Slashdot Mirror


Do You Want Best Buy Opening Your New Laptop?

An anonymous reader writes "I went to Best Buy the other day to get a new laptop for a client. I didn't realize till I got it home that they had broken the seal and opened the box. They put a sticker on the box that said, 'Inspected by Best Buy.' I found they had created the user profile, recovery disks, and installed a trial of Trend Antivirus. Seems to me this is more of a marketing agenda than inspection."

543 comments

  1. Why.... by SpaceCadetTrav · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Would you buy from Best Buy?

    1. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      Apparently some people do not live near a MicroCenter or Fry's. Go figure!

      dom

    2. Re:Why.... by Sponge+Bath · · Score: 5, Funny

      Because they have the best prices on Monster cables and extended warranties.

    3. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes, but people live within mailing distance of newegg. Unless you need the laptop TODAY, why buy from Best Buy when there is Newegg? Or hell, Amazon?

    4. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why do I buy from Best Buy? My work gives out "Recognition Awards". I actually manage to get them fairly often. They are $50 a pop and one of the things you can get is a Best Buy gift card. I save them up and then use them about $300 at a time on stuff (like a TV, etc.). I don't shop there with "my" money and wouldn't buy a computer there.

    5. Re:Why.... by Registered+Coward+v2 · · Score: 1

      Because BB matched Apple's edu price, included a $100 GC, and gave me nearly $60 in Reward Zone rewards; and I got a brand new unopened MBP. Sure, I normally use Amazon or NewEgg but sometimes BB's prices are less or I'm buying a gift that would be a pain to return to Amazon if they already have/get at the same time the game or DVD.

      Plus, it's fun to listen to the salespersons talk to customers. I never realized they needed to install anti-virus software on the Mac and optimize a OSX because there are two Mac viruses "in the wild."; or that a cropped sensor dSLR made a 200mm lens into a 280mm lens.

      --
      I'm a consultant - I convert gibberish into cash-flow.
    6. Re:Why.... by hedwards · · Score: 0

      Actually, extended warranties are a good deal. Back before they were so evil I did buy a laptop from them and got every cent's worth out of my warranty. As have the other folks I've known that have gotten them.

      The main thing is that after a few repairs they might suggest that it was always that way. Don't let them talk you down, if it is a covered repair and it is broken, then insist on them fixing it.

    7. Re:Why.... by Mephistophocles · · Score: 1

      Heard that. I'd rather put a drill bit through my skull. Slowly. Best Buy embodies all that's evil in the mediocre tech world.

      --
      Deja Moo: The distinct feeling that you've heard this bull before.
    8. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I don't think you understand the idea of "a good deal". For a warranty to be profitable it has to be an inherently bad deal. That is the likelihood that you'll break a laptop times the cost of a new laptop has to be less than the cost of the new warranty for the average purchaser of said warranty. Trust me by definition of being a viable business it's a bad deal.

      The only argument you can make for one is if the price of a laptop is large enough to cause undue stress on your bank account or you wouldn't actually be able to replace one in a reasonable amount of time and therefore would lose more money not having one. If that were the case then perhaps it is a good deal for you.

    9. Re:Why.... by kehren77 · · Score: 1

      And if you do buy a computer from Best Buy, why wouldn't you wipe it and start with a clean system as soon as you got it home/to the office?

    10. Re:Why.... by erroneus · · Score: 1

      Only buy business warranties. If you want to be treated like a consumer, then buy consumer models and consumer agreements. You will get what you paid for. But if you want to be respected, but "business class" machines and get business class agreements. It's that simple.

    11. Re:Why.... by codeAlDente · · Score: 2

      You probably needed your extended warranty because Best Buy opened your new laptop.

      --
      He once inserted random mutations into his code, just so he could have the experience of debugging.
    12. Re:Why.... by ddd0004 · · Score: 2

      I always go for the rust-proofing too. Those Coleco's will rust up on you.

    13. Re:Why.... by MBGMorden · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Your first paragraph described why insurance policies must be a bad deal because they'e good for businesess.

      Your second paragraph then described that they can still be a good deal if you happen to need an insurance policy?

      Isn't that the business model of every frickin thing in the world? Somebody sells something at a profit because other people need it enough to satisfy that profit for the product they need?

      --
      "People who think they know everything are very annoying to those of us who do."-Mark Twain
    14. Re:Why.... by Tharsman · · Score: 2

      In my experience, I love buying from BestBuy. I have seen situations where the computers are opened with the mentioned seals, at least in the cases I have gone through, it tends to happen with very cheap, horrible quality machines that are returned way too often. Don't work there to know for sure, but if I was manager I'd tell my employees to go through all of them and make sure they are in working order before they leave the store.

      That aside, BestBuy has some darn good service (again, in my experience, there is only ONE BestBuy I actively avoid as it seems to only employ retarded idiots that rather spend 1 hour talking and keep you waiting than bringing you the 1500 computer you said you WILL buy...) *ghem* sorry, derail... but anyways other than one isolated store, they have always given me great service. I had them even change me a computer once even if it was a few days out of warranty, something I had trouble doing even inside warranty windows with the rightfully defunct CompUSA and Circuit City.

      Their return policy is great, they ask almost no questions and I can even just say "because it was a piece of crap" and they will take it back! Sure, I do pay a bit of a premium there, sure they try to sell me their "decrapification" services to uninstall bloatware, but its not that hard to say "no thank you, I'll do it myself." Sure, I can get cheaper stuff online (I always get my pc build parts online) but try to return stuff because its functional but crap anywhere else.

      And thats just with hardware! If i want games, I know I can go there, grab a new copy (that they carry in plenty amounts) and pay for it and walk out, unlike famous game dedicated chains that try to push up my rear used versions of games that came out yesterday and seem to carry barely enough copies to cover pre-orders. They are also always spacious, organized and clean. In the last years, BestBuy has become THE Brick Geek Shop for all my geeky needs.

    15. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The margins on extended warranties at a local electronics shop I used to work for were huge, ranging from 250% and up. Unless you buy a product with a known life span, the expected cost of repair multiplied by the probability of repair (expected price of contract) is always much lower.

      Extended warranty contracts are popular because people tend to forget their unclaimed contracts and remember their little successes. We are irrational and biased when it comes to risk.

    16. Re:Why.... by MBGMorden · · Score: 1

      Ironically, your reason for shopping at Best Buy is the same reason I occasionally eat at Applebees. Every time they give out some award at work they throw in a $25 Applebees gift certificate.

      Oh well - their burgers are better than fast food, even if the rest of the menu is pretty blah.

      --
      "People who think they know everything are very annoying to those of us who do."-Mark Twain
    17. Re:Why.... by MBGMorden · · Score: 1

      Most computers these days don't come with installation discs - they come with restore disks (or more commonly now - a software program on the system to generate them). Unless you plan on buying an OS separately, there is no clean install available.

      --
      "People who think they know everything are very annoying to those of us who do."-Mark Twain
    18. Re:Why.... by djdanlib · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Indeed. Business class laptops are better built.

      Okay. I am not employed by a computer manufacturer or distributor, so you know. I don't even really like the brand I'm about to talk about. I'll probably catch flak for using this particular brand as an example, but it's pretty common that people consider it when buying a PC.

      Take for example the Dell Vostro, the "home user" aka consumer grade model. Then look at the Dell Latitude. They can be ordered with similar specs, but the Latitude costs a lot more for the same specs. Why? Well, besides the obvious "because a business will pay more" factor, they have sturdier mounting hardware that holds everything in place inside the chassis. That means when you carry it around every day, it won't fall apart as fast. It WILL fall apart eventually - that's always been my experience with laptops in general - but the Latitude will reliably outlast the consumer class Vostro by a great amount. Then again, you've still got a Dell.

      When you call the company for support on an enterprise class laptop, you'll have a different number to call, with a different length queue, and different agents to talk to. Even the website you visit is different. They have to maintain a specific level of service or businesses wouldn't do business with them, so you get in on that if you spend enough money on the computer.

      So you're absolutely right. It makes a difference.

    19. Re:Why.... by AngryDeuce · · Score: 1

      We CompUSA employees used to love the hell out of extended warranties back in the day, because they only cost us pennies on the dollar at cost, and pretty much nothing had to be verified as broken outside of the store. Since it was left to manager discretion whether or not to replace or repair the item, it was pretty much like getting to roll over your electronics every year or two. I bought a $300 17" LCD monitor when I started there and by the time they went out of business had rolled that over into a 24" widescreen that was 10 times better in every respect...all it cost was another $10 or whatever on the new extended warranty. Pretty much everybody did similar with everything like DVD players, game consoles, printers, digital cameras, PDA's...

      I don't know how Best Buy is, but given the fact that CompUSA folded and Best Buy didn't, I'd bet they aren't as lenient, especially with employees. As a regular customer, though, I know how much of a pain they can make it when it comes time to make good on that warranty, because CompUSA did as well, and like you said, you pretty much have to argue and fight. If you make enough noise, they will do almost anything to shut you up and get you out the door. If not, call their district office and complain...believe me, once their regional or district people get involved they will fall all over themselves trying to help you and get your ticket satisfied.

    20. Re:Why.... by Relayman · · Score: 2

      I tried to buy a "business class" laptop at the Apple Store and they had no idea what I was talking about...

      --
      If I used a sig over again, would anyone notice?
    21. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      There is a reason why sales staff in many retail outlets are pressurized to do a hard-sell on extended warranties - it's because the loss ratios on the policies are very low and the profit and sales commission is enormous. Given razor-thin margins on many commoditized consumer goods, the profit on the extended warranty may well be significantly greater than the profit on the item itself. There is no price competition because there is no open transparent market in extended warranties - if you buy the insurance, it will be from (or at any rate sold by) the same store as the insured product and there is no shopping-around.

      Insurance companies are not charities - they are profit making enterprises. On average, it is always going to be more expensive to pay someone else to accept a risk than to accept it yourself. It still makes sense to insure if the insured-against outcome is unmanageable. For example, in the unlikely event that your house burns down most people would not have the financial resources to buy new stuff and find a new place to live. However many people can manage the financial consequences of an unpredictable failure of a TV or washing machine. It makes more sense to 'self-insure' in this case. Over your life-time there will be some irritating losses but on average you are likely to save money.

    22. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Apparently some people do not live near a MicroCenter or Fry's. Go figure!

      What are you talking about? They have Fry's from San Francisco to San Jose! How many other places can there possibly BE?

    23. Re:Why.... by dorianh49 · · Score: 1

      Vostros are still better built than Inspirons, Dell's true consumer line. Vostros are more of a "prosumer" or "home/business" class laptop. I bought one for my wife that is still going very strong almost 3 years after purchasing it. Nothing is loose or falling apart. Meanwhile, friends and associates who bought Inspirons (I warned them) are experiencing build-quality issues right and left. But, buy a Dell Latitude, or Lenovo Thinkpad T-series, or HP Elitebook, or Panasonic Toughbook if you want a laptop to last.

      --
      Gravity is a contributing factor in nearly 73 percent of all accidents involving falling objects. -Dave Barry
    24. Re:Why.... by AngryDeuce · · Score: 1

      And if you do buy a computer from Best Buy, why wouldn't you wipe it and start with a clean system as soon as you got it home/to the office?

      The people buying the laptop at Best Buy in the first place, more often than not, are not savvy enough to do a full OS reinstall. There are obviously exceptions, but after selling computers for years at CompUSA, it's a pretty good assumption in my observations.

    25. Re:Why.... by Wrath0fb0b · · Score: 2

      That means when you carry it around every day, it won't fall apart as fast. It WILL fall apart eventually - that's always been my experience with laptops in general - but the Latitude will reliably outlast the consumer class Vostro by a great amount.

      Yes, but with the savings from the Vostro you can buy a new mid-range laptop when the current one breaks for the same per-time costs rather than being stuck with a well-built but dated machine for long enough to justify it's increased purchase price. Given how fast computer hardware accelerates, it makes more sense to replace often rather than sinking lots of money into a fast-depreciating asset. In 2 years, a $1000 laptop will be outspecced by entry level models at $500, so buying one of those twice as often (actually the current-dollars cost of a $500 laptop in 2 years is $470) makes tons more sense in a dollar/performance sense than buying the $1k model and holding on to it for 4 years.

      Of course, for the average consumer breakage means a trip to newegg or amazon and a few days waiting for a new device while a suit on a business trip to kerbleckistan has different needs.

    26. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Disclaimer: I was a Radio Shack employee 16 years ago LOL

      I loved Extended Warranties....because I took a 15% cut right off the top as a commission.

      For you, the consumer...meh.

      Now, granted, at least here in Canada, there are some companies starting to treat the Extended Warranty somewhat back to the customer's favor...

      I just bought a new recliner couch. The manufacturer offered an extended warranty on it for an extra hundred bucks...and I've seen so many recliner couches with a failed reclining mechanism that I bought it.

      The thing is, this particular retailer will credit the warranty back to you if it goes un-used. Now, of course, this is "store credit", so the store still gets their money in the end...but at least now I have an additional 5 years of protection on my merchandise, and if I never need to use it, I can go use that $100 for another purpose.

      Don't get me wrong, it is still hardcore in the store's advantage that I bought the warranty...but at least I get some value out of the warranty even if I never need it. I hope more retailers will catch on, but I doubt it...the extended warranties are all but pure profit for the retailer, and when does any retailer give up profit?

    27. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I tried to buy a "business class" laptop at the Apple Store and they had no idea what I was talking about...

      That is such a broad definition I don't know what you mean either. Are talking about a lightweight laptop that has Office, a browser, and solitare for senior executives, or a fire-breathing 8 pound monster for pounding code with three of every type of port? Or was it in reference to support / maintenance / warranty? It sounds like you went to the wrong store and asked the wrong question.

    28. Re:Why.... by Coren22 · · Score: 1

      That is because Apple doesn't realize that businesses use computers yet.

      --
      APK likes to ask for responses to the same things over and over. Maybe he just likes the responses?
    29. Re:Why.... by Coren22 · · Score: 1

      I am wondering if anyone has bought the HP Envy laptops yet and what their impression of the build quality is. By all appearances it was HP's attempt to capture the audience of people who like the Apple hardware, but hate Mac OS. If they are well constructed, I may consider buying one as my next laptop.

      --
      APK likes to ask for responses to the same things over and over. Maybe he just likes the responses?
    30. Re:Why.... by pkinetics · · Score: 2

      If you have to buy locally, find your nearest Costco. Much better return policy!

    31. Re:Why.... by PNutts · · Score: 1

      I used to go to Chotchkie's but the waitress flipped me off.

    32. Re:Why.... by Vegemeister · · Score: 1

      As far as I know, OEM PCs should have a valid SLIC baked into the bios. You should be able to download a torrent of the install disk, verify the hash against MSDN, and install a clean system. You'd probably have to use the same version of Winders that came preinstalled.

    33. Re:Why.... by spazdor · · Score: 1

      I'm Canadian, you insensitive clawed!

      --
      DRM: Terminator crops for your mind!
    34. Re:Why.... by jazman_777 · · Score: 1

      But there's also a cost in moving all your stuff over to the new machine and getting the new one just the way you like it.

      --
      Slashdot: Failed Car Analogies. Amateur Lawyering. Anecdote Battles.
    35. Re:Why.... by Rinikusu · · Score: 1

      Where else you gonna go to get hands on on a large variety of laptops? I'd rather not go by reviews alone, sometimes you just gotta go handle the damn thing.

      --
      If you were me, you'd be good lookin'. - six string samurai
    36. Re:Why.... by tedgyz · · Score: 1

      LOL! I had a Best Buy salesdroid tell me that my old cables go bad and I should buy new ones for my home theater. I neglected to tell them my knowledge of electronics because it would be a waste of valuable oxygen. I simply walked away. I avoid Best Buy like the plague.

      --
      "No matter where you go, there you are." -- Buckaroo Banzai
    37. Re:Why.... by UnknownSoldier · · Score: 1

      Because most people don't realize there are options compared to Worst Buy such as NewEgg, bluejeanscable, visualapex, bhphotovideo, etc.

    38. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Absolutely 100% about business warranties being different. One of my friends and I both have the same computer and our serial numbers are a few numbers apart. However, I got mine through an EPP and she just ordered online without using the code. She and I both had the exact same problems. To fix the first one, she was pointed to look through the forums to find what to change; I was e-mailed a .reg file to make the same change. To fix the second one, they sent her a new power charger for the shipping costs both ways on UPS ground; I was sent one for free with no shipping costs overnight. To fix the third one, she had to send in her laptop to be serviced wait a week and then have it shipped back paying for the shipping costs (after arguing with them that the repair itself was even covered); I had someone show up at my desk and replace the part for free (plus, I found out, if he couldn't fix it then he was going to shove my HDD into a new one). After all, its only worth jerking around joe shmoe.

    39. Re:Why.... by djdanlib · · Score: 1

      Okay, okay. Uncle! I give!

      Yes, the Vostro is a SOHO model. The Inspiron is the consumer model.

    40. Re:Why.... by TwilightXaos · · Score: 1

      There are at least 2 reasons why this might be an option:

      It almost goes without saying on this site, but one could install a free operating system.

      One could be replacing a laptop that had a OS bought separately. As long as the former laptop is unusable or wiped it is perfectly legal to transfer the OS to the new laptop. This could be done for several laptops, especially if one is not interested in upgrading to the latest and greatest version of a payed for OS.

      As a legally questionable bonus: If your laptop came with a license key for Windows 7, you could download an ISO here: (NB: the amazon links seem to be dead, but the DR links seem to work)
      http://goo.gl/EmxXQ

    41. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You worked at Radio Shack 16 years ago, putting you at least at 30 years old, and you use "LOL" as a punctuation? I shudder to think about your career path *since* leaving Radio Shack.

    42. Re:Why.... by rhook · · Score: 1

      Then use the Canadian Newegg site or NCIX.

      http://www.newegg.ca/
      http://ncix.com/

    43. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That is because only quiche eating businesses use apples

    44. Re:Why.... by rhook · · Score: 1

      Most of the warranty returns happen while the unit is still covered by the manufacturers warranty. Best Buy simply ships it in for you.

    45. Re:Why.... by Walt+Dismal · · Score: 1

      Why buy from a store that opens my purchase and messes with it? For the same reason I keep getting hamburgers at a place that lifts the top bun, spits on the burger, and drops the bun back. Because I hate myself, and like to live dangerously, and have more money than sense, and probably vote for Sarah Palin. Also, I watch Jackass.

    46. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Because they apparently have the good sense to do for you what the mass manufacturers have stopped doing: performing a final QC check of the product. They've figured out it costs them more to do that then to just ship it and have the customer find out if it's a DOA. It costs less to just ship you another to replace it.

    47. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Perhaps you should have tipped her more before she got to the flipping you off part.

      :|3

    48. Re:Why.... by Wrath0fb0b · · Score: 1

      But there's also a cost in moving all your stuff over to the new machine and getting the new one just the way you like it.

      It's a shame there are no tools that could copy the entire state a computer into some sort of "image" that could then be written to another computer!

      Let me guess, you aren't already making routine backup images of your computers and just waiting for a hard drive head to crush your stuff?

    49. Re:Why.... by Ameryll · · Score: 1

      Because when I purchased a laptop 3 years ago they were one of the few big box stores that offered an accidental damage warranty. And sure enough, when my tablet (real tablet PC, not one of those new fangled iPad excuses for a tablet) got hit by a frisbee and it cracked my monitor case, they replaced the whole damned monitor without any hassle.

      Also, while it's annoying that they install stuff on the laptop, actually burning the recovery disks for end users is nice. I know many of the people I play tech support for don't bother until it's too late (ie the computer's fried). If only the manufacturers still shipped the stupid CDs.

    50. Re:Why.... by rhook · · Score: 1

      And you still paid too much for that MBP.

    51. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      As a policy Best Buy does not price match any Apple products.

    52. Re:Why.... by Chris+Mattern · · Score: 4, Funny

      The preceding post was brought to you courtesy of Best Buy.

    53. Re:Why.... by thedbp · · Score: 0

      No, Apple missed that boat, they KNOW they missed that boat, they don't want to GET on that boat, and it's because they're killing the PC and replacing it with the iPad (which businesses are eating up).

      As soon as iOS5 removes the need for a PC, expect the iPad to accelerate it's genocide of the "normal" computer we're all used to.

    54. Re:Why.... by rhook · · Score: 1

      In my experience, I love buying from BestBuy. I have seen situations where the computers are opened with the mentioned seals, at least in the cases I have gone through, it tends to happen with very cheap, horrible quality machines that are returned way too often. Don't work there to know for sure, but if I was manager I'd tell my employees to go through all of them and make sure they are in working order before they leave the store.

      Nope, they open them so that they can have their "Geek Squad" optimize the machine, they then add the fee for that service onto the invoice. They do this so that they do not have to upsell the service to their customers, it's already included.

    55. Re:Why.... by spazdor · · Score: 1

      Actually, I live literally across the street from an NCIX outlet. Hardware purchases aren't too inconvenient for me.

      --
      DRM: Terminator crops for your mind!
    56. Re:Why.... by the_B0fh · · Score: 1

      You do realize that the business class laptops usually have a better class of GPUs and the cheap consumer shit don't, right? The cheap shit is almost always the Intel integrated crap.

    57. Re:Why.... by F34nor · · Score: 1

      $299 Lenovo AMD Fusion in 15.6 body. They asked me if I wanted to pay for this "service." I told them to fuck themselves. I swore I would never darken their door after they once basically refused to sell me something without my zip code.

    58. Re:Why.... by tagno25 · · Score: 1

      My Inspiron 1501 is still working, of course I have opened it to clean the heat-sink, replaced the HDD, added RAM, and replaced the wireless card.

    59. Re:Why.... by Registered+Coward+v2 · · Score: 1

      And you still paid too much for that MBP.

      Considering no one had it cheaper it worked out reasonably well.

      --
      I'm a consultant - I convert gibberish into cash-flow.
    60. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually, extended warranties are a good deal.

      Not really, depending where you live. In Quebec there is an expectation that your product will function a length of time proportionate to the amount paid for the product, which essentially means that your extended warranty will cost you a quarter of the price of the product, and will only kick in at the point where your product is not really gonna die if it hasn't died yet. They're a complete rip off here.

    61. Re:Why.... by hairyfeet · · Score: 2

      And thus brilliance was spoken. Hell one could close the thread right there. You can't even try units at Worst buy before buying online since they are 90% of the time "house brand" crapola made specifically for WB with the cheapest shit China has to offer.

      And Lord help you if you have someone stupid enough to take it to Geek Squad. I used to work at a shop down the street from a Worst Buy where OUR ENTIRE BUSINESS was nothing but fixing the fuckups by Geek Squad "agents". We used to call them the Greek Squad because one way or another they were gonna fuck you. i've seen RAM stick literally ripped off by ripping them out of the slot, I've seen a $300 GPU magically turned into a $45 GPU, a 400gb HDD turn into a 40Gb, and I hope you didn't have any nekkid pics of your GF because they helped themselves to anything and everything. One of the guys I knew that worked there had a 300gb USB drive with a batch file that looked for .jpg, .mp3, .avi, etc. That is why you always heard about CP busts with worst buy, because he before they started working on the thing they were looking for porn to snatch!

      Frankly I wouldn't buy a power cord from worst buy, out of the 20 or so WBs I've had to deal with there was exactly ONE I found that was decent, with knowledgeable guys that tried to give you a fair deal. When my nephew had to have a laptop for school ASAP they sat down and worked with him and gave him a good deal. Went back there 3 months later and they had fired the staff (my guess to save a buck) and replaced them with MickeyDs quality help. I wouldn't take WB junk on a bet.

      --
      ACs don't waste your time replying, your posts are never seen by me.
    62. Re:Why.... by znerk · · Score: 1

      I don't think you understand the idea of "a good deal". For a warranty to be profitable it has to be an inherently bad deal. That is the likelihood that you'll break a laptop times the cost of a new laptop has to be less than the cost of the new warranty for the average purchaser of said warranty. Trust me by definition of being a viable business it's a bad deal.

      ... you must buy some really crappy laptops.

      I spent $1200 on a "home entertainment" laptop (dual-core 2.8, 9600M, 6GB RAM, 500GB HDD, DVD-RW, and a 19 inch screen) nearly 3 years ago. Bought the 3-year "black tie protection" plan. Just brought it in for what I call a "not quite EOL" refurbishing... thus giving my 3-year-old laptop a new lease on life, and bringing it back to nearly-new condition.

      Admittedly, the brand-new laptops are better and cheaper than mine was, although not by much in either category (I count screen size as highly important)... but I feel like I'm essentially getting a brand-new $600 laptop, when that machine would otherwise have been just about ready for recycling.

      The cost for my "brand new $600 laptop"? $300, nearly 3 years ago.

      As an aside, NOT getting the "accidental damage" coverage on a portable device is absolutely retarded... when I purchased that laptop, I asked, "what happens if I'm driving down the interstate on my motorcycle, and my laptop jumps out of my backpack and scatters itself across 4 lanes of traffic?"
      The answer: "If you have the accidental damage protection, then bring in as many pieces as you can, and we'll replace it at no charge."

      Peace of mind is worth the $300 I spent on the protection plan...

      Final note: I spent $300, 3 years ago; instead of having to spend $1000 or more on a shiny new laptop this year, I get to fix all the issues with the old one for free. Sounds to me like I saved about $700.

      --
      This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.
    63. Re:Why.... by Attila+Dimedici · · Score: 1

      Of course, your friend will probably never buy from them again. At least that would be my response to that sort of warranty coverage. Of course, if I had three separate problems with a laptop within the warranty period, I probably wouldn't be buying from that vendor again, no matter how well the warranty service treated me.

      --
      The truth is that all men having power ought to be mistrusted. James Madison
    64. Re:Why.... by AK+Marc · · Score: 2

      I used to shop at the first CompUSA, and had a friend who worked for them in their second store, back when they only had two stores. They weren't like that with the customers. My friend mentioned all the things he got away with. But as a customer, trying a few (at the other store, so as to not get him in any trouble), they all failed. They failed because they "borrowed" from future growth to pay for capital expendatures, and when they didn't grow as fast as they needed, they ran out of money and folded. Circuit Shitty and others failed as well for different reasons. Best Buy won because in the fight to the bottom, they did it right (loss leaders that actually drew in people that bought higher margin items, people buying Monster Cables, etc.).

    65. Re:Why.... by Attila+Dimedici · · Score: 1

      Buying the extended warranty is betting that you bought a bad product. If you think it is a bad product, why don't you buy something else.

      --
      The truth is that all men having power ought to be mistrusted. James Madison
    66. Re:Why.... by sconeu · · Score: 1

      How many pieces of flair did she have?

      --
      General Relativity: Space-time tells matter where to go; Matter tells space-time what shape to be.
    67. Re:Why.... by vikisonline · · Score: 1

      Why not just lie to them then. Its not hard to come up with a fake zip code.

    68. Re:Why.... by kheldan · · Score: 1

      I wouldn't. Not something like a laptop. Regardless of where I bought it, I would INSIST on it being in a box that had not been opened since it left the factory, and I sure as hell wouldn't want Best Buy monkeys screwing around with it before I got it. Which, considering the stories I hear about Best Buy and things like laptops, I would get no end of grief from them for insisting on this, therefore I would never go there in the first place, and I wouldn't send anybody I know there either.

      --
      Are YOU using the TOOL, or is the TOOL using YOU? Think about it!
    69. Re:Why.... by bell.colin · · Score: 1

      It's even easier with servers fire up support.dell.com fill out the service tag and put in the problem description "Front panel says drive 4 is dead, send me a another one"

      1-4 hours later a new drive shows up at the front desk with a courier from Dallas wanting a signature.

