Slashdot Mirror


Identity Theft from University Computers

Different River writes "Someone broke into the administrative computers at George Mason University and accessed personal information, including social security numbers, of 30,000 students, faculty, and staff. "Before the hacking, the university was in the process of replacing students' Social Security numbers with other internal numbers to protect against identity theft." Looks like they just missed it."

259 comments

  1. To be honest.. by Tobias.Davis · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Any corporation / school / government entity that uses SSN to identify a individual either on paper or digitalized is out for a harsh reality: Personal identity theft is real and here to stay. Now if I could just figure out how to talk these old timers to drop the SSN number they want labeled on their checks..

    1. Re:To be honest.. by velo_mike · · Score: 1
      Now if I could just figure out how to talk these old timers to drop the SSN number they want labeled on their checks..

      Is this a store, or some other company you deal with voluntarily? Drop them if they won't drop the SSN issue - find someone else to deal with. Let them know why, and give them a chance to change the policy, but dump them and stick to it...

      --

      At the bottom of the endless pile of paper work which characterizes all regulation lies a gun.
      Alan Greenspan

    2. Re:To be honest.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Now if I could just figure out how to talk these old timers to drop the SSN number they want labeled on their checks..

      That's easy... just explain to them that if they insist on having their SS# on their checks, eventually they'll get pwned.

    3. Re:To be honest.. by ecammit · · Score: 1

      Yeah. The one thing that always gets me is that banks print your account number and sometimes social security number on checks that you cash. In today's digital age, banks allow you to view the image of any check that you gave out after it has been cashed. If there is someone that is less than reputable that gave you a check to cash, they can view the image of that check online after you have cashed it. Guess what is on the check that they now have... * your bank acount number * your signature * your social security number Think about it.

    4. Re:To be honest.. by Tobias.Davis · · Score: 3, Informative

      Actually I'm talking about my father, who insists that his SSN needs to be printed on his check. For myself, I'm a 27 year old that has little credit history no credit cards and only 1 dealing with a financial institute (for a vehicle loan). Yes, I'm eccentric but I have no use for the credit system in america. Any information I have on file is positive, but I don't go looking to use my SSN anywhere

    5. Re:To be honest.. by velo_mike · · Score: 1
      Actually I'm talking about my father, who insists that his SSN needs to be printed on his check.

      Now I understand. There was a store in the area a few years ago that was demanding my ssn be written on any checks they took. I've no idea if they still do, I left my things on the counter and walked...

      You're right, it's crazy to print that. Unfortunately it may take a case of ID theft to get him to stop.

      Congrats on dodging the credit system, I'm working my way in that direction (a whole lot harder when you bit into it hook, line and sinker...)

      --

      At the bottom of the endless pile of paper work which characterizes all regulation lies a gun.
      Alan Greenspan

    6. Re:To be honest.. by artifex2004 · · Score: 1
      There was a store in the area a few years ago that was demanding my ssn be written on any checks they took.


      That's nuts. I can see them trying to require your driver's license, as that's the form of picture ID they'd use to identify you (if they bother, and most don't), but not SSN.
    7. Re:To be honest.. by darkjedi521 · · Score: 2

      Images of checks is a new thing. My parents bank has been returning cashed checks to them for years. The only difference is its electronic now instead of paper.

    8. Re:To be honest.. by jjb · · Score: 1
      I wrote a chapter in the fictional book Stealing the Network - How to Own a Continent about a college student who steals social security numbers from his college. This is the second public story about universities losing tons of social security numbers because they continue to use them as student IDs since that book was released about 7 months ago. Universities should have stopped doing this so long ago...

      Anyway, read my chapter! The whole book was really good. Ryan Russell and Kevin Mitnick edited it and it features amazingly cooler authors than me, like Nmap's Fyodor, Dan Kaminsky, FX and a number of other amazing people. Read the reviews at Amazon if you don't believe me.

    9. Re:To be honest.. by thesnarky1 · · Score: 1

      Yea, I've seen that book, been meaning to buy it.

    10. Re:To be honest.. by rs232 · · Score: 1

      Reminds me of a College I attended that provided computer accounts with the password set to the last five digits of the student ID number. They then posted the exam results of every student together with name and ID number on a notice board. Most student never bothered to change the password .. )

      --
      davecb5620@gmail.com
    11. Re:To be honest.. by QMO · · Score: 1

      From GMU Homepage "Recognized internationally for its innovation"

      My soul mother (alma mater) changed from SSNs several years ago ('98) and the prevailing feeling in the news etc. was that they were behind the times then.

      Is innovation years late really innovation?

      --
      Exam 4/C again. Maybe I'll do better this time.
    12. Re:To be honest.. by Maestro4k · · Score: 1
      • That's nuts. I can see them trying to require your driver's license, as that's the form of picture ID they'd use to identify you (if they bother, and most don't), but not SSN.
      IANAL, but as I recall it's against the law to require a SSN as identification for things like checks. I'd check into it and report them, not that anything's likely to happen, but maybe it will. Identify theft is becoming a massive problem.

      My bank tries this on me whenever I call to talk to someone they want my account number and SSN to identify me. I always refuse and ask to use an alternate form of identification, a trick one of their CSRs told me about years ago. At least they'll accept an alternate form of ID though, some places refuse.

    13. Re:To be honest.. by David_W · · Score: 4, Informative
      My bank tries this on me whenever I call to talk to someone they want my account number and SSN to identify me. I always refuse...

      I'm curious why you have a problem with this? The bank already has your SSN on file (IIRC it's a tax requirement), so it's not like you are giving them any new information, merely confirming something that they can see on the screen in front of them.

    14. Re:To be honest.. by mwood · · Score: 1

      Hear, hear. Stolen SSNs would not be news if there weren't many, many organizations using them as identifiers without any specific need (other than that someone was too lazy to write a serial-number generator and wants to sponge off the SSA's.)

      Clue: if your *department* does not report taxes to the government, it has no use for SSNs. They confer no significant benefit and are a heapin' helpin' of bad press waiting for just the wrong moment.

    15. Re:To be honest.. by mwood · · Score: 1

      Actually, Indiana driver licenses used to have the SSN on them. This time around I was asked if I still wanted it on mine and I said, "no." Some organizations do catch on.

    16. Re:To be honest.. by Maestro4k · · Score: 1
      • I'm curious why you have a problem with this? The bank already has your SSN on file (IIRC it's a tax requirement), so it's not like you are giving them any new information, merely confirming something that they can see on the screen in front of them.
      Because it's actually illegal to require a SSN as identification unless you're the Social Security Administration. Also I'm not always at home when I call them. If I'm at work I don't want to be giving out my SSN on the phone where coworkers may hear me.

      It's largely the principle of the thing, their alternate identification is actually more likely to trip up someone trying identity theft than the SSN question. They ask me what branch I opened my account at. That's something that an identity thief would have trouble finding out, as it's not written down anywhere (except the bank's records I suppose).

      It's not just the bank, I refuse to give out my SSN as identification in general. I don't have a problem providing it when they have a legitimate need for it (for tax purposes for instance) but asking for it for identification is not a valid use, even if they have it on file for tax purposes.

    17. Re:To be honest.. by garwain · · Score: 1

      hrm, my bank usually just asks for my convienience card number, pin number, (through the phone system menus) then the CSR asks for the value of a recent deposit to confirm that I am who I say I am...

  2. FP! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Troll
    Before the hacking, the university was in the process of replacing students' Social Security numbers with other internal numbers to protect against identity theft." Looks like they just missed it."

    That would've been a lot funnier if you'd said "... Looks like they just failed it", implying that they weren't fast enough.

    BTW: FP?

    1. Re:FP! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      BTW: FP?
      Nope.
    2. Re:FP! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ahh... from someone who is apparantly used to... FALING IT.

  3. MOD PARENT FUNNY by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Finally, a new running joke. I am sick of Profit!

    1. Re:MOD PARENT FUNNY by sh1ftay · · Score: 0

      agreed. This is actually pretty good... much better than that old korean crap.

  4. This just goes to show.... by ecammit · · Score: 5, Insightful

    This just goes to show why using social security numbers for identification purposes is a bad idea. It always disturbs me how many places actually have that number. It was supposed to really be a secret number to identify your for social security, not everyday identification.

    1. Re:This just goes to show.... by Peyna · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Other than the BMV (and I can't figure out why they need your SSN), most of the places that have it are because they need to report tax information about you. You don't have to give it to anyone else. Some places will get annoyed with your request to have a special identification number, but they will accomodate you. My undergrad used to use SSNs for identification, but you could always request a different ID number at any time.

      --
      What?
    2. Re:This just goes to show.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not to mention it's technically against Federal law to require its use for purposes other than Social Security.

    3. Re:This just goes to show.... by Chicks_Hate_Me · · Score: 1

      I agree, it's ridiculous but not surprising (sorry I won't go off on how much I loathe universities) that they use SSNs as IDs. My girlfriend's university displays her SSN right on her ID card (attends SFSU, which displaying SSNs is illegal in California, but don't ask me how they get away with it) and my dad told me that Arizona puts your SSN right on your Driver's License. How idiotic is that?

    4. Re:This just goes to show.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Actually you're wrong, there are no "rules" that say it's illegal to use the SS number for that.

    5. Re:This just goes to show.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It was NEVER intended to be an oooooh "SECRET NUMBER". And despite the early cards which included the statement, "Not to be used for identification", there is NO federal law that prohibits the ss number from being used in any manner in which a business desires. The rotten part of it is the businesses that use the SS number in part to grant credit.

    6. Re:This just goes to show.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Blockbuster used to ask for a SSN, now that is just insane.

    7. Re:This just goes to show.... by BosstonesOwn · · Score: 0

      Massachusetts does aswell. Although now you can request a id # not with your SSN

      --
      This package Does Not Contain a Winner
    8. Re:This just goes to show.... by elBart0 · · Score: 1

      This has changed recently.
      If you don't have an S number already, (which I do, and my wife didn't), when you go to renew, you have to specifically ask to keep your SSN on your license, otherwise they will assign you an S number. When my wife got her new license this year, we got her SSN number off of her number.

      --
      09 F9 11 02 9D 74 E3 5B D8 41 56 C5 63 56 88 C0
    9. Re:This just goes to show.... by Caseyscrib · · Score: 1

      These companies should be fined (big) if this data is stolen. If this were the case, I don't think universities and businesses would bother collecting SSNs in the first place, unless it was absolutely necessary. It would also force them to pay more attention to security.

    10. Re:This just goes to show.... by EightBits · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Actually, not trying to be an ass here, but if there really is a law, could you please point me to it? My university is using SSNs for a number of things and I have been (unsuccessfuly) trying to get this to stop. If I had law to point to, I might be able to start the wheels turning.

    11. Re:This just goes to show.... by Kn0xy · · Score: 0

      Using SS #'s is pretty out of date and a bad way of identifying anyone anymore. I have been told that not even Branches of the US Armed Forces will not use SS #'s not just because they are afraid of identify theft, but the fact that SS #'s are not unique to each and every person in the US. Supposedly, it is highly possible for 2 or more people in the US to have the same SS #, therefore, the military will not use it as a means to identify it's personnel.

