Slashdot Mirror


Canadian iTunes Music Store Opens

Trillan writes "After appearing on December 1st, iTunes music store Canada is now officially open. Price is only $0.99 CDN (about $0.83 US) per song, so it's less expensive than the US store. This is probably fair since our CDs are usually cheaper here, too, at least on the west coast."

479 comments

  1. Possible? by CompSurfer · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Is it possible for Americans (USA) to buy songs from Canada's iTunes?

    1. Re:Possible? by double-oh+three · · Score: 4, Interesting

      The better question is; Where's a list of Candian proxy servers and where can I get the Canadian version?

      --
      "For years, I struggled with reality... but I'm happy to say I finally won out over it." -- Elwood P. Dowd
    2. Re:Possible? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That'd kick ass. Cheaper than Wal-Mart's $.88/song and better quality :-)

    3. Re:Possible? by glomph · · Score: 5, Funny

      Sure, it's possible for Americans to buy from the Canadian Itunes store! But as Pres.Bush will remind you, we can't be sure those bits will be safe! What's really IN those files?

    4. Re:Possible? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      No, you have to have a canadian credit card.

    5. Re:Possible? by The+Hobo · · Score: 4, Informative

      From TFA:

      "The iTunes Music Store in Canada works with the Canadian dollar, and purchase and download of songs requires a valid credit card with a billing address in Canada."


      Which is fine for me, but not for Americans..

      --
      There is another kind of evil which we must fear most, and that is the indifference of good men. -- Boondock Saints
    6. Re:Possible? by RhettD · · Score: 1

      No, for the same reason why us Canadians were unable to purchase songs from the US store; you need a credit card with an address in the country.

    7. Re:Possible? by DarryDoo · · Score: 1

      Canadian credit cards are mostly the same as US cards: Visa, MasterCard, AMEX...

      Guess that's why I can use my fancy Canadian cards in the US!

    8. Re:Possible? by prof_peabody · · Score: 5, Interesting

      Anyone can surf the Canadian store. You need a credit card with a Canadian address in order to purchase from the Canadian shop. I have been purchasing tracks from the US store here in Canada for the past year with my US based credit card. There are all sorts of loopholes like this in online shopping.

    9. Re:Possible? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      Pfft.. forget what the article says.

      Let's use our American mentalitly and just say we can use it. If they don't let us use it we'll just call them a bunch of flammatory names, say stuff like "WHATEVER, AMERICA JR!" and "OUR ARMY COULD KICK YOUR ARMY'S ASS!" (all in a really loud voice, of course).

      Yup.. the good ol' American way. ;)

    10. Re:Possible? by prof_peabody · · Score: 1

      I'm Canadian and I have been bying tracks from teh US store for a while. I live in Canada but have a credit card going to an American address. Nice try though.

    11. Re:Possible? by PktLoss · · Score: 4, Informative

      I'm a Canadian, and up untill today I have been buying songs from iTunes USA with my US credit card, so I can only assume that the reverse is also possible. Should the slide of the US greenback continue (the canadian dollar is already at a 10+ year high against the USD) and CDN$ > USD$ I will just switch back.

      If only I could return all my music bought under the US account for a refund and re-purchase at the lower currency price.

      Getting a Canadian CC isn't as easy as it was to get an American one. In the US your (my?) bank card also functions as a debit card from visa/mastercard. So merely having a bank card generally means you can buy stuff online because it functions as a visa/mastercard. Not so in Canada. Your bank card is not affiliated with a credit card company, instead it is part of the Interac network, which allows you to make purchases with it everywhere that accepts Interac (which is everywhere (except Tim Hortons)). So you would need to procure a Canadian billing address, a Canadian bank account, then a Canadian credit card.

      good luck :)

    12. Re:Possible? by Class+Act+Dynamo · · Score: 0, Offtopic

      What you say is funny and true, but there is legitimate danger to buying drugs from Canada if you are not careful. Less reputable suppliers may be selling counterfeit or ineffective-dose drugs, but more likely is that a reputable seller is three generations away from the counterfeiting is selling in good faith. That said, my relatives buy drugs from Canada because it makes sense. One must be careful, because it is a threat, just not quite as big as Bushie says.

      --
      My other computer is a Jacquard loom.
    13. Re:Possible? by TheBurningDog · · Score: 0

      yea, but the shipping kills the deal.

    14. Re:Possible? by canwaf · · Score: 1, Troll

      The US military is only as good as it's equipment. Canadian forces are much better trained, even our cadets seemingly are better trained than the 'elite' of the US military.

    15. Re:Possible? by bigberk · · Score: 1, Offtopic

      Real Canadian drugs you can trust... you think everyone up here is dropping dead from bad pharms? Fake Canadian pharmacies you should avoid, like these asshole spammers (please slashdot the site into the ground, spam/scam running out of China)

    16. Re:Possible? by secolactico · · Score: 2, Informative

      Canadian credit cards are mostly the same as US cards: Visa, MasterCard, AMEX...

      ... and the rest of the world. The catch is, the store has the ability to know if your card was emitted by a canadian (or wherever) bank. And your billing address must be canadian too.

      --
      No sig
    17. Re:Possible? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I'm a Canadian and I download my songs off of WinMX since most albums are crap and there are very few songs worth buying. :P

    18. Re:Possible? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      "OUR ARMY COULD KICK YOUR ARMY'S ASS!"

      Haha! The joke's on you bud, we don't even have an army!

    19. Re:Possible? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Care to back that up? No, I'm not an American, I'm Swiss. I'd just like to hear some of your proof, Mr. America Jr.

    20. Re:Possible? by IgnoramusMaximus · · Score: 4, Funny

      Or Canadian Tire money....

    21. Re:Possible? by damiam · · Score: 1, Offtopic

      It's dangerous to buy drugs in the US too if you're not careful. Canada doesn't have a monopoly on counterfeit drugs.

      --
      It's hard to be religious when certain people are never incinerated by bolts of lightning.
    22. Re:Possible? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    23. Re:Possible? by Rick+and+Roll · · Score: 1

      When they're safe, they're coming.

    24. Re:Possible? by Spillman · · Score: 1

      Offtopic yes, but I just have to comment.

      I can't understand people who would fall for that, entering credit card info on a non-secure connection is one thing.
      But who thinks you can really get a Schedule IV controlled drug w/o a prescription?!

      --
      sig?
    25. Re:Possible? by danheskett · · Score: 1

      Ahh.. RIGHT.

      I'd wager my money on a squad of delta operators against any batallion of any armed forces of any nationality (excluding SAS) anywhere on the planet in real-world fighting conditions.

      Read Black Hawk down sometime to read about how a delta guy ran back to base through a free-fire zone literally holding his guts, returning fire, in 100 degree mid-day sun after a 72-hr battle.

    26. Re:Possible? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      hmm, i could make some dough. . .i got a canadian credit card. Buy and resell, i could make what? 1 buck off each?

    27. Re:Possible? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What a wuss.

    28. Re:Possible? by BondGamer · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Step 1: Buy $10 plot of Land in Canada and stick mailbox on it. Step 2: Apply for credit card. Step 3: Save money in canadaian iTunes store!

    29. Re:Possible? by Sycraft-fu · · Score: 1

      If the US dollar goes back up, I might try it (not a big enough difference at this point). Having already procured a Canadian citizenship several years ago, I think I can swing the rest :)

      By the way: Tell the damn banks up there to get on the whole check card (what debit cards with CC logos on them are called) thing. It's one of the most useful changed to banking in the last decade.

    30. Re:Possible? by Jeremy+Erwin · · Score: 1

      Don't worry about it. The US dollar is weakening, and Apple's relatively high valuation of Canuck currency will soon cease to be much of a problem.

    31. Re:Possible? by ImSoRonery · · Score: 0, Funny

      I'm So Ronery I'm so ronery So ronery So ronery and sadry arone There's no one Just me onry Sitting on my rittle throne I work very hard and make up great prans But nobody ristens, no one understands Seems that no one takes me serirousry And so I'm ronery A little ronery Poor rittre me There's nobody I can rerate to Feer rike a bird in a cage It's kinda sihry But not rearry Because it's fihring my body with rage I work rearry hard and I'm physicarry fit But nobody here seems to rearize that When I rure the world maybe they'rr notice me But untir then I'rr just be ronery Rittre ronery, poor rittre me I'm so ronery I'm so ronery

    32. Re:Possible? by codemachine · · Score: 1

      Some of the credit unions here already offer them. It is possible other banks are too. They were calling them "Payment Cards" or something like that. You use it like a debit card or credit card, and it takes money straight from your bank account. I think you can also set up a line of credit if you want, people who get them often do so to avoid getting themselves in debt with their CC.

    33. Re:Possible? by germansausage · · Score: 2, Funny

      We Canucks have been underfunding our armed forces for years. There is no actual civilian department of defense to oversee the army, but instead we have a wierd hybrid of bureaucrat/generals running the show. Our helicopters (Sea Kings) were obsolete 15 years ago, and are referred to as 10,000 parts flying in loose formation.

      The Delaware National Guard could kick our army's ass.

    34. Re:Possible? by dalek_killer · · Score: 1

      Just as its not possible for Canadians to buy songs from the US, Its not possible for Americans to buy songs from Canada's iTunes. That is Unless you have a Canadian mailing address then you could.

    35. Re:Possible? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      My ordinary MasterCard does this... you can swipe it just like a debit card. (Of course, it's treated as a cash advance, which means you start paying interest on it right away.) But I always use plain ordinary Interac or credit card anyway.

    36. Re:Possible? by CharlesF · · Score: 1

      How are the fake Canadian pharmacies any worse than fake American pharmacies?

      --
      Do not read this sig!
    37. Re:Possible? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      which allows you to make purchases with it everywhere that accepts Interac (which is everywhere (except Tim Hortons))

      You're telling me that you can't use a Canadian credit card at Tim Hortons, and there hasn't been a public uprising?

    38. Re:Possible? by Monsieur+Canard · · Score: 1

      That's why when I heard that the US government was buying flu vaccine from our friends in Canadia I nearly plotzed.

      --
      He took a duck to the face at 250 knots.
    39. Re:Possible? by CrazyTalk · · Score: 1

      OK next question then - living in the USA, how can I get a Canadian credit card? With online payment, I wouldnt ever have to go to Canada to pick up my bills which (perhaps) could just be sent to a PO Box somewhere.

    40. Re:Possible? by stolen.identity · · Score: 1

      Cheque cards don't make much sense in Canada. Using a debit card at a store is "free" (costs money to the store, not to the buyer*), and there are really only three major credit cards.

      As far as I understand, Cheque cards are practically a requirement in the US because every town/state/street corner has it's own bank, and debit cards don't work as well because either they don't talk to each other or they cost too much.

      Cheque cards exist to provide the convenience of credit cards to people with crappy credit. In Canada, debit solves this most of the time.**

      * Yes, I know that the cost gets passed along. But the price is the same as the cash price.

      ** Tim Horton's doesn't take credit cards either.

    41. Re:Possible? by mjpaci · · Score: 1

      Canadian Snipers = teh bomb. In international competitions of Sniper teams, the Canadian's nearly always place higher than the US.

      http://www.snipercountry.com/Articles/KillingShot_ 2430Metres.asp

      http://216.239.39.104/search?q=cache:MQ8qdygzuvYJ: www.stormpages.com/swellal/sof.html+canadian+snipe r+afghanistan&hl=en

    42. Re:Possible? by Marc2k · · Score: 1

      Goddamn though, Tim Horton's is worth hauling your ass to an ATM for.

      --
      --- What
    43. Re:Possible? by Tragek · · Score: 1

      That and canadins have an excellent track record int winter excercises. Hmm. Let's wonder why?

    44. Re:Possible? by the+web · · Score: 1

      Off Topic but... Dude! "(except Tim Hortons)" You know how long the lines would be!!!

      --
      __
      Thou hast besquirted me, O leotarded one.
    45. Re:Possible? by Ubergrendle · · Score: 2, Informative

      Or Canadian Tire money....

      For non-Canadian Slashdotters... Canadian Tire is a chain of stores here in Canada that specialises in automobile parts and hardware. Its hugely popular and one of the few homegrown stores here that have fought off the onslaught of US box stores.

      They have a loyalty program of sorts, where they give you "Canadian Tire Money" for a % of your purchase (something like 2%?). This is one of the oldest loyalty programs in Canada, as I can remember my dad having Canadian Tire $ in the 1970s, and it must have gone back farther than that.

      From time to time, the $ is so popular that people will trade up for it at cash value. Also, from tiem to time, it will be dispensed as 'real' money from cash machines or store tellers due to human error. These make for amusing situations.

      The joke for the last few years was that Canadian Tire $ exchanged better with the US $ than our own currency. :) That's obviously no longer the case as the US$ has tanked for the past 18 months...

      --
      John Maynard Keynes: "When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do?"
    46. Re:Possible? by Reapman · · Score: 1

      Ya ya, mod this as off topic but, Whaddya mean TH don't accept Interac? I use it all the time there... Maybe it's an Albertan thing...

    47. Re:Possible? by amokk · · Score: 1

      Are you an idiot or do you just like pretending to be one?

      The type of cards you describe have been available for many years now. Some banks call them stupid names like "cheque cards" but nevertheless, they are affiliated with usually Visa or MC and work everywhere a regular credit card does.

      --
      I think, therefore I am an Atheist.
    48. Re:Possible? by nilptr46 · · Score: 1

      You don't like our cows. You don't like our trees. You won't like our tunes.

    49. Re:Possible? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yeah, but doesn't it get shipped to the US address then?

    50. Re:Possible? by Sycraft-fu · · Score: 1

      Well my sister seems to get charged fees by her bank (don't know who) for every trasaction over a certian monthly limit. I do probably 200+ transactions per month on my check card and don't pay for any of them.

      Also the nice thing about it is since Visa/Mastercard are basically worldwide, it really does work anywhere. I had no trouble in Norway using it.

    51. Re:Possible? by AusG4 · · Score: 1

      I have to say... I thought I was the only one that hated the fact that Timmy Ho-Ho's didn't take Interac.

      Solidarity, brother.

      --
      bash-3.00$ uname -a
      SunOS panda 5.10 Generic sun4u sparc SUNW,Ultra-2
    52. Re:Possible? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Ship what?

  2. Price per album? by CRC'99 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Wonder if these will still be $10+.....

    --
    Sendmail is like emacs: A nice operating system, but missing an editor and a MTA.
    1. Re:Price per album? by randomiam · · Score: 2, Funny
      Better yet, will the songs be priced at $CDN 0.99.

      If so, will we call them 'looney (i)Tunes'?

    2. Re:Price per album? by yabos · · Score: 2, Informative

      Albums are mostly $9.99 Canadian dollars = about $8.50 American :D

    3. Re:Price per album? by Helios1182 · · Score: 1

      Yep, and its in the summary. Some days I wonder if RTFA should be RTFS.

  3. Only album for sale at the moment... by TheLoneIguana · · Score: 5, Funny

    "The Best of Bob and Doug Mackenzie."

    Take off!

    1. Re:Only album for sale at the moment... by Eberlin · · Score: 5, Funny

      Uno, dos, tres...hat trick!

      Hey Hosers! What the heck is a vertigo anyway?

      I think that's what you get when you've had too much molsen, eh.

      Or when you've gone toe-to-toe with Tie Domi and your touque is the only thing that's upright.

      This is our iTunes commercial, so like buy our album and stuff, eh. We also have a custom iPod specially made for the great white north. It's completely white. Buy that too. We get kickbacks so we can get more beer.

      Our time is up. Good day, eh!

    2. Re:Only album for sale at the moment... by wgadmin · · Score: 1

      ... and, if CanCon had its way, 700,000 other Canadian classics (by 6 other well-known bands). Oh well, at least I can use this to top up my Glenn Gould collection.

    3. Re:Only album for sale at the moment... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      Don't laugh, their album ("Greate White North") is actually available: iTMS link.

      Ironically the album is available in the US store, but not the Canadian one.

    4. Re:Only album for sale at the moment... by DougMackensie · · Score: 1

      Hello english Royalties!

    5. Re:Only album for sale at the moment... by CrazyTalk · · Score: 1

      Come on - I'm sure they will have the "Best of Rush" too!

    6. Re:Only album for sale at the moment... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      C'mon, man, that's cold. You're ignoring all the Rush albums.

    7. Re:Only album for sale at the moment... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You forgot the, "...eh" as in:
      Take off, eh.

      (Hope I'm spelling that right...)

  4. About time by Fenis-Wolf · · Score: 3, Interesting

    About time. I don't see why it took this long. Was there some massive tech barriers, that restrained the opening, or was it Canadas version of the RIAA?

    --

    1. Re:About time by thenextpresident · · Score: 2, Informative

      No. Probably because people in Canada are legally allowed to download music. =)

      --
      Jason Lotito
    2. Re:About time by peculiarmethod · · Score: 4, Funny

      they were snowed in.

      --
      ** "It's not my job to stand between the people talking to me, and the ones listening to me." -- Pego the Jerk
    3. Re:About time by FLAGGR · · Score: 4, Funny

      Since we Canadians still use 486's, apple's been hard pressed to get iTunes to work on our pc's. We still use 486's because its so damn cold, and that somehow makes sense.

    4. Re:About time by nelsonal · · Score: 1

      No doubt you already knew this, and probably don't want me spoiling the secret, but Alberta is considerably warmer than most of Montana (at least once you get up to Calgary. You can grow fruit, while we're lucky to get lettuce to grow in our gardens (we had an 83 day growing season this year).

      --
      Degaussing scares the bad magnetism out of the monitor and fills it with good karma.
    5. Re:About time by jericho4.0 · · Score: 2, Funny
      Hell is probably hotter than a burning house, but I wouldn't want to live in either. :-)

      --
      "A language that doesn't affect the way you think about programming, is not worth knowing" - Alan Perlis
    6. Re:About time by Citizen+of+Earth · · Score: 2, Funny

      We still use 486's because its so damn cold, and that somehow makes sense.

      You really need to upgrade. I keep my apartment toasty warm with an Athlon.

    7. Re:About time by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      BURN! Total burn. Do you smell the smoke? ...Because you just got burned!

    8. Re:About time by InadequateCamel · · Score: 1

      There is probably a better reason, but I assumed that the reason was that Canada is simply not a big enought market to prioritize opening there. When you consider that California has a bigger economy and population than Canada, that isn't really that much of a stretch.

    9. Re:About time by aristotle-dude · · Score: 1

      What if you include all of those Canadians living in LA?

      --
      Jesus was a compassionate social conservative who called individuals to sin no more.
    10. Re:About time by FLAGGR · · Score: 1

      Stop being a Canada fanboy, I'm from Canada too and know damn well it's not that cold :) You just gotta learn to make fun of yourself sometimes.

    11. Re:About time by tbone1 · · Score: 1
      About time. I don't see why it took this long.

      I think there was a mixup on the bacon specs.

      Or perhaps Jobs is still mad about the last few Bryan Adams releases.

      --

      The Independent: Reverend Spooner Arrested in Friar Tuck Incident - ISIHAC, Historical Headlines
    12. Re:About time by codeguy007 · · Score: 1

      A Pentium 60 is much better for warming your abode.