      Place drive in old box and sit on loading dock.

      No questions asked and it's done, always pay extra for business/enterprise support (NBD,4hr, or 2hr (on-site/do it yourself)) it's well worth it.

    70. Re:Why.... by AK+Marc · · Score: 1

      or that a cropped sensor dSLR made a 200mm lens into a 280mm lens.

      Depending on the subtopic, that's correct. The dSLR will have the field of view of a 320mm lens, even if it still has the physical magnification of a 200 mm lens. Note that you will print both on the same size print, so to an untrained eye at a glance, they will not notice a difference between a 200mm lens on a dSLR and a 320mm lens on a 35mm camera (either regular or full-size sensor dSLR).

      So I'm not sure how that's an example of their silliness. Sure, that topic is highly debated among prosumer photographers (those with the dSLR arguing with those who had enough money for a full-size sensor and both being insecure about their choices), but for those who don't care? They *are* the same...

    71. Re:Why.... by interkin3tic · · Score: 1

      Look, it's right in the name: BEST buy. It's the best place to buy from. You're suggesting they didn't EARN that title? How dare you sir? How dare you?

    72. Re:Why.... by Jibekn · · Score: 1

      Yeah, because images work awesome when moving between hardware, especially from 3 year old hardware, and I wont get into OS differences. Profile redirection and network storage is the key, along with a setup script that handles office and all the other standard crap your org needs. At least that's how we do it, a new laptop is as easy as join the domain and reboot, tomorrow we hand it to the user after the GPO and scripts do their thing.

    73. Re:Why.... by mabhatter654 · · Score: 0

      My experience is that I've had white MacBooks for 4 years now. they have held up on par with the HP Business laptops my work buys... A little worse for wear because my kids were like 8-10 when I got them. One had to go in for water damage (kids) but it's been rocking every day for 1.5 years after being repaired.

      I'd put All the Macs at "Business Class" easily...

    74. Re:Why.... by mabhatter654 · · Score: 1

      Time Machine rocks when you need to upgrade or replace...

    75. Re:Why.... by Macrat · · Score: 1

      Best Buy embodies all that's evil in the mediocre tech world.

      I guess you have never been to Fry's Electronics.

    76. Re:Why.... by jdpars · · Score: 1

      I'm Canadian, you insensitive Claud!

      FTFY

    77. Re:Why.... by MagusSlurpy · · Score: 1

      What did the "refurbishing" do for you that you couldn't do yourself? I imagine it involved taking it apart, blowing out the dust, and reformatting, but that is all simply done at home for most people reading this site.

      And personally, I decided it was worth saving $300 to just double-check to make sure my backpack is zipped every time I get on my Nighthawk. Some people are less careful and/or clumsier than others and are actually justified in buying accidental protection plans, but some of us are OCD and are anally protective of our belongings (I had a g/f who went through phones about every six months, losing them, dropping them in the toilet, driving over them, etc.). In twelve years, I'm on my third cell-phone and third laptop, and that's only due to not enough power, not because of any damage. Hell, I just bought a new battery for my seven year old original Nintendo DS, because it still works just fine, excepting the 2 hours of gameplay per charge.

      --
      My sister opened a computer store in Hawaii. She sells C shells by the seashore.
    78. Re:Why.... by mabhatter654 · · Score: 1

      An Apple Store

    79. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Does that cute little OS from Apple multitask yet?

      Until it can do real multitasking it doesn't stand a chance in the business world. Oh, and I can see our secretary typing 100+ words a minute on a virtual keyboard. Yeah.

      At work we're not even that computer intensive, but we still use a laptop with a mapping application on half the screen and a spreadsheet open on the other half of the screen.

    80. Re:Why.... by BulletMagnet · · Score: 1

      What you failed to mention is this:

      Dell's Consumer brand line - including the Vostro - has all their support outsourced. The Lattitude, Optiplex, Precision, and PowerEdge support queues are based in Tampa, FL (if I recall)

      Call me shallow, but I get really tired of trying to listen to what you and I know isn't your first language trying to walk through a problem that I already know is well over your head but I need to placate you for 20 minutes before you will transfer me to someone who may or may not know a little (or lot) more then you do.... and maybe might be in my lingustic zip code as an added bonus.

      We looked at switching to HP business class hardware (so glad that didn't happen) but I was incensed to find out that their CAD/BIM class machines had outsourced support, and their business class laptops were 'currently' sourced in India however HP was setting up a US based call center. For a 5K workstation - good riddance HP.

    81. Re:Why.... by WorBlux · · Score: 1

      And you can usually buy third-party warranties at 30-40% of the cost. Personal article coverage can also cover computers, (pro-rated, but still not horrible) in addion to other things under one policy

    82. Re:Why.... by WorBlux · · Score: 1

      Furniture often or usually has a huge markup (100-400%)

    83. Re:Why.... by BulletMagnet · · Score: 1

      That means when you carry it around every day, it won't fall apart as fast. It WILL fall apart eventually - that's always been my experience with laptops in general - but the Latitude will reliably outlast the consumer class Vostro by a great amount.

      Yes, but with the savings from the Vostro you can buy a new mid-range laptop when the current one breaks for the same per-time costs rather than being stuck with a well-built but dated machine for long enough to justify it's increased purchase price. Given how fast computer hardware accelerates, it makes more sense to replace often rather than sinking lots of money into a fast-depreciating asset. In 2 years, a $1000 laptop will be outspecced by entry level models at $500, so buying one of those twice as often (actually the current-dollars cost of a $500 laptop in 2 years is $470) makes tons more sense in a dollar/performance sense than buying the $1k model and holding on to it for 4 years.

      Of course, for the average consumer breakage means a trip to newegg or amazon and a few days waiting for a new device while a suit on a business trip to kerbleckistan has different needs.

      You failed business economics.

      When you're on a 36-48 month depreciation schedule, the idea is they last that long. When you're a 15 year old kid, you need the $499.00 BoxPusher 100 - that you will replace in 18-24 months with another throwaway piece of shit.

    84. Re:Why.... by kelemvor4 · · Score: 1

      when I purchased that laptop, I asked, "what happens if I'm driving down the interstate on my motorcycle, and my laptop jumps out of my backpack and scatters itself across 4 lanes of traffic?" The answer: "If you have the accidental damage protection, then bring in as many pieces as you can, and we'll replace it at no charge."

      Peace of mind is worth the $300 I spent on the protection plan...

      Final note: I spent $300, 3 years ago; instead of having to spend $1000 or more on a shiny new laptop this year, I get to fix all the issues with the old one for free. Sounds to me like I saved about $700.

      Hopefully the contract spelled that out as well. I'm an extended warranty kind of guy myself, and I got boned on an onsite protection plan I bought with a rear projection t.v. from best buy in 2003. I still buy extended warranties for stuff, but I read the paperwork first and I don't shop at best buy anymore.

    85. Re:Why.... by Altrag · · Score: 1

      Memory Express is my favorite, though I've shopped both Newegg and NCIX (and a few others) as well.

      Amazon often has some decent deals as well.

    86. Re:Why.... by pokerdad · · Score: 1

      Sure its possible to get your money's worth out of a warranty; its also possible to get your money's worth out of lottery tickets. But both lottery tickets and extended warranties are only sold because the seller makes money on them, and this is only possible because collectively consumers lose money on them. Car and house insurance make sense because most people can't afford to replace those if they are lost. Most people can afford to replace a computer, meaning that the extended warranty isn't so much insurance as it is paying in advance for a service you might never use.

    87. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "Best" Buy?

      Can't someone sue them for falsely advertising their service as something it isn't?

    88. Re:Why.... by Renraku · · Score: 1

      Absolutely all of that goes out the window when the store refuses to cover the damage because all the plan covers is strictly outlined in the plan itself and isn't based one tiny bit on what they tell you in person unless you've got it recorded with approval from the person telling it to you.

      I had a laptop and bought a total protection plan to go with it. Three months after the original warranty ended, the power unit in the laptop failed and fried the motherboard, as well as everything connected to it. Best Buy refused to cover the damage citing that it was the manufacturer's fault, and the manufacturer placed blame on a batch of bad parts from a subcontracted company, which they were not responsible for, see, it says right there in their warranty.

      Upon further examination, the total protection plan didn't cover a lot of things. Sure, it covered accidental damage as long as it didn't involve water or liquids, and it covered failure due to wear, but it didn't cover defects in the equipment. I since learned that with these plans, if you want something fixed, you just have to find a way within the bounds of the plan to destroy it if it ever breaks.

      --
      Job? I don't have time to get a job! Who will sit around and bitch about being broke and unemployed then?
    89. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually in my experience this is the difference between a mid-to-high end business machine and a mid-to-high end consumer one that can possibly make consumer buys worth it: the consumer one is MUCH more likely to have graphics suitable for gaming. Otherwise you absolutely want to go for the business-class laptop.

    90. Re:Why.... by tompaulco · · Score: 1

      Because he doesn't have a laptop?

      --
      If you are not allowed to question your government then the government has answered your question.
    91. Re:Why.... by DarwinSurvivor · · Score: 1

      The only reason insurance (house, etc) is a good idea is because the cost of NOT having it if something goes wrong will most likely ruin you. Most people will NEVER get their money back on their house insurance, but if there WERE a fire, I highly doubt even 5% of the population would be able to buy a new one without ending up in the poor house. Laptops rarely fall into the category of "I will be ruined if this breaks".

    92. Re:Why.... by tompaulco · · Score: 1

      Grandfather is exactly right. On the average insurance policies are a bad deal for the consumer because you have to pay one average what they would have to pay plus their profit.
      This is only a "Good deal" if it will prevent you from breaking the bank on a particularly catastrophic problem.
      When it comes to laptops, you would have to be extremely unlucky to have a number of them break in your lifetime such that it would be better for you to have bought the warranty.
      Cell phone warranties are even worse. You pay 8 dollars a month and if you break or lose your phone they give you a refurbished one for only the cost of the deductible (about $90-$100), which happens to be about the same as the cost of buying a brand new phone on ebay. And then, if you break it again, you are out of luck, because they only cover one claim a year. This is an asinine policy considering that with your deductible, they are making money on the deal even if they gave you a new phone every day.
      Medical insurance is still the same way. You are paying out exactly what on average you would pay in plus their profit. The additional factor that makes medical insurance worthwhile is that the insurance company has contracts with the providers. If you go to the doctor you would pay $100. But if you have insurance, you pay a deductible of $20 and the insurance company pays maybe $50 and then your premium ends up being $70 to cover their cost plus profit. So you end up paying less overall, while still paying a profit to the insurance company. These numbers are all hypothetical and for illustration, but the principal is true.

      --
      If you are not allowed to question your government then the government has answered your question.
    93. Re:Why.... by Registered+Coward+v2 · · Score: 1

      or that a cropped sensor dSLR made a 200mm lens into a 280mm lens.

      Depending on the subtopic, that's correct. The dSLR will have the field of view of a 320mm lens, even if it still has the physical magnification of a 200 mm lens. Note that you will print both on the same size print, so to an untrained eye at a glance, they will not notice a difference between a 200mm lens on a dSLR and a 320mm lens on a 35mm camera (either regular or full-size sensor dSLR).

      While I agree with you - it is a FOV equivalence; when I've heard them explain it they make it sound as if the resolution is magically increased. It's not entirely there fault as most consumers think of lens length in terms of magnification, not FOV, and BB (nor many other shops, for that manner) doesn't really explain the difference. They never really explain what the smaller sensor does is essentially crop the picture, so you blow it up to get the equivalent size print as a full frame, losing some detail in the process; instead they leave the impression that the 10 - 200 zoom their pushing is the same as the 300 prime that costs more than the body and lens.

      or that a cropped sensor dSLR made a 200mm lens into a 280mm lens.

      So I'm not sure how that's an example of their silliness. Sure, that topic is highly debated among prosumer photographers (those with the dSLR arguing with those who had enough money for a full-size sensor and both being insecure about their choices), but for those who don't care? They *are* the same...

      Yea, there are plenty of measurebators on photo forums who make the /. crowd look like amateurs when it comes to arguing. To me, the silliness is they are pushing a misconception, often without realizing it, though some seem convinced it really turns the glass into something else. It's not that they are bad or evil; it's just they really don't understand the product they are selling and simply will say whatever it takes to make a sale. The marketing push to convince people that more mega pixels is better has added to the problem, IMHO, by pushing people to spend more on a body then the glass they hang on it. At least BB hasn't yet come out with Rocketfish SLR lens. Unfortunately, the local camera store, that had actual photographers as sales people, who tried to match camera with what a person planned to shoot, is a dying breed.

      --
      I'm a consultant - I convert gibberish into cash-flow.
    94. Re:Why.... by tompaulco · · Score: 1

      Extended warranty plans cover as little as possible. They want to make money on it, not pay for service problems. They are counting on the fact that you will either sell the laptop, break it during the manufacturers warranty, or buy a new one and forget about the old one in that time period.
      It is in your best interest to insure yourself on a purchase as cheap as a laptop, especially a $300 one.

      --
      If you are not allowed to question your government then the government has answered your question.
    95. Re:Why.... by Belial6 · · Score: 1

      I'm not a fan of Apple, but only someone in with their head in the sand doesn't know that there are real live keyboards for the iPad. You see, it has this thing call bluetooth. You don't even need a special keyboard. Just a bluetooth keyboard.

    96. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Does that cute little OS from Apple multitask yet?

      Yep.

    97. Re:Why.... by Ihmhi · · Score: 1

      I love Microcenter, and my friend on the West Coast speaks equally highly of Fry's.

      Microcenter's prices are good, their staff is knowledgeable, and their store is a goddamned candy store for tech geeks. How many stores have store-branded flash drives as an impulse purchase?

      The thing I love most, though, is their "computer buffet" dealy they have going (at least at my local Microcenter in NJ). They have prices listed up on a chalkboard above the center counter, and you can get a computer assembled piece by piece and built right there for minimal cost (or you could, of course, take the parts home and do it yourself).

      I went there with a family friend who needed a copy of Windows 7. "Wheres your cheapest version of retail Windows 7?" He dropped what he was doing, showed us, and didn't try to upsell us in any fashion.

      Microcenter has a customer for life here, and if you have one in your area you should check them out.

    98. Re:Why.... by tompaulco · · Score: 2

      That's why I only buy Fresh brand milk. and 100% Beef brand tofu dogs.

      --
      If you are not allowed to question your government then the government has answered your question.
    99. Re:Why.... by The+Dawn+Of+Time · · Score: 1

      Are we supposed to find your lack of vision compelling?

    100. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Is that the Micro Center where the guy checking your receipt when you leave looks like his diet for the past 25 years has consisted only of steroids? I'm a big guy and that guy's arms are bigger than my waist.

    101. Re:Why.... by nomadic · · Score: 2

      How about before multitasking it allows file management. Anyone who thinks it's not phenomenally stupid that the ipad won't let you actually work with files on it is so drunk on apple kool-aid that they're incapable of being reasoned with.

    102. Re:Why.... by mikael · · Score: 1

      I know the pain. But it can be mitigated by using external USB drives and the 'dd' command, which allows an entire file system to be stored as an image file and then restored or even mounted temporarily.

      For Linux, you should have separate partitions for kernels, configuration files, applications, projects, and user accounts. That way, you only need to upgrade a few partitions (kernels, applications and configuration files).

      For me, the best way to upgrading to a new Linux OS, is to install the new OS on an external hard disk drive, then make sure every existing package is matched by its most recent replacement. Then swap the two disk drives. If there is any problems with drivers I can go back to the old OS. Then copy over all user/project files.

      Being able to swap drives, allows for a free "code-freeze" backup copy to be made.

      --
      Vintage computer adverts: http://www.vintageadbrowser.com/computers-and-software-ads
    103. Re:Why.... by Clockwinder · · Score: 0

      Once they started selling ASUS products I became a "little bit" interested in Best Buy; however, ASUS computers come from the factory with enough crapware to begin with. I don't need my new computer molested by a geeksquad and have even more crap added to it. Not to mention, it technically isn't new anymore, is it?

      I buy all my ASUS laptops from newegg, and will continue to do so.

    104. Re:Why.... by AK+Marc · · Score: 1

      If the consumer doesn't understand and doesn't want to understand, why is it BB's job to educate them? If they did, they'd lose a sale (people like talking to BB and feeling smarter after, rather than dumber that they need some high school student or dropout to explain a camera to them). So I'm with BB on this.

      I was never a fan of the traditional camera shop. "what are you going to shoot?" "Whatever strikes my fancy, that's why I want the telescopic zoom with lots of artifacts. It'll at least let me frame the shot I want without taking 30 lbs of equipment with me every time I take a walk." Then I get the "evil eye" and condescending questions and stupid upsell "you really need the UV filter for your indoor portrait shots."

    105. Re:Why.... by Thundercat007 · · Score: 1

      This shouldn't happen, unless you purchased their set up package, or it was returned by someone else. They then "inspect it" which consists of them wiping the hard drive back to factory settings. Then placing a sticker on it saying "inspected by BestBuy". They threw in the recovery disks because someone forgot to take them out.

    106. Re:Why.... by Restil · · Score: 1

      Insurance is a protection against statistics, same as warranties are. If you purchase 1000 laptops, a certain percentage of those ARE going to break. However, Unless you purchase a particularly crappy brand, the cost to replace the percentage that breaks will not exceed (or probably even get close to) the cost of having an extended warranty on all of them. Although you probably don't want to purchase laptops in bulk, you can consider the same costs over the purchase of all of your
      electronic devices, and consider that at least one of them will probably break, but not most of them. If the 52" TV breaks, that will hit you harder than if your ipod breaks, but ultimately it's still a wash in the long run.

      Even house insurance is unnecessary (and not worth it), if you own a sufficiently large number of houses. Say you're a landlord and you own 100 houses, each worth $100k. Chances are good that at least one or two of them are going to be catastrophically damaged over the course of a 30 year period, but if you add up how much you're going to pay in insurance over that timeframe, it's a lot cheaper to just replace the house and pay for the damages yourself. Car insurance is a bit of a middle ground. If the car is old, you don't likely purchase comprehensive coverage on it, since you're never going to get its true value back. But you still have to purchase liability insurance. HOWEVER... if you know you're a safe driver and the chances of you being at fault in an accident are slim to none, there
      are options available to post your own insurance bond for the amount of the required liability coverage, and therefore not be required to purchase auto insurance.

      -Restil

      --
      Play with my webcams and lights here
    107. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Have you noticed it's always "for a client". No one will admit to going there for themselves.

    108. Re:Why.... by Registered+Coward+v2 · · Score: 1

      If the consumer doesn't understand and doesn't want to understand, why is it BB's job to educate them? If they did, they'd lose a sale (people like talking to BB and feeling smarter after, rather than dumber that they need some high school student or dropout to explain a camera to them). So I'm with BB on this.

      Maybe because they *claim* to have knowledge and are *helping* them when all they are doing is feeding them a line of BS? Consumers want to have someone help them fill their needs. Unfortunately most stores don't have a clue how to do that; unless it's run by Apple or Nordstrom. The "Geek Squad" is little more than a salesperson in a funny outfit. On a lark, I had them do an estimate and "home configuration" on a home theater system. (it was free but they normally charge $99) The result was a long list of the most expensive items in the store. When I asked any questions about layout, etc was "monster is the best there is. You need it and Geek Squad protection." they didn't even bother to layout the system or make recommendations on placement. I pity the poor schmuck who thinks they are doing anything but printing a bill of materials. I don't want to feel smarter than they are, but I would like at least some semblance of thought put into an estimate.

      I was never a fan of the traditional camera shop. "what are you going to shoot?" "Whatever strikes my fancy, that's why I want the telescopic zoom with lots of artifacts. It'll at least let me frame the shot I want without taking 30 lbs of equipment with me every time I take a walk." Then I get the "evil eye" and condescending questions and stupid upsell "you really need the UV filter for your indoor portrait shots."

      Oddly, I've never had that experience. BB, on the OTOH, always seems to have a reason to buy a cheap UV filter and added protection (cause that's where they make their money). OTOH, they do pice match Fry's, Microcenter and Apple, saving a trip across town.

      --
      I'm a consultant - I convert gibberish into cash-flow.
    109. Re:Why.... by Mike_EE_U_of_I · · Score: 1

      Yeah, a buddy of mine used to always buy the Best Buy extended warranty. The one time he actually needed to use it, he had to bring the laptop in five times to have the same issue fixed (three is supposed to trigger the lemon policy and get you a new unit). Best Buy argued that, since Best Buy was too stupid to actually fix the issue, none of the attempts to fix the laptop actually counted. My friend spent at least ten hours at Best Buy arguing, and at least 20 hours on the phone with me complaining about them. After six months without his laptop, Best Buy finally honored their lemon policy and gave him a new laptop.

          JFC! I will happily avoid all of this insanity by not buying the extended warranty.

    110. Re:Why.... by Mike_EE_U_of_I · · Score: 1

      You wrote "That means when you carry it around every day, it won't fall apart as fast. It WILL fall apart eventually - that's always been my experience with laptops in general"

          Yeah, mine too, until my family started buying Macbooks. Maybe we are just lucky, but the only one we had flake out was one my wife spilled a glass of hot tea on the keyboard (and it even worked well for 18 months after that!).

         

    111. Re:Why.... by cynyr · · Score: 1

      I have a love hate relationship with microcenter. If I was building baige boxes, or even moderate [[full] || [mid]] tower rigs it would be great. or not looking for anything to out of the ordinary.

      Things i have been unsuccessful at finding at microcenter:

      1) a 6"-12" power cord with an IEC C13 conector on one end and a normal 3pin on the other. I ended up buying a 3 foot one and hacking the middle out of it.
      2) a 6"-9" sata cable. These are hard to find just about anywhere though.
      3) mini-itx anything; cases, motherboards, SFF PSUs, slimline optical drives. hardish to find but newegg and amazon both carry a small amount.
      4) mini/micro-HDMI to DVI cable. Yes i could have used adaptors, but i thought it was silly to use 2-3 bits just to hook up my monitor.
      5) Round Sata cables of any length.

      Things that have gone very well, I'm now 4 laptops into my local store. All good no upselling, pushing or anything. Mention chrome and microsoft security essentials or linux and they just get the box for you.

      So overall good, if what you are looking for is fairly mainstream.

      --
      All of the above was encrypted with a Quad ROT-13 method. Unauthorized decryption is in violation of the DMCA.
    112. Re:Why.... by toddestan · · Score: 1

      Depends on what you buy. If you go for a gaming laptop, you can easily find a fast GPU in a laptop that is otherwise cheap consumer shit quality.

    113. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not only was it three problems, but we both had IDENTICAL problems happen at approximately the same time.

    114. Re:Why.... by AK+Marc · · Score: 1

      Maybe because they *claim* to have knowledge and are *helping* them when all they are doing is feeding them a line of BS?

      The vast majority of "advice" on slashdot is over simplification to the point of bordering on incorrect. Given the lack of complaints about that type of "advice" a minor inconsequential error about lenses that experts make in order to have customers feel better about their purchase seems normal. I've worked as a car salesman. I quit becuse the management encouraged lying, even when telling the truth would move a car, and the other salesmen were happily ignorant. At least BB is trying in this case and isn't far off of what is technically accurate (even if arguably so).

    115. Re:Why.... by coinreturn · · Score: 1

      The great thing about Fry's is that you can tell which products suck shit. There will be fifty boxes with bright labels on them assuring you that they have been fully inspected by Fry's employees and work great like the unopened boxes!

    116. Re:Why.... by Max+Littlemore · · Score: 1

      Not having Best Buy locally I can't say for sure but if TFA is anything to go by, I would buy there because I get an installation of Windows without having to agree to the EULA.

      If I must have windows, I would prefer to have it without a EULA.

      --
      I don't therefore I'm not.
    117. Re:Why.... by DigiShaman · · Score: 1

      It gets better. These ex-Geek Squad employees are now working in the corporate IT sector. They're *KILLING* my occupational credibility as an MSP consultant / sysadmin. Fuckers! They're riding our coattails only to be dragging the entire industry down with them. They shouldn't be answering phone calls in Tier 1 support let alone be allowed to be near someone else's computer.

      --
      Life is not for the lazy.
    118. Re:Why.... by Aryden · · Score: 1

      check these guys out http://www.firefold.com/ I've been buying cables from them for a while now and you just can't beat what they have and the price. I have a very love/hate relationship with microcenter as well. I worked there and it was pretty bad. But I don't go anywhere else anymore to get upgrades, accessories etc for my rigs. I do NOT go to the store I worked in, but their other location here makes that one look like a radio shack.

    119. Re:Why.... by Aryden · · Score: 1

      BestBuy isn't winning by a long shot. They've closed down so many stores here due to Walmart kicking the shit out of them on prices, never having what you want in stock and complete retards working in the store. My aunt, uncle and I went to the nearest one to their house to get them set up with Clear wifi. Even with me standing over them and telling the salesman to fuck off, they still got charged 3 times and that was after 30 minutes of them trying to figure out how to even ring it up in the first place. This was 2 months ago, not when Clear first came out fyi...

    120. Re:Why.... by hairyfeet · · Score: 2

      Oh Dear Lord no! Say it ain't so! Geek Squad running corporate IT? WTF? Hell they couldn't install a fucking floppy correctly! I got done with one of their "fixes" just last week, the poor lady was like "Why did I take it in to get fixed and it is SLOWER than it was to begin with?

      I ended up having to show her where the label on the front of her PC listed it as having 1Gb of RAM and now suddenly? 512Mb. Somebody got himself a free RAM upgrade at her expense. Sadly as I posted that is par for the course, I see quite a few "five finger discounts" coming from machines that have been in the clutches of WB. She called and had a fit and got basically told by management unless she had pictures of before and after she was SOL. I told her she was just lucky they didn't rip the retainers out as they have been known to do.

      I have seen parts stolen, parts put in backwards, hell I even saw a HDD that was obviously hammered in since they didn't know how to release the drive cage! That don't count the hot software I've seen put on (rampant) and of course them helping themselves to all pics, tunes, and videos. Frankly I wouldn't trust those clowns to shine my shoes, much less actually fix anything!

      I know this will sound like a plug for myself but it really isn't, just some sound advice. you need work done or a family member needs work done, a new desktop, etc and you don't have the time to DIY? take it to a mom&pop shop. it won't take long at all to ask around and most of us actually take PRIDE in our work. We charge reasonable rates and will be happy to tell you if a machine is worth sinking money into or not, hell I've saved three folks this month the cost of new builds by pointing out I could upgrade their CPU+RAM for a hell of a lot cheaper.

      Those Worst buy guys give EVERYONE in computers a bad name.That is why they have to advertise so much, to lure in new suckers. Me? i haven't even had business cards in nearly 2 years because I'm completely booked up just from word of mouth. If you do a good job you don't NEED to advertise, word gets around quickly enough.

      --
      ACs don't waste your time replying, your posts are never seen by me.
    121. Re:Why.... by arth1 · · Score: 1

      the principal is true.

      Yeah, it's the dean you can't trust.

    122. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You ought to take another look at "one of those new fangled iPad excuses for a tablet." Unlike a "real tablet PC", they tend not to break if they happen to get hit by a flimsy round plastic disk.

    123. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      As soon as iOS5 removes the need for a PC, expect the iPad to accelerate it's genocide of the "normal" computer we're all used to.

      You have got to be fucking kidding me. People don't really believe this bullshit, do they?