    12. Re:This just goes to show.... by $FFh · · Score: 1
      If you're in the US, good places to start looking are
      • Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA),
      • Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA), and
      • Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA)
      Also, some useful information can be found here.
    13. Re:This just goes to show.... by BandwidthHog · · Score: 1

      I looked into it a while back, as I'm the registrar at a school that uses SSNs. From memory, the law states that a government employee/agent/representative/whatever can't demand your SSN for non-essential reasons. A non-governemental person can ask away. You are under no obligation to give it out, but if they wanna be dicks about it, they are under no obligation to continue with the transaction if you do refuse.

      --

      Quantum materiae materietur marmota monax si marmota monax materiam possit materiari?
  5. I always hated giving the SSN by Class+Act+Dynamo · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I always hated that about college. Where I went, EVERYTHING was connected to the SSN of a student. They knew it was, at the very least, imprudent. When a student first enrolled, there was an option somewhere that the student could check off signifying that he/she would like to be assigned a non-SSN ID. It was in an obscure place, though. I only found out about it when I started working for the University. It was almost as if they hid it, knowing that this is the last thing on most folks mind who are just enrolling at the university.

    --
    My other computer is a Jacquard loom.
    1. Re:I always hated giving the SSN by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They probably did. Which is funny, isn't it? I mean, if they can do it for one student, why wouldn't it scale?

      Conservatism for laziness' sake. Ugh.

    2. Re:I always hated giving the SSN by drmarcj · · Score: 1

      I was an international student, and had one of those SSNs that immediately identified you as unemployable and undeserving of credit. So anyone who wanted to steal my identity was really barking up the wrong tree.

      Anyhow, it never made sense why they used SSNs rather than university-assigned student numbers Isn't the point of SSNs that they're for, oh, I don't know, Social Security purposes only? Since students pay the University, not the other way round, why would they need your SSN in the first place.

    3. Re:I always hated giving the SSN by happyemoticon · · Score: 1

      Yeah, it's a very bad system. The way we use SSNs nowadays is an outgrowth of the increasing need for a national id #, and the government's complete unwillingness to administrate such identification in the face of "big government" paranoia. To work (and in my case go to school as well) you have to show two of the following: Social Security card, driver's license, or birth certificate. And what you say about, "Here. Take my money. Please, have it," totally rings true: I tried to pay my electricity bill (which was in my ex-roomate's name for 1 more billing cycle) and they said they needed her SSN and verbal confirmation to even tell me how much was on the account. What am I going to do, increase her credit rating?

      And as far as unable to work and undeserving of credit, I'd think that's more a thing with your student visa than anything else.

    4. Re:I always hated giving the SSN by __aawavt7683 · · Score: 5, Informative

      Likewise. Apparently there was such an option on the applications I filed, but I never saw one. Actually, on the second, I left the SSN field blank. Chaos ensued.

      As for that incident, I ended up having two university accounts, they signed me up for health insurance despite my declining it, etc etc. Basically, they manually merged the two accounts using default options for everything. This after complaining to the registrar's office and such... I assume it occurred because the financial aid office had my SSN and that account was being used. It's all taken care of now. 901-xx-xxxx. Completely invalid. (900's don't work.)

      The other incident was at Michigan Technological University -- saw no option to not have my SSN as my everything-number. In this instance, I gave it because I didn't want to risk not being accepted. Later, I went to the registrar's office to try and get the so-called "M" number that they gave in place of SSNs. At the time I was told that I could only do it if I declared my account confidential -- have to show photo ID, everything done through the mail and so forth; a real pain in the ass. I put that off, but went back a month later with the intent to declare my account confidential. Lo and behold, magically, I no longer had to declare my account confidential and walked out with an M number. M0026xxxx. Still remember it, two years later, even. There's something about numbers...

      But, those're my stories. Really, you CAN change from your SSN after the fact. Many people have bitched, "That's the trouble when you don't stick with your SSN" and such, but I just start talking to them as though they're stupid. That's because they are.

      Go tomorrow, get it changed; keep your confidential data confidential.

      -DrkShadow

    5. Re:I always hated giving the SSN by ComputerSlicer23 · · Score: 3, Funny
      Yeah, I irritated several people, and made a lot of people in the registrars office laugh when they asked for my name, I just gave them my SSN to save time. Everyone understood it was an implication that I was just a number at the University.

      It actually saved time. It was the next thing they were going to ask for anyways, and they wouldn't do anything to my records until I told it to them. They didn't need to know my name, and if they did, it'd be on the first screen they pulled up if they felt the need to use my first name to make me feel like a person.

      Kirby

    6. Re:I always hated giving the SSN by Class+Act+Dynamo · · Score: 1

      The advice you give is sound. Unfortunately, I graduated last May, so the point is moot. I do hope you get modded up, though. It is good advice.

      --
      My other computer is a Jacquard loom.
    7. Re:I always hated giving the SSN by Nept · · Score: 1

      the absolute worst were the profs who insisted upon posting grades up on their door, identifying the scores not by name, but by Social Security number. To make matters worse, it was the CS profs who did this the most.

      --
      "Teachers leave us kids alone ..." - Roger Waters, Pink Floyd
    8. Re:I always hated giving the SSN by maxpublic · · Score: 1

      A national i.d. number solves nothing. It'll simply replace the SSN as a universal identifier, and that number will used to accomplish identity theft rather than the SSN.

      Max

      --
      My god carries a hammer. Your god died nailed to a tree. Any questions?
    9. Re:I always hated giving the SSN by canuck57 · · Score: 1

      I always hated that about college

      With good reason too. I once consulted to an unamed college and could not believe how disorganized, how poorly planed and how lax security was. But the Dean responsible was worried more about what other things and what I cost him than getting a decent set of backups. The kicker was we game him very low rates as I was between larger projects.

      Deans should not manage I/T and computer infrastructure. I/T manager needs to answer to the board/directors and have their own budget and standards. Standards based not on budget pilfering and politics, but based on basic functional and security needs.

      And lock down the firewalls and PCs. Heck, many run firewalls but have rules in them that pass all traffic both ways as the people neither have the skills nor the time to do otherwise.

      The fact of the mater is, the biggest boost to college computer security is when the internet connection becomes so clogged up it becomes unusable. And a call from a dean who is having problems watching NBA or porno is inconvenienced. At this point they usually have to get a bigger pipe or clamp down on abuse.

      I should note, not all colleges and universities are like this --- but many are.

    10. Re:I always hated giving the SSN by mattstorer · · Score: 2, Interesting
      Yeah, I did pretty much the same thing at my school. I was, unfortunately, blessed (?) with a remarkably easy-to-remember SSN; almost anyone who hears it could probably remember it without difficulty after the first time.

      So anyway, I went to get my student ID changed after the proberbial straw broke the camel's back: I had received a letter in the mail from the university, addressed to me, with my student ID (SSN) printed on the outside of the envelope. Boy was I pissed. So, I went down to the registrar's office to get my ID changed, which they were happy to do.

      A few thoughts:
      • first, at my old school, if you lived on campus you could order pizza from local pizza shops and pay for it using your student meal plan. you just had to provide to the 16-year-old on the other end of the phone your name, address, and SSN. Now, if this isn't one of the biggest loopholes for identity theft, I don't know what is. I mean, how the hell do I know the kid taking my order isn't going to misuse my information? What checks and balances are in place to ensure my information stays private in the pizza joint?
      • second, and not quite so bad, is that everyone in the school knows damn well student IDs are SSNs. even after I got my ID changed from my SSN to an internal ID, if I ever went to the health center, or had to sign forms of any sort, or order pizza, or whatever, I would be asked for my SSN. I'd ask them, "you mean my student ID?" and they'd reply, "your SSN." early on, if the questioner was a school official, I'd give them my SSN trusting they know what they're talking about, but found that they in fact didn't, they really meant my student ID. grrr...
      • but here's the weird part. about 6 months after I changed my ID from my SSN to an internal ID, I got a notice in the mail that I had to start paying my student loans, as I'd left school. I thought, "WTF? I haven't left!" so I looked into it. Turns out, there's a whole network of linkages between your student loans and your student ID - at least, at my alma mater - so when I changed my ID, I had a fair amount of extra work to do to continue to receive my loans. Just FYI, you'll probably want to inquire about this at your school's financial aid office if you decide to switch your ID - which I strongly encourage you to do, even if it is a pain.
      -matt
    11. Re:I always hated giving the SSN by mwood · · Score: 1

      The *officially recognized* uses of the SSN (paying taxes) are such that there's no point in stealing one or a million.

      The officially recognized uses of a general-purpose personal ID card backed by the word of the government would be easily seen as worth stealing, and hence worthy of vigorous protection.

      OTOH we probably shouldn't spin up another big government program just to encourage private laziness. How many organizations' need to identify people ever goes beyond "this is the same person who initiated the relationship"? A long list of identifiers issued by everybody and his brother would be more secure, and it wouldn't really be any less useful than One Number to Rule Them All.

      }enable broken-record{
      Organizations needing unique personal identifiers really need to start by asking the question, "what do we actually mean by 'identify'?" The answer to that question should tell you whence the identifiers should come.

    12. Re:I always hated giving the SSN by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You just described my identical experience. University of Iowa?

    13. Re:I always hated giving the SSN by mattstorer · · Score: 1

      nope. I don't really want to say which school I went to, don't really want to badmouth them publically you see... but it was in the northeast United States. New England.

  6. soooo by ikea5 · · Score: 5, Funny

    no mention of the grades?

  7. Suspicious? by Dekks · · Score: 2, Interesting

    It seems like bit of a convenient coincidence that this happened just before they replaced their ID numbers with something other than Social Security numbers. Someone has obviously been paying attention in their Computer Science classes.

    1. Re:Suspicious? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually, it's believed that the machine may have been compromised as early as November.

    2. Re:Suspicious? by FuturePastNow · · Score: 1

      That's my thought. Ten to one this was done by a student. If that's the case, though, they probably did it just for the challenge and won't do anything with the information.

      --
      Give a man fire, and you warm him for the night. Set a man on fire, and you warm him for the rest of his life.
    3. Re:Suspicious? by Reignking · · Score: 1

      You haven't met the students at George Mason, then :)

      --
      One man's Funny is another man's Offtopic.
    4. Re:Suspicious? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually, I go to George Mason University. And the implementation of the G numbers went in effect in Fall 2004. So our ID cards are identified not by SSN anymore. The database server however contained just about everything on us excluding address and phone numbers to my knowledge.

  8. And that's the one you know about... by ergo98 · · Score: 5, Interesting

    The most remarkable thing to consider regarding these types of stories is the fact that, more often than not, the hackers are incidentally detected (e.g. they send an email saying "give me money or I go public!").

    How many of these incidents happen with no one the wiser. Just guessing, but I'd wager at least 10 major silent exploits for every 1 publicized event. How many employees of Big Corporation are doing a ZIP of the company database onto a USB key "just in case", and how many servers are silently owned month after month.

    1. Re:And that's the one you know about... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yup, usually goes unnoticed. Talking to some hacker friends of mine, I learned that they had root on our local university servers throughout the 90s. Didn't surprise me much.

  9. Social Security Number by ikkibr · · Score: 1, Funny

    Why does it need to be secret? Is there anything important you could do with it?

    1. Re:Social Security Number by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why does it need to be secret? Is there anything important you could do with it?

      No, it's utterly useless. Give me yours, and I"ll prove it.

    2. Re:Social Security Number by Tobias.Davis · · Score: 0

      Social engineering, a form with a SSN (which usually includes a home address, in bad form) and a quick mind can do a lot with this information. Think of this, large clothing retailers that allow you to sign up and after approval use $500+ dollars on a one time shopping spree? There are so many examples of what a capable mind can do with this information.