  5. Re:Canada sucks by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Ignorant! We're socialist, not communist!

  6. Dont expect the store to be up for long by infonick · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Under the Canadian Copywrite Law, "personal copying" is permitted. This means I can download all the music I could ever want. The only drawback is a small tax on every cd purchased. thats ok though, i dont buy cd's often.

    --

    You are confusing me with someone who cares.
    1. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by cheshiremackat · · Score: 1

      CD-Rs too though... buy many of those? Lots of companies do... so they effectively subsidize Canadian fair use... Schweet!

      --
      Bad spellers of the world untie!
    2. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You can also copy music in the U.S. too, it's when you share (upload) your music - that's when they get uptight. I am legally allowed to burn my whole CD collection for my use, or download it, if I have the CD, just cant share it. Hence the trouble with bittorrent.

    3. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by jxyama · · Score: 2

      i think canadian iTMS will do quite well, actually... iTMS has been successful because it's relatively cheap, allows a lot of individual tracks to be purchased (instead of an album), easy to use, easy to find the songs you want quickly and you are guaranteed a certain download quality. i think the "fear" of being sued because you use downloading (which hasn't happened anyway... only lawsuits have been for uploaders) is not the only reason iTMS has been successful.

    4. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by smcavoy · · Score: 1

      one big difference is up here that personal copy can be given to a friend. i.e. making mix tapes or CDs for friends. not just making a backup for personal use. And on top of that, sharing music on a p2p network was not ruled illegal (under the current copyright system).

    5. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by pigscanfly.ca · · Score: 2, Interesting

      But why the hell would you be affriad of being sued if two seperate rullings have indicated its perfectly legal because of the coppyright levy?
      The only case in which I see iTunes being able to be able to use the not get sued philosphy is with audio books (which are illegal) .
      For iTunes to be successfull in Canada it will have to emphasice that artists are getting a fair share , since otherwise people will just continue to legally download music without paying for it.

    6. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by grumpygrodyguy · · Score: 1

      Under the Canadian Copywrite Law, "personal copying" is permitted. This means I can download all the music I could ever want.

      Yep, well said.

      That story is trying to invoke fear that the influence of copy control in America is bleeding across the US border, and tries to legitimate corrupt American lawmakers by claiming a 'better' alternative to sharing music online. Any country that willingingly makes information a permanent form of property has no concept of the word freedom.

      Thankfully there are nations outside of the US that check-in with common sense before unleashing corporate leg-breakers on their citizens.

      --
      The government has a defect: it's potentially democratic. Corporations have no defect: they're pure tyrannies. -Chomsky
    7. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by That's+Unpossible! · · Score: 4, Insightful

      "Don't expect the store to be up for long."

      Yes, I will chalk that bit of insight up there with the infamous, "No wireless. Less space than a nomad. Lame."

      If you think the fact that iTunes is one of the few "legal" places to download music is the reason for its success in the United States, you might be right. Fortunately for them, it isn't.

      Some things to ponder...

      Via your Canadian "free" channels, how hard is it to find a COMPLETE album, with all of the correct song and album information, converted consistently well to digital file format, complete with album cover art embedded? Because on iTunes it is easy-as-fucking-pie.*

      There is something to be said for being able to fire up iTunes, type in "Old Hundredth," sample the recordings available, find one I like, and buy it AND have it on my hard drive in a matter of 60 seconds.

      * Not to be confused with pie-fucking.

      --
      Ironically, the word ironically is often used incorrectly.
    8. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by jxyama · · Score: 1

      did you read the parent i replied to? that post implied that the canadian iTMS would fail because downloading is legal.

    9. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by yabos · · Score: 1

      No, you can't share your music in Canada legally. There is nothing (legally)stopping us from downloading stuff though.

    10. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by Justin205 · · Score: 1, Informative
      Via your Canadian "free" channels, how hard is it to find a COMPLETE album, with all of the correct song and album information, converted consistently well to digital file format, complete with album cover art embedded? Because on iTunes it is easy-as-fucking-pie.
      BitTorrent.

      Yes, we use BitTorrent up here. Nice, full albums, and many of which have good info tags, and high quality (many I find around 200-250 kbps).

      Now rarely are the album arts embedded within, but personally I find that a waste. It is a waste of space in my mind (embedded in every track of every song you own? Overkill.). But many albums do include JPGs of the album covers.
      --
      "Your effort to remain what you are is what limits you."
    11. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by Trillan · · Score: 1

      Yeah, I know it's legal. I choke a little every time I see the phrase "illegal copying" with respect to Canadian music. It ain't illegal (yet, at least) no matter how many times the labels repeat the phrase. But I think the store will prosper anyway, as very often I'd much rather spend $0.99 on a song than fight with the various measures the labels have used to sabotage the P2P system.

    12. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by taylortbb · · Score: 1

      Actually, there is an interesting loophole, if you claim your music was shared accidently you're ok. Most programs will offest to search your HD, if you let it and it finds all your music you can claim you didn't know what it did. Or when you download stuff you can claim you didn't know that left it open to other users. Basically, play stupid. The other thing you can do, have an un-protected WAP, that way you can ask them to prove it was you (basically impossible).

    13. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful
      Sorry to burst your bubble, but in Canada the government has already decided that everyone is a pirate. Thus anyone who decides to buy a device that is capable of copyright infringment, such as an ipod, is automatically punished via a "Levy". While the government hasn't broken any Canadian legs it has managed to get us to peacefully spread our legs, bend over, and take it up the ass.
    14. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by natrius · · Score: 1

      And when they don't come with cover art, there's always Muine.

    15. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Can you tell us the date and time when Puretracks went out of business? 'cause I mean if you're not completely full of shit and all it must have been shut down long ago.

    16. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    17. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by anethema · · Score: 1

      The levvy really isnt that much (yet), and i think its a small price to pay for legal downloading of any music we want.

      --


      It's easier to fight for one's principles than to live up to them.
    18. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by heeeraldo · · Score: 0

      easy-as-fucking-pie. have you ever tried to make pie? it's surprisingly difficult to get the crust right.

    19. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by Twirlip+of+the+Mists · · Score: 1

      Yeah, I saw how well that works just recently when doing some research for an article (an article which, now, will probably never be published; music piracy is basically dead according to recent stats). If you want to download something, Bittorrent works well. But if you're looking for something particular, you're shit-outta-luck. For example, if you want to get Dire Straits' first album, you're going to come up dry on Bittorrent. But you can get it in three minutes on the iTunes store, and that counts download time.

      --

      I write in my journal
    20. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by dp01011 · · Score: 2, Informative

      DISCLAIMER... THIS POST IS NOT INTENDED TO BE LEGAL ADVICE!!!!! Why should Canadians pay at all..... making digital copies of a recorded performance (for personal use) does not appear to be illegal in Canada according to its Copyright Act language: "80. (1) Subject to subsection (2) that act of reproduction all or any substantial part of (a) a musical work embodied in a sound recording, . . . onto an audio recording medium for the private use of the person who makes the copy does not constitute an infringement of the copyright in the musical work, the performer's performance or the sound recording." Cite: Copyright Act R.S., c. C-30, s. 80 (1985).

    21. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by shark72 · · Score: 1

      A fair chunk of the Slashdot crowd had similar doom and gloom predictions when iTMS went up in the US. They predicted its imminent death because of all the content available for free on the P2P apps, and because the DRM wrapper would surely be cracked (it was -- so what), because there was DRM in the first place, because it didn't have every piece of music ever released including that one where the chickens cluck their way through "Take The A Train",* and because prices were too high.

      A year later, iTMS is doing gargantuan business, Apple (and the record labels) are having the last laugh, and now, naturally, imminent death is predicted for the Canadian store.

      * I just checked. It's still not available on iTMS.

      --
      Sitting in my day care, the art is decopainted.
    22. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by aristotle-dude · · Score: 1
      That is bullshit. None of that CD-R levy money makes it through the bureaucracy to the artists/label. It all gets eaten by costs of administration by the government. It's nothing but a tax grab and the government gives the appearance of being tough on piracy. Like the songs? Support the artists by buying songs legally. CD-R levies don't give squat to the artists.

      Don't give me the, it's legal horse shit. Are those people on P2p close personal friends or family? No? Then don't share with them.

      --
      Jesus was a compassionate social conservative who called individuals to sin no more.
    23. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by aristotle-dude · · Score: 1
      What the hell does legality have to do with it? Ever consider doing the right thing? What if you were a recording artist?

      Besides all that, iTMS is convenient while making you feel good about supporting the artists. Are you so amoral and cheap that you would not pay a penny short of loonie for a song to keep? People give more than that somtimes to buskers on the street.

      Consider that a song costs less than a hamburger at McDonald's or about the same as a slice of pizza at those cheap pizza joints.

      --
      Jesus was a compassionate social conservative who called individuals to sin no more.
    24. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by aristotle-dude · · Score: 1
      You don't know what fair use is. Recording off the radio "is" fair use. Making burned copies of songs from CD's you own "is" fair use. Copying songs you have not bought "is not" fair use.

      Forget legality for a minute. What is the moral thing to do? Did you notice the word "fair" in that phrase?

      --
      Jesus was a compassionate social conservative who called individuals to sin no more.
    25. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      >Via your Canadian "free" channels, how hard is it to find a COMPLETE album, with all of the correct song and album information, converted consistently well to digital file format, complete with album cover art embedded? Because on iTunes it is easy-as-fucking-pie.*

      Indeed. I purchased "Vertigo" (duh) on my Windows XP desktop, but my old Thinkpad 760XL laptop can only run Win98SE (P166MMX, 104MB max), so I tried to convert the protected AAC file to MP3. Oups, it's got DRM, it won't allow me.

      Fine then, I'm in Canada, I could've downloaded it freely, but heck now I even paid for it, nothing's stopping me from downloading it (not even a guilty conscience).

      Well, what do you know. It took me no less than NINE downloads before I finally found a file that wasn't 25 MINUTES OF SILENCE.

      Then, on the two files I got that had the actual tune, one was badly encoded/ripped or something.

      Heck, a quick check in my P2P-downloaded tunes shows up a lot of tracks that are 128kbps but only 22KHz.

      Seems the industry is fighting from the inside now (silent files and crappy encoding). Can't blame them, and it's fine by me. They're playing within the P2P rules, and I'd rather see them poison P2P networks than send stupid multi-million dollars lawsuits onto kids and grandmothers.

      At 0.99$CAN per track (9.99$CAN for most albums), I'm sure as hell not gonna waste my time on P2P anymore if iTMS has what I want.

      Now that we have a TRUE music store (screw those idiots who sell Microsoft WMA crap), I hope they'll remove that stupid surtax.

    26. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      >one big difference is up here that personal copy can be given to a friend.

      Not exactly. If you're doing this, it's illegal under Canadian law. You're the one distributing copyrighted works.

      The loophole goes like this: you're allowed to make a copy for personnal use. So YOU have to ask your friend to borrow his CD, so you can then make your OWN copy/backup. Your friend didn't make the copy for you, so there was no distribution.

      I know it sounds stupid (since in the end the result is the same), but that's legalese for you.

    27. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by falcon5768 · · Score: 1
      Well see thing is, technically thats true here too... Oh sure the RIAA likes to scare people, but if you can produce the albums that you downloaded the music of, then well guess what, your off the hook (the person you downloaded from might not be though) See while your right, your allowed to download all you want there too, you still need to own the CD in Canada, dont kid yourself that your dont. The rules are EXACTLY the same as in the US, personal use only by the person who owns the CD. personal copying means your alowed a backup copy... guess what in the US YOUR ALLOWED TO HAVE A BACKUP COPY! Your not allowed to send it to people who down own the CD though which is the hitch and where the problems start.

      The thing is though, even with all this disscusion of "personal copy" and all, thats not what the iTunes Music Store is for. ITs for those people who dont feel like buying the CD and who like to preview their purchases.

      I dont buy CDs. I dont feel the overwelming need to go to the music store anymore. I use iTunes to do all my non rare shoping. and you know what I cut my CD purchasing in half now that I can hear if a track sucks ass or not.

      --

      "Slashdot, where telling the truth is overrated but lying is insightful."

    28. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by grumpygrodyguy · · Score: 1

      Did you notice the word "fair" in that phrase?

      I see, so you think 'fair' entails 120 year copyright terms for all information produced at expense?

      And 'fair' also describes information having only one legitimate(i.e. the highest corporate bidder) 'owner' at any one time?

      What happens in your 'moral' future when the media conglomerates own every piece of cultural information you've ever been exposed to, and forces you to pay a tithe(decided soley by them) in order to re-gain access to that information?

      --
      The government has a defect: it's potentially democratic. Corporations have no defect: they're pure tyrannies. -Chomsky
    29. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by gobbo · · Score: 1

      "why the hell would you be affriad of being sued if two seperate rullings have indicated its perfectly legal because of the coppyright levy?" [sic]

      Believe it or not, most Canadians are so heavily propagandized by watching Hollywood TV and consuming other US media that many of us have trouble discerning between USA institutions and laws and Canadian. They hear the mantra "downloading is stealing" and since they didn't read page 14 of the local tabloid three years ago, or watch the National news one evening last March, they don't know that it's okay to copy off a friend, or download, they just hear "stealing music," "piracy," etc. The vast majority haven't even heard of the levy we're paying for recording media, since it's just folded into the price.

      iTunes will fly because it's convenient and clean, a whizzy high-tech experience that just works. You can get album art and check out the video, preview the songs, and they aren't sabotaged by the RIAA or SOCAN 30 seconds in.

    30. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Indeed. I purchased "Vertigo" (duh) on my Windows XP desktop, but my old Thinkpad 760XL laptop can only run Win98SE (P166MMX, 104MB max), so I tried to convert the protected AAC file to MP3. Oups, it's got DRM, it won't allow me.

      But you can burn to CD and then rip to MP3. More than that, you should do that. Read the iTMS TOS: if the store ever shuts down and all you have is the DRM-locked file, then you have NOTHING. Likewise, if your hard drive gets hosed and all you have is one copy of the file, you also have nothing. So making non-DRM backups (with inevitable loss from transcoding, yes) should be a priority for anyone buying from any online music store.

    31. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by codeguy007 · · Score: 1

      Actually this is complete crap. The supreme court ruled that you can share music files from your harddrive under the current Canadian Copyright laws.

    32. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by codeguy007 · · Score: 1

      Well since the Canadian Copyright laws state that copying music is legal, they have decided that every one is not a pirate but a privateer. Unlike a pirate, a Privateer's actions are legally sactioned by the Government.

    33. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by chris_eineke · · Score: 0

      Canadian pie, eh?

      --
      "All you have to do is be fragile and grateful. So stay the underdog." Chuck Palahniuk, Choke
    34. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by aristotle-dude · · Score: 1
      What the hell does that have to do with paying the artist? If you don't pay for the musical recording in the first place, what rights should you have regarding it? None.

      Do you think concerts should be free?

      If you think musical recordings/performance should be free, do you mind not getting paid for the job you do?

      Your diatribe about media conglomerates is a straw man. The issue here is paying the artist because it is the right thing to do and a way to show appreciation for their hard work/dedication to their art. Cultural information? Are you on crack? Minstrels http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=Minstrels of the middle ages were paid for their performance of music, so paying for musical performance should not be something new.

      You don't get it. There may be many songs which are part of our shared culture and are now found in the public domain but performances by artists belong to the artist regardless of where the music comes from. It is up to the artist to choose whether to distribute it freely to others, not people like you.

      I think you are confusing "music/lyrics" (information) with performance (a product/service offered by an artist). Of course songs should eventually become part of the public domain but the recordings themselves are not information. They are interpretations/expressions of the "information".

      Regardless of how you feel about copyrights for music/lyrics (I agree with you about the 120 year copyright), that has nothing to do with not paying the artist for their performance of the piece.

      Here is my definition of "fair use". If you purchase a recording, you are free to do with it as you wish for personal use including creating your own mixes, using it in your home videos etc... If you have a book in your possession, you are free to take small excerpts via photo copying or quotation (with credits to the original work) and "use" it in your own art creation or academic work.

      Where do you get "use" as being a right to distribution or obtaining it without purchase? If you obtain tangible items without purchase/permission, that is called stealing.

      --
      Jesus was a compassionate social conservative who called individuals to sin no more.
    35. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by GuyZero · · Score: 1

      Nah, media levies don't make you a pirate.

      Think of it as a "single-payer music royalty" system, like health care. You pay for hospitals whether you're sick or healthy. So now you pay for music whether the CD is for backups or eDonkey downloads.

      It's not so much a country as a big buffet!

    36. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually, you are a little off. Because of the CD surtax we pay to the CCRA, et al, we are allowed to make personal backup copies. We are also allowed to make copies of friends CDs and the surtax is supposed to fairly compensate the artists for this potential loss.

      So I am allowed to copy my CDs to my HDD... AND... Someone else is allowed to copy my music, be it from original CD or my backed up copy.

      Where the ol'toes get stomped on, is when I start to distribute copies I made to other people, whether or not I sell or give those copies away.

      So, in effect, the laws will change... because technically, right now, someone copying from my hard drive is not illegal activity.

    37. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by That's+Unpossible! · · Score: 1

      Yes, but have you ever tried to fuck a pie?

      Piece of cake.

      --
      Ironically, the word ironically is often used incorrectly.
    38. Re:Dont expect the store to be up for long by schon · · Score: 1

      None of that CD-R levy money makes it through the bureaucracy to the artists/label.

      Wrong.

      It's nothing but a tax grab

      Except that it's a levy, not a tax, (which doesn't go to the government.)

  7. Is there a point? by Dancin_Santa · · Score: 1, Troll

    The only difference between the two countries is currency, and since the payment method requires a credit card anyway, that is not really an issue.

    What is the benefit of having a separate website for Canadians when the Internet is designed to be international? It isn't like there is some giant firewall at the Canadian border that blocks Canadian users from accessing the regular iTunes page. The media is also fully digital, can be downloaded, and doesn't have to come wrapped in cardboard.

    This is international commerce without the problems of nationalities getting in the way. I don't understand the point of having a separate website for a group of people who speak the same language as the original group.

    1. Re:Is there a point? by RhettD · · Score: 2, Informative

      It has to do with the licensing agreements carried out with the Canadian divisions of record labels vs the US divisions. Plus, us Canadians were unable to purchase music from the US store, as you needed a credit card with a US address.

    2. Re:Is there a point? by infonick · · Score: 4, Funny

      The reason for the different stores is the different laguage we use here up north. Instead of oh, say, "Pay Now!" It will say "Pay Now Eh?!"

      --

      You are confusing me with someone who cares.
    3. Re:Is there a point? by SpecBear · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Because partitioning the market makes the market less efficient. The less efficient a market is, the more it can be exploited for profit. And they can do this because the music copyright holders don't compete based on price. They can maximize profits by charging Canadians one price and Americans a higher price, but only if Americans are barred from shopping in the same store as Canadians.

      A bit of a side rant: Is anyone else out there really annoyed that corporations militantly defend their right to source work and materials from wherever's cheapest, but fight tooth and nail to prevent consumers from buying goods from wherever's cheapest? When I try to sell my labor, I have to compete in a global market, but they get to price their music on a country by country basis.

