoline! First, second, neutral, park! Hie thee hence you leafy narc!

    2. Re:Bored of the Rings by redpop350 · · Score: 1
      My ex wife (big tolkien fan) always kept bugging me to read LOTR. I tried once... but I had already found a copy of "Bored Of The Rings", and read it when I was still in high school.

      I couldn't stop laughing...

      I am very glad to have been able to finally know the story in a context that didn't produce the giggles every time, so I am SO glad they made the movie!

  11. Variations... by technix4beos · · Score: 5, Informative

    I compiled most of the variations into one message, so as to not hammer yet another poor server into oblivion.

    --VARIATION--
    Ernest Hemingway

    It was very late and everyone had left the hall except an old man who sat in the shadows the leaves of the old Mallorn made against the moonlight. The two elves inside the hall knew that the old man was a little drunk, and while he usually was quiet and kept to himself they knew that if he became too drunk he would start setting things on fire, so they kept watch on him.
    He's drunk, one elf said.

    What do you care?

    He's muttering about the secret fire.

    Leave him alone. He used to carry a ring.

    He'll stay all night. He should never have been rebodied.

    The old man rapped on the table with his goblet. The younger elf went over to him.

    What do you want?

    The old man looked at him. Another miruvor.

    You'll be drunk, the elf said. The old man looked at him. The elf went away.

    Look at his bushy eyebrows, he said to his colleague. There is nothing as nasty as an old Man. He'll stay all night and I'll never get any sleep.

    The elf took the bottle of miruvor from the counter inside the hall and marched to the old man's table. He poured the goblet full.

    You should never have been rebodied, he said to the old man.

    --VARIATION--
    Mark Twain

    NOTICE:

    Persons attempting to resolve the question of Balrog wings by means of this narrative will be prosecuted; persons attempting to define the nature of Tom Bombadil will be banished; persons attempting to find allegory in it will be shot.
    BY ORDER OF THE AUTHOR,
    Per G.G., Chief of Ordnance.

    FOREWORD:

    In this book a number of dialects are used, to wit: the Quenya Elvish dialect; the extremest form of the Rhovanion dialect; the ordinary Sindarin dialect; and four modified varieties of this last. The shadings have not been done in a haphazard fashion, or by guesswork; but painstakingly, and with the trustworthy guidance and support of personal familiarity with these several forms of speech.

    I make this explanation for the reason that without it many readers would suppose that all these characters were trying to talk alike and not succeeding.
    THE AUTHOR.

    CHAPTER 1

    You don't know about me without you have read a book by the name of The Red Book of Westmarch; but that ain't no matter. That book was made by Mr. Frodo Baggins and his Uncle Bilbo, and they told the truth, mainly. There was things which they stretched, but mostly they told the truth. That is nothing. I never seen anybody but lied one time or another, without it was the Lady Galadriel, or Elrond, or maybe Gandalf. The Lady Galadriel - the Lady of Lothlorien, she is - and Elrond, and the wizard Gandalf is all told about in that book, which is mostly a true book, with some stretchers, as I said before.

    --VARIATION--
    Mickey Spillane:

    I was sitting by the fire, puffing on a pipe, still nursing a hangover from the ale-fest the night before, when HE walked in.

    He had a long white beard, a magical staff, and legs that youd like to eat on toast.

    "Are you Frodo Baggins," he intoned.

    "I might be," I said. "Who's asking?"

    "My name is Gandalf, Mr. Baggins. And I need your help."

    I looked him over. "Lots of people need my help. What makes YOU special?"

    "Well, Mr. Baggins... there is a certain piece of jewelry. If it fell into the wrong hands, it could prove... troublesome. I need someone to take this ring to Mount Doom, where it can be destroyed."

    I stuck some more weed in my pipe, and said, "Look, doll, let's get one thing straight- you can't come into my hole, tell me a fairy-tale about a magic ring, bat those pretty eyelids, and have me fall at your feet. I stick my neck out for nobody."

    --VARIATION--
    Smeagol writhed in corruption, his lifelong attempts to collectivize the Hobbit economy had twisted his soul and body and brought ruin to the Shire. "Precious," he muttered. "Precious colective good giving according to need." He shuddered at the thought of the unbroken individual standing proudly over a conquered plain with the Ring, and felt jealous that the wholesome power could not be his.

    -Lord of the Rings, by Ayn Rand.

    --VARIATION--
    "Gandalf, Gandalf! Take the ring!
    I am too small to carry this thing!"

    "I can not, will not hold the One.
    You have a slim chance, but I have none.
    I will not take it on a boat,
    I will not take it across a moat.
    I cannot take it under Moria,
    that's one thing I can't do for ya.
    I would not bring it into Mordor,
    I would not make it to the border."

    -excerpt from Dr. Suess's FOTR.

    --VARIATION--
    Ray Bradbury

    In which Gandalf gains a new perspective on his heretofore unexamined mission:

    It was a pleasure to burn.

    It was a special pleasure to see Hobbits eaten, to see them blackened and changed. With the wooden staff in his fists, with this great python spitting its venomous pitch upon the Shire, the blood pounded in his head, and his hands were the hands of some amazing conductor playing all the symphonies of blazing and burning to bring down the tatters and charcoal ruins of history. With his pointed hat on his wizened head, and his eyes all orange flame with the thought of what came next, he mumbled a Word of Command and the Great Smials jumped up in a gorging fire that burned the evening sky red and yellow and black. He strode in a swarm of fireflies. He wanted above all, like the old joke, to shove a haunch of mutton on a spit in the furnace, while the flapping, ridiculous Hobbits died on the porch and lawn of the great Hobbit-hole. While the Hobbits went up in greasy, sparkling whirls that blew away on a wind turned dark with burning.

    Gandalf grinned the fierce grin of all men singed and driven back by flame. Fools of Tooks! he thought with an inward chuckle, as the smell of burnt foot-hair filled his nostrils, as welcome as the smell of a fresh-baked apple pie cooling on the sill.

    He knew that when he returned to Lothlórien, he might wink at himself, a minstrel man, burnt-corked, in the Mirror of Galadriel. Later, going to sleep, he would feel the fiery smile still gripped by his face muscles, in the dark. It never went away, that smile, it never ever went away, as long as he remembered.

    --VARIATION--
    The Lord of the Rings
    or The Land of Middle-earth
    by W.S. Gilbert and Arthur Sullivan

    SCENE. -- Front yard of Bag End in Hobbiton, the Shire. Various hobbits discovered standing and sitting in various attitudes suggested by Rankin-Bass films and trippy illustrations from the 1970s.

    CHORUS OF HOBBITS.

    If you want to know who we are,
    We are gentlemen of the Shire;
    In many an inn and bar,
    By many an alehouse fire,
    We dine on six meals a day;
    Our attitude's bright and gay;
    But we don't mean it that way, oh!
    If you think we are cutesy-poo,
    Like an Ewok or Jar-Jar Binks,
    You don't know what we do:
    When we don't smokes, we drinks!
    Our dwelling is Hobbiton;
    We only stand three foot one;
    We use evil rings for fun, oh, oh!
    We use evil rings for fun!
    If you want to know who we are,
    We are gentlemen of the Shire;
    In inn and bar, by alehouse fire;
    In many, many, many, many, many, many, many, many a bar, oh, oh, oh, oh!
    In inn and bar, by alehouse fire!

    Enter Gandalf in great excitement. He carries a pack of fireworks on his back and a staff in his hand.

    RECIT. -- GANDALF

    Gentlemen, I pray you tell me
    Where a gentle hobbit dwelleth, named Frodo,
    The ward of Bilbo?
    In pity speak, oh speak, I pray you!

    TED SANDYMAN. Why, who are you who ask this question?
    GANDALF. Come gather round me, and I'll tell you!

    SONG and CHORUS -- GANDALF.

    A wand'ring wizard I,
    A thing of spells and magic,
    Of stories dark and tragic,
    Of counsel I'll prophesy...

    That's where inspiration flagged. Although I could post the touching "Departure from Rivendell" scene...

    --VARIATION--
    LOTR by Cesil

    Dear Cesil: Is it true that Frodo lost the ring to Gollum? We were arguing about it during a study session at the local brewery, when these guys dressed like orcs let it slip that Frodo bit his own finger off, and pushed Gollum in Mount Doom so there was no evidence. Is Frodo the next Dark Lord? Anxious in Hobbiton

    Dear Anxious,

    You think if I knew the whereabouts of the ring I'd tell a puling college student? There have been crackpot doom theories (get it?) about the ring ever since it was lost in the last age. It's been a magnet for PBS loons when anyone disappears in a birthday party or a black rider is seen astride a flying saucer.

    Let's set the record straight with a few facts: After Frodo was exhumed in the Grey Havens following the suspicious circumstances of his "fading," particular attention was paid to the manner in which his finger had been severed. It was the opinions of "experts" that the tooth scrapes on the joint were consistent with teeth like Gollum's--worn by gnawing and grinding on bones. However the elves, having ignored the valuable lessons on interrogation taught by the Numenoreans, failed to follow up with questions regarding similar markings on various of Frodo's toes. Hence the persisting rumors.

    No doubt you're hoping that the ring was finally put to bed in the flames of Mordor--lo those many years ago--but that's not certain. There are unsubstantiated rumors that the nursery rhyme from the Middle Ages "Ring around the Rosie" is about the destruction caused by Sam Gamgee's wife Rosie when entrusted with care of the ring while Sam was off fighting wiccans and environmentalists who had risen in the ruins of the witch kingdom Angmar.

    Wagner's famous Ring Cycle is held by certain cultists to be a covert reference to the growing power of the one ring--soon to be passed to the Kaiser, and subsequently Adolf Hitler. Music lovers claim the evil influence of Isildur's Bane pervades Wagner's music, but between you and me, Anxious, it doesn't take much miscalculation to make opera sound like crud.

    Finally, those whacky New Age pranksters claim that the metal from the one ring flowed into the magma of Mount Doom, and is now present in minute quantities in every volcanic eruption--thereby gradually turning the whole of humankind into dark lords. This goes a long way toward explaining prime time TV.

    But in conclusion we'll have to admit that unless it's hidden in a yet another unfound Nazi stash, part of the crown jewels, or that talisman the Dalai Lama keeps around his neck, the one ring of power will just remain a happy memory.

    -- CESIL

    --VARIATION--
    a la "Doc" Smith

    "QX, Sam!" Cried Frodo. "That zwilnik Gollum had just enough jets to cut me free from that blasted ring!"

    Meanwhile Sam's steely gaze followed the form of Gollum into the cracks of doom. The kinetic energy of its wretched body's translation into one with the magma became heat. Heat added to heat. It piled up ragingly, frantically, equilibrating, then turning hotter. Hotter! HOTTER! "By Ulmo's carballoy bowels, ringman Frodo! We gotta get to clear ether!"

    "Udun's jingling bells, Sam! Its covered. I phialed a message to Galadriel to alert our boys in Aeries we'd be needing them! They'll be here in 3.3 minutes, Eriador standard time."

    And as the Grand Fleet of the Eagle Patrol blasted away from Mordor airspace with the two second-stage ringmen firmly in their grip, Frodo wondered when he would next be called upon to pull the chestnuts of the Valar out of the fire again.

    --VARIATION--
    By Neal Stephenson (heavily borrowed, and eerily appropriate)

    Frodo, the Deliverator, belongs to an elite order, a Fellowship of nine members only. He's got esprit up to here. Right now, he is preparing to carry out his only mission that matters. His armor is silver like the light of the full moon, jangling only slightly with its decorative gems. An arrow will bounce off its dwarvenmesh weave like a hammer off an anvil, but excess perspiration wafts through it like the winds over the charred plains of Gorgoroth. All the arrows of all the hunters in the world couldn't cut it against this one.

    When they gave him the job, they gave him a sword. The Deliverator never looks for trouble, but some Orc might come after him anyway---might want his armor, or his cargo. The sword is tiny, aero-styled, lightweight, the kind of sword a Hobbit would carry; it cuts quickly into load-bearing beams without visible effort, and when you get done using it around evil, you have to sheathe it, because it glows in the dark.

    --VARIATION--
    The King of the Nazgul (KotN) fingered the safety buckle that secured the shortsword in it's scabbard. It was modeled after the Gladius design, making it wholly inadequate for going up against Elven armour, but it was perfectly suited for being jammed in the collarbone of a Hobbit 'merc, without calling too much attention to it's owner. His XO, "Camel" Khamul had used a similar weapon in numerous CoIN missions in North Gondor, where he had been sent to disrupt "Elrond's" supply fellowships sneaking down the Is-ild-ur trail.
    The KotN smiled, even without a head. This mission was almost going to be a mead-run. Taking out a squad of sleeping halflings was going to be easier than slaying Wyvyrns sitting on a tarmac...

    -Hunt for the Ring, Tom Clancy

    --VARIATION--
    A Lost Short Story by J.R.R. Tolkien

    The chicken, sunlight coruscating off its radiant yellow-white coat of feathers, approached the dark, sullen asphalt road and scrutinized it intently with its obsidian-black eyes. Every detail of the thoroughfare leapt into blinding focus: the rough texture of the surface, over which countless tires had worked their relentless tread through the ages; the innumerable fragments of stone embedded within the lugubrious mass, perhaps quarried from the great pits where the Sons of Man labored not far from here; the dull black asphalt itself, exuding those waves of heat which distort the sight and bring weakness to the body; the other attributes of the great highway too numerous to give name. And then it crossed it.

    --VARIATION--
    Ringlord

    Frodo looked blankly at the garden. "Sam, is there a reason you pulled up all the flowers?"

    "Oh yes sir, Mr. Frodo, sir. Cause a them wassits, the bugs gottem. Aye. Yessir."

    Frodo turned his questioning stare back to Sam, "And I'm sure this has nothign to do with the fact that Farmer Maggot has been buying them for ten-pence a dozen, either?

    "Errrr....Oh no, not a bit of it, Mr. Frodo."
    * * *

    About that time, the visiting Archprocurer of Old and Mostly Unwanted Documents to Stick on a Dark Shelf in the Library, Gandalf of the More-or-less-seen tower of Isenguard showed up at the Inn of the Prancing Pony. The rough and tumble Eastern men eyed him supiciously. WHich was not unusual, they eyed everyone suspiciously. Including themselves, when they were about a mirror. "Hello there, Barliman. Could you get me a pot of Ale? On my credit, if you please."

    "You've been running up a good tab lately, Mr. Gandalf, sir. You sure you're good for it?"

    Oh, of course, Butterbur. 'Sides, the same law goes all down to Mordor. The night watch'd have my hide if I tried to cheat you. And its not like I expect some horrible fiend from beyond the pale of mortal ken to fight me in a gigantic duel above an ancient Dwarven City, leading to both our deaths, after all.

    Barliman stared at Gandalf. "Errr... that wouldn't be a Balrog you're a speakin' of, right?

    "Exactly sir. I cannot possibly be speaking of a Balrog since they don't exist. Hence I must be good for my debt. Haha."

    ~Terry Pratchet, though he would have done a much better job than I, surely.

    --VARIATION--
    LotR Z
    "This foe is beyond any of you... his power Level has reached at least 30,000 after fighting every Dwarf in Moria. Ki Fhy to the gate Aragorn, you must lead them on!" The muscles beneath Gandalf'sGrey Cloak strained in anticipation of the coming battle.

    Soon after, when they were nearly at the gate, the Balrog launched a surprise Ki attack, knocking down Borrmir and stunning Blazing Fist Gimli.

    Gandfalf turned to face him. "Fool!" said he, I don't have time for this nonsense... "Pure Flame of Arnor Shield Wall Strike!" The massive energy wall sstreaked off towards the Balrog, who was knocked flying... though no-one was sure whether or not he had wings.

    "Raaaaauuuugggg! Gandalf, I have not shown you my true power!

    Haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa aa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
    aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa aa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
    aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa...

    five minutes later

    aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa aa aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
    aaaaaaaaa!

    Now I am a Super Balrog 2!!!!! My power level has gone up to 3 million!"

    Gandalf just smirked. "I probably shoud have told you, after you left the service of Eru, we figured out a few new tricks. Here's a good one:

    Kaaaaaaaaaa------Meeeeeeee------Haaaaaaqa-----Me ee eee----

    -The Balrog laughed in anticipation of Gndalf's feeble attack-

    HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA! "

    The resulting explosion threw the Balrog back agaoinst the walls of Moria. His expression turned to one of complete disbelief. "Urrrghhh.... Ahhh... Ugghhhhh.... That's...not possible...."

    The rest of the Fellowship of the Z Ring stared, twitching slightly and grunting in awe at Gandalf!

    Gandalf grinned, "another one of those tricks I learned... I learned how to Hide my POWER level!"

    --VARIATION--
    My name is Baggins. Frodo Baggins. 00Hobbit, license to quest.

    Oh Frodo! Last night was magnificient! Stay with me here in Lothlorien forever.

    I cahn't Galadriel. The Grey Wizard, G, gave me an assignment to infiltrate Mordor, & destroy the One Ring.

    I know, and when I take the Ring from your corpse, I shall rule in glory, and all shall love me and despair. Last night was Heaven, Mr. Baggins. Now go there.

    BANG-BANG-BANG!

    ARRRGH!

    Galadriel, a Double Agent. Well, well, well. Too bad. But, I always preferred my elves shaken, not stirred. And certainly not shot.

    --VARIATION--
    Of the great War of the Ring, and the tast
    Of that Forbidden power, the long and
    Arduous trek, thru' fiery, blasted plains
    With faithful Hobbits and treacherous beasts
    To Chaos' edge, and there to cast the One
    To endless fire and eternal death:
    Sing Heav'nly Muse, that in Rivendell did'st
    First teach of the Rings of Power forgéd,
    In the beginning how the Dark Lord Sauron
    Brought into the world from fiery depths
    Of Doom this ring of gold, pouréd into't
    His Malice and his Evil; I now
    Invoke thy Aid to my Adventrous song
    That struggle as it might to take to th'air
    Though will I drag from bottomless perdition
    Things unattempted yet in Prose or Rhime
    And justifie the ways of men to Elves.