    3. Re:Social Security Number by ikkibr · · Score: 0

      So why they don't googleit? I'm pretty sure you could find thousands of SSN's in google...

    4. Re:Social Security Number by Anita+Coney · · Score: 1

      With a SSN and a forged birth certificate or forged drivers license you could can credit cards/loans/etc.

      --
      If someone says he and his monkey have nothing to hide, they almost certainly do.
    5. Re:Social Security Number by twiddlingbits · · Score: 1

      You obviously don't live in the USA. With someones name and SS# you can create a fake identity that appears to anyone and everyone to be the other person since they have all the right numbers. You could perhaps get a Drivers License, access Finacial Records, take out credit, etc. A lot of vendors have a 2nd level password if they use your SSN for Identity but there are still a lot that if you got the number they don't bother to verify anything else. It's also the number the IRS uses to track you for tax purposes, so give someone the other persons SS#, make money, pay no taxes and let the IRS hammer the person you stole the # from for non-payment.

    6. Re:Social Security Number by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That sounds like more a problem with businesses that grant/extend credit based on USING SS numbers rather than on the agency displaying them or making them purposefully/accidentally available.

    7. Re:Social Security Number by Anita+Coney · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Actually, it's a problem with both. When the SSN was first conceived is was specifically NOT supposed to be any sort of ID system. Obviously that changed.

      Some states have solved the problem. In Texas, for example, people can "lock" their credit information. With it locked no one can get credit reports which makes it impossible to get credit, even if the person has the SSN, drivers license, birth certificate, etc.

      Of course the credit companies are fighting these laws because they like the idea of fast and easy credit.

      --
      If someone says he and his monkey have nothing to hide, they almost certainly do.
  10. The worst thing about this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Interesting

    There are probably a lot of cases just like this where either the hacked party isn't even aware they got hacked, or the hacked party knows they got hacked and isn't talking about it. Which makes you wonder how long our credit system can stand up to rampant large-scale ID theft.

    Stock up on canned goods, folks.

    1. Re:The worst thing about this by shawb · · Score: 1

      Stock up on canned goods, folks.

      And use someone else's credit card?

      --
      I'll never make that mistake again, reading the experts' opinions. - Feynman
    2. Re:The worst thing about this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, mod this parent UP!

    3. Re:The worst thing about this by dasunt · · Score: 2, Interesting

      There are probably a lot of cases just like this where either the hacked party isn't even aware they got hacked, or the hacked party knows they got hacked and isn't talking about it. Which makes you wonder how long our credit system can stand up to rampant large-scale ID theft.

      Stock up on canned goods, folks.

      Americans have one of the lowest savings rates for a developed nation. There are several studies which indicated many Americans spend more than they earn. Even worse, other than home ownership, many goods and services that Americans buy do almost nothing to help their financial health.

      Now there is nothing wrong with spending money on what makes you happy as long as its within reason, but how many people out there have maxed out credit cards, drive a new car, have a full entertainment package ($80+ cable bills, cell phones with every feature and service imaginable, big "going-out" entertainment budget), and shop out of boredom, all while having little or no savings?

      This "buy now, pay later, I don't have to plan for my future" is what I'm worried about. A little ID theft here and there won't kill us.

    4. Re:The worst thing about this by maxpublic · · Score: 1

      They have the Boomer mentality, both personally and nationally. As in "buy now, make the damned kids pay for everything later".

      Max

      --
      My god carries a hammer. Your god died nailed to a tree. Any questions?
    5. Re:The worst thing about this by Maestro4k · · Score: 1
      • Now there is nothing wrong with spending money on what makes you happy as long as its within reason, but how many people out there have maxed out credit cards, drive a new car, have a full entertainment package ($80+ cable bills, cell phones with every feature and service imaginable, big "going-out" entertainment budget), and shop out of boredom, all while having little or no savings?
      What's annoying is most of the country makes it hard to save on some things, for instance where I live a car is an absolute must, there's almost no public transportation. I really wouldn't mind taking a train or bus to work to save money, but no such luck. I try to save where I can, but truthfully between my necessities (car payment, car insurance, copays on prescriptions, Internet access (I work in IT so this is a necessity), food, gas and student loan payments) I have little left each month. It's highly frustrating to be looking at another 20+ years on the student loans to pay and not seeing the possibility of having significant savings for quite a while.
      • This "buy now, pay later, I don't have to plan for my future" is what I'm worried about. A little ID theft here and there won't kill us.
      Very true, and it also creates an environment hostile to non-credit card using consumers. I don't have a credit card, don't particularly want one either, and there are times where it's a major problem. Thankfully I do have a check card that works like one through my bank, that's helped a lot and I don't have to worry about overspending.

      ID Theft is worse than you think though. Even if you find out about it early, the banks and credit card companies aren't terribly interested in helping you. A friend of mine found out someone had applied for a credit card in her name (I forget how she found out, I think she had a fraud warning on her credit report). The card was actually issued, and thankfully not used. It took her two months to get the credit card company that issued it to do anything about it, even though she could prove who she was. They just weren't interested in helping stop the fraud before it happenned, apparently it's easier to just charge it off and let the individual have to deal with the problem on their credit report.

  11. Bah, by Saturn+SL1-WNY · · Score: 0, Insightful

    And I'm sure the street value for social security numbers is really high too.

    Obviously, some people seriously need to take a good hard look at the best digital security tool, that's been around since the beginning of computers: THE POWER SWITCH.

    If computers nowadays were not always-on solutions (I'm sure 24/7 SS# databases in a university aren't a hot requirement) they would be less visible, and less prone to being destroyed by internet theives.

    1. Re:Bah, by mslinux · · Score: 1

      They sell for 60 bucks a pop in the US.

    2. Re:Bah, by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Dammit, I knew I was being over charged.

  12. I'm less worried over this.. by Tracer_Bullet82 · · Score: 3, Insightful

    than from internal threats.

    How many cases of internal theft do we know?

    As someone who once created and maintained my high school information database, I know how easy the system can be abused.

    What's very imporant is that Universities have strict and applied policies dealing with information and database handling.Limiting the numbers that have access is paramount.
    Background checks for personnel involved should be done too.

    --


    Timang tinggi tinggi
    parang sudah asah
    alang alang mandi
    biar sampai basah
    1. Re:I'm less worried over this.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Universities should also have a choice: These policies apply only when they collect the SSID.

      That is, no background checks required if they generate their own ID.

      -cmh

    2. Re:I'm less worried over this.. by standards · · Score: 1

      In the US, there are laws and regulations that exist to protect student privacy. These regulations are known as "FERPA". Although these FERPA laws seem to apply only to your "academic record", your academic record includes things like keeping the fact that you even attended a school (as being a student with an academic institution is defined as being part of your academic record).

      Of course, no laws prevent an academic instituion from doing dumb things like not using quality security strategies or outsourcing key administrative and instructional systems to an incapable supplier that has a great glossy and great marketshare. Spyware is only going to make this kind of privacy leakage worse.

      Of course, FERPA only applies to academic institutions - they do NOT apply to your employer, your church, or other non-academic institution.

    3. Re:I'm less worried over this.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I was a teaching assistant at a major university and a community college. One (or possibly both; I can't remember) of those schools gave me student rosters that listed every student's SSN. As far as I know, no background check was done on me before my employment (except checks on my education and such). I was not asked to take any special precautions with these lists, either. I doubt my students knew I had them.

      While I never considered doing something illegal with these SSNs, and made sure the rosters were shredded at the end of the semester, I wonder how many of my colleagues could've been less honest or careful...

    4. Re:I'm less worried over this.. by mattstorer · · Score: 1

      Limiting the numbers that have access is paramount.

      very true. but security is only as good as the weakest link in the chain, and if schools are publicizing SSNs as student IDs, then I would argue that there really is no chain to speak of - they're undermining their own security systems in the name of convenience.

      matt

  13. wow too bad.... by djeddiej · · Score: 5, Informative

    I had an opportunity to work at a University in Canada as a development contractor, and literally had access to thousands of student numbers and personal information. There is a large push to web-ify a lot of applications, but the educational sector is lagging in terms of security. A strong initiative has to be undertaken at all levels of academic administration to better enforce security rules, from the registation process all the way to marking and evaluation.

    --
    just a web application developer and instructor in Toronto, ON Canada
    1. Re:wow too bad.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It is really common in University environments to give the ITS staff supporting the system full privileges on the system. Sysadmins, database administrators, programmers, application support people - all typically have full access little of which is audited. Organizations are comfortable with the thought that an employee would put their job in jeopardy if they stole identity information - of course, the organization, unless explicitly told, would likely not know who had perpetrated the identity theft. The issue at Georgetown points out an even more glaring issue - the number of University systems that are exposed to the internet for no good reason. I point this out repeatedly to the powers that be in my organization. Though no one has given me a good reason why these machines are exposed to the internet, they won't implement better network security - like VLANS and the like. Too much work, I guess.

    2. Re:wow too bad.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Was this Waterloo???

    3. Re:wow too bad.... by DotNM · · Score: 1

      I work for my county's (Simcoe) school board, and while it's not post-secondary education, we do track a lot of information. However, my school board takes security very seriously. No system is exposed to the internet unless there's a really good reason, and everything is protected by multiple levels. The Admin network is seperated by a VLAN from the student services network, which cannot talk to the Admin network at all. The admin network can contact specific systems on the student services network and all access is logged. They also don't give out more privileges than absolutely necessary to do your job. Even though I'm a co-op student, I still had to get the Criminal Background Check done and everything so that they know me, even though I've been an official employee for about 2-3 years.

      --
      There's no place like localhost
    4. Re:wow too bad.... by ski2die · · Score: 0
      I had an opportunity to work at a University in Canada...

      That sounds more like a sentence than an opportunity.

    5. Re:wow too bad.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Use of SSN's as ID is not as common in Canada as in the US. Did the uni you were working at use SSNs for student ID? They only would need the SSNs for the staff's payroll.

      The valid uses for a SSN in Canada: http://www.hrsdc.gc.ca/asp/gateway.asp?hr=/en/cs/s in/print_03_06_30.shtml&hs=sxn

  14. It wouldn't have mattered. by and+by · · Score: 5, Informative

    Schools phase out SSN usage to prevent identity theft due to losing your wallet with your student ID therein. They still have the SSN on file for financial aid use and it's still part of your student record. It just isn't usually printed.

    1. Re:It wouldn't have mattered. by gl4ss · · Score: 1

      they could have had another, privilidged, db for that information though. one that only people who need to have access would have access to.

      but that would have assumed them to have a clue, or having cared..

      --
      world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
    2. Re:It wouldn't have mattered. by Caseyscrib · · Score: 1

      I just scratched my SSN off my ID card with a razorblade. If anyone at my college really needs my SSN they can just ask. It still bothers me though that they use my SSN to track my records.

    3. Re:It wouldn't have mattered. by Belfy · · Score: 1

      When I applied I did not provide the number. At the counter they asked for it and I asked if it was necessary. They said nope, here's your Student ID.

      The situation may be different with financial aid, but the school does not have my SSN on file at all and all records are by my generated student ID number.

      Most people don't need it. Ask them if it is necessary, and if they need it they'll be able to tell you what benefit it provides to you directly.
      (Such as credit checks etc.)