    4. Re:Is there a point? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yup, can't wait to buy a Buick LaCrosse in Canada, especially Quebec...

      For those who don't get the joke, 'LaCrosse' is French slang for masterbate.... mmmm Buick Masterbate... lovely

      Eh?

    5. Re:Is there a point? by Gr8Apes · · Score: 1

      Well said! We're either a global market, or we're not. It can't be get paid at global rates but have to pay at local rates, when local rates are higher. That's not sustainable.

      --
      The cesspool just got a check and balance.
    6. Re:Is there a point? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You're obviously a fake Canadian. Us real Canucks will most likely say: "Sorry for charging you for this eh, but could you pay now please?"

      BTW, sorry, I didn't mean to be so critical of your comment eh, but I had to point out the facts... Sorry. Have some Timbits?

    7. Re:Is there a point? by Trillan · · Score: 4, Insightful

      There are many, many differences between Canada and the United States -- including, in this specific case, entirely different organizations for Apple to negotiate with.

    8. Re:Is there a point? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

      when the Internet is designed to be international

      You have totally misunderstood the international concept of the internet. Actually, you have totally misunderstood the concept of the internet.

      The internet's primary function is NOT commerce.

      The internet's primary role is to share information. And that has always worked quite well, both locally and internationally. Internet-based commerce is a secondary part of the system and, as long as globalization isn't fully-implemented, will rarely be international.

    9. Re:Is there a point? by SpamJunkie · · Score: 1

      To quote the West Wing (poorly), "This is economics at work, sorting itself out. There are inefficiencies, hypocrisy, but that's how it works. In the end the market will find a solution."

      Even Bush can only keep the lid on it for so long.

    10. Re:Is there a point? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      Actually, price discrimination (what you call partitioning the market) is often more efficient. However, it may allow a producer with market power to obtain greater profits.

      The argument is this: if Canadians have a lower willingness to pay for online music than Americans, then producers can make more profit by charging a lower price to Canadians than they do to Americans. However, if producers are forced to charge the same price in both markets (or if Americans can easily buy in the lower-priced Canadian market), then some Canadians will be priced out of the market, which is a deadweight loss to the economy (i.e. it is inefficient).

      Allowing the producer to "partition the market" and charge different prices in different markets may increase profits but it may also increase total welfare (i.e. increase efficiency), since some consumers that would otherwise be priced out of the market can now obtain the good.

      In the limit, if a monopolist can perfectly price discriminate (i.e. charge each consumer their reservation price), then there will be no deadweight loss. From society's perspective, this is the most efficient outcome. However, the producer will capture all the surplus (i.e. profit).

      Thus, you can validly object to price discrimination on distributive grounds (as you appear to be doing, by complaining about music copyright holders' profits), but you cannot necessarily claim that their practices are inefficient.

    11. Re:Is there a point? by Linuxathome · · Score: 1
      corporations militantly defend their right to source work and materials from wherever's cheapest, but fight tooth and nail to prevent consumers from buying goods from wherever's cheapest


      Sadly though, this argument is a "chicken vs. egg" argument -- and I can see it both ways. Some companies are forced to go outside the country, because if they priced their product too high to match wages and benefits here in the US, they can't sell since the US consumer has lots of choices (imports are at a record high this holiday season). We as consumers should staunchly be willing to back up US companies with our wallets.

      On the other hand, the government could reduce imports (raising tariffs, etc.) to help the domestic economy, but how many Americans are for that? We're snowballing towards that global economy many of us hate to hear about -- eventually the whole global economy has to even out somehow, right?
    12. Re:Is there a point? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

      Partitioned markets are never more efficient than an equivalent free market, in the macroeconomic sense. Your argument is not from the perspective of efficiency -- it's an argument from the perspective of profit maximization by producers.

      Your efficiency argument is circular because it's only valid in an inefficient market, where producers enjoy non-market controls. In a free market, purchasers can arbitrage away artificial pricing distinctions. This leads to greater market efficiency. Canadians who purchase music at lower prices would resell them to Americans, rebalancing the artificial pricing distinction imposed by the producers. While this could happen today, there are enough frictional market restrictions due to the credit card requirements and DRM transfer requirements to prevent it happening on a meaningful economic scale.

      Don't confuse market efficiency with producer price maximization.

    13. Re:Is there a point? by shark72 · · Score: 1

      You've phrased it as if ending pricing in "99" is some sort of evil scheme concocted by Apple. The company for which I work produces products which we sell in the US and Canada; we price our stuff for the Canadian market based on what the Canadian market will bear. And, we'll set the suggested price to end in all nines, which means, of course, that it will usually be priced above or below the equivalent US price.

      And thousands of other companies do it, too. This is basic Marketing 101 stuff, folks.

      --
      Sitting in my day care, the art is decopainted.
    14. Re:Is there a point? by SmilingBoy · · Score: 1

      No, the grand-parent is right. You are mixing reality with a Microeconomics 101 market model: In real life, there are hardly any markets that are subject to perfect competition. Price-Discriminatin mostly leads to higher efficiency and social welfare (see Schmalenbach's famous paper from long time ago). You are implying a market with increasing average cost and homogenous products - but how is that relevant to the online music market? Fixed costs are high, marginal costs are close to zero. In a perfect market, prices would hence be close to zero. How would the "producers" now recover ther fixed cost? They couldn't. And because they would know this, they wouldn't enter in such a market in the first place. Therefore, you can only have a music market with market power for the producers: This market power is mainly achieved through marketing decisions (re-positioning their poducts) that lead to heterogenous product markets. Additionally, legal means like territorial licensing are used to geographically separate markets and be able to price-discriminate. Overall, this means that you can't legally get music for the marginal cost, which makes the market inefficient in a short-run, static sense. However, in the long-run, incentives to invest need to be preserved and hence, the music market may very well be efficient.

    15. Re:Is there a point? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Don't Americans find it annoying that they keep getting charged more for the same product? Try comparing gm.com and gmcanada.com. Go to "build your own vehicle", spec out the same vehicle with the same options, and then compare the final price after exchange.

      When I did this 3 years ago, the U.S. price was 22.5% more expensive for the same vehicle built on the same assembly line (with a different instrument panel). Even with sales tax taken into account (15% in Ontario vs. say 6% in Michigan), that doesn't come close to making up the difference.

      With the rapidly falling U.S. dollar, this gap may have changed recently, so sorry if the info is out of date.

      Even so, an American isn't ALLOWED to import a car from Canada if it's less than 6 months old, which effectively bars Americans from shopping for new cars in Canada. The only reason for this is for the U.S. government to give favors to the automobile companies.

      Even if the price is different, if there was truly free trade, then the prices would fall in line because there would be pressure for the U.S. prices to drop to meet the Canadian prices. The grandparent poster is exactly right. The rules favor companies but leave consumers screwed.

    16. Re:Is there a point? by ablair · · Score: 1


      " The only difference between the two countries is currency"

      You haven't been been up to Canada since the late 50's, have you?

  8. Re:but will Apple allow.. by Lord+Haha · · Score: 2, Interesting

    reality is though foreign currency fees will cost you more then 16ish cents you will save on the dollar, unless you buy ALOT at once (say 100+ at least before you would make it worth your time to do it)

  9. Fairness by Cid+Highwind · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    "This is probably fair since our CDs are usually cheaper here, too, at least on the west coast."

    That's not a usage of "fair" I'm familiar with. Are you Canadians getting 16% less music per track than Americans? Or did you mean to say "it's unfair in a similar way to the current CD price-fixing scheme"?

    --
    0 1 - just my two bits
    1. Re:Fairness by Canuck_TV · · Score: 2, Informative

      We get a deal on the 99c 'tunes. You, however, get a much better deal on hardware that costs thousands of dollars. Webstores have not kept up with the recent change in exchange rates.

      There are also different levies, taxes, and other costs that differ from country to country. Get over it. For once we _DIDN'T_ get screwed. Kind of nice.

    2. Re:Fairness by Trillan · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Fair for us, not you. :)

    3. Re:Fairness by yabos · · Score: 0, Flamebait

      Boo hoo. A top end G5 here costs $600 more if I take the US price and do the conversion to Canadian. I might as well just drive across the border and buy one. Then figure out a way to smuggle it back.

    4. Re:Fairness by WIAKywbfatw · · Score: 0

      Oh my God. You're bitching about paying fractionally more than the Canadians are?

      1. Well boo fucking hoo. Do you see dozens of Brits and Europeans complaining about the price of downloads from Apple's UK and EU stores? I'm not sure what the EU store pricing is set at but I know it's far more than the US one. And the UK one is more expensive still: 79p per track, which at current exchange rates (almost £1.00=$2.00) is equivalent to $1.50+.

      2. The Canadian iTMS might be a little cheaper than the US one right now but you haven't taken into account the direction that the US dollar is heading, which is down, down, down. Give it six months and instead of one US dollar being worth more than one Canadian dollar it most probably be the other way around. So, those tracks that you're bitching about being cheaper in Canada will have become more expensive in Canada.

      3. Find something more important than the price of music downloads to be pissed off about. Try the environment, civil rights or something else that suggests that you're capable of thinking about someone other than yourself for a change.

      --

      "Accept that some days you are the pigeon, and some days you are the statue." - David Brent, Wernham Hogg
    5. Re:Fairness by heeeraldo · · Score: 0

      just tell them it's a very large cheese grater.

      afaik, there's no duty on kitchen gear.

    6. Re:Fairness by Cid+Highwind · · Score: 1

      Oh my God. You're bitching about paying fractionally more than the Canadians are?

      No, I'm not. I don't buy music on iTMS, hence I don't really give a f*** about their pricing. I'm just picking on a slashdot story submitter who can't be bothered to learn what the words he's using mean.

      3. Find something more important than the price of music downloads to be pissed off about. Try the environment, civil rights or something else that suggests that you're capable of thinking about someone other than yourself for a change.

      Oh the irony...

      --
      0 1 - just my two bits
    7. Re:Fairness by vicparedes · · Score: 1

      Take it out of the box and throw the box out. Then again, you're out of luck when something happens and you need to claim warranty.

    8. Re:Fairness by mh101 · · Score: 1

      I believe this is what he means:

      I can drive down to somewhere in Washington and buy a particular CD for $15 USD. Or I can buy the same CD back home in Vancouver for $15 CAD, and not $19. Thus, it only seems fair that we're also only charged $0.99 instead of $1.25 or something similar. Plus, this also ensures that their sales are cheaper than physical CDs. i.e. the new U2 CD is available here for $12-13, but is only $10 on iTMS.

      The same pattern exists with DVDs, BTW. Same numbers, just different currency.

      --
      Duct tape is like the Force. It has a light side, a dark side, and it holds the universe together.
    9. Re:Fairness by Thijs+van+As · · Score: 1

      Oh yeah. Here in Europe the price of a song on iTMS is 0,99, so that's about USD $1,31 US or $1,67 CDN! That's globally 33% and 66% higher, respectively.

      So hey, don't complain ;)

    10. Re:Fairness by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0


      iTunes isn't yet a serious way to deliver quality music. it's a gimmick, like all the ringtones crap.
      and like the ringtones crap, value for money doesn't really enter into the equation so much.

      people buy from iTunes coz it's cool to download your fave mp3. people who are serious about their music library wouldn't go near.

  10. Re:but will Apple allow.. by Gryphon · · Score: 4, Informative

    No. The lawyers for record companies won't allow it; music sales are balkanized into seperate markets by country.

    This is why it takes Apple so long to roll out in each country -- they must negotiate rights for each market, one by one.

    To purchase from the Canadian iTMS, you must have a credit card with a Canadian address.

  11. Re:can i get an account... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    Why don't you just pay the extra few pennies for you music, you cheap leftist mother fucker. You think we Canadians want your type up here? Get fucked, eh?

  12. Aussie ITMS by z3021017 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Please Apple. Please.

    Australia/NZ now are the last English-speaking countries not to get iTunes so I hope we get it soon (as in the next 6 months).

    --
    Bored? Visit my exciting counter page!
    1. Re:Aussie ITMS by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Should be soon. The few rumors sites that have good track records (the ones that had this news up to a week ago) have it coming very soon. Apparently lots of licensing issues to iron out, but it's right around the corner.

    2. Re:Aussie ITMS by nxtr · · Score: 5, Funny

      there's a new zealand now?

    3. Re:Aussie ITMS by jxyama · · Score: 2, Insightful
      why does english-speaking matter?

      potential marketsize-wise, it's a no brainer where the next iTMS has to be: japan.

    4. Re:Aussie ITMS by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      why does english-speaking matter?

      Well, if they said "Australia/NZ now are the one-hundred-forty-seventh-last and the one-hunderd-forty-eighth-last countries in the world not to get iTunes," they wouldn't have gotten modded up as much.

    5. Re:Aussie ITMS by notthepainter · · Score: 2, Interesting
      Perhaps it is a translation issue? Australia would be much easier to "port" than Japan. Think of all the text on the iTMS, the Tom Waits biography is 3 screen tall, somebody has to go and translate all that.

      The original poster's point was that for the AUS/NZ market, they don't have to translate it.

      On the other hand, is the Canadian iTMS available in French?

    6. Re:Aussie ITMS by DAldredge · · Score: 1

      Because the translations of the site cost a whole hell of a lot less. IOW, its an much easier change than translating the site into another language.

    7. Re:Aussie ITMS by michaeldot · · Score: 3, Informative

      I heard a rumour that Telstra / NineMSN had put up serious obstacles to preventing this from happening, but I've not be able to see it confirmed either way.

      Anything reported in the press is insubstantial: David Frith on recent iTunes releases

      Australia's record industry also has a powerful lobby. They almost managed to kill parallel imports, and seem to be able to recruit high profile personalities (eg, Molly Meldrum) to spout the party line.

      I'd be interested to know what is really going on. But it's no use expecting to see any journalists dig up the facts, given publications like the Sydney Morning Herald's long-term hostility to the iPod.

      (How's this: when publishing a definitive review of MP3 players about a year ago, they omitted all reference to *the* MP3 player! They have to pay lip service to it now it's such a big hit, but most reviews damn it with faint praise. I think Creative must pay them more for their advertising.)

    8. Re:Aussie ITMS by xgamer04 · · Score: 1

      South Africa and Liberia have iTMS?

      --
      When you look at the state of the world, how can you not become a radical, liberal anarchist?
    9. Re:Aussie ITMS by michaeldot · · Score: 3, Funny

      there's a new zealand now?

      Yes, Old Zealand was where they filmed Lord of the Rings. All the towns look medieval so they didn't have to pay too much on the sets.

    10. Re:Aussie ITMS by GrahamCox · · Score: 1

      Sydney Morning Herald's long-term hostility to the iPod.
      I didn't think they were THAT bad, though I only ever read the Saturday edition. What did annoy me recently though was a) the iPod battery story was very one-sided and b) in a somewhat frivolous comparison of analogue/digital technologies (of all types) they preferred the original Walkman over the iPod - right, I'm really likely to carry around 250 or more cassettes, never mind the complete lack of random access to them, and the noisy distorted quality when I finally find the track I want. What were they thinking? I can think of no virtues that the Walkman had over an iPod, except that the iPod wasn't available in 1979, about the only compelling reason to buy a Walkman.
      They almost managed to kill parallel imports
      He he, I have a UK bank account, so I use iTMS UK to download songs quite legally direct onto my lappie here in Oz.

    11. Re:Aussie ITMS by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Good thing iTMS/Japan has already been announced, huh? :P

    12. Re:Aussie ITMS by martinX · · Score: 1

      Aussie Aussie Aussie!

      Oi! Oi! Oi!

      --
      When they came for the communists, I said "He's next door. Take him away. Goddam commies."
    13. Re:Aussie ITMS by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Aussies speak English now?

    14. Re:Aussie ITMS by Have+Blue · · Score: 1
      Two things:
      • Apple almost certainly did not write that biography; they must have gotten it from some standard who's who of music. There must be equivalents in Japanese that they can use.
      • They seem to tailor their selection to local taste, so there's a chance Tom Waits won't appear at all on the ITMSJ, and that it will have artists who are not in ITMSes outside Japan.
    15. Re:Aussie ITMS by rusty_rusty_rusty · · Score: 1

      You forgot Ireland...

    16. Re:Aussie ITMS by kiniry · · Score: 1

      Um, I think you forgot about Ireland. We are still waiting for iTunes here too!

      --
      Joseph R. Kiniry
      http://kind.ucd.ie/~kiniry/
      Lecturer
      UCD School of Computer Science and Informatics
    17. Re:Aussie ITMS by martingunnarsson · · Score: 1

      Since there is an iTMS in France that wouldn't be so hard. There is also one in Germany. Translation is not a problem.

      --
      Martin
    18. Re:Aussie ITMS by zsau · · Score: 1

      You know, it doesn't work when it was written as an acronym in the first place :P (Also, the old Zeeland is spelt with two e's and one a.)

      --
      Look out!
    19. Re:Aussie ITMS by gobbo · · Score: 1
      is the Canadian iTMS available in French?

      Oui.

    20. Re:Aussie ITMS by Evil+Al · · Score: 1

      nope, Ireland has no iTunes store, despite having Bono. Can we swap?

      --
      Ah, computer dating -- it's like pimping, but you rarely have to use the phrase "upside your head" -- Bender
    21. Re:Aussie ITMS by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      is the Canadian iTMS available in French?

      Oui.

      But it's mainly the interface, not editorial content, that's available in French. (Even the France store has plenty of artist bios and such in English.) There's also a weird imbalance in musical content: plenty of English-language Canadian stuff, precious little French-language music. I think it'll be a while before this store can truly be called bilingual.

      BTW, the mechanism for switching languages is odd: for French, visit the France store then return to the Canadian store. For English, visit an English-language store, then return to the Canadian store.

    22. Re:Aussie ITMS by Andrewkov · · Score: 1

      I love New Zealand, what with all those cute little hobbits running around...

    23. Re:Aussie ITMS by nxtr · · Score: 1

      shhh...

    24. Re:Aussie ITMS by Funksaw · · Score: 1

      I'm actually planning a move to New Zealand (from Texas) in about 7 months. I still don't see the point in buying from iTunes, when I can get the music I like to listen to, the way I like to listen to it, cheaper, simply by composing it myself! There is a DECIDED lack of Country-Techno music on iTunes.

    25. Re:Aussie ITMS by __aafkqj3628 · · Score: 1

      There is a DECIDED lack of Country-Techno music on iTunes.

      There is also a decided lack of that music in this country too (not that I'm complaining one bit).

  13. Canadian music... by PornMaster · · Score: 2, Funny

    They probably have Bryan Adams albums featured. :)

    1. Re:Canadian music... by xwinter · · Score: 1

      Don't forget Celine Dionne! Seriously, though, iTunes could use some more Canadian content, as bands like Mathew Good, and some old Tom Cochrane would be a sight for sore eyes in iTunes.

    2. Re:Canadian music... by Drakonian · · Score: 1

      It's modded funny but the features artists/albums are different. Canadian artists are much more prominent on it. The Tragically Hip and Sarah McLachlan are all over the front page.