    LotR, by John Milton

    --VARIATION--
    The Lord of the Rings

    Starring Humphrey Bogart and Marlene Dietreich

    Directed by Howard Hawks

    --VARIATION--
    A rather interesting link..
    http://ringil.cis.ksu.edu/Tolkien/Movie/lo tr.mov

    --VARIATION--
    o/` Wraith-wraithery, wraith-wraithery, wraith-wraith-eree,
    A Nazgul's as nasty as nasty can be.
    Wraith-wraithery, wraith-wraithery, wraith-wraith-eroo,
    your luck will run out when I'm looking for you.
    So give me the Ring, or you're Nazgul, too! o/`

    o/` Just a spoonful of lembas helps the athelas go down,
    the athelas go down,
    the athelas go down.
    Just a spoonful of lembas
    helps the athelas go down
    in a most delightful way. o/`

    o/` Feed the orcs, tuppence a bag,
    tuppence, tuppence, tuppence a bag. o/`

    o/` Oooh...taurelilomeatumbalemornatumbaletaurealomean or,
    if you say it too slow then you won't make it to dinner.
    Unless you've got some time on hand don't say I didn't warn ya.
    taurelilomeatumbalemornatumbaletaurealomeanor . o/`

    -excerpts from Merry Poppins, P.L. Travers & Walt Disney.

    --VARIATION--
    People were always asking me, did I know Gollum.

    "AAAIEEE!"

    With a crazed and deformed Stoor clenching his jaw on your finger, you only speak in vowels.

    With my finger, I can feel the half-chewed fish stuck behind his tongue. I totally forgot about the whole Ring destruction thing for a second and I wondered how clean his teeth were.

    The cave we're standing in won't be here in three minutes. You take an ancient evil Ring of Power and add a 98-percent concentration of flaming lava. Explosion. I know this because Sauron knows this.

    This is our world now. Two minutes.

    Two minutes to go and I'm wondering how I got here...

    Fade to a support group: "Remaining Hobbits Together."

    --Openning of Chuck Pahlaniuk's LoTR

    --VARIATION--
    LotR by George Orwell:
    "I cannot read the fiery writing," said Frodo.
    "There are few who can," replied Gandalf. "It is the language of Mordor, which I will not speak here. Translated into the common tongue, it reads:
    'All rings of power are equal,
    But some rings of power are more equal than others.'"

    LotR by Dave Barry:
    At the end of the Council of Elrond, everyone concluded that 'Shards of Narsil' would be a great name for a band.

    LotR by Matt Groening:
    Frodo suddenly reappeared, bleeding from the hand.
    Gollum triumphantly cried, "Hmmmm...hobbit finger with ring of power garnish."
    But as he danced in victory, Gollum slipped and fell into the pit of fire. The Cracks of Doom echoed with his last despairing cry of "D'oh!"

    --VARIATION--
    We were 20 steps from the exit when the giant flaming Balrons first appeared over our heads. These weren't your normal giant flaming Balrons but some sort of interdimensional Maia that would sit and spin in mid air before dissolving before your very eyes and sneaking up behind you. Gandalf had the pipe and I had the ring which, so far, I had been able to resist trading to the local drug lords for another package of white. Gandalf was shouting random Macrohydration spells while simultaneously trying to not trip over his robes and fall face first into the local pools of goo. Legolas took another drink from his flask and, once again, began explaining how elves were different than humans and much, much mellower.
    - Hunter S. Thompson

    --VARIATION--
    The trouble with writing an epic, I find, is knowing just where to begin. So here I am, quill and parchment at the ready, a full bowl of pipeweed and, dash it, have great difficulty in beginning! That's the trouble with epics, as I suspect old Treebeard himself would say, and wasn't he a one for insisting that every story begin at the very beginning - of time, that is, and it takes all one's memories of school training to be polite to the old boy when you're rushing to catch an Eagle.

    I brought this up with Gandalf when he dropped by yesterday. "Gandalf", I said, "Do you remember that old ROP we dropped into the crack of Mount Doom?" He did, of course. It was one of those rectangular - no, I mean rhetorical - questions. How could one forget? It was a tale to freeze thy blood, to make one's hair stand on end like quills upon the fretful porpentine - though I've never understood why one says porpentine when you mean porcupine. Something to do with elves, no doubt. I had been thinking of making a start by putting one of the elven marching songs on the title page, but all I can remember os 'Ding, dong, ding, dong, ding, dong, I hurry along', which would never do. Elrond would never approve.

    So Gandalf applied himself to the task at hand - and that's a sight to see that makes strong men gasp and the ladies swoon. You could see the blood whizzing through that magnificent brain of his, chock full of all that health food he grazes on with Tom Bombadil. When there's a problem to be solved, just slip a few nuts and berries to old Gandalf and stand back, I say. Frightening, really.

    So after a good think, Gandalf suggested Bilbo's eleventy-first birthday, and I knew right away I held the winning ticket, cash for life with no taxation. "Perfect" I told him. "That's just precisely where I'll set the starting post. You have hit the n. right on the h."

    P. G. Wodehouse

    --VARIATION--
    In summer, the scorching sun above Middle-earth sears the land. Perched high on the dome of the sky, it bakes everything down, forcing the Hobbits, the Elves and the men to do their work quickly and retreat to their homes, staying in the cool shade while the orb of light attacks them from overhead. During the winter, on the other hand, the sun only climbs above the horizon for a few hours each day, and then dips back and plunges the world into darkness. The snow drives downward, the winds howl, and everyone, men, Elves, Dwarves, Hobbits, and Orcs, can feel the chill penetrating to their bones.

    Frodo had set out from his home in the Shire, hoping for a chance to see the real Middle-earth. While his official purpose for the journey was to destroy a magic ring in the fires of Mount Doom, he had really accepted the invitation to join the quest because he viewed it as an opportunity to experience the genuine outside world. He had heard stories, of course, about how Hobbits who left the Shire, although naïve and ambitious at first, would eventually turn against the other cultures with scorn, and would long for their cozy hobbit-holes, their elaborate tea parties, their pipes of tobacco before second breakfreast. "Is it true what they say about hobbits who journey eastward, that we all eventually lose the spirit of adventure and just want to return to our cozy homes after a few months," he asked Gandalf once as they sat around the campfire, but the wizard declined to provide a direct answer.

    Regardless, he had remained inquisitive during the flight from the Nazgul and the stay at Rivendell. But as each day passed and the winter grew colder and more ominous, the dark bulks of the Misty Mountains loomed on the horizon up ahead. Their peaks seeming to be lost in the cloud cover, the mountains dwarfed everything, blotted out everything. Their massive bulks weighed on the members of the Fellowship, and the swirling snow seemed to wrap around them, cutting off and suffocating them. There, on the slopes of the Caradhras, Frodo suddenly felt small and insignificant, as if nothing that a little Hobbit could achieve would ever amount to anything more than that, snowflakes whirling in a storm.

    from A Passage to Mordor, by E. M. Forster

    --VARIATION--
    See Frodo run,
    Run Frodo run.
    See Sauron search,
    Gollum and Frodo are playing,
    Oops, Gollum dropped the ring in Mount Doom.
    Now Sauron will have to find another ring.
    -- See Frodo Run

    --VARIATION--
    Frodo crept down the stairs of the of the castle, his invisible cloak sweeping around his legs. He simply had to get the ring into Professor Saurons office without attracting attention. The castle was quite and he made his way without difficulty. A faint light was glowing from under the Professors door but nobody appeared to be in the office. Sneaking in quietly, he saw the volcano on the ledge bubbling quietly. He was just about to throw this ring into the fiery chasm when the door burst open and the Professor strode in. Not having time to think, Frodo Potter froze on the spot, grateful for being invisible.

    Professor Sauron wasn't the only person who entered the room however. A massive hulking glowing monster had also ambled in alongside him and they were now deep in a conversation. Frodo froze, although he had never met one of those before, he had heard about it enough times to know that the thing standing in front of him was a Balrog!

    "I want you to send a message to Professor Saruman, Tell him that I am prepared to join forces so that we can both live our lives without worrying about prying eyes. Fly swiftly for I need the message soon"

    "But I dont have no wings" said the Balrog dumbly

    "Use a broomstick you fool" snarled professor Sauron and swiftly left the classroom.

    So it was true thought Frodo Potter, Sauron wan't to get rid of him and he was willing to enlist the help of Saruman to do it. He had to tell his friends Pippin and Merrione, they would know what to do.

    "striding out of the classroom as fast as he could, he turned down a corridor without looking and a giant flash of green light blinded him. The scar on his forehead was now excruciating with pain. The last thing he saw before he blacked out was the figure of Elrond laughing madly.

    Frodo gradually became aware that he was now lying in a bed. Trying to get up, he heard a gently voice in his ear.

    "Ah, Frodo, it seems we are up and about already", it was the gentle voice of Headmaster Gandalf.

    "I suppose you want to know what happened last night, It turns out that your last Defense against Dark Arts teacher wasn't really Elrond at all but was actually Lord Melkor's minion, Smeagol. You see, nobody actually knew what Elrond looked like before he came to HobbitWarts becuase he kept to himself. When Smeagol arrived, we all assumed it was Elrond. Quite unfortunate really."

    "But I saw Professor Sauron with that Balrog, he was talking about removing those prying eyes"

    "Yes, Sauron was one of the first suspect something about Smeagol, it was all those potions full of rotten fish that gave it away he said. He knew he couldn't tackle Smeagol alone so he enlisted the help of Saruman. He was the one who found you unconcious"
    "You mean... Sauron is innocent?" stammered Frodo
    "Yes you fool of a Took! I've been trying to tell you that for the last 4 years" snapped Gandalf rather angrily "Now get some rest so we can send you home to your awful Uncle Bilbo"
    -- Frodo Baggins and the One Ring by JK Rowling ("Frodo Baggins and the Knarliest Ring" in the USA)

    --END VARIATIONS--

    I hope Slashdot seriously considers some sort of cache in the future. Google has it. Why not a simple cache for certain submissions?

    --
    user@host$ diff /dev/urandom /dev/uspto
    1. Re:Variations... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      nice job ripping a bunch of people off, fuckface.

      jcterminal
      http://x.nerdnet.com/

  12. Re:Christ IS almighty by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Praise be the name of Our Lord Jesus Christ.

    Actually the movie is ground breaking for the times we live in. There is no profanity or vulgar sexual content in these two movies and they are BLOCKBUSTERS! The Two Towers is raking in the cash and is still #1 at the box office. All this in a time where most #1 movies are full of garbage.

  13. Re:Christ almighty by Archon-X · · Score: 1

    Christ almighty

    Yes, my child?

  14. XXX LOTR by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Someone over here had a similar idea. I get the feeling hes not a Vin Diesel fan :P

  15. Mirror by Rufus211 · · Score: 2, Informative

    here's a mirror of the thread, as of course any messsage board will die under a good /. http://rufus.d2g.com:8080/lotr.html Someone else, please mirror this as it's only on my cable's upstream.

    1. Re:Mirror by Charles+Dodgeson · · Score: 2, Informative
      Someone else, please mirror this

      OK, a copy is now here, But I pay for excessive outgoing traffic, so if it gets hit to hard I will have to take it down.

      So would other people please also mirror it, so that we can distribute the load!

      --
      Prime numbers are exactly what Alan Greenspan says they are -S. Minsky
    2. Re:Mirror by venoma · · Score: 1

      Yeah, I also post on that MB and it is UNDER NORMAL CIRCUMSTANCES under very. heavy. load.

      I wish this hadn't been posted. Yeech.

  16. Ignorant fool! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Principally, it's a book, not a film.

    Do you know who J.R.R. Tolkien is?

  17. You bastards! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You killed the SDMB hamsters!
    Poor Message Board... I'll miss you

  18. Re:Christ almighty by ideonode · · Score: 1

    Umm, it's actually a book first. Which is why we're talking about re-writing it in the style of someone else.

    It is also, since you mention it, a groundbreaking, life-changing new product, almost, but not quite, utterly unlike the Segway.

  19. moron fauxking wIEnIE bouys by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    get over it. take the test drive. it doesn't hurt a byte. honest.

    ur so on robbIE's foems list.

  20. What you mean PJ's the Two Towers? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    That was bad enough, in my opinion. Why PJ insisted on re-writing 90% of the story is beyond me.

  21. Re:Christ almighty by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    almost, but not quite, utterly unlike the Segway.
    Nobody asked for people to start posting Slashdot comments in the style of other authors now, did they? Naughty naughty!
  22. Thomas Pynchon by meta.chris · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Thomas Pynchon, IMO, would be the most facinating and bizarre person to have written the trilogy.

    If it had been the case, Pynchon's Lord of the Rings may very well have made his Gravity's Rainbow (which varies from horridly arduous to incredibly beautiful) look like The Little Engine that Could (the only book out of the above that i've actually read every sentence from).

    1. Re:Thomas Pynchon by jefu · · Score: 2
      You have a sick and fertile mind indeed.

      The mind boggles. And having boggled moves on.

      My congratulations. I'd never thought of this, but now it will probably haunt me. And I'm likely to be grinning about this now for days.

      I would suggest that if you say anything about this anywhere near any MLA (Modern Language Association) get togethers, you may want to avoid dark alleys.

      The things you find on slashdot. Who'd a'thunk it?

  23. Lighten up by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Give us a breeak, will you? No one is suggesting that the LOTR should have been written by these other authors or in those styles--people are just having a little literary fun. Take a deep breath, step away from the keyboard, and stop taking yourself so friggin' seriously.

  24. My Favorite by chevelleSS · · Score: 1

    Was the spoof of Merry Poppins :) o/` Wraith-wraithery, wraith-wraithery, wraith-wraith-eree, A Nazgul's as nasty as nasty can be. Wraith-wraithery, wraith-wraithery, wraith-wraith-eroo, your luck will run out when I'm looking for you. So give me the Ring, or you're Nazgul, too! o/` o/` Just a spoonful of lembas helps the athelas go down, the athelas go down, the athelas go down. Just a spoonful of lembas helps the athelas go down in a most delightful way. o/` o/` Feed the orcs, tuppence a bag, tuppence, tuppence, tuppence a bag. o/` o/` Oooh...taurelilomeatumbalemornatumbaletaurealomean or, if you say it too slow then you won't make it to dinner. Unless you've got some time on hand don't say I didn't warn ya. taurelilomeatumbalemornatumbaletaurealomeanor. o/` -excerpts from Merry Poppins, P.L. Travers & Walt Disney.

  25. it's not fair by DrSkwid · · Score: 3, Funny

    the plebs have invaded the ivory towers and, gasp, have started enjoying themselves.

    Why can't we go back to when it was mine.

    I'd love to see your face when the first season of "The All New LOTR - Frodos Secret Diaries" starts on Fox.

    --
    There are places where the networks are not touching,and there are places where they are-Boeing's Lori Gunter
  26. Hollywood View of the World by pommiekiwifruit · · Score: 4, Funny
    Just remember that the President of North Korea, Kim Jong Il, which is working on nuclear weapons (and can already more than reach Japan with its missiles), gets his view of the world through Hollywood movies.

    Whatever you do, don't send Arnie over as a (republican) goodwill ambassador...

    1. Re:Hollywood View of the World by The+J+Kid · · Score: 1

      Whatever you do, don't send Arnie over as a (republican) goodwill ambassador...

      They didn't, they sent James Bond.

      --
      Moderation: +4. Modded 70% Funny and 30% Overrated. 100% Saturated.
  27. Re:Christ almighty by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Kudos for getting the DNA ref!

    -ideonode

  28. Re:Christ almighty by nmg196 · · Score: 2

    It's a book actually you stupid man.

  29. LOTR: The Twin Towers by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I think I saw that film on TV, it all happened in NYC, the end was much shorter though and less ORCs died.

  30. Dammit! (Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had...) by keller · · Score: 2, Funny
    WHAT?

    The ring is destroyed, aw man now you ruined the last movie for me, completely...

    --

    Enig? Det alt for hot det smor!

    1. Re:Dammit! (Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had...) by carlos_benj · · Score: 1

      That was the alternate ending. Yeah, that's it....

      --

      --

      As a matter of fact, I am a lawyer. But I play an actor on TV.

    2. Re:Dammit! (Re:Just think if SLASHDOT had...) by Reglar_Joe · · Score: 1

      You'd do yourself a big favor by reading the books sometime this year.

  31. left out... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    All your rings are belong to us.

  32. It's just another case of. . . by snitty · · Score: 1

    . . .far too much time on their hands.

    --
    Modular Redundancy--Because 4 out of 5 Nodes agree
    1. Re:It's just another case of. . . by lemonk · · Score: 1

      just like the kind of people who reply just to say how much time people have on their hands..

      --
      You are only popular on the Internet.
  33. Simple... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    We would have been different children, just like if Nick Nolte played Han Solo. Night would be day, and cats would be dogs, etc...

  34. H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarities by Nova+Express · · Score: 5, Insightful
    Oddly enough, just last night I was thinking of similarities between H. P. Lovecraft and J.R.R. Tolkien. (No, really.) Though much of their work seems diametrically opposed, there are a number of similarities in their life and their approach to fiction:

    • Both looked longingly back on what they considered idyllic childhoods.
    • Both were antiquarians who looked to an era in the past as a golden age, disdaining the present, the idea of progress, and the industrial revolution.
    • Both had fathers die at a young age.
    • Both were fascinated what most (non-geeks) think of as dry academic areas: Philology for Tolkien, Astronomy for Lovecraft.
    • Both were political conservatives of aristocratic temperment.
    • Both became leading figures in long-lasting, all-male affinity groups of fantastic fiction writers (Lovecraft with Clark Ashton Smith, Frank Belkamp Long, August Derleth, etc., Tolkien with The Inklings (C.S. Lewis, Charles Williams, etc.).
    • Both wrote tales in which the enormous and complex freight of their backstories was generally unknown to most of their protagonists, and only imperfectly revealed (if at all) throughout the tale.
    • Both wrote works deeply tinged with pessimism and melancholy. Their protagonists might or might not survive, but even in the best of outcomes the world they knew would be forever changed due to events set in motion long before their birth.
    • Finally, and perhaps most importantly, both used the tremendously powerful technique of salting their richly imagined secret histories with tidbits of real cultural, myth and history, which that gave their stories a resonance, depth and verisimilitude that their legions of imitators could never match. Lovecraft stole from dozens of arcane sources, while Tolkien delved into the roots of language to imaginatively reconstruct what he felt were "true myths" about the world.


    Now what I need is for someone who's both a Tolkien and a Lovecraft fanatic to write a critical essay on this topic...