    124. Re:Why.... by dadioflex · · Score: 1

      I am wondering if anyone has bought the HP Envy laptops yet and what their impression of the build quality is. By all appearances it was HP's attempt to capture the audience of people who like the Apple hardware, but hate Mac OS. If they are well constructed, I may consider buying one as my next laptop.

      I never have mod points when I need them. That was pretty funny on at LEAST two levels. Nicely done, but apparently too subtle for most.

    125. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Cropped sensor camera with crop factor 1.4 WILL "make" 200mm lens into a 280mm lens. It will be as if you used 280mm lens on 35mm film camera. It's obviously good to visit Best Buy now and then to learn new things.

    126. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No, it seems to be the opposite. Business users have no need for gaming graphics so usually business laptops have the intel garbage. Also the screen options are more limited on business laptops. Just look at Dell Latitude -- even if you pick the largest size screen, the screen resolution is universally 1366x768, which is completely unacceptable in any laptop larger than a 10" netbook. There is NO option ANYWHERE to upgrade the screen to something decent. Same with HP business class. At least Lenovo has some Thinkpad models with 1600x900, or for $200 (!) extra you can get 1920x1080. Consumer lines generally offer better screens, but the options are still slim. For the most part, custom builders like Powernotebooks.com sell the best laptops and actually allow CUSTOMIZATION, which Dell and the other big manufacturers have given up, for the most part.

    127. Re:Why.... by Meski · · Score: 1

      I empathise with your desire not to have cords slopping around, but if you're going to hack some out of the middle and join, it's probably going to be easier, and safer, to buy cable, plug, socket, and make it exactly the length you want (and probably use side entry plugs and sockets)

    128. Re:Why.... by ESD · · Score: 1

      Having bought a house last year, I can say that (at least over here) the insurance for the house is primarily for the bank providing your mortgage loan and not for you. The insured value of your house is there to pay back your loan if you can't do that anymore (and chances are you can't if it burns down because you have to pay for rebuilding it), so the bank demands that it's insured it so that it can be rebuilt if it's damaged beyond repair, protecting their investment. Actually the insurance or loan contracts probably prohibit you from doing anything other than rebuilding your house with the insurance money.

      The same goes for the life insurance you are required to have when you take a mortgage loan. (Technically, it's not a mortgage. It's a loan backed by a mortgage -> you get the money in exchange for giving the bank information and/or decision rights (the mortgage) when you use or sell the property. The bank doesn't own your house, but you do give them the right to sell it if you can't pay off the loan; they aren't fond of doing that though, because having to sell it is a huge cost and possibly risk to them too.)

    129. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Most people will NEVER get their money back on their house insurance

      HAW. If there WERE a fire, most people won't even get the company to pay out a fraction of what they've been paid.

      I've fought tooth and nail to try and cut down my homeowner's insurance but down here by the bay there aren't that many choices, so when the agent insists that they can't sell me a policy for less than $200k (home's appraised at $140k, and currently failing to sell for even less than that), what can I do? If the place burns down, I'm sure they'll refuse to pay out a penny more than the actual value plus whatever I can prove with receipts (unless I can prove too much, then suddenly it's not covered because I needed to pay extra for a rider for my "vintage" dvd "collection" and "professional" electronics).

      But hey, it's the insurance company's job not to pay you.

    130. Re:Why.... by arkhan_jg · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Perhaps you should have asked for their macbook PRO line.

      --
      Remember kids, it's all fun and games until someone commits wholesale galactic genocide.
    131. Re:Why.... by MrMatto · · Score: 2

      In my experience, I love buying from BestBuy. I have seen situations where the computers are opened with the mentioned seals, at least in the cases I have gone through, it tends to happen with very cheap, horrible quality machines that are returned way too often. Don't work there to know for sure, but if I was manager I'd tell my employees to go through all of them and make sure they are in working order before they leave the store.

      Nope, they open them so that they can have their "Geek Squad" optimize the machine, they then add the fee for that service onto the invoice. They do this so that they do not have to upsell the service to their customers, it's already included.

      I used to work at Circuit City and they would do exactly that. I had customers that wanted a specific model laptop and the only one available was "pre-optimized". They charged an extra $75.00 for the tech to open the box, go through the initial setup prompts and uninstall maybe one or two things. The customers came in looking for a laptop advertised at a specific price and it was my job to tell them that they would have to pay an additional $75.00 on top of that price because all we had left was the "optimized" version.

    132. Re:Why.... by adolf · · Score: 1

      It doesn't matter.

      What, exactly, are you expecting from laptop support that cannot be surmised as "This widget is broken. Please deliver a new widget."

      Whether I'm talking to a Mexican with poor English skills in Tampa, or a native Indian with excellent British in Bangalore, the result is the same: "The widget is broken. Please send another."

      Why? Because if the laptop is suffering from something systemic other than an incidentally-broken appendage, "support" (no matter the nationality) isn't going to help. You need an engineer. And that engineer's nationality and language skillset are going to be wholly different from whatever continent it is that "support" happens to camp out on this week.

      So why do you think it makes a difference?

      (This comment obviously written for a technically-adept Slashdot crowd. It does not apply to luddites.)

    133. Re:Why.... by AmiMoJo · · Score: 1

      They /do/ have the best prices on some items, e.g. a Samsung USB monitor/photo frame I picked up for around £60 was £120 in John Lewis and £105 online. When it comes to boxed goods there is little reason to avoid places like Best Buy and PC World, other than the minor annoyance of having to refuse the extended warranties and gold plated USB cables.

      If I discovered the box had been opened I would have returned it immediately.

      --
      const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)
      SJW, n: "Someone I don't like, and by the way I'm a fuckwit" - AC
    134. Re:Why.... by AmiMoJo · · Score: 1

      Extended warranties and insurance are never ever worth it for the consumer. If you want insurance get house contents insurance. It covers all your stuff and is cheaper and easier to claim on than multiple random store bought policies.

      As for warranties don't forget that in the EU all electrical goods come with a minimum 2 year warranty by law. On top of that in the UK the Sale of Goods Act applies which gives you protection up to five or six years on most electricals. The specific clause is that goods "must last a reasonable length of time", which for computers is generally take to mean six years. If your PC fails after the initial 2 year warranty period you are still entitled to compensation based on how long you have had it, so if you are in year 3 of 6 you would get 50% of the price back.

      --
      const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)
      SJW, n: "Someone I don't like, and by the way I'm a fuckwit" - AC
    135. Re:Why.... by Neil+Boekend · · Score: 1

      I do not want to replace a laptop often. Each time you replace it you smack the environment in the face (the cost of building those things is quite huge. Ad to that the damage if you simply throw it away in the trash (which you should never do in any developed country, except for the USA)). Now I don't mind doing that a couple of times, but I try to minimize it. An old laptop is good enough for a lot of things.
      Laptops you buy now will be good enough to browse, listen to music and edit some documents for years to come. Now if you wish to game on the laptop that's a different story, but I do not.

      --
      Well, I might have a way, but it only works on a semi spherical planet in a vacuum.
    136. Re:Why.... by AmiMoJo · · Score: 1

      While I agree with the general point that business laptops are better made (I had a Thinkpad X32 and now a Dynabook) they are still prone to manufacturing defects like the HP/nVidia chipset fiasco. The short version is that nVidia laptop chipsets had a nasty habit of expanding and contracting with heat until the solder joints failed and the laptop died. For years HP was using nVidia chipsets almost exclusively so pretty much every laptop they made during that period would fail around the 1 year mark. In the case of warranty replacements they would just install another fucked motherboard and hope it lasted beyond the 2 year warranty period.

      The moral of this story is don't buy anything too new or too high end. If you want something reliable get an Acer or Lenovo with an older Intel or AMD chipset rather than a cutting edge one because generally speaking the kinks have been worked out of them and any major problems with show up when you google them. Desktops are not dissimilar IME.

      --
      const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)
      SJW, n: "Someone I don't like, and by the way I'm a fuckwit" - AC
    137. Re:Why.... by nosferatu1001 · · Score: 1

      Systemic issue, refund please

      At least thats the UK law on the subject, not sure if its teh same in the US - I suspect not.

    138. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Why are you modded insightful, that has nothing to do with the actual question being asked. Same goes for all you turkeys replying underneath about where to buy from. Answer the fucking question!

    139. Re:Why.... by thesh0ck · · Score: 0

      Best buy does this.. when they ask you if you want the full protection plan that you pay for. They make recovery disks for you etc... this person *PAID* for this service. They are just to stupid to realize it.

    140. Re:Why.... by ESD · · Score: 1

      The insured value of your house is there to pay back your loan if you can't do that anymore

      Skip that piece, I mistyped and forgot to correct. (The insurance is there to rebuild the house as I said after that, not to pay off your loan. I got confused with the life insurance, which does have that function.)

    141. Re:Why.... by Zorpheus · · Score: 1

      I prefer to buy used business class laptops. They can be much cheaper than new consumer class laptops, and still outlast them.
      I don't need computing power on a laptop, so I don't see a reason to go for a new one. If I really need computing power, I have my desktop. But that does not really happen anymore.

    142. Re:Why.... by Methuseus · · Score: 1

      Better price for same/similar specs? That's what I did. Couldn't find anything near the price on Newegg.

      --
      Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity, though I'm not yet sure about the universe. - A Einstein
    143. Re:Why.... by iainl · · Score: 1

      Well, quite. The crop factor on Canon DSLRs is 1.6, so a 200mm would be equivalent to 320mm on a Full Frame.

      --
      "I Know You Are But What Am I?"
    144. Re:Why.... by Methuseus · · Score: 1

      So are many business class laptops, including many Latitudes.

      --
      Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity, though I'm not yet sure about the universe. - A Einstein
    145. Re:Why.... by mystran · · Score: 2

      But it can be mitigated by using external USB drives and the 'dd' command, which allows an entire file system to be stored as an image file and then restored or even mounted temporarily.

      No need to use 'dd' as you can just take a tar-ball of one filesystem. That way you don't waste space on storing (and more importantly moving) the garbage in unallocated space. There's nothing special about any of it, except whatever the bootloader (ie. grub hopefully) requires. You can use some Live ISO (usually the same one you used to copy the data over) to chroot into the system once the data is copied over and tell grub to reinstall itself (update-grub). The only other tweak required is patching new UUIDs to /etc/fstab (or you can give the old UUID to mkfs too I guess, though this could cause problems if you try to connect both drives at the same time).

      --
      Software should be free as in speech, but if we also get some free beer, all the better.
    146. Re:Why.... by eharvill · · Score: 1

      Microcenter has a customer for life here, and if you have one in your area you should check them out.

      I bought my first PC (clone) there back in 1991 or 92. I basically picked out a system and was able to customize to my hearts content (RAM, HDD, CD-ROM, video card, etc). That being said, I haven't been there in a few years as there is not one convenient to where I live now. I'll swing by Fry's for the occasional impulse buy, but NewEgg gets the majority of my purchases and recommendations to friends.

      --
      At night I drink myself to sleep and pretend I don't care that you're not here with me
    147. Re:Why.... by jones_supa · · Score: 1

      And 100% PITA...

    148. Re:Why.... by Wow8agger · · Score: 1

      You are absolutely right - also, there is typically less bloatware installed by the manufacturer that you need to fight through for the system to be usable.

      My advice to my non-technical friends and family is "Don't buy a PC without a Touchpoint"

      -matt

    149. Re:Why.... by Bob+the+Super+Hamste · · Score: 2

      Not all ex-Geek Squad employees would be bad, but you would have to find one of the original employees back from the mid 90's when they were an independent repair shop. The Best Buy Geek Squad is raiding on the coat tails of those original employees who actually did quailty work at a reasonable price. An example of the original Geek Squad work was when I had a laptop (a couple year old dell latitude with a reasonably fast 75mhz 486dx4 and 36 MB of ram and an aftermarket hard drive with a whopping 2.1GB storage) that had a couple of bad solder connections in screen that they fixed. At the time it cost me something like $20 to $30 to fix which was reasonable for a college student. I doubt today that Geek Squad would even attempt that repair let alone be able to get it done for less than $200.

      --
      Time to offend someone
    150. Re:Why.... by black+soap · · Score: 1

      I usually give them their own zip code. Sometimes I gave radio shack their own store address. The employees didn't seem to care.

    151. Re:Why.... by Registered+Coward+v2 · · Score: 1

      Maybe because they *claim* to have knowledge and are *helping* them when all they are doing is feeding them a line of BS?

      The vast majority of "advice" on slashdot is over simplification to the point of bordering on incorrect. Given the lack of complaints about that type of "advice" a minor inconsequential error about lenses that experts make in order to have customers feel better about their purchase seems normal. I've worked as a car salesman. I quit becuse the management encouraged lying, even when telling the truth would move a car, and the other salesmen were happily ignorant. At least BB is trying in this case and isn't far off of what is technically accurate (even if arguably so).

      I think we're in pretty much agreement here, about /. advice, BB, and car sales tactics. I don't think BB sales people are lying, just that they really haven't been trained to understand products they are selling so they either oversimplfy or make wrong statements as a result.

      Selling product protection (which is a separate issue), however, borders on car sales tactics. I hear statements (not just at BB) such as "If it breaks you get a new one and if we don't sell it you get a better one" all the time; and that statement does not correctly or accurately represent the T&Cs in the policies. If the sales people don't know that they should; but the need to sell this policies is what is driving their actions.

      As for technically accurate, it's a bit like saying putting smaller diameter tires on a car will make it similar to a fast car because you can now peg the speedometer. Yes, that is technically accurate - you now can peg the speedometer on both cars but you aren't going the same speed; but very misleading because of what people think a speedometer or lens length represents.

      --
      I'm a consultant - I convert gibberish into cash-flow.
    152. Re:Why.... by omnichad · · Score: 2

      I do evening and weekend computer repair - and I have to admit from the stories I hear - definitely ask around before setting foot in a mom & pop shop. Worse than car mechanics, they will make up problems that don't exist just to take your money. Stuck CD-ROM drive? That's a bad motherboard, sorry! That's a real example. I guess they couldn't be bothered to keep a 20 cent paperclip on hand. I took one of their customers, and they told everyone they knew that went there - I'm a little more busy than I want to be for a part-time business that doesn't buy advertising.

    153. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      A cropped dSLR sensor (nikon uses 1.6x) would make a 200mm lens into a 320mm lens, actually.

    154. Re:Why.... by gid · · Score: 1

      And that's why they ask "what you do plan to shoot?" "Whatever strikes my fancy and I don't want to carry around a big pack" is a valid answer, so of course they'll recommend a telescopic zoom, the artifacts are a trade off. But if someone is only doing portraits, macro, or whatever, obviously a very different lens will be recommended. Now people like you and me probably do all our research ahead of time and know exactly what you want, but sometimes it's nice to talk to someone with experience that knows what they're doing. Maybe the softness around the corners on the sigma lens really aren't as bad as they make it out to be so you can get that and save yourself $300 or whatever. This is something you'd probably never get at BB.

      I'm still very much an amateur, but uv filters are basically worthless. If you're worried about protecting the lens, a hood helps keep things away from the lens, and if you drop your camera, you might get lucky like plenty others out there and only walk away with a broken hood.

    155. Re:Why.... by godefroi · · Score: 1

      Amen to that. Customer service still matters.

      --
      Karma: Poor (Mostly affected by lame karma-joke sigs)
    156. Re:Why.... by godefroi · · Score: 1

      Yep, they do. Scary, huh?

      --
      Karma: Poor (Mostly affected by lame karma-joke sigs)
    157. Re:Why.... by hairyfeet · · Score: 1

      That is why I said ask around. it really ain't hard to spot the honest ones as we are usually swamped. as for a stuck CD being a motherboard? never heard that one although I had had boards have a bad IDE channel. If they wanted to keep the machine I would offer to install a PCI IDE adapter but usually when you get to the point a channel is blown that board ain't gonna last much longer.

      But it really ain't hard to spot the honest ones. just make like you are teh stupid and see if they start trying to throw technobabble at you. like car mechanics I've found if they start trying to throw technobabble at you right off the bat to intimidate? yeah they're a scam. Like I said the good ones will be busy and just give you a rough idea. Machine is running slow but haven't been having any hard lockups? They probably are full of toolbars and crap. Machine gets to desktop and promptly restarts with NO way to load even in safe mode? hotbar. If the guy has any exp he has seen the same shit a million times. I tell folks I won't know until I get in there but a good 90% of the time its PEBKAC thanks to them installing crap.I have 3 I'm working on now that are Security tool and toolbar loaded.

      --
      ACs don't waste your time replying, your posts are never seen by me.
    158. Re:Why.... by hedwards · · Score: 1

      Because laptops are notoriously susceptible to damage either from accidents or from just death related to heat, on top of that an extended warranty will cover things that the manufacturers warranty typically won't, like dead pixels.

      It's interesting to me to see all the ignorance about extended warranties being expressed here. Laptops are one of the few items for which an extended warranty is a good idea. I know I've personally gotten quite a bit more money out of mine than I've ever put into it.

    159. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      newegg has the best price on monster cables... best buy has five fold price gouged cables......

    160. Re:Why.... by Wrath0fb0b · · Score: 1

      When you're on a 36-48 month depreciation schedule, the idea is they last that long. When you're a 15 year old kid, you need the $499.00 BoxPusher 100 - that you will replace in 18-24 months with another throwaway piece of shit.

      Yup, your top of the line laptop with a 48 month depreciation schedule will absolutely last that long. For the last 12 months, however, you'll be using a well-built machine that's slower than an entry-level laptop.

      Think about what you would have bought 2 years in Aug 2009 ago in the mobile space: hint Arrandale wasn't released until Jan 2010 so you were stuck with Penryn. Meanwhile now I can buy a Sandy Bridge i3 that will absolutely cream any Penryn for $500 and you will be stuck with that Penryn for another 2 years.

      Of course, moving to a 36 month depreciation cycle (and then attendant 3/4 cost decrease) is a step in the right direction. Now you have a slightly slower Penryn you bought in August 2009 and you still have to deal with a sub-entry-level machine for another whole year before you can buy a new one.

      My analysis suggests that 24 months is better than 36/48 and that you can swallow the early breakage costs.

    161. Re:Why.... by Attila+Dimedici · · Score: 1

      Well, that "ignorance" comes from having worked in retail. I have never had a laptop that suffered damage that would have justified the price of an extended warranty. Not only that, none of the people I have known personally has had a problem that would have justified the cost of an extended warranty.

      --
      The truth is that all men having power ought to be mistrusted. James Madison
    162. Re:Why.... by Schemat1c · · Score: 1

      As soon as iOS5 removes the need for a PC, expect the iPad to accelerate it's genocide of the "normal" computer we're all used to.

      Sure the iPad is a cute toy for the execs and they are really pushing them to doctors as well but they will fill their niches soon and plateau. Typical of all Apple products, sexy and expensive but the glitter wears off fast.

      Meanwhile legions of PC users are actually getting work done...

      --

      "Nobody knows the age of the human race, but everybody agrees that it is old enough to know better." - Unknown
    163. Re:Why.... by znerk · · Score: 1

      What did the "refurbishing" do for you that you couldn't do yourself? I imagine it involved taking it apart, blowing out the dust, and reformatting, but that is all simply done at home for most people reading this site.

      And personally, I decided it was worth saving $300 to just double-check to make sure my backpack is zipped every time I get on my Nighthawk. Some people are less careful and/or clumsier than others and are actually justified in buying accidental protection plans, but some of us are OCD and are anally protective of our belongings (I had a g/f who went through phones about every six months, losing them, dropping them in the toilet, driving over them, etc.). In twelve years, I'm on my third cell-phone and third laptop, and that's only due to not enough power, not because of any damage. Hell, I just bought a new battery for my seven year old original Nintendo DS, because it still works just fine, excepting the 2 hours of gameplay per charge.

      Actually, the things it did for me that I couldn't do for myself included:

      • a new battery to replace the one that had started failing after nearly 3 years' hard use
      • a new (ok, factory refurbished) DVD-RW drive to replace the one that had started failing after nearly 3 years' hard use
      • a new (ok, factory refurbished) motherboard to replace the one that had cooked itself after clogging up with dirt, hair, etc.
      • a new (ok, factory refurbished) video card to replace that one that suddenly developed heat issues after the motherboard cooked

      All of which cost me the princely sum of a $300 accidental damage protection plan nearly 3 years ago, which translates as not a dime spent during this transaction.

      I could have replaced all the hardware myself, although I would probably have just purchased a new machine for the annoyance factor. I couldn't have made the stock, HP-specific parts materialize for free, though, and that's pretty much the point I was trying to make in the first place.

      --
      This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.
    164. Re:Why.... by znerk · · Score: 1

      It is in your best interest to insure yourself on a purchase as cheap as a laptop, especially a $300 one.

      Agreed, wholeheartedly. This was not a $300 laptop, unless you want to count the practically complete replacement of my 3-year-old $1200 laptop which was covered by the $300 protection plan I purchased almost 3 years ago.

      Were it the $350 laptop my neighbor purchased last week, Best Buy's Black Tie Protection Plan would cost $280 for the 3-year package... cheaper, in that case, to simply buy a new one when it breaks (if you account for inflation).

      As an aside, my laptop is not as fast as the one my neighbor just purchased, but it has an nvidia graphics card and a 19" screen, compared to the "Intel HD" video card and 13.6" screen on my neigbor's new machine.

      Not sure what it would cost for a new laptop with a 1080p screen, but I'm more than willing to have spent the $300 3 years ago for the new(ish) machine I have now :)

      --
      This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.
    165. Re:Why.... by AK+Marc · · Score: 1

      They should sell UV filters for how I use them, lens protection, especially when lending the camera. Despite making a show of being careful when borrowing an SLR, I invariably get a smudge by the time it's back, even if it was a borrow of under 10 seconds for a single shot. And using my shirt to scrub a fingerprint off a UV filter makes me happier than getting that same print off the lens, even if I had the proper cleaning cloth right there, as it's not worth the time and such compared to the cost of even an overpriced UV filter.

      And when I've been in a "real" camera shop and given the answer you suggest, I get steered towards point-and-click cameras, to leave the SLRs to the experts. I'm not a fan of camera shops, they are run by camera geeks who wouldn't talk to you as a peer (like some computer geeks do).

    166. Re:Why.... by AK+Marc · · Score: 1

      As for technically accurate, it's a bit like saying putting smaller diameter tires on a car will make it similar to a fast car because you can now peg the speedometer. Yes, that is technically accurate - you now can peg the speedometer on both cars but you aren't going the same speed; but very misleading because of what people think a speedometer or lens length represents

      And yet, you are wrong. Smaller tires will usually result in faster acceleration as well. Perhaps that grain of truth is why that "lie" could gain traction. The best and hardest lies to kill have a grain of truth in them. I know more than one car racer who went to the smallest tires allowed to increase acceleration and speed. When FoV is as foreign to a buyer as "final gear ratio" is to a car buyer, the over simplification that is right from the supposed context of the buyer is good enough. There's no need to assume they have some knowledge of the issues at hand (if they did, would they be in Best Buy asking the people there what they should get?), so the longer, more complicated, and more confusing "correct answer" never need be given. Though answering a question with an answer designed to move the product, rather than inform (even if the information is incomplete and contains untruths) is fraud. Sadly, it is acceptable fraud, so nobody would prosecute it, even if caught on tape. And think about it, what do you think would happen if a case against Best Buy came up about lying for profit when they said a 200mm lens on a dSLR were the same as a 320mm on an SLR (again, including dSLRs with full-size sensors)? Besy Buy would get a poor SLR with a crappy 320mm lens and their best dSLR and 200mm lens and take the same photo with each, print both at 4x6, making sure they were identical, and hand them to the jury and ask them if they think the pictures are "equivalent" or "identical" or whatever exact word the BB associate used on the tape recording of him. I would say that the average jury wouldn't see a difference, unless an "expert" was on the jury to be able to spot artifacts, and even then, a hung jury is probably the best a prosecutor could hope for. So I fail to see any reason to bash BB on this. Car dealers get away with worse all the time. And they manage to get prosecuted every once in a while for something similar, and rarely (if ever) convicted.

      Though I agree that product protection is a scam, and most who sell them will drop into scam-level tactics to sell them. They should be required by law, for any insurance policy, to reveal the actuary tables and the expected profit margin of the policy (just like they do with car insurance in most places, even if indirectly, I always knew the profit State Farm made in TX from their insurance, and if it were more than allowed, they'd send me a check for my portion the difference).

    167. Re:Why.... by TheTyrannyOfForcedRe · · Score: 1

      You forgot monoprice!

      --
      "Liechtenstein is the world's largest producer of sausage casings, potassium storage units, and false teeth."
    168. Re:Why.... by Sfing_ter · · Score: 1

      Ummm... at Fry's the likelihood is that another customer has purchased/taken home/opened/used/abused/disliked/returned the laptop that you just bought. Then they re-seal and sell it as new...

      --
      A computer once beat me at chess, but it was no match for me at kick boxing. Emo Philips
    169. Re:Why.... by omnichad · · Score: 2

      I don't know cars too well, but I always act extra dumb, as a way of tuning their talking down to the range of my crap filtering ability.

    170. Re:Why.... by TClevenger · · Score: 1

      We still have people on 4-year-old Latitude laptops. Why? Because they're salespeople that take their machines home with them, and only use Word, Outlook and Salesforce. For that, they don't need a new machine every two years. At worst, we have to pony up for a new off-brand battery for $20 from eBay.

    171. Re:Why.... by Hes+Nikke · · Score: 1

      just tell them 12345

      --
      Don't call me back. Give me a call back. Bye. So yeah. But bye our, well, but alright we are on a shirt this chill.
    172. Re:Why.... by Registered+Coward+v2 · · Score: 1

      As for technically accurate, it's a bit like saying putting smaller diameter tires on a car will make it similar to a fast car because you can now peg the speedometer. Yes, that is technically accurate - you now can peg the speedometer on both cars but you aren't going the same speed; but very misleading because of what people think a speedometer or lens length represents

      And yet, you are wrong. Smaller tires will usually result in faster acceleration as well.

      Actually, no. You are confusing acceleration, actual speed, and indicated speed. Smaller tires yield faster acceleration but lower top speed; indicated speed will be wrong as well due to the speedometer calibration error.

      --
      I'm a consultant - I convert gibberish into cash-flow.
    173. Re:Why.... by Chris+Mattern · · Score: 1

      Wow. That's actually illegal, you know.

    174. Re:Why.... by ZombieBraintrust · · Score: 1

      Most cities in America don't have an Apple store. There are only 2 Apple stores in Kentucky. One in Lexington and one in Louisville. Best Buys are also located in smaller markets like Owensboro, Paducah, Bowling Green, and Elizabethtown.

      Apple stores also doesn't have a large variety of laptops. They only carry macs.

      With Circuit City closed there are not many places to go browse electronics. You next best bet is an Office Max or Staples. From there you step down to the big box stores: Walmart, Target, and Sears where the selection is tiny.

    175. Re:Why.... by Yakasha · · Score: 1

      I used to work at Circuit City and they would do exactly that. I had customers that wanted a specific model laptop and the only one available was "pre-optimized". They charged an extra $75.00 for the tech to open the box, go through the initial setup prompts and uninstall maybe one or two things. The customers came in looking for a laptop advertised at a specific price and it was my job to tell them that they would have to pay an additional $75.00 on top of that price because all we had left was the "optimized" version.

      Classic illegal bait & switch method. Damnit, I'm going to sue Circuit City into bankruptcy!!