      --
      Random is the New Order.
    3. Re:Canadian music... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Wow, I guess this will be really great for struggling Canadian artists like Nickelback, Sum41, Celine Dion, Barenaked Ladies and Anne-fuckin'-Murray. It's good to know they put in a good strong effort to support these small struggling artists and labels... Myabe this will change the way the industry champions a handfull of Canadian artists to skirt around the can-con laws in the media, while pushing an endless stream of american 'hits' at us. Go iTunes.

  14. Re:Oh goodie by kyouteki · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    I'm sure Canadians read Slashdot. Don't think something is useless if you don't care about it.

    --
    A slashdotter who didn't build his own computer is like a Jedi who didn't build his own lightsaber.
  15. Canadian Credit Card Required. by amigoro · · Score: 4, Funny
    The iTunes Music Store in Canada works with the Canadian dollar, and purchase and download of songs requires a valid credit card with a billing address in Canada.

    Any Canadian out there who wants to be my best friend?


    Moderate this comment
    Negative: Offtopic Flamebait Troll Redundant
    Positive: Insightful Interesting Informative Funny

    --


    Nothing to see here
    1. Re:Canadian Credit Card Required. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Hmmm, I have a Canadian CC, any ideas on how to implement this so it can be done securely, i.e. nobody can rip-off the other?

    2. Re:Canadian Credit Card Required. by Rii · · Score: 0

      Dear Sir or Madam,

      I have a large bank account stuck in my home country, and need help getting it into Canada. If you give me your credit card number, I will be able to transfer the balance with your account, and will give you 10% for your trouble. Also, I'll let you pick a free song.

    3. Re:Canadian Credit Card Required. by huber · · Score: 1

      yeah for 10 cents a song ill be your friend.

    4. Re:Canadian Credit Card Required. by greed · · Score: 2, Funny

      Don't forget gay marriage is legal in Canada... so you could meet someone right here on Slashdot!

    5. Re:Canadian Credit Card Required. by zx75 · · Score: 1

      Well as to that... the potential WAS there, but then you went ahead and re-elected Bush. ;)

      --
      This is not a sig.
    6. Re:Canadian Credit Card Required. by ablair · · Score: 1


      "The iTunes Music Store in Canada works with the Canadian dollar, and purchase and download of songs requires a valid credit card with a billing address in Canada.

      Any Canadian out there who wants to be my best friend? "


      Now there's yet another reason to marry a Canadian

  16. Re:but will Apple allow.. by jxyama · · Score: 1
    of course not... you need a credit card with a canadian billing address...

    if you could just pick and buy from anywhere, don't you think europeans would have skipped waiting for the european iTMS and instead, just purchase from the U.S. iTMS?

  17. Fantastic! by Drakonian · · Score: 2, Interesting
    I've been waiting for this for ages. It's at the right price point too. Many CDs are $12.99 CDN here, meaning they were going to have to beat that to get my business. They appear to be $9.99.

    Now I can buy some Wilco albums for only $9.99 when they are often $20 or $25 CDN in stores.

    --
    Random is the New Order.
  18. Re:can i get an account... by VanillaDeath · · Score: 1

    Live with the service you already have, or move here if you want the cheaper rate that badly.

    --
    - Wilson
  19. Border run by Kipsaysso · · Score: 1

    Now I can run north of the border, buy iTunes GC, and return home giggling over the profits. Now only to factor in gas. Fortunantly war is fixing that little problem for me.

    --
    This is another way of starting a sig with this and ending it with that.
    1. Re:Border run by razjml · · Score: 0

      Yeah, at the rate gas prices are plummeting...oh wait.

    2. Re:Border run by cappadocius · · Score: 1
      Now only to factor in gas. Fortunantly war is fixing that little problem for me.

      Yes, because instability in the major petroleum-exporting region of the world tends to lower the price of oil futures market so well.

      --

      omnia tua castra sunt nobis

  20. Re:Oh goodie by RhettD · · Score: 1

    Suck it up, this is a big deal for us Canadians who haven't been able to get a 99 cent per click fix!

  21. Take my country, please by OldManAndTheC++ · · Score: 4, Funny

    Cheaper CDs, cheaper pharmaceuticals, affordable health care ... sounds like paradise! Would you Canadians just invade us, please?

    --
    Soylent Green is peoplicious!
    1. Re:Take my country, please by psyconaut · · Score: 1

      We're on our way :-)

      -psy

    2. Re:Take my country, please by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      This is probably fair since our CDs are usually cheaper here, too, at least on the west coast.

      Skrew you too man!

    3. Re:Take my country, please by Justin205 · · Score: 5, Funny

      Yeah, but our two tanks, five 60 year old helicopters, and 10 people are having some equipment problems, or so I've heard...

      (Disclaimer: I am Canadian. Yes, we make fun of ourselves.)

      --
      "Your effort to remain what you are is what limits you."
    4. Re:Take my country, please by icepick72 · · Score: 2, Funny


      Well, we fended you off in 1812. I suppose we could muster up the strength to help you out this time. Or maybe we will just take a less risky approach and marry you all into Canada. What do most American's prefer?

    5. Re:Take my country, please by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      with what army!? We only have toy soldiers =)

    6. Re:Take my country, please by DAldredge · · Score: 1

      But you have the Canadian McGyver (Red Green) on your side...

      AHHH!!!

    7. Re:Take my country, please by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Cheaper CDs, cheaper pharmaceuticals, affordable health care ... sounds like paradise! Would you Canadians just invade us, please?

      You know, 90% of our population is already within 100 km from the border. But Canada scraped the old US invasion plans a few years ago (can't find a link though), so now we have to make some new ones...

      The invasion will most likely come in mid winter - the Great Chistmas Offensive (just keep it quiet, eh?). With most of the US forces deployed overseas, we will most likely be home for spring break!

      The Great Canadian Imperial Forces will... but mom!! I don't want to take out the garbage now!!! ... NO CARRIER

    8. Re:Take my country, please by rikkards · · Score: 1

      Actually we didn't. The British did. Canada was not a country at that point for several years.

    9. Re:Take my country, please by Mechanik · · Score: 1

      Would you Canadians just invade us, please?

      Sure, but due to the cutbacks in defence spending over the past 20 years, Bob's the only one left with a rifle. He's cleaning it right now, but the moment he's done we'll issue him a magazine of ammunition that's about to expire its best before date, buy him a cheap Greyhound ticket to Washington, and have him politely demand your surrender "if it's not too much trouble."


      Mechanik

    10. Re:Take my country, please by merdark · · Score: 1

      Technicality. The people who fended off the Americans were living here, and eventually became known as Canadians.

      They were British at the time, but they were the same people. (Rather than having the British come over here, beat up people for us, and then leave).

      When people say 'we fended off the Americans', they are generally referring to the 'people', our ancestors.

    11. Re:Take my country, please by rikkards · · Score: 1

      Technicality is right no one is alive who fended them off. Our ancestors are not we. If it was we who fended them off we would not have allowed a government to basically starve our military to the point it is at.

      So it is not we, it is they.

    12. Re:Take my country, please by psyconaut · · Score: 5, Funny

      When did we buy the second tank?!

      -psy

    13. Re:Take my country, please by The+Cydonian · · Score: 1
      (Disclaimer: I am Canadian. Yes, we make fun of ourselves.)
      While the self-depracting angle is, I believe, a latent feature of all citizens of the British Commonwealth, the trick to successful Canook-istan humour, nevertheless, is to not crack these jokes when you're trying to date a Canadian girl.

      I, uh, learnt this the hard way.

    14. Re:Take my country, please by Refrag · · Score: 1

      Just send in the moose!

      --
      I have a website. It's about Macs.
    15. Re:Take my country, please by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sure, if you have no sense of ancestry, patriotism, or continuity with the soil of your birth. If you're a first generation immigrant, that's completely understandable. If not, then you don't have much of a connection with your motherland. Shame you didn't listen to more of your grandparents' stories, you might have some pride in where you came from. But hey - your semantics are REAL COOL. Sure make you a rebel. Wow.

      And before you go knocking Canada's military.... I've served (48th Highlanders infantry) and have relatives serving now. No, we could not fend off the US. Yes, we could go toe-to-toe with a mid-sized European country or Asian country of similar size. We could also contribute significantly to a *real* WWIII (not just gang-banging individual rogue states, I'm mean the scenario nobody except a few crazy fucks ever hope to see again). Apologies in advance if you're a vet. Pre-emptive F-YOU to your snarky reply if you're not.

    16. Re:Take my country, please by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      It's like the old Cornell joke.

      "I will found an institution where any person can find instruction in any study."
      "Hey, great idea, Ezra. But you'll have potential students beating down your doors. How will you deal with the demand?"
      "Wait till you see where I'm going to put it."

    17. Re:Take my country, please by MikeBabcock · · Score: 1

      I get it, so the modern black person in the USA with ancestors who were slaves isn't allowed to feel enraged with ongoing racist tendancies in america?

      --
      - Michael T. Babcock (Yes, I blog)
    18. Re:Take my country, please by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      DAldredge, you are an idiot. Please stop posting to Slashdot.

    19. Re:Take my country, please by MikeBabcock · · Score: 1
      Take a look at CBC's report on Canada's military while you're at it.

      A Senate committee recommended on November 12, 2002 that Canada should call all its soldiers home for two years and immediately give $4 billion to the military in order to start the process of bringing the military up to what is expected of a world leader.

      Here's a look at Canada by the numbers.

      Population
      30,007,094 (2001 census)
      11,507,000 (1941 census)
      7,207,000 (1911 census)

      Land
      Canada occupies 9,093,507 sq km, making it the second largest country in the world after Russia.
      Canada has 252,684 km of coastline and borders (243,791 km of coastline, 8,893 km of borders).

      Military Expenditure
      Price of F-18A Hornet fighter jet: $50,000,000.
      Canada's defence budget for 2001/2002: $10,570,000,000 - enough to buy 211 Hornets.

      Armed Forces
      • Today: 60,000 military personnel including 9,500 sailors, 19,000 soldiers, 13,000 air men and women and 18,500 administrative and support personnel. There are also 21,500 reservists.
      • Second World War: 60,000 men and women enlisted in Canada's armed forces in one month (September 1939) after the declaration of war.
      • First World War: More than 600,000 Canadians enlisted to fight in the First World War from 1914-1918.


      Navy
      • Today: There are 34 warships and 9,500 sailors in Canada's navy.
      • Second World War: 23 Canadian ships were sunk by German U-Boats in the Battle of St. Lawrence alone.
      • First World War: During the course of the First World War, Canada's naval service grew to a force of 9,000 men and 100 ships.


      Canadians on the front lines
      • Today: 2,300 armed forces have been deployed to combat terrorism; 1,500 Canadians deployed to NATO peacekeeping in Bosnia-Herzegovina.
      • Second World War: More than one million served and approximately 45,000 died.
      • First World War: Almost 620,000 Canadians served in First World War and 66,000 died.


      Canada in NATO:
      Of NATO's 19 member countries, Canada is...
      1st in land area (9,093,507 sq km), and sixth in total military spending ($10,570,000,000)

      --
      - Michael T. Babcock (Yes, I blog)
    20. Re:Take my country, please by ThousandStars · · Score: 1
    21. Re:Take my country, please by Twirlip+of+the+Mists · · Score: 1

      The people who fended off the Americans were living here

      And I'm fairly certain that they're all long dead. What's your point?

      --

      I write in my journal
    22. Re:Take my country, please by merdark · · Score: 1

      If you want to play that game, then I'm fairly certain all the soldiers on both sides of the 1812 war are long dead. So I guess we should just forget it ever happened.

      In fact, let's forget all history and only concern ourselves with things people who are alive can remember. Presently, the USA is one of the most despised countries in the world. Even the allies of the US don't much like the US. I take it US citizens are proud of this? They are proud that they have less freedom than their ancesters in 1812? Oh, right, they don't count.

    23. Re:Take my country, please by brarrr · · Score: 1

      I think the funiest joke I ever saw about canadians was here on /. on 9/11. (might have been fark). Someone posted that the canadian PM had directed the full support of the canadian military be sent to the US. the poster said something to the effect of "it's true, I just saw two guys go by on a bicycle!"

      --
      to email me: take my /. handle and append .net preceded by charter.
    24. Re:Take my country, please by identity0 · · Score: 1

      But I hear you've bought some mighty fine submarines from the Brits that are totally hot and really cheap, too! I've even heard them described as smokin', which must mean 'really impressive'!

      At this rate, you'll be giving the Americans a run for their money real soon, eh?

    25. Re:Take my country, please by snippy · · Score: 5, Funny

      It's not *really* a tank persay, it's just an overpriced, slightly used British submarine that we dare not put in the water.

      Buyer beware indeed.

      --
      "Crush your enemies, see them driven before you, and hear the lamentation of their women." - Conan
    26. Re:Take my country, please by kataflok · · Score: 1

      Last time I cracked a history book, I noted that we already did invade -- and burned the White House to the ground just to prove we were there. ... But then we realized we just couldn't take the watered down beer...

      --
      Mod me up, mod me down, flame me, praise me -- whatever you do, you help prove I exist...
    27. Re:Take my country, please by Cplus · · Score: 1

      I hope that I speak on the behalf of most Canadians when I say, please, don't bring him up.

      --
      "Share your knowledge. It's a way to achieve immortality." -- Dalai Lama
    28. Re:Take my country, please by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Just after the sub..... which caught on fire.

    29. Re:Take my country, please by anothergene · · Score: 1

      watch out for that dented submarine the Brits suckered us into buying... no wait it caught fire.

      --
      Who's leg do I have to hump to get a dry martini around here?
    30. Re:Take my country, please by 99BottlesOfBeerInMyF · · Score: 1

      I remember seeing article not that long ago about a canadian troop transport that had hit a mine in Iraq. The troops were saying they sure were thankful that their truck had armor, unlike most of the ones the U.S. uses. On a related note, I know someone making 70K in 6 months welding armor on U.S. vehicles in Iraq.

    31. Re:Take my country, please by someguyintoronto · · Score: 1

      right before we bought four lemon submarines from the brits... say is there a submarine buyers guide that we should have sent to ottawa?

      oh and when we're ready to invade you all down south, we'll get 100 canadians to roll them over the border... look out! :)

    32. Re:Take my country, please by Mir322 · · Score: 1

      And don't forget the military helicopters that crash and fall out of the sky on a semi-regular basis.

      (cannuck here too)

      ---

      --
      "There is always some madness in love. But there is also always some reason in madness."- Friedrich Nietzsche
    33. Re:Take my country, please by Gear_Media · · Score: 1

      Ummm. In case you forgot. Canada doesn't have any troops in Iraq.

      --
    34. Re:Take my country, please by 99BottlesOfBeerInMyF · · Score: 1

      You're right, my bad. I looked up the reference and it was the Scottish. Canadian, Scottish whatever :)

    35. Re:Take my country, please by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I noted that we already did invade

      That wasn't an invasion, it was a show of force - a partial retaliation to the American invasion of Canada.

      Basically, after we kicked them out of our country, we went down there, beat the crap out of them, burned down the left wing of the Presidential Palace (now known as the White House), then went home.

    36. Re:Take my country, please by demachina · · Score: 1

      "to basically starve our military to the point it is at."

      Starved....Starved?

      The U.S. spends around a half trillion dollars a year now on defense, intelligence and the war in Iraq. The U.S. spends as much or more than the entire rest of the world combined.

      The only reason the military looks starved is because there aren't enough feet in boots in the Army and Marines. It looks starved for a variety of reasons:

      - Americans are doing occupation duty in an amazingly large number of places around the world, including Germany which hasn't seen a war in 60 years and really even a threat of one in 15 years. The U.S. has troops in like a 100 countries now.
      - The Pentagon and the White House don't want to add soldiers to the Army and Marines because they don't want to pay the long term bill for all their benefits, healthcare in particular. This is a key reason they contract out nearly everything they can to Halliburton, KBR and Blackwater, they don't have a long term VA liability for them (though most of the mercenaries in Blackwater get bot VA benefits and a six figure contractor salaries and were trained at great expense by Uncle Sam).
      - The U.S. is engaged in two active wars against insurgencies, one really vicious in Iraq and the mordern U.S. military simply wasn't built to fight insurgencies or pull occupation duty. Insurgencies grind up a lot of soldiers and they cancel out most of America's technical superiority.
      - The Republican's wont institute a draft because they know it would be long term political suicide and its becoming increasingly hard and expensive to recruit volunteers in to the Army and Marines because American kids know it means standing in the wrong end of the shooting gallery in Iraq for long periods.
      - The Pentagon and Congress are obsessed with spending exorbinant sums on incredibly expensive weapons and they suck all the money out of the rest of the military especially the Army and National Guard infantrymen in the army boots. Their contractors like Boeing and Lockheed also like it when they hand them buckets of money for overpriced, behind schedule weapons systems many of which are canclled before the go in to production. The B-2 is a great example, at over a billion dollars a copy, while the B-52 and a few million a copy still does the majority of the death from above role since the B-2 is to small in number, expensive and logistically challenged to use in combat in any serious way.

      I could go on. I'm just amazed when American's take the position American doesn't spend enough on its military. Its a ridiculous position.

      --
      @de_machina
    37. Re:Take my country, please by rikkards · · Score: 1

      I could go on. I'm just amazed when American's take the position American doesn't spend enough on its military. Its a ridiculous position.

      Hehe. You should have RTFT (Read the F*ckin Thread) I was talking about the Canadian Military not the US military. Better description of the US military is that it suffers from Extreme SuperSizing. Canada has had problems with our existing Sea King helicopters, about a third of our 120 CF-18s are in for maintenance at all times and not flight worthy. Our troops were sent to Afghanistan in Green Cadpat camoflage when they should have had the Desert Brown.
      The Canadian Troops are well trained but unfortunately are funding deprived. The rumour is the replacement for our main battle tank is going to be the Striker which will open a new pandora's box. We have a soldier killed in Afghanistan by a suicide bomber who jumped into the Altis which is a open air Volkswagen Fox, ideally they should have had APCs and said bomber would have just splattered himself off the side but guess what no money.

      Canada has prided ourselves on being the world's peacekeeper but Afghanistan is not the same type of role that Canada has taken before. Rather being in the middle and non partisan, we are now considered a target.

      US seemed surprised that we didn't go into Iraq. Even if we had wanted to, we couldn't have afforded it.

    38. Re:Take my country, please by demachina · · Score: 1

      Sorry jumped in to the rant at Twirp and wasted a good ramp. Pretty common for right wingers to moan about how starved the U.S. military is around here and it is insane.

      Canadians should wear it as badge of honor that they starve their military though the helicopters risk lives. U.S. has the same problem with relatively new Coast Guard helicopters which have rapidly failing engines. They have two but when one goes they can't hover and they often have to make scary on the fly landings on a tiny deck.

      The world is currently not in a stage where massive conventional military expenditure is justified. Its mostly a waste on insurgencies and terrorism.

      I have mixed views on Canada being in Afghanistan. It is the one country that deserved invading after 9/11 with Pakistan a close second. It would be nice to stabilize it but its slowly torn apart one foreign army after another including the British and the U.S.S.R. It had more to do with collapsing the Soviet Union than just about any other single cause.