    --
    Lawrence Person (lawrencepersonh@gmailh.com (remove all "h"s to mail)

    http://www.lawrenceperson.com/

  35. Twain-dolf by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Mark Twain as Gandolf: "Rumors of my death have been greatly exaggerated."

  36. Re:Just think if OSNEWS had written LOTR... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...Eugena would have said the the one ring was'nt as good as BeOS.

  37. Peter Jackson by togethergod · · Score: 1

    If Peter Jackson had anything to do with the book it would consist of nothing but surfing elfs and dwarf jokes.

    TT was a farce, but will sell luch boxes

    1. Re:Peter Jackson by Hieronymus+Howard · · Score: 2

      If Peter Jackson had anything to do with the book it would consist of nothing but surfing elfs and dwarf jokes.

      No, that would have been 20% of it. The other 80% would have been battles, more battles and extra battles with some bad dialog (e.g. "if you want him come and get him") scattered in.

      HH
      --

    2. Re:Peter Jackson by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I was kinda let down by TTT. Hard to believe they made this film back to back with the first one. Almost like he shouldn't have had time to digress to Hollywood bullshit.

    3. Re:Peter Jackson by odaiwai · · Score: 2

      People who think that Peter Jackson made a bad movie should be tied down and forced to watch Raplh Bakshi's movie, followed by the Rankin-Bass fiasco (Orcs singing "Where's there's a whip, there's a way") and then forced to listen to Leonard Nimoy sing about Bilbo Baggins.

      dave

    4. Re:Peter Jackson by lostboy2 · · Score: 2

      with some bad dialog (e.g. "if you want him come and get him")

      Bad dialog? I dunno -- PJ has some classic lines in his earlier movies:

      "The bastards have landed!" -- Bad Taste
      "Kicking ass for the Lord!" -- Braindead
      "Your mother ate my dog!" -- Braindead

      I mean, come on, what more do you want? ;-)

    5. Re:Peter Jackson by PinkStainlessTail · · Score: 2

      You forgot the "Sodomy" song from Meet the Feebles (possibly the most disturbing movie I've ever seen).

      --
      "Slashdot is about legos and staplers." -Cmdr. Taco
    6. Re:Peter Jackson by Verne · · Score: 1

      Dude. You go to far.

      That Leonard Nimoy song is just wrong...

      --


      There are only two things in this world that smell like fish. And one of them's fish...
  38. Wait!!! Your violating the DMCA!!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    As I've read you can't imagine anything like this because it violates the DMCA!! This article needs to be removed now ... or I'll sue!!!

  39. This just couldnt happen by Albinoman · · Score: 1

    Cause hundreds of Sladotters would be trying to crowd around the press, breaking it and racking up a huge repair bill.

  40. According to Illiad ... by EvilTwinSkippy · · Score: 4, Funny

    According to Illiad the story went like this [userfriendly.org]

    --
    "Learning is not compulsory... neither is survival."
    --Dr.W.Edwards Deming
  41. Heinlein by Vidmaster_Steve · · Score: 4, Funny

    I'm imagining this book as written by a latter-years Robert A. Heinlein. You know, when he stopped writing quaint little "juvenile fiction" novels like Red Planet, Space Cadet and The Man Who Sold The Moon, and passed his "grim, gritty, post-future holocaust" novels like Stranger In A Strange Land and Starship Troopers.

    No... I can imagine it as written by the dirty old sex-obsessed mathematician that wrote books like Number Of The Beast. You know the ones I'm talking about. Like a Harelquin romance novel but with mathematicians, so it was cool and all for us dorks in high school to flip through the pages in the prolonged periods of downtime that we had in our English 3 classes back in high school. Yeah, you know those interminable stretches of time when the teacher was forcing you to read Grapes Of Wrath in class when all you wanted to do was bury your nose into some Clarke or Asimov or even Niven.

    So you'd sit there and turn the pages of Number Of The Beast slowly, your eyes darting up to your short, round, blonde teacher yammering away about the Joad family and their time in Needles (yeah, Steinbeck really made that fucking place seem just plain OMINOUS, really built it up to be about fifty thousand times more impressive than it really is. HEY KIDS! THEY'RE JUST FUCKING ROCKS!) between line breaks. Oh no, you're there reading a novel written by a man deep in the grip of senile dementia. One page will be discussing the six-dimensional nature of the universe, the next be describing in meticulous detail sex acts between two middle-aged paunchy scientists. Alternate universes, new positions... This book wavers between insanity and inanity.

    Now... Imagine the Lord of the Rings written in that style... Of course, since women in Tolkien's universe are about as rare as dragons (and the menfolk would much rather quest after said scale-beast than spend some "quality time" with the comely lasses) there would be a marked increase of homoerotic tension in the novel, punctuated with page after page of lovingly-detailed discussion on the technology and mathematics of Sauruman's magic powers.

    Couple that with some Ents and a few Orcs and a Goblin or three and we'll have the best goddamned novel ever written.

    --
    Why is it when I hit ^R that ZSH calls me a cocksucker?
    1. Re:Heinlein by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      >>Like a Harelquin romance novel but with mathematicians,

      ...He licked his finger pi times and put it in her waiting...

    2. Re:Heinlein by Iridar · · Score: 1

      ...He licked his finger pi times and put it in her waiting...

      pie, dolt. He put it in her pie.

      Sheesh...

      --


      Information doesn't want to be anything

      .
  42. Not directly LotR, but.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    ..There's a book of tales written by various authors, set in Middle Earth.

    For the life of me, I can't remember what the hell it's called. The (blank) Tales or something. Not to be confused with The (blank) Tales that Tolkien wrote.

    If I remember correctly, it opens up with a piece by Donaldson, and then goes on to other authors, some mostly famous, others quite obscure. (Peter S. Beagle, as seen in the opening blurb of certain versions of the LotR books, has a story in there as well.)

    Yeah, I know, not very informative, but I've only seen the book once, and still need to get around to reading it myself.

    1. Re:Not directly LotR, but.. by carlos_benj · · Score: 3, Funny

      I once read a book. It was about.... something. Had these characters in it and was set somewhere. I think it may be the one you're talking about....

      --

      --

      As a matter of fact, I am a lawyer. But I play an actor on TV.

    2. Re:Not directly LotR, but.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Clerks? Do you have that movie, with that guy, who was in that other movie...?

    3. Re:Not directly LotR, but.. by invenustus · · Score: 2

      That must be the book Ellen Feiss wrote her paper about before the PC crashed.

      --
      grep -ri 'should work' /usr/src/linux | wc -l
    4. Re:Not directly LotR, but.. by polaar · · Score: 1
  43. Can't be Gibson by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    it's almost readable - shit, but readable.

  44. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The main difference is that in Lovecraft's version the return to the Shire would have only been the start of the end and Frodo would be either dead or living like Gollum in the final paragraph.

    Actually that could be quite an interesting read.

  45. One of the few times when... by dpilot · · Score: 4, Informative

    "Read the rest of this comment..." is definitely worthwhile.

    --
    The living have better things to do than to continue hating the dead.
  46. The Adventure of the Crack of Doom, chapter 1 by ebcdic · · Score: 3, Funny

    As I stood at the window, gazing through the swirling fog, I observed a figure hesitating on the other side of the road. "A client, Holmes!" I exclaimed. "I have been expecting him," my friend replied, "tell me what you make of him".

    "From his hooded cloak I deduce that he belongs to some religious order," I began, applying the deductive methods that I had seen Holmes so often display. "Evidently he is of great age, from the way he stoops almost to the ground as he crosses the street, almost as if he were sniffing a trail." But as he reached the house, he stood up with surprising vigour, and we immediately heard the ring of the bell. Moments later, the door to our room sprang open, and in strode the dark figure, his face completely hidden by his hood.

    "Forgive me if I do not introduce myself," he said. "I have a task for you, Mr Holmes. A simple matter, no doubt, for one with your
    abilities. My master - a foreign potentate, his name need not concern you - is the owner of an ancient piece of jewelry, which has been stolen. It has no intrinsic value - it is a simple gold ring - but it has great sentimental value to him. Find it, and you can name your price."

    "Both your errand and your master are already known to me," said Holmes. He wrote a name on a sheet of paper and passed it to the visitor. "I have a number of other cases on hand at present, but I will look into the matter if I have time."

  47. If George Lucas.... by briggsb · · Score: 3, Funny

    wrote it here's what it would probably look like.

    1. Re:If George Lucas.... by rmohr02 · · Score: 2

      "Yousa steala precious from meesa!"

    2. Re:If George Lucas.... by kaalamaadan · · Score: 1

      On this note, there is a connection between Star Wars and LoTR. The term for middle-earth in Quenya is "Endor", the planet in Return of the Jedi.

  48. Re:Christ almighty by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I wish everyone would just shut up about this damn movie. It's a movie, not some groundbreaking, life-changing new product like the George Forman Grill.

  49. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Most of your similarities come from a common source:
    Both were romantics.

    However, there are some significant differences as well, for instance:
    Lovecraft was a solid agnostic/athiest whereas Tolkien was a devout catholic.

  50. If Bush wrote it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The ring is a Weapon of Mass Destruction controlled by the axis of evil. They tried to kill my father with it. Lets nuke Iraq.

  51. Re:I CAN'T BELIEVE IT by jedie · · Score: 2

    Well, you're new areound here aren't you? :p

    --
    "The majority is always sane, Louis." -- Nessus
    http://slashdot.jp
  52. This is just silly - Damn Straight! by zrk · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Maybe you need to lighten up a little. You comment is exactly the point! Parody is freedom of expression, and I find many of them hilarious. Think of it along these lines: If Windows hadn't been sold commercially, I don't think this parody discussion regarding Bill Gates would have made it to /. If Linux hadn't made it as a viable operating system, I don't think making fun of it would be a /. topic. If Cowboy Neal hadn't helped make/provide Opinion Polls, his name wouldn't always be used as a joke option on /. Sorry, Thalcon, this topic is news for nerds, and apparently you don't get nerd humor. Maybe you can find a way to deal with that.

  53. Ring Bearer's License Agreement by khendron · · Score: 5, Funny

    Somebody asked for a legalese LotR:

    Ring Bearer's License Agreement

    Please read the following license agreement (hereafter referred to as "AGREEMENT"). You must accept the terms (hereafter referred to as "TERMS") of this license to bear the Ruling Ring (hereafter referred to as "RING") to the Crack of Doom in the land of Mordor (hereafter referred to as "DOOM").

    GRANT OF LICENSE: This license grants you the right to bear RING to DOOM. You may bear RING only to DOOM, and any other land that is required to pass through in order to reach DOOM. Once you have reached DOOM, you agree forthwith to toss RING into the Crack that are found at DOOM. Any hesitation or deviation may be interpreted as a breach of TERMS, causing immediate and irrevocable termination of AGREEMENT.

    LIMITATIONS OF LICENSE: This AGREEMENT does NOT grant you permission to allow others to bear RING, except where circumstances make such a transfer desirable. Such circumstance will be interpreted as a transfer of license, and the new bearer shall be bound by the TERMS put forth in AGREEMENT. You are further discouraged from wearing RING, except in circumstances where the protection and insight provided by RING are deemed useful in reaching DOOM. Under no circumstances are you permitted to transfer RING to one Sauron (hereafter referred to as "ENEMY") or any employees or representatives of ENEMY.

    TERMINATION OF LICENSE: This AGREEMENT shall be deemed terminated under the following circumstances: (1) RING is tossed into the Crack found at DOOM; (2) Your death, and the death of all your companions; (3) Major deviation from the path to DOOM; or (4) RING is transferred, voluntarily or involuntarily, to ENEMY or an employee or representative of ENEMY. In the case of (4) with voluntary transfer, the Valar in the Undying Lands would like to have a word with you.

    --
    Life is like a web application. Sometime you need cookies just to get by.
    1. Re:Ring Bearer's License Agreement by clarkc3 · · Score: 1
      This AGREEMENT does NOT grant you permission to allow others to bear RING, except where circumstances make such a transfer desirable. Such circumstance will be interpreted as a transfer of license, and the new bearer shall be bound by the TERMS put forth in AGREEMENT.

      So didnt Frodo transfer the license to Tom B. then?

  54. Oh baby by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "Danielle Steele, Ayn Rand(!!)"

    Looks like market-orgasm time for sn0rt.

  55. Re:Christ almighty by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Yeah, but there hasn't been a groundbreaking, life-changing new product story on Slashdot since ... forever.

  56. LOTR UserFriendly style by andrius_sytas · · Score: 0, Redundant
    Ever wondered what Lord of the Rings would look like in the UserFriendly comic strip universe?

    Here is the answer. High octane laughs await.

    New to the strip should start by skimming through a couple of early UF strips to get in the mood, and this for Dust Puppy background.

  57. /. effect by someguy42 · · Score: 0

    Oh well, at least I got halfway through the thing before the /. effect hit.

    --
    The probability that someone is watching you is directly proportional to the stupidity of your actions.
  58. There is No Anti-Industrial Subtext by LPetrazickis · · Score: 1

    Actually, Tolkien's middle-earth has no anti-industrial subtext. Both Anwe and Melkor and their followers used industry.

    You would have seen this if Jackson had chosen to showcase a Dwarven civilization at the height of its power instead of debasing Gimli with "jokes".

    --
    Is this a sigs-optional kind of place? 'Cause I am totally down with that if you know what I mean.
    1. Re:There is No Anti-Industrial Subtext by nelsonal · · Score: 1

      I was pretty disappointed that the movie didn't include one of the ent's lines, I think it was Treebeard, about the orcs cut down trees that they don't need to use. The ents in the book didn't seem to have a problem with someone using the wood for products, it was the wholesale deforestation of the orcs that annoyed them enough to attack.

      --
      Degaussing scares the bad magnetism out of the monitor and fills it with good karma.
    2. Re:There is No Anti-Industrial Subtext by Big_Monkey_Bird · · Score: 1

      >

      Don't ask me, I'm merely following the thread. I was merely saying that Ayn Rand probably would have picked up on an anti-industrial subtext if there was one.

      Now, I'll go find the biggest, smelliest volcano/foundry and hug it.

    3. Re:There is No Anti-Industrial Subtext by odaiwai · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Yet another prime case for a "-1, Bzzt! Wrong!" moderation option.

      One of the key themes in the book is a rejection of the sweeping modernisations which Tolkien saw as destroying the villages he grew up in.

      Saruman and Sauron develop methods of mass-producing warriors (Orcs) with inhumane technology, while each hero is crafted by the good guys. Saruman's technology (the mines and mills of Isengard) is destroyed by the ents as evil works. The Scouring Of The Shire is a direct rejection of industrial methods from the pastoral idyll.

      Dwarven civilisation is the height of craftsmanship, not industrialisation.

      dave "nikon zoom"

    4. Re:There is No Anti-Industrial Subtext by Daytona955i · · Score: 1

      "Actually, Tolkien's middle-earth has no anti-industrial subtext."

      Did you read Tolkien's books? Saruman's turning to evil was essentially his adoption of Industry. This is clearly seen in the book as well as in the movie. His tearing up the forest to fuel the fires and the army he creates.

      "You would have seen this if Jackson had chosen to showcase a Dwarven civilization at the height of its power instead of debasing Gimli with "jokes"."
      Dwarves mines for gold, something done long before the Industrial revolution. They didn't mine for coal to fuel the fires of industry.

      The elves lived in the forest in a sort of symbiant relation. The hobbits of course were farmers.

      So all the good guys were not industrial and all the bad guys were. (the nutral ents were obviously anti-industry)
      -Chris

    5. Re:There is No Anti-Industrial Subtext by egreB · · Score: 2

      Dwarves mines for gold
      Strictly speaking, dwarves mined for Mithril. That was what lead Moria to its abandonment (is that a word?).


      The hobbits of course were farmers.
      Since I'm on to knit-picking, the hobbits were hunters too. They have "hunter-bows" in the last chapter of the sixth book (in Return of the King), the Scouring of the Shire. They even show some skill with them too. Wormtounge is killed by three arrows before Saruman fell to the ground.

      Else, I agree with you. Though I'm not sure wether the Ents opposed industry, or just industry involving trees. On the other hand, all industry in middle earth involved trees.

    6. Re:There is No Anti-Industrial Subtext by Kailden · · Score: 1

      I think I once read that Tolkein did not intend for any allegory or theme to be interpreted from his books. I wish I could find the quote.

      --
      I need a TiVo for my car. Pause live traffic now.
    7. Re:There is No Anti-Industrial Subtext by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      I think I once read that Tolkein did not intend for any allegory or theme to be interpreted from his books. I wish I could find the quote.


      Try the introduction...

    8. Re:There is No Anti-Industrial Subtext by efflux · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Another poster has mentioned the introduction which may be the case, but I'm at work and can't verify that right now. At any rate, he is quoted on bonus material on the extended DVD set as stating his dispised allegory, but favors "application". Nevertheless, as a writer, his views on the world will inevitably find their way into his writing whether he wants them to or not. I mean, if he's anti-industrialist (or at least anti-creeping-industrialist), he wouldn't portray industrialism/destruction of nature in a pleasant way, would he? No. Sauromon is a villian because he violates the principles that Tolkien holds dear. Whether that be integrity or respect for nature.

      As a final point, I would like to mention Tolkien's revulsion to the idea that LOTR is an allegory for WWII. Granted, we must keep in mind Tolkien did not intend this allegory (so there is a limit to how far we should take this), but it was definately on his mind when he wrote the books. I can state this unequivocally because it is what was on everyone's mind. It impacted every facet of society, shaped the way we view the world. So, in a way, LOTR must reflect this.

      --
      Do I contradict myself? Very well, then I contradict myself, I am large, I contain multitudes. -- Walt Whitman
    9. Re:There is No Anti-Industrial Subtext by LPetrazickis · · Score: 1

      His tearing up the forest to fuel the fires and the army he creates.

      Aule created the shepherds of the trees not to prevent the industrial use of lumber but to slow it down.

      Dwarves mines for gold, something done long before the Industrial revolution. They didn't mine for coal to fuel the fires of industry.

      Ah, yes, their gold must have turned into rings (and iron into swords) through magic and not smelting.

      The mithril mine looked identical to the hole the orcs dug near Fangorn in terms of ladders and hanging contraptions.