    176. Re:Why.... by hairyfeet · · Score: 1

      That is why again the reputable mom&pop shop is the way to go. my oldest took his S10 in to 3 different "big name" shops and they told him to get the AC fixed they were gonna have to rip out the dash, replace this part, it was gonna be crazy expensive. I asked around and found a nice old guy with a shop literally out in the woods. When I asked him why he was out in the woods he said "I'm swamped so why would I care where the shop is at? This lets me work in peace" so sure enough I knew I had a good one.

      He takes one look under the hood and breaks out this big shop fan and aims it at the engine. When I asked WTF? he said 'Most of these shops don't seem to realize that with these little S10s you just can't put Freon in them while they are hot, the pressure builds up and it only gets about half what it should". he put in the Freon (held about half a can) and told the oldest "If that switch sticks at any time if you'll just switch from hot to cold a couple of times it will unstick it. Common on this model". what the others said was gonna cost several hundred cost me $80.

      So I really can't say enough about the little mom&pops, you find a good one and they take pride in their work and aren't trying to screw you. my oldest has icy cold air now and it is just purring like a kitten.

      --
      ACs don't waste your time replying, your posts are never seen by me.
    177. Re:Why.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      So you don't have to order online and deal with BS shipping RMA crap if you need to return it

    178. Re:Why.... by AK+Marc · · Score: 1

      Actually no, I'm not confusing anything. You are confused, not me. "Faster" means higher acceleration to most people. That you try to use terms in the opposite of the general use and claim your definition is more technical is silly,

      Not to mention that, you are likely still wrong. Ever see a car run top-speed on the salt flats and then re-try top speed after adding 10,000+ lbs to increase top speed? I'm sure you'd argue that's wrong because more weight can't make you faster. But it does, Given facts I've seen with my own eyes and the ramblings of some random person on the Internet, the Internet is always wrong. Lowering the gear ratio could easily increase the top end and acceleration.

    179. Re:Why.... by Registered+Coward+v2 · · Score: 1

      Actually no, I'm not confusing anything. You are confused, not me. "Faster" means higher acceleration to most people. That you try to use terms in the opposite of the general use and claim your definition is more technical is silly,

      Nice try,but fast = speed and quick = acceleration. But thanks for playing. We have some lovely parting gifts...

      Not to mention that, you are likely still wrong. Ever see a car run top-speed on the salt flats and then re-try top speed after adding 10,000+ lbs to increase top speed? I'm sure you'd argue that's wrong because more weight can't make you faster.

      Adding weight judiciously could increase the achievable top speed due to changes in the car's aerodynamic response at speed; although theoretical top speed would be reduced due to simple physics.

      But it does, Given facts I've seen with my own eyes and the ramblings of some random person on the Internet, the Internet is always wrong.

      Such as you are in this case.

      Lowering the gear ratio could easily increase the top end and acceleration.

      No. Lowering the gear ration increases speed and lowers acceleration. I suggest a simple engineering mechanics book if you want proof, a basic statics book should do.

      --
      I'm a consultant - I convert gibberish into cash-flow.
    180. Re:Why.... by torkus · · Score: 1

      Not true. This is from someone who works with Apple's Enterprise reps on a regular basis.

      They want the business segment, but not badly enough to change their formula that makes them a win on the consumer side. And honestly what makes them so good for their market on the consumer side is exactly what kills them on the enterprise side. Despite that, they still try to make it work with some duct tape and special help.

      --
      You can get rich if you own a politician, but you have to be rich to buy one in the first place.
    181. Re:Why.... by spazdor · · Score: 1

      atic.ca is good too.

      --
      DRM: Terminator crops for your mind!
    182. Re:Why.... by djdanlib · · Score: 1

      I think you were unusually lucky.

      I used to work at a helpdesk at a college. Macs, in our experience at the helpdesk, suffer the same defect rate as other brands.

      None of my friends have had a Macbook for longer than 18 months without having to bring it in for repairs. These people aren't abusing their laptops, mind you. It's just that they aren't really special - they are decently good quality, and that's it.

    183. Re:Why.... by djdanlib · · Score: 1

      Well, we can at least find his lack of faith disturbing.

    184. Re:Why.... by virg_mattes · · Score: 1

      I'm still very much an amateur, but uv filters are basically worthless. If you're worried about protecting the lens, a hood helps keep things away from the lens, and if you drop your camera, you might get lucky like plenty others out there and only walk away with a broken hood.

      A hood isn't very good at keeping dust off the lens, and I don't feel any qualms about rubbing it off with a shirt tail or dry cloth. I shoot a lot of sports (mostly kid sports) so flying crud and misty/rainy spray is a real concern for me. The UV filter works for me in those conditions.

      Virg

    185. Re:Why.... by rhook · · Score: 1

      Yes, because using an automated tool to remove the ei.cfg from the ISO before burning to a DVD is so fucking hard to do. You don't even need to install any certificates to activate after the install.

  2. Best Buy buys used games by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Thus Best Buy is Gamestop. Gamestop opens games, messes with the contents and sells them as new. Gamestop is evil. Best Buy opens laptops, messes with their contents and sells them as new. Thus Best Buy is ... additionally evil too.

    1. Re:Best Buy buys used games by Riceballsan · · Score: 1

      Buying used games and selling them for less then you sell new games isn't evil, it's a perfectly reasonable business practice that helps the lazy consumer, (AKA ones who want to sell a game used but dosn't want the hastle/risks of ebay), admitted both of these companies are doing evil on their own, if I recall best buy used to not only open and install garbage on the PC, but charge extra for their superiour optimization that they ran on the computers, and trained their salesmen to say it sped the computer up by 50% or some crap (independent studies showed 3% increase at best and something like a 25% decrease in some cases). And to top it off if the customers didn't want to pay extra for it, they were usually out of the "unoptimized" versions, but wouldn't waive the optimisation fee without a huge arguement.

    2. Re:Best Buy buys used games by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You must have missed out on the Deus Ex shitstorm that has been hitting the Internets recently.

    3. Re:Best Buy buys used games by h4rr4r · · Score: 1

      That is not what he is complaining about. He is complaining about gamestop's practice of opening new games and still selling them as new. They did this to the new Dues Ex to remove an onLive coupon, They also do it when they let their employees play the games and still sell them as new.

    4. Re:Best Buy buys used games by jd2112 · · Score: 1

      That is not what he is complaining about. He is complaining about gamestop's practice of opening new games and still selling them as new. They did this to the new Dues Ex to remove an onLive coupon, They also do it when they let their employees play the games and still sell them as new.

      On the other hand you could argue that since gamestop opened the package the 'shrinkwrap' license does not apply. (Not that I would want to spend several years and no telling how much money in order to test this legal theory.

      --
      Any insufficiently advanced magic is indistinguishable from technology.
  3. No by nurb432 · · Score: 1

    How do you know it wasn't a return? ( tho to be fair, even sealed you still don't know 100%. i got burnt like that once, another company took a return, resealed it and sold it as new, even tho what was inside the box was a far older item, covered in years of dust. )

    What does that do to the warranty? What else did they install that you don't want?

    --
    ---- Booth was a patriot ----
    1. Re:No by JamesP · · Score: 0

      Yeah, and the whole thing smells of White Whine

      Geez, wipe the darn thing and install Linux.

      If they charge you for the 'optimization' tell them to fsck off and to 'undo' it

      --
      how long until /. fixes commenting on Chrome?
    2. Re:No by PCM2 · · Score: 2

      In my experience, when you by a consumer laptop from Best Buy, you'll want to wipe the drive just to install Windows. Best to repartition it, actually -- whatever's on that "Recovery Partition," you don't want it coming back.

      Just make sure, if it's an HP laptop, that you burn the "SWSetup" directory to a DVD before you start. It has all the hardware drivers in it, and I've seen cases where not all of those drivers are available from the Web site.

      --
      Breakfast served all day!
    3. Re:No by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This was for a client, so the OS was probably mandated.

      In any event, go for something with some semblance of standardization and documentation over Linux.

    4. Re:No by nurb432 · · Score: 1

      Geez, wipe the darn thing and install Linux.

      Sure, most of us around here can undo any damage in any number of ways, but the average citizen would have no clue they may have just got screwed.

      --
      ---- Booth was a patriot ----
    5. Re:No by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Wait... availability of windows drivers is a problem? Surely you must be new here. ONLY Linux has that problem. It always will too. It hasn't changed since 1925 when Linux was invented. In fact you have to write your own drivers and compile them yourself.

    6. Re:No by PCM2 · · Score: 1

      To be accurate, availability of Windows drivers is not technically a problem, since no hardware ships without Windows drivers pre-installed on it. The problem is closed source drivers, where you have to go crawling to the manufacturer to get copies, and sometimes they're not allowed to publish them because of their OEM agreements. That leaves you relying on things like HP's "Recovery Partitions," which are chock full of bloatware.

      --
      Breakfast served all day!
    7. Re:No by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And you have to be wary, sometimes you find malware disguised as the file you're looking for, or files that are difficult to distinguish whether or not they are the correct version you want.

      You know the ones you currently have work, copying them is merely risk management.

    8. Re:No by tompaulco · · Score: 1

      i got burnt like that once, another company took a return, resealed it and sold it as new, even tho what was inside the box was a far older item, covered in years of dust. )
      Well at least that explains why companies want to charge you a restocking fee on a broken item return.

      --
      If you are not allowed to question your government then the government has answered your question.
    9. Re:No by AmiMoJo · · Score: 1

      Problem with wiping the HDD is that if the laptop has a fault and you need to return it to Best Buy they won't be able to re-install it and thus won't be able to check if they really fixed the problem. Yes, they could just use a Windows disc, but Microsoft does not allow that. Their official line is that if your computer came with an OEM copy of Windows you MUST re-install it from the recovery partition or recovery media. It's stupid because if you machine came with XP SP1 you have a lot of updates and patches to do, but those are the license terms.

      Years ago when I used to do that sort of thing for an independent shop we once had a HP laptop come back from a warranty HDD replacement with a cracked copy of Windows on it, presumably because they lost the recovery partition. We installed a genuine copy with the license key on the machine's sticker, but apparently it was beyond the wit of HP's staff to do that. We used to have lots of slipstreamed up-to-date discs until Microsoft put their foot down, after which we were pulling a few gigabytes per day from Windows Update (you are not allowed to download the patches or service packs for offline installation unless you are distributing via Window Server either).

      --
      const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)
      SJW, n: "Someone I don't like, and by the way I'm a fuckwit" - AC
  4. For a true "New" laptop from BB by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    you have to specifically ask for an unopened one. They will then tell you that they do not have any unopened or unoptimized laptops. After this you can either speak to a manager (who will sometimes be helpful) or whip out your phone and order a laptop online for in store pick up. You will then be able to pick up an untouched laptop.

    The entire process is designed for them to make a little bit of extra money either through bloatware or selling optimized laptops. Basically a scam. I'm actually surprised you weren't charged for the "inspection". I'd check my receipt if I were you.

  5. Return it by The+Yuckinator · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I'd take it back and tell them it isn't new, then demand a heavy discount or an unopened/unstickered laptop. Better yet, I'd go somewhere else.

    While you're at it, take some time to wonder why you're buying a client's computer at Best Buy. Are you really doing your client a favour by getting them a machine with a return-to-depot-and-you-probably-won't-get-your-data-back warranty?

    1. Re:Return it by vux984 · · Score: 3, Interesting

      While you're at it, take some time to wonder why you're buying a client's computer at Best Buy. Are you really doing your client a favour by getting them a machine with a return-to-depot-and-you-probably-won't-get-your-data-back warranty?

      I've done this. Its usually because they want a laptop by lunch time, and do not want to wait a week or even overnight for a special order job.

      So you walk into BB and grab a unit that meets the specs, and just deal with the fact that its got windows 7 home premium, and you hope you aren't getting some goofy grey market product that you have to go to the japanese support site for drivers because according to the North America site that model doesn't exist...

    2. Re:Return it by Jah-Wren+Ryel · · Score: 1

      I'd take it back and tell them it isn't new,

      This is exactly right. BBY didn't open it, it was returned by a customer and they are reselling it. It is illegal to sell a returned item as new, at least in the US.

      My guess is that the "inspected by" stickers are their legal CYA - they still charged you the new price but they informed you it wasn't a new product by including those stickers.

      FWIW, this happened to me yesterday. I ordered via "store pickup" some accessories for my new HP touchpad (that "touchstone" wireless charging station is really slick) and some of the boxes had those stickers. I decided not to make a fuss since I was getting a ~65% discount to begin with and the store was otherwise out of stock. But under other circumstances I would have refused the merchandise.

      --
      When information is power, privacy is freedom.
    3. Re:Return it by makubesu · · Score: 1

      That's ridiculous. By that logic, I should send my PC back to Dell claiming it wasn't new because they had the nerve to install Windows on it.

    4. Re:Return it by The+Yuckinator · · Score: 1

      When you get a new machine from Dell it has a factory installed drive image. When you turn it on for the first time you're presented with a welcome wizard to create your user account and various other settings (dhcp vs static ip, I think, etc).

      TFA says that the user account was already created and extra software had been installed.

      I don't see anything ridiculous about calling it not new, these two situations are completely different.

    5. Re:Return it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'd take it back and tell them it isn't new,

      This is exactly right. BBY didn't open it, it was returned by a customer and they are reselling it. It is illegal to sell a returned item as new, at least in the US.

      My guess is that the "inspected by" stickers are their legal CYA - they still charged you the new price but they informed you it wasn't a new product by including those stickers.

      FWIW, this happened to me yesterday. I ordered via "store pickup" some accessories for my new HP touchpad (that "touchstone" wireless charging station is really slick) and some of the boxes had those stickers. I decided not to make a fuss since I was getting a ~65% discount to begin with and the store was otherwise out of stock. But under other circumstances I would have refused the merchandise.

      You're completely ignorant. I work for Best Buy. When someone returns something, it is either restored and CLEARLY labeled with a giant blue sticker that says "Open Box Computer" or it is sent back to the factory to be melted down for parts. Period. You don't know what you're talking about at all.

    6. Re:Return it by wesleyjconnor · · Score: 1

      Im also curious what the OEM would think about them doing this...

    7. Re:Return it by Jah-Wren+Ryel · · Score: 1

      You're completely ignorant. I work for Best Buy. When someone returns something, it is either restored and CLEARLY labeled with a giant blue sticker that says "Open Box Computer" or it is sent back to the factory to be melted down for parts. Period. You don't know what you're talking about at all.

      I'm pretty sure I know exactly what I am talking about.
      Or perhaps you can explain how it is that the items in the "inspected by" boxes had a bunch of smudgy fingerprints on them and were missing internal plastic bags while the same items in the unmolested boxes were pristine?

      --
      When information is power, privacy is freedom.
  6. I'm sorry, but... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...how on earth did you miss a bright red sticker?

  7. Nothing New.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I actually ran into this about a year ago....went to buy a particular machine, in a particular color...the only ones they had left in that color were "Geek Squad optimized" or something along those lines. They hadn't done the recovery disks, but the user profile was created, "junkware" removed, etc. Basically everything that those of us who know what we're doing would do after we unpacked it anyway. On top of that, there was an extra charge for this "service".

  8. And they didn't charge you? by sandytaru · · Score: 0

    Usually they slap a $100 setup fee on top of the base price for that particular "service."

    --
    Occasionally living proof of the Ballmer peak.
    1. Re:And they didn't charge you? by hellkyng · · Score: 1

      Yup that is exactly how they roll, we used to do that at Circuity City (worked so well for them). Basically it was 30 minutes of my time to open the box, remove adware, install AV, clean up msconfig and burn some recovery disks. We only charged around 50-60$ though for the service, which was mostly the AV and a bit on the top.

      I still think its sleazy but for some users in the area (red neck town) it worked out very well. The recovery disks and AV kept them from coming back two months later for an anti-virus removal that would run them 130$.

    2. Re:And they didn't charge you? by reasterling · · Score: 1

      coming back two months later for an anti-virus removal that would run them 130$.

      Wow, I mean, just WOW!

      Either you pay to have the anti-virus put on, or you pay later to have the anti-virus removed. Wait, I may just be a red neck, but I see something wrong here.

      --
      "For I desired mercy, and not sacrifice" -- God
    3. Re:And they didn't charge you? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I came here to say this. Check the receipt. You definitely paid extra for it.

    4. Re:And they didn't charge you? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Happened to my wife. She bought me a new Asus laptop for Christmas from BB. They didn't have it in stock so it was shipped directly to my home. Great, no problem there, I was happy. She used it a bit and liked it too, so she went back online to order another. Lo and behold, there was only 1 left, and in stock at my local store! So she ordered it online to pick up at store.

      She gets there and goes to pick it up. Oh look, the box has been opened, recovery disks were made and AV installed. And they wanted $100 more than she'd already paid online! She went off, raised hell (in earshot of the people waiting in line at the Geek Squad), they offered to charge only $50 more, she told them to credit her card and keep it. The manager rushed out from the back and said "No extra charge" - you'd think we were done. NO!

      We get it home, and assorted things didn't work (facial recognition/camera for one). Called local store to complain, sorry, no more of that model. Went home, she called BB Corporate and raised hell for another half hour. Ultimate result? Direct shipped a newer modem Asus laptop (better CPU, bigger HDD, more RAM plus WiMax we'll not likely use) for no additional charge.

      The motto? Don't give up, and don't take any s**t. There is someone higher up somewhere who can make things right - but only if they're motivated (like to get your mouth out of the store or off the corporate line.

      NetLarry

    5. Re:And they didn't charge you? by hellkyng · · Score: 1

      It definitely was an interesting practice. I should add that at the time we only did this to a percentage of the PCs, you could still buy an unmodified PC for normal cost. Typically though the custom set-ups were quite popular, given the general lack of computer knowledge in the area. We had one guy bring in a PC for troubleshooting that had two inches of "dirt" in the bottom of the case, in addition to a bunch of razors and a fair amount of human(?) hair. They was a deeply disturbing tech support experience for me.

  9. Great, more garbage by rolfwind · · Score: 1

    One thing I despise on regular windows laptops is all the crap they add on. Apple does this aspect correctly (and for the price one pays, it should).

    And no, I don't want BB touching my laptop. The recovery disk is nice (but should be there from the manufacturer anyway, cheap bastards), but I wonder what other bloatware they installed?

    The average buyer will probably see this as the same as the car prep done when buying a new car... but I want no part of it. In that case, it should work out just fine, geeks generally don't buy at BB unless they need a part fast.

    1. Re:Great, more garbage by Mephistophocles · · Score: 1

      geeks generally don't buy at BB unless they need a part fast.

      Every time I've tried that they either didn't have the part I needed (9/10 times) or it was at least 3 times more expensive than the average online resource. So this geek doesn't buy there, period. If I need a part fast, Amazon/NewEgg will overnight it - never needed one faster than that. Best Buy is a waste of good retail space.

      --
      Deja Moo: The distinct feeling that you've heard this bull before.
    2. Re:Great, more garbage by jazman_777 · · Score: 1

      I was visiting family not long ago, and my sister needed some component. I told her you can get it on NewEgg for $5, but she needed it now, and paid $20 at Best Buy. It was a defiling experience being in there and paying through the nose for a small piece of junk.

      --
      Slashdot: Failed Car Analogies. Amateur Lawyering. Anecdote Battles.
    3. Re:Great, more garbage by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      My dad enjoys some of the demo games that were included in a cheap Compaq (CDN$400) laptop.

      I don't see what the big deal is for most kinds of included software. There are some that make it hard to uninstall (or stop from starting at boot), and those I understand. It doesn't really bother anyone if they're easily uninstallable and probably made your laptop cheaper because the company dumped a truckload of money (not all you get, but some) in BB's face.

      Then again, the Sony Viao FW285 (~CDN$1200) that he bought included a lot of extra Sony software, like a photo gallery with facial recognition and DLNA server that he doesn't use and is probably not even aware they're in there.

      So which is the crapware?

    4. Re:Great, more garbage by omnichad · · Score: 1

      If I need a part fast, Amazon/NewEgg will overnight it - never needed one faster than that. Best Buy is a waste of good retail space.

      It's true that overnight shipping from NewEgg is usually cheaper than BB, but if it's a Sunday afternoon, I'd have to wait a LONG time before I'd be able to use what I bought, because weekdays are just too busy. I do go once a year or once every two years when I need something right away.

    5. Re:Great, more garbage by ZosX · · Score: 1

      I lost my laptop cable (long story) and needed one quickly. Best buy wanted 60 for a knock off 3rd party universal cable. I said fuck that and got an OEM cable for $8 on amazon. I was ok with waiting the couple of extra days for shipping and saving 40.

      fuck you best buy!

    6. Re:Great, more garbage by nickb64 · · Score: 1

      I needed a USB SD card reader, and the cheapest BB had one for was $20. I said fuck it, I'll wait two days and get it from Amazon with Prime for a couple dollars. Ended up gettting one that works just great for $5. I didn't have to pay 10% tax on it either.

    7. Re:Great, more garbage by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Apple installs crap called iTunes and iLife

  10. Uhhh by bobdole2111 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    This article is from 2009. Why is this now hitting the front page?

    1. Re:Uhhh by JustAnotherIdiot · · Score: 1

      Because gamestop opened games, therefore suddenly electronic retailers opening things is what everyone wants to read.

      --
      What do I know, I'm just an idiot, right?
    2. Re:Uhhh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Taco-gate. It will be on Wikileaks tomorrow,

    3. Re:Uhhh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2

      This article is from 2009. Why is this now hitting the front page?

      Because it was posted by timothy.

    4. Re:Uhhh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Since CmdrTaco has left, the quality control has lowered

    5. Re:Uhhh by erroneus · · Score: 2

      Damnit... I want to eat Tacos now...

    6. Re:Uhhh by Gruturo · · Score: 2

      This article is from 2009. Why is this now hitting the front page?

      It was in Taco's backlog. Now that he left, someone's going thru it, finally. And they're at 2009 already, we'll soon start seeing current news!

      (Jokes apart, Thanks for so many years Rob!)

      --

      Vacuum cleaners suck. Kings rule.
    7. Re:Uhhh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Because it was sitting in CmdrTaco's queue.

    8. Re:Uhhh by jazman_777 · · Score: 1

      I'm embarrassed, I didn't read TFA.

      --
      Slashdot: Failed Car Analogies. Amateur Lawyering. Anecdote Battles.
    9. Re:Uhhh by Kjella · · Score: 1

      So people will get nostalgic about the "good old days" when CmdrTaco was running slashdot.

      --
      Live today, because you never know what tomorrow brings
    10. Re:Uhhh by mincus · · Score: 1

      Not only is this from 2009, but BBY has been doing this since at least 1998...

    11. Re:Uhhh by gorbachev · · Score: 1

      He was using the Consumerist article as an example, not a description of what happened to him.

      Poor summary.

      --
      In Soviet Russia, I ruled you
  11. they open everything by ironicsky · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Any big ticket electronics I buy from best buy gets unpacked, plugged in and inspected by the employee and myself as proof that the device works, that its not scratched, dented or damaged and we both sign off on it. The difference here is, they do it in front of you. They have asked me before if I want their shit installed on the laptop before I leave and I always decline. I've purchased 2 laptops for personal use and 5 for friends/family (not as gifts, just helpful shopping) and never ever had this happen

    1. Re:they open everything by gknoy · · Score: 1

      Where do you do this? On the sales floor, at customer service? Before or after purchasing? I'd like to do it in a way that inconveniences me the least (and gets them to be the most helpful). Do you have a prepared spiel that you give them ("Before I buy this, I'd like to verify that it all works correctly")?

    2. Re:they open everything by bobstreo · · Score: 1

      Good idea, that prevents the issue of "rough weight equivalent" of bricks in the box that best-buy customers have experienced...

    3. Re:they open everything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And making recovery disks, I consider that a big plus. Saves a person up to 3 hours. I don't think this is THAT big a deal other than on principle. I've bought a killer laptop there, great gaming laptop, still running, was a superb price unmatched anywhere else (gateway p-6831fx). No qualms or misgivings whatsoever. I do live in a remote area where everything must come by mail, so shipping from newegg or anywhere else is exorbitant. So, yeah, to me Best Buy does have its time and place. I don't consider them the devil.

    4. Re:they open everything by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      My mom purchased a laptop from Best Buy at the same time I was picking one up for her from somewhere else [there was a miscommunication]. I called her when I bought the one from her and she was still in the BB parking lot about to leave. I had gotten her a better laptop for less money, so I told her to just go back in and return the one she bought (less than 10 minutes ago). They took it back, said the box had been opened (by there tech during the inspection), and charged her a 15% restocking fee. While I understand the desire to give the customer a working product, she should *not* have been charged for their actions. That was a few years ago, I've never bought, or will allow anyone I know, to buy a computer from BB again.

    5. Re:they open everything by Just+Some+Guy · · Score: 2

      Do you have a prepared spiel that you give them ("Before I buy this, I'd like to verify that it all works correctly")?

      That's pretty much exactly it. "OK, I like this one, but I'd like to open it and make sure everything's alright before I take it home." The salesman will figure out a way to make that happen if he wants his commission. Be firm, though. Sometimes they'll reply with something like, "you can tell it's in good shape because it's still sealed and the box looks fine." Stand your ground. You aren't asking for anything unreasonable, even if it's not very common. You wouldn't take delivery of a car without checking it out first, would you? There's no shame in looking at your would-be new refrigerator or TV, either.

      The last time I was at a large electronics store in another city, I told the salesman that I wanted to inspect my purchase before I got home because it was a long drive to return it if it wasn't in perfect condition. He kind of balked until I said "thanks anyway, but I'm not buying it sight unseen" and started to leave. He stopped me and had the box open in no time.

      --
      Dewey, what part of this looks like authorities should be involved?
  12. horrible by Killerfishmonkey · · Score: 0

    you should do like the rest of the world.. er.. the rest of the geeks.. buy from tigerdirect.com / compusa

    1. Re:horrible by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      No one in their right mind buys a piece of shit from tigerdirect.

    2. Re:horrible by idontgno · · Score: 0

      You actually mentioned the "T" word and didn't mention Newegg? WTF?

      I go to tigerdirect only because the occasional "on-line gift certificate" thing my employer does as "attaboy" rewards* are redeemable there and not at Newegg.

      If I'm spending my own money, it's Newegg.

      *Yeah, tangible rewards for good performance. It does happen. I'm at a loss why it happens to me, given the "good performance" thing, but that's ok, I'll spend it whether or not I think I deserve it.

      --
      Welcome to the Panopticon. Used to be a prison, now it's your home.
    3. Re:horrible by couchslug · · Score: 1

      If you KNOW what you are buying you can save money as an informed consumer.

      I stick with Newegg since TD used to have a bad reputation and the Egg has excellent service. No objection to TD anymore, but Newegg has always been good to me.

      --
      "This post is an artistic work of fiction and falsehood. Only a fool would take anything posted here as fact."
    4. Re:horrible by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      When NewEgg started selling unlabeled grey market Nikon SLRs I stopped any dealings with them. Sure, they took them back if people complained but they never updated their website to let people know that this camera didn't have a US warranty.

    5. Re:horrible by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I actually refuse to purchase from Tigerdirect because I dropped several hundred dollars on name-brand memory from there once and received knock-off brand with a fake sticker for the brand I ordered stuck on (spelling errors & all)... when I shipped it back, they refused to refund me because even though it was in an unopened package, I swapped the ram out for cheap knock-off stuff.

      I paid full price for the memory plus shipping both ways and I never ended up getting anything for it (they wouldn't ship it back). Granted this was a few years ago, they will never get my business again.