      I can say that I wasn't entirely plussed with Martin licking George W.'s boots this week. Canada should give him more of the 1 finger wave until he stops being a dick which is unlikely. He was looking a lot like Bush's other poodle, Tony Blair.

      --
      @de_machina
    39. Re:Take my country, please by rikkards · · Score: 1

      Apology accepted and understood :)

      The only reason that the Soviet Union failed in Afghanistan was that the US was funding the Muhajadeen (Sp?). The taliban fragments don't have this luxury. HOWEVER, all that Afghanistan is right now is Kabul and a small amount of surrounding area. The real issue will be when they try to get the warlords to give up control and their ever flourishing Poppy fields that appeared after the Taliban disappeared (the Taliban had (for once) done something right by banning Opium production but the US turned a blind eye right after 9/11 as the Warlords needed the money to fund their fight against the Taliban).

    40. Re:Take my country, please by demachina · · Score: 1

      The funding and arming is not as organized and concerted as the $3.5 billion Reagan pumped in to them, and the future Al Qaida, but they still do have plenty of benefactors in the Muslim world in Pakistan and Saudi Arabia in particular, some of them really rich. The kind of war their fighting doesn't demand a huge infusion of money since its mostly small arms and improvised explosives. I imagine anti tank and anti aircraft missiles are probably something they don't have in the abundance the original Mujadeen did.

      The Iraqi insurgents are also no doubt getting some help from Iran, Syria and the rest of the arab world.

      The Pakistan army just announced they are pulling their troops out of big chunks of the tribal areas and ceeding them to Al Qaida and the Taliban so the insurgency in Afghanistan has pretty much the same operating base it did against the Soviet Union though they can't be quite as open or blatant about it there.

      "US turned a blind eye"

      Nothing new here. The CIA has a long history of condoning or outright engaging in drug trafficing when they see an angle in it, especially a funding angle for wars, legal and illegal.

      It was great American propganda to make out like the Taliban and Al Qaida were major drug trafficers when it runs against every grain of their religion and they had largely stamped it out in areas they controlled with ruthless penalties for growers, trafficers and users.

      --
      @de_machina
  22. Re:but will Apple allow.. by interiot · · Score: 1

    So how hard is it to get a credit card with an address in another country? If it's not excrutiatingly difficult, won't there be a big trade in cross-country credit card deals?

  23. Re:Oh goodie by Scorpion265 · · Score: 1

    sigh, it was an attempt at humor, I forget how hard it is to convay over text sometimes

    --
    I am full of goo... black evil goo
  24. Don't forget tax by DJStealth · · Score: 4, Informative

    Keep in mind that the taxes in Canada are higher on average. In Ontario, we pay a total of 15% tax.

    Also, keep in mind, if a can of coke goes for $1 US, the same can will sell in Canada for $1 CAD.

    1. Re:Don't forget tax by yabos · · Score: 1

      I got emailed a receipt for the 2 songs I bought, and it didn't list any tax. I'll have to wait and see if they do actually charge it. They probably will, but it's weird they didn't list the taxes in the statement.

    2. Re:Don't forget tax by Rosyna · · Score: 2, Informative

      You pay $1 for a can of coke? Sheesh. Here in the US we pay 35 cents to 65 cents with 60 cents being the norm for an individual 12 ounce can of coke out of a machine.

    3. Re:Don't forget tax by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "In Ontario, we pay a total of 15% tax."

      what about income tax?

    4. Re:Don't forget tax by pipingguy · · Score: 1


      The difference is that our Coke machines have those temperature-dependent pricing processors. Since it never gets above 65 degrees American here, the machine charges the lowest possible price.

    5. Re:Don't forget tax by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      since i dont have a REAL email atm im a coward, a canadian one...
      here a can of coke could even be 1.25 in a machine(thats almost a full US$)

    6. Re:Don't forget tax by AusG4 · · Score: 1

      Taxes are included in the $0.99 price.

      --
      bash-3.00$ uname -a
      SunOS panda 5.10 Generic sun4u sparc SUNW,Ultra-2
    7. Re:Don't forget tax by goates · · Score: 1

      Don't know about Ontario, but Alberta's income tax is 11% across the board. The federal icome tax is basically whatever is left.

    8. Re:Don't forget tax by anaradad · · Score: 1

      You pay $1 for a can of coke? Sheesh. Here in the US we pay 35 cents to 65 cents with 60 cents being the norm for an individual 12 ounce can of coke out of a machine. You don't live in a large city, do you?

    9. Re:Don't forget tax by yabos · · Score: 1

      That's awesome. So it's an even better deal than I thought!

    10. Re:Don't forget tax by Norman+Lorrain · · Score: 1

      Yes, but thats balanced by our lower wages.

      Oh, wait...

    11. Re:Don't forget tax by Bastian · · Score: 1

      Here in the US we pay 35 cents to 65 cents with 60 cents being the norm for an individual 12 ounce can of coke out of a machine.

      If you mean Euro cents, yeah, that's about what I'm paying around here. If not, I think maybe you're living in the wrong decade or a drastically different local economy (I live in a city).

    12. Re:Don't forget tax by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      what about income tax?

      You pay income tax when you buy something?! You're in some fucked-up country dude.

    13. Re:Don't forget tax by DJStealth · · Score: 1

      Income tax is even worse. But I have no idea how it compares to other countries.

      See:
      http://www.taxtips.ca/tax_rates.htm

      Keep in mind both the federal and provincial governments suck us dry.

    14. Re:Don't forget tax by DJStealth · · Score: 1

      Wow, I just read the actual tax rates (around 31% for income between $35-70k/year). I just realized, we must be the only ones in the world stupid enough to pay a tax on a tax.

      Read below:

      "ON also has two surtaxes:
      1. a surtax of 20% of ON income tax (after deducting non-refundable tax credits) in excess of $3,856 ($3,747 in 2003). For a single person with a tax credit for only the basic personal amount, the ON tax will reach $3,856 at a taxable income of approximately $58,770 in 2004.
      2. a surtax of 36% of ON income tax (after deducting non-refundable tax credits) in excess of $4,864 ($4,727 in 2003). For a single person with a tax credit for only the basic personal amount, the ON tax will reach $4,864 at a taxable income of approximately $69,240 in 2004.

      Note that the second surtax of 36% of ON income tax is in addition to the first surtax of 20%. Thus, the surtax of 20% applies to ON income tax in excess of $3,856 but less than $4,864, and both surtaxes, for a total of 56%, apply to ON income tax in excess of $4,864. "

      We pay up to 56% tax on the taxes we pay!

    15. Re:Don't forget tax by CrazyTalk · · Score: 1

      22% rate on $70,000 per year? Sounds pretty good - I could be wrong, but I'm thinking the US Federal rate is 28% for that salary. Plus we have state and city taxes bleeding us dry as well, plus real estate tax, sales tax, tax tax...

    16. Re:Don't forget tax by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It is worth noting that the marginal tax rate in some states is higher than in some provinces.

      While US taxes are on average a bit lower, once you factor in health insurance it isn't all that much cheaper to live there, and I'm pretty sure the average houshold income is lower (but still roughly equivalent). Having lived in both countries, I didn't find a huge difference (a bit more services and taxes in canada, a bit less services and taxes in US).

      Certainly the distribution of wealth in canada is more uniform, so we have less extreme cases in both directions....

    17. Re:Don't forget tax by DJStealth · · Score: 1

      That's Federal Only. Add another 9-15% provincial tax.

    18. Re:Don't forget tax by CrazyTalk · · Score: 1

      The number I quoted for the US is federal only also. We dont have provincial tax, but we have state tax which is similar. Depending on where you live we may also have municipal or city income tax as well.

    19. Re:Don't forget tax by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Compared to the taxes I pay here in the States, it is a pretty good deal. I made $50k in Ontario - which boiled down to about $2400/month takehome. In Cali, I make $47k - which boils down to about $2400/month takehome. Two important points:

      (i) I don't get any social services for my taxes down here. Nor does anyone else.

      (ii) The buying power of the US dollar is roughly the same as the Canadian dollar for most things - as long as you are not converting. (That is, a package of cookies that costs CAD$4 is Canada costs US$4 in the US. Same with CDs. There are a very few exceptions.)

    20. Re:Don't forget tax by mcb123 · · Score: 1

      No, you're not alone. US politicians have that racket running here too. Corporate dividends are effectively taxed twice. The first time before they're paid out and the second time when shareholders report them as income. It's no wonder so many corporations move their headquarters outside of the US if they can.

  25. Re:Oh goodie by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Canadians don't read /. I should know, I'm a Canadian.

  26. Offsite Moderation Spam Poll by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny
  27. Re:but will Apple allow.. by xwinter · · Score: 1

    You might need Canada's version of a SSN, which is called the Social Insurance Number (SIN). Other than that, I am not sure how sticky banks are with the whole address thing. You need provide your billing address usually, and if you don't have a billing address in Canada, iTunes will probably tell you to "take off, eh!".

  28. Re:Oh goodie by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    Why didn't you just post a goatse link.

    The "editors" will mod you into the shitter just as quick for pointing out their slashvertising.

  29. NAFTA and Free Trade by cheshiremackat · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I find it interesting that Canadians right now enjoy more 'freedom' wrt music sharing/copying etc. We are allowed to 'share' our music with friends in exchange for a small tax on CDRs and MP3 players.

    Also, our AACs from Apple are cheaper ($0.84 today).

    The most interesting part? IP is not part of NAFTA, if it was, you could buy music in Canada and re-import it to the US. (Actually if IP was part of NAFTA, Apple CANADA could sue the RIAA to force lower prices as the present situation is anti-competitive) {interesting asside, Apple CANADA would have to do it, Apple USA would have no standing, goofy NAFTA dispute resolution}.

    INSTEAD, what I think will happen is that the US will force Canada to sign the WIPO and the world gets DMCA like treatment, as opposed to making the US laws more sane.

    So, for all those who asked, no you will not be able to re-import the music back into the US... even if you could get Apple to sell it to you at the lower price you would have to declare the purchase and remit duty on the purchase. Ever buy one of the "imported' CDs from the record store... part of the reason they cost more is excise duty.

    Bah, somewhat useless however, with the USD sucking lately, we could be back to 1.05Canadian soon, and we would want to buy your cheap music.... better get that trade deficit fixed soon!

    --
    Bad spellers of the world untie!
    1. Re:NAFTA and Free Trade by g0at · · Score: 1

      We are allowed to 'share' our music with friends in exchange for a small tax on CDRs and MP3 players.

      First of all it's not a tax, it's a levy. Second of all, it's rashly unjust since most artists won't see a cent from it. Third, it applies to equipment despite its end use (whether it has anything to do with music playback at all). Fourthly, what do you mean "small"? It worked out to about 7% of the cost of my iPod, pre-tax.

      -b
    2. Re:NAFTA and Free Trade by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      We are allowed to 'share' our music with friends in exchange for a small tax on CDRs and MP3 players.
      Thanks to the Home Recording Act of 1995, we get to pay our tax on CDRs too. That's OK though, because we also get to be sued and pay again. Oh, and we pay for the packaged version.
    3. Re:NAFTA and Free Trade by theancient2 · · Score: 1
      INSTEAD, what I think will happen is that the US will force Canada to sign the WIPO
      Speaking of which, this is an excellent opportunity to direct people to Digital Copyright Canada and their Petition for Users' Rights. :) (That's a paper petition that will be delivered to parlaiment.) Of course, it never hurts to write to your MP or the appropriate minister as well.
    4. Re:NAFTA and Free Trade by euxneks · · Score: 1

      ...what I think will happen is that the US will force Canada to sign the WIPO...

      Excuse me? You think the US has that much clout that they can make us comply with their draconian laws? Already there is a fair amount of anti-US sentiment due primarily to Bushy junior. I doubt the US could make Canada do anything other than sell you stuff at cheaper prices.

      --
      in girum imus nocte et consumimur igni
    5. Re:NAFTA and Free Trade by spotteddog · · Score: 2, Informative

      Actually, you CAN buy a CD in Canada and bring it back without paying duty on it *if* you follow the US Customs regulations on total dollar amounts and frequency of purchase. I used to do that when I lived closer to Canada (heck, I even ordered from Canadian music store web sites - I just didn't do it frequently).

      --
      . there used to be a sig here.....
    6. Re:NAFTA and Free Trade by anothergene · · Score: 1

      We're going to join EU any way so it doesn't matter.

      --
      Who's leg do I have to hump to get a dry martini around here?
    7. Re:NAFTA and Free Trade by Suicidal+Teapot · · Score: 1

      I thought books and music were exempt from duty, or is that just books?

    8. Re:NAFTA and Free Trade by nickstance · · Score: 1

      "Ever buy one of the "imported' CDs from the record store... part of the reason they cost more is excise duty."
      The reason they cost so much is that they are usually bootlegs or otherwise unauthorized copies, the fines in the US for actually selling those things are horrible, so to make it worth your while, you have to mark that sucker up 2-300%, the excise duty is negligible

  30. Re:can i get an account... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I'd love to move to a free country such as yours. but you selfish people aren't letting us in. :(

  31. Store performance? by psyconaut · · Score: 2, Informative

    The performance of the store doesn't seem terribly awe inspiring right now. Knowing that Apple don't tend to launch small, I can only presume that this means lots of happy Canadians browsing and buying.

    -psy

  32. Re:Oh goodie by Scorpion265 · · Score: 0, Offtopic

    My first negative post, alright!

    --
    I am full of goo... black evil goo
  33. No local stuff from Quebec? by NeedleSurfer · · Score: 4, Insightful

    In other country Apple had problem getting indies onboard, one would have thought they would be prepared this time. This ain't gonna work if they have no music from here to sell us, The rest of Canada might appreciate but the national fiber is too strong here for a majority of people to adhere to a service that doesn't sell them their own music...

    1. Re:No local stuff from Quebec? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      So now Quebec wants to be part of Canada? Every other day they want to separate.

    2. Re:No local stuff from Quebec? by Trillan · · Score: 1

      iTunes Music Store -- Quebec. Coming in 2008.

    3. Re:No local stuff from Quebec? by snippy · · Score: 1

      Please, if I wanted to hear Celine Dion singing I could just drag my fingernails across a blackboard, or step on my cats tail.

      --
      "Crush your enemies, see them driven before you, and hear the lamentation of their women." - Conan
    4. Re:No local stuff from Quebec? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They do have Celine stuff.

      Oh, you mean something ELSE than Celne... I see.

    5. Re:No local stuff from Quebec? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I am assuming you are talking about music in french, with local bands/signers like, say Beau Dommage, Harmonium, Madame, Les Frères à ch'val, Luce Dufault, and eurobands/artists like Niagara, Alain Souchon, etc. I searched for them and other, non-french-speaking artists & bands, and was appauled by what I found... or, rather, did not find. Somehow, TPTB at Apple seem to think that everyone, everywhere essentially listens to the american pop charts.

      Oh, I did find "Mustt mustt" from Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, but it was an *incomplete album* -- and that's just for starters.

      I think Apple should start diversifying the catalog and even, er, "localize" it for each country they sell to. This is just common sense. While Joe Redneck cow-music singer might be very popular in Lower-Rubberboot, Texas, no one knows him in, say, Germany... or Canada. And vice-versa (french-speaking people north of the US-Canada border might want to buy the latest from Loco Locass, who are unknown in the US).

      I haven't looked at the other stores (I mean the euro ones), but I now wonder if they, too, display the same dearth of local artists.

      Apple is denying itself a lot of potential sales & good will by ignoring local artists. Steve, wake up and smell the cofee, otherwhise, some more astute competitor will come and surpass you quicker than you think!

      p.s.: is it me, or is the UI for the store (the page layouts, etc.) can be confusing, esp. if you just want to browse/search various categories?

    6. Re:No local stuff from Quebec? by someguyintoronto · · Score: 1

      actually i was able to get "the stills" which is a somewhat indie band from montreal... but have to agree right now the music selection is way too commercial...

      also noted that their classification is really bizzare.. since when would you classify blue rodeo as "alternative"?

    7. Re:No local stuff from Quebec? by Tom+Courtenay · · Score: 1

      The Unicorns, One Speed Bike, The Stars, Molasses, The Arcade Fire, Godspeed You Black Emperor, Set Fire To Flames, The Shalabi Effect, A Silver Mt. Zion....

      Quebec has some amazing music coming out of it.

      --
      If you could be anything you want, I'll bet you'd be disappointed.
    8. Re:No local stuff from Quebec? by NeedleSurfer · · Score: 1

      Alternative:

      anything that isn't Bon Jovi nowadays

  34. EU Status? by Devalia · · Score: 1

    Arent Apple still being sued for not complying with the EU about having the same price throughout EU? I seem to remember it being cheaper in france or something than UK!

    1. Re:EU Status? by Rosyna · · Score: 1

      No, it was thrown out as being stupid.

    2. Re:EU Status? by achilstone · · Score: 1

      This is not just about prices but about free trade across EU member countries.
      iTunes insistance that UK credit cards are invalid in other iTunes stores e.g. France and Germany where prices are cheaper amounts to a restriction in trade. This is illegal under EU trading laws.
      There's an article today about iTunes overcharging UK customers on the BBC news website: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/4065539.stm

    3. Re:EU Status? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      APPLR OVERCHARGING IN THE UK? OH GOSH, WHAT A SHOCK!

      Try checking out their iPod prices sometime, they're like $300 more than the equivalent US model.

    4. Re:EU Status? by Phil1 · · Score: 1

      From today's BBC Website;

      Price per one track download
      UK - 79p
      Germany & France - 99 cents (68p)
      US - 99 cents (51p)
      Canada - 99 cents (43p)

      We are being royally screwed.

      --
      I'd rather have a bottle in front of me than a frontal lobotomy
    5. Re:EU Status? by Devalia · · Score: 1

      This isnt the problem, its the fact that when their selling under the EU they have to make it accesible to all members of the EU -- blocking Credit Cards is particuarly naughty and prices should be the same within the EU (from a different comment somewhat and an article they reffered to)

  35. I think you forgot... by laughingcoyote · · Score: 2, Insightful

    "No George Bush."

    --
    To fight the war on terror, stop being afraid.
  36. That's relative by johnny_sas · · Score: 2, Insightful
    "so it's less expensive than the US store"

    That's irrelevant; as someone here once said, $1 is still a $1 here, no matter what it's worth anywhere else.

    1. Re:That's relative by Trillan · · Score: 1

      Are you really saying there's no difference between a Canadian dollar, a US dollar, a Euro and a Philippine Peso?

      If there's no difference, I've got some Philippine pesos. I'm willing to trade them on par for US dollars. What do you think?

      So which would you rather have: 10 million US dollars or 10 million Canadian dollars?

    2. Re:That's relative by PygmySurfer · · Score: 1

      No, he's saying that a Canadian dollar in Canada is roughly equivalent to a US dollar in the US. When you factor in wages, cost of living, etc, it's pretty similar.

      I live in Canada, and work in the US. Many things are priced about the same (before you add on tax) in both countries. Also, the wages in Canada are typically lower than in the US, so we have to strech our dollar further.