  15. During a change over by Kipsaysso · · Score: 1

    The easiest way to hack is already being on the inside.

    --
    This is another way of starting a sig with this and ending it with that.
  16. In Australia.... by fodi · · Score: 5, Interesting

    One of the National Privacy Principles introduced by the Privacy Act 2000, prohibits a private organisation from using such information to uniquely identify a person. Maybe other countries should follow suit and enforce such a law...

    1. Re:In Australia.... by and+by · · Score: 1

      Here (the U.S.A.) we have a similar law. The Social Security Administration is the only agency / organization which is unconditionally allowed to use the SSN for identification purposes. Even other parts of the government can't if the citizen doesn't let them. That's why the IRS (Internal Revenue Service) allows you to fill out a form and get a Taxpayer Identification number (which you'd then use for financial aid).

      Private parties and organizations don't have the right to demand your SSN. Nonetheless, without at least a Taxpayer Identification Number to reference, you're never going to get credit anywhere.

      Essentially, a U.S. citizen can refuse to give the SSN to anyone but the SSI; everyone else has to assign you a number.

    2. Re:In Australia.... by Frogbert · · Score: 1

      Thats stupid, Its like saying you don't have to agree to Microsofts Eulas when clearly if you want to get anything done in a business world you have to.

    3. Re:In Australia.... by term8or · · Score: 1

      ... Whereas, in the UK nobody uses the NI number (the local equivalent of the Social Security Number) since huge numbers of people have multiple numbers due to government incompetence and individual fraud.

      --



      "As a writer / novelist you might want to spellcheck your sig. :) " - AC
    4. Re:In Australia.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Most other countries aren't as stupid as Americans so weren't doing something so dumb in the first place.

    5. Re:In Australia.... by Maestro4k · · Score: 1
      • Thats stupid, Its like saying you don't have to agree to Microsofts Eulas when clearly if you want to get anything done in a business world you have to.
      Exactly, the government doesn't even enforce the law so it's become entrenched and abused. Only now are companies starting to realize that it's not only illegal but a Bad Idea(tm) to use SSNs to identify everyone. It's sad that someone had the foresight to see this would be a problem (thus the law was created in the first place) but it took it actually becoming a problem for anything to be done.

      To give you an idea how entrenched it is, my health insurance company just finally changed everyone's ID numbers from SSN to another system last year. Up until then my SSN was printed on my health insurance card, which I have to provide to any doctor/hospital I go to so I receive benefits.

  17. Deja Vu by jonno317 · · Score: 1

    This same thing happened at the University of Texas a couple of years ago. One would think they'd learn not to use SSN for id purposes anymore, but to my knowledge, UT still uses SSN for everything. Eventually maybe schools will figure out that it might not be a good idea to use SSN for any id purposes other than its original purpose, but I wouldn't hold my breath.

    1. Re:Deja Vu by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      UT now uses an EID (basically a username you make up)instead of SSN. So things are getting better there.

  18. Idiots. by tuxter · · Score: 0

    I'm a fire fighter, and we are constantly cutting dead and fucked up people out of cars, the worst ones are the idiots who don't wear seatbelts. Don't tie down your WiFi, you are leaving yourself open, same for storing social security numbers and personal info on a college computer system. 30,000 students??? there is bound to be one cleverer than the sysop/security guy. This sort of stuff is pathetic, and there is absolutely no f'ing need for it to happen.

    1. Re:Idiots. by tuxter · · Score: 1

      Sorry to reply to my own post, but if these people are looking for sympathy, it's between shit and syphilis in the dictionary....

    2. Re:Idiots. by Chuck+Chunder · · Score: 1
      I'm a fire fighter, and we are constantly cutting dead and fucked up people out of cars, the worst ones are the idiots who don't wear seatbelts.
      Don't know if you've seen this.

      The sequel is a kicker.
      --
      Boffoonery - downloadable Comedy Benefit for Bletchley Park
    3. Re:Idiots. by tuxter · · Score: 1

      Fine, when the author is laying sprawled over the bonnet of his car with a windscreen embedded in his face and a steering wheel in his groin, maybe he'll rethink his story. "It's my civil rights" Sure it is, it's also my civil rights to call him a fucktard, Shouldn't he consider the rights of the people who scrape up these arse-hats?

    4. Re:Idiots. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why was the parent modded down???

    5. Re:Idiots. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I have no problem with someone who lives by his own principles. Now just watch while someone sues or otherwise tries to profit from this fellow's death.

      People who refuse to wear seat belts are fine. Survivors who try to sue for wrongful death on behalf of aforementioned dead person should go packing.

    6. Re:Idiots. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Probably because it was incoherent and bringing up personal facts that have absolutely no correlation with the story. Seems almost like a drunk troll.

      "I'm a farmer and when I fuck the sheep the who the cat ran off with the fur in the buckets! If not for the buckets we wouldn't be a mopping!"

    7. Re:Idiots. by Dun+Malg · · Score: 1
      Shouldn't he consider the rights of the people who scrape up these arse-hats?

      You obviously don't understand what rights are. It's perfectly within their right to find alternate employment. If they choose to work as a firefighter, part of the job description includes scraping dumbasses who don't wear seatbelts off the pavement. It may be their preference not to, but preferences are not rights.

      --
      If a job's not worth doing, it's not worth doing right.
    8. Re:Idiots. by tuxter · · Score: 1

      I'm a volunteer Fire Fighter, I do it because I choose to help, it's not nice sometimes, but I still do it. And I understand perfectly what rights are, You're just being pedantic and I really don't want to get into a conversation based around symantics.

    9. Re:Idiots. by Dun+Malg · · Score: 1
      I'm a volunteer Fire Fighter, I do it because I choose to help, it's not nice sometimes, but I still do it. And I understand perfectly what rights are, You're just being pedantic and I really don't want to get into a conversation based around symantics.

      You think the difference between rights and preferences is semantics, and that pointing out that the position you took was factually incorrect is pedantic? Then I guess we have nothing to discuss.

      --
      If a job's not worth doing, it's not worth doing right.
    10. Re:Idiots. by smidget2k4 · · Score: 1

      its also not your "right" to be able to legally drive, its not nessessary. Sure, you can drive illegally, but then you pay the consequences. "Rights" and privlidges are two different things.

    11. Re:Idiots. by BoiseAlf · · Score: 1

      I hate to contribute to the digression of this post, but I couldn't keep quiet. There needs to be a careful balance between individual rights and the effect of actions (or inaction) on others. I could care less if you don't wear your seatbelt, it's really not my concern. However, I should have the RIGHT to refuse any part of my auto insurance premium in supporting your breathing machine after someone scrapes you off the road.

  19. Inquiring minds want to know... by davezirk · · Score: 2, Interesting

    What OS was their server running????

    1. Re:Inquiring minds want to know... by grylnsmn · · Score: 1

      Depending on what department, it can vary greatly. In our ECE department, we have a Solaris server (cpe01.gmu.edu). The main server for the school is an old Alpha (named osf1.gmu.edu). However, from what I've heard around campus, this one was probably a Windows server that didn't have all of the patches applied. Many of the different offices operate as a Windows only shop.

    2. Re:Inquiring minds want to know... by paranoidgeek · · Score: 1

      More than likely the hack wasnt made possible by the OS but instead a custom built program or stupid admins.

      --
      Lima India November Uniform X-ray
    3. Re:Inquiring minds want to know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      emacs.

    4. Re:Inquiring minds want to know... by rburgess3 · · Score: 1

      Windows. Most of their computer labs are centrally administrated by the same servers that the admin. staff uses. Take that for what you will.

    5. Re:Inquiring minds want to know... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Like you had to ask...Win2K server

      via
      http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=http%3 A%2F%2F www.washingtonpost.com%2Fwp-dyn%2Farticles%2FA5188 -2005Jan12.html&btnG=Google+Search

  20. hm... by jj110888 · · Score: 1

    It makes you wonder if its worth it to steal someone else's SSN when you apply for a state university, with both berkeley and this one compromised...........better your SSN then mine, if you don't mind ;)

    1. Re:hm... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Unrelenting fucktard.

      May you, your shithole of a trailer and your even more ignorant cousin/sisterwife get sucked into an F5 tornado, along with that walking mange of a coondog and that pile of wrecked steel and cinderblocks you call a driveway, you nunshitting popefelcher.

      Please stop logging in here, lackwit. The chiggers that fall out of your mullet are absolutely disgusting. Your dog smells. You smell worse than a tour-ripe hippy rolling - stoned - in a steamy March meadow full of fresh cowpies. You have no idea how much we've been spending on deadly toxic fumigants to delouse the place after you finally leave.

    2. Re:hm... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Allow me to congratulate you on your spelling, even if what you write clearly reveals you to be a person in desperate need of some maturity.

  21. make them count by murderator · · Score: 1

    This is what i call "failure". But actually school administrators should be punished badly. I'd be very surprised if they wouldnt fire those lazy quakers - wannabe admins

  22. IT majors by Turn-X+Alphonse · · Score: 1

    PLEASE tell me this place is well known for it's high grade IT majors. That would be hillarious and really make my night.

    Alternatively just say they had a fully patched windows machine, both works fine.

    --
    I like muppets.
    1. Re:IT majors by daeg · · Score: 1

      This place is known for it's high grade ID majors and they run exclusively Windows and are always fully patched.

      Antyhing else you want me to say?

    2. Re:IT majors by Opticalsky · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Actually George Mason University is one of the few that have Ph.D programs in Information Technology, but it goes further such as they have "Information Technology with Concentration in Information Security."

      Kind of ironic that they would have a graduate program there for information security and they just got hacked.

      I think it might be an inside job though.

    3. Re:IT majors by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Keep in mind that the student body, the faculty and the administration are three distinct and pretty much mutually exclusive groups.

      This would probably be a dickup by the administration.

      Most school administrations I've dealt with (even in the Ivy League) aren't that bright.

    4. Re:IT majors by pat_trick · · Score: 1

      Don't discount the crossover between students and administration. Student work-study workers in certain jobs have access to large amounts of information. When I worked in college, I had access to nearly any computer on campus, as I knew the admin passwords by heart.

      One fool abused it, though. He was kicked out the next day.

    5. Re:IT majors by Different+River · · Score: 1

      Yeah, that's a good point -- I forgot about their Master's program in Information Security, their Information Security Institute, and their Lab for Information Security Technology.

      It's always amazed me how little university administrators make use of the expertise of their faculty, academic staff, and (esepcially graduate) students.

  23. Someone follow that example. by philovivero · · Score: 4, Funny

    We need more organisations using other unique identifiers for people than Social Security numbers. This will seem radical to you if you're a politician, but I recommend Social Security numbers should only ever be used for Social Security.

    My mother a few years back pointed out that once upon a time, our politicians actually said, boldly, in front of the entire nation, that in Soviet Russia, the government numbered the citizens. They said this was proof that the soviets were an evil dictatorship sort of country, and not a democracy, where we can vote for naked petrified persons (so long as they are American-born).

    She challenged me to imagine a beowulf cluster of Social Security numbers, and how easily such a cluster could be abused (a near-limitless supply of identities to steal).

    Now, sadly, all our base are belong to the myriad entities that have our Social Security number (along with mother's maiden name, date of birth, income, and all the other things identity thieves might want). You'd expect us, as a society, to be smarter than that.

    Hopefully others will follow the example of this school, and migrate away from using social security numbers for illegitimate purposes.