    6. Re:horrible by AK+Marc · · Score: 2

      That's what chargebacks were created for.

    7. Re:horrible by Khyber · · Score: 1

      I love how you guys say Newegg yet pricewatch will typically find the same part at a cheaper price.

      --
      Still waiting on Serviscope_minor to wake up to fucking reality and realize that Jessica Price isn't going to fuck him.
  13. Old News by supersloshy · · Score: 2

    Tell me when they AREN'T doing shady practices like this and then that will be news to me...

    --
    "Our country is not nearly so overrun with the bigoted as it is overrun with the broadminded." -Archbishop Fulton Sheen
    1. Re:Old News by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Old news indeed. The linked story was posted two years ago...

  14. Ehhhh by John+Napkintosh · · Score: 1

    I'm just going to format it and reinstall the OS anyway. OEM probably puts as much, if not more, junk on there than Best Buy.

    --

    Long signatures suck.
    1. Re:Ehhhh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Best Buy doesn't put anything except the AV on the computer. That best buy program that is installed when you buy it is on the computer before BB even gets it. Which when I was doing "presetups" was the first thing I uninstalled.

      Best Buy is a corporation that wants as much money as they can get, which makes them no different than any other corporation in the USA, we just need to deal with it.

    2. Re:Ehhhh by Bucky24 · · Score: 1

      Most people don't want to spend $100-$200 to get a fresh OEM windows copy on top of the $400-$700 they just spent on a laptop. Back in the day when new computers actually came with a fresh OS copy this wasn't required, but nowadays, as has been said several times before in this article's comments, most new computers come with a "restoration" disk which just restores a backup partition.

      --
      All the world's a CPU, and all the men and women merely AI agents
    3. Re:Ehhhh by Iniamyen · · Score: 1

      Except to do that, you'd probably have to purchase an OS (if you're using Windows), since Windows machines usually don't come with a true OEM OS disk.

    4. Re:Ehhhh by rriegs · · Score: 1

      Don't hate me for being a Geek Squad employee, but I can say that standard operating practice for pre-setups is to remove as much OEM bloatware as possible. One such item is the Best Buy "pc app", which is actually installed on PCs before their boxes are sealed by the manufacturer; all the Geek Squad agents I know remove this nuisance on sight. The only software we do install on pre-setups is anti-virus software. Annoying to some, yes, but OEMs have been preinstalling anti-virus for years, and quite frankly, I prefer anything over the Norton or McAfee they always seem to use. But don't get me wrong, I think what happened to the original poster is awful. Just know that Best Buy doesn't perform pre-setups on all the computers they sell, and it was definitely a mistake that the original poster received one without asking (or at least being told).

    5. Re:Ehhhh by tibit · · Score: 1

      Since Windows Vista, there's no such thing anymore.

      --
      A successful API design takes a mixture of software design and pedagogy.
    6. Re:Ehhhh by drcagn · · Score: 1

      Yep. At our precinct all of us remove Best Buy pc app on any computer we touch. And we genuinely remove bloatware on all of our PC Setups.

      --
      Scorta futuere amo!
  15. Taco leaves and the place goes to Hell. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    This article is from 2009. Why is this now hitting the front page?

    Taco leaves and the place goes to Hell.

    1. Re:Taco leaves and the place goes to Hell. by mkkohls · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Taco leaves and the place goes to Hell.

      Couldn't have said it better myself.

    2. Re:Taco leaves and the place goes to Hell. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      Yeah, under his watch you only get Timothy posting 12 year old stories rather than 2.

    3. Re:Taco leaves and the place goes to Hell. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You've not been paying attention. This place went to hell over a year ago. Taco left BECAUSE it went to hell.

    4. Re:Taco leaves and the place goes to Hell. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Yeah at least back in the CmdrTaco days the articles were only a year old!

    5. Re:Taco leaves and the place goes to Hell. by Beat+The+Odds · · Score: 2

      This article is from 2009. Why is this now hitting the front page?

      Taco leaves and the place goes to Hell.

      Or, Taco leaves because the place is going to Hell.

    6. Re:Taco leaves and the place goes to Hell. by pulski · · Score: 2

      This article is from 2009. Why is this now hitting the front page?

      Taco leaves and the place goes to Hell.

      Or, Taco leaves and decides to AC Troll.

    7. Re:Taco leaves and the place goes to Hell. by 6Yankee · · Score: 5, Funny

      Taco actually left two years ago.

    8. Re:Taco leaves and the place goes to Hell. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yay, I submitted that. Is it the most out-of-date story so far?

    9. Re:Taco leaves and the place goes to Hell. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      WHAT!!? He's gone??!!

  16. LOLZ by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is from 2009 HELLO!.. they probably don't do this anymore.

    1. Re:LOLZ by sqlrob · · Score: 2

      How about a link from this March or even
      end of June? Within a month and a half recent enough for you?

  17. Restocking fee by tepples · · Score: 2

    If I shop on NewEgg or Amazon, unlike at a brick and mortar store, I don't get a chance to try a laptop's screen and keyboard before I buy it. So if I find a keyboard or screen unusably unergonomic, I may have to pay a 15% restocking fee.

    1. Re:Restocking fee by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

      try at best buy, buy at newegg.

    2. Re:Restocking fee by PCM2 · · Score: 1

      Actually, Best Buy has a lot of models that you can't find anywhere else. You may be able to order a similar model online, but you won't know if the keyboard is the same.

      --
      Breakfast served all day!
    3. Re:Restocking fee by crashumbc · · Score: 2

      Generally, that's because Best Buy's models are made specially for them and usually use CHEAPER parts then the main stream model... I would NEVER buy a Best Buy model... that's just asking for problems...

    4. Re:Restocking fee by ThatsMyNick · · Score: 1

      Actually, they make sure, you dont find the same model elsewhere, so that you cannot price match it.

    5. Re:Restocking fee by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually, Best Buy has a lot of models that you can't find anywhere else. You may be able to order a similar model online, but you won't know if the keyboard is the same.

      Wonderful. They're using the same trick bed and tire manufacturers do to avoid comparison shopping. Special models for each store so you're never sure if they're the same.

    6. Re:Restocking fee by xquercus · · Score: 2

      If I shop on NewEgg or Amazon, unlike at a brick and mortar store, I don't get a chance to try a laptop's screen and keyboard before I buy it.

      This is why Best Buy needs to change their name to Test Buy. Everyone knows that you go to Test Buy to test the model out before buying it from Newegg.

    7. Re:Restocking fee by Amouth · · Score: 1

      and you can use their "price match"

      --
      '...if only "Jumping to a Conclusion" was an event in the Olympics.'
    8. Re:Restocking fee by Niomosy · · Score: 1

      If I shop on NewEgg or Amazon, unlike at a brick and mortar store, I don't get a chance to try a laptop's screen and keyboard before I buy it.

      This is why Best Buy needs to change their name to Test Buy. Everyone knows that you go to Test Buy to test the model out before buying it from Amazon.

      FTFY. As a Californian, I don't feel like paying sales tax (and possibly shipping, depending on what deals are happening) on top of not getting it the day I buy it.

    9. Re:Restocking fee by DrXym · · Score: 2

      Generally, that's because Best Buy's models are made specially for them and usually use CHEAPER parts then the main stream model... I would NEVER buy a Best Buy model... that's just asking for problems...

      I doubt they use cheaper parts. They're just models specific to their store so they don't have to price match because no other store carries those models. Even if the only difference between their model and someone else's is a single letter.

    10. Re:Restocking fee by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      As someone living in Washington... I do/did just the opposite... largely quit buying from Amazon after moving here... now much more Newegg or elsewhere.

    11. Re:Restocking fee by PCM2 · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I doubt they use cheaper parts. They're just models specific to their store so they don't have to price match because no other store carries those models. Even if the only difference between their model and someone else's is a single letter.

      No, he's right. "Cheaper parts" makes it sound like they're buying them from the back room of some storefront in Hong Kong, and that's not the case. But Best Buy's models are designed to be cheaper.

      Wal-Mart does the same thing. If you buy a Dickies jacket at a regular store, it might have a pocket on the inside front and inside left of the jacket. If you buy it at Wal-Mart, it might only have a pocket on the inside left, and the name of the product might be slightly different, but otherwise it looks the same and it will cost $10 less than anywhere else.

      I bought a laptop from Best Buy and as near as I can tell the main difference is that most versions of that model come with a Core i5, while mine came with a Core i3. I made the judgment call that for a price that was roughly equivalent to what I paid for a Eee PC 901 with a single-core Atom processor a few years ago, Core i3 vs. Core i5 simply was not going to make any difference for what I actually use a laptop for.

      --
      Breakfast served all day!
    12. Re:Restocking fee by AK+Marc · · Score: 1

      That's how Wal-Mart does it. Best Buy's ones aren't for cost savings at the expense of the usability/reliability was Wal-Mart does, but instead to prevent price matching. You can't price match when no one else in the world sells that model.

      And Best Buy had a Toshiba laptop on special for about half what it was everywhere else that I bought, and their specials usually beat everywhere else.

      http://www.bestbuy.com/site/ASUS+-+Laptop+/+Intel%26%23174%3B+Core%26%23153%3B+i5+Processor+/+15.6%22+Display+/+4GB+Memory+/+500GB+Hard+Drive+-+Brown+Suit/2906406.p?skuId=2906406&id=1218362797990
      http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16834220991

      You can click both if you want. I looked up a Best Buy special and it was a laptop for $480, and Newegg has it for $600. So why pay more for Newegg?

    13. Re:Restocking fee by jdpars · · Score: 1

      We in Nashville eagerly await Amazon's move here.

    14. Re:Restocking fee by xquercus · · Score: 1

      Yeah but Californians are all one offs. 270 million Americans don't live in California.

    15. Re:Restocking fee by xquercus · · Score: 1

      As a former Washingtonian, I too used to avoid Amazon in favor of Newegg if possible.

    16. Re:Restocking fee by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Anything you can find at Best Buy you can also find on Amazon, for less.

    17. Re:Restocking fee by gknoy · · Score: 1

      The machines you linked are not the same specs, though. The CPU and dimensions are the same, but the drive space and ram differ. (The Best Buy one still appears to be a better value, though.)

      Best Buy ($480):
      - 500 GB hd
      - 4 GB ram

      Newegg ($700):
      - 640 GB hd
      - 6 GB ram

    18. Re:Restocking fee by Swave+An+deBwoner · · Score: 1

      And BB lists the warranty as 1 year while NE shows it as 2 years.

    19. Re:Restocking fee by slick7 · · Score: 1

      Actually, they make sure, you dont find the same model elsewhere, so that you cannot price match it.

      The only thing worse than buying a computer at Best Buy, is buying a Dell computer at Best Buy.

      --
      The mind conceives, the body achieves, the spirit manifests.
    20. Re:Restocking fee by pspahn · · Score: 1

      Nah, I recall that story from a year or so ago where BB was selling EEEPCs with the same model number I had just bought. I bought on newegg, and the BB model was actually a little cheaper. Come to find out, the BB model had a different (inferior) wifi adapter and no bluetooth, and I'm sure that wasn't all.

      --
      Someone flopped a steamer in the gene pool.
    21. Re:Restocking fee by baegucb · · Score: 1

      So how did all that working for Microsoft work out for you? ;)

    22. Re:Restocking fee by AK+Marc · · Score: 1

      Yeah, I just matched model for model. As pointed out elsewhere, Best Buy prefers to sell unique part numbers so that they'll never have to price match anyone else, and no consumer can ever take a Best Buy ad to another store and get price-matched. You want it, you have to go through Best Buy and pay what they are asking. So I'd have been surprised if the specs matched exactly, but I didn't purposefully pick ones with different specs. If there's another on NewEgg that's closer, please link it, it won't match the Best Buy price, which is the point. For specials, Best Buy is usually better. If you want decent laptop for cheap, the best way to get it is check weekly in Best Buy ads and get the closest to what you want out of there. Best Buy is almost always cheaper.

    23. Re:Restocking fee by NotQuiteReal · · Score: 1

      The models specific to their store... deal has been around for ages... often large appliances and mattresses, and ESPECIALLY places that advertise price matching for the same model number.

      But it does work both ways, sort of. I know I have seen items at Costco that have slightly different model numbers, probably to "protect" other sellers in the vendor's regular retail channels.

      --
      This issue is a bit more complicated than you think.
    24. Re:Restocking fee by xquercus · · Score: 1

      Close! A number of friends worked at MS but I was an AT&T guy when I was in Washington.

    25. Re:Restocking fee by arth1 · · Score: 1

      Amazon? Some of us old farts are still boycotting Amazon over US patent 5,960,411 (one-click shopping).

      And if I weren't already boycotting them, I would have started once they took down Wikileaks without notice because of a phone call from Joe Lieberman.

      To me, buying isn't just about getting the best deal. Who will get the money I spend, and what will they do with it? Those are important considerations.

    26. Re:Restocking fee by tqk · · Score: 1

      Wonderful. They're using the same trick bed and tire manufacturers do to avoid comparison shopping. Special models for each store so you're never sure if they're the same.

      Wait'll you end up with one, then a couple of years down the line when your battery dies, what's a new battery cost?

      BestBuy == DumbBuy. WorstBuy, SillyBuy, StupidBuy, ...

      My discussions with BB technical support (GeekSquad) have been like talking with two year old Win* HellDesk twits. Never again. Life's too short.

      --
      "Tongue tied and twisted, just an Earth bound misfit ..." -- Pink Floyd.
    27. Re:Restocking fee by tqk · · Score: 1

      and you can use their "price match"

      Honestly curious: Can you?

      My battery's dying. BB says ca. C$120 to replace it. On-line offers say ca. C$35. Can I really expect to end up only paying C$35 via BB's price match guarantee? What's the fine print say?

      --
      "Tongue tied and twisted, just an Earth bound misfit ..." -- Pink Floyd.
    28. Re:Restocking fee by AmiMoJo · · Score: 2

      Restocking fee? You need some stronger consumer laws. In the UK anything bought mail order, including from sites like Amazon, has a statutory 7 day 'cool-off' period where you can return it for a full refund. The only thing you lose is the cost of shipping either way, but since most places do free shipping on expensive items like laptops in practice you only end up paying the return postage costs.

      --
      const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)
      SJW, n: "Someone I don't like, and by the way I'm a fuckwit" - AC
    29. Re:Restocking fee by DrXym · · Score: 1

      Most laptops have a brand name, a major model number and then a sub model number which is a jumble of gobbledegook that describes exactly what processor, memory, colour, hdd and other things it has. So I expect if it came to it the store would have drawn your attention to the sub model data.

    30. Re:Restocking fee by Amouth · · Score: 1

      that should have been "can't", not "can" should have read it better in preview - my bad.

      BB's price match is based on UPC - not only that but it also has to be available at that moment. Considering that a lot of their products they get with a custom UPC they are basically committing false advertising and saving them selves in the small print.

      --
      '...if only "Jumping to a Conclusion" was an event in the Olympics.'
    31. Re:Restocking fee by kaatochacha · · Score: 1

      Yes, this is entirely fair. Whatever you think about Best Buy being asshats, using a store for a "Try" , then buying somewhere else is really just wrong. I'd be willing to cut you some slack if you went to another local shop, but internet sales: What are you gonna do when there ARE no more bricks and mortar stores. I used to work, years ago, at a ski shop that went out of business precisely because of this: people would come in for sales recommendations, then walk off somewhere cheaper to purchase.

  18. This is the problem by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    When the first choice in your head is to go to a big box store for a computer. You would have gotten less hassle, lower price, and fewer headaches direct shopping with an OEM or at an online store. BB is for the casual user who doesn't know anything and doesn't care about price.

  19. They also removed a coupon by ArhcAngel · · Score: 0

    They also removed the coupon for CompUSA.

    --
    "A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky dangerous animals and you know it." - K
    1. Re:They also removed a coupon by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I know this is a reference to what GameStop did, but you realize that CompUSA doesn't exist any more as anything but an extension of TigerDirect, right?

    2. Re:They also removed a coupon by HarrySquatter · · Score: 1

      [Rainier Wolfcastle mode

      That's the joke.

      [/Rainier Wolfcastle mode

    3. Re:They also removed a coupon by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      CompUSA existed in 2009 as in when this story was written.

    4. Re:They also removed a coupon by ArhcAngel · · Score: 1

      I knew I should have referenced Circuit City instead!

      --
      "A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky dangerous animals and you know it." - K
  20. For some time now by ohcrapitssteve · · Score: 4, Informative

    Back in highschool, I worked in Geek Squad before it was called Geek Squad (we just wore black polo shirts instead of blue, and we were called "Tech Services") and can confirm they've been doing this for more than a decade now.

    1. Re:For some time now by Rinnon · · Score: 1

      Seconded. I worked in Geek Squad here in Canada in 2006 and we did this with every single computer as it came through the register. Opened, setup the user profile, turned on Auto Updates and firewalls, confirmed everything worked, put it back in the box. We didn't do it in advance though, just as a computer was sold, to ensure it wasn't a lemon. We didn't install anything additional though. The trials of Anti viruses came from the Manufacturer.

    2. Re:For some time now by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I was a PC tech when they transitioned from the green shirt to the black shirt (worst job ever!). Black shirts apparently made the "sheeple" think we were smarter. They did these checks 10 years ago allegedly to prevent returns for defective products (and were supposedly paid by the manufacturers to do so), but it was done after the sale back then and it was always optional. I just bought a laptop at Best Buy 3 weeks ago and they no longer do this.

    3. Re:For some time now by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      So Worst Buy has been selling used computers as new for decades?!. If the box is opened before the customer gets the laptop it is used, not new! We are lucky enough not to have a worst buy store within 50 miles of where I live.

      My name is Nonya F. Biznes
      Email: nonya@nonya.org
      Address: 123 Nostreet
      Notown, FU 77342-090

    4. Re:For some time now by Bob+the+Super+Hamste · · Score: 2

      Geek Squad was originally an independent repair shop until they were bought up by Best Buy. Early on Geek Squad was a quality outfit but that was back in the mid 90's and before they were bought by Best buy they had started to do some of the dodgy stuff but it really took off once purchased by BB. I would agree that Best Buy's Tech Services always sucked and was dodgy at best. In the mid 90's they were charging $50 to install RAM and me and a buddy always joked that we should set up shop in a van outside and offer hardware install services for half of what best buy was charging.

      --
      Time to offend someone
    5. Re:For some time now by ohcrapitssteve · · Score: 2

      Yep, we were told the same thing. We even had a tracking SKU for the setup to, I guess, prove to mfgrs that we did it (though we could have just as easily not done it and ran the track SKU anyway.) I did it because it was easy, and I didn't mind doing it, and it killed 5 minutes that I'd normally be forced out to the sales floor to try and sell our services. So I actually did quite thorough inspections of customer machines in order to kill as much time as possible, haha.... tested CD ROM drive, removed pack-in crapware, tested the AC adapter, turned on the pre-installed anti-virus, the whole nine. That job was pretty easy and actually got a lot less stressful if you just built a little rapport with the customers and tried to help them, because really, you got paid the same whether you were an ass or actually tried, and most customers were pretty cool. Made the time go faster, I thought. Something the current gen Geek Squaders seem to know nothing about.

  21. Check your receipt by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

    This was standard practice when I had the unfortunate experience of working for Geek Squad. They would have us do some 'pre-setup' units that would also have a 'pre-installed services' bundle attached at the register.

    If it was the only unit left, and you didn't want this service, you could get them to remove the cost by complaining, but otherwise they'd get you a unit that wasn't 'pre-setup'.

    Of course they're going to hand you the pre-setup one if you dont specify, and don't check...

    1. Re:Check your receipt by drcagn · · Score: 1

      This is going to depend on individual store policy. At the store I work at, we attempt to sell the client the PC Setup, and if they don't want the service and that's all the stock we have left, we give it to them for free.

      Some stores are obviously more shady than others. It's up to individual store management.

      I would never ring up a client's PC purchase and scan the PC Setup SKU without discussing it with the client first.

      --
      Scorta futuere amo!
  22. Re:do people still buy from brick & mortar ? by couchslug · · Score: 1

    My first and last store-bought PCs were two eMachine Celeron 400s in 1999. (They lasted about ten years after I passed them on and one still works, amazing for an eMachine!)

    The only things I buy with an installed OS are notebooks, and I make recovery media for my collection then wipe 'em to install Linux.

    --
    "This post is an artistic work of fiction and falsehood. Only a fool would take anything posted here as fact."
  23. Drivers by tepples · · Score: 0

    Geez, wipe the darn thing and install Linux.

    Only after you've determined that all the components have working Linux drivers. Otherwise, you might be left with no Wi-Fi, no Bluetooth, no OpenGL, or a system that doesn't come out of sleep or hibernation.

    1. Re:Drivers by jedidiah · · Score: 1

      > Only after you've determined that all the components have working Linux drivers.

      That's easy enough with a LiveCD or thumbdrive.

      --
      A Pirate and a Puritan look the same on a balance sheet.
    2. Re:Drivers by h4rr4r · · Score: 1

      You do that before you buy it.
      I hear this complaint over and over, all it says is that the person was too stupid to check first.

    3. Re:Drivers by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      But this is exactly what the freetard wants. Otherwise he won't have anything to spend him time on. The freetard loves spending days fucking with howto manuals and shit like this.

    4. Re:Drivers by Methuseus · · Score: 1

      Had the wifi work on one laptop with the Live CD, but wouldn't work in the full install with a whole lot of wrangling. This was about 4 years ago, but still a weird issue.

      --
      Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity, though I'm not yet sure about the universe. - A Einstein
  24. You get to pay extra for this by spacepimp · · Score: 0

    In BestBuy they call this a service and add something like $75 dollars to the sale price. They claim to remove the crapware installed by the factory, and create the recovery discs etc. I had a friend who needed a PC immediately and upon trying to buy a PC he was told that the ones they had left had all had this service done to them. When i told them that it was extra work for me to rebuild the machine, as I can't trust their tech to be honest and demanded that they not only strip the price of their un requested service, but that they give me a discount on the computer for making me have to start the computer from scratch. They knocked another 50 off the price of the computer for my friend. Its a shame that the average consumer should have to suffer this used car salesman BS. If my friend wasn't in a time crunch I would have driven the hour away to MicroCenter. BestBuy you're just making yourselves look bad.

  25. truth by shentino · · Score: 1

    At least they're honest about opening it.

    Unlike a certain game company that's fond of opening boxes and pilfering coupons...

  26. Is this really a problem? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I really don't see the issue here. BestBuy sells laptops to people who often don't know the first thing about computers. I think it's good that they check everything out before it gets to the end user and take the time to create the recovery disks (something users never do and lament when it dies). I suspect they get a kickback from Trend, although everyone should have an antivirus so I'm not to perturbed by that one either. It would be nice if they put a free one on there, but I understand them going with a paid one with a free trial.

    I just think this is an over-reaction to a pretty solid move on BestBuy's part. If you don't want a computer with kid's gloves, then why are you buying from BestBuy in the first place??

  27. Informed you are not. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Its called a PC-Setup and Restore. We (Im a Geek Squad Agent) setup the computer (perform system updates, tweaks, create restore discs, and install the anti-virus) so you can take it home and get right to work. We are not magicians and therefore must open the packaging to perform the work. We do charge extra for the services but considering the consumer benefits, its understandable and not unreasonable. I would have thought someone with ties to Slashdot would be alot less ignorant. We still offer computers unopened and unserviced. Next time, pay attention to what you purchase.

    Agent Anonymous

    1. Re:Informed you are not. by PPH · · Score: 2

      Yep. I went to BB with my dad to buy him a new PC. They explicitly offered this setup service, which we declined. I'm perfectly capable of doing this kind of stuff myself.

      Like the AC says: Next time, pay attention to what you purchase.

      --
      Have gnu, will travel.
  28. Best Buy's Customer != Newegg's Customer by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Honestly, I think they're probably doing a favor to most of their clientele. Considering that they don't price themselves to sell anything to people who know how to use Google, they probably have a reasonable expectation that most of their customers have trouble setting up user profiles, making recovery disks, and installing antivirus software.

  29. Best Buy? by kwiqsilver · · Score: 5, Funny

    Do You Want Best Buy Opening Your New Laptop?

    No, I don't. And I'd hope the security at the Apple Store is good enough to keep the Best Buy guys out!

    1. Re:Best Buy? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Do You Want Best Buy Opening Your New Laptop?

      No, I don't. And I'd hope the security at the Apple Store is good enough to keep the Best Buy guys out!

      Staples does the same thing.

    2. Re:Best Buy? by Osgeld · · Score: 1

      My local best buy sells apple =0

    3. Re:Best Buy? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The only reason that this was marked with that type of sticker was you must of bought a display model which they restored and
      loaded the extra stuff or you let thier techs handle it after a purchase.

    4. Re:Best Buy? by Just+Some+Guy · · Score: 1

      You joke, but Best Buy is actually my closest Apple dealer by quite a few miles. Still, it's not so much closer that I wouldn't drive the extra distance to get an un-screwed-with Mac fresh from the Apple store. The additional drive time is less than I'd spend at home wiping the drive and reinstalling the OS from media (yes, even with Lion) so I could be sure I was getting everything and only what Cupertino wanted me to have. Nuts to that. I have better things to do with my time.

      --
      Dewey, what part of this looks like authorities should be involved?
    5. Re:Best Buy? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Do You Want Best Buy Opening Your New Laptop?

      No, I don't. And I'd hope the security at the Apple Store is good enough to keep the Best Buy guys out!

      Where I live the "Apple Store" is inside the Best Buy. Sorry to burst your bubble there...

  30. Re:Why... by Grizzley9 · · Score: 2

    is this news?

    It's more history than news, considering this article is from 2009 . But lately that time scale seems par for the course. /. quality is declining.

  31. Video cam manipulation by GodfatherofSoul · · Score: 1

    I read a story from a girl who took her laptop in to Best Buy for work (Geek Squad?) and found that the video cam was routing output to one of their addresses. I never use mine and it's something I would have never even considered checking.

    --
    I swear to God...I swear to God! That is NOT how you treat your human!
    1. Re:Video cam manipulation by surferx0 · · Score: 1

      I read a story from a girl who took her laptop in to Best Buy for work (Geek Squad?) and found that the video cam was routing output to one of their addresses. I never use mine and it's something I would have never even considered checking.

      Yeah that story sounds about as credible as the in-home Geek Squad technician who was supposedly video taping some girl in the shower with his phone that she got hold of and then deleted the video (oops) before anyone of any authority was able to see and verify it.

      As a former employee of that company, I can understand the hate. But much of the hate is misdirected. The technicians don't want to waste their time opening up computers and "optimizing" them anymore than you want your item to be opened before you get it. These kind of initiatives come from above even the store management. Ask the manager for address of the district office and write a letter to them, that's the only way you are going to reach anyone with any kind of say in the what the store is actually doing.

    2. Re:Video cam manipulation by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I read a story from a girl who took her laptop in to Best Buy for work (Geek Squad?) and found that the video cam was routing output to one of their addresses. I never use mine and it's something I would have never even considered checking.

      References? Pics or it didn't happen!

    3. Re:Video cam manipulation by aztrailerpunk · · Score: 1

      You're getting real life mixed up with an episode of "Warehouse 13".

      --
      Foot placed squarely in mouth since 1983.
    4. Re:Video cam manipulation by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Isn't there a light on the cam that lets you know it's on?
      If you could cite this occurrence I might believe it but it sounds more like libel.

    5. Re:Video cam manipulation by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Aaron's was caught doing this, but the only reference I could find to Best Buy was the GP post.