      Of course one would rather have 10 million US dollars over 10 million Canadian dollars. But, how're you coming into that money? It's not very easy to compare dollars to dollars - there's many external factors involved.

    3. Re:That's relative by Trillan · · Score: 1

      Well, you're right in so far as "roughly equivalent" is concerned. There's really not much of a difference day-to-day; or, rather, there is, but which way and by how much varies from item to item, so my impression at least is that it all pretty much evens out in the end.

      Thanks for explaining! I agree now. :)

    4. Re:That's relative by PygmySurfer · · Score: 1

      Of course, when you're a Canadian making US $ like me, it makes a huge difference.. :(

      Damn your falling dollar, America..

    5. Re:That's relative by Trillan · · Score: 1

      Well, we do business with Americans, so it'll affect me sooner or later. :( So far we're coping, though.

  37. Re:Oh goodie by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Oops, I was going to include a link

  38. It's aboot time! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Finally, I have some music to groove to during the cold nights up here in the Great White North while sipping a Molson! Now where's my took?

    1. Re:It's aboot time! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      That's the saddest attempt at a parody I've ever seen. Sipping a "Molson"?? "took"?? The only people I know who are as ignorant as you, are... yep, you guessed it... Americans!

    2. Re:It's aboot time! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Careful -- he's probably shining his rifle to come after you, and he might not have brushed his tooth.

  39. And it's actually called... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    It's actually called "TunesA".

    1. Re:And it's actually called... by Nikker · · Score: 1

      No no no...

      EhTunes!!

      --
      A loop, by its nature, continues. If that didn't make sense, start reading this sentence again.
  40. Re:but will Apple allow.. by yabos · · Score: 1

    No you can't, just like we can't buy from the US store.
    They really had no choice on their pricing. There is already Puretracks(WMA, blech) with songs for 99 cents Canadian.

    Plus, our CDs are usually cheaper in stores here than they are in the US stores.

  41. What a deal! by bigberk · · Score: 5, Funny

    Sweet, what a deal for Americans! Only $0.83 a download, no wait, $0.85, oop, make that $0.92, don't worry guys it'll stop any day now, shit! $1.05 ...

    1. Re:What a deal! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      haha you're making fun of our weakening currency, i get it. we don't need canadian business though, you need ours

    2. Re:What a deal! by Deliveranc3 · · Score: 1

      That's sooo cold. But remember once we were far above them, though of course we will be again.

      Hehehehehe ban our beef, we'll stop shipping you grain, eat your funny green money we'll see who starves first.

      The above was not meant to be a reasoned analysis of the stability of our two currencies, just a hope that the Chinese will decide to lock their currency against the CDN $ rather than the american one. Also I'd like to have a really nice vid card cost less chocolate bars here.

    3. Re:What a deal! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I dunno, they haven't been able to export beef of softwood to us for quite some time but they seem to be doing OK. Even posting a surplus budget.

      They're economy is probably terrist-supported though and they have HUGE taxes and a military that we can only laugh at. Come to think of it, they also have the number 2 proven source of oil in the world. Invade!

    4. Re:What a deal! by bigberk · · Score: 1
      I dunno, they haven't been able to export beef of softwood to us for quite some time but they seem to be doing OK. Even posting a surplus budget.
      If I was American, investing in the Canadian stock markets would look real attractive to me right about now. Think about it, Canada's got huge oil and other commodity/natural resource sectors. And whatever investments you make now using your US dollars will be worth more US dollars later, since the Canadian dollar is always gaining value against the US dollar. Of course you could invest in euro valued stocks too but the Europeans don't exactly have a vibrant resource economy.
    5. Re:What a deal! by Bishop · · Score: 1

      just a hope that the Chinese will decide to lock their currency against the CDN $ rather than the american one.

      You have that backwards. If any country does any currency locking, it will be the Americans trying to tie their dollar to the Chinese Yuan.

      Seriously though the Chinese are going to open up the Yuan to be traded more freely. It should float like most of the other major currencies. We will have to wait and see how well this works. I don't think anyone expects Bejing to open up the Yuan like the US dollar.

    6. Re:What a deal! by Deliveranc3 · · Score: 1

      I've been thinking it's been keeping the dollar afloat and this will only continue. America has some pretty serious inflation going on which hasn't been matched by increased production.

      They really need some new inventions that JUST WORK to get people interested again, but I guess this is a pretty standard economic downturn, maybe the collapse of the U.S. global economy will come next cycle.

    7. Re:What a deal! by theancient2 · · Score: 1

      Really? Guess which country buys a quarter of your exports? :)

    8. Re:What a deal! by {Hecubus} · · Score: 1

      Sweet, what a deal for Americans! Only $0.83 a download, no wait, $0.85, oop, make that $0.92, don't worry guys it'll stop any day now, shit! $1.05 ...


      Don't forget, freedom costs a buck-oh-five..

      --
      Unix is mysterious, and ancient, and strong. It's made of cast iron and the bones of heroic programmers of old -
  42. Business opportunity by Atario · · Score: 1, Interesting

    1. Be a Canadian.
    2. Have a credit card.
    3. Set up website (totally automated, eh) offering to buy people iTunes songs at cost plus 5%.
    4. Advertise service in USA
    5. Profit!

    Of course I'm probably missing some DRM reason why this won't work. Not that I care.

    --
    "A great democracy must be progressive or it will soon cease to be a great democracy." --Theodore Roosevelt
    1. Re:Business opportunity by WordODD · · Score: 1

      Of course sending all those songs to people wil cost you a pretty penny. Unless you just want to make a $1.50 each month.

      --
      Please do not let scientific accuracy interfere with the intended humourous/interesting/insightful value of this comment
    2. Re:Business opportunity by damiam · · Score: 1

      Aside from DRM (which can be bypassed), it's probably against the iTunes EULA.

      --
      It's hard to be religious when certain people are never incinerated by bolts of lightning.
    3. Re:Business opportunity by johneee · · Score: 1

      Well, basically the problem is that it's against the licencing that iTMS sets up, so they're basically paying money to get DRM encumbered music that is no more legal than stuff they can download for free without DRM. So where's the benefit for the customer?

      --
      - ------- There are ten kinds of people in the world. Those who understand binary, and those who... Huh?
    4. Re:Business opportunity by Atario · · Score: 1
      Aside from DRM (which can be bypassed), it's probably against the iTunes EULA.
      Meh. Same thing.
      --
      "A great democracy must be progressive or it will soon cease to be a great democracy." --Theodore Roosevelt
  43. Re:can i get an account... by inkswamp · · Score: 4, Funny

    Ooh... I bet you're really Canadian, eh. All the Canadians I know put an "eh" at the end of everything they say, eh. Even when they're writing, eh. That's the truth, eh. I know it, eh. I've been there, eh. They do it all the time, eh. See ya later, eh.

    --
    --Rick "If it isn't broken, take it apart and find out why."
  44. Re:but will Apple allow.. by prof_peabody · · Score: 1

    No, please do more research. There are several American banks that have Canadian affiliates that allow you to get a Canadian credit card with a US SIN. The address issue can be worked around pretty easily.

  45. The best part is... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Michael Moore has already made a movie about Canada attacking the U.S.

  46. I live in the United States of Canada. by amigoro · · Score: 2, Funny

    I live in the United States of Canada. Do I qaulify?

    --


    Nothing to see here
    1. Re:I live in the United States of Canada. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Sorry as i Canadian i'm sorry to inform you ABSOLUTLY NOT! PERIOD! (there is no such thing as The United States of Canada, and therein lies your automatic dis-qualifications).

    2. Re:I live in the United States of Canada. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      lol, funniest map I've seen, ever.

      Thanks, I'll be able to piss off a lot of people with it. :-)

  47. itunes is great and all but... by seven+of+five · · Score: 4, Informative

    as an indie musician with stuff on iTunes, they don't have it together internally. I've had sales from 6 months ago that I haven't been paid for yet.

    it's great that they're opening these new outlets and all but they're lacking in some basics.

    1. Re:itunes is great and all but... by reverius · · Score: 1

      wow...

      do you suppose the record companies haven't been paid for their sales either?

      oh wait, no? they have? i guess that's a weird iTunes problem then.

      i'm betting this is one of those pesky instances of PEBKAC --- "problem exists between keyboard and chair"

      in this case, the "problem" is the guy between a keyboard and really fancy office chair who decides he doesn't have to pay you because you're not on a record label with lawyers.

    2. Re:itunes is great and all but... by michaeldot · · Score: 1

      Are you meant to have been paid? Is there a quota that has to be reached?

      I sell stuff through Kagi, but unless it reaches a certain value, they don't pay me until it does.

      What does your contract say? If you're meant to have been paid and you haven't, put it in writing. Breach of contract is usually an open and shut case.

    3. Re:itunes is great and all but... by seven+of+five · · Score: 1

      as far as I know, there's no minimum. I've been paid for some iTunes stuff (also Rhapsody and Sony Connect), but music bought thru the German ITMS is somehow 'stuck' owing to the newness (???) of the German store.

      Apparently I'm not the only indie waiting to get paid.... and yes I *think* the majors get better treatment but as far as payments go I'm not privy to that.

    4. Re:itunes is great and all but... by DataCannibal · · Score: 1

      You're an artist complaining that he hasn't been paid ?

      You're new to this business aren't you ?

      --
      No but, yeah but, no but...
  48. Re:but will Apple allow.. by Trillan · · Score: 1

    I hope you're not talking about the difference between buy and nominal, because it's usually less than $0.003 per dollar, but rather a fee levied by your credit card company. Still -- if they're charging you more than 16% in fees for Canadian purchases, you should really look into a better credit card.

  49. Re:Oh goodie by Justin205 · · Score: 0, Redundant

    Yeah, we've all been going to BitTorrent (legally up here, mind you!) for our 0 cents/song downloads. :-)

    --
    "Your effort to remain what you are is what limits you."
  50. Re:but will Apple allow.. by Trillan · · Score: 1

    Well, the US iTunes Music Store had no problem recognizing me as a Canadian before I even got a chance to claim I was in the US. So even if you could get a Canadian credit card, there's technical issues to hurdle. Yes, there really are databases mapping IP addresses to countries, and iTMS apparently uses them.

  51. screenshot available here by jeffehobbs · · Score: 5, Funny
    1. Re:screenshot available here by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      damned funny

    2. Re:screenshot available here by tepples · · Score: 1

      I did: In America, Rush looks like this.

    3. Re:screenshot available here by burns210 · · Score: 1

      Ha. I see it now.

      You deleted the default playlists from iTunes!

    4. Re:screenshot available here by Rev+Saxon · · Score: 1

      oh! I see it! The Canadian flag!

      --
      I am that much more enlightened and proportionally disillusioned
    5. Re:screenshot available here by JasonBee · · Score: 1

      Frickin hilarious is right...I've been listening to friends drone on and on about Rush for years...blehhh.

      I have video of some of these guys spontaneously breaking out into a chorus of drunken air drumming (all four!) to some Rush track...don't ask which one please I might have to kill you.

      BTW Rush has this great track with the chorus "take off to the great white North". Hosers...*sigh*

      Next week it'll be a BNL career retrospective - who knows!

      JB

  52. Ireland by pollock · · Score: 1

    Considering the U2 branded iPod, I expect to see Ireland come online first.

    1. Re:Ireland by Minux · · Score: 1

      You would think that Ireland being part of the EU would have got in already. But I guess they can allways hop skip towards Northen Ireland which is part of the United Kingdom store.

      --
      Nobody ever would have got anywhere had we just changed the default password though.
  53. Oblig. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Phase 1 -- On Ebay offer to sell any iTunes song for US$0.90
    Phase 2 -- Use Canadian iTunes to buy the songs cheap then give the files and account password to the purchaser
    Phase 3 -- Eh???
    Phase 4 -- Profit!

    1. Re:Oblig. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      step 1: collect underpants
      step 2:
      step 3: profit.

  54. Re:but will Apple allow.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Bullshit.

    I'm an American living in Japan. I bought two iTunes albums out here. Google always gives me the .jp version on accounta my IP, but iTunes had no problems. You just must not have a real US credit card.

  55. Distribution rights by Senjutsu · · Score: 2, Insightful

    ITMS US has the rights to distribute the music on their store as negotiated with the US companies who hold those rights.

    But, and this is crucial, those companies don't hold the rights to distribute those songs in Canada, or the UK, or Spain, or any other country but the US. So in order to sell the songs to Canadians (or in the UK, or in Spain) they have to negotiated the distribution rights with the people who do hold the rights in each of those countries.

    Hence each country needs its own store, with distribution rights negotiated with the local rights holder, which only sells to credit card billing addresses within the country to which those distribution rights pertain.

  56. ATTN Americans! by canwaf · · Score: 1

    As people, Canadians are very sorry for not containing Celine Dion ourselves, and allowing her to reak havoc on the world. Thanks be to all Americans who helped pay for her containment prison in the Nevada Desert.

  57. Does it really require the iTunes client to access by strider3700 · · Score: 1

    I'm not trying to troll here but I'm not overly interested in rebooting just to go browse and see what they have. Is it possible to at least browse the store under linux or is it mac or windows only?

  58. No Foo Fighters! by grifter7 · · Score: 1

    As a Canadian, i'm glad Apple finally delivered on their promise to make iTunes available in Canada.

    And of course I couldn't be happier they stuck with the $0.99/song pricing, even in our currency.

    However, my first search for music came up empty! In the USA store, 47 hits show up when I search for "Foo Fighters". However, switching to the Canada site results in "no hits". What the heck?

    Is this our crazy "Canadian content" laws overruling sanity again? How many other artists are mysteriously missing?

    1. Re:No Foo Fighters! by Senjutsu · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Easy with the conspiracy theories. Canadian content laws only apply to broadcasts on the public airwaves.

      In all liklihood, the problem is that the local Candian rights holder for the Foo Fighters hasn't signed on with Apple Canada yet.

    2. Re:No Foo Fighters! by grifter7 · · Score: 1

      Hmm... apparently there could be quite a lot less content.

      Music Videos:
      USA = 357
      CANADA = 27

      Great kids, we can buy all the Anne Murray and John Denver tracks we want for only $0.99! Break those piggy banks!

    3. Re:No Foo Fighters! by xgamer04 · · Score: 1

      As a geek, how can you purchase music from a group that fights one of our most sacred words?

      --
      When you look at the state of the world, how can you not become a radical, liberal anarchist?
    4. Re:No Foo Fighters! by grifter7 · · Score: 2, Funny

      They're on our side! They are fighting for the foo!

      Like Freedom Fighters, only better!

    5. Re:No Foo Fighters! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

      There goes my music, watch it as it goes...

    6. Re:No Foo Fighters! by PygmySurfer · · Score: 1

      I think it's great that our government is trying to save your ears from having to listen to that crap..

    7. Re:No Foo Fighters! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      And of course I couldn't be happier they stuck with the $0.99/song pricing, even in our currency.

      I'm waiting for iTunes Turkey. 99 Lira/song!

  59. Obligitory South Park Quote by commander_line · · Score: 0

    Canadian Representative: Our government has apologized for Bryan Adams on numerous occasions!

  60. must meet these requirements. by Man+in+Spandex · · Score: 2, Funny

    You qualify if you can manage to put "eh" and "yehaw" in one sentence that makes some sence.

  61. Not all music available? by Fancia · · Score: 1

    It looks like not all of the music that's in the US store is available in the Canadian one at the moment. :( And I was looking forward to picking up some Lemon Jelly...

    --

    Bít, zabít, jen proto, ze su liska!
  62. Re:but will Apple allow.. by billDCat · · Score: 1

    Nah, iTunes plops you into the store for a particular country based on your IP address, but you can change that once you get in, by selecting the "choose store" link from the main page. At home, it would automatically take me to the Canadian store. At work, our network is based in the US, so it puts me in the US store. I can still switch over to the Canadian store and buy without a problem.

  63. Arbitrage Opportunity? by fupeg · · Score: 1

    Here's how a Canadian could arbitrage this. Offer to buy songs for any Americans. They send you $x where 0.83 x 0.99 via PayPal. You then create a bogus Apple ID (email address), buy the song they want, email it to them eith the password to the Apple ID. They change the Apple ID password and the song is all theirs. Actually this could be simplified by purchasing "gift certificates" perhaps? I'm sure there's multiple holes in this, but seems like there's potential!

  64. Son of a! by lawpoop · · Score: 1
    "...it's less expensive than the US store. This is probably fair since our CDs are usually cheaper here, too, at least on the west coast."

    Gol' darned Canadian socialized music industry!

    --
    Computers are useless. They can only give you answers.
    -- Pablo Picasso
  65. Re: do you know who your #1 Oil supplier is? by guidryp · · Score: 1

    " we don't need canadian business though, you need ours"

    How often do you think you fill up on Canuck Gas?

  66. Re:but will Apple allow.. by Trillan · · Score: 1

    I guess I didn't explore enough. Thanks for the correction! Maybe I can buy and use songs from the Canadian iTMS while I'm over here in the Philippines... (My home and billing address is in Canada.)

  67. Re:but will Apple allow.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Bullshit. I'm an American...

    LOL! That takes the cake, really. With that immediate attack on someone for making a mistake, do you really think we couldn't figure that one out?

  68. Re: do you know who your #1 Oil supplier is? by rikkards · · Score: 1

    Probably less often than you pay for US electricity. It used to be that we (CDN) provided the states with a lot of juice but not anymore. I have a friend who works with the CDN gov who recently enlightened me on this fact. Can't explain why though.

  69. $10,000 Canadian to Fill Up My iPod by javacowboy · · Score: 1

    I have a 40 GB iPod, and all this time I wasn't sure how in God's name I was going to fill it. Now I can!

    --
    This space left intentionally blank.
  70. Is it legal? by NotQuiteReal · · Score: 1
    If you can get music cheaper in Canada - why not go all the way and get stuff from Russia (e.g allofmp3.com)?

    If it is not legal to get it from one, it is probably not legal to get it from the other, so you might as well not bother, or get it from the cheaper of the two, no?

    --
    This issue is a bit more complicated than you think.
  71. Who else from NZ/Oz can't access iTMS now? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Just wondering, has anyone else from NZ/Australia found they can no longer access the iTunes store?

    You used to be able to enter it, and look at the music videos in the various iTMS, listen to the previews etc.

    But now, even though it says you can, I can no longer enter any of the iTMS stores at all...Only happened in the last fortnight.

    1. Re:Who else from NZ/Oz can't access iTMS now? by darkpurpleblob · · Score: 1

      Yeah. The same thing was happening to me. I just checked again now and it appears to be working again.

    2. Re:Who else from NZ/Oz can't access iTMS now? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Heh - yeah :)

      As soon as I posted, I checked out iTunes, and wouldn't you know it...

      (I was just hoping it was buried far enough in the thread that people ignored it rather than wasting time tearing my ill-researched question to shreds :)

  72. Parallel Imports are dead now - US FTA by maroubra · · Score: 1

    Parallel imports are actually dead in about four weeks.

    Apparently our government caved during the Free Trade Agreement negotiations. Virtually all Intellectual Property Rights law changes to US law come 1 Jan 2004.

    We even get the Digital Millenum Copyright Act - believe it or not.