    1. Re:Someone follow that example. by gl4ss · · Score: 1

      how about a push to migrate away from using a widely accessible number as absolute proof that you're someone?

      --
      world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
    2. Re:Someone follow that example. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Genius

    3. Re:Someone follow that example. by Suhas · · Score: 1

      So this is how it will be done from now on. Good work.

    4. Re:Someone follow that example. by ashot · · Score: 1

      10 dollars to the person who guesses at exactly what point in writing the post parent picked up the ganj.

      --
      -ashot
    5. Re:Someone follow that example. by jimand · · Score: 1

      I, for one, bow to our new sarcastic overlord!!

    6. Re:Someone follow that example. by smatthew · · Score: 1

      It was right before he starting imagining his mother talking about beowulf cluster of social security numbers....

      --
      slashdot username - at - email.domain.name
  24. GMU's one-stop web page about the intrusion by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    http://www.gmu.edu/intrusion/

    And according to email sent to all GMU faculty, staff, and students, it's implied that the compromised was -- get ready -- running Windows.

    1. Re:GMU's one-stop web page about the intrusion by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      So? The server could have been running Linux. God knows that there have been plenty of exploits for Linux and related OSS apps.

      Although I would trust Linux more than Windows, if you don't run your shit right, then its really not the fault of the operating system that you're incompetent at running a production server.

  25. my 2 cents by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I don't care if the judicial system is suppose to be a reform system. Crimes of permanent damage should carry very harsh sentences. Such as identity theft, arson (which may damage unreplaceable property), etc.

  26. I'm a Student at GMU by grylnsmn · · Score: 5, Informative
    Here are the two emails that they've sent to students about the incident:

    To: Mason Community

    From: Joy Hughes, Vice President for Information Technology

    Subject: Illegal Intrusion into University Database

    The university server containing the information relating to Mason's ID cards was illegally entered by computer hackers. The server contained the names, photos, social security numbers and G numbers of all members of the Mason community who have identification cards.

    The intruder installed tools on the ID server that allowed other campus servers to be probed. An Information Technology Unit staff member noticed the attack while reviewing system files as part of the university's internal controls procedures, and traced it back to the ID server. The compromised ID server was disconnected from the network and is no longer accessible. The police are currently investigating the break-in. The university is subject to dozens of probes and attacks each day.

    There is no evidence that any of the data available on the Mason ID server has yet been used illegally. It appears that the hackers were looking for access to other campus systems rather than specific data. However, it is possible that the data on the server could be used for identity theft.

    Following are steps each of us should take to minimize the likelihood of ID theft from this, or any other similar incident.

    - Contact any of the three major credit bureaus to place a fraud alert on your credit file. The fraud alert advises new and potential creditors that they should contact you before opening any new accounts in your name. Additionally your existing creditors are advised that they should contact you prior to making any changes (e.g. credit limit change) in your account. Once you notify one credit bureau, the fraud alert will be sent automatically to the other two. All three bureaus will send you credit reports free of charge once they receive the fraud alert. The three credit bureaus can be contacted as follows:

    Transunion
    1-800-680-7289
    www.transunion.com

    Equifax
    1-800-525-6285
    www.equifax.com

    Experian
    1-888-397-3742
    www.experian.com

    - Continue to check all your accounts on a regular basis for unusual activity.

    - The Federal Trade Commission Identity Theft Hotline gives a good overview of what to do when you think your information may have been stolen but have no evidence that it is being used. The number is 1-877-438-4338. Press #3. The Federal Trade Commission also has a website with extensive information about identity theft at www.ftc.gov/idtheft.

    If you have further questions, please call 3-8116. The university's IT Security Coordinator Cathy Hubbs is monitoring this line and will ensure that your message is immediately forwarded to the most appropriate person.

    We understand that taking these steps is inconvenient, and regret that the server attack makes it necessary. While it seems unlikely from the evidence currently available that identity theft has occurred, it is important to take these protective actions. We will share any further information about the intrusion and its effects as soon as it becomes available.

    and

    To: Mason Community

    From: Joy Hughes, Vice President for Information Technology
    Subject: Computer Break-In Information Website Now Established

    A new website giving information regarding the illegal intrusion into
    the university's ID database server is now on line at
    http://www.gmu.edu/intrusion. The page can also be accessed through links on
    the Student and Faculty and Staff resource pages on the home page. Due
    to the large number of calls we have received on the information line,
    we are noting your questions and providing the information on this page.

    We will regularly update the page as more information becomes
    avail

    1. Re:I'm a Student at GMU by LiquidCoooled · · Score: 1

      Seems like a very measured response to a difficult situation. It gives accurate detailed information in a concise manner.
      It would be nice if all organisations would speak so clearly.

      --
      liqbase :: faster than paper
    2. Re:I'm a Student at GMU by marko123 · · Score: 1

      The SSN upgrade process should point to places and people to start investigating.

      Timing like that could be more than coincidental.

      By the same token, it could be a coincidence that only one student in the Computer Security Fundamentals 101 course was passed by a hoary professor.

      --
      http://pcblues.com - Digits and Wood
    3. Re:I'm a Student at GMU by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      GMU has no such class.

    4. Re:I'm a Student at GMU by CAIMLAS · · Score: 1

      "Computer hackers"? Sounds a hell of a lot like "common thieves" to me. I believe the police call it "breaking and entering", as they were indeed physically on the premise? Or did I read that wrong?

      Were this a network-based crime, I'd think the police wouldn't be on it - but the FBI.

      --
      ~/ssh slashdot.org ssh: connect to host slashdot.org port 22: too many beers
  27. MOD PARENT UP by One+of+the+abnormals · · Score: 0

    That was pretty funny.

    --

    2b || !2b =?
  28. suspiciosity by solaraddict · · Score: 3, Interesting

    The one thing that would make me suspicious would be the fact that the intrusion happened just as they were transforming the data to use some other sort of unique id - IMHO an insider alert if ever there was one.

    1. Re:suspiciosity by dbIII · · Score: 2, Informative
      The one thing that would make me suspicious would be the fact that the intrusion happened just as they were transforming the data to use some other sort of unique id
      That doesn't surprise me at at that it was found at this time - the system would be coming under more scruting than usual, so intrusions may have happened before but were only noticed at that time.
    2. Re:suspiciosity by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      shouldn't that be suspiciousness?

  29. Don't just fry the little guys. by PornMaster · · Score: 1

    You can burn the low-level guys all you want, but upper management should have had security audits done and weeded them out before an actual breach.

    We don't know if mandates from above caused things to get forced into production without proper measures because of unrealistic deadlines or pathetic budgets, either.

    Perhaps if the school as a whole had to carry information security liability insurance they'd be forced by an insurance carrier to be compliant with some security standards.

  30. Sue the bastards... by MLopat · · Score: 2

    So what legal recourse do the students have? As far as I'm concerned, the organization is liable, and the students should launch a class action lawsuit, if nothing else, but for lost productivity time, which is what companies usually seek when they go after hackers. The school is no better than the people that hacked them if they couldn't safeguard this personal and highly sensitive information.

    You'll also notice that the asshole of a VP didn't even apologize for the situation. Just that he regrets it. Makes me sick how there's no sense of responsibility there.

    1. Re:Sue the bastards... by DanteLysin · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I think the problem is that there is a general belief that SSN is a secure identifer. Back when I was in college (god, almost 10 years ago), in my first "IT job" (ok, so I was lab consultant), one of our bosses showed us how easily it was to access public information. From a name and city, he was able to retrieve the student's full address, SSN, and even retrieve the student's parent's property tax information. The demonstration did not involve hacking or unauthorized intrustion to another system. This was 10 years ago, when there was a lot less more "online" information about you.

      Assuming SSN is secure is like using a .rhosts file on your root user account.

    2. Re:Sue the bastards... by DrFalkyn · · Score: 3, Interesting

      I was one of the potential people whose information was obtained. I am not planning on taking action against the univesity nor would I do so even if finacially harmed, unless it can be proved that there was gross negligence. GMU has made a good faith effort to switch IDs from SSNs to the new 'G' numbers. If my information was used to fradulently open acounts under my name, I would estimate primary people responsible are in my estimation:

      1) The thief
      2) The creditors for their lack proper verification allowing people to open new accounts and charge thousands of dollars with a few tidbits of information

      Then, depending on the circumstances:
      - The makers of whatever software was compromised, be in Windoes, Oracle, IIS, etc.
      - The administrators of said systems for not securing their systems properly or keeping up with the latest updates

    3. Re:Sue the bastards... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      As a student at George Mason's Law School, I must say the thought crossed my mind ... then I regained my senses and realized what stupid nonsense that was.

      The school did what it could.

    4. Re:Sue the bastards... by MLopat · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Not sure why you guys are so opposed to the idea of sueing the school. They're not even being apologetic. The bare minimum I would expect would be a formal apology.

      Where would the money come from? From the school of course. This would just raise tuition you say? Well sure, but why would you want to goto a schoo like this after an incident of this magnitude. I wouldn't trust them. And there are other options. Its not like we're talking about Waterloo or MIT here.

    5. Re:Sue the bastards... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If the information is used and causes damages - the organization that took responsibility of the comprimised data may be at least partially responsible. However, there seem to be many responsible parties - especially if factors such as vulnerability exploitation are considered (is sys admin or vendor responsible??). To be taken seriously, criminal charges should focus enough penalty and number of prosecutions onto the individual(s) who performed (and facilitated) the illicit data transfer. Should the organizations or individuals who take responsibility meet some sort of standard for access, if so, what standard? I'm not a huge fan of big-government, but this seems a logical application of regulation/standards. And, compliance should be tested. They attempt to run bombs through airport security, the regulating agencies on data preservation could similarly attempt to access the data without authorization. Perhaps done utilizing social attacks as well. It seems the people given access priviledges must also be compatible with the standards.

    6. Re:Sue the bastards... by mpe · · Score: 1

      I think the problem is that there is a general belief that SSN is a secure identifer.

      In effect it's government assigned name. Most of the problem is idiots treating it as though it is a "secret".

  31. Universities are security risk by bigberk · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Universities are notorious for not having good network and server security (hard to hire the required large staff to oversee so much data). I now work in the computer security field, and when I look back at my university experience I see lots of very frightening things -- besides just the extent of the records the university keeps, they also tend to print things like your birth date on records. Having your date of birth intercepted is bad news, and it is really disturbing to see it printed in so many places, especially along side your SSN / SIN.

    On top of that, network security in general is weak and so there are all these students using unencrypted shell logins, and exchanging sensitive data over email. Or doing online banking on public machines, where key loggers could easily be installed. Lots of students live at the university, so they have to use computers for sensitive tasks like banking (unless they happen to have a laptop).

    The whole experience made me resolve to keep tight control of aspects of my privacy. If someone tries to hijack your identity, the tell tale signs are: money disappearing, and new accounts being opened. So you must keep accurate records of where your money is, and watch those balances. Also order yearly credit checks, which are free to do. If someone is opening accounts under your name, you can at least catch it.

    1. Re:Universities are security risk by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Online banking is largely a harmless activitiy. Reasonably banks will not show your account number online. Although they can certianly do some annoying things (reordering checks, etc), it is going to be very difficult for them to transfer away money.