      --
      Is this a sigs-optional kind of place? 'Cause I am totally down with that if you know what I mean.
    10. Re:There is No Anti-Industrial Subtext by DunbarTheInept · · Score: 2

      But the Dwarves shaped, melted, and crafted that gold. They didn't just let it sit there in ugly rocky lumps.

      And where did all that armor everyone wore come from? Grown from armor trees? No, Gondor was also industrial, and definately portrayed as good guys.

      What Tolkien rants about was the use of technology to replace natural breeding, specificly the creation of races through magics. The Ents are NOT portrayed as heroic nice guys. They are portrayed as a rather neutral force of nature that only cares about themselves, who were only helping the "good guys" because they had a common enemy.

      When the Orcs attack the Humans, both at Helm's deep and at Minas Tirith, it is quite obvious that the Humans have equal or better tech than the Orcs. What makes the orcsa major threat is their gigantic numbers achieved through unnatural means.

      --

      Don't label something "offtopic" unless you know the topic well enough to tell what's on topic.

  59. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by Charles+Dexter+Ward · · Score: 1

    As pointed often in these comparisions Lovecraft was an atheist and Tolkien was an avid catholic.

    But they share a lot of simmilarities, way beyond their lifes and lifestyle:
    They both created imaginary mythologies based on they deepest dreams and fears: Tokien created a mythology based on his catholic beliefs, where there was always a good vs evil fight, and in all chapters good prevailed. Lovecraft also created a mythology based in what he saw while asleep, but in his case they where nightmares; he created a colorful, vivid and even more complex mythology based on ancient cults where good and evil didn't exist independently but lived togheter.

    You could say Tolkien was inspired a lot by Lovecraft's works, which in some extent is true, but the main reason for these comparisions to pop up is that they where a lot alike, the only main difference was the beliefs they had in life. When it comes to it, all their writing was about their dreams, glorious and epic in Tolkien's case, and darks, frightful and chaotics in Lovecraft's case.

    Also, Lovecraft was a declared racist and a lot of Tolkien scholars say he was a racist too (actually there's a lot of controversy regarding the claims some people has made calling Tolkien a racists, but in any case he, as Lovecraft does, uses the color of the skin to represent the goodness or evilness of a vcharacter)

  60. What, no John Norman? by TerryAtWork · · Score: 2

    I'll write one myself, as soon as I work up the nerve...

    --
    It's Christmas everyday with BitTorrent.
    1. Re:What, no John Norman? by May+Kasahara · · Score: 1

      I'll probably write one later as well. I've got dibs on Douglas Coupland :D

  61. Hunter S. Thompson by agrounds · · Score: 2

    Hunter S. Thompson:

    It was getting dark. Not that the sun setting brought any true darkness to the Shire. These folks knew well the power of the Shire weed and it's potent effects on the uninitiated mind. Parties in the Shire could last for ages and involve imbibing liquids of every known colour and spectra in ghastly quantities. I had been sent to write a report for the Elvish council on the elventy-first birthday of one Bilbo Baggins. Not that I worked for the elves mind you. I was a free spirit in those days. A veritable nomad of unclouded opinion with truly obscene powers of light and fire. Working with the elves afforded me the opportunity to wallow in the heart of the Shire dream. To bathe in the glow of that hairy-footed dimunitive candor which all wizards aspire to, but none achieve. Truly to become one with the earth and to live amongst the Hobbits. I had to prepare for this journey well.. In addition to the wagonload of poppers, crackers, sparklers, flaming dragons, and starbursts, I needed to find a keg of the finest honeywine I could get. I needed to be prepared for an undertaking of this monumental scope.

    1. Re:Hunter S. Thompson by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Decent effort, but the one on the original list is better. Check it out.

  62. Monty Python's LotR by ites · · Score: 2

    'cuse me, are you the Fellowship of the Ring?
    Bugger off! Fellowship of the Ring? Bleeding fags! Of course we're not the Fellowship of the bleeding Ring, we're the People's Followers of The Ring. Bloody Fellowship of the Ring, prancing around on their bloody horses.
    Still, they're not as bad as the Judean People's Ring Front!
    Yeah, sodding Judean People's Ring Front!
    And the People's Front of the Ring!
    Yeah, bleeding People's Front of the Ring!
    And the People's Followers of the Ring!
    Yeah, sodding... hey, wait a minute, we're the People's Followers of the Ring!
    Oh, sorry...

    --
    Sig for sale or rent. One previous user. Inquire within.
    1. Re:Monty Python's LotR by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You can't forget the scene where the Nazgul
      are fighting with Strider in FOTR. You'd
      probably see dialogue like this:

      Strider runs Nazgul 1 through with his long sword.
      Nazgul 1:"Wot? That? It's only a flesh wound!"
      Nazgul 2:"C'mon n' fight, ya pansy!"

      or even upon reaching Rivendell, with this
      exchange between Strider and Elrond.

      Strider: "I had this hobbit with me not half an hour ago, and now he's stone dead!"
      Elrond: "He's not a dead hobbit, he's only restin'."
      Strider: "I know a dead hobbit when I see one,
      and I'm looking at one right now." ...etc.

  63. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by Zech+Harvey · · Score: 3, Insightful


    Ah! But you miss the most important difference between the two: One was devoutly religious, the other a devout atheist.

    Where Ronnie borrowed from the bible, Phil mocked people's reliance on religion to explain things larger than them in the Cosmos. Compared to all the things similar (I would whole-heartedily diagree on the "Golden Age" and Luddistic tendencies point for Phil though, from his writings he embraced new technology and science to give us rational explanations for things occuring around us we didn't understand), their one theological difference seperates the two in form and function, leaving only style.

    Being a fan of both, I would love to do an essay on the subject, but that's as close as I can come to it on Company Time. =)

    --
    Zech Harvey, MCSE, MCDBA, CCNA
  64. Zork of the Rings by ohboy-sleep · · Score: 5, Funny

    You are in an open shire west of a little, white house with a rounded front door. To the north stands your old pal, Gandalf.
    > N
    Gandalf appears glad to see you. "I am glad to see you," he says, "I hear you were given a ring. Could I see it?"
    > I
    You have:
    Flask of ale
    Bread
    Contract for three movies
    One ring to rule them all
    > SHOW RING
    I don't know which ring you mean.
    > SHOW ONE RING TO RULE THEM ALL
    Who are you showing the ring to?
    > SHOW ONE RING TO RULE THEM ALL TO GANDALF
    You are eaten by a grue.

    1. Re:Zork of the Rings by 2names · · Score: 1

      Legend of Eamon. Remember that game? Anyone? Anyone? Bueller? Bueller?

      --
      "I'm just here to regulate funkiness."
    2. Re:Zork of the Rings by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Absolutely brilliant!

      Thanks!

    3. Re:Zork of the Rings by robyn217 · · Score: 2

      That is too funny... This is how it always worked for me:

      Who are you showing the ring to?
      > SHOW ONE RING TO RULE THEM ALL TO GANDALF
      Who are you showing the ring to?
      (ARGH! let me try something else)

      > SHOW ONE RING TO RULE THEM ALL TO WIZARD
      Who are you showing the ring to?
      (ARGHGHGHG! Let me try one more time)

      > SHOW ONE RING TO RULE THEM ALL TO MAN
      Who are you showing the ring to?
      (AHAHAHRHHRHGHGH!!)

      > I HATE ZORK
      (Destroying 5.25 floppy and throwing Apple//e out the window.)

    4. Re:Zork of the Rings by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Play Zork on an Apple IIe... Now thats funny.

    5. Re:Zork of the Rings by dbc · · Score: 2

      Not only remember it, I knew the author. He also hung out at an Apple store in Des Moines, IA. Can't remember his name, prolific coder, though. Before Eamon he did a Star Wars game that was pretty cool for the time. That game was stand alone, Eamon had an adventure engine under it. We did a lot of "stupid Apple II" tricks in those days. (Not II+, I had integer Basic on the mobo. A move up from my SWTP 6800 system, remember those? Man, how I wished I could afford an ASR 33.)

  65. SPOILER in parent post for LOTR by NoInfo · · Score: 1

    (Parent provides a LOTR spoiler without any warning. Mod it down, please.)

    1. Re:SPOILER in parent post for LOTR by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      spoiler? its a freakin book! a classic at that. who thought the ring doesn't get destroyed?

    2. Re:SPOILER in parent post for LOTR by FuzzyBad-Mofo · · Score: 2

      Spoiler? You have got to be joking. How long have the books been in print? Even for movie-watchers only, the purpose of Frodo's quest has already been established in FOTR..

    3. Re:SPOILER in parent post for LOTR by Gluteus+Minimus · · Score: 1

      It's like saying you'll spoil "Band of Brothers" for someone by saying the Allies won WWII.

      --
      My sig's name is Sigmund, but you may call it "Siggy."
    4. Re:SPOILER in parent post for LOTR by ConceptJunkie · · Score: 2

      It was a joke. Not a great one, but a joke nonetheless.

      --
      You are in a maze of twisty little passages, all alike.
    5. Re:SPOILER in parent post for LOTR by GMontag451 · · Score: 2

      Warning: Spoiler ahead. In Titanic, the boat sinks at the end.

    6. Re:SPOILER in parent post for LOTR by yuri+benjamin · · Score: 1

      Or like spoiling The Titanic by saying "the ship sinks".

      --
      You make the mistake of thinking you can educate the fundamental stupidity out of people. You can't.
  66. Re:Christ almighty by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    If you'd started your comment with "I'm about to reference Douglas Adams" it couldn't have been more fucking obvious.

  67. That is it I'm out of here by RodeoBoy · · Score: 0, Troll

    That has got to be the dumbest thing I have seen posted here. Why do the editors thing that all geek are silly children and get off on this stupid stuff. This is worse then the never ending saga of Fartscrape. Just can the damn thing.

    1. Re:That is it I'm out of here by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      LOTR by RodeoBoy (535456)

      Why do the evil wizards thing that all hobbit are
      silly children and get off on stupid magic rings.

      Just toss the damn ring down the crack already. ...with apologies to RodeoBoy?...nah screw it - he
      can take it.

  68. What abot Jim Anchower? by minister+of+funk · · Score: 2, Funny

    LOTR by Jim Anchower: (The Onion)

    Hola, amigos. How's it hangin'? I know it's been a long time since I rapped at ya, but there been all sorts of craziness going on.

    First off, I get this new job as a gardener for this middle-aged short bastard-- Frodo Baggins. The work's pretty easy, and I can grow my own weed. I don't know what it is about the dirt in Hobbiton, but that's some sweet-ass green. Farmer Maggot grows the sh** bigtime and he's always up-in-arms about a couple of local peeps stealin' in. "It's good to share." That's what I always say.

    Anyway, I guess it's not fair to call Frodo (FB, as I call him) a bastard. He tokes as much as I do. I thought I might be growin' it a little too pure though. FB was all talking about this tall dude named Gandalf and how he told him to hide this one ring of his uncle Bilbo's. So, he's layin' this weed-tale on me. I'm already high and am getting a secondary-high of FB's breath and I'm thinking, "Sh**, that little ring would buy me a nice little stash," I shook that off. That was the old, out-of-work Anchower.

    There's this nice piece that works down at the pub. She's been eyeing the anchower package ever since I came growing. At Bilbo Bagins 111th birthday party last week, where he disappeared -- damn, I completely forgot that -- she was all over me. I don't even think she was drunk, and I know I wasn't hallucinating. I still have the bite marks to prove it.

    Anway, this Bilbo guy gets up and, I know it's his birtday and all, and give this wack-ass four word speech and vanishes. I was thinking I was a little too high but everyone else was surprised, too. He hasn't been back since. That's cool, I have a good job, weed, and he had his eye on the pub-chick anyway. Sick old bastard. I gotta give the pops props, though, I saw him sporting 111-year old wood at the pub and I know that I'm gonna be just as nasty at his age. That'll be sweet.

  69. Great, but one thing ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ... LOTR in legalese would have been 10 times longer than the original.

  70. Hmm... George Orwell, 1984 by MoreDruid · · Score: 1
    In Eurasia, Mordor is watching YOU!

    Ehrm.... Nevermind... Sorry... Mindless rambling... Crave coffee... *Gollem! Gollem!*... Master is nice, takes care of cofee... No! he only makes Decaf! Decaf no good!
    OK, I'm going to get a life now. You guys know someplace where you get a special deal for that?

    --
    The best weapon of a dictatorship is secrecy, but the best weapon of a democracy should be the weapon of openness.
  71. Hunter S Thompson by Megane · · Score: 3, Funny
    From this message:

    And now I've got this terrible cross with Hunter S Thompson popping into my head.

    "It was half way to Rivendell when the drugs began to take hold" Hunter S Tolkien "Fear and Loathing in Barad Dur"

    Actually that whole thread has a couple of ideas in it. The root message has Ned Flanders as Tom Bombadil:

    5) I concede to all those who said Bombadil was annoying in my last post. My memory of Tom Hey-ho-merry-dol Bombadil was far less hey-nonny-nonny-annoying than the actual experience of reading him. He ring-a-ding-a-dillo sounds like Ned-diddly-ed Flanders at a hey-doodle-hi-diddle-riddle-diddle-dee Renaissance Festival. And his "Hey, li'l dudes, that whole ring deal? 'tain't my prob-diddly-oblem" attitude nauseated me. The world's about to be turned into a giant Concentration Camp, and he's out prancing in the posies and unwilling to help? Feh.

    --
    #naabhaprzrag, #sverubfr-000, #agi-fcbafberq, negvpyr[pynff*=' negvpyr-ary-'] { qvfcynl: abar !vzcbegnag; }
  72. Anyone remember "Bored of the Rings"? by Woodrow+Stool · · Score: 1

    It was a parody published by either the Harvard Lampoon or the National Lampoon. I have a copy in paperback someplace, ran about 100 pages. The one thing I remember most was "Legolas" was known as "Legolamb".

    About 1973 I think.

    1. Re:Anyone remember "Bored of the Rings"? by unitron · · Score: 2
      There was also the horse Thermofax and the river Gallowine. That's all I can remember cause I haven't seen the book since about '72 or so.

      Oh, and I think the wizard was GoodGulf.

      --

      I see even classic Slashdot is now pretty much unusable on dial up anymore.

    2. Re:Anyone remember "Bored of the Rings"? by andfarm · · Score: 1

      It's still in print. I've got a copy.

      --

      TANSTAAFI: There Ain't No Such Thing As A Free iPod.

    3. Re:Anyone remember "Bored of the Rings"? by Daytona955i · · Score: 1

      You may have a copy but I haven't seen it in print. (ie. a publisher is still printing it so you can go buy a new copy at the local bookstore)

    4. Re:Anyone remember "Bored of the Rings"? by Daytona955i · · Score: 1

      I've heard of it but I've never actually seen a copy. Anyone know if it's online somewhere?
      -Chris

    5. Re:Anyone remember "Bored of the Rings"? by foote · · Score: 1

      I do. It was put out by the Harvard Lampoon. It was full of cheap bathroom humor, brand names, and cravenness, and it was hysterical. The wizard was Goodgulf, the old Boggie (Hobbit) was Dildo Bugger, who lived in the Sty. His nephew was Frito. Frito was accompanied by his servant Spam, and Legolam, Gimlet son of Groin, Stomper (dressed as the Lone Ranger), boggies Moxie & Pepsi Dingleberry, and Bromosel. The sought to destroy Sorehed's ring, which had been borne by Goddam for many years. They fought Narcs and the evil wizard Serutan. The elven land of Lornadoon was an amusement park. There were song and poem parodies, and the authors recreated the various languages. (Gimli the dwarf's war cry: Kodak khaki no-doz!). It was damn funny, and sleazy as hell. I'm not really doing it justice, but then it doesn't deserve justice. Read it and then wash your hands.

    6. Re:Anyone remember "Bored of the Rings"? by Shamanin · · Score: 3, Informative

      Also, they reversed the b's in bilbo to be dildo.

      Now if that isn't as creative as Jacksons elaboration of strider and aeowyns romance (read with sarcastic grin) and striders near fatal death in the skirmish in the fields of Rohan (read with sarcastic grin) then I don't know what is (read with sarcastic grin).

      Don't get me wrong, I think Jackson did a great job.

      --
      come on fhqwhgads
    7. Re:Anyone remember "Bored of the Rings"? by andfarm · · Score: 1

      Correction: I have a copy that I bought, new, at my local bookstore.

      --

      TANSTAAFI: There Ain't No Such Thing As A Free iPod.

    8. Re:Anyone remember "Bored of the Rings"? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    9. Re:Anyone remember "Bored of the Rings"? by jefu · · Score: 2
      It was by the Harvard Lampoon and I have a copy right here (it usually sits on my shelf of Tolkien stuff). It is adolescent, dated, rude, vulgar and very funny. Highly recommended for Tolkien fans and foes alike.

      I can probably do no better than to quote from the blurb inside the front cover : "This book ... tremor ... Manichean guilt ... existential ... pleonastic ... redundancy... " Orlando Di Bisquit, Hobnob

      Some of the characters included the Boggies (hobbits) Dildo Bugger and his nephew Frito, Spam Gangree and the twins Moxie and Pepsi ; the wizard Goodgulf (and his evil counterpart Serutan) ; Legolam the elf, Gimlet the dwarf and of course Arrowroot, Son of Arrowshirt. All going up against the monstrous evil nasty guy Sorhed.

      There you have it.

  73. My girlfriend showed me this one last night, by amarodeeps · · Score: 4, Funny
    ...check it out, it's really funny:
    http://home.nyu.edu/~amw243/diaries/

    I think Merry's is particularly funny. They are more from the perspective of someone who's seen the movies but not the books, but still great.

  74. The Teltale Ring by jonadab · · Score: 5, Funny

    I wanted to post this over there, but their server has succumbed, so...

    True!--nervous--very, very dreadfully nervous I had been and am; but
    why will you say that I am mad? The ring had sharpened my senses--not
    destroyed-- not dulled them. Above all was the sense of seeing in the
    wraith world acute. I saw all things in the earth and under the
    earth. I saw many things from the crack of mount doom. How, then, am
    I mad? Hearken! and observe how healthily -- how calmly I can tell
    you the whole story.