    Check (Registration Required):
    http://smh.com.au/news/Technology/Pate ntly-yours/2 004/11/25/1101219671693.html?from=storylhs

    I hope you know the words to the American Anthem! :-)

  73. and my credit card company by way2trivial · · Score: 1
    Will allow me to list multiple addresses as 'valid' on my card, so I can arrange shipping to alternate addresses.

    I've added my mother in charlotte, NC, sister in Rochester, NY, and my po box and home in NJ...

    I havent' asked them to add a valid address in another company, but I also don't use itunes.

    --
    every day http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Random
  74. Fixed URL by maroubra · · Score: 1
  75. iTunes.ca gift certificates? by dilg · · Score: 1

    Couldn't you just purchase a bunch of iTunes GC's like we can at Target? (any Michigander takers wanna make a run for the border?)

    1. Re:iTunes.ca gift certificates? by tepples · · Score: 1

      You need a local credit card to redeem gift cards.

  76. Re: do you know who your #1 Oil supplier is? by realdpk · · Score: 1

    Maybe he thought you would be interested?

  77. Re:but will Apple allow.. by Trillan · · Score: 1

    Thanks for the info. I'm trying the iTMS-C from overseas right now. It's very slow, though, so it'll be a while before I know... :)

  78. Rush Sucks, but Canada is okay by sokoban · · Score: 0, Redundant

    Here is a screenshot from the store. Too bad Rush blows donkeynuts.

    --
    09 F9 11 02 9D 74 E3 5B D8 41 56 C5 63 56 88 C0 is the magic number.
  79. Re: do you know who your #1 Oil supplier is? by IgnoramusMaximus · · Score: 1
    Simple. He lied..

    We are not there yet but its getting close. There are projects on the way though (primarilly in Quebeq) that will address this issue.

  80. Re:hrmmm..... BT canada works pretty well by vicparedes · · Score: 1

    MHO, Ipods (like all Apple products) are for people who have more money than sense.

    Perhaps you can enlighten us on how you based this assertion? I'm guessing you don't drive the cheapest car in the lot nor buy storebrand products in the grocery. Does this mean you fall into this stereotype that you've lumped Apple users into?

  81. Ob. South Park quote... by vwjeff · · Score: 1

    American TV Anchor: But, Mr. Minister, it isn't like this film is the first troublesome thing to come out of Canada. Let us not forget Bryan Adams.

    Canadian Film Minister: Now, now, the Canadian Government has apologized for Bryan Adams on several occasions!

  82. New store, same problems by H_Fisher · · Score: 4, Insightful

    And just like the US store, I'm sure it'll feature:

    A lot of pop artists;

    A good selection of works by earlier groups in various genres;

    Not a whole lot of imports; and

    A lot of partial albums for major singers, because some corporate asshat out there thinks that's good marketing.

    I used to download lots of music from Napster in college. Burned it CD, played the hell out of it. But I didn't keep most of those mp3s, and today with a steady job and a little different viewpoint, I'm willing to pay money for good copies and to support artists I like. So I checked out iTunes and loved it. I've spent about $80 there in the first month.

    But when I run across artists like Enigma (whose albums have been chopped to hell) and Genesis (none of the most notable songs from the Peter Gabriel era are available), what do I do? I load up my p2p and start searching.

    I don't blame iTunes. I commend them for doing the best they can to bring fire to the music industry cavemen. I admire what they're doing, but if the music makers want me as a consumer, they're going to have to deal with me on my level.

    1. Re:New store, same problems by mrchaotica · · Score: 1
      ...if the music makers want me as a consumer, they're going to have to deal with me on my level.
      Just to be the devil's advocate, that's exactly what they're thinking too: "If the consumers* want our music, they're going to have to buy it from us under our terms."

      Of course, they can take that attitude and shove it up their collective asses, because they're not gonna win!

      *Note to corporate fucktards: I am not a "consumer." I am a customer, damnit, and if you want me to remain so you'd better treat me as such! (In other words, re-learn a simple concept called "customer service!")
      --

      "[Regarding the 'cloud,'] ownership was what made America different than Russia." -- Woz

    2. Re:New store, same problems by DissidentHere · · Score: 1

      Great points, and I'll agree.

      When I hear about something I might like, I check iTunes first, and I'm happy to pay for it (.99 isn't so bad for a taste). But if I can't find it there I'll find it elsewhere. If I like it enough (and not being found on iTunes) I'll hit Best Buy (for mainstream stuff) or my local indie shop.

      Listen up RIAA! If you put out anything that is good people will buy it! If its crap, we'll sample it and decide it's not worth buying. The net is the new radio, no one listens to the radio anymore. Someone mentions band A, I check iTunes, no luck I'll check P2P, if its good, I'll buy the disc, if not I'll delete it. I'm certainly not going to share shit music with anyone.

      Artists and lables - get your shit on iTunes and other services (especially iTunes 'cause I want to hear your music). There are people willing to pay a reasonable amount for your art, and happily. And if the music is shit don't expect anyone to buy it but teenie boppers who will ignore you once your band/group/boy band is no longer 'cool' with the rest of the the clique.

      --
      "None of us are as dumb as all of us." - meeting mantra
    3. Re:New store, same problems by shark72 · · Score: 1

      "A lot of partial albums for major singers, because some corporate asshat out there thinks that's good marketing."

      That's typically due to some asshat composer or songwriter. Remember, multiple people hold copyrights to a typical recorded piece: the record company, sometimes the engineer, the person or people who wrote the lyrics, and the person or people who wrote the music. Generally, you must get each of those people's permission before selling the track online. In the case of an album where the band members wrote the words and tunes, that's not a problem, but it's a performer who gets help writing their stuff, posting the entire album can be a logistical nightmare... and as you've noticed, sometimes it's not possible.

      At times, both the record companies and the P2P services have proposed "compulsory licensing" schemes to get around this. A compulsory system would mean that a third party could distribute your stuff without your explicit permission, as long as they paid you for it.

      --
      Sitting in my day care, the art is decopainted.
  83. snoopblocker.com and proxyweb.net in Canada by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    snoopblocker.com and proxyweb.net are proxy servers located in Canada

  84. Re:but will Apple allow.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    And without the self-righteous conviction of superiority, how would we ever guess that you're not.

  85. There's a lot of missing stuff by blonde+rser · · Score: 1

    I checked earlier today and my first few searches turned up nothing. And these weren't super obscure searches. Normal stuff like the proclaimers and nofx. My buddy - the music elitist - thought it was great because when he tried to test it with hip obscure stuff a lot of it was there; including some indie Victoria bands. So what's going on... is there a big push to get the block busters on there and the really obscure stuff. And those of us in the middle are left in the cold?

    1. Re:There's a lot of missing stuff by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      indie Victoria stuff? Like Jeffery Sez? They rock!

    2. Re:There's a lot of missing stuff by katsiris · · Score: 1

      Probably like Frog Eyes, which isn't really obscure, just indie. But people don't bother to look for good music, so maybe it is obscure?

  86. Where is the australian store? by Bobsledboy · · Score: 1

    That's all well and good, but when are those of us in the land down under going to be able to legally purchase music online?

  87. Re:can i get an account... by deadlysloth · · Score: 1

    Oh common - its not "See ya later, eh" Its "Take off, ya hoser!" - and you say you've been there.

  88. ID theft in canada on rise. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    However, from a different news source, the identity theft in canada doubled last night. Primary investigations revealed that much of that information has been moving across the border to U.S

  89. Re: do you know who your #1 Oil supplier is? by incom · · Score: 1

    Actually, it's only ontario using US electricity, most other provinces sell the US power. And ontario is only buying US power becuase the liberals were bribed to do so, wonder why so many nuclear and hydro generators that are fully functional have been shut down? Stupid Mcguinty...

    --
    True genius is grasping a situation like a peice of fruit, and peircing it just right so that it drains dry.
  90. Logical Fallacy? by mindaktiviti · · Score: 1

    Or...something?

    What you said is not the full truth. There are restrictions. This is how it works in Canada:

    It is NOT legal to send copywritten files to people.
    I'm not 100% sure about receiving files however.

    What you're perfectly allowed to do legally is give your friend a CD that you purchased, and he is able to take that CD and make a copy of it.

    I'm not too sure how this would work with itunes. I assume your Hard drive is the medium that the song is stored on? So ...maybe you can give your friend your harddrive and he can copy it off of your harddrive? Maybe that would be legal.

    IAMAL

  91. Re: do you know who your #1 Oil supplier is? by Guspaz · · Score: 1

    Some interesting things in there:

    1) HydroQuebec exports almost a third of the energy
    2) Either I'm stupid, or the gov't is, because they think HydroQuebec is exporting "Hydraulic" energy. Don't they mean "Hydro electric"?

  92. Canadian music ? by Whygee · · Score: 1

    I just took a first look at the store and I noticed there was no French music or music in French from Quebec altought the interface was in French. Does somebody know if they plan to introduce new titles progressively ? It could be a good idea to consider this option...

  93. How co-operation beats competition... by Ralph+Spoilsport · · Score: 1, Troll
    All you need to do is go to MacMall and buy an external 160 HD for $130 as pictured here:

    Then find a Canadian Friend, and wire them money on a regular basis to buy tunage from the iTMS. Since you're saving 16 cents a track, all you have to do is record enough tunes on the drive to cover the cost of the drive (about 900) plus the shipping (about 100 or less, depending) to break even.

    Your Canadian Friend then DLs track to the Drive via the Canadian iTMS. Once the drive is full, or you feel you've spent enough, Your Canadian Friend mails back the drive with the note "Hey dummy - you left this on the desk, ya hoser - see you soon, yours truly: Your Canadian Friend".

    Of course, your Canadian friend has an incentive: he gets all your songs for FREE as he copies them to his own drive or DVDR or whatever floats his little Canadian Boat.

    I figure, if each tune is about 5 megs, you should be able to get about 32,000 songs on there, and at a 16 cent saving on each, you'll save USD$5120. Well Worth the Expense of the drive.

    RS

    FUCK DA POLICE!

    --
    Shoes for Industry. Shoes for the Dead.
    1. Re:How co-operation beats competition... by ICECommander · · Score: 1

      Yeah, but you will wind up paying for 32,000 songs, not to mention you won't get to listen to the songs until all of them finish downloading.

      --
      All your Sybase are belong to us.
  94. Re: do you know who your #1 Oil supplier is? by IgnoramusMaximus · · Score: 1
    HydroQuebec exports almost a third of the energy

    Yea and its gonna get bigger yet. It has to do with all those huge hydro-electric projects they've been up to. On the other hand Ontario has some nuclear reactors in mothballs that can be restarted, dont they?

    Don't they mean "Hydro electric"?

    Sure they do. Just dont expect some administrative assistant somewhere in one of those bureaucratic enclaves to be able to type all this techie stuff right. Me thinks she had trouble with a spell checker (although she can probably type 60 words per minute).

  95. In Soviet Russia... by Vadim+Makarov · · Score: 0

    you buy music at 5 cents a song.

    --
    17779 eligible voters in a district, 17779 'vote' as one. This is Russia.
    1. Re:In Soviet Russia... by spotteddog · · Score: 0



      In Soviet Russia....

      Music buys you!

      --
      . there used to be a sig here.....
  96. here's the old one by eobanb · · Score: 1
    --

    Take off every sig. For great justice.

  97. try this by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Read down through the comments. I think with javascript and any browser that supports it, you could be good to go with a little tinkering

    http://www.macosxhints.com/article.php?story=200 30 429215101277

  98. iRATE Radio - Free and Legal Music by MichaelCrawford · · Score: 2, Interesting
    Would you like to get new music to listen to without enriching the RIAA record labels? Would you like to support up-and-coming artists who can't get a recording contract or airplay?

    Many unsigned and independent artists provide free downloads of their music as a way to promote themselves. Of course the hard part for you is to find this music at all, let alone find the music that you're going to like without actually downloading and listening to it all.

    iRATE Radio solves this problem for you. It is a collaborative filtering MP3 downloader and player. It is Free Software, licensed under the GNU GPL.

    iRATE's central server has a database of about 50,000 MP3 tracks available from a number of music hosting services such as the Internet Underground Music Archives. The iRATE client fetches a few URLs from the server, downloads the tracks, and then plays them for you.

    As you listen to each track, you rate it according to your preferences. The client then uploads your ratings to the server, which then correlates them with ratings submitted by other users. Future track recommendations will be based on these correllations. Basically what that means is that if you and I like the same music, then iRATE will download for you all the same music that I rated highly.

    iRATE Radio is very close to its 0.4 release, which offers many improvements over the current 0.3 release. We can use your help in testing the upcoming release. If you want to help, please download one of the unstable builds. Subscribe to the mailing list and submit bug reports via the sourceforge bug report form.

    There is a new distribution page at www.irateradio.com that is aimed at the non-technical user. Downloading from there gets you the 0.3 release right now, but soon the 0.4 release will be available there.

    iRATE Radio is written in Java and welcomes contributions from new developers.

    --
    Request your free CD of my piano music.
    1. Re:iRATE Radio - Free and Legal Music by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      this is pretty cool. Thanks for the link.

    2. Re:iRATE Radio - Free and Legal Music by burns210 · · Score: 1

      and you didn't even put letterhead on your press release. Too bad.

      Next.

  99. Re:but will Apple allow.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    "unless you buy ALOT at once"

    Damn it...

    ALOT is not AWORD!

    - spelling nazi

  100. INDIA? by eobanb · · Score: 1

    Uh, HELLO!? Maybe you're forgetting the billion fucking people in the Republic of India, of which English is an official language? Seriously, this kind of ignorance is disgusting.

    --

    Take off every sig. For great justice.

    1. Re:INDIA? by z3021017 · · Score: 1

      I'm not being ignorant.

      According to the CIA World Fact Book:
      English enjoys associate status but is the most important language for national, political, and commercial communication; Hindi is the national language

      I based my statement on the national language of countries.
      I thought Afrikaans was the language of South Africa, and I just plain forgot about lil' old Liberia!

      --
      Bored? Visit my exciting counter page!
    2. Re:INDIA? by Ryano · · Score: 1

      I'm not being ignorant. ...

      I based my statement on the national language of countries. I thought Afrikaans was the language of South Africa, and I just plain forgot about lil' old Liberia!

      You also forgot about Ireland, where English is by some considerable distance the most commonly spoken language, as well as being one of two official national languages (the other being Irish).

      So, yes, you were being a little bit ignorant - in the sense of lacking knowledge - but then nobody knows everything, so you can usually get away with any amount of ignorance with a little bit of humility.

      The lack of iTMS for Ireland is particularly galling as Apple were ready to roll it out, but have been stymied by IMRO, the people who collect music royalties here. As Ireland is a market of only 4 million people, I can't see Apple putting too much effort into overcoming the objections of these local princelings.

    3. Re:INDIA? by DGregory · · Score: 1

      Why not just offer Itunes in English, with whatever languages they already have translated, and have the currency in Euros? That'd cover a whole bunch of countries. People all listen to a lot of American music anyway with a handful of local artists. Just do the American music and work with the local artists/labels after the site's up.

      Or heck just have one big Itunes web site for the whole world, so Americans can get that obscure Italian artist or something. I don't see why they need to regionalize it. We're not talking local sports and weather, we're talking music and you can find a lot of the same music in the stores all over the world.

    4. Re:INDIA? by Ryano · · Score: 1

      Why not just offer Itunes in English, with whatever languages they already have translated, and have the currency in Euros? That'd cover a whole bunch of countries. People all listen to a lot of American music anyway with a handful of local artists. Just do the American music and work with the local artists/labels after the site's up.

      If only it were that simple! It's not the case that Apple can negotiate a deal in the USA to sell tunes by US artists all over the world. Deals have to be done in each country with the people who hold the licenses for the music in that country. So we're not talking about negotiations about carrying tracks from local artists - the negotiations are about carrying the whole iTunes music catalogue.

  101. Re: do you know who your #1 Oil supplier is? by MikeBabcock · · Score: 1

    Actually, Ontario is a net provider of electricity to the US as well. During peak times, Ontario has sometimes imported power from the US, but its rare. Its much more common for Ontario to export power, just like Quebec.

    We sell americans fuel, wood, gold, electricity and water. They don't need us?

    --
    - Michael T. Babcock (Yes, I blog)
  102. why bother... by WebCowboy · · Score: 3, Informative

    ...with step one? Just get a PO Box from Canada Post. You don't need your own plot of land, a little box in Macs next to the frosty machine will do just fine.

    Besides, you couldn't by $10 of land anywhere in Canada (even in Winnipeg). Even $10 US--especially since at the rate the US dollar is tanking it'll be at par with the Canadian dollar in a year and with the peso by the end of the decade if the trend were to continue that long.

    BTW...this is how Canadians get HBO--they get a PO box in Montana and order DirecTV. Can't see why the same strategy in reverse wouldn't work for USians lookin' for cheap iTunes.

    1. Re:why bother... by kchoboter · · Score: 1

      hey hey... whats this "even in winnipeg"

      I'm from Winnipeg. Winnipeg rocks!

      And P.S. It does not have the lowest property values across Canada, what about up North or in the middle of nowhere Saskatchewan.

      --
      4B4556494E
    2. Re:why bother... by WebCowboy · · Score: 1

      And P.S. It does not have the lowest property values across Canada, what about up North or in the middle of nowhere Saskatchewan.

      Actually property values up north are likely higher than in Winnipeg--everything costs more up there, plus quite a few northern towns are booming Lots of money in Oil and Diamonds you know (Ft.McMurray--again--for example). I'd have to agree with you about Saskatchewan though. That said, compared to other big cities (around 500,000 or more) Winnipeg property is pretty cheap.

  103. Re:Parallel Imports are dead now - US FTA by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I hope you know the words to the American Anthem! :-)

    Yes I do



    America...
    America...
    America, FUCK YEAH!
    Coming again, to save the mother fucking day yeah,
    America, FUCK YEAH!
    Freedom is the only way yeah,
    Terrorist your game is through cause now you have to answer too,
    America, FUCK YEAH!
    So lick my butt, and suck on my balls,
    America, FUCK YEAH!
    What you going to do when we come for you now,
    it's the dream that we all share; it's the hope for tomorrow

    FUCK YEAH!

    McDonalds, FUCK YEAH!
    Wal-Mart, FUCK YEAH!
    The Gap, FUCK YEAH!
    Baseball, FUCK YEAH!
    NFL, FUCK, YEAH!
    Rock and roll, FUCK YEAH!
    The Internet, FUCK YEAH!
    Slavery, FUCK YEAH!

    FUCK YEAH!

    Starbucks, FUCK YEAH!
    Disney world, FUCK YEAH!
    Porno, FUCK YEAH!
    Valium, FUCK YEAH!
    Reeboks, FUCK YEAH!
    Fake Tits, FUCK YEAH!
    Sushi, FUCK YEAH!
    Taco Bell, FUCK YEAH!
    Rodeos, FUCK YEAH!
    Bed bath and beyond (Fuck yeah, Fuck yeah)

    Liberty, FUCK YEAH!
    White Slips, FUCK YEAH!
    The Alamo, FUCK YEAH!
    Band-aids, FUCK YEAH!
    Las Vegas, FUCK YEAH!
    Christmas, FUCK YEAH!
    Immigrants, FUCK YEAH!
    Popeye, FUCK YEAH!
    Demarcates, FUCK YEAH!
    Republicans (republicans)
    (fuck yeah, fuck yeah)
    Sportsmanship
    Books

  104. How coincidental, I just bought an Ipod by Hamster+Lover · · Score: 1

    A Canadian Ipod owner here. I recently bought a refurbed 5 GB Ipod from Tiger Direct for C$200, which seems an excellent deal as the unit appears to be brand new in every respect and has worked flawlessy for the last month.