  32. Escaping the credit system by Tobias.Davis · · Score: 0

    Just remember: Once you have the cards paid off and the debt subsided, save save save. That way, when times are hard you have cash on hand to deal with anything. And congratulations, for thinking outside of the box =)

  33. US Army and identity theft by Jeff+Carr · · Score: 3, Informative
    When I was in the army 1995-1999, the pay stubs were just printed on on a normal sheets of paper, and handed out to everyone once a month.
    Some of the information freely available to anyone who cared to look at it was:
    • Your full name
    • Date of Birth
    • Social Security Number
    • Bank Name
    • Bank Account Number
    • The Amount of the Deposit
    • The Date of the Deposit
    It had more information than that, but plenty enough to call my bank and transfer money to another account. I assume they've improved since then, but they should have known better even then.
    --
    The television will not be revolutionized.
    1. Re:US Army and identity theft by YrWrstNtmr · · Score: 1

      THe USAF had been mailing them to the servicemember far earlier than that. IIRC, no bank name or acct #, but the other info was the same.

  34. Walter Williams by genrader · · Score: 1

    This is offtopic but Walter Williams is a professor at George-Mason University. I consider him one of the greatest minds of our time :)

    1. Re:Walter Williams by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Blah. Another the-market-always-knows-best loony. Any guest host of the Rush Limbaugh show is not worth my time.

    2. Re:Walter Williams by genrader · · Score: 1

      His political views differ from Rush's a lot, Rush is a neoRepublican, Williams is a conservative libertarian.

    3. Re:Walter Williams by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Please, pimp your politics elsewhere. Its annoying and rude when people bring up stupid irrelevant facts in a conversation.

  35. Interesting by Skim123 · · Score: 1

    This exact same thing happened at the University of California - San Diego about 8 months ago or so. I got a letter shortly afterward, informing me of the break-in and urging me to put a freeze on those accessing my credit report and to review my credit report for fradulent activity. What a pain.

    --

    I could not justify my existence if I were a turkey farmer. Would I terminate myself? Undoubtably, yes.

    1. Re:Interesting by Short+Circuit · · Score: 1

      And here at Grand Rapids Community College. Several laptops were stolen, including direct-deposit routing numbers, names, and SSNs.

      And someone is actively trying to use this information.

  36. Prosecution by ewg · · Score: 1

    Even using alternative identification numbers will only limit identity theft rather than eliminating it. I think law enforcement and prosecution is the answer.

    After all, it's an information society: abusing personal information harms the fabric of this society, as well as the specific individuals and organizations involved.

    --
    org.slashdot.post.SignatureNotFoundException: ewg
    1. Re:Prosecution by CAIMLAS · · Score: 1

      Na, prosecution and enforcement are too expensive and labor-intensive. I'd personally sooner expect biometric IDs, chips in our arms, and various other fascist monitoring tools. Seriously. That's the trend, at least.

      --
      ~/ssh slashdot.org ssh: connect to host slashdot.org port 22: too many beers
  37. Brings up an interesting situation by ZeeExSixAre · · Score: 1

    So when you, as a student of George Mason U, get a bill for "MOULIN SPLOOGE" you can be sure it wasn't you... or was it?

  38. Web SSN matching / lookup by Tobias.Davis · · Score: 0
    Check out this website, I googled it up:

    http://www.searchbug.com/peoplefinder/verify-ssn-f ree.aspx

    I found this information on myself, I really wonder how many other applications these web sites can use your SSN for? Complete trackback with job history?

    The Social Security Number 812-60-84622 is valid and was issued in Indiana. This SSN is ACTIVE. Would you like to learn more about this SSN? Click on the link below:

    It's scary what our "Secret number" system is capable of.

  39. Sue the bastards? by mrscott · · Score: 1

    I really can't see what that would solve, except to force the university to spend a huge amount of money defending itself from legal attack with money that could be better spent on improving/fixing the situation. The knee jerk reaction to every situation in this country is to just sue people left and right and it really kinda sucks. As much as I feel for the students that have to deal with this, if any do sue the university, I really hope they lose even more time and some money in the process.

  40. Read the sequel! by Chuck+Chunder · · Score: 1

    Because he is indeed dead. The two other people in the car who were wearing seatbelts aren't....

    --
    Boffoonery - downloadable Comedy Benefit for Bletchley Park
  41. No such thing as "Just missed it" by Hangtime · · Score: 2

    This was no coincidence. Someone saw this coming change and decided to cash-in while they still could.

    1. Re:No such thing as "Just missed it" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The change probably wasn't really coming. The university is just in CYA mode. At least, that's the way it is in our university information systems. People sometimes talk, but no one has the power, the mandate, the resources, or the motivation to actually make changes. Because of the decentralized nature of our university, many people with access to data/running integrated systems probably aren't even aware of the issues.

  42. Re:FUD by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Actually everything you said is FUD. It's quite difficult to obtain credit/driver's license with only an SS number for ID. However, the more "false" data you have (birthday, full name, SS number, current/prior address, etc) makes the whole process easier. Since the SS number was never intended to be private/secret and since no law prohibits a business from using it in any way they see fit, it's not hard to see that bit of information so easily obtainable. The real problem lies with the businesses that rely upon it as their sole point of identification.

  43. T-Mobil/ GWU/etc. What is in common? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    MS Windows. Cool. And we scream about security.

  44. FYI by Nixoloco · · Score: 2, Insightful

    The machine that was hacked was in the PhotoID Office and it was a Windows machine. Based on the bahaviour it was exhibiting, that is- it was scanning other machines to infect, it may have only been a worm and this whole story has been somewhat sensationalized. It may have been oblivious to the fact that data existed on the machine.
    The fact that the machine may have been unpatched reflects poorly on University Administration (ITU) but not on the CS or IT programs.

    Disclaimer: I work and go to school at GMU.

  45. Re:typical MS bashing without evidence by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    There is NOTHING in the article to begin to imply this was an MS server/application. See the letter sent to students a couple posts down from yours.

  46. Grammar nazi time by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "...better your SSN then mine..."

    "Than".

    "Then" in this context means "next in the sequence", and I don't think that's what you meant. Unless you are hoping to be the next victim of identity theft...

  47. stop treating SSN like a secret by mzwaterski · · Score: 1

    Maybe we should just stop treating an SSN like its some secret that no one will ever figure out. The SSN is so commonly used that no company should assume that if you know a person's SSN that you are that person. Its like saying, if you know John Doe's birtdate, you must be John Doe...its going to generate a lot of false positives.

    1. Re:stop treating SSN like a secret by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      When you enroll into uni, is there anything to stop you from supplying a fake SS#?

  48. Re:A sucker born every second? by MmmDee · · Score: 1

    And wait, just how many people out there are going to voluntarily submit their social security number and email address to a website they know nothing about????

    --
    No man's an island, unless he's had too much to drink and wets the bed.
  49. Punished badly? by mrscott · · Score: 1

    Yes, it's a failure, but consider what you just said - I assume you mean that heads should roll and all that good stuff. Exactly what purpose would that serve? If this really was an unpatched machine sitting in an office, wouldn't it be better for IT to re-examine their procedures and take appropriate steps to prevent the situation from happening again? Contrary to popular belief, keeping hundreds of systems patched, particularly when they're out of the direct control of IT for whatever reason, can be pretty damn hard, even for really good admins.

  50. SSN's emailed in the clear by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    A few years ago, I was working with a company that had a contract with a state university in [state name withheld]. One of the university employees decided it would be a good idea to send us the login id's for each of the students, so we would know who was authorized to use the system. So they emailed us a spreadsheet containing every student ID of every student in their system (going back YEARS). Unencrypted, of course.

    The student IDs were all SSN's.

    1. Re:SSN's emailed in the clear by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why is it that people hide information when posting anonymously? Slashdot does not log IPs and its not likely you're in violation of your contract anyway.

      If you're going to keep the information away from us, at least have the courtesy of not making it blatantly obvious that you are doing so.

    2. Re:SSN's emailed in the clear by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No shit. Why write "in [state name withheld]" at all? Must be one of those faggots that likes to write "*giggles*".

  51. Same as always... by SpielDawg · · Score: 1

    The same thing happened at Dartmouth a few months back. Some hacker got into a benifits server in our machine room. This got them access to SSNs of all Dartmouth employees and their dependents. In response to security concerns, they're implementing a PERSONAl firewall client (sygate) instead of front end. Makes me feel safe, when myself and the rest of my family works there...

    1. Re:Same as always... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What's even funnier, at least to me, is that long before they used SSN, you had a Student ID number (5 digits and a letter). This was also your "User Number" to access the time-sharing system. Unfortunately, the student ID Cards had your Student ID and your birthday--which was your password. So if you saw someone's ID card, you could access their account.

      It was funnier when they implemented a system where students could charge meals on their student ID. The advertising for this had a picture of a student holding their ID card up where you could easily read the Student ID Number and birthdate. Oops.

  52. Re:A sucker born every second? by Tobias.Davis · · Score: 1
    It's not my number I put in silly, that's the sad part. I modified 2 numbers on my own ssn and put it in that way..

    Viva america!

  53. Or a good idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    If identity theft becomes rampant enough we can all nullify the significance of the SSN.
    It's useless anyway, if they want to provide benefits to ppl then why tag us and make us tell everything about ourselves just to get some free cheese? Just give ppl cheese if they need it for crying out loud.

    1. Re:Or a good idea by BosstonesOwn · · Score: 0

      The SSN is to really show you that you and every one around you is a number no more no less.

      --
      This package Does Not Contain a Winner
  54. Look at the students first by CAIMLAS · · Score: 1

    Look to see if one of the students may have been the thief, first. Doubly so for a student that works for the University. It's not too far fetched that a student caught wind of such a change and was given the idea to commit this crime.

    --
    ~/ssh slashdot.org ssh: connect to host slashdot.org port 22: too many beers
  55. Re:A sucker born every second? by MmmDee · · Score: 1
    It's not my number I put in silly, that's the sad part.

    I didn't think you'd put your own social security number on /., but I am wondering how many people in general will. You don't really need clever phishing schemes when so many people probably give away information without needing to be duped.

    --
    No man's an island, unless he's had too much to drink and wets the bed.
  56. Hacking...SSNs from Universities.. by Entouchable · · Score: 0

    The media has REALLY damaged the term hacking havn't they? It used to mean accomplishing or working towards a difficult task. I'd hardly say getting the SSNs of random people at a given University is hacking. ;)

  57. Stealing IDs of college students = good business by Palal · · Score: 1

    If the gov't doesn't do something to stop identity thieves, this behavior will continue. In 10-20 years college students, whose identites were stolen will be making big $$$ and will probably have good credit histories. That's where the thieves hit the motehrlode, and the former students won't even know where it came from!!!

    --
    -Palal
  58. Re:A sucker born every second? by Entouchable · · Score: 1

    Even still, a social security number by itself wont do much, even with a useless email address. You could come up with SSNs through educated guesses with no problem. It's the SSN combined with the other info about the person that opens them up for attack.

  59. The GMU Information Assurance Program by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    http://csis.gmu.edu/index.html
    Highly recommended , and also Designated as a Center of Academic Excellence in Information Assurance Education by the National Security Agency. Could this be an inside job?

  60. ummm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Hello! I can guarantee the culprits are the ones implementing the change or at least informed someone about the upcoming change and thought they would cash in.

  61. Dumb idea by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    1. There is no actual loss. Until someone gets their credit ruined becuase of ID theft, on what basis are you going to sue?

    2. Where do you think the money will come from? GMU will have to raise tuition or cut back on some academic programs. Its a lose-lose for students.