    It is impossible to say how first the idea entered my brain; but once
    conceived, it haunted me day and night. Object there was none.
    Passion there was none. I loved the ring. It had never wronged me.
    It had never given me trouble. For its gold I had no desire. I think
    it was the eye! Yes, it was this! The one eye resembled that of a
    vulture--a fiery red eye, with a dark shroud over it. Whenever it
    fell upon me, my blood ran cold and so by degrees--very graduallyI
    made up my mind to take the old ring to the crack of doom, and thus to
    rid myself of the eye forever.

    -- Opening section of The Telltale Ring, by Edgar Allen Poe

    --
    Cut that out, or I will ship you to Norilsk in a box.
  75. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by avandesande · · Score: 2

    'The Search For Unknown Kadath' was the most Tolkein-like of HP stories. My favorite from Lovecraft.

    --
    love is just extroverted narcissism
  76. Re:Christ IS almighty by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    No profanity or vulgar sexual content in these movies. Just a body count in the 10's of thousands.

    Why is it most of the "religious right", whoever or whatever they are, find killing acceptable but sex between consenting adults wrong?

  77. Here's Robert Frost "Disappearing Ring" by MickLinux · · Score: 2

    That server doesn't seem to allow anonymous posts, and I'm not going to sign up -- but if anyone else wants to copy this to there, feel free:

    DISAPPEARING RING (Mending wall)
    by Robert Frost MickLinux.

    Something there is that does not want a ring;
    that sends the frozen ice-fingers into the land
    and spills the servant-blood in the sun;
    and makes it lose itself so anyone can find it.
    The work of dragons is another thing;
    I have come after them and made repair
    Where they have not left one stone on a stone.
    But they would have the treasure out of hiding,
    to please their greedy eye. The loss, I mean.
    Nobody sees it or hears it when it falls
    But at greatest need we find it gone.
    I let noone know; my shadow even
    and set to hunt the ring once again.
    I keep a secret place for the ring as I go
    to each, the temptation that has fallen to each;
    and some are for power, and some for fear
    There may be a spell to make it stay that way.
    "One Ring to Rule them all and bind all" or somesuch;
    We wear our souls to greyness, just handling it.
    Oh, it's just another outdoor game,
    The ONE against all; it comes to little more.

    Where it is now we do not need a ring.
    Here is all beauty and gardens and ale.
    My apple trees will never blacken the hillside
    and eat Lobelia's flowers, I tell her.
    She only says "You are an imposter; Bag Hill should be mine!"
    Spring is the mischief in me, and I wonder
    if I could put a notion in her head.
    "Why should Bag Hill be yours? Isn't it
    true that you are an Underhill?" But here there are no Underhills.
    Before I claimed a thing, I'd ask to know
    what good I could do it, or it me;
    and who else might come hunting it.
    Something there is that doesn't love a ring,
    that wants it destroyed. I could say "Elves",
    but it isn't Elves exactly; and I'd rather
    Gandalf said it for himself. I see him there
    bringing his staff grasped firmly near the top
    in his hand, like an old stone wizard armed.
    I move half-shadowed it seems to me.
    Not by woods only and the shade of trees.
    He will not stop that incessant saying "take it to Mordor"
    secretly he likes having it for his own.
    He says again "Take it to the Cracks of Doom"
    - but his eye gleams at the saying.

    --
    Correct Horse Battery Staple: 72 bits of entropy. Enter "Correct H" into google. When it generates the phrase, that's
  78. Pynchon by njord · · Score: 2, Funny

    A Nazgul screams across the sky. It has happened before, but there is nothing to compare it to now. Down below, the hobbits work. The Shire twists and wiggles with the tiny shapes crawling across it's surface, with banners of white and red and green. Bilbo sits in the vaginal warmth of his End (his Bag End) and sucks of a dirty corn-cob pipe, listening to the the pads of leathery hobbit hooves against the earth, a whole dance number where all over the performers are drunk on some coconut-flavored drink and can't stay together. The erratic thumps of calloused soles on grassy ground plays a tune to which Bilbo in his reverie of pipe-weed and little invisible people can ponder like a hashishin marvelling at a knife while he drives it into the deep folds of date-nutured fat on a sultan's back.

    Meanwhile, Frodo of the Baggins of the Shire is trying to belch the alphabet in the Green Dragon while a group of plastered but endearing hobbits watch his strained efforts at staying on his little pencil-legs like a whitecoated, bespectacled scientist watches a mantis devour its mate. A tired and grunt precede each haletosic syllable of his poorly crated abcadarium, at which he wobbles a little to the left and then to the right. The barflies keep watching.

    Thomas Pynchon's The Lord of the Rings

  79. The Hobbit Fund by f8xmulder · · Score: 1
    The Hobbit Fund was founded by Grogo Constan-Underhill in the year 1383 of the Third Age through a cooperative effort of the Michel Delving Society and the Rohan-Isengard-Northfarthing Group (R.I.N.G.). The fund exists to help hobbits accept the passing of the elves into the Undying West and to raise support to support investigations into treatments for Ring Quest-related illnesses, injuries, or alterations to the Hobbit way of life. These funds will improve the quality of life for Hobbits both in the Hobbiton and Buckland regions, as well as those living in Bree and beyond, and will be a valuable source of care for future generations of Gamgees, Proudfeet, and Boffles, etc.

    The Hobbit Fund receives contributions made by both Hobbits and other races, most notably the Men of Rohan, who feel a particular kinship with the Halfling people. The Mayor of Michel Delving (and Dean of the Hobbit Fund) offers recognition of each contribution in a letter of thanks or a pouch of Southfarthing's finest weed, as is applicable.

    The Hobbit Fund helps transform an emotional and difficult parting of Elves from the Hobbits into a beneficial and caring time. Those affected by the fun are comforted through the realization that, though they can never attain the Undying Lands, they are still protected by the Men of the West, especially the Rangers who have been responsible for the guarding of the Shire for many years. Additionally, knowledge that will be beneficial for the future happiness of the Hobbit race is attained through the fund's many initiatives.

    Since its founding, the Hobbit Fund has raised almost a mountain of Gold, much of which was generously donated by the Dwarves of Esgaroth and the Lonely Mountain. These funds have supported over ninety different projects designed to foster improved relations between the Dwarves of the Glittering Caves and the Riders of Rohan, overcome sickness brought on by contact with the dreaded Ringwraiths, and increase Middle-earth-wide knowledge of herbs, spices, and weeds, among other projects.

    If you wish to donate to the Hobbit Fund, or if you would just like more information, you may contact Hama of the Guard (hama788@rohanmail.com) or visit the website at www.hobbitfund.org. Thank you for caring.

  80. What I would have like to have seen by Maudib · · Score: 1

    is a David Foster Wallace version.

  81. Re:I CAN'T BELIEVE IT by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    jedie@pandora.be.

    Sorry dude, you were trying WAY too hard.

  82. Frodo's Flying Circus by Vespillo · · Score: 1

    I wonder how Monty Python would have tackled LOTR.

    I doubt much would have changed, except that it might be a golden banana grown in the deep green houses of mordor...

    --
    The problem as I see it is that I have no personality of my own.
  83. pathetic by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    How many of you who posted with lords of the butt rings comments do not consider yourselves pathtic geeks?

    You're wrong.

    I only came to the post to see flames of all your loser "what ifs" so I would have something mildly amusing this morning. To my dissapointment there were far too few flames.

    LOTR may be a good movie... but all you no friend fantasy life assholes have to go and ruin it by blowing your loads thinking that it's the best thing since woman.

    Here's a sugestion. Take a shower, cut your hair, and go to a bar... meet real humans, girls even... talk about real issues... and for christ's sake... please stop stock piling guns and shooting up people at fast food restaurants.

  84. If Only Peter Jackson... by avgjoe62 · · Score: 1
    had included Tom Bombadil in his films. I have had this wish for many years that if a live action version of the film was made, Robin Williams would play Tom...

    "Ooohh...hobbits! That's so neat, man! You don't see them much anymore, they're so easy to overlook. Hey, let go of them you wierded out weed of a tree! [KNOCK! KNOCK!] Anyone in there? Oh, there you are! Wanna go look at Goldberry's water lillies [wink, wink}?"

    Ah well, maybe it is just a dream...

    --

    How come Slashdot never gets Slashdotted?

  85. LOTR by Anthony Burgess by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    There was me, that is Frodo, and my 7 droogs, that is, Samwise,Meriadoc, Gandalf, Aragorn, Gimli, Boromir and Legolas. We were in the Korova Hobbit Bar, slooshying a bit of music and getting all sharpened up with pipeweed for a bit of the old ultra violence on the Orcs of Mordor. Boromir gets to whining he wants the ring, so I pulls my nozh and prepare to give him a great bolshy tolchock with it, when suddenly, it begins to glow - that means great stinking Orcs of stinking Sauron are somewhere near. I imagine the scrap we'll have with them, all the time hearing the great music of the glorious Ludwig Van, all angel trumpets and demon horns.

    Anthony Burgess

  86. Similar concept in book print... by macX_rocks · · Score: 1

    Not LOTR related, but the idea of using popular authors' writing styles and major works' concepts and applying to the writing of 'Leave It To Beaver' episodes produced a book called 'The Beaver Papers'. Dunno if it is still in print, but look for it. Highlarious funny stuff.

  87. No LOTR Logo/Icon? by halo8 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Why oh Why Dear Slashdot Editors dose Lord of the Rings not have a Logo? Starwars has a Logo.. the Ipod has a Logo.. why dosent LOTR?

    Think about it.. all the Posts that are going to be made over the next +2 Years for LOTR.. Movie Reiviews, Spoilers, Trailers, DVD's, DVD Reviews, Special Ed. DVD's, Cast Interviews, Award Shows, ect.. ect... ect..

    LOTR DESERVES its own Logo/Icon

    http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=48383&cid=49 16 794
    http://slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=49299&cid =4983 792

    --
    The More Knowledge you have the Luckier you Get- J.R. Ewing
    1. Re:No LOTR Logo/Icon? by isorox · · Score: 2

      Spoilers

      Spoilers, I dont know where to get them from

    2. Re:No LOTR Logo/Icon? by Dirtside · · Score: 2

      The parent post gets repeated in every single LOTR story. I don't know why halo8 has such a hardon for an LOTR icon -- probably just an overeager fanboi. Can you mod something -1: Redundant if it shows up in every story on a topic? :)

      --
      "Destroy science and religion. Science would re-emerge exactly the same; but not religion." - Penn Jillette, paraphrased
  88. More than a joke in that. by twitter · · Score: 2

    You realize that the world IS watching that movie? Self rightous loons everywhere will be convinced that the best thing to do is fight to an honorable death. Sadam and Jong can both use this film to inspire their troops.

    --

    Friends don't help friends install M$ junk.

  89. What if Bush were Gandalf? by robyn217 · · Score: 2, Funny



    George W. Gandalf: "I would like to name Morder as an Axis of Evil. With the help of Elrond Blair and his elvish folks, and our superb strategory, we will not rest until Morder is defeated."

    Ari Schriber-Baggins: "Sir, there's no oil in Morder? Hmm.. There must be oil in Isengard, Sir."

    George W. Gandalf: "Like I said, the true axis of evil is Isengard. Our dispute with Morder can, and will be solved diplomatically."

    </Political Rambling>

  90. Raymond Chandler's "Lord of the Rings" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Raymond Chandler's "Lord of the Rings"
    By Jonathan Vos Post
    (a slashdotter who forgot his password)
    http://magicdragon.com
    Over 1,000,000 hits/month

    First page of 19 pages completed
    [footnotes deleted]

    Down these mean roads that go ever on in Middle-earth a wizard must go, who is not himself mean, who is neither tarnished nor afraid. He is the hero, he is everything. A complete wizard, an Istari, with the monicker Mithrandir, and yet an unusual wizard. He is a very lonely wizard, though he is the friend of all Free Peoples, and his pride is that you will treat him as a proud man or be very sorry you ever saw him.

    My name is Gandalf. Gandalf the Grey. To most of the folks in the West, I seem to be "just a wizard," a vain, fussy old conjuror with a long beard and bushy eyebrows, whose chief asset is my uncommon skill with fireworks. But trouble is my business.

    Men of the South sometimes think I'm nothing but a pest, a homeless vagabond, a meddler in the affairs of men, and a herald of ill-news. But there was darkness in Middle-earth, and it was much worse than the simple art of murder.

    Let me talk to you a minute about my biggest case. I talk as the man of his age talks - the Third Age, that is -- with rude wit, a lively sense of the grotesque, a disgust for sham and a contempt for pettiness. If there were enough like me, the world would be a very safe place to live, without becoming too dull to be worth living in.

    But there are not enough of me. Just five Istari, this Age. We were basically messengers sent from Valinor to 'contest the power of Sauron, and to unite all those who had the will to resist him.'

    That Sauron, he was the Boss of Bosses, the big enchilada, head of a damned Syndicate, and the most I could do was solve the mystery of who his front-man was, his under-boss, and put the team together who could cut the feet out from under him. Show him out "The Bronze Door" and then, "The Long Goodbye ... "

    Some thought this case was just a petty theft, a gold ring, stolen, lost, found, and hunted. There's a story about that ring, too long to fill one book, but what mattered most was who would wear it. I mean, who would wear the ring. Nobody goes around wearing a book these days. Some thought this case was just about the little guys - halflings, Hobbits, Holbytla, whatever - and how they had to stand up to the goons of the boss and under-boss. Some thought it was a weary travel tale, about a bunch of tourists ankling towards a certain Mount Doom. But then, as they say, there's "No Crime in the Mountains", and if there's no crime, then I've got no way to earn a paycheck.

    [the rest to be posted later on my domain;
    and/or in conventional publication]

  91. An "abridged script" parody of the TT movie by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny
    "The One and Three Quarter Towers"

    http://www.mathom.org/Musor/ttt_revisited.html

    Caution, spoilers for the movie!

  92. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by Ragnar+Forkbeard · · Score: 2, Interesting

    They may appear similar, but when you dig deeper much of that similarity disappears; e.g. Lovecraft may have been "fascinated" by astronomy, but Tolkien studied Philology at Oxford and went on to teach at both the University of Leeds and at Oxford.

    And are Lovecraft's and Tolkien's sources of inspiration really that comparable? Lovecraft's "dozens of arcane sources" vs. Tolkein's extensive use of the rich Norse and Anglo-Saxon mythic traditions?

    (Just a nitpick, but the Inklings weren't actually an "all-male affinity group", as Dorothy Sayers was a member.)

    --
    "America is - without a doubt - the most bizarrre culture this planet has ever produced." --James Lileks
  93. Tom Bombadillo! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I would love to see Dr. Seuss try and top Tom Bombadil's songs.

  94. He is a movie critic. by xyote · · Score: 1
    See the interview here around "We have brought four movies". Apparently he's not too thrilled about the new James Bond movie also from other sources.


    What next? Saddam Hussein as a romance novelist?

    1. Re:He is a movie critic. by deniable · · Score: 1

      What next? Saddam Hussein as a romance novelist?

      Actually, yes.
      Google points to a few references.
  95. Could be worse, could have been filmed by a SIG by EvilAlien · · Score: 3, Funny
    Dwarves are always little more than comic relief, its the plight of the Height-Challenged. Everybody knows that the only three in the Fellowship that can actually fight are Gandalf, Aragorn and Legolas. The short people are there to be rescued, laughed at, or carried around.

    "Funny-like-midgets" is deeply ingrained in our society. It is typical heightism. Its hate literature. It should be stopped! Is it too late to change the title of The Two Towers (gee, wouldn't want to risk making a reference to the WTC in literature written before they were relevant) so that we're sensitive to the Height-Challenged? How about "Lord of the Rings 2: HOOORAY FOR SHORT PEOPLE"?

    --
    perl -e 'print $i=pack(c5, (41*2), sqrt(7056), (unpack(c,H)-2), oct(115), 10)'
    1. Re:Could be worse, could have been filmed by a SIG by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You're a terrible troll. Don't even try anymore.

    2. Re:Could be worse, could have been filmed by a SIG by DunbarTheInept · · Score: 2

      Hobbits are shorter than Dwarves, but treated with more respect in the movies than the dwarf. It's not a short-person thing. It's a "Peter Jackson wanted to add comic relief to a story that wasn't ever meant to have any so he ruined the dignity of one character to do it" thing.

      --

      Don't label something "offtopic" unless you know the topic well enough to tell what's on topic.

  96. Re:Silly and Stupid by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Silly and Stupid, just like:

    http://slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=03/01/06/1957 24 8&mode=thread&tid=137

  97. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by Sloppy · · Score: 1

    You're not really Charles Dexter Ward. You cannot deceive me, Joseph Curwen, for I know that your accursed magic is true!

    --
    As copyright owner of this comment, I authorize everyone to defeat any technological measure which limits access to it.
  98. Actually by geekoid · · Score: 2

    I have always felt Star Wars ep1 was for more related to LOTR, then it was to Hidden Fortress.

    Git something the 'Evil Guy' wants vary badly.
    Evil Guy sends out minions.
    Using cunning and magic, the valuable item avoids the minions, and ends up at a 'great council'.
    The council decides there must be a group of people to go to the land of the evil guy, and destroy the evil by tossing a simple energy bolt down a shaft. This is acomplished by believng in one self, magic, and some last minute cunning.

    --
    The Kruger Dunning explains most post on /. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
  99. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by Creepy · · Score: 2

    It doesn't surprise me at all that Lovecraft is at least somewhat a racist, as the early to mid 20th century was mostly segregated, and many people still viewed blacks as more of a servant class (having previously been slaves). The question is, was Lovecraft more-so than his peers?

    I don't think Lovecraft was trying to associate skin color with evilness to be racist so much as to have the monsters be creatures of nightmares and darkness, which is a concept that has existed for thousands of years (a concept that is ironically promoted heavily by religion...). A creature of night would likely be colored black - like a bat, so they are camoflaged in their nighttime environment. Most of the creatures themselves were based on real creatures/concepts people had fears of, whether it be giant squid/octopi, dead-come-to-life (another religious inspired concept, as the reason for burying people 6 feet deep and putting a large stone on top of the grave was to keep the dead from coming back), bats (Nightgaunts), fish/sharks (Deep Ones, although that is also almost a fear of inbreeding), or creatures that appear out of nowhere (dimensional shamblers).