    6. Re:Video cam manipulation by GodfatherofSoul · · Score: 1

      It happened to a girl who regularly posts to a local forum, so I have no reason to doubt her story.

      --
      I swear to God...I swear to God! That is NOT how you treat your human!
  32. Blech. by L1B3R4710N · · Score: 1

    I'd be pissed off, honestly. Too bad the only computer stores in my area are OfficeMax and Best Buy. :(

    --
    "...the number of UNIX installations has grown to 10, with more expected..." - Dennis Ritchie/Ken Thompson, 1972
  33. Two laptops... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I bought a laptop from BB and specifically choose a laptop that had not been "optimized". But my step-daughter bought one that was optimized - but all they seemed to have done is install some BB software. No recovery disk or anything - we ended up creating that ourselves.

  34. Re:do people still buy from brick & mortar ? by Hijacked+Public · · Score: 1

    I haven't either, but every time I walk past the Apple store here it is slam full of people, plenty of whom walk out having bought something.

    Apple makes a laptop, a netbook, a tablet, a couple of different music players, and a phone. That is it more or less, so I can't figure what those people are all in there doing. But never the less they are in there.

    --
    "Sacrifice for the good of The State" - The State
  35. Re:Why... by erroneus · · Score: 1

    It's news because a LOT of people still don't know about BestBuy and the crap they pull on an unsuspecting public. I have had people at my office come to me AFTER BestBuy people hosed them and their machines over. There are many things I have heard which I am sure cannot be legal.

  36. Re:Why... by linear+a · · Score: 1

    CmdrTaco is gone, we're doomed.

  37. Re:Why... by Grizzley9 · · Score: 1

    And it was submitted by an AC no less, so not even blank trusted they editors to push through. Timothy, do you check anything?

  38. Re:Why... by sh00z · · Score: 1

    The news is that in 2011, the vendor is taking something out of the package, claiming that the manufacturer is unfairly competing.

  39. Re:Why... by interval1066 · · Score: 1

    CmdrTaco is gone, we're doomed.

    (scenes of chaos and mayhem ensue...)

    --
    Python: 'And then suddenly you have a language which says "we're all stuck with whatever the whiniest coder wants".'
  40. best buy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    that means you purchased a floor model. they load all bunch of proprietary software on there for demonstration and create usernames. When they sell those floor models they are supposed to remove all of the stuff they loaded but that doesnt always happen. I used to work in the pc department and had items returned just like this all the time. OR it was returned by a previous customer either way it wasnt new and you should receive at 10% discount at minimum.

  41. Anti Competitive by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Best Buy is opening laptops to remove products that would compete with their Geek Squad services... antivirus, things like that- they want to make sure you're only getting their partnered software rather than OEM bundles.

  42. how to use best buy warranties by KWTm · · Score: 3, Interesting

    had a camera covered by Best Buy warranty, one of those point-and-clicks (Canon Powershot SD400 or something). After a while, something mechanical failed --either the lens barrel wouldn't extend/retract, or the lens cover wouldn't close up. Also the slider switch (to select Photo/Video/Playback) was loose. It was covered by the 4-year warranty, so I went to Best Buy and they took it and sent it back for repair.

    After a month, repair dept sent it back to my local store, and I picked it up. It was exactly the same: mechanical failure, loose slider switch. I showed the staff at Best Buy, that it was malfunctioning and I hadn't even walked out of the store after picking up the camera. So they sent it back for repairs a second time.

    After another month, repair dept sent it back again. Again it was exactly the same, so I told the staff, WTF?? THey said they'd check. After a while, someone called and said, the repair dept could tell that I had damaged the camera, so the repair wasn't covered. What!? I spent almost an hour on the phone with some Best Buy headquarters person, saying, Hey, I just sent it back a 2nd time after having gotten it back from your repair department, and the 1st time there was no mention of damage, so it must have been the repair department that damaged it! (I was confident that it had not been I who damaged it.) The guy said that just because they send it back the first time it doesn't mean that they guarantee that it's in good condition, so it was perfectly valid to say that the 2nd time it was in crappy condition because it was already that way when they sent it back the 1st time.

    I said, fine, what about the slider switch that was loose? The guy said, it was already loose, as I had given in my statement the first time I sent it in. That's when it struck me: if I had *NOT* told them about the slider switch, then *THEY* would have been responsible for fixing it since it would seem that they had damaged it during the repair process.

    It was maddening, but finally I found a reason to send it back (I remember now: the first time the lens had gotten stuck in the retracted position, and now I could say that it was stuck in the extended position) and it went back. Of course it came back unrepaired, and I ranted and raved at the local Best Buy, saying that I had been missing my camera for 3 months now (in fact, it was a big deal since we had a birth in the family and I had wanted to take pictures). The local staff quietly upgraded to --well, an equivalent camera, but of course the model number had advanced since the 3+ years since buying the malfunctioning camera.

    Lesson: if there is more than one thing wrong with the camera, do NOT mention anything else wrong. Gives you more leverage when they try to send it back saying that repair is not covered, and you can say, "What about this here thing wrong? Did you cause this?"

    Maddening.

    --
    404555974007725459910684486621289147856453481154 in hex is "You sank my Battleship?"
    [GPG key in journal]
    1. Re:how to use best buy warranties by MightyMartian · · Score: 2

      The real lesson here is that non-manufacturer extended warranties or a horrible, expensive scam.

      --
      The world's burning. Moped Jesus spotted on I50. Details at 11.
    2. Re:how to use best buy warranties by MarkGriz · · Score: 1

      That's how to use a BestBuy warranty?!!!

      Sounds more like why you should avoid BestBuy at all costs.

      --
      Beauty is in the eye of the beerholder.
    3. Re:how to use best buy warranties by tedgyz · · Score: 1

      Absolutely! Why do they push the extended warranty so hard? Because it is profit$ for them. FSCK EXTENDED WARRANTIES!!!

      --
      "No matter where you go, there you are." -- Buckaroo Banzai
    4. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Caerdwyn · · Score: 1

      If you're buying a digital camera, B&H have excellent prices and no-BS warranty policies.

      --
      Everybody gets what the majority deserves.
    5. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Just+Some+Guy · · Score: 3, Funny

      A conversation between a friend and a Best Buy employee:

      Friend: I need to return this.
      CS Rep: What's wrong with it?
      Friend: It doesn't work anymore.
      CS Rep: It's out of warranty.
      Friend: But I bought the extended warranty.
      CS Rep: It looks like normal wear and tear. That's not covered.
      Friend: Is accidental damage?
      CS Rep: [checks warranty text] Ummm, yeah.
      Friend: So if I leave here and trip in the parking lot and it shatters into a million pieces and I accidentally slip while getting up and kick the shit out of it, it'd be covered?
      CS Rep: Ummmm.....
      Friend: See where I'm going with this?
      CS Rep: I'll start the replacement process.
      Friend: Knew you would.

      You just have to know how to ask properly.

      --
      Dewey, what part of this looks like authorities should be involved?
    6. Re:how to use best buy warranties by jcoy42 · · Score: 1

      You forgot to add hopefully I wouldn't become badly injured on your property..

      --
      Never trust an atom. They make up everything.
    7. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Just+Some+Guy · · Score: 1

      By that point, they were pretty eager to get us out the door and on with our business.

      --
      Dewey, what part of this looks like authorities should be involved?
    8. Re:how to use best buy warranties by LordKronos · · Score: 2

      Lesson: if there is more than one thing wrong with the camera, do NOT mention anything else wrong. Gives you more leverage when they try to send it back saying that repair is not covered, and you can say, "What about this here thing wrong? Did you cause this?"

      What the hell kind of lesson is that? So your idea is, 2 things break, you send it back and only mention 1 thing? Ok, so when you mention the first thing, they take your camera for a month, and even if they successfully fix it, the 2nd thing is still broken and you've got to send it back for another month. Sounds like a great plan.

    9. Re:how to use best buy warranties by wgoodman · · Score: 1

      I had a similar experience with a car stereo at BB. I had purchased it open box so I decided to get the warranty. After a year or so it stopped playing discs at all so I took it in. A month later got it back still broken, a month later, the same. The third time it came back broken, I asked for them to replace it with a new "equivalent" model per the terms. Their manager told me that since I had gotten it open box, I would be allowed to choose another model in the $120 range as opposed to the ~$300 range that would be considered a similar product. Of course they only had an $80 stereo and a $150 stereo at that time so I was stuck with the crappiest stereo they carried. When I raised a stink about them refusing to at least refund/store credit the other $50 since I was already getting rather screwed by the deal, they had security kick me out.

      Have not, and will not ever give Best Buy another penny of my money.

      (On a previous trip, I was told that I could not write a check to pay for a camera. They could verify that there were funds in the account, but since they apparently don't consider a passport valid ID, they refused to accept it)

    10. Re:how to use best buy warranties by n7ytd · · Score: 1

      You had a 4 year old camera that could be substantially upgraded by purchasing a new camera today for less than $100. It's obvious what their tactic was: frustrate you to the point that you gave up and went away. They weren't going to spend any of their precious time and money to fix your obsolete camera.

      I'd always thought that extended warranties are a sucker's bet. Then, my brother-in-law explained to me how he ended up with three new laptops on Best Buy's dime when they kept breaking after the current model went out of stock.

    11. Re:how to use best buy warranties by DogDude · · Score: 2

      The lesson should be: don't shop at Best Buy! Seriously... why in the HELL would you give them more money? Are you bored? Wealthy? Brain damaged? What would it take for you stop stop shopping there?

      I have a feeling that if you walked in the store and an employee shot you with a gun, that you'd post saying, "The lesson is: next time you go into Best Buy, wear a bulletproof vest"!

      --
      I don't respond to AC's.
    12. Re:how to use best buy warranties by gknoy · · Score: 1

      I thought passports were legally required to be considered valid ID?

    13. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Belial6 · · Score: 1

      It's not like manufacturer warranties are necessarily better. I have two identical Gateway computers that I got at Costco sitting here, and they both exhibit the same problem of rebooting if the weather gets up to about 78 degrees. The only reason I considered the computers was because Costco had their name on the box offering a second year warranty.

      Gateway says that I can keep shipping it in to them for them to test the system, but all they do is turn it on and let it run for an hour. If it doesn't fail within an hour, they pack it up and ship it back to you. Costco's response to this is that they will have someone in their call center sit on the phone with you while the Gateway India call center explains to you that a one hour test is testing everything, but you can ship it back in again, and they will test it another time.

    14. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      One word... SquareTrade.com. Cheaper and better service than anything you can get at Worst Buy.

    15. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Swave+An+deBwoner · · Score: 1

      Their manager told me that since I had gotten it open box, I would be allowed to choose another model in the $120 range as opposed to the ~$300 range that would be considered a similar product.

      A letter to your City/State Consumer Affairs office and an online complaint to bbb.org would have probably cleared that right up for you. Best Buy bets that the typical customer won't bother.

    16. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Khyber · · Score: 1

      They are, and any place that doesn't accept it is in violation of Full Faith and Credit.

      --
      Still waiting on Serviscope_minor to wake up to fucking reality and realize that Jessica Price isn't going to fuck him.
    17. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I think the lesson is not to buy the Best Buy warranty and to replace your camera once you break it. How many months would you have been without your camera then? ZERO.

    18. Re:how to use best buy warranties by toddestan · · Score: 1

      Normal wear and tear not covered? Isn't that the whole point of the warranty - that if the device breaks from normal use in the warranty period that it will be repaired or replaced free of charge? What a scam.

    19. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Just+Some+Guy · · Score: 1

      It's been a lot of years so please don't hold me to the exact details, but that was the gist of it. Wear and tear is different from manufacturing defects. For example, shoes wear out. If you buy a pair of Nikes and run the tread off them, they won't be covered under warranty. The warranty covers things like the sole falling off.

      --
      Dewey, what part of this looks like authorities should be involved?
    20. Re:how to use best buy warranties by tibit · · Score: 1

      BBB is another scam. Completely pointless. No teeth at all. All good it can do for you is being an outdated place to post negative reviews of businesses. Spare yourself the hassle. Forget they exist.

      --
      A successful API design takes a mixture of software design and pedagogy.
    21. Re:how to use best buy warranties by tibit · · Score: 1

      Agreed. I stopped going there a year ago or so. Microcenter FTW.

      --
      A successful API design takes a mixture of software design and pedagogy.
    22. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Aryden · · Score: 1

      That's the problem, Gateway (HP in disguise). I've never met a Gateway box that I didn't hate and that's after many many MANY years working in repair shops. Not all MFG warranties are bunk. I've been buying Samsung monitors for a while now not just because they've been a good price, but because anytime there is EVER an issue, I hit their support site, get a ticket in, get my mailing label and usually have a new monitor within a week to 10 days. I'm not talking about just MFG defects either. One monitor I sent back developed a dead pixel, while the 2nd I sent back was basically 4 pieces from getting knocked off my desk and shattered. They replaced both with no questions asked.

    23. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Aryden · · Score: 1

      There are a shitload of places that don't accept passports as ID. My girlfriend and one of her friends and I have all had issues using their passports as ID's. Bank of America wouldn't accept mine as ID when my wallet was stolen and hadn't had to time to go to the DMV and get a new license.

    24. Re:how to use best buy warranties by dakohli · · Score: 1

      That's the problem, Gateway (HP in disguise). I've never met a Gateway box that I didn't hate and that's after many many MANY years working in repair shops.

      Nope, Gateway is owned by Acer. I have had many laptops/netbooks over the years, and HP seems to be the winner for quality. We use HP products in our shop, and their business warranties are second to none.

    25. Re:how to use best buy warranties by trparky · · Score: 1

      What about SquareTrade.com? I've heard they have good reviews for their extended warranty. Better and cheaper than anything you can get at those Big Box Stores.

    26. Re:how to use best buy warranties by flonker · · Score: 1

      My family bought 3 HP Laptops. 2 of them lost both their power supply and battery very shortly after the warranty expired. The third one lost both power supply and battery during the warranty period, and was repaired under warranty. That third one then had a motherboard failure in warranty, was shipped to HP, and they held on to it for 2 months until the warranty expired, then shipped it back, unfixed.

      Of course, these are consumer models, and you said "business".

    27. Re:how to use best buy warranties by EvilJoker · · Score: 1

      Send an e-mail to your state Attorney General. This can be surprisingly effective- when the Ohio AG (where I live) was suing OfficeMax *AND* BB for not paying mail-in rebates, one of them denied me a (small) rebate, but I kept good records. I filed a complaint online (fairly easy), mostly just so that when they went to trial, there would be one more sheet in the stack of complaints.

      3 weeks later, I got my rebate check.

      Failing that, contact the local news, and try to get on their "Channel ___ on your side"

    28. Re:how to use best buy warranties by DrSlinky · · Score: 1

      Lesson: if there is more than one thing wrong with the camera, do NOT mention anything else wrong. Gives you more leverage when they try to send it back saying that repair is not covered, and you can say, "What about this here thing wrong? Did you cause this?"

      Maddening.

      No, the lesson is if you're willing to make a spectacle of yourself inside their stores, most managers will replace your warrantied item with store stock, just to shut you up and get you out of the store. Works at Best Buy. Works at Apple stores. Worked in Circuit City. Squeaky wheel gets the greasing, and such.

    29. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Khyber · · Score: 1

      Then they are in violation of a Federal Act and you need to let the proper authorities know.

      --
      Still waiting on Serviscope_minor to wake up to fucking reality and realize that Jessica Price isn't going to fuck him.
    30. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Swave+An+deBwoner · · Score: 1

      I have been successful 2 out of 3 times with BBB complaints (all of which dealt with rebates that were improperly denied). The successes were with Parago and TigerDirect ($20 and $30 respectively, last year and this year); the failure was with "The Express Group" for $150 back in 2007. FWIW, "The Express Group" is no longer in business :-)

      So you're correct that BBB can't force the company to do anything, but at least some companies try to settle reasonably to keep up a good BBB score (and yes, I know about the reports of BBB giving "A" ratings to companies that paid for them).

      In the case above, I don't see how it could have hurt to make a complaint with BBB and it might have helped. The online complaint form is relatively painless to fill out and in my three experiences the BBB folks did indeed contact the companies and state my case; not only that but they went back two or three times in the case of The Express Group to relay my replies to TEG regarding their replies to me.

    31. Re:how to use best buy warranties by mjwx · · Score: 1

      had a camera covered by Best Buy warranty

      third party warranties == expensive toilet paper.

      I live in Oz and there isn't a Best Buy in 14,000 KM's of here but I know that, any store offering a third party warranty is offering a scam. I thought it was common knowledge.

      It was covered by the 4-year warranty, so I went to Best Buy and they took it and sent it back for repair.

      Here's the second thing, if you have to get something repaired, deal with the manufacturer yourself.

      I once had a user who bought a HP Compaq (he wasn't too bright) and a thrid party warranty from Harvey Norman (a national big box retailer in OZ, did I mention this user wasn't too bright). The HP broke after 9 months so he took it back to the retailer, he was jerked around for another 9 months (in that time, he bought another laptop) until it was fixed.

      --
      Calling someone a "hater" only means you can not rationally rebut their argument.
    32. Re:how to use best buy warranties by k31bang · · Score: 1

      I don't know if they still offer them, but the replacement plans were always nice. Broken xbox, just bring it in and get an instant replacement. Thats about the only kind of plan I pay into.

      --
      -+-=-+-=-+-=-+-=-+-=-+ *** http://www.mountainfort.com *** +-=-+-=-+-=-+-=-+-=-+-
    33. Re:how to use best buy warranties by AmiMoJo · · Score: 1

      Any extended warranty is a horrible, expensive scam. Just get home contents insurance and make sure it covers mobile electronics (cameras, laptops etc.)

      --
      const int one = 65536; (Silvermoon, Texture.cs)
      SJW, n: "Someone I don't like, and by the way I'm a fuckwit" - AC
    34. Re:how to use best buy warranties by dakohli · · Score: 1
      I'll give you this one flonker, I'm willing to say that all consumer grade laptops have their share of problems. Earlier I said that HP was the winner for quality, and I am willing to step back from that. If you are willing to pay absolute top price for yesterday's specs, put up with weird driver requirements then Panasonic Toughbooks should be the undisputed Kings.

      I have seen them used in a Military Aviation Environment both on Aircraft and on the Ground (in the mud). One word: Awesome!

    35. Re:how to use best buy warranties by black+soap · · Score: 1

      I had a statistics professor who used to do industrial QA/QC. He offered any of his students a deal: if they bought a new computer at best buy, he would sell them an extended warranty for half the price of best buy's extended warranty. He was quite confident that with modern manufacturing, anything that failed would either fail immediately, break within the regular warranty, or far outlast the extended warranty. The extended warranty is just free money to the retailer.

    36. Re:how to use best buy warranties by SteveFoerster · · Score: 1

      What if they're not U.S. passports? wgoodman didn't specify. My wife occasionally had a hard time using her foreign passport for things before she got her greencard.

      --
      Space game using normal deck of cards: http://BattleCards.org
    37. Re:how to use best buy warranties by RobertLTux · · Score: 1

      back when i had a gas station job for us to be able to take a passport it had to be readable by US (so it had to have english text on it (with the normal "Native" text of course) but otherwise that it was of nonUS issue was a Non-Issue.

      The general policy was if you were decent about things we would be also (we would give some leeway about certain things if you were understanding about certain things.

      Just a few hints folks If you give us a large bill then expect to be spending at least a third of that bill and WE ARE A PREPAY STATION SO NO CASH NO GAS (you can do CC at the pump or postpay if we can hold your card while you shop in the store if you are also getting gas).

      --
      Any person using FTFY or editing my postings agrees to a US$50.00 charge
    38. Re:how to use best buy warranties by networkBoy · · Score: 1

      I got my BB extended accidental damage warranty free.
      I bought an open box video camera, and the store had lost the packing materials.
      I got them to discount the camera (beyond the already open box discount & last year's model discount) by the cost of the warranty (with the provision that I'd buy the warranty).

      They don't really care about the price of the camera, it was a display and needed to be disposed of. What they cared about was showing they "sold" another warranty.

      --
      whois gawk date unzip strip find touch finger mount join nice man top fsck grep eject more yes exit umount sleep dump
    39. Re:how to use best buy warranties by networkBoy · · Score: 1

      no then you claim they caused the second thing and make them fix it, while eating the cost of the first repair because now you're out a camera for two months. (hmmmm ethics?)

      --
      whois gawk date unzip strip find touch finger mount join nice man top fsck grep eject more yes exit umount sleep dump
    40. Re:how to use best buy warranties by norminator · · Score: 1

      Then, my brother-in-law explained to me how he ended up with three new laptops on Best Buy's dime when they kept breaking after the current model went out of stock.

      It's still a bad deal... Yeah he may have gotten 3 new laptops, but always at the expense of the previous one breaking, plus all the hassle to try to return it and actually get them to give you a replacement. Also, that's 3 new laptops to set up from scratch and get just the way you like it, only to have it break soon afterwards. Maybe I'm just getting old, but I'd rather have a reliable computer that lasts a long time and doesn't make me fight with it than always have shiny new toys that are going to fall apart soon.

    41. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Chuckstar · · Score: 1

      There is no federal act requiring companies to accept a passport as ID for purposes of paying by check. Companies can set their own policies as to whether and under what circumstances they accept checks (as long as they are not discriminating based on race, creed, sex, etc.)

    42. Re:how to use best buy warranties by Khyber · · Score: 1

      Learn what Full Faith and Credit means and implies. Identification from one government entity being accepted by another government entity is in there.

      "states within the United States have to respect the "public acts, records, and judicial proceedings of every other state.""

      Records including your fucking passport.

      Back to school for you.

      --
      Still waiting on Serviscope_minor to wake up to fucking reality and realize that Jessica Price isn't going to fuck him.
    43. Re:how to use best buy warranties by toddestan · · Score: 1

      Obviously items that are meant to wear like the soles of your shoes or break pads are usually not covered by a warranty. But on a camera, the only thing I might consider a "wear item" like would be the rechargeable battery. Things like switches and lens motors of course can wear out, but that those aren't really consider wear items so I would expect the warranty would cover that kind of thing.

    44. Re:how to use best buy warranties by n7ytd · · Score: 1

      It's still a bad deal... Yeah he may have gotten 3 new laptops, but always at the expense of the previous one breaking, plus all the hassle to try to return it and actually get them to give you a replacement. Also, that's 3 new laptops to set up from scratch and get just the way you like it, only to have it break soon afterwards. Maybe I'm just getting old, but I'd rather have a reliable computer that lasts a long time and doesn't make me fight with it than always have shiny new toys that are going to fall apart soon.

      I completely agree. My brother-in-law was gleefully telling me how he kept getting these new laptops, and in the back of my mind, I was thinking, "boy, you are getting some crappy hardware if it breaks this often." Also important to note was that the warranty did not cover any data recovery, so at each replacement incident, he shelled out $129 or whatever the Geek Squad charges to pull the drive and copy the data to the new computer. Apparently regular backups are key to working the Best Buy laptop warranty system.

  43. Sure it wasn't an open item? by chaboud · · Score: 1

    Sounds like you may have gotten an item that had been set up by Geek squad and then dumped. That, or someone is boosting attachment numbers. Good luck returning the machine that *they* opened.

    Back when I worked at Best Buy (15 years ago), my manager would send us to a back room to re-shrink-wrap returned merchandise. A lot of time has passed since, but it seems that Best Buy still incentivizes bad behavior.

  44. I used to work for Geek Squad.. by intellitech · · Score: 5, Informative

    I used to work for Best Buy Geek Squad (about 3 years ago, and for almost 5 years before that), starting when I was a sophomore in high school. And, I do hear this a lot, but not every "kid" that worked for a big box electronic store was terrible at their job. Geek Squad, yes, I know, I know. But that was a different time for me, so don't hate on it too much.

    Anyway, I can personally tell you that we saw at least 1 DOA laptop for every 20 we sold (a certain brand or two I won't name that sold for cheap accounted for most of them). That being said, customers, especially the grumpy I'm-entitled-to-everything suburban kind, do not like getting home, opening their new laptop, and seeing either a blue screen or nothing at all. It pissed off the customer, and then usually the store ends up losing more money because of people who demand to be compensated for the time they spent bring the computer back to the store. Remember, computers don't have a high profit margin, so giving away anything more than 5-10% on a computer which usually end up in a loss for the store. You may have your qualms with this practice, but it keeps their average customer satisfaction up.

    Now, in addition to that, I would also like to point out that when I was working for Geek Squad, we weren't installing trial versions of anything on there. In fact, back in the day, we used to do a free performance upgrade (registry fixes, bloatware startup-item removal, etc). I'm not sure why this particular part of the process has changed, but I'm sure there's a marketing reason for it.

    Besides, the only people this would really irk is the extreme power user crowd (us), and most of us are wise enough (hopefully) to buy our electronics elsewhere, anyway.

    --
    vos nescitis quicquam, nec cogitatis quia expedit nobis ut unus moriatur homo pro populo et non tota gens pereat.
    1. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I think that's the idea: If your laptops die so often that the returned items cancel out the the margins, and you have to resort to shady tactics to keep up a profit, expect to be put out of the market.

    2. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by dummptyhummpty · · Score: 1

      That's actually a good point (DOA). I forgot to mention that in my post below. It's weird your store did that for free, we charged $29 for ours, but this was late 2005-2007.

    3. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1
      Really? Just go away.

      Defending Best Buy and their practices? That's just sick.

      I worked for Best Buy about 10 years ago, in their tech dept. (This was before the Geek Squad branding) I was able to stand about 2-3 months there. It was a second job to pay for furniture and stuff in the new apartment. Everyone knew that I knew far more about computers than anyone in that store. Even a decade ago, they were pushing this "optimization" crap and it was completely worthless. It was a scam to get more money out of people. It didn't make any real difference, and the "techs" doing it didn't know what they were doing anyway. I saw them screw up a couple times and I fixed it. The management didn't care about anything but getting that extra money out of people at any cost. I got hired as the last act of a store manager that was being demoted and moved to a different store. He had too many ethics and didn't worship the bottom line.

      tl;dr BS, it's a scam, it sucks.

    4. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by HellYeahAutomaton · · Score: 1

      It pissed off the customer, and then usually the store ends up losing more money because of people who demand to be compensated for the time they spent bring the computer back to the store.

      Can you elaborate on the process of compensation for time spent?
        I am sure there are a lot of other people here who would want to know how to exploit this with their own hourly rates. :)

    5. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by mrmeval · · Score: 1

      Name them all, name your boss, name the store or you're just a poseur making shit up.

      --
      I'd go on a Vegan diet but the delivery time from Vega is too long. --brownkitty
    6. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by LordLimecat · · Score: 3

      registry fixes....performance upgrades

      Not to rain on your parade, and Im sure you were a good tech.

      But precious few registry fixes are performance upgrades; if they were, Microsoft would have had that switch on by default (since registry switches only do something when the kernel reads them and sets a known option).

      After years and years of screwing with the registry, xtweaks, etc, ive determined that generally, unless you have a specific goal (like "broken driver" or "virus in startup list" or "fix Office 2010 incompatibility"), you shouldnt be messing with the registry (and this includes registry cleaners). The people who designed the registry generally know a far sight more about it than the folks writing articles on 101registryhax.com.

    7. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by DigiShaman · · Score: 2

      I'm sure the registry fixes were tied Explorer.exe and other GUI effects. For example, XP has a reg key called "MenuShowDelay" that's set to 400ms. Change that to zero and now your start-menu flies as you mouse over the list of items. Personally, I think it should have been set to 0ms from factory. But I'm sure MS R&D testing thought 400ms was optimal for the masses at the time.