  62. Oldest excuse on the books by iamacat · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I bet they have been "in the process or replacing the system" since last century. They just didn't do any serious work on that until they got busted. Same as US Airways over christmas and countless companies with Y2K bug until 1999. Everyone with decision making power should take a serious pay cut and students should get tuition discounts to offset the cost of dealing with identity theft.

    If they really took the problem seriously, an upgrade wouldn't take long at all. Just mechanically replace SSNs in the database with unique, randomly generated 9 digit numbers and set up a web page that maps SHA(SSN) to the new ID.

    1. Re:Oldest excuse on the books by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They just started last year, and I think they'll be done this year. They now use unique 9 digit numbers (called G numbers) (which are not randomly generated, because it'd be really expensive to verify that a new number hadn't already been assigned). The old registration and billing systems has been phased out, the new ones will accept either SSN or the G number, and I think by next year won't use SSN at all.

    2. Re:Oldest excuse on the books by ashot · · Score: 1

      it'd be really expensive to verify that a new number hadn't already been assigned

      if you keep the list of assigned numbers in a heap, or sorted array it would be log(n)

      --
      -ashot
    3. Re:Oldest excuse on the books by iamacat · · Score: 1

      It's nice to know it's just bad luck, not procrastination. But as for checking ID numbers, a modern desktop computer can do this instantly. I doubt new students enroll faster than 1/minute, but in the worst case you could store an 120MB bitmap and just toggle a single bit to assign an ID number.

      Non-random approach is dangerous because you can guess ID numbers of your classmates and from then on it's much easier to access their information or worse change their class enrollment.

    4. Re:Oldest excuse on the books by kwatz · · Score: 1

      Well, I don't know what they're doing in the back end as part of the transition, but I do know that they have been making a visible transition to the new identification system since last year. All of the students were reissued new IDs with the new identification numbers last spring, and we're using those ID numbers in more and more systems & forms.

  63. Coincidence? by bataras · · Score: 1

    My guess would be that it's too much of a coincidence that while they're making systematic changes around SSNs, suddenly, they have a mssive SSN breach. Probably someone working on that project or originated therefrom.

  64. Response? by jayloden · · Score: 1

    I for one want to know how the school is going to respond to this. What steps are they going to take post-incident, etc.

    Hell, I don't even know how one is supposed to respond in a situation like this or what I would do, I'm just curious what the aftermath of something like this is (besides just alerting the police)

    -Jay

    1. Re:Response? by Nambu · · Score: 1
      By law, at least in California, the institution is required to directly notify each person whose records were known to be affected, and also make an announcement to the press.

      I know this because I just discovered a similar security hole at a large, private university. The lawyers said they'd be making a press release, but I haven't seen it yet. I'll post again to Slashdot when it comes out.

  65. it should be the other way round by wwwillem · · Score: 1
    I've been myself the victim of an identity theft, so I know what I'm talking about. But I still believe that when people get angry about organisations using SSN's, and they get stolen, the problem is really the other way round. It's not the issue that someone knows my social security number, the problem lies in the fact that shops, companies, organisations, etc. consider the fact that you know your SSN as a proof of identity.

    I don't care whoever knows my SSN, I do care that a cellphone shop gives a subscription to "just someone" because he can provide that number. That's stupid. Those retailers should be more carefull!! Like "Sir, we will look up your telephone number in the phone book and call you back tomorrow lunchtime, to ask you some questions", that kind of stuff. But no, because they want to do business NOW, they give you on the spot a $1000 credit card (like Home Depot or Sears does), just because you can show a driver license (faked in a few minutes) and an SSN.

    An SSN should be an easy identifier, nothing more than that. Like an ISBN number, but then for humans. Who wants to keep ISBN's secret? It's just dumb that the knowledge of an SSN is considered a proof of identity.

    --
    Browsers shouldn't have a back button!! It's all about going forward...
    1. Re:it should be the other way round by epsalon · · Score: 1

      I agree. If I had mod points, I would have mod you up. Having a unique ID is not the problem. The problem is not having a good authentication mechanism, even though such mecanisms are well-known for quite a while. Digital signatures, Zero-Knowledge proofs, anyone? Every person should have a smartcard that can do a ZKP protocol over phone lines.

  66. Come on now... by tommyth · · Score: 1

    Your SSN is everywhere on school records. I work at the Environmental Health and Safety Dept. of the university I attend, and not only does every different dept. in the school have their own copy of students' information, but anyone who has a job at any of these places can get access to it without any alarms going off. This is the case at many institutions. Sure, it's a shame that some outside group got in and away with some info, but I'd be way more concerned with the employees and student employees that play around with your information every day.

  67. FERPA by macdaddy · · Score: 1
    Many students don't realize this but as a student you do not have to give any university your SSN unless you are accepting financial aid from the university. Many universities make this quite clear to their staff on their internal Q&A websites. IIRC the Unv of Illinois was one such university that I found that data on. Also, IIRC, I believe the reasoning behind this can be found in FERPA. I could be mistaken but I believe that's the reason. I know I happened to come across it a couple years ago while doing research on FERPA at least.

    It never ceases to amaze me how many places have my SSN. My insurance company was, up until just this week, using my SSN as my ID number. So did my last regular employer, a state university. So did my employer and educational institutional before that (another state university). If memory serves me correctly my telephone and gas/electric companies required I provide that information as well. Everyone has that information and not a damned one of them have any right to it. It's only their convienent way to identify me from everyone else. The system has been abused for far too long. I would love to see privacy legislation that made it unlawful to require that SSNs be provided except for in those cases where it is actually required such as financial reasons (employer, broker, CPA, etc) or medical reasons (insurance company and doctor but NOT pharmacists). There are probably other legit reasons that aren't popping into my head at the moment. This legislation should also prohibit these entities from abusing the SSN system by basing an individual's ID number on their SSN or some derivative. Both of these items would be required for decent legislation on this matter. Some would suggest the use of a national ID card. I'm rather opposed to that personally, but that's another topic for another discussion.

  68. I used to go there by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    When I was learning solaris administration I was sifting through the nis+ tables in their computer science systems, and along with uid, gid, etc somebody had stuffed in all their ssn's.

    so yeah.

    not to terribly suprising.

  69. Fingerprint reader, any comments? by Linuxathome · · Score: 1

    How about identification via fingerprint with this reader? Anyone used it and are there any good hacks with it?

    1. Re:Fingerprint reader, any comments? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Well, it's made in China, so it's obviously a security risk.

    2. Re:Fingerprint reader, any comments? by Enigma_Man · · Score: 2

      You could hack someone's finger off with a sharp implement, and then get their stuff.

      -Jesse

      --
      Nothing says "unprofessional job" like wrinkles in your duct tape.
  70. Re:A sucker born every second? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Hey, there's a golf arcade game (Links 2003?) that allows players to play tournaments for real prizes over online connections. They ask you for your name and SSN before you can compete.

    If a video game company knew that greed could be that powerful, why not others?

  71. Actually breaking in? by kaitos · · Score: 1

    I know of this guy here at SIUE who was arrested and kicked out of the school for "breaking into the computer system and stealing information." What he did was found an anonymous public FTP, logged in, and poked around. What he found was all of the information for every foreign student that attends SIUE (They have to keep a database because of the patriot act). So what does he do? He informs the computer department (Office of Information Technology) that they really should have this stuff secure and not just open as it is. The next day the feds break into his dorm room and sieze all of his stuff. He was then kicked out of school.

    --
    -kaitos
    1. Re:Actually breaking in? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      An unfortunate lesson--when pointing out security flaws, if you're going to be showing that the people supposed to be taking care of it are incompetent, do so anonymously.

      ~~~

  72. Colleges and Universities need real student ID's! by jjb · · Score: 1
    Colleges and universities need to stop being lazy and actually generate their own unique social security numbers instead of using numbers that wer e supposed to remain secret and only be used for tax and federal benefit programs. This is so simple and yet because of this mistake, this keeps happening. We hear about it twice a year, but it probably happens at least 10 times per year -- organizations don't tell us when they get hacked unless they are required to do so.

    I wrote a chapter in the fictional book Stealing the Network - How to Own a Continent about a college student who steals social security numbers from his college. This is the second public story about universities losing tons of social security numbers because they continue to use them as student IDs since that book was released about 7 months ago. Universities should have stopped doing this so long ago...

    Anyway, read my chapter! The whole book was really good. Ryan Russell and Kevin Mitnick edited it and it features amazingly cooler authors than me, like Nmap's Fyodor, Dan Kaminsky, FX and a number of other amazing people. Read the reviews at Amazon if you don't believe me.

  73. A Blow To Mason's Public Image by mysixstring · · Score: 1

    The University Relations Department has put out an informative FAQ (scroll half-way down) which further explains the nature of the break-in and the current status of the investigation.

    The real impact might not just be from the information accessed. George Mason University has numerous agreements with many contractors in government and defense related fields. As a relatively new school, it has worked to build up prestige and relationships in the area. Many of those enrolled in IT&E programs are actively sought after by the industry and are placed in jobs before they even graduate. Since I am a student in Mason's Information Security program,this is somewhat of a concern, as this incident could potentially effect their recruiting efforts for some time to come.

    1. Re:A Blow To Mason's Public Image by herwin · · Score: 1

      Mason has had an optional alternative to SSN for the student ID number for years. They've also been quite proactive about data protection. The hacking problem has been a concern there since the early 1990s to my knowledge.

      I'd recommend putting a fraud alert on your credit data as a matter of course. I moved to the UK to teach, and within six months I had a computer fraud problem to deal with back in the USA. Apparently somebody noticed I was out of the way and decided to take advantage of it. The police and I were able to track down most of the beneficiaries of the fraudulent credit card accounts, but four years later I still have to deal with knock-on effects. It's better to have a little difficulty opening new accounts and not have to deal with other people doing the same thing.

  74. Simple id code for a person ... by chris_sawtell · · Score: 1
    ... can be made thus:- How about this for a simple hash id generation algorithm?

    echo 'Christopher Sawtell 21:30 15-Feb-1943 St. Pancras, London, England' | md5sum | cut -f1 -d' '
    Which for me gives:
    17f11db57259bdbdf45ed234f1b122ed
    Alternativly there is the sha1sum which gives a few more digits:
    ac8379e71974cca81580d29913d806b0e952f593

    Now then /.ers. Anybody else get the same hashes?
    We want at least a million tests. Don't be shy. This is actually a worth while experiment which doesn't involve totally wrecking some poor sod's web server.

    Post your data and hashes if both are _identical_.

    1. Re:Simple id code for a person ... by Dr_Barnowl · · Score: 1

      On the other hand, there's potentially tremendous variance in the source material.

      My thought was to apply a hash to the SSN before storing it - if everyone uses a different key to generate their hashes, you gain the benefits of using SSN as an identifier.

      - No-one has to record or remember multiple ID numbers
      - Everyone is using a familiar data structure

      Without the disadvantages

      - No-one, including people with direct access to the data, can steal a list of SSNs from the database.
      - Or cross-tie the records to other databases for "Synergistic Market Analysis" (unless they use the same crypto keys as their partners).

  75. Happened to me at Cal Poly SLO (or any CSU) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Anyone go to Cal Poly, San Luis Obispo? Or any California State University? When I registered for college last year at csumentor.com I was asked for my email address. I own a domain so I often give out companyname@mydomain, so I used csumentor@mydomain. Now I am receiving spam sent to that address. I didn't use that address for ANYTHING else, so the spam must have come from someone that was leaked my email from the college application.