    The pitch-black Nightgaunts, for instance, weren't really evil, but they were servants of a sort (they brought food [people in the story] to their masters). Ghouls (undead people) weren't always good, either, but they always had white, almost transparent skin (and were usually educated).

  100. Lord of the Rings as an allegory of the PhD by markhlfs · · Score: 1

    We have a copy of this pinned up in the lab at University: http://danny.oz.au/danny/humour/phd_lotr.html

    Personally I especially like the part about supervisors disappearing (and being presumed dead)...

  101. Crap, NOT ep1, but EP4. by geekoid · · Score: 2

    stupid adding numbers after release thing.

    --
    The Kruger Dunning explains most post on /. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
  102. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    You could say Tolkien was inspired a lot by Lovecraft's works,

    Stop right there. Do you have any evidence that Tolkien was ever aware of the existence of Lovecraft, or read him, much less being "inspired" by him?

    Lovecraft was an obscure American pulp magazine writer of horror and supernatural oriented short stories. Even assuming that these pulp magazines were available to read in Britain, it is highly doubtful Tolkien would have read them. Lovecraft was never well known outside of the American "fandom" scene until the 1960's or later; far too late to have "influenced" Tolkien.

  103. Heresy it is by Shamanin · · Score: 2

    Total heresy it is, we hates it, we hates it all... its whole casts of characters being drug actics it is, not at all like smeagal (golummmmm, golummmm)

    --
    come on fhqwhgads
  104. Nigerian 419 Version by ites · · Score: 4, Funny

    TO: BAGGINSFRODO@THESHIRE.ME
    FROM: SAURON@DARKLORD.ME

    KIND SIR, PLEASE ALLOW ME TO INTRODUCE MYSELF.
    I AM SAURON JUNIOR, RELATIVE OF THE LATE DECEASED
    SAURON, LORD. YOU WILL BE AWARE OF THE RECENT
    TRAGIC EVENTS OVERTAKING OUR MIDDLE EARTH, WHICH I
    CAN ASSURE YOU MY FAMILY HAS NO CONNECTION WITH.
    HOWEVER, MY LATE DECEASED RELATIVE LEFT A LARGE
    AMOUNT OF GOLD AND JEWELRY HIDDEN IN A DRAGON'S
    LAIR. THE ESTIMATED VALUE OF THIS TREASURE IS
    250,000,000 OLD SMEAGOLS. I AM SEEKING WELL
    WISHERS WHO WILL HELP ME TO RECOVER THIS RIGHTFUL LEGACY,
    IN RETURN FOR A MODEST 10% OF ALL
    GOLD RECOVERED. PLEASE DO NOT INFORM THE
    WIZARD OR HIS MINIONS OF THIS TREASURE OR THE
    CONSEQUENCES WILL BE TRULY DREADFUL FOR YOURS TRULY.
    ALL I ASK OF YOU IS THAT I CAN USE YOUR GOLD RING
    TO PASS INVISIBLY PAST THE DRAGON STILL
    GUARDING THE GOLD. ONCE I HAVE RECOVERED THE
    RIGHTFUL GOLD AND JEWELRY I WILL DELIVER YOU
    10% OF THE AFORESAID TREASURE AND OF COURSE
    RETURN YOU THE RING.
    I RECEIVED YOUR ADDRESS FROM AN ELF. PLEASE
    CONSIDER MY REQUEST MOST SINCERELY.

    --
    Sig for sale or rent. One previous user. Inquire within.
    1. Re:Nigerian 419 Version by Kitsune · · Score: 1

      Ohh, nasty nasty. hehehe :) Maybe that should be:

      SAURONJRROX214@AOL.COM

  105. LOTR by Infocom by Xebikr · · Score: 4, Funny

    You stand before the fires of Mt. Doom. Hot jets of glowing magma erupt on either side of you, searing your skin. The hair on your toes shrivels and disappears. Above you columns of black smoke billow into the sky.
    To the north is a small rocky ledge above the fires. To the south is a path leading down into Mordor.

    You find it hard to breathe here.

    >drop ring

    Which ring do you mean? The One Ring, or the Copper Ring of Gondor?

    >one

    dropped

    >wait

    Time passes...

    Your lungs begin to burn.

    >Take ring

    (One Ring) Taken.

    >Drop ring in lava

    Which ring do you mean? The One Ring, or the Copper Ring of Gondor?

    >one

    The lava has no good surface to put that on.

    >yell

    AAAARRRRRRRRGGGGGGGHHHHHHH!!!! Do you feel better?

    You begin to hack and cough from the hot searing fumes.

    >Drop one ring into fires

    You are not close enough to the ledge to drop the ring into the Fires of Mt. Doom!

    >Look

    You stand before the fires of Mt. Doom. Hot jets of glowing magma erupt on either side of you, searing your skin. The hair on your toes shrivels and disappears. Above you columns of black smoke billow into the sky.
    To the north is a small rocky ledge above the fires. To the south is a path leading down into Mordor.

    You double up with a choking spasm, hacking and coughing.

    >N

    You creep out onto the rocky ledge. You look down into the fires. From here you can easily drop the One Ring and complete your quest. Your heart thrills with anticipation!

    You fall to the ground in agony, clutching your throat. The fumes are too much and have overcome you. As you begin to black out, you think to yourself, "I'm sorry Gandolf. I failed. I failed."

    ******* You Have Died **********

    You have earned 275 out 300 points earning you the title of Grand High Elf.

    Would you like to RESTART, RESTORE, or QUIT?
    >

  106. Re:Christ IS almighty by ddimas · · Score: 1

    The sin in a sex movie is very particular and personal, and both sides are party to it. Also sex movies are a record of people actually having sexual relations with each other for money, otherwise known as prostitution The sin in a war movie is not personal or particular, and may actually (as in the case of LOTR) be entirely on the other side. After all, there was warfare in Heaven when the Devil rebelled. Also, no one actually DIED making the LOTR.

  107. from a 5 year old by geekoid · · Score: 2

    first...gandalf wanted to see my ring, but then he left. then he came back, and yelled at me...
    The he made me go away. then I got to this fire, and then I threw my ring in... and Sam was with me.

    --
    The Kruger Dunning explains most post on /. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
  108. XOR by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    William Gibson:

    The sky above mordor was the color of a dark lord's crucible turned to MAX-HEAT.

    "It's not like I'm using," Frodo heard a Ranger say, as he shouldered his way through the crowd around the door to Rivendel. "It's like my body's developed this massive pipe-weed deficiency." It was a Numenorean voice, and a Numenorean joke. Rivendel was a bar for professional expatriates; you could
    drink there for a week and never hear two words in Elvish.

    Gimli was tending bar, his prosthetic arm jerking monotonously as he filled a tray of glasses with ale. He saw Frodo and smiled, his teeth a webwork of Dwarven Steel and brown decay. Frodo found a place at the bar, between the unlikely tan of one of Elrond's whores and the crisp naval uniform of an Easterling whose cheekbones were ridged precise rows of tribal scars.
    "Gollum was in here early, with two Ringwraiths," Gimli said, shoving a draft across the bar with his Mithril hand. Mabye some business with your ring, herr Hobbit?
    Frodo shrugged. The girl to his right giggled and nudged him.
    The dwarf's smile widened. You are too much the Hobbite...

    PAGES TURN.

    "You wanna try now Frodo?"
    Wednesday. Eight days from waking in Rivendel with Sam beside him. "You want
    me to go ouy Mr Frodo? Mabye Easier for you alone?...." He shook his head.
    "No. Stay, doesn't matter." He settled back the elven sweatband across his forehead,
    careful not to disturb the the embriodery. He stared at the ring on his lap, not really
    seeing it, seing instead the forges of Mount Doom, smiths pounding deadly neon circles from
    from a terrabytes of code.
    He closed his eyes. Found the cold heavy ring...
    And in the bloodlit dark behind his eyes, silver phosphenes boiling in from the edge of space,
    hypnagogic images jerking past like film compiled from random frames. Symbols, figures, faces,
    a blurred, fragmented mandala of visual information.
    Please, he prayed, now --
    A Red Eye the color of Mordor Sky.
    NOW -
    --
    The Peter Jackson version is left as an extra credit exercise.
    HINT: Change wholesale portions in order to accomodate Liv Tyler and mirimax executives.

    1. Re:XOR by Valdrax · · Score: 1

      The Peter Jackson version is left as an extra credit exercise.

      Uruk-Hai: I kick arse for the Dark Lord!

      --
      If it's for-profit but free, you're not the customer -- you're the product (e.g., the Slashdot Beta's "audience").
    2. Re:XOR by The_dev0 · · Score: 2
      Stand back boy, this calls for some devine intervention!!

      Beautiful. Maybe you and I should get romantically entangled? (Is that the one with the donkey and the chambermaid?)

      --
      Never fight naked, unless you're in prison...
  109. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by JPelorat · · Score: 1

    Shouldn't that be Silmarillionarities?

    --
    Hokey statistics and ancient misconceptions are no match for a good thought in your head, kid!
  110. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by kallisti · · Score: 2
    he embraced new technology and science to give us rational explanations for things occuring around us we didn't understand


    Really? It seemed to me that his outline was thus: Scientist finds new discovery and it eats him, proving that the Universe is far worse that we can imagine. New discoveries never lead to new understanding, they in fact reveal that what we thought we knew was all wrong. Where does a new technology help anyone in HPL land?

  111. Call me clueless, but... by GeekDork · · Score: 2

    ... what the heck is this damn Soviet Russia joke about?!?

    --

    Fight hunger. Filet a politician and send him to a 3rd world country of your choice.

    1. Re:Call me clueless, but... by kyz · · Score: 2

      It's about this really bad translation of the game Zero Wing on the Megadrive. The bad guy CATS stands up and says, IN SOVIET RUSSIA, US ARE BELONG TO ALL YOUR BASE.

      --
      Does my bum look big in this?
  112. J. Michael Straczynski by technoCon · · Score: 1

    If J. Michael Straczynski wrote the Lord Of The Rings, it would have been called Babylon Five.

  113. i know that if *I* had written it by yulek · · Score: 1

    i'd be getting ready to commit suicide after seeing Gimli turned into comic relief and Legolas riding a skateboard down a staircase while shooting @ orcs.

    oh Peter Peter Peter :(

    --
    in this age of communication i'm just not getting through
  114. Turn it Around by jazman_777 · · Score: 1

    How about: what if Tolkein had written ?

    --
    Slashdot: Failed Car Analogies. Amateur Lawyering. Anecdote Battles.
  115. More Variations... by webmaven · · Score: 3
    There's a lot of further discussion over in Teresa Nielsen-Hayden's weblog comment section. Here's one as written by the Marx Brothers:

    "And as the Dark Lord's power spreads, these fell signs will be seen upon the --"

    "Boss, I don' like-a dat line."

    "But this is is in every ancient prophecy. It's called foreshadowing."

    "Well, you may-a called for it, but will it come when-a you call? Dat's a good one, eh, boss?"


    And here is another long list of variations, including this one, as written by Meatloaf:


    It was a hot summer's day in the Marsh of the Dead
    There was fog crawling over the swamp
    I could listen to the screams of the Dead Men Calling
    I could see their empty eyes and the candles blowing in the wind.
    You were licking your finger
    With the Ring of Power and I was dying just to ask for a taste
    We were dancing together up on the Crack of Doom
    And no-ones gonna know what we've done.
    --
    The real Webmaven is user ID 27463. I don't rate an imposter, because my ID is such a lame-ass high number.
  116. Homer Thompson by LastToKnow · · Score: 1

    "Ok, when I say 'Hello Mr Thompson, do you have the ring?', you shake your head and say 'no'. Got it?"

    "No problem"

    "Hello Mr Thompson, do you have the ring?"

    ".... yes?"

  117. Simple, It would have been like the movie by G00F · · Score: 2

    If everyone else wrote the book, the book would have been more like the movie. "Hollywoodized" or however you want to state it, more glitz more single powerfull hero, less of the beauty that made up what tolkien made.

    Movie is the best movie ever, but it is a bastardize version of the book.

    So what would have happened? well we can see what did happen. Watch the movie to see.

    --
    The spirit of resistance to government is so valuable on certain occasions that I wish it to be always kept alive
  118. Fishspotting by Jhan · · Score: 2

    The opening lines of Fishspotting, the story of Gollum:

    Choose life. Choose a job. Choose a career. Choose a family. Choose a fucking big horse. Choose tables, chairs, fireplace and a fucking big larder...

    Choose fishing, choose farming, choose good health, high cholesterol and six meals a day. Choose a starter home, choose your friends, choose leisure wear and the matching pipe, choose a three piece suit on hire purchase in a range of fucking fabrics.

    Choose DIY and wondering who the fuck you are on a Sunday morning. Choose sitting in that park watching mind-numbing, spirit crushing fireworks, stuffing fucking junk food into your mouth.

    Choose rotting away at the end of it all, pissing your last in a miserable home, nothing more than an embarrassment to the selfish, fucked up brats you spawned to replace yourself. Choose your future. Choose life...

    But why would I want to do a thing like that? I chose not to choose life, I chose something else and the reasons? There are no reasons, who needs reasons when you've got the One Ring of Power?

    --

    I choose to remain celibate, like my father and his father before him.

  119. NO! NOT XENIXXxxx,,,... (bugs, bugs, bugs) by MickLinux · · Score: 2

    Actually, I'm a conservative Christian, and for the reason you stated, I specifically chose not to see the move about Bruce Lee, in which is son was killed. Something about that seemed kindof fishy. Likewise, some of my coworkers were talking about a snuff film, and I immediately made it clear that I felt that was way out of bounds, and left their presence.

    Most of us conservative Christians *are* against killing.

    --
    Correct Horse Battery Staple: 72 bits of entropy. Enter "Correct H" into google. When it generates the phrase, that's
  120. Re:it's a good thing it wasn't...(repost) by syn3rg · · Score: 0

    This time using the [preview] button ...doh

    Enter the RING-BEARER
    Merry: O that we now had here
    But one ten thousand of those
    Hobbits in the Shire That do no work to-day!
    RING: What's he that wishes so?
    My cousin Meriodoc? No, my fair cousin;
    If we are mark'd to die, we are enow
    To do our country loss; and if to live,
    The fewer hobbits, the greater share of honour.
    God's will! I pray thee, wish not one hobbit more.
    By Jove, I am not covetous for gold,
    Nor care I who doth feed upon my cost;
    It yearns me not if men my garments wear;
    Such outward things dwell not in my desires.
    But if it be a sin to covet honour,
    I am the most offending soul alive.
    No, faith, my coz, wish not an hobbit from the Shire.
    God's peace! I would not lose so great an honour
    As one man more methinks would share from me
    For the best hope I have. O, do not wish one more!
    Rather proclaim it, Merry, through the Fellowship,
    That he which hath no stomach to this fight,
    Let him depart; his passport shall be made,
    And crowns for convoy put into his purse;
    We would not die in that man's company
    That fears his Fellowship to die with us.
    This day is call'd the feast of Isildur.
    He that outlives this day, and comes safe home,
    Will stand a tip-toe when this day is nam'd,
    And rouse him at the name of Isildur.
    He that shall live this day, and see old age,
    Will yearly on the vigil feast his neighbours,
    And say 'To-morrow is Saint Isildur.'
    Then will he strip his sleeve and show his scars,
    And say 'These wounds I had on Isildir's day.'
    Old men forget; yet all shall be forgot,
    But he'll remember, with advantages,
    What feats he did that day. Then shall our names,
    Familiar in his mouth as household words-
    Frodo the Ring-Bearer, Peregrin and Sam,
    Aragorn and Gandalf, Legolas and Gilmi-
    Be in their flowing cups freshly rememb'red.
    This story shall the good man teach his son;
    And Elendil Isildur shall ne'er go by,
    From this day to the ending of the world,
    But we in it shall be remembered-
    We few, we happy few, we band of brothers;
    For he to-day that sheds his blood with me
    Shall be my brother; be he ne'er so vile,
    This day shall gentle his condition;
    And hobbits in the Shire now-a-bed
    Shall think themselves accurs'd they were not here,
    And hold their hobbithoods cheap whiles any speaks
    That fought with us upon Saint Isildur's day.

    Ring-Bearer Frodo V
    Act4, Scene III
    William Shakespeare

    --
    The contents of this message have been doubly encrypted by ROT13
  121. not funny by SuperPedro · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Maybe it's funny if you're about 13 years old. It's just a bunch of gay inuendo.

    And by "gay" I don't mean "stupid". The author is seriously preoccupied with lame homosexual jokes.

    --
    Most sigs are dumb. This is one of them.
  122. If Slashdot re-wrote LOTR by blahlemon · · Score: 1
    Sauron would be the ultimate evil, not for making the rings, but because of the restrictive EULA they had.

    The hero's, on the other hand, would have fabricated a more flexible if slightly less clean looking version of the One Ring. Complete building instructions would have been made available to everybody with mailing lists created for usage support.

    The hero's would then bicker about different releases of the Ring, who's Ring was more pure to the source and ask the really important question, why do we still look like Sauron's ring?

    --
    It take more faith to believe in evolution than it takes to believe in God
  123. please mod up by pr0ntab · · Score: 1

    ::laughing so hard it hurts::

    --
    Fuck Beta. Fuck Dice
  124. Lord of the Rings by Quentin Tarantino by vurg · · Score: 1

    Well he's a movie director, not a writer, but here it goes:

    "Elvish motherfucker do you speak it!??"

  125. Re:Zork of the Rings (OT) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Well, I don't mean to be anal, but......... okay, I do intend to be anal. :)

    The Infocom parser was quite intelligent, and was capable of putting together sentences based on fragments you entered. In other words, when you were asked a direct question by the game to clarify your input, you simply had to answer the question, not rephrase the entire sentence. So, the exchange could have gone like this:

    > SHOW RING
    Which ring are you referring to?

    > ONE RING TO RULE THEM ALL
    Who would you like to show the One Ring To Rule Them All to?

    > GANDALF
    etc......

    But, I guess it's a little late to tell you this now. Sorry. :)

  126. "Who moved my ring?" and "Fellowship of GOR!" by Tackhead · · Score: 2
    > I'm imagining this book as written by a latter-years Robert A. Heinlein.

    Oh, please, someone do Heinlein!

    I've got two I whipped up.

    From the world of dumb management texts, I offer a parody of "Who Moved My Cheese", and from bad sci-fi the series of "Gor", uh, "novels".