      There are other registry edits that can affect cache and memory as well for XP. As for Windows 7, I'm not really sure there's much that needs to be done or anything that can offer tangible benefits anyways. Throw 4GB of RAM at it, and that sucker flies. It's rock solid and snappy.

      --
      Life is not for the lazy.
    8. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Not really, registry cleaners will clear out a lot of the entries commercial crapware will leave behind after they've been removed from the system, there are very popular commercial applications out there (Whom will remain unnamed) that treat the registry as their own personal pissing ground. The result is a buggy, bloated registry looking for file associations, libraries and settings that simply don't exist anymore or were changed in the latest upgrade.

      Some registry 'tweakers' act as a blunt-force instrument for cleaning up the registry and trying to improve Windows, more often than not these tools end up just causing more problems than they solve. Registry cleaners should do just that, clean. Delete invalid, corrupt and useless entries without touching anything else.

    9. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "especially the grumpy I'm-entitled-to-everything suburban kind"

      Yeah, this "Bitching-About-Entitlement"-fad has gone to far. I hate to break this to you, but if someone pays you for a laptop they are entitled to a laptop! Its not some kind of societal privilege thing. I mean, if I go to McDonalds, order a cheeseburger, and get food poisoning from it, you wouldn't say I had Entitlement Issues because I complained to the manager, would you?

    10. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oracle for windows REQUIRES registry changes if you want to remove Oracle. I know, because I was an expert in removing Oracle for Windows. Their uninstaller did not do the complete job if uninstalling.

    11. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by omnichad · · Score: 1

      I knew there was a delay, but I had no idea it was that long. And I did appreciate the delay. If you have the Control Panel enabled as a flyout menu you don't want that job firing off without hovering for a good bit. 200ms would probably be better, but I like the delay. If I want speed, I can use the arrow keys for instant pop-outs.

    12. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by rednip · · Score: 1

      Typically delays are put in processes because something else that it depends on needs to run first and I'd guess that it wasn't marketing that asked for it. Likely you didn't need the 'extra time' for any of your uses, but if you did...

      --
      The force that blew the Big Bang continues to accelerate.
    13. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by RadioElectric · · Score: 1

      I guess for Best Buy the important thing would be that knocking that delay down to 200ms makes the PC "just feel that little bit faster". For a customer who's just bought a new computer, that's probably reassuring.

    14. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Things like menu delay should never be changed unless a customer asks for it. I've worked with people who go down that path and it usually doesn't help anybody.

    15. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by Sun · · Score: 1

      Anyway, I can personally tell you that we saw at least 1 DOA laptop for every 20 we sold (a certain brand or two I won't name that sold for cheap accounted for most of them)....

      It pissed off the customer, and then usually the store ends up losing more money because of people who demand to be compensated for the time they spent bring the computer back to the store.

      The solution ought to be obvious, then. Don't carry the brand. Over-all perceived quality of the store goes up. Customer satisfaction goes up (except those customers that come in wanting that specific brand, but those should be few). Profitability goes up. Everybody (except "CrapsRUs") wins.

      Opening boxes is not a solution.

      Shachar

    16. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by LordLimecat · · Score: 1

      THere is a reason that has a delay, it keeps the menus from being obnoxious and appearing/disappearing too fast.

      As for the memory/cache options, those can be set thru the GUI, and there isnt really a one-size fits all; again, if there were, MS would have enabled that caching behavior by default.

      Possibly you have your own PREFERENCES, but what ends up happening is that you assume your version of Computing Nirvana is what everyone's looks like, and you enable all sorts of custom behavior that others may not appreciate.

    17. Re:I used to work for Geek Squad.. by mostlyDigital · · Score: 1

      True, the automated tools can easily do as much harm as good but there are valid reasons to dive into the registry. Install half a dozen apps. Then uninstall them. The odds are that five have left something behind. In all likelihood a couple have left kernel drivers behind. This is the sort of thing that prevents in-place upgrades and forces clean installs. Uninstallers don't. Cleaning the registry can be the only solution.

  45. Re:do people still buy from brick & mortar ? by MEK · · Score: 1

    > The only things I buy with an installed OS are notebooks, and I make recovery media
    > for my collection then wipe 'em to install Linux.

    I bought a laptop for my wife this week (from Best Buy) -- and this is _exactly_ what I did (except I did leave a minimal Windows installation -- just in case).

    --
    Credo quia impossibilis -- Tertullian
  46. Re:Why... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    But... should pathetic feebs cower more?

    We need to know, Mr. Kristopeit. Don't leave us hanging.

  47. Re:Why... by MightyMartian · · Score: 1

    We need a replacement... maybe CmdrBurger or CmdrPizza.

    --
    The world's burning. Moped Jesus spotted on I50. Details at 11.
  48. What about the EULA? by Eponymous+Coward · · Score: 1

    Did they accept the EULA?

    1. Re:What about the EULA? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I never thought about that,, they must have because it didn't come up.

  49. And, please, don't go all nazi on grammer.. by intellitech · · Score: 1

    It's been a long day, and I probably should have spent more time in the preview dialogue.

    --
    vos nescitis quicquam, nec cogitatis quia expedit nobis ut unus moriatur homo pro populo et non tota gens pereat.
  50. Re:do people still buy from brick & mortar ? by MightyMartian · · Score: 1

    They're worshiping at the altar, my friend, worshiping at the altar. Apple isn't a company, it's a religion. I swear to god, they could put out the iTurd, a steaming pile of shit on a plate, and the fanboys would be in there bragging how they bought two of them or how they'd heard rumors about the iTurd 2! Of course, what's really sad is that a few weeks later, Samsung would be releasing TurdX, and would have it banned in the EU because it stinks like shit, and thus violates an Apple design patent.

    --
    The world's burning. Moped Jesus spotted on I50. Details at 11.
  51. First and last mistake: by wjcofkc · · Score: 2

    "I went to Best Buy the other day to get a new laptop for a client."

    --
    Brought to you by Carl's Junior.
  52. Take It Back and Get a Refund by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Take it back. I don't purchase anything from Best Buy that has been previously opened.

  53. Fail by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Anything that begins in "I went to Best Buy" invariably ends in failure.

  54. Similar to my experience by fyndor · · Score: 1

    I bought a PC from there for work. I needed Vista Ultimate 32 bit on it instead of the Vista 64bit Home. But all they had left were PCs they had opened with Geek Squad "optimization" done on them. I told them I (my company) wasn't going to pay $75 for a service I didn't want or ask for, especially when what I was about to do was install 32bit Vista over it and wipe out everything their service had done. I am sure there is a reason why the only PCs of that model left had the optimization on them. People don't actually want to pay for that worthless service, but when all the "non-optimized" PCs are sold, Best Buy can still sell the service since they already put it on the PC before you ever walked in the door. Eventually I won the argument and paid the normal price for the PC. All was fine with me, because I was going to format it anyway. But if you plan on keeping the OS version it comes with, this current state of affairs where they "inspect" the PC would piss me off as well. They need to stop doing that shit. Full disclosure: I worked for Best Buy as a seasonal employee one year, and my girlfriend currently works for Best Buy selling computers. I am sure we will get in to an argument about this tonight as they have her thoroughly brainwashed that their services are a value to people. She even thinks Black Tie Protection is a good idea /facepalm.

  55. Re:do people still buy from brick & mortar ? by rat7307 · · Score: 2

    So...exactly like he did, but not exactly..??

    --
    Burma?
  56. They tried this on me by guttentag · · Score: 1

    They tried this with my new HP TouchPad but they couldn't find any software to install on it.

    1. Re:They tried this on me by Chanc_Gorkon · · Score: 1

      +1 for coffee snorting funny....

      --

      Gorkman

    2. Re:They tried this on me by omnichad · · Score: 1

      But they still tried to charge the extra $40, right?

  57. format c: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You should always format the harddisk and all partitions and then install a (free) OS yourself.

    The only interesting part of this story is if break the seal by a retailer causes any warranty
    problems with the manufacture. I guess they have checked it...

  58. Second hand by mr_lizard13 · · Score: 1

    So it's second hand then. And they're marketing it as brand new.

    I'd like to see them try to pull that stunt here in the UK.

    --
    "We live in a global world" - Harvey Pitt, former Securities and Exchange Commission Chairman
    1. Re:Second hand by RogueyWon · · Score: 1

      Sadly, it happens in the UK. I don't know whether it happens at Best Buy (who are still pretty much a niche player over here), but I've certainly had family members come across it at PC World. For the sake of US readers; PC world is a UK retailer that is more computing specific than Best Buy (the TVs and stuff tend to be sold through Currys, which is part of the same corporate family), but which aims at pretty much the same market segment. Nobody who is even remotely tech-savvy buys from them unless it's an emergency (when their late opening hours do come in handy).

    2. Re:Second hand by mr_lizard13 · · Score: 1

      So reading that page it looks like you have to actually request that service. A bit like Apple's personalised set-up. Other retailers offer something similar.

      In other words, not like the experience of the person in the original article, who only found out that they'd had a go on his new laptop after he noticed the box seal was broken.

      --
      "We live in a global world" - Harvey Pitt, former Securities and Exchange Commission Chairman
    3. Re:Second hand by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      So it's second hand then. And they're marketing it as brand new.

      I'd like to see them try to pull that stunt here in the UK.

      I'm sure they do and it's not a stunt. If you would rather roll the dice after buying a computer you're more than welcome to. Most online retailers offer this pre-setup, burn in service including Dell.

  59. Re:do people still buy from brick & mortar ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    apple is definitely a religion. people who use it are more loyal and incapable of reason than cult members. nopainogain-

  60. They have done this for years by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I bought a Sony laptop from Best Buy in 2004. When I went to pick it up I was told it had to be released by a manager and the manager was on break. When the manager came back they still would not give it to me because a Geek Squad guy was doing me a favor by setting the laptop up for me. As I looked behind the counter I could see him agreeing to the EULA and creating a user account for me. I bought the laptop to put Linux on it. I started yelling at the guy (I have no patience) to give me my money back. Overall I like Best Buy but I would not buy a computer from them again. Most of their staff would not know a computer if they tripped over it.

  61. Actually, Vostro is still considered business by Chirs · · Score: 1

    If you buy a Vostro you get business-class support. I called in because my fan was making a funny sound, they had a tech with a part there the next day.

    Now if you buy an Inspiron, then you get consumer-class support.

    1. Re:Actually, Vostro is still considered business by drinkypoo · · Score: 1

      It depends on where you buy it from. Whenever you buy anything from Dell you have to check to see if they also have it on the business site, because you can end up with a better value on one or the other.

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
  62. Aggressive Upsell by Rinikusu · · Score: 1

    Not only that, but they up the price by about $80. Granted, getting the recovery disks (THAT I SHOULD ALREADY BE GETTING) almost makes this worthwhile, but I'm gonna be irritated if I have to uninstall even *more* crap.

    I went to BB to look at an HP G4-1117DX and all they had were the ones with this treatment.

    --
    If you were me, you'd be good lookin'. - six string samurai
    1. Re:Aggressive Upsell by drcagn · · Score: 1

      Not only that, but they up the price by about $80. Granted, getting the recovery disks (THAT I SHOULD ALREADY BE GETTING) almost makes this worthwhile, but I'm gonna be irritated if I have to uninstall even *more* crap.

      I went to BB to look at an HP G4-1117DX and all they had were the ones with this treatment.

      Part of this service is the removal of the "crap." The only new software they install is the antivirus software that you choose.

      --
      Scorta futuere amo!
  63. Time warp? by bloosh · · Score: 1

    Um, that article is from 2009:

    "By Phil Villarreal on September 28, 2009 2:10 PM"

    I'm sure Best Buy is still doing this, but why are you digging up things that are nearly two years old?

  64. Setup+Recovery Discs by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The service in question is called the setup+recovery disc service. Yes, the open box thing bothers me too but the service isn't aimed at me or 99% of Slashdot's readers. It is aimed at people who don't want to do the initial setup themselves or for people who find the task of burning recovery discs difficult. What they do, is run through the initial setup, install all the Windows updates, install and configure an antivirus, run a number of system tweeks (called Geek Tweeks) and burn the recovery discs. It takes about 2 to 3 hours to do depending on the computer and it costs $99. The going hourly rate for computer work is typically $75 so the price is really not that terrible. The only reason they even offer the service is because there was demand for it from customers.

    If you find the service stupid or find it to be a rip off, it isn't aimed at you. I would not pay someone to mow my grass but you won't find me bitching about people charging to do so. And yes, in case you could not figure it out, I work for Geek Squad... lol

  65. Re:Why... by PNutts · · Score: 1

    CmdrTaco is gone, we're doomed.

    (scenes of chaos and mayhem ensue...)

    Dr. Peter Venkman: This city is headed for a disaster of biblical proportions.
    Mayor: What do you mean, "biblical"?
    Dr Ray Stantz: What he means is Old Testament, Mr. Mayor, real wrath of God type stuff.
    Dr. Peter Venkman: Exactly.
    Dr Ray Stantz: Fire and brimstone coming down from the skies! Rivers and seas boiling!
    Dr. Egon Spengler: Forty years of darkness! Earthquakes, volcanoes...
    Winston Zeddemore: The dead rising from the grave!
    Dr. Peter Venkman: Human sacrifice, dogs and cats living together... mass hysteria!
    Mayor: All right, all right! I get the point!

    And: "Yes, it's true. This man has no dick"

  66. More Bloatware? Even More Better. by tunapez · · Score: 1

    After a wipe, fresh OS and some 3rd party utilities it ends up being even more better.

    More important issue is why would you buy from BB in the 1st place?

    --
    Imagination drew in bold strokes, instantly serving hopes and fears, while knowledge advanced by slow increments...
  67. Re:Why... by Coren22 · · Score: 1

    MK = stagnated.

    --
    APK likes to ask for responses to the same things over and over. Maybe he just likes the responses?
  68. Free?!? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You should be happy, my grandma had to pay 300$ for that service.

  69. Microsoft ___ Home Edition by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I have clients who often like to disregard my advice. They think they can save themselves some money. So rather than buying a ThinkPad with Win7Pro and a nice 1080p display, decent battery life, and a reasonable weight. They go to BestBuy and buy a huge monstrosity with like a 17" monitor with only 1280×720 screen resolution, and terrible battery life. Then they complain they can't access their files because they can't connect to the domain controller because the laptop came with Windows Vista Home or Starter, so then you gotta upgrade the OS to something that can join a domain. I would usually have to reinstall the OS to get all the bloatware off. Then install the drivers, join the domain controller wait for the software to install from GPO. At my hourly rate, they have then not saved anymoney, because they had to pay me to upgrade them to and install Win7Pro, then they complain that the screen looks like crap, because the pixels are like one square cm each. Then after two months, somebody already broke the cheap POS laptop, and the employee who was unfortunate enough to be using it gets the blame. When if they just listened to me in the first place, they would have saved alot of time, money, and aggravation.

    My favorite was, a client bought a laptop from bestbuy, it came preinstalled with vista home edition and Office 2007, then then sold them a copy of the home/student version of Office 2010 (they sold them just the card with the product key on it), even though they TOLD them it was for a business. Then they don't have outlook, even though they are running an exchange server. All the computers in the office were setup to install with the volume license of office 2003 through group policy. I ended up just putting XP on it and Office 2003, but the whole process was a total bitch, and I couldn't believe how much best buy nickeled and dimed them. They also somehow managed to sell them a 1 year copy of McCrapee Antivirus, even though we were already using a business security suite from another vendor.

    Then they complain that my bills are too high, but it's all because I wasted time trying to clean up their bad purchasing mistakes. Ughhh... stuff like this makes me think my hourly rate isn't high enough.

  70. Keep 'em by IGnatius+T+Foobar · · Score: 1

    You know what? Best Buy can *keep* the user profile, recovery disk, and antivirus. And they can discount the price of the machine because they used the copy of Windows that I would have returned for a refund.

    --
    Tired of FB/Google censorship? Visit UNCENSORED!
  71. why the F would you buy from best buy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Let them go the way of Circuit City and CompUSA or all those other overpriced shitfests of ignorant half retarded high school droppouts selling you shit they cant begin to understand, let that shithead go back to working at taco bell where he can really make a difference in this world by not touching tech.

  72. Fry's by whoever57 · · Score: 1

    The last time I bought a Laptop from Fry's, they gave me $70 off the price simply because it had been opened and powered on once (but not set up).

    --
    The real "Libtards" are the Libertarians!
  73. Free service? by dummptyhummpty · · Score: 1

    I realize this is an old article, but at my store (and others in the area) this was $29 service that you would have to pay for, not something they just did. It sounds like this store was just throwing it in for their customers. We would create the restore disks and run an optimization. We would also (at least I would when I was moved up to GS) clean up all the crap that was preloaded on the machine. If the customer purchased AV/AM protection, we would load that too, update it and setup a scan schedule. Of course most of this was automated :-).

  74. Re:Why... by Yamioni · · Score: 1

    You just brought up old memories of Food Fighters. Oh God. It burns.

    --
    Cool post bro, highfive \o
  75. What you bought is an upsell by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Best buy will open a laptop, create profile, and optimization and about 30 to 50 dollars to the price of the computer.
    They have some computers that are not touched and then some are touched.

  76. Ask first by BudAaron · · Score: 1

    At least Nero asks before it installs unwanted junk. As far as I'm concerned I would that it back for a refund. I have no idea what they might have included!!!

  77. Re:Why... by Archfeld · · Score: 1

    Believe me the decline is nothing new...
    Witnessing the rise in noise to signal ratio for quite a while.

    --
    errr....umm...*whooosh* *whoosh* Is this thing on ?
  78. They also charge for it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I bought a laptop there last week, there were 4 of the specific model on the shelf, 3 had these 'inspected by best buy' stickers with the CD taped on them, along with a $99 tag on them. I bought the one without. It did come with the best buy 'app store' though.

  79. Newly refurbished by Meeni · · Score: 1

    So now, refurbs are new.

  80. So that's why.... by TemporalBeing · · Score: 1

    ...you have to get the Best Buy warranties...because they already invalidated the manufacturer's warranty!

    Yep, I'd return it, ask for a discount, free warranty for 2-3 years, etc. There's no reason for them to do that.

    It's one thing if you signed up for them to do that - it's another for them to assume you want it done.

    --
    Truth is like the sun. You can shut it out for a time, but it ain't goin' away. - Elvis Presley (source: imdb.com)
  81. As ex-geeksquad by nero147 · · Score: 1

    I used to work for geeksquad and what you got was a pre-optimized computer. The Trend is actually bloatware from the manufacturer, but the restore disks is a service that they offer. When I worked there they would pre-optimize/other services on a selection of their laptops especially the sale laptops. They didn't use to let you buy them without paying for the services, but they ended up getting into some legal trouble and the vendors got pretty irritated about the practice. I don't do that kind of work anymore (I'm a network engineer), but after working for Geeksquad for a couple of years I can say that there are people that really need that kind of service. Although I will agree that $200 for a clean install is a little excessive. I met person after person that knew noone that could do basic computer work. Not stupid people though. Doctors, lawyers, nurses and people with various other intellectually demanding jobs. They just weren't computer people. Also I've seen more people than I can count that got completely ripped off by freelance IT. People who had people take their old parts taken during upgrades, and people that were lied to about the condition of their hardware and what they were buying. At least with Geeksquad you have a company to sue if they rip you off. After that job but before I got out of the client side IT stuff I charged around $30-$50 for that kind of work, based on my general idea that I charged around half what geeksquad would.As a geeksquad agent you're expected to maintain a productivity of around $60/hour, but you also need to make up for the people that are in the back not selling. So it really ends up being more like $80/hour.

  82. two words by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    FUCK NO

  83. My goodness by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    People in the world are just looking for things to sue about.

    We do this at our shop for convenience. It saves the customer waiting two hours for the laptop to turn on for the first time. The customers would never make recovery disks, so it's also for our convenience when they inevitably get some extreme virus on there.

  84. Wipe it by p51d007 · · Score: 1

    When I buy a new laptop, I set it up, then, shut down the computer, pop out the hard drive, put the expiration of the warranty on it with a sticker. Pop in a clean drive and set it up the way I want. If something happens during the warranty period, I pop the original drive back in, before sending it in for warranty work.

  85. That was a pre-set up computer. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Uh, that was a computer that had a Geeksquad set-up with restore CD service done to it. I did like 12 of them today, you just got a free $100 (semi worth it) service for free, quit bitching. "Oh no! free anti-virus!"

    1. Re:That was a pre-set up computer. by TemporalBeing · · Score: 1

      Uh, that was a computer that had a Geeksquad set-up with restore CD service done to it. I did like 12 of them today, you just got a free $100 (semi worth it) service for free, quit bitching. "Oh no! free anti-virus!"

      But is it a service you wanted? If the answer is no, then there is a problem - especially if it is no for a majority of buyers. In all honesty, they should ask you whether you want it done or not and give you one accordingly regardless of whether they charge you for the service as it otherwise effects warranties, contents, etc. Manufacturer's (e.g. Dell, Gateway, HP, etc) could pick up on this and rightly refuse to provide service - saying that BestBuy needs to do it since they broke the contract with between you and the manufacturer. So there really is a lot more at play.

      --
      Truth is like the sun. You can shut it out for a time, but it ain't goin' away. - Elvis Presley (source: imdb.com)
  86. Circuit City tried this awhile ago too ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    When I was working at the tech bench at Circuit City our managers would have us open boxes and perform some services on the laptop. The reasoning behind this was that it would make it easier to sell pre-optimized units to our customers because they would not have to wait for the services to be complete or return later. The firedog crew and I were never really too comfortable with this arrangement when it was introduced, it simply felt a bit shady. The worse thing was when we would run a good sale on laptops or desktops our managers would have us pre-optimize half of our stock of the product in an attempt to try and force customers to buy the service. Needless to say this led to discussions with customers who thought (rightly) that they should not be forced to purchase services that the did not want on a product that was clearly already opened and used but being sold as new. I agreed with them and expressed their concerns to my manager as well as saying that this was probably at best unethical, he disagreed and we wound up with dozens of pre-optimized computers that no one wanted.

  87. re: extended warranties a good deal? by King_TJ · · Score: 1

    Honestly, I've *never* seen an extended warranty that was truly a "good deal", in the sense that it saved you money over any of your other options. Extended warranties are like insurance policies though; you agree to pay a certain price for a certain length of time of coverage, ensuring that if anything breaks, you're not out of pocket a large, surprise amount of money to get it working again.

    Most of the computers Best Buy sells are models more liable than average to break and need service in the first place, so I'd argue that rather than paying hundreds more for their extended service plan, it would be smarter to buy a better quality machine from the start. (I hate to name names, but the Toshiba Satellite and Satellite Pro series I've seen MANY people purchase at Best Buy stores over the years seem like they're always going back in for some kind of service work -- from dead motherboards to overheating issues to bad video chipsets, to broken CD/DVD drives and trays. A number of the HP Pavilion laptops I've seen people buy there had issues too - especially with power adapter jacks that came loose or again, motherboard failures.)

    When you're talking about a large investment like a car or truck purchase, I can see more justification for the extended warranty, assuming it really covers enough potential problems and it's being sold by someone reputable (manufacturer's own are probably safest). In those cases, you're probably doing financing over as long as 5 or 6 years anyway - so it's relatively painless to cough up the several thousand dollars so it's rolled into the monthly payments. Even if you only have 1 or 2 claims over the life of that ext. warranty plan and they total up to, say, $800-1500 less than you paid for the plan? You essentially paid for peace of mind that beyond that initially agreed-upon monthly finance payment, you wouldn't get stuck having to come up with $1000 or more all at once or have a disabled vehicle you were STILL paying the bank for until you could come up with it.

    With a laptop computer, you likely paid under $1,000 for it from Best Buy in the first place, right? If it lasts through the 1 year factory warranty period (and if not, will get fixed free by the manufacturer, presumably), you're probably in a good position to either A) resell it while it's still in good working order, and just over 1 year old, so you can recoup enough cash to put towards another new model, or B) use it until something DOES break and find out how much that repair costs. It may be possible to buy another identical (broken with a different problem) laptop off eBay or Craigslist and use parts from it to fix yours inexpensively. If it's just a failed hard drive or bad RAM -- no big deal. $100 or less in most cases to replace that stuff. If it's serious like a bad motherboard, just eBay it for parts (screen might still be good in that case, for example) and buy a new machine.

    I'm betting that if you always stick to my above strategy, you'll come out ahead of trying to hang onto an older system that has extended warranty left on it. There's some value in having a new (likely faster) machine that you miss out on if you keep fixing that older one, and disadvantages of waiting to get a broken one back from the shop if and when it does break and you use that extended warranty on it.

  88. Re: B&H by durdur · · Score: 1

    B&H is the bomb. It is the newegg equivalent for camera gear: they have practically everything, ship fast, competitive prices, no hassles. But generally they don't offer any warranty except what the manufacturer provides. And for some equipment that is rather limited (for Canon it is 1 year). Not a problem for me but YMMV.

  89. So don't buy the opened laptop... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    This is a standard practice called "pre-setting" the laptop. When customers buy laptops, they have the option to have anti-virus installed as well as other Geek Squad tweeks (removing unwanted programs that were pre-installed by the manufacturer, user profiles, etc). Normally, if a customer wants to opt in on this, it can take hours to get this service done. Best Buy gives them the option to buy a "pre-set" laptop that has the services done before hand, so the customer can walk out with all of it at time of purchase. It is for the customer's convenience and it is their choice to buy the pre-set laptop. It is not something that is snuck into a customers cart. Also, the anti-virus that is installed is not a trial, it is a full version. This isn't a shady practice, no one is out to mess with your computer purchase.

  90. Geek Squad Protection by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Best Buy will do this if you purchase the Geek Squad protection. Also, the sticker didn't just say inspected by, but it said inspected and setup by Geek Squad. I just recently bought my wife a laptop from Best Buy. The model they had under the display models were this way. When I stated that I didn't want the Geek Squad protection, they got a new one from the back.

    What the article didn't say, is that the laptop most likely came with a CD of the additional software they added to the computer, and that was taped on the outside of the box.

    PS: The reason this two year old story just made the front page is to point out Gamestop isn't the only company opening items and selling them as new. http://games.slashdot.org/story/11/08/24/2114216/GameStop-Opening-Deus-Ex-Boxes-Removing-Free-Game-Coupon

    1. Re:Geek Squad Protection by Chanc_Gorkon · · Score: 1

      Sometimes they don't give you the choice though since they do all sorts of presetup. Setup that doesn't need to be done.

      If you want computing easy...don't buy a laptop. Get a tablet or iPad.

      --

      Gorkman

  91. Actually.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    You got a presetup laptop. Not only did they open it, you paid for them to do so!

  92. Naturally by bigdavex · · Score: 1

    They had to open it to put the second-hand OnLive coupon in the box.

    --
    -Dave
  93. NO way!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Did u check for missing parts ;)?

  94. They did a really good thing... by Hymer · · Score: 1

    They made the recovery discs. I don't know any normal user who did that on their new PC... and I know many users who missed those discs.

  95. Geek Squad chiming in by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Actaully posting from a Geek Squad precinct right now, the unit that this person purchased was a pre-setup unit that had servies already performed to save the end user from having to wait 4 or so hours to get their new toy. Only 35% of the laptop stock is done this way and if he did not pay for the services ( recovery disc, pc setup, updates, and AV install ) then he got about 100$ worth of services at no cost.