    I originally bought the unit without knowing that Itunes would be on-line in Canada, what a bonus! I know several people that have Ipods even though we haven't had the Itunes music store this entire time and several retailers, among them Future Shop, regularly sell out of the Ipod Mini. With the added convenience of the Itunes music store, I predict it will get more difficult to find stock of Ipods.

    I find it interesting that the cool factor of the Ipod is so great that many stores have sold out of a product that up till now, was only half usable. I orignally bought my unit because the price was so good and didn't know that Itunes was coming. This is simply fantastic news!

    1. Re:How coincidental, I just bought an Ipod by mh101 · · Score: 1

      a product that up till now, was only half usable

      That's like saying a toaster made by X is only half usable until X also sells bread. And a Starbucks coffee maker is still 100% functionable if you purchase coffee beans from somewhere other than Starbucks...

      But I completely agree with you that it's exciting to finally have iTMS available for more than just browsing.

      --
      Duct tape is like the Force. It has a light side, a dark side, and it holds the universe together.
    2. Re:How coincidental, I just bought an Ipod by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Me too... and I'll never buy music from iTunes. 40Gigger is 80% full from my friendz amalgamated collections.

      Ooooh, you mean I can't download Ashlee Simpson's latest cr...track? Or the latest genre-merger that a marketing exec is trying to shove down your throat (Snoop feat the Doors, LBJZ... though i do have Aerosmith and RunDMC...)

      To all the wispy-eyed music execs who won't be able to keep up their coke habits... NO ONE CRIED FOR THE ENCYCLOPEDIA SALESMEN EITHER...

  105. In Canada by stephenMF · · Score: 1

    ...in Canada iTunes is only for old people.

    1. Re:In Canada by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      correction: ...cold people.

  106. Funny by billybob · · Score: 1

    It was obviously supposed to be a funny comment. He was poking fun at America, not Canada. :P

    --
    Joseph?
  107. Outed! by IncohereD · · Score: 1

    The rest of Canada might appreciate but the national fiber is too strong here

    Too bad you spell fibre like an American. You are clearly some sort of desperate Vermonter.

  108. Deal of the Day - Depeche Mode Remixes by grifter7 · · Score: 1

    The best deal going so far is the Depeche Mode - Remixes 81-04 album.

    37 songs, over 4 hours of music = $9.99CAN!

  109. I feel by craw · · Score: 1

    a song coming! To all you Canadians I proudly sing your national anthem!

    Oh Christmas Tree
    Oh Christmas Tree

    What!? Huh? That's not right?

    We did this to a fellow graduate student who happened to be Canadian. He was a good about this and would just say,... well it wasn't hoser but something that rhyme with duck cough. Must be a canuck thing.

    This was many years ago. When the USA won the gold medal in ice hockey in 1980 he caught a lot of good natured grief. He also got really drunk when every American bought him a drink when the Canadians smuggled out escapees from the American embassy in Iran in the early phases of the hostage crisis. Canada hid the Americans, then left Iran (the Americans suddenly became Canadians), then said duck cough.

    It should have not taken so long for Canada to get a iTunes Music Store. As someone that has worked with Canadians in the past (including conditions of ice storms, sleet, snow, and white out) all I can say that it is a boot time!

  110. Wow, Slashdot! by nordicfrost · · Score: 1

    2004-12-02 08:42:14 Apple Music Store launched in Canada (Apple,Music) (rejected)

    It's like you don't even try anymore. This site has become the fucking LAST to have any news. I have paid my last subscription.

    1. Re:Wow, Slashdot! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You mean, people still come here for news ?

  111. CANADA = Real Americans by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    CANADA =

    C ourageous
    A mericans
    N oble
    A merican
    D efender of
    A merica

    American live in a democracy and value freedom and are not afraid of anything ...

  112. Sandy Sings the Blues by Limited+Vision · · Score: 1

    But you'd only be able to download cover songs sung by Sandy McTire...

  113. CowboyNeal showing stunning lack of economics by Wolfhart · · Score: 1

    The dollar is at rock bottom prices. All iTunes prices are in dollars and then converted. This is because the U.S. is now faced with the largest deficit since before the second world war. Remember? Right from around when the myth about stock brokers at Wall Street jumping from roofs got started. Well, the U.S. is facing economical meltdown thanks to extremely bad policy and an uneducated (CowboyNeal!?!?) mob of people who continue to support this parasitic (and self-terminating) economy. No? Don't believe me? OK, ask one of the top ten financial officers in the U.S, see for yourself; http://business.bostonherald.com/businessNews/view .bg?articleid=55356

    1. Re:CowboyNeal showing stunning lack of economics by bstarrfield · · Score: 1

      Canadian i-Tunes users may see their prices rise relative to U.S. users. The dollar is falling due to severe economic issues inside the U.S.:

      • The U.S. trade deficit has crossed the $500 billion mark, and is its highest dollar value in history (though the deficit has been larger as a % of GDP for a few moments in the past, 1970's). This is about 5% of U.S. GDP. The trade deficit shows no sign of contracting;
      • The U.S. Federal deficit has soared to a new record ($7.4 trillion), and is set to grow at a rate of $700 billion a year - or more.
      • The U.S. economy is built primarily upon consumer spending - about 60-70% GDP. Consumers have seen very small rises in wages for the past thirty years, and have been essentially living off increases in real estate values caused by low interest rates (i.e. people would have constrained spending if they had not had access to home equity loans, etc.).
      • The U.S. manufacturing base continues to decline, and other goods in step. We don't have much to export besides raw goods, hence why buy dollars?
      • The Euro offers a replacement international currency, based on fiscal policy rather than "we're the great superpower, use our dollar!" OK, really simple, but the US dollar has been subsidized by nations around the world. Times are changing.

      The dollar will fall, if for no reason other than other countries will find little use for it. As an American, we frankly need the dollar to fall, especially against the Yuan (China). A trade deficit as large as the one we have cannot endure, especially when capital is being consumed at a ferocious rate by the Federal government.

      I have no idea how intellectual property prices will be affected by the dollar's decline. It depends upon the U.S. music / recording / software industries ability to maintain dominant and demand higher prices than the rest of the world. Should be interesting.

      --
      /* Dang, I can't type that well. */
    2. Re:CowboyNeal showing stunning lack of economics by gordguide · · Score: 1

      " ... I have no idea how intellectual property prices will be affected by the dollar's decline. It depends upon the U.S. music / recording / software industries ability to maintain dominant and demand higher prices than the rest of the world. Should be interesting. ..."

      They won't. Prices are negotiated with the rights holders, which in Canada is CIRA and in the US is the RIAA. They aren't related, except for being in the same business; ie a national rights organization for music.

      The British have always paid the most for music (iTMS UK, Napster UK, CDs etc) and prices in Canada have always been lower than in the US since the 70's, if you convert currencies to make that comparison.

      Although a comparison of download or CD prices versus currency values is interesting, the currency values themselves are irrelevant, because in each case it's domestic pricing for a domestic market, and in the domestic market only one rights holder has the right to sell music in that market.

      In other words, the RIAA has the right to collect royalties for the Rolling Stones in the USA but not anywhere else. Technically, importing CDs, for example, deprives the RIAA of their legal revenue while rewarding the rights holder in the exporting country. Online downloads are not cross-border because of this.

      Apple negotiates rates with the national rights holders, and that's about it, in a nutshell.

  114. whole of Canada by eean · · Score: 1

    Pretty much the whole of Canada lives on the US border, but the reverse isn't true. That would be the issue with PO boxs.

    Really what you would need is a Canadian friend.

    1. Re:whole of Canada by DGregory · · Score: 1

      That's a lot of work just to be able to buy from Canadian Itunes and save a few pennies. Even with a Canadian friend. Get the canadian friend to let you have a credit card be billed to their address. Then they have to mail you the credit card if you don't live by the border.

    2. Re:whole of Canada by PriceIke · · Score: 1

      [sarcasm]Getting a Canadian friend to buy your music for you and then upload you a copy of the track would be FILE SHARING and that, as the RIAA has made me understand, is THEFT.[/sarcasm]

      --
      It's not a lie. It's the truth with lossy compression.
    3. Re:whole of Canada by superpulpsicle · · Score: 1

      If your main intention is to save money, why not just get it on Walmart.com online at 88 cents?

      I like iTunes too, but there is no cheaper American option. And you don't need a Canadian address or worry about Bush's army coming after you.

  115. A better screenshot available here... by Limited+Vision · · Score: 4, Funny

    We may let Americans browse the Canadian store, but when Canadians log in, here's what *we* actually see...

    1. Re:A better screenshot available here... by gobbo · · Score: 1

      Jeeeeeezuz-murphy you hoser mods, that isn't informative, it's frickin' hilarious...

    2. Re:A better screenshot available here... by shadow303 · · Score: 1

      I should have known better than to click on that link - NSFW

      --
      I've got a mind like a steel trap - it's got an animal's foot stuck in it.
    3. Re:A better screenshot available here... by Sentry21 · · Score: 2, Informative

      PLEASE people, mark these links with 'NSFW' so that I don't get canned when I click a seemingly innocuous link.

  116. Re: do you know who your #1 Oil supplier is? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    >We sell americans fuel, wood, gold, electricity and water. They don't need us?

    You also forgot to mention that a lot of good hollywood actors happen to be Canadian.

  117. translation took a while... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I know a lot of people were complaining that this took a long time, though I can totally understand. It takes a while to go through all the interface/documentation, and add "eh" to the end of every sentence. Also replacing "fuck you!" with "I'm sorry" and "bitch" with "Kim Campbell" probably took a bit of research.

  118. allofmp3 by Blue_Nile · · Score: 1

    or you could just buy from www.allofmp3.com
    they're cheaper and offer encoding in aac, wma, ogg, and all the other codecs.
    They also have a lack of fairplay/DRM that all the other music stores suffer from.
    Only need a paypal account to try it.

    --
    Si Hoc Legere Scis Nimium Eruditionis Habes
    1. Re:allofmp3 by Warlock7 · · Score: 1

      Their AAC files aren't encoded from the original master recordings like those on the iTunes Music Store though. Which is one major advantage Apple has over everybody else.

    2. Re:allofmp3 by Blue_Nile · · Score: 1

      but does that really make a difference when all their files are burned at 128 kbs?

      --
      Si Hoc Legere Scis Nimium Eruditionis Habes
    3. Re:allofmp3 by Warlock7 · · Score: 1

      Absolutely. The initial source quality will affect the final encoded version.

  119. Canadian music has a lot to answer for... by bgeek · · Score: 0

    You gave us Bryan Adams, Celine Dion, Alanis Morrisette, Avril Lavigne, etc. Shame on you!

    1. Re:Canadian music has a lot to answer for... by ArmpitMan · · Score: 1

      Like your country is one to talk, with your Britney Backstreet-Sync Agulera-Los, and your Nickelcreed Bizkitstank Parks.

  120. To be pedantic... by brucmack · · Score: 1

    ...in exchange for a small tax on CDRs...

    It's actually properly referred to as a levy, because the revenue goes to the private sector. The term "tax" is reserved for money that goes to government.

  121. Lemme ax you a queshion by JPelorat · · Score: 1

    terrist

    Cute. Yet another cheap shot at Bush's pronunciation. My, we certainly don't see many of *those* these days. He's such a novelty, because no one else in the entire world has ever mispronounced words. =P

    You probably think that National Public Radio and Public Radio International are a group of highly educated people, right? Do you know how many NPR and PRI hosts slur that word just like Bush? I've heard at least 5 that consistently say 'terrist'. And I only get to hear 2 hours of NPR/PRI a day.

    Really. You should start listening to the people around you. You'll be surprised at what you hear.

    --
    Hokey statistics and ancient misconceptions are no match for a good thought in your head, kid!
  122. CD Baby on international stores by HoserHead · · Score: 1
    I own a couple of your albums I bought from CD Baby, but I'd really rather buy them from the iTunes Music Store.

    This was going to be a post saying "Do you know if CD Baby's music will be on the international iTunes Music Stores," but I just used VNC to search for m/n/m/l on iTunes, and it showed up. This wasn't the case when it first opened on Wednesday night. This is awesome. It's too bad that CD Baby artists don't show up when browsing the store (using the "browse" eye button in the top-right-hand corner of iTunes).

    As a personal aside to you: I was really reminded of your music when I heard "On the Run" by Pink Floyd, from Dark Side of the Moon. Were you inspired by them?

  123. Buy the tank? by matts-reign · · Score: 1

    We didn't "buy" it ... our highschool made it in shop class!

    --
    Waffles rock.
  124. Yeah, but we pay $70 more for a 20GB iPod by Art_Vandelai · · Score: 1

    Canadians pay a special levy on music CD-R's, flash memory cards and HD-based music players such as iPod. The $299 regular price in the States translates to about $356 CDN, but you can't get a 20 gig iPod for less than $429.99. Plus, we have to pay PST and GST. This is so our benevolent overlords can give royalties to Anne Murray, Shanaia Twain and Rush. Afterall, buying an iPod must mean that these fine Canadian musicians are losing money to private copying.

  125. Re:About time (canadian dollar) by Mia'cova · · Score: 1

    They were waiting for our dollar to catch up so they could save costs by marketting only 99 cent songs ;)

  126. Re:hrmmm..... BT canada works pretty well by SenatorOrrinHatch · · Score: 1

    I drive a honda Civic, the best value there is. (and I'm 2 meters tall!) And I do buy storebrands, they're the same thing for less money, so what possible reason is there not too, unless you have more money than sense?

    And yes, you can conclude from the fact that most people don't that I do in fact believe that the majority of USAians have more money than sense.

    Apple is just an extreme example. Their computers used to cost TWICE what a similar powered PC did. Now the price difference isn't so bad, prolly because they charge 10-30$ for each little piece of software that people need which, IMHO, should've been included already or as in the case of a modern linux distro, can be downloaded and installed easily and free of charge.

    Of course, most of MS's strengths come from the fact that most people know how to use it and every hardware company includes drivers for it. If Linux ever acheives near parity in these areas then it will actually be clearly SUPERIOR in most ways to Windows, not to mention free of cost.
    So I'm hoping in 10 years MS will be reduced to hawking faddish trinkets (MediaCenter PC maybe? Like a super duper $1400 TIVO?) and all the serious developement will be where it belongs, in free open source software.
    I think MS now is in the position that Apple was, charging much more for a functionally equivalent product and trying to convince people that it's worth the extra $$$, when in fact neither product is perfect and both have enough relative strengths that they balance each other out, and so a large price difference should be the deciding factor.

    --
    The Christian in me says it's wrong, but the corrections officer in me says, 'I love to make a grown man piss himself.'
  127. Don't worry the lower price won't last long... by mchenrytl · · Score: 1

    With the Bush administration being around for the next four years spending more while reducing taxes you'll see that next year there will be parity between the Candian Dollar and the US Dollar. You're already seeing record highs of the Euro against the US dollar. Look at the price of gold which is set to the US dollar. For it to hold it's value internationally, the price has gone up well over $400 an ounce.

    I know someone who's high up in the Bank of Montreal and they're expecting 1:1 with their dollar and the US sometime next year.

    The only real question is when will Canadians start trying to buy iTunes from the US?

  128. I'll stick with AllofMP3.com... by inkdesign · · Score: 1

    while I still can!

  129. Re:Possible eh? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    But does the store offer the same stuff, eh?
    I mean that's what it's all abuut isn't it, eh?

  130. OT: USD vs. Yuan by Bishop · · Score: 1

    The sad truth (one that people don't want to face) is that the Chinese, Tiwanese, and Koreans have been supporting the US Dollar for a while now. The US Dollar is overvalued. The poor USD Dollar is the only the reason why the Canadian Dollar has been doing so well.

  131. Cheap Dollar by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Ahh, remember the days when the canadian dollar was worth less than the American dollar?

    Thanks George W. Bush! I love seeing the dollar loose 30% of it's value in one term! Great job! I'm just glad I've converted my money into beer. Much better investement I'd say.

  132. You don't understand by WebCowboy · · Score: 1

    Whiole a lot of Canadians live within fairly easy driving distance of the border, actually only a small minority actually live ON the border, such that it would be just as convenient to get US mail as it is Canadian mail.

    That's not how it works anyways. PO Boxes have forwarding services for a small additional fee. you don't actually have to take a road trip to the US to get your DirecTV bill--the postal workers at the RPO just empty your mailbox regularly, slap a sticker with your real address on it on each piece of mail and fire it off to you. The only things they don't forward are oversized envelopes and parcels. That suffices for getting your US bills just fine.

    Anyways, the idea wouldn't make sense for iTunes unless you downloaded thousands a month. The main reason Canadians get US PO boxes for sattelite isn't to save money (because it would usually be cheaper to get a Canadian sattelite system anyhow)--it is to get content that is otherwise unavailable in Canada (HBO for example--it is not approved for broadcast in Canada by CRTC).

    1. Re:You don't understand by eean · · Score: 1

      Oh, OK. I didn't realize you could forward P.O. boxs.

  133. Re:hrmmm..... BT canada works pretty well by vicparedes · · Score: 1

    I drive a Civic myself and last I checked, they're not the cheapest "economy" car in the market. Don't get me wrong, I do agree with you that they offer great value for the price. But that doesn't follow the logic of your original post. In which you intimated that Apple products by their nature, attract people with "more money than sense." Which only leads me to believe that anyone who doesn't purchase the cheapest product (i.e. storebrands) has "more money than sense." In fact, why don't you drive a Ford Focus? It's been on Car & Driver's 10 Best for 5 years. Certainly a guy who's looking for "value" like you, will be impressed with the Ford.

    As for your assertion that Apple charges for software that should've come with the box, might I ask you which software you're referring to? iLife? FYI, it's free when you buy a Mac.

  134. NSFW? by commodoresloat · · Score: 1

    for "Not So Fast, Wanker!"

  135. big in japan? by crabpeople · · Score: 1

    "Australia would be much easier to "port" than Japan. Think of all the text on the iTMS, the Tom Waits biography is 3 screen tall, somebody has to go and translate all that."

    irrelivant. He hardly needs a bio written in japanes. After all, tom waits is already Big In Japan.

    ba dum ching!

    I got the style but not the grace
    I got the clothes but not the face
    I got the bread but not the butter
    I got the winda but not the shutter

    But I'm big in japan I'm big in japan but heh I'm big in japan

    --
    I'll just use my special getting high powers one more time...
  136. Yeah know by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
    We're bigger than you and on top. If this was prison you'd be our bitch.

    --

  137. Re:Canada sucks by Marco+Rossi · · Score: 1

    Klerck, what happened to klerck.org and your email address? Both don't work.

    --
    - Marco