    (The difference between good science fiction and bad sci-fi is that Heinlein is worthy of parody. Gor is worthy only of parody...) At any rate, permission hereby granted to reproduce freely worldwide; this text is in the public domain:

    WHO MOVED MY RING?

    (Scene: The Shire)

    Sam: "I'm bored of running around the Shire! Let's run somewhere else!"

    Frodo: "Hey, check out this neat-o Ring! Let's take it to Mordor!"

    Sam: "Yeah! Mordor sounds cool! Let's run to Mordor!"

    Frodo: "How are we gonna get there?"

    Sam: "Rivendell, Moria, wherever, who cares, let's go!"

    (Scene: An empty room with a sign reading "ONE RING TO RULE THEM ALL, AND IN THE DARKNESS BIND THEM!")

    Sauron: "Face it, Gollum, it's *gone*. You've got to work up some courage and send out some Nazgul if you're going to find it. It's out there somewhere in Middle Earth."

    Gollum: "But itsss preciousssss to me... it wasss heeree... Those nasssststy Hobbitsses running around Middle Earth, it'sss all their fault, nassssty theiving hobbitsses..."

    Sauron: "Huh? I wasn't listening, I was busily inscribing pithy sayings like 'IF YOU ARE AN EVIL OVERLORD SHAPED LIKE A BIG FIERY EYEBALL, RINGS COME TO YOU' on the Eastern face of Mount Doom."

    Gollum: "It means if we waitsses long enough, we will gets our precioussss back from those nassty hobbitses?"

    Sauron: "No, you fool, it means *I* might, but *you* still have get out there and look for the damn Ring yourself!"

    Gollum: "But you says I can findsses my precioussss too?"

    Sauron: "Of course! You were Smeagol once, no? You've changed before, you can change again!"

    Gollum: "Yessssss! I can embraccccce channnnnges oncccce again! I can findsss my preciousssss!"

    Sauron: "That's the spirit, Gollum me boy!"

    (Gives Gollum a hearty, encouraging slap on the back.)

    Gollum: "Yesssss!"

    (Exits, with a sign taped to his back, reading as follows:

    "IF YOU ARE NOT AN EVIL OVERLORD, YOU CAN STILL FIND RING BY CRAWLING OVER BARE ROCK FOR A THOUSAND MILES")

    Sauron: "Man, I love this job!"

    FELLOWSHIP OF GOR!

    Frodo: "I will take and bear you, Ring, for it is your purpose to be taken and borne by a Hobbit!"

    Ring: "Yes, take and bear me, Frodo, for it is my purpose to be taken by a Hobbit!"

    Frodo: "Now I shall chain you to myself, for you are my Ring, and it is your purpose to be chained to me at all times!"

    Ring: "Yes! Bind me with chains, for I am your Ring, and it is my purpose to be chained to you at all times!"

    Frodo: "Now I shall carry you to Mordor, because you were made to be taken to Mordor!"

    Ring: "Yes, please, Master Frodo! Take me to Mordor, because I was made to be taken to Mordor!"

    Frodo: "Now I shall cast you into the fires of Mount Doom and destroyed in the fires in which you were forged, for it is my desire that you be cast into the fires of Mount Doom!"

    Ring: "Now you will... HEY! WAIT ONE GODDAMN MINUTE, THERE! FIRES? DOOM? SAFEWORD! SAFEWORD, GODDAMNIT!"

  127. The Secret Diaries! by LarsWestergren · · Score: 2

    Check out The Secret Diaries of Cassandra Claire! This stuff is really hilarious!


    THE SECRET DIARY OF ARAGORN SON OF ARATHORN


    Day One:

    Ringwraiths killed: 4. V. good.
    Met up with Hobbits. Walked forty miles. Skinned a squirrel and ate it. Still not King.

    Day Four:

    Stuck on mountain with Hobbits. Boromir really annoying. Not King yet.

    Day Six:
    Orcs killed: none. Disappointing. Stubble update: I look rugged and manly. Yes! Keep wanting to drop-kick Gimli. Holding myself back. Still not King.


    THE VERY SECRET DIARY OF SAMWISE GAMGEE


    Day One:

    Frodo stabbed by Morgul blade. Oh no! Pippin cried. Told Pippin it would be all right as Mr. Frodo far too hot to die.

    Did I say that out loud?

    Day Three:

    Have followed Mr. Frodo to Rivendell where Elves will heal him. Gandalf told me to help poor unconscious Mr. Frodo get out of dirty clothes. So took clothes off him and gave him a bath. And another one. Then gave him another bath. Gandalf came and told me six baths was quite enough, Samwise Gamgee.

    Poncy old git probably hasn't taken a bath since the Second Age.

    Day Four:

    Wonder if it is time for Mr. Frodo to have another bath yet.


    THE SECRET DIARY OF LEGOLAS SON OF WEENUS


    Day One:

    Went to Council of Elrond. Was prettiest person there. Agreed to follow some tiny little man to Mordor to throw ring into volcano. Very important mission - gold ring so tacky.

    Day Four:

    Boromir so irritating. Why must he wear big shield like dinner plate all the time? Climbed up Caradhras but wimpy humans who cannot walk on snow insisted we climb back down.

    Am definitely prettiest member of the Fellowship. Go me!

    Day Six:

    Far too dark in Mines of Moria to brush hair properly. Am very afraid I am developing a tangle. Orcs so silly. Still the prettiest.

    Day Ten:

    Gandalf fell into shadow. In other news, I think I am developing a spot on my nose. V. serious situation, as Elven spots likely to last for 500 years or more.

    Still prettiest, despite blasted spot.

    --

    Being bitter is drinking poison and hoping someone else will die

  128. Lovecraft and Science by Valdrax · · Score: 2

    I honestly don't know where you got the idea that Lovecraft thought that science would bring us rational explanations for things occurring around us that we don't understand. Maybe you need to go back and reread some of his stories more. Whenever science comes up in a Lovecraft stories, it is always in the role of the plot device that reveals the horrible truth behind reality that shatters the mind of the protagonist.

    Two of Lovecraft's most famous quotes are:

    "The most merciful thing in the world ... is the inability of the human mind to correlate all its contents."
    "We live on a placid island of ignorance in the midst of black seas of infinity, and it was not meant that we should voyage far. The sciences, each straining in its own direction, have hitherto harmed us little; but some day the piecing together of dissociated knowledge will open up such terrifying vistas of reality, and of our frightful position therein, that we shall either go mad from the revelation or flee from the deadly light into the peace and safety of a new dark age."

    The latter one is straight out of "The Call of Cthulhu" itself! For more HPL science horror, read the classic mad scientist stories "From Beyond" and "Herbert West: Reanimator." You can read them and many others here.

    --
    If it's for-profit but free, you're not the customer -- you're the product (e.g., the Slashdot Beta's "audience").
    1. Re:Lovecraft and Science by Zech+Harvey · · Score: 2


      Lovecraft wasn't concerned with science proving our observations as you state here:

      honestly don't know where you got the idea that Lovecraft thought that science would bring us rational explanations for things occurring around us that we don't understand.

      He wanted to see the old notions we had tied to a Ptolemiec-like belief/science system that WE stood unchallenged in this universe. WE were the masters of this domain. All his stories directly challenged those ideas.

      He was interested in true science, a science he felt the people of his time wouldn't be ready for. Even now, we aren't ready. Say we do find alien life. What do you think we'll do? Who will really believe and who will just dismiss it as a hoax? His thoughts on science are STILL ahead of their time. We as humans AREN'T ready for the truth as to what is out there. Sure, we are growing more and more advanced, but as a whole, we still cling to several irrational beliefs we try to justify with science. That's not real science and that's the exact opposite of what Lovecraft understood and wrote about.

      --
      Zech Harvey, MCSE, MCDBA, CCNA
  129. Zero-Ring by moosesocks · · Score: 2

    All your ring are belong to sauron!

    --
    -- If you try to fail and succeed, which have you done? - Uli's moose
  130. FOR GREAT PROFIT !! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ziggy.

  131. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by Nehemiah+S. · · Score: 2

    It's been done, at least in regards to their literary inspirations (both borrowed extremely heavily from dunsany, etc)

    Look for books by Lovecraft scholar S.T. joshi (among others) on the subject. Or just do a google search on the alt.horror.cthulhu newsgroup (the question gets asked often enough that it should be in the faq)

    --
    ... and there is no doubt, that one day he will be
    where the eye of his telescope has already been
  132. Apocalypse Now Tolkien! by lamontg · · Score: 4, Funny

    Gondor... shit.

    I'm still only in Gondor. Every time I think I'm going to wake up
    in Mordor. When I was back in the Shire after my first tour it was worse.
    I'd wake up and I'd be nothing.

    I'm here a week now. Waiting for a quest. Getting softer. Every
    minute I stay in this city I get weaker. Every minute Sauron squats in the
    tower he gets stronger.

    Each time I look around, the Spires of Gondor move in a little closer.

    Everyone gets everything he wants. I wanted a quest, and for my sins
    they gave me one. Brought it up to me like room service. It was a real
    choice quest and when it was over, I'd never want another. I was going to
    the worst place in the world, and I didn't even know it yet. Weeks away
    and over hundreds of miles of trails through blasted landscape like
    a main circuit cable plugged straight into Sauron. It was no accident
    that I got to be the caretaker of the Dark Lord Sauron's memory, any more
    than being back in Gondor was an accident.

    --

    Elrond: Your mission is to proceed down the Anduin River in an Elvish
    row boat. Pick up Sauron's path at the Falls of Rauros. When you find
    Mordor, infiltrate Sauron's borders by whatever means available and
    terminate the Dark Lord's Ring of Power.

    Galadriel: Terminate the Dark Lord.

    Elrond: He's out there operating with any decent restraint, totally beyond
    the pale of Maiar conduct. And he is still in the field commanding orcs.

    Celeborn: Terminate the Dark Lord with extreme prejudice.

    Galadriel: You understand Frodo that this mission does not exist, nor will
    it ever exist.

  133. IN SOVIET RUSSIA... by Pig+Hogger · · Score: 2, Offtopic

    RING TOSSES YOU IN THE FIRE.

  134. Dr. Suess? by anthony_dipierro · · Score: 2

    My favourite is Dr. Suess: 'Gandalf, Gandalf! Take the ring! I am too small to carry this thing!' 'I can not, will not hold the One. You have a slim chance, but I have none. I will not take it on a boat, I will not take it across a moat. I cannot take it under Moria, that's one thing I can't do for ya. I would not bring it into Mordor, I would not make it to the border.'

    I have to believe that Dr. Suess would be a much better writer than that.

  135. Appologies in advance... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    In A.D. 2101
    War was beginning.

    Gandolf: What happen ?
    Frodo: Somebody set up us the ring
    Frodo: We get signal
    Gandolf: What !
    Frodo: Big eyeball turn on
    Gandolf: It's You !!
    Sauron: How are you gentlemen !!
    Sauron: All your will are belong to us
    Sauron: You are on the way to destruction
    Gandolf: What you say !!
    Sauron: You have no chance to survive make your time
    Sauron: HA HA HA HA ....
    Sauron: Take off every 'ring'
    Gandolf: You know what you doing
    Gandolf: Move 'ring'
    Gandolf: For great justice

  136. Hunter S. Thompson Style by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "We can't stop here! This is Nazgul country!"

  137. Henry Wadsworth Longfellow by tlambert · · Score: 2

    Gandalf the Grey, mighty wizard,
    He could stop a charging Balrog;
    And while falling to the bottom
    of a deep dark foreboding cavern,
    attack the Balrog, sword a-stabbing,
    to take the life o' the evil creature,
    ere below the two did hit the water.

    Gandalf the White, from death arisen,
    no longer Grey, seems now much stronger,
    showing up again, when unexpected,
    in the forests, not far from Gondor,
    taking arms, against the eye of Morodor,
    Saving Merry, saving Pippin,
    from mistaken wrath of Treebeard.

    Mighty Gandalf, resurrected,
    comes now upon the dwarf Gimli,
    comes now upon the elf Legolas,
    comes now upon the bearded rider,
    in bright light, his face is hidden,
    "Well met, again!", coming towards them,
    he speaks to them of sheathing weapons,
    Aragorn, the bearded rider, first to say,
    "Your name is Gandalf!", and the wizard,
    now his name is twice repeated,
    says, indeed, "That was the name". ...

    -- Terry

  138. Bill Gates and LOTR by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Lord of the Windows
    Frodo, here is the source code of Linux. DO NOT, I repeat DO NOT let anyone see it. You must throw the source code into the vulcan, otherwise the big bad god of Linuxor will take over the world.

  139. TH3 l0RD 0F TH3 R1NGz -by Scr1pt k1ddyz by doublehelix_nz · · Score: 2, Funny

    <b>TH3 l0RD 0F TH3 R1NGz -by Scr1pt k1ddy</b)
    <br><br>
    1t b3g4n w1th th3 f0rg1ng 0f th3 gr34t r1ngz. Thr33 w3r3 g1v3n t0 th3 3lv3z, 1mm0rt4l, w1z3zt 4nd f41r3zt 0f 4ll b31ngz. s3v3n t0 th3 Dw4rf l0rdz, gr34t m1n3rz 4nd cr4ftzm3n 0f th3 m0unt41n h4llz. 4nd n1n3, n1n3 r1ngz w3r3 g1ft3d t0 th3 r4c3 0f M3n wh0 4b0v3 4ll 3lz3, d3z1r3 p0w3r. F0r w1th1n th3z3 r1ngz, w4z b0und th3 ztr3ngth 4nd w1ll t0 g0v3rn 34ch r4c3. But th3y w3r3 4ll 0f th3m d3c31v3d, f0r 4n0th3r r1ng w4z m4d3.
    <br><br>
    1n th3 l4nd 0f M0rd0r, 1n th3 f1r3z 0f M0unt D00m, th3 D4rk l0rd s4ur0n f0rg3d 1n s3cr3t 4 m4zt3r r1ng, t0 c0ntr0l 4ll 0th3rz. 4nd 1nt0 th1z r1ng, h3 p0ur3d h1z cru3lty, h1z m4l1c3 4nd h1z w1ll t0 d0m1n4t3 4ll l1f3.
    <br><br>
    "0n3 R1ngz t0 rul3 th3m 4ll."

    1. Re:TH3 l0RD 0F TH3 R1NGz -by Scr1pt k1ddyz by Jeff+Binder · · Score: 1

      s4ur0n f0rg0r3d th3 r00t r1ng- 0n3 r1ng to 0wnz th3m 411

  140. Oh, yeah?!!! Read on. by ninejaguar · · Score: 1

    What about this:

    "...after all, you cannot appreciate Shakespeare until you have heard it in the original Klingon."

    http://www.scifi.com/scifi.con/word/kli/liter.ht ml

  141. Sonny Bono! by yerricde · · Score: 1

    I would love to see Dr. Seuss try and top Tom Bombadil's songs.

    I would love to see Dr. Seuss lose Eldred v. Ashcroft. Seuss Enterprises submitted an amicus brief to the Supreme Court in favor of the Bono Act.

    --
    Will I retire or break 10K?
  142. From "The Ringbearing", by Stephen King by Wraithlyn · · Score: 2

    The ring was getting heavier. And I don't mean in a friendly sort of way, no sir, dear reader. This skinny fucking golden donut jangled around my neck like a ball and chain from the funny papers I used to read as a kid back in Shire Rock, Maine. In those days the world seemed brighter, full of possibilities. Before that grey bearded cocksocker showed up and uprooted my life like one of Sam's ol' taters. Cook em, boil em, stick em in a fucking stew, he used to say.

    But that was then, and this was now. This was very much fucking NOW. Don't dwell on the past, the old gaffer used to say, or mayhap you'll lose your future. Wouldn't want to be caught daydreaming when one of THEM came riding by, or you'll find yourself a nice Nazgul shish-ka-bob, Frodo my boy. Just the memory of those terrible black shrieking phantoms numbed my mind, turned my spine to ice, and sent my balls shrivelling up into some pre-pubescent hiding place.

    --
    "Mind, as manifested by the capacity to make choices, is to some extent present in every electron." -Freeman Dyson
  143. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by Azothoth · · Score: 1

    And both inspire scads and scads of metal lyrics!

  144. Jack Kerouac as Sam by pyramid+termite · · Score: 4, Interesting

    So I was just hanging around the hobbit cats, you know, digging the crazy pipe weed and the ale and wondering if I could ever get all the truth of it down, you know, the real deal, not the kind of half baked stuff you watch on the palentir but something that would make my heart whole, when this crazy cat named Biblo and his even crazier nephew Frodo started making a scene with some crazy birthday party where everyone was getting drunk and wailing to the moon and watching Gandalf, that old conjurer cat just get heavy with the fireworks jazz and I was yelling "Go, go, go" with the rest of them and then that Biblo cat gets up on the podium, lays down a nice little riff about how life's too short and sweet to hang out with great cats like us and then he just wigged, said "Goodbye" and POOF! that cat wasn't there. Everyone just flipped.

    A little later, I got a gig as a gardener for Frodo and he used to lay on me all this crazy Elvish poetry about Elvish stuff, real high and mighty and soulful and sad, and one day that Gandalf came by and they were in the study talking away and because I started hearing something about the elves and just knew that Gandalf cat had some wonderful elvish poetry in him, I got too close to the window and started hearing all this wild, crazy talk about this ring Frodo had and this Sauron heavy who wanted to make the world into some kind of soulless meat factory and how he needed this ring to do all this and I guess I must have drank too much for lunch because I let out a little burp under the window and the next thing I know that cat Gandalf's pulling me into the house through the window threatening to turn me into something uncool like a toad and then he looks at me and says, "I know what a cat like you needs to do. You and Frodo need to go on the road."

    And that's how the whole crazy thing started.

  145. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by DunbarTheInept · · Score: 2

    Tokien created a mythology based on his catholic beliefs, where there was always a good vs evil fight, and in all chapters good prevailed.

    Uhh - were we reading the same book? Good did not prevail when the Riders found where the ring was. Good did not prevail when Gollum succumbed to his evil side and decided to lead the nasty little Hobbittses to Shelob. Good did not prevail when Ferney sold the Hobits out in Bree. Good lost during many of the chapters. Good prevailed more toward the end, not so much at the beginning, as behooves a fun story.