    I know its EZmode to bash on best buy and Geek Squad, least for /. since most people here are on the upper specturm not being scared crappless of a PC, but the Average Joe Idunknowcrap Doe dosn't want to deal with most of what we do to the units.

    Anyway, just to clarify there is nothing shaddy going on, its a service we provide and pre-set some units to save the average consumer time. I really think people who really bash Best Buy and Geek Squad are just jelly.

  96. duhh (2) by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    1) The Ministry of Information was hit with severe budget cuts.
    2) /. is between interns, and the management is temporarily responsible for the editorial duties.
    3) Someone who believes that all advertising is good advertising really likes Best Buy.
    4) George Orwell is alive, well and doing ad placement for the Geek Squad by recycling the best press he could reconstitute.
    5) The is the post PC era, and no one really needs laptops anymore, anyway.
    6) Because we care...
    7) This makes people who bought an Optiplex system from Dell direct fell better.
    8) Because the purpose of /. it to generate ad revenue by trolling.

    Take your pick...

  97. You bought from Best Buy, what did you expect? by Dr.+Winston+O'Boogie · · Score: 1

    Being among the shadiest companies with aggressive policies on squeezing their customers for everything they can, this is a surprise?

  98. EULA? by Arrturk · · Score: 1

    I'm curious as to how this impacts the EULA acceptance that is typically a part of setting up a new laptop? Would BestBuy be accepting it instead of you in order to install software on your laptop.

  99. EULA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Just be grateful that Best Buy are bound by the EULA and not you.

  100. Re: extended warranties a good deal? by tompaulco · · Score: 1

    I would never buy an extended warranty on a new car, either. If you know even a smattering of how to take care of a car yourself, like replacing batteries, alternators, radiator hoses, belts and so forth, then you are very likely to be better off without the warranty. They will show you average cost of repairs over the life of the vehicle, but the cost they show you assumes that you pay the dealerships shop rates, which are much higher than an independent mechanic and infinitely higher than your own labor. Also, on Auto warranties, they generally just extend bumper to bumper to last as long as the drivetrain manufacturers warranty. This is because they know that most of what they will be covering is stuff that is either going to be broke out of the box or work long past the manufacturers warranty period.
    I went with a buddy to buy a car and couldn't talk him out of the extended warranty onsite, because they said he had 30 days to cancel. However, once he got it home and went over it for about a week, he came to the conclusion that it was a waste of money. He had a hard time getting them to let him cancel, but he is pretty hardheaded himself, so he eventually got them to honor their word that he could cancel.

    --
    If you are not allowed to question your government then the government has answered your question.
  101. Riding on the coattails of GameStop by Neurotrace · · Score: 1

    Why else is OP posting a 2 year old article?

  102. Re:Why... by tompaulco · · Score: 1

    Because today we had an article about Gamestop opening retail boxes and pulling out online coupons. This article undoubtedly made it through because of the similarity.

    --
    If you are not allowed to question your government then the government has answered your question.
  103. Not here by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I just got a new laptop , $1500 or so, and the seal was intact. I did not purchase the recommended "pick three" service package that includes startup disks...

  104. Best Buy? Hell no.... by boweniant · · Score: 1

    I wouldn't urinate on the place if was on fire. Hell no I wouldn't let them in / on / around my equipment. If I don't know how to fix it the, I guess it's boot 'n nuke time. If that doesn't work then it's time to take the computer out to the rifle range.

  105. The real question... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ...is did they remove the OnLive coupon?

  106. EULA ??? by Zemran · · Score: 1

    So they opened it and installed it, therefore they agreed to the EULA not the end user. I would think that this means that the end user is not responsible for the agreement....

    --
    I love stacking my barbecues in the shed at the end of summer - you can't beat a bit of grill on grill action.
  107. Not only do they open/mess with... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Not only do they open & mess with the laptops, they also run the one time use utilities to create restore disks, then they try to extort you to buy the disks. When you don't you're not able to create restore disks on your own because they've already run the manufacturer proprietary app (HP in my case). I couldn't get the Windows 7 system image to run either, so I took the computer back and demanded a refund. All in all, they wanted over $100 to create the restore disks for me.

  108. Re: extended warranties a good deal? by FrellMeDead · · Score: 2

    I have no idea where you get your cars from or what make/model you purchase but with that aside new car purchases with the extended warranty are worth it in most cases. Regardless of how knowledgeable you are about cars/trucks, etc., there are still instances that a warranty is a must have. for example replacing or repair of a transmission (it can be done and I have done it but it is easier a maybe quicker in most instances to have someone else do it), electrical issues, repair of rear axle, bodywork, and engine repair are all reasons to have a warranty. Yes some people can do the diagnostics and repair but even then certain issues require special tools or need a lift to repair the issue in a timely manner. Also for most people it can save thousands of dollars depending on several factors the least of which are locations where you drive, number of miles per year you drive since increased wear and tear can be a big issue in a few years. Additionally the warranty requires the owners to get proper maintenance (either they do oil/filter changes, transmission fluid, coolant, and checks for tire wear, etc. In almost all instances, unless you are a mechanic and do this for a living or have more then one car you can use during the repair and/or have plenty of free time to properly do repairs in addition to normal maintenance then a warranrty/extended warranty is a good idea. This is especially true considering the low price of most extended warranties. Extended warranties don't just extend the standard bumper to bumper, at least in all that I have seen, they usually include a minimum of 3-10+ years of warranty coverage and some cover accidents that cover the difference between what your insurance pays and what they would pay (he manufacturer). Obviously extended warranties aren't for everyone especially those that only have a car for under 5 years since the standard warranty will cover most issues and any recalls. Extended warranties come in many kinds but in general the ones that are worth it are those that have little to no deductible, covers wear and tear (not just failing parts), and roadside service/breakdown coverage, etc. It can and is definitely worth it depending on what you get and for how long you are keeping the vehicle as well as how many miles you generally put on it. Saying that you would never buy an extended warranty or saying that some issues can readily be repaired by yourself is just being ignorant. Each person has different requirements and extended warranties vary wildly depending on where you buy, from which car manufacturer you buy from, and most importantly who is actually providing the extended warranty. As far as other extended warranties, most are rip offs and will never be needed or it's cheaper/better to just buy the same product again. In some specific cases it may be worth it but in general they aren't. Every person needs something different but aside from car extended warranties (from a reputable company) most others are just crap. It's just ignorant to group everyone in the same boat and then say that everybody should do what you do.

  109. Good practice in my view by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    As someone who works in a privately owned computer shop I approve of this.

    I think it's insane to send a computer home with a customer without OS updates installed or any anti-virus software. Yeah I think installing a trial is pretty poor when there are other free applications out there that do great, but aren't they taking care of the customer by making sure that known security holes in the OS are patched before they take it home?

    I loath Best Buy but I can't honestly say that I think this is a bad thing to do.

  110. Geek Squad Scumbags by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Not sure if this has been said, but they did this to my girlfriend's computer. I told her to buy online, but she's a bit more impulsive in the store, and she got an open one with something like "Geek Squad Upgrades". Unfortunately, it included a ton of crapware, including Trend Micro (sorry, opinionated here) and a registry cleaner. That's right, a REGISTRY CLEANER. They said that it runs "hidden", and that there wasn't an easy way to uninstall it. Unfortunately, it cleaned the wrong junk during a Windows Update, and it "needed" a full reinstallation of Windows, according to their geek squad... Probably only needed a system restore and to delete Best Buy's PoS software, but they just deleted everything on the hard drive without asking her.

    Basically, Best Buy techies are bigger scumbags than you think.

  111. so does booting a LiveCD and running mkfs work? by Locutus · · Score: 1

    if so then who cares unless they put another frack'n Windows sticker around the keyboard.

    LoB

    --
    "Anyone who stands out in the middle of a road looks like roadkill to me." --Linus
  112. BestBuy didn't open your laptop by Billly+Gates · · Score: 1

    The PC was probably returned and BestBuy restocked it. When I worked at Staples we even repacked boxes of pens with a shrink wrapper in the bank. Some money is better than no money and everyone does this. When you return it you say whether it is broken or not and if it is not broken they simply restock it. No biggie. FYI all the computers from bestbuy have crapware installed including the horrible BestBuy software installer.

    My Asus is one of them and I know because when I do a full system restore from DVD backup it reinstalls it. It is a contract requirement from the company and not the Geek Squad kid opening every laptop and installing god knows what.

    Just install PC-Decrapifier and get rid of it. Thats what I did with mine.

    It was annoying but lving in Alaska, I had no other outlet to buy electronics and BestBuy does buy them in bulk for a discounted price.

    If that still bothers you ask to exchange for another one and have Geek Squad open the box to make sure it was not opened before you buy it.

  113. Why Best Buy opens up the laptops by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    As a former Best Buy employee I can tell you exactly for what reason they have opened laptop boxes. Every week the managers of the store look at what laptops will be on sale or popular and add Geek Squad optimization and other services to a certain percentage of those laptops in stock. They do this so that they can sell you the completely overpriced Geek Squad services for the laptop you buy without you having to wait the few hours it usually takes to do everything. You can just grab one of the pre-optimized laptops and head out the door. What happens though is they will run out of unopened laptops for certain models and only have the pre-optimized versions in stock. They'll try to get you to buy the Geek Squad services, but if you don't want them they'll give you one of the pre-optimized laptops without charging you the extra they would have for the services because that's all they have left in stock. Best Buy actually loses money on most laptops they sell, especially when they're on sale. There's just no margin in them. The only way they make money selling laptops is by attaching Geek Squad's overpriced services and the to be avoided service plans so that's why they push it so much.

  114. EULA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I wonder if you can claim that you did not agree to EULA since it was BB employee who clicked "I agree"?

  115. You are getting free work. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    i used to work at futureshop and we did this too, however we charged a "setup" fee when people optionally purchased an in-store setup.. we someitmes did pre-setups to save time for the consumer, so they could walk out of the store with their new product right away instead of waiting an hour or 2..

    Basically they are doing this to save your time, by removing all the bloatware that comes pre-installed from the manufacturer. and making recovery discs, so if your HDD fails they, or you, have a backup of your OS, as the manufacturers do not suppluy them. This is in the best interest of the many.

      If you dont want a pre-setup, just ask for a machine that has not had one, they can always order one from their warehouse, or may have some in stock, then you can have your virgin machine, and do exactly what the BB tech did all by your smart little self... or you could let them do it and enjoy a couple hours of your life...

    your getting free work for that saves you time and possibly a headache, if you dont like it, why are you buying your PC at best buy, go somewhere else where they dont give a shit about the crap they sell you....

  116. Two Price Options by Kojow777 · · Score: 0

    BestBuy and other similar companies often have two price options, the higher price option means they do all the "setup work" for you. If you pay the lower price this means that you will usually go through a 2-4 hour setup and recovery disc creation process.

  117. Honestly are you that gullible? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Dude... Can You say "Display Model" ... or is that too hard for you lol.

    The Guy's just straightface bullshitted you saying its new. I used to see other salesmen in JB HIFI do that all the time when I worked there. I didnt though.

    Simply go back and say you gave me the Display model, wheres my 15% discount.

  118. Not just laptops. by sixsixtysix · · Score: 1

    I bought a Blu-ray player from there earlier this year (was on sale and cheaper than newegg/amazon). It was taped up in the "inspected by best buy" sticker tape. When I got home and set it up, I noticed the batteries were nowhere to be found. I called the store, and they said to come in; they'd give me some. I told them I wasn't wasting my time to go all the way back and wanted them to delivery them to me. Just as they got my address, my phone call dropped. I was too pissed to call them back. About a week later they arrived in the mail.

    --
    ...
  119. You're all retarded... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I currently work for Geek Squad and, therefore, I am qualified to properly comment on this post. Everyone here is acting like Best Buy is some major conspiracy machine that is out to get you. "Man I bet Best Buy is opening our laptops to break them!" I am sick of idiot customers acting like we're out to get them. It's complete bullshit. Now, to the point:

    WHAT YOU ACTUALLY PURCHASED...
    Is a BRAND NEW computer with a service performed on it by Geek Squad called a "PC Setup w/ Restore". That service includes installation of a full version of an antivirus, an operating system optimization (disabling bloatware, startup items and editing registries) and finally, creating recovery discs for the client. It is THE CLIENT'S CHOICE as to whether or not they want to PURCHASE that service or not. So either you bought that service willingly and are being a major douche who wants to bash Best Buy or the sales associate gave you a unit that had the service performed on it without charging you by accident. So basically, you're whiny either way. Either you purchased it and wanted to complain about nothing on slash dot or you didn't purchase it and therefore received $100 worth of free services.

    All machines sold at Best Buy are NEW IN BOX unless specifcally marked with a GIANT BLUE SITCKER that says "Open Box Computer". The only time we open a computer before purchase is to perform a PC Setup w/ Restore service. We perform this service on 40% of all inventory and, again, it is the CLIENT'S choice if they want to purchase it or not.

    Grow up. You annoy me.

  120. Sour Apple Syndrome by MBC1977 · · Score: 1

    While I am not a Best Buy employee, I do work in Best Best and personally I think they undercharge for the PC Setup and Optimize service (I realize this will be unpopular but I'm willing to jump on that dagger today).

    Could the average joe user learn to do the same stuff they do, yes. Does the average joe user care about doing that stuff, not really. They just want it to work, without consideration of what should be done as preparation to be used (i.e. system updates, adding anti-virus, setting up username with strong passwords, etc.) Yet, when something goes wrong they are quick to blame the vendor. Best Buy has pre-setup and factory-setup systems available for sale. If the customer indicates they want a Best Buy setup system, then they should pay the price, if not they can state otherwise. If the only systems available are pre-setup ones then, the customer can wait or pay the difference.

    Some of you "brains" (I do mean that in a positive sense) forget that not everyone can / or care to take the time to do preliminary work. Others of you fail to understand that Best Buy is in the business of making money through a wide variety of business strategies. This is just one of them. Were it me, I would charge more, because I think that the extra $99 dollars is low. Again this is just my opinion and I realize it will not be popular, but when you run a business (especially a public company); revenue needs to be generated and operating costs need to be paid.

    --
    Regards,

    MBC1977,
    1. Re:Sour Apple Syndrome by omnichad · · Score: 1

      Depends on the cost of living where you are, but I generally agree. The "idiot tax" is reasonable, but ONLY if this is an opt-in only service. Too many times they have shown they're willing to put them on the shelf labelled with the un-optimized price, and tried to pass it off on people who don't need it. If they don't stop that, then the price is too high.

  121. Because, then best buy agrees to the EULA, not me. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    So if best buy powers up the laptop and click through's MS's EULA and licensing agreement, then I don't have to. All on MS.

  122. They charge for this by drcagn · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I work at Geek Squad.

    Before I worked here, I abhorred the Geek Squad. But I needed a job, so I took this one. It's not really that bad.

    Tons of people actually want this service. They pay $100 for us to turn on the computer for the first time, go through the Windows out-of-box experience, uninstall the Norton/McAfee 30-day trial, install 1-year (or more) Trend Micro/Kaspersky/Webroot of their choosing, burn recovery discs (since the OEMs don't include them anymore), and install all Windows updates.

    All this takes about 2-3 hours and we use automated software to do this stuff.

    We "preset" computers as well, meaning we take them out of the box, perform all of these services, and then rebox them up and badge them as "Set up by a Geek Squad Agent." We are only supposed to pre-set up a certain percentage of our stock, however, a lot of what we agents call "cowboy managers" (managers who break standard corporate operating procedure) make agents set up 50% or more of the stock, hoping that people will be more inclined to purchase setups if they are already performed and they're all that's left.

    A lot of times at my store we give away the presets because the client doesn't want to pay and the preset stock is all that's left. It sounds to me like you got one of the preset units and they never charged you for it.

    By the way, the only two types of tape available in the entire store are "Inspected by Best Buy" tape and "Geek Squad Priority" tape. The tape says "Inspected by Best Buy" because it indicates that Best Buy is the one who sealed the box last. It doesn't mean that the presetup process is an "inspection."

    Given the high demand by some to buy their computers pre-set up, I don't think it's such a horrible service anymore. Some people are just stupid and want to turn on the computer for the first time and just click IE. The out of box experience, as silly as it sounds, can be confusing to many users, and they would rather walk out the door knowing that the antivirus is installed properly, even if that isn't hard to do at all.

    Before you go hating on Best Buy, keep in mind that margins in PCs are extremely low. Best Buy _loses_ money if you buy a non-Apple computer without any Geek Squad services. This is called selling a "brick." The PC sales market is extremely cut-throat. Office Depot makes its money by hoping you never send in a rebate or send it in incorrectly. Best Buy makes its money by attaching services. Without this, the price of buying a computer from these stores would go up.

    --
    Scorta futuere amo!
    1. Re:They charge for this by Chanc_Gorkon · · Score: 1

      No it's not a bad service if you TRUST Best Buy. I do not. :-P

      --

      Gorkman

    2. Re:They charge for this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I bought my Gateway p7811-FX there without Geek Squad services. I feel a lot less bad about it now, thanks!

    3. Re:They charge for this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I was a manager at Office Depot for a few years. Our entire business went down the tubes trying to compete with Best Buy in laptop sales. We offered all the same "PC Tune-ups" pretty much and tried to attach McAfee and MS Office or a warranty to every machine or we were losing money. The rebates honestly were never talked about, but I got yelled at every day over laptop attachment services and warranties.

    4. Re:They charge for this by Tiger4 · · Score: 1

      Great reply, but I have two questions:

      1. Do you set up the machines with the users as admin, or with two accounts, Admin (full rights) and (reduced privileges) User?

      2. I have to know: Scorta futuere amo! = Future like whores!

      ???

      --
      Behold, this dreamer cometh. Come now, and let us slay him... and we shall see what will become of his dreams.
  123. i quit reading after by nimbius · · Score: 1

    "I went to Best Buy the other day to get a new laptop"

    as we all know thats not possible; many have tried.
    Best buy is designed to sell the idea of technology to the elderly. its a well established government program. many "stores" give this away by their pedantic treatment of customers, and rigorous bureaucratic structure.

    you can confirm this fact simply by mailing your taxes to best buy, which will gladly be forwarded to the proper federal agency on your behalf.

    --
    Good people go to bed earlier.
  124. Been there, done that... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    First thing's first... don't buy the optimized unit.

    As I'm sure many posters will point out, they've done very little that you can't do yourself. This service is primarily for the rush sales (Black Friday, Boxing Day, etc) where people don't want to wait around for the system to be "optimized", so they've just pre-optimized them in advance. Trust me, worked for a store doing this.

    It's a completely worthless service, but the average customer will miss this optimization fee, and it's free money to Best Buy. Or at least it would be if they could find enough high school work experience children to do it for them.

    If you don't want this service, and don't want to pay extra money for stupid cruft you don't need, don't buy from the store, buy online. Or better yet, buy from ncix, newegg, tigerdirect, etc.

  125. Would have saved me from a DOA by dZap · · Score: 1

    Waiting right now for a replacement for the Asus Eee Slate that was DOA from Amazon UK.

  126. Average Users DO WANT THIS. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I've purchased a laptop from Best Buy, once. It was a fantastic deal and even a year later, I wasn't finding any thing with similar power, RAM, HDD for that price.

    I'm not an average user. 20+ running VMs at the house. Solaris, SunOS, Linux, BSD, and 1 Windows machine (Win7 Media Center recording TV).

    Anyway, Mom, sister, Dad aren't computer nerds. They don't know what a new computer will do when they get it home. If it doesn't boot, some will probably think they did something wrong and due to embarrassment, not take it back. Mom runs a hand-me-down P4 system today. Every time I try to get her to upgrade, she declines. "this is fine for me." At some point, her PC will break and the nice people at Best Buy sell PCs, so she will go there and shop. The kids will talk her into a new $800 desktop (she needs a $350 desktop), and she will learn about Windows7 - she runs Lubuntu 10.04 today.
    The will open the PC, plug it in and put their sticker on the case. Mom will like that, individual attention. She will believe what they tell her. I think those techs actually believe what they are saying - certainly their extensive training program wouldn't lie.

  127. Not new. by Chanc_Gorkon · · Score: 1

    They do this ALL the time. YOU CAN find a laptop without their crap. When you do, they charge you less. They put it on there because they want to sell you their crappy Geek Squad tech support. I reject it. The bad thing is that sometimes YOU CAN'T GET THE SALE PRICE WITHOUT THE BLOAT!

    --

    Gorkman

  128. Old news... by bwcbwc · · Score: 1

    I was going to mention that Consumerist has had stories like this for years. Then I noticed that the link in the story is to a Consumerist story...from 2009. Slashdot -- always up on the latest trends in commerce and the internet.

    This isn't just a marketing thing, it's an upsale. BB charges you for this system prep "service" and frequently tries to make it look like it's a required bundle with any laptop purchase, which it isn't.

    --
    We are the 198 proof..
  129. Staples in Canada... by Frederic54 · · Score: 1

    ... is doing the same thing and charge you $99 for it! So when the laptop you want has only "prepared box" left, you have to pay the "fee", or walk and find it elsewhere.

    --
    "Science will win because it works." - Stephen Hawking
  130. Re: B&H by SteveFoerster · · Score: 1

    B&H rocks, and not just for cameras. I'm pretty happy with the netbook I bought through them last year, and it was cheaper from them than anyone else, even with shipping.

    --
    Space game using normal deck of cards: http://BattleCards.org
  131. I don't go to Best Buy by bobcote · · Score: 1

    A few years ago I went to Best Buy because they had a good deal on laptops and I needed one for a very particular function. Before I left they opened the box and and turned on the machine.
    At the time they had a policy of a restocking fee for opened boxes. They told me this after I purchased the laptop. It turns out I did not need the laptop so I tried to return it and argued that BEST BUY opened the box. I could not have returned it without the fee even if I never left the store.
    They eventually relented and refunded the fee and started posting very large signs with the return policy.
    Moral of the story -- if they open the box before you leave get the manager's name and promise that they will give full refunds.

  132. As Long as thats ALL they did by RobertLTux · · Score: 1

    1 remove the unneeded trials (both OEM and BB)
    2 Check the settings to make sure they are "correct" for your purpose
    3 then they are liable if the restore set fails i would guess

    as long as they didn't A Charge for the "inspection" B Put anything "Funky" on at the same time i would say this is a nonissue at worst and may be a convenience at best

    --
    Any person using FTFY or editing my postings agrees to a US$50.00 charge
  133. Former BBY employee, here. by darniil · · Score: 1

    I've worked for the company twice: FEB98-OCT00, NOV06-DEC10. (Got laid off and had to return to the Beast.) First time I worked in Media, mostly selling software, this latest time I worked in the warehouse of my store.

    Frequently as we stocked the truck, we'd have Geek Squad people getting the laptops we were stocking so they could do all the prep work on them. There was even a point where they were checking the quantities of each SKU so that they could grab as close to 40% of each SKU as possible. (I don't say this as a dig at the GS guys; most of them were decent.)

    Why did they do this? Because someone at District said that they had to to that to 40% of each SKU.

    I can't speak for the other stores in my district, but what ended up happening at our store is that most people wouldn't want to pay the extra money for that service, the unmolested laptops would sell out first, and a few days after we received our shipments, all that would be left were the 40%. It got so bad that some models, week after week, wouldn't sell any modified laptops, so we'd have 20-30 of the modified laptops that were weeks old. Any customers who came in at the end of the week (especially if it was a model on sale) would find only the modified laptops. And these laptops were, of course, more expensive than the tag price they were looking at in front of the model.

    Then, naturally, since management was desperate to make sales, if a customer complained about it just a little, the managers would waive the service fee and sell a serviced laptop at the original price.

    And they wonder why they keep making less and less money.

  134. I was going to say no but ... by GarryFre · · Score: 1

    I've had my share of bad experiences with best lie but recently I bought an HDTV from them and got it home only to find that all the mounting hardware was MISSING, no bolts, no screws, no cables - nothing but the TV and the base. Despite the fact that when I bought it they got me to pay for their unwanted geek squad warranty by ganging up on me three salesmen to one customer and every time I said NO they pretended I said YES to buying the warranty, I got so frustrated I caved in and bought it. They got away with it because they were the ONLY electronics place around with a deal I could afford even with the warranty but they lost a LOT of business from me. Nine out of ten times I think of shopping at best lie I don't because I get angry when I think of what they did. I go there and a salesperson says something I want to slap them and call them skum! Despite this after the TV incident I would still rather them open it to make sure some idiot didn't leave something out of the box. They claimed my missing hardware was not possible. I would hate to open a new laptop to find it damaged, cracked or missing and have to try to prove to those jackasses that I didn't do it. I'd rather they not install their crap ware on it though.

    --
    www.Migrainesoft.com - Computer giving you a headache? We can fix that!
  135. Re:do people still buy from brick & mortar ? by Methuseus · · Score: 1

    Some people don't have the money to do that, unfortunately. Seeing a computer at a B&M that fits the specs of what I need and is at fire-sale prices is hard to pass up, when what I really want would cost about 5x as much from HP business. And about 3-4x if I built it. Granted I don't get the warranty you do, but I can buy one of these every other year with upped specs each time, and never had one crap out in less time than that. But I don't let people install crapware on them either.

    --
    Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity, though I'm not yet sure about the universe. - A Einstein
  136. Yes if i am present. by globeadue · · Score: 1

    I bought my first laptop years ago from best buy and they opened it in front of me a did a quick power on, ran though some diags and tested the screen etc. At first i was put back, kinda like wtf i wanted to open it up... but when i thought about that gave me piece of mind the laptop was sound. My last two laptops have been different, i get handed the box unopened.

    --
    ..just because you can, doens't mean you should...
  137. Re:Why... by Coren22 · · Score: 1

    you're an ignorant hypocrite.

    Is that why I post at +2 and you post at -1? To me that sure looks like I'm not the ignorant one in this discussion.

    --
    APK likes to ask for responses to the same things over and over. Maybe he just likes the responses?
  138. Open Box Item/used?? by OrangeMonkey11 · · Score: 1

    Would this not constitute an open box/used item since Best Buy open the item created a profile and load their crap on the system?

  139. Just ignore their 'offers' by rockstarjames · · Score: 1

    I usually snag any family member's laptops there but bypass any of the crap they try to offer. Then once I'm home I do a clean wipe, toss antivirus/teamviewer/chrome on it, and hand it over. I've bought about three laptops so far and haven't seen a sticker yet though.

  140. This is why I dont shop at best buy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Buy online, configure the hardware exactly as you want. Computer arrives, wipe drive and install fresh.
    It takes a little extra time but its worth it and you don't get a bunch of bullshit trial software or greasy fast food geek fingerprints on everything.

  141. Speaking as ex Geek Squad, this is a good thing by GoodNewsJimDotCom · · Score: 1

    I worked at Best Buy. A lot of laptops come with crapware installed on your computer, and they all need to be removed to optimize performance. Best Buy taught me that Norton is a joke, and should never be installed for any reason as it is worse than the viruses sometimes.

    I personally don't run with any anti virus on my home PCs. The trick is just not installing untrusted aps. So I'm sorry you have any antivirus at all.

    Geek Squad was a joke of a job though. I took it because I couldn't find any C/C++ or Java programming positions. The world is a strange place where you can be a master at a trade, but Human Resources won't even give you an introductory position.

    1. Re:Speaking as ex Geek Squad, this is a good thing by MrBippers · · Score: 1

      I personally don't run with any anti virus on my home PCs. The trick is just not installing untrusted aps. So I'm sorry you have any antivirus at all.

      Any takers on how many trojans/rootkits this guy is hoarding?

  142. this story pales when you consider by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    that hp entrusted all those touchpads to these slime ballz