    Needless to say, we use SSN for identification purposes everywhere at this school. Doesn't exactly leave me with a sense of security.

  76. I have my doubts... by korupt · · Score: 1

    I would venture to way that this article is severely over-stating the extent of the break-in.... assuming for a moment that the system compromised really did have the 30,000 SSN's removed from it.... by itself JUST the social security numbers represents approximately 264mb of data, if we just include names in this the data size can jump into around a gig, but the e-mail stated that the server contained the "names, photos, social security numbers and G numbers" of the students..... let's just venture to say that the hackers got greedy (an theat they didn't take the time to compromise the database program to spit out a file with just the SSNs) and took the whole thing...... we're talking with pictures easily 20+ gigs of data.... I could understand how a network admin might miss a network teansfer of maybe 100mb... but any transfer over a gig is gonna get noticed well before the routine check that their e-mail sent to students refrences.... In clonclusion... I think they're jumpingthe gun a bit here before they have all the facts in.

    1. Re:I have my doubts... by BitchKapoor · · Score: 1
      the 30,000 SSN's removed from it.... by itself JUST the social security numbers represents approximately 264mb of data


      Hold it there, cowboy -- you're off by a factor of 1024. 30,000*9 = 270,000, which is about 264kB. Allowing 100 bytes per person, we're still only talking about 3MB of data.


      In clonclusion... I think they're jumpingthe gun a bit here before they have all the facts in.


      In conclusion, I think you need to check your math next time.

  77. At least someone had to actively hack the SSNs. by insectibot · · Score: 1

    At my university, students' SSNs were just posted on the web for all the world to see. On more than one occassion. NYTimes article on the original incident; of course, you need to log in. Second incident was a month later. It all kickstarted the move to the non-SSN university IDs, but not before the university paid for credit checks for any affected student who requested it.

    1. Re:At least someone had to actively hack the SSNs. by EmagGeek · · Score: 1

      $ASSUMPTION_THAT_YOU_LIVE_IN_THE_US

      The university didn't have to pay for the credit checks. If you believe you have been a victim of identity theft, you get a report for free from each of the big-three credit bureaus..

  78. What about Viriginia University? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Did they also changed passwords, etc.? A cat of their NIS appeared in the web, see http://ftp.virginia.edu/public_access/toUVA/passwd -nis.virginia.edu (that seems to be where you could upload files). This already happened some days ago, but i wonder if they already did something against this.

  79. back in the day... by maxpublic · · Score: 1

    ...when I was an independent, I did a little consulting for a state university which shall remain nameless on computerizing their class sign-up system and allowing folks to set their course schedule for the term via the university's web site. They used the student's SSN and real name for the entire transaction, transmitted in the clear. I pointed out that this was terribly unsafe and could quite easily be used to steal the identities of every student who used the system, but suffice to say they weren't the least bit interested in hearing about my concerns. In fact, my short-term contract with them was not renewed because they didn't want to deal with the security flaws I pointed out and apparently were displeased that I'd had the gall to highlight said flaws in the first place.

    Not that I cared about the contract; it seemed terribly irresponsible to me to put so many people at risk and deliberately do nothing to reduce that risk despite being told of the danger. But I do wonder if they'd be legally liable for their behavior, especially in light of the fact that I told them flat-out just how dangerous it was and that they needed to change the system to protect their students.

    Max

    --
    My god carries a hammer. Your god died nailed to a tree. Any questions?
  80. Bit more complicated than that by Aexia · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I worked for AT&T Wireless when they were breaking off from AT&T proper. One of things that needed to be done was to replace all of the AT&T employee ID numbers with new AWS employee ID numbers.

    It. Took. For. Ever.

    All sorts of disconnected systems keyed to that AT&T ID # that needed to be updated and changed and the change need to happen in one fell swoop and nothing could fail.

    I'm betting a university setup is even worse.

  81. A little bit of karma... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Before she moved to George Mason, their CIO was the head of my department. After she left we found out we'd run up a six-million-dollar deficit during her tenure. Call me vindictive, but I can't help chuckling about this...though I feel bad for the other 29,999 victims.

    Ironically, our university quit using SSNs for IDs a couple months ago.

  82. Universities are almost always inside jobs... by EmagGeek · · Score: 1

    Universities are not that inept when it comes to setting up firewalls. Second, universities have SO MANY machines that the casual outside hacker isn't going to just stumble upon the id server, or even know how to find it....

    However, universities are INCREDIBLY inept when it comes to hiring cheap student labor to work in the IT department. Broke-ass students have both motive and opportunity to commit ID theft on this wide a scale. ID Theft rings are fairly well-known for approaching student IT workers at schools of affluence like Mason, where the majority of the student body are wealthy and have good credit.

  83. Privacy Act of 1974 by spockman · · Score: 2, Informative

    Read the Privacy Act of 1974, a quick Google will find it for you. We had to use it in the Military and it basically required you to give permission and sign a form that stated what the organization was going to do with your SSAN, covered a lot of different area's.

  84. Free credit report? by LanMan04 · · Score: 1

    Does this mean that if I call one of these credit bureaus and put a fraud report on my credit file (even though I'm not a GMA student or anything), I can get a free credit report? And that they call me before they increase my rates? Sounds like a plan...

    --
    With the first link, the chain is forged.
    1. Re:Free credit report? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      By the end of this year you will be able to get a free credit report (once a year) anyway. They're phasing it in, so this doesn't apply to all states yet, but will by year-end.

  85. The military needs to do the same thing by DaFork · · Score: 1

    You ever hear the phrase "Name, Rank, and Serial Number"?

    In the US Military, the serial number part is your SSN. This always pissed me off becausse when I was in the service, you couldn't write a check anywhere in a military town without writing your SSN on it.

    It seems that once your in the military, your SSN becomes public knowledge.

  86. Too little too late... by musicscene · · Score: 1


    The fact that *any* orginazation is in the practice of using your SSN as an identifier is B as in B, S as in S.

    Universities are notorious for giving away the farm on their students identity... there was not much I could do about it except refuse and only try to use my last four, but that made some admin angry because you would make them think.

    We all know this, but finally some organizations are begining to see the light... our SSN is not for identification.

    --
    "I'm not ashamed I can't function in society like I'm supposed to." - Paul Westerberg
  87. Penn State just completed change from SSN by trifster · · Score: 1

    Read more here:

    NEW PSU IDS IN EFFECT; SSN CONVERSION EXCEEDS EXPECTATIONS
    After nearly two years of extensive preparation and coordination,
    Penn State successfully completed its conversion of all centralized
    systems and many departmental systems to the new Penn State
    identification (PSU ID) during the winter break. The conversion of
    central Administrative Information Systems such as IBIS, ISIS, the
    Data Warehouse and eLion began on Dec. 19 and finished earlier than
    expected, with these systems being brought back online by midday Dec.
    22. The new PSU ID numbers assigned to students, faculty and staff
    now are in effect and are being used in place of the Social Security
    number (SSN) as the University's primary identifier. This number will
    be used in all internal processes that do not require SSNs for
    reporting and taxation purposes. SSNs still are being collected, but
    their use is strictly limited by new University policy. New steps
    have been added to many business processes for the assignment and use
    of PSU IDs. Penn State staff can find important information
    describing these new processes at
    http://ais.its.psu.edu/ssn/staff_spec.html on the Web. With the
    conversion of card-reading systems completed, including those
    operated by Housing and Food Services, the Library and Police
    Services, the new Penn State id+ cards are in use University-wide.
    Read the full story at http://live.psu.edu/story/9602

  88. What ever happened... by Paul8069 · · Score: 1

    To kids just hacking school computers to change their grades?

    --
    Paul
  89. What can you? by Lestat_79 · · Score: 1

    Maybe a stupid question, but as a non-american, what can someone do if they steal your SSN?

    Here in Belgium we have pasports which also has a number on it, but I don't see how they can use that against me.
    I've never been asked for an ID except for police or a bank.
    So what's the gain then.

    Sorry for being ignorant here...

  90. State ID's by the_rev_matt · · Score: 1

    Um, many states use your SS# for your driver's license and/or state issued ID card. Only recently has Missouri allowed you to use an alternate number...

    --
    this is getting old and so are you

    blog

  91. Happened at NYU last year by buktotruth · · Score: 1

    ...this is somewhat old news. Last year someone broke into NYU's gym computer (yes, I know)...and stole something like 10,000 student ssn numbers. This year, NYU has switched to non-ssn id numbers for students. Way to be reactionary and not proactive guys. PS. my ssn was stolen in this incident and I'm still in control of all my banking functions. People need to relax a little bit about this one.

  92. keeping your SSN private by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Since this types of incidents happens quite frequently our university does not ask students for their social security numbers anymore. This has been proven an important step in the right direction and we hope other colleges and universities will follow. For now, you should simply refuse to give your social security number to any school if you do not want it to get stolen. Schools do not have the right to require the social security numbers of their students but are supposed to use other types of identifiers e.g. sequential enrollment numbers.

  93. auto accident, health insurance by peter303 · · Score: 1

    Though I dont give out my SSN, most of my heath providers seem to have it and use it as an identifier anyways. I see it appear on my dentist records, the hordes of people involved in my recent auto accident, etc.

    Law say that only organizations that collect taxes can use the number. This includes your employer, the government tax and benefit departments, including the DMV tax on cars. SSN for driver licenses is technically not legal, nor for security clearances, private health programs, student IDs, etc.. But they all push for it.

  94. googling your SSN by peter303 · · Score: 1

    Actually try just a 8 digit subset of it so that strangers dont see the whole thing. When aquaintances have tried this, about half of them have seen their SSN listed on some websites. Scary!

    1. Re:googling your SSN by sd.patricia · · Score: 1

      Luckily, mine didn't show up. But it definately is overused as an identifier.

  95. They dont even use WEP by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The deserve what they got. The Manassas, Virginia campus doesn't even use WEP on any of their 20+ wireless access points.

  96. SSN is overused by Charlie+Monoxide · · Score: 1

    I'm a displaced Canadian living in the states. I'm absolutely amazed at the constant demand for my SSN. If you get a phone or any utilities, you must provide an SSN. Heck, I rented a washer/dryer at an apartment in Dallas and they wanted my SSN. Amazingly they forget the file folder with my credit history after they installed the washer/dryer (a few days before I moved in). Needless to say I now have a copy of my credit report (excellent, I must say). In Canada, since the mid 90's it has been illegal to use an SSN (called SIN, social insurance number, in Canada) for anything other than employment and income related, uaually banking (for interest reporting). Even within the various government agencies, an effort has been made to create a new identifying key that is NOT your SSN. Fucking utilities and every Tom Dick and Harry wants your SSN because it makes there keys and system identifiers easier for them. Screw you, the consumer, if some disgruntled employee or poorly implemented system allows some hacker access to your name, birthday, and SSN. Once your identity is stolen it is now your problem. Charlie (boo hoo on you) Monoxide

  97. ssn at med insurance by sd.patricia · · Score: 1

    My medical insurance (United Healthcare) just last year switched from listing ssn on id cards to some other kind if number. Although ssn is still used, at least if you lose your wallet, they can't find your ssn on the cards (unless you carry your ss card).

  98. social security numbers by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Once Bush gets rid of Social Security we won't have to worry about that anymore!