    --

    Don't label something "offtopic" unless you know the topic well enough to tell what's on topic.

  146. Usenet Oracle by len_harms · · Score: 1

    I can not belive no one bothered with this style. Usenet oracle

    > Oh great and mighty oracle whos toejam I am
    > unworthy to throwup. Could you re-write
    > the LOTR in your style?

    And in response, thus spake the Oracle:

    } OH THAT tired old story. How many more times
    } must I hear about the great Frodo Baggins. I
    } should ZOT you dead for even muttering that name
    } around me! What great power that was bestowed
    } upon him and he squandered it. Typical Hobit.
    }
    } You owe the Oracle 3 cans of Canned Hobit. Not
    } the creamed ones but the chunky.

  147. Re:I CAN'T BELIEVE IT by jedie · · Score: 2
    trying what way too hard you stupid cunt? do you think I typed in my email like that?

    lousy AC

    --
    "The majority is always sane, Louis." -- Nessus
    http://slashdot.jp
  148. Bilbo as BILL and Gollum as Batman... by May+Kasahara · · Score: 1
    Shireserfs by Douglas Coupland

    Friday
    Early Fall, 1401 S.R.

    This morning, just after 11:00, Frodo locked himself in his room and wouldn't come out. Bilbo (Bilbo!) gave Frodo this totally wicked flame from hell-- and he just wailed on some decorations for the upcoming birthday party that Bilbo had arranged. We figured it was a random quality check. Bilbo's so smart.
    Bilbo is wise.
    Bilbo is kind.
    Bilbo is benevolent.
    Bilbo, Be My Friend... Please!

    On his bedroom door, Frodo placed a "Do Not Disturb" thingy stolen from Bree's Prancing Pony Inn sometime last year. Finally, at about 2:30 AM, Merry and I got concerned and drove over to Farmer Maggot's to find "flat" foods to slip under Frodo's door. When we returned to Bag-End at 3:00 AM, there were still a few people grinding away. Our group is scheduled to finish the decorations (RTH: Release to Hobbiton) in just eleven days (Top Secret: We'll never make it). Frodo's lights were on, but he wouldn't answer his door when we knocked. Just then, Samwise in the office across the hall yelled and then glared out at us from his doorway. He said, "You're only encouraging him." Obviously he was stressed out-- I don't think Sam ever sleeps. Anyway, by this point, Merry and I were really tired, so we drove back to the house to crash.
    There was a mist floating on the ground above the fields beyond the Hill. I thought about the message and Bilbo and all of that, and I had this weird feeling-- of how the presence of Bilbo floats about Bag-End. Bilbo is a moral force, a spectral force, a force that shapes, a force that molds. A force with a shiny gold ring on a chain.

    (Okay, that was kind of a lame ender. How about this Frank Miller one?)

    The Dark, Pitiful Creature Returns, by Frank Miller

    (panel: The Gollumcave. Gollum is standing at the entrance, looking over the dark lake)
    GOLLUM (VO): I was only six years old when that happened. When I first saw the cave... Huge, empty, silent as a church, waiting, as the Precious was waiting. And now the cobwebs grow and the dust thickens in here as it does in me-- And the Precious laughs at me, curses me, calls me a fool... Never. Never again.
    (next set of panels: an older man, representing Gollum's voice Smeagol, is at the top of the stairs)
    SMEAGOL: Master Gollum? This somnambulism is becoming a bit of a problem. It's the ring, I suspect. Tends to make one overly sentimental.
    (skip ahead a few panels to one of Gollum watching the reflections in the lake. For a moment, he thinks he sees Bilbo in there)
    GOLLUM (VO): Baggins. I should turn away, right this second. Just a reflection. That's all it is. No harm in looking at a reflection... (panel: flashback to Bilbo entering the cave) You remember that night (set of panels: Gollum relives the riddle game and Bilbo stealing the ring from him. Gollum gets up and starts to leave) PRECIOUS (VO): The time has come. You know it in your soul. For I am your soul. You cannot escape me. (set of panels: some goblins are fighting amongst themselves in the Moria mines. They all kill one another. Gollum jumps down to their carcasses, ready to feast)
    GOLLUM (VO): This should be agony. I should be a mass of aching muscle... unable to move. And, were I older, I surely would. But I feel young again... the blood of these orcs is a baptism. Preciousssss...

  149. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by calibam · · Score: 1

    Then again, there's yet another similarity between the two that only surfaced in the last few years: Both of them formed the inspiration for two vastly different styles of Pen & Paper roleplaying. Lovecraft paved the way for the storyteller/scare-the-crap-out-of-you style employed by Call of Cthulhu and emulated with the ever-so-popular games of White Wolf, while Tolkien inspired Gary Gygax & co to make Dungeons and Dragons. Of course, I personally think that neither one of them would have approved of the creations that their fans wrought in their name, and are probably flailing about in their graves (especially Tolkien at the way his masterpiece has been bastardized), but it's still a point to consider.

  150. Tom Clancy does "Lord of the Rings" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    LOTR by Tom Clancy

    "In a hole in the ground, there lived a US Marine called Jackoff Ryan. He was married to a US Marine. They had two All-american kids, one who wanted to join the US Marines, and the other one who wanted to join the Navy, which was still ok. He liked fishing with his father's holiday house in Maine. His Dad was also a US Marine. (Aah; this is a boring as crap; time for that overworked plot device...) So they wrote it down and they decided it was a good idea. (That'll keep the suckers reading for another six chapters)

    (Now something for the sexless nerds who read this crap:) An encrypted radio transmission arrived on his MK-1234-BS NCA decrypter, which ran on a 12VDC Battery, in a black plastic box. As he read the message, his all-American kids unfurled the American flag and saluted it was they raised it high. Tears formed in their eyes, and they sang the Star Spangled Banner. (Now which foreign country shall we kick the ass of in this novel?) "The evil North Korean dictator Kim-Jong Il has built nuclear bombs and fired three ballistic missiles over friendly nations. He's taunting our President and making him look stupid!" "No Oil", he sniffed. He pressed the silvery grey delete key, on his MK-9876-XYZ keyboard.

    Next Message. "An evil Middle Eastern country run by a war criminal has ignored 44 UN Resolutions. Their leader was about to be tried by the International Court at the Hague, but the key witnesses car mysteriously went up in smoke." He read on. "The country is called Israel." He giggled in a manly way, and hit the delete key.

    Next Message. "A weak and pathetic nation we previously bombed flat that is run by a ruthless dictator has Oil. You have a pick-up vehicle that only gets 10 gallons to the mile." He dropped his coffee cup. "Evil son-of-a-bitch" he cried.

    (Time to make it look like I throughrly researched the evil foreigners. Easy given your average American schoolkid doesn't know where Canada is, I can bullshit to the max.) He knew this particular dictator liked Falafel. He grew up working in his father's hommus factory in the heart of the Arabian Desert where all the boys had camels, and the fathers sold their daughters into the slave trade. There was a girl called Fatima who was a double-agent for someone who didn't think they'd hear anything more about it, but they were wrong.

    (Who am I kidding! I can't write for sh1t! Liven it up so maybe they don't notice.) Lt Gollum Chukinston fired his MK-3.141 missile, which bypassed his radar vector thorough intercept pusher complex plate, and the O-ring fell in an all-American volcano, which blew up and killed many orcs in their desert tents.

    He thought that was the last he'd hear of it. He was wrong. Meanwhile Jackoff Ryan retired from the US Marines which he had infact never joined and became a fat, lilly-white-assed Lawyer who wrote books to a formula lapped up by nerds, gun freaks and other misfits who wonder why they have such empty, unimportant lives. Eventually he got bored and got other people to write his books, and though if he stuck "Tom Clancy's" before the title, no one would notice. By this stage no one was reading his books anymore, so no one *did* notice."

    Tom Clancy. Coming soon to a movie theatre near you with one of Alec Baldwin (who was pretty good), Harrison Ford (who wasn't bad either) or that bore who married even bigger bore Jennifer Lopez.

    God Bless!

  151. I'm still pissed at this guy by Ryosen · · Score: 1

    One more thing to add. The person that you so gleefully dumped on because he was "so dreadfully out of touch as to not know the basic plot of LOTR", as a direct result of your actions, may very well never read the books now. While you might sit on high with a smug attitude of your literary prowess (and believe me sir, it is a delusion), have you given the slightest thought to ask whether the person that you have turned away from reading, in your own words, such an important work, was under the age of 25? Have they yet to have the opportunity to read the series? Was the movie their first introduction to the works of Tolkein which, prior, had garnered little attention as of late? Bakshi not included. It's not commonly included in the school curriculums.

    My apologies to the rest of the readers here but, all too often we see this sort of garbage. Smug, anti-social (and invariably misplaced and unearned), elitist attitudes that turn away anyone foolish enough to enter into your small, tightly-guarded domain of self-importance and self-loathing. I almost have to wonder if your comments were made for no other reason than to elicit a reaction such as this one. Look! Someone has acknowledged my existance!

    You think that you have made a brilliant contribution to the discourse contained herein. Instead, you have merely succeeded in making an ass of yourself and possibly turning off someone from enjoying the very same writings that you hold so dear and foolishly take for granted. Not to mention wasting the past ten minutes of *my* life.

    I have never flamed someone in a public forum and I am typically very tolerant of people's opinions, but this kind of bullshit just really gets under my skin.

    And to think - I gave up my mod points in this thread to take this bait. I should have just marked you as a troll.

    --

    Ryosen
    One man's "Troll, +1" is another man's "Insightful, +1".
    1. Re:I'm still pissed at this guy by Cyclometh · · Score: 1, Troll

      One more thing to add. The person that you so gleefully dumped on because he was "so dreadfully out of touch as to not know the basic plot of LOTR", as a direct result of your actions, may very well never read the books now.

      Or he might go and read them. Who knows? Certainly not you, and not I. The series has been around for 50 years or more, and I don't really care that people haven't read it, but as far as I'm concerned, I'm not going to tiptoe around what to my mind is common knowledge. These things aren't revelations, they're not surprises, and I'm tired of hearing people carp about how the ending of a movie that was written 50+ years ago was spoiled for them because someone dared to discuss it openly on a bulletin board! The world does not revolve around the ignorant.

      You think that you have made a brilliant contribution to the discourse contained herein.

      No, I actually don't. I think I simply spoke my opinion- oh wait, I guess I'm not allowed to do that if it offends you, right? Piss off; I'm not the one with the smug, elitist attitude, sparky.

      Not to mention wasting the past ten minutes of *my* life.

      Now this is arrogance of the first water. You want to mod me down, go for it- but you take time to reply, you live with it. If you don't agree, great- disagree. But don't whine about *me* wasting *your* time. You want to talk, cool. You don't, then move the hell along.

  152. This one? by Ryosen · · Score: 1
    --

    Ryosen
    One man's "Troll, +1" is another man's "Insightful, +1".
  153. Kilgore Trout version by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Galadriel on the Half-Shell, by Kilgore Trout

    Queen Galadriel of the forest Lorien let her gown fall to the ground. She was wearing nothing underneath. "Your travels are over, Ring Bearer", she whispered, her voice husky with lust. "Seek no more, for you have found. The answer is in my arms."

    "It is a glorious answer, Queen Galadriel, Eru knows," the Ring Bearer replied. "I am going to accept it gratefully. But I have to tell you that I will be on my way again tomorrow."

    "But you have found your answer, you have found your answer!" she cried, and she forced his head between her fragrant immortal breasts.

    He said something that she did not hear. She thrust him out at arm's length. "What was that you said?"

    "I said, Queen Galadriel, that what you offer is an awfully good answer. It just doesn't happen to be the one I'm primarily looking for."

  154. The Ringbearer From Hell (BOFH Adaptation) by realbt · · Score: 2, Funny

    Hi people,

    Here's my attempt at a BOFH Adaptation. I thought the ./ crowd might appreciate this more than the other people. It's also available on the bulletin board.

    Ring Bearer from Hell
    (RBFH ... adaptation from the BOFH -- The Bastard Operator From Hell)

    We're out of food in the middle of nowhere-fucks-ville so I'm pissed. All we have left are these stupid elvish things. What the hell do they call them? To hell with it! They taste like fucking cardboard gone stale.

    Being the RBFH, I'm at least able ot keep myself entertained. I slip the Ring on and give Gimli a huge wedgie. That'll keep me snickering for a couple hours. At least I won't have to listen to him go on about Galadriel. What a bitch! First we go blindfolded, then she nearly lets me fall into her fucking water bowl, Ring and all.

    Aragorn decides to counsel with me. "We have a follower," he squaks.

    "Oh" (thinking -- what the hell do you expect does he expect me to do it? You're the one that let him get away!)

    "It's your decision, as the ring bearer: should we let him follow or try and catch the sneak?"

    Just then Legolas starts talking like a typical know-it-all Elf. God, will he EVER SHUT UP?

    "I don't think it wise for us to ignore him. He might try and sneak up on us while we rest."

    I was getting so hungry. Those damn lembas or lambdas or whateverthehellthosethingsare suck. "Let's catch the slimey twirp," I announce. "I want some real food."

    Gimli starts pulling at his pants. Maybe if he didn't spend so much time sitting on that axe of his, I think to myself and start laughing.

    "What are you laughing at, halfling?" Gimli asks in front of the Company.

    Aragorn jumps in. Damn. I thought I was going to have fun, for once. Gods, we all need a good hit from some sweet pipe-weed.

    "Let's not fight. We have bigger challenges ahead of us. Now, the ring bearer has decided we shall catch him. But to eat him? Do you think Sam can do it?"

    I have to hand it to the old man, Sam wasn't too bright. And he's no fun, either; I don't even have to do any work to make an ass of him. He's always talking about his Gaffer-this and Gaffer-that. Jesus. He's worse than Legolas.

    >dummy mode on<

    "Sam, do you think you can handle cooking the smelly thing? I'm fucking famished!"

    Sam turns, "Oh master!" (fuck, I hate it when he pulls that shit) "Oh master I shall try my best to cook up something nice. Send Merry and Pippin to get some 'taters and veggies and we'll cook up a good stew."

    "Sure thing" Now I wanted to shove Sting up his back-side for saying 'taters. *groans*


    .... after they eat and the RBFH is on watch while everyone sleeps ...


    Now what am I supposed to do? Everyone's sleeping. And fucking Gimli is being so loud I think the whole of Middle Earth can hear. This is so boring. I should have just given the stupid Ring to the smelly guy on the horse. I would have saved myself a whole lot of worthless time.

    I figure I'll go down to the river and fill-up bottles of water, put them in Sam's backpack to weigh him down even more. The stupid moron probably won't even notice.


    .... in the morning ....


    So Sam gets up and I tell him that I've taken some of his weight and put it into my pack.

    "Hey thanks!" he says.

    What a moron. He will *never* learn. I think I'm going to cast him into Mount Doom when I have the chance.

  155. So then, life is like this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "Hey, Aeris dies in Final Fantasy 7. Pick up your copy for $15 at any store."

    "Luke Skywalker is Darth Vader's son. I higly recommend this film."

    "If you didn't want to read this, then fuck you, your experiences should mirror mine in perfect chronological order for maximum enjoyment of the entertainment world. Give me a call when you want to know that in the crying game....it's a man."

  156. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by Pathetic+Coward · · Score: 2

    That's probably because both Lovecraft and Tolkien's earlier works were influenced by Lord Dunsany.

  157. Monty Python's - The Lord Of The Rings by hollow5555 · · Score: 1

    Ack! I could resist! Enjoy! http://exdomain.wox.org/~jazzman/lotr-python.txt Regards, Marc

  158. Re:IN SOVIET RUSSIA... by I'm+not+a+script,+da · · Score: 0

    What a country!!

  159. Re:H. P. Lovecraft and J. R. R. Tolkien: Similarit by Zech+Harvey · · Score: 2


    He disagreed with how man prided himself on being the center of the universe, much like Ptolemy. He was a very scientific and passionate individual, realizing that we are just a small speck in the universe. THAT is what his stories are about. When someone encounters something that breaks all the rules we have set up to protect ourselves from the truth of the universe and the tiny roles we play, they go window-licking bonkers.

    Take a look at the Elder Gods themselves. Of course humans revered them as Gods because they were so large and powerful, what else could they be? But Lovecraft wrote them as aliens. Why? Because even then he and others realized it could be possible that there is life other than ours out in space. It's a fairly advanced notion in any period time, including now.

    He also provided scientific theming in the creation of several of races, cloning and evolution, some I think I remember off-hand (No books to cite from with me. Sorry =P)

    But it wasn't really magic, mostly. It never was. It was like Frankenstein, so horrible and fantastic, and yet with a macabre scientific explanation behind it.

    The kick in the pants is, much like Poe before him, he didn't want to be recognized for his short fiction over his poetry -- Poetry which deals with a more fantastic tone and setting. I would surmise that is why he added the Dreamlands to his fictional stories, but that's just my personal theory. He was a very polar fellow (no pun intended).

    --
    Zech Harvey, MCSE, MCDBA, CCNA
  160. New movie:The Fellowship of the Ring of Free Trade by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Watch this 6 minute re-edit of the first LotR movie called The Fellowship of the Ring of Free Trade[.

    "Now, for the first time ever, the hidden prophecies of J.R.R. Tolkien's classic epic, The Lord of the Rings, are decoded in this accurate re-edit of Peter Jackson's blockbuster motion picture. Unknownst to many readers, The Lord of the Rings - once thought to be merely a story of archetypal struggle between good and evil - has been found to contain astute prophetic messages about the impending crisis of capitalist modernity.

    Numerous scholars and linguists have already deciphered the main theme of The Lord of the Rings as being the freedom of ordinary people to be left alone from the ruling elites. However, Tolkien's hidden messages about the disasters of capitalism and the insightful predictions about the current political climate have not been made public until now. The Fellowship of the Ring of Free Trade includes subtitles of the decoded dialogues in painstaking detail and the true identities that the story's characters represent within the prophecy. Hado i philinn!"

    "Mordor is in our midst." - J.R.R. Tolkien

  161. Last Post! by alpg · · Score: 0

    And the next time you consider complaining that running Lucid Emacs
    19.05 via NFS from a remote Linux machine in Paraguay doesn't seem to
    get the background colors right, you'll know who to thank.
    -- Matt Welsh

    - this post brought to you by the Automated Last Post Generator...